#history

1 messages · Page 67 of 1

zealous vine
#

How did the Suzuya sub-class differ from Mogami?

alpine onyx
#

Boilers for the most part

#

Iirc they dropped from twelve boilers to ten

manic latch
alpine onyx
#

From ten to eight boilers, my bad

manic latch
#

Shit

rapid junco
#

I talked about it sooner

#

But like i said

#

It's a better fate than being scrapped

eternal veldt
#

That's Oriskany, not Sao Paolo

#

Sao Paolo has only one bridle catcher, fell for that one today

shrewd pecan
#

my bad

#

looked close enough when I saw oryx retweet that

rapid junco
#

Paulo

#

São Paulo

manic latch
#

I have been thinking and

#

What superiority Abrams A2 has over LeopardA6?

#

Faster acceleration and more silent engine for %100 parts

But armor or penetration is a classified info

#

Leo 2 is faster irrc. Both has 42 ammo

cinder escarp
#

Superiority? None really.

subtle prawn
frigid karma
#

huh

#

they did it

frigid karma
#

does this countas the f-22's first A2A?

cinder escarp
#

yes

shut wren
#

it took em this long lmao

#

Didnt they find another ballon

spiral cedar
#

Over Latin America

#

China's done this before

#

It's just the longest it's been over the US

shut wren
#

fr?

spiral cedar
#

Yes

shut wren
#

You got anything from the other ones

spiral cedar
#

Nope

shut wren
#

bruh

#

So there isnt any other ones?

spiral cedar
#

Right now? None that the US knows of/has announced, besides the Latin America one

shut wren
#

ah ok

manic latch
#

Could be her as well

spiral cedar
#

Video, and now official comms state F-22

chilly osprey
#

F-22 with an AIM-9X

subtle prawn
thorn trail
#

Question: What's the historical basis for the Champy gun

#

the 406mm MLE

manic latch
#

The 406 mm/52 gun designed by the Schneider company was initially conceived for the Soviet Union as a part of the "Franco-Soviet Treaty of Mutual Assistance" signed in 1935, which entailed military and technical cooperation. While France never produced 406 mm guns, it was interested in developing them due to an emerging global trend towards increasing the caliber of battleships' main batteries. In the spring of 1938, the Schneider company handed the gun designs over to the Soviet Union, and that was the end of the story for the project.

thorn trail
#

Irl wise

manic latch
# thorn trail Irl wise

Well wouldn't be possible for Champ gun since they weren't build. So I will compare their wows stats

Champ gun gas better velocity as 850m/s while Soyuz is 830m/s

But Soyuz has heavier AP shell as 1,108kg while Champ is 900kg

Same deal with HE

thorn trail
#

Are these stats based on theoretical stats from the irl designs

manic latch
#

No clue. Should ask Rich about it. Not sure if anyone has blueprints public like WG does

#

But shell weight and velocity of wows is usually correct to irl stats or planned ones

delicate beacon
#

But shell weight and velocity of wows is usually correct to irl stats or planned ones
MurmWat

shut wren
#

we WT mfs do

delicate beacon
#

Not a SINGLE Dutch ship has a set of correct shell weight and velocity.

frigid karma
#

San Diego with the same guns

#

fires shells like 30% faster than Atlanta

#

usually correct, my ass

shut wren
#

ISU-152 and Kv-2 has same gun and ISU fire way faster

delicate beacon
#

That can be due to loading arrangements, crew space and ammunition storage locations.

#

Though it's still used as balancing factor.

frigid karma
#

the shell velocity

delicate beacon
#

Where's Richy

#

I need my 406mm stats

frigid karma
#

just

#

no

#

WoWs armor schemes usually line up fairly well with reality

#

but even then

#

PLENTY of exceptions apply

maiden citrus
#

my crew skill: french

frigid karma
#

are they fries

maiden citrus
#

can reload a bb shell in 10 seconds one handed

shut wren
#

Wish I had one of those mfs in my T-34-85

manic latch
#

Qwerty

#

You realise Velocity is not reload right?

frigid karma
#

can you

#

read

manic latch
#

Both has 792m/s..

frigid karma
#

Atlanta's arcs are way smaller

#

resulting in approximately 30% less travel time than Atlanta

#

you play wows right

manic latch
#

I don't give a hell about shell drag or arcs

#

They still share the same velocity

shut wren
#

like Shells travel faster instead

manic latch
#

Shell travel time yes

#

Not velocity

frigid karma
#

except their air drag coefficient is also different somehow

#

so actually, yes their shell velocities do diverge midflight

#

it's a fucking arcade game, never cite ballistics for it

manic latch
#

Duh

spring briar
manic latch
#

Rich do smh

frigid karma
#

muh sap

frigid karma
#

AoA be like

shut wren
#

What kind of alien auto loader yall stole from Area 51

maiden citrus
#

when austin gets real reload for a few seconds

frigid karma
#

this is .9sec reload

#

that's >720 rpm

#

it's firing faster than a browning

maiden citrus
#

and what's closer to the 40rpm

0.9 second reload

or

7.5 second reload

shut wren
#

.9 Would be more effective

frigid karma
#

i'm saying it's faster than irl reload

maiden citrus
#

slightly

#

as opposed to firing at

#

...

#

less than 1/4th irl reload

frigid karma
#

because it would be broken if it had irl reload?

#

they gave it the mbrb gimmick so it can temporarily be powerful, and have to play passively for the rest of the time

maiden citrus
#

sounds like their problem for putting it in the game

frigid karma
#

doesn't really matter anyway bc malta just kills you

#

at least the aa is good unlike le sherman

shut wren
#

Malta,the CV?

frigid karma
#

malta in wows basically deletes any CL it sees on sight

#

because CLs were being too oppressive /s

shut wren
#

Is it CV malta

frigid karma
#

yes

maiden citrus
#

sherman aa is pretty good though since dds have a higher multiplier, even if wows aa values are just 'whatever came to me in a dream last night'

shut wren
#

CV when in Wt

frigid karma
#

just play air

shut wren
#

I do play air

frigid karma
#

then how would you play CV

#

it's just air with you wasting time launching shit

shut wren
#

Other than the fact that in ARB mfs press their funny buttons

#

and fucking yeet me from 5kms away

frigid karma
#

play rank 1

#

it's free + dogfighting is fun

shut wren
#

fr

#

mfs cant aim for shit

#

but theres no fun without Shvak cannons

#

Rate my China tree

frigid karma
#

even a halland is scared of my midway

#

and now, louie louie

maiden citrus
shut wren
#

Highest i ever got was 50k

frigid karma
#

nice, very impressive

#

let's see paul allen's plane shot down count

#

(it's 80% fighters)

#

love how they finally nerf midway uu once i decided to get it

shut wren
#

The homie who brough a Mig-29?

frigid karma
#

stock chiha

#

i hate stuart

shut wren
shut wren
maiden citrus
#

rarely

#

mostly naval and a little air

shut wren
#

Mig money

frigid karma
#

do you recommend naval?

#

seems boring asf to me

shut wren
#

It makes alot of money

#

If you play right

maiden citrus
#

I find it the most fun part

shut wren
#

Gotta push to 3k

shut wren
frigid karma
#

the br compression is just stupid tho

maiden citrus
#

I don't play enough to know current things like that, I just have some US destroyers and gunboats

frigid karma
#

ah

#

higher tiers your cruisers have to fight

#

Hood

#

gl

shut wren
frigid karma
#

i mean

shut wren
#

Soviets mains

#

Should i start the israel tree

maiden citrus
#

I didn't really have much interest in higher as the realism and balance is poor yeah

frigid karma
#

"in land, an inferior force can hold back a superior force through tactics and land"

#

"on sea, you're fucked"

shut wren
#

Made some poor choices

#

wasted 200k

shut wren
frigid karma
#

like, in air you can at least leverage game knowledge to beat better aircraft

#

same thing in ground

#

what can you do in naval

shut wren
#

just die

#

Unless the snail has decide otherwise

frigid karma
#

in wows HE, fires and conceal help you even the gap

#

all 3 are irrelevant in WT, you are just gunnery target if you're smaller

shut wren
#

Torps

#

If you can get close enough

frigid karma
#

gl with that

shut wren
#

Snail bias

shrewd pecan
#

I'd just wait for a sale

#

and pick up the merkava II premium

shut wren
shrewd pecan
#

with that SL count?

#

good luck

shut wren
#

Both are prem packs

#

Ill just grind my miggie

shrewd pecan
#

ah the top tier air premiums

shut wren
#

J-8 is basically Mig-21 with extra engine

shrewd pecan
#

in regards to China

shut wren
#

ballon

shrewd pecan
#

I'd wouldn't bother with the J-7D

#

I would just save money and torture yourself with the A-5C

#

where you can just bully A-10s

#

until you reach the F-16

shut wren
#

yea fuck A-10s

shrewd pecan
#

then suffer with that until you get sparrows

shrewd pecan
#

the f-16 is like

#

the only top tier chinese plane worth grinding

shut wren
#

Im doing it for the PRC side

#

F-16 until J-10

shrewd pecan
#

I'd just go for Russia at that point

#

PLA side isn't worth it

shut wren
#

I am russian main

#

Its not worth it but its cool

shrewd pecan
#

at that point

#

I'd just wait for PLA side to get something actually worthwhile

shut wren
#

thats the air tree

#

Ground tree is better

#

the 1200mm pen tank

shrewd pecan
#

the

#

mid ass tanks

shut wren
#

99as

shrewd pecan
#

and the ATGM vehicle that would be good if you didn't get better in other trees

shut wren
#

and the Bias

#

Q-5 it is

frigid karma
#

Tato

#

Should i grind sweden, usa or china

shut wren
#

Sweden is the fastest to jet

#

USA has all the freedom

#

China has best of both worlds

frigid karma
#

ground specifically

shut wren
#

oh

#

Same applies to china

#

but uhh

#

let me check the tree brb

shrewd pecan
#

best stock grind

#

and you get everything

frigid karma
shut wren
#

No russian Bias

shrewd pecan
#

want a T-80?

#

want a Leopard 2?

shut wren
#

oh yea they get those

shrewd pecan
#

want a Leclerc or a Abrams in the near future

#

it will have it all

#

generally put

#

China I would avoid like the plague since its mid the tree

#

USA, Russia, Sweden and Germany

#

all good starter options

shut wren
#

Thanks snail

shrewd pecan
#

top starter tree is probably Sweden tho

shut wren
#

You get some russia and germany

shrewd pecan
#

you get the best leopard 2

#

with a better AA system

#

actual light tanks

#

and a good IFV

shut wren
#

Also Mi-28

#

russian thingy

shrewd pecan
#

you also do not have to deal with stock HEAT

shut wren
#

You also get suffering

#

Like the rest of us

#

But the 1.3 spaag looks cool

ivory ridge
#

for some reason

shrewd pecan
#

because its a export vehicle

ivory ridge
shrewd pecan
#

yeah it doesn't have the Swede doctrine excuse

ivory ridge
#

oh right the finnish 2a6 has heat too

shrewd pecan
#

man what is up with the F-16s MFD

#

a single 7.62 to the rear of the plane will knock that thing out for no reason

shut wren
#

Bias

shut wren
shrewd pecan
#

why are you grinding

#

the bombers first

maiden citrus
#

bombers are pog

shut wren
#

Soviet bombers got big boom

frigid karma
#

also

#

they win games

shut wren
#

Bomb bases

frigid karma
#

im pretty sure people in rank 1 don't know that you can manually shoot backwards in a bomber

shut wren
#

yeet those bitches

shrewd pecan
#

in terms of Soviet jets

frigid karma
#

so they just tail you and fly perfectly still

shrewd pecan
#

not my hottest area

frigid karma
#

unironically have higher a2a kills in my sb2u than my fighters

shut wren
#

I'm decently good at soviet jets

frigid karma
shrewd pecan
#

tho I'd bum rush the MIG-21

frigid karma
#

well, the ones without 12.7\

shut wren
#

Mig-21s good

frigid karma
#

praise the m2

shrewd pecan
#

then go for the aircraft you need for the MIG-29

shut wren
#

we dont get countermeasuers untill 21

shrewd pecan
#

this entire part of air rb for me

#

is a blur

#

until I got the F-4C

shut wren
shrewd pecan
#

then I didn't start actually having fun with top tier air RB until I got about here with the F-4J

frigid karma
#

is rb like more popular than ab for air

shrewd pecan
#

yes

#

only insane people play arcade jets

shut wren
#

I’m insane

#

Godmode farming

shrewd pecan
#

god damn

#

why the hell is my Sheridan win rate so high

frigid karma
shrewd pecan
#

I mean

#

that plays a lot better than

shut wren
#

Shvak mfs

shrewd pecan
#

war thunder ace combat but with worse controls

tough quail
#

prop arcade is way better than realistic

#

vice versa, jet arcade is trash

frigid karma
#

duly noted

shrewd pecan
#

prop RB

shut wren
#

Unless godmode farming

shrewd pecan
#

descends into spending 20 minutes

#

trying to find the one bomber who space climbed

frigid karma
#

i played ab and rb ground and it feels more or less the same imo

#

true story, i was about to kill this LVT controlling a plane until he kamikaze'd it into me

shrewd pecan
#

I don't really like arcade ground

#

since you can't really hide

#

and it just makes the issue with light vehicles getting to the best spots immediately even worse

shut wren
#

You gotta spade you tanks some how

frigid karma
#

i heard someone claim, while listing a list of reasons why f-35Bs cant land on arleigh burkes in practice, that the thrust would damage the deck

#

Thinkpitz \

shrewd pecan
#

ships have to be modified to be able to use the F-35B for that reason

#

🤨 tho if your considering flying F-35Bs off of Burkes at that point you might as well be turning cargo ships into makeshift aircraft carriers

shrewd pecan
shut wren
brave elbow
#

The crew of the U.S.S Texas in 1918

rapid junco
#

Remembers me of this picture here:

tribal mortar
#

We really need to Texas in Azur lane

eternal veldt
maiden citrus
spiral cedar
#

Cali, the ditzy battleship

eternal veldt
shrewd pecan
desert agate
#

you could theoretically put a heat resistant cover on the deck like a lot of US LHDs do

#

but you wouldnt be able to fit the aircraft in a Burkes hangar

#

so you'd be having a great time with sea spray effectively destroying the aircraft the moment the ship enters slightly worse and a flat calm sea states

frigid karma
#

i mean

#

landing it in anything other than flat calm seas is questionable

desert agate
#

im not talking about landing it im talking about keeping it there after its landed

#

if you're modifying a burke with a heat resistant deck you're clearly intending to operate the F-35

tough quail
#

theres a big difference between the usn not giving a shit about sea planes getting washed off in heavy weather during ww2

#

and several fuckmillion dollar stealth kets in 2023

frigid karma
#

GlowNaruhodo i was just considering how feasible it is for an F-35B needing to emergency land on a burke

desert agate
#

doable in an emergency yes

#

the deck will need repairs but it can be done

#

The Alraigo incident occurred on 6 June 1983, when a lost British Royal Navy Sea Harrier fighter aircraft landed on the deck of a Spanish container ship. Its pilot, Sub-Lieutenant Ian Watson, was a junior Royal Navy pilot undertaking his first NATO exercise from HMS Illustrious (R06), which was operating off the coast of Portugal. Watson was lau...

#

after all

#

a harrier landed on a cargo ship

frigid karma
#

imagine if they found out balloon boy was on that balloon

#

👀

sage bay
#

Lol

subtle prawn
maiden citrus
jagged monolith
#

Operation Satanic II when?

subtle prawn
manic latch
#

Ngl was ugly project

#

Mpf better

manic latch
cerulean ice
#

Not quite, out of the 250 years of history since 1772 Poland hates russia for at least 173 years of occupation, plus notably for communists - the war in 1920.
That said however, the significantly more relevant part of the period indeed is 1939-1989, it is not though "something russia did 30 years ago" but "something that ended 30 years ago and lasted for prior 50 years"

#

Now, you seem to be saying quite weird or drastic things. I don't blame you if you don't quite know the characteristics of Polish national identity or the modern-times direction course in relation to other countries or modern Polish perspective towards some of them, as horse doesn't seem to know either Smilebuki
So to address some of the things above:

ivory ridge
#

rare fox alo appearance

maiden citrus
#

he heard polish

cerulean ice
#
  • Starting from the simplest - I take it that Sweden part was mostly a joke, as it should be. Indeed the Deluge is right up there with WW1 and WW2 as the most devastating events for Polish lands, people, and culture. However, XVII century is significantly more distant from the other examples and is the only historical period when there even were any negative interactions between Poland and Sweden at all, before or since. In fact XVII century is probably the only period when Sweden was a major European player in the first place. So due to lack of bad blood Sweden is very much absent from any modern anti-national rhetoric and is just a country and economic partner as any other
eternal veldt
#

"I am a Pole" - Fox

cerulean ice
#

ba dum tss

cerulean ice
#

(Norway and Finland though both exist more in common consciousness as Fins are the based wódka friends, while Norway is a great seasonal working destination)

#
  • Now, the Germans... the Germans - The memory of Nazis and what they had done obviously exists, as it should. However, there is a a general awareness that Germany has been in fact denazified years ago (you know, unlike the country that made you mention Germany in the first place). And a subtle distinction between economical cooperation and political one - by the end of the day Germany is the European economical powerhouse and is right next to Poland, the direction for decades has been to firmly establish and expand economical cooperation/import/export of various sorts in various sectors and Germany is Poland's top market partner. And that is how it should be and that isn't ass licking. Political relations meanwhile have the catch of Poland always conceal-carrying a knife in case Germany gets any weird idea or just stares at them wrongly.
manic latch
alpine onyx
#

Would've helped Russia if they hadn't spent decades trying to hide just how much they were involved in the invasion of Poland

#

When did they finally admit to the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact?

#

1990?

manic latch
# alpine onyx 1990?

Well if it's was 1990 then it's Russia as you said. Soviet Union was at its end

cerulean ice
#

That said though there are political groups in Poland that rely heavily on anti-German rhetoric for one malicious reason or another. One of them is a fringe right-wing group that might even have monarchist elements, heavily populated by nutjobs... and also displays uncanny russian bias and is generally considered to have had a number of high-rank members on russian payroll, so go figure.
The other is the current (not for long) ruling party that has strong totalitarian tendencies/desires. From there are for example the guys suddenly flaunting the "germony big 1 trillion reparations". The malicious reason to use anti-german rhetoric and bring up nazis is really to conceal their own totalitarian desires - they hate the fact that EU looks at their hands so they have to have anti-EU/anti-German attitude politically, at least when dispensing propaganda (because by the end of the day they don't and won't resign from economic stuff with Germany actually, but they just need the nation to believe that they can not be made accountable by EU in any way, even when it comes to the money coming strictly from EU)

manic latch
alpine onyx
#

Without dipping into modern politics too much, there are still defenders of that pact in high ranking Russian politics

cerulean ice
#

"the pact never happened but it was beneficial"
yar har har

jagged monolith
eternal veldt
spring briar
spring briar
ivory ridge
#

but did they rebore deez

manic latch
spring briar
#

krem

elfin zinc
#

Ww2 started 1939 and ended in 1945

spiral cedar
#

WW2 started in 1937 and ended in 1945 Smuggybucky

#

The Battle of Shanghai (Chinese: 淞滬會戰) was the first of the twenty-two major engagements fought between the National Revolutionary Army (NRA) of the Republic of China (ROC) and the Imperial Japanese Army (IJA) of the Empire of Japan at the beginning of the Second Sino-Japanese War. It lasted from August 13, 1937, to November 26, 1937, and was on...

#

There are a few options for the start date of WW2, depending on what aspects you want to emphasize. I just like to use 1937 because it makes people think about what is meant by the start of WW2

manic latch
spring briar
desert agate
lone bloom
#

Most people don’t talk about the war between China and Japan as it relates to WWII

desert agate
desert agate
#

WW2 starting in 1939 is eurocentric and overall poor historigraphy

lone bloom
#

Hard agree

#

Agree on both of those counts lol

#

It started in 1937 in my mind

cerulean ice
#

define "most people"
people who for some reason intentionally omit it
or people who simply don't know because their education failed to mention it

lone bloom
#

I’m pretty sure the war in China only ended with the collapse of Japan at the end

spiral cedar
#

something something 1949

desert agate
#

in history classes in the west, WW2 started in 1939

#

in Western countries involved in the Pacific war you might see a mention of Japans invasion of China in 1937

#

but it isnt the start date of WW2

cerulean ice
glass trail
#

japan invading china wasnt as important because china wasnt a neutral country

cerulean ice
#

there are certain two countries where some people seem to believe that the war only started in 1941 AkagiLUL

glass trail
#

thats why 1939 is the widely accepted date

lone bloom
#

It wasn’t a neutral country?

glass trail
#

ill explain better

#

belgium was agreed upon in the 1800s to be a neutral country

#

nobody can invade it

#

poland was a country that had already been split several times

#

so when both of them were invaded, europe responded

desert agate
#

Poland wasn't in a state of diplomatic neutrality before WW2

glass trail
#

whereas china was a country on the other side of the world that nobody really cared about

lone bloom
#

There it is

spiral cedar
#

The invasion of Belgium was in 1940

desert agate
#

yes thats my point

lone bloom
#

There’s the Eurocentric mindset lmfao

humble mulch
#

Lmao

desert agate
#

people saying that 1939 is the start date of WW2 is eurocentrism

cerulean ice
#

but by that logic... Poland was a neutral country as well because they still had valid in 1939 non-aggression pacts with Germany and russia from few years prior

glass trail
#

im agreeing with yall Ehhssex

lone bloom
#

Oh, I see

desert agate
#

people acting under the erroneous belief that China is somehow less important than Europe

lone bloom
#

I thought you were disagreeing lol

glass trail
#

nono i was adding more explanation

#

mb

lone bloom
#

Yes, you’re correct

cerulean ice
#

if you agree then I don't understand your point

desert agate
#

i get your point now

spiral cedar
glass trail
#

no i agree that 1939 is the eurocentric date because poland and belgium were invaded around that time

desert agate
#

the eurocentric view of WW2 is being challenged in historical circles and I'm sure that we'll see history curriculums rewritten in 10 years or so

#

or maybe it wont happen because of 2nd cold war tensions

#

we'll see

lone bloom
#

It would be nice

glass trail
#

poland and belgium are in fact in europe

spiral cedar
#

WWII started in 1931, who’s with me

humble mulch
#

what the fuck happened in 31

manic latch
#

Ww2 started with WW1 5Head

humble mulch
#

Beer hall push?

lone bloom
#

WW2 started with the unification of Germany

glass trail
cerulean ice
#

what the heck is up with Belgium

manic latch
#

Isn't WW2 1939 because other nations didn't really give a fuck about China's suffering while waged war on Germany for invading nation?

cerulean ice
#

are you mistaking WW1 Belgium with WW2?

lone bloom
#

Pretty much

glass trail
cerulean ice
#

so you were talking about WW1 Belgium?

lone bloom
#

Nanking

cerulean ice
#

I don't understand

delicate beacon
#

I thought it was 1939 because it's the moment the wars weren't regional anymore?

glass trail
#

after belgium gained its independence france and uk both wanted control over it, so they proposed a neutrality similar to switzerland's

delicate beacon
#

Then again the US did still call the wars regional cirThink

spiral cedar
glass trail
cerulean ice
#

ok, but Belgium in WW2 was invaded right before France, 8 months after Poland

spiral cedar
#

Or, rather, a rogue part of the IJA overruns Manchuria and Japan decides to keep it

delicate beacon
#

WW2 started at the Battle of Tsushima

glass trail
#

...

cerulean ice
#

so why do you even mention it

#

there is like 3 other countries invaded in between Poland and Belgium even

glass trail
#

i mention it because it happened much later than the japanese invasion of china

cerulean ice
#

but is not considered a date by anyone

glass trail
#

and it was the most influential invasion after germanys invasion of poland

#

because of the truce that germany broke

#

so poland, then belgium

cerulean ice
#

but it is not a relevant date for any consideration of the beginning of the war and is way apart from the date in question, so I just don't get why you list those in a single breath

manic latch
#

Polands gets invaded

UK and France declares war on Germany for it

= WW2 hmm

#

While there was a China vs Japan thingy before but I doubt anyone making war declaration like this for China

spiral cedar
#

The only reason to hold 1939 over 1937 is if you think any war involving the British Empire is inherently a world war

lone bloom
#

The Japan vs China ‘thingy’ is a pretty big deal imo as it relates to the war

frigid karma
#

im just quoting foch, ofc

manic latch
desert agate
#

im not sure how Poland being invaded by Germany is any more global in scale than Japans invasion of China

frigid karma
#

since japan wants to nom

spiral cedar
lone bloom
#

Japan started shit in the pacific without any substantial pushing from Germany

spiral cedar
#

If any war involving the British Empire is a world war, then you can make that argument that 1939 has priority over 1937. But you then need to list a lot of other wars as world wars

frigid karma
#

the only reason why people consider 39 the start of WW2 is because they saw WW1 as a european conflict - except for the fact that WW1 also saw combat in Africa, the Middle East, Pacific and Asia

frigid karma
#

7 years war is the WW0

shut wren
#

World war season 3 when

frigid karma
cerulean ice
# desert agate WW2 starting in 1939 is eurocentric and overall poor historigraphy

I could try to make a point about only from September 1939 the war actually being "world" because only then were countries from beyond a single continent
...except it kinda falls apart due to the fact that the only reason for that intercontinental involvement being French and British overseas territories and dominions, where fighting didn't even take place (until Italy joins)
and it being then inconsistent with other conflicts whose dates are from inciting incidents and not from the day Brits or French join in

#

nowadays I often see the term "Beginning of the War in Europe" rather than just "Beginning of the War, period"

spiral cedar
cerulean ice
#

which at least doesn't elevate it above "Beginning of the War in Asia"

desert agate
#

ARGENTINA WORLD POWER

shut wren
frigid karma
#

no more world wars

lone bloom
#

It all eventually became an interconnected conflict. It didn’t start that way. Only in 41 did the pieces get lynched together

frigid karma
#

because british empire doesn't exist?

spiral cedar
#

They still had HK

cerulean ice
#

well they had that island still, which is in South America, so it was an intercontinental conflict

shut wren
spiral cedar
#

I meant at the time of the Falklands

lone bloom
#

But a part of that conflict started in 37, so we should say that the war started in 37

spiral cedar
#

Not today ofc

shut wren
#

True

frigid karma
#

Argentina was the last to join ww2

#

in august 27th, 1945

#

Therefore, WW2 started in 1945?

lone bloom
#

No that’s not what I’m saying

frigid karma
#

so major powers only?

lone bloom
#

I’m just saying that a piece of the conflict (that eventually became connected to all the others) started in 37 with the full scale Japanese invasion of China

frigid karma
#

then what about WW1?

#

Italy didn't join until 1915

spiral cedar
#

There were two main theaters of WW2, the European and Asia-Pacific. The former did not merge with the latter into one overarching conflict until 1941. I think that’s a valid point of view

frigid karma
#

should we change the start date (when all major powers became involved) to 15?

lone bloom
#

I’m not qualified to speak on wwi lol

#

Wwi is a big soupy mess to me

shut wren
#

Ww2 gang

lone bloom
#

I’m not at all saying that we should say the war started in 41

cerulean ice
#

the funny thing with not mentioning 1937 in USA is that it is considerably more relevant to the context of USA entering the conflict than 1939

spiral cedar
#

In regards to the eventual US entry into WW2, 1940 is more relevant than 1939

lone bloom
#

I’m saying that the sino Japanese war is connected to all the conflicts that make up wwii and that we should call that the start of the war

desert agate
#

WW1 is only really called a world war because there was no counter to eurocentrism at the time and the name has never had a serious challenge

spiral cedar
#

But the Second Sino-Japanese War started in 1931 NepSmug

glass trail
#

wwii start date as 1941 because thats when us got involved Blessex

desert agate
#

it really was for all intents and purposes a localised European conflict with a relatively minor theatre in the middle east

shut wren
#

And USSR

frigid karma
#

the war saw frequent guerilla conflicts, the palestinian conflict, the siege of tsintao, the seizure of various pacific islands, etc.

cerulean ice
#

like, ok, in Europe obviously 1939 is way more relevant, I think we can agree on that. But for USA it is like... might pick from either, one certainly makes more sense for the context of their own start

cerulean ice
#

it wasn't really Eurocentric at first, because it didn't claim "World"

desert agate
#

WW1 in the Pacific and Asia ended in 3 months

shut wren
desert agate
#

it was barely a front

#

it had no impact on the war whatsoever and absorbed almost no resources for any combatant

lone bloom
#

I feel like wwi should just be called the Great War

Wwii is, in many way, the sequel to that war. And it was much bigger, and actually on a global scale. Ww2 was a world war but ww1 was not

cerulean ice
#

it was retroactively renamed into World War 1 after the second war was legit a World War

frigid karma
#

Is iraq not in asia?

shut wren
#

In Asia

desert agate
#

the middle eastern theatre, as mentioned, was a more significant front and more relevant to the combatants of WW1

cerulean ice
#

imagine a different timeline where they are in fact called "The Great War" and "The World War"

cerulean ice
#

instead of shorthanded to heck "WW1 and WW2"

glass trail
#

gw and ww

cerulean ice
#

what next, WWW?

shut wren
#

Either way people died

glass trail
manic latch
shut wren
desert agate
#

the actions in Africa were again minor and relatively uninvested in by the major combatants

frigid karma
#

wkwk

spiral cedar
lone bloom
spiral cedar
desert agate
#

WW1 remains a European conflict first and foremost

frigid karma
#

relatively minor, yes, but also somewhat unprecedented to even see them involved in an otherwise eurocentric conflict

manic latch
desert agate
#

that is in fact the idea im challenging here

frigid karma
#

also America joined in in 1918, which would explain why postwar people called it a WW since the Americas also got themselves involved

desert agate
#

and where did the Americans fight

frigid karma
#

im not debating the fighting took place 90% in europe

cerulean ice
manic latch
frigid karma
#

i'm just trying to explain why people called it a World War

#

not necessarily trying to justify it

#

because it is pretty incorrect terminology

lone bloom
#

I feel like it was only called a world war after the Second World War

frigid karma
#

it was, actually

spiral cedar
#

Thinkpitz Gallipoli is in Asia right?

cerulean ice
#

depends

frigid karma
frigid karma
#

yesn't

spiral cedar
frigid karma
#

asian't

#

then it's asian

cerulean ice
#

it is on the eastern side of the strait, so when Turkey controls it it is Asia AkachanSmug

#

if it was on the western side of the strait it would be in Europe

desert agate
#

so the town of Gelibolu is located on the European side of the Dardanelles

cerulean ice
#

or if Byzantine Empire controlled it, then it would also be considered Europe still

spring briar
desert agate
#

however the Gallipoli campaign was fought on both sides

spring briar
shut wren
desert agate
#

the French fought on the Asian side and the Entente fought on the European side

frigid karma
#

the point i'm trying to make here, Hit, is that you have the Chinese, Japanese, Europeans, Aussies, Americans, Ottomans, Arabs, and Africans all fighting in one war

#

mostly European, and mostly in Europe, yes

cerulean ice
#

no, wait, crap, I screwed up

#

yes, it is on the western side of the strait

frigid karma
#

but the diversity of combatants made people after WW2 call it WW1

cerulean ice
#

so Europe it is

spring briar
#

Y’all bozos

frigid karma
#

that, along with the fact that it's pretty obvious WW1 led to WW2

desert agate
#

the French abandoned the Asian side after a few months and redirected their forces to the European side and to other fronts

lone bloom
spiral cedar
desert agate
#

unfortunately in my trip to Gallipoli I wasnt able to search for the abandoned French Gallipoli memorials

#

wasnt there nearly long enough

spring briar
#

Thx for trying WarPat

desert agate
#

i wanted to spend a few days on the peninsular but i was overruled by family

cerulean ice
shut wren
spring briar
#

Beyblade led to ww1

#

Its literally cannon

frigid karma
#

but most people attribute WW2 in europe starting because "hitler and germany angy"

cerulean ice
#

go to #memes

frigid karma
#

👀

spring briar
frigid karma
#

fox has been gone for quite a while i see

manic latch
#

Say. If Earth and 3 other planet was against 2 other planets

#

What war would that be called

desert agate
manic latch
#

Space wars?

spring briar
manic latch
#

Great space war?

spring briar
#

Krem

spring briar
#

Star wars

cerulean ice
#

it would probably end up being called "[something] revolution"

manic latch
#

floppaletsgoo Didn't Reagan did Star wars

desert agate
spring briar
spiral cedar
desert agate
#

theres a decent few there as far as im aware

spiral cedar
spring briar
#

Right I was in Drach’s server a couple days ago and they literally said Britain carried ww1

desert agate
#

ThinkZed does france have an equivalent to the commonwealth war graves commission maintaining french war graves overseas

spring briar
#

Not sure

lone bloom
#

There are a lot of reasons for the start of wwii lol

We could start by saying that human beings are terrible

desert agate
#

because if so y'all need to get them to do their fucking jobs

spiral cedar
#

The initial conditions of the universe caused WW2

lone bloom
#

True

#

The Big Bang

spring briar
#

Bazinga

cerulean ice
#

it would just be a difference between direct reasons and indirect reasons and context of the situation that led to certain developments prior

lone bloom
#

Hitler had a bad sandwich and he was feeling grumpy

shut wren
#

Homie went broke cuz he didn’t draw anime titties

frigid karma
#

chatgpt sucks at analyzing ballistic data

spiral cedar
#

Shocking

frigid karma
#

The H-39 battleship would be relatively effective at resisting the South Dakota's main armament, with the immunity zone stretching out to 36,000 yards. However, it should be noted that the immunity zone calculations are based on certain assumptions and may not accurately reflect real-world performance.

shut wren
#

Unbelievable

frigid karma
#

crappy ai

#

cant believe i paid 10 billion dollars for this

#

do you think best buy takes refunds

desert agate
#

Haven't cried in a long time but I teared up at Gallipoli

#

Very emotional place

spiral cedar
#

Sounds like it

shut wren
spring briar
desert agate
#

was eating in a restaurant and one of the owners came up to us and told us our ancestors were very brave

desert agate
#

where the Australians and New Zealanders landed on the 25th of April 1915

lone bloom
#

The ultimate take away from all of this should be that war fucking sucks

shut wren
#

For everyone

#

There are no winners

#

Only the bigger loser and the smaller loser

desert agate
#

The beach has shrunk in the last 100 years

lone bloom
#

Sometimes you just need a reminder

#

But this stuff is not nice

desert agate
shut wren
#

I though I saw a mammoth

desert agate
#

seeing rows and rows of graves was an experience indeed

#

thats just like a tiny amount of the graves at Lone Pine

shrewd pecan
desert agate
#

i got more pictures on my dslr but 6 months later i still havent been assed to get the pictures off it

frigid karma
shrewd pecan
#

for example most of the colonial conflicts during the age of colonization where the Europeans made off with all of the wealth of the natives at little cost

#

or WW2 where the US ended off in a much better place than it started

cerulean ice
cerulean ice
#

it is like saying "this movie sucks" and leaving a one star review

shut wren
#

I meant in world war 2

spiral cedar
#

The tragedies of war do no override its occasional necessity. But nor does necessity alleviate its tragedies

shrewd pecan
#

Yeah but there were definite winners in WW2

desert agate
#

EulaSip2 and the 407'000 dead americans were not winners

shut wren
shrewd pecan
#

a cost was paid indeed Im not denying that

#

But for what it gained I’d argue the US was a definite winner

desert agate
#

dancing22 WW1 was really a fuck

spring briar
#

Belgium was very big loser

frigid karma
#

but also

#

cool steampunk art

desert agate
#

60'000 dead in a foreign land for a few islands in the pacific

spring briar
#

All infrastructure destroyed, no repayments

desert agate
#

a cost paid indeed

frigid karma
#

don't you do tabletop ww2 games

#

why do you not know this

shut wren
#

The soviets and Chinese took the biggest hits for WW2

frigid karma
#

as a percapita analysis,

shut wren
#

Well USSR had more after effect

cerulean ice
#

chinese maybe (but then, proportionally to their absurd population those big hits still look small despite their sheer numbers

shrewd pecan
#

The former USSR hasn’t recovered from the population loss to this day

cerulean ice
#

but russians, just no lmao

spring briar
#

Very big oof

frigid karma
#

the ussr was in control of a massive communist empire that challenged the americans up to the 80s

shut wren
#

Shit came crashing down

frigid karma
#

they suffered greatly, but they also gained quite a bit from ww2 since they were effectively elevated to one of the top 2 world powers

manic latch
#

Still never understood what British did with their Lend Lease. Since irrc they got more than Soviets did

shrewd pecan
#

honestly the USSR I’d say is a case of losing less

shut wren
#

Or how ever tf you spell it

manic latch
#

I mean as British getting from US

shrewd pecan
shut wren
desert agate
#

Alone – long before visiting these battlefields had become something of
a rite of passage for many young Australians – I wandered around, awestruck at the savagery of the terrain, how the cliffs rose all but straight from
the shore, how the trace of the trenches meandered in parallel lines so close
together, how some of the gullies they’d fought in and for looked rather
more like abysses to my eyes.
Standing on the beach below the spot known as The Sphinx, I noticed a
great deal of erosion in the landscape all around, and wondered about it
until I suddenly realised. That was not mere erosion, it was the scars of
thousands of artillery shells hitting those hills!
At Lone Pine Cemetery, amid all the gravestones marked with such
words as DUTY NOBLY DONE, HE DIED IN A FAR
COUNTRY/FIGHTING FOR/HIS NATIVE LAND, A MOTHER’S
THOUGHTS OFTEN WANDER TO THIS SAD AND LONELY
GRAVE … I noted an epitaph that quite shocked me, going something like
DIED IN A FOREIGN FIELD. AND FOR WHAT?

shrewd pecan
#

And American aircraft made up large proportions of the RAF

frigid karma
#

i'm still hyper mad about BFV getting canceled because in BF1 we had the Russian CW in 1920

#

i don't think any other fps covered that conflict

#

and i was holding out hope for a Chinese Civil War as a DLC to BFV, it fit perfectly

manic latch
desert agate
#

game was bad

shrewd pecan
#

Game ended up good in the end

frigid karma
#

game is good

#

worse than bf1, but still good

#

the initial release was a shitshow with the gamers having a gamer moment about women, and the devs basically acting like dicks inr eturn

shut wren
#

I get sent to the gulag every match in wz2

manic latch
#

BF1 was the peak I guess. Bf5 and the 2042...

frigid karma
#

but, they recovered all of their bad PR when the pacific DLC came out

#

people were loving that shit

#

then they canceled all development promptly after al marj encampment

desert agate
#

Blessex the one smart thing maine ever said was about Australian reverse lend lease to the US

deep apex
frigid karma
#

because they needed to go smear feces on their brand in 2042

manic latch
frigid karma
#

by that point though most of the bf1/v team already left

#

because EA

#

fuck EA

shut wren
#

Fuck ea

frigid karma
#

we had fucking soviet soldiers in the files

manic latch
#

Command and Conquer Sadge

desert agate
frigid karma
#

we literally had a French tiralleur campaign

#

imagine if they kept the gallipoli campaign in bf1 story

#

and then never added turning tides

desert agate
frigid karma
#

Hit, have you played bf1 btw?

desert agate
#

course i have

#

i was one of the top gewehr m.95 infantry players

frigid karma
#

do you know for the gallipoli mission, there's actually an italian flag

desert agate
#

top like 0.5% or something

frigid karma
#

m95 is just for noobs who can't aim

deep apex
#

I was on console

desert agate
#

so true

frigid karma
#

SMLE is way better

#

you actually get a sweet spot

deep apex
#

I think my best rifle was the Gewehr 98

desert agate
#

SMLE sights always fucked me

frigid karma
#

just switch to carbine or radium

desert agate
#

i liked arisaka sights better

#

no

frigid karma
#

Arisaka is a perfect gun except for its reload

#

too slow

desert agate
#

as a point of principle i never used scopes

#

or optics

deep apex
#

Machine guns? Perino, browning, or Chauchat

frigid karma
#

radium is also iron sights

desert agate
#

scopes only if necessary

deep apex
#

Chauchat fired slow but it hit like a truck

desert agate
#

infantry rifles all the way

#

but anyway

frigid karma
#

and if you want a hyper ptfo rifle pick carcano

desert agate
deep apex
#

I always send scopes

desert agate
#

i loved the carcano

deep apex
#

Okay

desert agate
#

it was so nice

#

but also

frigid karma
#

"oh but no straight pull bolt" fuck you just aim better

desert agate
frigid karma
#

Hit

frigid karma
#

you are talking to a person who spent like 2 hours talking about wt here the other dya

#

you are not mod

shut wren
#

Agreed

desert agate
frigid karma
#

go cry to your gf tea if you want me to stop

deep apex
#

I was talking about bf1, not irl pepega

desert agate
#

hey @humble mulch

frigid karma
#

oh shit

manic latch
#

Snitch

frigid karma
#

snitch

shut wren
#

Silent help

desert agate
#

yeah im a snitch but i want history talk in the history channel

#

if you dont want history talk then why are you here?

deep apex
#

Chauchat was bad, but the concept it opened up was fantastic

#

Irl

spring briar
deep apex
#

Reliability speaking

frigid karma
#

it had good and bad

cerulean ice
#

shut the fuck up

frigid karma
#

but exposed magazine, yikes

cerulean ice
#

about Battlefield

spring briar
#

Kek

deep apex
#

THE CHAUCHAT IS A REAL WEAPON YOU IDIOT

frigid karma
#

Spoon, chill

spring briar
#

Why are you fucks talking about bf1

#

Gtfo

deep apex
#

I'm. Not.

frigid karma
#

Fox was just thinking we were still talking about bf1 because he has internet explorer

deep apex
#

I'm talking about the real Chauchat

frigid karma
#

anyways have an aircraft carrier

shut wren
#

Imagine that but with modern jets

shrewd pecan
#

so the suicide blimp?

spring briar
shut wren
spring briar
#

And it did not have reliability issues beyond yikes mud

shrewd pecan
#

I don’t think your gonna have a good time trying to recover a modern jet onto a zeppelin without making massive sacrifices in that jets design

desert agate
#

ITS FIVE INCH FRIDAY EVERYONE COME PACK UP YOUR BAGS AND HEAD ON DOWN TO AL FAW WEVE GOT SHOTS SHOTS AND MORE SHOTS

frigid karma
#

five inches?

#

checks pants

shrewd pecan
#

ah

frigid karma
#

sorry, i can't go

shrewd pecan
shut wren
manic latch
#

Shame nobody speaks about this proposal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Northwoods

Operation Northwoods was a proposed false flag operation against American citizens that originated within the US Department of Defense of the United States government in 1962. The proposals called for CIA operatives to both stage and commit acts of violent terrorism against American military and civilian targets, blaming them on the Cuban govern...

#

The proposals called for CIA operatives to both stage and commit acts of violent terrorism against American military and civilian targets, blaming them on the Cuban government, and using it to justify a war against Cuba.

desert agate
#

If you can find a better price on any stocked item we'll invade your country under false pretences of the discovery of WMDs

shrewd pecan
#

I see that brought up all the time

frigid karma
#

yeah, standard CIA stuff

frigid karma
shut wren
#

The CIA wanted to make a fake gay porno with a fake cuban Castro

manic latch
cerulean ice
#

as if I haven't heard that a few times already from another person

desert agate
shrewd pecan
#

man for invading a country for its oil weird we didn’t get control of their oil

manic latch
frigid karma
desert agate
manic latch
#

F

desert agate
#

not for long though

shut wren
#

Y’all let’s talk about the communit balloons

frigid karma
#

unfortunately, hit will always be briitish

lone bloom
#

What’s the deal with a Chinese spy balloon? I’m ootl

desert agate
#

not going to go into specifics because of politics but the republican movement has never been stronger and the current government even has a minister responsible for hashing out the details of a republic

frigid karma
desert agate
#

assuming this government wins the next election there will be a referendum on the monarchy question within 6 years

frigid karma
#

it's happened before

shut wren
frigid karma
#

media just made a fuss out of it now because WarShrug and they shot it down with a raptor

cerulean ice
#

they gonna be renaming HMAS into "His Mates Aussie Ship"

desert agate
#

yeah

manic latch
#

Damn

lone bloom
#

Lol

frigid karma
#

it's modern politics so i'd really

desert agate
#

can't keep a british watermark if we arent under the poms anymore

frigid karma
#

rather not talk about it

desert agate
#

new flag would be nice anyway

shrewd pecan
lone bloom
#

I saw a meme that was comparing the f22 to a mig and it was like “mig: 0 balloons; f22: at least one balloon”

desert agate
#

we havent changed our flag since before WW1

frigid karma
#

you don't want those zealanders fuck one-upping you lot, do you?

manic latch
shut wren
desert agate
#

a republic is effectively inevitable at this point

frigid karma
#

what's wrong with this?

manic latch
desert agate
#

libs wont win the 2025 election because their leader looks like voldemort and labor has (finally) unified around a republic

manic latch
#

Wish they added some kind of cross or borderline

cerulean ice
#

couldn't they have just put the naval sigil in the middle of the normal flag?

shrewd pecan
#

It’s a photoshop

desert agate
#

labor had unified around a republic in 1996 too but unfortunately two australian republicans cannot exist within 5 metres of each other without violence being involved

shut wren
#

Let me check again

shrewd pecan
#

Tho I wouldn’t be surprised if a kill marking on a F-22 appears soon

desert agate
#

1996 failed because the plan was stupid and no one could agree

#

the net referendum wont make the same mistakes

frigid karma
#

are you even allowed to make those markings anymore?

shrewd pecan
#

Yes

frigid karma
#

wouldn't that mess up the stealth coating?

manic latch
shut wren
shrewd pecan
shut wren
shrewd pecan
#

There’s also this one since a A-10 managed a F-22 kill during a exercise

frigid karma
spring briar
#

Sorry tato

shrewd pecan
#

Wonder how badly that 22 pilot got bullied for that

shut wren
#

I can hear the wasted money

spring briar
#

Sorry krem

manic latch
#

For what

shrewd pecan
spring briar
manic latch
shrewd pecan
shut wren
manic latch
shrewd pecan
#

I hate it when my kid lose their bus sized balloons

manic latch
#

Three bus*

shut wren
#

Gtg launching more balloons

manic latch
#

Red Alert Kirov was realistic all along

shrewd pecan
#

The F-22s combat kill record will succeed the F-15s by the end of the week

shut wren
#

All balloons

shrewd pecan
#

🤨 thinking about it up until ukraine most of the MIG-29s air to air kills were Cessnas

shut wren
#

I don’t think the J-10/11 has any

manic latch
#

Most of the Mig-25 kills were F4s irrc

shrewd pecan
shut wren
#

Damn

#

Cuban mig 29 wt when

shrewd pecan
#

Then the only F-15 technically shot down in air to air combat was a Japanese F-15 shooting down another Japanese F-15 during a exercise

shut wren
#

Man wtf

#

What’s with US planes shooting shoe US planes

shrewd pecan
#

22 November 1995: F-15J, 52-8846, of the 303rd Tactical Fighter Squadron, Komatsu AFB, JASDF, during air-intercept training over the Sea of Japan, flown by Lt. Tatsumi Higuchi was shot down by an AIM-9L Sidewinder missile accidentally fired by his wingman. The pilot ejected safely.[6][97][100]

manic latch
#

F

#

Guess you can say

#

"He take the L"

shut wren
#

NAAHH

manic latch
#

Say

#

Will Aim-9X continue

#

Or a new missile will come

shut wren
#

Aim 9Y

#

And Z

shrewd pecan
#

there’s been multiple attempts at new AIM-9X blocks

manic latch
#

Blocks instead going Y?

shrewd pecan
#

most have been cancelled for various reasons

manic latch
#

Can it still shoot land targets?

shut wren
shrewd pecan
#

AIM-9X is in the bracket of being good enough while the budget needs to go into AIM-120 upgrades and ultimately replacement

manic latch
#

Aim-220 ye

#

260*

shut wren
#

I feel the only reason wt ain’t added more new shit is cuz mfs are gonna leak the manuals and shit

manic latch
#

Wait till they add F-117

shrewd pecan
#

So with the war thunder classified shit

#

You can literally get that shit off of a U.S. government website most of the time

shut wren
#

Some of the stuff are classified

shrewd pecan
#

Only shit of value was the Chinese, French and Brit leaks

shut wren
#

I can’t access it

shrewd pecan
#

You can literally get the F-22s flight manual and it’s perfectly legal

shut wren
#

Lmao fr

#

I found em online

manic latch
shut wren
#

Some mf put a shell on the picture

#

The bp

manic latch
#

Also

shrewd pecan
#

Have the YF-23s flight manual