#general-feedback-discussion

1 messages · Page 851 of 1

barren crater
#

I wouldn’t call Carnos fine. They’re the most abundant thing on land right now. I’ve seen barely any adult pachys or stegos.

limber hull
#

i'll be honest, one thing i am a fan of, stego is actually hard to grow

barren crater
#

I went past a group of 10+ adult carnos today so yeah there’s something wrong

barren crater
limber hull
#

yea probably. But the fact that there's an apex that's ACTUALLY hard to grow is promising. Too bad deino gets the easy treatment

barren crater
#

Issue is that it’s an apex herbi. Since the smaller stages for stego are quite frankly shit. Which will be the case for other apex herbis. Apex carnis will likely be fast at least- and if diets are easy for them like the currently then it will probably be easy to grow. I don’t know much about gore update to comment on it.

cobalt compass
#

i hope for an avg player who decides to play apex carni their avg mortality rates are like followed if spawned in solo juvi:
juvi 70%
sub 40%

barren zephyr
#

@barren crater carno megapacks will be fixed when devs add more damn mid tier carnivores

barren crater
#

Although cera could be considered small/pseudo mid

limber hull
#

Funny thing is that the next "mid-tier" carnivore after carno is fucking allo which is 900kg bigger

barren zephyr
#

@limber hull they best way to solve the diet shit is buffing the dinos with the problem not nerfing the ones that don't suffer it

limber hull
#

Cera is pseudo-mid

#

Also cera gonna get clapped by carno most of the time

barren zephyr
#

Well yes, but what I mean is a carnivore that is not troodon, troodon just will split utah's playerbase not carno's

limber hull
#

Troodon is cool tho

barren zephyr
#

Yeah but like a said troodon will be more used by utah players, carno main might play it but just for 2 weeks after release

barren zephyr
barren crater
limber hull
barren zephyr
#

Should*

#

But we will know better when devs decide is a good time to update trello roadmap

barren crater
#

We just need a playable that at least in pairs- can kill a Carno. Which cera likely will be.

keen bough
#

do people agree with my post on phase two requests or is it bad?

barren zephyr
#

Just fact of adding another big carni ( in comparation with the current roster) will decrase carno numbers

#

It doesnt even need to be a carno killer

cobalt compass
barren crater
#

I only want to see like 5 apexes per server 🙂

#

Carnis that is

barren zephyr
cobalt compass
#

soft cap, making it a true challenge to become adult should be good

#

average players

#

or more like 70% of the playerbase that plays apex'

#

obv those number go up with less skill

keen bough
#

wonder if sandbox is one day going to be a thing

barren zephyr
#

Apexes will need to hunt herbi apexes to survive so that is enough to reduce apex numbers

half shard
#

Also surviving the long grow time

barren crater
#

Confirmed by devs

limber hull
#

Just make diets and growth unrelated

#

The biggest problem with diets as they are is the simple act of them so heavily impacting growth

barren zephyr
#

@limber hull @barren crater i think I've found the solution for herbi diet so they can have the 3 nutrient easier but they still need to migrate, make the different nutrients spawn close again (not as close as before) but in low numbers (enough to let a significant amount of herbis to stay there for and hour at least), also make the plants be finished in less bites, for the migration part, plants should respawn every hour and a half, between each diet point there should be at least one river, the time you would need to go from one diet point to another should be at least 20 minutes if you cross the river or 30 if you go around it, this way herbis will be able to stay in one area but would need to migrate after 1 hour, and by the time the other area has ran out of food, in the first area the plants would have spawn again

barren crater
# limber hull Just make diets and growth unrelated

I can agree to that. It’s quite crazy how having even 2 diets means you’ll grow for a long time. Currently having 3 diets is a must regardless of growth- seeing how it pretty much means you heal faster, regen stam quicker and more. So for those who want to take on riskier fights- having 3 diets is necessary rather than 1

limber hull
#

i just think diets should have less to do with growth. Make growth speed dependent on several factors, diet can be one of many factors

barren crater
cobalt compass
#

how much you spend on lootboxes prior

barren crater
barren crater
cobalt compass
#

also buynig the definitive and collectors edition

limber hull
#

However, since everyone knows you're in there, you can't just AFK there

#

You HAVE to be actively cautious

#

And know if something bigger wants it

#

Some animals should outright have territorial behaviours, something that can't be done with this constant search for dietary requirements

#

It's kind of like a comfort system, minus everything awful about a comfort system

barren crater
#

Sounds interesting in concept. I wonder how that would play out

#

Like a lot of things so far to me have cool concepts but then when you play desolate

limber hull
#

Nah, no debuffs imho for not following it

#

Only buffs if you do

#

Make people compete for comfortable territories

#

Carrot over stick

barren crater
#

Please. I hate debuffs with the whole preferred food thing. It’s just chores

#

Like losing damage? Has that been changed?

barren zephyr
#

I think so?

limber hull
#

i'll be honest, not too upset about diet debuffs. The act of eating a nutrient meal is way too easy

barren crater
#

Yeah I can agree with that I guess since I never have 0 diets so eh

barren zephyr
limber hull
#

carno for example, i cannot see being territorial

#

it's far too fast-paced

barren zephyr
#

I thought you said all apexes, maybe I'm blind

#

I see now

#

You said it in the first sentence, I'm dumb

cobalt compass
#

also i think wave meant dynamic territories

limber hull
#

yes

#

while it is true, apexes would be favoured, territories cannot be shared. If you have too many of one species in a territory, the buffs will go away

cobalt compass
#

so you could always expand or shrink in its size

limber hull
#

i'd say if the amount of animals is anything but your own kind or way over a group size within the territory, buff gone

#

megapacks and mixpacks literally cannot benefit from it

#

also i think some animals both should not be territorial or not care about species

#

for example, a dryo walking in does not remove buffs

#

because why the fuck should it

cobalt compass
#

what'd you say to visual hints like a light barrier similar to the map border but not so much vision disturbing but any other species have to use their vision and check for the physical markings and such

barren zephyr
limber hull
#

im unsure what you mean by that

#

its more like an apex wouldn't be annoyed if a dryo walked in

empty epoch
#

More like, it aint worth the hunt 🙂

limber hull
#

because the dryo isn't contesting it, nor is it big enough for the animal to even consider it a threat to the territory

barren zephyr
empty epoch
#

is this for AI or players?

limber hull
#

JWE is singleplayer?

barren zephyr
empty epoch
barren zephyr
#

How alone has to be some people to need global chat back?

empty epoch
keen bough
#

People rage quit on you in global chat when you hunted their sweet, beloved apex that they spent sooo long to grow in legacy,

cobalt compass
#

global was/is a pest

barren zephyr
paper oriole
barren zephyr
valid zephyr
#

Should definitely not be a thing on officials though.

dense vale
#

same but people dont like that, no freedom for us

#

or if a way to keep the baby and only throw out the bathwater was figured out first

cobalt compass
dense vale
#

it just took me a long time to find a private server i liked, but once i did it was best gaming i ever had. but its gone now anyway

valid zephyr
#

I try to stick to officials.

#

pity half the people there seem to have wallhacks these days.

hazy ferry
#

Why dont people want global chat?

dense vale
#

basically one team says it has too much garbage. then the other team says they want it optional on private servers with rules and moderation which can take care of the garbage parts. and thats it, been a stalemate for months lol

#

poop could maybe be good, but probably have to make it involuntary action. or else everyone is gonna have a field day trolling with it

candid schooner
#

No poop

#

Theres no reason, why do yall wanna see a dinosaur defacate so much damn

paper oriole
#

a poop defender TI_WTF

candid schooner
hazy ferry
#

Idk game is really empty and boring without it

candid schooner
#

Oop sorry didnt mean to ping with that

paper oriole
#

i think global chat works fine in sandbox servers, in fact it is very useful in sandbox servers. but it isnt needed for survival

candid schooner
#

Ye i agree

dense vale
#

with chat global gone, most plant food gone, wallowing mostly gone. im just bored frankly, need some kind of mechanics to interact with TI_Succ

#

id even take poop at this point im desperrate lol

paper oriole
#

aw hell naw

candid schooner
#

Gross

#

No thanks

paper oriole
#

no poop no poop

candid schooner
#

no poop no poop

dense vale
#

TI_Succ back to walking sim

paper oriole
#

at least no pooping sim

#

imagine youre hiding from a predator in a tense situation and the game just decides your dino has to drop a fat load and it just gives your position away and you die

candid schooner
#

Loll yeah

paper oriole
#

id be so mad lol

#

nO!!!!!!!1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

low canopy
#

hey atleast said thing would provoke some sort of feeling out of you, not even negative one
i would consider that a win

hazy ferry
#

Game actually is boring without global chat

urban flax
#

The problem doesn't come from the absence of global chat

#

The problem comes from the absence of things to do

hazy ferry
#

Even legacy sucks without it i like to see what other people are up to

#

People complaining people raging,cute baba etc…

#

Global is how i made most of my friends in the isle

urban flax
#

It ruins immerdsion

limber hull
#

i always turned global off in legacy

#

whinefest extraordinaire

hazy ferry
#

Then they should remove ai animals because you cant even tell whats real or not#

limber hull
#

if i wanted to listen to people whine and cry i'd visit a preschool

low canopy
#

global gave me more reasons to log back to the game (community), but devs have made their mind about not even giving the option,
all we can do is wait patiently for this QOL mod

hazy ferry
#

^

#

Theres no sense of community in the game

limber hull
#

eh, it was always better in sandbox

#

it should remain a sandbox thing

#

made sense for the sandbox with no stakes to not care about who talks to who

hazy ferry
#

Its also dumb that you cant inv friends or check what server you are on and its pop

limber hull
#

you can do all of those things

#

lmao

paper oriole
#

you can see the server youre on in your character menu

hazy ferry
#

Yeah but you have to 2 call next to them

limber hull
#

so?

#

do that

hazy ferry
#

Unnecessary

limber hull
#

at literally no point has "needing to 2 call a mate" ever been an issue

limber hull
hazy ferry
#

Evrima will never grow if this kind of community

#

Have fun with ur dead game

limber hull
#

I will

#

I'm having more fun than I ever had with legacy

low canopy
#

game badly needs group spawn option that could be used amongst steam friends or something, it can be very painful for newer players to fnd each other on map and making the start even more obnoxious

limber hull
#

i dont need a chat room attached to my dinosaur game to enjoy it

#

because if you remove global, you realise it's just a distraction from how bad legacy actually is lmao

limber hull
#

too late

#

brain fried lmao

#

should head to bed now lmao

hazy ferry
#

The game feels like a sandbox

dense vale
#

kinda agree

hazy ferry
#

An empty one

urban flax
#

Early Access moment

hazy ferry
#

I often run around for hours not finding a single person

dense vale
#

eventually copium, well have a map with biomes, some community aspect back, more mechanics, more playables

limber hull
#

i can consistently find people in EVRIMA. In legacy, you were either at the special lake everyone wanted to be at or in the dark zone

#

it was like oasis before oasis

hazy ferry
#

There are multiple hot spots in legacy twins,trike mountain,port,great falls,aviary,swamp,northern river

#

All over the map

#

Theres almost nothing interesting in evrima

dense vale
#

spiro need alot of work to actually feel "designed" and not "generated"

low canopy
#

i think spiro has potential and some amazing locations, its just they are often put to god knows where and wont be used
listing couple:
arch falls
old shallows
west coast and its caves
south pond
south waterfall
south east swamp
warehouse
radio tower
and the list goes on, its just they are underutilised

#

map also lacks clear path ways to move about, distances are far too great, like how many actually find their way to west coast ever

dense vale
#

v3 being bowl shaped with lots of places too look out and see where things are helped alot

#

traveling spiro im lost, cant see where anything is, hidden death fall all over, and i get punished by diets if i explore

hazy ferry
#

i agree diet system is kinda dumb thank god cerato wont be affected by it

#

i like it for herbis but not for carnivores

#

doesnt make sense meat is meat

dense vale
#

i was speaking as herb, i never play carni except sometimes bird or i like austro but its not in

manic flint
warm flame
#

I can't believe that SwisherSweet183 wants The Isle to add The Isle

hazy ferry
#

different plants give different nutrients but meat is meat 🍖

#

i doubt a 5 ton dinosaur cares what kind of meat it eats lmao

warm flame
#

I think that it should be different organs that give different diets

hybrid tiger
#

I really liked the types of meat suggestion let me find it

manic flint
hybrid tiger
manic flint
#

So meat =/= meat
Plant =/= Plant
TI_Succ

hazy ferry
#

🍖

manic flint
#

We have to deal with the system
Both groups

dense vale
#

id think you walk up and be like, eat meat, eat fat, eat liver as options, but i dont really play carni so not my place to say

hazy ferry
#

i like that

#

makes much more sense

warm flame
#

eat heart TI_Cry

icy lion
#

Gore is planned to be entwined with carnivore diets once it's added

hybrid tiger
#

I hope they do something similar to that suggestion

paper oriole
#

Wtf if you upsize magy to be bigger than allo it isnt even magy

#

Just replace it with a better sauropod

pulsar smelt
ashen wasp
# hazy ferry i doubt a 5 ton dinosaur cares what kind of meat it eats lmao

I mean. Different carnivores are adapted for consuming flesh with different levels of fat, muscle, etc. depending on what their prey has evolved to exhibit. Fairly sure I remember hearing somewhere that big cats are able to consume animals with levels of fat that would quickly give something like a human being a heart attack.

#

But yeah larger animals can’t afford to be as picky

pulsar smelt
#

Predatory animals CAN consume other predators.. it's just all about the specific animals biology. Jaguars eat cayman. Snakes eat other snakes, coyotes eat cats and dogs, shit, even herbivores will consume meat. Hippos eat meat, and even horses sometimes, deer too.

#

They called tertiary consumers

#

Blue whales are carnivores even

#

So size doesn't matter tbh

#

But the main reason carnis in nature generally don't eat other carnis is 1) it's dangerous and 2) transmission of disease.

But ya a vast majority of irl carnivores do eat a percentage of other carnivores :)

wicked osprey
#

welcome to carno flight school

paper oriole
#

Man that plant suggestion sound annoying as fuck ngl

#

Herbivores already tedious as all hell, have to stop to sniff and walk annoying distances at a slow pace to preset destinations. Then it would just be annoying “ugh jts just one of those plants again”

#

Changyuraptor is superior to archaeopteryx in every way

#

Changyu is smaller than herrera, hes just the best arboreal glider option

manic flint
paper oriole
signal beacon
#

Ah yes just what we need. More carnivores!

paper oriole
#

Deadass, carni scent was always better than herbis, so the devs made carni scent even better and herbi scent even worse

#

Tell me how that makes sense

signal beacon
paper oriole
#

“Herbivores, the already consistently slower moving faction, needs to stop to sniff to make themselves vulnerable sometimes!”

#

“You dont need to move to sniff plants, they dont run!”

#

Quality of life is very important

manic flint
#

We should be able to sniff blood at least bruh

paper oriole
#

And walk-sniffing is a quality of life perk

signal beacon
#

Just embrace the fact that herbivores will always come second and turn them all into static ai for the carnivores to ragdoll TI_Troll

paper oriole
#

Like i cant smell a massive bloodshed battlefield

#

Hey what is with you and shit

signal beacon
#

...excuse me?

pulsar smelt
signal beacon
#

That's it. The isle is being closed.

#

No more isle

paper oriole
#

Its a feature that would get old and annoying after the first or second runin

signal beacon
#

Let's play The Mainland

pulsar smelt
#

You'd have visuals carni plants are very obvious, just avoid those like you avoid other things imo

paper oriole
#

People think ”haha funni carnivorous plants” but they dont stop to think about how that would just be nothing but a nuisance if it was actually added

pulsar smelt
#

Everything in the game is a nuisance

paper oriole
#

Hypsis dont really suffer if they die anyway its literally just a hypsi lol

paper oriole
pulsar smelt
#

You lose nothing as a hypsi atm

paper oriole
#

nO!!!!!!!!!

#

Skunk magy better

pulsar smelt
#

Also plants would be in very specific areas.

#

But I do understand

paper oriole
#

No!!!!!!!!!!¡!!!!!!!!1!!!!!!!!

signal beacon
#

BoB ptera

low canopy
dense vale
#

are the carni plants playable

barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

I want a playable plant it sounds funner than current juv herbivore gameplay

pulsar smelt
paper oriole
#

Playable cliff the true apex predator

pulsar smelt
#

Bush simulator

barren zephyr
#

I want to play as air

signal beacon
#

Playable game TI_Troll

barren zephyr
paper oriole
barren zephyr
#

or actually we just need more food plant diversity

paper oriole
#

I doubt the devs even peeked at my doc lol

barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

Yeah i think they just ignore feedback almost entirely

signal beacon
pulsar smelt
#

I suggested to make the herbie diet as a juvi like the carnis. But it was down voted.

It's annoying that they can eat anything till 50 and get nutes but herbies have to stick to the preferred diet regardless

barren zephyr
paper oriole
barren zephyr
#

hmm

dense vale
#

i dont want a free ride, just achievable while still being able to explore and nest ect.

paper oriole
pulsar smelt
#

It's stupid how baby herbies can't eat any plant and get nutes till 50% but carnis can eat any meat till 50% lol

barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

Carnis can full up fight before they hit 50 again too to continue the free ride for a while

paper oriole
#

Also tons of bodies around

#

I consistently spawn at southwest and effortlessly obtain full food and afk in a bush

#

Praying mantis crunchy snack

#

Arthropleura when

barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

Just pretend its a venomous centipede TI_Troll

#

Probablt just ate plants and dead shit but it is the isle it can eat you too

barren zephyr
#

They have to nerf elden ring bosses, they have more chances to kill me than i have to kill them

paper oriole
#

Thats why it is a boss

#

And you are maidenless

barren zephyr
#

what about adding opossums or raccoons as AI?

paper oriole
#

Opossums are kinda helpless

barren zephyr
#

came out of nowhere ik

barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

Foxes are better because they can haul ass

barren zephyr
#

or actually they can climb n shit

paper oriole
#

Id feel bad about the poor opossum ai lol

barren zephyr
#

also realistically they could survive as they reproduce fast and live fast as well

paper oriole
#

They certainly die fast

#

Very short life span, surprisingly short. But they do have large litters

#

Its sad

#

I hope they reveal something good that ovi has that makes it unique

barren zephyr
#

Yes

paper oriole
#

Rn it just looks like juvi galli gameplay because galli runs and eats eggs too

#

Maybe let ovi sprint while crouched for better stealth while covering its tracks or something

#

Anything

#

Ovi deserved mimicry even if troo gets it too, ovi would have had good use for it

#

Yeah so ovi is kinda redundant as “mister egg thief”

pulsar smelt
#

I feel like ovi should be able to jump higher and maybe glide down from trees?

barren zephyr
#

No

paper oriole
pulsar smelt
#

Not like how you think

#

Less than a chicken I'd say?

paper oriole
#

Devs said a lot of things are gonna be eating eggs. Dont have to be an “egg eater” to eat eggs, to be specific with the statement

barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

Deer ai eating baby hypsi

barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

Yes

barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

And it still leaves the problem of ovi just being a midget galli

paper oriole
#

Like pteranodon

barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

You havent suggested otherwise yet

barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

I sant galli to pick up babies and throw them like a basketball

paper oriole
#

Ovi has nothing unique revealed for it yet

#

Nothing that makes it worth pickinng aside from liking the animal itself

#

Galli has good arms so it wouldnt make sense for it to have less use for them than ovi

#

NO!!!!!!!!!!!¡

#

NO!!!!!!!!!!!!¡¡!!!!!!!!!!!!

#

Oh well TI_Troll

barren zephyr
#

Ovi is not just little galli, ovi will surely have it easy to steal eggs by something devs will do

paper oriole
#

We have ovi's concept and there is nothing on it that suggested a unique ability. The devs have not said anything about it either

#

I hope it gets one, ovi is one of my favorite dinosaurs, but i am ready for disappointment

#

Masochists will play magy

#

Yes

#

Consistent disappointment

barren zephyr
#

Ok, galli has weak jaw and cant hold eggs with hands so it has to stay near the nest to eat eggs like it was a plant, but ovi can carry eggs so he can go eat them safe?

paper oriole
#

Same i can be a masochist with a better dino

paper oriole
sacred yacht
#

Hopefully next update helps deino out a bit.

barren zephyr
sacred yacht
#

Yes

paper oriole
#

And how will being able to hold a soecific food item make ovi worth playing. Also plants and meat chunks are carryable so i doubt eggs will magically not be carryable

barren zephyr
#

Is not a river everyone has to cross enough?

sacred yacht
barren zephyr
#

You die

paper oriole
#

2lazy link them

sacred yacht
#

Oh well

dense vale
#

wait are you gonna be able to eat your own eggs. PogBlue infinite food glitch

paper oriole
#

I doubt you could without suffering consequences

low canopy
#

trash diet TI_Troll

paper oriole
#

And they could easily bypass such an exploit by making reproduction drain resources

barren zephyr
#

Eggs will be hard to do enought that wont be worth makin them just to eat them

sacred yacht
#

To sum up my feedback I just said Deino needs more oxygen, tail physics, and better resting animation

paper oriole
#

Seems like basic quality of life upgrades

barren zephyr
sacred yacht
paper oriole
#

Cease

sacred yacht
barren zephyr
#

Abort mission, no eggs

paper oriole
#

A dino abortion would just be like Stepping on the egg lol

sacred yacht
#

The oxygen also doesn't scale with growing and from 1-100% the oxygen amount is the same

barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

Galli picking up eggs with its arms and just chucking them in a river

#

Throw the eggs at the parents and run away

sacred yacht
paper oriole
#

Imagine ovi can steal eggs and then hatch them and group different species together that would be so broken lol

sacred yacht
barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

N o

barren zephyr
paper oriole
#

n O

barren zephyr
#

Better save them in your stomach, when they are prepared you throw up

sacred yacht
dense vale
#

im waiting for someone to put teampoop in thier name

paper oriole
barren zephyr
sacred yacht
#

I've also played with lots of people that know this and just sit next to the water for 5 minutes or so until they see the deino surface for air

signal beacon
sacred yacht
paper oriole
barren zephyr
#

Or make more shallow parts

sacred yacht
urban flax
#

I know this has nothing to do with the current topic but...
Bruh insects 1/4 the size of Hypsi ? That'd be 5 kg bugs
Suggestions are going wild these days

sacred yacht
dense vale
#

theres many many miles of river, feel like if you choose to drink at a popular spot its just the risk you take

paper oriole
#

no i am Mira TI_delete_this

sacred yacht
barren zephyr
sacred yacht
#

My other suggestion was tail physics and the rest animation not have your head sticking up into the sky. Just laying flat like a real crocodile would

signal beacon
bronze pike
#

it seems pretty cool

#

but no debuffs should be given

topaz plaza
#

@naive stone every time you need the nutrient you'd have to trust your life to some random dude on the internet and hope he doesn't kill you for fun, which a lot of players do. Huh? this is a terrible idea

paper oriole
#

punishing deinos with lower biteforce if no pteras around have the nads to come down and pick its teeth. punishing ptera players by tying a nutrient to picking the teeth on a hungry predator that will oneshot them

#

if anything like this was added, it would be best if it was nearby compies coming by to pick teeth on deinos if they rest for a while

#

but the deino shouldnt be punished, it should be an aesthetic thing

topaz plaza
#

yes, this too. This implies that you'd always be able to find the other species, but that's not the case on empty servers, or, as the dino roster increases, you'll find a single species harder to find

#

yea doing this with compys could be cool

paper oriole
#

we already have compy ai so if it would come up and harmlessly nip at deino teeth and then scatter if the deino moves it would just be a cosmetic feature that adds some life to the game

naive stone
#

Considering the deinos would benefit from it (as if they didn't have the ptera, obviously stated) I would assume it'd be more likely they'd be more friendly. Another thing would be to use AI pteras to do the job, too, like what was just mentioned, just instead of compys pteras. But yes, there would be a sense of danger to it for pteranodons - as there is realistically with modern day crocs and birds.

paper oriole
#

just utilizing the already existing compy ai just seems better and also to not punish anyone for not taking part in the symbiotic relationship

honest sparrow
#

Bro did I seriously just do my random general feedback check to find a shit suggestion

paper oriole
#

imagine how awful ptera ai would be, considering how bad the elite fish ai was when it fled, and how much the land ai runs in to water and in to obstacles

#

ptera ai would be crashing in to shit constantly and never make it anywhere lmao

topaz plaza
#

ok firstly there is no ptera AI and there won't be, secondly, realism alone isn't a good enough reason to put something in the game

paper oriole
#

deino shouldnt rely on ptera players to help it with some toothache

#

and if it is just cosmetic then pteras are still gonna have no reason to risk it

#

it either punishes deino or it punishes ptera or both and thats kinda just bad

naive stone
#

Eh it's just a suggestion

thorny lynx
#

Returning for another reminder... f r o g

manic flint
#

F r o g

#

Literally the best recieved feedback in existence

ashen wasp
#

(Egyptian Plovers don’t actually clean crocodiles’ teeth. I do like the idea of mutualism though, particularly for Compy)

manic flint
#

Beipi actually looks pretty decent and sounds good

still needle
#

not sure if its still a thing but if you cling to the side while in water and look straight up and hold space you can take off

gusty patrol
#

depends how much stam you have left

#

but on most rocks you can swim up, or theres a section at south if that was the area, where you can walk on the wall- like not steep enough to fall off of it

limber hull
#

@topaz plaza planned with gore

topaz plaza
#

How's gore gonna affect the herbivores?

limber hull
#

herbis will get changed when they get changed

#

they could get changed next update. Doubtful they're staying as they are

#

the whole running around forever thing is silly

topaz plaza
#

yea i agree but are you saying the devs confirmed a change or you just guessing?

topaz plaza
#

@potent arrow there is counterplay. If you run around randomly in the same area, the footprints become a jumbled mess, making it very hard to tell which ones lead to which. i've done this multiple times and it always works

vital stone
#

Having buttons show up on my screen in a mini game like fashion would be pretty immersion breaking.

barren zephyr
#

@silver rose widing rivers more is too much, you are asking for 90% of getting killed by a deino, also no one would go to those places

vital stone
#

Yes I have, but I'm not a big fan of the idea of a mini game like thing that flashes buttons on my screen 🤷‍♀️

barren zephyr
#

@potent arrow they just have to put river wallowing back, just make worse than mud pit wallowing

barren zephyr
vital stone
#

I do agree that it should be more engaging, but not in that way.

barren zephyr
#

Is like having a mini game for the females when they have to lay eggs

#

But why? It doesnt even make sense, moving your body to court females is effortless

#

Where did they confirmed it?

#

Yeah I know that, I mean I'm in this discord and I'm not blind

#

@barren zephyr most people that will court is because both want to make a nest, it doesnt makes sense that if the player of the male does it wrong they cant procreate, it would make you not feel you are the dinosaur because you cant choose if you accept the male or not, also I dont think 2 friends want to do that minigame evrytime, I know is simple and is what you dont want but i think is better something like the group invitation, male does the dance and then the female chooses to accept or decline

#

@tepid river one dev said theres going to be a family system, so I dont think you should worry about that

potent arrow
rare fractal
#

@potent arrow So why do you think dinos shouldn't know what their own abilities do...

potent arrow
#

@rare fractal from what I understand the devs did this to prevent meta gaming or whatever you call it, so it doesn’t become a numbers game knowing exactly how many hit from something it would take to kill something.

rare fractal
barren zephyr
rare fractal
#

Bite damage already exists as a stat you can view

#

So it's a selective af standard

potent arrow
rare fractal
potent arrow
limber hull
#

nope, that's outright how much damage is done

#

500N = 500 damage

potent arrow
#

Oh

rare fractal
potent arrow
rare fractal
# potent arrow Yeah cases like that don’t make sense. Which I hope changes

Well no damage values make sense, realistically a utah would 1 shot pretty much everything with a pounce or neck bite, carno would 1 shot utah dryo and teno (with a headshot), dryo would deal bleed damage with it's bite, ptera would deal considerably higher damage than it does now, a teno kick would 1 shot carno if hit in the head, a pachy headbutt would completely shatter the bones of anything it hit, it wouldn't just partially disable them they ain't getting back up. And deino would 1 shot literally everything.... it's a consistent standard that damage values aren't realistic whatsoever

#

Balance supercedes realistic effects of attacks unfortunately, they always will

#

and for good reason

potent arrow
#

I agree

wooden mica
#

plot twist, deino lunge is working as intended and thats why its not being changed TI_Wheeze

barren zephyr
#

@hasty obsidian any other kind of forest than jungle would work

#

I didnt asked for opinions

limber hull
#

what a shame

#

on the isle discord, you don't get to consent to opinions

wooden mica
#

ooh dramaaaa

limber hull
barren zephyr
#

I'm sure cerato is 5.5 playable, i just ask cause I'm desesperated

limber hull
#

im cracking a joke lmao

wooden mica
#

I was doing the same ya dingus TI_Wheeze

topaz plaza
#

@signal beacon if this creature is meant to hunt small prey alone it doesn't make sense to give him an ability to communicate better than others

paper oriole
#

A more accurate utahraptor should be less of a social animal than our jp raptor

signal beacon
#

Ik that's why I made it live in pairs

paper oriole
#

That special chat just seems kinda random on utahraptor

signal beacon
#

Idk I just thought itd be neat. And I thought it would be fitting cause of how our Utahraptor will likely be the most bird looking thing in the roster

#

Is there anything else wrong with it?

paper oriole
#

Not really, considerinn we have feathered dinos with beaks faces

#

Utahraptor would look more birdlike than our leather raptor but even a feathered velo would look more birdlike than that bulky beast

signal beacon
#

Yea

paper oriole
#

Or feathered austro if it isnt still a mutant

#

Like utahraptor would still not scream “bird” as much as the other smaller and more narrow snouted dromeosaurs

signal beacon
#

I kinda just thought itd fit its playstyle. I pictured it using that to coordinate with its partner without blaring its location to everyone

#

Is there anything wrong with the rest of it tho?

paper oriole
#

Dont really think so, utahraptor makes sense to still have a pin ability minus the large prey pouncing

#

And a more interactive pin doesnt sound bad

signal beacon
#

So should I just yeet the bird call thing?

paper oriole
#

Doesn’t really fit it, id even go as far as to say it fits velo more. Utahraptor works best as just a more bulky brawler ambusher with kickboxinng and pinning

signal beacon
#

A stationary kick that could put the little jp knockoff in its place would help it

#

Kinda like gallis kick but not shit

paper oriole
#

Yeah id say real utahraptor would overpower our jp raptor in an outright brawl

#

Would kick its shit in

signal beacon
#

Cause I also see pachys bulling it if it's only move was a pin

paper oriole
#

Our jp raptor seems best keeping its style of avoiding taking damage alltogether while more accurate utah could tank some more hits and deal more raw damage

signal beacon
#

@keen basin what about our pins are good rn? They are just straight up insta wins

topaz plaza
#

well either way they probably already have a good idea of what they wanna do with both the new and old raptors so

keen basin
#

But I like all of the other ideas!

signal beacon
keen basin
#

Utah can pin pachys?

signal beacon
#

Irl Utah weighs around 600kg iirc

keen basin
#

Yeah

signal beacon
#

Pachy is 500kg

keen basin
#

Ah

#

So I could see a struggle mechanic there

signal beacon
#

I'm just saying pins and grabs and grapples will get very dumb if we dont do something about them being 1 shot snore fests

paper oriole
#

This is a certified prehistoric wildlife moment

keen basin
#

To a degree your right, but a 600 kg raptor pinning down a hypsi or dryo is fair

#

But pinning pachys needs to have a different mechanic

signal beacon
#

I mean hypsi would die from impact damage and dryo would have a chance but it's best bet is to stay where it belongs, in a field

keen basin
#

Yeah lol

urban flax
keen basin
#

I would like it

signal beacon
#

Oooh yay another mid/pseudo mid teir therapod carnivoreTI_Trollge

keen basin
#

But they can’t add that because then devs don’t get their Jurassic Park simulator lol

signal beacon
keen basin
#

Although some planned dinosaurs are unique

paper oriole
#

@warm burrow give reasons other than ‘favorite dino’ cus it costs a lot of money to add a new dino

#

Neo is basically midget allo

#

Sub allo gameplay

keen basin
#

But it could happen

signal beacon
#

At least utah has a unique playstyle that cant really be replicated by most of the roster. Neo is just allo/albert but small

keen basin
#

Yeah true

paper oriole
#

He even looks like an allo hes basically the allo version of the tarbosaurus meme

keen basin
#

Lol so true

signal beacon
keen basin
#

Yeah but all of the more well known dinosaurs are JP rip offs lol

warm burrow
warm burrow
keen basin
#

Maybe it could have a more pride oriented allo playstyle that is mixed with a carnos

signal beacon
paper oriole
#

I just looked it up neo is an allo/catchar relative

keen basin
signal beacon
#

I'm pretty sure dinosaur planet has a more accurate spino in terms of looksTI_Wheeze

keen basin
#

Lol

signal beacon
#

Mfw hypo spino is more accurate than regular spino

keen basin
#

I would love a realistic spino with maybe a bit of a JP kinda head just to fit The Isle but what we have now is a monster

warm burrow
paper oriole
#

And its obvious its an allosaur by its looks even without looking it up. Did you really not know the family of your fav dino

#

Carchar is an allo relative, neo is one too

keen basin
#

Lmao

paper oriole
#

We have like 3 allosaurs in game

#

Maybe 4 if they make their carchar a skin for giga

warm burrow
paper oriole
#

His v shaped double crest that ends right before his eyes is a dead giveaway for most likely being an allosaur

warm burrow
#

true

signal beacon
#

If anything we need more herbis. Although our roster genuinely needs to be purged because holy shit I've never seen so much roster bloat in an attempt to get all the big names while also having obscure ones

paper oriole
#

More herbis? grappler Iguanadon and fruit bat tupandactylus moment (please doind)

keen basin
#

I would like to see a Cryolophosaurus

signal beacon
paper oriole
#

He would cry and his tears would be venomous TI_Troll

urban flax
#

Cryo would serve as food for magy

signal beacon
#

Dinosaurs when they dont have anything unique: VENOM

keen basin
#

It would have a solo, nomadic life style and hunt like a mix of bears and foxes

paper oriole
#

A megaraptoran could be unique i think. A megaraptoran and prestosuchus are the only two carnis i can think of immediately that could be valid additions

paper oriole
#

Megaraptorans have very nice arms

paper oriole
urban flax
#

Our bary is literally a megaraptor who can fish

signal beacon
#

Didn't megaraptor have opposable digits?

paper oriole
#

Australovenator had almost pronated wrists

keen basin
signal beacon
#

Tribals wen the megar picks up their spear: TI_Scream

paper oriole
#

I think australovenator and some tiny dromeosaur had the most flexible wrists of any theropods discovered iirc

urban flax
#

If we were to add yet another theropod, I would like balaur or changyuraptor. Maybe upsized versions of them.

paper oriole
#

But since the isle already messes with dino wrists it means little

paper oriole
keen basin
# urban flax So... allo

It wouldn’t latch on tho it would stalk prey and then essentially just lacerate them and take chunks of flesh from living prey. Kinda just eat them alive. Or it could fit a hyena niche

paper oriole
#

However, balaur is an omni not a carni

#

A very nice omni

signal beacon
#

Literally every niche imaginable has a carni for it. Or multiple

keen basin
#

No Herrera climbs and acts like a leopard

paper oriole
urban flax
#

Maybe we could have more arboreal creatures tho
A bigger arboreal herbi than hypsi, and a bigger arboreal carni than herrera

urban flax
#

I still say titanoboa would work as an arboreal apex

#

And nothing else

signal beacon
#

Dinosaurs were the animals that decided to just throw shit at the wall and see what sticks. Such as taco (and it somehow fucking stuck like cement)

keen basin
urban flax
paper oriole
#

Herrera but it is morbidly obese and shops at walmart

#

Thats cryo

keen basin
paper oriole
#

Its basically just allo with a different crest

keen basin
#

Unless I am missing something I thought herrera was supposed to climb and then latch onto big animals and kinda just climb around on them

paper oriole
#

Herrera was shown ripping off a chunk in his concept

#

So he may be a flesh grazer + he can climb. Vs cryo who is just a weaker allo that for some reason flesh grazes

signal beacon
#

Itd be nice if it pinned down smalls and flesh grazed larger animals crossing through the jungle

#

Like little fucking gnats

keen basin
#

I could see Yuty tho, it would kinda fit the niche of like a badger/hyena

signal beacon
#

Like I said. Literally everything is full

keen basin
#

Does it? I thought it was like a mini allo

signal beacon
keen basin
#

Ah that makes sense

keen basin
signal beacon
keen basin
#

Cool that’d be fun

#

Like a weasel lol

jagged jewel
lyric spoke
#

I must be the only person that thinks courting should have an element of gift-giving, itd be ironically less goofy than the courting we've seen so far

paper oriole
#

It looks stupid af on tenonto and stego's dance is just plain bad and looks like they arent even trying lol. Utahs was stupid too its showing off its bald ass arms

paper oriole
#

Would be nice if the male stego could flare the color on its plates and maybe do a little side profile jiggle

#

i had another idea for tenonto maybe i should draw it and put it in suggestions but the devs wont pay attention lol. theyd rather have animals with showy features and distinct personalities break their necks or slightly shift their body weight

#

pachy court will probably be it breaking its own leg or something

#

considering their track record so far

unborn lance
#

The issue with courtship is that it's a multiplayer system. You can't gameify it too much without inconveniencing players who just want to group up with friends. I think additional systems must be based around impressing the female player. Not a system.
For example "play fights" to show off a player's skill or even obtain alpha status. Allow males to build nests and decorate them or store them with food. The skin system could include a few more options for vibrant highlights on males. Less camo = more skill needed for survival.

paper oriole
#

for magy's court it should have a breath holding competition until both of them die

paper oriole
#

i dont know why but i can easily see tenontos locking arms and duking it out similar to kangaroos

#

some other animal does it too that ive seen but i dont remember which

#

yeah like that lol

#

the males trying to shove eachother to the ground, a harmless game, it could maybe cost stamina but they dont hurt eachother

#

just a shw of strength

#

idk about it being like spiders, since the wrestle would just be for male vs male, on females it would be a more passive thing

#

against competing males it would be a fight to show who is the bigger chad

#

on trikes it could be something similar. a male and female could tap their horns in a smaller side to side gesture but males could also grapple eachother with their horns in a more aggressive but not deadly duel

#

so it is one mechanic but two different ways it can eb used

#

yeah kinda

#

some theropod could have something like the open jaw fighting

#

um. dont question it

dense vale
#

feel like if you make it too complicated and competition it will make bad behavior and loser griefs them or something

paper oriole
#

already, i can see normal court dances being used to dance on top of bodies so its nothing worse

#

yeah i can see it being used for that more than its used for courting already

#

court ship dancing on top of a body while you bodyguard

#

ptera already spams 1 call

unborn lance
paper oriole
#

same skins are already gonna be a decisive feature if they affect the offspring

unborn lance
#

They'll probably go the easy route of selecting random colours and patterns from each parent.

signal beacon
#

Its buggy. And so is utah, and teno, and pachy, and dryo, and hypsi, and all the main mechanics, and... fuckin hell

paper oriole
#

the isle

signal beacon
#

The Isle. You won't fix it.

#

It

paper oriole
#

Reads “map”, instantly downvotes 😎

signal beacon
dense vale
#

main reason i dont want it now is cause theyl feel like they can spread stuff out even more lol

paper oriole
#

We need better landmarks not a map

signal beacon
#

We need a map so we can plan out clan battles like in BoBTI_Troll

dense vale
#

but serious note, its a type of suggestion where i agree with most of the problems but not the solution, to me the solution is more get rid of the problems in the first place, rather than accept it sucks and slightly fix with something else

warm quartz
#

Sorry for suggesting it I guess?

tight oxide
dense vale
#

i also apply my last comment to the herb juvi diet suggestion, i want to interact with a diet system, it just needs to be more reasonably achievable. i dont like the idea of making the few things you can do in the game so rare that you have to make it not apply, thats losing mechanic interaction

tight oxide
bold palm
#

@obtuse obsidian you do know they can hear you right? If you are resting you make breathing noises and if you just sat down you scent trail would also be there. Try crouching instead to mitigate that problem and don't move around or you will leave scent. I don't know what you've experienced though and maybe you are being hacked on sometimes, but I have rarely experienced anything where someone just runs up on me, just one time and I reported it immediately to the admin. They came on and tracked them down. You might also try going to a spot that is less known and well hidden where a hacker may not go. ? Anyway, good luck.

#

@obtuse obsidian also if you are streaming sometimes people will find you if you reveal your location and server. Stream sniping is definitely a thing. peace.

limber hull
#

that's how troodon is meant to be played so

manic flint
#

enough to kill 1 pachy

last lily
manic flint
#

bruh first time playing carno since u2 and i am starving to death cause i cant eat for some reason

#

i tried logging but now the server is full

barren crater
#

@coral swan What do you mean by change animations? Allo already has new animations for evrima?

coral swan
barren crater
#

Also I'm assuming they'll keep the calls and just up the quality of it to match evrima

barren crater
limber hull
#

allo does look really good in the new anims, i dont think anything about legacy animations look that good. The ambush looks fucking stupid lmao

coral swan
#

No, it's not "different" for me, I just hate it ^^ I've learnt animation so I'm picky about movement.

barren crater
limber hull
#

eh, i always thought it looked silly

#

i never liked it

#

new allo animations look really good, decent weight to them and look actually speedy

barren crater
#

Allos legacy animations look stiff in comparison. It actually looks like it can run and turn rather than that laid back legacy run it had. Heck even the trot looks active https://youtu.be/aTnXdFgGPHY?t=25

Yeah I know these are pretty old, but I wanted to put all the animations in one place for easier access. BUT I make isle videos as often as I can so if you wanna tune un for more, then it might be worth subscribing! And uh leave a like if you enjoyed and if you didn't enjoy, then dislike!

▶ Play video
limber hull
coral swan
#

Walk looks better, trot looks like it's when a human walks like moving the same arm with the leg, run is..meh..they pretty similar

limber hull
#

that trot tho lmao

#

allo is probably going to be an insane endurance/ambush with that trot

barren crater
#

I mean it depends on what it has to contend with

coral swan
#

and now imagine the juvie moving its leg only half way in and with 1000% speed cause this is what will happen

coral swan
barren crater
#

Juvie animations will be different for allo based on what bryan said in 2020

limber hull
barren crater
#

Everything will have different juvie animations, that was the issue with legacy

limber hull
#

id honestly give allo pretty bad stam for sprinting in ambushing, but a decent trot speed so it can keep up with stuff like stego in endurance hunts

barren crater
#

Also depends where it mainly hunts. Allo with low stam is fine with a trot speed similar to that (Who knows how fast that trot is, but it looks too fast imo)

limber hull
#

Trot looks insane

#

its quite literally a jog

barren crater
#

I wouldn't be surprised if that's one of the fastest trots in the game

coral swan
#

the trot is not fast, it's unbalanced looking

limber hull
#

what

barren crater
#

Let me just say, that allo running animation you're looking at is 52kph. So if you compare (probably a bad way to do it?), it is pretty fast for what its meant to be- a trot

#

So technically allos animations let it run up to 52kph but they'll never allow that lmao

#

For good and obvious reasons

limber hull
#

probably yea

#

honestly im kind of a fan of endurance trot-down allo with dogwater stamina but a fast sprint in ambushes

#

also give it pretty garbo swim speeds pls

barren crater
#

Yeah I'm fine. Don't see an issue with that. Since it can traverse without having to run everywhere lmao

#

garbo swim is fine but imo it should (unless it does already?) scale with age.

#

but even if it doesn't, eh

limber hull
#

also mildly dogwater turn-rate. Not carno bad but not amazing either

barren crater
#

Running or turn in place?

#

I feel like brawlers should be great at turn in place

#

generally at lower speeds not just turn in place

limber hull
#

allo isnt a brawler tho

#

nor should it be

barren crater
#

I thought it was? I'm confused as to what it is then

limber hull
#

it's endurance/ambush bleeder animal

#

im not sure why it'd be a brawler

barren crater
#

Ah I guess yeah, but whats considered a brawler then? Like what traits would you need for that?

empty epoch
#

who knows

limber hull
#

brawler is something that's a tad more defensively oriented with a lot of combat potential and generally suffers in the speed department for that. The goal of a brawler should be to hit your opponent hard to make it go away or to delay before you make your getaway. Teno and pachy are brawlers.

empty epoch
#

Cerato

limber hull
#

cerato would be a good carnivore brawler, yea

empty epoch
#

yes

limber hull
#

its goal is to scare things away from bodies

#

which is best suited to a brawler

rare fractal
#

yes

#

mmmmm yes

barren crater
rare fractal
limber hull
#

i wouldn't define something like a stego as a brawler. It's kind of just "tank shit and hit hard". Its goal isn't even so much scaring off attackers as much as punishing them for even coming close.

#

Like it just kills things

rare fractal
#

Tank is a better term

limber hull
#

unlike pachy nor teno, which do a lot to "brawl" their opponent and have to assess the situation, stego can't do flexible things with its attacks or bait the opponent, stego is ENTIRELY defensive. It can rarely outrun, it almost always has to hit the thing till it stops moving\

#

hell, stego is outright immobile during its best move

rare fractal
limber hull
#

true as that may be, it did have over moves and it also had its "best move" still be not exceptionally lethal (on a single hit). The move could be comboed and had utility that allowed the rest of its kit to complement

#

Stego fucking swings the tail and the thing either dies or it doesn't

#

There's no intricacies to the combat style, it's an extremely static animal

rare fractal
#

Perhaps we don't tie tanks to having massively damaging attacks as much as it is a general limitation of mobility

#

cuz that omits teno from the category while maintaining tank as a definitive class

#

(yes, I am arguing the accuracy of arbitrary dino categories... this is what I consider entertainment xD)

limber hull
#

hmrg yes kos rules

#

always fun and never fucking annoying/stupid

hybrid tiger
#

Ye like if I’m surrounded by utahs as a pachy why should I be punished for going in first

low canopy
#

think for yourself sometimes, Imagine you were playing a herbivore and the initiative of showing agression was entirely removed from you, would it be fun?

limber hull
#

did you guys know that carnivores can both generally outrun and outstam herbivores, or have some other method of evading them?

#

its really incredible what you can do with a little bit of situational awareness and not wasting all your stam running up to a pachy herd

hybrid tiger
#

It’s almost as if you can run away from a fight and the isle isn’t a deathmatch

limber hull
#

god forbid!

barren crater
#

If there ever was a rule- the only 2 rules that should be implemented are no mixpacking, and pack limit rules

limber hull
#

or

#

no rules at all honestly

barren crater
#

or that

urban flax
#

@barren zephyr

#

I didn't think I would use this screenshot that often

low canopy
#

while its not an issue, the other extreme is just as bad aka death match

urban flax
#

Your opinion vs a dev's.

#

When saying "KOS is not an issue" he meant that they don't consider it a problem. It's literally intended as part of the game.

dense vale
#

you just have to find private servers with kind of rules you like, if thats still around. officials are supposed to be random free for all

compact hare
#

There are tons of servers with those rules
If not, the majority of big servers have them

hybrid tiger
#

Cope harder

urban flax
#

Why were you friendly with a stego in the first place

#

If there are no players on servers with those rules maybe that means these shouldn't be part of the base game...

barren zephyr
#

Literally carno is busted with it’s turn radius rn.

urban flax
#

If you don't want to meet toxic players, then the only solution is to not play online games

#

That's what balance is for, you're supposed to either be able to fight off or outrun pretty much everything else in the game

#

As a pachy, you can easily run away from a stego. As a Utah, you can run away from tenos

#

I don't see how that's relevant to KOSing now, that just sounds like a skill issue
And I'm not the kind of person to bring that up everytime someone complains about the game

hybrid tiger
rose lily
#

having bad situational awareness is your fault

mint girder
#

You could’ve ran

#

The teno isn’t very fast compared

#

You could’ve kept running without getting on a rock I don’t think the teno wouldve caught up

#

Why’d you hop off the rock then

keen bough
#

Ok well that's the game, stop complaining, sorry to be mean and brutal but that's life

mint girder
#

Yes you could stay on the rock and live

#

Teno can’t really climb

keen bough
#

Guys, this is situational we don't need herbis to not be able to attack, that's a silly idea,

#

What if a group of let's say para's were being stalked by allows, wouldn't it make sense for the paras to attack the allo? Or what about Oviraptor who steal eggs, if herbis can't attack then they can't do anything to protect? Use your brains man

#

Or to protect a bab? If it attacks the bab and not you you can't attack it

mint girder
#

I know

keen bough
#

It's a PvP online, survival game, you can't expect toxic peices of crap to not exist

mint girder
#

I wouldn’t consider teno killing Utah’s toxic

keen bough
#

Ofc it doesn't make sense, humans are A-holes and there is nothing you can do to change that

mental marlin
#

what im wondering is why are you letting those herbivores get anywhere near you in the first place

#

if you are playing a carnivore and you let the herbivore know you exist , you are already making mistakes

#

all of the current herbivores are slower then their carnivore counterparts so if you die to one its always 100% your own fault , so quit asking for moronic things like not allowing them to kill anything they want

mint girder
#

Doesn’t make it really toxic animals do that all the time

urban flax
#

Let's say it was just very well played of that Teno to manage to ambush a group of utahs

keen bough
#

Yeah like srlsy don't accociate herbis with peaceful, otherwise it will be the most fricking boring thing to play ever, let them be aggro. Let them play their own unique playstyle, that's what makes the game fun man!

burnt bone
#

@barren zephyr The issue with the suggestion about KOS herbies is that they kinda need to attack first. If pachy gets bit by a carno, that’s 1/4 of its hp and the carno is likely to hit another bite. Pachy has to go on the offensive to survive encounters. Pachy isn’t the only one either, tents lose the fight to carnos if they get rammed. And the suggestion just allows carnos to keep ramming until they hit the tent. Lastly, people in this game hate mixpacking, and this will force people to mixpack.

#

Yes, but how can it tell if you are friendly, or just trying to lure it in

#

Plus, I’m not talking about that specific scenario. People are just terrible and will kill for fun. I’m talking about the larger balance of the game.

#

Adding something that restricts offensive combat will restrict defensive combat

#

For example, Pachy’s turn nerfs while ramming takes away my main escape tactic, which was to turn and ram the face of who was chasing me.

limber hull
#

the turn nerfs are fine imho, works well for the attack and animal

warm flame
#

@jade schooner the spino's size compared to that rex was dondi scaling the rex to be like JP3 in size, this is (probably) the size we'll get for spino

#

I think the size is fine, I think the design is overall really good, but I do wonder how it'd look if they edited the model

#

I also find it ironic how the hypo spino is more accurate in shape than the normal one

jade schooner
#

Same

#

But like you said, the overall design is really good. I really like it too

#

But just those little details (tail and leg length mostly) are really details that would make it stand out, aside from its humongous size, length and the sail

#

It comparison to the other theropod apexes

stiff storm
#

Can we get old pond + wallowing on water edges back

warm flame
#

what's the size now?

barren zephyr
#

TThis is the newest

warm flame
limber hull
#

legacy spino looks awful

#

i hate it so much

barren zephyr
#

same

warm flame
#

I liked the legacy spino when it was first released, it worked then, fit in with the rest of the models and its stats fit it and it had some really nice skins

but now with how overtuned its stats are with it looking like a paperweight and the skin is just meh I don't like it much

warm flame
#

the tiny stubby legs look like it has like 0 thigh

merry mantle
#

Yeah lol

warm flame
#

sunken into the body

merry mantle
#

The base of the tail is really throwing me off

dapper mirage
#

My question is why limit creative freedom

limber hull
#

Giving complete player freedom leads to the fucking eyesore that is BoB. I’d rather no neon nightmare

dapper mirage
#

Well obviously say no to neons

#

But people are going to make horrendous skins regardless no matter what

#

It’s inevitable

limber hull
#

True but they won’t be pink so I take comfort in that

dapper mirage
#

I’m worried that they’ll just decide to delete every vibrant color because it seems like something this team would totally do

limber hull
#

Hypsi exists, so do troodon, those two are colourful af

dapper mirage
#

Like I’m really hoping we get some options for shades of red other than the weird half red/orange thing we have now

#

Based on how dodgy they’ve been about it I just get this feeling that the system is gonna be way too limiting

odd sedge
#

I agree that golds and stuff shouldnt be banned. But bright colors should not be included

dapper mirage
#

Granted I don’t KNOW but I have that gut intuition

#

man people really don’t want to see colors do they ☠️

odd sedge
#

Id rather have the bottom than the top

dapper mirage
#

Again I do not want neons

#

The neon green dilo crest in legacy is proof that that looks awful

#

But I’d love to see bright colors available in places other than male details so people have the option to blend more and be creative

#

And worst comes to worst just add a skin filter like BoB for the players who don’t want to see any bright colors no matter what

paper oriole
#

Why do those raptors have beaks wtf lol

odd sedge
paper oriole
#

Proximity debuffs are heavily abusable

signal beacon
#

Have a fodder dino stand next to herbivore.

Debuff the herbivore

Have another carni come over and kill the now debuffed herbiTI_Troll

urban flax
#

Just with how he described it... Play carno
Make a pack with another carno
Have your friend greet the stego
Wait for the debuffs to come
Take his place and kill the stego without risk

topaz palm
#

@placid iron
"Combat: Combat is the only real fun thing to do in this game currently, so let's make Dryo a juvi-murdering machine."

This is completely unnecessary. If combat is the only thing you enjoy in the game, that's fine. But turning every playable into a combative creature is not a good move. Dryo could definitely use some love right now, but gearing it towards combat only narrows our available gameplay styles. Combat isn't the ultimate goal.

paper oriole
#

Have one pack mate debuff the herbi, then the rest of the pack comes in to range for the attack

#

Not even herbi exclusive either, abuse a rex with a dryo, abuse an allo with a galli. It is just a trollbait mechanic

signal beacon
#

And then there is the "debuff herbivores for killing carnivores" oneTI_Troll

signal beacon
#

I'd love to put someone who thinks herbivores are pacifists into Africa and let them see what tries to kill them most
The lions and hyenas
Or all of the eternally pissed off herbivores

#

Cant wait until they find they study about omnivorous trikeTI_Troll

placid iron
low canopy
#

nerfing shit animals like ptera and dryo into further irrelevancy is not much of plan either

#

unless plan is to have everyone play carno that is 🙂

paper oriole
#

ptera isnt that bad, but dryo is hella boring now and has been for a while

signal beacon
#

I can see why carno was buffed. Although I think it's just a bit too agile now, but nothing to serious. The problem arises from literally every other animal getting nerfed or broken and diets getting turned into... this

rare stirrup
#

broken game

signal beacon
dapper mirage
#

Unless it’s something stupidly busted like stego, buffs are always better than nerfs

paper oriole
#

flat out buffs and nerfs often arent even the answer

signal beacon
#

Yea so Revert most of the herbis nerfs and see what happens. Carno still too strong? Fix diets. Still? Then think about nerfs. Although most of our animals would be viable if they... y'know... worked

dapper mirage
#

If anything I think carno should get even MORE buffs, but I’m in favor of buffing everything so that everything is stupidly good. Very hot take

#

Like 100 damage utah needs to be a thing

#

Mind you carno is fine as is currently

signal beacon
#

I mean other than stun spam carno had a really good spot last patch. Oasis and ease of food was just fucking it over. But now everything is broken

dapper mirage
#

But I think everything should be pushed to their absolute limit stat wise so everything feels super powerful

paper oriole
#

100 damage utah sounds like wed need to inflate health pools which isnt too great

dapper mirage
#

55 damage utah is lame and cringe

#

Having to inflate health pools is a good thing

paper oriole
#

inflated health pools and damage output becomes a problem later on

signal beacon
paper oriole
#

like whats next 500 damage allo with 4000 health?

dapper mirage
#

Honestly stego would be fine at 4K-4.5k

paper oriole
#

bruh

#

you want to buff damage and then nerf hp on large animals

dapper mirage
#

Well for one thing, the only large animal that isn’t deino is stego

signal beacon
#

Inflated stats are not the way to go at a certain point. Things would get beyond crazy

paper oriole
#

wed get to a point where mid tiers and large animals and smalls are too closely melted together

dapper mirage
#

Stego should have relatively low hp compared to other apex herbivores

gaunt hinge
#

Utah would be so much more viable to skilled players if they just gave it the update 3 acel back
That’s it
Or increased dismount that doesn’t allow it to get clapped every single time it lands it’s ability when it hops off

paper oriole
#

stego already takes extra head damage it is good enough

dapper mirage
#

Does the extra headshot damage matter right now? Cause it’s still unkillable

paper oriole
#

we dont need weirdly inconsistent health pools

signal beacon
#

Remove stego
Remove deino
Fix the other animals
world peace

paper oriole
#

thats 1. shit ecosystem 2. utah pounce is jank as fuck

dapper mirage
#

It is partly an hp problem

paper oriole
#

not really

dapper mirage
#

Deino needs raw dps to kill steg

paper oriole
#

deino doesnt even need to be killing steg, but a fracture on his lunge would be good anyway

#

to head fracture steg and make it fuck off

#

or easier to take down

dapper mirage
#

Should a deinosuchus not hunt a stegosaurus?

paper oriole
#

not really its designed to drown mid tiers

#

thats why its got the weight bracket

odd sedge
placid iron
#

or give it the tug-of-war thing if a stego is stupid enough to go super deep in the water, currently no punish for that

paper oriole
#

fracture on the lunge would probably be fine enough

#

head fracture is annoying to have

#

so it would make them think twice

gaunt hinge
#

I remember the days when deino could actually kill cocky water stegos TI_Succ

paper oriole
#

was it the machine gun alt bite days

dapper mirage
#

I do not understand the argument of an 8 ton crocodile should not be able to hunt a 6 ton herbivore with a tiny head

paper oriole
#

i remember back when deino alt bite was insane it could easily kil stegos

signal beacon
#

Deino should be removed. Crocs just dont work in this game

paper oriole
#

but big alligator

dapper mirage
#

big alligator is the only argument you really need

#

you see how insane those things are

gaunt hinge
#

That’s because the alt bite wasn’t used a bunch

low canopy
#

you really DONT need more reasons to play deino as it is, its like second most played animal after carno

gaunt hinge
#

It was lunge > bite > alt > bite > alt and you’d make it out at half health as Deino if the Stego wasn’t using its head

signal beacon
#

Deino is cool, but it one shots half the fucking roster while being invisible half the time

paper oriole
#

deino

#

this is no meme, this is a solid argument for why deino belongs in the dinosaur horror sim game known as the isle

placid iron
#

true

paper oriole
#

just give huge alligator fracture and see how that plays out

gaunt hinge
#

delete the horror in that post and you got the isle bc frankly lots of horror aspects rn are not there

signal beacon
#

The devs putting 3 seconds of thought into how a gator would work: TI_TenontoCry

Big gator: TI_HypsilWow

urban flax
#

Guys, I've been thinking for some time for a way a tug-of-war mechanic could work. The problems devs brought up with it are :
-Uninteractive
-Locks two dinos in a situation where they can't move, but others can still attack them

So, when a deino lunges something that is more than 50% of itself but still under its own weight, it starts the tug-of-war. Maybe tug-of-war is only possible when lunging a specific body part, like stego's head.
Both dinos stamina deplete very quickly as they try to overpower each other. As long as the lunged dino has stamina, it can move around and drag the deino, but at a very reduced pace. Once it runs out of stamina, the deino can drag it slowly. If the deino runs out of stamina, it releases its prey.
Whaddya guys think ? (Especially you Miragaia I know you can find flaws where I don't see any)

paper oriole
brave surge
#

horror only existed with hypos around

paper oriole
#

not even tbh

#

at night its just carno spam call except dark, vs carno spam call when it is light

#

i dropped a noodle on my keyboard ignore that awful typo

gaunt hinge
#

Things I miss about the isle:
It being dead silent at night and hearing giant crouched footsteps behind your real estate tree

paper oriole
#

no but it disturbed my fingers

signal beacon
#

One day, troodon will get 2 tapped by teno biteTI_Troll

paper oriole
#

troodon when trample comes. "gues i'll die"

signal beacon
#

Troodon had like 3 seconds of thought put behind it.
It was like "heho cool night time predator"

#

Teno just throws it away like the little fucking rat it is

gaunt hinge
#

ngl in that Troodon concept art Tenno did not look like it was having a good time,

signal beacon
#

Either troodon was upsized or the teno was young.
Those troodon almost stood shoulder hight

dapper mirage
#

Just gonna drop this here btw, new deino size estimate compared to rex

#

so yeah, isle deino is way undersized

signal beacon
#

Scratch that. They are literally fucking taller than the teno when risin in that concept TI_Trollge

urban flax
placid iron
#

Troodon players assembling a 12 man pack only to be killed by 2 carnos in less than a minute

signal beacon
#

Troodon players when dryoTI_Troll

#

I will Kos all troodon as a dryo

#

Easier to breakTI_WeSmart

paper oriole
#

long neck good for grabbing and using like a handle

placid iron
#

Troo mains fear the dryo kick attack

odd sedge
#

Troodon is gonna be bullied by every dinosaur.
But on the other hand, Troodon will be the perfect animal to harass humans

gaunt hinge
#

I feel like.
It’d be a neat perk for troodon to have the ability to make its calls sound more distant, (mimicry in particular)
But I’ll probably expand on that when the five hour timer is done TI_Stego

signal beacon
#

Troodon mains fear any animal that isn't a fucking ant

tepid gate
rare fractal
placid iron
#

honestly I feel like troodon will be reeeeally fun to play when terrorizing humans, crawling through vents like xenomorphs, mimicking human speech, etc.

dapper mirage
#

Basically talks about deino’s size and stuff

odd sedge
paper oriole
#

troodon mimicking the horrified screams of its human victims like the annihilation bear

gaunt hinge
#

Leeroy Jenkins Troodon.

signal beacon
#

Troodon...

  1. Requires huge packs to make any impactful kill

  2. Can literally get bit to death by herbivores

  3. Has no feasible way of being faster than fucking dryo. And no way of being more agile.

paper oriole
#

your friend disappears in the woods, you don't know what happened but the next night you think you hear him crying for help from that forest

#

but it doesnt sound quite right

signal beacon
#

In the dark forest you hear a faint "uwu"

gaunt hinge
urban flax
signal beacon
#

Dryo will literally be able to hunt troodon

gaunt hinge
#

Yeah?

paper oriole
gaunt hinge
#

Some people don’t care about stats so much as having fun with like a 15 person group

signal beacon
#

If you're getting oppressed by fucking dryo, you need to rethink your addition to the game

odd sedge
#

You walk into the woods, your flashlight flickers and from the rustling bushes, you hear a crow like
"Fock off, uwu"

placid iron
#

troo balance also seems like a nightmare, like if venom is crazy strong it could be super powerful, but we literally know nothing about it other than "stronger in packs"