#history

1 messages · Page 59 of 1

spiral cedar
#

Nonsense. The Japanese 18.1” gun killed more Japanese aircraft than any other battleship gun of WWII

lime belfry
#

words to live for

spiral cedar
eternal veldt
#

Beehive shell

#

So effective it explodes in your barrel and forces the whole turret to evacuate

#

Die-joubu desu

spiral cedar
#
Vice Admiral Kurita's Second Fleet steams about 100 miles ahead of Vice Admiral Ozawa's carriers.

At 0920, YAMATO's lookouts spot aircraft approaching at 13,125 feet. This is the fighter unit of Air Group 601's second strike. Admiral Kurita has received no information about a friendly overflight. Cruiser TAKAO fires four starshells meaning "identify yourself", but no reply is received. The planes keep approaching.

At 16,400 yards, YAMATO and the other ships execute a turn to port and open fire. YAMATO's main guns, loaded with "Sanshiki-dan" shells, are fired in anger for the first time - but at friendly forces! Four Mitsubishi Zeke fighters are damaged. Another ditches. MUSASHI's lookouts correctly identify the planes and she is the only ship that does not open fire.```
lime belfry
#

see ? we are getting somewhere

#

now I am gonna scroll down and read the rest

#

see if anything pop up

eternal veldt
#

Good luck doing something that historians have been finding for the past 3 decades

lime belfry
#

well I busted some myself but it minor stuff

#

like a revolver that some dudes in the jungle made 70 years ago

#

actually had a name and a production number

#

but u know, that just gun community stuff

eternal veldt
#

Japan had the minor inconvenience of destroying all the sekrit dokumints upon surrendering

#

"Oh, what's these? Haha, my big Shinano plans?"

#

"yea hahaha, I accidentally lost them, sorry sir, dont mind that burning furnace there, it's just too cold today"

lime belfry
#

The Vietminh had the minor inconvenience of never even bother recording anything

#

but yeah, not a gun history channel

#

I dont want to go down too much on that

spring briar
#

Digging tunnels takes time
No time for administration

shrewd pecan
#

we go into basically

#

any type of history here tbh

lime belfry
#

well but not gun u know

shrewd pecan
#

man

spring briar
#

@lime belfry i will steal your pho

shrewd pecan
#

we go on insane rants about tojostan

#

and other things

eternal veldt
spring briar
#

No

lime belfry
spring briar
#

I actually love pho

eternal veldt
#

Stop doing the white powder

spring briar
#

No

lime belfry
#

In short, there is a discussion recently about this gun

#

and they thought it was Vietcong

shrewd pecan
#

I mean

lime belfry
#

but I went into crazed mode and just went to a museum which I remembered had 4 of these guns

#

to check

shrewd pecan
#

the Vietcong ended up with everything from MP40s

#

to homemade M1911s

#

its not surprising

lime belfry
#

well I mean

#

in the end

#

it wasnt a VC gun

#

it was a Vietminh gun made by CAX

#

which was pretty impressive because they made a near perfect copy of the Enfield

#

in quite a large production

#

I managed to find 5 examples in museum

#

and grandson of a worker that made the gun contacted me

#

and sent me 2 photos of the guys with these

#

so... I guess I solved a mysery that was there for 70 years

spring briar
#

Artillery exam final question

lime belfry
#

so i guess that why you like it

spring briar
#

What war was this shell used in

eternal veldt
#

I should probably try, er, what is it

spring briar
eternal veldt
#

Bahn mi

lime belfry
#

it a joke

#

Banh Mi

sleek folio
#

WTF is this real? how's the project called?

spring briar
lime belfry
#

Baguette, but better

eternal veldt
lime belfry
#

sorry french but we stole your stuff and made it better

spring briar
eternal veldt
#

It doesnt take much to conjecture up a design

#

As Kaiser Wilhelm II did

#

Whether it floats without sinking is another thing entirely

lime belfry
#

have u seen the german and their confidence they can mount a 51cm gun on a ship ?

#

it easy to just imagine

#

it hard to actually turn it to reality

eternal veldt
#

If you are referring to H-44

#

They are unrestricted studies

#

Basically "please dont send me to the eastern front"

shrewd pecan
#

insane propaganda designs that would of never been built or finished

spring briar
#

And they werent even looked at by navy high command

spiral cedar
spring briar
eternal veldt
#

Its almost as delusional as that 7.5k ton speedboat design

lime belfry
#

I want some of the stuff the German engineers smoked before they came up with another insane design

#

sounds like some good stuff

eternal veldt
#

With 12 20.3cm guns and Jumo turbines

#

On 40 knots

#

Sure Germoney

shrewd pecan
spiral cedar
#

The Japanese only ever had to maintain 8 41cm powder magazines and they still got one to explode in port. How they are going to keep a few dozen from doing that is anyone’s guess NAGAFUCK

shrewd pecan
#

its meant to be eye catching enough to not get the engineers sent to the Eastern front

eternal veldt
spiral cedar
eternal veldt
lime belfry
#

u know, for being essentially the "most famous AAA" in ww2

#

the Flak 88 isnt mounted on a lot of ships

spiral cedar
#

Yeh

sleek folio
#

in what moment someone can think is possible in the first place?

eternal veldt
#

Do you consider Habakkuk to be real?

#

Its about as demented as that

spiral cedar
#

Okay, let me clarify. Some dude sketched it out; doesn’t mean anyone ever thought it should or would be built

shrewd pecan
#

its the equivalent

#

of someone going into shipbucket

#

and making a shitpost ship

spring briar
lime belfry
#

yeah just because some German dudes came up with something so they didnt get turned into Volksturm

#

doesnt mean everyone thinks it viable

#

most designs are just paper that got jerked off by wehraboo

eternal veldt
#

You know what

#

I have to find that speedboat again

#

With literally floatinf boing boing airfields

shrewd pecan
#

like there's far better examples of "crazy" ship ideas that were put under actual consideration

eternal veldt
#

Its too much

shrewd pecan
#

arsenal ship is one of them man

spiral cedar
lime belfry
#

kids 100 years from now gonna look at all the shitposts of tank and ship designs that some dudes on Deviantarts made

#

and decided it was real

spiral cedar
#

Story of H-45

lime belfry
#

but honestly, HMS Furious is a shitpost that became too real

#

surprised she isnt in AL yet

spiral cedar
#

Fisher is a shitpost come to life

#

I had a fierce time with the First Lord - Very fierce!

"The 18in was ordered by the Admiralty (ie Fisher) direct from Elswick, the only firm with plant to handle such huge pieces. The Ordnance Board were simply bypassed, which was probably illegal"```
shrewd pecan
#

the AL History patron saint lord fisher

eternal veldt
#

no please, I don't want to go to Murmansk

sleek folio
#

what is this?

shrewd pecan
#

what the hell m I looking at silver

shrewd pecan
#

dear god

lime belfry
#

man, those chocolate mixed with drug is too strong

#

but honestly, kinda creative

#

very creative even

shrewd pecan
eternal veldt
#

This is (according to the signature and the mark) a design from 1940, fora diesel powered light cruiser, which should be able
to accomodate up to eight twin engined bombers (Ju 88 ?) on the open deck, without hangar. Take-off and landing should be
possible on an inflatable raft, 200m x 20m, extended by a rollable mesh, 200m x 25m, which would have been rolled out by a
torpedo like float and was intended to dampen waves. I first thought, the aircraft were on catapults, but it rather seem to be
ramps for lowering them on that inflatable airfield. Additional to the four propellers, there seems to be a Voith-Schneider
propeller, too, maybe for better maneuverability during the process of launchinmg and recovering the aircraft ?
And no, it doesn't seem to be intended for one-way missions, because landing of aircraft ist explicitely mentioned.

lime belfry
#

are those JU88 ?

eternal veldt
#

again, the concept of inflatable airfield is already very meme-worthy

shrewd pecan
eternal veldt
#

now when you realize they're using fucking Jumo turbines

#

The Royal Navy stands no chance against this

spiral cedar
#

A hundred paper drawings of inflatable airfields is still of less combat value than one USS Ranger AkachanSmug

shrewd pecan
#

insane thought experiments

eternal veldt
#

H-44 looks sensible compared to this shit

lime belfry
#

RaNGer in AL is broken for her rarity

#

she can outdamage Enty if RNG is on her side

#

and RNG is in her name

eternal veldt
eternal veldt
#

One gives everyone lung cancer with funnel smoke

#

the other gives everyone heat stroke with a funnel that runs alongside the ship

#

all because Fujimoto and Hiraga needed to have a dick measuring contest

#

tfw Kaga is so inhospitable it has to go into rebuild earlier than Akagi

lime belfry
#

damn it, wrong gun

eternal veldt
#

Such is the meme that is early aircraft carriers

#

Many experiments, few successes

lime belfry
#

what with using 76.2mm than refers to it as 8 cm ?

spiral cedar
#

Well, the Japanese classified their 410mm as 41cm, then 40cm

#

Their 200mm as 20cm

#

Their 203mm as 20cm

spring briar
#

46 as 40

spiral cedar
#

Their 46cm as 40cm

lime belfry
#

no wonder why IJN ships in this game has inconsistent bust size

#

not even the Japanese know

spring briar
#

48 as 36

#

Truly the best

alpine onyx
#

rounding errors

spiral cedar
#

Very aggressive rounding errors

spring briar
#

“Incel rounding”

alpine onyx
#

Inshell rounding

spring briar
#

But in reverse

spiral cedar
#

Intel grounding

spring briar
spiral cedar
#

Well, maybe 460mm sounds too painful

eternal veldt
spiral cedar
#

At least these shells will go down on you

eternal veldt
#

The Brits also referred the 15"/42 as a super 13" early onwards, need to check

spring briar
#

Super 13”

#

Or 13.5”

eternal veldt
#

13.5

#

I hate the British 1.5" system

#

Reee

spiral cedar
#

12, 13.5, 14, 15, 16, 16.5, 18

lime belfry
#

Laugh in "using pounder to depict gun"

spiral cedar
#

Or, chronologically,

12
   13.5
      15
            18
        16
    14```
#

sad Fisher noises

spring briar
#

13.4 -> 12 -> 13.4 -> 12 -> 13 -> 14.96

eternal veldt
#

16.5 banished to the shadow realm

spiral cedar
#

Good

spring briar
#

787 mps mv

eternal veldt
#

16.5 bad? Haven't really seen details on it.

lime belfry
#

@eternal veldt huh, I guess you need to go to Maryland to find the answer

eternal veldt
#

Dont think even built.

spring briar
#

16.5 just isnt that innovative in any way

spiral cedar
#

Classic Indianhead moment

spring briar
#

Which is sad

lime belfry
#

classic US military storing moment

#

everything shipped to a place then disappeared

eternal veldt
#

could be worse

lime belfry
#

never heard again

spiral cedar
#

Storing equipment or terrorism suspects?

eternal veldt
#

"oh no, our documents are damaged by a leaking rooftop, what do"

#

"Toss it out or something, idk" - British archives

#

Okay, I was wrong, not super 13.5

#

"14" experimental gun"

lime belfry
#

Virgin: Noooo I must destroy these documents and kill myself so these valuable intelligence don't fall into enemy hand

eternal veldt
#

Not that much better

spiral cedar
#

TFW the US Navy re-classifies info about a long-obsolete 1920s fuze…in 2010

This document was removed from the web site in Mar 2010 at the request of the USN, NAVSEA Washington, DC for classification review. If you are an EOD technician and need ordnance data, the US military Joint Explosive Ordnance Disposal Technical Support Center, EODTSC@navy.mil supports EOD operations worldwide 24/7.

lime belfry
#

vs Chad: Let me just archive everything and show it 70 years later to flex

eternal veldt
#

Broke: Commit sudoku

#

Woke: Tie yourself to the ship, have Neptune literally reject your suicide, then become the president of your ship's club post-war

#

Good job Taihou

eternal veldt
#

Nobody ever reported why, either.

spiral cedar
#

One of the guys on the bridge of…either Fusou or Yamashiro, was standing on the bridge as it capsized with other officers so as to go down with the ship, but got pushed out by the water force and ended up surviving

maiden citrus
lime belfry
#

or maybe they just changed their mind half way and decided to live

#

who knows

#

for all we care all the guys that were with him died

#

so his story had no witness

spiral cedar
#

Indeed

maiden citrus
#

He destroyed three enterprises during the sinking

#

Barehanded

eternal veldt
#

Can't even redo my Hatsuzuki post anymore now that the action reports are gone

lime belfry
#

hatsuzuki easily the cutest among her class

#

favorite art design

eternal veldt
#

She isn't in game yet, unless you are referring to her canned coal version

#

which was, indeed, what provoked me into writing about her in the first place

spiral cedar
#

Isn’t she?

eternal veldt
#

We have Harutsuki and Suzutsuki, but not Hatsuzuki

lime belfry
#

it her canned coal version

spiral cedar
#

That’s right

lime belfry
#

in AL, the cutest of the class is Hanazuki

#

clearly just way out of the league compared to the rest of her sisters

eternal veldt
#

tfw it took this much ammo to kill her off:

WICHITA: 300
NEW ORLEANS: 360
SANTA FE: 1233
MOBILE: 660

lime belfry
#

now that fairly interesting

#

I dont know the Japanese had their own Oerlikon

#

the budget one anyway

#

looks to be fairly similiar in term of stats to US version

#

which kinda means that despite being in a literal destroyed aircrafts, these things still work

#

impressive

spring briar
lime belfry
#

@eternal veldt I think this is fairly good documents regarding Japanese AA in 1945

#

not sure if u want to see it but it very detailed and not just stats slap on a pic

#

I am still searching if they actually include the Type 98 8cm but even if it doesnt have it, it still a good doc

#

this gun wasnt even in any wiki article

eternal veldt
#

What is mostly missing for the 8cm are closeup photos. specs, I think they are available.

lime belfry
#

probably

spring briar
#

305 mm model 1867

delicate beacon
#

GK-2 cirThink

delicate beacon
spring briar
lime belfry
#

I think I have found it

#

thank god

#

@eternal veldt

#

that all to it

spiral cedar
#

Thinkpitz Haguro took a hit from a 500 lb GP bomb (likely from a Fanshaw Bay TBM) to her No. 2 turret that completely obliterated it and caused a fire in the barbette that forced its powder magazine to be flooded to avoid an explosion. Given the non-armor-piercing nature of the bomb, one might wonder whether the turret would have survived—or, at least, not led to a magazine fire that hurt the ship’s buoyancy and trim—had it had a more typical 2-2.75” of roof armor instead of the 1” she had

eternal veldt
#

That's...weird.

#

Bore is 76.2mm, IIRC.

lime belfry
eternal veldt
#

rounded, as said.

lime belfry
#

and since by the time of this report, dated 1945

#

they have 0 pic, only captured document

#

so that should be the official stats

#

seems to be very consitent with Navwep

#

this report was done by the US Marine

#

same rate of fire and all

#

Ammnuition differs wildly tho

#

the doc I found stated the shell weight like 14.4 lbs

#

that is way heavier from what Navwep stated

#

muzzle velocity is also different

spring briar
#

Practice round perhaps

#

Navweaps doesnt usually include those

lime belfry
#

should we trust the Marine report or the Navy report ?

#

I feel like since it was captured documents

#

it should have more weight

alpine onyx
#

So yes, likely no turret fire

spiral cedar
#

Thinkpitz Yamato took near-miss bombs from B-24s causing significant fragments that killed topside crews, penetrated the forward 15.5cm turret gun shield 14 times(!), and penetrated the aft 15.5cm turret gun shield 3 times.
<insert complaint about thin turret armor here>

lime belfry
#

anyway, I trusted that the 8 cm type 98 mentioned in the screenshot above is the same as the 76.2mm gun in question

spring briar
#

It is

lime belfry
#

probably the US assumed based on document, it was called 8cm and because no gun was captured (yet), they assumed the same

spring briar
#

Barrel length checks out

#

With the 76mm number

#

Its not a very detailed report anyways

lime belfry
#

Yeah cus they havent found one yet

spring briar
#

Maybe bulletpicker has smth on it

lime belfry
#

the 127mm mounted on Yamato was extremely detailed

eternal veldt
#

Because they're the Type 89s, basically the IJN equivalent of the 5"/38

lime belfry
#

gonna post the screenshot of that

#

and compare with navwep to see if everything is the same

#

Intel can vary from branch to branch and year to year

spring briar
lime belfry
#

not much on this one

spring briar
#

Poor 5”/25

lime belfry
#

5''/25 getting the L

#

the US intelligence guy really has a sick sense of humor by having a pic of 2 Japanese guys getting chopped in half by something next to their destroyed type 89 as a reference picture

#

like there probably a hundred of pictures out there as ref but they picked that

spring briar
lime belfry
spring briar
#

They having a giggle

ivory ridge
chilly osprey
#

has two pings
can only find one
NotLikeDuck

spring briar
ivory ridge
frigid karma
#

Some other guy pinged you to show me your discord handle and deleted his message

subtle prawn
#

I never deleted my message

lapis wraith
#

In order to keep their troops morale high in the Pacific, the US military decided to make ice cream ship that litterally give fresh ice cream to soldier in the Pacific, you would eat an dessert in the jungle nice

desert agate
#

Australian servicemen often traded their alcohol (which was banned in the USN) for ice cream

#

the brits figured it out too when they showed up

frigid karma
#

yeah, it was basically a student exchange program

#

brits and americans would swap places on some carriers

desert agate
#

RAAF pilots would fly into American seaplane tenders with booze and leave with american sweets and cigarettes

subtle prawn
manic latch
#

Still my favorite tho TohruHarts

shut wren
#

Funni

maiden citrus
#

that was me trying to make soyuz real for you

subtle prawn
cinder escarp
#

Well, they weren't really classified, just ITAR restricted

frigid karma
#

So we have leclerc, challenger, type99, and now f-16

#

Am I forgetting something

#

Euro copter?

cinder escarp
#

And having seen/saved pretty much all the leaks, the CR2 and DTC-10-125 (ZTZ99 ammo) leaks are the most damning.

frigid karma
#

Yeah

#

I mean why do these players even bother citing these things anyways, has the snail ever made changes based on actual irl evidence the forums present

cinder escarp
#

120C

fossil monolith
#

What’s all your opinion on the F 16 leaks

shut wren
fossil monolith
#

I don’t get why people leak it It’s already the best at toptier f14 and f16 combo I’ll get you an instant win

shut wren
#

They leak everything

fossil monolith
#

Well not everything most of the stuff that people leak are like modern stuff because top-tier is broken It’s not fun to play at all

eternal veldt
#

It doesnt matter if it is classified documents

#

The company explicitly stated that any non-public, classified material will not be reviewed

#

So the fact that the crayon eaters are still leaking it, shows they are immensely dumb

#

And actual security threats to their respective nations

fossil monolith
#

I mean America not to harp on it they have a lot more bigger issues than some missile getting leaked online and a whole fighter jet too

shrewd pecan
#

man the F-14 isn't gonna be unseated from top dog in top tier until everyone has active radar homing missiles to fling

fossil monolith
#

Another thing I can completely see the f16 getting faced out within 25 years

kindred reef
#

what was the name of the second Kronshtadt class going to be?

eternal veldt
#

Sevastopol

shrewd pecan
#

its a handful of manuals

#

its shit likely actual intelligence services already have their hands on

#

🤨 like the AIM-120C has been around since 1996

fossil monolith
#

I mean we’re on the cusp of six generation jets gen fors can only go so far the phantom was just retired three years ago with the kai model

shrewd pecan
#

we're already near the end of the gen 4s operational span

#

F-35s already in full service

#

and the USAF already has a flying sixth gen prototype

fossil monolith
#

The six generation bomber fighters are just around the corner I bet there’s one locked up in a hanger somewhere in america

shrewd pecan
#

the USAF's sixth gen more than anything is gonna be fighter meets AWACs

#

its going to be a fundamental shift in what we call a fighter

shut wren
#

They Always have something more advanced

#

Its a rule of all militaries

#

What you see is never the Best

tight violet
#

cage armour of all kinds only exist because of the rpg-7 warhead's design flaw doesn't it

cinder escarp
#

Not like the uh, CR2 or DTC-10 leaks

thorn trail
#

idk where my friend found this but this is cursed

eternal veldt
#

It also doesnt work.

#

You fire the main guns and those two flight decks are history.

#

Hybrid is a great concept on paper, very shit in practicality and execution.

thorn trail
#

Wait what's the historical basis for the Champy Gun

#

the 406mm mle

eternal veldt
#

Its a gun built by Schneider and exported to the Soviets.

#

That's all the information we have on the guns. No information on whether they'd be used on Alsace No. 2.

#

Champy is just a shitty Gascan turret swap with a pair of 100mms added on anyway. MurmWat

thorn trail
eternal veldt
#

No.

frigid karma
#

No, Soyuz didn’t use those guns

#

They have their own guns

#

This is just a one off thing

eternal veldt
#

The Soviets basically asked for a lot of foreign help.

#

Even the Germans supplied a triple 406 turret drawing to the Soviets.

thorn trail
#

what turret was this

eternal veldt
#

Philbin, Tobias R. "The Naval Dimension of the Hitler-Stalin Pact." The Lure of Neptune: German-Soviet Naval Collaboration and Ambitions, 1919-1941. Columbia, SC: U of South Carolina, 1994. N. pag. Web. 14 July 2016.

shrewd pecan
eternal veldt
thorn trail
eternal veldt
#

Langley and Arizona.

somber knoll
#

ik it's just a Sushi diorama but damn the sculptor did a rather very fine job.

spring briar
#

Nice

kindred reef
#

ok so i just saw this meme and is this real? no way this can be real right?

#

i know the americans did stuff like this on their fighters

#

and even some of their light bombers

crimson flume
#

why wouldnt it be real

kindred reef
#

because when i think of the germans in ww2, i do not think of them painting things like this on their planes

crimson flume
#

just searched up "goofy fw190 nose art" and got this

kindred reef
#

what?

crimson flume
kindred reef
#

oh

desert agate
eternal veldt
#

Greyantifoulinggreyantifoulinggreyan-

desert agate
#

RAN might not have used the grey in the 60s and 70s when she retired

eternal veldt
#

I think Ive seen one of Vampire's underside photos while she's in drydock.

#

Odd. Can't find it anymore, and the other ones point to pale pink. I guess I'm mistaken.

#

yeap, no longer grey.

eternal veldt
#

okay, so at least I'm not insane, but yes, as you said hit. Likely not used post-retirement.

delicate beacon
#

Every time a Japanese force gets mentioned in my book I wonder what warcrime they'll be doing today

#

Arashio kept firing after the Jan van Amstel was sunk and left the remaining survivors to their fate.

#

No depth charges this time, fortunately.

eternal veldt
#

could be worse, executing people in the water.

#

Who dropped depth charges?

delicate beacon
#

Firing at an upside down ship might as well be executing people in the water.

#

Fortunately she seems to have gotten bored

#

Another Japanese Destroyer managed to pick survivors.
Though that may not have been a fortunate fate either.

eternal veldt
#

Also, giga crappy image, but Spanish cruiser Baleares sinking.

eternal veldt
manic latch
#

Tashkent was praised for a storm corridor, crew could move along the ship without being exposed to weather.
Closed bridge was found comfortable at high speeds or in storm, but during the war it prevented proper observation of attacking aircraft.

#

Tashkent is comfy Tashkent_Thankful

rapid junco
#

USS Arizona, São Paulo and USS North Dakota at NY Yard, 1920

maiden citrus
frigid karma
#

purple to UR
museum ship
it's practically a ship from launch (2nd event i think)
not overly exceptional service career
no one really expects

ivory ridge
#

Hit is gonna kill you

frigid karma
#

nothing new

#

and since commonwealth factions are likely never getting in, this is probably the best he's gonna get VickyXD

tough quail
#

oh no

maiden citrus
#

Don’t steal the man’s hope

tough quail
#

there has to be one of us left with hopes and dreams

frigid karma
#

Tea has hopes and dreams, he has his annual furry convention in september to look forward to

tough quail
#

well no that fits perfectly in line

#

essex yorktown gets turned into a regular yorktown, vampire gets turned from australian to british

frigid karma
#

Also quacken you know damn well they don’t give a shit about launch date if they feel like it

#

silkworms

#

Counterpoint

#

The welsh bitch

#

Yeah yeah, i know

#

They also thought the annexation of Czechoslovakia is its own thing

#

And the Rhineland

#

Just you wait

delicate beacon
#

Rather interesting that Bosscher has to specify a case the Zeroes did not shoot at survivors.

junior trench
#

"see, it didn't happen... this time."

delicate beacon
#

To be honest, it might have happened because they ran out of fuel and munitions.

lime belfry
#

Chicago II, from CL to CA

#

she blonde, has big assets in default art

#

her 2.0 version gonna be no doubt hot

junior trench
#

?

#

Chicago CA-29 was a Northampton class heavy cruiser

lime belfry
#

oops

#

mistype

#

but whatever

#

only the US has II ships anyway

#

since they are the only faction that lost ship then immediately replace it with a better one of the same name 1 year later

#

meanwhile, other factions just cope and seethe or never run out of idea to name a ship

#

well except for Hammand, she got degraded from a DD to a escort DD, which is worse I guess

tough quail
#

except they tried making one of her sisters a II

#

and the art degraded like crazy

#

if Chicago gets the same treatment she'll be very mid

desert agate
#

vampy had a fine career, wouldnt be british and isnt even a candidate to be added to AL let alone UR

lime belfry
desert agate
#

northampton 2 looks like a crappy ai generation

#

which is unfortunate because im a sucker for cocco girls

frigid karma
#

Honestly she looks fine beside the skin tone

tough quail
#

she looks so much like one I honestly think she might be

frigid karma
#

It’s a tad too light

#

And that looks weird

#

Would also appreciate us seeing her other eye

tough quail
#

artist is either touching up AI shit and/or has atrociously mediocre shading skills and does not understand color theory at all

#

it's awful

desert agate
#

the design is just overly... smooth i guess

#

theres no detail

#

its just jarringly out of place

frigid karma
#

Who’s her artist anyways

tough quail
#

skynet

frigid karma
#

Posting this here for convenience, and are quite detailed but the rest is kind of overly smooth yeah

#

Especially the face

lime belfry
#

it still looks relatively well designed imo

#

maybe we are just too used to seeing flashy, shaded art from other AL ships

#

Northampton II looks a bit bland by comparision

#

but still, her art is wayyyy better than her original

frigid karma
#

Horse prefers the og

lime belfry
#

alot of early AL ships art dont stand to "modern" standard now

frigid karma
#

But yeah I agree, the og version looks dated

lime belfry
#

Houston also looks super dated and they better buff some "Stats" for her Clevebro version

#

preferably Biloxi kind of Clevebro

#

because out of all the sisters Biloxi looks the most mature and least boy ish

ivory ridge
#

counterpoint

#

stop releasing IIs

lime belfry
#

why not ?

ivory ridge
#

plus0

#

because it's a garbage implementation

#

plus

#

inter hull class IIs

#

are extremely unlikely

lime belfry
#

but why it garbage

#

u need to specify

ivory ridge
#

you realize skins still have rigging?

lime belfry
#

what do we lose if we have II ?

ivory ridge
#

it reduces the history of the second ship to an afterthought

#

it's just hurr durr im the same ship but stronger

ivory ridge
lime belfry
#

but then the new ships have skills that arent from the original

ivory ridge
#

so could new fucking ships

lime belfry
#

Hornet II doesnt have Doodlittle raid

#

something Hornet I has

ivory ridge
#

how is that relevant

lime belfry
#

which means Hornet II is still unique, she doesnt inherit everything from I

ivory ridge
#

She is the SAME FUCKING CHARACTER

#

that's the problem

lime belfry
#

it doesnt just "Oh let just copy paste art, skills but make it better"

#

and turn it into glorified retro

ivory ridge
#

it's still

#

worse

#

than making a new fucking character

lime belfry
#

so let's say there are 2 seperate Yorktown that look different

#

we have to assume the first Yorktown died

ivory ridge
#

We dont have to do shit

#

that's not how the game works

lime belfry
#

how do u want the game to work plot wise ?

#

we have like 10+ timelines where some died, some lived

#

what do u want ?

spiral cedar
#

Can't wait until Amagi II makes everyone very confused AmagiHeh

ivory ridge
frigid karma
#

Um

ivory ridge
#

lore has nothing to do with what i want

lime belfry
#

so that a you problem then

frigid karma
#

Shitcan basically asked aoste if amagi 2 was possible

lime belfry
#

I am perfectly fine with Yorktown II

frigid karma
#

Aoste told him this shit can’t revive dead people

lime belfry
#

She shares same skins with I

frigid karma
#

I like yt

#

So I like her as a ur

#

I get the complaints tho

lime belfry
#

honestly it a good way to remaster old ship art imo

ivory ridge
#

also again

lime belfry
#

or made them relevant in plot

ivory ridge
#

everyone coping about Houston or Helena

#

they wont do

#

inter-hull

#

IIs

lime belfry
#

why cant I have Houston II or Chicago II, I like the design

ivory ridge
#

because the 2 ships

#

are different

#

hull classes

desert agate
#

HuTao_Yawn if you want to remaster old art and make them relevant again then just do it dont take away from ships that deserve better

lime belfry
#

unironically people just want to farb to something new

#

that the biggest problem with II system right ?

#

to say it bluntly

ivory ridge
#

no

#

what the fuck does that even mean

lime belfry
#

u just want new characters

#

new art

#

that about it

humble mulch
desert agate
#

mate if i played this game just to wank to it i wouldnt play the game

humble mulch
#

Go fight in general

#

Not here please

lime belfry
#

ship history ? bruh like imagine AL cares about ship history except for a couple dialogue and skill set ref

desert agate
#

sorry tea

frigid karma
ivory ridge
#

they are both DD ingame

frigid karma
#

This is gonna age as well as your no 1937 rule mate

ivory ridge
#

And you're not gonna age if you dont stop being a cunt

lime belfry
#

u really making age as an argument now ?

#

u know what ? fine

frigid karma
#

What no I didn’t

lime belfry
#

let talk about hull class design

frigid karma
#

I was just pointing out a lot of undie’s rules

#

Aren’t

lime belfry
#

how do u gonna design Escort DD

#

so they are viable in game ?

ivory ridge
lime belfry
#

and not just weaker DD ?

frigid karma
#

I mean we have DEs in game

lime belfry
#

tell me ?

frigid karma
#

They’re just listed as DDs

humble mulch
ivory ridge
#

we have 2 DEs ingame

humble mulch
#

All of you cease now please

#

Go argue over shit elsewhere

#

This literally isn’t the channel or place for this type of bullshit

lime belfry
#

ok I am just gonna go back to history

#

and post AA stuff now

#

dm me for continue argument

#

before both got banned

tough quail
#

raa raa raa raa

spring briar
#

people when they say "I don't care about history and don't play AL for the history" but then their game deletes itself because AL without history is nonexistent

tough quail
#

i want my big titty shipgirls to also tickle my nationalism boner

#

it makes the horny stronger

lime belfry
#

I feel like there is a threshold between "We make ref to history" vs "Yeah let do 80% historical accurate"

frigid karma
#

But what about the little titty ships

lime belfry
#

obviously I like AL because they care about minor factors like gears

#

when stuff irl are OP and also OP in game

#

but then they also made stuff that irl kinda failed miserably and made it OP in game

frigid karma
#

At this point I just play AL for the memery

#

The actual sailboat is a CIWS?

#

Fuck it sure

lime belfry
#

and then this whole weird circle of "Why is the same ship is either Elite or SSR or UR"

frigid karma
#

We have a random ass missile dd fighting with ww2 ships? Why not

lime belfry
#

Like why is Royal Fortune has as many FP as a WW2 CL

frigid karma
#

Clearly

#

Doesn’t follow its own rules often

lime belfry
#

Cleveland class the most consistent class in the game

#

every ship wears same ish uniform

tough quail
#

it is always time for silkworms

spring briar
lime belfry
#

everyone has this sporty, tom gal

spring briar
lime belfry
#

and all of them are chill

frigid karma
#

Well until the subclass came along

#

But even they look quite similar

#

Cleve supremacy

lime belfry
#

yeah they look very similiar

#

no ship class has that consistency

#

essex used to, until Hornet and Yorktown

frigid karma
#

I mean Perseus does lmao

#

Her sister looks practically identical

#

But it’s a sample size of n equals 2

desert agate
#

KGVs are all reasonably similar

lime belfry
humble mulch
#

It doesn’t

lime belfry
#

I think Takao is too consistent of a class

#

but then it was made by the same artist

#

so it an unfair comparision

spiral cedar
frigid karma
#

Jaba with the actual history

humble mulch
#

But again this is #history, please talk about actual history instead of like bitching about game design or art that has zero connection to anything historical

lime belfry
#

I think some people claimed Hipper is flat as a ref to her actual design being very different from the rest ?

#

can anyone fact check that

#

not a Hipper class enthusiast

alpine onyx
#

Hipper maintained a rather flat bow compared to the rest of the class

#

Blücher and Eugen got both the Atlantic bow, much more curved

lime belfry
#

ahhh so it is true then

alpine onyx
#

Forst is Hipper, second is Eugen

#

Maybe a better angle on Hipper

frigid karma
#

Boob size in this game is mostly arbitrary though

lime belfry
#

either a coincidence of art choice or very well thought

frigid karma
#

While an interesting tidbit, likely a one off thing

lime belfry
#

cool to know the fact anyway

tough quail
#

it lines up at least

lime belfry
#

also, there is this thing that a Spanish dataminer found like weeks ago

#

this mysterious plane icon

#

it has not yet appeared in game

tough quail
#

thats a proper sprite

lime belfry
#

so the plane is not released

tough quail
#

probably for the raid

desert agate
#

RAAF PBY-5Am of number 43 squadron RAAF
The PBY-5Am was an Australian modification of the venerable PBY-5A
The modification was ordered in response to a joint allied desire to launch long-ranged aerial mining operations in the occupied Dutch East Indes, leading to the requisition of a number of PBY-5As having their weight drastically reduced in order to provide them their range
The modifications included the removal of all armour plating and the removal of the landing gear, effectively re-converting the aircraft back to PBY-3s, which also did not feature landing gear
The conversion process took approximately 2 months requiring the effective disassembly of the entire airframes to remove anything that could impede the massive range requirements of the aircraft
The removal of the armour plating was a contentious issue, as the operations were intended to be joint-Allied, but American pilots refused to fly into combat with the armour removed leading to the US acting primarily in a supplementary role, providing targets, intelligence and FOBs (in the form of flying boat tenders) for the squadrons

The RAAF planes were then painted completely black, giving them the nickname of Black Cats (the US also operated black cats squadrons but did not participate in aerial mining)

Throughout 1943-45 the RAAFs Black Cats would raid ports as far North as China, but primarily in the occupied East Indes where they would launch night time raids on almost every single port in the South Pacific AO, tying up considerable Japanese resources as they needed to dedicate multiple minesweepers to each of their ports in order to export the vital raw materials from the Indes to fuel the Japanese war, however close coordination with USN assets meant that the raids would often create traffic jams of ships waiting for the ports to be swept of mines allowing USN submarines operating primarily from Fremantle, to attack the waiting merchants, significantly hampering the Japanese ability to export raw resources from the region

While the raids themselves did not directly sink a significant number of warships, the tying up of minesweeping resources and the USN submarines waiting outside recently mined ports would decimate the Japanese merchant fleet

lime belfry
#

it probably a Guardian ASW aircraft

alpine onyx
#

Could probably find half a dozen "reasons" for Hipper being flat compared to the rest

#

Since there were a number of differences between the three completed ships

lime belfry
alpine onyx
#

And even more if Seydlitz and Lützow get involved

lime belfry
#

has a very unique feature on the bottom

spiral cedar
#

Hipper got breast reduction surgery so she could actually be useful in a fight

lime belfry
#

so I think it must be the icon of a Guardian, which isnt in game

#

but could be anything really

frigid karma
#

I feel it’s interesting ad1 skyraider got the ur slot

alpine onyx
#

Hipper is tsun because she had the highest rated boiler pressure

lime belfry
#

since 2D "chibi" plane art is hit or miss

alpine onyx
tough quail
#

deutschland took hippers tits

ivory ridge
#

that's the first time i heard of that datamined plane and it feels sussy af

tough quail
#

that why she couldnt aim

frigid karma
#

When a lot of other usn planes of the same time period are SSR

tough quail
#

skyraiders outoerform everything the USN has ingame at its job

lime belfry
#

there are some planes that have sprite but arent actually in game as a variant

frigid karma
#

Seems like ad1 should’ve also been SSR

#

Tbh

tough quail
#

you are way underestimating how ridiculous skyraiders were

frigid karma
#

Like doesn’t skypirate hold 4 torps

spring briar
lime belfry
#

for example, do you know that Indomitable has a Sea Hornet rocket variant ?

#

I actually foudn that out accidentally

ivory ridge
#

i mean she has a skill

lime belfry
#

yep

#

and that Sea Hornet firing rockets

desert agate
lime belfry
#

I believe it possible they might release a variant of sea hornet with rocket later

#

because the Hellcat with rockets are already in the game long time ago

frigid karma
#

That feeling when manjuu made rockets better than bombers

lime belfry
#

it belongs to a barrage of Tincoderoga

#

u can check it yourself

frigid karma
#

Rocket dps in this game is so good that my yt2 runs two hvars .

lime belfry
#

so it "released" with tincoderoga but not farmable until recently

spiral cedar
frigid karma
#

Despite usn being the dive bomber faction

lime belfry
#

I think Volga also has an unique plane sprite

#

not yet released

#

need to screenshot it again

chilly osprey
#

Tin Cod Eroga sounds like a threat

lime belfry
#

but there are hidden unreleased aircrafts in barrage

#

like Illustrious with aug has a Spitfire rocket barrage

tough quail
desert agate
#

TBF with radar bulge

tough quail
#

but a skyraider can too irl iirc

lime belfry
#

disappointed Skyraider doesnt drop Napalm in the game

tough quail
#

its just a skypirate is a dedicated TB which nobody wanted post war

lime belfry
#

literally what made it famous

tough quail
#

skypirates are more flexible

frigid karma
#

Sky raiders?

#

You mean?

tough quail
#

err

#

skyraiders yes

#

this is getting confusing lmao

frigid karma
#

Yeah, i realize pirate was a meme full on torp bomber

#

But, in the context of AL

#

Where it’s still very much ww2 shit

lime belfry
#

I need to screenshot Volga barrage again

#

unique aircraft in it

frigid karma
#

You’d think pirate deserves the ur slot more than raider

#

I’m cutting out the sky part for convenience

spring briar
frigid karma
#

Isn’t Volga barrage just some crystals?

lime belfry
#

no the first aerial barrage

frigid karma
#

I dont think there’s planes

tough quail
#

raiders are pretty much the same thing but better, and put into full production as opposed to 2 prototypes, so makes sense to me

frigid karma
#

Ah, idk that one

tough quail
#

plus lets be real

#

pirates were put in as el cheapo wyverns

lime belfry
#

Meteoric hope or something

frigid karma
#

Basically yep

lime belfry
#

give me a sec I will screenshot it

tough quail
#

so it just took a backseat to full production aircraft

frigid karma
#

Fair enough

tough quail
#

it would still be UR worthy tho if not released at the same time as either of those though

#

i agree with that

lime belfry
#

the real question is why isnt there more "Ace" variant

tough quail
#

good plane i enjoy

lime belfry
#

like we have some Ace variant back then but now ? nah

tough quail
#

however

#

what we REALLY need

#

is this bullshit

lime belfry
#

why my Stuka "Ace" Rudel variant that just do extra dmg toward BB or something

tough quail
#

germoney can have ace planes when they made anything actually launchable from a carrier

lime belfry
#

HMS faction secretly waiting for Meteor to be in the game

frigid karma
#

I feel like

#

If we got the flapjack

frigid karma
#

We can get basically anything that flies off a Cv

spring briar
#

Does anyone remember this gun

frigid karma
chilly osprey
#

Is that the one where the Americans hot-glued four 20mm Oerlikons together?

spring briar
#

Quad 20mm oerlikon mk.15

#

yes

#

they just threw four oerlikons into a bucket

#

and cut a slit in it

lime belfry
#

why is Sextupple Bofor the rainbow AA tho ?

chilly osprey
#

Evidentially none of them had ever seen the German quadruple mounts yet

lime belfry
#

like u can argue it still the best AA in the game rn

spring briar
lime belfry
#

insnt sorry

#

mistype

frigid karma
#

Only ur AA is postwar French 57

spring briar
#

because it isn't post WW2 ig

#

the 57 is slightly post war

lime belfry
#

slapping 6 Bofor barrel is truly genius

tough quail
#

its also a handout to keep france from nuking shanghai

spring briar
#

horse we were actually trying to peacefully leave

frigid karma
spring briar
#

until hai phong

#

haiyaaaaa

tough quail
frigid karma
#

Everyone crapping on all the new aa related ships and gear don’t realize that uh

#

W13 hard

#

Is coming

lime belfry
#

heavy fighters in AL are all OP

spring briar
#

These two should be UR AA
but only one is
sadness

chilly osprey
#

76/62 for Italy when?

tough quail
#

everyone crapping on all the new AA without realizing that 57s

#

are based

spring briar
#

if you look at the 57

#

you can see the influence of the 37 acad

frigid karma
chilly osprey
#

Oh fuck

lime belfry
#

in a game where we have all the AA and fighters know to man

chilly osprey
#

That's in this too?

#

Wargaming what the fuck

spring briar
#

no

#

haiya stop giving phoenix heart attacks

#

because

#

US accidentally sank lamotte piquet

frigid karma
#

Accidentally

spring briar
frigid karma
#

They still believe that?

#

Damn we underpay the cia

spring briar
#

don't you mean overpay?

frigid karma
#

Underpay implies they are exceeding their job expectations

spring briar
frigid karma
#

Overpay implies they’re not

#

And anyways I don’t think the cia existed

#

Back then

spring briar
#

idc really

frigid karma
#

Which was why we allocated part of the budget to time machines

spring briar
#

cia is cringe

lime belfry
#

ok

spring briar
#

Anyways here you can see the design influence

lime belfry
#

that the unique unreleased plane volga has in her barrage

#

a silver soviet plane with red star on the wing

tough quail
#

carrier launched yer-2s when

lime belfry
#

that definitely isnt a VIT-2 or SU-2

tough quail
#

likely an su-2

lime belfry
spring briar
#

oh

#

this

lime belfry
#

SU-2 sprite

spring briar
#

that's an SU-2

lime belfry
#

kinda cute actually

spring briar
#

SU-2R actually

#

SU-2 has a smaller protuding turret in the back

lime belfry
#

VIT-2

#

so the plane sprite is new and unreleased

#

as a gear

#

but introduced as a barrage

tough quail
#

hmm

frigid karma
#

You know

#

Bombers should have reverse aa

#

They do dps to enemy planes, but only after they pass them

tough quail
#

that would be rad

spring briar
tough quail
#

i can kinda see it

lime belfry
#

but yeah, like I said, devs will add easter egg planes into game as barrage

ivory ridge
lime belfry
#

and released it later

ivory ridge
#

but for now we dont have any supership

lime belfry
#

it happened to Tincoderoga

ivory ridge
#

and hopefully we never will

#

so we should be safe

lime belfry
#

so far, I find 1 new plane never seen before

#

and 2 planes with rockets

spring briar
#

I'll take a closer look at Joffre's barrage then

lime belfry
#

nah Joffre doesnt have anything new

#

she just launch purple french planes

spring briar
#

bruh

#

no love

ivory ridge
#

Inb4 soviet gear lab before an italian one

spring briar
#

hopefully not

lime belfry
#

I also checked the italian

#

no new plane

tough quail
#

they just get shoved into the same tab

#

basically the same thing

spring briar
#

france an italy getting shafted is normal

lime belfry
#

so we "may" see a new soviet TB, and 2 new variants of sea hornet and spitfire

#

which is nice, british rockets should be unique compared to HVAR and german one

spring briar
#

RP-3's

#

kekw

#

anti sub rockets

tough quail
#

give me ptabs even though they make literally no sense in naval warfare and would set phones on fire

spring briar
#

quack that's what I mean

ivory ridge
#

if we cope a lot about Naval planes we could get the naval G.55 or Re.2005

spring briar
#

RP-3's had like 5 different ones

#

AP

#

SAP

#

anti sub

#

uhhhh

#

carrot

ivory ridge
#

like if they keep adding shit that wasnt navalized anyway

lime belfry
#

maybe it a LA-5 ???

spring briar
#

found it

lime belfry
#

I mean it is in WOWS so who knows

spring briar
#

exactly 5

#

nice

#

memory still work

#

wait

#

nvm

#

they didn't include AP

lime belfry
#

Or this

#

dunno, probably have to wait until they announce it

spring briar
lime belfry
#

perhaps next russian event

tough quail
#

i really want a stupid naval sturmovik

#

i want it i want it

spring briar
#

I really want
uh
like anything french or italian really
ngl

tough quail
#

if we can have fucking naval stukas breaking physics i can put el flying tonk on a boat

spring briar
#

Quacken please explain

tough quail
#

whats that weird heavy fighter france was fiddling with pre-war with like eight 20-30mm guns

#

put that in too

lime belfry
#

wait

desert agate
#

bukiPride beaufighters

lime belfry
#

huh I think Aquilla has an unique italian plane

#

gotta zoom in

spring briar
#

this image is not real

ivory ridge
#

I wonder what's coming first between french and italian CV lines

#

probably french but they had a line more recently

#

then again they were right after the DDs

tough quail
#

either way my wallet flies out the window

lime belfry
#

yep

spring briar
#

who's getting a carrier first
Sparviero for Italy or Painlevé for France

lime belfry
#

Aquilla has some sort of hidden unreleased aircraft

spring briar
#

ah ok nvm

#

let me just µ

lime belfry
#

Re.2001 has no insignia on the wing

spring briar
ivory ridge
#

dude

#

it's the other plane ingame

lime belfry
#

and so is the G50

#

No insignia visible

#

but Aquilla has one

ivory ridge
#

weird

spring briar
#

is it just me or did I see cleve typing here for a microsec

lime belfry
ivory ridge
#

the equippable g.50 has it in the art

lime belfry
#

hmm

#

interesting

frigid karma
#

So I was playing bf1 the other day and I just realized

#

I think the battleship behemoth is shooting 343mm

#

Air burst

#

Rounds

lime belfry
spring briar
lime belfry
#

so there one with insignia and one without to tell the difference ?

ivory ridge
frigid karma
#

Like the explosion is very much above ground level

spring briar
#

I bought Béarn once it was established that she was a meme

frigid karma
#

And he’s the best Cv player

spring briar
#

and could be played as fighter bogue

frigid karma
#

on sea

ivory ridge
#

i dont play carriers anyway

frigid karma
#

Bearn isn’t really 201 bogue since she does a shit ton of damage too

spring briar
frigid karma
#

You can build for fighters but you’d have more game impact with standard farming builds

ivory ridge
#

cuz the only italian planes ingame and equippable are both fighters

#

while Aquila has a torp barrage as well

#

so it's likely that

lime belfry
#

if u use non preload, she will spawn the G50 with insignia

#

maybe they just happens to have 2 art of the same plane and cant decide which one

#

or forget to optimize or something