#vrchat-general-2

1 messages · Page 1323 of 1

blissful stag
#

.

ocean arch
#

it probably takes me maybe 30 seconds more than av2 but not hard at all once used to av3 setup

nimble linden
#

This is the same with 2.0. its just that the type of blendshape needed changed. But the setup is still mostly the same

ocean arch
#

yea

jovial kestrel
#

Sometimes people just need a little push from something like a tutorial fairy to get started.

vocal shard
#

AV3 is easier than AV2 cmv

velvet gull
#

Tupper, are there any plans/or has it been taken into consideration, to implement tracking with more than the 6 points we have currently?

nimble linden
#

If you are on the fence about 3.0, please, I implore you to set some time aside and learn the new system. I was skeptical at first and it put me off of working on it for a while. But now that I've learned it, it is the single greatest advancement in Avatar creation and allows for some amazing things. Don't be a dummy like me. Just try it and it will change you're perception of what is possible.

jovial kestrel
ocean arch
#

I really wish we could see the shrinking thing we could do with av3 avatars back again xD. That was awesome to see back in beta

velvet gull
vocal shard
#

Yeah you get easier control over things compared to AV2 while a basic avatar is crazy easy to set up. Sure it’s different but once you learn it’s really seamless just getting a basic avatar out

opaque shard
#

Question, what does the VRChat team do usually?

ocean arch
#

development

#

but they also do other things I assume, like spending time with family and friends

jovial kestrel
#

Human things.

ocean arch
#

ye

spice olive
#

I need help

jovial kestrel
#

What sort of help

ocean arch
#

wuzzup

polar path
#

has anyone found the murder 4 bed hiding spot yet

#

like you cant see the name tag or player

blissful stag
#

just pain xD

spice olive
#

I texted @jovial kestrel

cosmic shale
spice olive
#

Saying why i need help

jovial kestrel
#

What do you mean? Everyone noticed the emoji fix.

cosmic shale
#

Yesterday friend requests were broken
That might’ve fixed itself for all we know

vocal shard
#

I only use cloud and money emotes smhh

jovial kestrel
ocean arch
#

Just by going on their canny shows a lot that's being done

opaque shard
#

Does VRChat's devs have split teams?

cosmic shale
#

Well they might all be the same person

fresh garnet
#

From what I've seen in their hiring spaces, a staff member "wears many hats".

#

But that just means they assist with other things outside their main duty.

cosmic shale
velvet gull
ocean arch
#

One I voted for a few months ago was marked as "under development"

ocean arch
#

and was implemented as the saving feature for av3 avatars

rancid jewel
#

neat

golden scaffold
#

There's usually a lot of stuff we want to do, but there's a time and place for those things. The Canny should serve as a guiding tool for future features and feedback. I think we'd be misrepresenting it if we suggested it was an actual roadmap, but it's likely the closest thing to one.

covert chasm
#

i'd like to have like a

#

"cool idea" or "yep we read this" or something status

#

which would be kinda annoying tbh, we read everything posted on the Feedback/cann yboard

#

we just don't respond to all of it

#

unless a Canny's post status is "complete", assume that it may or may not eventually get into the application

pliant tangle
#

Phasmophobia uses trello and I think its a really easy way to see what theyre up to.

covert chasm
#

mmmmmm Phasmophobia is quite a different beast than VRChat 😛

ocean arch
#

Smaller game too

pliant tangle
#

right but trello though, thats my point

ocean arch
#

The canny looks more organised than trello imo, but that's just me

covert chasm
#

we've considered trello in the past but most of the opinions we got on it ranged from "no" to "nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo"

ocean arch
#

even though having used trello in the past

pliant tangle
#

lmao ok

rancid jewel
#

the hell is a trello

covert chasm
#

basically a public-facing "what are you working on" list

supple python
#

bruh im in vrchat and my social menu says offline where my status would normally be and is literally treating me as offline 😂

ocean arch
#

Trello is a project management tool for sorting and organising stuff

rancid jewel
#

oh ook

jovial kestrel
pliant tangle
#

understandable

covert chasm
#

not really, we use canny as a suggestion box

#

and as a bug reporting method, which isn't what canny is meant to do, but "using something to do something it isn't meant for" is the most vrchat thing ever

ocean arch
#

In a way, other companies like Frontier Developments use something already similar to what vrchat uses for their canny, where you vote for items that may be of importance (and the higher voted ones usually typically get more attention)

#

Trello kinda has that but you'd need plugins for it

supple python
uncut trail
#

@tupper here an idea weekly maintenance this could help improve servers

supple python
#

lol pretty sure they have near constant maintenance

covert chasm
uncut trail
#

Ah okay

pallid cape
#

👀

ocean arch
#

a lot more than just weekly maintenance, plus player count goin on since there's been a lot of that happening over this and last year

#

at least from what the convo occurred a while ago

#

Actually (doesn't have to be a question that can be answered if you can't). Regarding the AV3 features. Any idea why the shrinking ability for avatars back in its beta wasn't implemented? The only thing I can assume why would be the case is that it would break the menu or worlds but I'm not entirely sure.

#

Was a really cool feature to see though at its time, but yeah

rancid jewel
#

tupper you need to motivate the servers
compliment them a couple of times that should do it

jovial kestrel
#

Take shifts headpatting the servers.

velvet gull
#

Yes, its pc only

jovial kestrel
#

There are little icons in the top corner of the map thumbnail that can tell you this. But yes, VC is.

sharp rose
rancid jewel
#

i think just b club is quest compatible

noble depot
#

what's the weekly headpat amount for team members because it needs to be raised

#

if I had a headpat emote it'd be right heckin' here o:

rotund meadow
#

my vrchat keeps crashing after it loads my account 😦

green surge
young mirage
#

Hello

covert chasm
#

@rotund meadow @green surge This channel is not meant for VRChat support. You can try going to #user-support-old to get assistance from other users, or check #vrchat-support to contact our Support team.

uncut trail
#

steamvr causing my oculus to crash

#

displayport error

raven mango
#

But we are supposed to use that user support channel if

uncut trail
#

yeah using oculus vrchat no problem but with steamvr yes

raven mango
#

ig

#

Oh yeah the quest version doesn't crash. It's the pc and oculus link using quest 2 that does

shut apex
uncut trail
#

no

shut apex
#

Seems very odd to me

uncut trail
#

yeah streamvr crashing my oculus

shut apex
#

Welp time to scream at steam

oblique silo
#

im not able to toggle voice in game in vr, (valve index)

blissful stag
#

how long do i need to play vrchat to upload avatars?

hard shore
#

Pinchis putos gringos

#

Contesten hijos de la gran puta

fathom ether
lethal heron
#

@hard shore based

#

@blissful stag 24 owa owas i think

#

i just got my upload confirmation thingy today altho i'm banned 💥🌈♥️

frail raptor
#

Hello everyone

valid ingot
#

Hello Cameron

vocal shard
#

just a question but am i not the onlt one with both sdk2 and 3 saying: FileNotFoundException: C:/Users/samur/AppData/Local/Temp/DefaultCompany/rainbow/prefab-id-v1_avtr_eeafd9a9-b2ec-443e-bf41-ee73d675f700_2770833373.prefab.unity3d

ruby needle
#

You have errors in your console

#

solve them from top to bottom

#

Something causes the build to fail, thats why you get the error

blissful stag
#

sorry caps

vocal shard
#

yea but when i do fix it, it messes up my rigging and then my gun that i have attached to my wrist, no longer is attached cause one of the errors is to remove the right wrist and spine so it messes up rigging really badly but idk i theirs another way to fix that

blissful stag
#

what do i press to clear the 8gb?

ruby needle
#

The top one

#

But usually you don't want to do that

blissful stag
#

why?

#

my laptop is trash soo XD

ruby needle
#

The cache is there to not download everything all the time

#

old data will automatically be removed if it's not been used for ages, or if the cache is full the oldes will be overwritten

blissful stag
#

i dont understand what you mean but okay??

rancid jewel
#

If there is something in the cache that has not been accessed in a month it will be removed

blissful stag
#

like what?

arctic rune
#

Anyone know who @gilded garnet is?

#

They randomly send me a link to some anime watching website

open crescent
#

No

jolly vortex
#

lol why are the mods of vrchat on steam sensitive?

whole idol
#

mmm anyone having trouble signing in?

#

Failed to authenticate to realtime servers error for me

#

:c

hybrid bone
#

Hello

hybrid bone
whole idol
hybrid bone
#

I dont think they transfer

whole idol
#

:c

hybrid bone
#

Its 2 different accounts

whole idol
#

ye ik

hybrid bone
#

Just wait they will fix it probably.

#

Check for an update or smthing

whole idol
hybrid bone
jovial echo
#

hello

hybrid bone
#

Hey

ionic bane
#

Yo

uncut trail
#

1 hour streamvr crashes my oculus grr

frail raptor
#

Hello

#

Its currently one am and I cant sleep worth a shit

ionic bane
#

yeah

astral crescent
whole idol
#

thx bro ill try

#

bad thing is i have to copy a token but i cant sign in with steam so xd

golden horizon
#

ya know I get that you have problems with servers and shit but why not funnel some of that 15 mil into the servers eh? I mean there are games that have less people, less money with better servers. c'mon

umbral reef
frail raptor
#

Anyone wanna be friends on VR chat?

golden horizon
cunning plaza
golden horizon
#

Lets be friends

cunning plaza
#

I’m down

frail raptor
#

I don't understand😅

late void
#

Ughh I hate that alcohol makes me sick I'm so left out

#

😩😩

golden horizon
#

Same name Donut2Ninja
If you drink add me, cause we got lots of people that do lol

pseudo carbon
#

Hey is anyone else friends list not working on vrchat?

#

cant send requests

frail raptor
#

@pseudo carbon it's been weird lately yes

pseudo carbon
#

or see my friends

golden horizon
pseudo carbon
#

@frail raptor any way to fix?

cunning plaza
#

@golden horizon gonna add you on discord I’m not home right now

frail raptor
#

I literally got drunk last night and had a bit of a hangover

frail raptor
#

@pseudo carbon Not that I know of, just a bug

cunning plaza
golden horizon
#

again.....

pseudo carbon
#

so it'll just fix on its own then?

cunning plaza
#

It should

golden horizon
#

Pretty much

#

They seem to always have some sort of issue every weekend

frail raptor
#

Yeppers

pseudo carbon
#

reeee

cunning plaza
pseudo carbon
#

just wanna pway with fwiends

cunning plaza
#

Apparently, they talked about it in the announcements

golden horizon
cunning plaza
golden horizon
cunning plaza
compact prism
#

facts

late axle
#

Hi Donut

cunning plaza
#

Why is it so much easier to make friends in VRC?

vocal shard
#

no screaming

golden horizon
#

why not

vocal sluice
#

Hi everyone I am a new VRC gamer! I hope you guys like the game too haha

vocal shard
#

people are napping
gotta talk quietly

golden horizon
#

oh sorry...

cunning plaza
#

sorry we’ll stop yelling

golden horizon
vocal sluice
late axle
#

I bet VRC gamers pog

timber grail
#

What the fuck is vrchat

vocal shard
#

what is the difference between 2.0 and 3.0 avatars

arctic elm
#

3.0 is better

#

did i just witness someone get thanos'd

bold epoch
#

I havent had friends here

#
  • cries in the corner while eating potato chips *
topaz nest
#

i don't have friends anywhere...

vocal shard
#

😔

bold epoch
#

can I add you guys later ?

patent python
#

Why am I getting an error saying vrchat is not responding?

floral gate
#

I need to figure out how to turn o. My mic

vocal shard
#

whats the difference

floral gate
#

How to turn on m9c

#

Mic

viral abyss
#

Хай

vocal shard
#

isn't vrchat api photon

#

VRChat server architecture is photon

carmine egret
#

Is there way to disable people sending you friend requests .. ?

vocal shard
#

you don't like new friends?

carmine egret
#

I don't like when I get 20 fr a day

vocal shard
#

maybe you are cool

carmine egret
#

from people that I never met

#

They just click on my world click on me and oh.. how funny it would be to try and add that dude to my friends list ..

ionic bane
#

yeah that's understandable

vocal shard
#

oh thats makes sense

#

I though they are in same world as you

carmine egret
#

And I don'T have any super popular world.. What do people like Jar do with probably like 50 fr a day ?

vocal shard
#

50 is popular

carmine egret
#

50 what ? fr a day ? I mean I imagine Jar gets these numbers if not more.. Heck he has 1000+ people in his world all the time 😄

#

If I get around 10-20 a day with world where in PEAK times we get around 100-150 people at most then..

#

And idk about you 😄 But I don't add people that I've never met into my friends list

ionic bane
#

what is your world anyway?

carmine egret
#

As you can see not that popular world so that many friend requests is a bit unexpected

ionic bane
#

you gotta be doing somethin right for that many friend requests

carmine egret
#

No its just kids

vocal shard
#

O yo you made that I played it once cool game good job

carmine egret
#

I tried accepting a few.. then joined on them and found QUEST2 11 year old child with the green brush avatar..

vocal shard
#

do you say kids play vrchat

ionic bane
#

yeah

vocal shard
#

sure they are like 13 and up

ionic bane
#

nah under

carmine egret
vocal shard
#

Nah Ive met a 6 year old

#

I remember there was kids and there was a person having nsfw avatar

#

And have multiple 11 year old friends that are actually cool

#

furry nsfw avatars ofc

carmine egret
ionic bane
#

I mean I don't really care about them but bein on vrchat isn't really a good experience for kids most of the time

vocal shard
#

sure becuase there so many furries

ionic bane
#

those guys are normally pretty nice from my experience

carmine egret
#

usually yea

vocal shard
ionic bane
#

but I've seen people attacking kids for being on vrchat and that can really hurt their confidence

vocal shard
#

are there even vr games for kids only

vocal shard
#

sure there are few like angry birds clones or something

carmine egret
vocal shard
#

sure they can see nude furries

bold epoch
#

too many kids injected with josedubs insanity

vocal shard
#

children trauma to see a 9th foot furry

carmine egret
#

😄

vocal shard
#

As long as they don't let the kid free and he ends up in the void it should be fine

bold epoch
#

even Im not a fan of furries I like the skin that I have

carmine egret
vocal shard
#

yeah seeing things they shouldn't see

carmine egret
#

😄

ionic bane
#

they can just have high safety on

bold epoch
#

is @carmine egret a furry ?

carmine egret
#

nah

vocal shard
#

how many furries are there on this Discord

bold epoch
#

me !! @vocal shard

vocal shard
#

you doens't look like

bold epoch
#

@vocal shard your not my friend on vr so that is why your not sure about my skin furry

vocal shard
#

but what furry skin

#

a free or paid one, thats matter

bold epoch
#

black furry with gold accents with green eyes

vocal shard
#

I assume it was one of those free ones

bold epoch
#

my friend lets me use his so yea I got the skin and I love it

carmine egret
ionic bane
#

yeah me too

#

biggest threat to me is standing for hours on end

bold epoch
vocal shard
#

Granted I had been in VR for a while by the time I upgraded

carmine egret
lethal jay
#

I use a quest link and motion sickness is not an issue for me

vocal shard
#

how many furries can be right here

carmine egret
#

Def you're gonna feel less sick with 144 FPS in index than 40 in QUEST

lethal jay
#

Probably a lot, most won't come out though

vocal shard
#

why so

lethal jay
#

Cuz there are people who think they are bad and shouldn't exist

#

(Not me)

vocal shard
bold epoch
#

since my eyes are squint my vision is having a double layer hahahaha FUCK

carmine egret
#

noone ? I am sad.

vocal shard
#

what is Impim

lethal jay
#

Weird lookin furry imo

vocal shard
#

well

bold epoch
#

what those that look like ?

lethal jay
#

But then again technically all of them are

vocal shard
#

why there are many weird looking ones

vocal shard
#

lnik

#

link long

bold epoch
#

mine looks like a fox

vocal shard
#

what type of fox

#

why you got a car on profile pic

bold epoch
#

long pointy ears

lethal jay
#

And exactly how did you get that link

carmine egret
#

🤔

lethal jay
#

It's only accessible via api

carmine egret
#

Seached google for Impim VRChat

#

And copy URL

lethal jay
#

Doubt

#

But you do you

vocal shard
#

so something with a hoodie on

#

not very furry

carmine egret
#

Yea

#

I wouldn't consider impims furries but who knows.. I am not an expert

supple lantern
#

Heya, I want to get back into playing VR chat again, However I really don't want to just use any random character model and would much rather prefer to play with my own model.

However I will never attain trusted rank unless I play without it for the time being. I was wondering if I can send someone the Unity project for my character model and have them upload it so I can use it to play.

carmine egret
#

Which is quick 🙂

lethal jay
#

?upload

shy spokeBOT
#

You must obtain at least "New User" Trust Rank in our Trust and Safety system in order to upload content. You can get this by just spending a few hours in VRChat, hop some worlds, and make some friends. Give it some time and you'll be able to upload content in no time.

As an aside, you must have a VRChat account to upload content. That means you can't use a Steam account, Oculus account, or Viveport account to upload content like worlds or avatars.

Source: https://docs.vrchat.com/docs/frequently-asked-questions

carmine egret
#

Or even New User.. that is even faster

supple lantern
carmine egret
#

You got VRChat account right ?

supple lantern
#

Yup

lethal jay
#

Won't take long, it really won't

carmine egret
#

Try adding couple Trusted users and just jump around couple worlds.. 🙂 New user is usually at around 12-24H of playtime max I'd say 🙂

#

Don't spam friend requests though..

lethal jay
#

Had 2 alts become new user within 10 hours of creation playin normally

carmine egret
#

Yea.. New user is quick

#

Known ->Trusted usually takes a while

#

Though I went from Known -> Trusted within like a week

lethal jay
#

Yeah but anything past user is worthless

carmine egret
#

I show avatar for everyone but then the rest I show only for Trusted and friends.. For known I only have Custom animations

lethal jay
#

Most people I know have them off completely

carmine egret
#

I hate seeing the robots.. So I show basic avatars for everyone

feral blade
#

same

#

i hate seeing robots , if someones a problem ill just block their avatar

#

theyll come up to me and obviously be doing a bit and all ill see is the fuckin grey robot

carmine egret
#

Though I undestand that some people just can't afford that cause of FPS.. But I got not problem with that as I get 100+ FPS in VR

feral blade
#

the only tihng that lags me is HUGE avatars, and ppl with like 200 mb avatars

#

itll lag my game like shit when it loads, so hard i see the steam vr background because my application is actively crashing

compact granite
solar nebula
#

can i combine my oculus and vrchat account?

blissful stag
solar nebula
#

show me your ways o mighty one

#

oh lol

late void
compact granite
#

but the sdk literally gives you a button to change blend shapes

#

and crunch your textures please god

warped summit
#

^

late void
#

Any sdk that's older than like 2 months doesn't have it

#

It's such an annoying problem. I hate seeing bloated size avatars with their shitty calculated normals that change when you open your mouth. It was unity's duck up

#

I'm glad they released an sdk update that makes you change it hahaha

unreal verge
late void
#

I have an avatar full of emotes and music and it's like 50 something. To get to 100-200 you either got to have like a "video" on it or you messed up the normals import stuff

unreal verge
#

I'm not familiar with this issue

late void
unreal verge
#

My optimized version is around 20-30 MB and my heavy version almost 50 MB

late void
#

If you see an avatar that's "lighting" changes when you talk, that's unity calculating the normals instead of importing or legacy or whatever. And it BLOATS the file size

#

Avatars go from 5mb to 70mb

unreal verge
#

Oh so they don't have normals attached maybe?

late void
#

No they do

#

Just unity 2018 as like hmmmMMm we gonna make this auto go to calculate hurr durr

#

It's so bad that vrcs new sdk is like NO CHANGE IT TO LEGACY

#

Quest is limited

unreal verge
#

Afaik that got quickly removed because it caused major issues in performance

late void
#

No cool things for quest 😛👎

unreal verge
#

Yep

late void
unreal verge
#

I mean Quest avatar audio

late void
#

Ohhhh ohhhh

unreal verge
#

Never had to deal with that normals problem luckily

late void
#

If your avatars are completely flat lit you might not notice it

#

But always check the file size. If it looks strangely high... It might be that issue. Though, like I said if you're using the newest sdk you no longer even have to worry

unreal verge
#

I don't know anything about normals though. My avi has the one attached that i got originally from the creator

#

50 MB with 7 audios and lots of toggleables seems reasonable

#

It's 46 MB iirc

late void
#

That's fine then if it's got alot of stuff

cosmic wind
#

yea are you guys going to going to fix the request invt and invt bugs a lot of people are having a problem with it when people are not getting the the request invts or invts

late void
#

I know it's poop

cosmic wind
#

yea it is

unreal verge
#

@cosmic wind oh hi lol

cosmic wind
#

hi

minor yacht
#

let's go I'm a trusted user now

vocal shard
#

where is furry room

chilly basin
unreal verge
uncut trail
#

qhy am i seeing 3 17 worlds n 1

#

black cat cant find anymore

vocal shard
#

anyone trynna play and just mess around?

#

dm me if yes

uncut trail
#

worlds wont update

#

i keep joining same random black cats

hexed raven
#

Yeah

#

It had happened for a couple days by now

stuck veldt
#

🦆🍴duck

vocal shard
#

Mmm tasty

uncut trail
#

wtb working update

#

world*

vocal shard
#

Hey how do I know do quest players see my avatar, what kind of avatar I have to pick that they can see me

feral blade
#

in menu itll tell you if its quest compatible, look for the little green icon

vocal shard
unreal verge
#

Yes

feral blade
#

Yurp

#

unless they use link cable

unreal verge
#

But then they aren't Quest users

#

Then they're PCVR users

chrome rivet
#

Hello

grave sand
#

yeah I prefer to play cabled

#

most models don't load directly on quest

late nexus
#

Hello

chilly basin
#

I can later, if you would like

small kiln
#

Anyone got any ideas as to why the video players in vrc have suddenly stopped working for me

vocal shard
#

try a few more worlds with players if those still dont work ill go out on a limb and say your wifi connection might be struggling

honest forge
#

update changed up avpro, the wc has to update the worlds to get them working again (pain...)

nova oar
#

I still can't login

#

My pain is forever

uncut trail
#

steamvr keeps crashing oculus displayport while in oculus vrchat no crashes

vocal shard
#

use a vrc acc

#

@nova oar

nova oar
#

Im tryna login to the website

#

It dont work

vocal shard
#

uno momento por favor

#

thats interesting cause i logged in

#

restart ur browser/router/try incognito mode

honest forge
#

need a stronger connection probs

vocal shard
#

^

#

taking your router to gym wont work

nova oar
#

Bruh im sittin on 500mbs

#

My internet is gucci

rancid jewel
#

vrchat

nova oar
#

Keeps telling me my username or password is incorrect after I’ve changed it to ensure it is correct

#

Also unable to login to the sdk in unity

#

Which is what I was tryna do from the beginning

vocal shard
#

that one mod messing with a user on his luchbreak be like

#

no im joking

nova oar
#

I just wanna upload an avatar man

vocal shard
#

some services may be off i guess

#

i noticed today i had to relog to the sdk in unity

#

that was uh 5hrs ago

#

and on mobile browser

nova oar
#

Did u get in tho?

small kiln
rancid jewel
vocal shard
nova oar
#

Then ig im just cursed

vocal shard
#

take some time off and try a bit later

nova oar
#

Gotta get my hands on some nasa tech to login apparently

vocal shard
#

its not like ur on gunpoint

nova oar
#

I been trying for like 8 hours

vocal shard
#

yeah

nova oar
#

Welp heres hoping i can acc login at some point

ruby needle
#

Do you youse any special characters or font nonsense in your username?

#

Try using the E-Mail instead of the username.

nova oar
#

I dont and I have

#

Nothing seems to b workin for me

vocal shard
#

Nonsense in your username makes you less searchable

nova oar
#

Just normal letters

#

Nothin weird in my username

vocal shard
#

Problem is the people to avoid have your player ID which is static.

#

Nothing you can do.

#

At least my favorites worked last night

#

Thats an improvement I guess.

violet summit
#

is the game broken again?

#

i cant seem to upload any avatars

vocal shard
#

it just works

#

maybe the mitigations are being tested

#

who knows

nimble kettle
#

can you wiggle in vrc with vive trackers?

violet summit
#

depending on what "wiggle" means yes and no

vocal shard
#

Lmao

nimble kettle
#

can i send a youtube example link here

pliant epoch
violet summit
#

^

nimble kettle
#

yay thanks

violet summit
#

you can throw it back

nimble kettle
#

i tried googling that but nothing came up

#

i scored a deal on some vive trackers and they are arriving soon

#

very excited

violet summit
#

i hope i shouldnt need to ask this, but are you a quest user?

nimble kettle
#

yes, quest 1

violet summit
#

do you have base stations?

#

or are you getting them?

nimble kettle
#

they come with what ai am getting

pliant epoch
#

Are they 1.0s or 2.0s? You also need base stations and a VR ready PC.

violet summit
#

i hope so.... ive seen a lot of people be disapointed bc they didnt do research...

nimble kettle
#

yea yea i got a great pc for that

nimble kettle
#

so what is coming is a htc vive, the controllers, the 1.0 base stations, 2x 2.0 tracking pucks, 1x 1.0 tracking puck, and all the extra hardware for the base stations and pucks

#

for 370 usd

vocal shard
#

i think u saw too many of the vids from that ytuber

#

that he wiggles in those vids

#

but yes u can totally do that.

violet summit
#

thats not a bad deal but i pray for you. that is suspiciously cheap...

vocal shard
#

true

pliant epoch
#

That deal seems too good to be genuine.

vocal shard
#

something will be broken

violet summit
#

im not saying thats guarenteed

nimble kettle
#

yea, he has sold other stuff before and he says it works fine so i trust him

violet summit
#

but its always a big risk on the 2nd hand market

vocal shard
#

xddd

violet summit
vocal shard
#

if i was you

#

i would turn a cam and record step by step after u get ur box

violet summit
#

if i were you, i would go pick it up in person and ask the guy to show that it works when you pick it up

#

and that

nimble kettle
#

i cant he lives several states away

vocal shard
#

to have proof that something is faulty from the start

violet summit
#

and yea, record yourself opening it

nimble kettle
#

ill do that

vocal shard
#

opening plugging etc

#

and turning it on

#

that way u can protect ur ass

violet summit
#

depending on the site

nimble kettle
#

i got it thru facebook

violet summit
#

if you can prove it didnt work then you can get your money back

#

i dont think facebook allows for that...

nimble kettle
#

pain.

#

oh well

#

we will see:)

violet summit
#

and i hope they packaged it properly

#

i worked for my countries biggest courier and packages get thrown a hell of a lot

nimble kettle
#

yea it happens lol

vocal shard
#

+1

viscid pendant
#

Could someone tell me if there's a way to remove the 4 characters at the end of my name in game?

violet summit
#

move from a steam account to a VRChat account

#

the 4 character thing is because you are using your steam account

nimble kettle
#

yes the metamorphosis

viscid pendant
#

Ooh okay

#

Thanks

#

Will my avatars and worlds transfer over?

violet summit
#

google is your friend

regal furnace
#

if you merge yes

violet summit
#

and izu is your friend

vocal shard
regal furnace
viscid pendant
vocal shard
#

or so

violet summit
#

google is more consistent than people in discord, most of us are guessing half of the time or using google ourselves

regal furnace
#

wasnt it hours?

vocal shard
#

it took days for some my buddies

#

so to 3days

unreal verge
#

For me it was immediately

vocal shard
#

but it varies i guess

unreal verge
#

But that may be related because i did it just like an hour after first time playing

mellow zodiac
#

i am the menace

violet summit
#

did you merge accounts?

#

or did you just make a VRC account and use that?

unreal verge
#

I did merge

mellow zodiac
vocal shard
mellow zodiac
#

yes no

vocal shard
#

you have avatar hidden also

mellow zodiac
vocal shard
#

yes

unreal verge
#

What

mellow zodiac
#

the yes is the no

vocal shard
#

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

mellow zodiac
#

the. menace.

vocal shard
#

not funny didnt laugh

#

anyways...

mellow zodiac
#

the yes

vocal shard
#

ಠ_ಠ

mellow zodiac
#

go to random chat

vocal shard
#

no i dont think i will im done talking with you. ಠ_ಠ

mellow zodiac
#

the no

lyric onyx
#

Bruh. Would anyone like to become Vrchat Besties?😭😭

rancid jewel
#

!online

floral flaxBOT
#

There are 21266 users in VRChat currently

rancid jewel
#

approx 21266 people probably would

vocal shard
#

oh my god

#

savage

#

Anyone know how to adjust the UI while laying on my couch in FBT?

#

It is really uncomfortable. Would be a great QoL improvement.

#

i hate that aswell

dark vale
#

Why do you use fbt on a couch? Am I dumb?

twin fractal
#

you dumb

vocal shard
#

you know. lay down a bit after dancing and whatnot and then u press the menu and bam out of proportions big window

twin fractal
languid beacon
#

Go the ready player one method and just shut VRChat down on Tuesday’s screw over that one guy who can only play on Tuesday’s

vocal shard
#

I use ovrtoolkit and just communicate through discord.

#

The UI is too uncomfortable.

#

adeon what? xd

#

Also an invite all for a group tab would be a nice QoL

twin fractal
#

it would. but it's super niche and I doubt we'll see it anytime soon

violet summit
#

why do i keep showing as "offline" for myself and why am i not able see some friend who are online despite them being on

#

when im literally sat in the game and in a discord call with them

#

game broken as usual?

#

actually, i dont really even need to ask that

#

ofc it is

twin fractal
#

it takes a while to update sometimes. get vrcx

vocal shard
#

the api is having hiccups

#

read announcments

rancid jewel
#

hah api go brrrr

steel condor
rancid jewel
#

yeah pretty much

vocal shard
twin fractal
#

yeah I'm in a few clubs where it would be pog to invite everyone at once for events and shit but the majority of players aren't

vocal shard
#

Most of my friends can really leave orange or red status. The game has other issues I won't mention.

#

Then it takes 10 seconds for someone to ruin it. So I'm pretty over playing atm.

#

someone to ruin it? it sound like you have a bad case of 'oh idunno how to set up my safety settings properly' it does.

#

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

vocal shard
twin fractal
#

definitely a good idea but with how the devs operate I'm assuming it would be a very low priority feature atm

vocal shard
#

Where does that fit into safety settings.

twin fractal
#

you haven't seen the drama that happens in these sort of large group functions

vocal shard
#

invite only worlds i guess. and idunno what u mean by turn everyones headset off

#

I spend about 80% of my time at large events. Now im just going to sit in publics and complain about QoL like I use to.

#

hey please explain the turn everyones headset off part.

#

im curious

#

Exploits with no fix. Optimized crashers and desync exploits.

#

most of the things ur typing right now is fixed by either toning ur safety or/and turning off objects on world

frail raptor
#

Hello everyone

vocal shard
#

simple as that

frail raptor
#

Hewwo >:3

vocal shard
#

oh shi i take that back ur a furry

#

hello there

frail raptor
#

Pfft

vocal shard
#

not wanna do the hewwo near furries. they might get bad ideas

frail raptor
#

Should I be offended? 😅

vocal shard
#

:d

dark vale
#

Hello furry killz

vocal shard
#

of course not cameron. im just being cautious

twin fractal
#

yo

frail raptor
#

Ok?😅

normal kettle
#

just blasted some earrape indian music on cute couple, feeling good

vocal shard
#

:| toxic

frail raptor
#

I stay out of most conversations😅

normal kettle
#

ok pussy

#

jkjkkjjkjkjkjjkjkjk

#

plz dont cancel me

vocal shard
#

on ur way to nuisance?

normal kettle
#

its my first day on vr

frail raptor
#

Congratulations, you have entered the world you will probably never leave-

vocal shard
#

nuisance any% speedrun ya performing?

dark vale
#

Taut behave yourself we are not here for your language

frail raptor
#

I love this server already lol

regal furnace
#

getting vr is the first step to getting insane

dark vale
#

And the other step out of your life

vocal shard
#

your autofill changed immersed to insane

#

weird...

normal kettle
#

ok josifee

dark vale
#

Thank you.

frail raptor
#

I'm just here existing

twin fractal
vocal shard
#

taut word of advice... treat others in vrc how u would want to be treated. this way its enjoyable for everyone

#

and u dont end up nuisance rank

frail raptor
#

That's the first time I've heard anyone say that bro, you've earned my respect.

normal kettle
#

OK

vocal shard
#

tyty but not acc friend req's randomly. sry tho.

dark vale
#

Does anyone want to join vrc with me?

lavish scroll
#

How do I get the Very Poor, Poor or other ranks? And also what do they do?

vocal shard
#

in work

regal furnace
vocal shard
#

😂

noble depot
lavish scroll
#

Lmao ok

dark vale
#

The very poop medium good eycellent is for avatar optimizarion

regal furnace
#

to get very poor, you must be a very poor avatar creator /s

normal kettle
#

esxtra pore

dark vale
#

And you get visitor at start and then like new user user known user trusted user and friend

lavish scroll
vocal shard
surreal crypt
#

lmao

lavish scroll
#

Using the non-VR option sadhly

noble depot
#

If you made the avatar, I'd def look into optimizing with CATS Blender plugin o: (atlassing, combining meshes, etc)

dark vale
#

Very poor avatar as your is only meaning it will take some time to load for others to see you.

#

Doesnt mean anything significant

regal furnace
#

pffff, optimizing is for nerds

noble depot
#

def not true, avatars rated as Very Poor are going to be more performance intensive than one rated at good/excellent

surreal crypt
lavish scroll
#

Also are avatars with join animation allowed? Like my avatar (Not made by me) plays music and makes some particles, sparks, fire ans some random things for 30 secs when I join the game

regal furnace
dark vale
#

As visitor, I will not see any of your animations. Visitors like to drop servers so I disable it to prevent it

twin fractal
#

you could have a vrcPerfMedium avatar that's 80 mb vs a vrcPerfVeryPoor avatar that 8 mb but has 70,001 polys

vocal shard
#

I'm going to wear avatars my computer can handle and look for new friends. My name change is in 5 days.

lavish scroll
vocal shard
#

Starting a new house.

dark vale
#

Change avatar

regal furnace
lavish scroll
#

Ow.

noble depot
#

Unless the avatar has a parameter you can set in the radial menu to disable the animation, no

lavish scroll
#

Well I have to find a boy-avatars world then (Again) .-.

dark vale
#

Skip male chars they look gay. Pick female chars with big baloons

lavish scroll
#

But yeah most of them really do

dark vale
#

See? I saved you 5 minutes of your time

lavish scroll
#

Well rn I don't want to go avatar-hunting so I will change it tmr

#

Ty anyways

dark vale
#

David I was kidding. Sry you are new yes there is same as many avatars for male and female.

lavish scroll
#

I wasn't even going to listen to your advice but you are right. 69% of male avatars look weird or gay or just not good for me.

dark vale
#

Don't listen to people discouraging you using avatar you like

lavish scroll
#

Ty for telling me anyways 🙂

vocal shard
#

hmmm

lavish scroll
noble depot
#

kinda teetering to rule 2 lol

lavish scroll
#

Well I gtg. (Entering VRChat!)

young mirage
#

Hey guys we’re gonna go to find people that are interested into making some tick-tock’s on VR chat

vocal shard
#

For some reason, it's showing me logged in on quest when i'm on desktop. Not sure why that is.

#

most if not all avatars with a obnoxious intro are eboy avatars

lavish scroll
noble depot
supple python
#

damn... vive pro eye been out for so long and vrc still doesnt support the eye tracking, sad times

vocal shard
#

That's strange but at least it's easily fixed.

#

hate speech? where?

#

People can just make their own avatar if they are not happy with the variety of public ones.

#

It is a free game.

#

yeah thats what good bout here

dark vale
#

Its free, but you need powerful rig and you can buy expensive things like fbt or vr headset. So practially its most expensive game

vocal shard
frail raptor
#

What is the app to create the avatars?

dark vale
#

But the basic model is free

regal furnace
vocal shard
#

you could buy rtx titan to play cyberpunk. does that make it most expensive?

noble depot
#

would also recommend getting CATS Blender plugin as well!

vocal shard
#

^

dark vale
#

U can use vroid its easy toolcfor feee avatars

vocal shard
#

cough cough. u cant export them right?

noble depot
#

You can, they're just kinda badly optimized and not Quest-compatible from what I've seen

vocal shard
#

ah ok

noble depot
#

eyebrows/irises use transparency

cosmic shale
#

People cared about quest compatibility when?

dark vale
#

Photoshop is useful for editing textures too

vocal shard
#

never

#

i use gimp

dark vale
#

Never tried

vocal shard
#

free gnu image manipulation program

#

or whatever was it called

dark vale
#

I will give it a try thx

cerulean plover
#

Who can help me with my quest i need to make it a wireless pc vr with virtual desktop

crystal zinc
#

Hey, I need a bit of help. I'm playing VRChat for the first time in forever and I can't remember how to do special actions for certain avatars. I'm playing Optimus Prime and I can't remember how to transform T^T

noble depot
crystal zinc
#

CHeers, I'll try it out now :)

noble depot
#

keep rule 15 in mind o:
edit: message was removed

cerulean plover
#

Who can help me with my quest i need to make it a wireless pc vr with virtual desktop

jovial kestrel
steel condor
#

Okay, I got VRChat two days ago... I don’t have a quest vr, however I have a PSVR. Can you somehow make it work on the pc?

noble depot
#

With iVRy or TrinusPSVR yes, though you'll need a VR-capable computer o:

steel condor
#

Hmmmm.... are they trust worthy, also how would I tell if it’s VR compatible

torn python
#

we really need a room option to make it where Visitors can't join us, like allow us to choose what ranks are allowed in publics. Cause i really hate when visitors come in disrespecting everyone in a lobby and trolling everyone.

noble depot
#

iVRy is on Steam, and TrinusPSVR seems trustworthy to me lol
By VR-capable I mean a computer that's powerful enough to run VR - a GTX970 equivalent or preferably better, at least 8 GB of ram, a good CPU, etc

steel condor
#

Ah okay. I’ll look into the one on steam, as I trust steam so hopefully that is also trust worthy too, cheers mate!

steel condor
cosmic shale
noble depot
#

Segregating the community based on what rank they are would not go well

rancid jewel
#

yeah

#

plus it would probably only feed the superiority complexes even more

cosmic shale
#

Kinda dumb

steel condor
#

How does it select trusted?

unreal verge
#

Ranks don't say anything anyways except maybe playtime

noble depot
#

The basic idea behind the trust system is good, but people got superiority complexes over it

steel condor
#

Is it all based on time played?

rancid jewel
noble depot
# steel condor How does it select trusted?

The trust system is based off of many factors - friends, worlds visited, avatars/worlds uploaded (if the account has permission), and active hours all help, alongside not getting kicked/banned/muted/reported, etc
Time def isn't the only factor o:

cosmic shale
jovial kestrel
#

Basically anything you do in the app contributes to it in some way.

noble depot
#

^

steel condor
#

Fair play

cosmic shale
#

So basically it’s gonna slow you down if you get kicked by a lobby full of speds

unreal verge
#

Or degrades your rank depending on if you're annoying to everyone

vocal shard
#

maybe its just the longer you play the more of a prick you become who knows

cosmic shale
#

Or if you get spam reported by some dude with alt accounts

steel condor
#

Yh I bumped into a person who had a avatar which could crash... I didn’t believe him so I asked him to try it.... I crashed 😂

cosmic shale
torn python
rancid jewel
#

one time I got kicked from an instance because the instance owner selected public instead of friends when making the instance and decided kicking was a better idea then just making a new instance

unreal verge
steel condor
#

Big brain

vocal shard
cosmic shale
noble depot
cosmic shale
unreal verge
#

You can't stop avi crashers without disabling the whole avatar

cosmic shale
noble depot
#

ah fair
crashers that aren't stopped by hiding the avatar entirely aren't avatar crashers though lol

unreal verge
steel condor
#

I have chosen to disable it unless it is a friend or someone I can trust from chatting

vocal shard
#

No protection is the best way to play imo

#

yall unlucky af or im just lucky af

unreal verge
cosmic shale
#

You don’t disable a whole rank’s avatars unless you have a craptop or you’re just an asshole by nature

torn python
vocal shard
#

what

steel condor
#

Huh?

vocal shard
#

I think your confused entirely mate

cosmic shale
#

Speech 100

torn python
#

There are many models that bypass the particle limit

noble depot
#

VRChat definitely doesn't want you to be crashed - not to mention hiring a team specifically to comb through the tens of thousands of avatars would be kinda ludicrous lol

unreal verge
#

I disabled avatars from non-friends at least in lobbys with more than 8 people or if lots of people switch avatar rapidedly cause it causes major lags/freezes for me

vocal shard
#

soft cap, hard particle cap is like 2.1 billion and a bit last time I checked

steel condor
noble depot
steel condor
#

iVRy

vocal shard
#

At least I think since ive seen so many crashers with the same max of 2.1B

vocal shard
jovial kestrel
unreal verge
#

If you never want to crash uninstall VRChat - problem solved

noble depot
steel condor
#

Pog

noble depot
#

should clarify, lite version is free

steel condor
#

Ah is that the same as the normal version? Still works I mean

torn python
#

I highly doubt reporting a user does anything. There is a 7 year old still on vrchat with a NSFW model and I reported him 3 days ago

unreal verge
#

If my pc would be able to handle it i would probably enable everything except animations and audio for every rank

noble depot
#

Might be worth trying iVRy anyway to see if your computer can handle VR in the first place though! o:

steel condor
#

Seems like iVRy is the best option then

vocal shard
steel condor
#

Cheers @noble depot

noble depot
#

yw! c:

vocal shard
#

if your on windows easiest and best way imo is windows game bar recorder

torn python
vocal shard
#

thats extremely interesting. never knew u can play psvr with a beefy pc to pcvr

noble depot
#

also Shadowplay/ReLive if you have it, which lets you save the last couple minutes of gameplay o:

vocal shard
#

shadowplay

#

best software ever

noble depot
vocal shard
torn python
vocal shard
#

thats like saying I found a pedo with (redacted) but im not turning it in because I dont want to look at the (redacted)

unreal verge
#

I don't record ever on my pc

vocal shard
#

tfw 1tb of vrc vids recorded

unreal verge
#

I also disabled shadowplay cause idk how much performance it takes

noble depot
#

They can't do anything without evidence (screenshots, video, output logs, etc) - otherwise it's indistinguishable from a false allegation

vocal shard
#

+1

unreal verge
#

I never reported anyone. Well i don't have a reason to because i'm rarely in public worlds

vocal shard
#

you dont need to record all the time lmao just make sure your recording program is ready to go

rancid jewel
#

ye

unreal verge
wide cove
#

is there a way to force vrc to automatically launch at a custom resolution?

wet thorn
#

So will any avatar work with the new vive facial tracker or will the avatars need updated?

unreal verge
vocal shard
#

just hit windows key + G and should popup with a bunch of shit including recording

rancid jewel
unreal verge
#

I don't have that it seems like

vocal shard
#

Might need to install xbox or som lemme check

noble depot
#

you have to enable it in the Windows settings

vocal shard
#

oh ok

noble depot
#

"press win-dows gee, enayble"

unreal verge
#

Need to see how much performance that takes. In VR i can't run intensive stuff in the background

rancid jewel
#

game bar doesnt take up too much performance

wide cove
noble depot
#

sorry, linked to the wrong page initially - the -screen-width 1920 -screen-height 1080 options don't work? o:

vocal shard
#

I always have it activated its never useds more than like half a percent of cpu idle

#

for me at least

unreal verge
#

Yeah it uses around 0-1% CPU while idling

noble depot
#

resoulutions given are an example obv
Also, you could try holding Shift while launching the game to bring up the Unity launcher, and change the resolution from there maybe? o:

wide cove
#

im trying to get custom window sizes rather than the default options and the width and height options dont work

steel condor
vocal shard
#

lowering res works wonders

steel condor
rancid jewel
vocal shard
#

k/d imagine not recording good times in vrc ;)

noble depot
#

HTC might have hit themselves with a false advertising suit lol

lusty latch
rancid jewel
#

thats a lot

lusty latch
#

I can't tell if I'm impressed or disgusted

#

kinda both tbh

vocal shard
#

dont have time to edit it

#

last time i checked was 25hrs of footage

#

now probably more

lusty latch
#

upload that shit to the "hub"

vocal shard
#

the tube

#

if i get some spare time

rancid jewel
#

👀

vocal shard
#

of 5min clips. so a lot of stuff

#

good memes from past year

runic spade
#

How long does it take for a password reset request to send

#

Like, 5 minutes?

rancid jewel
#

probably

runic spade
#

Mk

cold prairie
#

lol

#

n

runic spade
#

?

woeful salmon
#

I'm on EmperorZero's Danganropa Avatar World, trying to find Junko

vocal shard
#

have you tried in the Junk bin? :D

woeful salmon
#

?

runic spade
#

I did

woeful salmon
#

I don't get it

vocal shard
#

you will never get it

#

XD

runic spade
#

You were talking to me, right?

vocal shard
#

no

woeful salmon
#

Is it because of her name, right?

runic spade
#

.

vocal shard
#

yes xd

#

sry

#

keep searching

#

if u find one with not as pretty face as junkos thats her sis

opal flicker
#

I was dancing for an full hour with some random people in the room of the rain

#

That was fun but now I am almost dead

vocal shard
#

what room is everyone in?

rancid jewel
vocal shard
#

thanks 🙂

lilac swan
#

I'm in my bedroom

limpid dust
#

Anyone wanna join me in the MERoom world just to chill and watch some videos

leaden shell
#

bruh, apparently farcry 2 is the same as furry according to VRchats world search

regal furnace
#

the world search apparantly includes descriptions

fathom ledge
#

silly question but i sign into vrchat through oculus but when i download the desktop steam version i cant sign in because i dont know my username

#

so how would i even sign in?

regal furnace
#

you cant sign in your oculus account on the steam version

ruby needle
#

Upgrade your oculus account to a full VRChat account

#

Then you can use that everywhere

fathom ledge
#

pretty sure i did that awhile ago to get rid of the digits in my username

#

or maybe that was something else

ruby needle
#

if you have no digit's then yes you have one

#

you'll need to look up your username and password then

leaden shell
#

I dare someone to search up farcry 2 in the search feature to see what worlds appear

fathom ledge
#

hm alright i can sign in because i know the password and email but not username but display name doesnt count apparently

ruby needle
#

email works too, yes

surreal crypt
#

(f)a(r)c(ry)

fathom ledge
#

oh really i can just put my email in the username bar?

ruby needle
#

yes

leaden shell
fathom ledge
#

oh bet thank you i probably shouldve tried that

leaden shell
#

when the image uploads

ruby needle
#

@leaden shell random chat is not a image hosting channel

leaden shell
#

well where is an image channel?

ruby needle
#

Either use a image host if you need to post here, else directly ask in the appropriate channels

rancid jewel
#

there are no image hosting channels

ruby needle
#

^the channels where the questions belong allow uploads

regal furnace
#

use imgur

leaden shell
regal furnace
#

not a image host channel either

ruby needle
#

Also not a hosting channel for other conversations either.

rancid jewel
#

vrchat pictures is for.. well.. vrchat pictures.

leaden shell
#

ok I'll use imagure and put it here

regal furnace
#

use that one

rancid jewel
#

i use discord embed links

regal furnace
#

or that

leaden shell
rancid jewel
#

theres nothing wrong with furry worlds

vocal mortar
#

loading worlds takes ages rn, are the server updates happening?

leaden shell
#

I know there isn't but i just got confused cause i was looking for a farcry 2 one so i could be african militant#1451252

rancid jewel
#

oh ok

leaden shell
#

bruh, now world download is at 100% but wont pop up with the go button

limpid dust
#

Yah same thing happened to me

dark vale
#

Restart client next time you start it and join that server it will be instant @leaden shell

rancid jewel
#

yoo new build
thanks team

polar crown
#

big hugops for vrc team through migration

hot echo
#

thanks guys!

thick scarab
#

nice to see that they know what's going on and they are fixing it

compact granite
#

do people have that many active friend requests at any given time that they'd need to have that history restored?

verbal meteor
#

I know a few people who... sit with a lot of them in there for some reason, I think a lot of it's because you find that annoying friend of friend and haven't got it in you to say no to avoid drama.

light pivot
#

I probably had 8-10 sitting around at one point, but when they became more obvious they got annoying so I cleared them.

compact granite
#

but you aren't told if a friend request is pending, just decline it by the end of the day

verbal meteor
#

streamers sit with 100's of them as well and just give in trying to clean em up.

compact granite
#

but why restore that history then lmao

verbal meteor
#

Beats me. XD

light pivot
#

I frequently used to just let them sit if I wasn't ready to accept the request from that person yet. Always funny weeks or months down the line when you accept and just turn yellow on them.

compact granite
#

i just don't add people if i don't plan to ever talk to them again

vocal shard
#

for the open beta

regal furnace
#

to get a notification when open beta rolls out again

onyx raft
#

Wish vrchat would show all the keybindings, only found out about using upper right letters to rotate held objects, and end being afk mode through other people

languid beacon
#

@leaden shell You searched for "Farcry 2". No worlds contain the word "Farcry", so you're getting all of the ones that either have a "2" in the name, or have a word with as many similar letters as the word "Farcry" which, well...

thick scarab
#

to be honest the world search is kinda weird, you look for someting like ''snow cabin'' and things that only have cabin or snow on it's name show up

languid beacon
#

It will prioritize the ones that have both first.