#sk-discussion
7259710 messages · Page 7758 of 7260
Not in terms of available information about the game
Because I can't play Dying Light 2 and er Elden ring right now
And preordering a game after a release date is set isn't going to push that date up
They even opened Elden Ring pre-orders before showing the gameplay
jesse what the frick are you talking about
Did you run out of games on Steam?
Desperate for silksong and unable to play The Dying Light 2 and Elden Ring while still in despair
That's a weird choice, yeah. idk why fromsoft did that, but ig they can coast on name recognition
Just play Spore then lol
I certainly have enough games I want to play that I haven't yet
inscryption
Wait till GoW gets the glorious big yoshi mods
Yk there's some computing or estimation on game releases or pretty much everything and for now Silksong's date is unknown cuz they don't have budget limits rn compared to hollow knight which was limited; on the computing thing on when it releases it needs past info of what is the speed of making stuff and current budget, but since Silksong was bigger than anticipated and has higher budget, it might take a longer release date plus with not rlly accurate info than the past since things are on a bigger scale now-
exhales
what
Yeah, pretty much
I wouldn't play Spore again
I meant like estimation stuff on game releases would be inaccurate cuz u need past info-
People often try to use HK but that's not really a good reference for the reasons you mentioned
Pretty much
And many differing factors
Conclusion? No solid Silksong release :)
Yeah like they changed engines midway through HK’s development
Also a human doesn't have the exact same working time/skills for literally 6 years or smth
wait what which was the original
Of course not, there'll be no solid release date until TC announces it
Stencyl iirc
Whats iirc
Or something with an s
If I recall correctly
solid 4 digit release year here guys
2202
sorry my mouse is a little dumb it stops working randomly it didn't capture the whole thing
this is the correct release date
trust him bro
I trust only the red-named
Silksong releases early 1 AS
I trust only the aqua names
I think that in February we will have some news, maybe the game will be released March
I think you’re wrong and that it releases in April
Do you trust me
1/5th or, as I would normally put it, blueish red
Mmmm idk, no one know actually
No, not that date
Pliz
I do only trust those who are red-named, but being red-named is not enough to be trusted. Just one of many requisites
What about TC?? Hmm??
Guys the date will be leaked on the first milisecond of 1st january 2000 due to the computer malfunction
Trick question! They don’t!
Silksong releases
Silksong2K
Silksong releases the day after the day before
Silksong releases in 2202 dont u guys still believe 🗿
I never believed
Silksong is like Neverland. It only exists if you believe in it
My guess from first was early 2023
Silksong is inside my dresser
Please give him kromer
no, itll be 2022
He has held william hostage since 2 days
good morning
Eyy i knew it
Pfft
I don't do guesses on when is Silksong instead I ask myself if I'm worthy to have Silksong
-inspired by that one yt comment
you went to sleep while i arrived, now i go home in 1h and your back up
And I'm probably not 
i wish i would have been sleeping all this time
Prove
Pink-name lies
Once you’ve climbed the tallest mountain, sailed across the widest sea, and scaled the deepest ravine, only then will the release date be revealed to you.
god told me
what if i already did it?
Ok
Woah!
Graigus told me 
Check your dms



Invasion of the Nitro Boosters
...didnt recived anything?
No fyre go back to booster channel
You must not have been worthy

Woe
You also have to be pure of heart
So... they arent innocent? 👿
Just how it is
Nor are you!
The Buddha sat under the Bodhi tree for 1000 days before he knew the Silksong release date
Then he reached Nirvana
Exposed 
Ello I’m back
You truly are a prophet. Glory be
Is there any news or Is chat still falling into despair?

i got news for my car's extended warranty with a wierd link, but other than that, no
You will know when the red sign appears at #hk-announcements
Until then, no news, you can relax
Toot toot chugga chugga big red car, driving near and driving faaar
Also, if there were truly SS news the chat here would be absolute chaos.
wait i just realized mod might need to write the link to make sure theres nothing wrong with it, for my defence this isnt a troll or anything its actually a message i had, exactly 1 month old actually
proceeds to type it for them /hj
Ok
I forgot that this server has an announcements chat
Yeah, it's great!
In ur dreams
Now what?
The kind people at #hk-announcements will be there to find out if there's news first and tell you about it

So you don't need to be checking
no don't do this don't make me imagine
You don’t need to imagine
U kept it 🗿
(mark unread)
oh...
ss ther yet?
you right
Dont be shy press the button
will ss be ther in feb?? waddoyou think
no
No
Official announcements are the only thing that matter
||what i think||
why not feb
No
It's jan. 20 rn...
Because TC hasn't said it'd be Feb
Nothing points to feb
Talking bout february we are 10 days away from the "release date" aka chat going apes.hit
So why would I believe it would release this February in particular
There’s no evidence for February at all
If feb 1 is release day they would've announced it rn or soon with some small hints, news and stuff
they didnt say anything at all lol
I just realized there was no HK patch in December. This must mean they are focused on releasing Ss and the final HK update in February!
||nvidia leak||
But February is a strong possibility
exactly
I thought you’d pull that
The didn't say anything, so why would I think it's this February? I myself don't think it's this year
But I pull the same card against you, when they changed it to June 30th
There's no material evidence for February
||google||
Google isn't an evidence at all
Every month Is a strong possibility therefore no month is strong
yes that’s why it’s spoiled and crossed out
And there's no news coming out rn lmao
February is the strongest
It's a strong possibility if you really want to believe it is
clearly you haven't been around long enough to know me 
I don’t see any reason at all for February
Because nintendo will face HK five years ago
Not really, not moreso than other months (aside from December, which is more unlikely)
what
Feb has no strength behind it
Aight everyone bet believers or doubters of february 
Then there's the Nvidia leak
Was 2017 really 5 years ago?
The leaks are useless
Yeah
itd have been 4 YEARS then
Nintendo face to face
I see
No

That's not too long
^
I doubt it
Games take time to make
No mind to think
Wait does Elden Ring release the same day as HK’s anniversary?
No words from team cherry that it’s even close to done
No will to break
And this is a game that is hand-drawn, has huge amounts of content, and is developed by 3 people
If it's feb, it will be for none of the reasons discussed
Graig says it’s going well but he doesn’t know when it’ll be finished
No way to say whether it will be in Feb. Definitely not substance to regard it as a surety
Each frame is manually drawn or adjusted
And also probably tons of little details
I don't give a shit about a will my mind is dead
Feb is as likely as any other month, which is plausible, but not probable
Nvm it’s a day after (I think? Steam says 24th but google says 25th)
I just mean that there's tons of effort put behind visuals
February is actually less plausible, that's because of the big release of this month
I don't see how 4 years is too much time to develop that
nah
Multiple games can release in one month
Big releases don't figure into SS release
Especially when those games are on different platforms
tc doesnt do marketing that much lmao
Since... as a dev team, TC will release the game when it's done
We don't know what they will do
I think there is a moderate chance of news on the 5th anniversary
Gone are the days where you need to secure a massive release day profit to offset manufacturing costs
there better be news at least
Not confirned
Or they’ll just continue to work on the game since there’s not much else to show
TC hasn't really shown much regard for anniversaries
what the hell - i dont even want the game, i just want to know if i should be excited now or in 3 years wtf
News on the new Salubra plushie or smth like that
True, but this is the 5th one
and?
That would be the best news
Fives are important or something
No fuck fives overrated numbers
15 and 87 are the best numbers tho
Best number is x
cap
The only good number is 0
Can be all the numbers
you are a bottle cap
Silksong news on the i anniversary
Therefore best is somewhere in there
Zzzzz
It represents my iq
Zᴢz
They're also slowly managing another game but idk
Still, Silky Song will probably be released in February
Fearless Fox is just a lore document right now I think
Nope
Silky song
Sussy song
There's no basis for asserting probability of a February release
Yes
Yes
As long as there isn't NEWS at least, we can expect it at any moment lol.
What about asserting definitibility
Lmao
oh yeah the blackwyrm is dryya how about that how do you feel
I feel that Kirb has immunized me against blackwyrm jokes 
Proof that Sans is Nes:
Whenever someone tries to predict silksong release date, I get more will to make a document on the worst theory me and froggy made in this server months ago
SANS IS THE NINTENDO ENTERTAINMENT SYSTEM?
I still remember every single shit I and he said.
"If we use proper inference, from our assumptions and the axiom of completitude, and taking into account Wilhem's Razor, it is logical that Silksong will not be releasing this February" - #hk-lore regular, probably
Are you sure
Yes
It explains how the 3 brothers and Esmy are children of Ogrim and Isma
Is ss actually gonna release on Feb 1st? Cuz i kinda doubt it
Probably not
It's generally assumed to not be releasing
at all
The earth will end before it gets released
By anyone with deductive capabilities; silksong will nor release along leaked lines
William's razor?!?! How do you know about his razor huh?+!!
𝕊𝕚𝕝𝕜𝕤𝕠𝕟𝕘 𝕨𝕙𝕖𝕟? 𝕀𝕕𝕜, 𝕒𝕤𝕜 𝕥𝕙𝕖 𝕕𝕖𝕧𝕤 𝕚𝕘
ok.
At this point we've passed the two week buffer (which is itself a flawed assumption) so yeah, even some of the people who believed in Feb 1 are starting to backpedal to feb as a whole
Oᴏᴏᴏᴏᴏʜ ᴡɪɪʟʙᴏᴏᴏᴏ
They changed the topic and asked me if I knew about the hit game Among Us
Don't worry, it's just #hk-lore regular jibber-jabber nonsense stuff

reminder that this is william's profile
Lmao 💀
i dont think you needed to remind me.
His current condition after feb leak
yeah he’s supporting the communities art endeavors
Hey Tissy!!!!!! any news on Silksong?!?!??!?!!!
he's resorted to drinking
Can you believe it guys? Silksong, just a week away. Silksong is in a week! Woohoo! I am so happy about this information. Silksong! Just a week away, oh wow. Can you believe it? Silksong! Just in a week! It got here so fast! Silksong! Just a week away!
He has an actual account?
So does Ari
yeah
his last message was a year ago but yeah
He is also wide
He reacted with 😐 half a year ago
No it's secretly graig spying on us from 76 different accounts
true
Honestly he seemed non existent on the internet at this point
Believers anyone?
what an amateur, leth is spying on us with thousands of accounts, all the ss regulars are leth alts
LMAO
When will i become a leth alt
Are you guys confessing.....
Does he take control after i chat here too much
We are one already you just don't know it
or they're pretending to not know 
ok but how should i name this?
what if he already has control over you 
:ur_mom:
True Infection
Yes I am leth, do not tell anyone because it breaks the NDA, but silksong is releasing March 21 this year
if theres nothing in february at least then.... doo doo fart
hummmm maybe not
ok
ik but
Ur def an alt acc look at ur pfp 😨
*To Team Cherry:
Report on the creatures known as "the community"
Yesterday I made a joke to "the community". Interestingly, the results of the experiment where unintelligible noises and words emanated at rapid speeds from the many mouths of the creature. I will try something entirely new tomorrow and document more fascinating results.
Leader of experimentation, Graig*
Bro you ARE team cherry
finally, a real leak
Doo Doo Fart if SS doesnt at least get news in feb
Spiderman: No Silksong Home
Spidervoid: Far from silksong
guys maybe they're monitoring our response to this post
Spiderhornet: Silksongnotcoming
HK Community: Far from Silksong
Graig's task for today is to try poking us with a stick and see what happens
Yeah graig's offline since 2 seconds i'm doing it now
Nice one
Like that one fluke?
Yes
Spidershaw: No needle home
We resemble the fluke
Dayum alr
Lmfao
for me it was Spiderman: No Cinema Open . and it still is :)))
We are multiore beings like the fluke
We get poked, like the fluke
We are fluke
Whos flukemarm
I never mentioned that name 
oop
Yeah who
accurate
We remember the fluke
Damnnn
I'm in this picture
The average ss waiter
don't worry there are more high definition fluke pictures I can post
new boss in ss !!! thats why it takes so long - look at these realistic graphics!
OMG REALLY ?!?!?!??
Silksong is HD 4K 5G lets gooo
5G lol
there's a parasitic fluke that feeds on your liver while you're still alive because that's parasites for you!
I believe silksong fans will get into a metamorphosis while they're waiting and will outgrow their need for silksong
our eyeballs
not silksong
Coughed in 4K HD Corona Pandemic-Panorama
Oh there's worse
What about the worms inside it
not a good assassins creed game
Oh no. Our Silksong. It's broken.
There's no
Silksong never existed
Those worms could be feeding on our sanity
thats why im insane
Theory: Silksong is a game that will keep us waiting so that we will never know we're actually inside the matrix
I'm pretty sure it's this thing?
(seriously don't do it)
That's actually silksong
what
thats actually existence
fuck why did i click on that
No we got silksong at home
the hell
Now imagine that but its everywhere inside of you
That could be the average ss waiter
W pfp
silksong at home be like= bug
its a parasite that feasts on your liver
a real life fluke
Silksong at home= Hungry Song
sounds tasty
If you got that reference
deep frying it might be viable
Honestly it look like a tounge
Eat.
Why
Because yes
Delicious.
Deep down we're all Hungry Knights
Honger
how did a picture of a worm that eats your liver while you're still alive turn into a conversation about how hungry we all are
Wonder. Will Silksong be optimized with Dual Sense contoller?
Honger 2
wdym?
Delicious be Eat.
Delicious.
Modus ponens.
Eat.
🤝 
Grubs also taste nice
wdym?
Honger 3
wdym?
the triggers an stuff
What do you mean with a dual sense controller
SS is created with controllers in mind, switch controllers are not fundamentally different in terms of layout
Honger 4
Honger 5 World War
dual sesne controler is the ps5 controler
Honger 5 Part One
I know. Same layout
Gamepad Dual Sense. New generation of Playstation gamepads. Will it work on PC version. Because original Hollow Knight don't support some major features like changing charms on the bench
You could change charms at a bench with a controller
With Dualshock yes
I mean
Honger 6 the prequel to the sequel of the prequel of the part 6
With any controller if you set it up right
If you connect a controller to your pc i'm sure you could play with it
Stfu i havent even released Honger 5 Part Two yet
imagine using a controller?
So long as you can wire it it should work fine
yeah, but dualsense has all those extra feeling stuff, like with the r2 trigger being more "realistic" when holding a gun and such
Honger 5 Part Two
Haptics aren’t really that important
i know
Idk why it would use them, unless for a ps5 port
But you haven't released the 6 prequels and 87 spin offs yet
Well touchpad for strange reason doesn't seem to work on PC version with Dual Sense. On PS5 everything is fine.So I don't get it. And buttons in tutorials are like XBOX. Like WTF
There are none yet
That’s just how pc games are in general, prompts assume Xbox
Honger 6
Final part?
Well I wrote Team Cherry bug report about this issue. Hope they will read it
It’s not a bug
Its because xbox is much easier to connect most of the time
With Dualshock it recognises it as a Dualshock
And if a touchpad isn’t a thing in normal controllers then that isn’t a bug either
Honger 7
Then you probably had something configured wrong
Wish games used smth like outer wilds where u could manually change the prompts
Honger trilogy registered
Or maybe just there is no Dual Sense support yet.
Ps controllers being used aren't uncommon and i just don't get why not have them
Honger 8
Dualsense is already supported by windows
If it can register inputs then it works
TC probably isn’t going to add new features retroactively every time a new controller is designed
Dualsense isn't some uncommon one tho
Why add any prompts at all then lmao, that's a shit belief
Ok found this on forum. Hope will help 1: lauch steam in big picture mode (you can do that blick clicking veiw then big picture mode)
2: once ur in big picture mode go into settings in the top right
3: Go into controller settings and make sure both Playstation Configuration support and Generic Gamepad Configiration support are both ticked
4: From there you can just exit out of big picture mode and launch the game up normally and it should work
It’s five years after release
It's a problem with gaming in general
Honger 9
Every controller has the same basic inputs the game requires, TC shouldnt need to add every new controller to the prompts list every time one is released with new features
And not like ps controllers were uncommon in 2018
We don't need every one of them, a basic dualshock 4 layout is just fine
From what i've seen most controllers share very similar layouts
.
Besides, what you'll find is TC probably playtests with an xbox controller so that's what they feel is the appropriate standard
Honger Finale
Wait dualshock's are recognised? Huh
Honger epilogue cash-grab
im not a madman
Honger side character spin off?
Honger is serious quality content i wont spin off lol
So it was a configuration thing
I am just glad and happy now that everything is working. No worries for Silksong. Hurray
why are game journalists talking about 1st feb and not talking about 24th feb 
Thats when elden ring releases
Even if it's the anniversary, TC really doesn't want to touch that day
Why are you sure about that?
Im back 
I can't believe fromsoft stole that day from TC
hi back
#boycottelderring
can't believe fromsoft stole the day from jesus grist himself
Yo
Because Feb 1 at least has the nonsense leak as pseudo-evidence
And they can always do 24th after the 1st has passed
24th is from team cherry employee 
Jesus Grist 
Guys I was just talking to Team Cherry and they sent me this image
24th february is dead 
Team Cherry deleted feb 24??
I need a Nintendo direct
So do I. Not for SS, though.
Finally 24th feb's gonna meet the eradication of humanity
Feb 24 is Doom Day confirmed, dammit can't even turn 15 ☹
So do you guys think SS will release before or after elden ring
After
Yeah after
After 100%
Before would mean in the next month, after would leave much more time. Seems pretty clear which is more likely
Ohhhh Elden Ring
So if it’s after and not really following the leaks, when is the next most probably day? 😭
None
March
I doubt you could even imagine it
tbh it would be dumb to release ss at the same time at elden ring
There are no days more reliable than others
March is also my favorite day
What if they just don’t care about their competition
there would be less ppl playing ss
ER is barely competition, isn't even on the same platforms, and the industry is big enough for multiple games to release around the same time. Plus even if people play er first so long as they play SS after it really doesn't matter
That’s also what I think ^^
depends i guess
you know games tend to be released on months, and sometimes coincidences happen 
It's not like people have to choose to play one or the other and can't play both
Yeah but ER and Silksong Fandoms are a big overlap
Not on the same platforms? It comes out on PC.
And SS is on switch, and er on ps or whatever
I think they meant same genre maybe
that sometimes is the case though, not everyone can afford both games
That’s true too
Switch audience isn't going to care about er, ps/xbox isn't going to care about ss
SS is much cheaper than ER, and they don't have to buy both at once
It's not like somebody is only ever going to have $60 to spend on games
Tammo. You know SS isn't coming to ps/Xbox at launch
That's my point
it will come later though, so it won't compete with ER
That's why they aren't in direct competition in that regard
So…. Silksong for February?
yes
One can only hope
Or not
Competition only exists for PC players, and even then people can buy both games. If you can afford $60 for ER, then at some point you will probably be able to fork over $15 for SS
Hopefully...
Either way er has built up huge amounts of hype that SS will not match if it releases in feb. It will simply be drowned out, and believe it or not, TC likes to make money, so it probably will get delayed
gnosklis
How fast do you even type tammo what
It won't be drowned out, read what I just said
If TC liked to make money, they wouldn’t have made hk 15$ and the dlcs free lol
A lot of the people waiting for Elden Ring are also waiting for Silk Song
They have different audiences, and the industry is big enough to accommodate multiple releases in general proximity
There is some competition with ER. Like arch said. There quite a large overlap of fans. At least on the pc side. You do have a point that people can buy two games, which is true but saying there is no competition (even if the Devs aren't competing) is disingenuous
They released hk because they ran out of money
Those people will play both games regardless of how close together they come out
😊
TC just doesnt care about games releasing same month or anything period
Delaying sales a bit isn't the same as losing them
Even if some people don't buy SS day one because of ER, they'll still buy it eventually
And some fandom overlap isn't the same as having the same audience
more like tc just doesn't care 
I don't think Silksong is make or break for them like Hollow Knight was, so I don't know if they need to maximize sales if they don't want to
Nobody who has been waiting for SS is going to completely ignore the game and never buy it just because ER came out around the same time
SS February release is very unlikely but ER doesn't factor into it
But day one sales are what TC want, as would any company
Day one or day 100, who cares
Friendship ended with silksong
Elder ring is my new best friend now
Tammo, is SS ever likely to release any month any year for you ?
HK had a slower launch, and it ended up doing just fine
Betrayal
Not particularly moreso than others
yeah but people weren't has hyped about hk than about ss
This seems like a silly argument seeing that it's not coming out in February anyways
we dont f know
All the more reason not to agonize over planning day one sales
i saw an article about that and i was like WHAT DO YOU MEAN when they thought people wouldn't buy it as much
Its not about doing fine, it's about making money. It's a company
be pretty strange if developers didn't care about initial sales I think
initial sales sometimes dont matter more than long term sales
It's a company with low expenses and a stated priority of accessibility instead of money, and long term sales don't care about er at all, which is where they made the bulk of their money
ok lets for one second imagine it comes out on the 1st, how would we all react?
wdym
i cant imagine because the 1st is not realistic
ig I would buy the game and play it
i would play the game
:thatdwanyethejockronsonemoteyouknowtheone:
you have no imagination
Just because they want the game to be accessible that doesnt mean they're gonna just ignore earnings
Not what I said
I mean yeah no dev says 'we want money' 🥴
i meant emotionally
Initial sales are important. It's what gets the ball rolling and people talking about your game. If 10 people buy a game, it will be really hard to convince more and more people to buy it as well. No matter how good it is.
^
ig surprised and a good deal concerned
i would emotionally play the game
lol that's good then
devs can't just not care about how their game does initially
The slower a launch it has, the slower its gonna build up, the sooner it faces away
I mean just look at HK. SS is basically guaranteed to at least exceed that in terms of initial attention, and that was more than successful
yeah but it'll do amazing, ten people aren't going to buy silksogn just because ER is already out
You're all way overstating how much ER will hurt TC
swear to god silksong better not release just before exams for me
there is too much hype about it
SS is an indie, they were never going to be the media's big focus anyways
personal i don't see whats so cool about elden ring
Wa
woah
ER won't hurt TC at all because I don't think they'll release it in Feb or March anyway 🥴
Are we saying it will? I thought the argument was releasing SS around now would hurt it because of er
SS isn't dependent on being the only title releasing during a given period to be successful
agreed
personally I took ER as an example for "should TC worry about big titles' release windows when considering its own"
It would, at most, be a slim decrease in day one sales that would eventually become pretty much unnoticeable, but it's probably not releasing in Feb anyways.
Which is a reasonable discussion
And that's the only reason why I'm even disputing the point
a large majority of people who are going to play silksong on release are already fans who are going to play the game no matter what really
SS probably isn't releasing in Feb, so ER specifically probably won't matter anyways, but other big games exist
Which is not ideal for the developers of a sequel, I don't think
you want new people to play, not focus on the old fanbase
It's fine for the developers, since that's in addition to newcomers, most of whom won't have heard of the game until its release
The people who have been watching the game all along are the fans, of course, but once it's released (if it's effectively marketed as an independent experience) newcomers will play it
And since newcomers continue to begin playing HK even after 5 years I don't think that TC needs a superlatively large newcomer audience at launch
But the devs want new players to play, which they wont be doing if ER comes out and takes all their time and money. They're both souls-likes, their ideal customer base is very similsr
but i feel as if most people who would be interested in silksong have likely already heard of and probably played hollow knight
Eh i wouldn’t say « large majority » I think a lot of ppls s’il hear about silksong relatively fast
I think it may even help ss in some cases, because some people, who are actually looking for elden ring, could notice ss
They're not souls-likes
Except they are?
SS is also cheaper and will not require exhaustive hardware, it's a much more ostensibly welcoming title to newcomers
Souls likes arent defined by their hardware requirements, it's the gameplay and difficulty
Geez I wonder why lol, maybe being radio silent for so long might have something to do with it? But who are me mere mortals to complain
Artstyle that remains effective even over time and a low price point do a lot to allow for new players to continue playing the game even after years
It's the gameplay, which is entirely different. SS is a metroidvania, DS is an action rpg defined by its deliberate combat
At this point I just need some news, whatever they may be. Anything.
DS is often described as a 3D metroidvania
is getting a bit mental
Difficulty doesn't determine genre
celeste is a soulslike
Celeste is not a soulslike?
That's where the souls like label comes from?
Well it's not, least not in the normal sense, since it pretty much disregards metroidvania progression
From the style of gameplay. Games that play like dark souls. Not every hard game is a souls-like
of course it's a flight simulator
Geometry Dash is a souls like
Exactly
getting over it with bennet foddy is a soulslike
In the sense that the world is interconnected and backtracking is a major part of the game
People who call any hard game a soulslike are people who don't really know what the genre is and just think "hard = dark souls"
"hollow knight is the dark souls of mario" 
I am the dark souls of #sk-discussion members
But how you interact with the world is entirely different, and how backtracking is motivated and integrated into progression is different
You may as well call zelda games metroidvanias and soulslikes or whatever if backtracking is all that counts
I understand the comparison but the games remain so distinctive that to assert they have identical audiences is silly
Overlap maybe, but pretty much any two games will have some overlap
It's like Outer Wilds and HK
dn are the dark souls of
Outer Wilds and HK have some audience overlap because they play with some similar ideas, but they are very much different genres of games and have different appeals
To me, a souls-like is: a knight, a dark palette, you die and lose some sort of progress and come back to your body to recover it. What else am I missing? hah
there are no wheels in hollow knight i don’t think, i wonder if Silksong will have wheels? this would be cool
If you render soulslike wholly subjective as a label then arguing based off of it is meaningless
So very similar to HK and SS 
To me the thing that stops Hollow Knight from being a soulslike is how snappy it is. Attacks and movement are pretty much instant with not a lot to them. You look at Salt and Sanctuary, a 2D soulslike, and what's the difference: it has a lot of animation on attacks and rolls exactly like Dark Souls.
wheels
there are wheels but they aren't used for vehicles
And dark souls
Elevator mechanisms and caravans had wheels 
where
mechanisms
gears mate
That's a rather superficial similarity and leaves a ton of room for differing experiences
gears are toothed
woah
Then what's your take on a souls-like?
I can’t remember where but I’ve heard the same joke, maybe with something different than « soulslike » but it was something difficult, and the joke went on to like «trying to make a sandwich at 2am while your toaster is broken and your out of clean knifes is a soulslike! » or smth
Does it matter
Well I think if you're pointing out others' opinions it's only fair to give your own
i think silksong should go mental and have a cart with wheels
seems like releasing silksong is a soulslike 
aw naw, my cover is blown
.
Have you guys ever played or know about Nier replicant?
Almost a souls-like. But it’s missing a knight
Soulslike as a genre is nonsensical since it's basically just "how much do I think this game is like dark souls"
Minecraft is a souls like due to deliberate combat 
You may think HK plays like dark souls. That does not make it objectively true, and the differences are pronounced enough that HK has a very strong independent identity
And saying that minecraft combat renders it a soulslike isn't inherently wrong because the genre itself is nonsense
Soulslike could very well become a new type of genre or something
It means different things to different people
Metroidvania is anyway
There're no standard criteria for soulslikes, no consensus on what it means
Arguing that something qualifies as a soulslike when that has no real inherent meaning is not really a strong basis for anything, especially not audience overlap
ofc this is a problem with genres in general, not just soulslikes, but it's more pronounced in this instance
Idk the community seems pretty united on this one
It's a meaningless term
well that’s a bit far i’d say
Trying to attribute something like ER's negating/irreparably harming SS's sales to their both sharing such a vague descriptor is hardly reasonable
In the context of the conversation it is meaningless
Not all things that could be described as soulslikes would share an audience with the actual dark souls games
It might not hurt SS long-term but it’s all about what’s on people’s minds first
i mean i agree in the sense that genre doesn’t have that much to do with da base, cause it’s also listed as a platformer there but that doesn’t mean that someone who loves mario would like hollow knight
fan*
An AAA souls-like game or an indie platformer?
By that logic SS could never release in the same month as a AAA game
Indies necessarily take the back seat to AAAs, there's not really a good way around that
SS can't outsell ER but it doesn't have to
Between its dedicated audience, low price, and exclusive platform relative to ER it would do fine
Maybe it even does outsells it long term and we get surprised haha
Wouldn't really be surprised
It seems like AAA games are just hype
Meanwhile we are all here still actively following a 4 year old game
Graphics that don't get dated, low price (even lower on sales), generous regional pricing (probably), SS will definitely have the potential to sell more copies than ER over time
It would take a long time, sure, and it's not a guarantee, but SS doesn't need to outsell it anyways
Imagine if TC pull the ultimate troll and price SS at 60$
coming back after a while but someone finally debunked february first?
I’ve bought HK 4 times by now so idc tbh
i’d still buy it 😛
i would not
You have to remember it's not just any AAA game it's Dark Souls
60 bucks will definitely be too much for a game like ss
Eh value is subjective but I am kinda inclined to agree, even if I would probably pay $60, it would be overpriced
I'll take $40 for Silksong, tops, lol
I’ll take it free
£25 would be my upper limit
It’s not dark souls, I was talking about elden ring
Anything else is practically stealing from me
Realistically a price increase of any magnitude is dubious, $20 is probably as high as it could possibly go
Isn't elden ring dark souls??
Yeah
No but for all intents and purposes of gameplay yes
tc literally steal your money and give you fucking pixels and text files
Same devs, not part of the franchise
Thats what they said about sekiro and bloodborne
Because it was true of them too
Eh
I think they’ll make SS 25$
Why?
Just a wild guess
Nah
Real england is far worse
$25 would be a rather significant price increase (66% increase) on a price point that worked very well
I think 25 would be a fair price
I think it could be like 15/20$
am I living in bloodborne
yes

20$ at most
brain gets filled with eyes blimey, that's pretty schewpid
Just from a sales perspective increasing at all is kinda of questionable merit, but such a significant increase as $25 is pretty risky
Chewsday innit bruv
I imagine it will be 20 atleast
Even that wouldn't really make all that much sense but they could
it is actually thursday id advise you to check your facts 
Thursdee innit bruv
you mean fursday
If it comes out anytime soon, and it does costs 20$, I’ll probably do a giveaway here just in case someone can’t afford it yet
thursdee doesn't sound like a british accent and you know it
it's coming out tomorrow
"british accent"
Price again?
there's like 50 bro
Bri'ish*
and none of them sound like that
"It is achsually fursday id advoice yuu check yer facts, bruv"
it sounds like one of the british accents we have a lot
OwO what's this
you drive for 10 minutes and the dialect has changed entirely
she a bunda lengers fam she got bare back styll
ikr i just went back and now...
U know, ppl make fun of english accent but.. scottish accent..
Dont be silly, British people don't drive.
I have no idea what this means
are you even british
clearly not
you catch the tube for 10 minutes and the dialect has changed entirely
the chewb
Choobe*
public transportation!
We didnt even say same thing smh
go get on chewb off t'east Lunden, meet some right different blokes
pull up to the motive with tha mandem bruv
Pretty cool innit
meet some propa bunda lengers
a lot of people do a london accent as a british accent and i dont know london slang that well 
sorry dude, but you dared question a snailing, agony shall rain upon you
The one thing (ignoring free Healthcare and gun safety laws) the brits have over america
there's about 6 London accents
Got me this bag o crisps and a botu o wo uh for only 5 quid
depends which borough your from
translated to: lol you get even more snailed ||(ik your gonna snail this now ._.)||
americans be like boddle of warder
we also haven't got american accents
a "baddle of waadar"
Better then bo uh o wo uh
a bo'ol oh wo'ah
no bo uh o wo uh is vastly superior
Thats a rather schtewpid statement innit
we have better drinking laws too
americans be like hey y'all im headin out to get me some potato chips and a baddle of waarder yee haw guns i am fat
bit of a stewpid fing to say m8
this seems like your having a stroke out of context
Tbh britain has everything better its just the clown accent
Using ds to represent flaps is cursed ngl
we have like 600 accents
Just the 600 clown accents*
"yall im bout to head out and and get some rootin tootin tater chips and a baddle of wader"
Yeehaw
at least we got free elfcare innit
And cheaper schools 
Elf?
elfcare!
i do care for elfs
Damn another day of getting better at the accent
I cause them harm 😀
yes the british do not discriminate against elves
Brits: my favorite food to get every chewsday is chips from [British fast food place] and a burger. I also occasionally get crisps from the vending machine. Every night I have fish and beans for dinner.
Yea britain doesnt actualy have ppl living there its elfs.
nandos
nah fam you're getting a nandos with the mandem
stop elf discrimination worldwide
shut up the british ninjas are already on their way
Elves are people you racist piece of shit

Actually wait you're monke
🦍
Nvm no one's people for you
Elvis is still considered a human stop egagering smh
it becomes much more apparent that it's an image when it's a ping message
Btw imagine colonising someone for their spices to end up eating shit like bread sauce and toast sandwich
The only correct accent is mine
You're all wrong
whenever I hear an american person i feel like im in a movie
imperialism moment
oh i can see... then wait imma fix that
whenever i hear an american person i want to die
Fair
fun fact the current british accent actually originated from america and current souther american accents are closest to what old british sounded like
you hear them all the time on discord
toast sandwich is sick with baked beans and war rations wdym
what is the current british accent
Then there are australians, but noone talks about them cuz they arent real
whenever i hear a person i want to die.
War rations im ok with but beans on toast is dogshit
🤝

there is no singular british accent
🤝
Chewsday innit bruv nandos crisps fish and beans, bo uh wuh uh
unfortunately
i cant hear handshakes 
roadman
i got a friend who has the most classic stereotypical 'MURICAN type of accent but he's actually australian
if you're talking to a posh british person they'll pronounce their T's and shit
is nandos a british thing or is that in other countries I can never tell with most things
I feel like australian accent is 50% yeehaw american and 50% briish
As opposed to a glottal thing?
what
there are two types of brits, people that pronounce castle as carsle and people that pronounce castle as cassle
cassle >>>
I am a cassle person
Glo'ul
r u from the north
yorkshire
going batshit insane
i'm so sorry to hear that
Bapshit
bap
shut
Bapshut
ba'shi'

bap shut
yorkshire is a government conspiracy
The uk isnt real
facts
I wish
Neither is australia
fuck it earth isn't real
And u know what? Mexico isnt real too
australia sunk into the ocean a long time ago
No more tacos
the government distracting us with a global earth when it really isn't real at all
in superhero movies nowhere is real except america
endgame had a few mins of asia
Asia is in america
i see
well except spider man far from home that was entirely in europe
everything is america
america is mid
america is B tier
yea it's a solid B
perhaps C tier
i'd say a solid low B
Europe, thats a neighborhood in Jersey, right?
America is B tier compared to every country and F tier for a first world country
yes thats what I meant thanks
india s tier
eh
S for shit
genuinely can't think of a worse first world country than america
A really famous female singer with a huge fan base (I don't remember her name) released a new studio album some years ago without having said anything about it before. It was a kind of surprise. People woke up and were surprised. Imagine that's what happens with SS
nah all those north european countries are s tier
L
other than France
Is china a first world country
no
finland is s tier
Ok so yea america worst
f for failuire
all Nordic countries r S tier
North Korea
uhh norway is s tier
W opinion
not first world country
Ss chat turned into something i never expected
ah yes my favourite first world country North Korea
XD
um what tier is russia then if even us is fucking b
We shit on french ppl but french food is so bussin, respectfully
you never really hear much from the nordic countries and that's because they have their shit sorted
Russia is A, for alcoholism
Russia isn't first world
Maybe North Ireland is worse than America, with all that Brexit stuff going on
Well... Not really
what classifies as first world anyway
someone said us is b tier among other countries and f tier among ||us|| first world
They have food, money, water
mainly western countries
ah
my guy boris j has been all over the news recently and it's great 
True, prob some of the best places to live in
His new album slaps
sided with america during the cold war
russia is D tier
that seems like a pretty biased definition 
D for Dputin
it's the definition
3rd countries were on the USSR side, and 2nd world were basically everyone else
Wait seriously??
Fr
lmao that's fucked
Nah y'all capping
I thought it was like a well developed system
no
when the 4th world dropping
Or it might be the opposite. 2nd are USSR allys and 3rd is everyon else
Scandinavian countries also have their shit and shortcomings
that definition is kinda worthless then
the 2nd world is the ones that sides with Russia
what's the point of describing the countries like that
the Third worlds definition is blurry
well yeah every country does, but the scandinavians have less than most others and are usually high on quality of life ratings
what do you consider 2nd world countries then?
The 5th world is where it's at
Hmm yes my favorite SilkSong topic, real world country shiz
generally i'd rather live in the US than most of them
Yes, but what about their suicide rate? In Finland that's extremely high among the youth
what about countries that were occupied by Russia and didn't have a choice 
Your name.
Blue is First, Red Second, and Green Third
Red is sus
Japan is first world??
wait northern ireland is blue but republic of ireland is green?
lmao Germany is split on this map
so which one is it now?
russia invaded belarus ukraine kazakhstan and others? cool
||yeah ik it's ussr||
yeah ofc japan is first world
Ireland green???
exactly how it should be 😌
Ireland was neutral
i'd rather live in the US than Japan
Isn't the first/second/third world labeling kinda arbitrary
which part of africa is a first world country
me too but mainly because I don't speak japanese 
that's the topic of discussion yeah
despite the definition I think '3rd world country' nowadays is used to describe an undeveloped one
this channel got way too real
We need a new definition this one kinda crap
Which is also pretty arbitrary
went from bri'ish jokes to this shit
nah US is kinda shit
"Underdeveloped" is pretty nonspecific as far as criteria go
yeah, thats what i see one as
better than Japan imo
US dogshit
Japan is just ridiculously glamourised by western media
US probably isnt as bad as it's made out to be at least you have decent rights there
healthcare tho
i've been a few times it just feels like england but slightly shitter
I can't imagine living in a country where there is no social security/universal wealthcare/whatever you call it
Eh depends on if you're white
I don't think it's as bad as that
yeah I genuinely cant imagine going to a hospital then having to pay for that
how is Austria and Switzerland third world, but somalia second
It can be
it can be like that mostly anywhere
Same. Maybe it's because I'm Spanish

Whether or not the problem is unique to the US does not change that it is a problem the US has
First/Second/Third dont mean rich or poor. Its just who sided with whom during the cold war
gotta pay for the ambulance 
sorry i broke my leg heres $5000 uwu
oh, we always learned that like third means underdeveloped or developing countries and first developed
its ridicously costly at times too from teh sounds of it
Which is kinda arbitrary
You know what else is arbitrary
Really this paradigm is just a vessel for ethnocentrism rather than anything meaningful imo
silksong
Your name
why are we talking about this in ss discusion btw
a vessel? 
Because it's ss discussion
Because ss always gets off topic
what else would we talk about?
