#40k-book-club

1 messages Ā· Page 48 of 1

severe trail
safe plover
#

šŸ™„

tall phoenix
#

why wouldnt it be tbh

#

its the entire galaxy

#

bigotry is never going away lol

safe plover
#

its used in the context of alien(alien not alien alien)

tall phoenix
#

I mean no it isnt

severe trail
#

and then we get the

tall phoenix
#

xenophobia also refers to humans as well

severe trail
#

"THEY WOULD HAVE FUCKING HUNG YOUR DEGENERATE BROTHER ON MY HOMEWORLD"

#

based GW

safe plover
severe trail
#

Warhammer crime is a gift

tall phoenix
severe trail
#

giv more

tall phoenix
#

MORE WARHAMMER CRIME

dreamy ledge
#

Oh this is book club I thoguht this was lore whoops

severe trail
#

I am paraphrasing slightly

dreamy ledge
#

warhammer crime please release an AOS book

severe trail
#

but it is essentially the same thing

#

just slightly less uh

#

shouty

dreamy ledge
#

Tbh I assumed there wasn’t much abhuman racism because of the necromunda books

#

But uh

#

Gotcha

#

I guess warhammer Australia is slightly less racist

tall phoenix
#

remember mutation = bad

#

these people are literally nazis lol

severe trail
#

BABY INCINERATOR

#

LETS FUCKING GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

tall phoenix
#

They make the abhumans also repeat a prayer mantra btw

#

"Im unclean but im forgiven."

dreamy ledge
#

LMAO

severe trail
#

I wish the munda books

#

as in novels

#

had the same quality as warhammer crime

#

tbh

tall phoenix
#

yeah its to gaslight abhumans to make them think they are inferiors of the human species

#

so they dont revolt etc

#

also sorry got that wrong, just checked the book

dreamy ledge
#

How do chaos generally view mutants then

tall phoenix
dreamy ledge
#

I imagine much of the same

tall phoenix
severe trail
tall phoenix
#

it depends really

#

LOL yeah

dreamy ledge
severe trail
#

there's def where imperial worlds

dreamy ledge
#

Or do the useful ones get a pass

severe trail
#

were abhumans aren't

#

horrendusly oppressed

severe trail
tall phoenix
#

^

dreamy ledge
#

Ogryn?

severe trail
#

yes

#

but simplified

tall phoenix
#

all abhumans

severe trail
#

including voidborn

tall phoenix
#

its basically gaslighting propaganda

dreamy ledge
#

Lmao

tall phoenix
#

so they think they are inferior and dont resist and bow down

#

its very fucked up

#

Wraithbone Phoenix explores abhuman racism a lot

#

they also call them "abhie(s)" lol

dreamy ledge
#

Void born aren’t even like mutants lmao

tall phoenix
#

like "mutie" etc

#

well they are

#

but like-

#

its literally just pale skin, dark eyes etc

severe trail
#

abhumans are born from 2 abhuman parents

tall phoenix
#

theres a really good Crime story involving them where they are being trafficked as slave labor

severe trail
#

or I guess for voidborn and beastmen

#

they can come from a normal human

#
  • abhuman
#

maybe for beastmen

#

I like to think Gor is helmwar's child

#

one of like

#

one trillion

dreamy ledge
#

Lmao

#

Yeah

#

I think the meme is he fucked a goat

#

But I’m pretty sure it’s just a random event like in AOS

severe trail
#

tbh

#

I could see Helmwar fucking a beastman

#

dude is down horrendus

dreamy ledge
#

Bro is down so bad

severe trail
#

ngl I can't belive they made him marginally less ugly

tall phoenix
#

fat fuck

dreamy ledge
severe trail
#

oh

#

is it like

#

meant to make him look better

#

LOL

dreamy ledge
#

Yeah

severe trail
dreamy ledge
#

Every artist before the one that made this was like, put to death

severe trail
#

it was the worst thing she's ever done for the imperium

dreamy ledge
#

They king louie tf out of helmwar

cerulean peak
#

who's this fine man

tall phoenix
#

Lord Gerontius Helmawr

#

the supreme governor of Munda-munda

dreamy ledge
#

Helmwar? The probably evilest character in 40K that we know of

severe trail
#

not really

#

he is def like

#

one of the most evil planetary govenors though

cerulean peak
#

is there good necromunda litterature

severe trail
#

he's also competent

dreamy ledge
#

Fair

severe trail
#

which is horrifying

cerulean peak
#

i know nothing of it

dreamy ledge
#

I’d say top 5

severe trail
#

rulebook lore

#

Rulebook lore

cerulean peak
#

looks dope tho

severe trail
#

rulebook lore

#

always for munda

cerulean peak
#

feelsbad

severe trail
#

the novels are very very supplemental

tall phoenix
#

^

#

the rulebooks legit tell stories btw

#

that like

#

have actual consequences

severe trail
#

Ngl

tall phoenix
#

and shit actually changes on the planet lol

severe trail
#

if you had told me

#

10 years ago

#

helmwar would no longer be the leader of munda

#

I would have called you

dreamy ledge
#

Crazy that helmwar’s ā€˜reasoning’ for being horrible

severe trail
#

insane

#

and stupid

tall phoenix
#

Same.

severe trail
#

but uh yeah

dreamy ledge
#

Is that horrible people are more deserving of power

tall phoenix
#

im so glad Necromunda writers are the way they are

severe trail
#

Helmwar is in a coma

#

lol

#

his now "first" daughter

#

is in control

tall phoenix
severe trail
#

"first" as in she murdered

tall phoenix
#

theres wild shit like uhhh

severe trail
#

everyone else infront of her

tall phoenix
#

congradulating more gang violence

#

lol

severe trail
dreamy ledge
#

I read if forever ago but I forgot

#

It’s like, the best quote ever

severe trail
#

also ngl

#

I lowkey did not like the hive secundus stuff

#

for munda

#

the lore in it was

dreamy ledge
#

Literally me and another gang killed each other for 50 credits

severe trail
#

very meh

tall phoenix
#

its mostly a slowburner

#

or more like uhhh

severe trail
#

it feels like its all setup

tall phoenix
#

side-story

#

Yeah basically that

severe trail
#

for something

tall phoenix
#

Nah it is

severe trail
#

and its weird because

#

GW rulebook lore doesn't really do that

#

like ever

tall phoenix
#

the only important event in it, is Haera getting a proper spyrer suit

severe trail
#

honestly my only real reaction to the end of it was

#

"that was it?"

#

"Haera gets a fancy spyrer suit and the Van Saar teams die horribly"

#

and its not even like gone into lol

dreamy ledge
#

I am very excited for the rest of the house gangs to get their treasure hunter boxes

#

I forgot the archetype name

severe trail
#

inb4 they get forgotten

#

like all the bounty hunters

#

GW PLEASE THERE'S LIKE 20 MORE WHO NEED MINIS

dreamy ledge
#

WIAY THERES FERRYMAN GANGS?!?!

#

Well you hire them

#

But

#

THERE IS RULES

severe trail
#

Yes

dreamy ledge
severe trail
#

they deserve it smh

#

the same way Vandroth deserved his, and every other bounty hunter

dreamy ledge
#

did they ever fix the bug that gives outcast champions spells that never fail?

severe trail
#

Yes

#

iirc

dreamy ledge
#

Crazy

#

And they fixed vindicator gangs making them like

#

Fun

#

I already loved them tho

severe trail
#

Helot gangs still suck

#

but Helot gangs are for the derranged

#

I love having autoguns as an upgrade I have to pay for

dreamy ledge
#

LMAO

severe trail
#

Oh also

#

they're cheaper then juves

#

for actual gangers

#

Helot juves are

dreamy ledge
#

They have juves???

severe trail
#

they're certainly an option that you could bring that is not exactly detrimental

severe trail
#

Anyways they suck

dreamy ledge
#

Lmao

severe trail
#

run normal Gangers

#

for the love of god

#

you will actively make it worse for you to play the game

dreamy ledge
#

Im so excited to read the pdf of the ashwaste nomads

#

They are so cool

#

And so easily could have just been an NPC faction like the hellstrain gang

severe trail
#

hellstrain?

dreamy ledge
#

The incest genestealers

severe trail
#

oh malstrain

dreamy ledge
#

Did I say hellstrain

#

Damn it

unborn merlin
#

Red Tithe was pretty damn fun.

hearty niche
#

Got to love this minimalistic book cover

brittle tapir
#

listening to blood meridian. i wish i knew spanish

shy lark
#

Trust in the judge

brittle tapir
safe plover
#

nah i maintain

#

the lost and damned a lot better than solar war

#

idc

tall phoenix
#

I mean

#

Solar War is not a good book

#

so thats not really a bad statement lol

safe plover
#

but my hatchet is already sharpened...

unborn merlin
#

The Lost and the Damned gets a bad rap.

#

I personally enjoyed it a lot.

tall phoenix
#

Yeah I didnt really hate it when I read it, I just moved on lol

unborn merlin
#

I was sold as soon as the Beastmen showed up.

brittle tapir
#

ok i finished blood meridian

#

had to get some whiskey in me to properly digest this shit

#

my conclusions are that the judge is a representation of God in the gnostic sense, a materialist force of human will who cannot be defeated by any means since he is at the core of humanity

safe plover
#

why are u reading real books

shy lark
#

It's a good book

#

I wondered if the beloved Judge is a personification of humanity, or McCarthys bleak view of humanity

tall phoenix
#

definitely one of those lol

shy lark
#

I find it decidedly funny if you look at him as just an ordinary man, what a stud

tall phoenix
#

Lmfao hes definitely not ordinary but i agree its funny

#

fucking albino macho-man 😭

severe trail
#

Blood meridian good

tall phoenix
brittle tapir
#

if that was what cormac was going for

tall phoenix
#

its left up to the reader

#

much like the ending

#

hes very much the epitome of a "evil force of nature" to some extent

brittle tapir
#

he is a materialist to the extreme

#

and he can't even be argued with

#

that's the part that messed with me the most

#

at first i thought he was a representation of satan but it's deeper than that

royal egret
#

I think he’s a representation of a evil gang leader

brittle tapir
#

he isn't the leader though

royal egret
#

Whatever he was

#

It’s been years since I read that book

unborn merlin
#

Brother can heave a cannon on one shoulder while also appearing omnipotent and capable of persuading any man.

#

He says that he will never die. He dances in light and in shadow and he is a great favorite. He never sleeps, the judge.

brittle tapir
#

Glanton is the maniac gang leader with little morals

#

but the judge is always there at his side

#

edging him towards insanity

royal egret
#

He’s a representation of how far the homies will go

tall phoenix
#

hes always the one guiding people towards evil shit

#

the seed is already laid pretty much

royal egret
#

Huh I forgot that Cormac did No Country for Old Men and the Road too

tall phoenix
#

Its important to take notice of the early signs of dementia

brittle tapir
tall phoenix
#

Yeeee

unborn merlin
#

I do find the idea that McCarthy found these two completely irredeemable pieces of shit in a history book and said...yeah I can make a banger western folk horror story with this.

royal egret
#

I need to re read a lot of those, I read them when I was probably too young to be reading that and appreciate it

tall phoenix
#

its why I like his character, hes edgy for edgy's sake on the purpose but hes pretty deep still

shy lark
#

I vaguely recall McCarthy being into gnosticism, so it's a valid reading

brittle tapir
#

the judge is a man of science who knows everything

#

science is materialism

tall phoenix
#

Man this is making me want to re-read the book

#

I read it like all the way back in college lol

#

people were asking me "oh whats that book about!"

#

me at the passage about scalps (aka half the book)

shy lark
#

I was telling my friends about it and they didn't care, post sad pepe

#

That's exactly what I told them about, and the babytree

brittle tapir
#

i had just finished listening to the road

#

last week

#

and that one is waaaay more gnostic

#

also holy shit the movie waters it down so much

tall phoenix
unborn merlin
#

Bro really said whatever in creation exists without my knowledge exists without my consent.

tall phoenix
#

Actually hold on

shy lark
#

same bro tbh fuck unknown things

tall phoenix
#

there has to be a Holden wojak

unborn merlin
#

The Judge knows how to Reddit.

tall phoenix
#

Damn, I hate this

#

LOL

unborn merlin
#

KEK

severe trail
#

Horrid

royal egret
#

It’s funny cause the Road has so little in common with No Country

brittle tapir
#

also something i had to take the time to think about is why he does what he does to children

#

i think he desires to destroy childhood innocence

tall phoenix
royal egret
#

Real

#

Where Holden sigma male edits?

tall phoenix
#

Im sure they exist

shy lark
#

is cwc forbidden here

royal egret
unborn merlin
#

I can't recommend Richard Poe's narration of Blood Meridian enough. His Judge is truly terrifying to listen to. His Spanish is pretty good too.

royal egret
#

lol why are there so many of these lol

shy lark
brittle tapir
#

yeah but i know cormac didn't write his pedo stuff for shock value alone

#

at one point he shoots a kid's puppies for seemingly no reason

unborn merlin
#

The real dude was an alleged pedophile and child murderer.

brittle tapir
#

i really think the judge hates childhood innocence

unborn merlin
#

There's definitely more fact than fiction if you take out the supernatural stuff.

#

They were real people doing very real and heinous acts which probably makes the book even more eerie.

brittle tapir
#

meh i looked into the historical accuracy too

#

the judge holden irl person is barely known about

royal egret
#

I don’t think the strict historical accuracy is that important

#

It’s the vibes and general idea that he’s going for

brittle tapir
#

his entire character is written from samuel chamberlain's a count of the glanton gang

#

who writes specifically about a very tall pale guy with no hair at all who seemed very knowledgeable

#

that's all we really know about the real guy

tall phoenix
#

its historical fiction

royal egret
#

Cormac sure does like downer endings

unborn merlin
#

We don't know anything concrete about the dude because he really was a supernatural being.

tall phoenix
#

It still exists within a modicum of reality but has semi-supernatural elements

brittle tapir
#

it's very important to the story

#

he wanted to represent the world as it was in that period without embellishment

#

the horror of the story is how it was real

#

the glanton scalper gang really existed

unborn merlin
#

I still think McCarthy's biggest downer book is Suttree. Please please give it a try if you haven't already. It's tied with Blood Meridian as my favorite book of his.

royal egret
#

I guess but I don’t think any of his other books which aren’t real are less horrifying

#

It’s horrifying but it’s also told in such a like

#

Idk the prose and descriptions are what makes it

unborn merlin
#

All the Pretty Horses is phenomenal as well. Most romantic book about horses ever written lmao.

#

Really need to finish his Border trilogy.

brittle tapir
#

i think i'm done with his books for now

#

my psyche can only take so much

#

the road really bummed me out hard

royal egret
#

They’re very depressing

unborn merlin
#

They're all pretty depressing lmao.

royal egret
#

The Road is like

unborn merlin
#

Maybe not so much his later books.

royal egret
#

The happiest ending he does that I’ve read iirc too lol

unborn merlin
#

The Orchard Keeper is a pretty easy read.

#

Being his first book and all.

#

It's just one big slice of life book about people being goofy in the mountains.

royal egret
#

I don’t think I’ve read most his books, just some of the depressing ones lol

brittle tapir
#

apparently a blood meridian movie is in the making right now

unborn merlin
#

I'd say 75% are pure depression and the other 25% are super sincere character studies.

brittle tapir
#

the same guy who directed the road movie

unborn merlin
#

People don't really read his more comedic stuff which is incredibly funny.

#

Granted it's usually just poor mountain folk trying to get by in life. Super holistic stuff.

royal egret
#

Idk how you’d film it

brittle tapir
#

yeah but this time it's real

#

cormac signed off on it before he passed away

royal egret
#

But who knows

unborn merlin
#

They've been trying to make that movie for decades now lmao.

#

Get the guy who did Bone Tomahawk to direct it.

#

I'd watch it in a heartbeat.

brittle tapir
#

some books just shouldn't be made into movies but we'll see

unborn merlin
#

Yeah but somebody was going to take a shot anyways.

royal egret
#

Bone tomahawk deserves a better name for that movie

unborn merlin
#

I find it pretty fitting.

#

It's just an incredibly well made b movie lmao.

royal egret
#

Yeah

brittle tapir
#

im still pretty disappointed in the road movie, i watched it before reading the book and it's ruined for me now

#

the scene with the man they meet is so stupid in the movie

royal egret
#

I haven’t seen the movie

#

The book depressed me a lot

#

Even if it ends not terrible

brittle tapir
#

the movie is a lot more uplifting

#

in a way i dislike

unborn merlin
#

It's a solid movie. Just not as weighty as the book.

brittle tapir
#

it's like it thinks you're too stupid to feel sad enough

unborn merlin
#

The scene at the house is so much more unsettling in the book.

#

Remember wanting to throw up as a kid when I was reading it for the first time.

brittle tapir
#

also the movie goes with straight christian themes instead of gnosticism which idk how cormac thought was ok

#

this scene is what really annoyed me

#

the random old man is so important to the story for me in the book

#

in the book he doesn't believe there is a god for how can there be one with everything that has happened

#

and when the man asks what he thought he saw when he saw the boy he replies:
i don't know what i saw

#

and the movie goes with:
an angel

#

like fuck you movie

brittle tapir
#

this man brings absolutely no joy in the book

#

he's bitter and he's barely alive

unborn merlin
#

The movie is more hopeful in tone. Don't think it's an entirely bad adaptation but it's definitely a different vibe. Remember it having some great acting.

brittle tapir
#

of course the acting is great with the cast

#

and the ending does hit hard as well as the book

#

also something really weird about the road is how its fans are so obsessed with the cause of the apocalypse

#

as if that has any bearings on the story

#

anyways these books introduced me to gnosticism which im looking forward to learn about

#

very interesting belief system that i'm not surprised to learn got almost stomped out of existence numerous times in history by big christian denominations

shy lark
#

Clearly, Arianism was the only one to have it right. It's not my fascination with the goths that dictates it

tall phoenix
#

NOOOO

shy lark
#

what're you, a council of nicaealet?

brittle tapir
mental cobalt
#

I bought a scifi book called Project Hail Mary to read after Siege nod

tall phoenix
#

wise, the 30k rot must be cleansed

mental cobalt
#

Then we go back to the 40k setting nod

frigid osprey
#

40k setting is soo much better

tall phoenix
#

Diverse characterisation is needed!

#

šŸ—£ļø

royal egret
#

It’s easy to enjoy both, depends on what I’m looking for

#

They have very different vibes

tall phoenix
#

I was literally about to say "i hope someone isnt triggered by this statement"

#

like clockwork

royal egret
#

Sorry yes I mean ā€œThis subjective setting bad, this subjective setting goodā€

paper maple
#

Nobody asked

#

centrist ahh

royal egret
#

We must always compare things by shitting on one, it is impossible to enjoy two things

tall phoenix
#

I mean people will always have differing opinions on the subject

royal egret
#

Grimdank ass opinions

tall phoenix
#

You'd know redditor

royal egret
#

I didn’t say we need to enjoy all of it

paper maple
#

You always do though

#

"wah wah i dont like this opinion, people must enjoy everything and not have a differing opinion because it irks me"

#

legit pick a lane

royal egret
#

ā€œI like this this thingā€ isn’t ā€œthis thing is better than thisā€

paper maple
#

I mean so? You also dont need to always do that either yet you do

tall phoenix
#

Alright kids go argue in private please

royal egret
#

If ā€œI like both settingsā€ is making you this upset

tall phoenix
#

Its way too late in the day for me to police another spat

royal egret
#

Then that’s on you

paper maple
tall phoenix
#

Again, take a time out.

#

I legit cant with you two right now

royal egret
#

Too mainstream

#

Age of Apostasy is what really hits

frigid osprey
#

The horus heresy is boring as fuck

#

Superhero soap opera

#

Marines Vs Marines

#

boring

frigid osprey
#

Yawn city

paper maple
#

Its got some good books but about like 3 dozen bad ones so I wont comment more beyond that KEKW_ogryn

royal egret
#

I get if it’s not your thing. There’s definitely plenty of bad books, but that’s not unique to the heresy.

frigid osprey
#

Yep there are plenty of bad 40k books, you can do so much more with the 40k setting itself though

#

Which is the poggers bit

unborn merlin
#

It's okay dude. I like the HH conceptually. A good chunk of the books were dookie tho so the execution couldn't been better.

#

I do think it pays off having read most of it whenever you end up reading about a legacy character.

tall phoenix
#

😭

#

55 books and dies like a fucking hobo

unborn merlin
#

KEK

#

Okay maybe not all legacy characters.

tall phoenix
#

LMAO

#

I didnt understand why people hated Knight of Grey until I finally read it.

unborn merlin
#

Meant more like the ones who are still active like Lucius or Bjƶrn.

tall phoenix
#

Oh right lol

#

to be fair they are very blank too imo

#

Abaddon is like the only one i actually like

#

everyone else is a bit of a caricature and no different from their 40k counterparts, which is something HH struggles with a lot

unborn merlin
#

Ahriman had some cool bits. Lucius was pretty much Lucius lmao.

tall phoenix
#

Oh right yeah I like him too

#

and yeah Lucius is just "arrogant asshole but no demon powers yet"

#

so nothing new kek

unborn merlin
#

Sev never made it out of the DA sex dungeon.

#

Uuuuh Kharn was great in most of his stories.

tall phoenix
#

When he said the one-liner I clapped

royal egret
#

Sigismund gets a good arc, there was a few other characters it was nice to see

unborn merlin
#

It's been said a million times but tdlr should've been way shorter and there's both some high highs and low lows.

royal egret
#

I was surprised they did Sor Talgron

#

Yeah it had a bunch of issues cause how it started and they planned it shorter

unborn merlin
#

Sigismund was pretty cool.

royal egret
#

And obviously there’s a lot of subpar authors with the good ones

#

But overall I think they stuck the landing

#

The later half is much stronger

unborn merlin
tall phoenix
#

something-something "get up"

#

dude I soy'd so hard when he beat up eresus

royal egret
#

I liked it the first time, then the fanbase ruined it

unborn merlin
tall phoenix
royal egret
#

There’s a lot of stuff I enjoy but

unborn merlin
#

I was kinda only half listening at that point I vaguely remember it.

tall phoenix
#

(:

#

I mean there wasnt much

#

the entirety of Siggy's scenes are

#

hes loyal

#

hes no.1 Fister

#

he kills generic supervillain marines

#

also Dorn said bad words at him

#

but reverse

unborn merlin
#

If we're going to be critical here, Dorn took way too damn long to forgive the dude. We didn't need him to be mad at him for some odd twenty something books.

#

Sigismund whenever Dorn tells him to cart himself.

tall phoenix
#

He forgor

royal egret
#

He didn’t really forgive him, they just got over it.

tall phoenix
#

also that yeah

#

half the point is Sigint learning to live with it

unborn merlin
#

They should've made up and just made some cookies together.

royal egret
#

Sigismund arc is to not require Dorns approval

tall phoenix
#

also him realising in the future of 40k theres only war and religion, but you might miss it if you blink

royal egret
#

Dorn struggles with dealing either the immaterium and accepting its bullshit

tall phoenix
#

Its one of the most goofy parts of the Siege imo

unborn merlin
#

I know, just being a little goofy here. I don't think Dorn was written all that well for most of HH. At certain times he was loosely goosey with the rules to the point that it went against his character only to revert back to old ways.

royal egret
#

And accepting that they can’t go back

tall phoenix
#

I appreciate the idea behind it but its so repetitive

#

"you think the emperor is a god? What is a god?"

#

OH MY GOD

#

SHUT UP

unborn merlin
#

Obviously that can be chalked up to having a dozen cooks in the kitchen.

royal egret
#

Little column a little column b yeah

tall phoenix
#

Also yeah like, as much as they advertised the Siege as "we are all working together on this narrative" they very much ignore half the shit they put in the novels half the time

#

which is kinda funny but like its warhammer so its whatever lol

unborn merlin
#

Like Dorn from twelve books ago would've been more lenient. Then Dorn in the next book has a total stick up his ass.

tall phoenix
#

Yep.

#

Again the authors kinda clearly dont know what the other is writing aside from footnotes they pass over skype/discord

unborn merlin
#

Like the whole back and forth with Mal was so done to death dude.

royal egret
#

The siege they do fine with, it’s just the other books they didn’t

#

The main sticking issue is when it shifts author and you notice how much worse or better they are at writing character

unborn merlin
#

I liked the Dorn and Sig dynamic during SoT for sure. Repentance and death only in duty to the Emperor is hella Black Templars.

#

I forgot what the short story was called but it's the one where Dorn chastised him for helping Garro and Euphrati but that never really gets resolved or referenced for like some odd twenty books.

#

Super frustrating.

tall phoenix
#

Its fiiiine

#

fodder Short is fodder Short

tall phoenix
#

focus on the books

unborn merlin
#

Sucks when some of those shorts were some of the best stories.

#

Banished to the anthology realm.

#

No hope of returning or getting a satisfactory ending.

tall phoenix
#

I still hate how you pointed out Dorn was getting rid of Remembrancers

#

then in the Siege he sees Slenderman about to commit suicide and just makes a new remembrancer order

unborn merlin
#

No fr it was fucking redundant.

#

I thought I was going crazy. Like wasn't this resolved already?

tall phoenix
#

KEK

tall phoenix
#

again its whatever, the entire Interrogator order concept is goofy anyway

#

one of the most egregious parts of the novel for me

#

and thats wild because I do like Saturnine

unborn merlin
#

Just another convoluted way to tie into the Inquisition...but of course the last book literally fucking ends before it actually gets interesting.

tall phoenix
#

||And Fo is also one of the founders of the Inquisition because??? Lmao||

#

holy shit that part was funny, but I didnt mind it because I love Fo

#

hes literally just Gru from Despicable Me

unborn merlin
#

Like people were championing the book like it resolved so much. My brother in Christ none of the non-astartes characters got closure.

tall phoenix
#

It left way too much open yeah, Abnett does say he tried as much as he could to close a lot of plotlines but I never really felt like that was the case minus like... Loken i guess?

unborn merlin
#

It just ends as they put Big E on the throne??? Like hello???? Tune into the next four anthology books guys.

#

Maybe then we'll find out what happens to Jimmy Bob from that one book you spent half the runtime reading.

tall phoenix
#

Ironically im very much looking forward to the anthology because these last 3 novels wrapped up nothing.

royal egret
#

What a mark

#

Smh

tall phoenix
#

if the "carrion lord of the imperium" by ADB doesnt cover that shit im throwing my PDF in the trash

unborn merlin
#

Straight up. GW manages to sucker me back in for more slop.

#

They know what they're doing.

tall phoenix
#

Im not paying money for it so

unborn merlin
tall phoenix
#

I mean uh yeah we gotta adhere to them

unborn merlin
#

Oh yeah totally.

tall phoenix
#

But anyway yeah anthology makes sense my only hope for it at least is like

#

covers the cleanup efforts of a literal cthulu shitstorm that was the last stages of the Siege

#

Explains how the Emperor is doing on the toilet

#

because we got literal titans nailed to palace walls, whos gonna be cleaning that shit up

unborn merlin
#

Can't wait to learn what happens to Katsuhiro and that stupid baby ten years from now.

tall phoenix
#

shut the fuck up

#

LMAO

#

God I hate Katsuhiro

#

bro needs to head back to Ind

unborn merlin
#

I'm invested now man. I gotta know.

tall phoenix
#

The baby will get a nice job in a smoke-choked factorum

unborn merlin
#

John Grammaticus teams up with the baby to defeat a Lord of Change.

#

Trust the process thumbsup_ogryn

runic root
#

Can i rant for a second? I just read "call of the lion", by gav Thorpe, (in Horus heresy, book named "tales of heresy") and albeit that the short story isnt badly written (also not really well written, just ok), the heresy and crusade era calibanite marines grind my fucking gears....

Like, your mission is to reconquer the stars, peacefully If possible, by sword and flame If necessary. And now this Dunderhead of a calibanite (belath) comes to an esteemed terran space marine of the legion (astelan) and is like "nuh uh, not the will of the emperor is the deciding factor, but the shrewed and intransparent, convoluted secrets of the lion".... "Lets just murder everyone without even saying hello. Millions can die, lol, lmao even"....

No wonder half the legion went rouge.... Out of all legion betrayls, the one of the darkangels was the most uncalled for, self caused and most avoidable and as long as that stubborn weakness of secrecy and mistrust (and aggressively favoring the lion over the emperor) exists, i will refuse to call them the best legion #blueberrysupremacy 😤

tall phoenix
#

though im not really against cartoonishly evil loyalist marines so i didnt mind it as much even if Gav is just a bad novel writer in general

runic root
tall phoenix
#

Yeah never buy a dark angels book written by Thorpe

#

I learned that the hard way reading most of his DA novels, prime tier braindead stuff

runic root
tall phoenix
#

Duuude holy fuck that book is from like 2003

#

But also nah the book is very much written in that same tone in english, I read it almost 2 decades ago now but i still remember it pretty well

runic root
tall phoenix
#

lmfao

#

Yeah it got re-released like 3 times i think

runic root
runic root
tall phoenix
tall phoenix
#

he just cannot write books

runic root
#

And here i thought abnett would stick harder to his almost enjoyable mediocracy than a politician to his campaign lies..... Who'd thunk that he'd devolve from mediocre to bad

tall phoenix
#

Oh come now hes not that terrible.

#

Hes a very good writer.

#

He just has moments where his head can go up his ass at times.

runic root
runic root
tall phoenix
#

Yeah mostly rulebooks/other fluff, Gav has been in warhammer since the 80's so hes one of the old guard essentially.

tall phoenix
#

The 3 books combined are over almost 800 pages

#

(your average 40k novel is usually 300-ish pages)

runic root
tall phoenix
runic root
tall phoenix
#

LOL

#

Well hes a freelancer currently, but still pops up to do warhammer stuff sometimes like that new mediocre Votann book

tall phoenix
runic root
tall phoenix
#

Kyme is just a dogshit author yeah, i think anyone really likes his works that much unless its something non-Salamander related.

#

mostly

#

Abnett mentions in the afterword of Novel 3 that Kyme's "tip" for him was and I quote "Just write as much as you want, don't worry about the wordcount." so he basically barely did his job as an editor and it really shows.

runic root
#

šŸ’€

tall phoenix
#

But yeah like I said i think they are absolutely worth a read

#

just be prepared to quick-read some pages, because it draaaaaaaaaags

runic root
tall phoenix
#

ADHD would go bad with Siege but theres nothing we can do

brittle tapir
#

40k books are terrible if you have ADHD it's like trying to read the entire dictionary

runic root
#

Jokes aside, i am probably gonna read it like the first Ahriman Omnibus. Normal reading until it gets boring, then fast, skipping lines browsing over the fluff until stuff is interesting again, rinse and repeat

runic root
safe plover
#

why do you think i hate legion so much

#

shits unreadable

runic root
# safe plover shits unreadable

I managed to read it. But it took me forever. I devoured horus rising in 2 days. I needed 3 months for legion, 5 months for mechanicum (too many descriptions/details šŸ™ˆ)

#

Btw i read all six Uriel Ventris books (the Double omnibus) and the night lords trillogy in 10 days.... I can be a fast yet accurate reader, i read the Count of Montecristo in an 9 hour binge read all nighter at age 15, however, the book needs to captivate me in order to do that, if it doesnt, its like treading on molasses

hearty niche
#

Audio books are good for me for that reason

#

But sometimes I need the actual physical book so idk

#

Some more free content lol this ones like 11 hours Long tho

#

The reader also does voices for like different charecters so it might not be for everyone lmao

#

This one's about the spyships that get sent into the warp and there encounters they meet in the warp

#

I forgot the actual name for the ships I mean

safe plover
#

the second book is the only one i read

#

first 4 are too good

#

dan just went fucking all out with the weird terminology in that legion

#

better yet all the terminology he used was wrong

runic root
hearty niche
#

Ok I'll put that next on my list ty!

runic root
wintry blade
#

In ice and fire, what are your bets as to what the space marine is?

runic root
wintry blade
#

No I mean the character in the book, Fire and Ice

wintry blade
#

If I had to guess, I’d say he’s alpha legion

runic root
#

Havent read it yet

#

By whom is it?

wintry blade
runic root
safe plover
#

ye very magyar hangolo

lavish rune
#

Love Fehervari

#

Slowly working my way through his Dark Coil works

shy lark
#

Speaking of which, I'm having an hard time focusing on The Reverie. I'm only on chapter 7 but does it pick up later?

tall phoenix
#

its a Fehervari book

#

you're either gonna like it or not like it

#

its a bit hard to explain with his writing style lol

royal egret
#

If you don’t, you will be judged

shy lark
#

It's something about The Reverie, the writing is fine but I want to do anything else

royal egret
#

I would just put it down until you’re in the mood

#

He’s definitely that kind of author

shy lark
#

A palette cleanser is probably in order, I got through his Requiem Infernal just fine

severe trail
#

Dark coil is peak fiction

lavish rune
#

I'm usually a horror/weird fiction reader so Fehervari was a good fit. Only other 40k writer I have experience with is Nate Crowley

runic root
#

I am still torn how i should feel about James swallow. Some of his sister of Battle stuff i like (despite it being cheesier than an 80s action movie with Arnold Schwarzenegger) but some of his books....

unborn merlin
#

He's got some bangers.

#

At worst his stuff can be boring. Don't think I've read a genuinely horrible book by him unlike Thorpe or Kyme.

hearty niche
#

Fell asleep listening to a audio book and now I don't know where I am KEKW_ogryn

drowsy urchin
#

what are you using to listen to them? Most applications have a sleep timer if you've not noticed

#

or did you just forgor šŸ’€

hearty niche
#

I was listening to a free one on YouTube lol

drowsy urchin
#

ah šŸ˜„

lethal valley
runic root
lethal valley
#

The iron kingdom, sadly it's a really cool premise and a part of the important ish dawn of fire series,

lethal valley
tall phoenix
#

I legit got no idea how a team of authors is capable of something like this lol

unborn merlin
#

Never underestimate mediocrity and an easy paycheck.

mental cobalt
#

No dawn of fire Note

shy lark
#

but do read the first law

mellow knot
#

As an aside, if you ever want a switch out of BL stuff, Jim’s thriller books are really good - I particularly recommend ā€˜Airside’.

tall phoenix
runic root
runic root
#

I think i have the two volumes after wolftime as an eBook, but ive not gotten around reading them just yet

runic root
mental cobalt
#

No context

#

go in blind

runic root
sonic walrus
tacit raft
#

as an aside from any books, i got most satisfied with Landau, Lifshitz : field theory

#

most entertaining

#

dont recommend reading when drunk, gonna reread it multiple times, trust me

opaque pagoda
#

I am in the middle of Dead man walking whats everyones thoughts of it

#

i felt it was a slow start but ramps very quickly

severe trail
#

It’s good

#

Imo the best dkok focused book

tall phoenix
#

^

#

Thats saying a lot considering most DKOK books

hearty niche
#

Read that as...D Kok ...

opaque pagoda
#

it was hard to in the beginning but def the focus into other peoples eyes is great

tall phoenix
hearty niche
tall phoenix
#

lmao

#

but honest mistake staregryn

hearty niche
random marlin
# severe trail Imo the best dkok focused book

I agree, notably because it felt more like nihilistic satire at various points than Krieg, for instance, which felt like it took itself much too seriously, making it an uncomfortable read, at least for me.

tall phoenix
#

Krieg books definitely suffer a lot from hero-izing them id say but the problem is their core fanbase is so braindead they'd probably still not get the message.

#

They'd see shit like throwing away your lasgun before you get gauss'd to save resources as "badass" more than horribly disturbing

safe plover
#

WOWOWOWOWO

#

SO KEWL

tall phoenix
safe plover
#

best thing about kreig is their lore until the formation of the krieg corpes

tall phoenix
#

lmaooo christ

#

(not wrong though)

safe plover
#

its tru i liked the story for their planet

#

but everything else ehhhh

tall phoenix
#

I still cannot believe how people love all the backstory flashbacks for the Kriegā„¢ļø novel but the moment it becomes current-time its a borefest

#

one of the funniest common critiques ive seen of it that always gets me

random marlin
# shy lark Speaking of which, I'm having an hard time focusing on The Reverie. I'm only on ...

It does pick up later, however Reverie is quite different from Requiem Infernal. Peter tends to try different tones in his various short stories/novels and with Requiem Infernal, he was trying to do something like Gothic Horror/Name of the Rose.

Reverie is very different as it's one of his more "straightforward" books as it delves into the Resplendent chapter.

Also, maybe it's better to read short stories between his books, it's easier to see ties and connections between each story this way.

For instance, the short story Aria Arcana may have been a better fit as it's directly tied to the events of Requiem Infernal.

That's something quite unique with the Dark Coil, each story gets better if you read it again after having read other Dark Coil stories.

For instance, when I read Blind Sight in the White Dwarf it was published, I liked it but didn't enjoy it that much, however, I enjoyed reading it again after having read The Thirteenth Psalm and seen the connections between the two stories.

Same thing for Nightbleed and Nightshift Nineteen, I feel that each story elevates the other.

But I'm citing stories which have direct links, however there are more discreet links between other stories, such as (at least) one between Requiem Infernal and Fire Caste.

I think there's something playful in that, a bit when you're watching a show such as Severance where there are clues and setups/payoffs everywhere and if you start playing along looking for clues, it becomes quite fun. But I also understand it's not everyone's cup of tea.

random marlin
tall phoenix
#

Lmaooo yeah its hard to tell because Lyons is such a Krieg fanboy at times.

deft bramble
#

being a regiment "fanboy" staregryn

severe trail
#

Lyons really likes Krieg

#

but he also ironically gets Krieg as well

#

unlike

#

a lot of them

royal egret
#

He’s the title card

random marlin
#

Sure, but he becomes this way because of his contact with the dehumanized Kriegers and their way of approaching any conflict. Things could have been different for him had it been a regiment from another culture who had come to the planet's rescue, rather than the Kriegers.

shy lark
shy lark
#

It's a surface reading but I did read it as the kriegers are just dead kids men walking and it's more or less the end result of the Imperial Guard where civilians get picked up and dehumanised and spit out again broken and dehumanised when they're not usable for war

remote glacier
#

That seems like

#

...the #1 thing they would maintain

#

šŸ’€

#

Like if you're gonna die for the Emperor, might as well lessen the chance of you dying from like

#

your lasgun fucking exploding because you didn't clean it

severe trail
#

unless you count plasma lol

hearty niche
#

Don't they train the men using those guns to efficiently use them without causing a plas melt down

#

Or is that the astartes

#

Cause I know guardsmen w lasguns know how to booby trap the guns so if an enemy tries to use it , they explode

severe trail
#

also operator error

#

ect.

hearty niche
#

Yeah honestly I would stay far away from plasma guns lmao

#

Wouldn't even want to be behind someone using one KEKW_ogryn

severe trail
#

Well

#

they're good at killing shit

hearty niche
#

Good at deleting

#

Simply gone

unborn merlin
royal egret
#

Mordians are what the fanbase thinks Krieg are

#

Have multiple cases of them standing their ground and maintaining disciplined fire and slow withdrawal from greater daemons, death company, chaos marines, Necrons, and so on.

safe plover
# remote glacier Kriegers have unstable guns?

"The signature weapon of the Death Korps of Krieg, the Lucius-pattern lasgun operates in the 21 megathoule range, but is designed to draw from a standard Munitorum-issue power pack. Consequently, the Lucius lasgun discharges a more powerful shot, but drains the power pack at a correspondingly increased rate. This also puts a great strain on the weapon, limiting the rate of fire and requiring such features as additional heat sink rings lining the exterior of the barrel. Even with such considerations, an over-taxed Lucius lasgun can quickly overheat. The added danger of the weapon overheating does not perturb the famously stoic Krieg"

#

yeah theres even the heavy varient? i forgot whats its called

#

with the big power backpack

#

thats even more unstable

#

but its only for specialized unites

severe trail
#

Overheating isn’t unstable

#

It just means you can’t fire it

severe trail
safe plover
#

close enough

digital saffron
#

Which feels really damn weird

tall phoenix
#

hes such a enigma lol

runic root
#

@tall phoenix i am bored. Can you pick a fight with @safe plover over legion please

#

🫣

safe plover
tall phoenix
#

literally me rn

safe plover
#

im trying a new build hop on

runic root
runic root
runic root
safe plover
#

i dont think my laptop can handle streaming

#

i can try

#

strike 1

runic root
safe plover
#

ok yeah its not happening

#

i cant move lmao

runic root
runic root
mellow knot
runic root
#

@safe plover on my way home. Might consider playing a few matches in about an hour. If youre still on by then

safe plover
#

nah not today i think

#

i think im coming down with something too tired to play anymore

runic root
runic root
#

Btw tmr still stands on my side. Gonna be online from 10-16 German time

safe plover
tall phoenix
#

The update is cancelled guys sorry

runic root
tall phoenix
runic root
#

Cancelled or delayed?

#

Or are you pulling my leg?

runic root
safe plover
#

šŸ¤”

#

yeah same timezone for me

#

idk if the update would drop for me by then but if its up yeah im down

runic root
#

I'll just keep an eye on my steam acc and circle back to you on that

#

But trying new ogryn builds together would be fun. Cant wait to abuse the punch of the knife lol

safe plover
#

cant wait to rush through trappers without a care in the world

runic root
runic root
runic root
#

Didnt find anything in the patchnotes.

runic root
mental cobalt
#

No one is pulling leg

#

it's there

#

trust

#

read legion

#

"I am alpharius"

runic root
runic root
drowsy urchin
#

Oh I'm actually really interested to hear what Rob has to say. Hadn't noticed this new show before either

random marlin
#

The first episode was about Krieg I think, but the author wasn’t present.

runic root
#

@safe plover how is the health? Ready to kill some heretics in a bit?

runic root
safe plover
#

good morning @runic root

hearty niche
#

00:00 TEASER
00:35 INTRO
02:03 PROLOGUE
04:01 CHAPTER 1: THE GHOUL
11:58 CHAPTER 2: INTO THE BOWELS
24:10 CHAPTER 3: THE RELIC
34:15 CHAPTER 4: AFTERMATH
41:18 CHAPTER 5: THE BREACH
54:18 EPILOGUE
57:27 OUTRO

Step into the void beyond the Emperor’s light with "The Ghoul Stars Hunger," an original Warhammer 40K audiobook that plunges you into ...

ā–¶ Play video
hearty niche
#

Support me on Patreon: https://patreon.com/HistoritorJames

The Miasma of Despair — An unofficial Warhammer 40k short story.

This one is particularly spooky guys, don't blame me for any heretical nightmares that may ensue.

šŸ”” Subscribe for more Warhammer 40k lore, short stories, and history!

šŸ“– Written and narrated by: Historitor James...

ā–¶ Play video
runic root
#

@safe plover had fun playing the new update yet?

safe plover
#

I played one trial which then crashed on me twice

#

a psyker talent currently causes the game to crash

#

sons of selenar is alright btw

tall phoenix
#

booo

runic root
# safe plover I played one trial which then crashed on me twice

I played ogryn. With several other ogryns. Highest diff. We played 3 trials....

A little bit underwhelming. Feels like 3-6 difficulty tiers were missing. Also, when as a final boss a deamonhost showed up, i wished they wouldnt have taken the corrupting aura away.

runic root
safe plover
#

ogryn felt great in meatgrinder

runic root
runic root
#

Also, i heared mod users got shafted badly again with this update, which doesnt surprise me.

safe plover
#

happens every update

#

people just dont update their mods

tall phoenix
#

mod users deserve the treatment

safe plover
#

😔

#

you hate mods now

tall phoenix
#

always did

safe plover
#

you dont even play this game

tall phoenix
#

Im literally in the game

#

I got it open right now lmao

safe plover
#

discord mod hates freedom big shocker šŸ™„

tall phoenix
#

what in the-

safe plover
#

mods let people get more control over their experience

finite frigate
#

discord MOD hates MODS kinda ironic....

tall phoenix
#

Pretty messed up man

cerulean peak
#

Playin' darktide vanilla

tall phoenix
#

Weaklings.

cerulean peak
#

I don't need to see other people's numbers

tall phoenix
#

How else will you be able to judge them and be an elitist?

#

AND complain about havoc or someting idfk

cerulean peak
#

Never needed a reason to complain chadgryn

runic root
royal egret
cerulean peak
#

Nice. My german classes finally paid off

runic root
tall phoenix
#

he saw my trinkets and instantly left

#

fucking elitist pieces of shit

severe trail
#

Ngl

#

I have the scoreboard mod for one reason

#

I get dopamine seeing numbers

#

I get why it’s not in the game though

shy lark
#

I'd like a scoreboard mod just for meself, I like challenging myself to do better

celest heron
#

I have 2 mods in darktide and vermintide

#

Numeric ui, and dodge counter

runic root
#

Scoreboard has upsides and downsides, like almost anything else. If anything, id like to see in game statistics for me, only pertaining to me, not others. Like damage dealt, blees/burn damage inflicted, amount of enemies killed, etc. That way i can improve myself without the ego pissing contest

runic root
# tall phoenix fucking elitist pieces of shit

The amount of condescending people in this game is alarming. Sometimes , all i wanna type is "I get that youre upset we lost that round, good Sir/Mam, but that is no reason to denounce my or our teammates skills entirely, especially not in that colourful language"....

The amount of salt sometimes thrown at me in the game Chat, especially on malice/heresy/sometimes even regular damnation is nothing short of harrowing

severe trail
#

I don’t type at all lol

tall phoenix
#

you get used to it after awhile

shy lark
#

The guy I play with is usually fine but in Darktide he won't stop whining about other players

#

Maybe it's the game after all

safe plover
#

but i pretty much only play auric damn

#

i guess people tend to be more toxic in higher and lower difficulties

wise yew
shy lark
#

that shit what liam neeson said to the wolves in that one movie

#

I just gotta do better šŸ’Ŗ

runic root
severe trail
#

I say gg if it’s really smooth

#

Tbh

#

But I don’t really count that as typing personally

runic root
runic root
runic root
#

Sometimes one of the teammembers likes my name and asks me how i thought of it (happens rarely). Then i also type to explain. But thats very rare.

runic root
runic root
wintry blade
#

Any book recommendations?

#

I think I’m scraping the bottom of the barrel

unborn merlin
#

The Catcher in the Rye

severe trail
#

I don’t like that book

safe plover
runic root
#

If you like crime that is

wintry blade
random marlin
#

(replace "Sutter Cane" by "Peter Fehervari")

hearty niche
minor granite
#

I wanna buy my first book. What's a good suggestion?

random marlin
runic root
safe plover
#

my god Saturnine fucking SUCKS

#

like rogal dorn would ever fucking talk someone from suicide

#

LIKE ROGAL DORN WOULD GIVE 3 FUCKS about an unemployed rememberance

#

""ā€˜I don’t give a shit,’ said the Great Khan.
ā€˜My lord,’ Niborran pressed. ā€˜Colonel Brohn is a senior and decorated
Army officer, and an essential part of the-ā€˜
ā€˜Not a single shit,’ said the Great Khan."

#

WHO THE FUCK IS WRITING THIS

#

i thought i was done with slop

tall phoenix
cerulean peak
tall phoenix
#

But okay so I REALLY like Dorn talking Slenderman out of committing suicide

#

BUT

#

I will absolutely agree the Khan scene is so goofy

cerulean peak
#

Brace for the end and death (i,ii,iii)

tall phoenix
#

"Not a single shit" is the most un-primarch thing ive ever read in a book lol

wise yew
#

So hey that's something positive

#

Khan on the other hand

tall phoenix
#

šŸ’€

wise yew
#

Ehhh

drowsy urchin
#

Why wouldn't Dorn talk Sinderman out of suicide

#

what

safe plover
#

NOT A SINGLE SHIT

tall phoenix
#

Yeah the Dorn scene is good, the Khan scene i agree kinda took me out of it.

#

I also am of the opinion that the word "shit" gets used way too much in this book too tbh

wise yew
#

Kind of funny how that works but anyway

drowsy urchin
#

I didn't even remember that part so I had to google if it even happened

safe plover
wise yew
#

So apologies

tall phoenix
#

Kill him Clad

#

do it

safe plover
tall phoenix
#

Dorn likes to believe hes a "good" person at the end of the day and a defender of the people.

wise yew
safe plover
#

"hey bro we NEED rememberancers to uhhhh report uhhh stuff????"