#h1-story-discussion

1 messages · Page 10 of 1

frozen jolt
#

👍

zenith wedge
#

👍

bleak osprey
#

huh.

true harness
#

that do be some liminal space thing

#

I've seen episodes of twin peaks that were less weird

patent acorn
#

Malles those messages weren't in response to you

subtle birch
#

ok

ebon sigil
#

Chronos isn't a god tho

true harness
#

he is

#

he's a titan

#

not an olympian

#

but titans are gods

ebon sigil
#

No, Titans are Titans

#

They were the second order of divine beings, bellow that of Gaia and Uranus

static lion
#

Imagine ur children are gods and u don't even get that status

proven falcon
#

uranus haha

#

get it

open berry
#

juvenile, tomato be upon ye 🍅

ebon sigil
#

Just as you have demigods etc. as a lower title

#

If they were just "gods" then we wouldn't have two different words, we'd just called them gods to begin with

#

Not "titans"

#

Titans have the power of gods and more

#

For example the titans cannot truly be killed, just contained and imprisoned. Whilst at least one god died, Pan.

true harness
#

oh, gotcha. I didn't know Pan died in the mythology.

subtle birch
#

alr now

#

how did bro get adiosed

azure cradle
azure cradle
#

đŸ„¶

supple walrus
supple walrus
# subtle birch how did bro get adiosed

one day, some guy on a boat said "the great god pan is dead". that's it. that's the story of pan's death.

other story i know is he decided to not eat the apples of the hesperides that supposedly make the gods immortal because he figured he'd rather be dead than be around when humans stop worshipping him. can't find an english translated source on that though and while i trust my source to have used original sources, i don't know what their source actually is so not sure if that's legit

ebon sigil
#

None of them have some official bible that a central gouverning church made doctrine.

#

Anyway this discussion is semantic so let's move on

#

I just love that the Titans were in Dante's Inferno (because they were not gods but rather forces of nature)

subtle birch
#

whats

#

Dantes Inferno

ebon sigil
#

Best poetry of the entire work, except that of Lucifer himself, is about the Titans

ebon sigil
subtle birch
#

alr drop some of the best lore poems rq

#

man is actually reciting the poems wth

ebon sigil
#

In the 8th level, just before the last 9th level, the Titans were chained in huge wells of water. Since they all beget from Gaia, earth, they were powerless in water. When they moved in their prisons the very earth shock as their giant shackles rustled.

But Dante noted that they were not tortured, there was no pain inflicted upon them that he could se. Virgil explained: The Titans were the most prodigious and strong creatures in existence, to have all that might brought low, to have fallen so low, to have become powerless after being so powerful, was a worse fate than nearly anything fathomable.

subtle birch
#

Dante and Virgirl??

ebon sigil
subtle birch
#

like DMC?

ebon sigil
subtle birch
#

huh alr

#

btw

#

that was a

#

"poetic greek myth looking ahh"

true harness
#

Dante Inferno (The Divine Comedy) is basically the self-insert fanfic of Dante where his goes on a magical journey with his parasocial bestie to see all the people he doesn't like literally burning in hell

#

and at the end he gets the girl

#

10/10 top ao3 content shadethumbsup

subtle birch
supple walrus
# ebon sigil Hey wanna know a funny thing? All of the myths are from "some guy"

i guess i didn't write clearly enough, i didn't mean to say that some guy on a boat made up the story, it's that... some guy on a boat saying pan died is exactly how the story goes

"Whereupon Thamus looking from the poupe of the ship toward the land, pronounced with a loud voice that which he had heard, and said: The great Pan is Dead. He had no sooner spoken the word but there was heard a mighty noise, not of one but of many together, who seemed to groane and lament, and withall to make a great wonder. And as it falleth commonly out when as many be present, the newes thereof was soone spred and divulged through the city of Rome" https://penelope.uchicago.edu/plutarch/DeDefectu.html

static rose
#

Probably just skipped town for tax reasons...

regal pollen
#

How many times does Zagreus acknowledge his title of god of blood?
I can literally only think of like one or two times its acknowledged during the story

#

I think it’s super poetic that Zag and Than are super connected the way they are because of Zag’s title
Him being the god of blood sorta makes him a god of life, making him and Than opposites

true harness
#

That very point is highlighted by Achilles in the codex

patent acorn
regal pollen
#

Yeah, but outside of the codex, and when he mentions it, is it ever referred to by any other characters? Or just him and Achilles?

patent acorn
#

Don’t think so

static rose
#

Yeah, I think it's a realization between just Zag and Achilles.

subtle birch
#

I check the

#

book bonding

#

went to Achilles

#

and Zag said "wait Achilles says I'm the god of blood?"

#

then when talks to Achilles Zag tries to deny it

regal pollen
#

I mean the god of the dead and a technical god of life’s child being the god of blood makes a lot of sense

lapis depot
#

Persephone is only a demigod (in this canon), though, so Zagreus is too, which may explain why he bleeds like a mortal. On the other hand perhaps bleeding is kind of an essential quality to be a god of blood anyway

subtle birch
#

thought it was

#

Zeus's

#

with Demeters

subtle birch
#

"đŸ€“"

#

lame

lapis depot
# subtle birch with Demeters

they changed that to avoid weird incest things happening. Persephone's father is an unnamed mortal and Demeter is only a foster sister to Hades

subtle birch
#

wha

regal pollen
#

Huh

subtle birch
#

foster?

#

I dont get it

regal pollen
#

so
 the pantheon in hades is a non-incesty version?

subtle birch
#

wasnt it the 6 siblings Hades Posei Zeus Demeter Hera and one I dont remember

regal pollen
#

yknow the whole reason the family HAS THE BAGGAGE IN THE FIRST PLACE

lapis depot
#

no, not even close, there's still aphrodite and ares implications, but they wanted to avoid incest in the main relationship lol

#

though actually wait I forgot

#

aphrodite isn't a daughter of zeus, so no, even that one isn't incesty

#

huh

lapis depot
subtle birch
#

Chronos spayed part

#

Aphro and Ares fine I dont mind

#

but

#

aint

#

the whole Greek pantheon jsut a

#

family tree

#

or your average math question shape

#

like Demeter being a foster is highly "how"

lapis depot
#

I think wanting to just avoid that aspect of it is neither here nor there, it's just not that important tbh

subtle birch
#

alr fair

regal pollen
#

I mean they avoided it in percy jackson too

#

but in a way less sensical way

subtle birch
#

wussies

regal pollen
subtle birch
#

imagine

#

the coffin of Zaggy and Melly

lapis depot
#

I think part of it is that brother-sister incest is one thing (still kinda icky, but kind of acceptable for gods of the same age) but Persephone being Hades' niece is just... strange

subtle birch
#

but tho something people should focus on

#

is how Hades got that dawg in him

#

asked for Zeus-her father's permission

#

and he just swooped her

#

yoinked

lapis depot
#

not in this canon so idk

#

I mean, he both didn't ask and Zeus isn't her father in this canon

subtle birch
#

talking abt the myth

#

since yk incest stuff

lapis depot
#

yeah greek myth was weird about that

subtle birch
#

plus gods be doing worse things than incests

supple walrus
#

i don't remember rn

lapis depot
subtle birch
lapis depot
#

more in their tone honestly, but it feels pretty undeniable when you hear it

subtle birch
#

plus, marriage is a lie made by Hera to prevent Zeus from populating

lapis depot
subtle birch
#

ngl I would like to hear some blasphemous voicelines in the new Hades 2

#

try something new

supple walrus
lapis depot
#

I mean, Ares says "dear" in a very particular way, Aphrodite is pretty flirty all the time but she's really cranking it up here, and it fits the source material, so yeah idk

#

also, in most of her other duos she's just sassing the other god, which doesn't happen here

supple walrus
#

true, ares prob wouldn't call anyone else dear like that

lapis depot
#

"we can carry on in private about that" lmao

supple walrus
#

oh. i didn't watch the whole thing bc i'm supposed to be getting ready for workbouldy will check it out later, thanks

subtle birch
#

"hey Zag, Ares my husband"

#

seems outa pocket to say

earnest terrace
subtle birch
#

Hephaestus: why are we here

#

just to suffer

supple walrus
#

there's always someone butthurt on olympus
ftr if it sounded like that, i didn't mean to argue against it, i was just wondering because i honestly couldn't remember and i feel the game is often deliberately vague about things

#

sometimes i wish it was possible to reset just the dialog in a file

earnest terrace
#

(about the butthurt part)

subtle birch
#

based off Greek Mythology.

#

honestly I think they did an amazing job tho

#

didnt even notice that there was no swearing

#

just old but gold trash talking

supple walrus
#

There is made up swearing, blood and darkness

true harness
#

Better teach him that swear before he picks up any other

#

Imagine you don't tell your son to say Blood and darkness and a while after he starts saying motherfu-

mortal dune
#

Honestly this isn’t the worst parenting approach? Like he’s being weird about it but if you teach a child both the meaning and use context of a swear as well as the degree of appropriateness towards using it then they’ll be more aware and curses and etc. won’t be as enticingly unfamiliar or rebellious, so they will actually model the behavior you want

#

If a kid says a swear word it’s better to educate upon it in great detail because that makes it less cool :]

true harness
#

mfw my parents start infodumping on every curse words imaginable, forever destroying my willingness to swear (and my capacity to be fun at parties)

mortal dune
#

Nah it just means you have to be extra creative

#

Which can either be a boon or a burden

true harness
#

Ares duo boon with Samuel L. Jackson : Curse of cursing

deep canyon
supple walrus
mortal dune
#

That’s an angle I’ve never considered before!!

#

Wow that’s so fascinating

#

Say it with me: generational trauma

#

I think Hades’ upset at Zag leaving was a mixture of him being disappointed in/kinda envious of Zag for abandoning his duties as Prince when Hades himself has always refused to abandon his duty as Lord; anger that he was behaving (what Hades perceived as) spoiled and self-indulgent, thinking Zag aspired to be like the Olympians; feeling threatened by Zag interacting with the Olympians and potentially getting Persephone in danger; and something to the left of sadness that his son was running away

#

Hades says himself that Zag was the only person he had left he considered family, so to lose that so violently must’ve been hurtful

#

Zag in doin what he does inadvertently actually gives Hades back his familial support structure

#

At minimum he now has Persephone to balance him out, and some amicable relationship with Zeus which makes his work-life a little easier

#

And of course a developing relationship with his son

frozen jolt
#

I think at the beginning of the game and prior to it he sees zag as the direct cause why persephone left and he resents him for it without zag having done anything wrong, and his act of trying to escape both reminds him of her leaving and angers him because he can’t do the same for various reasons as you said

#

hades and his beef with his own baby

mortal dune
#

Oooh though that’s a valid interpretation I would honestly kinda disagree

#

Imo if he did blame Zag then he would be more vindictive about it, especially after Zag reveals he knows about him mom. I imagine he’d make comments specifically about Zag’s fault and etc

#

I don’t think he had beef with Zag as a thing that happened? He more so blames himself for Persephone leaving

frozen jolt
#

it’s been a while since I played the story so forgive me for not having my stuff in order LOL

mortal dune
#

Like he does love his son for the most part and tried to raise him to be a good man, which I think if he resented him he would shunt the childrearing all to Nyx

frozen jolt
#

I just remember playing it for the first time and some things really stuck with me and struck a nerve

mortal dune
#

Oh for sure

#

Understandable completely

#

But yeah Hades’ insults to Zag are primarily about Zagreus’ character, which is attached to Hades’ own issues with the Olympians and trauma as a God and Older Sibling

frozen jolt
#

I think if I were to play it again from the start I may have different opinion and analyses but it’s such a beast to replay and gameplay-wise its hard for me when I’m all maxed out and have been for so long

true harness
#

Oh, now I wonder if Hades will talk to Zagreus about being an older brother, since melinoë is there... Though I'm not sure Hades did much in his childhood. Given he was in someone's stomach.

mortal dune
#

OH MANNN

#

THAT WOULD BE SO COOL

#

OH please please that would literally be perfect

mortal dune
#

I really hope they don’t go down the route of making Hades like, super sweet on Mel but still tense with Zag that would suck badddd

#

Undo all of the character work on Hades’ part

true harness
#

Don't get your hype up too much, maybe we'll just see a flashback of zag asking hades
"Father, do you have any advice about taking care of Melinoë ? You had younger siblings too..."
"Zagreus, the only advice I could give you is to not get eaten."

mortal dune
#

Hades is like at his core not a great parent (he doesn’t have a lot of the necessary qualities), it’s part if the reason he messed up so bad with Zag . So him being a great parent to Mel would make his and Zag’s relationship even more fueled by spite and specific dislike rather than simple incompetence

mortal dune
true harness
#

it do be good advice

mortal dune
#

Like the vignettes at the beginning of each run demonstrate a LOT about his relationship with Zag

#

Small things like that would deepen the worldbuilding and overall narrative about family a LOT

true harness
#

How to be a good older brother :

  1. Don't get eaten
  2. ???
  3. Blood and Darkness my whole family is screwed up
mortal dune
#

Zag telling Mel “you know, father never told me being an older brother would be so booring” or something idk

#

It doesn’t have to be so jokey

#

Zag being an adult helping take care of his child sibling is also a unique dynamic

true harness
mortal dune
#

Pffft jesus

#

I imagine Zag would end up parenting Mel to an extent which would add a dimension to her disposition that Zag didn’t have

#

Where Zag had Nyx and Hades (both kinda dark and gloomy and not super affectionate) Mel will also have Persephone and Zag as well

#

A lot more balance and light in her life

#

ORRR nother story plot, she maybe wasn’t raised in the underworld and thus doesn’t know them well

#

I don’t like that potentiality because it strips her of a lot of deep potential relationships

true harness
#

I feel like she wouldn't be as driven to rescue Hades if so

mortal dune
#

She might, it’s happened in stories before

#

Off the top of my head you have like. Hercules in the Disney movie

true harness
#

Does hercule rescue Zeus ?

mortal dune
#

Hunter x Hunter maybe?

mortal dune
true harness
#

"Hey big dude, what're you doing in the deepest pits of tartarus ? Anyway, I'm searching for my father, Hades. Heard of him ?"
"GIRL I AM HADES UNTIE ME THIS INSTANT AND I WILL SEND YOU BACK TO THE STYX I SWEAR"

mortal dune
#

She might’ve heard stories, or been with them when she was very young

true harness
#

then he just rips off the chains himself out of sheer offended rage and proceeds to EM4 you while shirtless

mortal dune
#

It’s especially not uncommon in Greek myth stories for children to be captivated with a parent they even never met

#

Like Perseus maybe?

#

I wouldn’t like it but it wouldn’t surprise me

#

Similar thing to the orphan hero, mitigating these relationships to create a sense of tragedy/lost opportunity also handicaps your ability to add depth to your protagonist through the relationships that shapes them

#

She at least has Hecate

fiery zinc
#

they personified planets, hermes is mercury, ares is mars, aphrodite is venus, zeus is jupiter, chronos is saturn, look into astrotheology

#

pluto is hades

mortal dune
#

Those are their Roman names

fiery zinc
#

all the ancients did this, in norse mythology hermes/mercury is odin in egypt thoth etc.

mortal dune
#

I think the differences between those three are stark enough to differentiate them

fiery zinc
#

nah

true harness
#

source : they told me directly

atomic forge
#

Why did persephone not go home with zagreus

zenith wedge
#

Do it again

atomic forge
# zenith wedge Do it again

Im at a certain part where she says something about olympus n a war n stuff, i skipped through all of em, what does it mean

zenith wedge
#

Dem made cuz persephone gone > gods helping zag may make them notice where she's hiding and if that happens > chaos

#

But just keep escaping anyways

atomic forge
zenith wedge
#

10 clears

atomic forge
#

I’m pretty close

#

I got 7 clears atm

subtle birch
#

comes and goes lol

#

oh wait ohhhh

#

the storyline

#

sunset was still a thing

dire sandal
#

this is probably a more general question about greek mythology but when a new god is born how is there "space" for their new job?

#

For example before Thanatos was born who managed peaceful death

#

and were they angry over their loss of control over a piece of the world?

#

If Zag is the god of blood like Achilles suggested does that mean Ares's power has decreased because he controlled bloodshed and therefore blood before his birth?

earnest terrace
#

I wouldn't consider 'bloodshed' and 'blood' to be part of the same portfolio

#

But in regards to your question overall, I don't think there's a proper answer for that

#

Probably a good topic for worldbuilding/theological discussion

subtle birch
#

how flawed the world was before them gods

subtle birch
#

Greek mythos were convoluted

#

like hell them greek writers be writing whatvever they want

#

plus, most of the greek bible were burned off bcs of some Chrsitian fanboy

#

so questions like those were never answered

#

and so

#

its more like a "it just works" momento

true harness
#

"greek bible" thanthink

subtle birch
#

alr it was like

#

a piece of paper writers wrote on

earnest terrace
#

CULTURAL HEGEMONY REEEEEEE

supple walrus
# dire sandal this is probably a more general question about greek mythology but when a new go...

i think the answer to that question is mostly that the gods weren't just characters in stories as they are to us, but part of actual, practiced religion. people would make offerings to a god in hope they'd help them with whatever issue they were having, that's how they'd become god of their thing. eg ares isn't some sort of marvel super hero / villain with special powers of controlling war, just who you'd pray to if you're going to war (unsure if pray is the correct word but you know what i mean). that's also why some, especially older gods are gods of a whole lot of things - different people in different circumstances would have different relationships to their deities.

it's kind of like asking, if the christian god created everything, where did he come from? there's no answer to that because that's not the point of that religion

#

as for how that works in hades, the game, specifically, i tried to figure that out at some point and i think it's just... there's no logic to it

subtle birch
#

"it just works"

supple walrus
#

yea

actually the thing that makes the least sense to me in the game regarding that is than and hypnos being implied to be around the same age as zag, ie relatively young

mortal dune
#

I mean in mythos that did happen with the Titans, which I imagine was partly the point of the Titanomachy

#

Like Helios was the Sun Titan eh? And then when he was defeated it became Apollo

#

Metaphysically I do believe it’s just a matter of the shift in belief, as people would begin to believe in a certain god over another part of the domains would transfer as well

#

So in game, as Zag becomes more renowned as a god (perhaps even over Ares in certain aspects) he would take over certain domains

mortal dune
safe cairn
#

Than is definitely way older than Zag

#

if you're talking about the painting that's basically noncanon

#

Than talks several times to/about Persephone and how he knew her before she left

#

same with Meg

safe cairn
#

that would imply he is still "around" in some capacity at least

supple walrus
#

persoally i am less confused about thanatos and hypnos being older than zag (i think they are supposed to be), but about them being much younger than the olympic gods

open berry
#

re: gods and regarding jobs and such when new gods enter the world, fwiw many gods had multiple domains beyond their primary ones they're most well known for

true harness
#

In fact it gets pretty crazy

#

I think notably Artemis and Zeus are very God of the kitchen sink

#

Apollo too a bit, as well as hermes and athena I guess ?

#

Now that I think about it, I imagine it's the same for catholic saints thanthink I don't have any example in mind, but I remember seeing some wild associations

daring hamlet
#

(sorry, catholic mentioned)

earnest terrace
#

he had so many portfolios that he didn't even really have one "characteristic" thing

earnest terrace
#

Incorrect, Packrat: Helios was the Sun

subtle birch
normal zephyr
#

agh the weather here already started to get hotter

#

Persephone go back to the Underworld pls

dire sandal
#

persephone, the goddess of global warming

true harness
#

I can't believe Zagreus is responsible for global warming zagshock zagsad

fair portal
#

Major Spoiler: |||So I went to fight Hades for the tenth time... only to discover he lets me go, lol that was quite the surprise! It's sad though, because I had a good build going, I didn't intend to complete it, but I had the shield and I entered three chaos gates (to see if I can get chaos to talk about the beowulf aspect). Either way, I quite enjoyed the ending here, and hearing Orpheous and Euridice sing with that awesome song? Damn. Well worth it. I'm mostly glad I could get this so I didn't get spoiled without earning this first. Now I'm gonna just have fun with the game.||

true harness
#

That's awesome ! Have fun and good luck on your new job

latent nebula
# dire sandal For example before Thanatos was born who managed peaceful death

Going back to this quickly I believe there’s a dialogue line with Hermes where he says it used to be his job to bring souls to Charon, and he didn’t seem too upset about it becoming Thanatos’ job
I could be misremembering that though.. there’s so many lines it’s hard to keep track (though who knows if that was part of true Greek canon or only Hades canon)

mortal dune
#

It’s definitely only Hades canon

#

If there was any conflict like that in real Greek myth it would have been violent

supple walrus
#

it was also in blood of zeus thozaglol

subtle birch
#

heard there was a trailer

supple walrus
#

idk i'm not following the news on that

#

also apparently hermes guiding souls to the underworld is not just in the game, according to this, they cite the odyssee and others https://www.theoi.com/Olympios/Hermes.html

he would also guide dreams to people👀

mortal dune
#

Oh yeah that part is canon

#

The part about Hermes being like, okay with giving his job up to Than is almost assuredly made up

supple walrus
#

oh, that's what you meant, sorry, i misunderstood

wondering about the exact dialog though because i don't remember game hermes actually giving up the job

earnest terrace
#

Neither do I

#

Seems like a random thing to change

subtle birch
normal zephyr
#

i thought about it and just realize how painful some of Zag's death can be

#

the guy just kind of shake it off when he comes back tho 💀💀

#

Zag stronger than me fr if i died from a spike trap you bet my ass ill be locking myself in my room for like a week to cope

#

to be fair he is a god and i guess dying over and over again just kind of make it better??

tranquil lotus
#

thats why we love zag

earnest terrace
#

i feel like learning how to cope with death would be one of the first things a cthonic god undergoes

raven arch
#

Has anyone here not finished your first run yet

daring hamlet
raven arch
#

Nah I have finished it

#

I just meant if anyone here didn’t finish it

#

So I could talk about the game without worrying abt spoilers

zenith wedge
#

This channel isn't spoiler free so you are fine

#

(spoiler marks may be used if you want anyways)

raven arch
#

Alr thanks

supple walrus
#

like even the stupid things players will do like post lernie magma baths to replenish health with stubborn defiance - it just makes sense for his character

true harness
#

it's probably similar to a boxer getting a beating in the ring. Not particularly enjoyable, but hey, that's how it is

mortal dune
#

Also, a huge theme within the game is actually Zag's resilience I believe! The fact that he keeps trying in the face of all of those struggles informs a lot about how he approaches his relationships with everyone in the game, and how he changes the lives of the people around him

#

It's not just the symbol of the Sisyphean task, it's also that his arc of character growth involves him learning to take more responsibility within his own life, and the inciting incident to all of that is that in order to get what he wants (freedom, his mother) he can't run away from the things that hurt him anymore and has to face them head on

#

That part is concretized in his many deaths, but you see it also in his romantic relationships with Meg and Than (admitting his faults and apologizing to Meg is a "painful" thing he would not have wanted to do in the beginning of the story, and having the patience and emotional maturity to address Than's anxieties is also a trait he had to develop through "painful" self-reflection) and especially his relationship with his father (choosing to come to some sort of understanding and sympathy/empathy with Hades, as someone who had abused him, is also a rather painful thing to do).

#

I guess the way I'd summarize it, is that his many runs to try and reach the surface functionally represent Zag's coming-of-age story where he achieves self-actualization and maturity, and his many deaths during those runs symbolically represent the more painful adult realities of his situation that he has to learn to accept and become content with

trail otter
#

Yall- I recently got persephone back down and hermes just mentioned that he knows ‘someone is back’. Is that just a random line of dialogue or does that mean stuff’s gunna change (like the other gods finding out)

random ginkgo
#

Idt they know until you trigger the epilogue’s steps, that’s why they keep helping you believeing still you’re escaping to go to Olympus, though it could be one of those godly hunches

trail otter
#

(Idk if this is even the right channel mb)

trail otter
#

Okay thank god 😭

true harness
#

Yeah, Hermes knows about the whole shebang but he's the best so he's not making a fuss with the others about it

#

I love Hermes, such a homie

#

Bro doesn't have a mean bone in him, because bones would slow him down

trail otter
#

Too true

normal zephyr
#

honestly watching Theseus having a melt down bc he keeps on losing to Zag is kind of funny and a bit sad tbh

normal zephyr
#

hes sooo scared that his bull bf is gonna leave him for Zag damn

fringe trail
icy sigil
primal flint
#

When a Boon drops in the game, what is Zagreus actually seeing?

#

Like, what exactly is the ball? Is it a portal? Is it a mirror, a crystal sphere? I know this is super specific but It's been bugging me lol.

frozen jolt
#

well what i remember is that its a one-way communication, the only way he can respond is by making an offering

safe cairn
#

When he gets each boon for the first time he comments on the shape, so I think he literally is seeing the icons lol

#

for example Artemis, he says it can only be one heavenly archer

#

(or several)

frozen jolt
#

well then maybe hes seeing them the same way

#

or maybe its a little suspension of disbelief (?) for gameplays sake

static rose
#

They're definitely one way. The gods can make out a bit of his environment but he can't communicate back in any way (other than accepting or not accepting the message).

primal flint
#

Oh you can't swear here. My apology for swearing was for nothing. LOL.

I am so irritated.

#

Trying to finish the hearts/Ambrosia with everyone. Finally got a ||fish to appear|| before picking up a ||Poseidon|| boon... except apparently, if you buy a boon, that doesnt count towards it appearing in the Boon pool.

#

So even though I bought a core boon for that God, I never found them again. So I never got to unlock the hearts.

#

I'm just going to bring the chamber reroll next time.

true harness
#

oof, yeah, shop boons are not the same wrt talking

#

unlucky

primal flint
#

Unfortunately, a painful lesson learned today. I will get to see the ending sooner or later.

#

I can take solace that I did unlock Athena and will soon unlock Hermes' hearts though.

supple walrus
#

iirc you can just keep the fish, ie not sell it to the head chef, and use poseidon's keepsake to make him appear in the next run

random ginkgo
#

It’s very funny to imagine Chaos playing hide and seek with a tiny Nyx, an entity that looks like if a Biblically accurate angel became a humanoid floating around trying to catch a tiny baby

primal flint
#

I'm going to have to try this.

zenith wedge
#

Taking a boon anywhere will add them to your pool

#

But as junco said yesh you won't get the right dialogues if it's from a shop

#

(I think you can only get the "look how charon helped us"/duo dialogue/generic)

primal flint
#

but I finally did it. Oh my god.

#

Absolute horrible luck with Poseidon. He was the biggest problem of all. but that sweet relief when I got him and the fish... I know I could've swapped m Keepsake to his, but

  • 1 I wasn't expecting him to be so stubborn!
  • 2 I was trying to get others unlocked as well, so I was running Hermes for fast runs.
#

A few tears though. Tears of both relief, stress and satisfaction. Hades has to definitely be my favourite game.

zenith wedge
#

Keeping the fish does work but sometimes rng just hates you

violet thicket
#

i need a really good clan to join but i cant find one

#

wait

zenith wedge
#

I thought you were a bot bouldy

violet thicket
#

is this thw wrong discord sever

#

is this hades rng discord?

zenith wedge
#

Nah

violet thicket
#

lol my bad

#

there is two games called hades

#

well thanks

pseudo stump
#

Bad bot! zaglol

primal flint
zenith wedge
primal flint
#

I bumped into him several times whilst keeping a fish and no matter which order I found him, it did not trigger it. As soon as I caught a fish THEN spoke to him, it triggered.

zenith wedge
#

Some stuff have certain priority but is mostly story stuff

primal flint
#

Rotten.

zenith wedge
#

Someone here took like a month? To get Asterius to mention the hidden fists phrase

#

Is also what causes the typical post/question of "if my quest bugged?"

zenith wedge
#

Cuz characters will start talking about what's going on

random ginkgo
#

So how much does Zagreus exactly know about the Surface, Greece? Since the amount of time he ventures past Hades is quite varying, sometimes only a few steps, sometimes enough to reach a crossing to get run over by a chariot. Ik it’s mostly for jokes but I’m just curious

supple walrus
supple walrus
earnest terrace
#

but in regards to actual firsthand experience, probably not much, no

mortal dune
#

He canonically doesn't know/understand what birds are

#

His primary source of information about Greece is Achilles I believe, everyone else either doesn't know as much or doesn't bother to tell him

open berry
#

re: poseidon heart, fwiw the text trigger literally is just "has a fish on hand" but you also need a minimum of 18 fish caught in total up to that point. entirely possible it was funky rng, or you didnt meet the minimum fish requirement

primal flint
#

so either RNG was super specific, or it is what happened what worked. which would be what the guide said to do.

open berry
#

dunno what to tell you, i just looked at it when i replied 😭 game be like that sometimes

glass pollen
#

Mostly because I like the idea of him interacting with living mortals even briefly

supple walrus
#

zagreus also seems to have read a lot of books. or at least own a lot of books. or at least has them scattered around his room. maybe those or some of those are greek books and books about greece?

mortal dune
#

My personal headcanon is that Zag just doesn’t read any of them

#

Cuz he doesn’t use his weights and he doesn’t sit in his chairs and he doesn’t play his board game

#

Only thing in his room he uses at all is the Harp

#

He’s far too impatient and inattentive to read imo lol

normal zephyr
#

Zag's deaths on earth is so damn goofy

#

like wdym he ran into a wall that was painted to look like a tunnel with an opening on the other side

#

goofy ahhh death

#

and that one time he sniffed a flower and died

#

do you think he experiment different new ways to die when he reaches the surface

#

it seems like a Zagreus thing

supple walrus
# mortal dune He’s far too impatient and inattentive to read imo lol

yeah i can totally see thatzaglol however if we go with the adhd thing i could also imagine him as hyperfocusing on stories, making him able to read books tho. it's not like they have a lot of other media in the underworld, and he does read achilles' codex if the player does. plus he's been stuck in the house of hades his whole life, and even if we imagine that as being bigger than what we see in the game, that's sorta limited

mortal dune
#

Ooh good point

#

In that case I think he obsesses over Achilles stories cuz that’s his mentor and his idol

#

So if Achillies is telling it or is part of it or is recommending it then he’s on top of it like ants on cheddar

normal zephyr
#

zag i feel like he’s a HUGEE reader (hah), like he was not allowed out the house and that is bound to get boring at some point, plus he also gushes over Theseus the first time he met him

#

saying he’s a legend n such

trail reef
#

Hamburger

zealous fox
#

thesus

random ginkgo
normal zephyr
#

hypnos is lowkey the scarier twin change my mind

#

i fear people who are chill

#

they usually have some sort of unyielding rage hiding somewhere i know it

random ginkgo
normal zephyr
#

he is constantly on like 2 hours of sleep

#

i dont think he even sleeps the guy seems to just nap

random ginkgo
#

He is 🍹

normal zephyr
#

he's very cute

#

i want to put him in a grinder

mortal dune
#

I mean, he is pretty powerful. He put the entire House to sleep just cuz Zag asked him to lol

strong skiff
#

he's my idol

mortal dune
#

Something I find interesting is that Hades, despite his anger at Nyx, still refers to the Underworld as ‘their’ realm. It gives the implication that he typically acknowledges her authority over it, which is an interesting contrast to the evident violation he feels about her butting into his conflict with Zag

#

Cuz technically, Zag is ‘their’ son

earnest terrace
mortal dune
#

I mean sure

#

But I’m specifically talking about that respect in the context of their coparenting of Zagreus

earnest terrace
#

Mmm

#

Yeah Hades is definitely frustrated but he very much seems the type to maintain a separation between work and personal life in that regard

#

Even if the two are very, very closely related

mortal dune
#

For sure

#

It's hard when your partner is your boss or vice versa or anything of the like, that power imbalance and the weight of that responsiblity really wears down your relationship

#

Now imagine that they're not even your partner, that you are limited by that lack of immediate intimacy

earnest terrace
#

Yeah I can't imagine Hades and Nyx being actual 'partners' in any deeper way than what they are now

#

i.e. stable colleagues who work closely together

#

But that in itself can cause weird rumors and implications

#

And for all their power and dignity, neither of them are remotely emotionally unshakeable individuals

mortal dune
#

The thing is is that like, I can imagine them being partners on a deeper level in that they have a lot in common, evidently do care about each other (going back to that respect Hades showed, and to Nyx respecting him back), and their history as co-managers of the underworld and co-parents to Zag

#

Persephone has a line where she mentions it, Nyx implies a deeper connection there as well, but I get the geenral consensus

#

(in my head they have an interesting qpr relationship but that's obviously just fanon, everything ^ is canon)

mortal dune
#

They’re narrative foils and they have a lot of tensioned conflict between them throughout the story and honestly I will say it’s a little more balanced of a conflict than I’ve seen portrayed

subtle birch
#

just work mates

#

plus both of em know 1 or 2 things abt relationships themselves

supple walrus
#

does anyone remember if there's dialog on the aspect of nemesis suggesting she had already used it before the events of the game?

stark meteor
supple walrus
#

Ah right thank you

plush quartz
#

I just realised, humans other than the characters we meet(even then, most of them are actually demi gods), arnt really present in the game, nor talked about. This whole time I wanted hades 2 to have promeuthes in it, but creating humans and liking them is a huge part of his character in greek mythology, so I guess in hindsight(pun unintended) it wouldn't make too much sense with lacking context.

#

Obviously shades exist, and we get a lot of talk about the souls of enemies. But nothing about human culture or what civilisation is like on the surface.

earnest terrace
#

Probably because we play things from Zagreus' perspective, who although he knows some things about surface civilization (e.g. his conversations with Achilles, Skelly, Asterius), he generally isn't incredibly well informed (e.g. his convo with Thanatos about how humans view death); there's also the simple fact that the surface itself isn't incredibly relevant to the story of the game, hence why we don't get too much info about it

dire oyster
#

just saw an opening from Hades himself talking about where the satyrs may have been coming from. Think they were from Kronos now?

sick anvil
#

how tf did satyrs become the evil dudes

trail reef
#

they hate everything

#

I hate them too

sick anvil
#

ooh idea

#

they got forced down into the underworld because of the harsh surface conditions

#

and uh

#

went mad

#

probably a mid theory but ill take it

timber thistle
#

How do I get the permission to post pics

zenith vault
timber thistle
zenith wedge
#

Send to another discord, right click and copy img link

#

Or use smth like imgur

timber thistle
#

Too much work for a small detail

#

So dio can make you prank orpheus that youre the same god

#

Thats actually a detail from real world myth where historians theorize dionysus is an offshoot of a much older god( by that I mean the time period when they were prayed to)

zenith vault
#

In some Greek paintings and mythology sometimes zagerus is considered dionoysus

timber thistle
#

Yeah thats what I meant

zenith vault
#

Ohhh

timber thistle
#

I shouldve mentioned that the older god was named zagreus😭

zenith vault
#

Man idk

#

Should I pick vengeful mood or battle rage epic?

zenith wedge
#

Have fun dusa

rain otter
#

...this doesn't sound good?

zenith wedge
#

Just go đŸ”«

rain otter
#

Ok, the epilogue

#

I love the game

#

I'll oviously still play it, but I wanted to still leave my impression

#

The voices, the characters, the gameplay, the fact that a defeat is a part of the story and not a reset

#

Everything is made really well and with love

#

The game is brilliant

main flint
#

Congrats on reaching the credits!

rain otter
#

Thanks!

supple walrus
#

random thought, at first i disliked the phrase "fear is for the weak" because i hate when weakness and being afraid are posited as something negative, but then i realized

the phrase also means it's ok to be afraid when you are, in fact, weak. and by itself it doesn't judge that

pseudo stump
#

Oh yeah! There was often a guy at a table on the main walkway of my university who displayed a similar phrase: "religion is for the weak"

#

To clarify, he very much meant it in the same vein

frank helm
#

How does Theseus get to be in Elysium? Isn't this the same guy who tried to kidnap Persephone? The Olympians don't seem particularly fond of him either.

supple walrus
supple walrus
pseudo stump
earnest terrace
#

What matters is that you accomplished significant things, not whether you were a good person while doing them

#

Nor even whether those things were even necessarily good

mortal dune
#

What’s especially hilarious about this point is that even though Hades himself doesn’t like it he (as literal King) has not changed it since he got there

#

Sure maybe the mortals would riot or something but him not even like, considering it is so silly to me

trail reef
#

I liek cheeseburger

outer gale
#

Ever tried kebab?

rain otter
#

Ok, I just beat the ugraded heros. Giving Theseus a car and a machiene gun is extremely funny

trail reef
#

I LIKE IT

sick anvil
#

im only using that pact from now on bro

open berry
#

its very funny and he laughs maniacally as he speeds around the arena

sick anvil
#

IM YSUNG THAT PCT BRO

#

IDC IF IT GOES HIGHER THAN MY low HEAT GAUGE

#

GIVE !! HIM!!! A CAR!!!!

zenith wedge
#

em3 should always be recommended

#

not bc its easy but bc its hilarious

sick anvil
#

YES

lucid basin
sick anvil
frank helm
sick anvil
#

Also doesnt he have like

#

a panel of judges

#

i only remember king minos is on it

frank helm
#

In the mythologies he does.

They don't seem to be there in this game.

sick anvil
#

Damn

#

oh yeah

#

he has like

#

that line

trail reef
#

Kill minos

untold tide
#

Judgement

trail reef
#

thy end is now

opaque pawn
#

Don't think I'll ever get over this line (final boss intro) ||we're gods boy.|| Ugh it's just always going to give me chills

obsidian mica
#

Ahh I think I’ve finally unlocked the next step in Achilles story!!

sick anvil
sly cloak
#

the devs reduced my polygon count

sick anvil
#

dev polygon scandal

frozen jolt
#

Ok I’ll take this here bc it’s relevant
Was dusa implied to be trans at some point or am I misremembering. There is So much dialogue in this game

#

Canonically I mean

#

I know she is ace but I remember something about it
 I don’t know how to find it though

#

Melakar kind of answered but pinging @open berry Just in case u know what I’m talking about specifically

mortal dune
frozen jolt
#

?

mortal dune
#

(Sorry sent it too early)

frozen jolt
#

I don’t remember the line

mortal dune
#

It went something like “I’ve left it behind me an am much happier now without it” or something

#

So the implication here is body dysmorphia at minimum, which could then be extrapolated into body dysphoria

#

Persephone also has a couple lines that could be extrapolated into a beat about transness, when she talks about changing her name

frozen jolt
#

I think, then, it would be too vague about dysmorphia either đŸ€”

frozen jolt
#

Dusa feels more intentional, implied or even hinted at to me

#

even if it’s not as direct as her being ace

mortal dune
# frozen jolt Well her previous name meant “young maiden”. Considering she’s a woman I find it...

In my mind sometimes a story doesn’t have to be a direct 1-1 to be about a certain thematic element, y’know? Fundamentally the Persephone-Kore bit is about Persephone finding an identity and a presentation that suits her more than what was assigned to her at birth, so it reflects elements of a trans-story in that way and thus, if someone chooses, can be interpreted as such I feel

mortal dune
# frozen jolt I think, then, it would be too vague about dysmorphia either đŸ€”

As I’ve been taught, dysmorphia is more about one’s dislike of their body for perceived flaws with it (so Dusa not liking her body on an aesthetic level), which is a much easier connection to make with the line as it exists versus dysphoria, which is about a deep feeling of disconnection one feels towards their body via gender identity specifically

#

They’re both possible interpretations 👍

upbeat willow
#

Important to note: dysmorphia isn't just a dislike of percieved body flaw(s).
Its much more than that and effects those are dysmorphic a heckin lot

mortal dune
#

Oh for sure

#

It’s much more intense than just dislike that was just the first word I could think of as well as the word it’s defined by in the dictionary 😅

sick anvil
#

woah dusa gender

#

i love this game 🙏 how many genres is this thjng

mortal dune
#

Like, one I think

#

I think it’s just a straightforward roguelike, right?

mortal dune
#

I like that Hypnos shares more colours with Chaos than Nyx, Charon, or Than. It’s a cool way to show he’s a bit of a black sheep among them

normal zephyr
#

ive been saying this to my friends but they already think im cray cray

#

do you think the reason Nyx favors Than more than Hypnos is bc of how similar he seems to be with Chaos

#

i mean

#

in a dream the limit is your imagination after all

#

their domains seems to cross much more than Nyx's other children

mortal dune
#

I don't know if it's necessarily that Hypnos is like Chaos, because what she disliked in Chaos was their lack of real empathy? If that makes sense? They drifted apart because Chaos was a largely uninvolved parent- which is a little ironic, considering everything

#

But Chaos would definitely see more value in Hypnos than Nyx would, which could create discord between them for sure

#

Hypnos and his realm are far more closely intertwined with the lives of mortals than Nyx's or even Thanatos, in that the latter all work from a distance where he has to work up close and personal. Both in the codex and in general mythology Hypnos is considered to be a kind and gentle god, of which is complimented by his cheery disposition- also of which is contasted by the darker, more gothic dispositions of his family.

All this to say, Hypnos is himself a bit of a wrong note- he's so different from his family it makes him weird and a little unpredictable to them, which I think Chaos would enjoy :)

#

I so so so desperately hope the two of them interact in Hades 2

solar depot
#

i love their weird little grandson shadepwease

timber thistle
#

Why does Hades not throw his spear for range? Is he stupid?

zenith wedge
#

em4:

timber thistle
#

Damn they really made me pay so Hades can play with the Y button

limber widget
#

finally rolled credits on hades 1 in time for hades 2!

exotic sedge
#

Now to go after the Epilogue while the wait continues!

limber widget
#

there's an epilogue? 😭

exotic sedge
#

Yes

#

Max relationship with the gods

#

And keep talking with people to eventually trigger the true ending

#

Depending on how much of that you've done, shouldn't take too long

limber widget
#

oh i see, guess I need to get round to that, thank you

exotic sedge
#

Plus, there's some other sidequests you can also do!

#

But a thing at a time

loud umbra
#

Is there another thing to do for hermes to unlock his hearts? Hes the only character I have left to max out hearts for but even after I completed his quest to defeat charon twice he hasn't unlocked his hearts. He did acknowledge it with a voiceline the next time i spoke to him but its been a couple of runs now and he still hasn't unlocked

zenith wedge
loud umbra
#

I did that as well but he didnt say anything zagsad ill try again though maybe i just need to do it a few more times thank you 💖

exotic sedge
#

You sure his keepsake was maxed out?

zenith wedge
#

If yes then have fun with the rng

exotic sedge
#

He needs to speak of it three times

zenith wedge
#

Wait he has 3 dialogues for that?

exotic sedge
#

Yeah

#

He needs to speak three times about his keepsake

#

That's his favor

zenith wedge
#

Huh, where did you see that

exotic sedge
#

The wiki

#

I'm pretty sure he needs to talk three times

#

I actually went to check again, but they didn't actually say how many times

zenith wedge
#

That's why I asked lol, was also checking

exotic sedge
#

Maybe I'm hallucinating

#

Mixing it with the fact the plume must be maxed at 3*

#

Or something

zenith wedge
#

Disciple of hermes caught spreading misinfo about hermes himself

exotic sedge
#

Regardless, I think that in the game he has at least three dialogues about the plume

#

Even if you don't have to hear them all for his favor

#

Let me check what Youtube has to say about his favor

exotic sedge
#

Ok, survey says he only needs to speak of it once

#

But there is more than one plume related dialogue in the whole game

#

That must have been what threw me off

loud umbra
#

pog i got it on my latest run i think maybe i did just have another dialogue blocking it the previous time

#

but his was the first one i maxed out so im sure that i def talked to him more than 3 times w it

exotic sedge
#

Well, glad you finally got it

exotic sedge
fallen jackal
#

best aspect on exagryph?

zenith wedge
#

Eris/hestia

#

If you have low amounts of blood go er9s

fallen jackal
#

im at level 2 with hestia

fallen jackal
#

damn i didnt think it'd be that strong

#

i think i killed the aspect with this hammer boon that makes it so i dont have to reload

#

lmao

zenith wedge
#

You can still reload

fallen jackal
#

oh you're right

fallen jackal
#

oh this was the wrong channel

#

lmao

atomic wagon
#

In game lore, demeter is our grandma instead of our grandma/aunt right

pseudo stump
#

Yep!

mortal dune
#

Yes

#

Demeter is the child of Hyperion and not Chronos in this

#

So are Hestia and Hera

elder summit
#

Why don’t we just poor cold water on Hypnos head?

earnest terrace
#

for what purpose

pseudo stump
#

To make him cold and damp, of course!

frank helm
devout summit
#

if he makes us suffer like that then no he doesn't deserve to

earnest terrace
#

what suffering

devout summit
#

By making fun of us every time we die

#

Also question

#

Is it ever established who the disembodied voice is describing stuff

earnest terrace
#

Hades 2 makes it rather clear

devout summit
#

Then I don't wanna know atm

earnest terrace
#

Fair lmao

devout summit
#

Still trying to beat the first one

#

Only got it like 3 days ago

supple walrus
open berry
#

hes just like. bad at social cues yknow.

silk needle
#

I am trying to complete the epilogue achievement with minimum spoilers as possible what is the important one step to achieve this?? Completed 100 runs won maybe 30, completed heat 16.

frozen jolt
#

deepen your friendships with everyone, and keep talking to them

native rapids
#

someone help me understand the sequal pls i played the first one like crazy

#

bought the 2nd one now

#

but idk whats the story behind it

frozen jolt
#

it's a direct sequel, and i can imagine the game's story will speak for itself

mossy spruce
#

what should I do?

frozen jolt
#

you can keep the fish with you instead of turning them in to the chef, then use his keepsake

#

eventually youll get the heart dialogue

mossy spruce
#

thank you for answering it nonetheless

frozen jolt
#

you need to have caught a fish before talking to him, so the easiest thing is to just keep the fish from a previous run

muted kiln
#

||Is there more story after i take god of venture home?||

static lion
muted kiln
#

I see thanks

#

The game feels stale now

static lion
#

there's lots of different duo boons and weapons and aspects to make each run feel more unique

#

so u can try some new fun builds to keep it interesting

quasi forum
#

do guys use the death defiance card?

static lion
#

card?

quasi forum
static lion
#

yes

#

death defiances are good

earnest terrace
#

otherwise you will never get anywhere

earnest terrace
#

#h2-story-discussion , please

calm egret
#

I swear I pressed that

mental thicket
#

Question to see if I messed up - is there a point in raising your relationship with || Dusa || that will lock you completely out of the possibility of || getting a menage a toi (sp?) with Thanatos and Meg? ||

I thought I had raised my relationships with everyone kinda simultaneously but then hit a point where I can't give nectar or ambrosia to certain characters, but can give Ambrosia to others. I didn't think I'd "crossed the point of no return" because I havent given the ambrosia yet (that felt like a 'next step' move that would lock me in) and my dialogues with everyone didn't really give me the impression I was locked into a specific path in that regard

#

It's nothing I'm gonna restart a save point for but I wanted to try to adjust my nectar/ambrosia hoarding accordingly, but googling relationship stuff might spoil story points I haven't reached 😩

frozen jolt
#

youre not locked in, dont worry

#

theres no point of no return because you can give ambrosia to whever you want as much as you want

atomic wagon
#

Am I stupid or does hades have a point? Haven’t done 10th clear yet
-provides son with resources
-son doesn’t do his chores and runs around breaking stuff
-son is at risk of starting a war with the olympians
-is an average authoritarian hardass dad
-doesn’t seem abusive, just exacting

pseudo stump
#

Hades isn't wrong in many respects, but giving Zagreus the cold shoulder for years and years kinda undermines a lot of it. Something something sans love resounding gong

patent agate
#

Yeah, he's more worried about Cerberus than Zagreus. Is like if Hades didn't want three kids and no money, but no kids and three money.

north cypress
#

the story is carefully set up such that you can see how their conflict developed on both sides, but Hades is definitely mega harsh sometimes. I'm a fairly sensitive person which def colors my perspective, but I'd argue there's at least a few things he says to Zag that, while not explicitly violent or profane, are super scathing and come off more as trying to get under his skin or get back at him than achieve anything constructive.
I think the fact that Nyx puts her foot down with Hades at least once(?) says a lot too re: how he can start to get too focused on results over everything else. Definitely not an evil guy or anything tho

earnest terrace
#

Yeah I wouldn't call Hades abusive necessarily, but there's definitely an argument to be made that he's emotionally neglectful and not the best at actually encouraging or inspiring Zagreus

#

His approach often seems to be just "do this or you're bad," which is not exactly a very constructive way of going about it

#

And just immediately dismissing Zagreus' own views and preferences as naive or foolish

north cypress
#

Yeah the question of him being abusive is complicated I think, and outside the scope of what I'd feel comfortable talking about myself so I'd have to duck out, but the game plays with a lot of dynamics and ideas that are going to be very familiar to a lot of people from/in toxic or abusive situations. There's a good breakdown of those somewhere on Tumblr but I don't know where it went sadly

#

Zag's need to escape is arguably just as much about Hades as it is wanting to find his mom, for example

glass kestrel
#

how do i free Sisyphus from his punishment? its the only achievement ive yet to get besides Complete Set and Friends Forever

valid fjord
silent apex
# north cypress Yeah the question of him being _abusive_ is complicated I think, and outside the...

I'm willing to put it out there that Hades isn't abusive. At least, not purposely/maliciously abusive.

Abrasive and rude? Definitely. But he is NOT doing it out of malice. I don’t even think he’s spiteful in the way you'd see from the standard abusive father figures you might see in other media.

He loves Zagreus, and wants his son to be better at his administrative work. He treated Persephone with immense love and respect- so much so he's pretty much the most unproblematic Greek God in non-Hades discourse. There's even a dialogue showing (late game spoilers) ||disdain for Zeus kidnapping her.|| between him and Zagreus.

#

I feel the major impacts of Hades' attitude (intentional or otherwise) against Zagreus was offset by Nyx's care and motherly support. That doesn't excuse his ineptitude as a father figure.

#

(As an aside, this is not an argument meant to defend or justify abusive behavior. Simply a perspective and my own thoughts on a character from a game I immensely enjoy. Abusers have a special place in Hades and will see no respect from me.)

earnest terrace
#

I do feel like there's also an argument to be made that the whole debacle over Zagreus (initially) being stillborn and Persephone leaving from the grief probably left Hades with some severe doubts and mixed feelings

#

Like, he loves Zagreus, but the latter is also a perpetual reminder of what happened with Persephone

north cypress
#

It's been a few years since I did the main story for Hades 1, but the vibe I kinda get from Hades is that he wasn't fully prepared, emotionally, to be a parent (not unwilling, just not fully prepared), much less in the circumstances that it happened in and those which came about as time went on. He's gruff and loves rules and order and everything being in its place at the time it's supposed to, and it seems to have been very personally challenging for him to adjust to the reality of what parenthood entails. Add on then, everything surrounding the situation, and whew.
(to be clear, I don't say this as any kind of knock on Hades - parenthood challenges literally everyone who goes through it and on top of that he and Zag have very different personalities, which is more what I'm referring to! ^_^ )

earnest terrace
#

Hades definitely isn't a perfect person, but he had to deal with a lot of unfair stuff that understandably impacted him emotionally and that he can't be blamed for

native gyro
#

He got stuck in the worst place on the planet, but the Underworld is cooler because of his renovations, doing paperwork all day while Zeus put a burden on him that could start a war

earnest terrace
#

I can only imagine how bitter he feels knowing that he's stuck forever in the Underworld whereas the Olympian gods can go wherever they want, including the Underworld

native gyro
#

They arent welcome. Hades wont let them in, except Hermes because of his work

earnest terrace
#

Hermes just proves my point

atomic forge
#

Does hades also have the problem of "taken by styx"? I thought it was just Zagereus.

north cypress
#

he does! he just doesn't usually get on its bad side as much as Zag does haha

atomic forge
#

Damn, makes sense why he is so pissed.

#

Being stuck in the underworld forever.

native gyro
atomic forge
#

And he saw the outside world beforehand, so it is kinda worse for him

earnest terrace
#

legit got the worst trade deal in the history of trade deals

lost scaffold
native gyro
#

@lost scaffold it refers to the people who were born in the realm , for ex Thanatos, in one of the encounters he mentions he cant stay out of the underworld much himself

mental thicket
#

Underworld realm really got the rawest ends of the deal in general

magic hazel
#

is the game playable at 45 fps?

slate creek
#

Do you need to increase the heat to keep progressing in story?

signal crater
slate creek
signal crater
magic hazel
#

Guys does the heats affect hades fps?

frigid mirage
#

Ok hold on

#

Is Nyx Meg's mother?

frozen jolt
#

I don’t think so

pseudo stump
#

Nyx is as a mother to Meg, but not actual mother

pseudo stump
#

Yes

rain otter
#

Ok

cosmic hatch
#

how many times do i have to go through this game before meg starts letting me give her ambrosia

pseudo stump
#

I was able to start that process around run #130

cosmic hatch
#

well i beat the main quest

#

very happy with it

atomic wagon
pseudo stump
#

That's so quick zagpls

atomic wagon
#

than and meg both had ambrosia in that range
Zagreus has unmatched charizzma

atomic wagon
#

Theseus didn’t try to kidnap Persephone in the game lore? Ain’t no way Hades would’ve let him off the hook that easily

north cypress
#

I don't think so, if for no other reason than like you said, Theseus definitely wouldn't be in Eysium anymore 😂

#

he'd probably be enjoying some nice quality time with the Furies instead

pseudo stump
#

I wonder how much he'd annoy each of the Furies

north cypress
#

oh man haha

#

"mmmmuuuurder!"
//stage voice "is that all you have to say to me!"

#

he would do so well in wrestling.

pseudo stump
#

Absolute heel of a man

normal zephyr
atomic wagon
#

Than hadn’t even shown up for me 7 times on my 20th

#

Just rng ig

native rapids
#

whats the sequal from one to two? i played one where is the connection i didnt get i t

remote badger
#

did you mean the story connection between Hades 1 and Hades 2?

scenic bolt
#

what do you have to do to get the epilogue ??

#

i've done hella runs and it's just not happening

zenith wedge
#

After that you need to max your bond with 6 of the olympians

scenic bolt
#

ohhhhmy goddddd

zenith wedge
#

(dem counts as max once you reach the lock)

scenic bolt
#

my poor nectar

zenith wedge
#

After that more dialogue with Persephone until she mentions invitations, talk to each god once and soon after should be done

scenic bolt
#

thank you thank you

zenith wedge
#

If you have done the chaos-nyx quest you may need to talk to them too

scenic bolt
#

good to know

visual grove
#

i can just start a new save if I wanna experience the story again right?

#

been playing 2 and wanna play through the 1st story again

pseudo stump
#

Yeah

atomic wagon
#

Why does Dusa require so much more ambrosia

pseudo stump
#

She's very physically active!

zenith wedge
hoary trench
orchid leaf
#

If anyone happens to have a clip of zagreus getting the job from Hades to be the security testing officer for the underworld and could link it to me it'd be appreciated. Searching Hades zagreus conversation gives me results for the entire game, not just between the two.

pseudo stump
# orchid leaf If anyone happens to have a clip of zagreus getting the job from Hades to be the...

Boop. Watch for a few min starting at my timestamp: https://youtu.be/XsQgdsI1Izc?t=4952

At last, something productive to do. Thanks for this bonus playthrough, patrons!

Support us on Patreon! â–ș http://patreon.com/playframe


Playlist â–ș https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLvFQJa1XAXzzARrR4D5GOn-pK7rMriSRb


Check out the PlayFrame Store! â–ș https://store.dftba.com/collections/playframe

Dan's Twitter (@DanFl...

▶ Play video
orchid leaf
#

Baller ty

pseudo stump
#

Noooo pls delete spoilers

#

Lest I steal your potato chips

fast remnant
#

on it. had no idea how this happened. (leave the lays alone)

#

and now my penchant for typing multiple messages instead of writing one paragraph makes deleting them individually a pain XD

coral cedar
#

will the eldest sigil upgrade not appear unless i have the right amount of darkness? or did i miss smth... i just got the nyx convo abt it but it didnt appear at the contractor!

supple walrus
molten finch
#

yall help me out here how do i unlock the beowulf shield

opal kraken
#

So one thing I wonder, was Charon born looking like that? Or did he get to into his work like his sister?

zenith vault
#

Here

#

@molten finch

molten finch
#

thank you!

sand kernel
#

what happened to that bot

#

this is a hades channel, not a hades II channel
try #h2-story-discussion

pseudo stump
sand kernel
tough latch
zealous arrow
supple walrus
#

i think he was was wondering which sister they meant. tis isn't charon's sister though

afaik there is no dialog that mentions wether or not charon always looked liked that

vagrant heath
#

If I were to go with a head canon (no lore support), it'd make sense to me that the Gods wouldn't be born the way they are now. They would've changed over time to suit their role.

#

Especially if I think of IRL mythology, and how certain gods can change over time

zenith wedge
#

#h2-story-discussion (pls delete)

strong skiff
#

god this server reminds me of hardcore survival again...

tawdry citrus
#

omg so homer is the one that kicks off all of hades?

glass kestrel
#

im so lost on how to free Sisyphus

#

I've maxed out my nectar bond with him

#

I've maxed out my ambrosia bonds with Meg, Nyx, and Hades

#

and yet for the past like 20 runs, nothing

#

and like i dont have much else left in terms of dialogue

#

i just dont get what im doing wrong

zenith wedge
#

Rng issue most probably

glass kestrel
#

ugh

#

im 3 achievements away from completion

zenith wedge
#

Just gotta push through it sadly

glass kestrel
#

and 2 of them will be completed once I free him

#

and the last one im almost done with

#

one must imagine Sisyphus a stubborn ass

#

yknow what? at this point, i think i should just not free him. out of spite.

atomic forge
#

Okay, so here's the question Hades 2 is released, and Im downloading it right now. I never got around to unveiling the plot of the gods by stuffing them all full of jelly. So what's the plot on that front?

zenith wedge
#

They pull the "persephone ate pomegranate seeds so she's bound to the underworld" as a lie

#

Zag asks mom if the Olympians know it's a like and she goes "even if they know they won't find it worth it to discuss"

atomic forge
#

Was there a rebellion that I missed?

zenith wedge
#

Nope

#

The epilogue was to prevent a war in case the truth on why persephone was gone was revealed

atomic forge
zenith wedge
#

If you mean how to trigger the epilogue?

#

Max nectar with 6 of 8 olympians, bunch of talk with mom > invite all gods by talking to them

#

#h2-story-discussion

#

Delete the other one too dusa

weary totem
#

^_^ thanks for the help

swift crown
#

How do I know if I'll trigger the 3some scene with Than and Meg? I've maxed out both relationships and saw their individual bed scenes and Meg has been the only one with a heart icon above her head sometimes 😭

Like do they both need heart icons or I need to go to Zag's room before talking to them or???

frozen jolt
#

it’s completely random, they will both be absent from the house but appear when you go into zags room

regal furnace
#

Zagreus: I mean, Dusa if you REALLLY don't want it then I guess I'll take it back
Me:shadeohboy AMBROSIA!!!!

sand kernel
shut charm
#

Just finished the epilogue! Nyx said something about inviting chaos, but I never got the chance to do that


fiery python
#

I love the way achilles and patroclus's quest ends and how you forge their bonds. Super sweet zagluv

#

also I think Zag himself might be one of my favorite protagonists ever

zealous arrow
zenith wedge
#

#h2-story-discussion (please delete)

patent acorn
#

Can you delete this message?

brave flame
#

????

zenith wedge
#

Hades 2 spoilers

supple walrus
#

maybe we could get the bot telling people this isn't a hades 2 channel in here...?

pseudo stump
#

Maybe even every Hades channel! I've been getting spoiled left and right

patent acorn
#

@full kindle if you wouldn't mind, could you sticky that message in all of the hades 1 channels

full kindle
#

?stick This channel (and category) is for discussing the first Hades game. Please go to #h2-discussion to talk about Hades II.

#

?stickspeed 2min

zenith wedge
#

Ty

patent agate
#

I just learned what happens when you steal from Charon

#

never expected for the scratch disco sound zaglol

dreamy wing
fiery python
#

He looks so cool in all his glory

dreamy wing
fiery python
#

Oh nah, I've just stuck to than's

#

Might have to try it

patent agate
#

TIL you get mocked for being killed by a tiny rat.

#

In my defense (?), I picked the wrong boon for the Stygian blade.

#

This game has everything.

patent agate
#

That was my reaction as well

#

"oh a tiny ra- OMG!"

#

I can kill Asterius with closed eyes but a tiny Vermin?

#

Who wins?

[The son of a mortal and a God] - [A tiny half-dead rat]

pseudo stump
#

I want to know how SGG playtesters (i.e. everyone at SGG) reacted when they heard the roar

#

I appreciate that Tony is just inexplicably, terrifyingly strong. No justification whatsoever

patent agate
#

And how Greg Kasavin had to keep a straight face while saying "lol you got killed by a rat"

dreamy wing
tropic tulip
#

is the hades universe in a god of war type situation where each region/country of the world has the gods of the religion most people follow?

tropic tulip
earnest terrace
#

Unless they're going to argue that all gods from other faiths/systems are 'below' that of the Greek gods

sand kernel
#

Well, if thats true, I can't wait for the Aspect of Allah.

earnest terrace
#

I don't think they're willing to go quite that far

sand kernel
#

you dont say 😄

zealous arrow
#

Some of the hidden aspects are described as “future” aspects, which means their wielders haven’t come to take up the weapon yet.

What the game is saying with the presence of these aspects though is that there are other pantheons in the world of Hades that have or will come to be outside of Greece, but characters like the Fates have a hand in essentially all myths and faiths

stiff patio
#

i'm very confused how to do zeus' favor I started with his boon then got 5 others.. am I missing something?

earnest terrace
#

So how would one resolve that

zenith wedge
stiff patio
zenith wedge
#

Random mostly

#

Just take zeus boons then talk with the others and hope they give the right dialogue

stiff patio
#

is it 5 of the right dialogue in 1 run? or just 5 ever

zenith wedge
#

In total

#

Tho idk if the game expects you to have hermes or dem talking about him?

#

Probably does

stiff patio
#

I feel like unlocking the epilogue is kinda hard :l

zenith wedge
#

You could ignore him and do someone else's favor

#

You only need 6 out of 8

#

Start working on others and if zeus happens to unlock, neat

stiff patio
#

So ig I skip Demeter and Zeus

zenith wedge
zealous arrow
zenith wedge
#

Cuz y'know, her favor is the epilogue

stiff patio
#

Wait a minute


zealous arrow
#

Entities*

stiff patio
#

So it’s really 5/8 then Demeter is the 6th?

zenith wedge
#

Yeah

stiff patio
#

Oh that’s less bad

zenith wedge
#

What gods have you maxed?

stiff patio
#

Hermes Athena ares Dionysus and then Artemis should hopefully be soon 
 her thing is taking so many runs

zenith wedge
#

Can work on pos's while doing arty

#

Catch 18 fish then have at least one with you when talking to him

stiff patio
#

I’m missing 1 fish I don’t think I react fast enough for the rare thing to proc

zenith wedge
#

It doesn't need to have rarity iirc

#

That's for the prophecy

stiff patio
#

Oh

#

Wait it’s just 18 fish on me at once?

zenith wedge
#

"catch 25 fish including one rare and report to Poseidon"

zenith wedge
earnest terrace
stiff patio
#

I’ve caught so many fish

#

Can the fish I bring him come from a past run

#

Like the 1

zenith wedge
#

Yeah

#

Just don't deliver them to the cook

stiff patio
#

Oh

#

So I need another 25 fish

#

I’ve delivered them all to the cook 🙂

zenith wedge
#

Just keep the next one you find

#

You already have the 18 fish total caught part

stiff patio
#

oh ok

zealous arrow
earnest terrace
#

Plenty of possible theories

pseudo stump
#

Do any of the aspects represent anybody who exists outside our material universe? Or is everyone on Earth

silent gust
#

I've always been a fan of the idea that Odin is actually Hermes

pseudo stump
#

Oh hecc

#

Thanks

remote minnow
#

Idk if it's spoiler, so I'll mark it as one. Question is about late game Thanatos.

|| Does anyone know if Thanatos has a line after you finish the game? I haven't seen him at all since the "true" ending, almost everything else is maxed out, most gods just give the repeatable lines at this point, and the house is chill except from Hades and mother. I've had like 30-40 runs since finishing the story, kept playing because I wanted to see Than again, but he didn't come. I know I haven't done all encounters with him yet, I fear that with finishing the story I've cut myself off from a scene I've been working hard towards. (He was the first I maxed nectars for, done the ambrosia as well, and had him show up to an important meeting once.)

If it helps, I've been running with butterfly+mort, I usually can ramp with butterfly to 20% damage boost. ||

zenith wedge
#

Also butterfly doesn't affect his spawn rate

remote minnow
#

I've read on Reddit that you have to take damage for him to come, but that seems weird to me. Is it real though? Because then I'll just start conceding some health at the start of each chamber and switch the keepsake for something else.

zenith wedge
#

False

#

If it was true some speedrunners would see him all the time bouldy

pseudo stump
#

Hah, Reddit! They've a "You can find Mew under the truck!" playground energy

remote minnow
# zenith wedge False

Thanks. I had a hunch but had to ask. Then I guess I'll just continue to fulfill my duty and try to escape.

uncut adder
remote minnow
# zenith wedge Just bad luck

It really was just that, played some more and he showed up, and did it every third-fourth run since then. Feels like he had some scripted downtime after game completeion, as if he would've been busy working on surface stuff.

normal zephyr
#

i gave Hypnos all my nectars and ambrosia only for this guy to call me his best friend

#

ive been pining after this silly sleep god for ages only to find out he's not romaceble sob

#

got friend zoned by hypnos im going to cry

abstract sage
#

I FELT THAT.

pseudo stump
#

The boy has a crush on Meg though!

zenith wedge
#

Follow the bot dusa

uncut adder
patent agate
#

TIL Zaggy called the Hydra "Lernie". I wonder if he had called Cerberus with pet names too lol

zealous arrow
unreal dagger
normal zephyr
remote minnow
# unreal dagger I can't believe this myth is still going around

It was sketchy enough that I cougth wind it's probably false, but nevertheless: what once gets out, will just spread since it's the internet. Also I was looking for a dev to say "no, why would we do something like that" but didn't find it, so that might be a reason why it's still out there.

glacial sun
#

I have a question, who is the face in aspect of zeus shield?

patent acorn
#

honestly no clue

full kindle
#

Hi all, just a quick note that I am updating the channel names here & in the Hades II category, you'll start to see those rolling out shortly. There are no other changes beyond the channel names being updated. 👍

solemn pagoda
remote minnow
tawdry citrus
#

supergiant could have just let zagreus tend to the garden in peace but they decided to have the narrator choose violence lol

earnest terrace
#

@inner warren The whole 'pomegranate forces you to remain in the underworld' thing is a ruse by Persephone to convince the gods to allow her to come back to the underworld every now and then; it doesn't actually have that power

#

Zagreus being unable to leave the Underworld is because of his heritage, not whatever he ate