#[ALL] broken music megathread

2159 messages · Page 3 of 3 (latest)

fallow sail
#

camellia

plush ermine
stoic berry
#

f8 Tower of Raging Tempest

viscid stirrup
#

how does this have to do with music

viscid stirrup
#

ToEW (this played fine like 2 days ago)

image.png
south herald
#

ToDIE f3

noble summit
#

2000th message but tort has one at floor 8 or 9 i dont remember

south herald
#

it seems

#

f6 f7 too make that the entire tower atp

south venture
#

Has anyone contacted Scattle

#

That’s an artist I’m particularly interested in

#

Not that I’m really gonna play the game much with this update but, he’s my fav artist that I’ve found out about from etoh and I’m curious if he would allow it

bronze sapphire
viscid stirrup
bronze sapphire
#

technically they do

#

as the song actively contributes to a better experience for the player

#

and roblox just naturally pays the devs for playtime

south venture
#

Devs use the songs in a profitable game

viscid stirrup
bronze sapphire
#

just because devs give credit doesnt mean they lose all money earned from the song being in game

south venture
merry gate
#

therefore it is commercial

south venture
merry gate
#

Not in robux but once you devex over $600 in a tax year you will have to report that income

#

Digital currency or not artists usually tend not to like having someone earn any form of currency off their work without permission

dry egret
#

Idk why tf i

#

Replied to that

#

Sorry arx

#

But i will say

#

We should try contacting all artists involved in

#

Jsab

#

Like shirobon

#

Carti

#

Chipzel

#

HONESTLYYYY hate to say it

#

Odds are when chipzel says yes

#

Shed say no to

#

Super hexagon

#

FUCK

#

YES

dusk aspen
viscid stirrup
stark storm
south venture
#

Where can u see the whitelist

small vessel
rancid ingot
#

toah f2

rancid ingot
noble summit
#

to

#

toie f1

#

also f4

south venture
#

Good I hope it stays like that so I don’t have to look at some fuckass massive text wall on my screen for the entire time

#

Plz fix this shit and add the setting where it never appears unless u hover over it

merry gate
#

After reconsideration camellia is whitelisted

image.png
jovial mountain
#

tores might be not over

#

/j

dry egret
strong basalt
merry gate
#

I discussed the terms with aet and we came to the conclusion there was a misunderstanding

#

in camellia's email

strong basalt
#

ah got it

runic fox
#

camellia's guidelines have sections specifically for games, wherein he gives a distinction between unofficial and official maps/charts

image.png
#

since etoh towers become a full part of the game itself, etoh applies under section (3b)

#

not 2

#

and camellia has already stated "Usually, licensing fees are 800 USD/song in official licensing terms" in their original response, i'd recommend actually reaching out to camellia yourselves before making an adjustment like that

merry gate
#

we arent distributing song data that is downloadable or easily extractable though which makes me inclined to believe not but i would like to have extra clarification anyway on their terms since nobody can really decide what to settle on sobbing_face

#

for this - we wont need individual permission/licensing

#

i think its best to contact camellia

runic fox
merry gate
#

but what im saying is music isnt downloadable from roblox or roblox's client when downloaded, its streamed

#

if you wanted to make the music downloadable, you would have to have it go through manual moderation under roblox for it to be available like that

runic fox
#

that's a pretty risky interpretation of their terms

merry gate
#

it really is sobbing_face

#

thats why im on edge about it too

runic fox
#

etoh is pretty wildly different from the examples he gives for (2)

merry gate
#

however the matter is moreso tower builders using their songs, whom apply under individuals, and when they upload their music for use in etoh, that data isnt downloadable

#

i think the biggest issue though is that

#

we are licensed under roblox

#

technicall

#

which automatically should deny this

runic fox
#

shifting the terms of its music usage from (3a) to (3b)

merry gate
#

ah ye i suppose i can see that

#

im gonna talk to the rest of the devs abt this cuz like

#

they cant really come up with a decision on this either

runic fox
#

(3b) says to contact camellia directly via email so probably just do that

merry gate
#

i think we would try to but the moment any licensing comes up we are not going to license any music

#

and we woud then jus deny their songs to be used for towers

runic fox
#

fair enough

noble summit
#

somd the challenge

image.png
dry egret
#

Not even the dmca free playlist?

trail smelt
trail smelt
south venture
#

Bro how the fuck does that get posted

#

😭

#

I ain’t even gonna try again

noble summit
#

also toig's portal room

noble summit
#

sogp f1

magic dock
#

ToMI(M) f1 (displays question mark)
f5 and f8 (no song)

noble summit
#

NOOO todan rooftop

image.png
#

and floor 7-8

dry egret
#

Does this imply that

#

The music is

#

Getting replaced already

#

?

silent brook
west ocean
#

? = takendown?

noble summit
#

yes

dry egret
#

Fuuck

narrow tartan
#

basically everything in ToETU except f2, f5 outside, f6 and f7

lean sigil
narrow tartan
#

it doesnt

lean sigil
dry egret
#

Oh what the fuck :(

#

Boom kitty not allowed?

#

Isnt etoh hella similar to gd in a way i thought hed be much more chill...

#

Wheres our

#

Etoh rap song

strong basalt
narrow tartan
primal acorn
#

CoWN - ToTH floor

#

i love listening to "?"

image.png
narrow tartan
#

ah yes my favourite music in EToH: “?”

red moth
#

none of the music in any of the monthly towers play

south venture
#

I haven’t played etoh since the update to the music system that has made the song title take up half the screen

When will some not braindead developer fix this

#

I asked Camille to do it in atos and they had it complete within one hour

quiet heart
#

a lot of torer

kind palm
#

I don’t think anyone is restoring any music anymore because. Copyright n shit

dry egret
fallow sail
#

i was playing mach nine yesterday and there being no music on f3 really threw me off lol

craggy nymph
#

whats actually the issue

dry egret
#

Really going ahead and

#

Taking shit down

#

Man give us more time at least :<

stark storm
#

i think that would be pretty nice but personally i love the new ui

primal acorn
lyric vault
#

actually does this count

image.png
dry egret
#

Or

#

Is it entirely the title display

lyric vault
dry egret
#

okar

south venture
#

Etoh now has the second worst in tower UI in any obby game I’ve seen, obviously behind CSCD

#

And it has the least customization

#

Filling the screen with opaque purple boxes, increasing the button sizes, and now this music thing is just ridiculous

#

And it was rushed too, and gamma said “sorry I had to drop the update early but I’ll release an update later with x y and z changes” and then bro steps down before it

#

I know he’s still around but how many times is the UI going to get irreversible updates where more shit blocks the screen