#beta-discussion
1 messages · Page 881 of 1
I hope the shared space I can use bookshelf props to decorate and show something like a prop or pants and cape
An extra tree house is such a cool idea.. or maybe decorating the existing tree house and sharing that decoration! And people could have an invitation to join your treehouse but they could opt to not
I should also say that using a controller makes placing props completely random, so that functionality really needs some work.
Shared spaces is a neat concept, but what worries me most is the lack of options for newer players, especially once assembly ends. Maybe if there was a small shop set up by the assembly qg to buy items solely for your shared space (like tea table, swing, maybe even bonfire etc) it would open up new decoration options and allow players with less cosmetics to make a space with something more than the 5 or so base items we have now.
*cosmetics
I like the idea of having a personal space in game but i don't see myself using it that much because i mostly play alone
this is not a feedback but imma say it because whirthun is here, can we have a personal home space like we had in light awaits
Just throwing this out there as it hit me. Going all the way to the treehouse, sitting down to set up your space to then potentially hopefully share it-- it's quite cumbersome when you can in theory do the same in home space with a couple friends. I feel maybe the location isn't the best? Don't get me wrong, it's really cozy, but you do have to put in a lot of effort to traverse to it. Maybe, the shared space could be small as it is now, but adding spaces elsewhere in other realms and home? A small treehouse, kinda secluded from the "main hub" to chill out and talk could be quite calming-- at least for me. Though i can imagine the number of issues an area like that could impose on new players being placed in home. But i'd like to definitely see more shared spaces in other realms, so you have more options-- could be a treehouse themed after the realm it is in. So it correlates to the season and quest you do to unlock it from
If schedule will be followed, Live Sky on Switch will be released on June 2021 (TBA). I'd suggest wait on Live release, since it's not that much time to wait anyway, imo.
I think the new office is a better space to play in tbh... ;-; I can use it for video making and a lot of other things, if it’s based on just the props I own, then I don’t see many use cases for it...
I really miss the personal Home space we had back in old beta/Light Awaits. I think it would be much more useful than this shared space, tbh.
Oh and you can still talk with friends while you are in editing mode but i d like to see more little space hidden in the realms
I like the idea very much and I particularly love the place that has been chosen! The treehouse offers so many fun activities and the shared space could help to keep it a busy and appreciated place ❤️ Having a wardrobe installed there would be very nice.
The fact that the terrain is very uneven makes me wish I could have more influence in how and at what angle, etc. I can place the various items.
Thank you for all the hard work and thoughtfulness you put into everything concerning the game ❤️
If all the 8 people in the server are friends with eachother, it would be great fun, but if there are 2 different playgroups, it creates unhealthy environment, and they'd be competing for that time slots to share place and flex. It would also be ego battles of "you leave the server" vs "no you". It can be greifing for players.
I wish the game gave us more opportunities to interact in the sense of activities like hide n seek, I think the pillow is a huge missed opportunity for what could have been a great mini game of musical chairs
I do also feel that the shrine you sit down at to go to your shared space is going to be quite confusing if you come into it blind, i knew what i was looking for (thanks beta screenshots
), but others might not. it looks like a regular meditation shrine, it would be neat if it had another motif that we can uniquely relate to shared spaces only.
If i share my space and if someone else shares their space my space would disappear and i wouldn't be able to share mine.
This could be a huge problem in live version because of so many players.
Or for that matter, how the bookshelf could have been used for storing cosmetics that you could share with friends... and they could wear them in the space for a while
Are we talking about roommates 
And also result is players literally showing off how many props they own — which in the game you can earn by either purchasing the IAP or by having participated in assembly for now
If you did neither, I think all you can own is pretty much the table (if you didn’t do any activities from assembly)
I feel its small too, and besides what the others already mentioned i miss some color from it. Majority of our props are bluish grey which is not too noticable if we only put down one thing but when its 10+ i had the feeling i moved into earth trial land 
Yess,
people can confuse it for return shrine like there's in sanctuary and ark
i wonder if we might need more visually interesting decorative items (things closer to resembling toys, like the pinwheel) -- shared spaces feels like it's trying to go for the same appeal as "decorate your own room/house", but something about the currently available props as well as the location right now aren't really hitting that appeal for me personally -- i feel like the currently available props lack that sense of personality/personal interest that really makes that kind of activity appealing
maybe they could combine that with aviary and bring it back as a personal space... 👀
I wish we could have lil neighbors!
mostly just so i can go "✊
dinkleberg.."
The treehouse has already most of the props. And it isn’t the best place to have a camp when you already have a huge and beautiful treehouse next to. I wished to have the option to make collisions available for other players. But right now the locked location doesn’t seem the best and the area is quite small. When I try to edit my space, I fall or enter treehouse and then everything goes poof. I have to restart editing. Also there are lots of crash and the menu being active on screen all the time limits the movements of the player while trying to place props. Also I don’t understand the number yet since we can’t really place more than one for each. I really like seeing my friends being able to use my props and have fun together. But I hate it being locked to one really small place
I think the other thing that’s missing is an incentive to join someone else’s shard space... for now I can see it mostly being to try out a prop you don’t own
But what it should be is to play an activity or a game together.. something where having more people makes the experience better, imagine the shared space being an area that dynamically changes from one person to another (an obstacle course or something), it becomes organic activity
currently all props just become chat tables, I don’t need a dedicated space for that, I love the dreams village and I’d probably take anyone there to enjoy the music and the snow
ahh i'm aware! i'm definitely planning to play the live version, but if possible i'd like to join the beta as well 🙈
tysm for answering my questions tho!!
I haven't been able to do the Assembly Quests yet so I can't test out "Shared Space".
The concept for Shared Space is very cool, I have to say that. However, based on what I can see on screenshots posted by testers, for my opinion, it feels "too small" considering we can place a plethora of props around it. It'd feel cramped if we were to place all props that we own.
I do have one suggestion tho, make it twice or thrice as bigger and since we already have "underground" doors at the Treehouse leading to different levels of Hidden Forest, why not create an "underground" door that leads to the "Shared Space" itself?
I see, check the pinned message here regarding that (just in case) , and hope that 2nd wave will be announced 
Please contact TGC by DMing @hardy carbon 
thank you!!!
I like the concept of shared spaces, but I wish there could be these spaces in all the realms, it would make it much more appealing and fun with friends and other players.
The area could also be bigger, and for a solo player it kinda makes it boring.
Add more players and multiples of the props for a solo player or an option to try/buy other props (tea table, swing, seesaw) as we can only carry 1 item.
I'll be deleting comments related to hacking now. Do note that continuing this topic or making jokes about it will result in mutes
Its strange we can only place one of each object, and i hope more than just this season’s objects will be added. This random assortment of dollhouse items can’t really make a cohesive space yet
I ended up in a meeting, but am reading through all of your feedback now. Thanks for taking the time to type it out! I promise it's not in vain 
have a great meeting! we'll write up some more as we test 
Oh heads up guys if you try to place something on top of a wardrobe it will shoot into the wall and crash your game
I haven't got to test Shared Spaces much (mostly because it crashes like Beta does when I'm nearly done decorating and I need a moment to calm down
), but I really like it so far! The placing and camera controls make the whole thing extremely frustrating though. I wish you could place something and still be able to move it around before pressing a "confirm placement" button of sorts, and that the camera would stay in place when you're decorating 
I'm not trying to dismiss your point or anything here, but building a mobile platform secret area equivalent, wouldn't that constitute as "exclusivity" itself and wouldn't that contradict your statement?
But we have the office...?
I get and understand your point but isn't "Nintendo Area" available for everyone tho? They can always ask a friend (who own the specific items) to drop them off to that specific area itself. Just like with Office itself.
For the moment I don’t really like the shared space, I find it messy (after this is a new thing in beta that’s normal it is messy lol). But I think it will be great in the future ! Animal crossing vibes 
I am under the impression that access to the mario area will be like the office, where you need someone with the right cape to take you in. With that said, I thought the mario area is here to stay for everyone, just need to have a Switch friend to take you in.
You are correct
Yeah, and to be honest, it's not all that fancy compared to the office.
wait, did they add in the next season's preorders already? epic. just need shared spaces to b fixed noww
good news for you...
Yes but no, it crashes the game
Along with Assembly area, it would be great if other places like Sanctuary, Dreams village, forgetten ark, and perhaps social spaces (?) also had these "shared place" shrines.
True. I find it hard and feel claustrophobic given the restrictive linear movement.
It's just a perfect recipe for danger for my opinion, since there's Eden red ore and crabs
why did they not ping for updates?? im dying this is so hype
Its in treehouse for assembly, in a wide open area
Before, "The Little Prince" Season Pass Pre-order were available on Shop maybe by mistake or intentional, but who knows but it causes crash and now, it's not showing on IAP Shop anymore (atleast for me)
I prefer shared space to be available in home space. Like, add an island off shore for that. And add more interactive functions to the props, so they are more than just props. Even just simple ones like, a seat function for the seat cushion. The ability to place items onto the shelf- have several add bottoms on the shelf and then we can choose what to put on it- could be our cosmetics.
In all honesty, shared space was underwhelming for me :(
Which part? Just curious 
And explaining provides better feedback on how TGC can improve 
I think my main issue with shared place when it loses the ‘new’ factor will be that there is not much we can do there which we cant do anywhere else (currently at least). I would like the idea of the editing mode being a private space tho but its not that currently.
I can't confirm anything on this front, but this is in discussion - the idea of having Shared Spaces locations in different realms.
I personally would play with share space more if it’s in home space, because I wouldn’t have to travel to a realm to do that, and I would have greater chances of bumping into my friends and have fun with them together.
Also, just the fact I would have access to my cosmetic close by~
Personally I have to say I don’t think I will be using shared spaces in live much
I have very few cool props in live such as the seesaw and the swing. I would love if the shared spaces items don’t have to be owned, and you can just choose from a selection. Also, I would love an option to close the decoration mode, so I can spend time in my space without others disturbing and practice playing music.
Reading through your feedback, I totally agree with some of what you're saying. This version of Shared Spaces is a first take and nowhere near what we would think of as 'finished'. We want all of your feedback on this, especially the 'meh', so keep it coming. We've already passed along one big batch to the team.
I thought when it had said to share your mind space that we would be given a link or something more private to give to our friends. Though instead it was with everyone in the instance.
Personally, setting up camp somewhere has always been one of my favorite things to do in Sky. I have spent several hours the past few years just hanging out with friends even before props existed, and they've just added more to that experience to me. I think Shared Spaces will be just like that, a way to do more of what we already have for those who enjoy it since we can place a bunch of props on top of props we carry for cozy greatness 
Share space with krills 👀
i actually like interacting with strangers... imagine going on CR and see someone setted up a little tea resting spot 
The one area of your feedback that I don't think we'll be immediately addressing is the point about props just feeling like props. That feedback makes complete sense, especially when it comes to how valuable a prop is to players, but there's no simple solve if that makes sense - something for us to put more thought into in the future.
You don't want that. We're terrible roommates. We knock stuff over all the time, eat all the Winged Light in the fridge ... sing loudly in the shower?
One of my favorite things to do when I'm bored is carry the swingset (or other props, this one is just my favorite) around and place it in random places so people can use it. It's really cute to see people hang out and become friends around a random spot you created 
Yeah, the swingset is a great example of an instant fun prop.
You bring it, and you bring the fun.
It's not that I don't want to hangout with strangers, just the wording made it seem like Shared Spaces is a place for you and your currently established friends.
edit: I reread the beta updates and I misinterpreted. Sometimes you just want a place in Sky that isn't home to be in with you and your 7 friends.
I wonder how often people get to see the spaces you have made, though?
I do that too. Love seeing people having fun ♥️
In addition to this, some people don't really own some of the items "available to be placed" on Shared Space but Spells exists for it (e.g Bonfire, Swing, Seesaw, Table) and I hope we could somehow place a spell for it as well.
I finally got to finish my Shared Space in beta, and I'm all
at people running around and using the seats and chatting
So far I've gotten a lot of merges and seen different Shared Spaces pop up too
Private parties
? But i agree at some level i had the same thoughts.
My sky pals are planning a get together in one of the realms and I immediately thought of Shared Spaces as a place we could go with all of our props and chill.
maybe having something to do unique to shared spaces would make them more interesting? because so far all you can do in them is sit and chat, but that can be done kind of everywhere... Maybe a minigame (like hoops) or something to pass the time would be nice
During days of love I did the exact same. Walked around placing a swing set. Sometimes to bring mischief to friends too 
It’s sweet seeing people take the incentive to use something you put down. Personally right now my favorite is to plop down hammock somewhere and seeing people sneep snorp 
anyone agree with my nickname?
anything new happen in beta?
Shared space added to assembly area
Only with the daily quests color
i like the less saturated version of the emotes etc.
I keep the shared space cleaner than my room tbh
are you talking about that really yellow ui color from rhythm and earlier or are you talking about the softer yellow one from more recently
if the former: no I do not miss that 
Do you still crash when you try to get the pre-order, or is the pre-order thing not out anymore
@spark lance the next season isn't being tested in beta yet, so I've removed your message. Please be aware anything you've seen isn't official 
oh ok, i saw a yt vid so i thought it came out??
If you don't see a lot of people posting about it here in the beta channels, it's not out yet.
Probably a lie to avoid getting in trouble. Do report them to @hardy carbon so TGC knows!
#live-feedback hi good afternoon i wanted to talk to tgc at the request of some friends about the cover of the event rainbow days the cover this sinples for 175 candles the colors are beautiful plus the cover model this slimples the players want me to change it if they use an old model like the old model of the supreme cover of the assembly season or something innovative like the cover of the ocean of the earth day event they want something cool like that cover something beautiful because most of the beautiful covers are paid for like the snowflake cover remembering that no are you talking bad about anything just passing the opinion of several players have a good afternoon
Pre order is removed from the shops
If you want to post in #live-feedback, you need to write in that channel. Devs won't see your feedback here!
You already posted that. 🙂 You can post it in the channel you linked in your own message.
So pre-order is over, or is it just for now until the bug is fixed? can't get onto beta rn cause im not at home lol
I really like the idea behind shared space since it’s as close as what i expected from assembly, having collison with other players’ props. But having a beautiful huge treehouse there already making it lose the interest. We have a lot of beautiful places in sky that we prefer to spend time and maybe have a little camp with friends. So it’s being area locked is the main downside for me. Other things I’d like to share are, players are not asked to enter someone else’s space. But when you share your place some are there only to edit their personal space. So you don’t really get to share your space with others when everyone is just sitting down and editing their own stuff and filling up the server. So I think it should work a little differently. I haven’t tested enough to see how long is the cooldown but it would be nice to let the player know when exactly they can share their space again.
Shared space feedback:
- I really love the idea that you can create a personalized space and chill with friends or strangers in it
- the timer and how it functions is still a bit confusing for most people I guess, like why can you only share your space once in the instance? Or is there a cooldown after you shared for the first time and do you need to wait for the cooldown to pass before sharing again? I’d like to get more text hint on it.
- lots of crashes happen in shared space (and in this build in general)
- it would be really cool, that in the same principle of shared space, you can have a private space (for when you want to spend some alone time in game - ie. When you simply want to practice instrument without interruption, or when you are just too tired to socialize but want to enjoy the beauty and calmness of the game). A way to have a private space but also let your friends know so that it wouldn’t seem rude to them and they wouldn’t feel hurt.
It was probably a bug, it will be available later when season is ready for testing
No one was able to accept it, they removed it due to the bug not being able to claim it. It will return later for everyone.
Please post this im #beta-feedback
"sky kids play sky irl"
Also, #beta-feedback 👀
I’m gonna do that, but since Whirthun is asking us about feedbacks I’m posting it here too. For discussion.
he asked us like 20 mins ago smh my head
Everyone please don’t clog the beta discussion with feedback. You can post it in #beta-feedback thank you 😌
whithun did ask tho
ok but they still read it in #beta-feedback so might as well post it there so these channels dont get cluttered lmao
I’m sorry but sharing my experiences is not clogging up the channel. What clogs up channel is the unrelated topics. So don’t confuse the two please 
This was exactly my point thank you
Whirthun specifically asked for feedback on Shared Spaces here and hasn't announced they're not collecting feedback anymore, so it's okay to share
While it's also true feedback should be posted in #beta-feedback as well so it gets documented there for all the team to read it
Someone know if is still possible to cr in vault with spiral glitch that also involves oob? And if is still possible to reach ||PNR|| by oobing?
Thank you in advance 🙏
i rest my case
You cant spiral from the second to third floors so i dont think so? You can from third to fourth
Not really since spiraling through walls crashes the game mostly.
going through any wall any way crashes the game wdym lol
Thank you for your answer 🙏
Please go to this channel #beta-feedback and post your comment. 🙂
dont post comments that have already been posted! it is basically spam
The timer thing was confusing for me too. When you guys removed your spaces and nobody has anything active there but i still couldn’t use the icon to share mine. Im not sure if it was because i did it once already when i first entered the area or why. I also crashed two times and it was still unavailable to share.
There was very unrelated topics here yesterday not even beta related. So It’s a little unsettling to think experiences being spoken here is clogging up the chat. We are also sharing our feedbacks and reports to respective channels
Occasionally a TGC rep will appear here but they arent here now, best to send in beta feedback channel
question; will everyone have the bloom teaset, swings etc in shared spaces comes even if you dont own the props?
what even is shared spaces
You can only use props you own
ok ty!
Well I was half way through carefully arranging stuff in the shared space... When suddenly it crashed

I was able to share again when I crashed or relog in. But it’s very confusing yes.
New area in assembly where you can put your props bring back gold ui
yes i want the old ui back lmao
also thanks
Cribley "Bring back gold ui" the speedrunner
Don't you talk about it often?
eh yea but i dont think anyone would've remembered lol
What is gold ui
old ui
Live ui?
Ui that's gold 👁️
When about will the beta test?
Please read #beta-faq 
That space is nice but yes there are a lot of other beautiful places that we wanna hang out with friends in. It would be wonderful if they could enable consensual collision outside the shared space too.
Where would I go to ask a question about the Switch Beta? I didnt find my invite email until today because it got put in the wrong folder, and my discord invite to the switch server isn't useable anymore
Beta testers' feedback is very important for TGC to create a good player experience! Please try searching for things yourself instead of asking here when possible, and remember to submit your thoughts in #beta-feedback so the devs know how to improve 
I really wish one day we can have at least one shared space per realm...I would love to build my cozy hangout place in Vault of Knowledge ❤️
!support you should contact tgc
Contact Player Support in-game: Tap the cog menu (top-right corner) ⚙️ → Tap "Support" → Tap "Contacting Us"
If you’re unable to access your game, you can contact Player Support by using this link: http://bit.ly/skygamecs
The wait time for a Support ticket may be several days, depending on the Support team's backlog. Your patience is appreciated! 
No, I don't think Support is the way to go for that. More likely ThatHelpBot.
It's the Discord server invite, proooobably should contact a mod or @hardy carbon instead
Might be best to DM @hardy carbon to speak with tgc staff about that.
it'll take a bit for them to reply
I don't know if the mods here are also mods on that server, though.
I wonder if it’s possible to make share space a spell? So we can establish a share space anywhere we want.
Oh, i thought both are the same thing ,sorry

Oh right, maybe not. Thought they would be 
Most of the mods here are mods there
Well then,
In game support handles in game issues, so not Switch beta invites, anyway.
Support through game is the place to go for account issues and the live sky support stuff. Contacting tgc and speaking with reps is more here
hope that makes some sense 
xynth memorizing all of the emoji names
they're in the emoji menu...
maybe cribley was talking about typing out the emote like :SkyLOL: to be
cuz I do that and often forget I can just click on them 

contact @hardy carbon and include your email address and the switch code sent to you in the message so we can compare it with our distribution list to get you a new server invite code. If you already messaged the bot, send a second message with the additional information.
Thank you, I will!!
Basically everything I listed out above to whirthun haha
Hello I have a question about the game for Switch. Does the game require Nintendo Online? I heard that it's a paid subscription and I want my friend to play Sky but she doesn't use Nintendo Online
It does not
You can read more about the Switch version here as well: http://bit.ly/SkySwitchFAQs 
Hello!! I just found out about shared space. How can friends enter your shared space? And can strangers wander in ur space?
you need to share your space first
What is a shared space? 
Shared spaces are better experienced in person, if you have access to beta. But it's basically a space you get to decorate and then share with others in your instance, and they get to share theirs too!
Oh ok. Thanks for explaining
I don't have access to beta, that's why
My sister is angry because of that, she wants me to get Nintendo Switch Online so badly 
Oh ye, do Switch players have access to a keyboard? I don't own a switch, so idk how it is
U can connect physical keyboard to switch, if u don't like the one on screen it's kinda bad
Shared space is now available for testing? or still pending to be added?
it's available now
Do you think bots can think?
Check the main treehouse
ok was figuring where it is 

Main treehouse, on the right side of the entrance there's a small staircase
HOW MANY TIMES DO I HAVE TO SAY IT.
YES.
Wow...the first shared space i encountered has everything from bonfire to all Assembly items

I was thinking about the prop numbering on the menu in editing the shared space... What if we will be able to use prop spells inside the shared space? That would be an indicator how many spells we have in our inventory. And also it would be awesome to use my bonfire spells in shared space 
I already sent feedback just in case you wonder
in cardi b voice That's suspicious..... That's weird 
i do wonder why there are numbers on them
On what?
props in the shared space
Are new players who start isle in their own server thru the caves? Wanna give good feedback but if they are alone it doesn’t really matter.
i wish they improve the Floating Ring so it gives feedback when someone jumps through it just like the real one (make sparks when you move through), now it is just a floating frame. It can be much more fun instead of becoming a mere deco item that does nothing 
What exactly are you asking?
When you start the game are you alone or can you be merged with other people in the caves?
We can already use spells in shared space no? It just works the same way as outside of the space (as one addition to the space you already created). I don’t really get the indicator of how many spells we got part can you elaborate?
I think it would be helpful if the newbie is alone for the first part of isle. And not distracted by somebody else.
On live you can be merged with others. I haven’t tested that part on beta yet.
I tried several times and I was consistently alone
Tbh I always thought that you are alone during the first part of it till you get to the temple ‘cause the two times that I’ve been a newbie, I’ve never gotten merged during the first part
You can merge with others during the first part actually. And I was able to follow a new born moth into the first part too.
I've merged with capeless just born moths in home and isle before 
I tried to say that prop spell being included in the multiple prop placement. Right now you can use spells apart from multiple prop placement. And you can’t use any other prop when you cast a spell. But it’d be nice to add bonfire to my shared space and wear my firework stick at the same 
But since you can use extra bonfire spell to have it in the space anyways, I don’t see why you need to have it when editing the space? Also spells are consumables so it seems logical to me that they get consumed when you use it for once.
But outside of the space in general, I’d love to have the ability to use a spell and my prop at the same time, and not having to choose one between the two of them indeed.
Is anyone else crashing all the time, specially on tree house map?
Yes, and in Forest brook map too.
I’ve had moths merge with me before when I was playing music in the Isle, it’s so sweet because you can tell in their head they’re just like “whoa.. you can do MUSIC?? Whole songs?? In this game??”
Awww that’s so cute
Sorry B I start to get your point now. You mean use multiple prop spells in the shared space right?
The idea of having it in editing area is so i can wear my own prop at the same time. Otherwise you can cast the spell anywhere anytime and it doesn’t make a difference, yeah.
Can i merge my items into my friend's shared space so we can work together to make a perfect place?
next stop: sneaking your friend to the edit area 
Ye that could be an interesting point. Personally I’d be ok if technically it’s complicated to implement and therefore not possible, but sure it would be nice to have more options
Inviting your friend over to your inner mind space for co-editing 
Right now chat still works when you’re friend is having a mind session. So that’s an interesting idea 
I can’t see my friend talking when I’m in editing mode tho. But friends can see what I say. I need to do more testing on that part I guess. 
no private monologue sessions in your mind palace? what it's this 
So, the shared space now is basically just inviting ppl to your home with only what you hv placed. I was expecting a place where we all can bring our fav sets of items and work together to complete a space we love.
shared mindspaces 🧠 
Next step: shared brain cells 
that's what I'd love to have, collaborating with your friends to make the perfect shared space 

don’t we already share braincells beta gremlins being beta gremlins and all
so we only can share space for 5 minutes?
You can share it longer if no one else wanna share. But yes five minutes is the timer for now.
I am sure sky bday lasts more than 5 minutes
(it is perfect to celebrate someone's bday there i mean)
oh my, if you're in editing space playing an instrument others outside the editing space will see and hear you playing - same goes for honking and chat
you can't interact with people outside the editing suite though, you'll be none the wiser
Shared Spaces have nothing to do with Sky's anniversary 
no i mean friend's bday
After 5 minutes a Shared Space has been shared, others get the chance to share theirs so everyone's spaces can shine
You can share it again after 5 minutes, and so on
You can’t share again unless you quit the instance and go back again, from my testing experience.
all props are gone, right? u need to reassemble them again
I crashed a lot and returned to the same instance, so that explains it
That's interesting!
One workaround is to bring enough people to make it a full server. So that you won’t be interrupted.
And no, your edited space will be saved even when you log out.
if someone grabs your hand while you're editing you'll see your hand holding something invisible 
thank youu
they cant see your unedited space then? or they can witness u edit them?
your friend can't join you or see you in editing space but some things seem to bleed through
No they can’t see unless you press the share button
when you're editing you'll be sitting in the meditation circle from your friends' pov
i see
thank youuu
I’m not patient enough for an enchantment TS
Feedback 👍
Wow I thought this was general chat.. my bad
Where is shared spaces?
Reminder that as testers, we should try looking for things in Beta ourselves when possible! If you are still struggling to find something, please remember to submit it in #beta-feedback as that feedback is very valuable for TGC and can help many players in Live 
@dry thunder for your question in the other channel about switch capes, they are iap so they don’t come free. The game itself is f2p on switch tho. You can read more about the Switch version here as well: http://bit.ly/SkySwitchFAQs 
Thank you! @gilded talon

Did they delete the little prince season preorder thing or did it disappear to me?
Not just you.
Me when isle makes the already vague introductions even more vague.
WHAT HAPPENED TO THE ORIGINAL PLOT OF THE MOVIE?
in what way?
Tbh I think Isle now in beta explains a lot more than what we have in live now 
I never realized just how much of this game is actually dependent on server pushes... they can even push changes to the game without an update :o I always thought the component would have been coded into the game... like all the changes to isle and the updates to the shared space
hey hey, i still dont get the concept of the shared space. is it like a private home that we own? and can people edit the things in it?
you make a private home of your own, edit it yourself, and share it with other people
no way!! that is awesome!! tysm!!
The bad thing about it is that I can’t test it because I haven’t completed the six quests... but I’m too busy (and lazy haha) to ask for help and do them now
Like...
In live it’s like: So uh darkness, stars fell, and I put you here to save them all, yk, there’s the portal and this is all you need to know bye
And in beta it’s like:
We spirits! Oh no darkness! Elder light gone! Bad! Us gone! Go restore light! Have a cape! Now you’re prepared to save the Elders who save us! Go kid! Spirits connect the world! Help spirits! Go to the temple! The temple of the Elder! The Elder Ancestor! Go to him! Give light! Yay you gave light! Look constellations! Look gate! Fly! Look Prairie! Look grateful spirit! Look closet! Look hairstyle! Now continue! Yay! 
dont you guys think that it would be better if, after the season(the end), all the seasonal realms, (the ones with quests u have to complete) would just have its final form completed? i just think its too much especially for the new players, its really hard to catch up for some :/
Mmh I don't think so, when I started playing I loved seeing all the missions and that each mission unlocked something new from the map. It was a very nice experience
I don't think it's something to "catch up", seasons give lessons and heartwarming/wholesomes stories. Plus it gives such a good feeling when you finish all the quests in your own time, experience is important.
That's just my opinion. 
At first it looks a bit empty, but seeing that with each mission the place fills up more is quite nice
Plus, when I was a moth I really liked exploring the realms, stumbling into new places (underground Forest) or being surprised.
"Why is an angry expression here? • Taps, starts falling and panik •"

:OO,, is that the angry expression? sorry i mean tooo ,
ohhh XD okiee
I just think Sky is more about seeing the story of the spirits and making friends along way and in your own time.
Being surprised by Golden Wasteland and finding the jewel there that Ark is
hmmmm i guess it is nice. i was just reminiscing of my moth days. glad i started earlier, i would have been extra confused XD
Seeing different stories, each with their own lesson even if small.
sky is definitely a game that you play at your own pace when it comes to exploring. except when its ts day
its satisfying to find a new area and work through the quests until you've restored the area or walked through the story of it. they're like a giant sidequests
The bad thing is I can't test it because I'm trying to test out new player experience
yess,, the TS week, is grind week
although I suppose by now I've seen most of it
Mhm! Sometimes I don't even candle run, just want to stay on Hidden Forest with the umbrella.
i'm still hoping they find a way to revamp the ts system without too many people getting angry about it. i personally don't think ts really promote healthy behavior, or at least the behaviors that sky is supposed to promote. like hoarding candles instead of building friendships, candle grinding, that kind of stuff. but this is a whole other topic not really related to beta 
just imagine if the rainbow cape doesn't change prices (or for whatever reason increases the price, not that i think it will) and we have a ts that week. and its a new ts. rip our wallets
Mhm! And happy testing everyone!
Still waiting for Little Prince in Live. :SkyLook:
The opening sequence and tutorials are a work of art honestly, also now I actually understand the sky lore
oh yeah, the tutorials and intro are much clearer. now all they have to do is fix the auto running and camera lock bugs, and we're good 
I saw a video it's so clear now, and yet curious. 
Perfect, in my eyes :)
do a bunch of quests to unlock item
quests for ts items? that would be interesting... not sure how they could implement that into what we have now but not a bad idea. you should give feedback on that!
Daily quests complete flag. Need to do dailies every day TS is there for a 50% discount on their items and emotes. 
I was thinking weekly ts, but they are much much much cheaper. So we'd have a chance to see more ts a year, and be able to afford them
Currently we get to see ts 26 times a year. And with the seasons rapidly growing, that's not gonna work out in the long run
I've figured out why some krill tricks work in live but not in beta, basically the ones who make your kid stationary (stands still) will work, as in live rn you can't move when using home trick, and as in beta you can, same with other tricks. For more info check my video, there's a comment about other tricks too.
this especially. we still haven’t seen the dismiss ts at all and those chances get lower with every new season that comes out
plus for anyone who saw a TS but missed an item or two because they didn’t grind enough , the chances of seeing it again get smaller and smaller.
I get that the point is to try and discourage the need to have everything but when you have players who do have everything because they just got lucky enough to learn of the game’s existence earlier then it’s going to create that need in newer players to have it all too.
I still think forcing the need to do all dailies while TS is here will compensate for the price drop... I mean in seasons the way to grind seasonal candles is 1 candle from the daily quest realm and the rest of your candle income is from the quests (not including the gift from home shrine). 4 days of seasonal dailies and realm candles will add up to 20 candles which is the average price for the top items of a spirit's tree during a season.
It might be fun to have a ts visiting station where several ts visit all at once on a random rotation every week/month and then players can choose what to buy (or not) with no price changes
I think a weekly TS but cheaper is a great idea. Get to cycle out the growing list of spirits, it de incentivises grindng and the culture of two weeks worth of waiting while also subtly telling new and current players that if they specifically want an item NOW that they can purchase a candle pack, helping TGC with revenue
It also means doom for players who don't do CR on a daily basis.
It could, though my thoughts were that it would cycle the spirits much more quickly so players could decide whether or not to get it now or whenever it returned.
Don’t want to make the exact connection, but think Genshin character banner type visits, if that makes sense
Tbh, I wouldn’t mind if whole seasons repeated at this point
They won’t, but it might be fun
lightseekers 2 electric boogaloo* 
Dreams of Winter 2018 season
One of the pitfalls of the TS system is they announce the spirit on Tuesday, prices aren't know until the day they arrive. You have 4 days to grind candles for what you want, but if you don't have enough candles, buy some or wait until next visit. You cannot buy out a TS if you have zero candles on Tuesday when it is announced. This created a bad play style of "I don't want to upgrade this friendship just in case the next TS is one I want" or "I won't gift a heart " for the same reason. I have friends who only gift hearts if it's a repeat TS due to this issue.
so maybe what we need is a ts for the whole two weeks
So it says, “darkness came and the stars fell and with their light we faded away”
Shouldn’t that say without their light
Weekly ts was a thing back then and they were cheaper. Theye were reduced to one per two week because of player feedback. Weekly ts is tiring.
Did anybody miss the Winter season 2020 when it came to Beta?
Oh yeah weekly ts was awful, even if it was only for a few weeks at a time.
Pretty sure we got slammed with crab call followed shortly after by don’t go (or the other way around). They were cheaper, but honestly not by much
I joined beta for Sanctuary so I wasn’t able to test Rhythm
i was here for beta rhythm. there was a lot of chaos for a season we tested for only 12 days
I think that would go into feedback so they can assess and fix it.
Well then a longer traveling spirit duration every two weeks would help with the price and savings, but it does seem a bit bleak moving forward with so many new TS arriving
Considering that Rhythm was a rerun of the Winter 2018 season 
yeah, it made sense why it only lasted 12 days. its just that beta got a bit heated during the time we tested the season.
i'm glad that beta's calmed down a bit since then 
It couldn’t have gotten more heated than during the times they’ve introduced afk and ts AP lock
oh you'd be surprised.
still really hoping AFK is never ever a thing
just still a bit shocked it was even thought of in the first place - it doesn’t sit right at all
It picked up the pace again during the Winter 2020 / New year 2021 season
they thought of something like that even in journey lol
i remember in a talk about journey they created a way to make players so that they don't feel taken advantage of
Now im curious what was the most heated discussion in beta history.
definitely the owl hair/ winter piano discourse. people were insulting each other. i hope to never see something like that again 
things feel alright right now
decisions I’ve seen that feel really questionable aren’t really there anymore thankfully
(Winter 2020 because SoD was released around December in Beta, and New year 2021 because of it's release in Live in the 1st week of January)
Chat is sneepy 
there’s one confession I really want to make but am unsure if to
will keep it to myself for now
well confession is the wrong word but anyway, I don’t know what to talk about
No one has anything to talk about in Beta Chat rn, so... 
If you don't mind me asking, what was the point of contention on? Were people just claiming that one was better than the other? If it's not preferable to talk about, I completely understand, just curious
Enchantment moth but I think it was about what should be the Ult and what’s ‘worthy’
A "moth" is a new player. They have brown wings, they flap around uncontrollably, and they are drawn to flame!
I was able to play the Early Summer 2020 season during it's run in Live
there was a cosmetic switch halfway through. the owl hair used to be a regular item, and the winter piano was the ultimate. the winter piano also had an animation, but we didn't know that until the switch happened. when closed, it looked like the regular piano, and we didn't know that it opened. people didn't think that the owl hair was worthy or extravagant enough to be an ultimate, and many people thought that the change to the winter piano was too drastic. the feedback channels used to be public so people kept build up on each other to the point where it got so aggressive that the feedback channels now are private only for the devs to see
Oh man that's intense!
the animation is very cool though but that’s not the point
Its alright. It's been over a year since then, and both beta and sky have gotten better 
Hm. That does seem like a lot. I'm glad the community has gotten better since then 
today the owl hair is literally worshipped over
what a turn of events
I don't really like owl hair tbh-
i think it’s implying that the people in the story faded away like the light of the stars did
@umbral sky the stars fell.. which means they no longer shone and so how could there be light by which someone could fade away? :( I’m still not getting it
With all of these new changes to sky, I’m wondering if they’re planning something mega huge for the 2nd year anniversary
I know it won't happen but live progress wipe. 
I wonder of they’ll do anymore realm upgrades like they did with the isle and prairie
Please no.
i think it means that: the people needed the light to survive -> the light disappeared -> the people dont have what they need to survive -> the people disappear too
it’s like if u dont have any food to eat, then u’re going to starve
im sorry but thats the best way i can think to explain it ;;
Any new season content in beta yet?
Same…
Litterally won't ever happen because that would mean they have to compensate all the purchased IAPs 
It would happen in Beta, but not in Live
I don't want to imagine a live progress wipe... 
tgc would go bankrupt
Me too. It would be reasonable if it was only a Beta progress wipe, but a progress wipe in Live would be... 
Exactly-
I doubt they’d wipe live as there would most likely be a lot of legal issues. They could discontinue the game though, which would be legally ok, afaik
No games will ever do a live account wiped unless u violated something and got suspended lol. Or yeah, the game is deleted
anyways there's a video on youtube about krill call 
Perfection , a like for the video
I sneak into beta for questions... is this allowed? maybe
Do the items on the assembly quest giver stay after the season or do I gotta buy them in live now?
Props from the questgiver are permenant, u can buy them anytime at the treehouse
There is no logical reason for a live progress wipe and that would destroy the trust of the paying and not paying players too. Why would anyone wanted to do that.
I should probably go back to rewatch the isle cutscene cause Ende confused me totally 
Thank you 
I really prefer the current opening. It feels more lore heavy.
This new one feels “oh darkness came and we died derp”
Plus it’s missing the line “if only they had listened” which is heavy and implies something bad happened.
This new intro feels kinda like a downgrade
A small bit, but that’s just the logo and a blocked entrance into the unknown new vault area
I wouldn't call it a downgrade
I call it a downgrade because even though I can’t put my finger on it, it feels like something is missing.
I’d know what it is if I see it but now it’s just a gut feeling I have
It still has the same feeling as the old Intro. It's not like it destroyed the spirit of the old Intro. They just tweaked a few changes to it
I wouldn’t say it destroyed the spirit of the old intro, but it definitely changed the tone
It’s missing that “if only they had listened” line, and for some reason I feel that’s a major loss. I don’t know what it is about that line, but it feels important to the story
Yeah, I’m not saying it destroyed the old intro, just that it’s missing something
Lore channel has been trying to figure out an explanation for “if only they had listened” for a long time
Meanwhile i skipped the lines when i was a moth
Adds a darker and slightly more sinister feel
Like they had done something to cause the destruction/fall
I think I have an idea of what "if only they had listened" means
Would love to hear your take on it!
Perhaps it's better to talk about it on #lore-discussion-spoilers
Yeah, and to be honest this game is a bit dark.
That line implies there’s more to this game than just friendship and giggles.
Yeah, that must be what I feel is missing from the new intro, otherwise it’s fine
Anyway, I found something very interesting in Beta yesterday
Wholesome looking games always have dark lore 
I saw this window frame in the 3rd treehouse in the Temple Area. I'm not sure if it resembles anything from Sky's history

Hello? Is anyone there? 
Hi
Beta chat was dead just when I presented my Beta discovery
Hey @spark lance, did you get enough sneep snorp today? 
Take kirby for an example. Cute game, right? Well no, there's literal gods, including ||a bleeding biblically accurate angel eye thing||. This cute little pink alien takes down these gods, pretty self explanatory if you know the series
Does anybody know what the window frame is?
Is the new Isle introduction only in beta or is it in live already
Beta only
more than anything, I want the team to slow down and take care of themselves
I care about them, that’s all
cramming does nothing but hurt everyone
how do I write a feedback thing of “please slow down”
"Hey tgc, I think you guys are adding new stuff to sky way too fast. Mind if you guys slow down, please?" Something like this idk
Brain dead
ye basically
Shared spaces is really cool but is making my game crash a bunch
Isn't it the same with live?
Tgc has been making games for over a decade and has things planned out months ahead of time, they’re fine
mistakes can be learnt from
just feeling very overwhelmed at the rate of events and the sort, but feedback can’t hurt
will do that
But aren't they adding stuff way too fast? Like so much changed during this build-
But then again this is beta
That’s just how game dev is
this real? https://youtu.be/7ICnt_pT_ro
just not wanting things put in before they’re ready more than anything
that’s what feedback is for
some stuff is unfinished being put in - just wouldn’t mind a bit more time for polish is all
i didnt think they would change the user experience this much
Yeah, almost too much, in my opinion 
But the whole point of beta is that things are unfinished
It’s not supposed to be polished
i feel like this is a thing they would keep tho
also in speedrunning you are supposed to overcome the time consuming stuff someway lol
insert quote from beta faq about things being unfinished in beta
i know things are unfinished and i liked how they changed visuals in isle, but adding cutscenes that they already have in the beginning of the game is unnecessary in my eyes
time to write a long feedback message brb
well in Beta yes chdjcjdj obviously
think properly, Voluntary
So much for being a scout-in-training when I'm already a fully fledged scout in Beta
It's always Where's the update. And never how is the update
I've been wondering that as well! But as beta testers we should do our best to figure out and test things on our own before asking. Remember that your struggles can help many players in the Live version and that feedback is extremely useful for TGC! Please submit them in #beta-feedback 
I actually really like the new change to the intro.
I don't, it could've stayed similar to the current one
It's a huge meh for me.
Seconding ignis
or years in some cases
I think the new intro fits its intended purpose of making the game more newbie-friendly
I think it’s nice because you can’t rewatch that beginning cutscene without reinstalling the game
or clearing your app data and creating a new account
i don't see how the new intro affects anything badly after the bugs get squashed
it gets rid of one bit of lore that some people were fond of
what is that
One reason why I don't like it
"If only they had listened"
"If only they had listened..." Why take that part out? It was so lore worthy 
IMO that should definitely go to #beta-feedback
Will do after 5 minutes
who knows the secrets tgc have on the lore
The lore chat does
plus it gets changed all the time with no clear answer, only based on interpretation
that's the fun of it
but keeping that one bit of lore is harmless and removing it nullifies a lot of discussion that has gone on here
Sometimes, mysteries must remain unsolved for they can contain dark secrets no one must set their eyes on
I love that part 
i like the new passion aggressive tone of the new narrator
Wait can someone say all of it rq?
I’d rather TGC tell the story… not lore chat
you can watch my video of the whole thing
And that's your preference which you are allowed to have
Aight, time to spend over 6 minutes watching it
I doubt they'll tell the story outright anytime soon tho
it's intentionally left very vague
Imagine the feast the lore chat will have if they do 
Fineeee, gather around the bonfire, I'm going to play a lullaby for you! 
over 17
I like the new intro tbh the old one was a little confusing for new player imo I remember being absolutely clueless about what I was supposed to do but I guess now it’s more easy to introduce Sky to newbies
Hhhh I don't like it, I prefer the current one
I like how you can view the murals anytime. Plus rewatching the elder cutscene, it all made a bit more sense. I will miss the old stuff, but I'm excited to see these changes come to live
The current isle is entirely on yt right? So I can watch it anytime when it gets removed?
Yeah. I might also be able to record it. Maybe I'll post the differences between em here
Please do!
I think someone posted the old intro, yesterday
#beta-screenshots-videos message > from cmo live vs beta video
hmm... is the beta having some maintenance? or is it just me and a server error?
the game crashed everytime when I delete the items in my shared space
Unless they fixed it, one of the Eden statues will give a server error message. Other than that, I haven't had one pop up for me. 
that's probably it. i'm doing an eden run ;D
thank you so much~
The only location shared space belongs is home.
Someone mentioned it was because of 2 object overlapped. Try removing other stuff first. But they should fix it fr
oh and bug report
get it ,thank you!
I have a question and maybe one of you guys can help me out! I would be super appreciative.
I tried doing a detailed search on discord but couldn’t find my exact answer.
Which cutscenes were updated? Thank you so much for reading! 🥺💕
looks at #beta-screenshots-videos seems a lot in Isle of Dawn. People have posted videos
how many placable props do we have in the game again? excluding spells
pillow
pot
fire brazier
tent
bookshelf
spotlight
hoop
hammock
torch
table
feast table
bonfire
swing
seesaw
teaset
am I missing any?
that's about it
so we have 15 placable non spell props in game, and the limit to shared space is 16
Will there be 16th items in the future?
I think so
Conspiracy theory building itself.... The mystery of the 16th... 
Maybe ||Rainbow bonfire|| jk 
tbh... i don't hate the idea of getting that 
Can I rant about performance in intro on Isle? Place Intro the text Isle of Dawn shows and the FPS hits so hard on 11 FPS
Try deleting them in the reverse order you inserted them... basically if you put down a, b, c, remove first c then b then a
Just throw some Borax on the flame and poof, green flame. 
It's kind off weird that we have the number of quantity of props showing up,when we can only put one prop and can't own several
maybe we can place several of the the smaller props in the future
omg imagine you can put multiple we can make a tea house 
You mean restaurant?
-capitalism entered the chat
tea house where people drink tea in it. it's a thing 
How a capeLess cape is a Cape???

The cape is there, it's just so magnificent our brains don't register it
:0 that’s without cape not capeLess cape 
Somebody call Skybot here
Oh wait nvm. I know how to summon him. TETH!!!
wait, who are we talking about, @spark lance? 
You're here, just in time 
the act of being capeless vs equipping an invisible cape are two completely different parts of a sentence. the real name of the cape is a mystery yet to be revealed. players refer to it as both the invisible cape and the capeless cape.
Is that Nick? 
PNG cape 
no but that's a good one 
The TGC staff who wore a bucket while introducing the Season of Assembly?
Regular Cape Without the cape assets and expensive as hell
It's more of an unknown cape to me
It's called "Emperor's New Cape" (if you get that reference, kudos to you fellow FF fan) and no one can change my mind.
Alt+shift+delete cape

Ktjn magenta sky kingdom when bruh
Can somebody pls. call Nick here?
Krilltjn as a krill face when bruh
any time some is magenta it means we forgot to bake something.
Well can you forget to put the whole build in the oven? For scientific purposes? I wanna see the whole kingdom in magenta 
Ah, Magenta = a little undercooked and needs more time in the oven
my eyes
Download the beta bulid to your phone and cook it using the oven
Technically it works
and no i cannot really explain baking, it's pure wizardry
But the result will be far from magneta
You can do it but only once
What was Nick's name again?
HO HO HO
NIIICK
NICK
When a developer sees a magenta texture on certain level
TGC coder: I need coffee
I heard you all figured out I know magic
oh great wizard of the tree what is your wisdom
i’m still trying to figure out which cup the ball is under
Nick
🎶 *do you wanna build a snowman treehouse?*🎶
Nick, is this you? Ktjn just sent the GIF here not long ago
Season of dream it should build a snowman theme instead of help a girl dancing.
Excuse me are you trying to imply my treehouse isn't up to your standards? AHEM

Ktjn is the imposter sus
HI
it's true, he could be 4 ft 8 and i'd never know it
Google Meet: Ktjn wants to join the meeting
It's a krill, don't let him in
Oh that's true
We were trying to calculate your height and stopped at 73 burgers tall
i could be 7 trash pandas in a hoodie and none's the wiser

Quality
so you're saying you're not 3 krills in a trenchcoat but rather 7 trash pandas / racoons in a hoodie 
Well at least it's not 3 krills in a trench coat.

Is there panda's in sky?
Is oreo a panda?
oreo is kinda like a panda
ktjn is now 7 oreos in a trench coat
oh gosh
Double stuffed oreos are bigger though so that changes a lot. So what kind?
Is anyone else getting constant game crashes in various locations?
🥺 🎅
absolutely everywhere
Dunno if she likes those
There's 11 staff online and there's two krill in among us
regular ol oreos 
Oop. Brain seeds got beaned


Thank you! I wasn’t sure if I should report the bug but if everyone is having this issue then I am sure it has been reported enough times
just take the average height of a pot and find how many pots you can stack end-to-end 
always helpful to report, even if a duplicate. they can catch a minute detail that may not be showing in others’ *reports
Ok i give up 
😂 @sick pendant
They're immune to seed planting 
I wonder which word triggered the automod 
This is a known and well-loved feature that is at the CORE of Sky and we will NOT nerf how powerful cats are against krill.
ktjn confirmed 7 trash pandas in a hoodie
Ignis, aren't you a walking trigger for the automod? 
Swear words oc what did you expected
The pointing spirit waving reminds me of a skykid waving in light awaits 
What about dogs? I love Oreo 
There were none 
Is megabird secretly a cat?
I swaer this goshdarn newfangled thingamajig
could we have cats in the game? Then we could eat krills for lunch
Here comes the lore
Lore chat lurkers: write that down, write that down
Megabird who 
I really think that if we wish enough one day we might ride a krill just like Oreo 
A krill walks into a bar and says, “Ouch!”
the old UI is secretly made of cats 
Megabird our lord and savior
Who's megabird ?
a big bird
Megabird is the god figure of sky
Megabird is ███████████████████████
I haven't seen ? Ig ?
mm I see, makes sense
You bamboozled me, i thought that was spoiler 
maaah eyeeeeees
Ah yes. Megabird is a white long box.
lore
oh like creepers in minecraft 
It's the bird-like constellation you see in orbit and the credits. I always see it as a phoenix symbolizing rebirth,
what did i come back to 
What's megabird?
From That famous street that no one knows how to get to? And asking for directions?
A really big bird
Oh- okhaay
It's always what's megabird and never how's megabird
The dead bird in the valley ?
Wut
Are we talking about Star Lord?
The one in front of the arch areas?
There's a bird laying on the entrance of 2nd valley area
that's minibird
Oh yeah
Nick what do you think about underwater seasons? 
Ahhh probably that big manta in sanctuary then
That's elder manta
Bulu bulu blup
Alright I'm heading back into my treehouse for the night. GOODNIGHT EVERYONE ❤️
Ok I am upfor it
Watch out for the bugs !
Oofff @sick pendant
Seeds planted successfully

Thanks for hanging out with us for a while 
Ufff amazing pun
don't let the Sky bugs bite
Thank you for joining us.
underwater in games always seem to be... Less than favorable. flashbacks to old 90's games and their horrid water levels, especially a temple that shall remain unnamed
Ok but imagine atlantis themed season. With deep caves that repelish your light and occtopus as new darkness creatrue
temple of water wasn't that bad
No I mean if u think of it like the water in the valley where we skate (the area with the 'Im proud of u son' stance)
Underwater game reminds me of abzu
I mean I've only played the remake for the 3DS but hey
Imagine caste on the bottom of a sea and fish swimming around and long algae plants from the bottom all the way to the surface and on the deep parts darkness octopusses
Where are the shared spaces?
treehouse
They fixed it in that version. play the N64 version and cry
Anyone else hate the new intro?
mm, what was wrong?
Quickest way to complete the water temple as intended required raising and lowering the water level 12 times.
I like the candles that show murals, but I feel like the new intro is....boring and lacking in comparison to the old intro. Even the Light Awaits intros were super amazing too.
what the game lacks now is any mention that other characters you meet are players too
not that it hasn't been lacking that for a while
Yeah, my first day playing, I thought they were NPCs. 
Maybe the murals in Isle should be tutorial murals on how to play instead of replacing the old intro. But honestly they won't do what I feel is better. Still giving feedback though.
I agree, I downloaded sky without having any idea what it was. I was shocked when someone unlocked chat and wrote hello. I thought they were bots helping me with levels 
I only knew that to begin with because a friend invited me to play with them
if I just found it from the play store and suddenly have "An NPC" plop down a table and say hi I would find that shocking too
that is the point they have been trying to put forward for lone scouters
As the Google Play Store says it was single player
Still says "Casual" and "Single Player." Man, if you want TS, it ain't casual...
You'd still need help
The game's app store page has the info but I was lazy to read 
I think the idea of the new cutscenes is to encourage players to keep going forward. I've seen some people say before that they gave up pretty early because they couldn't figure out where to go or what to do, so I think they're trying to make it a bit more clear to at least guide new players to the temple, and then you can go back to explore more later if you want to
That is correct. I always think that interactive gameplay would pull them more into the story
Keep in mind, a lot of console only gamers most likely made it to the Switch Beta and gave feedback on the new player experience, so they made those changes due to actual new player feedback. Us giving feedback from a different perspective would help perfect the new player experience. 
I don't like how hollow the new intro feels.
The previous intro had alot more feeling to it because the child has not awaken yet, and it encourages you to begin your journey.
The murals in Isle should be tutorial murals on how to play instead of replacing the old intro. Like a more in-depth description of how to walk, and that lighting candles and stuff helps you progress through the game.
Maybe instead of moths spawning in the home space when starting a new game, they should wake up on the Isle pier like the old Light Awaits builds. That might help.
(I put this in feedback)
As someone who was that confused player as a moth, i found the changes incredibly helpful. Putting myself back into that old moth mindset, and it worked well
I don't disagree that there is probably some more stuff that could be included in the tutorial, but I guess you also don't want to overwhelm people right away. Everything that I know about Sky now, I didn't learn all in one day. There needs to be a balance between helping new players but not giving too much info that they also get overwhelmed and give up because of that too
I just don't like how the moth walking from one mural to the next seems to interrupt the flow of the intro. I also like that the child hasn't woke up yet until afterwards.
Controls are very simple that isle is already a tutorial level. And the first time playing it tutorial.
the balance between not giving enough information and giving too much is tough
if you give too little or too much there's a risk of people getting overwhelmed
Imo, I think you as a player get to control the flow, for some people that's great and some people they don't like it.
I guess I just really liked the intro as is though. I mean, I'm a Sanctuary moth but I look back at the old Light Awaits builds and wish they left some things as they were back then.
And I honour that opinion and respect it.
I agree with you as an Enchantment moth
The issues with other players affecting your progress and it force pushing you through the cave could be a bug. I would report or leave feedback on it and maybe it can be adjusted more before it's finished
Because when I managed to do it by myself, it did have a message that appeared telling me to go light the next candle cluster, so I think you are still meant to have full control there. It seems to be having other players in the area messes it up right now
Ugh waiting for the update 😩 I am bored
pspsps never heard of trash pandas btw
Only trash panda I know of are racoons
We just met Ktjn and Nick earlier @scarlet moon
Yes, it's just a nickname for raccoons, because they like to dig in people's trash
cute trash pandas 
I'm so confused. What does raccoons have to do with TGC devs?
Read the chat about an hour ago and you will understand 😂
Ohhh did you become friends?? XD
Update
update time? 👀
Yall so quickj

Updooot
shiny objects catch my eye
Update notification 🎉
what is this about an updoot 
fixes, polishing
Enable shared space and bug fixes
Update yay
Shared spaces is already enabled though
Woohoo
beta time to wake up! 
Is there a new update??
Crash fixes and improvements
nice
Let’s hope it actually did fix the crashes.
They kind of forced the shared spaces to go in with a backend update but I’m sure it was buggy because the whole old build was buggy, here’s hoping this build is good!!

Chibi glitch is now back 
All that wasted salt over a bug
imagine that
Just a normal day

Hehe, people are quick to draw conclusions about things in beta... 
Not sure with the hometrick. Anyone can check? I dont want to lose wing anymore hahaha 😆😆
Well based that the home glitch getting patched was (probably) cause by the UI update... Least likely
Meaning?
Did the rainbow cape's price also change after the tree being changed around? It seems the tassel now costs candles instead of hearts.
so tassel costs 20 candles instead of hearts now... does anyone know if the rainbow cape’s price has changed as well?
don’t worry, i used the salt for popcorn
I can check once it’s finished downloading for me
I don't really have time to check anything. I have to go to work. 
The rainbow cape price did not change
:Home glitch was accidentally fixed when updating UI, I don't think it got fixed but rather Chibi Fall got fixed (no longer crashing)
Maybe 
The spirit tree is different though, so we no longer have to buy 4-5 trail spells just to get access to it and basically adding to the price 
So now it's... 180 candles right? Counting the first trail spell
Gonna wait for the new update desc before I update. Google being late as usual 
at least it isn't 205 
Tassel is 20 candles now
What are the new prices for everything else?
So cape is still 175, but since it’s at the bottom of the tree it’s now just 180 because spell, right? Nice nice.
Thank the Devs.
🎊 
If you go for the tassel as well... It does add up to 205
To be fair, it was 20 hearts originally which was 60 candles.
Mine still not appear
Time to test krill trick once more
;;
Anyway, can you guys buy the pass now ? For ios user after update
Please
sobbing go brrr
Krill trick is related to ui, it's not coming back 
what is stepping mode?
Pass isn’t even in the shop anymore for me.
Chibi fall bug
What allows you to do chibi fall, chibis no longer crash 
The pass isn't in the shop anymore, it ran away after beta kids got mad at it for crashing them 
Home trick doesn’t work any more. Logical since it’s related to ui change.
XD😂 yeah right
What is 'stepping mode'? 🤔
O h
Would have preferred if it stayed as hearts to reduce candle price but hey! If that means more people can get the tassel, fine by me 
when you drag your leggy
waiting for beta to download :D
Stepping mode is when you hold down your skykid and then drag their leg around making them dance
nice thighs you got there
Ooh, thanks!
Great stepping mode fix!
Well, I mean, if you don’t have 20 hearts it’ll cost you 60 candles and only if you have help to get them. Which is more expensive.
you do the stanky leg and the sheer power causes your skykid to break reality
Omg great i get to save hearts in live then

How did y’all able to watch the new Isle Cutscene... (From Beginning at Home Space (when opening Sky for the first) to Daylight Cutscene)
I know I know, I said it as someone who saves tons of hearts

20 candles for hair accessory isn't bad, more people can get it! 
Here I was hoping to keep the heart price because I'm richer in hearts than I am in candles on live

You might wanna watch Kakdamba's latest vid
I’m just not going to buy the extra spells. Unless I end up having enough candles over the rest of the month.
me who sub and already watched
(Either he make an alt and abandon that or TGC execute data wipe for Beta Players)
😭😭😭 have to wait an hour, cuz I'm🤖
this update is taking very long to download!! i am getting excited 🥳
Starting a new account (make sure your actual account is backed up to something), or watching someone else's video of starting anew.
For my video I just signed in using a local account, rather than using my Game Center ID 
smart smart
How do I get into the beta?
My local account somehow always logs me into my game center account
A link for beta? Yes but no, beta invites give a link to become a beta tester if you're fast enough.
But right now... Nope
My beta is still downloading ;-;
I'm dumb lol
me who has my Local Account sync to Game Center sync to Nintendo and unable to join as a New User because every time I choose Local Account, it bring me back to the same account I sync to both Game Center and Nintendo
Hey is there something New in Isle of Dawn? This update mentioned it
Links go out when they are ready to take more testers, make sure to get the beta invites role from #beta-faq
Beta testers such as Tara's Sky Journey used to make new accounts alot as they would update the starting sequence.
The way to change to a new account is to swap to a different account login elsewhere (Like swapping Google Play Games accounts), and removing the Sky beta's cache and data before trying again.
Can’t see that because my Local Account was Data was Overwrite with the Same Game Center Data and synchronized together
Fast question
If you buy the pass does the game crash?
I wonder if the price of the rainbow cape changed... I was going to pass on getting it cause it’s too expensive for me in live ;-;
It’s gone now.
What's new in the Isle? Where can I find it
Reminder that as testers, we should try looking for things in Beta ourselves when possible! If you are still struggling to find something, please remember to submit it in #beta-feedback as that feedback is very valuable for TGC and can help many players in Live 
apparently it did not
I am so dumb wryyyyy :(
Ohno
Alright I got to do something bye
Tassel now costs candles.
And the cape and tassel are at the bottom of the tree.
TGC I love you <3
Sort of, it’s still 175, but it’s now on the bottom of the tree so you only need 180 candles to get it now.
Items got moved around, lowering the price but not really.
And the tassel now costs hearts
So the tassel costs candles too??? ;-; oksy still skipping out on the rainbow cape in live but I’ll d]probably get the tassel
Buying cape + tassel would be 200 candles

cutscene changes + additions for new players, there's some white candles in the first isle cave that can make you watch those cutscenes
Can't blame ya, 175 is a lot for a cape! I rather wait for TS 
hmm, the rain in the treehouse area still affects you while you're in the shared space -- this is a bit of a conundrum 
also, the old sleepy music doesn't return -- gonna request for that in feedback, i liked that
tassel costs 1 full candle run now?? I LIVE
Yes, but they were asking about cape, weren’t they?
I think it's nicer to have a variety in currency for cosmetics since people can always favor one more than the other, but I guess having to choose between cosmetics you can afford has always been in the game 
Ahh ok, thank u 🙏
Budgets 
Wait what
According to the MOTD? :pWow: :SkyTada:
🤖 

Yeah, Tassel is literally only one full CR. I make 20 candles every single day. It’s pretty cheap. I don’t mind the currency type shift. Tho I do have 100 hearts and it would have been nice not to have to spend more candles, but I’m glad that more people will be able to get it now.
Yasssss I can chibi fallllllll
IT IS TIME TO RISE AND GRIND GAMERS
6?!
Yay extra 20 hearts saved and ready for tier 2 white 
whaaa let's go i'm ready to test it 
I don't think the MOTD can be trusted in beta much, it's not always reliable 
is it only me who had bought the tassel for 20 heartsn
Watch how days change in beta 
Chibi fall it’s back 
So did I 
either way, we're closer to july so we're closer to testing the new season 
MOTD? 👁️👄👁️
motd = message of the day
Motd = many otters tap dance
Ktjn writes the motd so maybe it's true 
Or maybe it's in last year's schedule too like the pass 
Happy they moved the cosmetics to the bottom of the tree and changed the tassles to candles 
Nooo they decreased the number of fireworks allowed from 5 to 3 in beta ;-;
Yay less lag 
What is stepping mode, if I may ask? 
tgc wants less boom boom 
We were able to send 5 fireworks out before the cooldown right? Now its 3 only
Wait is there the season pre-order???? 
It's time to CR spam.
When you press your sky kid and then move around like a noodle. Useful for chibi fall!
Boom boom boom lemme hear you say wayo 
Ooooh I didn't know that had a name!
Thanks 
Fireworks spam literally did use to crash the game before and it does take quite the toll on the game still for some. Sad that I can’t throw them as often but happy it will make people’s lives better 
I remember seeing videos of how firework spam used to be 
The new season is about to start. Is TGC not going to issue the qualification this time?
Probably on early june or so
It was bright to put it lightly Kas 
they'll release invites when they need more testers, not necessarily whenever new seasons are about to be tested
I mean it wasn't done for Assembly till waaaaay later
anyone know if the price of rainbow cape changed? i got mine so no idea
What's 'stepping mode'?
okay i guess ill just wait
what's the price of the tassels now?
20 candles instead of hearts
how does the price tree look like now?
1 full cr ez 
So I wasted my hearts... 
also does the boat sell trail spells instead of the tree?
That's surprisingly cheap. Wonder if it's wrong...
cape on first lvl side branch and tassel on 2nd level side branch
Is there pics on the new update????
Ok new prices! So, the cape and tassel are both at the bottom! The cape still costs 175 candles, the tassel is now 20 candles instead! The tree otherwise is pretty normal, but at the very top there is a trail spell that costs 5 hearts and it will give you the “rainbow” trail spell! On my account I managed to get every colour of spell from the tree, I think!
thank you nastymold! (btw im a fan but uh yes anyways-)
nastymold poggers
stepping mode?
I hope they keep that 20 candles price tag 
thank you too meg! i appreciate the effort
Nasty Pogs
dragging out one of your skykid's legs, it's what makes you chibi fall 
ooh like the d-pad basically (to drag ur leg)
Pogmold for the win
Trail cost 5 heart each now?? 
Just the one at the very top! That one has the “rainbow” version that toggles through all colours
no just the top one
Thanks 
how long does the rainbow trail last again?
Can't wait for android

Heyo nasty! Seems weird not seing your name in green
does the rainbow spell have a different icon? or does it just look like any normal trail spell 
I wouldn't be in too much of a rush to make new content about the rainbow event, things are going to change again soon.
ktjn is typing
hey ktjn!
I think they’re all 60 minutes?
please don't announce when staff is typing 
Thank you Devs for the tree adjustment. ❤️ So thankful.
things always subject to change
are you sure you mean seconds and not minutes...? 
Aren’t they 60 min?
It scrolls through all the colours in the spell form 👀 like the spell is a gif, almost 
they should be much longer than 60 seconds
Can they switch it to 60 years ? 
60 seconds is quite the nerf lol
HAHAH SECONDS MY BAD 
All trails last 6 milliseconds, don't blink or you'll miss them 
60 seconds will make everyone riot 
Ktjn wdym by pre-order in #beta-known-issues 
oh that's pretty cool! thanks for answering 
I can send a picture of the spell in a second
or, video I guess!
The new season pass was available for a while, tapping on it would cause crash
There was the preorder seasonal pass in the shop yesterday. That was bugged and still not announced yet
Oops sorry wrong reply
wha
Also I notice that new season countdown
6 days
H u h since when it was there???
look at the build number, not sure why you're squinting at me
mmmm i see nothing about new season welp
Hope the MOTD will not prank us 😅
From previous update till when the shared space was fixed yesterday
noone was able to buy it dw
O h
Why always the shop is busy!!!???
Because the shopkeeper is sneeping 
they need to rest! 
They ran out of spell stocks
any android tester get update now
shop should just be a permanent fixture at home at this rate lol
Wish I can get
Bruh traveller pls, if u wanna open the shop then open it , sleeping during business hours is bad for the buisness 
Not until later
True, but then visiting the beautiful Ark would lack reason anymore.
Android testers suffering rn
Android update come on I'm doing ritual 
Imo they just activated the "inactive season" period, which then starts appearing motd saying when it will start, but not necessarily will start after those days, and that only to remove the pre-order for now so people won't crash by tapping null stuff 
Tl;dr: Don't trust the motd that much
prolly another 20-30 minutes for android, it's still under review
How about an easier route to ark instead? Like a boat from wasteland social space straight to ark 
are you sure traveler currently doing business hours rn? Cuz in TGC land it is 11:18pm
Hoping google to not stuck again🤞
me not having beta and just chilling here: 
Is the current Days of Rainbow guide basically just being Rallying thrillseeker with the rainbow cosmetics Intentional or..? 
That'd be cool too.
Same here
They have been hibernating for days
wakey wakey
Hold on theres a beta update?
lol
that's for you to decide 
You might wanna go to #beta-faq and reselect the beta updates role because it sometimes glitches and removes them.
Woah, ktjn. we get to decide?
as always 
Rally thrillseeker the gay icon of sky
🏳️🌈
Please stop with the woe-is-me android comments

All spells posted to #beta-screenshots-videos
you can see the rainbow one in action if you’d like!
this is standard procedure for beta builds, it's not going to change unless google changes their processes
not related but I really want to draw 3 dark dragons in a trenchcoat but I'm bad at drawing
Google is google
^^you'll have to take it up with google, not tgc
By the way new update?
we know that, we just lovingly remind ourselves that Google is not helping
All Sky creatures lack canon genders and sexualities, so its up to fans to headcanon their perspective if they want to. Everyone will end up having a different view of what everything is.
Aaaaaaaaaa update already TwT
Ok so they finally fix the chibi crash
Oof being lore enthusiasts are we
My skykid is a jellyfish, end of story 
Has this changed any anti krill tactics again?
Instead of let people chibi Fall devs make it chibi crash as intended feature
Granted I haven't seen it at this hour but the hyperbolic comparisons to actual human suffering that's been going on in this channel amongst Android players is really just not appropriate here in the server or in general.
Perhaps it is Thrillseeker themself... or a long lost twin

I go for 5 seconds and it's chaos again 
not sure if I understand but OK 
Lore: Theillseeker is gae
Watch as its the end of days of rainbow and the guide does rally lvl 4
I like the hyperbolic subtle reference to reality that this is still infact a game
stay cozy beta testers
I'm an Android player, and I agree with you. I don't find it a suffer to wait. Patience is key! Plus, if players are that distressed about the delay on Google's end, maybe they should take a break and try and relax.
two words
gay thrillseeker
Trying to update on data is annoyingly slow 
DoR guide let’s us unlock the secret Lvl5 rally with rainbow particle effects
Anyway, good luck for finding other bugs in beta bulid. I still doing the live candle run yet
Oh right need to cr well cya
When its school but u wanna play sky
so uh…i just asked…not any complain…lets just skip
From now, I will just read the comments for an hour while waiting for the update.
An invisible beta skykid just launched fireworks at me and then my game crashed
darn kids nowadays
Man I hate it when invisible children launch fireworks at me and break the fabric of reality 
We have the invisible cape
Now get ready for invisible children
.....Invisibility spell to hide from crabs and Krill?
sneaky stance with the invisible cape, when you sit your sky kid becomes invisible
From what spirit the invisible cape in beta guys?
Invisible as in invisible cape or fully invisible
Woah... invisible kid come back and teach me your ways so I can hide from crabs 
he did crash the game tho
why would you want to hide? as we speak im waiting for a krill to notice me 
Invisible spell in Sky for 5 mins when
Skykid 1: look i bought the invisible cape
Skykid 2: where
Skykid 1: exactly
What's next ? Invisible homespace? Heh-heh.... No pls 
When I was a moth I used to think there was an invisible spell just cause of that one minor bug where the stars on the capes of players who merged out of the server would stay floating in the air 
is the rainbow dude actually the thrillseeier
Won't get krilled if there's no game to be krilled on 
invisible krill
when it rains in the completed treehouse it rains in your editing space as well, I don't know if I like that - when entering editing space the place you meditate at is also exposed to rain and even if it doesn't harm you while you're editing it doesn't feel good 
Maybe yes maybe no, perhaps a lost twin or thrillseeker themselves 





