#zigbee-archived

1 messages · Page 151 of 1

lean swift
#

Does anyone here have experience with Zigbee group bindings? I'm not having any success getting my dimmer switch to directly control my smart bulbs.

tropic depot
#

some devices don't behave well

#

what type of dimmer?

lean swift
#

GE/Jasco Enbrighten dimmer switch (43080)

#

In theory it supports it, but I know reality is often different.

tropic depot
#

hrm Adminiuga may know... I stay away from GE. Had some zwave plugs fail and several appliances

#

so I avoid them all together now 😄

#

lol

lean swift
#

Lol. 🙂 I wanted to avoid it, but Inovelli's Blue switch is still a little ways off, and I wanted to start playing now.

#

As a more general question... where's a good place to go to learn more about clusters and bindings? I've always run everything through HA, so I've never gotten into that aspect of Zigbee. And is there a way to see what a device's current bindings are?

dense owl
#

interesting, thank you. I suppose it's likely that something like a smart plug would almost certainly act as an extender?

dry fossil
#

Without knowing the exact model, that's a fairly safe assumption.

#

If you have any in mind, maybe someone here can confirm.

#

I think it tends to be the bulbs and wall-mounted switches that are hit and miss.

twilit narwhal
dense owl
#

still planning so I don't have any specific models in mind yet, but thanks or the info all

lean swift
raw hazel
#

hi guys. does anyone know the work arround zigbee devices that pair just fine with Home Assistant creating ONLY the devices, not the entities???
I have a dozen of 2 gang zigbee dimmers (tuya) that paired ok but did not create the entities, just the devices.
TS0601
by _TZE200_e3oitdyu

molten linden
gleaming jay
#

I recently added some aqara magnet door sensors, temp sensors, and ikea outlet, usb repeater, and the ikea switch for the outlet. It's my first dive into zigbee and so far two of my door sensors have dropped off and now so has my ikea switch

gleaming jay
#

I got one of the magnet sensors going but it's dropped off again

#

the switch is the latest to go

#

and i'm using ZHA

gleaming jay
#

i've managed to get the switch to re-pair now, but i'm concerned this is just going to keep happening

gentle flint
#

They are not wrong, i just wish it was selectable behavior. Well, this is fixed in thread, so I'll wait till those appear on the market

gentle flint
gentle flint
ivory hound
#

anyone has any idea why a perfectly good Aqara Weather Multisensor would not pair anymore in zigbee2mqtt? context of the issue: it was in my network and it just die I've clicked little button to wake it up (nothing) I've clicked button to wake it up and try to reconfigure from z2m (nothing) clicked button and try to remove it (fail), force remove it from the network (success). now I can't add it back (battery has a bit over 3v, led blinks when button is pressed)

#

my take is the device somehow is still in my network and I don't see it, this is why is not pairing anymore

#

any ideas how to solve this situation?

inland coral
inland coral
mighty river
#

I hope someone can help me 😅 ...So I'm new to HA and trying to migrate from OH to HA. I'm running in some issues with one Zigbee device (deconz). In HA it only has one Entity and that covers the battery status. It concerns the ZG2833K8_EU05 by Sunricher. In Deconz it is reflecting as expected with 4 zones (as it was working in OH)

fierce ledge
#

Situation: I have a blank sheet. Very new Home Assistant install, no Zigbee set up yet. I have a Conbee II stick, bunch of Tradfri and Aqara hardware.
Should I go for Deconz, ZHA or Z2M? 🙃

graceful notch
#

z2m

#

no questions asked

#

😆

#

but it's a bit more work to get it set up

violet dagger
#

conbee II on z2m? eeeh

graceful notch
#

works perfect here

#

0 glitches

#

been running it for a while now

violet dagger
#

thats good considering its still in experimental support for z2m

graceful notch
#

yeah I never understood why it's still experimental

#

literally 0 issues (unless user errors)

#

I don't even use an usb cable 😄

proven vector
#

Uff seems like lots of troubles with aqara. I also have installed 2x window/door sensors near each other and integrated them into HA with ZHA. While 1 is working perfectly fine, the other one gets it's status stuck on Closed/Open position. When I re-pair it in ZHA it works fine for some moment, and then gets stuck again after around 20-30 minutes. Any suggestions on what to do?

graceful notch
#

how do you pair it ? how far away is it from the concentrator/router/repeater..

#

is there anything in the log, if you enable debugging ?

austere patio
proven vector
#

No I didn't tried to change the battery yet. Like for me it works, and HA is showing that battery is at 100%. I have 2nd sensor nearby, like in less than 1cm - that works totally fine.

#

How can I enable debugging logs?

austere patio
#

Battery level reporting for Aqara sensors is unreliable

#

Many of mine report effectively the same voltage for the entire lifespan of the battery so the percentage never drops

proven vector
#

they are showing 100% on both, so I assume they also are not showing the real %

#

Still when I re-pair the sensor it starts working, then again gets stuck after ~30minutes. 2nd sensor that is nearby works totally fine...

austere patio
#

If you exchange batteries between the two sensors then that would be pretty indicative of the problem

#

Older Aqara sensors have no configuration, they just join and report stuff

#

So if it's not reporting then it either didn't join, or can't report due to a weak battery or other adverse network conditions (which likely isn't the case if the second sensor works)

fierce ledge
# graceful notch z2m

That's the only one I haven't tried yet haha. It requires reflashing the conbee right?

mighty river
#

Can someone help me out getting a non supported device working? I already joined the device to the zigbee network. Type device: "LED1935C3"

#

Can't figure out how to add the new device

#

Already found the problem! Needed to start "Zigbee2mqtt edge" instead of the normal one!

sour shadow
#

The problem is actually that you're using the old add-on repo for Z2M

#

See the pinned messages

graceful notch
#

no reflashing needed 🙂

pearl hawk
#

Can I somehow see which zigbee events are triggered? I use ZHA and a Conbee II USB stick, if that matters.

sour shadow
#

devtools -> Events and you can listen to events

pearl hawk
#

Yes, but which events to listen to? Ah, sorry, my HA must have been lobotomized, I just restarted and now I have zha-events in the list of events. I thought it should be something there, but didn't see it until a restart...

dry fossil
#

You won't see things in the list until you have at least one listener for that event type.

#

ZHA maybe adds its own listener 🤷‍♂️

fierce ledge
graceful notch
#

No problem, it’s the only thing i did, other fw through a deconz docker and then started using z2m

mighty river
sour shadow
#

the P has an amplifier, so is a long term better choice

mighty river
#

I guess that the range should be a lot better than the Ikea hub?

sour shadow
#

Well, there's a lot of it depends, but ... probably

mighty river
#

I mean, I don't have issues now.

sour shadow
#

As it's a mesh network however, range from the stick is less important

mighty river
#

I will go with ZigStar Stick v4, I see it has EU shipping so thats great

#

Oh it even has a LAN version!

#

Thanks @sour shadow !

pastel scarab
#

I am using deconz with home assistant and I just bought some aqara water sensors that I plan to use as leak alarms in the kitchen. Since they are expected to remain “dry”, how do I monitor and make sure that they are in range and working (i.e. transmitting)?

sour shadow
#

All sensors should report in every few hours

#

I assume that deCONZ exposes that last seen information in some way

violet dagger
#

You can lick them from time to time

#

👅

pastel scarab
#

Haha

violet dagger
#

There's also a button on them to awaken them

sour shadow
#

Check the attributes of the entities, see if there's some information about when it last reported in

pastel scarab
#

I see “last changed” and “last updated” in the home assistant GUI. Does either of those reflect when they last transmitted something?

sour shadow
#

I'd expect last_updated is likely the one, but I don't use deCONZ

#

Zigbee2MQTT has a last_seen attribute

pastel scarab
#

Easy enough to monitor them for a while to determine if that’s the case. Thanks!

sour shadow
#

Or go push the button on it to get it to check in, and see what changes

vivid shore
#

So, .. for anyone who might have some input on this.. I currently run deconz on a Conbee II stick hosted on a Intel NUC. I'm a bit sick of the shole 2 meter USB 2 cable trying to run it as far away as possible from anything that might interfere with the radio. Is there a good alternative for Zigbee that I don't have to deal with these shenanigans with and can just plug into the NUC without worrying?

sour shadow
#

Not that you can plug into the NUC - the problem is the interference from it after all

#

There are network based coordinators, such as the ones Tube sells, but that's the only other option

vivid shore
#

hm

#

tbh sounds a bit interesting.

#

the whole BT interference thing is a pain in the ass.. especially since i dont even use BT for the NUc

sour shadow
#

It's not just BT, it's USB 3.0, and any other form of RF

vivid shore
#

the USB3 issue isnt just a conbee thing?

sour shadow
#

No

#

See the pinned messages

vivid shore
#

huh.. yeah ok

#

found a post about wifi channel overlap.. you know if you lose your zigbee network if you change the channel for your deconz stick?

sour shadow
#

Yes

vivid shore
#

damn.. that'd ba a last resolution then.. gotta check if anything is near ch 11

sour shadow
#

Odds are good there is, channel 11 is a terrible choice

vivid shore
#

yep

#

ofc theres loads of shit on 11

#

wish i'd seen that before heh

austere patio
#

If your network is mostly bulbs and other routers then there's a good chance they'll pick up the new channel after a hard reboot (off for 10s)

vivid shore
#

good tip, worth trying before a full reset if it comes to that

left shale
#

Does anyone have recommendations for Hue hub emulation software for zigbee2mqtt? Looking to get hue sync back from when I converted from the hue hub. Hopefully trying to run it on my HA machine but I have had difficulty in the past due to port 443 being in use

#

Thanks in advance and feel free to ping me.

dry fossil
#

It wouldn't be anything to do with Z2M. You'd run something in/via HA, and HA knows to control the bulbs via MQTT.

#

I don't know what it does or if it's any good, but I think I've seen people discuss an #add-ons-archived for Hue.

worldly apex
#

Hello, I have a Zigbee Tube hub cc2652 and trying to pair a hue switch. I have the hue switch in pairing (blinking red light on the front) but I cant get it to pair with the Tube hub.
thoughts?

molten linden
worldly apex
#

I did. I get the green red flash. its in pairing, but not connecting.

#

Am i missing something to put the gateway into pairing?

molten linden
#

Zha or z2m?

worldly apex
#

trying to z2,

#

ugh. z2m

molten linden
#

They have a permit joins button in the GUI I believe

#

Definitely should be supported

worldly apex
#

I am sure it is... I think its me

#

🙂

#

should the GW be in BLS for pairing?

molten linden
#

BLS?

worldly apex
#

zBSL

molten linden
#

No that is only for firmware updates for the coordinator

#

No need to mess with those unless doing an upgrade

stray wolf
#

i just got my zig-a-zig-ah! today. what do i do to update the fw?

molten linden
neat anvil
#

So, I live in NA, and I have been for a while trying to find a resonably priced zigbee wall dimmer switch to just drop in and replace the one I have there already. But I can't seem to find any. Does anyone have a suggestion?

bold dune
#

😁 that was my issue I reported, but it is back I guess?

bold dune
#

I have some sengled bulbs that report power is watts is there going to be any changes to these to make them show up in the energy dashboard or is it something I need to do manually?

dusk bough
#

@sour shadow hey bud, when you get a sec, it seems the config worked, cause it successfully added the intigration and set up the usb dongle i assume, but when i go to search and then try to pair the aquara temp and humidity sensor it wount connect

dusk bough
#

nvm

#

i got it

#

i undid everything and reinstalled zigbee's intigration and it worked

stray wolf
#

anyone have fun ideas and use cases for the aqara cube? i bought two.

stray wolf
#

also how do i restrict zha to only scanning on certain channels? that way i can have it scanning on a channel my router isn't broadcasting on? or am i thinking of this the wrong way

left shale
dry fossil
#

Which is all fine... but nothing to do with this channel 🤷‍♂️

old swan
#

Hi, I am trying to get my Ikea trådfri to connect to my deCONZ but I only get failed to connect. I am trying with both a 5 button and a 2 button

#

it starts to blink rapitly and then a fading blink

dry fossil
#

My experience with IKEA stuff is that it takes a ton of attempts to get them to pair. Unless someone comes along with better suggestions, I'd just say keep trying.

#

Took over 30 attempts each for me to get the repeaters to pair (with Z2M).

old swan
#

I cannot see a choice for the two button,only the five, can i add the two button there as well? the choices I have is 5 button remote or dimmer

brave horizon
brave horizon
brave horizon
obsidian sandalBOT
#

To format your text as code, enter three backticks on the first line, press Enter for a new line, paste your code, press Enter again for another new line, and lastly three more backticks. Here's an example

Don't forget you can edit your post rather than repeatedly posting the same thing.

For over 15 lines you must use a code share site such as https://www.codepile.net/ (pick YAML for the language) or https://paste.debian.net/ (pick YAML for the language).

austere patio
brave horizon
old swan
wicked heart
#

Hello, not sure if this is the right channel: I am experiencing issues with Conbee II and ZHA. It worked for over 6 months and now it stopped, it doesn't even see new devices on the network to add. Anyone experiencing the same problem? Running the latest HA on RPI4

sour shadow
#

What changed? Did you upgrade HA? Something else?

wicked heart
#

it stopped working before I attempted the upgrade. Nothing really happened other than I had a power failure and some of the ikea plugs stopped working (they are acting as routers). Since then nothing really started working. I removed all ikea devices and only try to pair aqara sensors... even brand new ones.

pastel scarab
#

I had a question yesterday regarding aqara water leak sensors connected through deconz. My problem was that i could not find a way to determine when they were last seen. HA seems to not update “last updated” unless the value of the sensor changes. In deconz I can see when the sensor was last heard from. I tried zha today for the first time to see if it would behave differently. It seems to be the same, although in the zha config I do have “last seen” under zigbee info. Is it possible to create an entity of this information so I can build an automation that monitors the sensors and make sure they do not become unavailable?

sour shadow
#

Template sensor will do it

pastel scarab
#

Alright that seems promising, albeit challenging 😀

sour shadow
#
template:
  - sensor:
      - name: Sensor thingy last seen
        state: "{{ state_attr('sensor.thingy', 'last_seen') }}"
pastel scarab
#

Cool that looks like a great start!

#

Thanks

hoary crest
#

if i get a Electrolama zig-a-zig-ah! stick, can i use it with z2m while still using my raspbee II with deconz on the same host? so i can migrate my network without a bigger downtime

sour shadow
#

Yes

#

Just ensure you use different channels and pan_id values

hoary crest
#

great, thanks, now just to wait the stick becomes available again 😄

austere patio
hoary crest
#

I'm aiming for recreating my whole network as i have several dead devices on my current one anyways 🙂

#

great opportunity do do some cleanup 😄

austere patio
#

Ah. Good luck with the new stick then!

hoary crest
#

thank you for the offer though 🙂

dusk bough
#

so i have a centralite 4256050-rzhac
and the ZHA doesnt see it's enegy monitoring

#

but i know it has it

#

is there a way to rewrite the config to make it show the energy usage also?

#

search "Electrical Measurement Cluster" in the doc to get where it's power info is if your interested in taking a look

minor atlas
#

kshaffer

dusk bough
#

if someone is good at scratch making devices work like this, ill offer some free stuff for someone who wants to help, just ping me

#

ive got some zigbee keypads, door sensors and alarm stuff that comes up as unk_model that would be cool to use

nocturne depot
#

I'm not sure if this is the right place to ask - i've a couple of tuya zigbee light switches connected via a Silvercrest zigbee hub and they work fine in HA with the Tuya V2 integration, but they seem to fall asleep(?) semi-regularly and are then completely unresponsive in HA (and in the Tuya app) until they're "woken up" again by manually pressing the switch. I've checked and restarting the zigbee hub doesn't help. Anyone know what's going on with that?

stray wolf
#

if i use the official hue hub i can get rate limited by spamming too many light commands, right? what if i hook my lights directly up to my zigbee adapter, will this get around rate limits?

eternal drum
#

I just got Slaesh's stick, and I'm trying to set up ZHA integration and I'm getting the error that says "couldnt start ZNP" unhandled command sys.resetind Any help on this?

#

After some time this error goes away and it seems happy, however it can't seem to find devices that are in pairing mode.

dusk bough
#

lol

#

so also have a lamp module

#

jasco ZB3101

#

it gives me power consumption but no on off switch is recognized

#

i cant win

#

lol

stray wolf
#

anyone have recommendations for zigbee lights and lamps (like the hue go lamp)?

violet dagger
#

You would need to be more specific

zinc laurel
#

hello, i just got my zigbee dongle and added to my hass server i managed to add a vibration sensor but when adding it to lovelace it just says "detected" and the battery percentage

#

do i need to pair it tru the app to get the values? i'm using zigbee home automation integration

sour shadow
#

Check the attributes of the entity that reports detected

zinc laurel
#

device_class: vibration

#

state: on

#

but not moving the thing

#

shouldnt it be off?

sour shadow
#

If it's in range of the coordinator (the dongle) then it'll update that report when the device decides there's no vibration/motion

#

If you paired it and then moved it to another location, it may not be in range

zinc laurel
#

i see, it is kinda next to it on a non vibrating surface

#

is there like a pooling rate to tweak? or tied to the device

sour shadow
#

No, end devices (battery powered) aren't polled

zinc laurel
#

i see

#

i'm looking at the info of the coordinator, it says , last seen: like 25mins ago

#

it's a Texas Instruments based coordinator

sour shadow
#

Push the wake/pair button on it, see if it reports in

zinc laurel
#

it did not, let me try the usb3 port but dont think thats the problem

#

i have it on the front usb

sour shadow
#

No, don't use the USB 3 port

zinc laurel
#

oh okok

#

so i'm seeing this clusters tab

#

shouldi bind it to the coordinator?

sour shadow
#
  1. No USB 3 ports
  2. Short USB extension cables are good
  3. Avoid WiFi interference
zinc laurel
#

okok

#

i did reconfigure the sensor and now it says "clear"

#

dryer_ ias_zone : clear

#

xd dont know that that means XD i will try chang it the device type

sour shadow
#

clear, as in no vibration

zinc laurel
#

mhm ok i will vibrate the thing

#

do the led colours of the end device mean something? or just random

#

it came with no documentation

sour shadow
#

No idea

#

You only mentioned a vibration sensor so ... how on earth could we know?

zinc laurel
#

the box literally says "Smart home" that's it xD no documentation no markings no nothing

#

i think it is working now

#

updates are quite regular now

#

so for zigbee that should be the whole process, add device-set device to pairing - enjoy?

sour shadow
#

Add device in place, set to pairing, pair, done

zinc laurel
#

neat ok then ill see what it can do, thank you! have a good night

solar hamlet
#

Any recommendations for wifi/zigbee/zwave switches that offer local control? I have some tp link casa ones but dont want to buy more since they are removing local access. I do have other ZigBee devices setup so can use that if people recommend it too. edit: usa budget, flexible (only buying a few not the whole house), prefer wifi open to ZigBee zwave (have integrated into my ha already)… have neutral wire already. First looking for regular non dimmer switches might care about dimmer/3way in the future

hoary crest
#

hrm i installed a new smart plug some days ago, using deconz, its the same brand and model as the one i already run a few weeks, they look identical in deconz, just NWK and IEEE differ, i can turn it on and off, but i dont get the same sensors in HA, the original one has a power, a temperature and a consumption sensor, the new one not ... what might be the problem?

hoary crest
graceful notch
#

yeah they blocked it in the firmware of the device, if I'm not wrong

#

some aqara plugs have similar issues

hoary crest
#

but why? 😦 can i flash a better firmware? 🙂

#

also the firmware seems to be the same for both plugs, at least phoscon tells me its version 09-06-2019 for both plugs

junior viper
#

So extremely tired of getting WOT error messages from Z2M, could it be this, that, could it be my piece of sh*t ConBee, could it be that. Is there any better alternative than ConBee II available in the Nordics?

sour shadow
#

Anything CC2652 based

junior viper
#

I've seen them 🙂 Thx

tight ibex
#

Zigbee n00b here. Are there any HW which is preferred/better than others in the list of zigbee radio modules for HA integration? I've seen the Conbee II mentioned quite many places

violet dagger
#

CC2652 based is the best

drowsy wind
#

Hi guys I finally decied to integrate my Zigbee USD directly on HA using integrated tool, but I get this error "Your network is using the insecure Zigbee2MQTT network key!"

#

What should I do?? There's no info abouth that on the WIKI etc

#

Thanks

tight ibex
#

Hmm, seems to be a lot of different USB products bases on the CC2652, however no match yet for anything available in Norway 😦

molten linden
#

I ship to worldwide (from the US) and happen to be building some USB coordinators now. (tubeszb)

tight ibex
#

Jep, shipping not normally the problem. Insanely high customs and VAT handling costs are

#

And ironically, all the various junk sent from China on ali or ebay, are sent mostly right through customs with virtually no shipping and customs cost.

old swan
#

Is it possible to pair Ikea Åskväder with deconz?

old swan
jolly crystal
#

Sup, dunno if it fits here or rather integrations. I've been off this all here for long and just periodically run updates. Now it came to my mind that I want to measure my electricity usage. And I wonder what is the thing to go for these days? ZHA or Deconz? My stuff still runs in Deconz and I have a few of this awful looking Osram Smart Plugs that are only used for on/off yet. I heard they can actually measure usage as well but I can't find such a entity known in HA. I just ordered some other Smart Plugs as well that are capable of doing so. So is this about Deconz or anything else missing? Also is there anyone who runs that with the new Energy Tab from HA?

sour shadow
#

ZHA > deCONZ

jolly crystal
#

Thanks Tinkerbell, good to see you around

sour shadow
jolly crystal
#

kk ❤️

austere patio
drowsy wind
austere patio
#

And then run the "form network" tool

drowsy wind
#

Ok I heard about that

#

I’ll try to use it

#

Thanks man

austere patio
#

If you're basically starting from scratch, you may as well run the energy scan to see if 15 is really the best channel for your network

#

20 or 25 might have less noise

#

In either case, remove the ZHA integration and add the following to your HA config:

zha:
  zigpy_config:
    network:
      channel: 15  # or 20 or 25, depending on what the energy scan says

Once you restart HA and re-add ZHA, it will form a brand new network with that channel

drowsy wind
#

I actually haven’t added any zigbee at all so I’ll definitely reset it

austere patio
#

Have you used the stick before with Zigbee2MQTT?

drowsy wind
#

Yep

austere patio
#

Ah, okay. Eventually we'll get network settings stuff into the ZHA UI but for now command line tools are the only way to do this

drowsy wind
austere patio
#

You would be waiting for possibly a very long time 😆

drowsy wind
#

Ok I’ll try to reset it then, so quick summary I’ll need to reset it, then add that part on the yaml and then finally add zigbee stick using UI, right?

#

Thanks man really appreciate it

austere patio
#

Yep

#

Remove the ZHA integration first

#

And restart HA after adding that section to your config file

#

You only really need to add that to the config file if you plan on changing the default channel

drowsy wind
#

Yes I’m gonna do that, but first if I’m not mistaken I should reset nvram?

austere patio
#

Do the scan first, then reset NVRAM

#

It requires a formed network to run and will throw an error if you don't have one formed, if I remember correctly

drowsy wind
austere patio
#

Go for it

green ember
#

hi! I'm having a strange issue with my hue bulb. it's part of a zigbee group with an ikea tradfri bulb, only those two. I can turn the group on and off no problem, but here's the issue - when the group lights turns off and I call the light.turn_on service with brightness=255 within 10 seconds of them turning off, the hue bulb starts to blink, the tradfri bulb happily shines away. this does not happen if I toggle the group manually from the group entity controls or when I turn the hue bulb itself on, it happens only when it's turned on by the light.turn_on service and only when the brightness is greater than 240, below that it blinks once but no more. I'm using the HUSBZ-1 stick with the latest firmware. and I can always reproduce this. any ideas what might be happening here?

molten linden
#

Got a tuya air box - thing updates every 3 seconds gonna chew up database space at that rate.

obsidian kettle
#

Looking for Zigbee smoke detector recommendations. I’m using a ZZH stick for my ZHA integration.

brazen robin
obsidian kettle
green ember
gentle flint
molten linden
untold slate
#

I can't get my zzh stick to work on any Pi, but it works fine on an intel-based machine. Any ideas on what I am doing wrong? 🙂

graceful notch
#

is the stick detected ?

obsidian kettle
untold slate
#

Um … you mean have I flashed the stick? It wouldn’t work on the Intel machine if I hasn’t, I think.

untold slate
#

Z2M also seems to recognize it. It starts just fine. Just doesn’t receive any messages.

#

On Debian/Intel, Z2M runs in a container just fine and messages are received.

On PiOS/ARM, Z2M runs in a container just fine except Zigbee traffic doesn’t show up.

Exact same container config.

merry lion
#

hey folks, this is my first message here and also my first steps with home-assistant. I installed home-assistant on an RPi4 with the official home assistant Raspberry Image. I also use the Raspbee2 from dresden electronics (deCONZ).

#

Home Assistant works, detects already some devices in my network.

#

I added the deCONZ add-on afterwards, configured it by selecting the only suggested device (/dev/ttyAMA0), but when i open Phoscon via the Sidebar of Home Assistant i can see that it has not found/connected to the Raspbee.
When i look at the deCONZ Add-On Logs i see this: https://hastebin.com/mowahepove.apache

merry lion
#

i just tried to use ZHA instead of deCONZ. Uninstalled deCONZ Add-ON, rebooted host completely, and then tried to add the ZHA integration. It detects the device (/dev/ttyAMA0) but then i get "Failed to connect" in the Add integration dialog for ZHA.

calm valve
#

I assume for HA Container, I have to add my Zigbee stick to Home Assistant in a slightly round about way?

calm valve
merry lion
#

i am running it in the OS (the official HA Raspberry Image)

merry lion
merry lion
calm valve
#

I'm using it in a container.

#

I've just realised Zigbee2MQTT is saying that it isn't connected to MQTT server so I'm not fixing that

merry lion
#

ok understand

calm valve
#

Well, at least one of us does haha

#

It was up and running not so long ago

#

Do I even need to have it installed in a Docker..?

gentle flint
merry lion
calm valve
#

I have it on a pi.

#

I have been at this on and off for a week so I'm a bit all over the place haah

merry lion
#

ah ok. well i am totally new to HA, and i do not unterstand the different installation methods yet. I think that even when you run HAOS it will install docker and run HA across containers. I think thats how the addons are supposed to work. I am just wondering at the moment how i can access the host system? Is that even possible?

#

And you did a manual install, right?

#

the container?

calm valve
#

Yeah the container one!

#

Nah, I'm pretty sure my MQTT is working.

#

I have it as an add on in HA and can ping different topics

#

Pretty sure I don't need it in a container

#

So it's just connecting my Zigbee Stick to HA through ZHA which I am getting stuck at now

calm valve
fallow carbon
#

People. I have a group of outdoor lights that turn on and off together, but occasionally one light will miss the off command and then gets left on. Right now after an off command i have a 1m delay then check the states, and re-send the off command. Still the other day I had one light that refused to turn off. Are there and better solutions for this?

merry lion
calm valve
#

Yeah

#

Although it seems to be working...?

#

I havnt added any devices yet...

#

Almost had an IKEA bulb there, but it failed aha

#

Got it.

calm valve
#

@dry fossil thank you for all your help. If you could just tell me how to attach the Zigbee Sonoff switches haha

dry fossil
#

Why the hell are you tagging me? I'm not even involved in this conversation.

calm valve
#

Yeah, I've no idea. Sorry. Thought I'd turned off the notification.

dry fossil
#

Turned off? You explicitly tagged me there by typing my handle.

obsidian sandalBOT
#

@calm valve Generally, don't tag people to ask for help - it comes across as bad manners, you’re demanding somebody answers you. It’s different if you’re thanking somebody, obviously. If you do tag somebody keep it polite and respectful. Remember that everybody is a volunteer, and nobody has to help you, and people may block you.

Similarly, please don’t DM (direct message) people asking for help. It also comes across as demanding, and means that others can’t learn from what you do.

Finally, please keep tagging people in replies to a minimum. That too can become annoying very quickly and should be used only when it's necessary (such as if it's been a long time, or there's multiple conversations going on). When using Discord's new Reply feature it defaults to pinging the person you reply to, click @ ON to @ OFF to stop this - on the right side of the compose bar.

dry fossil
#

It's okay. I can hide the pings. Just have to block you. 👋

calm valve
#

Oh dang haha

little elbow
#

Hi Guys, Just a little stuck wondering what I am doing wrong. Got a Rasp Pi 4 with HA iso on it. I have a SONOFF Bridge and motion sensor. In HA I have HACS which has eWeLink addon to add the motion sensor to HA. I set an automation when the state changes from off to on to turn on a light. Worked once but now in the HACS panel it's very slow to get updates if there was or was not motion. Is this normal?

#

Just found AlexxIT so will look into that

hoary crest
#

@merry lion you need to disable bluetooth for the raspbee II to work, just put the sd in a sd card reader and put the reader in your windows machine, you should get a new drive in windows (dont repair it even if windows asks you to do it) and there should be a config.txt, add enable_uart=1 dtoverlay=disable-bt there, put sd back into the pi and it should be working

#

or at least enable uart support, not sure disabling bluetooth is needed but works for me 🙂

merry lion
hoary crest
#

Boot is fat

graceful notch
#

errr why not boot the pi

#

and ssh in to it ?

merry lion
#

fml, it only shows hassos-data, hassos-kernel, hassos-overlay, i have to figure out why it does not show the boot partition.

merry lion
graceful notch
#

in /boot

merry lion
#

haha, yeah thats where i looked 😄

graceful notch
#

no idea how hassos messes around with it

#

but regular pi setups just have /boot

#

with the config

merry lion
#

i know thats why i am confused

graceful notch
#

oh

#

google says, ssh in to port 22222

#

not 22

merry lion
#

ahaaaaaa

graceful notch
#

and it would be /mnt/boot apparently

#

well that is according to something, someone wrote in 2020

#

:d

merry lion
#

i love this google thing 😄

#

i will try that

#

thanks

graceful notch
#

no prob, could try looking for rpi config.txt hassio

#

that's how I found it

#

or this 🙂

merry lion
#

ok, in the meantime i figured how i boot the fat partition on mac. my macos did not show it in diskutil app, but the diskutil cli. So i manually had to mount it:
cd ~ mkdir rpi sudo diskutil list # get correct device. in my case /dev/disk4s1 sudo mount -t msdos /dev/disk4s1 ./rpi

flint belfry
#

using ZHA with conbee II and I'm receiving data fine from passive sensors (motion/weather) but my smart plugs that used to work are now in some state where when I flip the switches in HA they flip back about a second afterward without anything changing on the device -- not seeing any errors show up in the logs

#

seems like something is wrong with communication but not sure where to start debugging it

flint belfry
#

I restarted HA and things worked for a few minutes but then went back to the same issue

flint belfry
austere patio
#

Have you tried cutting power to them, waiting 10s, then plugging them back in?

flint belfry
#

nope - I could try - I have 4 of them and they all exhibit the same behavior at the same time

austere patio
#

Have you enabled debug logging for ZHA?

flint belfry
#

no but I will now

#
2021-09-04 21:48:08 DEBUG (MainThread) [homeassistant.core] Bus:Handling <Event call_service[L]: domain=switch, service=turn_off, service_data=entity_id=switch.sonoff_s31_lite_1_0d9d6a22_on_off>
2021-09-04 21:48:08 DEBUG (MainThread) [zigpy_deconz.zigbee.application] Sending Zigbee request with tsn 40 under 41 request id, data: b'012800'
2021-09-04 21:48:08 DEBUG (MainThread) [zigpy_deconz.api] Command Command.aps_data_request (18, 41, 0, <DeconzAddressEndpoint address_mode=2 address=0x2F3F endpoint=1>, 260, 6, 1, b'\x01(\x00', 2, 0)
2021-09-04 21:48:08 DEBUG (MainThread) [zigpy_deconz.api] APS data request response: [2, <DeviceState.APSDE_DATA_REQUEST_SLOTS_AVAILABLE|2: 34>, 41]
2021-09-04 21:48:08 DEBUG (MainThread) [zigpy_deconz.api] Device state changed response: [<DeviceState.128|APSDE_DATA_REQUEST_SLOTS_AVAILABLE|APSDE_DATA_CONFIRM|2: 166>, 0]
2021-09-04 21:48:08 DEBUG (MainThread) [zigpy_deconz.api] Command Command.aps_data_confirm (0,)
2021-09-04 21:48:08 DEBUG (MainThread) [zigpy_deconz.api] APS data confirm response for request with id 41: e1
2021-09-04 21:48:08 DEBUG (MainThread) [zigpy_deconz.api] Request id: 0x29 'aps_data_confirm' for <DeconzAddressEndpoint address_mode=ADDRESS_MODE.NWK address=0x2f3f endpoint=1>, status: 0xe1
2021-09-04 21:48:08 DEBUG (MainThread) [zigpy_deconz.zigbee.application] Error while sending 41 req id frame: TXStatus.MAC_CHANNEL_ACCESS_FAILURE
2021-09-04 21:48:08 DEBUG (MainThread) [zigpy.device] [0x2f3f] Delivery error for seq # 0x28, on endpoint id 1 cluster 0x0006: message send failure
2021-09-04 21:48:08 DEBUG (MainThread) [homeassistant.components.zha.core.channels.base] [0x2F3F:1:0x0006]: command failed: 'off' args: '()' kwargs '{}' exception: '[0x2f3f:1:0x0006]: Message send failure'
#

so yeah seeing send errors

austere patio
#

MAC_CHANNEL_ACCESS_FAILURE

#

Do you have your Conbee away from all sources of interference (like USB 3.0 ports) and on a USB extension cable?

flint belfry
#

I do have it a couple feet away from the rpi/ssd cuz it's been an issue

#

I could try further probably

austere patio
#

The error means that the Conbee believes the Zigbee channel is busy due to interference from other sources

#

So it just refuses to transmit

flint belfry
#

ok that's helpful, thank you - I'll try to move it some more

#

moved it several more feet and it's running more smoothly now... damn interference is annoying with zigbee

austere patio
#

The Conbee is a lot more sensitive for some reason

zinc laurel
#

heyo! any idea how to bind forever the adress of my coordinator? it seems to change in some way everytime the vm or the whole server is restarted and zigbee2mqtt goes crazy

graceful notch
#

I have the same stick just directly in a nuc, with 0 issues 😄

signal tide
#

When i update my current core 8.8 to >9.x my ZHA integration stops working. ?? anyone else experiencing this also ??
[12:23]
i get : The system cannot restart because the configuration is not valid: Component error: zha - No module named ‘zigpy.state’
[12:23]
any way to fix this ?

signal tide
graceful notch
#

do you have automation triggers set up ?
Integration ‘zha’ does not support device automation triggers

#

-edited- 😉

sour shadow
#

Well, no

#

All chatter about zha belongs here

graceful notch
#

got it

sour shadow
#

I'm surprised zha doesn't support device triggers though, I'd have expected it to create devices...

graceful notch
#

same but it could be something in the config, causing the error

#

as it refers to zigpy.state

sour shadow
#

Seems likely, but shrug

calm valve
#

Really struggling to get a Sonoff basiczbr3 connected to HA. Is there any extra steps that I need to complete? It is outside, but it's not far away from the Zigbee stick.

sour shadow
#

What is "not far away"?

#

What stick? What other routers do you have?

#

What's between the stick/other routers and the Sonoff?

dry fossil
calm valve
#

Less than 20 feet. Slaesh Zigbee stick. There is a floor between the stick and the Sonoff, as well as a wall. There is an Ikea bulb near to the sonoff, but not many other Zigbee devices

sour shadow
#

The wall is likely a large part of the problem

#

The floor won't help

calm valve
#

I've read that the Ikea Bulbs act as routers. I know there is still a wall between the bulb and the Sonoff, but surely that wouldn't be that big of a deal? Suppose it must be...

dry fossil
#

Not all walls are created equal. Construction in different houses can vary wildly.

sour shadow
#

Construction material, thickness, angles, antenna design, other interference... all that plays a part

calm valve
#

Sad. Would there be a work around?

#

Maybe a Zigbee router closer to the door?

sour shadow
#

Yes, or one outside by the router - so that the signal travels at a right angle through the wall/window

calm valve
#

Thanks for your help!

#

again

dry fossil
#

Or knock holes in the wall to allow line of sight smart2

austere patio
signal tide
zinc laurel
#

hello ! what should i tweak for zigbee to work properly? i have a TS0210 sensor that' instantly change when detects vibration but takes quite a lot to return to the "clear" state is this normal?

mighty river
#

Hello I just installed home assistance.
I have an IKEA gateway running.

What’s the best practice?
Shall I disconnect the IKEA gateway and connect all devices with homesssistant or is it better to connect the IKEA gateway itself to homeassistant

ashen coral
#

Unless you have another zigbee host device (like a conbee), you need the TRÅDFRI gateway.

sour shadow
#

conbee blobcsignno
CC2652 blobcsignyes

#

(unless you're using deCONZ for some strange reason)

ashen coral
#

If you have something else, put the puck in a box in the attic (don't throw it away, it has it's uses)

zinc laurel
#

also i'm getting this error when trying to change the sensitivity Publish 'set' 'sensitivity' to 'Dryer Vibration' failed: 'Error: Write 0x84fd27fffe2c1b91/1 ssIasZone({"currentZoneSensitivityLevel":2}, {"sendWhenActive":false,"timeout":10000,"disableResponse":false,"disableRecovery":false,"disableDefaultResponse":true,"direction":0,"srcEndpoint":null,"reservedBits":0,"manufacturerCode":null,"transactionSequenceNumber":null,"writeUndiv":false}) failed (Data request failed with error: 'MAC transaction expired' (240))'

sour shadow
sour shadow
mighty river
#

I have a conbee up and running

sour shadow
#

Then you can use ZHA (or even deCONZ) instead of the gateway

zinc laurel
#

Ok that worked thank you! so, all battery powered devices will b like that? is there any brand that updates instantly?

sour shadow
#

Well, they're all going to have their own threshold

#

I don't use any vibration sensors, but somebody else will probably know

zinc laurel
#

yeh hopefully there is a work around i dont see any way to integrate it if it takes that long to update =/

sour shadow
#

Some Google searching will likely find you reviews of different models

austere patio
zinc laurel
#

for a zigbee device to be used as a bridge for the mesh thing they do, do they need to specifically state it in the sellers description? or all wall powered devices act as bridges?

sour shadow
#

They need to be mains powered - most are routers

#

Sengled bulbs aren't, and some two-wire switches/dimmers aren't

zinc laurel
#

i see so preferably a 3 wire switch? with live neutral and ground?

sour shadow
#

Or any smart plug, or any other brand of light, or many other things

hardy crane
#

Is the ZBMINI from Sonoff pairing for everyone as a light or is it just mine that is misconfigured in deCONZ?

#

Ah never mind Phoscon does think is a light still but after restarting HA it is now a switch

violet dagger
#

restarting HA always works

modest quiver
#

Tinkerer any reasons you recommend the CC2652 over the Conbee? I’m looking to get some signee stuff and have been looking at these two as well as the CC2531

violet dagger
#

CC2652 is newer and more powerful

graceful bobcat
#

This afternoon I swapped my HUSBZB-1 for one of Tubes ethernet coordinators.

#

I was able to rejoin all my devices and all seemed well.

#

I have two Kwikset Convert Gen 1 locks. I had to reset one of them (mainly because I was struggling to get it to join the new network) the other joined fine

#

the one that I reset is joined and visible in ZHA. Status for the lock is working fine. But lock and unlock commands are not working

#

I get

[homeassistant.components.zha.entity] lock.front_door_lock_ad1f03fd_door_lock: Error with lock_door: [<Status.FAILURE: 1>]
#

the other lock which is the exact same model is working fine

#

I did remove and re-add the device using ZHA a few times. I also reset it on the lock side when doing that as well

#

curious if im just missing something or theres something else I can try

sour shadow
spare talon
#

I'm switching from zha with conbee 2 to z2m with a cc2652 on home-assistant OS and had a couple of quick questions: is the hass-io plugin the recommended way of running z2m on home-assistant OS? I also know I have to re-pair my devices, should I remove them from ZHA first? Is there a recommended order of operations?

dry fossil
#

There's no hassio (you mean HA OS) and there are no plugins (you mean add-ons). But yes, if you're on HA OS, the Z2M add-on is probably the simplest way to use it.

spare talon
#

oh yes, I do mean add-on

dry fossil
spare talon
#

ok got it

#

thank you!

modest quiver
#

Thanks Tinkerer

tiny timber
#

My Hue network (or perhaps the API calls) has been having a bit of grief lately. Considering transferring all the stuff over to my Conbee ZHA network as I don't really use any features of Hue that can't be replicated in HA. Anything I should be aware of that might be an issue there?

spare talon
#

looks like I have some bulbs that worked fine with ZHA that z2m doesn't support yet... surprisingly

spare talon
#

fortunately, external converter was easy to figure out for it

gentle flint
dusk bough
#

aqara temp sensor isnt updating on ZHA it connects, and then like almost right after seems to time out

#

try to delete it and it still shows up in the list

#

wondering if the new version of HA has somekinda bug messing with me

dusk bough
#

so i think it had to do with routing

#

cause when i remove all zigbee devices and add just the temp it seems to update in real time

#

ill test some

#

cause ill need those outlets to work also so if routing through them makes it fail that will suck

tiny timber
#

Make sure to pair Aqara stuff in place with all your routers on. Most of it will not re-mesh.

dusk bough
#

thx for the tips man

alpine cipher
#

Hello, just a quickie

#

if I would install a 2nd Z2M coordinator on a different zigbee channel, would this create a problem somehow ?

sour shadow
#

Not if you kept the pan_id different

#

I ran like that for months, with overlapping meshes. All you have to do is build them out separately

alpine cipher
obsidian sandalBOT
#

@alpine cipher When using Discord's Reply feature it defaults to pinging the person you reply to, which can get frustrating for the target. Click @ ON to @ OFF to stop this - on the right side of the compose bar.

You have to change this every time (thank the Discord devs for that).

sour shadow
alpine cipher
#

by the way, Z2M is amazing !

#

together with the ZZH

#

that you suggested, never had an issue - now want to sunset my HUE and ZHA coordinators

#

do you think I need an additional network ? I have 50 routers and 55 endpoints currently on Z2M, I have 27 routers (lights and switches) on my HUE, 6 routers and 9 endpoints on ZHA

sour shadow
#

Short answer - no

alpine cipher
#

thanks

remote patio
#

my z2m addon has started sending the hold action instead of the single action for single clicks of a xiaomi button.. double click still sends double

#

at least for one button..

sour shadow
#

What version of Z2M?

remote patio
#

ok.. now it's doing hold release single again

#

in a quick sequence

#

1.21.0-4

sour shadow
#

Did you update it and then see the behaviour change?

remote patio
#

no.. i didn't even start to make these automations until after I installed this version

sour shadow
#

Then likely it's down to the button and the way it's talking to Z2M

remote patio
#

it seems like it's basically started to do hold release instead of single.. but sometimes if you do a very short hold it does hold release single in sequence.. I'll have to investigate if it's just this one button.. I have more of this model

#

never had any issues with any of them before

remote patio
#

hmm.. there seems to be a huge delay to button presses relative to how it used to be

#

say 6 seconds between button press and when the press is detected by z2m

near echo
#

Can you check the logs in z2m whether the messages received are immediate? Also check the cpu usgae, it might be running at 100% which may be caused by some other process.

dry fossil
#

It's the hardware...

#

Z2M hasn't decided to fuck with you and send random events.

#

If it's confusing single/hold/double, it's the physical switch that's the problem.

feral pebble
#

Hey! im switching over from smartthings to Home assistant and want to automate everything locally. what would be the best zigbee stick to get? (i run Home assistant in a vm on a ubuntu system if that matters)

worthy vine
#

Also, make sure your hypervisor system can forward the serial port to your VM.

thorn flume
#

Are those CC2531 based zigbee to usb adapters really so bad?

sour shadow
#

Yes

obsidian sandalBOT
#

The CC2531 and CC2530 sticks are cheap for a reason. They're fine for testing, but do yourself a favour and buy something better.

What something better? Anything CC2652 based (see here for some) or the current generation EZSP (see here for some).

The Sonoff ZBbridge isn't advised since it uses WiFi, and the HUSBZB-1 uses an older chipset so should be avoided.

thorn flume
#

But they would be so cheap :c

sour shadow
#

You're getting what you're paying for

fresh shard
#

I am using a using a CC2531 on an Odroid running Zigbee2MQTT...

#

I preformed the hack to my aqara motion sensors to enable 5 second resets on motion triggers... I am using a script to reset the state to off after 5 seconds as the default is to reset after 90 seconds. At first all of this seems to function fine. But for some reason the normal reset of the motion sensor turns the sensor back to on at the normal 90 second point and then immediately to off

#

Anyone have any idea either how to fix this or how to achieve this in a different way.

#

Can anyone tell me how to find /opt/zigbee2mqtt/data/configuration.yaml on an Odroid install?

#

Forget it I'm pretty sure I found it

sour shadow
#

How did you install Z2M?

#

Docker?
Bare metal?
Add-on?

spare talon
# fresh shard I preformed the hack to my aqara motion sensors to enable 5 second resets on mot...

that hack relies on the aqara "debug" mode, it's not very consistent (I found that it would switch to off as expected, but then fail to notice another motion event until the 90 second normal timeout completed). I gave up trying to use the aqara for stuff I wanted on a less than 90 second delay, the philips motion sensor seems to work, has something like an 8 second detection loop... would be curious if anyone else had a solution though

#

(the philips motion sensors are relatively much more expensive)

violet dagger
#

there are other motion sensors in the market

spare talon
#

so far I've tried one from philips, one from aqara, and one from sonoff. They don't really list how long they stay "detected" so it's trial and error... unless someone documented it somewhere?

#

(for the record, I love trial and error)

violet dagger
sour shadow
#

Hue are also quite configurable

violet dagger
#

whats the delay on konke?

spare talon
#

I'm in the states, doesn't look like I can get the develco here, but thank you for the tip, I will look around

#

yeah, I like the Hue a lot, except the price tag 😛

forest shale
spare talon
#

no, hue devices can pair to any zigbee network

forest shale
#

ok thanks.. that may tip the scale for me to try the motion sensor 🙂

sour shadow
idle plank
idle plank
#

I got them working by restarting home assistant and re-configuring them. I think because I'm running on a Raspberry Pi Model B (1), it did some timeouts during the initial configurations.

leaden yarrow
#

Hey all. First I'd love to say Wow. Love HA. Second is that I have run into a bit of a problem getting the Zigbee home Assistant Integration setup. I had it set up a week ago, but ran into a server issue and after reboot, I cannot get ZHA to see the Conbee II or complete the setup. Any ideas would be greatly appreciated.

spare talon
spare talon
leaden yarrow
#

@spare talon I'm running it as an OS in ESXi. I have the Conbee II passed through to the VM. Everything was working, but after a failed drive and reboot. It caused a few devices to get lost. I thought deleting the app and re-installing it would fix the issue but now I can't install the Zigbee integration. It fails on setup.

round geyser
round geyser
austere patio
#

Did you previously use your stick with Zigbee2MQTT?

round geyser
#

nope!

austere patio
#

All of the network settings are logged but the network key is only logged at the DEBUG level so it won't be present unless you had debug logging enabled

#

And it's completely randomly generated

round geyser
#

oh that is very likely, I've reported bugs in the past. The unfortunate thing is that it's qcow2 on top of zfs, so it would take some splunking. Do you know off hand what the message is?

austere patio
#

The first line would contain Network settings and then list them all

#

Really any log containing debug info for zigpy-znp will contain enough to reconstruct it

round geyser
#

well look at that, I apparently had debug logging on before I upgraded

austere patio
#

You can grep for DEBUG (MainThread) [zigpy_znp.zigbee.application] Network key: (the double spaces in ] Network are correct)

round geyser
#

haha nope, that was right after I upgraded. But I now have an example to search for

austere patio
round geyser
#

thank you!

next token
#

I hope someone could help me out on this one, my zigbee2mqtt network went complete haywire. And since then even when Z2M is down, lights and wall outlets are flickering on and off at random intervals

#

It started with the following error: Zigbee2MQTT:error 2021-09-07 12:59:55: Error while starting zigbee-herdsman. After reflashing the CC2531 stick it works for a couple of hours and it reoccurs

#

Might be related when I started grouping lights and binding them to switches?

violet dagger
#

are you sure that's the only relevant log line?

next token
desert pumice
#

Is it worth investing in more zigbee hardware with the new Matter/Tread standards coming?

violet dagger
#

its not just gonna stop working and you don't know how well matter will work or whether it will succeed in becoming a widely adopted standard

dry fossil
#

||It won't beat Zigbee||

#

It's all just hype and marketing right now. No substance, and already been delayed.

#

It doesn't really do anything that Zigbee can't already, so why would everyone jump ship from a well-established ecosystem to something new?

near echo
#

Just for the information, all new chips used for zigbee are also capable of thread. (Except those with cc2350/51). Hence, it is just a matter of OTA flashing IMHO when thread picks up

desert pumice
#

got it, thanks guys

valid wharf
#

Morning!

I'm going to buy wall switches for my new home and I have found the aqara line that looks nice and have good features.

I was looking for suppliers in Spain and the switches are priced between 40 to 44€. In Aliexpress the same switches pricing is arround 20-23€. Which for a full house is quite a lot.

I was wondering if any hub is the same or should i get one. The idea is to integrate it with home assistant.

Also, I have found the zigbeetomqtt project and that might be a very solid option to avoid xiaomi's hub.. But it misses some features that xiaomi hub provides.. So for now I think I'm going to buy the xiaomi and i'll buy the Z2M hub and play around with it.

Any recomendations on which hub to buy?

sour shadow
#

Well, there's no Z2M "hub", just sticks

obsidian sandalBOT
#

Buy something CC2652 based. This list is a good one, both Tube and Electrolama have been proven to have excellent customer service. The current generation of EZSP sticks (see here for some) are also a good choice for ZHA.

The Sonoff ZBbridge isn't advised since it uses WiFi, and the HUSBZB-1 uses an older chipset so should be avoided.

sour shadow
#

Of course, the "missing features" may help us help you

valid wharf
#

The only feature that I'm missing is the power consumption meter, all other stuff is ok

sour shadow
#

Z2M 1.21 has that

#

It reports the required information for #energy-archived - and if it doesn't for that device you can extend the support

valid wharf
#

Thanks! Seems that I was reading some old-ish information.

#

I have already readed the list posted by the bot. Any recommendations beside that? I don't mind soldering or tinkering, but just looking for something reliable and with good range.

sour shadow
#

Just buy something from the list - as mentioned there both Tube and Electrolama are good sellers

valid wharf
#

👍👍 thanks, will take a look at the list and buy something from it.

#

For a two floor house (about 90 square meters per floor) one stick might be enough, or should i buy two? (One per floor)

sour shadow
#

One is enough - see the pinned messages for how Zigbee mesh works

valid wharf
#

Thanks! I just started to dig into zigbee and need to learn about it.

valid wharf
#

Just bough tube's CC2652P2 Based Zigbee to Ethernet Serial Coordinator

#

It suits my needs and I liked that it can be by it's own.

#

Thanks for your help @sour shadow

jolly crystal
#

Sup, today I received the suggested frient 20202500 Motion Sensor Pro and added it using ZHA.
Now I see all the entities it added and I don't really get it.

  • The battery isn't being measured (unknown), is that correct or failure?
  • What's the switch for? I can't turn it on anyway.
  • There are 3 occupancy sensors which switch on/off. I've also seen just a single one on and the other's off as well. Are they any different or just duplicated?

Like if I build an automation is it sufficient to just use one or rather all 3?
Maybe stupid questions, it's just my first motion sensor and I don't really have a comparison.
Cheers

sour shadow
#

Details of what you see may help, but on Z2M it reports occupancy, temperature, light levels, and battery state (healthy/needing replaced)

jolly crystal
#

I wanted to upload a SS but it's disabled here

obsidian sandalBOT
#

@jolly crystal Rule #6: Please do not post codewalls (text longer than 15 lines) - use sites such as https://paste.ubuntu.com/ (just not Pastebin).

Please take the time now to review all of the rules and references in #rules.

sour shadow
#

The Motion Sensor includes two logical outputs - one for occupancy with high sensitivity and one for alarm with a lower sensitivity.

jolly crystal
#

Good to know, they're overall 3 tho and the battery is unknown

sour shadow
#

battery state (healthy/needing replaced)

#

So, that's normal

jolly crystal
#

Aye so it doesn't support 'measurement: %' but it hasn't an entity for these battery states either and just shows via LED

next token
# next token I hope someone could help me out on this one, my zigbee2mqtt network went comple...

Might actually found the problem... I was flashing Z-Stack_Home_1.2 (default) to the device instead of Z-Stack_Home_1.2 (source_routing). My network has almost 40 devices, 25 of them are routers, so I should be fine. But I think I was overloading the network with adding that many devices and also grouping and binding them to each other.
Will try when I get home if this will solve my problems

mighty river
#

Hi. Not sure if this is the correct channel: I recently added a ConBee II USB Stick to my Raspberry Pi 4 (with SSD via USB) , with the up to date version of hassio.

I can see the usb device at /dev/ttyAMC0 and when looking into deCONZ I see only 1 node with a blinking blue dot but no other device is appearing. I tried several devices, none of them are discovered.

Using the same stick with windows 10 and deconz, everything is fine. Any Idea?
PS: Firmware update through Phoscon on RPI4 was successful but changed nothing regarding this problem

dry fossil
#

Use a USB extension cable.

mighty river
hearty night
#

I'm looking at getting a zigbee ceiling fan/light combo, my current setup is a single on/off wall switch with a remote, looking at the supported list, https://www.zigbee2mqtt.io/devices/99432.html would be the only known supported route ?

sour shadow
#

Well, that's a remote

hearty night
#

that looks like a fan/light wall switch, which I don't plan to use

#

I imagine that remote is zigbee and the integration is emulating it?

sour shadow
#

No, it's not emulating anything

#

That page you linked is for the physical remote and how it works with Zigbee2MQTT

#

So, you pair the remote with Z2M, and then the remote talks to Z2M so you can do "stuff" in Home Assistant

#

It's just a bunch of buttons, by itself it controls nothing

hearty night
#

oh I see, so the remote is just a middle man, which really shouldn't be necessary for a zigbee ceiling unit right?

sour shadow
#

It's not even that - it talks to Z2M

#

Any ceiling unit would also talk to Z2M

#

You could bind the two, or let HA handle it

#

(with automations)

hearty night
#

I may need to read up more on these ceiling units but its not possible for HA via zigbee to talk to the ceiling units directly?

sour shadow
#

Well, sure, that's what Z2M would enable

#

(or ZHA)

#

It sounds like you want:

  1. Something that's wired to your fan/light combo that can control it
  2. A remote to push buttons on
#

?

hearty night
#

no, ideally this would not depend on switches or remotes

sour shadow
#

Well, you need (1)

#

Without some smart device wired to the fan/light combo, you can't do anything with it from HA

hearty night
#

I plan to get a zigbee enabled ceiling unit

sour shadow
#

Once you've done that then you can control it from HA - whether through automations, the frontend, remotes that send messages to HA, whatever

#

The thing you initially linked is not a Zigbee ceiling unit though

hearty night
#

you have pointed me to the supported devices on this channel and that was the closest thing I could find which initiated my query 🙂

sour shadow
hearty night
#

that is a physical switch though right?

#

what I plan to do it hardwire the ceiling unit on, and replace my switch with a touch screen that will interact with HA

sour shadow
hearty night
#

that's basically what I do with my lights right now, they're all always and automation / voice control controls them, I'm going to be working touchscreens into those as well

#

all always on

gentle flint
hearty night
#

I'll still have physical switches below the touchscreens to cut off power to the end device plus my control screen if need be, but generally speaking HA should be controlling the end devices directly without the need for physical switches or remotes

#

amazon hass a zigbee filter option under connectivity when searching for ceiling fans under home improvement but the fans listed don't mention zigbee :\

#

I get different options if I filter by zwave so that's promising

main condor
#

Anyone got experiance with setting up conbee 2 and HA with z2m ?

dry fossil
#

Yeah, and they all throw the Conbee in the trash and use a compatible stick.

main condor
#

The stick is working fine with ZHA,
HA is reconize it. but z2m dosent boot.

#

i followed the guide from z2m site that says that i have to ass serial adapter.

#

But when HA boot it gives me this error : Setup failed for serial: No setup or config entry setup function defined.

dry fossil
#

You read the part in the docs that says Conbee support is experimental, right?

main condor
#

yes

sour shadow
#

Does the Supervisor menu show the stick?

main condor
#

Yes

#

The guide show that i must add Serial adapter code..

  • When added and reboot HA it says setup failed for serial: No setip or config entry
dry fossil
#

.share the whole log

obsidian sandalBOT
main condor
#

Found the issue.

The serial code must me in zigbee2mqtt configuration.yaml
and not HA configuration.yaml

its wokring now..:) ..

queen bluff
#

I got the ikea motion sensor with dconz and see there is an attribute call dark. Any idea how I can use this in my automation?

hearty night
#

if I have a motion sensor for which HA is able to integrate with but is only giving me a "device offline" action in automation, does that mean thing not everything is mapped for this motion sensor or something ?

queen bluff
#

cant see to reference it within node-red

#

my bad i think i found it

hearty night
#

"device offline" trigger that is

feral pebble
#

what would i need to do to get it to work as a zigbee radio? im using an old laptop running linux. home assistant runs in a virtual machine

spare talon
#

that's a cc2652rb development kit

#

I mean, you almost certainly could use it to build a zigbee coordinator, but it's also probably a lot more than you need unless you want to develop on the zigbee coordinator firmware

#

also looks like it doesn't have a built-in antenna so you'd need at least that

austere patio
#

It has a trace antenna, like the CC2652R kit

#

There is also a build of Z-Stack for the CC2652RB but I'm not sure if it will work with this dev kit's pin mapping

spare talon
#

ah, neat. I didn't see it on the datasheet.

austere patio
#

So if all of the other Zigbee coordinators are out of stock and you want to possibly end up in the situation of having to re-compile the firmware for it yourself, it'll work fine

sour shadow
plush smelt
#

Has anyone ever changed the sensitivity on a Hue motion sensor through HA or deConz? Any docs/info?

austere patio
#

It should be a Philips cluster on the device, you can write a number 1-3 (or 0-3) to the sensitivity attribute

plush smelt
#

1 high, 3 low or the other way around?

austere patio
#

Other way around

hallow vine
#

Does anyone have any experience with the Xiaomi Zigbee hub? I'm trying to listen to events on the hub but I'm not sure of which entity that I should be listening to.

#

Im trying to figure out the event that take place when connected to a Xiaomi cube

#

or if anyone has any tips on how to figure out what side its on when used the Xiaomi zigbee hub

dry fossil
#

Which integration are you using?

crude matrix
#

hello all! I just received a 4 pack of Sengled smart outlets with power monitoring and I cannot get them to pair with HA using ZHA. I have all of my other Zigbee devices on this setup so I would like to not have to switch control types if possible, or if I can add a second Zigbee coordinator and then have a separate network to use for things like this.

hearty night
obsidian sandalBOT
#

@hearty night When using Discord's Reply feature it defaults to pinging the person you reply to, which can get frustrating for the target. Click @ ON to @ OFF to stop this - on the right side of the compose bar.

You have to change this every time (thank the Discord devs for that).

sour shadow
#

Well, then, which of the many Zigbee integrations are you using?

#

My mind reading abilities are on holiday

hearty night
#

HubZ Smart Home Controller

sour shadow
#

That's a device, which integration?

#

ZHA?
Zigbee2MQTT?
deCONZ?

#

Something else?

hearty night
#

must be ZHA, Zigbee Home Automation ?

sour shadow
#

Why don't you look in configuration -> Integrations and see what you did?

hearty night
#

Zigbee Home Automation is the integration I'm using, what I pasted above is what it calls itself after being installed

sour shadow
#

Then it sends events

#

Many devices in ZHA send events rather than create entities

torpid cove
#

Z2M here. switch BASICZBR3
I have an automation action that turns switch on > 300ms > turn switch off
However recently switch would stuck on. Is it bad wireless signal? or some other problem?

#

It used to work fine

dry fossil
#

What do the logs say?

torpid cove
#

I have disconnected it so I see log now.
Do you mean log in Z2M?

#

checking HA log

hallow vine
#

Trying to figure out if its sends events in addition to creating entities.

dry fossil
#

If you're not using ZHA/Z2M/deCONZ, you're just using a normal integration 🤷‍♂️

#

Its docs should tell you how it works.

#

That said, every integration sends events, because everything in HA is events... if you have no entities, listen to all events.

dense owl
#

Does anyone know what would be the most bare-bones zigbee transceiver I can get? I literally only need to subscribe to a single binary topic to trigger a DO, and maybe publish a single analog value. Zigbee is already overkill for this but I already have the network. I'm basically looking for something to help me put together a minimum-viable zigbee device. Lowest power consumption and least amount of features I can manage.

hallow vine
# dry fossil Its docs should tell you how it works.

it works just fine, the entities just don't match up what ZHA picks up on the Xiaomi cube. I need to figure out what side it is and i would like to do that with the existing hardware not converting everything over to ZHA.

obsidian sandalBOT
#

@hallow vine When using Discord's Reply feature it defaults to pinging the person you reply to, which can get frustrating for the target. Click @ ON to @ OFF to stop this - on the right side of the compose bar.

You have to change this every time (thank the Discord devs for that).

dry fossil
#

Go listen to all events. Turn the cube over. See what events appear 🤷‍♂️

hallow vine
#

"entity_id": "binary_sensor.cube_158d0006eb9621",
"action_type": "flip180"

#

Bleh, no landing side event, ill need to convert everything to ZHA if I want to use this cube

sour shadow
#

ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT are the best ways of doing Zigbee in HA - ditch those hubs and be free 😄

austere patio
#

You can also buy Texas Instruments CC2652P/R modules for pretty cheap

hallow vine
#

Thanks @dry fossil and @sour shadow. Yeah when i got this there were not many options. In my last build i used the Sonoff Zigbee bridge flashed with Tasmota. Works great.

austere patio
#

If you have one of the newer Aqara hubs I believe you can easily access the Silicon Labs Zigbee radio inside of it and use it with ZHA, I think without taking the hub apart

crude matrix
#

Can anyone assist with Sengled Zigbee smart outlets that won't connect to ZHA. I thought that they would be universal and would not like to have to get thier hub.

austere patio
#

Are you sure they're searching for a network to join?

crude matrix
#

they go into pairing mode as soon as I plug them in and I have also reset them and tried to pair

austere patio
#

They usually have some fading LED to indicate that they're searching for a network

crude matrix
#

blinking red is pairing mode

austere patio
#

Try unplugging them from the wall for 10s, permit joins in ZHA, and then do the sequence to get them to join. ZHA permits joins for only 60s from the time you click the button.

crude matrix
#

ok, I will see. Thanks!

#

That worked! I guess I got ahead of myself with excitement lol

austere patio
#

Awesome! Some products just refuse to join for no good reason until you pull the batteries or cut power, not too sure why

crude matrix
#

I think I just tried it backwards lol

dense owl
main condor
#

Any one tried that the reconnect function dosent work in z2m ?

leaden yarrow
#

I have run into a bit of a problem getting the Zigbee home Assistant Integration setup. I had it set up a week ago, but ran into a server issue and after reboot, I cannot get ZHA to see the Conbee II or complete the setup. I'm running it as an OS in ESXi. I have the Conbee II passed through to the VM. Everything was working, but after a failed drive and reboot. It caused a few devices to get lost. I thought deleting the app and re-installing it would fix the issue but now I can't install the Zigbee integration. It fails on setup. Any ideas would be greatly appreciated.

austere patio
leaden yarrow
#

@austere patio No as I cannot add it to the dashboard to enable anything. Unless there is a different way to do so.

austere patio
#

It's not a ZHA feature, you want HA to log everything produced by ZHA and its dependencies

#

It'll show up in your home-assistant.log file

leaden yarrow
#

@austere patio Thanks for that. I can get it to install, but it won't startup

"Couldn't start deCONZ = dresden elektronik deCONZ protocol: ConBee I/II, RaspBee I/II coordinator"

austere patio
#

What does your log file show?

leaden yarrow
#

Couldn't start deCONZ = dresden elektronik deCONZ protocol: ConBee I/II, RaspBee I/II coordinator
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "/usr/local/lib/python3.9/asyncio/tasks.py", line 492, in wait_for
fut.result()
asyncio.exceptions.CancelledError

austere patio
#

That error message alone means nothing, the surrounding lines have all the context

leaden yarrow
violet dagger
#

Aqara E1 contact sensor in hand

sour shadow
#

ooooh

violet dagger
#

since T1 is never coming out online

dry fossil
#

I like those. Have them all round the house and they work perfectly.

violet dagger
#

funnily the image is lying, they don't look like that

dry fossil
#

The only one that went offline only did so because I changed coordinators and haven't paired it again yet 😂 Can't get to the inside of my garage door with all the junk in there.

#

No? What do they look like? Mine are just like the image on the box.

violet dagger
#

nvm... a magnet is was stuck to the side

dry fossil
#

haha, yeah.

violet dagger
#

another mounting option it seems

dry fossil
#

Yeah, I guess you can ignore the smaller part and just put the magnet on a frame instead.

violet dagger
#

but i got only one magnet

#

ah i see...

sour shadow
#

The P1 looks kinda neat too, I wonder if it'll come here

dry fossil
#

I don't think it's to mount the pieces. I think it's an alternative to the smaller one. The bigger one has the reed sensor.

violet dagger
#

P1 can be found on aliexpress but the prices...

sour shadow
#

The bigger one is just a bigger magnet

#

I've opened a few 😄

violet dagger
#

and its probably giant due to batteries

#

i opened a few myself of all protocols

sour shadow
#

Yeah, but there's places, like the garage, where I'll take a large sensor with a longer battery life over a smaller one with a shorter life

violet dagger
#

sure, still.. the prices

sour shadow
#

Also, being able to tune the opening distance is neat

#

Yeah, I'm not buying unless it's reasonable

violet dagger
#

because its labelled "for professionals"

sudden summit
#

Morning all, I recently switched from Z2M to ZHA and I find it a much nicer experience. However, using ZHA groups with 2-5 lights, I very often find that when I turn on/off the group that one or more bulb either stays on/off. I never really had a problem with this in Z2M, am I doing something wrong? Could the be changed with QOS? What is the default QOS in ZHA btw, I cant seem to find it. Thanks

feral pebble
signal tide
modest quiver
#

Whats a good price / link to buy the Aqara door sensors? I have been looking on AliExpress but there are loads of sellers and I'm not sure what price range is reasonable. Given the slowboat from China delivery I'd prefer to get ~8 at once so I can setup the entire house in a single shot and perhaps get a small bulk discount.

violet dagger
#

most china deliveries are by air mail

sour shadow
#

Depends on where in the world you are too... prices for the UK may not help you much if you're in Japan 😛

violet dagger
#

you can get 10 pcs for around 100$

jolly crystal
#

The Motion Sensor works very well. Thanks again guys. Now it came to my attention that the old Yeelight color 1 is just garbage, losing connection like 4 times per hour.
New bulb: Wifi vs Zigbee?
Tradfri bulbs any good? Could probably just drive to Ikea later.

sour shadow
#

Zigbee > WiFi

jolly crystal
#

Thought so ❤️

#

Tradfri good? Or rather something else?

sour shadow
#

Tradfri are fine, at least for CCT - I don't use RGB. Hue are the gold standard, but you pay for that

jolly crystal
#

Yeah only need white for kitchen. Even dimmable would probably be more of a gimmick

sour shadow
#

I have found CCT to be really really nice

spare talon
jolly crystal
spare talon
#

what's the color temp range on those?

#

Oh I see it in the manual setup

#

454 is pretty good

sour shadow
#

Plenty bright, at least for me. I've got two of the globe units and one of the GU10s acting as the main lighting for a room about 25 meters square. All controlled by Adaptive Lighting, with the globes limited to 75% brightness at their brightest

jolly crystal
sour shadow
#

Yeah, I don't need anything even brighter 😄

spare talon
#

I got a really good deal on some ecosmart bulbs so I put them in my kitchen (like $5 USD per bulb), but they only do 370 mired max which isn't quite as warm as I want 😅

#

next to the hue bulbs in the hallway that can do 500, it's pretty stark

violet dagger
#

Seems Matter is moving forward slowly "We will integrate Matter into the existing hubs – Aqara M1S and M2 – through a software update (OTA)"

sour shadow
#

They've pushed back until some time next year from memory

raw hazel
#

Hello guys. Good day to all.
I am trying to remove ZHA integration from HA and it is not working.
I can disable it, nut I can't remove it. Any thoghts?

#

*thoughts

sour shadow
#

What do you mean?

#

Many (1.8K) integrations are internal to HA and can't be "removed" as such

lone bison
#

Hello. Is this an ok place to ask about a Zigbee2Mqtt issue?

austere patio
raw hazel
lone bison
#

My issue is that devices are not getting created in HA. Sometimes the individual entities do show up, but they are not associated to any device and they disappear after a while

raw hazel
# sour shadow What do you mean?

Hi Tinkerer, I added the ZHA integration to my instalation, and now I want to delete it and reinstall it because it is not loading properly.

woeful sentinel
#

And suddenly, 1 of my 20 hue lights thinks it's off but the brightness is at 1%. What gives?

#

when it's on it works normally. when i switch it off, HA says it's off, but when i look at it it's like, 1% bright.

#

(Z2M)

dry fossil
#

It's off. Welcome to the world of LED lights... residual current is enough to make them glow.

#

Yet another reason to use real bulbs and smart switches. That, or fix your electrics.

native gale
#

How to get the raspee functionable?

woeful sentinel
#

So that socket or circuit has started going bad, yeah?

jolly crystal
mental hedge
#

Evening Friends
Are zigbee e27 bulbs always zigbee repeaters?
Asking for a garden implementation to help extend my zigbee range to cover the entire garden

sour shadow
#

Well, no, it's not about the fitting but about the device...

#

Sengled bulbs for instance aren't repeaters

mental hedge
#

Ah
So up to the specific brand / implementation

#

How nice, I'm sure all the advertisements clarify what theirs is >.>

#

Thx Tinkerer

hearty night
#

anyone seen a good zigbee ceiling fan/light that accepts E26 bulbs ?

hearty night
#

E26/A19, I found an E26 B10 fixture but that won't work

crude matrix
#

I have 26 devices on my Conbee II stick and I have now lost control of my devices. I have all mains devices except 6 "bulb remotes" from Lutron and I have just added 4 Zigbee Smart Outlets to the network. I can see the data from the smart outlets for power consumption but lights will no longer work to turn on or off. Do I have too many devices on my network and can I rebuild my network mesh with ZHA somehow?

violet dagger
#

so much for Zigbee 3.0 standards, Aqara E1 doesn't expose the contact sensor on a ZCL cluster but there is a manufacturer specific one :/

sour shadow
#

And you're surprised?

violet dagger
#

well no, but there was a glimmer of hope

sour shadow
crude matrix
sour shadow
#

ZHA may have some useful log output, not sure

#

It might be a problem with one device misbehaving

#

You could try power cycling all the mains powered devices one at a time

crude matrix
#

i power cycled the ones in the basement where I am in my office and I will go through the house to do the rest after work and see if that fixes anything.

molten linden
fleet lodge
#

T1 looks like it leverages ZCL cluster

violet dagger
#

E1 is not working with the T1 config

sudden summit
#

Evening I recently switched from Z2M to ZHA and I find it a much nicer experience. However, using ZHA groups with 2-5 lights, I very often find that when I turn on/off the group that one or more bulb either stays on/off. I never really had a problem with this in Z2M, am I doing something wrong? Could it be changed with QOS? What is the default QOS in ZHA btw, I cant seem to find it. Thanks

violet dagger
#

to be honest, that doesn't sound nicer

austere patio
sudden summit
austere patio
#

If it's a group command, Z2M and ZHA should be asking the radio to send the same data so you should be seeing the same results. Does the bulb state in ZHA match what the device is doing? Or is it "off" but the bulb is still on?

gloomy pivot
lone bison
#

yes. I just updated the situation in the #integrations-archived channel since I don't think this is zigbee specific

gloomy pivot
#

it definitely is, since you're using z2m

sudden summit
crude matrix
lone bison
# gloomy pivot it definitely is, since you're using z2m

@gloomy pivot Thanks. I'll report where I'm at back to this topic.
I have narrowed down my issue to the HA/MQTT auto discovery. When Z2M sends its discovery messages to the MQTT broker I can see them in the explorer, but then disappear right away. Also, if I have the Integration page in HA up and I trigger a discovery message the # of devices under the MQTT integration increases by one, but when I click into it it isn't there. It is as if the device gets created and then immediately deleted.
Any ideas on why that could be happening? Also, this is only happening for Z2M devices, not other mqtt devices i have with auto discovery

gloomy pivot
lone bison
#

Here is what I am seeing in the mqtt explorer when I trigger a discovery message for a motion sensor from Z2M: https://imgur.com/a/miDveqM
You can see under homeassistant/binary_sensor a message appears and then disappears

gloomy pivot
#

does everything work in the z2m ui?

lone bison
#

Yes, everything seems to work in the Z2M UI. I can see all of the devices and their properties

gloomy pivot
#

can you control them?

lone bison
#

They are all sensors

gloomy pivot
#

are you using z2m as an HA addon, or standalone?

lone bison
#

I'm using the addon

#

I have read that

gloomy pivot
lone bison
#

yes. I have read everything I can find

gloomy pivot
#

how about logs?

lone bison
#

the Z2M logs say that that it is publishing the discovery messages:
info 2021-09-08 16:56:25: MQTT publish: topic 'homeassistant/sensor/0x00158d0001aea731/battery/config', payload '{"availability":[{"topic":"zigbee2mqtt/bridge/state"}],"device":{"identifiers":["zigbee2mqtt_0x00158d0001aea731"],"manufacturer":"Xiaomi","model":"MiJia human body movement sensor (RTCGQ01LM)","name":"Kitchen Motion","sw_version":"Zigbee2MQTT 1.21.1"},"device_class":"battery","json_attributes_topic":"zigbee2mqtt/Kitchen Motion","name":"Kitchen Motion battery","state_class":"measurement","state_topic":"zigbee2mqtt/Kitchen Motion","unique_id":"0x00158d0001aea731_battery_zigbee2mqtt","unit_of_measurement":"%","value_template":"{{ value_json.battery }}"}'

#

I don't see anything in the Mosquitto log, but I may not know where to look

gloomy pivot
lone bison
#

Thanks. I've been asking over there roo

molten linden
#

Anyone in Australia with access to a hot air solder rework interested in a tubeszb router at a steep discount let me know I have one in the country that needs a tiny fix.

bronze apex
#

Any reason why I've random devices not connected to anything on the map but work without issue?

bronze apex
grand reef
#

just got my Sonoff Zigbee bridge and sensor kit. is there any reason NOT to flash tasmota on to it immediately?

crude matrix
#

looks like my Conbee stick crapped out and I removed the lights from it and am in the process of adding them back to my Nortek stick. That will allow me to combine them and then monitor a second UPS for my server.

dry fossil
lone bison
#

More info on the issue I am having with Z2M devices not getting created in HA. I turned on logging for mqtt and here is what happens when I trigger a discovery message for one of the devices: https://pastebin.com/2PteP61T
It looks like HA thinks the device already exists so it removes it

gloomy pivot
#

does it?

#

have you tried removing the device from z2m and adding it again?

#

how are you "triggering a discovery message"?

lone bison
#

yes, the device gets created very briefly, and then removed. I am triggering a discovery message by updating the name in Z2M and checking the 'Update Home Assistant entity ID' option

true kelp
#

Hi everybody,
Not directly Zigebee, bit kind of related:
Does anyone have experience with the Magenta Smarthome base and it's integration into HA ?
This thing seems to be like an all-in-one hub for zigbee, homematic /homematic IP and seems to also be capable of WLAN.
It seems to be a tint product ...
I'm asking because Aldi (in germany) now get's it for a cheap price...
and having a backup hub for my Homematic might be nice....

gloomy pivot
lone bison
gloomy pivot
#

idk man

silent lintel
#

One of my Z2M bulps (philips hue) started turning on by itself. Every night, and it usually happens around 8:30pm and 2:30 am. I've had it for about a year, and it just started about 2 weeks ago

#

Running Z2M in a docker container on an intel nuc, with the ZZH!

sour shadow
#

If HA just reports it turning on (in the Logbook or the entity history) then it's not an HA thing. I've never seen Z2M do that either, so I'd say bulb glitching

silent lintel
sour shadow
#

Weird...

silent lintel
#

probably a dumb thing since I know they dont use z2m, but there's no way a neighbor could be turning it on and off right?

#

I just realized if that were the case, id probably turning their device on and off as well

#

I just asked the neighbors, and I'm not turning on/off any of thier lights, and they don't even own IoT stuff

gloomy pivot
#

you using adaptive lighting?

silent lintel
#

no idea what that is, so im guessing no]

sour shadow
#

Or flux

silent lintel
#

I just looked up the flux integration, and I never messed with that. it does seem cool though

sour shadow
#

It's not as cool as Adaptive Lighting 😉

silent lintel
sour shadow
#

Logbook is the thing on the left, called Logbook

#

It covers the history of many entities, basically a logbook of what's happened

#

Entity history is a view of just that entity

#

for example

silent lintel
#

Ahhh. I think I may not have that. Back when i was on a Pi, i setup recorder to inlcude a made up boolean to keep it slimmed down

#

Don't see a logbook in my yaml

#

Well now i know what I need to add to my yaml, to look at the logs.
Thank you Tinkerer!

ember matrix
#

Hello there, i use Z2M with Electrolama coordinator. (latest Z2M, latest Coordinator FW) some days ago, my Xiaomi Door sensors are do about 6-7 sec delay... Other sensor is not (like Xiaomi motion detector) only the door sensors... Only change that i add two now Zigbee device (smart plugs, it run router mode) but door sensors connect the coordinator directly.

Anybody affect this problem? what cause it? I try to replace battery, reregister to network, but not help at all....

sour shadow
#

If you want the Xiaomi to change parent you need to remove them and then either re-pair them (they'll pair to the first thing that responds) or pair them explicitly to that router

ember matrix
#

I dont wat to do this, i try to figure aut, why do this delay. Before last week, it working well. I dont think that cause the two new Smart plug. I checked the MQTT data traffic, but it not MQTT side problem, Z2M clearly say, that the sensor not send info to coordinator (only about 6-7 sec after, that the event happen).

#

"or pair them explicitly to that router" <-- This one is never working to me... If i enable the registration to only one router, the new device never connect it... Only if enable it all. (but in this case not only register to coordinator, but any near router)

sour shadow
#

You need the most recent coordinator firmware for that to work

#

You also need to then remove all routers and re-pair them

ember matrix
#

I see. I use latest FW, but some router is paired long time ago..

#

But unfortunately it not help the root cause... Now i tested 4 Door sensor (2 connect same router, 1 connect to other one, and last one connect to the coordinator directly) all of them is delay.

#

I observed, that if i restart Z2M, after some min, is better (1-2 sec delay) but about 5 min later, is bad again.

austere patio
#

CH340 driver in the 5.x kernel had a regression for some range of versions

ember matrix
#

@austere patio yea i also think, but i would like to inform here that somebody affect this or not, because i try to exclude that the problem is "my machine"

quartz flume
#

Hey guys, please help... i spend the day tryng to configure zigbee2mqtt and after a painfully day, the devices paired in z2mqtt do not appear for christ sakes in HA, i didn't find any clue on where is the problem, do anyone have a couple of minutes to give a hand?

  • the events are shown in mqtt broker, i saw it with mqtt.fx
  • mqtt broker has setted to auto discover it
  • reinstall, repair, restart, nothing changes the problem.
lone bison
#

sounds familiar. what topics do you see in the broker? do you see zigbee2mqtt/ and homeassistant/ topics?

quartz flume
#

Only zigbee2mqtt

#

{"level":"info","message":"MQTT publish: topic 'zigbee2mqtt/bridge/response/device/rename', payload '{"data":{"from":"XXXXX","homeassistant_rename":true,"to":"sensor"},"status":"ok","transaction":"4ks0v-1"}'"}

#

Oh, theres some homeassistant too i did not see

lone bison
#

what do the homeassistant messages look like?

quartz flume
#

{"automation_type":"trigger","device":{"identifiers":["zigbee2mqtt_xxxx"],"manufacturer":"TERNCY","model":"Awareness switch (TERNCY-PP01)","name":"sensor","sw_version":"Zigbee2MQTT 1.21.1"},"payload":"single","subtype":"single","topic":"zigbee2mqtt/sensor/action","type":"action"}

#

{"availability":[{"topic":"zigbee2mqtt/bridge/state"}],"device":{"identifiers":["zigbee2mqtt_xxxx"],"manufacturer":"TERNCY","model":"Awareness switch (TERNCY-PP01)","name":"sensor","sw_version":"Zigbee2MQTT 1.21.1"},"enabled_by_default":false,"icon":"mdi:signal","json_attributes_topic":"zigbee2mqtt/sensor","name":"sensor linkquality","state_class":"measurement","state_topic":"zigbee2mqtt/sensor","unique_id":"xxxxx","unit_of_measurement":"lqi","value_template":"{{ value_json.linkquality }}"}

lone bison
#

those look like zigbee2mqtt topics

dry fossil
#

The second one is a discovery message.

quartz flume
#

Sorry, little (a lot) tired,

#

{"availability":[{"topic":"zigbee2mqtt/bridge/state"}],"device":{"identifiers":["zigbee2mqtt_0x000d6f00166882d1"],"manufacturer":"TERNCY","model":"Awareness switch (TERNCY-PP01)","name":"sensor","sw_version":"Zigbee2MQTT 1.21.1"},"device_class":"illuminance","json_attributes_topic":"zigbee2mqtt/sensor","name":"sensor illuminance lux","state_class":"measurement","state_topic":"zigbee2mqtt/sensor","unique_id":"0x000d6f00166882d1_illuminance_lux_zigbee2mqtt","unit_of_measurement":"lx","value_template":"{{ value_json.illuminance_lux }}"}

#

{"availability":[{"topic":"zigbee2mqtt/bridge/state"}],"device":{"identifiers":["zigbee2mqtt_0x000d6f00166882d1"],"manufacturer":"TERNCY","model":"Awareness switch (TERNCY-PP01)","name":"sensor","sw_version":"Zigbee2MQTT 1.21.1"},"icon":"mdi:toggle-switch","json_attributes_topic":"zigbee2mqtt/sensor","name":"sensor click","state_topic":"zigbee2mqtt/sensor","unique_id":"0x000d6f00166882d1_click_zigbee2mqtt","value_template":"{{ value_json.click }}"}

#

That's right now?

lone bison
quartz flume
#

ok just configure the MQTT Broker to use auto discovery ?

#

Just add ```

mqtt:
discovery: true

to configurations.yaml ?
sour shadow
#

Assuming you entirely set up MQTT in YAML

#

If you set it up in the UI that's already the case, and mixing UI and YAML for MQTT just breaks it

quartz flume
#

Well, it was already there, so, if i remove it goes back to the default value ? Should i do that to avoid the problem of breaking it as Tinkerer said ?

#

And, how exactly i would know if i set it up in the UI ?

sour shadow
#

Was that all you had under mqtt:?

quartz flume
#

Yes

sour shadow
#

Then yes, that risks breaking it

quartz flume
#

I prob added it sometime today, and do not remember anymore

#

Ok, i will comment it out and restart the HASSIO

obsidian sandalBOT
#

Hass.io was the old name for the appliance like install option, that uses Docker. It was renamed in January 2020 and is now called Home Assistant OS (see #330990055533576204).

quartz flume
#

HAOS, sorry

sour shadow
#

Just restart Home Assistant - no need to restart the whole computer 😛

quartz flume
#

Its running in a raspberry 2

sour shadow
quartz flume
#

Done, but still nothing was found by HA

#

Tried to change the name of the device, and no errors, all the MQTT happened, but nothing appears as devices

obsidian sandalBOT
#

If you're having problems with your updates to your configuration:

  • Check the troubleshooting steps
  • Check your log file - remembering you may need to set logger to info or debug
  • Explain what the problem you're having is - sharing configuration, errors, and logs
sour shadow
#

I'd run the standard steps, particularly setting the log level to info or debug for at least all of MQTT

quartz flume
#

What are the standard steps ? Redo everything from 0 ?

lone bison
#

Try adding this to you HA configuration.yml:
logger: default: error logs: homeassistant.components.mqtt: debug

#

Then restart HA then restart Z2M after HA is back up

#

you should see mqtt logs with the messages coming in

quartz flume
#

Ok, will take 5 minutes at least

#

I did not have to restart it find the the device already

#

and, i do not know why. O well.

#

Thanks, really thanks

#

I think the problem was the configuration.yaml, and for some reason it did not worrk at first restart

quartz flume
#

And now it do not work anymore 😢

#

Just is unavailable

#

just as i restarted it and added a new device, it stoped receiving data in HA, MQTT.fs is working fine

#

It cant be a Mosquitto broker problem right? Because HA is publishing data too

neat anvil
#

Well, this is not fun.. I got some Sonoff Zigbee switches "BASICZBR3" and although it seems to pair... I doesn't show up in HA anywhere. Ideas?

#

Okay, rebooted HA, and it appeared.. Odd.

quartz flume
#

It do not give any sign of life anymore :/ anything i could do ? It should be working :/

gilded bridge
#

Anyone able to help install the Conbee II - just got HAOS running on a windows VM first time...

hardy crane
#

First install the addon then the integration

#

once the addon is working the integration should show up itself as discovered

gilded bridge
#

Awesome thanks. I didn't realize I first need to add it as an addon