#general-feedback-discussion
1 messages Ā· Page 304 of 1
that... has nothing to do with what he said tho
What is more logical? Rex having bonebreak or deino?
you can have deino make people be cautious AND make it better designed lmao
rex probably
Then it is majestically failing at its job because people aren't being cautious around water any more than they used to be before deino
Because they just drink at safe spots to avoid it, or rely on pure luck
deino doesn't really have any way to capitalise on a bonebreak since the prey can just leave
that too
Are you being illogical on purpose? First you say that the devs wouldn't benefit from unlimited money in any way - shape or form
(until erik eden came and you bowed down, admitting to lying about your opinion just because u don't like "my narrative")
Now you're saying players aren't more cautious around water than they were before deino? what?
Why do people hesitate to drink from most spots in populated areas? Deino's existence
i love how you brought up something entirely unrelated to the conversation lol
also he didn't say that at any point
Bulbulu has lied about his opinions before just to win an argument/discussion, so of course I'll bring it up and assume he's doing the same thing now
What did he not say
I gurantee you, you can try to answer that question and I will pull up a screenshot showing you he said exactly what you think he didn't lol
Yeah exactly, and anyway this has nothing to do with bonebreak
Why is it more logical for REX to have bonebreak and deino not?
because rex can capitalise on it
deino? not as much
if we're talking realistically, lol
deino would be able to punish players more for drinking water
okay but its not about "punishing" it should be about actually finishing them off
being a pest doesn't really help deinosuchus at all, it's not pachy
like in all situations you'd be better off just drowning it rather than fracturing it
Okay here is my undebatable statement on it
Rex having bonebreak, would make it ALOT more powerful in its position
(being able to capitalize on it and just doom a dinosaur with a legbreak)
Deino can't exactly chase a stego down after fracturing its body, it's just punishing
Would Rex be more powerful than deino with bonebreak? or the other way around?
but that's exactly the point, deino can't DO anything with it, it's just there to be a mild nuisance
you proved my point, it exists purely for deino to be a mild annoyance (not to mention with how fracture damage works, deino would have to likely attack stego multiple times to GET said fracture, in which it'll just get powerswinged a few times and die for the sake of being a mild irritant)
rex would be more powerful than necessary, with bonebreak
deino would not be
sure, but deino would gain no value from having it, rex would
you seem to be under the implication that rex is already a set power that would be overtuned with the addition of fractures, despite not knowing where rex stands balance wise due to it not being implemented
We all have a good idea of where rex stands
do we? we have zero actual gameplay of it in any matchup
the most we know are leaked stats that very well might be placeholder, as it was with trike
I'm back, what did I miss ?
I was getting on your level
Uh nothing interesting it seems
Also the question wasn't about infinite money
It was about 30K $, which isn't that much for a game's development
You make stuff up and then leave when someone you respect calls you out on it lmao
30k?
Which is precisely what you do every conversation you engage in
Apart that you never leave because you don't respect anyone
is it pathological or what? these lies are insane
the amount of times i mentioned "million" and "Infinite" must have been more than two dozen
after asking the question
š š
you quoting yourself isn't a reliable source
what is going on w you
i said 300m and infinite, he says i said 30k. what?
i have a question for you
why do you care so much lmao
ah it was 300M
I guess it wasn't important enough for me to recall perfectly
i don't like when people
- avoid questions
- change words
- lie about something to win a discussion
all of which, this dude is living on
Dude's used to lying
that's surprising to me i'll be honest
I told you before, I'm only doing this with you specifically
eh, i've known him for a while, it's just you who gets that lmao
you're lucky like that
Bro answered one of my questions, and then when I showed it was a dumb answer - he refused to answer any more yes or no questions
and then when erik came, he admitted to lying
it's just not a reliable behavior
You argued with a point that you didn't even believe in, just to oppose the truth
300 million extra dollars would help the development's speed and quality no matter what you say
i'm right and if you deny it you're wrong, simple as
well, you making them "yes or no questions" is kind of the problem, because you very much use that strategy to construct a narrative using very defined ultimatums in which no rational person would want one of them
yes or no questions only work if those are the only two options. you use it for more complex questions with multiple layers
how can i construct a strong valid point with the "Yes or no" questions, if the point is wrong?
and then get angry when people answer them appropriately
There is nothing wrong with yes or no questions, you're sensitive for not liking them
well, there's the thing, you can't
your point relies on creating ultimatums
Yes or no questions are very good at forcing someone to simplify their belief, making it easier to get to the bottom of the problem
so that you either illustrate whoever you're against as a fool, or force them to agree with you
Yes or no questions are necessary
they're not
There it is
The exact reason why everyone hates you
Yeah they are, you just don't like them because it forces you to not be wrong lol
you can have a debate without forcing an ultimatum
i don't like them because i want people's real thoughts, not something i've forced them to pick between
I don't debate to debate, I want the solution and "yes or no" brings it faster
That's how I managed to make fun of the dude, because he answered "No" to a question that is an obvious yes š
exactly
it's a far more complex question, but you made him to be a fool because you forced him into an ultimatum
exactly my point
you use it as an excuse to weaponise disagreement
And I'll keep doing that everytime you ask one of yours absurd "yes or no" questions
If that makes you happy somehow that's a bonus
Refusing to answer questions just proves you're insecure about being right in the current discussion
if you think you're right, you shouldn't be scared
because the question itself is not a yes or no question, but if you phrase it as one, it becomes either
"you're an idiot"
or
"you agree with me therefor i win"
if you answer yes to a question and it ends up provingmy point, then why are you even debating anymore
another day another peak isle discussion
This place never gets boring
you keep confirming my points and that's really funny
true true
@urban flax here's your best friend
there is no force, it's just yes or no
Riveting
how tf do you keep track of this lmao
There is very much force
I'd post the "how to argue like an a*hole" picture I get in my Pinterest feed every so often, so we can see how it compares to the way you "optimize" your debates
Sadly I haven't saved it
That's called worship
why do you care this much about this discord, i forget everything that's said in here like the day after
genuinely feels like it. man has so many quotes specifically from whoever for whatever
truly, the heights of intrigue
@wispy abyss " it is a horror game, not an animal simulation" it is a survival animal game actually and i wrote (horror) because for somone it is also a horror, for others not
I don't forget other people's stupid behaviors
I love false dichotomies
when it comes to proving someone's wrong
that's somewhat sad
that statement was purely related to debates
No what ?
i hope you find something more positive to do with your life lol
joking because of your no on screenshot xD
Oh right
The time you spend here typing as many messages as me, is as productive as me typing whatever i'm typing
it's all not productive, this is a discord discussion bud
i do muay thai, i hope you find something good to do
mr 30k messages
In all honesty, I prefer defending an undefendable opinion than agreeing with a certain kind of people
And if you keep asking me obvious yes or no questions which only have one possible answer I'll keep answering the answer you don't want to hear
nevermind i mean, mr 140k messages. holy
and yet, despite that, i don't actually spend my memory on thinking about those who have wronged me on the internet
You prefer to spread misinformation by defending something wrong, rather than agreeing with me?
So if I say "germany was the bad guys in ww2", you'd rather disagree with me than accept the truth?
We've gone way offtopic
god damn
Lmfao you keep proving yourself to be illogical
What
random radical extreme
No matter how annoying someone else is, if they say "grass is green" i will agree w it
That's because you've never met yourself
it was an example to show how illogical bubu is
I love this discord sm
You do have a way of finding examples
A very specific way
"i'd rather spread misinformation than admit someone i don't like is right about a fact" lol
it's based on an imaginary situation you made up in your head
Examples are a good way of showing you don't know what you're talking about
but he never did that tho
it's an example of a radical extreme that never happened and never would happen
hypotheticals are made up situations, does it mean they're not useful? NICE LOGIC mr 140k messages
Who is "you" here ? Is it me or you ? Or people in general ?
We're still way off-topic tho
theories are to a certain degree "made up scenarios", does that mean they serve no purpose? nice logic mr 140k
But I did expect the conversation to end this way
Theories are usually based on evidence or logical conclusions
thanks, mister alt account
Mr 140k (Nice Logic Niche)
omg
"i spread misinformation"
New name found
It's just my opinion, glad that you take it as a fact but you really shouldn't
ahah
You literally just said you prefer defending something you know is wrong, rather than admit someone you don't like is right
that just proves you're not credible
whatās that username lmaooo
No matter how much of a liar and a bad person I think you are, I'll still agree with you if you say "quetz is a good addition to the game"
Do you know what petids pieds is?
I never implied you were right in any conversation
300 players with 60fps and low ping
Agreeing with someone can imply both are wrong
Are you sure you want to stick w this? š
i know, question still stands
Yeah, agreeing with someone doesn't mean they're necessarily right
some wild petits propaganda
How is it propaganda
Officials won't have good fps (with 300 players) until years from now
Why wouldn't I
itās easy to sustain just one or two servers, thereās like 30 officials
guys where can i report an hacker? because i was an full adult diablo with full health and got killed by an baby cera..
ok and? petids's gateway is way more alive than officials, it's way more fun
petids is 3 officials in 1 map
There's channels for official servers of each region where you can ping an admin
thanks!
@urban flax here you admit that 300 million dollars technically WOULD help the game's development
proving that you agreed w me, implying i was right
šŖ¤
now that that's proven, the topic ain't necessary anymore
If we talk about the entire conversation, I don't think you were "right", no
You did state a few obvious facts, but your point was, and still is, completely absurd
Itās pointless
I know, I'm just having fun
š³
it is
What was it already ?
Oh yeah, global VC bringing millions of dollars to the devs overnight
the cheese
my point was that fact
and you agreed w it lol
cheeseee
Interesting statement
my point for close to an hour, was "infinite money/300m will help the development"
your point was "no it won't" for an hour until erik came
and then you agreed with the fact, in defeat, so you agreed w me
So that's how you see it
no that's what it was lol
The conversation's topic for close to an hour was specifically about the money and development
I'm afraid I don't recall perfectly, could you show me some screenshots ?
The bait is very inticing
You don't know how to check your own message history despite 30k msgs?
I prefer when you post screenshots
adult deino will ruin adult suchos lol
if youre talking about subs/juvies... yeah duh
so lungeable in the water lol, where theyll mostly be fighting you
the fact that this discussion is still going is wild
deino is not getting buffs to contend with something like the land apexes because its not meant to. this is confirmed by kissen. no hooting nor hollering will fix it
i missed all of it im just picking up where i left off
fair
Its pretty much the deino having fractures guy using a motte and bailey over and over until it devolved into this
@wheat drift just play on petids
officials are just not good
like they're bad, genuinely bad
dude why are u advertizing pettits 24/7 š
i'm not an admin or a mod or anything there
officials are just bad and don't deserve any attention because servers like petids exist
tf does that suggestion even have to do with petids
petids doesn't even change the spawn zones lmao
eu4 official has less fps than petids even though petids have 300 cap
Do you lack a thought process?
"None of the spawns are meaningful, they all require hours of walking/swimming for player interaction"
"deino groups are basically non-existent"
The main problem here is that he misses player interaction
okay, but what that suggestion has to do with petits
petits doesnāt change the spawns
Last I played on petits, the hotspot still at south plains lol, so deinos would still wanna go there
if you're bored because you don't find enough interaction, don't play official
south plains, highlands, north jungle are all hotspots
and throughout the map, you'll find players
omg you actually changed your username to mr 140k xdddd
I just prefer not dealing with high ping and rules, so me no likey petits
thatās so peak
no rules make server a bad served imo
with no rules you can play however you want
Petids gateway is active everywhere, and has more hotspots
Officials are irrelevant and bad
i frankly prefer no rules. i find admins on isle servers quickly become exceptionally... nosey
iāll be honest 300 players is too much for small map like gateway, itās okay if you want constant player interaction, but you know if thereās players everywhere itās getting boring
like the time i got stalked by some admins for breaking their rules that apparently were only enforced for me and my friends, while "regulars" got a free ticket to just ignore them
Official gateway is pretty empty, 100 players is simply not enough to make the map alive
Anecdotal alleged irrelevant experience
around 200 is good, 300 is just wild, especially in places like sanctuaries
tHIS IS PEAK COMEDY
you've taught me a lot
oops
anyways
How is 300 wild for gateway?
officials have better ping for me so me likey more
because gateway is not big enough for 300 players
also i despise how petits spawns FULL ADULT DEINOSUCHUS CORPSES for free around the map
i donāt like players being everywhere
How is it not?
that is unnecessary handholding for so many creatures
too many interactions, too many players
Ok go have your fun growing in a corner of the map in 100pop , you definitely one of those
you can also grow in a corner on petits lol
that impacts nothing about the mighty cornergrow meta
Attacker's problem was lack of player interaction, that's why i suggest he just go play on petids
harder on petids than on official
his problem was that it was hard to get to south plains lol
iām having tons of fun, if i want more player interactions i go to the hotspots, if i dont i stay at the less populated spots, on petits players are everywhere
@limber hull ultracrepedarian subserviant ass observation
the only way for you to get player interaction is to go to hotspots? š that should not be a thing
in petids you always have to be aware, that makes it more realistic survival-wise
you're always immersed
south plains is still the hotspot on petits. he'd still struggle to get there
this ain't DoD
i said āmoreā
Wait petits does that
you bet
Nope
at least 200 of my hours is in petids, both NA and EU. you're just lying lmao
definitely does with carno corpses if thereās a lot of carnivores starving
Petits has a lot of problems and has to constantly shoot carnivores in the foot in order for the server to not blow up from corpse count. A good in-between would be better for population
i know it does because all of my mates who play on petits a ton say it does, and i just keep stumbling upon full adult deino corpses
it won't blow up from corpse count regardless homieboo because of corpse despawn mechanic
play cera, go to the shore, sniff, and there's a bunch of random dead animals out miles into the ocean that shouldn't be there. Those are the corpses designed to deal with the "lack of AI"
there's stegos out there for some reason
corpses despawn alot fyi
and no. the lack of ai is to force player interaction
If you read the entirety of my message, you would see that I already addressed that
i've had 5 regulars of petits tell me the server does spawn these corpses, and you tell me it doesn't
it doesn't spawn corpses what?
it does lol
it def does
Yes there is a system to spawn corpses for juvies
(except it also spawns full adult deinos for some bizarre reason)
i know this because i FOUND said full adult deino just kinda lying around in the middle of nowhere
and i was super excited till my mates said "nah, that's a spawned corpse"
much less interesting after that
i thought i stumbled across something super rare, but it was apparently a common thing
HES NOT
It's new. And the root cause of needing that system is that carnivores are struggling due to lack of AI and insanely high player count causing body wipes which then requires "help" for carnivores. Which is really a not super great experience
caps lmao
frolo come on we played tgt yesterday
spawning corpses is their way of getting more players
what do you prefer, officials or petids?
oh no
oh yes
bro itās āpetitsā not petids
Playing without the carnivore handholding system was night and day. I would find immediately adult maia corpses, adult carno corpses, etc, right after respawning as a baby. The issue with this system is that is has to exist in the first place due to corpse wiping, and corpse wiping has to exist due to extremely high player population. So like I said- a happy population medium would fill out the map a little more while also not destroying the frames and performance enough to facilitate corpse wipes for lower end hardware
how many times you will call it petids lmaoo
pieds works completely fine and 300 seems pretty perfect as a pop
You can say it works completely fine but that is simply not true
I wish corpses could not tank performance as much
well petits aint that good, the only good thing are the player counts and stuff it gives (other servers do the same anyway) I dont like the way admins are meant to act. with not allowing you to appeal but they keep you in the discord to make their server bigger than what it seems. admins arent meant to act like petty tyrants while the owner himself acts like a petty tyrant favoring people who are streamers. Its so dumb I jsut want a server thats fair to the players. I want a server the size of petits that is actually good and acts upon appeals and gives actual warnings. so
lol
petids has a tyranny issue?
true tho
That's unsurprising
have you not seen all the stuff surrounding it atm? it permabanned a streamer over literally playing on a server that wasn't petits
actually hysterical tho ngl
You were clearly stream sniping. We saw you on multiple replays where it was obvious while you also were in the guys twitch chat
Poutine has been summoned
wait what? we played yesterday night
When did u get banned
buddy thats his side of the story I joined his stream after what happened š
he wasn't. he has several people who can vouch for him
stream sniping is a serious ruining steamers experience thingy
frolo got exposed lmaoo
poutine is better at managing petids than the devs are at managing officials
gulp
Minimal effort is better than no effort yes
like sure ban me i dont honestly care.
thats fax
we played troodon yesterday like when did it happen
i haven't seen the devs ban anyone unfairly 
This is probably beside the point of any general feedback posts though
dont need to harass me bro like come on
That seems to be rather common these days
where did we took on the harass road?
I have a brand new Alienware PC and still experience high ping swings and severe fps drops in areas with a large number of bodies or petits, which as mentioned is fixed by corpse wipes (unless they have a 'ddos attack' which more likely probably means their servers are overloaded). Corpse wiping is inherently damaging for carnivore players as it ruins the enjoyment of hunting and killing another player, and I have personally lost almost every player body I hunted to a wipe, causing me to stop trying to play on the server.
The fact that such frequent corpse wipes need to happen in the first place is due to performance issues, which is due to high body count, which is due to high population. All I'm saying is that I don't want officials to have these same issues. This a happy medium of maybe ~150-170 players instead of 100 or 200+ would be nice.
i saw flows typing..
who is flows
lol
ping is purely of your wifi connection and wifi card
that's your anecdotal subjective opinion, doesn't happen to me so
it's funny that it spawns corpses, then has to delete them because there's so many corpses
i have a legion 5 pro laptop and i seem to be doing better than your pc lol
arenāt corpse cleanups automatic?
Great for you?
players of official will always complain about lack of player interaction
so petids is the only solution
I think this has strayed awful far from being #general-feedback-discussion
itās petits LMAOOO the fact that you keep typing it wrong says a lot honestly
petids was a suggestion to someone saying they miss player interaction in #general-feedback
this started because south plains doesn't have a deino spawn lmao
Aye, came in to see if anyone had been talking about Deino south plains spawn, and saw all'a this instead
I know, and it's been thoroughly derailed in my view
I am quite literally only saying 150-170 pop is better for lower end devices because higher pop causes corpse wipe or body assistance systems to have to be implemented which cheapen the experience of the game. Full stop. Please stop focusing on the fact I dislike petits because you like petits. It is merely an example for use of what I would prefer the official servers do not do.
Pretty sure there can be other options than that particular server
LMFAAOO
well yeah but most of them have snowflake rules
I'm sure someone could argue that for Petits as well
nah, its alright, we just went a lil bit more onto discusing the general feedback feedback's discusion
This is a circling convo anyway. We get daily suggestions about lowering playercap and doing X and Y. Can't please everyone
Anyways in my incredibly humble opinion, Deino players can all go suffer for choosing to play as the RNG environmental hazard
Petits has basically no rules wdym
Anyway, player interaction on officials may or may not be lacking, especially if the statement of not seeing people all the time still applies. Not sure on that one though.
300 players is good dont change
omg he typed it right, heās evolving
yeah thats fair
I honestly look forward to what it's gonna be like when y'all push it to 400 lol, ultimate isle fun
I didn't say I would listen to them. I'm just stating a fact. You can't have it all
400 is too much for gateway lol
make it 340 c:
its alright, maybe
where did you even come from?
i mean if you want whole map to be south plains yeah sure
300 last night and i was honestly not running into anyone highlands, west rail, south plains
having constant player interactions is not good.
That is another good point in that higher population and constant player interaction makes every area feel like an exhausting war zone
basically yeah
24k messages, in officials - at least 50% of the map has close to 0 player interaction
that shouldn't be a thing. the map should be alive
Please quit spamming stickers and add something valuable to the conversation
in officials, it's not survival anymore
in petids, you always have to look over your shoulder
Higher player count doesn't increase the population percentage of lesser-used areas of the map. It just makes the "popular" areas worse
a survival game should always have you cautious, officials are useless at that
The officials are definitely still survival
all the pachys I have annihilated with carno
that is absolutely wrong , you don't play pieds
you have never touched pieds in your life if you think the lesser used areas aren't more used in pieds compared to official
Why would I choose to walk into a cesspit
At the same time, they might not want you to always run into things. You can be cautious on the chance/risk you do run into things, even if you only do so rarely. Since you still don't know when you might.
for what reason you check the amount of messages people sent? lmao
there is 10fps on threadripper and rtx a6000 on sp, that makes other places more popular
to see how little of a life some people have
wdym?
They mean that it's time to stop obsessing over this topic and start anew
Can we move away from worshipping pieds and just look at the actual facts of how it feels to play in an area completely saturated by players (arcade type of fighting, too much focus on pvp or avoiding pvp) and a less populated area (wary, silence is uncomfortable, something might be watching you)
At the end of the day the game is survival horror
real, letās find another topic to argue over
guys hop on petits pied to argue more c:
Maybe it's time to consider different servers with different rules and settings attract different types of players and that's fine
Additional dimorphism could be cool if it's not too much effort to do
translation: stop talking about petits for the love of god
Maybe I should offer my take on buffing stego, that ought to be fun
lmao
No thank you. Arguing isn't discussion. Thanks for stopping the conversation lol
Though I struggle to imagine what could be done
do it
no need to put god in this convo
do tell?
I'd say that's the whole point of having the ability to change settings/rules and all that
micheal jackson is so majestic š
This.
Prolly oughta take that to offtopic or dms bud
Don't wanna draw the wrath of the admins
If there's some proper feedback to discuss about stego, I might, but for now it wouldn't fit "feedback discussion", I was mostly joking as a response to "find something else to argue about", since I'm pretty sure my idea is somewhat controversial at least.
Bet
God damn it's like this channel is incapable of talking about a feedback related subject š lmfao
Someone give random feedback on a random thing and let's talk about that
hmm i still want to hear it
@urban flax Now there's a feedback for you, I believe.
Mind if I DM you then, it's a bit of an essay xD
Send me a copy too rah
@cyan flame also this whole time i thought your pfp was thomasššš
yeah sure!
You and half this discord, yes. xD
wait iām not alone lmaoo
Oh no, far from it.
@bold sedge
9 reasons why stress debuffs are bad (Bubulblu's mixpacking List) :
- Griefers can and will continue griefing even with debuffs, unless they lead to death, which would pose a much bigger problem.
- Depending on the range and timing of debuffs occuring, players can abuse them by regularly getting away from each other and continue griefing.
- It ruins prolonged fights. Some fights in the game can last for 30+ minutes, but the game cannot tell the difference between a fight where no one hits each other for some time and mixpacking.
- Mixpacking isn't necessarily an issue. There is nothing wrong with a group of small dinos hanging around a larger one who they know cannot catch them.
- Temporary alliances can be fine. Two groups of predators can hunt the same prey and decide to help each other until said prey is dead, or two prey animals could stand side-by-side to defeat a powerful predator, without being necessarily griefers. The point of the game is to maximize your chances of survival.
- It promotes deathmatch gameplay instead of survival, by forcing players to either run away or kill anything that isn't their own species.
- A fast dino can purposefully debuff a slower one by following it and causing debuffs. Again, griefers don't care if they're being debuffed.
- It ruins hiding. In a jungle or near water, two players can be very close to each other without being aware of each other's presence. Debuffs occuring would give them away to each other.
- Stress implies forcing psychological reactions on a player, which is a bad thing to do in a horror game. A dino has no reason to be stressed or afraid if the player controlling it isn't. The game should try to scare off the player themselves, not their character.
idk why it looks like thomasā¦
dont say "god damn" please
Will do!
There is an ignore/block button if you'd like to use it but you can't police my language, sorry!
I can do the same nws
Please don't break the rules to bring up controversial topics I'd rather not get in trouble
@bold sedge what are your ideas on how those debuffs would work?
a lot of people worry about trolling with a stress mechanic and I'm not sure how it would be implemented
maybe it could only apply debuffs to the faster species in an altercation, allowing larger and slower animals to be protected against little mixpacking rats (like a cerato and raptor getting debuffs for hanging around tenos and diablos)... But idk
making mix packing or mega more fair or balanced
nerf mixpacking and megapacking š
That doesnāt mean anything as far as weāre concerned
Megapacks are ok but mixpacks are bad\
your one of those making us suffer
if a carnivore is near herbivore after not dealing any damage to any specie for 10-15min it should get some debuff
I feel that any mechanic to "police" grouping limits will either be nowhere near as effective at stopping the behavior and/or far, far too heavyhanded for innocents caught in the crossfire as active moderation
yes good point
Megapacks are definitely not okay and cause just as much unbalance as mixpacks
but im tolking about 30 ceras for example
I just dont wanna fight 6ceras and 4 dibbles at once ok?
I encountered 12 dilos as a solo cerato š
If you dont want to deal with mix packs dont play Official servers
good to hear
Twelve. Like what even
that's why mega/mix packing needs to get debuffed or idk ANYTHING THAT IS NOT POSSITIVE FOR THEM š
Was it 12, or a few and a lot of hallucinations
Important distinction
Your nerver going to see 30 ceras if you do at that point just hide
YES THATS IT
it is atleast 4 dilos idk the count of group tho, 4 is ok
No it was 12 plus hallucinations meaning it was more along the lines of 36
š aka completely doomed

mega/mix packers needs to get some debuffs/nerfs imo
I normally don't like Ceratos or Cerato players but that's just
How would you nerf a player
his dino
Ćrgh.
NO how not what
I hate ceratos because they megapack just as badly as dilos
Dilo and cerato megapacks are very popular. Followed by carno packs
It's unfortunately a case of "best bang for your buck"
IM HAPPY I CHANGED SOMEONE TO GOOD
Cerato gamig is "spam rmb to win" while dilo gamig is "bite 2-3 times and then spam rmb to win"
after 15 min without dealing damage to any specie while being near to a herbivore for a time of 10min in a "that circle thingy" of 50 meters it should get some kind of fever nerf like fast dehrydration and hunger loss
I understand why people do megapacks and how they end up happening (being a lot of generally kind people who want to have fun, or from nesting) but there needs to be something to deter them
Both are barely more tolerable than dealing with 1 Deinosuchus
I was always anti-mix/mega packing
@leaden bronze this tho
The only nerf that would work against mixpacking is making megapacks and mixpacks scentable from afar, you cannot change my mind
Megapacks could likely be handled by parasites but mixpacks are a little less easy to figure out
why do you say if they die that is gonna be bad? like wth
This already exists
I kinda just ignore them and go to another place
The wrath of god has and will always be the best solution to mixpacking, megapacking, and cheating, all in one
Unfortunately there is no god. The admins can't be everywhere at once and they're unpaid volunteers with human lives
Because the punishment to the mixpackers is exploitable and can hurt innocent players
I have found cure to all theese
Mixpacks are a problem but megapacks are not
So even if we made mixpacking or megapacking actually against the rules, even admins couldn't solve it
Die because you didn't notice the deino in the nearby pond you decided to rest on the shore of
50 meters after 25 min? how can an innocent player not see
reverse diet buffs in mix packs
Yes, it just needs to be made more noticeable
Have you been to the new south plains region?
faster dehydration + deino in water doesnt count BOOM
The innocent player.. gets followed.. what can they do
So deinos are allowed to mixpacks but not the rest
nope, hordetest is buggy
So deinos can mixpack as long as they stay in the water?
u gonna make me sick c:
You can still tell how you'd solve the other points, I'm curious
The only mixpacking that is good is with herbs.
deinos cant reliably mixpack as they cant angage in most of fights, all they can do is let someone cross it is like VERY SEEABLE of dude doesnt go away from river or pond
I mean, pay them maybe?
Its can
its can what? I did put many things in there
Yet they do it a lot
Deinos mixpack all the time
then just leave deino is not gonna jump you when your not near river
@vernal ermine I hope they don't even add them because it doesn't fit with the dinos also tf you mean humens with m16s
You kinda have to assume a mixpack near a river or body of water is working with a crocodile
4 dibbles and 2 pachys can indeed jump you
Sure, but how do I know there's a deino underwater
You don't want humaans in game?
Humans and guns are already in game
yea, pretty most of the times is not happening
Unofficials can enable them
rly? does it crash my pc?
You can always find a server that has them disabled once they're officially/fully released though
We need them on officials !!
Make it happen RIGHT NOW !!!!
Yea they've currently got some crashing issues
Its not the humans its there wepons why cant they just make a spear or somethin it would be more fun for me
when I shot it goes "fatal error" c:, even tho I got r5 7600x
How are they going to defend themselves with spears?
Your CPU won't prevent fatal errors depending on the source
Trike missing attack sounds
yes unfortionatly
There's also going to be "humans" who use spears
can prevent most of the issues, like 3957153158215801285127581280 bodys at sp
Propaganda
But said humans will be 9ft tall monstrosities
Perfection
when are u adding that humanoid bat thingy
Me? I'd add it right now if I could
neantherdal after 777 buffs core
But I'm not a dev, I don't make those decisions
Can't you just blackmail them ?
bro spears are short range and far range but they are better at short range also it can fracture through lung or some other organs so its dangerous
I think that's a whole other can of worms
do you know if they are going to add trikes attack sounds soon?
okay but we're talking vs giant dinosaurs
I feel humans with spears are defenseless
a spear is not gonna stop a carno rushing at you at 57,5km/h
a regular human wielding a spear vs most of the roster?
human dead
Presumably
they hunted mamothes with spears your makin fun of
Actually that barely, if ever happened at all
mamothes could not run away and humans were simply too overpowered
which server has humans
And if/when it did happen it took an entire tribe and presumably traps to fell one mammoth
I think the faster mixpacking animal could get the debuffs only. For example: a cerato hangs out with a stego. The stego is chilling, living a normal life. The cerato is suffering very increased hunger and thirst drain due to stress from being around a larger animal. The cerato is being punished for trying to use a larger animal for protection. Now imagine the stego has no interest in mixpacking, but the cerato is still hanging around for protection or is scouting for a large megapack that plans to kill the stego. The innocent stego player who cannot run away from this stupid cera who is faster than it enjoys the benefit of a weaker threat- one that might be slower, or be forced to leave his scout position to eat and drink due to his risk of dying. The stego has a better chance of slipping away
humen's have something op what is it you tell me?
there's VERY little evidence to conclude that early humans EVER hunted healthy, adult mammoths
possibly juveniles or weakened mammoths, sure, but healthy adults? hell no, way too much risk
humans are the only thingy to sweat so humans could hunt anything even a bit slower than them
Which server has humans
Thing is, mammoths weren't slower than humans
little mamoths is what I am talking + no proof c:
they hunted weak ones i know or sick
what about a carno following pachies n such
they where faster but they get tired 100x faster than humens
Weight (*and diet) should also factor in
Oh yeah little ones maybe
But when you said "humans killed mammoths with spears" I thought you meant adult ones
Because if we include juveniles I could probably kill a brachiosaurus bare-handed
humens are smart thats why we dominated the world
Also in game, we're playing, we know what that spear can do, and how easily the human wielding it die.
yea cuz they were wooly and they were very heavy and even todays elephants cant run as long as humans do
Are there any servers w humans?
koala is so braindead tho
anyway, let's run down humans
gen 1: 9 foot tall, can climb, "human" (not really human), probably can use spears, fast, deadly in close range
gen 2: normal height, moves about as well as a regular human can (slower than a stegosaurus lol), great stamina, terrible melee damage, has guns/vehicles/bases to compensate for how terrible it is without them, basically entirely reliant on its possessions to not die
fr its not humans vs dinos its humans vs humans in dino bodies
petit pieds probly?
why tf you gotta slander the koala what did it do
it does not have humans
I wish gen 1 had hair...
Probably doesn't need weapons honestly (gen 1 that is)
I hope they make somethin about humens inteligent abilities and make that useful
Rebuilding/repairing bases
Good point that is a great way of surviving
that is what i meant
inventory management, base/vehicle/weapon repairs, able to use items in general, proximity voice chat are some examples
Absolutely nothing, that's the issue with it
lets go finally
But not lethel weapons fair ones would be perfect
they're gonna be lethal lol
Ark clone
guns tend to be lethal
i mean, if all it takes is "having a gun" and "dinosaurs existing" to be an ARK clone, lots of MC modpacks are ark clones lol
What's special with petit pieds
I can't wait till they add mutants. It's going to be fun being spiderman killing dinos
idk they have human rules i think
yea they do
You can be a human in the server? Like the humanoid
..there are no humans in petit pieds
dont start this again
petits pieds gotta be the best server
Humans won't be out for a year or two
also idk what u mean because humans are not on petits
Tf are y'all saying
they're already out
I tried searching "human" on the searchbar but I found no active server with humans
you can play them atm
human has been played on evrima for years depending on the server you're on
it's not just not like finished at all but it was there
What would happen if they added that skinwalker after rex? Like this early
What servers ?
i dont know that at this moment
So you don't know what your saying
Buddy
norden survival
How many players
a lot
I think guns should have a special damage calculation that makes them apply locational damage modifiers twice
That's the best way to make them properly balanced imo
powerful or terible ahh
So you are saying on norden survival I can play as a human and get guns and vehicles
Not vehicles
vehicles? no. guns? also kind of no because i think they crash the game LMAO
You're not getting guns, humans spawn with them
And there are no vehicles yet
How many years before humans are out? In your opinion
We get gta 6 before humans hahahaha
Easily
Gta 6 before humans is crazy
Hopefully 1
Maybe 2 until they're really working and fleshed out
How many more dinos are we lacking in the roster? Apart from megalania, giga, rex/trike, allo, quetz
alot more lol
A thousand or so
What should the roster of dinos look like before they add humans?
honestly? i reckon we'll seen them soon after rex/trike
Bc truthfully we should have 10 more dinos before humans
there's been a LOT done
But that's not the vision
add allo already
There doesn't need to be a specific amount of dinos before humans tbh
In fact, the sooner the better, as otherwise every existing dino will have to be rebalanced to account for the humans
hard disagree
humans are vital to balance earlier, not later
the later you wait to add humans, the worse things will get for their balance
If you added more dinos that are truly different play style from some of the others then game would be epic
Makes no sense
you know what has a truly different playstyle? humans
Makes perfect sense
makes perfect sense idk how it doesnt
imo dont rebalance dinos but buff humans, dinos should be lethal to humans 90% of the time
they are
How are you gonna balance 10 more playables around humans if humans havenāt already been implemented and balanced around the current playables
if you get jumped by a dino, you die
TL;DR: they are not waiting to add humans until after the entire roster is out, just until after the pillars of dinosaur gameplay are in and sturdy. Likely sometime after elders, we'll have to see if they consider burrowing to be one of those pillars
You don't need humans to balance dino gameplay. That's just what this team is going with
That's a bit early to say this
Some dinos may have it too easy against humans, others too hard, so they'll need a rebalance
That isn't a need it makes no sense how it would be a need
The game could be a full dino game if it wanted to be
dinos should be easy to kill uncareful humans
no, you need humans to balance human gameplay. you add them earlier to balance them around a smaller roster, then make slight adjustments as new dinos are added
In what way will dinos be rebalanced? Like what kind of things will be overpowering humans
Okay that makes more sense
Yes
dinos should kill humans 25/7 imo
I have no idea, I can't see the future
Both should be a threat to each other
Dinos should not go out of their way to kill humans because they're easy prey, they should kill humans because ignoring them might get them killed
Super dumb but I won't argue. Wouldn't do any good
What are they going to do when there's no more dino mechanics to make?
Working on humans doesn't mean they won't be paying attention to the dino experience
20 years until that's a reality
well, yea, of course, dinos don't have infinite mechanics
how cool would it be if you as a human could operate a few facilities that are currently on the map, so Jurrasic Park vibes only just research stations where you as a human then have tasks, like photograph dinosaurs, inspect the dead body of a dinosaur or repair generator in station xy
hardly. we've basically almost got every core mechanic besides... burrowing, basically
Realistically it kinda does
Oh, I though you wanted to have a conversation about this, sorry
burrowing is the only core dino mechanic i can think of that isn't completed
Not focusing entirely on the dinosaur mechanics =/= not keeping them in mind
I get your point but I'm saying it does mean something is on the back burner
And a back burner for this team means barely any progress
This isn't a big dev team
What core mechanics do we have?
itās gotten to the point where people donāt even recognise the core mechanics, incredible
Each dino is very well made imo and has unique mechanics
Pounce for example. Eating as cera to get bile
sparring, climbing, swimming/diving, night vision, diets, pouncing, grappling, flying, there's more i can;t think of right now but you get the idea
I just don't know the definition, I have a few K hours on the game though
Ohhhh ok, hm
There's elders too
Not yet
god I need burrowing and a life cycle system please elders
TRUE, I forgot, elders and burrowing are the two incomplete dino mechanics
and strains, but I personally believe them to be an extension of elders
After we add ray guns
burrowing isnāt even necessarily a core mechanic since itās specific to certain creatures
It's a core mechanic to that creature
yeah okay ābird dogā (recon plane for the United States military during the Vietnam conflict)
Yea I'm good with guns so be afraid owl
I'll take a whole raptor pack down with my pistol
hop on gen 2 wavepoole server
I wouldn't consider strains a core mechanic either
When you pull out your pistol you can get quick draw mechanic like in red dead and slow motion headshot all the dinos
depends on how deep they make the system
I wonder how they'll make strains available, like what will you have to do
not every species will get strain specific forms
but if the strains system allows for advanced forms of mutations, you might get more interesting abilities
Bc how well they did dinos. You understand that this game stands out
Only to be call of duty
Could be interesting though
How do you make slow motion work in a multiplayer setting
Yeah tbh, EVRIMA has become superior as the best dino survival game
Humans will either break the game or make it a bit more fun
I know party animals did that
I have no idea how
Big facts
It probably wouldn't lol. Was just messing around
If humans come in i hope they doesnt make the game bad
It shouldn't. Mutants though? Idk
Maybe an ability causing some sort of uh "domain expansion" making slow motion only a thing within a bubble of the area
That would look and feel weird for those just outside the bubble
Also hell if multiple humans do that in the same vicinity
The isle as it is now, and the isle with humans, will be 2 completely different games
We just have to hope that the isle with humans, is a game that will work
It should bc of Jurassic Park and all that. What do you think about mutants
Mutants? Can you show an example
It would be a real bummer if The Isle with humans doesn't work
At least there unofficials will be able to disable humans at will if they prove to be too much of a bother
I guess it'll "work" but will it be the isle anymore?
I wonder if there'll be unofficials with dinos disabled tho
That sounds stupid but why not
It will only begin being "The Isle" once humans are added
So rust without base building
Precisely
Lol no it wouldn't work
Probably not
Tell that to unofficials server owners
Lmao
sure
How will that not look goofy
What's wrong with them though, balance wise
Let that thing have dilo nightvision, herrera climbing, and hypsi spit
Is it already being modelled?
yep
well, it's still a human, so it'd be extremely squishy
Should humans be able to build structures?
Balance-wise, should they be able to build a base
there's also this variant of gen 1
gen 2 (regular humans) will be able to repair and upkeep structures around the island
this is a gen 1 human?
and they eat other humans or
they're referred to as "cannibals" so yea probably
I don't understand their purpose
Not sure they can handle that. Due to everyone saying the have low fps somehow on this game
ohh hell nah the isle Dinogame -> The Isle Aliengame uff:(
this is always what the isle was intended to be
Why do people always associate mutants with aliens
Also, shouldn't the server pop be higher before humans?
had the game been fully funded on kickstarter, i think we'd have seen a very different isle
(Assuming the map will be as big as gateway upon humans' arrival)
I hope humans have a seperate population to dinos
yeah
how large should each be? 70/70?
I don't see why they should do that
I think dinos should always be at least 100
Let people who want to play dinos play as dinos, and people who want to play humans play as humans
i dont think this is a great idea
people complain about how many other dinos they see now, it'll be a lot worse if half the server is humans
having two seperate queues for every server rather than letting everyone just pick what they want while they're in seems bizarre
it's the same as limiting carnivores, or limiting apexes, or limiting whatever
It has no real purpose and only serves to hide the design flaws that can come with an unbalanced roster
but shouldn't the current server pop be higher before humans' release?
You are making a grave mistake here.
I think server pop should be higher, but "before humans" ? Why ?
what
It's postponing an addition for no good reason
It would have to be separate queues
Okay so assuming we would still be using gateway, or a map as big as gateway
Won't the map end up being even more lonely, with even more areas harboring close to 0 players - if the pop was 100?
Say 40 of the pop was humans and 60 was dinos - assuming humans will huddle up to survive, how will the map feel alive?
I don't think it's the same at all, the gameplay and progression of dinos and humans will be entirely different. Plus I would much prefer to see marjority of a server be juvi apexes than humans
Dinos huddle up to survive
It won't change a thing
100 pop is a game killer anyways. That's way too low
Dinos don't haaaave to huddle up to survive, every dino has its way of surviving
Humans do have to huddle up (i assume) - they're harmless and super fragile
Assuming they will take inspiration from how (not)powerful we are irl
"harmless"
woe, spas-12 upon thee
How many of the 50 humans will have access to that though
I remember update 4 hordetest
Back when I got with a bunch of people and we kicked a FG deino to death
20 of the 50 will probably be freshspawns
probably like 3 maybe lol tbh
Also I got pounced by a juvie raptor and kicked it to death
And I saw some dude run to a hypsi and kick it to death
I'm just assuming that humans will huddle up way more than dinos will
if that assumption is true, isn't 100 pop too little for gateway?
I don't think they will
The main way to survive for humans will be to hide
More people means it's harder to hide
100 pop is already too little!!
Hm
So humans will instantly go to structures and stuff to hide
How will they be able to roam?
By taking risks
I feel humans will absolutely need vehicles from the start of their implementation to the game
mutant people existed in legacy?
Old old Isle had tribal humans
Your suggestion for humans is really good though and actually fits into the games theme
"going down the path" implies they didn't plan to do this since the game was inception
the only difference between then and now is tribals used to be racially questionable stereotypical "native american" type characters, and now they're actually unique
The chance of existing servers that will turn humans off, and still be active with full pop, is imo 100%
Oh boy. A woke
Wait so we won't get tribals because they're offensive?
"a woke"
what does that even mean. Also, no, it just looked dumb
I guess native Americans weren't tribal
That's not the issue lol
š
im not going to touch that, and also, unrelated to my point
the point is having a bunch of native american looking characters on dinosaur island looks dumb and makes zero sense how they can survive better than a dude with a gun, armour and vehicles
by making them mutants with beyond human abilities, you can actually make that less dumb
If they're mutants with hair I'll be happy
I was rewrite xDD I forgott that you can edit your message xD : But I would say: The thing is, I don't have a problem with normal humans, I posted an idea I like in general, but I'm just not a fan of mutants hyper dinos and humans, that's something I don't find nice at all. of course there are people who celebrate it, and people like me who don't like it at all. I just hope that there will be servers that offer gameplay without mutants
@valid brook weve used up 2024-2025s "bucking is useful again" time and now it is back to normal
lmao
this is the 2nd time i've been pounce by raptors, spend most of my stam with no effect. the first time i died, so this time (knowing what i was doing is stupid and i'd likely piss off a few raptors) i took trucuusfdlasfdj or w/e its called and it had 0 effect. only reason i killed then is cause they kept getting glitched during their pounces or pouncing eachother
but Yeah I also think theres also full server without mutants @vernal ermine
(im in many different channels chasing cheaters, if yer saying something directly to me, ping me)
the endless cycle
xDD
tbh
Hasn't Star Citizen basically ceased development now ?
How's this?
I hope you have a good day and don't have to worry about cheaters too much
I think that part was irony/a joke, but I think it's true that things are going way too slow
To the point where even the devs working on the project don't believe in it anymore
its bizarre that people say stuff like this when the HT is actively being updated
How would you make them faster
also the concept of "throw more devs at it, it'll fix itself" is just silly imho
handful gone this mornin. Normally when we get on in the mornin the word spreads and they quickly start leaving the servers enmasse
Nice!
There are games out there releasing more frequently, despite their releases being more complex than the isle's
With that in mind, why are the devs having a hard time with releases for the isle? Why are the updates not getting released sooner
Like what are they missing, is it manpower or what is it
genuine question
what games?
Because small team+huge project+pioneer in its genre
Dead by daylight for example, they release 2 killers and a couple of updates before the devs are even close to finishing 1 playable
I am convinced that in a few years there'll be a bunch of freaks relasing an Isle 2 with better performance, faster updates and better-designed mechanics
But doing that requires someone walking in the dark and lighting up the way beforehand
Is it because the team is small?
A killer in Dead by Daylight is ages less complex than a dino in The Isle
Also much, much bigger team
I'll be real, DbD is HARDLY comparable
It is because of the 3 things I mentioned
For starters I think I can count the animations required for killers in DbD on two hands
It has the benefit of having basically every killer follow a very easy formula
The hardest part is animating, modelling and creating the killer's power
I'd say a DbD killer takes, at maximum, 50 unique animations?
Rex has apparently over 1000. It's not comparable
Idle+variations if there's any
Walk
Attack
Leap over window
Get stunned
Destroy something (often the same as attack)
+2 to 5 animations for their special ability
True
As for survivors, each one of them is 0 extra animation work because they all share the same ones
So it's just model work
Honestly 50 was a massive oversell
Are you saying the isle is the most work-requiring game ?
Oh there's also versions while carrying someone, + hooking someone
And memento mori
But animations while carrying someone are hardly different and might just be a matter of animation layers
Fun fact : I'm currently animating a dragon for Total war warhammer 3, and it's 57 animations (without variations)
And that's already a lot of work
You forgot the totally important and vital feature of steppy on boon totem
Given that, again, we have animals which need entirely new locomotions, abilities, gimmicks, models (for different stages of growth), skin meshes, diet lists/migratory zones, egg models, nesting mechanics, sounds (for each stage of growth), night vision ranges, stats, attack damages (including gimmicks such as bleed, venom, fracture, etc)
Yea probably lol
Isn't it the same as destroying anything else ?
I also find that a bit disrespectful, as if he knew how much the game owners earn from it and that they can afford more devs. Above all, proper development takes time; it's better to take more time than to make something buggy. You can't compare The Isle 2 to Start Citizen at all xD
It is 90% of the time lmao
DbD has built itself a formula for the purpose OF making content easier to produce in quick succession
So comparing it to The Isle, a game which purposely goes out of its way to make each animal exceptionally unique with personality and kit, is not really fair
A W+M1 Legion plays exactly the same as a W+M1 Wraith. A Maia plays NOTHING like a Deino
And in addition I'd say the size of the studio also plays a role. There are so many things that play a role in the economics alone, but we can hardly talk about them because it's none of our business and we don't know.
Uuuhmm akschually since Legion's rework they play VASTLY differently and Legion involves ACTUAL TACTICS and there is a high skill-ceiling and complexity to both characters
Rex in the isle takes more work than 2 killers and game changes in dbd?
Now what if I don't press right click on either then what's the difference
and to say you earn enought money, have more devs is just: š
Their business is not our business
Hehe
funni
For SURE it does
OVER
ONE
THOUSAND
ANIMATIONS
blocked
Would you say the isle is the most hard to develop game?
xD yeah
No. I wouldn't make a sweeping statement like that
Are all killers the exact same in Dead by Daylight, yes or no ?
I would say it's tough
No?
What games out there are harder to update than the isle?
The most hard ? Not at all
idk, i'm not a dev for any of them. I think these questions don't really serve much value to anyone tbh
I think the hardest game to develop out there would be a physics-based game for sure at least
Playing "who's the bestest dev" isn't really doing much for anyone
I dont think the hardest but its also not easy and Star Citizen have his pysics already and just need to add new ships and and make new planets and co, The Isle Devs need to do with new Dinos also new animations, new physics, new sounds, new movements....
Physics-based multiplayer game
Like I'd argue Fortnite would be HELL to develop, but that's backed by billions of dollars in funding and a colossal studio
I gurantee you that when gta 6 releases, its next updates will take way more work than updates in the isle
but gta 6 will still release updates faster and more frequently, so why can't the isle do the same?
GTA6 is being made by one of, if not the largest and most profitable development studios to ever exist
Because GTA6 is GRAND THEFT AUTO 6???
One of the biggest video game franchies in the world?
Yeah that's true, you're right
But why would its updates be faster than the isle's, even though its updates are probably way more requiring than the isle's?
When The Isle sells as many copies as GTA has, maybe you'd have good reason
It's THE biggest franchise š
The Isle is Afterthought's first and only game, Rockstar has had decades of games and therefore profitability
Because it has millions, if not billions, of dollars in funding to back itself on
Not at all comparable lmao
Because Rockstar has hundreds of developers, if not over one thousand employees
Because they have about 100x as many people working on them, and have already set plans for when they're going to make updates and what they're gonna contain
The Isle has around 30 people
And the game will be pretty much finished by the time it releases so easier to update
Rockstar is a much larger studio, so you can't compare that to that. Furthermore, many games are getting faster updates because there's usually less work to be done, as much of it is already perfectly programmed. Rockstar can easily release a new car and a new story in GTA Online; everything is already programmed, including physics, movement, and so on. The Isle has a lot more to do each time they release new dinos, because some have special new characteristics, which can't all be simply copied from existing dinos.
How does the money make any difference, money can't exactly fast forward time
Such a bizarre comparison
Biggest video game franchise in the world, and one of the most anticipated titles in the world vs indie dinosaur game
not fair to compare a AAA company to an Indie
Yes it can also can we stop talking about this
Really stupid convo
šÆ
Money can fund insanely large development crews because developers need to get paid. It can also fund expensive computer programs to use in the game, like physics engines
and licenses
How does more developers mean faster progress?
is this bait or are you setting something up
Because for example. If I ask BMW to manifacture a car, but within a timeframe that is impossible, it won't matter how much money i give them
The developers probably also want to be paid well, and an indie developer has to be able to afford that first. You're underestimating the impact of labor costs.
I just thoroughly believe that the amount of time this game takes between updates has become unrealistic
what do you think would happen if the isle had 1 dev instead of the amount it has right now? Would development time stay the same?
If you ask 1 person to make you a car you're gonna wait for longer than if you ask a group of 50 people to do it together
So you're suggesting that if the isle just hired more dev teams, the game would get updates and dinos faster
if they could do that, yes
Maybe
But it isn't that simple tbh
Yeah so how can you use the same argument for gta 6 then
If it wasn't that simple, why is the answer to gta 6 getting more frequent updates - due to more devs
A bigger team can work on more things at once and make progress faster
But a smaller team is easier to manage, especially when breaking ground
depends on scope and execution, the isles original scope was 3 dinoās iirc but to please the community it is where itās at now
Because Rockstar has embraced the complexity that is handling thousands of devs working on the same game and has adapted their management to be able to do it efficiently
okay and how are you gonna find the right people for that job?
"Work on my niche dinosaur survival game with mutants and 55+ roster members" is gonna make most traditional skillsets seem rather redundant
Every Dev costs money, a lot of money, they will paid, no matter you earn with your game money or not, in many countrys you need to pay also social costs for your workers, thats very expensive. so dont write everytime: "How about more devs?" Just Team behind The Isle knows how much devs they can afford
I guess by offering enough money?
guys please learn econimie again thats all not easy
i dont think you understand how this works
Why don't the team just hire more devs? Like why not just hire more teams, if it's true that more devs = faster progress
Money can't substitute passion
This kind of project requires passion
do you know that they have enought money?
What's stopping them from hiring for example 50 more devs
Past mistakes
maybe they don't want to have to manage more people? The dev team tends to be very close for The Isle, and I doubt just throwing in a bunch of new people really works for how they like to do things
I write it 10 times!
Like what
That's almost entirely unsustainable
Unsustainable as in financially?
Like a certain dev having a disagreement with the project manager and proving they should not have been trusted with the game's development despite being a competent programmer
What's the problem with doing that though
Why not just put some energy in orchestrating larger dev teams
Are you still arguing over this useless debate about fkn devs
you can actually hire 50 more devs but what is when you dont need them anymore, Many simply quit, and surprise, in some countries, even termination is expensive. And what if you suddenly don't earn enough with 50 more developers? Assuming you pay $3,000 without taking into account social security contributions and other costs, that's already $1,800,000 more per year!!!!!! But what if you don't earn as much from the game? You see, even with just $3,000, a lot of costs add up. As a company, you have to be careful when it comes to personnel.
I see we are autistic today
Why not spend some energy into learning game development yourself so you can make your own game ?
you should prolly delete that (friendly warning in case you get banned)
Is it against the rules?
That's not relevant to the conversation, I'm just curious about the decisions around the isle specifically
What is preventing them from just hiring more devs and managing them efficiently
It is
If you're not willing to learn game development in its entirety just because someone asked you to, you can probably understand why someone else would not be willing to learn large company management just because someone asked them to, right ?
Ohhh gotchu now I understand your point with the rhetorical question
Just stop telling The Isle team to hire more employees when you obviously can't or don't want to understand the magnitude of these decisions. I find it completely disrespectful to say, "Why aren't they hiring more? Why don't they do things this way?" Sorry for the harsh words, but that's simply unacceptable. And it keeps coming up in the channel where the team is attacked like this!
But that doesn't really correlate
If they're able to speed the development of their game while still keeping the same quality, that's just positive
here's a simple answer, they don't want to
long answer, orienting, training and managing all those new devs is an effort that takes time away from development, and doesn't mesh well with their very close-knit team design
What if they don't want to speed it up ?
Why
Because they're fine with the rate at which it goes ?
I wrote this 10 times
he doesn't understand
Because Don doesn't believe he would be good enough at management that he would be able to direct more devs into making the game faster without sacrificing his own health, as has happened in the past ?
Developing the game faster with the same quality is just good though for the community, the game would flourish
why is that not in the best interest for the devs?
men read my text and you have the answer
@maiden anvil great idea to make Carno even weaker
š¤¦š»āāļø i cant anymore
My message above
Does the team have the capacity to hire 30 more devs? If not then I understand why they haven't done it
honestly? i dont think you ever will
if you can be told why a dozen times and still not get it, i accept the fact that you will never get it
he will never get it I argument it with 20 points and he still doesnt get it or wont
I just acknowldged that I understood
To be fair, do you think a small game hunter should be strong?
It shouldn't be too strong (Which it isn't), but it shouldn't be too weak either (Which it would be if your suggestion were added)
The only problem with the current charge is the hitbox is a bit big, reducing it a bit would be perfect
a lot of devs get snatched up immediately by larger companies
Perhaps my suggestion would be better if Carno was still 1.8 tons. Idk⦠I just donāt like it using charge as a combat advantage
This may be my opinion but I donāt like seeing Cerato loosing to a Carno
it's Carno's ability, why shouldn't it be used in the fight?
Iād just prefer it using it as a hunting tool. Probably just my opinion
The fight is a hunt...
To creatures around its size || which it should not hunt ||
You really don't like Carno, huh Xd
There is no need to keep Carno even more attached to the smaller dinos
with enough money it won't be a problem though so i don't see why they haven't done it
My theory is maybe they prefer developing over a longer time and don't want the game to update fast. Which is fine in itself, because:
Perhaps it's a passion project that they want to work with for a long time. Developing the game faster would ultimately just lead to them finishing too early.
Perhaps they want the project to span another 15 years or so, so that it can be a large part of their lives. So the focus here isn't "efficiently" developing the game fast with more devs, it's rather to expand the lifetime of the game
Maybe it will keep the game alive for longer also, developing over time instead of finishing too early
Who said I hate it? I just think it should be part of its niche to specifically hunt smaller things
But the way I see it right now, itās only agree to disagree
But the charge is part of the hunt, but the things that Carno can hit. There is no need to limit Carno even further
Correct me if Im wrong, but currently if carno was made to be only able to hunt things smaller than it, it would only have 4 prey options that actually satiate it, those being galli, omni, pachy and dilo, which isnt even on its diet.
Carno would literally starve to death
Then I blame the Carno players who want to hunt FG Tenos
Carno is stuck hunting things smaller than 2t and you want to lock him into only hunting things smaller than 1300?
Yes
Kkkkkkkk
^
The roster simply isnt big enough to support such an insanely specialised playstyle
You died to a Carno recently, Isn't that right?
Perhaps in the future?
Years, maybe
Funny but I rarely play this game
I could tell
Letās hope some day there will be enough of small things so Carno can become what itās supposed to be
"I want my dino survival game to have FOMO and microtransactions" isn't something I thought I'd see posted