#US-Idaho
1 messages · Page 3 of 1
Not gonna lie. The buttes are only 1000-2000ft higher than their surrounding areas around here but they give coverage as good as MHR lol. KBS (Kimama Butte Station) is ridiculous. Though apparently it's somewhat unresponsive apparently.
I never use it. Everything I do goes through ISR
I did the thing
Kimama is only like 600ft higher than the interstate lmao, but yeah, I need to visit it this weekend and figure that out
https://youtu.be/t5a8KrCR9tY?t=1186
@clear flare and others. Time stamped if you want to know where almost all of your buttes come from
A presentation on the geologic story behind Yellowstone's supervolcano, its hot spot, and more by geology professor Shawn Willsey.
Support these educational videos! Your generous support allows me to create more videos. Send support via:
PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=EWUSLG3GBS5W8
Buy Me: https://buymeacoffee.com/...
Our geography is OP
You say that but did you know Utah has super volcanos too. There's a second mantle hot spot plume it formed the Indian peak caliente calder, the Tushar mountains and now Monroe peak is directly over it. For now it's capped by huge mountains and won't erupt or is unlikely to erupt until the continent moves the hot spot location to the wasteland by I70
Hahahahha
The whole basin and range is interesting
HACKING
There's 4 active volcanos in Utah but they erupt rather in frequently. Black Rock Volcanic Field, Santa Clara Field, Marysvale Volcanic Field, Hurricane fault field
There's the velo volcano in the Santa Clara Field hah
Back when lake Bonneville existed.. an underwater volcano rose to the surface and became Pahvant Butte
I love shawn wilseys channel. He talks about so much cool stuff in our states and wyoming
@willow raft whats this?
ha ha ok. no biggie ill kill it off
thanks getting the ID stuff added! looks great
Couldn't be bothered to add it to my path so I just threw it in the working directory lmao
I have fam in american falls, maybe one day ill try to get them to hop on the bandwagon
they have massive windmills on their land.. so easy placement there.. at least if the people that put them there let them screw a node to it lol
o.O so they have access to hills? 🤤
I actually don't know that I'd trust a build on a Windmill, don't they vibrate crazy bad?
prob lol dunno
Hang them on a rope
preferably on the end of a blade
@clear flare can you add the new infra nodes to our page or get it to Littleton.
Like Danskin and stuff
I’ll get Danskin and put up the ones for the others when they go up hopefully sooner than later
We got snoooowwwww baby
@clear flare @obtuse quiver
Neighborinfo is it configured correctly on FPR and MHR to broadcast every 14400 over Lora?
MHR should be. We’ll double check when we move over to make sure nothing is spamming too much or being too quiet
I believe so, I can check later.
Y'all switched over yet?
Had to replace the Rak in ISR. Just finished and got it over. Heading back to do the hackerspace node and then home to do the rest of mine. All the infra should be over tho
Well it will probably take 24 hours for most node data to populate
Oh I see ISR and MHR
Hell yeah
Clear hops to MHR too
The strength to MHR is awesome too. FPR and MHR have a very strong link
I still can't trace passed MHR lol maybe when everything settles in it'll be better
You should be able to. I just saw your node data show up. But also trace routes are unrealiable
We really should get a router up that's in between MHR and FPR as a failover
It really might be the best way
Would be ideal
Make it look like a weather station
I agree, but there is no chance that I can make that happen before next spring or summer lol
@clear flare another thing. Are all your routers rebroadcast all
It's what I moved to and TRs became more reliable idk why
Oh interesting. They should be but I’ll double check. See if I can get SidPatchy to double check MHR too
Let me know when you can see AUR. It's node info is quiet at 43200 but ultimately it sends out telemetry every 10-15 mins atm
It's 1 hop from fpr
@clear flare also don't feel bad if TRs don't make it. Like ultimately I have a 40% success TR rate to AUR and it's 1 hop from me LOL. I think something deprioritizes them
@clear flare are you f9b5
Something's wrong with my app but I can look at the debug panel and your msgs are there .. 3 hops
Still waiting on other node data
I am
Saw that. It’s a good explanation. The triangle is delta right?
@clear flare how's all the Idaho linking going. MHR over?
We're connected, though since not everyone has a high enough hop count set we don't get full freq51 convos. that's to be expected though. Still trying to poke and prod some of the folks who are less engaged to move over
I did have to fix ISR on the day of the change. my rakboard died so I had to steal one of the other planned deployments with replacements ordered
Also, got a couple more amps ordered to get an amped rak on Bennett. Hoping to get Bennett and/or Davis deployed this weekend.
I DID get a bit of interest from East Idaho. There's a guy in Teton who is going to put up a freq51 router somewhere around https://www.heywhatsthat.com/?view=D972V1XJ
Theoreticaly link to MHR @151 miles LOL
Compute summits visible from any location worldwide
Also, @alpine crescent is scouting spots in Boise 😄
Lucky Peak (aka Shaw Mountain) seems like it may be a good starting place.
Once we get an initial connection to Danskin or ISR, then we'll have to start working on some redundancy and getting more relays on MF51 around the valley.
Go ahead and set it to 7 medium fast. Can handle all of that
Our entire network right now is using about 0.33%, we have so much bandwidth available
That's probably not going to make it go butt put big Southern Butte up to help him out
I hope he named it Grand titty
😆
Haha I agree. BSB will make a huge difference for them.
We need to figure out the BBS system. All BBS host nodes should be set to seven hops
Mine are. That being said, I think we need to settle on whether or not we use !cmd or just cmd
Fpr is doing well. I've been monitoring its BBS link for peers and it seems to be listening and there seems to be replies
does FPR just respond to commands without hte bang?
or does it need the bang?
cause my bbs is calling just bbslink and it's not pulling any messages from FPR
but I do see FPR's messages coming through
or rather FPR's link calls
@obtuse quiver
He replied in the UT channel. I realized that the chats were a bit split so I just moved the quesiton over there lol
Let's get a concerted effort to move everybody to seven hops maximum. I want to see if that realistically hurts congestion anymore
@clear flare hey, so some weeks or months back i added Utah and freq51/intermountain mesh. any reason to add Idaho to it with the same link? https://meshtastic.org/docs/community/local-groups/#utah or since its the same no ?
Below is a list of groups that have been actively organizing Meshtastic networks in their regions. Feel free to contact
Oh yeah that'd be great!
I think adding it to ID would be good, even if they point the same way. Otherwise ID folks won't know where to look
ok can do unless @willow raft wants the PR
If you have time, I'd say go for it
ok im on it.
I've got nothing against you doing it :)
had it open so thought id offer
done on there and here https://github.com/ShakataGaNai/awesome-meshtastic just waiting for PR merges
hmm denied. how do we want to work this? this is go list idaho in their list.
@noble jetty @clear flare
Oh dang. I wonder if it's just the same domain, or if we could forward it from like idahomesh.com LOL
IMO, having it in the United States section makes it kind of harder to find, because that's definitely my first thought to look for
You know I don't know how to respond to this.
we could trey go discuss it with him here. https://discord.com/channels/867578229534359593/871540428510474302
hmm.
I mean, I guess it's not a BAD standard to have. If we did it, everyone would get to do it and that could balloon the page
make it more cumbersome to navigate
i guess. but would have an entry for idaho already the same or not. hmm.
With ISR and MHR on freq51 I really did hurt Idaho’s mesh :O. can’t even see out of Twin Falls
On LF20
I've been considering throwing a little placeholder site on magicvalleymesh.net (and intermountainmesh.com/.net) and giving it a little explainer on how it applies to Idaho before kicking them over to the documentation
I will work on that a bit today
cool could do that and just add that link to the PR then. name it magicvalleymesh instad lol in the PR that is to resovle the issue. .
up to you guys
idahomesh.com is better imo
I will build something that works for all of the domains
dope. just give me a place to point my records to 😄
cool don’t forget to ping him here. https://discord.com/channels/867578229534359593/871540428510474302
Umbriel Keys Reset. Please delete the node and rediscover it
MHR's G2 replacement is configed and ready to go up tomorrow. When we go up, gonna jump over to Cotteral Hills HP to drop the potential link down to NPR when it goes up.
Then just have to get Kimama back up and then we're back on track.
Fuck yeah I think that'll be good. Plus ultimately it'll be more reliable. FPR can remain a BBS link. I don't think that that's a bad idea. But there is enough hops in between both of those that bbs's on both sides that are manageable by people are so much better than putting the BBS on a hill
I agree. My house is at most 2 hops from FPR
so if the change helps us get through hopefully it'll start working
cause right now it feels liek FPR is deaf to MHR
but also maybe the FPR filter will help?
@alpine crescent here's another potential spot for a node 😛 https://www.heywhatsthat.com/?view=NEKCU2WF
Compute summits visible from any location worldwide
Holy moly, no kidding! Looks like a bit more of a trek to get to, but that's some freakin visibility lol. I may have to plan a drive out that direction and see how accessible it is.
I was also looking at this guy once we have an initial connection to the valley
Compute summits visible from any location worldwide
There's actually someone up there now on LF20.
Por que no los dos
I have no idea what @obtuse quiver plans are for a v5.2 with weather, filtering and an 8 dB
Baymesh filter, BME680 from V4, no plans for 8dB.
I think these are the best deal on antennas right now:
https://www.aliexpress.us/item/3256806241790045.html
I replaced the Alfa on WC2 with the 45cm (rated 7dBi) and it really improved its connection to the valley. I think that 45cm is the sweet spot. bash bought both the 45cm and 55cm versions. The 45cm I have measured have better SWR. The 55cm had a much more flat curve, but SWR wasn't quite as good at 915. I'll probably order a 35cm to measure too, but I need to get some measurements in a difficult spot first. Hopefully before we get more tariffs.
Good info, thanks. I picked up a 45cm.
Sadge. I've loved my 10 dB Omni 🤣
OP as hell
I've debated putting a 10 dB on AUR LOL
but it would become way to obvious
Do you still have that rokland one?
Yeah I still have the 8. I have three more tens
What color best blends up there
It's sticking straight out of a bright blue shack. There will be no blending in. 😂
MHR-G2 is live
@noble jetty it got spicy. 15ft visibility. Ladder icing over while I was on it.
Started dropping snow pellets as we got down
Hahaha good times
What color is the tower I mean
Sorry, not sure what you mean. The shack is light blue, The T-post is dark green, the conduit is bare zinc coating.
I love those conditions. Amongst my favorite kind of weather
Okay so dark green would match the tower
Okay so rustic brown then
Me too, when you live in a dry place your whole life those foggy moments are really special!
Cotteral is up. In theory, when Kimama is restored and NPR goes up it might be an alternate route
At least until we can get BPP up then it’ll convert to client
Heywhatsthat link?
Coords
Best I got right now
If it doesn’t quite work, I won’t be terribly upset. It was literally a 30 minute drive from the Harrison Lookout, where I was parked
Solid maybe
It would have to be directly on the highest point though
I don't know if you gave me the correct GPS cords because it was a little off
If it's not directly on the highest point, it absolutely will not work
I think I got it there. How tall is NPR going to be?
And how much a difference will that make?
I mean there's a keepout zone on the tower of the base of the tower.. that's at least 12 ft tall so we know it's going to be above 12 ft
The average keepout zone for the base of a tower is always 10 to 12 ft. As long as the tower is more than 100 ft tall obviously
I think NPR is a tower is 270 ft tall?
But a lot of the higher areas are already taken up by pc25 equipment and stuff
So there's pretty much just one available area. I just don't know how high it is up.
Tonight i need to reset my home node. Because don't know why i can't Bluetooth connect to it. And i need to get back to this stuff after now finishing everything else ive been doing
Hopefully the Bluetooth is working. Otherwise... I don't know c to c cable running down a tree?
does it show up but won't connect? Forgot the Bluetooth connection on your phone?
I don't know if tvm hq node is active but.. i can't connect to the ndoe by Bluetooth anymore just never appears. So im assuming it might just be off
What's the status of all of Idaho being on 51?
51?
Freq51 is the name of the mesh that spans Northern Utah to Southern Idaho.
I can try to push for that. Because probably need to check my relays before the winter hits. And thus can set them all to 51 and whatever else
Probably medium fast as well im assuming
Ok, I'll look at it more tonight when i reconnect to my home node. And can see the mesh again
MediumFast is a goat'd present
Not much loss
Big increase in air time available to each client
@clear flare is Danskin switched to MF?
I don't see it on the node list
It's not linked, so even if it was you wouldn't see it
It cant' see anything here yet
Awww needs another router in between huh
Maybe that Hayden peak you posted haha
I had planned on doing Danskin and Davis up in teh same weekend, but Danksin took me 4 hours to get to one way lol
Bennet will take you some time as well but it's pretty goated if you can get up to the top and post it up
Yeah, honestly I think Hayden is superior to both
it's 150 miles or so from Harrison LMAO so a 1w node up there with a good antenna might reach
Worst case it can drop down to ISR adn then up to MHR
Por que no los dos.
We have basically shown that you need routers on both sides of the valley. That's the SLC experience. And it unifies coverage.
Oh for sure
Wonder if Hayden could see NPR LOL
Whats the theoretical range when you factor in earth curvature?
Probably about 150-170 miles at 10k feet
oof so hayden to MHR would be on the edge lmao
Compute summits visible from any location worldwide
159 miles to MHR
124 to ISR
I remember when I was impressed by a 30 mile hop
I want to get permission to put up a long life stratospheric balloon
Take that longest hop
😂
I'm hoping to get Lucky Peak up in the next handful of weeks, which should connect @clear flare and @frail hedge's routers.
Will need to get Bennett and/or Davis up to bring it all in and convert Danskin over to MF51
Weird my home node was just off. But had power and everything in the ammo box was clean
But back online
What's your home node?
Tvm hq
I mean what's your board model, lol.
Um... The standard wisblock one. I have to check the exact number
Seems to be a thing that happens, I wonder if lightning can induce a brownout in some of these devices.
Lmao goals for real!
would be weird since no strikes near my house in the suburbs. but all the mountain stuff is alive. I'm thinking maybe day night cycle, with the sun and cold nights, doing sometihng to the battery and solar. Just a very rare chance of power off for a split second
Omg it’s alive
Nice! Did you do anything to get it back up?
Threatened it via building a replacement with a Heltec t114 lmao
It knows...
I think it actually just got run down and hasn’t had the voltage to turn back on because of the lack of sun
But some sunny days will hopefully replenish it
does anyone have a read on north and south tvm relays. i haven't picked them up yet since my reset of my home node. go the table rock one just fine
I wonder if you need more batteries in it and a bigger solar panel
What's its build
Yeah, my mobile node received from both north and south within the last 5 mins
10w18v solar panel through a waveshare mppt with 5000mah Eve cells. Runs the amp at 1w and a rak.
It ran for 2 weeks at like 15-20% airtime before it had like four or five days of cloudy skies
Yeah I'd have gone 20 watt lol just cuz this will give you trouble in winter
It's the amp that takes more than one thinks
Plus all the annoying led's on the wave share and the constantly on boost and buck converter
it'd be easy to upgrade the panel
20 W acopowers on Amazon are nice
Sizeable but really nice
I've got a 25watt eco worthy just chilling here 😄
That works too though those are even bigger
They have lots of sizes
Us built. A real quality output. Charges in extremely low light
And actually rated for up to baseball sized hail
yeah i have a stack of different ones. i figured 10w18v would be plenty because according to docs old FPR was a 114+amp on a soshine
but it had 1s12p
this si the solar i've used on all my nodes
long cable, cheap, durable, plug and play
It better crap gold too if it's gonna cost 30% more than the ecoworthy. 😂
I'm baffled by FPR v4's performance because the solar panel is absolutely dinky.
I guess the trickle charge was enough because it had a huge battery pack.
its a 1000x more durable lol
mine has survived hail
my soshines did not
ecoworthy might if it uses real plexiglass
it was a heltec
nrf52 based
they dont need anything
Its why I like nrf52s and dont usually care for 1 wat
VERY power efficient
Yeah, but I figured the amp would suck down a lot of power.
he had the amp set I believe for a specific amount of amplification
I think it was 4 dBm
bringing it to 1 watt
so not much power
Huh, it tracks. It was like at 85% still when I got to it.
Makes me wish we'd get a station G2 with an nrf.
e22 + nRF 😛
POTM has a Soshine. That thing has been up for like 2 years. It's windy as hell at POTM.
Gdane also did something smart/interesting, he cut a hole in the NEMA box to recess the bulge on the back of the panel into the enclosure and glued it right on. 90 degree is not great for solar, but apparently it's good enough with an oversized panel. Anyway so the cabling is all internal in the box. Nothing exposed to get ripped out.
I don't know who this is:
https://malla.freq51.net/packet/15317
but we didn't get that down to utah 🙁
So now that we’ve cleared up our congestion, are you guys hearing us out of Idaho?
That is me
It's cool to see how many unique gateways heard it in malla
The only explanation I have is that FPR is half deaf to stuff
FPR needs a filter
Cause we get everything from you guys lol
Having more gateways could really actually help determine where a packet dies
That will be super nifty
@obtuse quiver
You want me to make you one of these for FPR?
#1197577977781821541 message
Cavity filter would be better, but I think these are still good.
Is that a bandpass on a little breakout board?
It's a murata filter soldered inline in a pigtail. No board at all.
It next to never gets hail though. I had hail smack a node in Huntsville lol. A lonely node
Also maybe make a box with an angled front so you can still recess it in but at 45 degrees
Ehh just give mt ogden a good filter
It will see MHR no problem
FPRs signal is good. There's not as much noise up by FPR as there is at NPR and POTM
Quieter environment even on the SDR
Much quieter
Might be easier to just angle the whole box and correct the antenna polarization later.
I mean you can 3d print boxes. Someone made a good model file for it and shared it on printables. Wouldn't take much to modify it in freecad if one isn't maximally lazy 😂
Like me
Why not both? The idea is to have redundancy it would be best if both links are as good as possible.
And printing a box big enough to fit the entire SoShine in would take forever!
I mean up to you. I thought you were done with FPR for the winter
Wasn't aware you had plans for the 5.2
I do, I'm waiting on Bash for my battery.
You don't have much time. The road closes Nov 1st down at the lower gates. You'll be walking for a very long time
Trust me I know. It sucks. That's how I almost wasn't a alive anymore
Doesn't look that snowed in yet from here.
Waiting six months to get anything done sucks is all. 😬
Then you might want to hurry
And you don't need to wait. You just need an alpinist. I'll go with snow shoes and skis
You need to make it perfect and reliable as this will likely be your last update for some time if you don't want to snow shoe
Snow shoeing sounds like fun.
Evo and Level 9 could probably outfit you or REI if you don't have any
And yeah it's fun. It's chill too.. you usually stay warm
But yeah, two weeks might be a little tight. I don't want to rush something out, but I think everything is accounted for this time. I want to upgrade the enclosure to a steel box.
Give that Rokland to Bash for Mount Ogden though. 😂
I would save the upgrades
You don't have time
It's basically do or don't in less than two weeks
Fair enough. Just the filter can be done this weekend.
No! We want him to use the baymesh3 he purchased
He has the space in his enclosure. It's going to be much better
Well then you have a time crunch is all I'm saying
I have the filter. Everything's ready. We just need to have him pick it up and take it up the mountain
Space Thursday?
Yes! I'll be there around 8:30 8:45
Hey, will you bring your hot plate on Thurs? I would like to try and remove the Taoglas from one of my existing hats.
Here's my trick
It's been working well
I put it on my stovetop 😄
Mmm, lead residue where I cook food. 😋
it will puthair on your chest.
@alpine crescent how’s the parts acquisition coming for Hayden?
I got a good chunk of them today, actually! I'll be assembling the bulk of it this week.
Based on my schedule, I may not be able to drive down to place it until the following weekend, though.
Awesome! If Hayden is anything like Harrison you might be ok before November. Pomerelle is still dry.
Finger crossed. It was a little chilly and rainy today in the valley 🤞
@willow raft dang still needed special stuff done i see lol. https://github.com/meshtastic/meshtastic/pull/2059
Below is a list of groups that have been actively organizing Meshtastic networks in their regions. Feel free to contact
but its up 😄
hah well done.
i still need to scoure through your info you sent me. add more to the docs.
I'm pretty handy at documentation if I have all the details. Happy to help 😄
@frail hedge @alpine crescent if the TV swaps to freq51 once Hayden is up and a link is established, is there a central location that should have LOS to 0 hop Hayden and potentially the others that could be home to a Meshing-Around BBS node? I can donate a Femtofox to this endeavor if needed
That's a great question. I'd be happy to host in Star. @frail hedge may be a little more central in Meridian, but I suppose either could work. Maybe once the connection is established we can do some tracerouting to determine the best spot.
If its at your house, it'd probably be best with grid power. they take about 1 5000mah cell/day
Or just rebuild what you're building for Hayden LOL
The nice thing is its all one piece. though you'd want to give it network access so you can remote in and tweak for fix it
Or just give it internet and a tailscale connection to me and I can do that LOL
All eight 21700s 🤓 😅
LOL
Making sure it doesn't go down this winter lol. I'm making the battery trays removable, though, so we could tone it down next year if need be.
Sounds good, I'm down to help get that up and running when the time comes.
ya i'm going to switch over, whats the link to the freq51 thing again. so i can post it in the mesh before i swithc
meridian is my home node. but pearl and melba are my relays
thank you
Might be good to coordinate with @alpine crescent when he's putting up hayden so you can do some testing in town. I should be down here in Twin to test from this end
problem is my relays are a hike, so getting to them is a pain in the ass to reach
I believe in you! Take your new bride with you 😛
i wish i could, but i have more work before that can happen.
So, for context. The reason for having teh meshing around bot somewhere that has direct LOS to hayden is to minimize hops to other BBS nodes. I'm 3-4 hops from the SLC BBS nodes and if you were 3-4 hops, if we synced every 30 min we'd have a solid bbs network that lets us post messages from anywehre to anywhere
My plan is to head up to Hayden on Sunday, 11/2. I'll keep you guys updated on here.
Do you have remote admin set up for them to switch setting over lora?
I imagine they need to get updated too
No all manual. Because forces me to do inspections a few times a year
Next weekend i'm switching my nodes over to freq51 based on what idahomesh.com info says
So start of the new month should have nodes all updated firmware. And to the new freq plus medium fast speed i believe we all willbe on
I'm planning on getting Hayden up tomorrow afternoon, so that'll be perfect timing!
I'm gonna have to figure out how I can update and fix Danskin -_-
So we should be making a decent push see next few weeks to the change over
Also don't forget to post in the mesh. So people not on the discord can know
I can't get to you guys
Well for your area
Haha i see it
Funny how someone else thought of that name
lol
oh
its a slick app
Thats the BBS link setup that we're going to use across the whole mesh
i have a pi 3 and 4. i should use the 3 for a bbs node. someday
the 4 i still need to turn into a atac server
i use OpenTak
i tried using freetak. but i don't know just couldn't get it going. but assumed i'm just doing something wrong
but freetak isn't developed
is the guide i tried
this is super easy
the dev is really good if you join teh discord
helps a lot and is super repsonsive
thank you, i will try it out proberly tomorrow. since gotta do media server work with a new hardrive. so might at well try opentak well in the tech support role
also you might find this build cool, if you haven't seen it yet
The Military contacted me...
I reverse-engineered a $20,000 military IP mesh radio using just $106.23 in open-source parts. This isn't a gimmick—it's a fully functional MANET router capable of push-to-talk, GPS sharing, ATAK integration, and more. In this video, I’ll show you how I built it, tested it, and deployed it in the real world—no...
that would be cool. i had plans with doing atac stuff. but then life and marraiage, made money go bye bye. granted happy, but now i have future to plan for
idea was to intergrate the pi atac server into a very long flight drone drone. basically give you a mobile atac server that can have clear connection even in the mountains. minus exetremes
lots of power on that drone to fly long enough
be better off with a baloon solution 😛
a decent flying wing, with flight controller, you can pack with a lot of batteries. or better yet just mini gas engine. and get a lot of flight time
hours and hours
also a gas powered drone, ive wanted to do. because thats just cooler. also ever since i seen a guy do mid air fueling with drones. i've wanted to do that. though his was more impressive because he did mid air recharging
i love seeing hobbiest make crazy stuff.
Like building a function mesh taht covers 10000 square miles? 😛
ya
that spans 2 states and 4 regions?
though if i had the money i would make a meshtastic chinese spy ballon. because... why not
sure it wouldn't help us for long. but.... would be cool to know how long it would travel the world
i would be arrested so fast if i had more expendable income. hahahaha
hell i once had a plan to build a liquid fuel rocket when i had a shop
lol
I'm working on a wild idea. A battery drone.
If I want to keep a fixed wing electric drone in the sky constantly. I can send up a sort of tanker drone if you would. Recharge in flight.. and bring it down.. to charge and wait for the next interval
Adding that to ardupilot is gonna be fun
wait. do you mean instead of mid air rechaging like i mentioned. it's a mid air battery change??
anyone else super frustrated with the lack of reliability of Meshtastic? I just can't seem to get messages delivered reliably
I've got 100% reliablitity down here in Twin.
Where are you at? How is your infrastructure?
I'm in Eagle, I have 3 nodes at my house, but can't get a message over to Star
i've been trying to grow things here for a while..... https://www.starhamradio.com/meshtastic
@clear flare I've taken my radios down to Hagerman before (a while back) and wasn't able to see a single other node......has that changed down there/
might be interested to hear that Freq51 the Intermountain Mesh is getting something up on Hayden Peak hopefully today or next weekend weather permitting
if you were IN hagerman probably not going tos ee a difference since they're in the canyon
I saw that freq51.... TVM HQ messaged about it on the long fast recently
That's our map
Currently have a link from Mount Harrison that covers the majority of Southern ID that is ~130 miles to a peak over Layton in UT. kind of spotty atm but there are hopefully redundant links being set up soon
can you reach up to the Boise area via RF?
If all goes well with Hayden, it should be a 110 mile link from Hayden to Indian Springs in the south hills or 150 miles to Harrison
It's happened before on LF20
but was super unreliable
So, Hayden and ISR and Harrison are all pretty high powered nodes. The answer is: "According to physics, yes"
and since we've seen it with FPR, I've zero doubt that we can do Hayden down to here
i used to have a radio up on the ridge in star, but brought it home to update the firmware and never put it back
it is a solar node though, and can run indefinitely
it's currently strapped to my back fence......but not really at elevation
That's about all I deploy at the moment.
was thinking about putting it on the roof of my house to see what i can reach
Have you heard of MeshCore? https://meshcore.co.uk/
My harrison router is a cavity filtered G2 with a 25w solar panel and a 3s8p battery back
I actually flashed it to a few nodes to test, and found it WAY more reliable and usable, but nobody else was using it
one of the coolest things about MeshCore is that is has a room server feature, kind of like a BBS where you can store messages
Sure have, we were talking about it yesterday a little bit, but personally, the community is the biggest detriment. I lurk in their discord and they just talk all kinds of shit about every other mesh protocol warranted or not. Their attitude is very elitist. They also lack all of the tools and fun things that the meshtastic community has built like ATAK plugins, monitoring tools that patch in, etc
yeah, community is much bigger for meshtastic for sure......but reliability and usability was much better in my testing with MeshCore......I was really hoping for Meshtastic to catch up by now........i put the latest MT on all my devices, and am still left wanting
where can i find the meshcore discord?
This is a nice write up btw!
Thanks, it was just a quick and dirty page to help our ham radio group understand meshtastic and try to grow it up here
Nah mid air fast recharge. Use bleed air off the main EDF to cool the process
Are they on 51 hahaha
Here, yeah. 😄
but the tallest building here is like 5 stories and there are only 55k people in "the city" lmao
so there's less obstruction, less RF noise, and less of, well, everything LOL
yelp thats me. hopefully that improves things if we all do a reliable change over
thats smart using the air speed as passive cooling.
LF is only good up to about 60 total nodes from my understanding. once you're beyond that you need to start looking at other presets like med slow or med fast
also, go @alpine crescent go! Braving the weather for the mesh LOL
Operation Hayden Peak Deployment is a go LOL
a good relay on haydon will reach far. and if you make a ultra long range node with yagis you can really bridge any gap
@clear flare can you reach up to Boise via RF from down there?
are you already on the freq51 network?
Yeah most of Twin Falls and teh couple folks in Burley is
does it reach up here?
We are going to find out how Hayden peak works today
boise area atleast for my stuff will be switching next weekened
@frail hedge what nodes do you have up here?
Hayden peak is getting deployed this afternoon. @alpine crescent is the one doing it and he's just getting ready to go up
i own the north tvm, south tvm, and table rock tvm relays
plus the tvm hq
so i'm basically surrounding the treassure valley
i think almost everyone in the valley has dirrect connection to one of my relays
i believe i responding. but i've been at store hurs ago and been chatting with friends
yes! thanks
@frail hedge are you switching all your nodes to freq 51?
ya. that is the plan
because they are a network meat to surround and bridge the valley
it will be interesting to see how that affect the default long fast around here.......might really hinder it
i'll have to swap at least one of my nodes to freq 51 so i can stay on top of it all
i probably will do a once a week or 2 week pop over to the default. to send a message
When I moved my infra over, it definitely had an impact on Twin Falls.
because my hq node reaches a lot
I detest when a regional group decides to buck the standard.... makes it so travelers can't tke part.
what is the reason for the switch?
improve connections, stablity, and also data push through
@frail hedge @alpine crescent suggested, that if Hayden works well, you could probably leave TVM South on LF20
is the default overloaded? or will it be more reliable?
LF is only really reliable up to like 60 nodes
it's too bad there isn't a way to bridge the separate networks
Beyond that you need to switch otherwise the links are too slow and you get a lot of packet collisions
i can do that. but only if hayden can high reliably signal strentgh to other node
otherwise maybe tablerock i will switch over
Yeah for sure. maybe do TVM south last and test the others to Hayden?
tvm i will freq 51 last. because it's the hardest hike
and if you can, swap over a node at home if you have a spare to help test Hayden
how many nodes can MEDIUM_FAST handle?
my home node tvm hq i will flip between freq 51 and efault once a week or every 2. to broadcast the freq51 message
if my tbeams didn't breka i would just make them auto broadcast weekly. but damn antennas broke on both
though tvm hq i'll turn into a bbs node using my spare pi 3. if thats wanted, and i get the set up instructions
heck yeah! a BBS would be super cool
It's in the works. Dual radio nodes is a planned feature.
since bbs i know, is really good. since store and send STILL DOESN"T WORK!!!
yes, its one of the coolest things about meshcore, is that you can run a bbs on a standard node.....no need for a pi
plus bbs technicall can let you connection the west coast to the east coast
I run a BBS down here. There are a couple in SLC and we are working out the linking for them. Getting more in Boise and East ID and then all linked is the goal!
if we properly intrgrate bbs. we don't have to worrying about always being conected, thansk to saved messages. and hop limit can be elimated
Pretty much but the BBS links over RF, so there needs to be links somewhere lol
though funny enough we can also make node id numbers within a bbs network. basically phone numbers. so hop limit doesn't exist, so long as there's a way for the network to reach the target area
but gets messy if the node leaves it's noted region. unless you want extra overhead
because there i no real reason we can't have designated regions in the network with their own id codes. so instead of talk everyone. you can just message salt lake region. or only twin falls.
just requires a lot of coordition ot make sure all stations run the seme registry
I'm en route with the RAK powered up in the trunk. Keep your eyes peeled for HPR_c312 on freq51 in the next couple hours 😎
will do
though i really should try to find a way to connect my home node to my computer. since bluetooth range can't reahc my room
Safe travels!
so if anyone messages me and wonders why im slow to respond. thats why,
Sounds like you need to get yourself a mobile node haha
hey now lets not give reasonable solutions
Better plan, rebuild your home node with PoE and network and then you can just connect over IP
Then, instead of using your phone, you can get a server, spin up a vm, laod up ubuntu, connect the node to a terminal and use it at your computer
ya best to spend over 1000 to fix a 50 dollar problem
THEN you can build virtual meshtasticd sim nodes that pass data packets over UDP and have 5 or 6 different nodes for different functions for FREE
Sorry, i thought you wanted unreasonable? 😛
though if i add my pi3 to it as a bbs node i can then use wifi to reach my computer
Honestly, if you can get a good pi hat (i have one of the adv pi hats from frequency labs somewhere), slap a poe adapter on it and put that in a box is the way I'd go for a home node if you can't power an esp chip via solar
with enough solar everything can be solar power
Unless you can get your hands on a nebra, but those look pretty dried up at the moment
I run my G2 on my roof off a 16ah 12v lifepo4 battery with a 25w12v solar panel
like $60 in hardware + the node
though i could run a cat cable all the way from the node to the crawl space, then up the wall to my computer
stupid but cat5 is like what 10 dollars a thousand feet
Baymesh has been on Medium Slow with about 600 active nodes and they are switching to Medium Fast now probably because of congestion. Medium Fast has twice the data rate of Medium Slow, so presumably over 1,000 nodes. I don't think it scales linearly.
and thats a lot of nodes at 600 already
Yes, honestly I think Freq51 would be better off on MS until we hit 500+ nodes.
to bad we can't easily do a multi speed set up. have nodes that can send and receiver on two freq and/or speeds at once.
so in a town everything can be short fast, then medium fast connecting towns, and so forth
because why push for speed to reach 100km if you just want to talk within 10km
well always wanting to share to those far.
but i know we can do that with two nodes connected to a pi. because the pi can just copy and paste from one to the other and vice versa
but a basic read write script wouldn't be the most eligent solution.
Here's hoping @alpine crescent didn't get stuck on the side of a mountain :S
Hopefully he told someone nearby where he's going. 😬
Presumably 😮
Good news bad news. Good news @alpine crescent is alive. Bad news Hayden peak is already closed
So maybe once the weather clears and if he feels like bushwacking a ways Hayden peak may be beyond us until Spring
I will do the hike on foot if someone wants to come
Because thats an all day trek on foot maybe a camp at the peak
anyone in here control the website: https://freq51.net/migrate I think it might be good to list setting the freq to 51 in the ios GUI instructions
I have 2 of my 3 radios on Freq51 setup......waiting for people to pop up......so far nothing
Share a screenshot of your channel and preset config.
both are in my office though......not outside and not at elevation.......going to try to stick one on the roof tomorrow
off to bed, will check again tomorrow
Remember the boise area only recently got the freq51 message. So will take time
Definitely get the frustration when things aren't quite working though. I'll let @frail hedge and @alpine crescent work out how/when to tackle Hadyen. Alternatively, was thinking this could work in its place if it has to wait until spring: https://www.heywhatsthat.com/?view=K2DWSCFS
Compute summits visible from any location worldwide
That is a spot we should tackle regardless i think. Because good range and coverage. For now would be a good stop gap until hayden. Because with roads to hayden closed, we'd have to backpack it. And i can assist in that, be would want it to be two man team.
Brownik said it was only a couple miles from the peak, so if you could drive to the gate it might not be TOO bad
but if Bennett is easier to get to, it's honestly a bit more "middle ground" than Hayden is
More likely to get to MHR for sure
A few miles is easy then. I could solo that. But i aint trusting my honda to make it to the gate 😂
Ideally we want high (hayden) and mid (bennett) ground. Because we want high for range and mid for coverage
will do i’ll add that tomorrow thanks.
There is another route to Hayden that may or may not be better. I went straight down through Murphy.
It comes in from the north, where my route came in from the south. The red circle is around where I got stopped.
I guess Murphy doesn't show on this map but it's south of Melba.
Also, my route also said only 3 hours, but apparently it assumed I'd be going 55mph down these bumpy, windy, dirt roads 😂
Needless to say it took much longer...
That to china ditch, it says the same thing on those dirt roads. I think 55 is the default it assigns to country roads
How does the topo look for that spot
Tomorrow ill look on some hiking trail sites and apps. Maybe they have some details like a trailhead
Compute summits visible from any location worldwide
Well shoot. The other way looks like it's actually BLM land.
Thats good
Looking at it, seems like if you can make it to turntable north or city range south. It's an easy trek the rest of the way.
Most time consuming part will be dig andq chiseling into the mountain for the antenna mast
Maybe you and I should try driving that other way soon, @frail hedge.
Depending on how far it is, See if you can do a C6 style "Fuck you hippies" install LMAO
10-12ft mast and concrete
Ya agreed. Assuming the roads are doable for me.
I mean i can....
I set up my south relay well tocking my plate carrier with plates. Thats was an extra 20 pounds of bullshit. But good exercise
But pressure treated pine and galvanized brackets work best
Easy to carry in 4 foot beams. And light. Plus durable
Deck screws to tie together and also spike the foundation so it can be pulled out
I've got a t post with pressure treated 2x4 mount I was gonna use. I can send you pics and deets tomorrow and we maybe can come up with a plan.
The 2x2 4 foots i found work perfectly
Plus cheap like 2-3 bucks
2x4 for foundation might be best if we want total height to be 12 feet
So 2x4 buried 2-3 feet in the ground with screws. Then 2 sections of 2x2 at 4 feet a piece ontop
If your'e gonna go that high, I'd go with a 4x4, but that gets heavy
it's not a small rak build. it's quite the build that he put together 😄
We only need the antenna up. The module can be 5 fert high
oh no the loss. better to be as close as possible. plus the antenna is mounted to the box
Ya true
If it were a G2 and you could push more power to compensate for hte loss, i'd be less worried
And like hell we going to get the really high end cables for these things. Just to have almost no loss
Because we still operating in happy fun time prices
IMO, for the regional connectors like MHR(Mount Harrison), Hayden, and Bennett we ought to keep them as tight as possible
Getting the distances we need to get means we need to optimize for as little loss as possible
Ya after you mentioned the loss i agree
I think your plan of elevating the antennas for the nodes that are built to service an area are fine to do do somethign like that as long as it's not awful
But Hayden has to go 110 miles to get to ISR lol
God dann those skewers are good
150 miles to get to Harrison
We could do a dual node set up
thats more hops tho.
One runs a yagi and another rocks omi
True but if future planning for bbs. That matters less
omnis work just fine IMO even with that plan
True but if we want max signal will quality to bridge distance a yagi will be more reliable. Will give less coverage. But that doesn't matter if it just needs to be point a to b with let problems
Maybe when we decide to try to fold in Vegas to the Intermountain Mesh 😄
Haha ok ok i get the point
Most of hte places that even these routers are gonna go are going to dual purpose service an area AND bridge regions, so, we could try an omni aiming at MHR from hayden if the omni's other lobes can still cover enough of the TVM
and that might not be a bad idea. I've jsut not experimented with yagis at all so i know their directional is strong but i dont' know how good the lobes are
But to test it we would beat be doing it in easy to reach locations
better? https://freq51.net/migrate
yes, thank you. Wasn't meant as a criticism btw.....just trying to help make the transition easier
Oh no for sure. thank you for the suggestion. more info we can add to make it easier the better. thank you!
keep them coming 🙂
Just noticed step 2 in the Android instructions doesn't include changing the freq slot to 51. 🙃
Thats a pretty important step
thanks. forgot. i only did it for IOS. thanks. dont have an andriod to get a image from but will work on that.
The screenshot that's in there already looks good, just need to add it in the bullet point list.
thank you sir
Thank you for getting that put together!
😛
lol
Anyone in the Treasure Valley switched over to freq 51 yet? I have 2 radios and don't see ANYONE.
I have a few switched over in Star.
My rooftop node is on Freq51, along with a couple of my mobile nodes, but medium fast may not punch as far yet without some relays switched over.
That should change dramatically this weekend though lol
ok, i have one in my backyard, and one in my office........if it warms up, i might put my outdoor solar node on the roof and see if that changes things
I know a few are waiting for my stuff yo switch over because of the coverage i provide
And that will happen Saturday
I genuinely feel pride knowing i keep seeing people mention in the mesh. That because the tvm is changing over they will to.
Though i should post another reminder today
i put my solar node with a good antenna on my roof.....waiting for first contact
You probably won't see too much until after this weekend
Because once i switch my stuff over. Basically everything in the valley is visible to each other.
Though i wish star radio node we know who that is
Because that dude is visible somehow everywhere.
@clear flare status of maybe getting Boise in on the Freq51 mesh..
Not sure what channel those homies are on
Hayden hopefully this weekend. The TVM relays are happening this weekend. @frail hedge is spreading the word.
This weekend it goes down
Holy shit. Hell yeah
@frail hedge you can point people to https://freq51.net/migrate
This mesh is gonna be So YUGE
Saturday i have 3 change overs. Sunday we put up a new node at hayden
Let's hope we can comms in less than 7 hops between SLC and Boise
That will be a milestone
My count, if Hayden can hit MHR, Boise <> Hayden <> MHR <> FPR <> beyond
Assuming it all works @frail hedge @clear flare please get with @pine tapir and @mellow girder to PR allllll of the infra into the infra page
We can do that in 3. I planned a route out before ocer a year ago when i originally planned the link up
But it requires work
If the butte north of Twin hits Cotterel and Cotterel can hit NPR? Boise <> Hayden <> Flat top <> Cotterel <> NPR <> beyond, but that’s a pretty big maybe I think
We will do a PR to add it for sure
🥳
We all need to post in the default mesh about the change over
To ensure all are informed
Agreed. Post that like a couple times a day and before you switch each relay
Ya i plan to post again tonight
Then tomorrow before work and again tomorrow then and then Saturday morning
And until i change over the south relay i will jump back to default once a week to post. Then after then once every two weeks for a few months
Just to make sure no onc eis left out of the loop
I plan on keeping one of my Heltecs on the default settings for a bit as well to monitor what's going on there after the switch.
If i could i wish i could have s node just shoot a canned message on a timer.
I imagine the traffic will cut down a lot since a few of us are part of the main coverage for our areas
Also, am I understanding correctly that transmitting to a favorited node does not add to the hop count? Like if HPR has ISR as a favorite and vice versa then that's a zero hop link?
Yes but that's for a future update i think 2.711 he said
Ah, right. K cool, that'll be a big one.
Oh without a doubt that will change so much
Now if only store and forward could be made to work... Because ive wanted that to work for over a year
The meshing-around bot can do that amongst other things.
Thank you for the tip. I'll look into that
You’re welcome. Assuming you already have a Raspberry Pi to use, it’s pretty simple to get up and running.
Ya a pi 3 i have
Well, sounds like it would do exactly what you want. You could set it to fire off an automated message every hour/six/12/24 hours whatever you would like.
Thank you, appreciate the info.
today be the day
Good luck! Be safe. Hollar if you have any questions when you get up there if you have service
i have service when at my node in pearl, but not so much the final mile leading to it
all the dips in the hills and such
Well, screenshot the config page 😛
im just wondering if change over my hq before i go or after
i feel before would be best sic ei know it have direct to my nodes
I’d change it first so you can have something to try to trace route back
ya thats what i'm thinking
maybe set it to broadcast as fast as it can
so it's pinging quicklyinstead of slow
what do you thing would be best setting to change for that
rebroadcast i'm thinking. but maybe the node data one might be better
Node info broadcast interval. Set it as low as you can. Like 1800
ok
And don’t forget to add your HQ node’s public key to the admin slot. And Brownik’s
ya i have those saved already
because i don't to make that mistake after 1 hour drive
Definitely LOL. If @alpine crescent can today, see if he can test remote admin once it’s up.
Though he may have to drive to get connection idk
ya once i have it configure and detecting stuff i plan to message him
if my north is working, it should be visible basically anywhere that can see the north mountains
basically prospect peak, if you can see it you can get my signal
Love it
i wonder how the pile of boulders holding up that tower is doing. because i had to secure it orginally by just stacking rocks around it..... I think i moved like 400 pounds of rock before it finally was holding good
I need a personal node again. But wondering if i should do 10k mah battery or a 5k. Because at first for meshtastic but eventually will be a tak node for hiking and such
If it’s just for a node, 5k would be enough if it’s nrf
But eventually with a halow module and i think a pi zero.
The 10k sounds like it becomes more needed. Also thinking if needed i can toss into a relay if a battery replacement is ever needed
@clear flare ive reset nodedb but nodes are still showing up
Did you change from LongFast to Medium Fast?
Yelp but the nodedb form long is still there
ya app cache / bug issues.
When you swap, double check your settings to make sure it took
Can you trace router anything tho?
Nope tracing aint going anywhere
Ok. I bet if you plugged it into your computer and looked at it in the client site they’d be gone
It’s just a buggy phone thing
Ya
Getting i got right it seems
I can't see to set broadcast lower then 3 hours using tab
Well the app
That’s fine leave it at that. Eventually it’ll want to be a bit higher anyways
Im trying to force broadcast now using chat
Rebooting also does it
Hoping if i send out 3 texts.. something bounces back
No just hq
Might have to go get a relay swapped before anything crazy happens.
Ya
But was hoping i would get a bounce. Since my hq can reach pretty well
16 feet up in meridian gives pretty good range after all with how flat things are
Ok off to the relays
But those settings i posted are correct. Yes
Because from the guide they look exact
Yep
Ok good
Also anyone know something good around eagle or boise. Was recommended kb burritos. Because im traveling all day so got not time to kitchen
Was told there salsa bar is good
A second vote for KB if you're in that area
@frail hedge how’s the relays?
Pearl relay up but connection troubles
They can see my messages but i can see there's
Anyone got a drone that can fly me up a blanket. Ahhh this wind is stronger the the death laser we call a sun
Tvm pearl relay (formally north) os now switched
figure out its comms?
Yeah. It’s all working now. Just some standard troubles of nodeinfo and getting confirmations
He’s off to do another router before the big trip tomorrow to do Hayden
coolio.
https://www.heywhatsthat.com/?view=W6IBMR2A
gonna get the rest and then put together info for the website
Compute summits visible from any location worldwide
Great wx for the work today.
Shadow valley estates sounds like an area villains live
Anyone got updates on medium fast. Node count and mesaging
Not seeing anything down in twin yet, but I’m thinking that Hayden will get it established
My rooftop node has seen 20 nodes so far!
Eeyor's, Gingers and Symphony are me (5 nodes), TVM'sx2, KN6BU's x2, Johnnytastic and Ragequit01 are what's been spotted so far.
Good to here, thank you for that information
Oh if messages aren't going through
What you have to do is reset your security key
And reset node database
hit me up (eeyore rak) so I can catch your newnode info... I hadn't reset my node before the cut over (probably why I couldn't DM "TVM HQ" earlier)
I pinged in chat
gotcha, hit "exchange user info" to try to get an updated entry... screens hot in one moment
Never saw your message
you aren't showing up my node list, but I'm catching broadcast from you
going to grab a traceroute from my end
I have a Client_Base (Symphony) running, I can cut it off if we can't make a circuit
SLC folks reporting that Trace routes can be finicky depending on density
Client_Base should be fine assuming the only favorites it has are your nodes
(can't imagine it would be an impact unless we hit some collision magic)
I'm assuming not everyone has moved over yet, but it'll definitely smooth out as they do
it's some tricksy stuff
Eventually if you trace route enough you get through
Can't wait to see hayden connecting us up.
Hopefully it does. Since no gurantee
Well, I have a pretty high degree of confidence
You see my direct messages?
But, I also am VERY curious if it'll hit MHR LOL
That one is possible in theory
150 mile link LOL
negative - I think one of us has an unreliable path
if the ISS can make the shot...
lol
Ya getting no connection to you now
I'm going to drop my Client_Base out of the equation
What even is client base
if behaves as a router for "favorite" nodes
Ahh ok
I can imagine it causing collisions
Just a matter of time and others converting over too probably
And Hayden could help
It's gonna be pretty monstrous. Cavity filtered 1w + 5.8dbi antenna
A private went through but the second stoped
some cool mojo... the pictures of the tiny cavity filters were really cool... I'm not an infrastructure guy, but have seen pictures of 2m filters that look pretty darn huge
Also in public i saw you and respojnded
915mhz aren't too huge, but definitely the biggest thing in the box
got an update for you in node db - I think we got a solid ckt with key exchange
fwiw, on the freq51.net page if it's not stated the nodedb reset may need to be mentions (also, I'm not the best at following directions - so may have missed that step. If so, apologies.)
nothing on Pearl - but I am willing to go on Node safari tomorrow
i don't know if it is. i'll check. I don't think it's required, but it helps when there are keys that get regenerated
Nah a you good, because we screwed up reset the security keys
I got pearl yes
Just tracing it now to clear connection info
I am getting a repeated failed connection on DM's to HQ
He did
oh i missed that ;O
Ive gotten 2 failed messages in public
samsies
That one passed
tbh, you're kind of limping tonight without TVM south or the new hayden
I'd be curious to see if these same issues occur after that happens
Failed again, and this with clear connection to a few nodes. Thus nothing is catching
think I made it through on the freq51 channel
Nothing
Im trying to see if digit amount is effecting things
3dhomejoe spit it out man! What's on your mind.
I switched one of my nodes about 24 hours ago here in Kuna but I am not getting anything. 0 Nodes 0 Messages. Do these settings look correct?
Weird result here
Yeah
It does, but infra just changed over tonight
I caught "English words" but not "Number of words is"
1 bit yours is on 8bit, pretty sure doc said 1 bit
See if text amount effects your success
that bit setting - where is that available in the Android client?
Weird nothing else had this problem
Not on the app
In the Channel setting
standby - you've missed some stuff
Ok so yours has failed at a chracter limit as well
But also some stuff didn't reach me
Character limit isn't an issue
lack of nodes is the issue righ tnow
Don't go crazy chasing ghosts yet 😛
So not coliisions, but turn around time on rebroadcasts?
MF is like 4x the speed of LF
so collisions is less of a problem now than before
It's also less forgiving
It's got a smaller link budget than LF
That means that if you were on the edge of reception before you're not getting there now
The fix to it is more nodes
So, it's almost there between the two of you as it is
but IMO, see what Hayden does to improve things tomorrow and get a few more folks moved over
How many 1 did you get. Because i get 10 and only 4 say confirmed
5 are just stuck in limbo
Ok
my understanding is channel chat works via flood routing, DM's use last reliable path routing
10 sent
my expierence is that the mesh cannot be relied upon to note delivery state, I have had false negatives and more worringly falso negatives
screenshot coming
3 confirmed on my ends, 5 limbo, and 2 failed
did you get a "message a" from me?
no
no changes in public since my screenshot at 2227
(I also have no nodedb entry for brownik nodes)
tomorrow, I can run a node up on a ~30' mast and let it run in "client" tomorrow
Ok, maybe we are getting interference on this freq?
@clear flare what are your thoughts?
That's strange cause I have like 5 of them on Freq51
all my thoughts are here 😛 #1203524130410860585 message
I'm in Star
I think a simplex shot from Star to SE Boise would be a stretch, I'm below the bench
Malice says we need more nodes
I think that until infra is done and you have like 75% of people that you won't have an accurate representation of what it really looks like
I think patience is a key step in thsi process 😛
But makes no sense we need more nodes if the nodes connected cleanly with good los aren't working
Well, we're getting Hayden up tomorrow, so hopefully that will help a bit.
It dpeends 100% on how strong of a connection you had previously
@frail hedge I'm no sled dog, but I've done a handful of winter SOTAs, I can 'shoe up and get to within bluetooth range of some towers if need be.
I know our window on "easy" is closing
Same, i can get anywhere i need to.
I will watch from my chair and drink hot chocolate on your behalf!
Also what the fuck, table rock is now unmessageable
I had that setting off, but now it's on again
rock or rovk?
sorry champ, I mentioned it while I assumed you were up there
Well hopefully brown can remote fix it
Traces on both relays from base plus nodedb data
If I can get any transmissions through 😅
If being the big question
that -10 snr tells me you're right on the edge of reception. if you dip to -11 or -12 and chances of getting through a pretty low
Nothing i have on direct. Everything is bouncing to the relays
have you gotten any signal metrics telemetry?
I'm checking out for the evening. I don't have discord on my phone, but am around for troubleshooting from my end typically in the evenings.
I greatly appreciate the TVM infrastructure and all the work that's going into this Freq51 effort. Guys, this is some cool stuff, thank you.
curious that your trace is so far off that
Maybe jus how the app records things?
Tablerock received my private message. Pearl is still instantly denying me
Maybe both need their nodedb wiped again
How many folks have moved over would you say?
The relays perfectly see everyone, because they had zero trouble seeing peopleand messages. But people have trouble reaching the relays, thus have trouble reaching others
That's pretty normal
Infra nodes tend to be really loud and have clear sight to people
but people often times have sub par antennas, are in noise areas, lots of other factors
That's literally everyone's scenario
Reliablity above all, because messages at mach jesus aren't fast when they cant go awhere
I agree
This was a concern when i proposed going to medium fast in boise like 8 months ago
That it wouldn't effect reliablity of getting messages out
Plus not be fruitful if not enoug people
should we have reliable traceroutes? because I'm not able to traceroute to most nodes
Trace routes in SLC are about 50:50. down here in southern ID they’re pretty reliable but we don’t have as much everything as the treasure valley or SLC
I'm up in the Treasure Valley
well, if i'm having trouble getting traceroute through, wouldn't that mean i'm also likely to have problems getting DM's and message through?
No. We have been seeing traces fail but messages going through
Trace routes are lower priority and will get dropped on occasion
IME if you're getting 50% on traceroutes, your message delivery should be pretty reliable. You should do your own testing though.