#PuddleStompers Guide to the Tri-M System

1334 messages · Page 2 of 2 (latest)

lament dawn
#

nelson flight type is what it shoulda been from the start

#

nelson flight type is genuine nelson erasure and I am completely for it

crisp moss
#

what is nelson flight type

#

what are you talking about

lament dawn
#

field guide to suldan?

zenith star
#

I know people often jest about having bad luck. But I am forever haunted by my beautiful boss encounter that went up in flames by rolling 7 ones on structure dice in a row.

lament dawn
zenith star
#

I gave up trying to not powercreep the Nelson with the Aldrin because I genuinely couldn't make a mech I considered "good" and not powercreep the nelson

lament dawn
#

EXACTLY LOL

#

I made a nelson alt that I quite like

#

avoiding nelson erasure (mostly)

zenith star
#

The aldrin is literally from a failed project of mine called B-Sides lancer that attempted to rebalance everything just to shake things up for a campaign of mine and the Aldrin is basically just the B-Nelson.

lament dawn
#

you showed that one lol

zenith star
#

You remember it?

lament dawn
#

parts

zenith star
#

Or did I post in here

lament dawn
#

you posted in here

zenith star
#

My B-Displacer was beautiful...

lament dawn
#

that was the one you showed lol

zenith star
#

On Attack: Take a Stress
On: Lose a Structure

#

So clean.

crisp moss
zenith star
#

Elegant.

#

Absolutely fucking busted.

lament dawn
#

oh my god

#

fraud

crisp moss
#

90% of my players dont use mine either

#

I LIKE BALANCE

#

TOO MUCH

lament dawn
#

THIRD PARTY CAN BE BALANCED

#

VERY MUCH SO

#

field guide to suldan fuckin isnt

crisp moss
#

i mean

zenith star
crisp moss
#

it can try

#

it can even succeed

#

but it probably wont

zenith star
#

There is a wide spectrum.

lament dawn
zenith star
#

Granted, I don't use homebrew much either.

#

Mostly because its been impossible to find time to play.

crisp moss
#

none of my regular group are super into lancer so they dont

#

care

lament dawn
crisp moss
#

IMI?

lament dawn
#

ilean modern industrial

#

oh wow you people dont play the game

crisp moss
#

never heard of that one

zenith star
#

And when I was playing I wanted to play all the frames that still caught my eye and I wasn't super interested in a lot of homebrew bandied about often, I found a lot of it overstatted or just. Far too wordy for no reason and worse, didn't play nice with C/C.

crisp moss
lament dawn
#

tragedy

#

Im so sorry

zenith star
crisp moss
#

i dm, i dont care about using peoples third party

lament dawn
#

lol

crisp moss
#

im playing in ONE game

zenith star
#

Oh Vulc escaped his family

lament dawn
crisp moss
#

wallflower gm vanished off the face of the earth

burnt egret
crisp moss
#

after saying game was tomorrow

lament dawn
#

something about X men probably

zenith star
#

MVC 2 meta

crisp moss
#

to be fair, base game lancer

#

with NO suppliments is

crisp moss
#

moderatly balanced

lament dawn
crisp moss
#

the suppliments (even first party)

lament dawn
#

NPC's in particular

crisp moss
#

actually especially first party

#

the mechs were stronger when they were weaker

#

when 3d6 was a lot of damage

#

when 3 armor was frame defining

lament dawn
crisp moss
#

YES IT IS

lament dawn
#

core book, that mourning cloak is doing 6d6 @ LL6

#

lock in

#

we explode people in this bitch

crisp moss
#

im gonna come ot your house and deal you 3d6 damage with a warpike and you can tell me about that

zenith star
# lament dawn SAYS YOU

I stand by Tri-M being far more balanced than you give it credit, my tenants for it was nothing better than the best stuff in base, it doesn't require any fuckery with C/C, and if an effect was to be long, I would make a grand attempt to put it into as few and as clear words as possible.

lament dawn
crisp moss
#

if you dont look at seimei

zenith star
#

Please.

#

Try the Koschei.

crisp moss
lament dawn
crisp moss
#

that you rn

lament dawn
crisp moss
#

witch? more like bitch? i dont roll averages

#

i max roll

#

EVERY

#

SINGLE

#

TURN

burnt egret
zenith star
crisp moss
#

yeah acutally

zenith star
# zenith star

this is the wordiest thing in the whole pack. It is a lich alt

lament dawn
#

Im just saying he fuckin has em

lament dawn
zenith star
#

Its a lot, but it is trying to account for a LOT of edge cases because it is so close to fully breaking the game with a missed interaction.

crisp moss
lament dawn
burnt egret
zenith star
lament dawn
zenith star
#

I forgot

burnt egret
#

As opposed to over or around?

zenith star
crisp moss
# zenith star thanks it's trying.

its not busted i dont think , its just awful and i hate it and its gonna haunt my dreams, days and nightmares until the day i shuffle off this mortal coil

zenith star
#

That would be a ground up endeavor, adding keywords now would onyl make things worse.

crisp moss
#

overall, 7/10, give it more armor

zenith star
burnt egret
lament dawn
#

you people are incomprehensible why are we making these extremely high effort homebrews when we dont even use homebrews lol

crisp moss
#

it doesnt

crisp moss
#

duh

#

and for validation from strangers on the internet

#

also duh

burnt egret
#

Yes it does! It’s been seared into your brain! That means it worked!

lament dawn
#

hey is this idea possible to justfiy

zenith star
ionic sundial
#

I have played 3 oneshots of lancer

lament dawn
crisp moss
#

bad idea

lament dawn
crisp moss
#

hollow earth

zenith star
crisp moss
lament dawn
#

and bam

#

problem solved

crisp moss
#

im gonna kill myself and then you

lament dawn
#

unless you want to fall to the center of the earth in which case go for it and die

lament dawn
crisp moss
#

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

#

FUCK YOU GOT ME

#

FUCK

#

MY WEAKNESS
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

zenith star
# lament dawn Im just saying he fuckin has em

I do have them, but they are a minority of the guide and I have made what I think is a good attempt dealing with edge cases but still condensing rules text down whilst making sure to keep clarity because I won't be there for a random user to DM me at 3 in the morning asking if the Stumpp or the Hund is the top.

crisp moss
#

(i melt into lancer goo)

crisp moss
#

i love seeing peoples mechs that are a fucking novel and then my frame is like, 4 sentences

#

and i get people telling me its busted

lament dawn
#

your mourning cloak alt is busted btw

#

immobilize?

#

insane

crisp moss
crisp moss
crisp moss
lament dawn
#

k

crisp moss
#

that k just fucking killed me

#

im sobbing and/or crying

lament dawn
#

usually does

#

many such cases

crisp moss
#

that was brutal

#

fucking devestating

lament dawn
#

minor spelling error

zenith star
#

Send the link to your lcp Bela, I need to start ingratiating into other spaces for good will and friendship.

crisp moss
crisp moss
#

i cant spell,

#

many such cases

ionic sundial
# crisp moss and i get people telling me its busted

I once saw a meme that was a dude looking at a TCG card for Verilord the Throngler, With 1000 Words of Effect Text, and going "heh, mid tier at best" and then the same guy looking at Some Random Squirrel and shitting his pants in terror.

#

It do be like that

lament dawn
# crisp moss

genuinely trying to find a mech that isnt wordy from my LCP and, uh this is kinda the best I got

lament dawn
#

it's not bad

lament dawn
#

but it's not as small as urs

crisp moss
#

I HAVE WORDY SYSTEMS

lament dawn
#

ur words are tiny dude

#

dude my words are HUGE

crisp moss
#

NOOOOOOOOO

zenith star
#

I got non-wordy mechs, I actually have a lot of them dangit.

crisp moss
#

fitz has a lot of flavor text if that counts

zenith star
#

SWMG Steve, whose average mech is composed of thunder words from Finnigans Wake is an outlier and shouldn't be counted

crisp moss
#

thunder words...

zenith star
#

Hey. The Seimei isnt wordy...

ionic sundial
#

My longest system/power/trait is probably the core passive for one of my HORUS mechs

lament dawn
#

waas this the yeti?

zenith star
#

I gotta go find my wordiest system.

ionic sundial
#

it was the ithaqua so somewhere in the ballpark

crisp moss
#

i literally think that mask of many faces is the longest text i have that isnt compendium

#

maybe Zwarte Hoop

zenith star
#

Fools.Court is notably wordy for an invade but I know I have a longer one

crisp moss
#

do traits count?

ionic sundial
#

Usually when I have something get too long I make part of its function a new equipment tag

zenith star
#

Its probably the Hermes is the wordiest system.

lament dawn
zenith star
#

I am actually proud I thought I would have way more wordy stuff but again, Ive made a big effort to condense rules to simple and clean versions.

lament dawn
#

this system is kinda bad ngl but I think it is my least wordy

crisp moss
#

shortest for me i think

#

two sentence mod, all it does

#

unless you count this

#

which is zero sentences

zenith star
#

Boom. Least wordy one.

lament dawn
#

ok that is like

#

doesnt count cuz it's insanely weak lol

#

NUH UH DOESNT COUNT

zenith star
#

I think it's fine.

#

I include reliable damage as also the "cannot roll under this"

#

Cause that is a part of the keyword.

lament dawn
#

but that doesnt mean the weapon always does AP reliable damage

#

because it says roll

#

not deal

#

you can roll a 500 but if I have armor 500, it's 0

zenith star
#

You are going to make me make it wordy you meanie.

lament dawn
#

so you're rolling a 1d6 with reliable 4, you roll a 5, you just do 5 non-ap damage

crisp moss
lament dawn
#

also a portion of an attack's damage being AP is gross

lament dawn
lament dawn
#

but it's a bit weird

zenith star
lament dawn
#

that would be rather strong

zenith star
#

But it loses its verbal punch.

lament dawn
#

I think that is a good mod then

zenith star
#

This is just a system.

lament dawn
#

strange

#

but ok

zenith star
#

Its just "you carry a lot more additional ammo so you can spray and pray harder and therefore get more lucky hits"

zenith star
lament dawn
#

I can in fact call ur stuff strange

#

because it does not imply that mine is not

#

lol

zenith star
#

I honestly believe a ton of my stuff is above board. Even SW//MGs

lament dawn
#

also you havent even read my LCP

#

you read a trait on the zeilinger pal

#

okay I've read ALL of your release LCP

#

ALL OF IT

#

same with sixth voice

crisp moss
#

ive read yours

#

hornet gun and all

lament dawn
#

ah I'm flattered

#

sorry for ur loss

crisp moss
#

still peak

lament dawn
#

only mech I genuinely had an idea for how to draw it but I gave up cuz my buddy told me to do that and it was better than anything I would draw

zenith star
#

Like I have it downloaded.

lament dawn
#

(also genuine reccomendation this chart is insanely useful, I made sure that my base stat averages were within these ranges)

zenith star
#

I was just joking about the zeilanger because I knew you had the meme ready

lament dawn
#

lol ok fair enough

zenith star
lament dawn
lament dawn
zenith star
#

Now its still balanced around its limitations and brain melt, but it certainly is strong.

lament dawn
#

they were quite statted lol

zenith star
#

I have nerfed them in the meantime if you havent looked at it in a bit

lament dawn
#

I check up every so often, I saw

zenith star
#

Particularly the Hund is down to 2 speed to really make it the "heavy" option

#

Plus there is the issue of transforming in melee into the far squishier stumpp so you gotta risk it a bit when going for the gashes

lament dawn
#

yeah I do think that mech is rather well balanced for the nature of how strong the concept is

#

lots of the stuff in the LCP has been made much more reasonable

#

though the solomon and seimei remains upsetting

zenith star
#

So it will be forced to take more heat on average unless you have a good gamer chair.

zenith star
#

its a strong argument

lament dawn
#

I just think it's deranged

#

but math works out

zenith star
#

Oh yes.

#

it is a pure question of "does it deal more than average strikers? Its broken. If not. Its fine."

#

But it is purpose built to slightly disgust anybody with normal sensibilities

lament dawn
#

I mean yeah theoretical max is in the stratosphere

#

but averages are reasonable

zenith star
#

I hope someday I get an angry @ about how busted it is like a year or two from now and I will know in my heart that is a poor GM whos player rolled godly that day.

#

While sad that to balance that there will be a player who never recharges their TCB

#

for a whole campaign.

plucky prism
#

I have an @.

#

I have arrived.

#

I could not be left to kitbashing in peace.

zenith star
#

The only reason I removed the clause about starting uncharged is that I had one or two tests that had all 10 weapons start uncharged and it was a horrid feeling I wished on no one.

crisp moss
plucky prism
#

Ahhh. This one was fun to give feedback on.

#

What exactly was solomon 1.0 again?

zenith star
#

It simply barraged when it skirmished and had 6 heavy mounts.

#

This was 3 years ago.

#

I was young, foolish, and unable to drink alcohol.

#

I mean I still cant but thats for the taste issue.

#

The 6 mounts, SP weapons, Recharge, and Stupid stats were always there they just had to keep being jostled until settling into a "balance"

plucky prism
#

The richard has still come the longest way I think.

#

Though that may just be ptsd.

zenith star
#

Yeah. It's actually fun now.

#

The Nobel used to be an Improvised attackTM frame

plucky prism
#

Another 5 attacks into archer ship.

zenith star
#

Another 9 invades to the white witch

steep terrace
zenith star
#

Come into my thread.

#

Make this your first post.

steep terrace
#

What can I say, I like to make a big first impression

#

But so far loving your work by the way

#

Please don't shoot me

zenith star
#

Can't, hands are too brittle typing a novellas worth of feedback in another thread.

steep terrace
#

Yknow what, fair

#

In case you ever feel the need. (I want to pilot a nightengale so i should be able to fix it up)

#

That and maybe a Baba

#

(which is a fuckin treat )

zenith star
#

Its nice to hear somebody mention some of the non-problem children talking in here.

lament dawn
#

oh sixth voice

#

lmao holy shit

zenith star
#

I have a tendency to either be bluntly curt or agonizingly salubrious. No in between.

lament dawn
#

I aint reading allat

burnt egret
#

I am

zenith star
#

Okay I am finished now Vulc do that for me.

zenith star
#

Going to be expediting the guides 0.8 version before the mass March Exodus so expect that within 3 weeks hopefully.

zenith star
#

I have secured some Lancer PDF templating tools. This bad boy will be standardized and sleek.

#

I have no clue why I am so excited about this.

#

Also, I’m expediting it so that I can be sure to have some sort of announcement happen in here before the mass discord exodus early March if they go through with all the bullshit ID stuff they want to do. So I may go silent afterwards in here, but the project will continue to be worked on and updated through the itchio page, my bsky, and on the Lancer subreddit when the full guide is done, though I’m obviously not going to update on reddit nearly as often.

zenith star
#

Also, over 220 downloads at this point for the 1.0 lcp! Thank you for your support everybody!

zenith star
#

Line art and test title for the cover have been finished.

dim zodiac
#

@loud valve

#

Holy shit this fucks