#lore-discussion

1 messages · Page 101 of 1

wicked heath
#

Guys, I heard the frank peterson = guest theory got debunked by ep1. Could you guys explain me?

ripe berry
#

look at the pinboard behind Ted in the past segment

#

House Fie - Mayak - Crows
it seems likely they were investigating the Guest bc of this

unkempt sleet
#

the origin of the modern cult heh

ripe berry
#

yep

#

almost everyone in that room becomes a cultist (except Ted and maybe Franklin bc we dunno what happened after the Petersons Stick Together)

wicked heath
ripe berry
#

"Giants?" on the Crow paper

wicked heath
#

There’s a big bird but like

#

A bird

tall citrus
#

AS? What’s that

snow mauve
tall citrus
#

Oh

muted moon
dry patio
#

Hello chat

shell gull
bronze tundra
#

👽🛸🌎

wise mulch
#

Vandal is man in the hats son 👶

stiff spire
#

real

tulip ore
#

Like that explosion on meteo station gave him abilities

cunning wave
#

I think that in season 1 of wtrb quentin is already in raven brooks because of the hn2 cutscene where he sees theo grab aaron and go inside his house so most likely quentin just never showed up for reasons idk

tall citrus
#

Is the crow man Theos brother

#

It would make sense

#

How the crow is always around Theo

cunning wave
muted moon
#

it could be a forest protector

cunning wave
#

yeah that is true

muted moon
#

a myth about bird men in the forest

#

it specifically says giants, not giant, so its likely theres multiple of the "giant crows"

#

which is obviously the forest protectors/ravens

cunning wave
#

did the forest protecters come before or after the guest?

ripe berry
#

unknown

#

they are linked though

cunning wave
#

well if the guest came first and they are studiyng the forest protecters then the guest would not be franklin burt if the forest protecters came first then maybe

muted moon
#

the guest probably came after

cunning wave
#

the guest is a person cause i think nikita said he is

muted moon
#

noone said he was a person

#

but its implied

strange lance
#

who do you guys think yellow kid is, if anyone

strange lance
#

Who already has a poster

#

And also looks nothing like aaron

#

Its clearly meant to be someone or something else

muted moon
#

wait

#

ivan

#

orange

#

maybe an older story where he went missing too?

cerulean knot
ripe berry
strange lance
#

That'd be weird cause its used alongside the other kids everywhere

strange lance
#

It also wouldn't make sense for that to be him cause you know he doesn't go missing in the final game

#

While the colors are similar the shadow kid's poster color is more yellow

shell gull
strange lance
#

it honestly probably was meant for Ivan considering all the rescue squad members have colored backgrounds while mya, aaron, and nicky don't

#

why they even bothered including it though idk

#

I doubt it means anything though

muted moon
#

in aarons cell

shell gull
unkempt sleet
#

i thought it was just a clue as to who we play as, as all the other kids posters is visible in the toom while only Aaron's is a silhoutte

silver vine
#

guys

#

The Neighbor built the act 3 house

#

why isnt it not there in HN2 or any other game

normal socket
silver vine
normal socket
#

Is it not?

silver vine
#

no

normal socket
#

Ok

hazy slate
#

Originally I thought it was the 7th kid class, but then Quentin got revealed.

strange lance
unkempt sleet
#

oh didnt know that

#

seems weird to include a kid that we never saw before

#

and will never saw again

#

in fact, we never saw anyway

unkempt sleet
#

and that was never the part of the story

#

and havent been ever since too

#

in fact, never was

silver vine
strange lance
#

Whoever has this hairstyle

#

Hair off to the side

tame quartz
#

And used for evidence

tame quartz
silver vine
#

Quentin being in SN is canon

#

Ozvard literally told me that

#

Mya is DEAD she cannot be a class in SN

#

And Aaron, he's the one who's locked up in the basement

#

And why would he break into his own house

#

As much as I hate to say, the first HN graphic novel has ghosts in it

#

There you go

silver vine
tame quartz
#

How is that the case if he never interacted with the gang in hn2 and also bosco bay doesn’t have ghosts 😭

dry patio
#

Never trust chatgpt

tame quartz
cunning wave
strange lance
#

nickys already got one

silver vine
#

You srsly use chatgpt

#

I've read the fricking book

#

It's so bad

#

It literally has ghosts

#

They literally communicate with ghosts using Ouija boards

#

And the ghost itself shows up at the end

tame quartz
#

so the ghost from sn is based on peterson

#

Not a ouija board

silver vine
#

Idk

#

But Quentin is canon to SN

#

That's been confirmed

tame quartz
#

Doesnt he come to HN during the events of HN2

strange lance
#

I'm still pretty sure quentin is only there cause he's dreaming like the trailer literally shows us

tame quartz
#

Wdym

strange lance
#

meets rescue squad or whatever, falls asleep and he's "in" SN

strange lance
# tame quartz Wdym

in the trailer where quentin was revealed it starts with him in his office, he falls asleep, and suddenly he's in SN

#

thats how he's able to be in SN cause physically he cannot be there

tame quartz
#

So he was dreaming the whole time

silver vine
#

The rescue squad imagines him there

tame quartz
#

Dawg what

silver vine
strange lance
#

then why would they show Quentin falling asleep lmao

silver vine
#

Idk

tame quartz
#

How can u imagine a person u dont know yet

silver vine
#

Trinity meets him

strange lance
#

its obviously meant to show Quentin is imagining SN

silver vine
#

She knows him

#

Mhmm

strange lance
#

if they wanted to say oh the kids pretended he was with them they would've shown the squad doing such

tame quartz
#

unless they are stretching it

silver vine
#

They are

tame quartz
#

for the plot of the traitor

silver vine
#

SN spans across season 2

#

Trinity meets Quentin during that

tame quartz
#

Ok well he didnt meet trinity before the rescue

silver vine
#

There's also an entire episode titled secret Neighbor

#

In season 2

tame quartz
#

why would they imagine him if he wasnt part of it

silver vine
#

Trauma

cunning wave
tame quartz
#

The rescue operation

tall citrus
tall citrus
tall citrus
tall citrus
cunning wave
tall citrus
cunning wave
tall citrus
#

So does the guest control the protectors?

cunning wave
ripe berry
tall citrus
ripe berry
#

there's a character named Andrew in the FNaF books
but what RBC's talking about is a fan name for the HN1 Pre-Alpha Player Model

tall citrus
#

Ohhhh

#

I got a question in the hn1 and 2 why is every word spelt wrong and when tvs are playing why is it in another language

ripe berry
#

the Hn Language (unofficially named Wayron Croobian) is a made up language based on one from the main dev's childhood

tall citrus
#

Oh I just read sum in feedback and it said hn2 isn’t apart of the main story

ripe berry
#

wrong

#

SOMEHOW everything is canon
(except Alphas, Betas, Demos, #nog-simming, and the AS Pilot)

silver vine
#

Please

#

It's self therapy

silver vine
#

Even tho its not a dream, it does take place in Nicky's mind

#

But In talking about HN cartoon

tall citrus
#

The as?

silver vine
#

Where he actually builds the act 3 house irl during the he events of HN1

#

Yes

tall citrus
#

Hollon lemme re watch episode three?

ripe berry
#

no multiverse exists btw

silver vine
#

Dude

ripe berry
#

so everything's contradictions are all in one timeline

silver vine
#

Have you not watched any of it?

tall citrus
silver vine
#

And you did not notice the act 3 house

#

Really?

#

The roller coaster?

tall citrus
silver vine
silver vine
silver vine
tall citrus
#

Hollon ima rewatch it

#

Oh I never watched this episode

glacial whale
unkempt sleet
glacial whale
#

I hope they understand it because if not I give up

hazy slate
#

actually

#

I was also paranoid it was gonna be Nicky thanks to the AS

tribal talon
#

What's you guys' opinions on "the book"?

glacial whale
#

What book? The books or one in particular?

tribal talon
#

the one in the series

#

animated

ripe berry
#

Welcome to Raven Brooks

crude dew
unkempt sleet
#

Hello Neighbor 2 doesnt involve Nicky

#

The books show Nicky's story before and during HN1 Act 1

#

And the Show just shows him before and during HN1 Act 1 and after Act 2, but it's a different interperation from the books

mint vapor
#

what if the guest is a urban legend in raven brooks and goes around tricking peoples minds into doing bad things. like, he could can tricked the neighbor into kidnapping!

silver vine
#

His missing posters are there in the office

#

You haven't noticed it?

#

Those are there as well

#

But there's also Nicky in one of the posters

ripe berry
#

this is a unrelated event

#

this event happens ~40 years before the game

#

(due to one of the characters involved being a child at the time)

silver vine
#

The one in the alien costume is the Baker

ripe berry
#

Gerda the Baker is roughly the same age as Mr. Peterson if Welcome to Raven Brooks is to be believed, and Mr. Peterson is ~47

#

there was also a package sent to youtubers which among other things confirms this is referring to the missing posters seen in Quentin's Office

#

in fact, those packages are how we know of rbbarchives and it's password

#

from what we know yes

ripe berry
#

likely separate

#

we can trace back the Halloween Incident Kids to the kids seen in the Hello Guest Prototype Ride due to official statements, in-which (eben though HGP isn't canon and details can always change from the first prototype to a final game ~3 years later) they were attacked by the Guest

#

which is also shown in the version of them seen in Hello Neighbor 2 Alpha 1.5

#

so it's safe to assume they aren't the Guest

ripe berry
#

yeah I'd say so

ripe berry
#

based off official statements
(somehow) it's one human doing everything

ripe berry
ripe berry
#

it's appearing out of nowhere from WATER

#

Secret Neighbor's lore makes it possible to ignore anything seen in that game

#

SN is basically imagination of a plan to save Nicky
HNVR is them actually putting a plan into action

ripe berry
#

and HNVR's Ending, with spoiling anything directly ties into Act 2

#

yeah
Guest itself isn't supernatural
but the Guest probably has stuff that can make it do all the "supernatural" stuff it does throughout the franchise

#

lol

ripe berry
snow mauve
#

Luck devices, magic cursed coins, weather station, bird entity

#

Etc etc

#

GIMME

#

Nobodies

silver vine
dry patio
#

Imbir is D goat

snow mauve
#

Franklin Masters Peterson

dry patio
#

Latest Animated series episode

snow mauve
#

Them*

#

They have no gender

silver vine
#

HNVR does a good job of tying the guest to HN1

#

I wonder how AS is gonna do that

snow mauve
#

Big reveal 👏

viral dove
snow mauve
#

No

cold gull
#

Who's the best suspect for the Secret Neighbor role

wicked heath
snow mauve
#

Trust me you don't wanna be in that server

tame quartz
wicked heath
#

I already lost everything……

snow mauve
snow mauve
#

If you don't mind me asking

tame quartz
snow mauve
#

Where crowface was right there

#

In front of everyone

tame quartz
snow mauve
#

The part where delroy fought with Nicky at the amusement park

tame quartz
#

franklin?

snow mauve
tame quartz
snow mauve
#

LMAO

#

I didn't see what you were replying

#

Mb

tame quartz
#

its alr

snow mauve
#

I thought we were still talking about nicky

tame quartz
#

Well I think nicky is secret neighbor because in the madness trailer, we hear peterson in his head. Knowing this, he could very well betray the gang just because of that and also he has been against them recently

snow mauve
#

i dont think thats the case tbh

#

plus he like already abandonded his group

#

bit too early

#

and the secret neighbor episode hasnt came out yet

crude dew
trail haven
#

Shapshifting isn't canon, it's only for the game

silver vine
#

Guys

#

If the coins cause bad luck

#

Why do Peterson and cultists have several of them

snow mauve
#

There's no way you're this serious

#

The cutlists has the coins because they're likely doing the guest's favor and cuz they're evil, they're handing out the coins to everyone in town so they can watch chaos spread

#

As for theo, he clearly isn't doing the favor like the cultists, instead he's trying to collect them all and hide them away from the cultists. He's pretty much kinda helping the town

silver vine
#

I can see that

#

But why does Peterson have so many of them

silver vine
#

But

snow mauve
#

Not buts

silver vine
#

Won't the coins give him more bad luck

snow mauve
silver vine
#

Isn't that the whole deal

snow mauve
#

It's protection!

silver vine
#

....

snow mauve
#

Plus he's already cursed with bad luck anyway lol

silver vine
#

The coins mechanic need to be explained more

snow mauve
#

He lost pretty much everything

snow mauve
safe charm
#

Like we already know

#

They give bad luck

snow mauve
#

Exactly

#

Thank you guestyyy

silver vine
#

So, why don't they have bad luck

#

Are they immune or smth

snow mauve
silver vine
#

Clearly

#

HN2 nightmare

snow mauve
#

The hell you mean clearly 😭

silver vine
#

Crow pukes coins

snow mauve
#

Your dumb ahh was asking why

silver vine
#

I'm asking how the cultists are touching the coins

#

And have several of them

#

And not have bad luck

safe charm
#

Magic probably

#

They work with guest

silver vine
#

Also, Trinity held up a coin in ep1

safe charm
#

Most likely

silver vine
snow mauve
#

She didn't keep it tho

safe charm
#

Ye

snow mauve
#

So I guess it only happens who ever keeps it

silver vine
#

Then why does Peterson keep several of them

snow mauve
#

Jesus christ

snow mauve
#

Here

#

Did you not read?

silver vine
#

I did

snow mauve
#

Clearly you didn't lol

silver vine
#

So is Peterson like, immune

snow mauve
#

Duhhhh

silver vine
#

If he has more coins, shouldn't he get even more bad luck

safe charm
#

He’s already

#

Cursed

#

Though

#

Sooooo

snow mauve
#

Thank you

silver vine
#

So he can keep how much ever he wants?

snow mauve
silver vine
#

Nah

snow mauve
#

Yah

silver vine
#

It doesn't have to do with gloves pal

snow mauve
#

It does pal

#

🙂

#

Think about it, if it's being touched by a physical item or thing that isn't living

#

Then it won't affect it

#

But if something alive like human skin that touches it

#

Then it's definitely gonna affect it

#

It's science thinking bro!

safe charm
#

Also your the lore master….. not us

snow mauve
#

I am the lore master!

#

:)

silver vine
#

Then

#

Explain to me

#

Why are there literal golden apples in Mayors house and museum

#

How are they different from coins

snow mauve
#

I will throw holy water to this man

#

and banish em to the shadow realm

snow mauve
#

Once they see someone not have a coin

#

Bingo!

silver vine
#

I'm not talking about coins 😔

snow mauve
#

Hand them the coins

silver vine
#

In talking about GOLDEN APPLES

#

LITERAL

snow mauve
#

LMAO

silver vine
#

Golden apples

snow mauve
#

Shit my fault there lol

snow mauve
#

What you expect lol

#

why not have a snack..

silver vine
#

The ones in HN2 🤦‍♂️

snow mauve
#

Yeah

silver vine
#

They are literal metal

snow mauve
#

It's a snack

silver vine
#

On display

snow mauve
#

Dummy

unkempt sleet
#

they are just cool props

silver vine
#

Oh come on

snow mauve
#

Yeah yeah I know

#

tiny crow

#

Wake up

#

Pull yourself together

unkempt sleet
snow mauve
#

like the books version

silver vine
#

The golden crows aren't just props

safe charm
#

I think it’s just the cult

#

Symbol

#

Like statues

silver vine
#

You can insert the coins into the crow statues

unkempt sleet
silver vine
#

Has noone noticed that

#

....

#

I'm literally playing HN2 rn

#

There are coins in their brand

snow mauve
silver vine
#

Breaks

snow mauve
#

where are you finding it

#

Lol

silver vine
#

Beaks

#

...

snow mauve
#

Breaks or beaks?

silver vine
#

Bro

safe charm
#

I mean he’s right

#

But like I think it’s just cult decor

snow mauve
unkempt sleet
#

the statues dont have a throat though, they just hold it with their beaks

snow mauve
#

grrr

unkempt sleet
#

you cant throw it inside them like the HNVR one

snow mauve
silver vine
#

You can place the coins in the crows beak

unkempt sleet
#

And in your opinion, what does that signify?

snow mauve
#

tiny crow right now

#

explode

silver vine
unkempt sleet
#

?

silver vine
#

Or that's what makes you a cultists

safe charm
#

What

silver vine
#

Something

#

Putting the coins into crow statue has to do something

unkempt sleet
#

That sounds like an assumption without much evidence

#

We never saw Crow statues as important things in the lore, Sure they might signify a cultist (even though Ted's house has two of them too) but like, I dont think we have any evidence to support the assumption that they do anything at all

snow mauve
tall citrus
#

Any one have a video or a doc explaining the lore?

ripe berry
#

closest thing there is is Gavin's old Lore Doc (which other then being a tiny bit outdated and having some inaccuracies is mostly solid https://docs.google.com/document/d/1AcAI9lMucsQW_4F-20n6OdBkCnRdKZ0Ku4qTB6kpi20/edit )

#

I'll explain the 2 errors I can remember rq: First off, it's 2017 and not 2015
Second off the ending of Hello Engineer is wrong but then again it was written right after the game came out so we couldn't have known better about what was going on in the ending
and ignore the thing about the Guest being a "entity of greed or envy" and HN2

#

it's missing Hello Neighbor: Search and Rescue, Hello Neighbor 2, Welcome to Raven Brooks and the one who made the document didn't really like what Welcome to Raven Brooks was doing to the story (even though everything is still canon somehow)

#

and S&R/HN2 had parts of the WtRB Story implemented in them kinda

#

WtRB is a easy-to-watch Youtube Series, so Imma just link it here
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z0MZRMp0nxA&list=PL4nWU0IcZ3kgr0WQ-XYamIb-dI150AUQU

#

these should be able to help you out newcomer!

wise mulch
#

LORE!!! squareneighbor

mental knot
stiff spire
#

real

ripe berry
#

so uh

#

thoughts on AS S2 Ep. 3

unkempt sleet
#

peak

cunning wave
#

quentin is the G.O.A.T.

tribal talon
#

Time to address the elephant in the room...

#

The Thing has finally returned after 7 long years!

unkempt sleet
#

And he is more cooler than how he was in HN1 innocent

safe charm
tribal talon
#

The second I saw his sweet black pulsing a$$, I nearly fainted!

#

I don't need The Guest when I have that. The Thing will always be the true main antagonist of Hello Neighbor in my eyes.

eager island
#

and now he is just a minor character

tribal talon
#

We don't fully know that yet.

eager island
#

we know

tribal talon
#

It feels a lot more important now with the vibe it's giving.

unkempt sleet
#

He was always a minor character in the overall story though
He is just important to Nicky's story

eager island
#

just the embodied carpet of Nicky's traumas constructed in Nicky's mind

unkempt sleet
#

Not the Raven Brooks or Theodore's story

safe charm
#

The guest clearly is

#

Hes just the true antagonist of hn1 because he only affects nicky

tribal talon
#

I would love to see a dream sequence or something in Season 3 maybe of Adult Nicky fighting it.

safe charm
#

Guest actually has powers in real world

eager island
unkempt sleet
#

Yea

tribal talon
#

Either way, I can't wait to see more of it in the show.

#

It's not completely out of the window that The Thing could've been Re-Written to be something more.

unkempt sleet
#

Probably not

safe charm
#

Nah

tribal talon
#

Trauma is definitely a huge part of it, there's no doubt about that.

unkempt sleet
eager island
#

yes

unkempt sleet
#

He's still the same old Thing

eager island
#

and there are still people in the comments who write "shadow creature neighbor's brother"

glacial whale
tall citrus
#

Ik this goes back to hn1 and I should know this but what’s the shadow man

opal steeple
#

and trauma

tall citrus
#

Wait if Aaron was in theos basement and Theo was locked up where did Aaron go

#

?

tall citrus
#

But then in hn2 he got out in the attic how did Theo get him again

snow mauve
ripe berry
#

ignoring contradictions
if you want to experience the most of the HN Franchise in chronological order:
Peterson's Stick Together Teaser
Bosco Bay
Bad Blood
Grave Mistakes/AS S2 Episode 3 Teaser
Puzzle Master
Missing Pieces/Hello Neighbor Hide and Seek/HNHS Release Trailer
Waking Nightmare
AS Episode 1
AS Episode 2
AS Episode 3
Buried Secrets/Hello Neighbor 1 Act 1/AS Episode 4
AS Episode 5
Hello Neighbor VR
AS Episode 6/Hello Neighbor 1 Act 2
AS Season 2
Secret Neighbor Quentin Reveal Trailer
Secret Neighbor (Do Rocket Event Last)
For Bonus content go to https://www.helloneighbor2.com/rbbarchives and type in the code "HATCHERYWINGATE"
AS Season 3/Hello Engineer
Hello Neighbor 2 Late Fees
Hello Neighbor 2 Back to School
Hello Neighbor 2
LayoutV2 Teaser
For Bonus content find the Tapes and open the Fountain in Hello Neighbor 2's Freeplay Mode
Hello Neighbor 2 Patch 9 Forest Sidequest
The Raven Brooks Disaster
Hello Neighbor 1 Act 3
Hello Neighbor 1 Act Finale
Hello Neighbor Diaries
The Neighbor's Notebook
Reset Day

#

this might change overtime but this is how it's laid out rn

silver vine
ripe berry
silver vine
#

It will?

#

Wait

#

Crowface is human?

#

So, crowface is different from guest?

snow mauve
#

We won

ripe berry
silver vine
#

Wha

ripe berry
#

Guest isn't supernatural like at all - Alex

#

(In AS)

snow mauve
ripe berry
silver vine
#

He turned into a crow in AS tho

ripe berry
ripe berry
#

Red eyes doesn't immediately mean "ok, this is the Guest"

silver vine
#

He does turn into a crow in the games

snow mauve
#

Why you lyin

safe charm
#

Also

snow mauve
#

Same character

ripe berry
#

outside of hn2

silver vine
#

If he was just human, how can we explain his HN2 shenanigans

#

He can run as fast as a cart

#

Jump pretty high

ripe berry
#

nothing says a human COULDNT do that

cunning wave
silver vine
#

What's the guest actually doing in the new teaser

#

I can't make it out

ripe berry
#

BUT

#

we do know the "Secret Neighbor" in strapped in a chair there

safe charm
#

Maybe guest becomes supernatural like you Said

#

At the end of AS

ripe berry
#

and it's likely when the "You know our secrets... let's just kill her! No... we can use her..." lines are delivered

ripe berry
#

not now

#

not ever

safe charm
#

That doesnt make sense

#

AT ALL

silver vine
#

So, the secret Neighbor works for guest?

snow mauve
#

SMH

shell gull
#

Alright got back and saw Ep 3

snow mauve
shell gull
snow mauve
#

Because

#

Logic

shell gull
#

Glad to see Nicky still Traumatized.

snow mauve
shell gull
snow mauve
#

About the thing being whatever else..

safe charm
shell gull
#

Also would love to dissect what’s on that Book.

safe charm
#

Did you miss

#

This

#

He also Said crowface is a human

shell gull
snow mauve
#

Hey @shell gull

#

Dun dun dunn

shell gull
snow mauve
#

How he became supernatural

#

Dun dun dunnn

shell gull
ripe berry
#

The Guest in AS isn't supernatural at all

#

no powers or anything

#

bro's just a normal dude

#

a STRONG and FAST normal dude
but still a normal dude

shell gull
ripe berry
#

he's like the speed of a olympic runner but he's still a normal human

#

AS S3 Finale also apparently is still before HN2

ripe berry
manic dirge
cunning wave
ripe berry
#

This party never stops! Non-Human Guest is dead and Contradictions have no meaning! Canon is a Flexible Term and the AS reigns supreme! Welcome, one and all, TO LOREMAGEDDON!

silver vine
safe charm
#

Will be explained in ep18

silver vine
#

It could mean that HN2 could take place simultaneously

ripe berry
#

S3 is HE

#

he's at the GAAP

#

he cant be both at the GAAP AND the Museum at the same time

silver vine
#

So, HE takes place before HN2?

ripe berry
#

yeah

safe charm
#

Season 2 was hn2

ripe berry
#

he lied 😈

safe charm
ripe berry
#

also cant be HN2 if Ted's still IN JAIL

snow mauve
#

:>

shell gull
shell gull
# ripe berry also cant be HN2 if Ted's still IN JAIL

Also looking at it now it seems that Time Skip in the HN2 Intro was not the same Day and seems to be a Week+ of time, which would explain Both DLCs taking place during that Time while the School DLC was at Night.

ripe berry
#

lol

tribal talon
ripe berry
#

it's the Neighbor's Notebook

silver vine
#

Literally

wise mulch
#

He loves his old art chair

#

(Fortnitr Minecraft neighbor 2 lore)

manic dirge
#

Wait when was AS story finalized?

#

I swear Alex said when it was

warm finch
#

Hold up

#

In the tv show cannon with hn2

manic dirge
#

Everything is connected

#

Somehow

spring prairie
white fjord
#

Saw yesterday someone saying the guest is peterson's dead brother

#

I personally think thats wrong cuz
In the golder apple amusement park theres a giant structure of the guest

#

So its clear thats the guest is related to the raven cult

#

Means corrupts of raven brook those who do magic and all and caused lucy yi's death

#

So the guest is related to them and against the peterson

safe charm
#

Him a person

#

Now

white fjord
safe charm
#

Nope

#

Tell me this

#

Is a person

white fjord
safe charm
#

The vr game

#

As well

safe charm
white fjord
safe charm
#

Hes more like a demonic entity creature

#

An old urban legend

white fjord
safe charm
#

Seperate from guest in the Books

#

I Think

white fjord
silver vine
#

But that never was confirmed

safe charm
#

Dude

#

Hes not a person in hnvr

#

Theres no way

silver vine
#

He's clearly a metaphorical

#

Like GN2

#

It's not a demon

white fjord
#

Otherwise why would there be costumes of guest in mayors house

#

Multiple costumes

cerulean onyx
#

Those are outfits of the cult

#

Those are not guest outfits

teal imp
#

If you bothered to look at them closer you can tell its obviously not a guest costume

shell gull
ripe berry
#

We can at least agree that the Crowface is a human statement hardly affects things

#

the Guest still somehow does supernatural-looking stuff

#

it's just a HUMAN doing that supernatural-looking stuff

silver vine
#

basically

#

guest is not supernatural

#

but has superhuman abilities

snow mauve
#

🤯

ripe berry
snow mauve
#

we are lore masters

#

And we both get it

ripe berry
#

but tinyCrow is kinda right
Guest finds a way to basically have supernatural abilities without actually being supernatural himself

tribal talon
#

I had a question, is the forest protector with the guest and venerate it or they are two separate "team" ?

ripe berry
#

they're working together

tribal talon
#

ok thank

crude dew
#

guest vs bookshelf. Who wins🤭

wise mulch
#

He loves his old art trash bag

crude dew
#

ah i see the mix of artstyles. Excellent!

glacial whale
#

I miss the old art. I know people say the final version defined the artstyle of HN but I still like the way the furniture, floors, roofs, and feeling it gave off. I am pretty happy with HN2 full game style. You got me typing a paragraph over a trash bag

eager island
glacial whale
#

It was brought up

#

People are allowed to talk about different art styles but I can’t?

shell gull
ripe berry
#

all this is doing is further proving that

#

also

#

HNVR

tribal talon
#

guys he's not a demonic entity or that stuff

#

he

#

is

#

birdman 😄

ripe berry
#

exactly

safe charm
# ripe berry exactly

While everything is apperantly canon there had to be some kind of split in the canon

#

Somewhere unless

#

Idk

ripe berry
#

idk either

safe charm
#

This is driving me

#

Cra cra crazy

ornate grove
#

diablos circ

thin lagoon
#

anyone wanna talk lore?

tribal talon
thin lagoon
#

what thing?

tribal talon
#

This Thing

thin lagoon
#

explain, Im listening

thin lagoon
tribal talon
#

Yeah it's official name is "The Thing"

thin lagoon
#

ok

#

go ahead

tribal talon
#

So. What if instead of The Thing being a manifestation of Nicky's trauma, it's a ghost that only certain people can see.

#

Kinda like how in FNaF Into The Pit, only the main guy can see Spring Bonnie when Spring Bonnie is posing as his dad.

thin lagoon
#

yeah...but I doubt that

#

cause nicky stopped seeing the thing after he moved out, and only started seeing it again after he returned to the town

#

because he was afraid

tribal talon
#

I'm 100% confident that The Thing used to be a representation of Nicky's trauma but because of how much the story has been Re-Written, altered, etc. I wouldn't say it's that far fetched for The Thing to be Re-Written to be something more.

thin lagoon
#

yeah

#

But you'd be suprised by how much they had planned already

#

I discovered something that NO ONE seems to talk about

tribal talon
#

What?

thin lagoon
#

its not too big but I think its important

#

Do you know when there was a secret thing in secret neighbour, that you had to do several times to get access to a code that unlocks a zip file that unlocks a game?

tribal talon
#

You on about the Hello Guest prototype?

thin lagoon
#

yeah yeah

#

there was a cutscene of a big wall getting destroyed and behind it was the weather station from the show

#

This weather station is very important somehow

tribal talon
#

They've had the whole idea of the weather station for ages, it's just that only now, they're starting to actually utilize it.

thin lagoon
#

yeah

tribal talon
#

If I'm not mistaken, I believe the Guest used to be Mr Peterson, but then it became some supernatural creature and now it seems to be a masked killer or something (kinda like Ghostface)

thin lagoon
#

but quick question: are the hello neighbour 2 alphas canon in any way at all?

tribal talon
#

I don't believe they are.

thin lagoon
#

also what's up with that weird detective guy?

tribal talon
thin lagoon
#

for that costume to exist, people must know about the guest

tribal talon
#

For me personally, the annoying thing about how Hello Neighbor's story is that, because of how vague it is and how often things get retconned, changed, Re-Written, etc, it gets really confusing to keep up with the story and know what things happen when and if certain things mean the same thing anymore.

thin lagoon
#

true

#

its really interesting for me though, and I think the show is starting to clarify things up in a good way

tribal talon
tribal talon
#

That's what it seemed to be but I'm not fully sure.

thin lagoon
#

at least I know that hello neighbour 2 takes place way earlier than I thought

tribal talon
#

I'd even say back during Alpha 3, The Thing was meant to be an actual person and not some monster.

thin lagoon
tribal talon
thin lagoon
#

ya know a lot of people are sayin that crow face is The neighbour's brother but....

tribal talon
#

My personal thoughts on The Thing is that I have no clue how major it is to the overall story but because it was the main villain of the original game, how supernatural and strange the story has gotten and the heavy emphasis on it's existence and threat at the end of third episode I hope it's something more than just a representation of trauma.

#

One thing that has never fully been understood in the first game is that at the end, before you get the last cutscene, you see a house with Mr Peterson trapped on one side and The Thing blocking the door on the other side, still to this day, I have no clue what that meant.

thin lagoon
#

what's annoying is that thing was trying to get in

#

like, why? it has nothing to do with Peterson

tribal talon
#

All that I can possibly think is that The Thing can effect other people.

thin lagoon
#

I think I get it...

#

Thing doesnt just affect nicky, but everyone who has endured trauma in some way

tribal talon
#

Have you seen Murder Drones?

thin lagoon
#

because peterson had the car crash, and lost his kid

thin lagoon
tribal talon
#

I was going to use something in that as an example of my point.

thin lagoon
#

oh

tribal talon
#

An idea I have for what The Thing could be which opens the possibility of it still being the big bad of the franchise.

#

What if what it is is that, it's a demon that attacks people mentally.

#

Where, if you're mentally weak, you become exposed to it.

#

And it can possess people that way

ripe berry
#

while that is a neat idea

#

it's sadly incorrect

#

we officially know what the thing is

thin lagoon
#

do we?

#

Did they ever confirm?

ripe berry
#

it's just how this franchise represents nicky's fear and trauma

#

it was said in some qna in 2020

tribal talon
#

If you think about it, in episode 6, Nicky did seem to be possessed.

ripe berry
#

also they said smth about wanting to Ground the Story with AS so I doubt they changed the Thing for no reason

tribal talon
# ripe berry it was said in some qna in 2020

My point earlier was that the story of Hello Neighbor has changed that often, it's impossible to know what things still mean the same, the story of Hello Neighbor in 2020 was probably very different to the story of Hello Neighbor now.

#

The Guest literally went from, being Mr Peterson, to being a supernatural entity to being some other non supernatural masked figure.

thin lagoon
#

Indeed

ripe berry
thin lagoon
#

Hey remember that huge guest statue from the hello guest game?

ripe berry
#

plus that was a character in a WIP Game so it's to be expected story details changed a little bit around him

thin lagoon
#

whats up with that?

tribal talon
#

Btw. @thin lagoon thanks for being one of the only people who actually respects my ideas of potential theories.

ripe berry
#

(also, would now be a good time to say Everything is still canon (Games, Books, etc) without the use of a multiverse based off what the Creator (or I should call him Nikita) has said)

thin lagoon
tribal talon
ripe berry
#

the Thing is a character that existed for years with it being known what it is so I doubt they could get away with changing what it is without people realizing

#

with the Guest, well, as Alex | CEO said, his lore just makes no sense

#

he's a human that isn't supernatural

#

yet in Graphic Novel 2...

#

well..

#

this just speaks for itself

thin lagoon
#

what happens there?

thin lagoon
ripe berry
tribal talon
#

That's kinda proving my point. The story has changed so much, some things went from being cannon to non cannon, it's impossible to know what anything means for certain and it's not that far fetched to believe that certain things have changed.

ripe berry
thin lagoon
#

ok maybe he isnt supernatural, maybe he's using something supernatural

ripe berry
thin lagoon
#

like, we see that huge purple beam in the show when theodore's brother falls in the hole

ripe berry
thin lagoon
#

there IS something supernatural in the series

ripe berry
# ripe berry

despite the contradictions, everything is canon still and there's no multiverse

#

(minus Alphas, Betas, Demos, and the AS Pilot)

thin lagoon
tribal talon
# ripe berry nothing has been decanonized lol

Some things in books don't line up with some things in the games and animated series, they say the guest was never supernatural but in one of the books, it literally appears out of nowhere and possesses Mr Peterson, with how much things are changing, it's kinda impossible for everything to be cannon.

ripe berry
#

and was never applies to everything

#

from Graphic Novel 2 to Reset Day to HNVR to AS to Hello Guest Prototype

#

how that's possible idk

thin lagoon
#

I should read those books..

ripe berry
#

it just somehow is

tribal talon
#

When did Tinybuild say that everything was cannon?

ripe berry
#

in 2020 it was Mayak will explain the inconsistencies

tribal talon
ripe berry
#

in 2024 it's we dunno but we do have Nikita (the Creator of HN) saying "Yes" to a question of if everything still being canon

tribal talon
#

Okay

ripe berry
#

earlier in that same convo

#

Books are still canon

#

AS is Canon

#

Games are canon

#

How they're all canon?

#

We dunno

#

they just are

#

and there's no multiverse

ripe berry
#

and it was stated in 2022 the AS Pilot isn't canon anymore

ripe berry
tribal talon
#

Because of how impossible and strange it would be to somehow make everything still canon, I'm just going to say that Tinybuild saying that everything is still canon is a load of rubbish and lies just to confuse us.

#

It's just them trying not to admit that they changed the story several times.

ripe berry
#

and in 2020 they seemed to actually have a explanation in mind involving the Mayak Weather Station for it

tribal talon
#

What I think they're doing is trying to copy FNaF with how they tell the story by making it stupidly confusing. And nearly impossible to explain how everything ties together.

#

Because a big reason why FNaF is so popular is because of the theories.

ripe berry
#

plus they're still acknowledging the books somewhat

#

AS premeired in 2022

ripe berry
#

Hello Neighbor Diaries released in 2023

wise mulch
#

Books don’t make sense in the lore

#

But apparently they’re cannon

ripe berry
#

NOTHING makes sense in the lore

#

Everything is canon somehow

wise mulch
#

Exactly

ripe berry
#

Mayak will Explain Everything

wise mulch
#

They keep changing the house layout every game too

ripe berry
#

in like 500 years or smth since I doubt AS is gonna answer our questions

tribal talon
# thin lagoon how are they copying fnaf?

One of the main reasons why FNaF has stayed so popular is because of theories so what Scott does is add things to the lore and change things to keep people making theories.

ripe berry
#

Animated Series (Welcome to Raven Brooks)

wise mulch
#

Whoops, I’m stupid lol

tribal talon
#

Tinybuild is trying to do a similar thing but the main difference is, FNaF provides reasoning for how some things can connect to other things. FNaF just doesn't give any exact answer.

thin lagoon
ripe berry
#

tinyBuild states there's a reason then proceeds to not reveal it for over 4 years at this point

#

I do believe they actually got a reason

tribal talon
#

Tinybuild just completely flips things on its head with every new release and says that it's all canon so people try to make theories on it but because of how confusing it all is, it's straight up impossible to explain how it's all connected.

ripe berry
tribal talon
#

MatPat explains this point a lot better than me.

thin lagoon
#

a long time ago

ripe berry
tribal talon
#

This is one shot of that video that I perfectly agree with.

ripe berry
#

actually the reason Alpha 4 took so long is because:

#

Pre-Alpha to Alpha 2 were basically complete by the time they actually released the Pre-Alpha

#

There were Trailers using the Alpha 2 map before the Pre-Alpha dropped iirc

#

they had plenty of time to make Alpha 3 by the time they dropped Alpha 2

#

however they hadn't had enough time when Alpha 3 dropped to make Alpha 4 so the development suddenly slowed down a lot

#

btw

#

Matpat didn't know this but uh

#

the Fear Rooms were already in development in Alpha 3

muted moon
#

why have people gone back to thinking the guest and crowface are the same

ripe berry
#

they weren't made in response to MatPat's Theory Videos at all

muted moon
# thin lagoon wait wut

the guest isnt supernatural. gn2 and reset day show that ted is the guest. crowface is in teds house while ted is in prison. alex said the identitys of crowface and the guest are seperate. crowface and the guest are seperate beings

ripe berry
ripe berry
#

there's the main plot of the game

muted moon
ripe berry
thin lagoon
muted moon
ripe berry
thin lagoon
#

wow so now everything I thought I knew is poof

muted moon
#

alpha 2 feels like it might have its own story

tribal talon
# thin lagoon since when?!

Exactly my point! They're adding new things and changing things constantly to confuse us in an attempt for us to make theories to to give the game series more popularity.

ripe berry
# muted moon id say either alpha 2 or 3

either way it was before MatPat made his theories, thus MatPat was wrong about tinyBuild trying to MatPat theory bait at all (except for when they did actually do that with the Animated Series Pilot by begging him to make a theory on Twt or smth)

muted moon
#

they arent

#

everything is meant to form a story

ripe berry
old glacier
muted moon
ripe berry
thin lagoon
#

he made too many

muted moon
tribal talon
muted moon
ripe berry
#

Guest is like one of the only actually lore important things we don't got a explanation on

muted moon
#

everything is canon

thin lagoon
muted moon
#

guest isnt supernatural

#

in gn2 and reset day guest is shown as ted

muted moon
ripe berry
thin lagoon
#

oh

tribal talon
#

What I'm going to do is make my own theories from what I've inferred from the games and animated series and despite what Tinybuild is trying to make us think, I'm going to ignore things that don't line up with the animated series like the books because that throws so many spanners into the lore.

thin lagoon
#

yeah cause I thought his name was theodore

muted moon
ripe berry
muted moon
#

but AS is mostly its own thing

ripe berry
#

like Hello Neighbor Diaries (release December 2023) or Hello Neighbor VR (release May 2023)

#

and instead focus on AS

muted moon
#

you know how in fnaf the silver eyes trilogy is like a retelling of the games?

#

what if AS is hns version of that

tribal talon
#

I've completely ignored my knowledge of basically everything in lore apart from the animated series and it has made me enjoy watching it a lot more.

muted moon
ripe berry
muted moon
ripe berry
#

...

#

you completely misinterpetted Scott with FNaF

#

the Silver Eyes Books are THE definition of a different timeline

#

they aren't in the same continuity yet they share several common details

#

with Hello Neighbor meanwhile

#

everything is in one Continuity

muted moon
# ripe berry the Silver Eyes Books are THE definition of a different timeline

"The truth is that after a while lore can become so dense that there isn't room for a story anymore. Another truth is that what makes for a good game doesn't necessarily make for a good book. Sometimes a timeline gets so full that the only way to tell a real story is have the story set in a different timeline, an alternate universe, a different location, or perhaps from a vantage point that isn't entirely what it appears to be."

muted moon
#

"a different timeline, an alternate universe, a different location, or perhaps from a vantage point that isn't entirely what it appears to be."

#

"or perhaps a vantage point that isn't entirely what it appears to be"

ripe berry
#

this isn't the right channel for continuing this but isn't Henry literally dead in the Silver Eyes Trilogy
how the hell is he in FNaF 6

muted moon
#

the order of the silver eyes trilogy is weird

#

fnaf 6 and the fnaf 3 end of night minigames happen at the same time

muted moon
ripe berry
thin lagoon
#

it's a completely different story with different characters

muted moon
#

all the same events happen

thin lagoon
#

it's about charlie

muted moon
#

just in a different order

ripe berry
thin lagoon
#

the original games are not about charlie

ripe berry
#

anyways yet again if we wanna continue the FNaF Convo thing here we should move to #games or #off-topic

#

this is the HELLO NEIGHBOR lore discussion channel

thin lagoon
#

funny how people get side tracked

tribal talon
#

All I'm going to say is, The Hello Neighbor Story has changed a lot and I'm not believing Tinybuild when they say that everything is canon while not being a multiverse because from a story point of view, that would be literally impossible.

ripe berry
thin lagoon
#

welp

#

ima go now

ripe berry
thin lagoon
#

fun talkin to y'all

#

buh-bye

snow mauve
#

Bye

#

Anyways

#

LUCY

#

YEEE

ripe berry
#

Anyways

ripe berry
snow mauve
ripe berry
#

Quentin saved the kids

#

The Thing gonna be a Thing in AS Ep. 4

tribal talon
#

I honestly love how characterized The Thing is in episode 3, it feels like it has its own mind and personality and that honestly makes it an even more scary villain.

#

Hello Neighbor in itself isn't very scary, the most scared I get normally from Hello Neighbor is simply just jumping to a sudden jumpscare but The Thing in episode 3 was the only time ever in this franchise that I felt legitimately terrified!

#

You have no clue what it is, it can show up literally anywhere and can easily blend in and hide in dark environments meaning you never know when it's going to show up which is honestly a terrifying concept for anything horror.

snow mauve
#

👏 👏 👏 👏 👏

cunning wave
#

the thing was shown first in act 3 and the thing was shown in ep3.... coincedence?