experimental-features-feedback

[sweet vine]

We're constantly adding new features to the Experimental Queue and Test Features.

This channel is for feedback on the current experimental features in game that don't have a specific channel.

Currently those features include Perfect Dodge and Hold-To-Dodge.

[warm kayak]

😔 delete both of them

[tropic sparrow]

#sentinel-ssig-feedback message

[wraith egret]

please graduate the weapon spawn improvements already.
they're good and having them as test features only causes issues when battlepass missions require specific maps.

and get rid of the sig cooldown changes when hitting. twk said it was never intended to be a test feature but it has existed for over 2 years and was never in any patch note.

[tropic sparrow]

if you dash or just press the dodge button for any other reason before getting hit you can't perfect dodge if the stun is too low

[uncut hearth]

i think it should be if you dodge the first frame before an attack, how it is now kills dodge reading.

[wraith egret]

this is because getting hit doesn't reset the dodge mashing check (which is probably a bug)
it should work properly when stun lasts more than 30 frames

[glossy kelp]

I don't mind hold to dodge, if someone burns their dodge that's fine. It might help new players and might reduce mashing in intermediate players. Expert players it won't really affect.

I don't like perfect dodge at all, it's unnecessary.

[forest lagoon]

there aren't too many situations where you should be dodging immediately after getting hit. if anything, this is just encouraging more bad habits for players who impulsively dodge earlier than they should've. delayed dodges are just a lot more optimal in a variety of situations that makes PD (perfect dodge) a niche tool by comparison

[meager surge]

"foda said that there is not LVL100 rewards because they don't want to make people farm/grind xp and waste they life" then they add dodge buffs to make people waste even more time learning dodge timings for every attack, sig, every, wall interactions, light sig followed up by light attack from weapon x to y at every amount of damage and defense/strength variables, is just impossible to learn every SITUATIONAL TIMING in this game, if you try do that, you will waste all you training time in this, and still lose since you don't reserved time to learn: reads, when to approach, baiting, when to punish, how to adapt to new playstyles, and + when a balance path comes all that training may need to be done again since balance will aways be changing... it's impossible to learn all dodge timing, and that "pros aways dodge frame 1" IS A MASSIVE LIE, it's impossible to do that with dodging... but do you want to know what is possible to get all timings??? yes you can learn all inputs from a single legend or a litle/the basics true combos timings off all, i remember some pro saying it will main wu shang in both, 2v2 and 1v1 since he think is too hard to TOP MASTER 2 different legends at the same time one for each gamemode

[uncut hearth]

thats a bit of a stretch

[silent spade]

i aint readin allat

[pallid arch]

.

[random glacier]

Stupid mechanic

[wraith egret]

perfect dodges in their current state make it less rewarding to read dodges
I think they should activate when you dodge an incoming attack rather than out of

besides, the issue with hold to dodge nerfing 1df strings is still very prevalent

[final haven]

yeah it should be like if you dodge the attack in a frame perfect way

[meager surge]

the game is not forcing, but is rewarding lucky inputs, since is impossible to do perfect dodges every time in every scenario due to the amount of variables there is in brawl(your stun depends of the damage build that you have, then it also depends of the strength/defence difference of you and your enemy, and also depends of for example if your bounce of a wall or the ground, and there is more, it also depends of the player input delay or ping) the stun is so variable, you can sure learn one or 5 dodge timing after some attack attack but then change the amount of damage you have and the defence/strength and the timing now is different, for this reason i use macros, lock the game behind tide inputs is bad, it make apex keyboards and macros advantage, i think the only thing that need to lock the pros is it's mind and capacity of adapting/know when it can punish, baiting, remembering/paying attention to the opponent actions/and it's own too, like for what direction he dodge, what he do after get hit... all of this things i said make a good pro player, and don't depend on tide inputs or macros/good keyboards, IT'S ALL MENTAL, getting in the opponent mind

[naive parcel]

React to this if you want bmg to make a 3v3 game mode

[wraith egret]

your stun depends of the damage build that you have
not true. no stats in the game change stun.
also depends of for example if your bounce of a wall or the ground
does not affect stun
the stun is so variable
it is literally 100% constant

for this reason i use macros
you just admitted to cheating

it make apex keyboards and macros advantage
the perfect dodge test feature has a mechanism that prevents doing perfect dodges if you're mashing

[wraith egret]

axe nlight always does 26 frames of stun
legends may travel further, but they stay stunned for the same number of frames

powers have both FixedImpulse and VariableImpulse (force), but there is only FixedStunTime (no VariableStunTime)

and stun is directly read from the FixedStunTime variable with no modification (barring some special cases with bubble tag and brawldown where the stun is overwritten)

[meager surge]

i just tested in training mode, the bot can perform an action after around 23 frames with 0 damage, but with 130 damage he can only perform an action after around 44 frames, i counted one by one with the same legends and stats, well, when i said stun i mean the time where you can't dodge or do anything, this time is aways the same? i tested on training mode and this time varies with more damage accumulated

[wraith egret]

let's move this to dm

[wraith egret]

so apparently stun can last longer than the FixedStunTime value if the stunned player is moving faster than 96 units per frame
this probably doesn't have a notable effect on strings, but it's still interesting

[eternal vault]

definitely, when you get hit at high damage youre always stunned for longer if it knocks you somewhere far

[lavish hemlock]

Perfect dodge doesnt fit brawlhalla at all. The idea that you can "PD" after a hit is weird not while you getting hit because its not any normal fighting game, you can "PD" almost everything by just playing normally and i dont think thats a good thing. also yes while perfect dodge is meant to reward you its doing the opposite cuz to get the benefit from it you need to be grounded so if the enemy saw you perfect dodge them 100% they will punish you for going to the stage. im not implying that perfect parry benefit should not be "only grounded" because it will be busted but rather that its a feature that cannot be in a platform fighting game its function really differently than any normal fighting games especially brawlhalla.

[twilit lintel]

its bad (edit to elaborate, it rewards getting your dodge read, just delete them both please)

[wraith egret]

For an up-to-date list of all Test Features along with when they were added, please visit https://brawlhalla.com/test-features
that list still has sticky bombs 💀
refer to https://brawlhalla.fandom.com/wiki/Test_Features for an actually updated list

EDIT: they finally updated it let's goo
still missing a few test features

[wraith egret]

shouldn't the

In tandem with Hold-to-Dodge, we’re adding Perfect Dodge to Brawlhalla to reward players for perfectly timing their dodges rather than mashing or holding the Dodge input.
be at the top of the section? or have a space before it?

[cunning wigeon]

I mean I play on switch and I barely see any purpose in the perfect dodge maybe because i'm dodging and I get a perfect dodge randomly out of nowhere or it just doesn't happen. Then I remember that video of the demonstration of the perfect dodge with the spear was pretty good but in a live game? to me it seems very unlikely a perfect dodge will be active to get out of the slight dlight of spear. That's maybe because I really didn't do what the video demonstrated though you can just dodge backwards and forwards or anywhere to dodge a spear slight dlight. But also perfect dodges aren't as rewarding when you perfectly time them and really randomly happen in a sense of that even when you aren't getting attacked you can just do a perfect dodge once or twice and then never again. Don't know if perfect dodges are really gonna be game-breaking with how much perfect timing you need but again I play on switch and maybe it's a bit harder on console(?) but also just a thought that perfect dodges could be looked at and maybe reworked if not could be just a scrapped idea.

[distant wigeon]

People saying some players would care when it's clearly stated you'd get your dodge 20 frames sooner if timing perfectly

I think it's great as it adds skill to dodging and prevents mashing ✅

[open anvil]

The feature should not be graduated in my opinion. Perfect dodge takes away reward from dodge reads and promotes more neutral-heavy playstyles especially in high levels. This makes the game much more rewarding for passive players and kind of takes away the fun for a bunch of players.

[steady plume]

im not sure that it would fit on the game

[ebon horizon]

yeah no im not gonna make a long ol speech about the fundamental mechanics of the game all i know is i hate this hold to dodge as it allows for guaranteed dodges on low dodge frame combos and just kinda advertises a very passive playstyle

[lost mist]

i agree with that

[twilit lintel]

i honestly hate the perfect dodge feature, string weapons become bad and combo weapons like axe and hammer become almost broken (the community is complaining about axe rn being broken due to mainly this) so i say DON'T IMPLIMENT GAME-WIDE

[woven zephyr]

A quick reminder. Weapons in brawlhalla aren't broken. People just know how to use it better than you, if not better then you just didn't Dodge.

[summer cliff]

i think youre missing the point of what the guy is saying
in general yes id agree with you on the fact that the game is pretty balanced, and saying that axe and hammer are broken in this context might be an exaggeration
but i believe youre not fully getting the idea @twilit lintel is trying to communicate
generally speaking, by design, all weapons perform roughly equally on the scale of a full engagement (such as a string, combo, signature, what have you) in terms of damage and positional advantage. for example, most basic bread and butter strings will usually deal ~25 dmg
but each weapon will offer a unique implementation of how to achieve the same end goal, and you can sort those impls into 3 general categories: heavy, medium, and light weaps (some ppl might do 2 catgs but who gives a shit its still the same idea; its a spectrum and you just draw arbitrary lines)
heavy weaps focus more on stronger riskier attacks such that you can do more dmg with less actions, while light weaps push you towards doing extended strings utilising weaker but faster atks. at the end its just a risk vs reward difference, but the final product remains the same. just for the sake of argument, lets say heavy weaps need 2 atks to do the same thing that medium weaps can do in 3 atks, while light weaps would need 4 atks
now diffensive (hi) options, such as dodges, dont really favour any one catg in all situations, but if we assume the defending player has a steady supply of defensive options this could favour heavier weap. this is bc engagements will break in a very short time providing less opportunity for followups and more strongly favours the strength of each individual atk. therefore, in this specific case, heavier weaps are better since youre usually only hitting a single atk
what perfect dodge does is that it makes defensive options more abundant and punish opportunities less rewarding which would allow the scenario described above to favour heavier weaps
hope this helps

[woven zephyr]

Understand bro. But I just got outta school I ain't trying to read an essay man.

[twilit lintel]

the subject is perfect dodge, not the weapons themselves, im not saying axe and hammer are broken, i said combo weapons would become almost broken and meta, and string weapons would become a lot worse because obv reasons, you cant string for that long, perfect dodge would shift the meta and change the way people play the game far too much and in a negative way

[pale dust]

day one of asking for 3v3 ranked to be permanent mode

[normal ibex]

this channel is for feedback on experimental changes only
current experimental feature is perfect dodges

[keen patrol]

nerf perfect dodging, like it only counts as a perfect dodge if you do a frame perfect dodge on an incoming attack.

[rustic pilot]

See the idea behind perfect dodging as a way to counter the new hold to dodge feature was great but there are issues with it. Certain weapons like axe or hammer benfit heavily from this because of there shorter strings but higher dmg output but things like scythe or katars will struggle alot more to get high dmg dodge reads because the new perfect dodge feature makes them able to get there dodge faster. This makes there strings short and there punishes much less. The idea was great but the execution is flawed. At a pro level I personally think it will cause the meta to shift towards heavy weapons.

[rustic pilot]

that is infinitely wrong there are better weapons than others in Brawlhalla but not broken to the point where they can't be beaten by skills. Brawlhalla has achieved a level of balance in which there are stronger weapons but not to the point everything else is trash. (other than 2020 GS) if 2 people at the same skill would 1v1 with a stronger weapon the stronger one would win

[valid saddle]

The Perfect Dodge 20 frames benefit shouldn't stack with the shorter grounded dodge cooldown. As of currently, if you perfect dodge into the ground, you immediately get your dodge back even if the dodge down was read by the opponent. As an example, bow slight - slight read for a dodge down doesn't guarantee you a dlight follow-up after the second slight anymore, even if you covered the perfect dodge as early as possible (It's even worse if you're doing it on reaction).

Perfect dodges are not hard to input at all after most strings, and i've observed that not only i, but also my opponents get perfect dodges most of the time, even more often than normal dodges (or hold dodges). For something that's so easy to do, it has no right in simply making specific reads have no reward at all.

Also, the VFX and SFX for the Perfect Dodge are very bad. The sound is very obnoxious for something that occurs so frequently, and the visual flash of the character model is disorienting. I understand that these FX are likely placeholders, but i'd like to see them changed asap if these features are to be implemented. I'd love to see a different animation for perfect dodges, that give it a distinctive look: maybe instead of being a spherical forcefield, i could be something like a prism. The audio could be less intrusive while still preserving it's clear distinction from the sound of a normal dodge (and maybe a hold-dodge could have it's own sound too).

I'd also appreciate if not only Perfect Dodge, but every tipe of dodge had a more perceptible directional animation, which would help a lot in terms of tech-chasing in advantage state, also rewarding fast paced gameplay and just marking post-hit game state clearer and more readable for spectators.

[summer cliff]

i havent played with it but judging from a lot of peoples reactions it doesnt seem like a good idea
esp considering it might not be very doable for some people bc of inconsistent lag, bad input devices, motor disability, etc
i know the window is 4f which is pretty wide for something called "perfect" but its more about the principle; brawlhalla has always been trying to be accessible (gameplay-wise) and this just goes against that
if this does graduate however make sure to add a bot setting in training to ensure the bot always tries to do perfects or never does perfects
and just to mention it while im on the same topic, a bot personality slider for the same thing

[pearl delta]

#help-booth

[open finch]

nearly every dodge read is still possible when you perfect dodge the problem is that it doesnt do anything of use

[inner lotus]

ngl take perfect dodge and hold to dodge out the game pretty plz and with a cherry on top

[bright carbon]

can someone explain to me why the game still doesnt have native dualsense support?

[sharp merlin]

Like on mobile, pc, ps? I’m pretty sure it’s a problem with the device though, no matter what

[wild shadow]

The "perfect dodge" is so stupid guys, it completely takes away any skill in brawlhalla and should be removed.

This is my opinion though I believe I do share it with many others

[normal ibex]

??? how does it take away skill??? i agree it's a stupid fearure but for different reasons

[wild shadow]

It takes away skill by making EVERY SINGLY ONE FRAME COMBO e a s a l y faquin dodged EVERY TIME

[sharp merlin]

You mean the auto dodge?

[normal ibex]

simply do not use 1 frame combos then

[sharp merlin]

Katar mains gotta predict a dodge after every attack🗣️

[kindred lotus]

this made no sense

[sharp merlin]

Most katar legends have only 1 true combo if I remember. GP to recovery is the only one. All the strings have 1-4 dodge frames

[naive parcel]

Katars needs more true combos
Make dlight nair true

[obsidian jacinth]

slight dlight already true we dont need a 3 hit combo on a weapon thats so easy to read dodges with

[sharp merlin]

If I remember correctly though, that’s only on Lin Fei

[obsidian jacinth]

Slight dlight is true on nai lmao

[marsh lily]

no way right?

[sharp merlin]

Damn, guess I don’t need to try and dodge read after slight. I genuinely did not know that

[naive parcel]

True
lol

[edgy nymph]

Perfect dodge and hold-to-dodge mechanics make katars far too punishable. Since katars only have one true combo, and most of their other strings have 1-3 frames, each string becomes incredibly easy to dodge out of, rendering katars as a D-tier weapon. Moreover, a significant aspect of Brawlhalla is securing 'clips,' and being able to dodge out of tight combos will make such moments much rarer and likely impossible in most skill tiers. I believe perfect dodge and hold-to-dodge mechanics will diminish the satisfaction derived from Brawlhalla and encourage passive gameplay. They will disproportionately reward heavy weapons while making fast weapons ineffective.

[bright carbon]

pc

[wary blaze]

After playing for several days in the trial, what I noticed right away about the new Dodge mechanic is the time in which some matches started to take place. This is very tiring, some players simply want to run around the map, use a dodge, make an attack and run again to do the famous passive gameplay, I really think these new features are very bad, I hope this doesn't make it into the game In the end, repeating myself, the game was very tiring to play in the experimental.

[wraith egret]

the latest patch removed perfect dodge from test features
(hold to dodge wasn't)

[lavish hemlock]

we won

[edgy nymph]

I honestly think hold to dodge is even worse then perfect dodge.
hold to dodge will pretty much destroy all string weapons

[dense coral]

yep, totally agree
what is the point of having dodge window if it's all dodgeable anyways? it's not "dodge window" now, it's just a check of whether it being true or not. 1 dodge window string and 5 dodge window string have no difference at all if hold to dodge is in the game.

[tropic sparrow]

perfect dodge might've been the worst test feature ever. Hold to dodge doesn't really matter, a lot of times you don't want to dodge anyway, hold to dodge will at least allow you to always dodge when you intend to and may even make it easier for string weapons to read their opponent (since your opponent won't not dodge when they intended to or won't have their dodge come out at the wrong timing).

There's also a very good reason to slightly delay your dodge anyway, so you can mess up your opponent's timing on their dodge read. And @dense coral there is a difference between a 1 dodge window string and a 5. A lot of strings that have a 5 dodge window are jumpable or fastfall-able, so it's probably good if you don't waste your dodge escaping that.

I don't really care if it's added or not, but it literally doesn't change anything and can make dodging easier for new players + experienced players could also make use of it if they want, but they're likely not missing their dodge timing anyway. Normally if you just double tap the dodge button at around the right time you're not missing the dodge window

also it should be mentioned that you have a 4 frame window to dodge a 1 frame string because of the 3 frame buffer the game has on your inputs

[edgy nymph]

Everyone misses their dodge timing from time to time. Hold to doge makes it so you can never miss dodge timing. Maybe because you're valhallan you don't miss your dodge timing often, but for the majority of people, we do. Also, many players do use their dodge whether it's a 1 dodge frame or 5 dodge frame. I'm low diamond and I still use my dodge, even if it's a 5 dodge frame. I strongly agree with what @dense coral said

[tropic sparrow]

I don't really understand what you're trying to say. If you miss your dodge timing so often why wouldn't you want this feature in the game? You seem to think it would somehow make you better at the game or something, but if you're dodging everytime you get hit even when you don't have to, a decent player will easily take advantage of that regardless and hold to dodge will not aid you in the slightest.

All hold to dodge does is let you dodge when you intend to regardless of your skill level, but it will rarely be a factor in if you win or lose. If my string has any dodge window at all, no matter how small, I'm always expecting that my opponent is capable of dodging that. Trying to win games off of praying your opponent misses the dodge window seems like a very inconsistent strategy

[edgy nymph]

I disagree. Let's say you are playing katars. You do a string that has 1 dodge frame. Timing that dodge perfectly to get out of it is incredibly difficult. Hold to dodge will make it so 1 dodge frame is irrelevant as you'll always be able to get out of it. You can't expect to get 100% accuracy for any dodge. Hold to dodge will make it so regardless of the dodge frames, you'll guarantee get out of it. It takes away some of the skill in the game as well, as timing your dodge wont matter anymore

[tropic sparrow]

I think any katar player would much rather know that they hit their string because their opponent chose not to dodge rather than not knowing whether they intended to dodge but missed their input or went for a no dodge mix up

[balmy quail]

yeah but anyone past silver can dodge 1 dodge frame combos so its not taking away much skill and by adding hold to dodge it would help with hand cramps and stuff from spamming dodge from playing for awhile

[edgy nymph]

No one can get 100% accuracy on 1 dodge frame. Not even pros. Introducing hold to dodge will make it so anyone will have a 100% chance to dodge out of any string regardless of dodge frames. This essentially just makes 1 dodge frame the same as 5 dodge frames

[summer cliff]

hold to dodge isn't meant to make missing dodges less likely
it's an accessibility setting to prevent you from having to mash
if you don't wanna miss your dodge you mash in the live game
but in exp you hold
and btw 1df is a 4f window cuz of the dodge input buffer
which isn't that hard to get consistently

[balmy quail]

Id rather that than the hand cramps every day

[autumn wind]

perfect dodge not good

[summer cliff]

perfect dodge downright terrible

[pulsar jasper]

Dodge changes just sound super unnecessary. Mashing is preventable by learning your timing and that is just a part of the game. You drop the skill celing so much by adding a feature like hold to dodge, especially when it works off the first frame you exit hitstun. I also think it will make it WAY harder for players who are learning the game since things get much more percise the higher elo you go. Once they actually begin to get better at the game, they will have developed this essentially useless habit of holding dodge, rather than considering not dodging and using other movement options. Its like learning the game with W = Jump + Aim up. Just makes it harder later for them imo.

[stoic bridge]

gang gang

[normal ibex]

i think it's more of an accessibility feature than anything, since it prevents the need for mashing or semi-precise dodge timings

i personally dislike the hold to dodge feature, but i like the idea of altering mechanics to cater to less capable or newer players

[pulsar jasper]

I totally understand it being an accessibility feature however it almost feels like an unfair advantage rather than accessability. To their credit it sounds incredibly hard to add any sort of accessibility features to a fast paced fighting game. I just really feels as though this is not the right direction. My main concern would just be how easy and consistent it would make things. Its fun to be able to catch people off gaurd with a quick 2 hit string that they could dodge but didnt quite register fast enough. Feels like it would remove that part of the game. Just an opinion ofc, I still totally see your point

[normal ibex]

yeah like i said, i don't like the feature. but it's interesting to add more emphasis to catching dodges. (also if you want to continue the conversation feel free to do so in #118778495085182976 or #generally-off-topic due to the slowmode)

[naive parcel]

I'm glad perfect dodge is dropped and never coming out

[meager surge]

SIMPLE Quality Of Life idea: just add a DASH ONLY keybinding option... the game have a aim up and jump togheter or separated option, so why i can't separate dodge/chaseDodge from dash

[pliant mango]

why do you want it to be different

[simple brook]

I want the ability to bind GRABBING A WEOPON, by itself. It annoys me that you can't do this.

[wraith egret]

press the throw button
and disable pickup with quick attack

[simple pivot]

Probably to remove miss-inputs (unintended dodges) when you dash dance, platform cancel or just move fast. But making dodge and dash separate buttons would require a new muscle memory to be learned.
While it's an interesting idea, it removes an important movement skill: timing

[pliant mango]

cool

[simple brook]

I press the thow button already, what I don't like is when I try to attack and pick up a weopon. I didn't know you could disable that. I'll do that.

[balmy quail]

please add in hold to dodge i dont wanna lose another controller

[sharp merlin]

Just time the dodge

[balmy quail]

thank you so much for your inciteful wisdom may the gods bring you endless luck

[pliant mango]

hold to dodge cool tho, im of the opinion tht strings were never meant to be easy anyways

[untold sage]

he is the gods

[sharp merlin]

I can confirm that I am every god

[neon pawn]

ideas for experimental feature:
-make chase dodge not burn dodge
-normal dodge cooldown for gravity cancel
-making weapon throws deflectable/blockable by [certain] attacks
-more/double damage on sigs in streetbrawl

[hot talon]

make crossover optional to turn off, they are pay to win.

[molten cave]

There just skins lil bro😭

[hot talon]

they are ptw lil bro ask anyone good

[wise cosmos]

Idk where to write it but please put an option to hear the normal sfx/disable crossovers. The lightsabers are so quiet and confusing and if anyone charges a sig with a crossover I don't know which sig they are charging or simply using. I can't learn crossovers animations too, it's kinda painful

[molten cave]

Just go into training and learn what the start up’s look like /sloved🙂

[vocal marsh]

PLEASE do not make this dair change. if you whiff you should be punished for whiffing in a competitive game, take it away from axe if uyhou want consistency (axe shouldnt have it anyways). You should have to use your movement properly to space moves, not just get off the hook with a grounded version like axe already has. This is something high level players already complain about axe having because it lowers the skill ceiling and raises the skill floor for bad players. Not to mention blaster dair and spear dair are ALREADY 2 of the best moves in the whole game, so is axe dair (i play all 3 of those weapons).

[tropic sparrow]

they are the only dairs that don't hit grounded

[vocal marsh]

sword, scythe, even gauntlets will drop if you go too low, katars and boots dont do full damage if you miss-space and only hit grounded. lance, axe, bow, cannon, and orb have it, but one of those dairs actually should require spacing and usually does (axe dair)

[hot talon]

thats stupid? why waste 100+ hours learning the startup for ever sig on every weapon for every character when they can just add a option to turn off crossovers

[tropic sparrow]

Still the only ones that don't hit grounded

Anyway, visually the dairs are looking a little weird. I think spear dair could be a lot smoother in the animation, maybe hold the character in place for a few frames before popping them up. Gun dair for some reason shifts forward a little

[vocal marsh]

dawg i just said sword and scythe also dont hit grounded, at least the dont in the same way spear and blaster dair dont

[tawny trench]

Agreed. The blasters dair looked wonky as hell. I don't think the change is bad but the way it works and the animation definitely looks like it should get some fine tuning. I feel quite a few other weapons, (mentioned in what you're replying too) At least animation wise when looking at animation correctness (I don't know about competitive wise and cannot speak for it, and know these changes would greatly effect the competitive scene) could benefit from grounded variants, like hammer dair, which I'd imagine instead of going through the ground would hit the ground instead, kind of like gp. Or sword dair which would probably be similar to dlight when grounded with a lot less range.

[tropic sparrow]

not only do they hit grounded, they get a combo for it

[vocal marsh]

If sword dair hits grounded in your mind then so do spear and blasters and they have combos too.
Spear: dair>sair>nlight, Dair>fastfall> dlight, dair>dair>dair etc
blasters: dair>gc dlight> sair, Dair> gc nlight> cd nair, dair> sair

i guess a better way to phrase this, is that only katars, boots and axe hit grounded when you are stacked with the opponent, why add that to 2 more weapons who already have insane dairs? and why is axe in that same group with katars and boots when their moves hitbox in always stacked?

[tropic sparrow]

you are confused

[pastel hearth]

yeah the dair changes are not it, why would you lower the skill ceiling so much

[hot talon]

i agree that shit looks broken and easy, mainly the blasters one

[pastel hearth]

so real

[kindred lotus]

lets give scythe a grounded dair too

[cinder bloom]

these looks awesome. not a huge fan of the visuals on spear dair, but conceptually these are great changes

[tawny trench]

please don't give scythe anymore string options

[tropic sparrow]

"You shouldn't be rewarded for 'missing' your DAir and hitting the stage"

[vocal marsh]

bro used the pixel perfect way of hitting hammer and sword dair grounded and ignored the thing i said about being stacked on all of them but lance and bow

[tropic sparrow]

far from pixel perfect and stacked just isn't a factor that matters

[molten cave]

BECSUSE if I spend 20 dollars on a crossover I want the crossover to look cool

[hot talon]

bro, the option to turn it off would be client side? that means i would be the only one to not see it lil bro

[normal ibex]

i definitely agree, at the very least you should be able to disable crossovers in ranked

[spiral shard]

i might be a little early to talk about the newest experimental features - but here's some thoughts i have from clips shown:

blasters grounded dair

• would it make more sense for the user to hover above the shots, the same way if the user were to hit the dair? this might need some discussion
• if we are to keep this change where the user continues to fall, why do they pivot the tiniest bit forward while hitting grounded dair? this pivot seems strange and it doesn't make too much sense

spear grounded dair

• i feel like for the grounded variant the user might want to bounce a little higher than what it currently is, bouncing that small off of the ground looks a little odd with the current animation and how long the spear's handle is

these suggestions are kinda nitpicky, but would help the moves a bit. these additions already look great, it's nice seeing older weapons get some love.

[normal ibex]

why are the test features written as a giant slab of text 😭 tl;dr

[summer cliff]

text features

[normal ibex]

text lack of features

[summer cliff]

theyll prolly have a dedicated channel for those reworks so you might need to repost this when thats up but ill chime in anyway
i think the grounded blasts on blasters are better than just hovering; having a hovering gdair would probably feel pretty weird and besides it doesnt really offer anything new over the normal adair
what this gdair does is essentially act like a falling/platform cancel or gc dlight
it also mirrors other gdair variants that stop the user on the ground and not in the air
also the problem with a floating gdair is well its an extra floating tool that can get pretty annoying on a weapon that has so many floaty dair spammers
as for the fwd scoot yeah it does seem odd but i think it might be to prevent it from having too much aoe advantage by making it hit even further forward
as for spear also same thing applies where having a high bounce on miss does make it extra floaty and annoying
but i do agree the animation looks choppy and nauseating

[spiral shard]

that is true, the hovering and higher dairs of blasters and spear respectively might promote a floaty playstyle for those weapons so nevermind that - you make good points

i agree with you on the animations. it gets the point across but they might just be rough animations for now until it graduates. i'm now just eager to test it to see how well it flows with the rest of the movesets

[warm spear]

Don't know where to put thism, but greatsword needs a serious nerf. Nearly everyone can agree to this. It kills too early. It has very little recovery frames. Hit boxes too large for such a fast weapon. It's a serious problem for the brawlhalla community and playerbase

[molten cave]

Great sword counter: jump🥰 problem solved

[obsidian jacinth]

landing tech...
also very very damage specific

[tropic sparrow]

hitting a grounded dair is not damage specific

[tropic sparrow]

op

[icy jungle]

Wild

[fallow wasp]

Reduce the drift on spear dair grounded version

[sweet vine]

Moona — Today at 11:52 AM
new spear dair is negative on hit meaning when you hit this move you are forced to dodge or get hit

[summer cliff]

1. blasters dair: (video 1) if you aerial the first blast and ground the second blast, a grounded blast gfx will appear for the first blast even tho it wasnt grounded; its abnormally large and looks weird
2. both: (video 2 and 3) there are still cases where you can hit the aerial version on the ground; grounded check should be slightly further down
3. blasters dair: (video 4) can be reduced in duration if hit closer to the ground, not sure if this inconsistency is intended or if its good or not
4. blasters dair: (not pictured) ground check should be moved forward to more accurately represent the move's area of effect; for eg if you dair into the ground as youre falling just outside the edge of the map youll do the aerial version where id expect the grounded version
   note: for number 4, target method should change from ground check to something like path, collider hitbox should be slightly in front of the user's origin
   same for point 2 considering spear dair

also foda said on stream that blasters and spear are the last 2 weapons with no gdair
thats not correct sword and hammer are also missing gdairs

[turbid eagle]

how do i send a video in this channel lol, i have something with the spear dair i'd like to add here

[wild wyvern]

ive mainly messed around with spear since the blaster's change seems to only make it so you can dair as a landing option without missing the target stacked on you.

Labbing it in training mode its definitely interesting but it will honestly not be very practical. From what it looks like right now the grounded dair has more stagger frames than the opponent, and unless the opponent expects you do go for it (when the grounded dair is super fast) neither player will be punished unless the opponent doesnt have a dodge.

I would love to go into the in-depth details but the broad strokes is that its a flashy set up tool or get off me tool that has some degree of utility with GC Dlight, Wu Shang Nsig, Kaya SSig, Ada Ssig, Arcadia Dsig, etc, its just that none of it is confirmed and you would only really use it to get the opponent off of you or set up a crazy kill option if you have the right spacing or signature space.

The opponent recovers so fast from stun that it would make using it in 2v2 comboes extremely tight

[tropic sparrow]

I noticed there is an extra frame between the 2 shots of gun DAir where there is no hitbox

There's 13 frames of startup on both the experimental version and normal version. Each shot has 5 active frames but the experimental version has a frame inbetween the shots. And each has 18 recovery frames

So it's gone from 41 total frames to 42, making the experimental aerial DAir slightly easier to punish

[tropic sparrow]

collision bubble too wide

[knotty solar]

love the blasters exp changes

[slate edge]

Is sentinel new sig only in experimental still?!

[summer cliff]

you need 250 message i believe

[hot talon]

BROKEN

[novel mesa]

#sentinel-ssig-feedback yeah it is

[summer cliff]

here when the ground check happens youre still over ground
so the game latches that and initiates gdair
but because youre moving backwards relatively fast you clear the lip of the stage by the next frame
now youre supposed to snap to the ground but theres no more ground so it just snaps you down to the collider
this is an issue of speed, making the collider thinner might make this more rare but i think it might be impossible to get rid of completely

[summer cliff]

here you can see the same issue but normal instead of pivot; since your deceleration is sharper when travelling backwards, this makes the fwd buggy variant easier to land than the pivot one
the 2nd vid has a slight variation on the pivot one thats closer to the ground which might illustrate my point better

[novel mesa]

it is niche combo honestly and the follow up aint the best

[summer cliff]

@wraith egret can you remind me how collisions work

[hot talon]

i dont see that as being "niche" that shit looks way too good

[novel mesa]

i am not a blaster player so idrk but i feel like the follow up to slight aint that great and the hitbox of the grounded dair isnt that big

@copper verge @willow wind me big scared

@kindred lotus look up more it aint about dair > sair, it is about grounded dair > slight

#experimental-features-feedback message

[kindred lotus]

No offense but dair into sair is still good

[summer cliff]

i think this happens because you creep over the lip of the edge by a tiny bit as youre rising from the jump before the dair
and this happens because youre holding fwd towards the stage
so yeah making the collider smaller would make this even harder to do
but even rn it needs very precise timing and inputs; here a very similar set of inputs produce opposite results

[tropic sparrow]

you don't need to move forward, just being above the ground is enough

interesting that this doesn't count as a ground touch, show feet in training mode

[summer cliff]

grounded touch is defined as your bottom ecb resting on a ground hard collision (your top ecb can also give you a ground touch but you need to be clipped inside the stage for that matter so we can safely ignore it)
during the pogo sequence in the vid your bottom ecb is only above the ground line at the apex of your jump and since youre not moving horizontall you never get the chance to touch the ground
and the reason why you get a wall touch is bc your top ecb is touching the wall during the bounce (wall touches only check top ecb)
but what this clip tells me is you need to be at a certain height for the move to consider firing a ground check, and be within a thin range just off the wall for the width of the collider to interfere with the collision calculation
since i mentioned them, your collisions (see image, ecbs are cyan) are defined as 2 2×2 unit boxes independent of your hurtbox; one is at your origin and the other is 120 units above it. your player name and arrow are always fixed relative to your ecbs
for ref, a std hurtbox is 145×160 units where the cetnre bottom touches your origin

[tropic sparrow]

yes

[summer cliff]

and then you get weird shit like this
this might actually make you able to impale yourself with the map and get kinda stuck but it doesnt seem to happen with the way dair works
also you walltouch before sending out the collider you force the aerial version which is probably only relevant if you have an L shaped wall since otherwise youd be to far up to touch the wall while starting gdair (can confirm it is the wall state that interferes, not the L corner)

[tropic sparrow]

Axe DAir seems to avoid this problem by making it's collision bubble very tiny, scythe GP has the same behaviour as spear DAir. But it seems greatsword DAir solved the problem by requiring both cricles to collide, but I know it runs into other problems. Maybe this is something that could be done universally

[summer cliff]

i think its always possible as long as the collider has any radius at all
if you remember thea sboots being able to do the full length grounded version while staying on a wall
they fixed that issue by moving the collider down but it can still happen just less often
@wraith egret do colliders check for a single broken raycast to hurtbox (? or ecb) or all

[spare elk]

lol

[gloomy hearth]

the explanation is really stretchy legs

[wraith egret]

@tropic sparrow @summer cliff
the new spear dair transitions to the grounded variation using a ComboOverrideIfRelease.
for this situation, there are 3 relevant events where the transition happens:
the user is on the ground
the user is on the wall
the collision check succeeds

the collision check works by doing a raycast from the legend's hurtbox center, to the hitbox's top. if there are multiple hitboxes, multiple raycasts will be done.
each power can set a custom min number of raycasts that need to find collision. for all of them except for greatsword dair, it's 1.

there's also an extra check where if the legend's position (which is at its feet) is below the point where the raycast hits the collision, that raycast is not counted.

spear dair's collision check hitbox is set slight forward. that's probably why the check finds the wall.

[tropic sparrow]

Grounded gun DAir right now is better than the normal DAir. The lack of variable force gives you consistent follow-ups at kill percent. Also normally when you hit a DAir when you have no dodge you don't get any follow-up that your opponent needs to dodge out of, grounded DAir has SAir everytime. Nix also has DAir chase dodge NSig as a confirmed string

Move needs variable force and probably shouldn't have any follow ups past orange

[summer cliff]

i graphed it out
the scale is 1px/1u
this is the strictest case where youre just above the ground line and youre just off the wall
to elaborate furthert on your point, the collider is 14×14 with an x offset of 10, the hurtbox has an x offset of 1
the second image has the estimated bad zone, i estimate its ~9×231 where the bottom forward corner of the zone kisses the lip of the hard collision
if we only consider cases where the bounce doesnt clear the ground and you hit the wall (where most ppl would probably say something went wrong) the zone shrinks to the bottom ~45u
edit: you might also consider extending the zone up by ~11u for a total of 56ish units since the hitbox would be burried inside the ground otherwise

[gloomy flicker]

the spear grounded dair resets all your options if you dair and fall off the stage, that needs to be corrected, and it also allows you to jump over attacks which is not healthy for the game especially with spear in its already overtuned state, if this change were to be considered spear would need some healthy nerfs before this go goes through

[summer cliff]

you do actually touch the ground
see here your collisions are on the same level as a grounded entity
now design-wise is this intended or should stay in the game thats a sep thing

[neon pawn]

Please remove dash snapping

[vocal zenith]

nerd alert

[hot talon]

lmfao

[warm spear]

nerf the hell out of vivi. Wtf is this? none of her sigs are punishable.

[molten cave]

Says the one that has nitro😭

[warm spear]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KwumAslGI-Q

Take notes brawlhalla. Even pros are calling vivi broken

[vocal zenith]

I got it for free thanks 🙏

[terse temple]

Clash mechanics like a special animation of sparks or something and both opponents are set back to neutral

[glossy kelp]

I like the concept of having grounded versions of blasters and spear dair. Good work.

[wraith egret]

it's already very easy to see when there's a clash. I don't think a special animation is needed.

can't hurt tho.

[gloomy flicker]

The dair change on the blasters is good, it give the weapon more mixups and some possbile follow ups. It would be a nice addition

[tropic sparrow]

Grounded gun DAir into chase dodge NAir is only a string vs legends with 4, 5 or 6 defence. Legends with 2, 3, 7, 8, 9 defence don't get sent high enough for the NAir to hit. Which is weird because the grounded DAir has no variable force and it doesn't work on both 3 and 7 possibly for different reasons? or is it some rounding error

[summer cliff]

I'm not on pc rn can you check power viewer? maybe it has like 1 varforce but I doubt it
I'll investigate tonight

[tropic sparrow]

It's 0, but this has been a noticeable thing for a while now, I assume it affects all attacks but is only apparent at very low hp. Vraxx gets NLight Dash DLight true but only vs Legends with 4 defence

[summer cliff]

well in this case nlight has varforce
but still pretty funky
I could see this being due to rounding or something similar
but that still doesn't explain dair since that should never be a part of the calc
like for dair it's positional
but for nlight it might an extra frame of stun unless it's also positional I can't tell without frame stepping it

[tropic sparrow]

it's positional for both, koji the only character that's close enough to get hit, ada and magyar are fine. What's weird is that it's the 4 defence character that's getting hit in both gun DAir NAir and lance NLight DLight, but for the gun string it's because they're getting sent too high, but for the lance combo it's because they aren't getting sent far enough away. Or maybe they aren't getting sent far enough away during the gun string as well

[fallow wasp]

Do something similar to hammer dair

[gloomy flicker]

scythe could use a grounded dair expeditiously

[kindred lotus]

That's what I'm saying

[summer cliff]

forgot to reply to this
scythe already has a grounded dair kinda
its only on hit and i think its only an anim thing

[brisk summit]

I think that the blaster dair grounded version isn't a good contribution to its kit in its current state.
Simply because it ruins all reads/dair attempts on maps that have platforms. On previous patches the dair hit no problem, but now platforms create a kind of "blaster dair" safe space, where it's not possible to hit the opponent cuz of the grounded version hitting the platform. This honestly could be fixed by having blasters only react like this to just the stage and not the platforms I think
edit: nevermind, ducc proved me wrong. Good change, I like it

[summer cliff]

if you hold down itll ignore the ground check and youll be able to do the aerial version through soft collisions
now its not possible to fully do dair on a platform you can only do that partially but i think that usecase is more niche
edit: you can it just needs a very specific setup

[brisk summit]

that'll take some getting used to, but alright, then I have no issues with it honestly

[summer cliff]

weird snapping behaviour when going up onto the lip of the stage
you can both snap up or down
this feels like everything is technically working correctly but it just looks a little wonky

[solar kelp]

As a spear player, it doesn't need grounded dair. blasters i like the change, but i would've given it to sword over spear

[pine nova]

grounded dair on sword sounds shit if it kills momentum 😟

[toxic current]

Did you change in game BGM or is this something you added to the recording? O;

[summer cliff]

modded music

[toxic current]

Ooh I see.

[knotty pagoda]

platforms ruin blaster down light grounded version most of the time

[summer cliff]

hold down to ignore the platform

[brisk estuary]

why cant i type

[kindred lotus]

You should give SCYTHE groundpound a grounded version and make it have less end lag on hit so we can string it into moves more casually.

[twin sequoia]

i like the sentinel sig

[hasty prawn]

Cool

[hallow kindle]

Please change the ability to break frames and effectively TELEPORT DISTANCES AWAY by pressing dodge, jump and fall input almost at the same time, turning around, and repeating. It is fundamentally impossible for PC players to perform this without specialized key binds for everything that would mess combat up, yet I just had a controller player try to teach me how to do it while im on PC and I realized how broken of a gap in movement that is, and then my game crashed.

[wraith egret]

dashjump fastfalling is a standard thing everyone with a bit of experience knows how to do

and it is in no way hard on pc

[hallow kindle]

It is hard enough to cramp my hand attempting to, and even when I slightly did get it down it was not to the same effect of a console player side by side, and that's if I can by chance do it in the first place. Even when I did get it, it was not teleporting me consistently. Also how can people go "teleporting is normal everyone knows how to do it" I have 2000 hours, im a decent player but not the sweatiest.

[wraith egret]

it's EASIER on pc dude. you just need to practice more. the only comparison you have is you (learning) vs your friend (knows).

[summer cliff]

you have 2000 hours and yet you're still unable to teleport
seems like a skill issue to me

[spring compass]

i got very unoptimal binds and this input is still easy, with 2000 hours id expect you to be very aware of this mechanic and do it too lmao

[tribal solstice]

Dang we still haven't graduated Sentinels new hammer side sig rework? Is anyone opposed this? He def needed an update and I've been having fun with it in experimental but want to take it to other ques. Would be great if this just graduated before the next patch please! 🙂

[fallow pollen]

i literally have 60 hours on kbm on console and i can still do it you're just bad gang 😭😭

[vernal folio]

I'm a pc player and yeah its easy when u catch how to do it (it's my technique):
1:
Press ➡️ and press the Dodge button while u're on stage to Dash in

2:
Release the previous button the 0.00001s after u used them (without being violent with ur pc lol, do it sweatly)

3:
Immidiatly press Jump and ⬇️ at the same time (ur finger should have pressur in the Jump button first and in the ⬇️ in the second time)

4:
Reapeat the step 2

Bonus:
It's at this very moment u can press Attacks/Dodge/throw.
Do it before ur brawler touch a stage if u want him to do an Air attack or a Gravity cancel.

The step 3 is hard to explain but easy to do show IRL:
It's like u put your finger straight ☝️on the floor verticaly ⬇️= the top of ur finger will touch the floor at the first time and then the plate sharme of ur finger will touch the floor horizontaly (if u dont want to broke ur finger xD):
Then on pc it's the same but instead of starting to press ur finger in the button straight and verticaly ⬆️❌️u put it horizontaly ⬅️✅️ and instead of letting ur finger falling down to this new position u do it with the muscle of ur finger like u move it as if u want to scrape / wiggle / tickle with your fingertip.
Did u get it ?😭

[kindred lotus]

[vernal folio]

☝️🤓

[kindred lotus]

sayin all this and not bein a pro would be crazy

[vernal folio]

Why ? (I think i am but my gameplay isnt actually perfect because of my laptop hp pc that give me low fps, and i need some experience even if i've +2000h in the game)

[kindred lotus]

[vernal folio]

https://tenor.com/view/luntry-gif-26563186

[round sonnet]

https://tenor.com/view/imageperms-gif-2037061634831860252

[vernal folio]

https://tenor.com/view/silent-tears-crying-sad-gif-16585808055705185572

[silver imp]

Hold to dodge seems too over powered in my opinion, and i think that it should not be added to ranked brawlhalla

[wintry moth]

Thats called bunny hopping and if you cant do it its just a skill issue 😭

[wraith egret]

nobody calls it bunny hopping. it's dashjump fastfalling.

[summer cliff]

some ppl call it bunny hopping but djff is the most common/technical/domain specific term

[patent slate]

Right hear me out

[torn sky]

Hear me out on this crazy idea: Make a weekly challenge thats somewhat difficult and i you complete it you get a random free skin that cant be an exclusive

[patent slate]

Or we get more refunds😂😭

[spring violet]

fix mobile (ui and erythin)

[sinful sedge]

Look at other platform fighter games menu UI character select screen.

Give it a new fresh look that looks modern and not like a mobile game. I want to be proud of playing brawl and people who see the menu don't take it seriously.

Clean UI clean character select, revamp it please it will improve respect for the game.

Also new 3, 2, 1 brawl, make it clean.
LAST THING Keep the main menu screen a consistent light color so it's consistent and professional

[wintry moth]

Yeah ik but when u do it repetitively all across the map back and forth people generally call that bunny hopping so im just used to calling it that

[pliant mango]

i really want a way for legend weapon skins to be used on other legends omg

[twilit lintel]

1. Keep Blasters And Spear Grounded Nair For Full Release
2. Nerf Vivi
3. Reverse Blasters Nerfs In Experimental+Keep grounded Dair

[summer cliff]

1. new dairs aren't graduating
2. pretty sure vivi is underperforming, seems like a pretty mid legend to me after 21 levels but can he powerful in the right hands; doesn't need a nerf at all
3. no

[twilit lintel]

Why 3 (Blasters suck)

[summer cliff]

they really don't

[foggy narwhal]

I think that the spear grounded dair shouldn’t do the little pogo on the ground UNLESS it hits someone. As a spear player I’m used to the aerial pogo moving my character forward ONLY when it hits, otherwise remaining in place. I feel like that should apply to the grounded version as well. Just have the legend plunge the spear into the ground on miss like greatsword grounded dair and only do the pogo thing on hit so that it doesn’t mess with muscle memory for normal aerial spear dair

[soft orchid]

As an Arcadia main, don't do this to yourself. There is a reason why the #2 rule of greatsword is never use grounded dair. If they did something like this to spear I would cry and switch to jaeyun (we don't need 1 more jaeyun player). I actually really like the grounded dair because the part of the move that bounces you is pretty short. I feel like you can throw out bigger hitboxes with it. However my playstyle for spear is nair 💀 so I may not be the best judge on that.

[foggy narwhal]

My idea still has the bounce for spear grounded dair, but only if you hit someone with it. On miss, the ground plunge aspect wouldn’t be as movement restricting as greatsword’s grounded dair because there wouldn’t be any follow up bridge moves. I just want it to be more consistent with the aerial version of spear dair, only bouncing when it hits someone.

[zenith pewter]

Bunny hoping is a absurb thing to call it

[gloomy forum]

What is this man on about 💀 😭

[fleet wren]

its not too hard to do it with base settings

[pseudo basin]

lvl 100 reward shouldn't just be a Legend name color swap
Please give us a worthy reward
Idk .. like a color scheme or something 👁️👁️?
Thank you very much ❤️
Image of a slightly yellower Tertiary Team Yellow color scheme

[wanton siren]

Let me know if this is not the correct channel (I see the feedback channels, but all seem to be specific). I've been playing since Battle Pass 1 and would like to give some general feedback and suggestions for improvement.

In my opinion, the biggest issue I have with the game has been the introduction of emojis post-game, specifically the negative ones like the "thumbs down" and "clever" emojis. I think it's great to give players more options to communicate, but those communications should always encourage positivity. There is nothing worse for me than having a great game, an epic close match even, and then, when you lose (or win, it doesn't seem to matter), you get spammed with a "thumbs down."

I have young kids who also love to play, and it's always disappointing for them when they experience this negativity while trying to improve - to the point that they do not want to play online with others. I recognize that the emojis are already out there, but please keep in mind that positivity should always be basis with new features.

Perhaps, like Fortnite recently announced, there could be options for players to "hide" unwanted emojis. Let the negativity and 'griefing' happen post-game if it must, but players should have the option to avoid seeing it and having their experience negatively impacted.

[summer cliff]

imagine trying to 100% that colour
good luck getting 25k hrs

[quick folio]

The hide option is brilliant, i hope they add this!

[simple brook]

This would be a great feature, a lot of people would benefit from this. Thumbs down wasn't meant to be a negative emoji, but the community has turned it into one, which is sad.

[grave sun]

Please let me turn off the yellow legend's name, I don't want to be sweaty for the rest of my life. People keep being in monkey mode and trying to hunt me down the moment they see my legend's name. Please!!!!! I'm begging you!!!!

[novel compass]

Plz fix keyboard on mobile .controle not showing i cant set the look up button

[tidal marten]

idk

[desert perch]

@grave sun wait so they force the color on you and you can’t remove it like a title?

[grave sun]

Yep

[neon pawn]

being able to put directional inputs on multiple buttons on controller would be nice to make stuff like dash jump instant fast fall easier! 🙂 Its already possible with things like steams controller settings or ds4 windows but an in-game option would be better for lans

[pine nova]

Graduate sentinel ssig and remove the dair changes & hold to dodge

[agile robin]

a title or an avatar feels like a better idea to me because you can remove both, you don't have to show ppl you have a 100 lvl legend

[fallow wasp]

if you’re going to add a grounded variant to blaster dair, please add more lag to it, the move is already spammable enough and hard to punish, just try gaunts into blaster matchup against people who just spam dair, it’s genuinely horrible

[formal lodge]

yo this blaster dair change gotta come asap thats all i have to say

[lunar gulch]

Make it where i can turn off gadgets there fucking gay

[normal ibex]

you can do that in ranked

[lunar gulch]

Ik but im talking about experimental or even f2s

[acoustic flame]

grounded dair on blasters is very very fun to use. im a long time blasters main with like 300 combined legend levels on blasters. It gives dair more uses and as i said its very fun and smooth

[slate nexus]

although this is a good idea to hide the emojis in post game, just like fortnite ppl will find ways around it(variations of emotes, teabagging, etc) so its not all about hiding it, its more about the community being nice

[spark scarab]

the post game chat should be back, cuz it was just freedom, if u didnt want to see just disable chat.

[pliant mango]

gay was originally a synonym for happy or joyful

[magic leaf]

I like the new Spear Down Air attack 👍

[rich gulch]

Don’t sig spam or else you deserve every thumbs down

[wanton siren]

I don't think that is the issue or the correct attitude, Carl. It's not about punishing signature spamming—besides, people can spam signatures all day long as it's predictable and easy to punish. The real issue is the intent to grief someone. I'm sure you have witnessed this. I believe more power should be given to players to address toxic behavior in the community.

[rich gulch]

Nah every character they add has stronger and stronger sigs with faster movement

[daring sail]

Not rlly. They just have boots so it feels like that.

[acoustic flame]

the thing i hate the most is forced positivity. like just leave the game if u are so salty that you want a feature banned. getting mad over some emojis is insane to me. i think we should get the post game chat back too. why should the game cater to softballs who cant take seeing an emoji. Just play the game and stop complaining about trivial shit. Maybe complain about the game's horrific input lag

[spark scarab]

thats just forcing positivity, u can even say that this is censorship.

[kindred lotus]

Allow tournament maps on experimental

[summer cliff]

this completely defeats the point of experimental

[kindred lotus]

No experimental is playing games where there is nothing to lose

[summer cliff]

no it's for the devs to try new things in its own environment to get data points and see how new features perform
it's literally called experimental for crying out loud
also if we assume you're correct wouldn't that mean that having wacky maps is fine bc there's nothing to lose

[kindred lotus]

No one actually thinks of experimental in that way the majority of people think of experimental as playing without losing elo and there an option to turn off test features

I’m also saying make an option for tournament maps so you can turn it on or off

[summer cliff]

sure most ppl think of it that way because there isn't a straight stock causal mode (cuz if there was no one would play experimental) but that doesn't change the fact that the devs still treat it as a testing ground
no you can't turn off test features in experimental
and yes I know you want a tounrey maps switch and I'm saying I disagree cuz it's goes against the intent of the mode

[kindred lotus]

How would the addition of tournament maps not make it a testing ground

[summer cliff]

you get less diverse data by skewing your dadset towards a handful of maps
which is especially bad if the feature you're testing has rare interactions that don't occur on tourney maps
and how would test maps fit into this setting

[kindred lotus]

The way your your talking it seems as if your assuming that there will only be tournament maps people can still play the other maps if wanted

Also I’m talking as a casual brawlhalla player so this is what the majority of people want I can guarantee if you ask someone if they want tournament maps added the will say yes

[summer cliff]

im aware you want a toggleable setting just like in ranked
but what im saying is it goes against what exp is
i know what most ppl will prolly never even open the lobby settings menu but its about the principle

[kindred lotus]

Not really it’s still experimental at the end of the day

It’s about what the community want in order to make it a better game do you really think the principle will take priority of making the game better

[wraith egret]

always listen to the players' problems, but never their solutions.

a tournament toggle will prevent proper testing of new features, so it will harm the game in the long run.

[kindred lotus]

Why do you think I would request tournament maps the problem is legit in the solution and how will it prevent proper testing of new features and I’ll give you an example most people did not have season 1 battlepass so brawlhalla brought it back because most people wanted it

[wraith egret]

how will it prevent proper testing of new features
like ducc already said, because some test features may have interactions that you won't find in tournament maps

[weary sinew]

Please hurry and push test feature of "hold dodge to dodge while in combos". Some weapons it feels kind of impossible to escape(scythe, cannon. lance, greatsword, etc).

I don't want to spam the dodge button on my keyboard/controller. It doesn't work half of the time anyways

[magic leaf]

Yes please; awesome feature

[acoustic ledge]

um ok

[wanton siren]

I’m not sure I agree. Forced positivity would be swapping an intended “thumbs down” for a “heart” emoji. I’m not looking to censor anyone. If it’s important for someone to express themselves with a spammed "thumbs down" or "RIP" to feel good about themselves, they should go for it. However, there is no dialogue between players or indication that their emoji has been received. So, no foul either way. Disabling emojis or some emojis simply gives players more power to avoid toxic behavior post game if that is important to them, which it is for me and my young children who don't understand the negative behavior towards a game.

[wanton siren]

I’m not advocating for forced positivity, rather suggesting a way for neutral post-game communication. This isn’t about trivial complaints (which may seem trivial to you), but providing feedback for a game I love in channel designated for feedback. Thanks for the input, though.

[pliant mango]

I think.. huh message gone?? 10 minute timer moment

[normal ibex]

please keep the topic related to feedback on the current experimental features

[acoustic flame]

it is tho. i was just making my point clearer

[normal ibex]

it absolutely is not related to current experimental features.

[normal ibex]

i moderate this server because i like the game and i like some of the community members, and want to give back by helping with moderation. i don't care what the context is, none of what was being said is on topic for this particular channel, so if you want to continue it move it elsewhere.

[formal lodge]

sooooo like when are we getting hold to dodge live? I'm sick of mashing my dodge button just to miss time it by one frame and get trapped in a suddenly true combo :( (I think hold to dodge is good 😊)

[kindred lotus]

Honestly, people have mastered it by years. Hold to dodge just removes a skill element in the game

[desert perch]

If hold to dodge were to be added, it should be similar to the non optimal fast fall, with things like this. It should have a different visual and audio effect so it is known when the hold to dodge is used, it should have a longer cooldown when using it so if caught right afterwards you get punished longer for it, there should be some added end lag on the dodge so you can’t hold and wake up attack right out of it, maybe even make the iframes duration on the dodge shorter to incentivize not overly relying on that as a crutch to save yourself like platforms and weapon throws are now.
Also the person mentioning inescapable weapons must have had a typo they for spelled katars wrong four times.

[sly jetty]

Blaster Dair needs to be a lil more diagonal, its already not completely vertical so make it a little more diagnal and it will be a lot better

[steep turret]

You should add it that you get harder bots based on how you dc, if you disconnect because of Internet turn it to hard bot, if you dc because of Xbox turn off turn it medium, and if you just plain disconnect just make the character not move at this point

[icy zinc]

wrong channel

[summer cliff]

not really

[kindred lotus]

Yeah, that's a good one.

[desert perch]

What channel is the best for a suggestion of changing the look of valhallan and diamond borders for 1s and 2s?

[summer cliff]

twitter and reddit

[fervent wasp]

Where can I suggest to fix freezing on mobile brawlhalla? It even happens offline on every phone.

[twilit fox]

sentinel nsig is great for recovery

[pulsar glen]

where can i suggest to change the lance Side-Air and Down-Air interactions with the side of the map, im not sure if its a bug but i mean when you do a Side-Air away from the stage right after touching a ladge and it does it really fast but it has like no hitbox, its costed me dozens of stocks.

[broken knoll]

Hey devs
Dude I’ve been playing brawlhalla for a while now
I got placed in gold rank as I was gold last season and I started dropping rank until I was in silver or iron or whatever
And then I lost 22 games like the players in iron or whatever rank is right below gold shouldn’t be that good at the game nor should most of them have gold/diamond banners and max brawlhalla battle pass skins
I don’t know if it’s just me being bad but I’m pretty sure I’ve never struggled this bad in iron 🤷‍♂️
Maybe if you guys could take a look at who’s being loaded into which rank in ranked 1v1s

[vital plover]

I've had the same problem with even being the rank BELOW silver (in 2v2s)! no matter what i'm doing, ranked or not, i get enemies in profoundly higher ranks who absolutely annihilate me. So i don't think it's a skill issue, the matchmaking is just iffy. Or those people have the same problem of enemies way higher rank/skill so sbmm puts them where you are since you both perform worse against way better enemies. I agree, Matchmaking is odd.

The reason i even got placed in that rank was because i would get plats and diamonds in my placements, so i only won 3/10 placements, and iirc two of those three were also plats/diamonds.

[vital plover]

this didn't really fit anywhere but charging blasters nsig with barazza while using the battle pass 3 blaster makes it invisible

[versed saffron]

Not really an experimental feature, but what I have for Caspian is have him in katar ssig smell a flower and then throw a katar like normal

[winged blaze]

just remove every boot legend in ranked, they are not fun to dealk with and barely fun to play with as its way too easy of a win nad too stupid as u cant punish anything

[desert perch]

Add a weapon throw cooldown or decay feature. Or make it like a double edged sword feature.

[normal ibex]

it already is a double edged sword. if you miss your weapon throw, you lose your weapon

also a decay is unnecessary given that weapon throws normally deal very little damage

[desert perch]

Also for the weapon throws the hitboxes for each weapon show be viewable via training mode and as it is decrease the size of all of them across the board to the size of the hitbox of the missle for the Isaiah down blasters (not the explosion) the one on the missle.

[granite basin]

Gauntlets side light makes it almost impossible to hit the player without having to throw your weapon maybe remove the jump it has when you do a side light

[distant ruin]

Pls add a brightness feature, the game is so mf bright its insane

[sage hound]

you can change the textures for the game

[grizzled hull]

Bubble go brrr

[desert perch]

Make a separate key bind for dodge and dash, would stop from accidentally dodging right in someone’s face

[novel mesa]

skill issue

[red meadow]

the bubble gadget I feel like it would be exclusive to bubble tag,it just makes sense in a way

[karmic cave]

The bubble needs to be nerfed in the amount of extra damage. A bubble and and a stickey bomb instantly kos

[mossy bronze]

Make the bubble bomb a gamemode weapon. Either that or make an actual casual queue.

[dawn lynx]

please let us disable gadgets in friendly queues, there's literally 0 reason why we shouldn't be able to

[surreal coral]

Remove the new gadgets, annoying af

[hazy tendon]

where to suggest features (I have a brilliant idea for a gadget but don't know where to promote it)

[red meadow]

just say it here and hope that a dev checks these channels

[sage hound]

twitter and reddit

[stray harbor]

I thought the new gadget would be fun but it's just annoying

[wraith egret]

you can dash midair when the bubble pops

[sage hound]

this is a game feature

[wraith egret]

i don't think this is intentional. the bubble kick uses the same time variables as dashing.
but it's a cool thing sooooo keep it ig.

[normal ibex]

if you throw the bubble powerup down or down-diagonally on the ground you immediately put yourself in a bubble

also interesting that when throwing a bubble downwards while stacked with your opponent, both players get caught in a bubble

[summer cliff]

result of no bounce and self damage

[minor dome]

Surely there is an experimental feature that brings back aus tournaments with small prize pools

[sudden trench]

devs PLEASE add clans on console 🙏

[summer cliff]

i feel like bubble bomb just doesnt integrate well into the normal gameplay loop
sure its an interesting mechanic thats fun to mess around with that fits the general game, but i think it should be relegated to more casual/party gamemodes
the increase in damage is kinda meh in a vacuum but comes an issue when paired with bubble mechanic
and the bubble mechanic just by itself is such a massive punishment bc it removes the most fundamental and defining mechanic of the entire game which is movement
couple that with the horrid bubble controls that make sense in their own gamemode but not in a normal stock or timed match, let alone in 1v1
what it basically boils down to most of the time is the game unplugs your keyboard and gives your opp an aluminium bat to bash you in the skill
this brings me to a slightly unrelated point which is how a vocal minority keeps asking for tourney maps and no gadgets in exp
and i feel like with every wacky map and gadget we get that request is more and more justified bc they widen the gap between exp and ranked.. a lot of people like to play exp as a less sweaty ranked without the obvious punishment when losing
and i think having a more competitive exp might be better for everyone not just those players, that way new features can be tested a more ranked/tourney-like environment so their effect on the competitive scene can be more well understood

[novel mesa]

they wull if they ever do a clan update rn clans are worthless

[whole sand]

why is the game having the same issue patch after patch that I cant commentate on the chat while im spectating someone? I cant believe is something that is intended since the chat appears while the game is running. I think after some patches this should of been a view but i don't see how it should not be something that keeps being an error.

[sudden trench]

yeah but it boosts aura

[novel mesa]

it doesnt like at all

[forest kiln]

Further Increase the amount of time it takes before you can dash after getting hit

[buoyant stump]

Remove imugi

[modest dagger]

i feel like the new dodge could really improve the quality of life for alot of players

[rocky nacelle]

Nerf Imugi

[dusty yew]

Guys anyone wanna play hyper escape?

[vital plover]

^^

[twin storm]

Make a Unranked 1v1 Queue, or put Ban Gadgets in Experimental

[frozen ruin]

make a ranked 2v2 with no damage to teammates

[bronze crypt]

[torpid niche]

Now that i have a phone that can play brawlhalla, i Tried plugging in a keyboard into my new phone(android) today, everything works great. Wasd to move, lattack, hattack, dash, throw/pickup. However theres no way to change keybinds.( that i could find ) It doesnt even show up in edit controls. I need to separate light attack picks up and aim up lol.

[vital plover]

make a friendly 2 with friendly fire

[mossy bronze]

The bubble thing doesn't belong in experimental, make it a gamemode thing.
It shouldn't do that much extra damage and force.
There should be a way to get out of the bubble if you're hit with it.

[summer cliff]

getting out from the bubble prolly gonna end up being mashing a button which foda said is something they dont wanna add to the game
so yeah just relegate it to a bubble tag gadget

[tall basin]

bmg i been playing this game for almost 8 years and never would i ever have thought i would lose a game to a giant snapping turtle throwing a piece of hubba bubba max at me while i was offstage

[vital plover]

this is the best sentence i've ever read

[zealous kettle]

🤣

[vital mantle]

check out the new bomb #brawl-media message

[tired portal]

Animation for grounded dair on blasters and the spear dair are both very akward but functional. Gun dair should be tuned because it feels buggy to hit right now while grounded.
Spear should push you higher because it feels useless right now.

[rigid pike]

Is this where we give feedback on game modes? Because 3V3 ranked crew-battles with 2 stocks should be a permanent game mode. I have friends who uninstall/reinstall if crew battle is in the rotation and I believe making it permanent would keep players on the game.

[ancient oxide]

brawlhalla a bum ass game

[bronze crypt]

Generally, this channel is about feedback for features in the testing phase (which can be played with in experiment)

But this is a good idea

[rich dove]

u can leave the server mr bum ass

[ancient oxide]

sym

[rigid pike]

Ok cool. I didn’t know where to throw this comment but as long as the idea spreads, I’m happy.

[glossy kelp]

please nerf the everloving heck out of imugi

[bold blaze]

What about u make cooldowns for the sigs

[summer cliff]

already exists

[bold blaze]

It doesn't... I mean make cooldowns for sigs so they can't be spammable

[wraith egret]

every move in the game has cooldown, and there's also a global sig cooldown

[bold blaze]

What I mean is if there is cooldowns it should be more than 5 seconds

[foggy mural]

#1, they already exist. On miss, you are not able to do anything for a certain number of frames which, is alot higher than light attack moves. #2, why is there a need for a cooldown for more than 5 seconds? this absolutely will kill the game. There is no reason for any idea of that significance to be implemented into the game. Signatures are apart of the game. And, if you face a "signature spammer" you should be able to win as they have a limited amount of moves. some legends have extremely big hitboxes which cover a large percentage of the map. Take, imugi side sig on gs. Now, thing about onyx dsig on cannon. Is there a reason for a 5 second cool down for that onyx sig? The answer is no. Take a look at professional players and ask yourself, why don't they sig spam. You'll find that they are easily punishable and light attacks are far better.

[wraith egret]

the "not able to do anything" isn't cooldown. it's endlag/recovery frames. cooldown does exist but is "not able to do the same move".

well phrased wall of text. good job.

[bold blaze]

Brother it's just a suggestion am not attacking

[foggy mural]

I am not attacking either. I wanted to share my input about this idea which quite a few people have. And, why it will never be added to the game. I apologize if you see this text as attacking you in a certain way.

[safe gyro]

Implement Damage deduction on light attack or Heavy attack if a player didn't do light attack or heavy attack after 4-5s damage and reset when they do one. Surely this would stop thoes passive play.

[novel mesa]

no ?

[bronze crypt]

Honestly, this feels like a really forced solution for sigspam.
Instead, I would advocate for the addition of a mandatory tutorial and the rebalancing of sigs to accommodate more for the high gold/plat playerbase.

[dense oak]

I feel bad for what your just went through but I see your point
Not just the frames but a added countdown
It literally went over everyone else's heads☠️

[kindred lotus]

People caught in the bubble bomb don't need to receive so much extra damage after getting hit

[kindred lotus]

remove hold to doge

[bold blaze]

Ikr they are all spammers that's why

[novel mesa]

or get good ? sigs are overall very punishable if you have the correct positionning and general awareness of the sigs

[bronze crypt]

1. I don't struggle against sigspam, I simply don't enjoy the game when I or another player spams
2. Sigspam makes the game incredibly frustrating for newer or lower ranking players (like, high gold and below)
   Which is already (in my opinion) enough reason to rebalance them to be less annoying

[novel mesa]

1. Thats fair honestly
2. The problem is no matter what golds and below will always complain about them no matter what. You can nerf them as much as possible they will complain due to lack of positionning and punishing. Unless you do something that would make sig unless it isnt a smart idea to nerf sigs for gold and below.

[torpid relic]

Remove imugi

[dense breach]

^^

[spark scarab]

the same way u want to disable negative emotes, u could just disable post game chat and keep the emotes. its not to add both, and they could even add a parental control system like in xbox where you have to put a password/pin that only parents should know to change this kind of configurations, and then just disable post game chat and enable emotes. they should bring post game chat back and give the option to disable it like it has always been.

[spark scarab]

instead of keeping the battle pass missions, we could have a kind of "battle pass ranked" gamemode, like a normal 1v1 or 2v2 but you get the battle pass xp for each win. it would be harder to get more elo but you would get more xp the higher your elo (like the legend and account xp).

[slate portal]

its funny cause I just had an epiphany for that last point exactly.

All of the console are now starting to integrate discord in addition to their own chat/social platforms yet we no longer have chat in-game. I've kind of developed this mindset where I just don't rematch console players for the simple fact that EVEN IF we have a good match, there will be no way for me to contact them outside of clans (which aren't even multi-platform). I've even discovered that players you cannot add using the feature in game are 9 times out of 10 console players. I understand that this server (and many others like it) have an LFG chat but why go through the trouble of using a third party when I could just use features that had already existed previously.

TL:DR -- Console have discord but in-game chat still doesn't exist anymore

[keen hinge]

i have bug that Escape menu doesnt pop up when i press ESC button. I have to spam it and it will randomly work. I had 2 keyboards and its not bc of it :/

[fervent sigil]

fr i always wanted to be in a clan with my friends

[wraith egret]

check if "hold to pause" is turned on in your settings

[summer cliff]

didnt yall say that spear and blasters dair arent graduating on stream (~may 14th)? or am i going crazy

[trim lion]

Hey since I didn't really use experimental features I didn't know about grounded dair but after this patch I see an issue

[summer cliff]

i know this still in dev and not fully public but uh to whoever is working on walldodge found some potential issues: (number ref to the vids)
[1] the user accumulates more speed the longer they stay on the wall, making tall walls zip the user up extremely fast
[2] the user can ride downwards facing slopes
[3] upwards facing walls can boost the user up (extreme momentum issue exists in 7 too)
[4+5] a break in the wall (such as a steep upwards facing slope or pressure plate collision) makes the user jitter up and down; this depends on which type of dodge the user inputs and if the user is above or below the break
[6] ceilings give the user a seizure
[7] thin walls have funny behaviour; side dodge causes the user to go off the ground during the dodge and will throw the user up; up dodge gives the user an insane upwards momentum boost (this can happen on normal walls too if the user somehow becomes airborne during the dodge by leaving the wall as the user goes up or if the user misses the ground as they clear the ledge)
[7] the user can reverse the dash direction of down dodge if they hold out during the ascent (actually i kinda like this even if its not intended it shouldnt get changed)
[8] gamemode collisions when playing brawldown make the user go down in a weird way; this doesnt happen if the gamemode is stock or timed etc
[9] laser ouchie
[10] this might just be a side effect of how @wraith egret added this in but pressing dodge while not holding in makes the user ungrab the wall, this also applies to all wall dodge types when exp features are disabled (what we did was pass in the entity's wallstate when determining which dodge to pick and removed the check that prevents an entity from dodging if in the wallstate; did not modify any dodgetypes)

[summer cliff]

found another issue
you can press out and then dodge but it has be frame perfect, otherwise youll lose your wallgrab state due to well not being on the wall anymore
this causes the user to zip up similarly to the thin wall and upslope cases
edit: holding up during the dodge makes you go insanly high, the vid here shows the case where you release the direction after frame 1
double edit: outdodge actually lets you gc

[haughty pebble]

d

[vital plover]

d

[obsidian jacinth]

So you wanna have people spamming katar nairs 20km away from you, without attacking you?

[spring violet]

yd u buff lance lmao😭 its not punishable enough. Nerf recov frames

[simple river]

[tiny blaze]

hey guys a have a question, is it actually better to play in keyboard than control? because i see a lot of pro players play in keyboard but i never seen one play in control :c

[wraith egret]

1. please only ask questions in #help-booth
2. there are plenty of pros that use controller. play whatever is most comfortable to you.

[tribal copper]

Hey, that happend to me

[kindred lotus]

Skill issues, I played a plat 2 days ago I think,, and he complained abt me using 10 sigs in a five stock match, six of which hit him, two of which were bait, and two of which missed. Golds and bad players will always find something to complain about it is literally a skill issue

[bronze crypt]

1. That guy is just stupid and my reasons are far removed from whatever nonsense he's spouting
2. Again, as a high to mid Plat player, regardless of whether I win or lose, I find sigspam annoying, and it seems that the large majority of players do too

[vale basalt]

The bubble thing is too goofy and doesnt fit. Try making a sticky bomb that lasts a lot longer is harder to doge and does more damage

[spice creek]

spear grounded dair is p good

[cerulean notch]

I dunno, could be funny, it's meant to be friendly so, why not 0td ur teammates just for fun or spam with them too :3

[crude nebula]

@slim finch If it's not about experimental please talk in #brawlhalla

[kindred lotus]

it's called friendly 2s for a reason..

[steep comet]

Idk if this is the right channel but. There should be a option to turn on friendly fire in unranked 2v2s

[kindred lotus]

how about you js.. go to customs

[steep comet]

That defeats the point what I mean is in unranked 2v2s you can turn on friendly fire

[cerulean notch]

It's called "Friendly 2v2" for some reason buddy

Btw, I've never heard someone call it "unranked" lmao

[steep comet]

Ik but it would be a nice option
I didn't know what it is called I always join my freind

[pure pewter]

This battle pass release stuff is annoying and unnecessary. I was already annoyed with the 100 notification I’m getting cause they can’t reveal it all at once but that was given the hype pass but now I click to see the new stuff and I can’t even see a list of it instead I have to waste my time playing a stupid game

Any one else remember when the brawl dev team cared about people not spending too much of there lives on brawl

[fallow wasp]

BE ABLE TO TURN OFF LVL 100 LEGEND NAMES PLEASEEEEEEEE

[kindred lotus]

muting the server can also help

[slim finch]

Fix 2s please

[novel mesa]

#brawlhalla not here thanks we already talked about that

[strong spade]

Why Brawlhalla don’t add keyboard support on brawlhalla xbox ?

[alpine oyster]

is there a channel for skin ideas or something like that?

[novel mesa]

no there isnt

[kindred lotus]

just put it in #sig-rework-suggestions

[bronze crypt]

Please do NOT follow @kindred lotus's advice, there is already WAY too many suggestions there that aren't about sig reworks

[kindred lotus]

trust me fr. it's only place where people can give a damn a bout an opinion. asking about skins doesn't fit here anyway. nobody really follows the rules either

[hazy vale]

I’d say all the experimental features are fine but nerf teros now fuckers!

[kindred lotus]

Competitive mode it’s ranked but its in experimental something close to ur peak in ranked like a diamond ranked player should not be going against someone that’s in gold or lower

[mellow aurora]

Graduate sentinels charged ssig 🙏

[glossy forge]

remove imugi

[trail lava]

I suspect team damage is off due to the griefing potential (but this wasn't apparently the case for 3v3 when it was the seasonal mode).

[worthy wren]

The bubble bomb knockback(and damage maybe) doesnt work probably with jiro when hitting it with the up sig ability (with the scythe ),
Like the opponent doesnt follow the hit moves as should be and just stay at the same place without even the bubble being blowed up
I dont know how to describe it properly 😭

[cerulean notch]

You mean the opponent (intl the bubble) is not affected with the Jiro's scythe Nsig?
The signature hits but the bubble doesn't pop nor is affected at all

[jaunty crystal]

devs question why isnt there any gamemodes for 3v3 / 4v4 in the actual unranked/ranked queues

[tribal mica]

before adding new experimental features fix the messed up matchmaking system
im a plat why do i get paired up with diamonds and valhallans

[plush gale]

I like the change to sentinels side sig (the charged version), needs to reduce the range slightly while bringing the hit boxes in closer together

give slightly more nlag after whiffing

Increase the charge time ever so slightly for the new version to take effect, I was able to pop the charged version almost instantly

Hope this helps 🙏

[worthy wren]

Yes, (im not sure if they r damaged or not, but the bubble isnt popped, and the full attack isnt acheved just the first hit, as the bubble stayed in the same place), i can send a video of it if needed

[wraith egret]

please do.

[worthy wren]

It seems that i cant send media lol, so i send it in the dms and u send it?
And i activated"show damage" and he was damaged but the bubble didnt blow up

[tawdry swallow]

i dont know why people hate on experimental features like they are actually good

[rotund forge]

Can you please make it so the bubble gadget doesnt make the person who gets hit by it sent in a random direction? it just doesnt make much sense

[modern wasp]

Truly truly to whom it may concern, I really do want the numbers or percent of the health of the players it would help alot and make testing easier and now getting specific combos. Would recommend this to be added 100%!!!

[thorny quartz]

İt is not worked me i sellecthed new engine test beta but it still not works

[solid path]

It gave me some weird internal cheat error or something. I'ma opt out for now cuz I dont wanna get banned but IDK whats going on

*the tech-test

[zenith flint]

tech-test update has severely reduced my performance actually, before the update i wouldn't really see any stutters or frameskips but now it's constant. for my 144hz monitor the game can't hold it steady, whereas before i was pulling 800fps+. i have the launch options set to [-framefix -setfps 144] so i don't think i did that wrong.

[sinful sedge]

Same

[cerulean notch]

I remember there was a specific channel for the challenges feedback but oh well, this is experimental too

Was trying the challenges and this happened, the dash dancing one doesn't work properly, if I'm doing it wrong pls someone say it

[cerulean notch]

actually nvm, I just needed to use the exact same keys that are being showed, my bad

[lofty timber]

New experimental features are regularly being added to Test Features and the Experimental Queue!

If any current experimental features don't yet have a specific Feedback channel in the Feedback category, feel free to share your feedback here!

For an up-to-date list of all Test Features along with when they were added, please visit https://brawlhalla.com/test-features

Please do not suggest additional experimental features or otherwise in this channel.

[bitter crescent]

Tech test update makes my game 3 bar in ranked almost every game

[hybrid hamlet]

game feels weirdly choppy even at 120-140fps (rx6650xt, r5600, 32gb ram, m.2 ssd

[stoic pumice]

does the new spear dlight make it so that you cant infinitely bounce off people anymore

[white moon]

i have a 4090 and this game feels like garbage
It feels like im behind, like playing in mud, i cant count the amount of the times ive attacked someone thats not in range and it actually hits because my game skips frames (not lag due to wifi), its like I have to predict where theyre gonna be and I cant see those frames

[hybrid hamlet]

This fixed it for me (-high apparently does nothing, framefix is what fixed it, set fps to my screen hz)

[normal ibex]

-high does nothing

[hybrid hamlet]

yeah i noted that

[wraith egret]

so don't use it if it does nothing

[hybrid hamlet]

used it before i knew that it did nothing lol

[white moon]

wow you are quite rude bro he even said it in the message you gotta relax chill bro

[worthy wren]

@wraith egret wait a minute how u got that? 🙂🙂

[covert mantle]

Brawlhalla give me a 7-day band, and when the period ends, I enter the account and take another band? What is the reason?

[foggy flame]

how do i change the fps on ubisoft?

[near jackal]

Petition for brawlhalla to add a west African server😔

[copper willow]

make clans 2.0 with better features like being able to search for public clans just copy clash of clans for ideas idk

[cerulean notch]

Yeah, whatever works but do something with clans lmao

[restive geyser]

my bad this aint a feedback 😆 I suggest adding a filter feature for legends so u could find all legends with the specific weapon u wanna play with

[ionic trench]

at a minimum. pls add to console

[loud ginkgo]

I know this isn't exactly "Experimental mode" feedback but could we not have minigame maps in 2v2 friendlies? The maps added in todays update are awful for 2v2, it's making the game feel horrendous to play.

[mossy bronze]

There used to be a map feedback channel but I guess we don't care about dedicated feedback anymore ^
I would also like to express my immense distaste of the new map pools. Pls fix.

[cerulean notch]

About that, they already said they will fix it as far as I know
But in October 2 (aka new ranked season) Why not sooner?

[thorny berry]

Look at my name

[kindred lotus]

no

[crimson bison]

This isn't an experimental issue, but for some reason you cant text when you're spectating a game. Also the text box isn't there after opening store, you have to back out in order to bring it back.

[drowsy gust]

just played an experimental game and someone did the woman laugjing emote, then it continued to do the laugh for the rest of the game after they stopped doing tje animation

[gloomy hearth]

yeahhhh I've experienced that glitch alot. I already tried emailing support about that. but regardless, that's not an experimental feature

[drowsy gust]

is there a bug report channel or something

[cerulean notch]

There's an in-game bug report system

[sage hound]

which most likely gets ignored as well

[cerulean notch]

I mean yes but, it's there anyways, would be better just tell a dev an issue here in discord if you see em in whatever channel, worked for me once lol

[sage hound]

good for you, man

[sage hound]

since there is no map feedback anymore, i'll put this here
why are there other versions of ffa game modes in the matchmaking games instead of normal timed ffa?

[cerulean notch]

bro, you check their Twitter often or...?
(Not in a bad mood/way)

[sage hound]

i left twitter some months back
haven't deleted the acc yet tho
and haven't been keeping up with the news except the bp items and megaman items (no maintainance or patches)

[cerulean notch]

Well, in that case, they already said thatt was a mistake and will fix it in October 2 when the new ranked season beggins (for some reason)

[karmic cave]

Brawlhalla why did you add the temple maps to 2v2s?
Remove it right now

[gloomy hearth]

I got the temple map on rotation too
idk who chose what maps to put but so far we got too many maps I wanna ban but still only two slots to ban. Mustafar is a must ban. lava floor is not good game design. temple is just straight up a party game mode. spirit realm has the same issues as temple but its got walk off which arguably makes it worse
Divine realm is the same issue but with no traps. I can live with the new BP map but its not very good for being competitive

atp I just want the map set selector on friendly 2s and also Experimental 1s

[kindred lotus]

Lol fr, that was very annoying

[sick sable]

Yeah

[static plover]

When players pick random, XP should be added towards random instead of the legend randomly chosen

[modest gazelle]

Get rid of them mini game maps on 2v2s it’s just not it

[worn trench]

I gotta agree, at least make them only available through a toggle, it was a very unpleasant discovery when playing with my friend the other day. Having two map ban options is nice but I want to ban like six maps atp

Maybe having a stage hazards toggle would be good? And include the Star Wars maps in it

So that people who wanna play without map obstacles can

[oblique forge]

this
maps like these exist either only in special modes, or custom lobbies

Maps like these have no place in regular brawlhalla matches

[cerulean notch]

People don't even bother to inform themselves, that was literally a mistake cuz they already say that will be fixed soon????

And I bet there will still be people that will not even read this message and will complain about the same issue over and over and over again

[vital plover]

i suggest an experimental trial of a mechanic where the boomerangs can be hit to deflect them, or otherwise redirect them

[frail juniper]

Experimental features feedback

[long ocean]

Experimental features feedback

[golden estuary]

Is there any consideration of a toggle for gadgets and team damage in friendly 2s. Maybe even an unranked game mode for 2v2 that already has team damage on?

[latent spade]

SUPPORT FOR MORE THAN 1 ACCOUNT LINKING AND ALSO LINKING TWO STEAM ACCOUNTS PLEASE 🙏

[kindred lotus]

Next gen console support for 120fps

[near delta]

Please yes ye unranked 2v2 with team damage is yes

DAMNIT DIDNT MEAN TO PING MB

[frail juniper]

Experimental features feedback

[wraith cape]

Chat on switch platform

[solemn kraken]

Experimental features feedback

[pure star]

Experimental features feedback

[kindred lotus]

can we make it so we can link more than 2 accounts lmao

[bright plover]

can we add more gadget

[fickle prism]

Can you work on fixing or removing the small elo bar in 2v2s because when I’m down in in 1400 in the main rank bar , I’m fight 1700 because of the small elo bar and I have a lower elo at the end of the season because of that

[cerulean notch]

This... Is not about bp missions

[tight yarrow]

I have these constant lag spikes but it isnt just for the game, it lags my entire pc like every game i play it does it like 3 times and it has cost me so many stocks and games, its only online. I played it with every combination of tech test and vanilla game and it does it every single time. it will lag for a full 15 seconds at a time. I have a constant ~50 ping and it only happens when i play brawlhalla. i can provide videos too

[fallen comet]

good

[silver orchid]

the aftershadow bug is back on high refresh rate monitors with the test engine again

[dark dagger]

The small elo part is your personal elo. The large bar is team elo.

[kindred lotus]

love when i get d-aired once and get exhausted immediately everytime lol

[mellow stump]

How about an experimental firework gadget? It will go the direction you input and explode in 3 seconds (holding it can lower time for trigger explosion)

[high cave]

NEW UI IS GARBAGE!

[thin zodiac]

+1

[cerulean notch]

yoink

[wispy fossil]

i hate this new ui

[silver vault]

hi i have 250hz monitor but in this update i see only 60 fps on the game

[jagged vessel]

seems a bit unpolished, but i think its going in a good direction

[proud hull]

When I run the game on tech test I get a 24mb update then when I launch I get a black screen any suggestions? I've tried deleting the game and downloading again and restarting pc nothing helps

[wraith egret]

I love this new ui

[silver vault]

i have 250h monitor but i see only 60hz on this update

[strange moth]

Straight up, this update made me uninstall. The ui feels super cluttered, and doestn even work half the time with text missing on everything. And then the game itself feels INSANELY laggy. I have never had this much rollback before this update, not to mention inputs just being eaten entirely. Shit job imo

[frozen bobcat]

the new UI is so shit

[spark rapids]

The new UI is so horrendous, it looks like some unfinished highschool kid project.
Please bring an option to toggle it off.
The game is laggy, you are doing a combo then the game freezes, this started after the update.
Also I am getting 60 fps instead of 300.

[tacit echo]

Not experimental, but feedback on the new layout. Specifically in the lore section. The lore is so tiny (at least on Switch) as to be practically unreadable.

[woven oasis]

Hi, I love the new UI and new character choosing images, looks awesome. But I really wish we could have an option to turn the yellow legend name off since I don't really want people to know what my main and weaknesses are, it's just a strategy thingy. So it would be great to have that option. And also I think taking rematch should engage BO3, at least in rank matches. It would add much more meaning to the rematch button since everyone either doesn't take rematch because they don't like the way others use it as a tool for BM, taking a draw then leave, or they themselves will use rematching for the exact purposes. Thank you for reading.

[tough snow]

my only issue with the ui is that the shop now has a weird scrollbar, i prefered all the categories fitting on one page

[kindred widget]

Brawlhalla why in the new UI you can’t customize your room lobby’s for example before if you pressed the top left button that says custom online you would be able to switch game modes like if I was in a ranked 1v1 lobby I would just press the top left button and switch to whatever mode I would like to play so pls bring that back😭

[frank heart]

For some reason I can't upload images, I wanted to show here that some background designs have its end visible due to my ultrawide 21:9 resolution, so they look odd

[rich bloom]

guys, where is bug channel?

[broken pike]

Surely I can't be the only one going from 900fps to 60?
Literally unplayable like this.

PLEASE fix the tech test.

[sage hound]

there is no bug channel😭
report the bug here
or if you need help, go to #help-booth

[scenic gorge]

new UI is cool
but definitely beta still
no need to call it shit

[rich bloom]

https://i.imgur.com/Bpui4rL.png
okay, here is a new ui bug
(dont have permission for image upload)

[near delta]

60 fps is unplayable? im having issues too but come on.. 60fps is good for a lot of people, unplayable is a massive exaggeration to the point it's more of just a lie

[quick spindle]

I'd like to agree here, since the new update I noticed a drastic drop in frame consistency and I turned my fps on to see its being limited at 200. It definitely used to be 999, also the argument "good for some" is ridiculous, I want what we had.

I had switched my thing to -framefix and not -framefixunbounded, still I wish I could verify this with more than a claim, but I do feel that framefix is not entirely ready. If your desktop encounters any issues with rendering other applications brawlhalla will suffer. Having framefixunbounded acts as a buffer

[quartz garnet]

This new ui is terrible. It’s looks like copy from „successful” game. Bring back old one or at least let us choose which one UI we prefer. New is way less clarity than previous. It’s looks like everything is on everything.

[rugged marlin]

there are SO MANY characters that just refuse to be typed when I'm making a clan name, what in the gods green earth is up with that?

[sage hound]

there are still places where the old ui hasn't been updated like when confirming a purchase or leaving the game

[golden tide]

On phone the new UI Doesn't show the next window , for example we cannot configure the training bot or Change the lobby

[fringe garnet]

Is there a channel where we can provide suggestions?

[mellow stump]

The new ui is so nice and creative, feels really clean

[onyx vortex]

Bro the new menu looks horrible it’s laggy and looks like we are back in the beta version it would be incredible is we went back to the old version

[cerulean notch]

How that looks like a "beta" 💀
And lag? Nah, at all

[quick spindle]

can we just get a dev blog with better communication 😭

[light dirge]

FIX this I can't switch stuff back to custom or do the way to enable stuff and some sound is off for some reason like it's delayed for some reason and it is lowkey laggy

[rugged sparrow]

The UI looks awesome glad to see a game that actually cares about how it looks rather than just getting gameplay so far I have experienced zero bugs and it’s been running way better than previously

[spiral iris]

UI has got some awesome looks but you cant scroll through the shop with ur mousewheel

[crimson crater]

Make. Gadgets. Optional. In friendlies plz. 😭

[cerulean sun]

Anyone wanna play friendly 2s team combos? Code: 756244 eu/me

[tight mesa]

We do have a search bar now though ;D

[cerulean notch]

My uhm, why I can't see any of my level up skins in training?
https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/334796885799993346/1297260675776778353/Brawlhalla_2024-10-19_12-10-39.mp4?ex=67169927&is=671547a7&hm=4e5e431d2dbcbf3706f9ac936ebcef08fcd2a99b25ae23c4177381607c4cd6c5&
I own the skin, it should appear there

[next sentinel]

in training mode you cant customize the bots you cant even open the tab for it.

[mortal mortar]

im locked in 60fps even with the 240fps launch codes?

[tight yarrow]

is anyone else having the problem of there inputs just stopping mid match or them getting very low connections and walking off stage

[swift coral]

Everybody has a shit ton of issues regarding the games performance after the update

[sage hound]

my inputs are delayed to the next century

[ionic trench]

do you have your skins collapsed in settings?

[cerulean notch]

Yes, I have it, I use Artemis lvl 2 for example, and the same happens, it doesn't show any level of the progressive skin if you see the video more carefully, it's like, it doesn't show the skins that aren't available rn since the bp3 well, clearly already ended a while ago

[ionic trench]

dang

[swift coral]

Same bro

[bronze crypt]

Hopped onto the game yesterday and all my presets (camera settings, collapse settings, name settings, team settings, legend drips and favorites) had been reset back to normal.
But I can see that it probably didn't affect your drip/load outs, so my advice would be check your settings again if you haven't

P.S. collapse upgrades is supposed to be off if you want to see the rest of your upgrades

[mighty ivy]

if we're talkin about glitches here, I play on switch and I can't make one match without freezing up when somebody does a gc x-sig
then again, I'm on switch

[swift coral]

There's just horrible amount of problems with the game after the patch

[cerulean notch]

Some of my load outs were reset too, but others don't, I don't think that's the problem, I haven't checked carefully but I suppose, as I said, in training it's only being showed the skins that are currently available, for that I should check if that affects my epic/other bp skins too and not just the progressive

Other thing I noticed is that idk if it's with each patch or from when to when the favorite weapons got resrt too cuz hapens often, they just uncheck and that's it

[storm nova]

have u gone to the beta test?

[near delta]

not everybody but multiple people

[kindred lotus]

the bh servers has been so ass that I can't even do ranked nor customs without teleporting every 10 seconds. my signal drops randomly in-game even with perfect Internet

[cerulean notch]

I thought it was only me, yeah, the signal is not good at all
Sometimes it's even in green and somehow I'm still teleporting randomly

[strange quest]

Cool looking update but it killed the performance
The game is unplayable for me in terms of fps and connection

[astral stone]

Idk if anyone of the devs is reading this but i think yall should add a character with faster weapons next time. We recieved 2 heavy hitters recently. In my opinion yall should add a legend with katars and orb

[sacred maple]

some experimental features i would like is some snack or health bar thing we can eat to gain health (spawn rate should be slow to reduce longer matches), and randomize teams in 2v2 customs

[kindred lotus]

I've never seen a platformer fighting game have a gain health feature.

edit: I haven't played much smash but off the top of my head I never knew you can regenerate your health in SSB. @cerulean notch (mb for pinging)

[cerulean notch]

Super Smash Bros. ?...

[swift coral]

Horrible

[twin meteor]

Magyar hammer dsig hits in the way up like tezca gaunts dsig?

[cerulean notch]

Yes, there are food in the game (from different games or just generic food, pizza, burgers, etc), each one regenerates a little amount, for example Kirby's Maxi tomatoes healt 50% of damage, theres another one (cant remember rn) that healt 100%, as well as peach with her final smash make peaches appear on the map to cure herself while the others are sleeping (secondary effect)

And dw, I dont mind the pings

[pure dust]

Yeah but in competitive most of that isn’t there

[cerulean notch]

I didn't say it was on the competitive, only told him it was a thing into the game, only cuz the game CAN be competitive doesn't mean it always SHOULD, casual players exists yk?, but honestly, I don't think that mechanic fits Brawlhalla at all

To the guy next to my message: Nah dw, you good, there will always be people thinking that fighting games need to be competitive all the time and not just a game

[kindred lotus]

Mb jf I started an argument or sumn I was js confused bc I never knew SSB had healing items n stuff (since I haven't played it in a long time) but yeah, I disagree with brawhalla having healing items too

[worthy valley]

idk where to suggest but make replays show what inputs were made so people can look back in replays to see the inputs etc

[sage hound]

do something about bots. they will disregard their teammates if it means they'll hit you. they don't care if their teammate gets hit, receives great damage, receives more damage than the actual target, gets ko'ed or gets killed completely. as long as it hits you, they'll be fine with it

[flat rapids]

If a bot is on your team, they should be able to detect if you are attacking them currently, and predict the knock back, instead of just attacking the opponent in the middle or your attack

[sage hound]

exaclty. thank you

[radiant fossil]

This channel is for feedback on the current experimental features in game that don't have a specific channel.

You can check out all the current experimental changes by visiting https://brawlhalla.com/test-features

Please do not suggest additional experimental features or otherwise in this channel.

[gaunt pendant]

this is happening to me too.. i usually play with 120fps and no matter how much i mess w settings its still 60

[wraith egret]

if you're using -framefixunbounded, replace it with -triplebuffer

[gaunt pendant]

thank you

[balmy quail]

this a new feature?

[normal ibex]

line of sight got broken in the latest update

will hopefully be patched soon

[naive spindle]

No wonder I’ve been getting hit through walls

[tiny slate]

Rayman Nsig hits through deamon island

[sage hound]

spear and greatsword recovery too

[drifting valley]

The snap dash distance reduction feels very sluggish, and is not very fun. Going back to slow, passive neutral isn’t fun. This feels almost the same as what the game was before snap dash was introduced. This is from the perspective of a high APM, reaction based playstyle. I can’t speak the same for other playstyles.

[shadow igloo]

I think the reduction of snap dash distance is a godsend. Opponents are no longer "teleporting", game feels more bearable. Speaking as a casual player who is trying to bring some other people into the game I really wish it gets brought into the other modes in the future

[finite island]

snap dash distance reduction made the game a bit slower but i like it more that way, and im no neutral player i usually play very agressive and it being slower made it easier to punish those who play very safe imo

[tiny slate]

nah man in the middle of deamon island
rayman can tickle your balls from down there

[sage hound]

tickle?
nah he pounds you

[clear lion]

this is kinda funny to look at ngl

[sage hound]

of all the mistakes the devs have made, this is by far the best one

[cinder bloom]

holy shit
what else??

[mild pike]

kor nsig

[desert perch]

Snap dash reduction should be added it’s a good change

[blazing fern]

This is fuckin GREAT

[paper adder]

i like snapback reduction because as someone with above 50 ping i could never get any use out of snapback anyway, leaving the game into a teleportation fest where people with bad internet is a death sentence for above palt gameplay, although i have noticed much more passive neutral players. but in the end it feels much more plausible to mix up the appraoach so that they can't just keep spamming the superpower of snapback to just teleport out of the way of any approach. so more passive players, but its much less effective

[light eagle]

Les go my main got buffed

[novel mesa]

it was a bug so no kor didnt get buffed

[echo basin]

the game is unplayable! it stutters all the time it feels like im playing on 10fps. jesus christ....

[light eagle]

Who said I main kor
I main rayman so like, yeah.

[novel mesa]

because i though you reacted to the pic just above
doesnt change the fact it was a bug

[limber veldt]

Why we can't played keyboard on Xbox ?

[edgy obsidian]

Ask xbox

[left yarrow]

a

[pine shale]

I'm having trouble with matchmaking in experimental

More precisely with sbmm

[pine shale]

Assuming it exists, it's broken. I played exclusively against plat and bronze level players today. Long story short it was a bad experience

[fringe oracle]

Keep the new Sentinel side sig ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

[cobalt basin]

Wait what they do to it

[slow echo]

yeah works on queen nai spear nsig

[sage hound]

not any more

[lethal wadi]

[sterile ice]

I have a q like u know the settings for increasing ur fps? Is it removed bcus i cant find the beta that allows u to do it

[wraith egret]

the default branch is now the same as the techtest branch

[fringe oracle]

@cobalt basin experimental has a double swing for a fully charged ssig

[viscid lynx]

I have a request to make the graphics of the brawlhalla launched on Ubisoft the same as the one launched on Steam because the steam one looks a lot better and is way more responsive for some reason and we ubisoft launcher players don't have that

[fierce cosmos]

just play on steam

[cobalt basin]

Ahh I never knew Ty bro

[lone fjord]

Boll

[lost fable]

my game often crash since the Patch 9.00

[kindred lotus]

[twin bane]

Me too, all my clan mates usually crash since patch 9.00

[drowsy wharf]

Hey, is that bubble item supposed to affect the user when you're close to the target?

[novel mesa]

yes
there is a bit of AOE once it explode

[drowsy wharf]

Okay, thank you, just wanted to check

[thick monolith]

-high -triplebuffer -setfps 144 // Use this in the Regular Branch since it's now Tech-test

[sterile ice]

thank you so much ill try it out

[sinful sedge]

What does triplebuffer do? @thick monolith

[novel mesa]

high does nothing

[thick monolith]

no really?

[novel mesa]

yeah -high does nothing at all

[thick monolith]

Okay

[pulsar onyx]

works the same as -framefixunbounded (deprecated)

It basically disables vSync so combined with -setfps you can set the maximum preferred fps amount

ex: -triplebuffer -setfps 1000 (capped at 1000 fps) JUST AN EXAMPLE BTW (ty ducc)

[summer cliff]

setfps is limited to 1000 not 999
cuz the engine runs on 1ms ticks

[topaz birch]

What happened to tech test?

[wraith egret]

the default branch is now what used to be the techtest

[tender bolt]

game keeps crashing now

[flint goblet]

artemis scythe nsig flying bug, no bug will top that, could actually be a feature

[vivid grove]

Brawlhalla can we please get a ps5 version of the game ever since i got a ps5 years ago my weapon skins disappear when i scroll through them my entire map in matches disappear and its frustrating because i cant even play the game without this happening this happens daily and makes me want to stop playing

[agile tendon]

On console I can't use my mouse and keyboard bruh

[dire glacier]

its a flash game on a console stuff like that is inevitable

[vivid grove]

Its been like that for yrs but on ps4 it works fine

[kindred lotus]

remove hold to dodge🙏

[hybrid hamlet]

AMD software seemingly does not work very well with brawlhalla, getting 13fps, i alt tab it goes back to the fps which i capped it to (165) i do any minor input either with or without mouse and it drops down to 13

[royal junco]

That’s pretty bad, but I’m also on an NVIDIA rig and can’t get consistent smooth performance either

[hybrid hamlet]

Yeah that seems like a game issue then

[dire glacier]

i forgot that existed tbh

[sinful sedge]

Why does the menu drop to 3 fps after the match, can we work on maintaining high fps in the menu so the overall quality of life is better

[frozen fox]

It’s not a brawl update if something don’t get messed up: Cannot create clans using these letters Q,W,K,Z,X,B

[dire glacier]

replace glory with mammoth coins

[novel mesa]

no

[outer portal]

Shutdown

[quick spindle]

This isn't related to experimental but i'd love to see -writestats also generate for client matches

[grizzled gorge]

fr

[abstract slate]

yeah, my game will stay at the frame cap of 300fps the first couple of games im on and then randomly drop to like 80fps and stay there until I restart (5% cpu usage 10% gpu usage) so obv it's not the computer just wish they would fix the game already

[gray ridge]

I have same problem since that patch, it seems like poor game optimization after they went to 64bit dunno why tho.

[rose fable]

FIX THE CLAN NAMES

[lime lance]

game randomly crashes during matches agrivating asf

[tame oak]

whenever i spectate someone and exit to the main menu, the menu doesnt let me navigate any of the game options or use any buttons with my controller (wired ps5 on win11) except the middle button. the only way ive seen to undo this is to use my kb/mouse, or enter the store page and exit. this has been going on for months and its not game breaking but its kind of irritating and seems like a small qol patch shouldve fixed this half a year ago :c

[novel mesa]

will happen when guild update

[vernal lance]

please add a team dmg counter

[kindred lotus]

Yeah that would be funny

[primal magnet]

+1 😂

[modern hull]

real

on another note account level should be uncapped so that we can see exactly which Level we're at and not rely on the "Legend" title

[sinful sedge]

I think the fast fall change makes fast falling easier in the short term but in the long term it hurts players movement
It's hard for me to determine whether I timed it correctly perhaps an little animation can be added to show it, but if I time in incorrectly without knowing my movement becomes sluggish and it messes me up.
At the least I'd propose having an option for having the assisted fast fall, same goes for hold to dodge.

[wraith egret]

i can notice the difference very easily when i time it wrong. but adding a visual indicator is a good idea.

[worthy peak]

yeh idk tf happens

[ancient shale]

please make an option to turn off crossover's in ranked at the very least🙏

[summer imp]

We need to see the elo of the opponent

[kindred lotus]

Fix matchmaking, played my first ever solo ranked and i went up against a greasy nerd with endless combos

[obsidian jacinth]

uhm ackshually endless combos dont exist, they are all dodgeable at one point

[solemn kraken]

hmm real

[thick bone]

Any1 else facing input delay in customs

[cerulean notch]

Everywhere buddy, everywhere 😔

[lucid karma]

still no fix to the clan names? certain letters don’t appear when you try to create a new clan

[novel mesa]

wont happen until the guild update happens

[midnight hull]

i need this now

[fallen girder]

Omg coming back after a year and having to verse 4 crossovers I’d never seen before was the most infuriating thing

[fallen girder]

I play Orion so I would legitimately just off stage kill ‘em everytime

[polar pumice]

I had fenrir mordex when I woke up it's gone how do I get it back bruh

[sturdy flame]

scammed

[dire glacier]

why can you only do so many refunds

[strong smelt]

Fellow Yellow Man

[lucid karma]

so u keep buying mammoth coins and put money in BMGs pocket after making a bad purchase

[dire glacier]

but they're owned by ubisoft why the fork do they want our money

[lucid karma]

who doesn’t want more money?

[dusky breach]

Real

[dire glacier]

but what would they do with all that money other than make the game better

[viscid bane]

.

[delicate hill]

Is there a way to stop the skirmish pop up from popping up after every fight?

[vestal moth]

functional builds for ARM based ios devices... yet the arm macs have a stuttery mess

[dire glacier]

add impact frames

[normal ibex]

hell no

[safe cove]

This may not be related but id love ranked 2v2 solo queueing. none of my friends wanna play this game and im not one to talk to new people

[strong smelt]

Online 4v4 would be so incomprehensible but funny

[dire glacier]

replace glory with mammoth coins

[tepid crane]

it would be epic

[desert sapphire]

have a short and long version of sword recovery, can make a short version of recovery by fast falling

[elder wolf]

mordexs are evil, destroy them

[kindred lotus]

remove hold to dodge plz

[umbral schooner]

why not do a light attack mode. so people can get better with light attack combos

[kindred lotus]

For real though

[strong smelt]

Add Attack Decay (like what they did in Multiversus)

Attack Decay basically insured spamming was not as effective in game.
After 3-4 times of landing the same attack spammed over and over again, the damage and knockback of the attack would be greatly decreased, prompting the spammer to do something else.

[wraith egret]

it was a test feature in the past. it sucked.
you shouldn't be punished for your opponent being bad. losing to spam is a skill issue.

[gusty pecan]

🤣 true that

[dire glacier]

replace glory with mammoth coins

[gusty pecan]

gift me some

Okay, non-man?

[dense hearth]

Plz fix it so my wep throws don’t always go through the enemy and I get punished 🙏🏾

[void grove]

Weapon throws only hit if they lasted 10 frames I think

[dense hearth]

That’s crazy

[wraith egret]

that only applies if you're stunned. it's to prevent you from breaking out of combos just by throwing your weapon beforehand.

[dire glacier]

what engine does the game run on

[normal ibex]

flash

well, adobe air

[dire glacier]

doesn’t that not exist anymore

[steady gale]

PLEASE change the snap dash feature back to the way it was originally, i speak for everybody when i say nobody asked for this 🙏

[gloomy jasper]

🙏

[wraith egret]

programs don't stop existing. adobe just decided to stop updating flash because HTML5 was better and safer, so browsers dropped support for it.

[rough orbit]

spear mains would kill you

[strong smelt]

I am a spear main (Orion solos)

[rough orbit]

one of my mains is orion, and my most played weapon is spear

[summer cliff]

thats the runtime
engine is custom

[shy yew]

@hardy shale Hello from across dimensions hehe

[hardy shale]

Oh i see you.

[shy yew]

We should brawl sometime, theres some other rlly good players in the sn server (like, really good)

[hardy shale]

i used to be a brawler now i don't even play the game lost my motivation due to the servers not being good on the caribbean side and stopped playing since years @shy yew

[shy yew]

Dang..

[dire glacier]

replace glory with mammoth coins

[novel mesa]

no

[severe ridge]

no

[hybrid glade]

make a title for people who got over 1mil points in events, like naughty valhallen or something

[waxen flower]

add stats to the banner

[distant ruin]

Please add a brightness filter. Sometimes it feels like I’m looking at the sun bc the game is so bright😂

[sage bay]

Just reduce the brightness of your device...

[cerulean notch]

I think bro doesn't know how to

[dire glacier]

something about the new ui: it didn’t make the game better, it only made the game look better. i’ve been experiencing weird-looking things with the ui, mainly the toolbar at the top right of the menu covers part of lobby settings. it would have been better if you changed the ui instead making it look different, cause the game still retains its beta-like quality, without the beta-looking quality

[somber totem]

Not true

[wraith egret]

while you are stunned, weapons thrown less than 25 frames ago cannot hit.

[void grove]

Then what’s true smarty pants

[wraith egret]

while you are stunned, weapons thrown less than 25 frames ago cannot hit.

[dire glacier]

why

[cerulean notch]

Cuz yes

[wraith egret]

before this mechanic, you could easily break out of an incoming string just by throwing your weapon up

it's a confusing mechanic, but it's better with it than without it

[dapper tide]

Pro play was pretty much both sides standing at opposite ends of the stage chucking weapons at eachother looking for an opening.

[kindred lotus]

remove hold to dodge but it is enebled when fighting someone with great sword

[raw olive]

Being able to put a list of attacks (like in the new challenges) in training mode, so one can practice more specific combos, along with being able to choose how much the margin of error would be in terms of frames

[fallow wasp]

Where’s the damage numbers UI refresh dropping, it’s been 4 months since brawlhalla’s dev blog teased it and it’s no where in sight. It’s just damage values, how hard is it to add. What. Don’t tell me they’re working on another cross over 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[slim geyser]

Just for fun, a gamemode without sigs

[glad trellis]

Just for fun, a gamemode with only sigs (nvm we got free for all)

[turbid rapids]

MAKE A SETTING TO REMOVE SPECIAL MOVING SHITTY MAPS

[kindred lotus]

add a damn normal 1v1 que w/ no hold to dodge

[dire glacier]

add single weapon throws for dual weapons such as daggers, gauntlets and blasters, if the thrown one isn’t received again, what’s remaining of the weapon will act the exact same but with decreased force, damage and durability

[civic steppe]

some sigs wouldn't work though

[drowsy gust]

did sentinels ssig graduate yet

[obsidian jacinth]

the challenge input detection needs to be reworked or it nees to be explicitly stated that before certain moves you need to jump or chasedodge as it is not clear for certain challenges like the unarmed stylish strings which attacks need to be chasedodged or jumped before

[normal ibex]

it would be nice to have optional inputs indicated with brackets

[hard laurel]

Make it so you have to be level 23 and up to play ranked I CANT STAND THESE SPAMMERS

[vernal lance]

please add a team dmg counter

[novel mesa]

?

[cerulean notch]

ah yes, level 23 cuz you're level 23
Also nah, just get better, spam is very very very very predictable, if you can't against it it's your fault honestly

[hard laurel]

No I'm 84 ._.

[strong smelt]

Force new players to do tutorial

[hard laurel]

Exactly

[cerulean notch]

Maybe not strictly force em to, maybe just throw a pop up when they open the game to enter tutorial or idk, make the tutorial more noticeable in the menu?
Cuz you need to actually search it

[strong smelt]

Yeah fair

[dreamy stratus]

BRAWLHALLA X SONIC ?

[glossy lava]

PLEASE

[solar lava]

Thea as sonic

[dreamy stratus]

shadow as tezca

[solar lava]

Knuckles as cross

[kindred lotus]

how would the blasters work tho

[hybrid wedge]

maybe shadow should be cross then because he has guns

[cerulean notch]

I don't think Sega would be happy seeing Shadow with guns again 😭

[jaunty acorn]

Apologies if this isn't the place for this, but I couldn't find a better feedback channel for these comments.

I tried the Challenge Preview yesterday. Fantastic! Love the way it's set up (I'm assuming the UI in & out of the stage is a work in progress, so I'm not worried about that). Love Lin Fei's dialogue. I truly feel like I'm being taught how to be better at Brawlhalla by the Teacher herself! It really stretches my painfully average skills. Very well done!

My one concern about the system is that it seems to kick out the player as soon as they successfully complete the tutorial. It feels great to clear one (party favors & all), but once I get it right once, I want to go right back in & practice it to make sure it wasn't a fluke. It feels unintuitive to have to go back in just to try the combos again.

I know there's training mode of course, but I do really like being able to see the list on the side of the screen & the check marks that show what I've done correctly, and it would be nice to be able to do it correctly again & again. Perhaps after the first time it's all cleared, there could be some Lin Fei dialogue congratulating the player, and then it keeps you in that same room so you can do it again over & over until you want to leave?

Just my two cents as a silver/gold player. Thanks for all you do, devs! I am consistently amazed at the great things you guys are adding to the game for all of us!

[gusty pecan]

❤️🤢 🤮 💚

[wraith egret]

the information given by lin fei needs to be conveyed in a way besides a wall of text. most players will skip it, and young players who don't speak English (or any language with a translation) simply can't read it.

being able to play the demo in slow motion, with an input display (not just a "you need to press this now". timing is important!), would also be helpful.

[nocturne gazelle]

Suggestion, I need to have an option in the preferences tab to disable the sounds of special weapons, I can't get over this noise of weapons from the Star Wars theme, I know this isn't the right place to talk about this but I couldn't find another place, please forward it to the right place, thank you very much

[dire glacier]

they don’t even have an accessibility it’s unlikely

[red meadow]

brawlhalla doesn't even have an option to hide crossover sigs,what makes you think they'll do it to audio?

[cerulean notch]

They could be annoying for some people but lightsabers would be weird with regular sword sounds ngl
Probably not, isn't necessary neither

[brave radish]

aye, y'all should add a GC Jump, when you ain't go no more jumps you do the GC and you jump on the platform, so it's more likely not to die off stage so easly, would be a fun feature

[summer cliff]

i mean its a client side option that way the people who pay the money for those cosmetics get to experience them, and its always visible on stream so IPs would be happy
but those audiovisual differences can be pretty significant and thus affect the competitive integrity of the game
watch any stream and youll see 70%+ of the time if a pro is playing a legend with a crossover available theyd opt for it
ig you could attribute this to pros wanting to show off their dedication to their mains but i really dont buy that its biggest factor (just look at how devil jin got zariel nerfed)

[strong smelt]

If you match with a placement match player in Ranked when you've already finished your placement matches, your elo shouldn't change from said match

[wraith egret]

Just dodge

[brave radish]

ye but a jump is still better, I lost so many stocks cus I was just a lil out from the sides of map, and it's frustrating

[haughty nimbus]

That's the coding it's supposed to be like that

[meager lagoon]

time your jumps

[dire glacier]

make the game run on an engine that isn’t meant for free browser games, it would be undeniably better

[umbral oriole]

I like the sentinel buff

[subtle locust]

Yes PLEASE do this, I am in the exact same situation and it takes forever to get on, I understand why they implemented it but I really think its doing more harm than good

[cerulean notch]

Although what if you lose the first device?
Bye bye account's progress/items?

[wraith egret]

it's likely a limitation imposed by the platforms. not something in bmg's control.

[vestal moth]

make a functional macos build for silicone macs

[void grove]

Make a feature in training where you could play as a base character, and it would like a robot and change the stats and weapon

[chrome onyx]

Make a feature where you can use any character signatures for each type of attack.
Example: Val gaunlents N-light on Gnash idk

[ionic ice]

Make a lil cool down on signatures or limit the sigs u can use so there wouldnt be alot of sig spammers

[summer cliff]

literally already exists
there's a 10 frame global cooldown on sigs

[dim matrix]

limit the sigs...? are you okay??

[livid zealot]

Honestly when chakrams is split and you morph it should stay split

[winged sapphire]

But then what are you morphing

[ionic trench]

Yeah visual bug. It still acts split :p

[livid zealot]

ohh

[ionic ice]

can u make it so we can ban legends we dont wanna play against

[hollow stream]

💀

[quick verge]

i agree

[red meadow]

https://tenor.com/view/skill-issue-gif-3836540956679717108

[novel mesa]

thats a stupid idea

[idle basalt]

Make hold to dodge not come out on the first frame of hit stun. Have it come out on frame 2 or 3

[civic steppe]

wouldn't that make mashing the dodge button the better option though? if hold to dodge doesn't activate on the first frame then i have a much better chance by spamming dodge

[shut portal]

admins when making the deal with wwe why did you add undertaker and not his brother kane? Honestly it sounds great but which character will this special skin be? my answer: MAKO, why is it that mako has special abilities very similar to KANE, for example he will enter the opponent's map, KANE will come out from under the ring and do a choke slam move I think it sounds great and it's nice to think of a costume that I've been waiting for for 2 years...

[unreal moth]

i dont wannnnna play against anybody with a fucking hammer or anythinng od the sort that u can so easily heavy spam with cuz you cant fucking do anytrhing else

[novel mesa]

the reason might be because WWE didnt want kane to be a crossover

[obsidian socket]

ion get it

[void grove]

Make it so that you can mute the annoying ahh mega man and star wars blasters noise and option to change them to the normal sound

[red meadow]

they wouldn't do that

[cerulean notch]

They WON'T do that*

[red meadow]

because of their money feeding contracts

[void grove]

Such a money grab costing 500 for a cross over no one uses this should be considered fraud

[serene pasture]

Lots of people use these cross overs actually and love them, maybe it's just you🤷

[void grove]

I’m not talking about crossovers in general i’m talking about the newest ones that have been and extra 400-500 mammoth coins like bruh bmg stop trying to make trillions of a png platform fighter

[cerulean notch]

well, is a flash game lol
⬇️ That

[wraith egret]

png
actually more like svg

[dire glacier]

add training room presets

[drowsy gust]

can we get 2v1 training mode as a custom game, and also as an option while queing with a teamate, or even just a 1v1 with my teamate while we wait for a match.

also, was thinking abt adding more game modes to the casual que, like expermental/team dmg unranked 2v2, morph 1v1 in casual, i cant think of anymore.

also also, can we get a display or live count of people queing for any gamemode, bc i would be queing for 7 mins in strikeout for a match, then i go to experimental to get matched in 10s or 10mins+ for the brawl of the week, just wanna see where the ppl are at, where i can actually play the game, that's all ig.

[summer cliff]

having a multilplayer waiting room can have a lot of challenges cuz this game uses a client server arch
basically youd need all clients and a server instance to be synced which is pretty resource intensive (also have you ever noticed how matches take 5 seconds to load, youd need those 5 seconds every time you started a queue)

the problem with extra queues is that either they'll take away from existing queues or they'd be dead

[void grove]

add a multiplayer training mode

[cerulean notch]

Do y'all know you can add a dummy bot in the lowest difficulty in custom games or connect a controller to be the dummy instead-

[summer cliff]

the lowest you can do in custom is pushover not dummy
I think a lot of people would be satisfied with just adding a dummy bot to customs and having it disable xp/gold rewards
like even without framestepping or bot control

[cerulean notch]

Didn't meant to write dummy, is a bot in low difficulty but ye mb
Also, that's a solution I guess, with the disabled xp and gold is fair

[thin condor]

not really an experimental feature, but please make the search option in the store better.
If i search for ex. "boots" only the battle boots weapon skins with the word "boots" in the name pops up instead of all boots weapon skins. (for example the adidas boots dont pop up since they are called "forum mid"). Same goes for all legend skins etc. Seems like an easy change to make, just put all weapon skins in categories for what weapon they are for.

[spark scarab]

please test the weapons before releasing them, every single new weapon comes to the game broken

[ionic trench]

m8. By that logic this game would have no weapons. Period. If weapons were tested/perfected before release then we should not have patch notes for any weapons. Besides it’s quicker to assess/adjust weapons by having more people play it instead of being limited to just the dev team

[red meadow]

this is just me personally,but I think bmg should ban new legends from the ranked queue until it's balance patch

[quick temple]

just ranked, it ain't that serious

[red meadow]

that's...why I suggested it?...ban new legends from a competitive queue?...like they do in tourneys?...

[void grove]

if this was directed to specifically me you can’t do jack junk in customs besides setting the dummy to push over and 99 lives

[cerulean notch]

1. Yeah, it was for you
2. Whaaar, you can't do what in customs? You wanted training, fighting against a bot/using a bot with a teammate to do team combos IS training 🤷

[void grove]

i said training which is a mode therefore the same features as training

[novel mesa]

trainning mode is an offline mode for a reason

[void grove]

o k

[fallow wasp]

How much would the game change or benefit positively or negatively if legends had different hurt box sizes, say legends like teros as a Minotaur (also still needs a nerf despite being nerfed a bunch) would have a bigger hurt box. Cough cough* also Imugi to stop all the gold screeches out there

[summer cliff]

probably bad for the game
ingame gfx proportions are wacky anyway

[lusty steeple]

how much would the game change if bmg buffed blasters

[novel mesa]

they did buff blaster like 2-3 balance patch ago

[red meadow]

btw who told bmg to change their server netcode,because it sucks ass

yeah sure no input delay BUT THERE'S MORE ROLLBACK

btw brawlhalla's input buffering is how they deal with input delay,but it sucks even more now because of how often you rollback now

[wraith egret]

input buffering is something present in every (good) game. it has nothing to do with dealing with input delay.

[sharp frigate]

Brawlhalla needs to nerf tf out of Priya

[spark scarab]

but theres some obvious things like not making a dair fast, fast recovery time and possibility to move around.
like, chakram dair is basically unpunishable, you gotta read a jump or a fast fall, this weapon is fater than sword, the only fair move is slight cuz of the high recovery time, if they tested the weapon just a little bit they would notice its too broken.
im not asking to release it perfectly balanced, but the last weapons we got came to the game completely broken (gs, battle boots and chakram now)
i think it would be great to add a test phase where the weapon is tested by pro players before releasing to the actual game ( you can say they do that in lans, but its for like 3 days and i dont think people who play new weapons in lans are going to give feedback, theyre just going to play for fun)
Smt around 2 weeks of testing before releasing would be great and the community would be happy
Ik the devs dont know enough about the game as players to do this testing, thats why i want pro players to do it/

[cerulean notch]

Dunno if the capes are still experimental but do y'all remember they added an actual cape to the bp9 Roland skin?
Why not doing it for other skins with "false capes"
(a few examples)

[brittle bison]

This is probably going to be ignored
But I feel like BMG could use Experimental test more game changing mechanics
Things like a rework for Dex (So low dex legends can actually have a risk for it)
Or even new movement that can make speed more worthy (For Thea)

Etc

[red meadow]

btw the game audio is still very much bugged

[bright carbon]

Instead of hold to dodge I think you guys should add hold to fastfall and hold to attack

[sand heath]

Buff cross

[sand tulip]

WHY WOULD YOUR GUT CHAKRA IN MORPH 😭 🙏 YOU MADE IT SO BAD IN MORPH NOW PLSS BRING IT Back TO MEE

[novel mesa]

they didnt even touch chakram yet what

[sand heath]

buff cross

[sand tulip]

Yes they did

[novel mesa]

Just checked every patch note since pryia release and they changed nothing about chakram idk what you ae tlaking about

[wraith egret]

"since priya release"
priya was released last patch

[sand tulip]

Thank you @wraith egret But I can't send photos here but I already sent you what they patched

[wraith egret]

skill weapons aka gauntlets
lmao

[ionic trench]

maybe not experimental rework. but in morph chakrams dont stay split anymore. please change it back DX

[ionic trench]

welp found a slight issue. i cant press back to get out of the store. have to press the store icon istelf again.

[cerulean notch]

Bro this is for feedback, not reworks :v

Quoting your message:
"maybe not experimental rework. but in morph chakrams dont stay split anymore. please change it back DX"

[ionic trench]

thats not a rework its them trying to fix a bug

[ripe shard]

Make recovery axe have less start up frames and shorter distance

[ionic trench]

where is/is there a feedback channel? im only seeing the drop down category. which this channel is in

[normal ibex]

there is no general feedback channel

[strange moth]

So actually question regarding the experimental feature with the 40% less distance on platform snapping.... Why??? It honestly feels kinda horrible and makes movement feel much less intuituve IMO

[marsh saddle]

put a gadgets on/off option and tournament maps only option

[normal ibex]

already exists in ranked

[inland meteor]

mrrow

[wise cliff]

I need help. I've had Teleportation for three weeks now, and I can't find a way to fix it. I've reformatted my PC, replaced the internet cable, changed the network drivers, and called the internet company, but nothing has solved this problem. If anyone can help me, I'd really appreciate it.

[boreal geyser]

so far I only seen pc players have experience this,and Im also having some lag problems with other games too,so it might be steam servers dying because of spring sale

[narrow pumice]

Petition to give us a general #suggestions channel so we can give ideas that we want to.

[void grove]

Petition to give us a general #suggestions channel so we can give ideas that we want to.

[fallow wasp]

I beg give grounded spot dodge end lag so players can’t mash attacks and cover themselves at the end of the stage and punish you because the map size is so laughably big that any attempt to try and attack is so obviously telegraphed.

[wraith egret]

get better at movement

[kindred lotus]

make it so every sig has like a lil dot before or where it hits so i can acctually tell what sig someones going to do like koji sword ds:)

[novel mesa]

every sigs already have different visual cues just learn them and learn the range

[void grove]

Make it a setting that you automatically get primary/secondary weapons while in the training queue

[terse hazel]

they should make an experimental feature where you can drink water

[fallow hawk]

Am I the only one who wants to slightly change stance system? by allowing you to choose what to stat upgrade and downgrade? some characters like ember have their best stance possible but others like Lucien will greatly benefit from it. I think it is worth adding to experimental to test it.

[heavy jetty]

They should add a feature that if you share a weapon with someone if it’s thrown at you or just next to you then you should be able to pick it up and use it

[void grove]

Add a feature in trading where you can customize the dummy’s dodge pattern

[kindred lotus]

Make weapon throw broken again 🗣️

[alpine oyster]

do the thing with block attack it would be more interresting to play, that would be perfect for exciting battle

[tame marlin]

add damage numbers and you can choose to place the HUD in the corner or bottom center of the screen

[ionic trench]

(they already gave confirmation they're adding dmg numbers)

[hot wagon]

props for the 9.05 patch notes changes, its by far the best balancing patch note I've seen so far, you addressed 2 out of the 3 biggest problems in the game, so 1st greatsword and you couldn't have done a better job balancing it imo, 2nd 2s characters power creep only missing on balancing kaya a little bit, 3rd one is imo 3 dex axe because of 9 atk teros and imugi, even though this balance patch was a work of art u guys created a monster (might have overdone it whit hammer) because 9 atk teros is undisputedly the best character in the game when the patch notes drop and imugi is imugi, so my advice for fixing this problem is just nerf a bit of recovery time on miss on a few moves and take away side light nair true combo ONLY ON 3 DEX AND BELOW! This makes it so teros is still very good but is more viable on 4 dex (7 atk not nearly as broken as 9 atk) Edit: I'm a blasters nix main so I'm eternally grateful to you for the buffs❤️

[latent warren]

Yeah bro 100% correct

[kindred lotus]

make dlight -jump gp on orb true and give dlight a more vertical hitbox also on orb

[vocal shale]

[spark ether]

Wanted to share a little bit of feedback on the companions & QoL features for them. If we're going to have a designated slot for them, I feel we should have some of the same features other cosmetics have. More specifically, being given the ability to equip your companion on every single legend at once like you can with sidekicks. A slot for them in the inventory section wouldn't be a bad idea if it isn't already in development.

[void grove]

Make it so you can black list mirror matches

[queen solstice]

I don’t wanna play vs the same diamond lvl 100 teros for the 61th time while begin low plat💔

[modern hull]

suggestion: allow a player to invite a spectator watching non-tourney lobbies

[errant kayak]

Please do not go forward with this movement change it’s actually so sluggish

[errant kayak]

Please..

[errant kayak]

Please don't do it.. movement is all I have.

[void grove]

Please don't do it.. movement is all I have.

[void grove]

Please..

[cerulean notch]

Dafuk are y'all even yapping about

[kindred lotus]

crossover skin with death from pus in boots2

[normal ibex]

please read the pinned message/channel description before sending messages here, thanks!

[kindred lotus]

bismillah

[fallow wasp]

fix this

[cedar crystal]

Why the fuck there's so many glitches while playing rank? I can't see when the players are dodging they simply appear like 4-5 frames have skipped and what's with the server issue? I play on the SEA server and have a very good internet connection yet sometimes ping drops to red. It's been happening on my mobile since the recent rank season update. What the fuck devlopers are doing? Why can't you pay some attention while releasing the update, mobile players struggle on its own but with these glitches the game is just too frustrating to play. @toxic linden

[dusky creek]

be able to ban characters in ranked.
say if your plat and higher you are able to ban like 1-2 characters from being played

[cerulean notch]

If you're plat or higher you should be good enough to play against pretty much every legend so......

[modern hull]

2nd

[wraith salmon]

Quite literally LMAOOO

[errant kayak]

Don’t go through with this movement change i beg of you

[warped flax]

Add some stuff on pc like chat, crew, addfriend and invite to mobile

[random smelt]

Please make kbm playable on xbox brawlhalla... i really want play on my console

[errant kayak]

Please don’ttttttt the movement is literally perfect why reduce the speed 💔💔💔💔

[mystic delta]

Rebalance the game, blasters solo everything rn. They took skill before now they dont. (I like blasters being good but I dont like any particular weapon being broken)

[desert perch]

☝️ Skill issue. The weapons “good”, not broken. It isn’t chakrams.

[cerulean notch]

☝️ Skill issue² cuz chackram is decent to say at least, is like katars but worse (from a katars main)

[harsh niche]

can any of the brawl devs add sky/goldforged varients of compainions

[summer imp]

Dante crossover 🔥 jeayan

[neon pawn]

BRING BACK OLD DASH
BRING BACK OLD DASH
BRING BACK OLD DASH
BRING BACK OLD DASH
BRING BACK OLD DASH
https://x.com/lolwitty1/status/1910901430027690203

witty / STING RAY (@lolwitty1) on X

nah on a real note, I'm def gonna quit brawlhalla very soon. I don't think this game has been worth playing since 2022, i only really stuck around because other people wanted me to but i genuinely don't enjoy playing the game at all. new dash completely ruined the game for me 1/?

X · Apr 12, 2025, 3:42 AM

[cerulean notch]

Womp womp get better, if you're bored of the game is more than 100% fair but blaming just 1 change of mechanics rest credibility of your concerns and makes you look like you're just giving a vague excuse to quit

[meager lagoon]

sting ray dropped a huge fact

[frail horizon]

hammer damages way too much for how fast it hits

[covert pelican]

https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/1138501886215995412/1361031173471473722/image.png?ex=67fd468e&is=67fbf50e&hm=42aa24c5c70c5cea678aeecc5e9452a4af415942b4a104b119a257882d1665d7&=&format=webp&quality=lossless&width=1216&height=684

please place skins on the main store page that are equivalent to the crossover placed on the title screen.
now we are seeing the Avatar on the main page, but only the Destiny 2 crossover is showing up

[lilac girder]

The meta post this last patch is awful; axes offer full 360 range, arguably way too much power, and swing at the speed of a blade. Same applies to hammer, aside from the first point, way too powerful for its dexterity. Teros, as the most obvious example, was already stacked is now even more efficient for low effort, high reward gameplay

[errant kayak]

BRING BACK SPEEDY DASH JUMP

[errant kayak]

This movement change CANNOT graduate please for the love of god

[hushed jay]

Idk if this is the right channel, but PLEASE allow us to get a couple refunds a year. When I was a noob, I spent them all on LEGENDS i bought with COINS. You can even decrease the time in which the refund is available, but please allow us to get more refunds 😭

[errant kayak]

please.

do not change the movement..

[lilac girder]

Genuine question, what aspect of the game got mistaken for the necessity of hammer getting buffed? It’s already fast and arguably too powerful, and now… are we serious? I have the same exact feelings about the axe, but at least it isn’t this bad

[harsh niche]

tbf i addapt to dev changes. play about if the game is a better version good, but most of the games players are long term players, moddifying or reworking an aspect of the games core movement system ruins muscle memory and veterans of the game dislike this

please add goldforged / sky forged companions ❤️

[errant kayak]

Please keep the movement speed as it is…

[desert perch]

Changing the movement wouldn’t be a bad idea. The game is too passive now.

[errant kayak]

No stop it

[ionic trench]

hate to break it to ya. the game always been passive. and i doubt movement will change that. if movement is buffed then people are pro gonna be even more passive since mistakes will be more easily punished

[stark schooner]

Add proritize neutral to mobile

[vale blaze]

They don't actually check this btw

[errant kayak]

I don’t even care.. I need the movement to stay the same speed or my career is over.

[errant kayak]

Please. Keep the movement speed as it is, I beg of you.

[swift coral]

But like the game wasn't THIS passive before snapdash

[ionic trench]

maybe. all i know is before dash was even implemented/the reason we got a dash was because of the one tournamnet set years ago where one of the guys straight up made a twitter post mid match because no one could/would approach

[swift coral]

Not dash but snap dash the mechanic where if you are above the stage close to the ground and press dash you snap down to it

[ionic trench]

yeah. so dash but faster/more consistent
so too slow = very passive but also too fast = very passive 😅

[cerulean notch]

Skill issue, be better, you have great movement, use it bruh

[swift coral]

Yeah the problem I have with snap dash it that it makes catching landings extremely difficult, I'm not saying to remove it but imo it needs a bigger nerf. It also makes the game almost impossible to play at a high level of you have around 70-80 ping

[neon pawn]

Bring back old dash pls listen to the pros

[uneven sun]

bring back old cannon🙏🏽

[desert perch]

☝️

[kindred lotus]

old cannon was more like playing with a slab of iron than an actual cannon 🙏

[uneven sun]

😭💔

[void grove]

Hi folks, I couldn't find a forum here so I'll just post here.
Why BMG will not do customization of the player's start screen, I do not mean the frame, circle and kill line - I mean the very pose in which the character stands, IF IN THE GAME IS IMAGE RANDER TOOL (which is used only by youtubers to create previews for videos (and it is also very inconvenient and there are few options )) but if each player can freely customize the pose of the character, this game feature would be useful and players would be able to express themselves. -Rentane

[primal hawk]

SPAMMING SIGS IN RANKED SHOULD BE A REPORTABLE OFFENSE

[mystic wind]

Not knowing proper spacing should also be a reportable offense, slow down.

[primal hawk]

thats true asf lmao , but thing is like , some legends especially in 2s are like pretty damn annoying , and i see people that dont even use the light attack button and are like 1600 in 2s that get destroyed in 1s

[stiff elbow]

For god's sake remove new dashes it's killing the game, you think it's cool but it's not
There are no fundamentals left in this game most of the players quit 😭 it's so embarrassing and frustrating
The game is not enjoyable anymore

[stiff elbow]

Randoms with 0 fundamentals placing with 0 aura or hype like there is in any other game you take they are just mashing
Listen to the community and old pros make appropriate changes you don't have too much time
There won't be any future

[hoary canopy]

DAWG WHY AM I GETTING GHOST PINGED HERE

[void grove]

SPAMMING SIGS IN RANKED SHOULD BE A REPORTABLE OFFENSE