#Unauth. Program Use/Macro Use Banwave Megathread
1876 messages · Page 2 of 2 (latest)
i cant trust this game anymore , false bans evry where , its all region what i see now
thats crazy
and the 2 afk farmers i reported in Aakman still there xd
thats crazy ya
Im glad you might have found the correlation
Now they just need to replicate it on their end and find what EXACTLY is triggering it
And go "oh yea thats not bannable"
Ye each region had at least 2-3 times more bans since the 15.3 maint, and for some reason eu/na up to 5 times more
does your friend know anything more? like any info
is it in other games as well?
Eac is supposed to be there to scan your pc for any software that might temper with your game files
From what i understood yes
Either that banned you or abnormal activity, which shouldn't be EACs job
Or game in general, poor phrasing
Anyone that got banned do the Valk 1-shot combo? I'm sure plenty do, that haven't gotten banned, just asking.. I know I do at Centaurs and rebind my keys in game to my mouse buttons to use one hand (yes I'm lazy)
Nice selfreport 
You do kinda hope they're talking about the skill
Not the input
Then again
Shai players
ofc the skill rmb and s+rmb is the only wstuff you use
Happened to my guild mate
Unless I am misunderstanding, rebinding your in-game keys should not break ToS, but maybe extensive times where you are literally holding down two buttons whether mouse or keyboard may trigger something in the system..
I was playing awa valk with Space+MB i dont remember if its left or right
And my account still fine
Ye ofc there thousands of valk players and afk fishers and everything
We still have nothing specific about the banned people
Rather than most of them afk fished/trained/dummies and used g hub (not for macro just stayed in the background)
Unless we magically find something I am afraid PA is the only one who can give us an answer
I am curious about today, they usually release ban list on friday as well
Coming from someone who was wrongfully banned as I know I did not do anything wrong I’d find it stupid of them to be handing out any other bans right now unless they know without a shadow of doubt someone has cheated
Makes no sense to be potentially wrongfully banning other players and giving themselves more work
But hey nothing makes sense here
Exactly, that's why I think today will give us some info
If there is no list they are probably working on it
If they release a shitload of bans again it means more people are going to get screwed
I'm still wondering when they're gonna be done with it because really BDO is a part of my life I've been doing nothing the past few days other than working
that's their last reply date 2023-03-22 23:42:17
yeh no clue when anything is gonna happen
I don't wanna go back to Path of Exile T_T
No one would wish for that
hang in there!
Thanks
i really hope they reply back
yeah we all do, especially that I put time, effort and even some money in the game and that's how I'm being treated, I mean it's an MMO I'm sure everyone else here is like me
does anyone know if PA support works on the weekend?
they do , but in reduced capacity
ty for info

ever think that actual cheater might try to get away with this thread?
Sure, but the GMs are investigating. If they detect an actual cheater, they should stay banned. A re-evaluation of the ban reason is all this thread was trying to accomplish
yeh exactly
if they manually check what has been detected it should not happen that an actual cheater gets unbanned
they should have manually checked each account first before ban in the first place
people put in thousands of hours into this gama lmao
I guess it's kind of a "we trust the system" thing
We do not know how bans are handled. Manual review may have taken place, but if the data that was used to decide was faulty, even a manual review would not have spotted it
Aka right now we dont know anything and can only wait, but giving judgement on either side is not exactly helpful or necessary
who said they dont done it , its only the people got banned , imply GMs has done nothing and its fault of EAC or Autoban or Mass report error 😄
PA has stated on multiple occasions that they do not have any automated bans. All bans are manual and if a ban is manual someone had to review it before it happened. That being said if the data that was used to determine the validity of a ban is flawed or erroneous there can be situations where someone might get banned even though they did nothing wrong. Errors are always going to happen because humans are prone to making mistakes, what really matters is how errors are caught and handled in order to minimize the amount of erroneous bans as much as possible.
We're the tickets we submitted also by person or automated
I don't know but I wouldn't be surprised if the original response was fully automated.
I imagine if you manually review a ban before you issue it, then your support team probably has no reason to believe the ban is not legitimate. I don't know if that's what is happening here, or really I don't know how PA handles these cases at all. It's all speculation based on what is commonly seen in the industry. It may sound a little dumb to automate that kind of response but if you pay for the support you provide then you likely want to minimize interactions that will have a pre-determined result, or that are irrelevant for the scope of what you're supporting. The reason you'd do this is in order to keep costs down.
Again, I don't know if PA does this but it is pretty common practice in the support industry. When I worked in IT Helpdesk roles there was a lot of automated responses based on data solely provided by internal systems. You can understand how in that case errors can occur. You lose out on customer experience when you do this so in order to balance things out it would be desirable to be strong at communicating and rectifying errors to your consumers. If you are accepting, honest and doing your best effort to correct errors and keep your consumer informed along this process, then the benefits can outweigh the cost of not having any automated response or processes.
That all being said I'm hopeful there will be a positive outcome, its the reason that the mods allowed these threads. By working together and sharing our experience and feedback we can not only support eachother but also help PA in this process.
Given that PA has already stated that they are investigating these cases all we can do is wait, though I do understand that not hearing anything back can be quite frustrating, anxiety inducing or stressful to some. We can't expect any announcement on this even if I'd personally like to see one, but if there is any erroneous ban I hope they will correct them.
I have seen a post on reddit about someone on Thailand server being unbanned, with the "help" of a Programm Called "MOSS" , but i dont think that most of u can replicate it as its an "Esport Anticheat" so he had it running in the background for another game where he plays Competetively outside of official "Ranked" mode (Private Leagues or ESL or sth like that) and it logged all of his actions and he could send PA "Evidence" that he did nothing, but i doubt that all of you have a similar programm running in the background so to say, that it is likely that its a "Special" case in this banwave cuz like i said that person can "Prove" that nothing was running in the background, and that there was an error. Maybe thats enough of a reason for them to say "maybe 90% (or more) of them were really not using something if that one guy who we thought DID something can prove that he didnt do it" but we will have to wait and see
Regardless if we did, what's to say the program doesn't flag us AGAIN and we are back to square one. They have to figure out exactly what's flagging us so it doesn't happen again.

True, but I just wanted to give u guys a kinda objective Opinion about the "HEY THAT MAGICAL PROGRAMM MOSS UNBANNED ONE GUY" Post that you will most likely see during the day that will not give you "false hope" but be honest with you in the terms that I see it, as someone whose friend was banned wrongfully
2 things will happen, either by this coming patch they fix it, or another wave of people get banned. Which of course will grow more eyes to the issue.
If another wave it could be 1 person or it can be upwards to maybe 100 people. If that happens they can try to keep looking + know something is definitely wrong.
On our end "playerbase" pretty much figured out why it happened, so I'm sure PA is getting to exactly how. So it doesn't do it again
Then why are they even bothering to tell people to appeal for it (15 days to appeal thing during login) if they are just going to turn down the tickets anyway, it does nothing but clogging up the system and waste everybody's time, if anything that's just toxic because the outcome of the tickets are predetermined and sending in a ticket would just be rubbing salt in the wounds.
I dont think thats the intent. It sure can be a way of seeing it but I highly doubt that is anywhere near the intent, I'm sure they are doing their best to look into every ticket as long as it falls within scope of what is supported.
I got a question since I am not fully aware of how the process at PA actually works, so you mentioned that they are manually looking at everything already at the first time, which I'd assume that is all the base information that EAC gives them. When they want to review a case more thoroughly like in those cases right now, do they then have to work together with EAC to get a more in-depth view on what actually happened?
i just hope they share what caused this
what did we have in common 
I’d like to hope this is at the forefront for them right now
some friends were saying this shit can be caused if u change ur payment info and shit like that
at least remove the ban until it is solved 😭
The ban list
I've been following this
They usually throw another list where few people get banned every friday
Yesterday there was no list at all
I think (or at least hope) they actually fixed some stuff
Ye definitely
Unless only 1 thing happened
They are sweeping all this under the rug
If not, then consider no list yesterday a step forward
Don't know for sure, I would assume so. They don't tell us anything more than anyone else sadly. We can only make an educated guess.
I think (if they are not doing that already) that they should reverse the last EAC update, review the banned accounts, and then slowly work on whatever tf happened
However a list on a Friday isn’t consistent is it?
over the past like
I think it is, just doesn't have many players usually
2-3 weeks it was very consistent
in every region
and that is when that weird EAC update dropped
I mean it's obviously just a guess but it kinda lines up
March 9th I think
Right before the bans anyway
I see
I am just curious as to what got all of you banned
Like why did EAC or whoever think you were cheating
Aren't we all.
But I am afraid that regardless of the outcome we won't get that info
Since they obviously feel like they are not obligated to provide it
I really hope we do get to learn more about what happened, though I doubt they will give us much details if anything is found.

Exactly, as long as they are sure it's fixed they can just (hopefully) unban all the innocent accounts
And will probably say something like don't worry this won't happen again
Source: trust me bro
No one thinks that
I even doubt if this all gets fixed that they will publicly announce it or God forbid compensate for the trouble
Yea well they said that at first with the ban appeal requests, and then replied to all the tickets later to say they would investigate further.
Not by PA, by any support that trusts its system, happened to me in another game
btw exact same happened in a game called "hunt: showdown" like 3 weeks ago in case anyone didn't know
i dont think we've gotten replies to tickets for multiple days now 
I would not expect them at least until next maintenance
AllsI got was canned response for a whole week on 4 opened tickets from 14.03, I thought it was the end for me until everyone else ended up here the following week
Which gave me much hope
That it’s a big mistake
yeh I'm pretty sure you got saved by the fact that even more people got banned the following week not gonna lie
probably yeah ;-;
Ngl they are probably just discussing this with EAC or between themselves, whether they should make it public and what are they going to do about it bla bla
I bet they are still working on that, and later on they might start actually helping with the accounts
in the Bann post also is written , there is many Videos of these Afk farmers on Youtube and Facebook , maybe , thats why so many got banned now , not say 1 of u , done anything wrong , only had a stick in Keyboard to trigger 2 keys and think , i done no macro and im fine
Most support staff couldn't be anywhere further from the community because support is outsourced to other companies that have nothing to do with PA other than a business transaction.
A GM can be anything from a PA employee to some outsourced contracted individual from a third company. They follow procedures that are outlined by PA. That's why they need to trust their systems.
simple look utube/facebook and u see , whats the problem is , not EAC is that 😄
Yep
little Quote from the Bann Post : We've recently seen an increase in advertisements promoting macro functions/client modifications through social media and various video-sharing websites.
They have many reasons to rely on the systems they make/buy
so when u do a little research on utube : Macro farm BDO , u find all these Afk farming Ba...s
They have no idea how black market looks
Who would be so eager for them to do a more thorough investigation for them to only find you cheated
Logic
EAC is known for faulty bans and no real protection against cheaters
I am sure that there are definitely cheaters between banned players
of course there are
But we know for a fact that there are cheaters who didn't get banned
And people who are not stupid enough to risk their accounts for what, fishing bot?
also again the people who got falsely banned in hunt by EAC only were about 20
So system is flawed to some extent obviously
so number means NOTHING here
I love how people accuse over 70+ people for cheating
i trust in u , u never used macros , there is windows internal funktions to spam use funtktion of keyboard , evryone knows how Numlock works
Just because "it's a fishing event"
end yes its no macro , but afk farming
afk farming is not illegal
As far as I know
Even macro is not illegal
It just has to follow some rules and not play the game for you
i understand all of u banned guys , try to sell us a story , im so innocent KEKW

all BDO/EAC/GMs fault
illegal no. against ToS, yes
On what grounds?
that is the weakest argument I have seen
You are accusing over 70 players for cheating
EAC error does not correlate to a large number
With basically no arguments whatsover
I literally just told you that
As I said before, PA is investigating. Judgement now will not lead to anything so i will have to ask you guys to stop generalising and being prejudiced
Well ofc
But you don't have to be ignorant and hold them guilty as well
They've done nothing wrong to you
PA can hold them guilty until proven innocent
You sure?

Same EAC who didn't ban all the cheaters on tournaments that I've played on
eac also seemed certain when banning people in lost ark, hunt, apex and all were wrongful kekw
In different games
i mean this Discord Discussion is close as Funny , as all MMO-Forum Discussions ever : Im Banned i done nothing wronk haha
Same EAC that banned shitload of lost ark players that were innocent
What is this argument again
Same EAC that is still not banning lost ark bots which are 60% of the playerbase
how do you want us to prove it
when EAC has encrypted logs
that only EAC can decrypt
do you know anything about how this works, they have all the info we have nothing
They sent all the help they can to PA
The ball is in their hands now
No one cares about convincing you trust me
Who needs to convince you
Who are you
XD
true
in LA there was 25% playerbase banned , here is only 50 People KEKW , what u like to say bro .... whay is only u 50 Banned and not 10-20k ? yes BDO playerbase is 100k
in hunt 20 people got banned and it was proven to be wrong nice argument 👍
Because system is not destroyed, just flawed
Could've been 100 players, 200, 300, 1000
All depending on how fucked up the error got
Oh also, even more people got banned than on the official list
Thank God it's not those numbers
when i see Datacolection theread , u all have different specs on your PCs , when there was an Error , there much bigger wave and BTW 50 people is not a bann wave , is usaly Banns , some more than other weeks 😄
Are you legitimately blind
We checked all the other servers
it's +100 officially btw and people who weren't on the list got banned too
please don't speak in this thread when you have no clue about the matter at all and are just here to cause mayhem
There is always 0-4 players every week
And right afteer the EAC update
Bans number multiplied by 2/3 and on eu/na up to 5
Yes that looks like they "enhanced" the system to catch more cheaters
And I hope they did
You can't look at anyone and definitely say they are a cheater or not unless you work for PA, and even if you did you could never be 100% sure unless you had full access to that person's physical property. There's no point to try and point the finger at anyone. We can only be patient and hope that there will be results. Its already created enough of a stir in the community to get an acknowledgement that it is being investigated, I think that's already a step in the right direction.
That being said the point of this thread is not to try and throw blame at someone or something, its to come up with constructive evidence. feedback and criticism. It also to provides an avenue for people to vent their frustrations with the recent bans in a respectful and supportive way. Everyone can have their opinion but please don't try to force your opinion onto others. Now be nice to each other please. We don't really need anymore arguing over things that aren't really relevant to the purpose of the thread.
It's just that we have so many people who are most likely innocent here
yeah ride to grind spot and see last weeks Afk-farmers and look this week , all scared now and are in the thread and like to know , how PA handle this
simple say to yourself peeps : i done things wronk and go from now on a better way
No one care for your theory it’s irrelevant
as all of here said
if PA comes back after their investigation and clearly states yup you ALL did exactly THIS then it's 100% justified
this whole thing is more about the "please tell us what we did"
they already did comment
As both Joey and I already said, this discussion is not necessary and not constructive. This is the last warning, stop it now. Otherwise we will take further measures
I am just curious why are some people so determined to accuse/prove that the banned players are cheaters
Can't say I didn't warn to stop arguing can you?
no clue like by now we all know it' just a waiting game
It's okay they are obviously shaken for some reason
Most of us are aware of the situation here
Let it be, we'd prefer if the thread remained helpful to others. Nobody cares to join a discussion if its just people arguing with each other instead of trying to reach a common goal.
Yep
ANYWAYS I think I still didn't mention this
at the case of the hunt players where basically the same happened they had the same procedure as us here
Better we focus on figuring out the issue here and keeping up the positive atmosphere until PA responds
They all got canned replies - then they formed a group with people who think they got wrongfully banned too
They all compared their programs/hardware/etc and came to the conclusion as us that there isn't really anything in common
so what I wanna say with this is that we don't necessarily have to focus on what programs we have on the pc since it does not seem to matter (except it's actually something against TOS then obviously)
Ye but there has to be a reason why specific group of people got banned
Or at least what makes them specific
Example of how we think the process goes:
- EAC detects a violation
- Violation gets sent to support which checks EAC data, if it looks valid then it will be pushed to PA for review & approval of the ban.
- Ban is processed, reviewed and applied if it is deemed to be valid according to available information. This information will likely be EAC data and other system data which would have been collected by EAC or the client.
- After receiving a notification of the ban, a player sends a ticket to appeal ban.
- Support once again checks EAC data to confirm the ban and sends out an automated response based on a criteria set by a procedure which is more than likely outlined by PA.
- Further investigation can be initiated by PA if deemed necessary.
Its important to remember that support is outsourced however PA employees can conduct further manual review as they have authority over these outsourced support agents.
Having outsourced support does mean there is a certain disconnect in between PA, the community and the support being provided. Reminder that humans are prone to make mistakes, it is wrong and unrealistic to assume that errors do not occur when it comes to detection and verification of bans. There will be errors. What really matters is how PA handles those errors. That's why we are here, to hopefully help correct any errors that may or may not exist.
Reminder this is all speculation, we don't know for sure that this is what actually happens in the background.
I have a question you can ingame bind to actions in the same Button?
Like space+RM
Im talking about ingame settings
yes 
Why would that have something to do with it unless you charge back the purchase of something.
I think then it warrants a ban
if you dont charge back it dosent matter
Maybe people here were banned for using an unauthorized program/macro and were found guilty by Pearl Abyss. Y’all submitted your appeal for innocence but I find it disingenuous to the player base that mods are allowing a safe haven for people already found guilty and silencing anyone with opposing views. If the bans were a mistake then the bans will be overturned. It clearly states that all bans undergo exhaustive investigations before bans are applied. So in essence everyone is claiming Pearl abyss is unable to do their job correctly.
But all bans are final!
Yet I receive an email stating they will look into the ban one last time so they clearly don’t believe they’ve done their job properly
It doesn't even have to be them that didn't do their jobs properly, it easily can also be EAC
Hey does everyone use a keyboard with a volume control dial?
My one thing that I got new last month was get a new fancy keyboard because my old one was 15 years old
Still I wouldn't use that as a change that could get u banned lol
In case that's why u are asking
I'm using one and didnt have issues
My keyboard also as media scroll for volume and pause/continue
I do agree with this. They created their own program to flag cheats. They are going to believe their own program over people saying they are not guilty of cheating. People can lie but a program doesn't, If people think there is an issue with the program that is another thing but some people in here said stuff that warranted a ban regardless.
Everyone really be clutching at straws now huh
We all just trying to figure out every little change we’ve made recently
Yeah like the guy asking if his new monitor had anything to do with it...
don't really see what's wrong with asking that
When they tell you that they won't do anything anymore and you keep sending tickets to support. Even making posts in Reddit and discord. Some accounts were not even allowed to send any more tickets that some created other accs to send tickets.
That question was stupid sry to say.
The monitor one
I can understand the programs relate to mouse etc
but a monitor...
yeah but desperate times call for desperate measures and in a situation like that you try to look for anything you have changed recently as dumb as it sounds
you can reprogram the buttons of a monitor
You pulling things out of nowhere when it makes no sense makes it worse. Im sure out of the thousands of players just a few handful have specific programs for the mouse and/or other programs...
No I'm just stating that it's a valid question to ask when one truly believes they are innocent and it's one of the things that has been changed
Like the other guy said echo chamber. gl
that 1st msg is like what they always send in cases like this
also they didn't say they won't do anything anymore, they said they're looking into it now
then they sent us oh we gonna look at it etc
Looking into something and doing something are two different things. What if they say they looked into it and its final?
Will people be in here stop? Highly doubt it
if they come back after their investigation and can actually tell what happened and it's justified then almost no one here will say anything
But they wont. Why do people not understand this?
as the moderators also said multiple times it doesn't make sense to point fingers or anything like that it's all about waiting now since no one knows anything so discussing anything besides that does not make any sense right now
Why would they tell you the specifics? Theyw ant to maintain that a secret whihc is why its vague for how many years now?
they wont
cuz in there eyes it helps ppl who make cheats
they're obliged to do this normally
read eac rules
Any game that created their ow program to detects cheats wont tell you how it works
nono
that is just....
If they give you an idea of how it works or what make it detects something then people can exploit the programs and find out or get an idea of howw to bypass
No game will do that
I'm just trying to figure out what I did differently I've never used the knob on my keyboard until after that patch
I wonder if the knob registers something is all
We know how it works
it doesn’t work so I don’t care what they find as long as they fix it and I get my account back and this doesn’t happen to others
They already tell you with the ticket. Like 3rd party software/macro was detected
You just want specifics which they won't give you
nah what they are saying is "with the recorded evidence" they normally would be obliged to show that
because it's recorded evidence about an individual
No
EU law
not sure how different NA law is but EU law goes above TOS
ESPECIALLY when it's about private data
You are agrreing to their tems and service
I m sure a large portion of players dont bother reading this stuff
let me pm you and I'll explain it to you since this is once again derailing from anything relevant to what this thread is for
Delusion at this point
You are the one that brought up EU law
lol
Bringing the game TOS which you accepted is part of the convo
yeah but you are coming from a completely different stand point which is NA so it does not make any sense to even discuss this
since I have no clue about NA law and you have no clue about EU law
I didnt know thye made special rules for EU players because of their law 😮
you are aware that different continents/countries have different laws right
Yes companies abide by different rules for different countries. What
yeah but devs wont change their rules because of that
Is this another clickbait?
They are nbot obligated to show you the specific reason why you got banned hence the response you got.
that's exactly why netherlands for example has no lootboxes because PA is below the law in netherlands
People in here are just emotional
Lootboxes and tos and the security of their game are different things...
Sorry to break it to you
security goes even above country level so your argument is even more invalid
idk for the rest but for me i am sure that i didnt use any

I, not saying everyone here did but some did and admitted to it.
No program is perfect
But some people here seem ot be delusional asking for stuff that they wont simply give
Tf would I still be here if I new I cheated and them doing a further investigation would lead to the same outcome
i mean from what i heard/read i think even viruses can affect it no ?
^^^^^^^^^^
and by the look of how many ppl got shnapped
something might have gone wrong
also heard from a friend that eac did something with there update

The game was free 1-2 weeks ago more people got intot he game
so it might be a problem from eac side
Not hard to believe thats why it went up
Bruh
surely a dude who is level 67 50% would risk his account for fishing money
Then they would...I don't know...make a new account instead of being here?


not asking u to believe in any of us tbh
but at least dont throw random shit
and started to talk like u guys cheated u did that etc blah blah
i did say nobody is guilty but people here admitted to getting banned for cheating on another game while having bdo open. banned for messages and botting .
Yea if you think we did it, cool. We (each person as their own) know they didnt
just spare us that convo cuz i am sure everyone who's account got shnapped is as tilted as me and as worried and paranoid as me
thinking what did they do wrong
or what happened
some were meming bro
😭
xD
Anyways I'm trying to see if anyone used their Fn key or used their volume dial
Clearly we all did something or have something that triggered it
dont thik it is function key problem or volume dial
I use mine but it just turns the volume up or down, I didn't touch the setup of the media dial, its a razer keyboard and the dial is above the numpad
And I feel like it's something manual because every week it's more people
I also have a razer keyboard with the dial above the numpad
But I have this keyboard for some good months, and always used the dial, I doubt it could be it
Odd question, in game could you turn up and down the dial on your keyboard?
Well the anti cheat just updated 2 weeks ago and that's how suddenly people got banned
I probably won’t get an answer but I asked support when this “trigger” occurred
Because this last month I’ve had a new rig with almost zero software
huh you asked them something more after they said they are investigating now?
I just hope we get a fix by this coming patch, I JUST got my carrack after months of doing the dumb dailies. That was agonizing
Whoever made the system for carracks are clearly a masochist
Wait one is bad the other isnt
What

Yes I did because it could help their investigation I believe as I gave data on both the pc but forgot to add the date i built my new one which will obviously be of help
ahh yeah makes sense, but no answer to that yet right?
No reply as of yet
Probably won’t be I just though it should be noted because if this happened after 16.02 then I’ll be truly dumbfounded as to what could of trigger it seeing as this new build has nothing.
Don't expect anything to be done on the weekend
.
yeah true
Yh kinda just waiting for patch day and hope for some good news for all of us
Well the ones that never cheated/
how's the cure without bdo doing?
Meh
I went outside
Overrated
I will say when I saw the e-mail that I got banned my heart sank but after seeing others in the same boat and feeling in the same way I feel a bit of camaraderie with all thats been going on.
and you are a troll, sooo
That’s how I felt for that first week when there was only a few of us and as I was getting nothing from support I thought it was the end for me
As bad as it sounds it was a morale boost seeing a lot more come here the following week saying they were also wrongfully ban
sometimes false flags come up ive noticed most games tend to get false flags, when i staffed on servers we had it a few times where it would flag someone for cheating but they werent (other games)
Because I knew it would gain attention
Which it has
I always do, whenever listing to music / watching Netflix, and grinding
if this story about the Thai player is true, doesn't it indicate that there's false positives?
and if there's false positives, then why treat bans like the player gets put in a black hole? there should be more communication, if the process has flaws like this
I mean, its a reddit post about someone in a Facebook group, maybe it is complete fake, idk, what I do know is that IF it is true then they believed that other Anti Cheat called MOSS over their First Ruling of EAC, which IS kinda Sus, AND could mean that they are re-checking all other bans as they could be false too, but like i said maybe that also didnt happen cuz ... idk havent seen Thailand Server Lists and if there is one Crossed out/ Taken out of the List
that's me. sry my reddit might look sus, i never used it before but just wanna share out the information
it's Black Desert Online Thailand group.
I cant paste a photo here
wellllll ok xD I mean I heard enough stuff at Reddit that i am allways doubting it, and it made my bdo life a bit "better" so sry for that i hope you can understand why I wrote it like that ... but the 2nd point of my argument still stands, why would they trust another anti cheat over EAC.... if they are banning on the EAC "Reactions"
he's an esport player, I believe he's in a LoL tournament or something like that. And he also requested a log file from Riot, when he was in the tournament. and he also have his own log file for a anti cheat called "MOSS" that record his pc log. It's not running 24/7 I believe, he use it when he play LoL. maybe he afk life skilling, and play LoL at the same time idk. I'll dm you the photo of that post. It's confirmed that the ban was lifted.
sent.
Nah don't bother these lads are here to convince us such things cannot happen under any situation
Man this wait quickly thing is nerve wracking lol
PA isn't exactly known for its communication
Or indeed it's record for owning up to mistakes
i wouldnt sit and wait for their reply
my friend who got unbanned years ago when kakao falsely banned him took months

what the fuck
if people got banned for no reason and they get a general copy paste response from the support thats disgusting
welcome to bdo
So it make takes months ?
They better rebox the items that will go away then
And work on my gear 
Why you still here?
No one care for your opinion it’s irrelevant
It's not only his opinion that is irrelevant 
You are here reaction
Have a good day
I love the mods
anyone hyped for the new region?
Yea hopefully we get this sorted out before it comes to NA/EU
Asking in a thread full of banned players if we’re hyped for new region
This made me chuckle
who ghost ping me 
wasn't me 

@rustic mesa It was a guy calling you/ppl here hackers and blah blah
any updates on our hopeless case? ;-;
it was likely that nothing would happen over the weekend
I'd assume wednesday
I hope so..

It'll all be okay, atleast you know your not alone
just wondering if it would also be better if we send a ban appeal to eac 
I thought that too
We could but I have a feeling PA is already done that on our behalf. They want to get to the bottom of this as much as we do
PA didn't send out a Friday notice of Account Restrictions this time around, seems more promising for this whole overall issue
i dont see in aakman afk farm dude anymore , not saying u was 1 of em , seems so many got false reported
names i reported 5/5 on the list of the 3 last bann posts


The force is strong with this one
tom literally represents us all in that gif
Stay patient lads, hope everything is gonna turn better soon
I also hope yall used the week to reflect on some more important things :p
Also for anyone who wants, place your guesses on how many bans are we gonna see tomorrow, I am curious
yeah i actually went on a trip in the weekend xD
If you guys discovered the green weird thing outside, I've heard people call it "grass"
And something tried to melt me they call it the sun
I live in an area where it's common to ride horses, rider passed and said to myself "yea guy is probably going for a courser"
No bans at all today????
it doesn't look like it

Should someone send follow up message on ticket and see status?
If theres no bans maybe they figured out what was happening
when i was in your Situation , i would send Ticket all 2-3 Days , so they see , u care your account
no bans has never really happened so they must have found something
It does truly stink that if they wrongfully banned us we are missing out on various coupons, events, and goodies
at least in the past 3-4 months
Think we are just going to eat whatever was missed while we were banned. Who knows how long this could take though. My thought is they are still investigating and didn't want to wrongfully ban others while this whole case is taking place
yup
i sent one in yesterday asking about it
ah alright then we dont need more to ask one is enough
I believe they need to go down the list and see if its "yup this account needs to be unbanned and Oh this one should still stay banned"
and do a full release at once vs one at a time
oh wait no i dm'd a gm not a ticket, feel free to send a ticket in @blazing folio

but yeah they're probably just making sure people are actually false positived etc.
I wonder if we need to wait till now next patch for potential unban or if they have capability of unbanning outside the weekly patches..
aight ima do that later
Guys I'm thinking they will all unban us on April 1st saying it was all a joke 🤣
REVERSE GIVEAWAY

Or they release a ban list with over 200 players on april first😎
.>
ban list with 900000 people
Q_Q
@frank solstice do you think it makes sense to ask them if they have any info/update? Or should we still just wait
id keep waiting for now

btw I checked the other servers too in case anyone is interested in that:
no ban in korea
no bans in south america
no bans in turkey
no bans in russia
no bans in thailand
so they are definitely doing something rn
Yes, can only be a positive right
Was hoping I’d have my account back by now
Guess it’s back to the waiting game for now.
@blazing folio let me us know what the reply says
I didnt message yet cuz mod said keep waiting for now
Oh okay
I've been the GM of my guild for 5 years I don't want to lose it, if you don't log in for 2 weeks a guild member can swipe it
tell a friend to then
Or a trusted officer
Well if we get unbanned before next week it'll resolve itself
sadly we don't have any clue to how long this is going to take
i had 2 drops from the guild bosses
that expired by now
and a mermaid tear
hope they give it back to me
when they unban us 
im gonna miss bloody outfit 
don't worry at some point we'll get an answer copium

this is a lie there are bans in Tw today ❤️
mb didn't know taiwan has a server
still extremely unusual that the regions that I said had no bans at all
seems jp also got 1 person xD
yeh didn't know that one either I listed the ones that I looked at, however 1 person could be a completely manual investigation too, my point just was that the fact that on many servers no one got banned is definitely something
none on the major regions i guess
Im glad you guys are doing research
Im too smooth brain
Also why Im 100% not guilty...too smooth brain to break the rules
same 😦
...what
well different regions have different Tos
who pinged me
Probably either an accident or a troll that got removed by a mod
My English is bad, I'm sorry, I'm translating everything they write on Google to find out something
So
Still no word on our accounts
Getting fed up of this bs now
It's an mmo rpg support, I have no idea what are they doing all day, but in every game they take days/weeks to work on a simple issue
Imagine if it takes days to send someone automated message
How long it will take to actually accomplish something
I get they’re busy with content release prep etc but this should be at forefront of everything
They should at least have a certain sector of people working on such stuff
Anyhoo stay positive and prepare your mentality for a big ass waiting game
Like assume they will take a month to finish it
And try to find something else to enjoy in the meantime
I juggle 2 jobs and attempt to stream. BDO is my only "escape" and hobby so that is hard for me to do.
says who 
So much for that latest coupon code that gives you a bunch of fat rewards
pretty sure our last hope is next wednesday
if we get nothing by then it's gg
wdym it is gg ?
after that I don't necessarily have any hope anymore
They pretty much left us in the dark
Create a new account, new character, new you.
I've payed a lot in game and it's not very cheap in my country xD

they yeeted the other channel 
oh
When is it Monday in Korea though?
Still no email or ticket reply
^
Atleast if we got a " we are still investigating " blah blah
I can potentially lose my guild in 2 days woo

They prob still didn't touch the issue yet
But stupid events are going strong!

soon ™️
So did someone already follow up asking for status on one of their tickets?
ye me
is the followup ticket still open?
ye
ok 🤞

Spanish: hoy a la cuenta de mi hermano, si compartimos PC, le ha dado error (a mi me daba este mismo problema antes del baneo.... por si sirve de algo)
English: today to my brother's account, if we share a PC, it gave him an error (I had this same problem before the ban... for what it's worth)
That is unrelated to any ban and is a common error that users experience. If you need help resolving it please go to #help-portal and open up a ticket.
when
last friday

so... no hope xD?
.....
i never lost the hope ... and be happy!!!!
Once again nothing
yeh they already did that last week
innocents free with maintenance now ?
no one has gotten any kind of answer yet
maybe soon , after maintenance , sicne is 2 weeks now


Start of 4th week for me with no news
No update or nothing
Is it that much of a puzzle for them?
did you send them a friendly reminder?
No I haven’t
They said they’d let me know once they have investigated.
Is it that hard to have an employee check our logs
It’s been 3 weeks and nothing
Incompetent

Don't lose hope guys
when did you do that?
like 5 ish days ago
hang in there
what's the eac? xD
the anticheat of the game
is there any news now ? is like 20 days now , they bann in 1day and u wait now over a period of 2 weeks , get no answers or what ?
im loading up bdo now with another game in the background if i get banned ima laugh
yup we got nothing besides the "investigation is still ongoing"
I sent a new reply to ask for feedback on this situation, next week makes a full month I got restricted
you are welcome to go suggest stuff on web forum. try keep keep post stick to its topic
apparently they deleted everything on the subreddit about this
PA dont run reddit, reddit is completely ran by different people. they are not going to let u post anything unless u are famus
but I have said before. my friend who got banned over 2~3 years ago took them like 6months to get unbanned or something not sure exact time. but patient and go do something else while waiting is all i can say unfort 😦
your best bet is here, forum (PA) and streamers get the process bit faster (plz dont go spam at steamers)
pls move on and remember not to feed the trolls after midnight
I'm sorry what?
a post was deleted
There were some troll posts that were removed, don't worry @static trellis
we cant post in forums
i am confused @fading skiff
and so are u 
what are we on about now 
make new account, not required to buy anyhthign and post :3
Hope you fellas get answers soon 
Thanks @wind bane that means alot.
i think after Maintenance u all free agane , have some Hint for u
RisingSun the Lv67 gamer , gts his Ambassador back after Mt. https://www.naeu.playblackdesert.com/en-US/News/Detail?groupContentNo=4657&countryType=en-US
so very good chances we all free !!!
@astral juniper
oh he is still Ambassador ? think he was the banned 67 guy , must heared something wronk than 😄
Kitteh coming back 😮
He is banned like us, they just never took the discord role.
they never removed the role as yet, is all it is
the monthly announcement is just an ongoing thing for the ambassador stuff
it doesnt correlate with the ban(s)
sadge
but think its good sign , when he got it agane , somehow he must get reward 😄
I have no updates for myself, we have to wait.


I'm not banned but for real i also just checking every day for that bcs i want you free


For inappropriate trade interesting.. Any posts about bans for Program Use/Macro use?
nope
From what I see we are still in the fridge (frozen from March 22 to 2297) .... nothing new is known, right?
sorry what you are going through. i hope you hang in there
So I'm still patient even though we're suffering unfair bans?? I keep sending a weekly ticket to see if something happens?? (sorry i'm spanish and my english is poor --> google traductor)

i hate to break this to you. you won't get your account back. once you're banned, you're banned.
lingering in this chat gives you false hope, and that's unhealthy
took me almost 2 hours to backread the 1715 messages
If that was true, they wouldn't have re-opened our tickets.
doubt he read all comments
1700 comments is like 200 page book of words

this is a bad joke, they are laughing at all of you, they can't take so long to see what happened and unban the innocent. im not banned but yes my friend dont know how is this possible
It's kinda sad they don't appreciate their community, and I'm not saying this to bad mouth them or anything I'm just sad that they'd give us no attention
I got wrongfully banned when Kakao ruled the game and I got my account back.
yeah nothing we can do rn other than hope i think
how long did it take
to get un banned
1 month

almost 1 month for us
1 Month for me since 2 days ago
I'm hoping that you all will get a verdict soon then. Remember, mine was when Kakao was around so I don't know how quick PA is to solve things like this.

TLDR version:
- They implemented new/altered criteria to detect malicious macro/program use in BDO
- They reconsidered that just this detection alone may include programs or malicious code (virusses) ran on PCs either unrelated to BDO, or unaware by the players
- Therefore they will only apply bans if absolute clear abnormalities are detected within BDO
- If you will be unbanned as a result of this investigation, you will be contacted individually (I assume by email)
That sounds like they will reimburse all lost time of paid buffs like value packs, kama blessings, etc as well as give you all the login rewards and event items that you have missed out on.
That's very nice!
yes!
Keep in mind there is still an ongoing event where you can obtain Ellie's Seals for some very nice rewards. So go grind or fish for them! ^^
also the easter eggs

I wasn't affected but I was reading this post, it's very good that they investigated it and finally found possible causes and put remedies. Congratulations to those who were affected unfairly, and welcome back to the game 🙂
HI SIR
I GOT MY ACCOUNT BACK

Touché 
how many days has it been is real question
do u come back as returning adventurers
;o
🤣
should've been 4 weeks, some 5 weeks
well if u were gone for 31 days then yeah ull come back with returner status xD
finaly we back , Poggers
All the haters who accused over 100 players of cheating with no arguments rn 🥶
do you guys wait for returner?
there is always clowns that will say ppl are cheaters instead of actually trying to think that people might be innocent and we have big big issue
now the real question is what will these players get for compensation for losing 30+ days of not being able to play, lose all attendance rewards/events /silver lost during this time , but overall TLDR gj from PA team for actually admitting the ban was wrong and unbanning people thats big win , since alot people got scared that if u get banned unfairly and not get unbanned game wont be worth playing
as stated in the mail, they are preparing to give back the lost items / benefits
yea thats great lets hope the benefits are worth the time /silver lost in 30 days = ) anyway gj from the team who fixed the ban shitshow
Did they determine what programs or things caused the false bans? How do we make sure it doesn't flag us again??
that's what I am wondering too
We dont know details, but it seems like the programs itself were not detected incorrectly, just the use of them
Aka the difference between detecting a cheat program being installed, but not being used
they said it could be viruses, malicious code or "PC management programs" which can be anything
yea, i doubt that info will be speicified to protect the anticheat processes
Fresh install of PC with no programs installed but Black Desert as a precaution 🤣
I was running the game in a fresh windows 11 because I got a new ssd
Computer did not even have steam or other games installed at the time
Black Desert considers Windows 11 malware
WE HELD THE LINE!
Ehh, can’t even argue with that 🤣
❤️ love you all
The real question now is uh
the cheat detection may have happened way before, and only been actioned then, as these investigations take time (as you saw now)
Probably right. Wouldn’t have any idea what it could have been. Cause I came off a 10 month break and saw bdo was slow and immediately upgraded pc lmaoo
Eitherway, glad to be free
glad to see you guys be freed too
I just did two different complete scans with antiviruses and there is nothing suspicious on my pc
so I doubt I have a virus
Now, do I wait 3-4 more days for returner
happy to know a community effort to shed light on a topic got solved amicably and to the benefit of the user
my friend said I am offline for 27d now in his friendlist does that mean I have to wait until friday?
I think you need 31 days
I can't send pics here
but
Who’s Eligible as a Returning Adventurer?
- Adventurers who haven’t logged in to the game for at least 30 days (720 hours) and haven’t used the Web Central Market (Black Desert+/official website) for at least 30 days.
this is on the website
yes which is basically the 31st day
i know some have missed on the actual time and logged in like a hour 2 soon etc xD
but this is entirely up to you
i assume those who were banned the compensation would only be up to the point of the email
no more
Honestly, I'll just log in later today
I can probably benefit more from just casually playing 3 days than the returner rewards
well it does give login rewards usually and different pearl deals etc and access to olvia channels again etc
but thats ur call
also gives you the famous "returner player rng" 
lies
- a downgrade
Whoo I’m back, can finish work and get back into routine 😂
they said they will unban the gearlets

making no progress in the game saved u
we determined that imposing restrictions on accounts without major abnormalities in their in-game records would be unjust
great news 
Received the email, account is back
glad we all got our accounts back. I don't agree with this sentence however.
does not say benefits
I dont agree with anything in that statement. i read: if someone uses optimization tools for their pc and our shit program detects that as a cheat we generously think it would be unjust to restrict that account - but only if we get mass spammed
I am so sorry for the individuals to get banned because of that
With all this they might add the programs to a whitelist
it appears that I am not getting returning adventurer buff even though I've been banned since March 14th. so don't bother waiting a couple more days to log in.
unless you're sure you haven't logged into the launcher (to check ban status) or the website
Yeah, and I also logged into BDO+ app on the phone at some point, which allowed me to check CM
its too bad, i was looking forward to the returning adventurer buff. it was the only bright side to this.
I too dont have returner bonus, every week on maint day I would try to log in to see if everything would be sorted out, no login on the app thou
I haven’t tried to log since 17.03
Would I get returning bonus even though I logged in on app?
Probably no
Nope
Because it also counts app logins (As you can talk to your guild without being in-game, as well as the cm)
Gz fellas on unbans
they said that so they don't have to unban more people
they are too lazy to investigate 2 waves already

GZ all who got unbanned!
I'm so happy for all those who got unbanned. 
This did not age well.
Stuff like this is what ends up on reddit and everyone yelling "then you shouldnt have cheated"
but there wsa a clear indication something was 'off' so
glad it went somewhere, esp with the things we gathered up together
Ye since the thing happened I keep every possible background task off, and even check the task manager now and then bcs of paranoia
Yea now Im paranoid to do anything other than bdo lmao
no anything else. only bdo now. shh
I'm just not sure of one thing, what caused the ban that i had so that i can stop using it
I have few apps working on my PC which I'm not sure about like for example Net Limiter
it can be a virus it can be a code from a programm - they will never say exactly what it cause bcs that would help hacker to avoid that kind of code
that just makes me give bandwidth limits
so... i should just keep going and get banned again xD?
i mean they checked it and would be weird if ppl would again banned bcs of the same thing
i hope so
i mean they didnt found anything suspicious in your game data
@thorny forge OP, did you get your account back?
I believe they did find out and dont want to say anything as for us to not ask questions on the topic
Anyone get mail yet of missed rewards while under ban?
Nope, not holding my breath probably won’t see them for a few weeks.









