#isle-discussion

1 messages · Page 235 of 1

lost citrus
#

i'm just legit confused

regal notch
misty pivot
#

fledgling baiter

void marlin
#

I feel the same way. And it's not about mechanics. But about fun. No playable is fun anymore. Something happened to make Evrima so... So... TI_GarboSquint
Boring perhaps? I don't know. But Legacy is way more fun (in my opinion). I had some great experiences, even whitout only fighting.

lucid urchin
void marlin
misty pivot
#

the ghost of islecord

regal notch
void marlin
#

Me neither
And I can't have fun with it anymore

regal notch
#

I can't even take it seriously anymore is my issue LOL, I used to value my dino but now I'm just like... eh, some bs is gonna take it out randomly and I'm helpless about it anyways

#

I've just stopped caring, even casually I just don't lol

void marlin
regal notch
#

it's part of my fixation on Bary, at least then it can survive some of the pin meta chaos

regal notch
#

plz no, Bary at most would have fun with an underwater grapple but even then I hope it doesn't get a pin lol

lucid urchin
#

Not saying you're not allowed to rant, because I can empathise with a lot of your points, but in no way is the game finished. If you're that burnt out, put The Isle on the shelf for a bit and come back when you feel rejuvenated.

The Isle isn't the only game on Steam.

misty pivot
#

all my shirts are too short, all my shorts are too shirt

void marlin
regal notch
lyric hollow
#

I don't think you need to justify not enjoying the game
Based on this massive list, it really looks like the fun of each of these playables has been sucked out of you
I personally find most of them very fun, as do others I guess, but there's no shame in admitting that you're not enjoying and that the game isn't for you

Tldr: you don't need to blame the game and try to criticize the game's features / design to justify anything. Just say you don't like apples rather than listing 20 problems about apples.

regal notch
lucid urchin
muted crypt
#

Yeah, there is a lot of inbalance rn, you should prob take a break. They will eventually iron things out and if the game makes u mad consantly, you will burn out so bad you prob won't touch the game at all. take a break bro and come back in like half a year-year.

regal notch
void marlin
regal notch
floral junco
#

Maybe hop off officials and you'll start enjoying the game again lol

lyric hollow
regal notch
void marlin
lucid urchin
floral junco
#

Sounds like you're just burnt out then, I've been having a great time playing all the dinos (except Deino because that is still the most boring thing to play).

regal notch
indigo cave
floral junco
lucid urchin
lucid urchin
#

Closer than you think.

lyric hollow
floral junco
#

I think Legacy has Evrima beat in one very key area: vibe.

indigo cave
#

Did you leave the server?

void marlin
lyric hollow
deep wolf
#

huh

floral junco
#

The isolated, tranquil, almost anxious feel of Legacy is very good. All mechanics and playables aside, being on Legacy felt very different.

lucid urchin
regal notch
#

I know the devs have a different size chart for what they consider mediums, smalls, etc.. but my god I wish mediums we had currently (dilo, raptor, cera maybe) weren't in the boat they're in rn where they just don't even matter or are worth playing unless you mix pack or get to full growth before anything making you strictly only killing whatever's smaller than you... which then promotes the very cycle dondi memes about how isle players just kill each other because that's the only mentality.

lyric hollow
#

Legacy was incredibly bland and cartoonish.
The only thing it has going for it is nostalgia, not quality

indigo cave
deep wolf
#
  1. Please do not tag/pm developers
lucid urchin
deep wolf
feral shadow
# void marlin Don't get me wrong, but I love The Isle. It's an incredible game, absurdly engag...

i find it funny, because a lot fo the things being thrown around are things i feel about legacy, i really dont have any motivation to play any specific species in legacy, unless its not in evrima, legacy just feels like you are playing to grow, and nothing more, i havent even experienced most of v3 and thenyaw, because populations on legavy are so tightly packed. i think its more of a point of view thing over any actual concrete "betterness" in legacy.

lucid urchin
#

Either click the blue @ symbol or hold shift whilst clicking reply.

feral shadow
#

most of the reason i hop on legacy is for nostalgic purposes

floral junco
#

I'd still pick Evrima over Legacy, and I have both downloaded so I could play either whenever I want, but I think the only think that Evrima hasn't eclipsed Legacy on (and honestly may never) is that atmosphere Legacy has when you're traveling the map by yourself.

deep wolf
#

is there any plans too add a system that lets you check if your prime before you hit prime?

lucid urchin
#

Much better.

floral junco
#

I think Evrima comes close to that sort of vibe with the new light fog, or other times when the ambience dies down.

feral shadow
deep wolf
indigo cave
#

There are two reasons to play legacy
Anky and pue, that's it

lyric hollow
deep wolf
#

oh, do you know where that message is?

dapper dagger
#

Evrima is not in a good spot right now, but I'd still take it over Legacy. Excluding pinslop, Evrima's combat is still more interesting compared to Legacy where you're just tailriding.

feral shadow
#

ill take pinslop over tailriding anyday and i will die on that hill

floral junco
#

Legacy atmosphere feels more like a classic hardcore survival game, DayZ-esque bleakness. Evrima atmosphere feels a lot more alive and full, for better or worse.

regal notch
dapper dagger
#

I won't leave Legacy entirely without credit though because Dilo was a literal FORCE at the end of it. And I remember there were times when Dilo was good in Evrima. But unfortunately not right now.

feral shadow
#

legacy utah players are the worst

lyric hollow
#

It's not even pinslop anymore tbh. The thresholds have been reduced a lot over time.
And even then, it thematically makes sense to subdue your prey and prevent escape.

Tail riding is just [vomit]

lucid urchin
floral junco
#

As fun as it was to kill things with juvi Cera on Legacy, the tailriding is just way less engaging in the end.

dapper dagger
#

Clones don't work right now and even then, Dilo has bizarrely bad agility with no slide, and it's way too loud for its size

void marlin
feral shadow
floral junco
dapper dagger
#

NGL my most hated dinosaur back in legacy was Giga. I remember earlier times when Giga was so fast it invalidated so many things

feral shadow
lucid urchin
indigo cave
regal notch
#

I love Dilo, like I'd love to play Dilo rn... but why when everything has as good of NV, pins it easily or can get into a corner and prevent it from ever doing anything lol

dapper dagger
#

I also hated Shant back then, because way back in progression times when I worked my way up to a Spino, it wasn't long until I was then ran down by a Shant and got whooped.

lyric hollow
#

I have never seen a dinosaur be called the sherbet of dinosaurs lol

feral shadow
regal notch
#

Dilo is the glass bones debuff rn

lucid urchin
indigo cave
#

I'm so glad people are finally realising dilo is on the gutter

regal notch
dapper dagger
lucid urchin
regal notch
feral shadow
indigo cave
#

Carno has "bad" nv

regal notch
floral junco
dapper dagger
#

TBF even as little as just giving Dilo a slide to make up for its bad agility and making it much quieter would make it much more viable.

floral junco
#

Troodon venom fog right now is genuinely epilepsy inducing during fog, I'm shocked the devs are letting that stay in the game so long with no quick patches to fix.

void marlin
regal notch
indigo cave
feral shadow
dapper dagger
#

Gonna be honest I'm not a fan of Troodon venom inducing fog. I thought it was cool when only Dilo did that.

regal notch
indigo cave
void marlin
regal notch
#

troodon still has that engagement element to it even if I don't like the hallucination mechanic being added, where you actually have to flank and time your pounces, work as a group, bait, there's not just a 1 button kill

floral junco
#

Dilo's clones also used to be less buggy back when they had more ways to counter them, but in the pursuit of trying to make the clones impervious to being countered they have bugged them to hell and back so many times I've lost count.

regal notch
feral shadow
regal notch
crude girder
#

Bear655

dapper dagger
#

I remember when Maia was first added, Dilo was actually capable of being a serious threat to it if it was in a pack.

void marlin
floral junco
void marlin
feral shadow
regal notch
void marlin
regal notch
lost citrus
#

I'm of the opinion that most animals light enough to be picked up by quetz will probably just die from the initial peck

dapper dagger
#

Hot take(?): I remember when Carno charge didn't do bleed and that it could only charge when it was running. I wish it had stayed that way. Now Carno's just kind of braindead and its part of the reason why Dilo struggles so much now.

regal notch
regal notch
void marlin
dapper dagger
#

Yeah Carno charge does bleed

regal notch
#

something something skull bash internal bleeding

dapper dagger
regal notch
floral junco
regal notch
lost citrus
void marlin
#

Give Oingo Boingo a pin

regal notch
feral shadow
regal notch
#

Anyway, gimme Bary or fix Dilo, just ffs lemme play a medium and exist in this pin meta filled with giants and apexes

floral junco
lost citrus
#

I've done that with a troodon when playing ptera, it was fun

void marlin
#

Give Venan a pin

digital tulip
regal notch
#

dev jumpscare

void marlin
#

Omg a red role homo sapiens sapiens

ruby oak
#

hi

lost citrus
#

hi

wind acorn
#

Hi Kissen

void marlin
#

hi

tepid robin
#

hi

regal notch
#

kissen I don't mean to ask this like a "ETA" but more like, is the plan to drop the trio of dinos together or release 1 by 1 in testing etc?

lost citrus
#

so many owls NotLikeThis

void marlin
ruby oak
#

twit twoo

wind acorn
tepid robin
regal notch
void marlin
digital tulip
#

Hi!

I'm not really here though. I just laughed at the meme. I can't chat atm. Ruhl busy.

tepid robin
ruby oak
#

Happens.

zinc stratus
#

Not breathing until bary drops

tulip glade
#

Devblog Friday

regal notch
wind acorn
regal notch
#

also a dev posted, that means I have to repost

ruby oak
#

2026 is going way too quickly

tepid robin
#

bary 67

void marlin
#

Things I hate the most:
1- jego
2- Venan
3- Rumple
4- Rex and Cera
5- 99% of the USA population

paper willow
tepid robin
void marlin
ruby oak
#

No hate, it is Wednesday

indigo cave
feral shadow
tepid robin
void marlin
lost citrus
tepid robin
feral shadow
void marlin
lost citrus
#

doesn't look like any pheasant I've seen

tepid robin
ruby oak
#

If spices and meat were both sourced from the same animal, that animal would be cajun chicken

void marlin
feral shadow
void marlin
indigo cave
ruby oak
feral shadow
#

wait no

void marlin
ruby oak
#

No why is that actually scary, I've been saying that for months

tepid robin
void marlin
ruby oak
#

but I say it with two L's, this is wrong

feral shadow
#

nvm im dumb it just kind of looks like a golden pheasant, but im 90% sure thta is a species of pheasant

lost citrus
tepid robin
dapper dagger
#

One thing I don't look forward to about the game's future if it people at large just end up treating the game like an apex carnivore simulator after future playables, and if 70% of the playerbase only touches Rex, Spino and Giga

And that's coming from someone that really likes Spino and would love to play as it. But it'd be really lame if Rexes and Gigas were to be all I see as a Spino.

void marlin
indigo cave
feral shadow
void marlin
#

@feral shadow, jego is bullying me 😭

void marlin
tepid robin
void marlin
ruby oak
tepid robin
indigo cave
#

Hating on ceras is crazy

void marlin
quasi vector
#

stinky cera😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭

zinc stratus
tepid robin
void marlin
#

People I hate the most:
1- Cucho
2- Rumple
3- Venan
4- Gotta choose someone
5- Same thing from 4

dapper dagger
#

Decent chance that Alberto ends up being the ultimate broken op midtier when it gets added, and then people would hate Alberto so much that the past Cerato hate will look tame by comparison.

regal notch
#

I love cera

indigo cave
#

I like cera too

regal notch
#

👀

manic fulcrum
#

Tbh the only change I think Cerato needs is the charge bite slowdown effect happening as soon as it clicks the charge bite rather than after max damage

regal notch
#

Cucho we should play cera together

indigo cave
#

My little trash compactor

void marlin
manic fulcrum
regal notch
#

there we go

#

the best part is quetz might be durable enough to take a cera bile bite so it can throw up mid air and projectile vomit on someone randomly

void marlin
regal notch
#

thought you'd like it

dapper dagger
#

Cerato vs Bary gonna be a fun matchup I think

regal notch
#

too ba quetz won't be out until 2028

void marlin
#

People I hate the most:
1- Cucho
2- Rumple
3- Venan
4- Gotta choose someone
5- Same thing from 4

manic fulcrum
#

I mean I imagine Quetz would have no more health than a dilo at most. So it’s only taking like 1 maybe 2 charge bites at most

Good thing about Quetz though is it’s tall, so you can’t headshot it reliably

void marlin
regal notch
tepid robin
#

good things

indigo cave
void marlin
# regal notch bad things

Holy crap
People I hate the most:
1- Venan
2- Cucho
3- Rumple
4- Gotta choose someone
5- Same thing from 4

regal notch
#

ayyyy

outer plank
indigo cave
void marlin
outer plank
regal notch
#

legalize killing baby dryos

tepid robin
indigo cave
outer plank
tepid robin
regal notch
#

I'm doing great things in life, like burning dryos

void marlin
misty pivot
#

hi

grand grotto
#

The frenzied apple pie is making hamburger factory in Atlantis

void marlin
misty pivot
#

I do its ok

indigo cave
grand grotto
tepid robin
#

I dont like the red haired guy from Shrek 3

indigo cave
tepid robin
errant spade
#

Is the carno's charge broken right now? I just came back to the game after a few months and it doesn't feel like it's working

void marlin
indigo cave
#

What the hell are you naming your characters in English bruh

tepid robin
indigo cave
grand grotto
tepid robin
void marlin
indigo cave
#

Oh dang

void marlin
tepid robin
# oblique geyser

I was once thinking about making children with your wife to keep your family fed

grand grotto
oblique geyser
neon elk
#

hi

regal notch
regal notch
tepid robin
#

Or keeping your son in a basement for his whole life, not saying a word or teaching him language so you can release him after he is a fully grown man into the public

regal notch
grand grotto
tepid robin
cinder cave
regal notch
tepid robin
neon elk
#

dreams

cinder cave
grand grotto
acoustic wagon
#

When devlog?

grand grotto
cinder cave
oblique geyser
#

this chat has gone nuts

grand grotto
cinder cave
acoustic wagon
grand grotto
tepid robin
grand grotto
tepid robin
#

Waiting whole month just to get 5 minutes of happiness and repeat

indigo cave
#

Wait why did it get deleted?

grand grotto
#

Bruh I got work tomorrow someone go in for me pls and thank you

neon elk
#

we all get deleted, some day or another

grand grotto
neon elk
#

hi

grand grotto
sick kraken
#

oh my god devblob snuck up on me. its on furday

neon elk
#

oh yes
true
dblog should be this week

that is jolly

neon elk
cinder cave
grand grotto
indigo cave
#

Wait what? What as nsfw about it?

neon elk
#

we should all re-read rule 5, methinks

neon elk
# indigo cave Wait what? What as nsfw about it?

its more then just NSFW

Do not post anything which is NSFW. This includes but is not limited to: excessive profanity and sexual/illicit content, Hateful, threatening, provocative or vulgar content or videos/images of animals under duress in any form is not allowed. Nor is any content which infringes on copyright or violates any other applicable law(s).

Do not post hyper distorted audio, maximized audio, or videos focused on the subject. In short; Don't blow out peoples ear drums. Also please refrain from discussing controversial topics such as religion and politics.

grand grotto
neon elk
cinder cave
indigo cave
#

I see

regal notch
#

nothing is sfw at any job ngl, having you rphone out is a crime

neon elk
grand grotto
indigo cave
#

Loud funny tho TI_Succ

regal notch
# indigo cave Loud funny tho <:TI_Succ:447626423365271562>

Loud humor, Is it better than normal humor? Worse? Different? We will explore every aspect of the idea, and explain why we think all humor should be cherished and nurtured... well... maybe we'll just scream instead.

Check out my boi, Pelo! https://www.youtube.com/user/123pendejos

Subscribble for more viddles ► https://www.youtube.com/circlet...

▶ Play video
wicked prism
neon elk
#

woohoo!!

void marlin
neon elk
#

hm

feral shadow
lost citrus
#

Mmmm

void marlin
feral shadow
indigo cave
#

Wait I lost image perms over a mistake? Come on what the hell :/

void marlin
feral shadow
indigo cave
#

Rumple that was uncalled for TI_Succ

void marlin
regal notch
feral shadow
regal notch
#

burgerminmi

void marlin
neon elk
regal notch
#

eat minburg

tepid robin
indigo cave
#

Venan you are evil

regal notch
feral shadow
regal notch
neon elk
#

which button

void marlin
#

People that should be banned from The Isle:

  • Venan
  • Only Venan
neon elk
#

r'e*

indigo cave
#

My loud video gets my banned but threatening minmi doesn't? I see how it is

tepid robin
void marlin
regal notch
indigo cave
#

'r

void marlin
#

'

regal notch
#

^ someone beat me to it

indigo cave
#

,

void marlin
#

_ _
_ _

indigo cave
#

Very intriguing dinosaur discussion

void marlin
regal notch
#

u'w'u

void marlin
tepid robin
regal notch
void marlin
regal notch
tepid robin
#

I will meow if devs drop kentro and austro ht right now

tepid robin
indigo cave
#

Why the hell are the O with accent banned ?????

regal notch
void marlin
tepid robin
indigo cave
#

Why? TI_Squint

wind acorn
#

Chat getting weird again🤣

void marlin
void marlin
regal notch
tepid robin
indigo cave
#

I have to say islecord has the weirdest word bans in the history of ever

void marlin
#

Kentro > Minmi > Anky

void marlin
regal notch
indigo cave
void marlin
regal notch
#

but with stego's template

void marlin
#

Give Kentro a crush

regal notch
#

doesn't even have spikes on its thighs, pathetic

feral shadow
tepid robin
void marlin
regal notch
#

wkentro should deathrll

indigo cave
feral shadow
feral shadow
void marlin
tepid robin
indigo cave
void marlin
feral shadow
indigo cave
#

Oh, I hope your pillow is comfy today then

regal notch
void marlin
tepid robin
indigo cave
#

Are evrima servers dead? Can't connect to anything

regal notch
#

you know who else hates kentro and minmi?

void marlin
regal notch
tepid robin
regal notch
void marlin
regal notch
tepid robin
regal notch
#

even got prime ngl

void marlin
regal notch
#

or a twitter user

void marlin
#

AALOSAUURUOS FRGILOS

tepid robin
regal notch
#

F

neon elk
wind acorn
void marlin
neon elk
#

oh

void marlin
wind acorn
#

lol

regal notch
#

minmi hiding in corpses be like

void marlin
neon elk
#

oh

tepid robin
regal notch
regal notch
tepid robin
nimble raven
#

wtf did allo idle get changed in skin customization menu, its so stiff lol, its moving just very slightly

regal notch
visual crow
void marlin
visual crow
regal notch
#

I'ma shower, too much stinky kentro worship in here

void marlin
void marlin
#

I like those black - gray - white skins

tepid robin
nimble raven
tepid robin
#

look at my cool prime elder canni allo I have grown 3 weeks ago

void marlin
nimble raven
#

duuuude they changed allos idle I think, its noticeably way tamer

tepid robin
nimble raven
void marlin
void marlin
#

Dw, you'll get it someday

tepid robin
void marlin
west thistle
#

can 2 allos pin a prime steg?

void marlin
#

Well, it's bed time for me
Goodnight everyone!

west thistle
#

asking beacuse uh.. i think its not possible

tepid robin
void marlin
west thistle
#

no i wasnt...

tepid robin
west thistle
#

so my report.. i hope it goes thru

void marlin
cerulean vessel
#

hi, i just begin to play again after some time, any place you can recomend me that has a lot of action?

tepid robin
regal notch
#

Real talk, why is someone excited for kentro, what's it going to do that stego doesn't with the addition of pin defense?

#

Sell me on this creature

nimble raven
#

did sanctuaries just stop working lmao, I keep seeing raptors and ceras that should be wayyy too big to comfortably be in sanctuaries, its dumb af

regal notch
tepid robin
cerulean vessel
tepid robin
low cloak
tepid robin
regal notch
somber urchin
#

cactus teno

regal notch
tepid robin
regal notch
dusky night
#

Walking herrera exhibit

regal notch
low cloak
regal notch
#

But why no love for Ovi

brittle sequoia
sick kraken
#

nice

regal notch
misty pivot
low cloak
tepid robin
cinder cave
sick kraken
brittle sequoia
regal notch
low cloak
#

I wanna grief nests and not feel like evil so bad

brittle sequoia
regal notch
#

Typing in the shower js hard

regal notch
#

I wanna play hypsi Nd hVe colors back again

#

Gimme back my blu

#

Anyways did you know prime is gaeaunterd by eating newborn dryos? Crazy stuff,

onyx galleon
#

elite spawn still not fixed?

regal notch
onyx galleon
tepid robin
#

Okay guys I'm going to bed
Goodnight everyone

regal notch
regal notch
tepid robin
onyx galleon
#

if they didnt fix what is already ingame imagine what is to come ahahah

regal notch
indigo cave
#

I cannot embed either TI_Succ

regal notch
void marlin
void marlin
indigo cave
charred root
midnight tundra
#

I just realized theres a new change in steamdb changelog. First one in a week.

manic fulcrum
#

DONDI fix MZ’s and my life is yours

proud forge
#

why cant i lay eggs on my nest?

hoary sage
frozen cove
#

stop making them fix stuff so they can work on the things people want... more dinos

regal notch
cinder cave
#

Hwhat

sterile gulch
#

aadas

regal notch
#

pretty looking dog

nimble raven
#

My favorite dinos easily, first spino, then yuty, and the rest dont really matter cause the first two are exponentially higher lmao

sleek marsh
proud forge
#

wait so why does it say im infertile right when i hit 100%? how do i make more basbies

sleek marsh
#

You're too old

mighty lake
#

yall is the new developer blog coming out soon

lost citrus
lost citrus
mighty lake
#

hmm kay

rustic scarab
#

We getting any updates to stuff soon? Being a black hypsi is killing me dudes

jolly mantle
rustic scarab
violet phoenix
#

thanks for taking care of us baby carnos-us 8 ❤️

regal notch
#

it's /unstuck to fix your positioning right?

rare tide
regal notch
#

neat

teal mist
#

THE ISLE

drowsy basin
#

THE ISLE

uncut mason
#

The Isle

misty pivot
#

hi

uncut mason
#

Hi

rich elk
#

BRO

#

DID THEY JUST WIPE THE HORDETESTING SERVERS

misty pivot
#

why are you on hordetest

teal mist
#

there is no hordetest mate

uncut mason
leaden cobalt
#

THE ISLE

rich elk
#

🙄 There is a hordetest branch

thin nest
#

why are you using hordetest

lost citrus
#

Now if they pull the HT, that's maybe news, as it would suggest they are prepping for another one

leaden cobalt
#

The Horde

misty pivot
leaden cobalt
real pendant
manic fulcrum
#

I just watched a Teno get grabbed at a pond I was gonna drink at

#

Scary times

halcyon locust
#

can someone remind me if we still get the devlog at the end of february despite it being a shorter month

real pendant
#

Yes (I would assume)

subtle sleet
halcyon locust
#

aight

subtle sleet
#

Right before you were about to either cross or drink lmao.

ruby oak
#

burger

undone cliff
#

What the fuck is pinslop

indigo cave
#

Pins. They are slop

hoary sage
indigo cave
#

Slop is something common of low quality, in this case getting pinned/pinning

somber urchin
#

TI_HypsiShrug the name people who don't like pin use for pin.

undone cliff
#

That's dumb

wind acorn
#

It’s like saying AI slop. Cause it is. Though I doubt a pig would eat AI slop

rare tide
# undone cliff What the fuck is pinslop

A dumb word people use to complain about pins because they can't actually come up with intelligent ways of reworking/improving them and instead just act like the entire concept is so inherently flawed that they should just be deleted completely

indigo cave
#

There have been thousands of suggestions to fix allo tf are you on

undone cliff
#

Eugh

rare tide
lost citrus
#

If we get austro and bary in the same HT, I wonder if that will finally revive the swamp

#

Inevitably deino will be popular in that HT too

indigo cave
#

That's why so many people want it gone, it's a very unfun mechanic to cheese fights

lucid urchin
real pendant
somber urchin
undone cliff
ruby oak
#

happy birthday krowwwww!!!!!!

opaque flint
#

Happy birthday @undone cliff itstime

rare tide
indigo cave
indigo cave
#

Dibble is especially a victim of this, both allo and rex just walk over it with pin

lofty oriole
indigo cave
#

It's literally the opposite, if the game was realistic trike and stego would 1 shot literally everything

real pendant
#

Also deino would have a higher biteforce

blissful shoal
indigo cave
real pendant
#

Wait LMAO

#

I’m gonna keep it like that. Its funny

blissful shoal
#

suremacy

leaden cobalt
#

Wait did I spell that wrong as well

misty pivot
#

yes

leaden cobalt
blissful shoal
#

you should remove the p to be suremacy too

leaden cobalt
#

Let me fix that

sterile gulch
#

Good night guys, I hope I wake up tomorrow and see a patch

glass stump
cinder cave
forest haven
#

A kind of ring game mechanism or something similar where you could buck to get out of pin and both players have to hit rings correctly to keep hold/get out would make pinning entertaining and manage its one sided-ness

cinder cave
regal notch
#

what if bary doesn't fish like ptera, but instead catches elite fish TI_LUL

midnight tundra
manic fulcrum
# indigo cave Dibble is especially a victim of this, both allo and rex just walk over it with ...

I do agree that there are certain situations where it just feels really bad. But there’s also situations where I feel it’s fine. Such as Omni sneaking up on a gali, or an Allo sneaking up on a Carno, or a Rex who wore down a stego.

At least with Rex, just making the prime slower than the adult would fix most of the issues with that. It doesn’t need to run at 40km with murder sprint. With Grapple I think just increasing the conditions a bit for a pin would be fine, having to outweigh the opponent more (or through wearing down) would be nice

There is an outlier(s) though, which is Dibble and Trike who are animals designed to sit there and fend for themselfs. Currently I don’t think they even do that well. Ceratopsians in general are rather disappointing and both could use some universal buffs. Which I do have a few ideas for

regal notch
#

no I mean the one I put there LOL

manic fulcrum
#

I just dislike the whole “PINSLOP BAD” hysteria the community has come up with because no one had a problem with it until Allo & Rex. Granted I’m not saying it’s perfect and it does need work. But instead of just fixing the few issues with it people just want to flat out remove it

regal notch
#

I think pins should result in damage if you don't methodically try to ambush so that you can't just RMB the second you cross paths, but instead have to treat it with a sense of actual ambush

regal notch
#

nobody enjoys games that are built on taking someone else's agency away, hi yugioh.

manic fulcrum
#

I wouldn’t mind raptors threshold being lowered to 50% of weight same as Allo.

Grapple thresholds should be increased as well for pins. Only needing to weigh 1kg more is ridiculous to me and it should be 150% or even 200%. The prey should be worn down by the time they are pinned, or you should be a vastly larger animal/group

regal notch
#

I think the mechanic as a whole needs polish instead of stat adjustments

forest haven
# regal notch I think pins should result in damage if you don't methodically try to ambush so ...

Yeah real I honestly love the idea of pinning but the way they executed it so far is just.. ugh
If it doesn’t line up at least have it not work. I mean seriously how is a Rex pinning something 6 feet away from where it slid to a stop. Which is just the most obvious issue with it. At least have the Dino being pinned get dragged to it looks better gosh.
I don’t even want to get into its mechanical issues.

regal notch
#

something lunges at you and you're facing it with teeth and claws and you somehow just end up on your stomach flailing and doing nothing back?... why not allow pins to have positioning so that a front pin results in the predator taking damage, side pin taking somewhat less, and from the rear actually being defenseless for more realism?

uncut mason
#

Pinning just needs some back and forth happening. Stamina levels alone ain’t cutting it

forest haven
regal notch
regal notch
#

on top of this, we see groups where one pins and another helps bite for more damage anyways.... I think that gets away with a little much without punishment if you can just pin someone point blank without thought

#

in no world should something pin a target, kill it, and come out well enough to repeat the same thing on another target having not taken any damage whatsoever

uncut mason
#

Pinning does leave the pinner open to attack, but that rarely happens

regal notch
#

that said, I like the sparring thing, just had a duel as a baby dibble against a baby t-rex in sanctuary and actually felt like a back n forth

#

felt like punishing the player for not thinking more about their target. They went for the grab instead of just biting or positioning, that let me defend myself and get headshots in return, strategic play was present instead of one sided nonsense

sleek marsh
#

Make pinning a build up attack that requires 3 successful pin attacks in a row whereupon the third actually pins

forest haven
regal notch
uncut mason
#

I agree that the requirements to initiate a pin should be more narrow. After a pin happens what about an exchange of fast random key presses to succeed on a defensive action or fail one. If both sides keep succeeding the quick actions then stamina determines the outcome

regal notch
pliant urchin
#

Pinslop became a term after allo and rex were added but people very much had an issue with omni pin

uncut mason
#

It’s my only idea so far

regal notch
#

mash O to escape!!!!

indigo cave
pliant urchin
regal notch
#

My take is The Isle's always taken precedent to stop and consider your surroundings, positioning, and odds of survival... pinning doesn't involve that but it needs to

sick kraken
#

i think people have more of an issue now because we know so many carnivores are gonna get pin

pliant urchin
#

You mean you don't want to spam space bar to get released from a pin!?!?!?! TI_LUL

sick kraken
#

once rex got it, it was no longer a long arm dino thing. it’s just every big guy

indigo cave
uncut mason
forest haven
#

I mean the ring game mechanism would be less inclined to macros if you had to make one ring which was changing sizes fast match up with another that changes size each successful buck which happens when you match them up

indigo cave
sick kraken
indigo cave
#

"uhm yes let me somehow force a quadruped as heavy as me just by using the very forward extreme of my body while simultaneously also ravaging it somehow"

sick kraken
#

just watch giga will have pin

sleek marsh
indigo cave
sick kraken
indigo cave
#

Allo and omni have free body parts to hack and slash at the prey, rex is stupid

indigo cave
sleek marsh
sick kraken
#

pinning things 4 tons and under is fine because that thing had no business being in your range, and if it can’t pin then rex never kills it. it just runs away. unless it fractured actually… rex don’t need pin

uncut mason
#

Being able to toss things is fun though

indigo cave
sick kraken
#

i really think the pinning apex should be spino. but whatever. it’s both. maybe all 3

indigo cave
#

I really think the pinning apexes should be none

regal notch
#

Rex imo has a different problem altogether

sleek marsh
indigo cave
sick kraken
#

rivals has used that and it’s gone terrible. i’ve seen other games have that mentality and it just kills them

sleek marsh
sick kraken
#

nobody thinks it’s broken it’s just not necessary at all

sleek marsh
indigo cave
sick kraken
regal notch
#

They're too common and too easy to upkeep. I feel as though apexes should be designed to be natural ecosystem threats. A t-rex should be hungier than a cera that just threw up. There shouldn't be 20 t-rexes available on the same server eating everything and just being fine, they should be struggling to find food to the point only 2-3 ever make it to sub adult period

sleek marsh
sick kraken
#

rex has speed boost AND fracture to secure kills. yeah it also needs to pin you

sleek marsh
#

Its like saying superman is OP lmao

sick kraken
regal notch
sleek marsh
sick kraken
#

yeah it’s the king of dinosaurs so ofc it needs to be broken. like what are we doing. it’s just the name

regal notch
indigo cave
sleek marsh
sick kraken
#

if rex is just better than spino and giga because it is “king of dinosaurs” we need new game direction lmao

regal notch
weary siren
sleek marsh
regal notch
#

point people are trying to make is that t-rex is already plenty strong but it was also given a tool that makes anything helpless on top of its already great top tier power

indigo cave
regal notch
sick kraken
sleek marsh
regal notch
sick kraken
#

i’d rather just balance based off what’s fun and makes sense. not because of some label someone gave it

indigo cave
real pendant
sick kraken
#

rex shouldent be the strongest thing because some dude called it king of dinosaurs

sleek marsh
regal notch
#

in any case, apexes need to be harder to make exist altogether

indigo cave
sick kraken
sleek marsh
regal notch
crisp vector
#

Did someone say Batman?

sick kraken
#

and having 1 super op thing does not make the game fun

sleek marsh
regal notch
sick kraken
sleek marsh
regal notch
sleek marsh
sick kraken
regal notch
indigo cave
real pendant
#

I like Ceratosaurus

sleek marsh
sick kraken
#

trike was also probably stronger or about equal to rex

manic fulcrum
#

I mean I agree that Rex should be the most physically strong carnivore. As I don’t see Giga nor Spino doing more raw damage than it

But that doesn’t make it the “strongest” at everything. Just in raw power as a carnivore. Something like a trike or Giga is still a threat to it

sick kraken
sleek marsh
forest haven
#

The strongest dinosaur goes to my gym

past dune
#

Why is

sick kraken
sleek marsh
past dune
sick kraken
regal notch
past dune
sick kraken
#

actually cool i didn’t know either did those things irl. new info rocks

sleek marsh
sick kraken
forest haven
indigo cave
lost citrus
regal notch
past dune
sleek marsh
regal notch
leaden cobalt
#

Hi

sick kraken
#

cucho that guys flame baiting

regal notch
forest haven
sleek marsh
past dune
#

Oh boy!
Free money!

regal notch
sick kraken
#

i think my favorite part of the isle is how realistic dilophosaurus is

forest haven
sleek marsh
sick kraken
#

no i meant the isle

past dune
sick kraken
#

prolly

regal notch
#

I love how realistic taco is

manic fulcrum
#

Rex is an animal designed to break through walls. That’s its niche. Things like trike and Anky should be able to defend from it and be no pushover, but neither is a Rex.

What (ideally) Rex should struggle with is animals who are more mobile than it and can afford to dance around it, or use bleed to slow it down. It’s a juggernaut, and you have to play around it rather than fight through it

wraith hound
#

What in the hell is a troodon ?

sick kraken
#

it’s a troodontid

past dune
#

Why are we having a balance discussion... this is The Isle. It doesn't matter.

manic fulcrum
leaden cobalt
sick kraken
past dune
#

Just play your silly dinosaur and be happy.

regal notch
indigo cave
sick kraken
#

they could balance it if they’re awesome

sick kraken
indigo cave
#

Why is pißed off banned bruh

manic fulcrum
#

I do think Rex is a bit too good at everything. The only changes I’d really make to it are A: the prime being slower than the adult & B: slightly less turning while running

past dune
#

Imagine if Rex was hard to grow.

indigo cave
sick kraken
#

it just has pin and speed boost and fracture. pick a prey securing ability buddy

#

you get 2 of those. you gotta lose one

manic fulcrum
regal notch
indigo cave
manic fulcrum
#

Ai really is just a safety net for animals to endlessly grow

regal notch
#

Guys, humans should pin

sick kraken
#

yea ai needs some changing but alas. diabloceratops ai is coming

past dune
lost citrus
sick kraken
#

i don’t even know how you fix it because i actually like ai in most cases but it just makes apexes way too easy

#

if you cut ai in half then like omnis are prob gonna die and i don’t think that’s really necessary at all

manic fulcrum
sick kraken
#

before you can cut AI you need to make it easier to find people

undone cliff
indigo cave
past dune
manic fulcrum
regal notch
sleek marsh
sick kraken
lost citrus
#

I love AI for environment and aesthetics, but it is way too easy for some animals to subsist on them

regal notch
#

when humans get vehicles, the vehicles should pin.

sick kraken
indigo cave
#

I still think ai animals could works wonders if they had random spawns and had growth times. Having 5 grown dibbles on the same spot every few minutes is so ass

regal notch
#

GUYS OH MY GOD THEY MADE IT IN THE DISCORD... THE MESSAGES, LOOK!!!! IT's TOoO LAtE

stone tiger
past dune
sleek marsh
sick kraken
#

i think the games already very good but i see a lot of things that should be changed

manic fulcrum
#

Tbh I think just lowering the ai amount of stuff like boars, deer & turtles would be fine. But you should introduce small Ai into sanctuary’s & making foraging a universal mechanic for juvies/small carnivores. That way it’s easier to start the game, but the challenge should come from maintaining your food upkeep

stone tiger
#

How would a dinosaur pin a vehicle?

lost citrus
regal notch
sick kraken
past dune
sick kraken
#

i think unofficials will carry us if they became more tweakable. and let us make custom maps

indigo cave
regal notch
sick kraken
manic fulcrum
#

Can’t wait for Hyposlop

regal notch
#

srsly what happened to this chat LMAO

sick kraken
#

if strains are treated like rex where anyone can get it because it’s awesome it’ll be a bit annoying i’m sure

indigo cave
#

(had to fit in my daily strain slander somewhere)

manic fulcrum
#

STRAINSLOP!!!! These devs just keep adding strains and it’s ruining the game. REMOVE IT!!!! STRAINSLOP STRAINSLOP

lost citrus
sleek marsh
#

Can't wait for all the "prime hypo Rex dominates this server" yt vids

past dune
sick kraken
#

it’s crazy because metta said that unofficials can’t even choose how much ai spawns. it’s all or nothing

indigo cave
past dune
sleek marsh
sick kraken
sick kraken
past dune
indigo cave
#

Not being able to control how much ai spawns is crazy what TI_Succ

#

How do they do body drops?

sick kraken
#

but i don’t think half ai even solves the issue because it just creates a new one. we need like actual plugins or something so owners can really mess with how ai works

stone tiger
#

Server owners have limited control

past dune
indigo cave
#

So the game has modding? I'm confused now

sick kraken
#

i mean ya petits has really crazy stuff

#

stegosaurus body summoned to thee

past dune
indigo cave
#

I just realised that Poa has been missing for a few days, have you guys heard of them?

regal notch
#

According to all known laws of aviation, there is no way a bee should be able to fly. Its wings are too small to get its fat little body off the ground. The bee, of course, flies anyway because bees don't care what humans think is impossible. Yellow, black. Yellow, black. Yellow, black. Yellow, black. Ooh, black and yellow! Let's shake it up a little. Barry! Breakfast is ready! Coming! Hang on a second. Hello? - Barry? - Adam? - Can you believe this is happening? - I can't. I'll pick you up. Looking sharp. Use the stairs. Your father paid good money for those. Sorry. I'm excited. Here's the graduate. We're very proud of you, son. A perfect report card, all B's. Very proud. Ma! I got a thing going here. - You got lint on your fuzz. - Ow! That's me! - Wave to us! We'll be in row 118,000. - Bye! Barry, I told you, stop flying in the house! - Hey, Adam. - Hey, Barry. - Is that fuzz gel? - A little. Special day, graduation. Never thought I'd make it. Three days grade school, three days high school. Those were awkward. Three days college. I'm glad I took a day and hitchhiked around the hive. You did come back different. - Hi, Barry. - Artie, growing a mustache? Looks good. - Hear about Frankie? - Yeah. - You going to the funeral? - No, I'm not going. Everybody knows, sting someone, you die. Don't waste it on a squirrel.

past dune
sick kraken
past dune
sick kraken
indigo cave
sick kraken
#

it’s hard to work with atm

indigo cave
#

What's the difference?

sick kraken
#

if it was supported you could work with it like gmod and just do what you want. rn u gotta like jimmy stuff and its limited

#

if it was supported we’d have dragons basically

past dune
#

There is no official mod support, there is no modding kit, there are no tools provided, and it is not something that the game will just let you accomplish easily.

But that hasn't stopped people from trying to take apart certain parts of the game and insert their own functionality on the server end.

sick kraken
#

or entirely new zone mechanics created by a modder

indigo cave
gilded palm
#

unironically gmod is probably an apt comparison of the desired endpoint from what we've heard. That'd be in the future though with proper support

sick kraken
#

no we can’t insert models or anims and stuff

indigo cave
regal notch
past dune
floral junco
#

I hope someone mods an acorn collection quest into the game.

past dune
gilded palm
indigo cave
sick kraken
#

i feel like the isle needs an ideas guy who’s studied game design for a long time to help in certain problem areas

gilded palm
#

The last thing this game needs is an ideas guy

sick kraken
#

i would love an ideas guy

gilded palm
#

We already have too many ideas

regal notch
sick kraken
#

ok most people don’t really think things thru and haven’t studied game design

past dune
regal notch
gilded palm
#

Studying game design isn't really that important at the end of the day, at least academically

sick kraken
#

if it’s someone who knows a lot about game design and is creating thought out ideas then maybe they should atleast listen

past dune
gilded palm
#

but also the issue is that contributing nothing but ideas is not needed nor helpful in a situation like The Isle where we have years of unimplemented concepts already sitting there

sick kraken
regal notch
indigo cave
misty pivot
#

omni rock

gilded palm
sick kraken
past dune
indigo cave
#

GreatSuccess.gif

sick kraken
gilded palm
gilded palm
past dune
#

Hmm

indigo cave
sick kraken
gilded palm
#

On paper, many of the game's concepts are very solid imo, and things lacking execution are either down to time constraints or cut corners, neither of which can be solved by a more robust design document

gilded palm
sick kraken
#

i mean yeah it’s programmer who has more insight into these things. it would be useful

gilded palm
#

Though also of anyone the devs are probably among the best suited to draw conclusions about player behaviour from the data gathered by official servers

indigo cave
sick kraken
#

someone along the way coulda said hey maybe rex doesent need 3 kill securing tools. unless the objective was just make awesome power fantasy guy. which i think is likely

sick kraken
gilded palm
#

given that any data gleaned by community servers is inherently shifted by their individual rules, moderation, any addons to their servers, etc, while players are limited to their individual perspective or the perspectives of those around them

gilded palm
# past dune The data can tell lies.

Sure, but I think having that data is still better than not when trying to draw conclusions about player habits on official servers as a whole

gilded palm
#

You can't treat it as the gospel end-all-be-all, but it'd be silly to throw it out entirely off the fear of it not being entirely accurate

indigo cave
sick kraken
#

that’s true but the issue is just lack of player interaction, which leads to the whole ai issue. there’s people with ideas…

gilded palm
#

it also probably provides far better information about player movement and the like than other forms of observation could allow