#beta-discussion
1 messages · Page 1111 of 1
DoR testing over or are the npcs bugged?
sky anniversary was done in beta!
It will be ongoing like the rainbow event too. Because they change things at party and rainbow. Comes with next update.
Where are the seasonal candles?
DoR & Anniversary testing will resume with the 18.0 patch, for now it’s over
It seems like they are bugged and not there.
18.0 means they will resume with the new season testing, right?
Probably, but running seasons full length in beta is not a necessity unless something new needs to be tested
I never knew how to get the guitar from the anniversary ever lol
I can help you!
That would be great (:
Alright you can just send me your qr 
Is the third quest about music shop? If it is then i hope we get an update beta soon, the music shop still under development 
the Music Shop debut is until 4th quest, we have some time till then.
You can't play beta on Switch.
Do you think they're going to include another feature unlock after the 5th quest, or is that what the flowers are supposed to be? I thought with the door in the music room we would be getting another area in there. 
We don't know future plans, we just get stuff to test. Seeing how fresh the latest music shop update was to the upcoming live update and the effort TGC puts in DoR revision (regardless outcome is liked or not), I expect bug fixes and minor changes for season, no new features
I hope the very annoying white candle lighting on benches would get fixed. It's been like an year it still didn't get fixed.
That's been in the game since launch.
Fr?
Yeah. I think it's mostly a connection issue, but it has been happening on and off forever.
This may be related to the network status, like sometimes the door won't open
(ping off) they thought the candle bench glitch is a new one and they thought it'd be nice if it got fixed - since you mentioned "bug fixes" in your message 
has been going on for me for ages
i've a nice connection and sometimes it still happens 
The only solution is pray to it lit up randomly
I know
Maybe if you explain your question in more detail we can answer for you. But better ask in #questions-and-help if it's not about beta 
Which channel would be beta chat?
Um, this one
There's also beta season testing but it's only active when there's major seasonal testing updates
does anyone know wether or not the summer items may be coming back? (the sunhat, iap umbrella, iap bunny etc)
Unfortunately we beta players just get stuff to test and no one knows future plans ahead
alright thank you 
I only need 33 candles left to finish my last spirit in beta, are the candles in each realm back yet?
Anyone else having issue getting wax from the daily music quest?
No sadly not
the beta season should have ended on the 30th, but the duration was set incorrectly. that is why there are no realm candles despite the season still being active. apologies for any confusion.
Thank you for explaining! I guess then there's no need to bugreport missing candles anymore?
〔 I’ve been bamboozled by the updates message
〕
That's a good assumption, yes
my eyes lit up once i saw beta updates, only to be let down with no actual update
i honestly wish days of crab was an actual event for april fools, but instead of being called days of crab, it would be called "days of fools" or something.
i like days of crab for the name of it and i want the crab stuff it would offer
my idea is mainly that there would be a fools guide in home where they would offer items like whoopee cushions and stuff. and in the office, there would be a crab guide that gives all the items created during the april fools prank of the days of crab event.
days of crab where every single item in the sleepy traveler's boat is replaced with a crab trick spell
Imagine Days of Krills, Krills chase kids all realms 
April fools joke where all the og qg appear at home and then when you open their tree it shows u can buy ults but when you do and go to your closet and click the ults it's crab on head hat.
people would be so upset 😭
Error 404: seasonal candles not found
^^^
honestly tho it'd be worth it just for the crab hat lol
Well another bad luck …I can’t get my owl hair because of only 23 candles🙂
I hate it🙂 because i did tried so much to get the seasonal candles i wish someone have informed us..
At least you’ll. Probably be able to get it in Live?
Yeah,I will but I really had hope to get it in beta too , I thought the duration is correct 
There there! I’m kinda in the same place cus i’m gonna miss the first 2 ugs (i got the hair when it was still on the bottom of the tree)
now i want a crab hat accessory or shoulder crab
hello .. is it my bug or there are no orange candles?
Oh man I really thought 0.18.0 was out but turns out it's about translation message
Wouldn’t expect it until mid to late May at the least tbh
So, will the season candles return for the rest of the season or no?
I still haven’t gotten everything I’ve been too busy
don’t think so if they planned for the season to end on a specified date.
It’s basically a scheduling error, not necessarily a bug
So it won’t be fixed?
:(
Oh well. At least I’m really close to getting everything so I should have enough candles if I do every single daily quest
No word about it being fixed so most likely not, unless they magically choose to extend the season but I wouldn’t bet on it
IDK if the music hairpin is still in Music Shop, will it come back soon?
Almost had a heart attack when I saw beta update, my phone is very full rn and a new update is gonna kill me
It did disappeared from music guide spirit's tree.
Afaik the music hairpin isn't even in any of the recent #beta-announcements. I doubt if it's intended to be in there.
Just a thought for ya’ll; would it be cool if the Modest Dancer handled a soundproof room of sorts? It’d be fitting to their, shyness? And give them a proper purpose in the Music Shop, since they’re kinda just… there… They could show you where to go or something!
They seem like they wouldn’t like the chaos of the shop much either so it’d be cute if there’s a more quiet room they use to relax!
So, it was an accident? :o
bruh i wasted all my candles on that hairpin
this is why we need the candle packs
Did you not like the hairpin?
no i bought it so if it's gone that means it was all for nothing 😭
this cooldown bruh
that happens in beta sometimes
but for me the pin is still in the closet 
oo ok i'll check...
after i do some cr'ing on switch hehehe
my best advice for beta is to always have a stock of candles, but to also be prepared to lose anything and everything
i cant believe theres no seasonal candle for today
5 candles you can still get. 4 from quest and 1 from shrine
I know, but I still need a lot more to get the last heart 😔
Please see pins.
For the new ones: beta is still a test... Don't complain, take what you get. Tgc can take all of your candles, items, or cosmetic as well, if there is a problem with it. So complain of loosing. We just here to find bugs and help with the game performance.
okay
Hate it when you cant report hackers without lighting them 
There was a hacker. I friended so I could report them. But the report was bugged.. It doesn't send the report.. The hacker knew about it. And laughed at me and spamt emotes level 4 all... It was a moth.

Oh my God, there are still no seasonal candles on the map today, and I am almost ready to graduate
Omg so I'm not alone
it made me lose 20 candles a day😭
A total of 60 candles were lost
浅问一下,怎么解锁#beta invites
We ask everyone to please post only in English on this server, @keen estuary. Unfortunately, moderators and staff aren't able to support all the languages spoken by our global Sky family.
Could you tell me how to unlock # beta invites?
Ktjn made a statement that the season is technically over, but the counter is messed up, that’s why there are no seasonal candles.
And will they give them back or it just works like this? (Sorry I'm new to beta)
You have to wait for another beta invite wave.
Give what back?
The seasonal candles
Seasonal candles are only available when there is a season active to test. Just like live. Whenever the new season starts, they will be available again.
That's too bad. It's just today. I don't understand.
What is today? I don’t understand.
But the season is still active, you can do tasks and the spirit is at home
Translation problem, my English is not good.
The season is over, but the counter is messed up. Ktjn announced it last night in this thread. Ignore the spirit. There are still tasks to do everyday just like live, but the candles will be regular and not seasonal.
@keen estuary it’s okay. Are you in beta or waiting for an invite?
Uh How does this software reply? It seems that I am not very smart.
#beta-discussion message the message clark is referring to for anyone who's interested (ping off)
Thank you!
@keen estuary can you explain what you need help with again? 
I don't think I can learn.
Why do you have avatars?
Just for fun.
There's no possibility to do the seasonal task before the last one, is that a bug?
The grammar is wrong. My English is not good.
Ok. Please remember to not reveal any personal information online, especially not on a server with 400k members.
That is definitely a bug.
Thank you. I will pay attention to it. Bye-bye, my friends. I'm going to go offline for dinner.
Could you please delete the messages that contain personal information?
Wow, you guys are amazing
Why do you say that?
Because my dream is to go to every place in the world, but I find it can be realized here.
oh no 22 hours left??? the music shop hasnt done yet aaa
The music shop will stay forever
no i mean the bug thingy still there
the 4 music sheet thingy too
i guess the tgc will fix that after season
That NPC stays forever too
i mean i cant use the music sheet even tho i already bought it, i wanna see what it does 
You can do that after the season, so why did you mention when the season ends? 
i dont know what i'm saying anymore my englishgrammars are messing my head
wait what is the third quest in live?
Basically we need to take a BETA Test break until new BETA season is up so, we have a Vacation this summer so take a break and get some fun in LIVE.
(just imagine)
if sky collab season related to any ghibli anime then i'll
💜
Bruuuh, Sky collab season teaser will come during Sky anniv. or Days of Summer events LMAO 
||Me hoping for Fashion designing season cuz of Met Gala||
Steampunk season please- Imagine the outfits that could give us hhhh <3
The season is over already, everyone! Ktjn confirmed yesterday!
The season is already over. Read my message above this one.
I didn't tell them that on purpose. They weren't asking about candles, therefore it wasn't relevant and could have just confused them more
I know. I was just letting that person know.
Are days of rainbow guides still on beta?
No.
Do you think I should quit beta bc I haven’t really been playing it anymore and I’m just starting to get overwhelmed by updates. Think it would be better not to waste this beta space?
ehh i usually only play when there's updates
Hm, they’re not gonna remove the Anniversary Guitar, are they? 
i wish 💀
Late reply, so ping off. But yes, devs always say to focus on Live, because that's where the real game is. You can always come back to beta when you are more available. If you're Android you don't lose your place, unless they decide to purge everyone.
Chat wont show for me or other ppl I talk to in sky beta
People, I have a question
speak
or forever hold your tongue!
(ping off) We don't know for sure. 
So what was the question?
They said they had a question and went offline lol
They left us in suspense
Why does the rendering quality and fps drops whenever i open Keyboard on My iphone 13 ?? is it a bug ?
Sounds like a bug to me, I can't imagine it's intended... Could be your phone having too much work (I've no idea on the abilities of the iphone 13 though), could be some bug in the software that actually lowers them, but it's probably not intended.
That happens to me on iOS for… as long as I can remember tbh
Definitely since at least launch. Unsure if it’s intended though
It happens with every iphone
Iphone 13
Iphone 12 pro
Iphone se 2nd gen
I'm not on iPhone, but I'll keep an eye open for that. I guess given your observations of it happening on various devices and Mirian's statement of getting that error ever since the game launced, you can file a bug report but the chances it'll be acted upon are relatively low.
Someone remind me what time grandma is
It's at xx:35 to xx:45 where xx is replaced by a hour being away an even amount of hours from reset, or reset itself.
So if reset for you is at 9am, it's at 9am, 11am, 1pm and so on.
Edit: Though that question is better asked in #questions-and-help since grandma is live already.
Yes i know I just decided to ask here as I figure it doesnt matter eheh ^^
just popping in to say henlo - how’s everyone doing? Has conversion day been nice?
(for personal reasons imma not look in screenshots)
Tho the bouquets do seem a retextured clam, they were however nice additions for completing the season. Just made me feel sad when first seeing its gone. Twas nice seeing bright colored stuffs in that snow. Tho i do hope newer players who'll play the game later on would still see the bouquets at least once. For the music shop, I think it's nice seeing snowflakes fall as wax there @spark lance :)
the bouquets would be nice as a special little treat for completing all the quests, but as a permanent addition, it would end up keeping people from actually using the theater. the reason i don't like the bouquets is cause without them being there, you KNOW you'll end up in a server with people performing and stuff in the area. but if they're there, you most likely will end up in a server where people just grab the bouquets, and then just run off into the music shop to go afk. for the music shop the afk wax isn't a bad thing tho
Twas just sad seeing them go 
They're literally Rose's cousins... Same fate... Harsh.
i mean... they could always just make the bouquets decorations in the map instead of collectables. so that they're permanently there, and they won't keep people away from the main point of the area
Tho rose didn't give wax 
So I just saw a video talking about new Chat system but during demonstration it showed annoymous chatting without any ..... ? I confused, isn't the chat will be ............ when annoymous is talking. Or I just missing something in #beta-announcements
I've never had motion sickness but beta on iOS is acting such a way that I could imagine I'll have it. Most noticeable on camera movement during jumps or Skykid running on uneven terrain, and during rotation of camera left - right during Skykid running
Anonymous still have the ......
Motion blur?
No, it's not (just) that
Huh, maybe the anti aliasing blurry effect?
I definitely get motion sickness from the game, but it’s usually only while I’m already nauseated by something else outside of the game.
Flying through Forest almost made me flatline on the spot.
Funnily enough I find myself kind of jumping or like moving with my skykid. I've learned not to walk while playing sky 
Forest with camera swivel is the worst though, and I don't really get motion sick much. I used to kind of get it when lighting friend but now the camera doesn't move ||thank the elders||
I was about to leave feedback on the camera controls.
So something wasn't right for the camera control's then
it's probably intended, as you'd be looking at the keyboard when typing, not the game
Most typists don't look at the keyboard and actually look at the output to ensure no typos happened. I barely look at the keyboard for example.
I'm one of those crazy people who will type out conversations mid flight when playing on Android with controller and a Bluetooth keyboard... Sometimes I do the same on switch when I have a free phone/tablet (though that's only in live)
My device lags a tiny bit when opening the keyboard on Android, but I think that's because the keyboard generates a brand new space to type in
when is the music shop coming out officially?
It doesn't happen for chatting, but for message boats and meditation and stuff
We don't exactly know. When the third quest comes out in Live, it'll tell you how many days until the fourth quest. that's when the music shop comes out
I've noticed I get a bit of lag with regular chatting with the on-screen keyboard as well as with boats/shrines/etc - I've been chalking it up to my velvet being kinda meh, and to my p20 pro being... Four years old now I think?
God I just know waiting for next season is going to be pain. I'm already itching for a new update... A crumb of content,, and ik new season is nowhere near close. Hopefully DoR developments soon.
Hey guys when is the next invite wave?
Whenever they need more testers
the next invite waves are random so they'll only send a invite if they need more testers. just keep a look out just in case
Tysm maymei!!
Tysm perpul!!
where is my mini turtle in a new update?
I ate it 
oh boy this is not right
If you're talking about the head turtle that became the shoulder one... For those who got it on the head it's not available anymore and also got removed. If you got it on the shoulder, and it's gone, sounds like a bug and all you can do is to head to #beta-bugs-android or #beta-bugs-ios though be aware TGC generally doesn't compensate for issues in beta unless they prevent TGC from getting necessary testing data or a dev has nothing at all to do (which I doubt ever happens).
@spark lance It's one of Thatskybot's standard answers to "where is xy" messages. I don't think it's serious.
I ate it 
Bad Skybot, no eating the turtle >:(
No problem! 
If you have any more questions, feel free to ping me! 
How long do we usually have to wait in beta to get a new season?
Until the official version has about 20-30 days left on the ongoing season
Lets see what happens on reset
We explode
well time to try and just complete the tear 2 capes now.
Bruuh, it's summer vacation lol! It'll not explode ehe
Imagine if Tier 3 capes design is ||old cape design||
imagine
Devices: Becomes Stove, Low FPS
Put a cooler with Flex Tape
I'll just dip my phone in Liquid Nitrogen instead (using steak clippers thingy of course)
WARNING: Liquid Nitrogen has —196 °C and It'll cause your phone will frozen like iceberg. Just stay on Air Conditioned rooms
I'm sure it'll be fine~
Tear 😢 2 capes

hahaha i didnt notice that
the next ts in beta should be the earth prophet right?
Yes
Liquid nitrogen is no good for phone
o-0
How do you know ? and how did you know about dismiss ts ?
We’re basically following the live schedule, just way behind
Know the past TS backwards. Start at Sunbather
Whatever happened to the Moth-o-meter thing? Whatever it was that showed some people were veterans
It wasn't a moth meter or a veteran meter. It was a shepherd meter. It only raised when certain friendly actions were done. The Shepherd System was a shelved feature and changed to the "guide feature" we have now.
It was never intended to be a "here's a veteran." In fact, it was to help the people who earned shepherd help new players get acquainted with the game and learn the ropes from a more seasoned and friendly player.
The "guide feature" is when you lead a confused moth by the hand, right?
If you want more info on how the Shepherd System worked, here's a quick video on it. #beta-screenshots-videos message
Anyone tested how many likes does the message candle shrine require for a heart 👀
50
In a nutshell, the more you helping others your meter will goes up and become a shepherd. And others will see you too have a icon, that means you are kind enough helping people before. The feature is kinda dead for a long time after new constellation was introduced
It's kinda like a trust system
uhmhmmm doez anyone know where the music hair pin iz im trying to help @merry frigate get it 😭
I'm unsure if it's still in the game, but talk to the jester in the music shop.
at least u can get it when it comez 2 live JSHSJ
i knew i got it from there i was so confused why it waznt there LOL
Lol yeah, Mkay then.
It seems it was never in the patch notes either, so maybe it wasn't meant to be in the game yet?

hmm maybe? 
I do still have it in my closet, though.
wait u mean for beta patch notez right
hello
well yeah surely they wouldn't write it in live patch notes 
YEAHHS just making sure

i have a question 💀 its a really bad question too
so uh- yall know what the next ts is right?.....
Well it wasn't said yet. The last one ended at may 1st as far as I'm concerned
beta is behind live by some time, so whatever live had that time ago, we should have it
it should be earth prophet, but no guarantee, ts aren't given importance in beta from what i understand.
alr- i need to go sleep soon- the ts stuff makes sense tho
The season leaving 😭
That means we'll be testing a new season in a month or so
I wonder where the next season place is
eden
?
prairie or isle tbh
its been 7 seasons since a prairie season came 
wow lol prairie seems pretty likely then
i think they should roll back on prairie tbh, it's getting too much love what with events and all
isle/eden wouldn't hurt. i loved prophecy. perhaps they could add a new isle season near the vast sea to the right of isle.
true, i think if they wanna do more events they should def be in other realms, but prairie still deserves another season since its been so long
isle is empty
Oops yeah i was gonna add that isle is way too empty and it absolutely deserves more but i got distracted
i'm sick of special stuff in prairie 💀 where my isle gang at
i would like to see them add more stuff in isle, because isle is just desert, cave and temple, its tooooo empty
i hope there will soon be a cosmic manta cape.
Same!!
tbh, i'd love to see either an isle or a vault season, since they've brought back "owl" hair maybe this could be a new manta cape, maybe? 
Ok, testers! Let's take a BETA Break until new season is up cuz it's summer vacation! ;P
climb to summit for season entrance 👍
oh dear that'd be a nightmare..

iOS testers sweating about being kicked-
I want another interactive season like the Little Prince one
stares at ominous test flight countdown
i'd like that tbh. but just. please not as expansive as starlight desert. love the area, but it is hell to fly across to where i want to chill.
this.
Would also be nice for skykids to learn how to waltz
but maybe not an area as small as prophecy, please. 
bruh! been saying that in feedback for the last year and a half. i still have hope but i bet they'll make it cost 40 candles with a 20AC lock
peformance area is also small right
I have the candles but that would suck
i like the small areas, they are easy to navigate. a perfectly sized area imo would be flight (not counting the entrances to the areas, but the main island area)
as long as we get interactive rooms like the trials, i'm okay with the small main area
as a veteran i'm BORED of the repetitive gameplay
Okay so season countdown says 15 minutes, so will candle transfer happen then or at next reset-
true, true. 
Well, do CR in BETA to stay active ehe. And that's my tips
i've 180k candles no thank you
agreed. though veterans may have it, tgc should be considerate of people who cant afford that, they're ridiculous prices already, and this inflation is horrendous. it's their job to take care of people on all ends of the candle earning spectrum.
when you have thousands of candles it feels useless and boring to cr 
apologems in sky when
pffft if only i wasn't lazy
How about..............
Design your Ikea stuff in Shared Space?
i can't control shared spaces for the life of me 
Shared spaces got really confusing for me
i doubt they'd ever do that..
they nuked it with that prop limit. i hate that. i'd actually use shared space if not for that.
never say never lmao
EXACTLY!! i agree 100% with you, it was so fun before and now they just made it almost impossible to be creative with it.. 
fast forward 84 years later, us with white hair, tgc plz add apologems and fix server issues
just imagine the things we can do without the prop limit 
i mean we already have white hair...........
i'd make a whole beach party if there was a shared space in sanctuary. 
Can't you exchange the blue note headdress in the music shop?
wdym exchange?
Its been since yesterday that my beta wa slaggy
u mean a new season? we don't know
I was looking at the time, and it suddenly disappeared.
What happened? It looks strange for the show season guide to redeem the tree
that is because the season has ended in beta.
I don't even know, i also saw the tree of the season guide too and it's kinda bugged
Hugs and vases stacked on top of each other, at the bottom of the exchange tree
it's been an hour without the season and I'm BORED

I'm looking forward to the new season 😋
when will it come tho :c
Beta testers don't know when things will happen in Beta
Any Beta announcements will be made in #beta-announcements!
Why are all your avatars animated?
You get animated emojis and pictures when you pay for a subscription. You can find info about "Discord Nitro" in your settings.
Since you're under 18 years of age, you'll need to ask your parents if you want it
Wow, your English is good.
question, after how many season quests does the music shop unlock? i wanna mess around with the instruments, but would like to avoid doing as many of the quests as i can before i can do them in live with my friends
If I remember correctly, it will open after the fourth quest.
tysm!! 
Thankyou!
is the harp still missing?
Wow! The season is over and i got many regular candles! Now I can take a step closer to the invisible cloak.
I'm looking forward to next season.
Hi, can i ask a question? Is the music🎶 headdress over?
I don't know. I'll take a look at it now and tell you.
yes 结束了
Wait whose the next ts in beta?
please tell me its troupe greeter ive been waiting on its pants for so long
No one knows beta next ts. It might follow past ts schedule, it might not.
I don't remember which one should be following if we keep doing the same sequence as Live but delayed. Maybe check the wiki?
earth prophet
Probably when there's a month left in the live season as it's a common occurrence for that to happen
(E.g. Abyss testing starting in Nov and Performance testing starting in Feb)
Supposed beta TS schedule based on the ones we previously had in live:
Earth Prophet 
Hiking Grouch 
Troupe Greeter 
Yoga Guru 
Scarecrow Farmer 
Spinning Mentor 
Daydream Forester 
(These are not guaranteed ofc, could change at any time)
When the TS is coming, gonna use those 100k candles
Reference:#beta-screenshots-videos message
spongebob waiting at table meme
me over here with 230k+ candles
they better start rolling the ts out soon because i got candles to spend
I counted how many days into the season on average it took for the beta testing to start for a new one and got an avg of 50.6 days. So hopefully around may 31 we will see new testing, but again just an estimate. TGC has started as early as 40 days and as late as almost 60. So all I can do is guess 
Yeah most of the time they start it at about 40-50 days left
typically new season testing starts 2-3 weeks before a season ends in live
Since seasons have different lengths, I usually look at when a season is ending in live
I wonder if the changes are in Valley ice rink are intended, except for the missing rock outcrop where the spirit lives and the meditation shrine is
I dont imagine they are, one of the devs i think did a texture rework because it was expected to look different than what it is now
I like the tunnel tho
I am a fan of the holes tho, i think it gives it a better look
I think tgc is improving valley,but they still not finished it and make the valley look chaotic now
I love the hole in the walls in the juggler cave, you can get the cake by flying over the hill rather than through the windy tunnel
No need to chibi fall or spasm in the past to get it
The tunnel is a pain, especially when we need to relive the juggler and people already started it and you cant catch up 
beta chat so quiet bc no updates 😭
Yeahh that's how it is
just focus on live until then. now that the season ended i don't think i'll be logging on much until the next update
Could someone remind me of what quest gave us access to the music shop? Thanks 
Am ok with pings
Does anyone care about each other?
Quest 4, but that can change in live. We just test features in beta.
Thank You! I was trying to remember since i finished the quest in beta a while ago 
let's hope they're working on DoR in this time i guess. if that's the case they can take as much time as they need 
Is beta gonna be dead until the next season?
Good chance it will be
Probably unless there's some big update till then
we'll probably see days of summer testing at some point though
Also whatever they're going to do for the revamped/adjusted Days of Rainbow stuff that should be coming with testing for the 0.18.0 version (but of course we don't know when exactly testing will start for that)
at some point this month for sure; DoR will be next month so i don't think they'll take too long with it
Actually days of Rainbow in live got postponed to July
Precisely because of the revamp they're gonna do
Yeah, in live it seems like we may end up having Days of Rainbow and the Anniversary celebration run kind of simultaneously like they did with Days of Fortune and Days of Love a year or so ago, since the revamp will be delayed to a different patch release
ahhh, I see. interesting! fair enough. if that's the case then it'll probably be a while for sure. I quite liked the pants from the days of rainbow event but if they're going to revamp the whole event, I'm curious as to see what they're going to do with it
To be clear, we don't know for sure if they're going to revamp everything or what exactly they're going to change, they just said they want more time to work on the event based on all the feedback they got. I'm curious to see what happens too though
I don't understand why my light encounters always flash back, which bothers me very much.
does v.0.18.0 include the new season?
There is no 0.18.0 to test. How would we know? 
??
Sorry, discussions about trading hearts are not permitted on the Sky server.
Wait, they're revamping Days of Rainbow??? I hope the pants are kept, I really like them. I understand that many of you didn't though, so my hopes that they are kept aren't very high
Oh! I also have a season idea I wanna run by you guys
Season idea:
The Season of Knowledge
———————————————
The season about learning, being a season dedicated to actually teaching sky kids about Sky and it's lore and such.
The season would have you and the seasonal guide, a little skykid-sized girl, being taught by 4 different teachers about different aspects of Sky. The four teachers include:
Hyped Explorer:
- Teaches about the various architecture in Sky
- Amped up looping emote
- Explorer's outfit and hat (accessory)
Gentle Gardener:
- Teaches about the various plant and wildlife in Sky
- Forehead kiss Friendship emote
- Flower in a pot prop
- Gardening apron
- Rapunzel-style braided hair
- Habiscus flower hairpin
Bouncy Musician:
- Teaches about the vast instrument culture in sky, and how to improve at playing
- Idle dancing emote (Similar to certain stims ADHD/autistic people have)
- Singing instrument/voice
› Turns the player's voice into an instrument where they can sing
» Appears as a microphone - Messy hair
- Short-sleeve shirt with super baggy sweatpants
Knowledgeable Historian:
- Teaches about the history of Sky and how things came to be the way they are
- Deep voice (Like even deeper than the fish call)
- Super long trench coat cape
- Double-bridge glasses mask
- Ruler prop for measuring height
——————————
Oh! The ultimate rewards would be:
- Freckle mask
- School uniform (male and female versions)
- Backpack necklace accessory that hides your back prop inside so you don't have to constantly look at it
Forehead kiss at the right heights could make it an actual kiss or a kiss in the belly button
I’m not sure about modern human school-themed season since I think a lot of people don’t have fond memories or pleasant associations with school… BUT it could be like disciple-wise guru type theme that goes along with the other traditional cultural themes of sky seasons. Maybe like Tibet or Indian inspired?
Dark I see you still awake 
coughs #wishlist-and-ideas-archived
Aw, it's a cute idea!💜💜
Oh, my apologies 
It's ok
beta chat sometimes transform into a wishlist 
It's hard to hold back after seeing the new content.
It does tend to be a wishlist channel during these times
Hello, I want to ask if days of summer might be returning and when but I didn’t want to discuss in gen chat because beta spoilers. Can any of you help?
Apparently, this is how this often translates from Chinese I learned. “Care about each other” = “mutual heart exchange.”
We don’t know yet, we’re still testing Days of Rainbow & Anniversary event
Ok, thanks for responding
Also, keep in mind that just because we test something in beta doesn't necessarily mean it will go live. There are a bunch of things players have tested in beta that never made it to the live game. (Shepherd System, invisicape, resizing upon rebirth are a few of those things)
if we resized after rebirth every time i'd cry i like my tall
No update week: having sky kids eat the scenery and testers go increasingly insane since [insert year when beta sky began]
aka BETA Test vacation
Is this the official new season content?
I remember reading about the resize after rebirth as a moth and getting excited for doing my first eden run because of the possibility of becoming extra tall or small... I was so confused when that didn't happen
We currently don't have anything to test at the moment
be it so
Performance season testing just ended a few days ago, and we are waiting for the new Days of Rainbow event to be added in, probably on the next update but we don't know for sure when it will come.
Next season testing will probably take at least a few weeks/months to start.
Didn't the performance season test end yesterday afternoon?
It was supposed to end on the 30th, that's why seasonal candles disappeared on the last few days, but the guide and constellation remained due to a bug
But yes, it ended for real yesterday at reset
oh oh
hi hi hi
Are you Chinese?
Hello! Do you need anything?
I have, I have.
I'd like to know how often to distribute some test suits.
Invite waves come out when the devs need more testers.
It could be months, it could be weeks or it could be tomorrow, we don't know.
Well, thank you.
You're welcome 
Speaking of wishes, I want smooth long straight hair that’s all equal length. I guess it’ll look like a blanket lol
The season just ended, new beta season probably comes out 3 weeks later but who knows? Just my useless prediction
And yes i know they’re working on it, hope it’s something i always wishes for
Are you sure about that…? 
Would have been nice if you counted all past seasons before saying always, and "will always" in beta is a not existing phenomenon 
I just noticed sometimes follow arrow appears even if there just strangers around
Hm seems like it pops up now when stranger follows to light you
i think it does yeah
It pops up in live already and not only when they follow to light you. Happens when both parties fly too, which should cancel follow to light.
Another bug I’m getting is randomly bringing up chat dots as I touch the middle of my screen while flying.
Sometimes with nobody else around me, I should add.
hello I have a question
how do you get the tgc cape when your already in beta?
Just like live you have to ask for someone to take you in
Or wait until we’re testing something where the office is open for all. But generally, everyone in beta has the cape, so you can probably ask a friend.
ok
hi, beta players, will tgc fix the live server meditation friend note bug in near future update ?
No one knows devs plans because we are just players getting stuff for testing. Report as a bug and be sure devs will work on it. For how long, depends on bug type and hardness
id say a better answer would be routinely check #beta-known-issues
Why are there 9 icons on performance guides tree and in beta 5 Quests?
Are you taking into account the emotes you get to perform with the guide?
Soo you get to do a bunch of dances together ?
|| I don’t have beta but watch beta videos so idk||
Yep! Those kinds of emotes make the guide's tree look longer than how many quests are in it
Ooh ok Ty!
I can't continue season quests after the season ends
i cant send messages in sky, what is going on?
Can you say what contents of it you send on that message is?
Nvm, I guess it was in-game translation was disabled that cause people can't chat. You can't chat at all
Sooo any idea if rainbows will be later in live ?
We won’t know until it’s announced in #news, the delay announcement (from #beta-announcements) mention that it’s likely to run in July instead of June
Pretty much poking at #beta-announcements with a stick. Update.
I need beta test link
was just boutta ask if we had a rough date for days of rainbow 😭 uuuugh whyyyy
Beta is full right now, you'll have to wait for an invite wave
The delay was due to feedback & further develop the event, this is the only time I’ll ask to be patient with devs
Well, Devs confirm that the Days of Rainbow will land at least on July or sooner June. Had to add more content to drain those candles

Will the blue concert headdress disappear after the 3rd anniversary?
The paper crown?
if you're talking about the anniversary crown then yeah
if you're talking about the one in the music shop, it will only disappear when the season ends
thanks a lot
Ooh so the musical note pin accessory is gone? 
yep it is!
Now that i think about it, the reason i found the DoR guide this year to be a little lackluster from its tree was because last year, we had a big tree of trail spells. But i guess we dont need that big of a tree anymore since the spell boat now has the trail spells
that doesn’t seem right tho? (responding to the music hair pin being gone)
what do you mean by not right? 
Manta Cape and Jellyfish hats when?
Ultimate rewards don't return, so no manta cape. Jellyfish hair can return with TS.
Sounds like fun ideas, but not really beta related.
Agreed. I also felt this year’s DoR is lackluster, maybe if we could actually buy from the spirit those changing colour trails? Idk
Last year we were forced to buy the coloured trails before accessing the already expensive cape, so I think it's better to have them available at Ark instead.
i'm not sure if it's because of last year's mass harassment problems amongst the community but it feels like they "minimalized" the rainbow in this year's days of rainbow stuff 😭 i'm still not okay with the pants (submitted feedback already)
It would also be nice to buy a few extra spells from another guide/spirit
It doesn’t have to be the trail spells too :3
They're reworking the whole event.
That was what we wanted last year, so thankfully it is being changed this year
IDK, but trail spells is the best. I was Hoarding it almost every day 😆
Okay, one thing I always wonder: why does TGC take so long to add basic and simple things to their game.
They just took 2 years to add an audio option and it didn't even work well when it came out, and now they're going to release an old message history option that you can see these messages through the scroll, Dude, this was supposed to be something that should have been in the game a long time ago, already at launch, and not something that arrived in almost 3 years.
And don't even say that Tgc is a small team, they don't have time and these 2020 excuses.
i feel like they really need better programmers
somehow EVERYTHING manages to be buggy in some way or another
I think their idea and focus of the game changed slightly over time. It used to be really cryptic experience and emotional game. They probably didn’t know it will become what it is today
nowadays they focus more on making cosmetics to sell than on game quality
That's why we don't have new things anytime soon
Well yes because a good amount of people mostly focus on having new cosmetics and the next big thing. We had an amazing Halloween event last year and this year there’s the challenge of surpassing that (to give an example). I believe it must be overwhelming all these new ideas they have to come up with, wanting to please everyone when it’s impossible! And I don’t think programming it’s so easy to do either… someone say already that we’ll never get the game fully free of bugs. I know is not a small team anymore probably, but they’re still human beings. The game has cycles, there’s gonna be amazing periods of time for the community and the game experience, there’s gonna be bad periods and some greys in between
Anyways, those are my thoughts. There’re other sides to the matter (sorry for my rusty English)
The krill have been trying to scan our QR codes all this time and just thought that getting really close will help the scan. They just wanna be friends
Monster eye scanner 
context in sky memes
yes
I think you’re missing the point, bugs are apart of programming. Nothing is perfect, theres always is going to be bugs. And you know? You’re just going to have to deal with it.
But you know what. Bugs are essential to everybody’s code no matter if you feel ashamed of it or not. They are like mistakes that help guide you through it and of course there will be more errors within the game as you play it, but that’s ok. Because nothing, like in life, is perfect and you should just be happy with what you have. No matter how infuriating it is to go through it.
You guys are the best game, you know, I'm still looking forward to the next season, because your game is so great. Do you have any news about the new map? I'm looking forward to it.
I certainly understand their side in this regard, yes they really bring cool stuff and new mechanics by events like: Geyser, turtle etc... but this seems to be something that was done in a hurry, Because in some cases your game even crashed because of that, so I think simple things like changing the sound, graphics and message history are essential things for the game and can't be missed.
Tgc taking so long to put basic things reminded me of epic Games for taking so long to put a shopping cart in their store, I know they are different companies but that's just an observation, I think they should focus more on game quality than making cosmetics that will be forgotten in the future
Like rainbow cape, autumn cape from Halloween, Since the game will eventually get tiring, it will always be the same things and Tgc will only stay with people who only buy cosmetics and the quality of the game will decline
lol meanwhile im still waiting for the game to give us any scrap of lore that they really havent given since the games launch
you sound like the type of person to defend ydev's if/else code 😬 most bugs can be avoided with good coding
Wait, let me rephrase that.
you... really don't know what you're talking about lolll
Yes, no game will be bug free, but sky could have as few bugs as possible to avoid certain future problems
If you meant it like that, that makes more sense then what Elliot said. 🤷♂️
try and see how well a game runs with hundreds of if/else statements lol
Yeah yeah whatever like as if you’d know im in a coding class to begin with. Anyways im not continuing on with this, bye.
LOL you started it. i suggest paying more attention in it or seeing a different professor 
elliot theres no reason to be this condescending lmao
maybe if they didn't attack me first while pinging me :/ if they won't be kind about it of course i'd be put off
I didnt even attack you wth?
Exploits ruin multiplayer games, that's why I don't like chibi fall
just take a look at this and form yalls own opinion
w/ever
my point is a lot of bugs have been detrimental to players
they just disagreed with your statement, thats not an attack? but sure
i dont disagree with your point though about sky really needing to just fix the bugs that cause the game most problems :/
Oh, I think I just got the wrong message from what you said. 😂
I can't wait to welcome the next season. Who knows the latest news?
my biggest problem is that there are a lot of bugs in live with BRIGHT flashing lights and no warning from the devs. it's ok though it be like that val!! np
i really wish they would focus on the bugs that could cause serious harm to people with epilepsy. and ofc people with anxiety having to deal with the krill but that's an intended feature so
also sorry ive been stressed and grumpy
lols they still havent done anything to spirit reliving where the camera just starts going everywhere and gives people motion sickness since travel spirits came into existence 
AHH i hate that part so much
i also rly don't like the sound mixing with the krills especially if you're wearing headphones
i think it would be fun to compile a list of sky bugs that have been around for say, over 8 months, that haven't been fixed yet
maybe plus stuff they have fixed like the hand hold bug on switch
i also just wish they would put some of that huge investment they got into the programming rather than pushing out new content
Hey it’s okay, we all been there. I hope you get to rest well and soon
that means a lot tysm 😭 even just peoples support can help
Allow some weeks to go by and come back to see if there’s news 
btw are the flowers in theater still not appearing?
It appear in the 2 entrance to the backstage
Is 🎼 accessory limited ?
I believe so
Okay but chibi fall leads to some seriously hilarious scenarios
Beta chat, is there going to be a free in game money instrument that lets you hold notes or what? Or better yet let you hold notes on all the stuff?
Ask the devs. We don't know what they're planning.
Guess thats a no on currently beta revealed things? Hhhhh
I suppose.
You can always browse the #beta-announcements channel for what is being tested in beta, but if nobody seems to be raving/raging about anything, there's not much going on right now.
you can also post stuff that you want to see in #beta-feedback !
I think it helps because at times there’s not enough time to reach certain areas the normal route so chibi fall Can really help, having to skip through multiple cutscenes can be extremely frustrating, and at times people don’t even bother to help you when you play alone, I’d like to see your side on how it ruins it, if you don’t mind 🥺
i agree, CF is really convenient because tgc expects there to always be 4 players to open doors in vault which is absolutely not the case
usually i'll go to vault and there is literally nobody there. if there are enough players ofc i'd help open them
Chibi falls are also cool because you can access cool oobs :3
Where is Chibi falls? Why haven't I seen it?
Hello beloved citizens! Skybot here to remind you all that if you are having trouble finding something in Beta, please submit that to TGC in #beta-feedback! You may ask here if you are struggling, but together we can help many Live skykids have a great experience
Remember to check #beta-announcements and #beta-known-issues as well!
Chibi fall isn’t a place, it’s a glitch - you can clip through the ground and enter out of bounds areas using it. I recommend looking it up on YouTube if you don’t recognize it from the description and would still like to know what it is!
Thanks, though I don't understand.
Does this mean that there is something on the ground that the dwarf master enters the model
Hmm, search for “chibi fall glitch” on YouTube if you’d like! It’s easy to understand when you see it! Much easier than to describe it. 
It is the act of the dwarf master entering the model (…or so I think). It’s not a place. ^^
I went to see it. I know.
🤔Faults like this, which are good for us, do not want to be repaired, and use the fault to collect candles to save time.
The team has removed spiral and the hovering trick. We might expect someday they will remove rocket and even chibi fall.
Believe me, some ppl will mock players who have been using this glitch.
It wAs NoT iNtEnDeD tO bE in ThE gAmE MeChANic, YoU aRe a FoOl fOr BeInG AtTaCHeD tO tHiS kInD of ThiNG
TGC staff stated that they are trying to keep OOB (most of them need chibi) as long as it doesn't interfere with game mechanics and development
I don't think they'll remove them tbh. That's like the most used ways to oob and they know it's a huge part of Sky
Sometime ago, chibi fall causing crash
And they fixed it
Yeah it was lovely, cuz we players have been relying on this "glitch".
I was just stating, some ppl here will mock us if we stand up for a beloved "glitch", like when hover was removed, some have the decency to degrade other players for complaining abt it
I think these bugs can take us to some very beautiful places.
This topic better fits in #general-sky-discussion because chibi mechanic is already in live for years now 
Just realized the musical hair acces is the same one but with diffrent color from the china verison 
Hi there!
Also in my experience i have had many times where there’s been enough people and i’ve just been completely ignored by people who break their way in instead of trying to open the doors 💀
the same logic works for people who use chibi fall and don't help others, you can say that this never happened to you but me and several players yes, And you can also tell me to wear chibi, but I don't like chibi.
@tepid schooner i hope tgc keeps the rainbow pants
ik some ppl aren't happy abt them bc they're re-skinned jelly pants but i hope they dont change em
i already put them on my oc cos i wanted the jelly pants but missed them by ONE WEEK when i was a moff
auuuugh the 40s cooldown is annoying
I'm not familiar with it since it's gonna be my first time catching days of rainbow, I thought they're IAP's but yet again I always forget I got Beta and barely make it to play since I got no friends
And same I missed the same ts when I was a moff 🥲
yehh
the rainbow pants are iap, they were originally $15 but the community complained about the price and they brought em down to $10
the cape is igp and so is the braid
i wish they were going to bring back the rainbow flower, but this year they have an iap for 2 smaller rainbow flowers
and the beanie is iap
I didn't look into all the rainbow cosmetics, I just saw the cape on one of my friends and decided I wanna save up for it :'
;-; it's 175 candles
i have 480 but man
that's gonna bring me way down
but i really really hope they keep the iap gay jelly pants
they will, its IAP
I got a question ! Once i done recording the shared memories candles some hours later my friends still cant be able to saw the candles , is it because i dont have likes on the shared memories candles?

well yea but i just meant i hope they dont re-design em
try standing right next to the candle and then having them tp to you?
your friends should be able to see your candles before they have 3 likes
edit: holy (honk) why is the chat cooldown a minute long 
What about dont even have a single like 
they should still be able to see them
your friends are the ones that give you likes
it could just be that they;re on a diff server
Ok! Thanks! I will try that

YES MAAM!
also try going to #questions-and-help if you have any more problems, they should be able to help 
Usually beta testing for a new season starts when there's a month left in the live season, so keep your eye out for that
my beta is giving authentication error
"no authentication information"
I can't get into the beta so
Hi everyone!do ya know when will the new season in beta start?
Is there any information about it like name or...?
Nope, only devs know
Most likely, there won't be any season news for beta in quite a while
where do u get the second guitar that looks like a triangle? i can only see the acoustic one on the table so idk if i have to get it somewhere else?
it's in the office in the same place you get the founders cape 
ahh tysm 
updoot 
Ooh, new update. I sure am hoping for a fix to the broken external keyboard support. People in beta have been thinking I’ve become anti-social.
Questions. Tons of them.
Rainbow trousers are missing :(
All the new rainbow stuff seems to have been removed
ngl, good 
Let's hope it won't be like turtle 2.0 situation
i miss turtle friend
The new harp is available too
Praying for this update for the manta suit bug (been a year now) to be fixed… 
beta: NEW UPDOOT!
the update: bug fixes and improvements
My prayers go to piggy crash fix and spiral coming back. But I guess they still need a few years
damn updoot got my hopes up 
Oh, so it’s not just me. After typing one message, I then have to un-dock and re-dock my iPad every time I want to say something to someone. I’ve resorted to mostly just honking and emoting whenever possible.
Yeah, same… it’s crazy. Blue tooth keyboards have same problem
There was also something similar that happened in either an iOS or discord update. Now, if I leave discord to open another app (like an Internet browser), when I come back, the message field is gone and I have to force close and reopen discord in order to type something. It’s really a pain when I’m mid-sentence and just checking spelling or the proper name of something.
I know what you mean with discord, though I suspect it’s a different type of bug. If you turn you ipad 90 degrees, and then turn it back, the keyboard field will reappear. The sky beta external keyboard seems to show random key presses. For example, typing starts to trigger menus, and screen button presses.
UPDOOT?
Bugfixes and improvements
wow the harp is.. definitely worth five dollars huh 😬
(that was sarcasm)
Ah, maybe the last bit is related to what I was experiencing recently while flying. Touching the screen to control navigation, chat dots (…) started to appear for apparently no reason.
What happened to the rainbow pants? They are gone? 
days of rainbow is getting reworked, so they mightve been removed to be redesigned or replaced with something else
Yeah, they probably just removed it because it's not going to be included in the 0.17.5 patch in live, so they may not even want the files to be in it anymore so people can't leak unfinished content somehow
did they get rid of the earring too? It was the best
Yes, it seems like the earring has been removed for now too, along with the double rainbow flower that was broken to begin with
can we talk about the harp 
They… have not fixed the external keyboard bug. 
Still doesn’t seem like they’ve fixed the bug of the triumph handpan sounding like it came from the dollar store 
/s
is the chat delay fixed?
hmmmm the harp definitely got a slightly upgraded design. Would I buy it? Of course not
still looks like a kiddy toy harp you'd buy your 5 year old nephew as a birthday present
Give us the majestic wonder of craftsmanship that wouldn't fit in most doors and will probably kill if it fell on the musician
Ugh external keyboard bug still there with new release. Will have to renew the bug reports. I sure hope this doesn’t make it to live. Oh, I see Ned already checked.
the ice rink is back to the way it is in live
i keep laughing at the harp thing-- who looked at the harp and said mhm yeah somebody would pay for this when we literally have a 5 heart version on the base game constellations
no more holes in the ice tunnels
i was honestly expecting the triumph harp to look really fancy, why does it look like the original harp but cheap and unfinished..?? it even has the same sound, are we paying for the music note on it or
Lol i thought it was big update 
I think if they reduced the costs to buy the IAPs, a greater volume of sales would more than make up for the lower prices.
that you will need to get to get elder hair anyway. The harp is required to finish the constellation. There aren't a lot of people who didn't get the harp
Same with guitar lol
Perhaps
the triumph harp looks like the person was crafting the original harp but gave up halfway
edit: i said crafting sorry ive been playing minecraft LOL
the chat isn't delayed as far as I can tell
Same the light in my eyes died the moment I saw a small text wall
$5 harp sounds the same
I am so so sorry for the devs but not a single soul is interested in the harp- it looks like a bad joke, not even the design is popular 😭
it does sound a bit different but still, not worth it
the $5 harps very existence deeply offends me
somehow the original harp looks better
If only the music shop instruments were IGC ( aside from the ultimate reward remakes ) 
tgc please read feedback the community is on fire and you are just throwing coal at it EJASKLGJHAG
Quite frankly, I already lost hope in the last build and will now be very surprised if this doesn’t go live. Which makes me rather frustrated because using the touchscreen keyboard is so impractical on my device for several reasons… I suppose quiet days are coming. 
Sorry DEVS, but no one will pay this much for the instruments in the music shop. You could’ve made a whole new set of instruments, like a cello, viola, violin, tuba, triangle, or something else
I don't hear a difference between the triumph harp and the regular one
the harp at least should be igc, $5 is still A LOT, and the value is higher in other countries
ppl were already mad abt the harp before we even saw it, i cant believe theyd add it to the game when it looks like that as if itd change our minds 💀 the whole triumph instrument situation gets worse with every update
The music sheets… they feel like they’re meant for the village theater’s performances! What are yalls thoughts
I want an harmonica, can we spread the word about it 
I wouldn't be mad about the harp if it was TALLER THAN HEIGHT 0 AND HAD 50 STRINGS
@elfin elk They could have made it sound more elegant . Referring to your post in #beta-screenshots-videos
I wouldn't be mad if the harp was instead a viola. 
if the harp gave me a candle for each note i played i still wouldnt buy the damn thing
Oh, have new sheets been added?
edit: Ah, that’s awesome!! Looking forward to checking them out after catching some sneep snorps! 
omg a triangle would be amazing
Same
the irl harp sounds more beautiful
Why must everything be IAP, stop with that because no one would buy. Instead make it candles or hearts.

I get that the team is busy and yada yada but there's no excuse for an harp reskin
at least let it be another TS instrument, but gee, WHY THE HARP
ikr
The holes in Valley have refrozen, but the lower polygon count still makes it look horrible. And snow drifts are still detached from the ground, etc.
i just dont get why it exists. the ts instruments and returning ults sure, but why a reskin for something you can get at any time for igc?
I think TGC needs way more time to develop each update of the game than they currently do rn. I mean the original base game took like nearly 2 decades to develop whereas seasons are taking a lot less time to develop. Like yeah they probably have drawn up various concepts for seasons early in advance but the actual development and implementation is like what? Lasting a span of a few months?
It is unacceptable at this point, not only that. These iaps are unnecessary could easily ne IGC items when they are remakes... The guitar for example " ah yes if you dont wanna wait a year for the pleading parent ts, buy this reskinned guitar "
Exactly. I’d rather see less iap and more ways to collect in game currency for cosmetics
At this point TGC should stop adding new things and fix the current problems
just wondering why the app store description is more descriptive of the update than the discord one especially with the "please visit our discord for more information" line that's always at the bottom?
yeah I think if they worked on one instrument IAP instead of bringing a whole bunch, it'll be more worth the money
i was really excited to get the returning ults at first, but watching it descend into more and more iap reskins of items that cost igc.. man
btw we can't buy any more trail spells? I thought it was a permanent thing
Ults to me cost like 10$ because that’s what the AP is worth
ever since they added the rhythm guitar and the harp, i wonder if they'll keep doing this with other existing instruments
Tbh they should make a collection of instruments package instead of individually have different prices for the instruments
I will only get these in beta, because they are free. I will not purchase any of this in global when it comes 
Imagine a reskin piano 
imagine a reskin of that round harp thing
Apparently, those were for Days of Rainbow testing, or so it would seem. They disappeared as soon as the event ended.
Instrument season pass that gets you all the instruments as they release 
Imagine them releasing a grand piano instrument 
Imagine.
i went from wanting to get most of the new instruments, to wanting none of them
im not buying any of these if they come to live in their current state and at their current prices. i dont want to support more decisions like this being made
I would love to have a triumph bell (I've been waiting ages for any of the two gratitude bells to come back), and even if its a reskin I'm willing to pay for it
But then again, making a free, basic instrument, an iap, even if of course we are not forced to buy it, it sounds offensive
For people with collectors fears or sky musicians, the harp its just- a horrible joke
seems so
They should just do the performance pass that includes the instruments in the music shop.
Were the rainbow trousers removed?
oh well, another winter piano but make us pay for it 
I have strong collectors fear but the fact that most of it are the IAP I have to just say no to them
they could just do an IAP pass into a sound proof music room where you could play any original instrument you like
If the harp had a diff sound itd be fine. Idc if its a huge harp or not so 💀
🌈 pants gone? I got the moth pants on when I logged in after update
maybe its good nobody likes the reskins, we can save our money 😔
I really hope we are able to get them back.
if you havent sent feedback yet i would recommend politely helping us reach out to the devs before keep burning the beta testing discusion 
The harp looks like a stone wing crafted by a child 
I didn’t rlly care for them so if they’re finally getting a makeover i’m excited!
At leas twice it unique sound I think
Hope TGC devs listen to all the people opposing these instruments and strive to make a package or bundle. UNACCEPTABLEEEEEEEEEEE 🍋
a C- elementary school crafting assignment
guys the iap harp does sound different !!
its slightly higher I think
yet again and again, no, no its not worth it
Correct me. The harp is not out yet?
If they are giving the pants a remake, will they reappear in the closet or will they make them buyable again.
if two skykids played the two harps with their backs turned to me, I wouldn't be able to tell who's playing which harp
tgc bring back the $15 ults I was so excited for them 
The harp is out, and the chat is burning. 
i was getting burnt out around bloom but performance rly made me start playing again, and watching all of this go down has just. made me not want to play again 
they will make them buyable again except for those who already bought them, so they'll need a new invite wave to test the new pants
From todays update right.
um, is it just me or this year's Rainbow cosmetics just poofed
They didn’t poof, they got stolen
Tbh I think the whole iap idea started going downhill when the season of the little prince happened. After that season TGC has been adding in so many iap
Ooh, opening a music sheet caused the game to freeze and the music continued briefly after force quitting.
That’s really not fair if they make everyone have to have a new invite wave.
I never experienced burnout but gosh the iap issue is making me want to quit before I spend a single buck more in this game 
They do it because then nobody would play the live game otherwise
Its getting out of hand agreed.
Beta doesn’t cost anything.
Lol my rainbow pants is gone
I hope the next season will be bomb or I will also stop playing because I can’t just spent money on a game

So we can’t get them again in beta isn’t fair.
They're probably talking about iaps from beta that end up in live. 
I think what Daka meant was not spending any more money in live lol
if they start new season testing and everyone just forgets abt the instruments i think i will go crazy
it will reach live if they don't change it, even if I'm a beta tester I experience things better in live with my people, and I am willingly paying stuff I alredy have in beta so I can enjoy it as well with my live group, the instruments were the peak of my excitement, finally!! I can take the handpan part instead of rogue!!
[but huh they raised the prices]
Ye same because everyone almost complains about the instruments and they will I bet forget about that theme and will start only about season
i mean, the sky music community is pretty big and striking
I had really really high expectations in the music shop
I honestly played sky for its music
Same tbh
Hello
so i was scrolling through #beta-screenshots-videos and i just wanna say what's the point of having an iap harp when you can already get one for a couple of in game hearts?? Like i still don't get it 😭 and the design is trash anyway imo 
So do we think because we have other rainbow IAPs but the pants missing that means we will see them potentially revamped? Ik we won't know until we know but that's what I'm thinking
.
Unless it's a bug I still have my other new DoR stuff
that's what everyone here is upset about too
We've been complaining about that for hours now 
Yeah we think the iap side of the game needs some changes...
I actually really like the design for some reason
but yes, the harp is bad and a weird idea for an IAP. It should have a lot more of the "wing" shape they're trying to go for.. and perhaps sound different.. and be larger.. and maybe just scrap the harp and make any other instrument 😭
that's the most likely reason they're gone or it's a bug lol
is it just me or the iap harp sounds like the guitar
Give us violin cowards not another harp ||/lh||
I remember people had all those cool theories about what the music shop would be (like being able to create custom sheets and share them with other Sky kids), which made me think just now how nice it would have been if they had put more care into the community aspect of it all instead of… well, adding more cosmetics (making them all IAP is just a cherry on top).
my rainbow pants got reduced to atoms
I now have the sad 
there should be a triumph winter piano, i think thatd be neat since the winter piano used to be rhythms ult. for igc of course
Was the original harp 5 hearts?
I cannot recall off the top of my head
Ikr, the music shop polemic feels like a punch in the guts, when the map is wonderful and I friggin love it but when you first enter they just spit at you iap and iap and iap, not a single igc instrument
WHAT 
yeah the winter piano would've been nice
When will we get an igc instrument in music shop
imagine you go into a music shop thinking you can get a cool instrument for igc as a moth and see its all iaps except for some music sheets and a (currently missing or limited item) music hair pin 😭😭😭
Like here you can't have any of these take a consolation lolipop hair pin
Manifesting igc instrument please
My dream instruments are a bell and an harmonica!!!!
Come on its not that hard is it 
an accordion would sound great in sky
if you dont care abt music sheets then the music shop kinda sucks if youre an f2p player. you get to just look at all the stuff you cant have, how fun
my dream instrument would be a grand piano,
imagine if it was a placable instrument prop and once you place it you can just sit on it to start playing
plus it would be a great addition to shared space, everyone can try it out
I think they could just slap the flute animation on top of a little harmonica design, make it sound scrunkly and I'm pretty satisfied
the grand piano should also have more keys to play
Honestly amazing prop idea!! It would be cool if there would be enough room on the bench for two people to sit and play together!
Viola instead of harp👁️ 👁️
I don't care about music sheets I learn songs online but even as not a f2p player all these iaps are making me sweat 
Knowing tgc that would be an iap that's costly 
$20 probably 
A bench You say?!...20$usd
perhaps more since the anniversary guitar exists
The anniversary guitar was 30 and just a regular instrument. Go higher 😭
I want to forget that the anniversary guitar is a thing 😭
Anniversary guitar has no function and sounds like a regular electric guitar
honestly what does the music shop rly offer to older players or f2p players? if youre an f2p player you cant buy anything. it barely functions as a shop. if youre an older player there isnt much point in buying anything bc you already own all these items, but better. i bet most ppl would buy them solely for the design when the sound is what should be important
I don't even check if anniv guitar changes bc I just cannot express how much I dislike the whole concept of it and how it's a ripoff 💀
I wouldn't mind if the grand piano is a season ult
a man can dream
I took the liberty of pasting this message in #beta-feedback because it really resonates with My opinion!
The music shop its an awesome map though, the guide and stagehand are pretty interactive and I absolutely love to roam around!!!
But more than a shop.... feels like a museum, I cant even carry the instruments in my back
there are players who would buy them to flex
I wish you could take all of the instruments and play them in another area. Currently you can only walk away with the instruments that are played standing up
haha remember when you could walk with the electric guitar in hands
its great that the shop looks pretty but at the end of the day it should still be a shop, and currently there isnt much worth buying. its cool to finally be able to play instruments i dont have but at the same time, an area filled with all the stuff i cant have doesnt like, feel great??
in before the whole Rainbow cosmetics got legit scrapped and Days of Rainbow 2022 is cancelled
New instruments will have new sounds, I guess so .
Waiting for next updates.
they havent said anything abt it being cancelled, only that its being reworked and delayed to july 
Anyways, I'm runnign off, it was a pleasure talking to y'all! Have a nice night 
Is this mean the whole DoR 2022 Will get revamped?
Are holes in Valley patched? 
I'm an older player and I wish they'd put the actual instrument ults in there so the new players would get it, rather than these knock offs
. Plus if they added new instruments, rather than stuff like the remade harp. What about a much larger harp that you have to sit on a stool to play? Why does it need to be slightly altered models that still sound the same?
When the music shop first announced i thought that maybe ALL of the currently available music sheets including seasonals will be available for igc (on a rotational basis maybe? 🤔). I don't mind that we can't bring the instruments to other places but i just wish we have some kind of sound proof room 😔
yes the IAP harp looks like a toy you can buy at walmart
IAP harp only have 5 strings while the original have 7
i was imagining something more like a fancy gold or black lyre, not some kids workshop project that got thrown down the stairs
same
Oh also what came to my mind when it first got announced was that there would be a specific room where we could change the pitch notes (i think that's what it's called?) So we could play the instruments with whatever sound we like 
So many possibilities for instruments... And yet it is always the bare minimum...
The iap harp looks like it's made out of cardboard bruh-
If they're really going to bring a harp reskin I think they should wait for Days of Love and pair it with some cute baby angel wings as a Cherub Pack.
They also should go hard on the winged aesthetic. It looks like someones first woodshop project. Add feathers, make it look ornate and pretty! It's almost the same as the base game harp right now
sure but then it'll be $20
This is just me wanting cherub wings so bad
cherub wings as a cape 
the wings themselves would probably be at least 20 anyways, at least throw a fun harp in with it!
thats a really good idea! instead of the base game sound it could be a bit more elegant sounding. tbh i dont think the harp really fits for the music shop and doesnt really need to.. exist. but it would make more sense for days of love
but yeah like sol said then theyd make it cost $30
please i need cherub wings or something im obsessed enough with the phoenix cape as it is, i need more wing capes
well ive just seen the harp and i still think that the music shop is just a ||lazy|| cash grab and i mean i love tgc but its just aaaaaaaaaaa it annoys me so muchhh
Fitting since the Vietnamese translation is literally Children’s Harp
I wish the new harp had a more elegant harp sound cuz rn it's definitely not worth it
i think the biggest thing abt some of these instruments is i dont get why they have to exist. whats the point in a new reskinned harp? why does the office guitar have to be there? why should i buy the triumph guitar other than it looks pretty? why do these have to be iaps?? its nice to be able to get ts items at any time but i dont want to have to pay irl money for something that could come next week. its just taking advantage of ppl not wanting to wait some unknown amount of time to play an instrument
also agree @ micha it rly is starting to just feel like a cash grab 😔
the topic of wings and feathers reminds me of the Flight Ult feathers testing where people just straight up made it multiple wings like biblically accurate angels 
Idk if I'm just trippin' or if my senile self is kicking in but did the beta channels rearranged?
If it had a more elegant sound I think it would be worth it. And a slight colour change too. Other than that I think the actual design is really nice
the season chat sometimes gets hidden
I really don't think we need a new harp, especially in it's current state. Just seems like a quick cash grab, same w/ some of the other instruments
Maybe they could change the new harp to one u would see in a performance, taller and larger. Then maaybe it would be worth kt
I think TGC thinks this game is played by rich kids who are easy to fool into buying reskins
watch them make plead take even longer to return so more ppl buy the triumph guitar, bc lbr they have and will choose ts
I know about that, I just thought the channels were rearranged or I'm just forgetful like forgetful storyteller XD
Yknow after being funded by pixar i expected more... Guess i shouldn't have
Edit: they got a co-founder of pixar on board. Apologies, must've heard incorrect information
They were funded by Pixar??
they haven't been in a while, except the season chat
i love the rythm guitar design but idk about spending $15 on it :')
Musical Hairpin is missing/bugged in the Guide Tree right?
Pls i've been waiting for pleaful for so long i rather get the original igc guitar than the knock off iaps

Beta known issues made a statement about the missing rainbow items.
they weren't funded by Pixar, they got a co-founder of Pixar on board
Just wish they would put more effort into the music shop items, especially since they're iap. Mainly how they look, as the bugle and harp look like little toys for kids. But the sound could use work too, like I said earlier with the harp
i love tgc but even im not someone who has the money to spend on every reskin in existence
jgkhchluvvlclvh v omg its 1 am already
With days of rainbow being on 0.18.0 does that mean 0.17.5 will only include the 4th quest, music shop and the final quest? 
OMG IM IN LOVE WITH ALL THE NEW MUSIC SHEET
imo the triumph instruments should have fancier and more elegant designs than the originals, w more elegant sounds to match. like the bugle could sound prettier rather than loud and brash like the original, and the harp could sound more like an irl harp rather than midi harp sound
Beta testers' feedback is very important for TGC to create a good player experience! Please try searching for things yourself when possible, and remember to submit your thoughts in #beta-feedback so the devs know how to improve after getting an answer here
Remember to read all of #beta-announcements and #beta-known-issues too in case it's mentioned there!
I remember tgc saying that days of rainbow would be moved to July
ARE MUSIC SHEETS WORKING NOW??

The season is over.
They're still tweaking the last quests
id honestly rather they just bring the original ones back, it kind of hurts to know moths won't be able to enjoy the ult instruments i have ww
that and it would feel nicer to me to see them up on display for everyone to enjoy
I like the original bugle sound, great for blasting for fun, but having it on 2 instruments just doesn't seem right
Yeah ik i meant the update on live 
rather than two seperate instruments, more of just bring back the originals- not recolored, not with extra things or other sounds, just tributes to the season it came from all for new players who missed it to have fun with
Am I the only one confused by the music quest.......... Idk what I'm supposed to do 💀
I'd rather it be spells of the original instruments that last like an hour or more that you can buy for 5 candles
All topics about live should be in the propers live channels though.
it feels more inclusive to me for the ults to just be brought back, especially with sky being a lot about inclusivity and bringing everyone together and the like
it's not working rn
I meant.. yk what nvm 
Nah, I hope hairpin missing is just a bug 
What did you mean?
Good to know, thank you Sol 
yw and love the kitty 
I was asking what the content order on updates would be
since days of rainbow will be moved from 0.17.5 to 0.18.0, means 0.17.5 will contain the remaining performance quest?
i dont see why it wouldnt be in 0.17.5, rainbow and performance are unconnected
Probably so. Hopefully.
Oh man, it's time to delete 3gb worth of storage again
Yk what this time I'll delete all my downloaded vids 
what we wouldn't do for some bug fixes and improvements
why would they make a new 5 dollar version of an already permanent free item
it's not even prettier, like ???
Imo it should be like 50 hearts, maybe even $2.99, and even that's a stretch
the fact that tgc removed the 0.17.5 DoR cosmetics from the closet gives me some hope, mayhaps they'll be changing some? removing? adding some more? igc?
i feel like it shouldnt even exist...
True lol, I can't find a single reason why I'd even get it
if i see someone in live with the "harp" im gonna combust
It sounds like it was a bug. It’s in beta known issues.
I’m ok with the new guitar, even the handpan and such is great! But this is the worse thing I’ve seen in game so far hopefully they change their minds
omg hi kahz and arti why are yall here its almost like we were all just talking abou-
but i agree. its just... terrible. its really also a waste of a good name tbh
I was hoping for something with at least a pretty design but its hardly any different from the FREE permanent version like cmon, what a waste of 5 dollars
The free version is better /srs
they choose to remake a free harp instead of a VIOLIN
istg they are avoiding making a violin fr
This paid version is one, overpriced, two the design isn’t that good considering a majority think the free in game version looks way better, three, it seems like a cash grab but not even a good one at that.
i just had a good idea. tgc should make the harp and guitar igc in the music shop guide's spirit tree, since they aren't remakes of ults. they should make the ults iap, but make them cheaper... about the same as an adventure pass, due to each of the items being from different seasons. also, for the harp and guitar, make the guitar maybe a bit lower pitched, but a tiny bit louder, and give the harp a more magical tone, kinda like the original sanctuary handpan. (edit: also maybe make the tgc guitar a bit lower pitched, kinda like my idea for the rhythm guitar. they could get away with pitch changes with the rhythm piano, so just do the same with the tgc guitar.)
Wait question, why would they make a harp IAP when we already have a harp igc??? I thought the instrument IAPs were for the ult gifts 2.0
Does anyone know any statement by the Dev about the revamp of permanent instrument? I read about ult but the decision about harp is just weird to me
I mean... It's in constellation, igc, and the design is not that different from the og. Why do they need to make it IAP? 
Honestly idk

It sounds the same to the igc harp too
Tgc's quality with the recent IAPs in beta has been, frustratingly horrible
Also I noticed they changed up the music shops area, I haven't seen any mentions Abt it
I'm crying rn the new harp looks so..aksksjsnn
and it really sucks to see they keep making such decisions, I love sky a lot but these recent IAP decisions make me feel less happy paying money for things from tgc
sighs incredibly loud
It sounds the same too
Hajnabajhwjdhdheh 
I can just see the beta feedback channel
The new harp is fairly disappointing, the clear lack of care goes to show how they’re holding this IAP. It sounds the exact same, has a worse design than the in game which is only what, five? Hearts. If they would just listen with this tiny thing. we don’t need another harp that doesn’t even look better than the igc one
honestly even if the design was better than the original harp i still dont think it should be an iap
its so frustrating tbh... i really hope they recognize their wrong-doings and come back from this
they even angered popular youtubers, like noob mode and nastymold
the permanent free harp and paid harp sound the exact same, its just that the paid harp costs money and looks... awful, to say the least
can they please just LISTEN TO THE COMMUNITY????
i feel like this is just a grab for completionists, and a real low move to make.
in conclusion, there are so many other option for things they could add that the community actually WANTS, but no, silly harp that looks bad is good 👍
tbh? It feels kinda disrespectful tgc keeps playing this reskin items game recently, besides the beautiful recreation of a beloved ultimate hair, the stuff we're getting now is so depressing, barely any changes and they cost more than they should be costing
What’s up with the sudden boom of reskins, the penguin hair was cool because it’s unique in its own way and so are some of the instruments (at first) but then the anniversary guitar came out, the white guitar, the harp, the pants from DoR. I’m honestly scared about the future for IAPs, are they all going to be low quality like some of these (more specifically the electric guitar and harp)
The ult hair had a lot of work and care put into it, and it shows. The instrument reskins don’t look or sound like there was a lot of work put into them
i dont even get the point in reskin iaps of instruments that cost igc. if we're getting reskins of igc items, they should still cost igc. a change in the design and the fact that theyre always in the shop doesnt suddenly suddenly make them worth what they cost
besides.. id rather have new items anyway. it feels like bc we liked returning ults they took that as an ok to make iap reskins of everything
please no tgc dont turn into a pay-to-win ads everywhere game 
The reskins I understand they want to try and bring back old cosmetics and stuff ykyk
But IAP harp???? Now that, that is questionable
My thought exactly with guitar
Why isn't the music hair pin permanent in the shop? It doesn't have any correlation with the performance season to be limited
As for free items, I don't think there's anything else to buy other than some music sheets.
Sure guitar ,it looks cool and all but it’s just not worth money to pay for any instrument that you can get by regular means free,
was wondering that too, felt super weird that it left when performance ended in beta
The penguin hair gave android and switch players a chance to experience older alts they couldn’t get to experience or even players who couldn’t afford the seasons pass at the time. But half of these other reskins just feel like they’re trying to get as much money as possible as if they don’t already get quite a bit from events like days of fortune or days of love, they also get a fair bit from the ppl who buy the season passes and buy seasonal candles packs to complete the constellation quickly
I thought the music hair pin was to celebrate the release of music shop 
theres so many cool new electric instruments or fermata instruments we couldve gotten, but we just got instruments ppl will buy bc theyre sick of waiting for a ts. i feel bad for ppl that join after performance ends and feel like they have to get the office guitar, bc who knows when musician will return?
dear tgc.
GRGARGGGRGRGGRGRGR
why, just... why?? reskins are just bad and lazy, and making them into IAPs????? no. feeling like deleting sky right now.
your humble beta testers
Im gonna go submit to feedback and pray they get their act together with this stuff bc its getting ridiculous now
dear thatgamecompany,
SCREAMS
sincerely, your beta testers
I wish they’d work on something actually important like I dunno maybe the travelling spirit system? With how many spirits we are getting in the mix plus with some being or going to be fairly expensive (looking at flight and dreams especially). I wish they’d do smth to actually improve the game
||starts barking
||
Remember how many versions of the ult hair there were? How many times they refined it, and in the end they chose the design that was the most popular with us. Why can’t they do the same with, say, the anniversary guitar? Or the triumph instruments? Why do they put so much work into a season whose ap is $10 but don’t put a similar amount of work into iaps that are $20-30??
I love the new handpan design but why is it so much more flashier than the ULT from sanctuary. It shouldn’t outshine an ultimate in any way shape or form
iaps that shouldnt even be $20 or $30
it gives them the dough so thats enough for them 
..i mean, what do you want them to say? sorry handpan owners, we'll just go make the triumph handpan uglier now to make you feel better
Then improve the ults, give the ults a new reskin that’s free. Like an updated look or something for people who own them or make the new instruments less flashy as to respect the older ult instruments
Tbh the og handpan design is kinda meh
Why do the newer instruments need to be less flashy though?
I’m not saying make them uglier but like the two hand pans. Which would you chose? The new one which has tassels and looks kinda like a turtle or the hand pan ult that looks drab and used
Every update it just feels like we all get angrier lol God I hope tgc does something to make up for all this because they've been doing more harm than good imo. Like the good nuggets of stuff are surrounded by mass bitterness.
Yeah in other games reskins are typically purchased to apply to existing items
yeah, i would choose the sanct handpan. i think the new handpan is kind of ugly
The ult sounds so much better too though,.,.,.,., and its not like players can get the old one so giving them a boring version just cus they joined sooner sucks
to make up for it make all the ults come back! /joking
Is the rainbow day gift packs missing? Double flowers, earring and trousers 
Rainbow iaps will return to our closets right?
(Tbh I would too, I love the colour) but the new one is cute in its own way. They can’t satisfy everyone but why make the iap for the new one double the price at least make it like maybe the black and white capes and make it 50 hearts
When triumph instruments first came out, their colors were more subdued. I’m not a fan of the saturated colors in the current design
Why not give us more igc items why can't there be equal iap and igc items released for music shop...?
Tbh what I feel about the updates was more to.... Confusion. Like why would they do it? 🤣 It's just incomprehensible
I would rather them just straight up re sell the season then try to resell just bits and pieces of old seasons as a quick cash grab
There’s just a lot of iaps as well with the music shop which is weird considering how much sky revolves around music and it’s instruments and sheets in game
Triumph igc for 150 hearts 
Honestly just i want the old sound. The new handpan makes it a lot easier to memorize percussion parts of music sheets but the sound itself is horrendous
Yes, with the 0.18.0 build, as stated in #beta-known-issues
Cry in no friends
What's new that they changed?
the triumph instruments being better than the original ults is totally subjective. i think the triumph instruments were given designs to fit triumph and the music shop, and they shouldnt be boring or worse bc otherwise original ult owners feel bad abt their ults. if you feel the new handpan is better, get it. at least original ult owners have the option of choosing which one they can use, i can only get the triumph ults when i like the originals more
I’d rather wait months to get the instrument over paying around 27 dollars in CAN money to get the handpan or any of the new instruments
is the rhythm guitar the anniversary guitar?
the influx in typers XD
It's the blue reskin of the electric guitar
I mean at least they’re releasing the instruments some of us could never touch so I’ll stick with that
#beta-discussion
tgc: 🧑🦯
#beta-known-issues
tgc: 🙇
I really hope they really listen to us this time, their attempt to "fix" what they were doing really hasn't even fixed a thing
that's the anniversary guitar
Isn’t that hacked tho?
In the music shop you can test out instruments you don’t have correct? Are the ults there as well? I cannot remember because I’m honestly satisfied with that
Im trying so hard to give tgc the benefit of a doubt, but its getting harder with each beta update
Bug fixes and improvements. But currently, the discussion is aimed to the recently added IAP harp. The sound is similar with the one you can get from the constellation
That’s still not something we should discuss here then though, imo?? Idk it gets a little fuzzy but the general rule is that illegitimately obtained content like that isn’t up for discussion here…?
Yes, it's in the #rules to not discuss any content that is acquired through illegitimate means.
me who was about to bring up that point: 🧍
Let’s just say, I hope they add in a violin. It would be cool surprise if it showed up in the music shop but I’ll stop talking about the hacked concept I kinda forgot sorry
Someday…. 
It’d be really interesting to see them add in a new instrument into the shop after completing the season or doing some sort of task and boom, Theres a new instrument. I’d say make it hearts like the other perm con instruments but make it harder to acquire like maybe 75-80 hearts??
the concept of adding a violin itself isn't against the rules when it's not about illegitimately obtaining it, so lets talk about if we could get it by tgc adding it to the game
i want a note-hold violin so bad
sustain?
Dw we have moved on illegitimate ways of obtaining it! But as I mentioned, it would be cool for them to add it in game into the music shop to igc
Violin !? Cello when? 🤔
Then we can have a kind of full blown season of orchestra
season of middle school band 
ahhh i used to play the cello it would be so nice considering the bass instruments we have now... don't sound great
harmonica when
What I want is a clarinet or a trumpet! I desperately want to play the instrument I grew up on as kid which was an actual trumpet
Conductor sticks(baton) as ultimates!
Saxophone when? 👁️ 👄 👁🗨
this gives me a season idea hehe oh boy
we got the theatre kids and now we need the band kids
i would love a clarinet!! or a bassoon
sky grand piano when
My season im making actually has baton sticks as the third ult haha. There’s also a clarinet and violin in my season as well 
Ooo a 🎷 Sax even...
organ in sky when?
i hope they add instruments with more octaves or just an advanced mode with all notes pls i beg 😭 😭 😭

asking tgc for a violin is like being a frail victorian child asking to go out to the garden to see the sun one last time before they die of the black plague but tgc is the mother and they victorian child ( #beta-discussion ) will never see the sun
I need a full drum kit 🤌
Season of music battle!
Season of dance battle!
Imagine a Tuba or trombone 
i want a theremin powered by diamonds
or just anything actually new at this point 😭
"please sir, can i have some more 😔"
church organ when
Playing the Theremin would cause you to lose a tiny bit of light. 
otamatome when
Can we actually have drums in the game that have drum sounds not whatever the drums in game rn have 😭😭 + I want a piccolo
the real question is how did that victorian era child get the black plague
i was thinking about the piccolo but would it sound too similar to the switch ocarina?
actually why didnt they make a clone instrument of that so poor ppl + people who dont have switches can get it
crab otamatone
That's..oddly specific 👀
Getting bit by a flea or mammal (like a rat) infected with Yersinia pestis. 
oh i know yersinia pestis.. i know her well
More likely to get bagpipes than a violin at this rate lets face it x
That's good, i will play it in the middle of the storm and say "do you fear krill? " to my moth friend
Bagpipes would be amazing ngl
People today still get the Black Plague. It still exists, it’s just rare
is the rainbow beanie hair in beta for days of rainbow?
Does the hatp sounddifferent from origibal harp?
I don't get why they can't bring back old rainbow flower and have it be like past charity items where 50% of funds go to charity. I don't want double. I want asymmetrical look.
would like more igcs for days of rainbow 
Oh yeah for sure. I have sent in a bunch of art people have made including my own of items for rainbow. I just also really loved the hair flower.
so.. nothing really new besides a harp heh..?
It is updoot day my dudes!
(Yes it’s a Vine Reference)
They fixed those music sheets you can buy in the music shop, so that's new
Where should I apply for qualification?
📱iOS/Android: Learn about the sign-up process and how to get notified when invites happen in #beta-faq!
Switch: The Switch Beta testing period has ended with Live launch. All future content testing will be conducted on Mobile only.
I was about to check if the music shop was different in Live but then I remembered that quest hasn’t been unlocked yet lol
theremin is one of my favorite instruments so its something I think would be really fun to make
so hopefully someday! 
Also believe me we do hear you re: violin!
One thing is there's been some tech stuff needing solutions before it could/can exist-for example sustained notes, which just got it's first instrument with that feature in Performance! 🎸 But I do see you, wishlist posters 👁️
tl;dr: WAFO for now 
The fact that a violin has even the possibility to exist has made my day
Definitely!
Sustained notes was definitely a big feature hurdle before, I'm thrilled now that we got it since it opens up a lot of new opportunities! 
Since before it was implemented as a feature, I'm sure no one would want a violin that you could only pluck the strings at instead of getting the usual glorious sound 
this technically isn't beta related, but ash is here so i might as well mention this, i kinda hope the next season is more of a cooking based season, allowing you to prepare meals for your friends that gives wax and such. one of the pants for the season could be an apron that makes you slightly chonkier, idk. anyways that's my stupid tiny idea.
Theres also always a few other hurdles to jump over (like making sure items match the characters and narrative of the season is one!) but i am pleased to confirm to you all that tgc is not an anti-violin organization 
Never give up on your wishlist ideas. They might come true ✨
Lmao Ash I am so happy 🤣
Will past instruments like the harp, horn, flute, and other seasonal instruments get the held note upgrade or will they stay the same? It’s okay if you can’t say anything about it yet
Personally I'll usually go through wishlist or feedback channels for one when a season is in early development, i know others do the same too!
Also I honestly can't tell you either way-as I don't know myself! I don't really foray into the musical side of things (for good reason, I'm rubbish at music 😂 ) so thats a bit out of my sphere. HOWEVER this would make an excellent feedback post if you havent shared it there already!
So electric bass coming soon? There aren't that many bass instruments so having them would be great
Is the Musical Hairpin bugged or it's supposed to disappear when the season ends?
Can u make a riddles what's next in BETA? ||Pls don't make me overeat the WAFOs
||
how about a set of drums?
I can say that there's definitely going to be more sustained note instruments coming in future seasons etc however, now that the option is available! But whether the sustained feature will be applied to past instruments-that I just don't know myself. 
A season that focuses on musical talent would be awesome (I'll include this on the wish list tomorrow)
Season of Orchestras 
Yeah or season of symphony
Very basically, a bit more info about my idea since u actually reacted to it, is basically that a group of chefs have come to the hidden forest to prepare meals for all the spirits, but they seem to have lost confidence in their cooking (possibly due to a karen). Anyways, so you, being the generic overpowered main character that solves everyone's problems, must prepare meals for the chefs so that they can uh... do like... a thing. Idk I had an idea but at this point I'm just starting to wing it.
Was this closed-off room in the music shop always there, or is it new, too?
I am trapped in its window
I agree with this. I thought it would stay after the season cuz I didn’t have enough candles to get it during the season 🥲
making riddles on the spot is a lot harder than it seems but here goes 
||I strike without warning, yet many anticipate my offerings. I am whole, yet made to be broken; soon to be formed by many.||
the answer:
||beta bug fixes and new features
||
I hope rainbow pants get made to be less jelly whisper look alike
that is my wish since rainbow revamping is happening
The room is opposed to my entry
Hoping that we can get a proper folk/concert harp in game (not just another lyre, as nice as lyres are)
Patiently waiting for a very fantasy (DND) themed season
(Yes I just want elf ears, but I also want a spell book to spam effects-)
I have succeeded in getting into the closed-off room in the music shop
'Wingardium leviosa' The true table driving 
I want an elf ear item but like head accessory so we can wear with any hair SO BAD 
When will you be qualified?
Tomorrow
I wish the white guitar go back 😢 why update it, I'm about to pay that in live
wait, white guitar doesn’t show up in current BETA?
◖ I love how my first reaction to the rainbow pants being gone was “ I'm without my 'loons ” 
Mom = Harp + Dad = Electric gituar
Their kid = Electric harp
the white guitar is still there, i was playing it earlier 
i think they were talking abt how the tassel on the guitar was removed
