#general-feedback-discussion
1 messages · Page 491 of 1
can confirm maias are very sensual in their noises, including laying down/getting up
personally when i sit and stand i dont go MMMMMH
yo ok so like different classes for mercenaries theres the tracker, tranq, capturer, assault
tracker has service pistol and a tracker gun
same with tranq instead of tracker gun they have tranq
capturer has net
and pistol
assault has ar with pistol
yes?
what do u guys think
about the mercenaries classes
@barren zephyr now that’s epic
yeah danke
Hold up.
Classes.
Now we're talking.
Instead have specific classes for different mechanics. For example ~
Tranqer, Assault, Capturer, and Tracker
Tranqer has Service pistol and tranq rifle
Assault has service pistol and AR
Capturer has net gun and service pistol
Tracker has a tracking needle and service pistol
Each class comes with a different uniform (not primal carnage stuff. im talking about like actual armor)
like the ones in the teaser
jesus christ how long does it take to type
since dinosaurs moan when getting up and sitting down, will humans do that too when they're added?
LMAO
humans should have a moan button
Scientist: Specialized with science (obviously). Capable of implanting trackers/implants into dinos. Perhaps could be capable of crafting different items such as medical kits or anti-venoms (if venom is added).
Assault: Specialized in combat. Has steadier aim and faster reload than the other classes. (Could be divided into Support and Assault, with one specialized with melee and one specialized with ranged weaponry.)
Ranger: Specialized in wild life survival and taming. Has significantly better sprint speed and better stamina than the other classes.
Thoughts? ^^^
so dinos feel awkward when they btie them and they oan
I really want humans' 1 call to just be the screaming sounds from the howling mouse vine.
XD
that's when humans should just moan really loud
or you just say a really bad pickup line
It should instead be "how you doin'"
But the bad pick up line idea is actually pretty good
what if you come across a group of like 10 humans just spamming pick up lines
@steady cradle
they most likely didnt steal eggs all the time
Actually, one recent discovery has much of the scientific and paleolithic community currently going with the concept that Oviraptors were not egg stealers at all.
But the Isle doesn't necessarily strive for realism in the anatomical or dietary departments so perhaps Oviraptor could be added as an egg stealing omnivorous small dinosaur.
Oviraptor seems a bit too small compared to the rest of the survival roster.
I think a larger relative like anzu may be a better choice
oviraptor wasn't the thief of those fossil eggs in particular
but that doesn't mean it wasn't oportunistic and tried to snatch one to eat it
plenty of carnivores will eat ostrich eggs, from egyptian vultures to lions. So an oviraptorid could be a jack of all trades both being able to hunt small game, scavenge, eat some plants and eggs
@urban moon im afraid so say this but the neck thing of dilo doesnt exist
It was made just for jp
I know but it would still be nice and cool if it can be done or not
If they wanted they would problably have done it by now
But still lets see what hapens
That's true and yep
- copyright problems (maybe? idk)
2.it would look like shit on the TI dilo
I prefer the relatively realistic dilo we have, and the frill wouldn't fit the model imo
same
iirc Universal can get ppl into legal trouble if they wanted to, regarding dilo frill
though they most likely won't bother, it's still a bad idea.
I don't mind a strain monster-dilo getting a frill of some sort, but keep the regular dinosaurs grounded in reality pls
@blazing charm I love your suggestion so much
You have a perfect idea
That i really want the devs to consider it
will give Ceratosaurus an unique ability
and its own scavenger niche
It has my full support
they are already pushing it with the JP sound effects, so let's keep the dilo as it is
nice job with this suggestion, fits the scavenger playstyle even more and incetiving cerato players to do so
Good suggestion Jaffad
❤
👍
@sacred sand i believe devs have said they don't intend on adding seasons, so i wouldn't hold my breath for that, i do like your suggestion and the idea of seasons and temperatures though- especially with how it could interact with stamina (sprinting to warm up in the cold, risking overheating in the heat, etc.)
I don't believe the Devs dismissed seasons, but I'm pretty sure they said snow was not going to happen.
hum, if they could add seasons other than snow i certainly wouldnt mind, have a southern winter where theres no snow but its just cold and everything's dead lol
Ah, i see, yeah i tried to avoid linking everything to snow in winter as snow isn't exactly the most fun thing to work into a game, and hard to implement without it being too overpowering ig
if they really wanted to go for it, changing some ground textures to white, lessening the grass in some way, making the trees leafless, and making snow fall instead of rain (not gather or anything but just as a visual effect) is really all they need for sufficient ambience imo, but being from the south all we get is slightly dead-er grass, barren trees, and.. still rain lol, so a southern winter would need less changes
Yeah, i just really like the idea of having to prepare for winter and the struggle of getting through it, as it's already a survival game, so the visuals would be good with just a few adjustments imo
the one bothersome thing about severe seasonal differences is new players arriving mid-winter and getting fucked, so ehhh
also storing food is a no no from the devs
Don doesnt want to give players the option to hoard
Perhaps more wet and dry seasons then? Instead of winter, summer, spring and fall?
Yeah, people being discouraged to join during the hard seasons would be an issue
not only would dinos be out to kill you, but the environment would be too
So during the dry season, there's less bushes, less rain, lakes ponds and rivers become a little smaller. And then during the wet season it rains a lot more and there's a lot more food, but a chance of flooding and stuff too
don't starve is an unrelenting survival game with severe seasons, and generally joining in winter means you die immediately unless the locals adopt you quickly enough lol, so youre best off not joining at all. wet and dry could be more accommodating, yeah
You could add a temperature mechanic. But I personally like the idea of 4 seasons (normal, wet, normal, and dry). In the dry season rivers dry up and only the deepest spots of rivers and lakes have water. In wet season they flood possibly splitting the map in half where only the best swimmers can cross.
And won't corpse dragging make it possible to hoard though? I've heard that's already being planned
the bodies will just be out in the open and they despawn
Hoarding would be like emptying food into a nest and being able to take it out again as an adult
o H right- yeah my bad
yeah nah, that would be busted lul
store a whole trike under the ground sdkfj
Hey, could a <@&401466542140817419> send this to Dondi for the chance that he’ll see it? I was just thinking, concerning the Deinosuchus’s swimming anim, wouldn’t it be more realistic to have the teeth below the water? That would make it blend in more, like the way it is rn is that the head is above, but if Dondi was to angle the chin down maybe 15-45°, the teeth would be covered. Just my 2 cents, I know this probably won’t happen I just feel as if it would be more realistic and easier to hunt if there wasn’t any pearly whites to spot when you were tryna creep up on something.
Or Developer, either one
Youre in the wrong channel, this isnt suggestions; and also the animations arent actually going to be as high or low in the water as they are shown in animations. The water used is just a test to make sure it looks alright. The developers do see the suggestions and the animations arent finished.
@upbeat halo post this in #general-feedback, and you shouldn’t ping moderators to show something to a dev if it’s a mere suggestion. That’s why they HAVE the suggestions channel.
Also that's not something you should really tag us about 
Also dondi isn't the one that animates
pihrahni: speaks
[ Everyone disliked that. ]
Pachy should take about the same time as Galli to grow, to be quite honest.
gallis about the same grow time as utah i think. maia should grow same speed as allo, and pachy same as dilo once it gets its needed buffs.
oh pachys getting a buff?
That's a fair point actually. @wintry cipher I concur.
Also if anyone wants to voice opinions on any suggestions I've given please do, especially regarding the nesting suggestions I've given.
I know Don doesn't like the idea of having to manage a whole bunch of meters at once, so the temperature stuff might be prudent to leave off on. hot and wet seasons have been discussed though and I feel they have a high chance of being put in as environmental factors for gameplay.
I CAN see seasons affecting nesting viability though for very obvious reasons. wet = more water= more fish = more food for babies, while it would be suicide for a sucho to nest in the dry season. meanwhile, predators such as utah might thrive in dry seasons because they are quick enough to avoid most of their foes to get water, and feast on the bloodbath of bodies resulting from people fighting over water
its less about direct buffs, and more about situational benefits
maia should grow faster than allo, we already have an hadrosaur that takes the same time to grow as the allo which is the para
maias grow at the same speed a carno does, which is pretty ok
pachys should just grow faster in general is all
yes of course
but they also need a bit of a bleed res buff and perhaps a reduction is speed, sort of like small diablos without bleed, essentially focused on defence
What does ⏲ mean when it’s a reaction on a suggestion
That is planed and you just have to wait

tf does fuzzy mean "where's my slower growth times"? what needs slower growth?
I think he just want the game to be more about afkaing
lets add an afk meter too
your dinosaur NEEDS to afk to refill the meter
when it hits 0 you die :^)
Everything @indigo sun
Never mind rip
why even suggest that
everything besides pachy is fine atm
btw, im open for opinions on my suggestion
More skin customization is always welcome
I would love more patterns
yeah, especially with the lack of colors for carnivores
the only fun one is carnos being able to have a power rangers squad
Right now even if we had many colours people would still just be recolors for another Guy as everyone shares the same pattern
i wanna be a green anky with near perfect camouflage and hide next to a path and break peoples legs out of nowhere
i also want to have a unique skin
cuz ive seen 3 different people use the giga skin i made
If there were at least more patterns they would look different even if they use the same colors
oh yeah the amethyst rex
And green highlights :^)
I also need non neon red blue and purple
i wouldn't say the colors should be neon but like
having purple and actual red and blue would be nice
I mean we have many greens while we could have neon green but we dont, why cant we have many reds blues and purples?
i want a darker green than the dryo colors
rn the dryo colors are about the only green that doesnt look yellow-ish
first person
v to toggle
????????????????????????????????????????
idk but i have a really good idea for it
Rexes can have neon green too
@paper oriole the heal bleed part maybe wouldnt be nessasary because you cant die from bleed. But the rest of it is pretty smart.
i mean if you are bleeding badly after a fight and need to rush to a hiding spot, not having the time to really find a good one so you sit in the nearest bush
a dino could see your erect tail sticking out and attack your vulnerable, immobile self
but you'd be less visible to passerbies while healing if you could curl inward in the less convenient spots
IQ 200
'twas just a lil thought lol
Honestly, it's a valid concern. I'm just trying to think how to do it without having to make extra animations for every animal
You still die from bleed btw
not while resting.
Dont think itd have to be every dino, just the more bendy and lanky ones mainly, i guess most would get the tail curl tho
If theyre adding new animations for grazing tho maybe they could do this eventually
get rid of the current mercenaries skin
its shit
i like the first one with all the helmets and gas masks
Heavy gear
That needs to be
see look
bring this back for humans or at least update it
to more detail
keep the gas mask and helmet it looks cool
everything looks cool
pls isle
dont die on me
(1) This isn't where you post suggestions, this is where we discuss em
(2) I kinda feel like this counts more as feedback
(3) Mercs haven't been in the game in a very long time, the ones we've seen were merely super early prototypes.
Lol yea that was more feedback
@shell mica troll suggestions are not allowed. Suggestions that have a meaningful impact are allowed, not “finish this” t
@valid flower
The isle has planned to add humans since it first popped in the internet
you'll have to deal with it if you bought this game thinking it would just be another normal dinosaur survival game
There'll most likely be plenty of community servers that enable dinosaurs only.
That too ^
If that will be an option then brilliant
@barren zephyr I disagree. Lots of people enjoy no alt turn (even though I hate it). A huge number of servers disable it so it's clearly a popular option to choose. Removing just the option wouldn't improve the game in any way.
the devs have discussed and warned people that alt turn will be force enabled, it is only a matter of time.
encouraging people to continue avoiding it only causes more misconceptions about this mechanic that is integral to future combat.
May just as well let servers disable NV
Is just stupid being able to turn off a basic mechanich
And removing It will stop people from doing suggestions based on no alt turn balance
I'm gonna agree with Ricsie. The game really is balanced around alt turn. Regardless of enjoying alt turn, it's very much a proper mechanic and most servers only remove it because "dinosaurs aren't ballerinas." And also people will come in with proper balance suggestions
I dont think it should be possible for an allo to die to a single galli because the player couldnt alt turn on a server they happen to like the rules of
☝
I used to be against alt-turn, but the game is balanced around it for better or worse. I really needs animations though, seeing allos and gigas turning in place at the speed of sound holding one leg in the air like overgrown scaly flamingoes is stightly jarring.
It surely needs animations
But lack of animations isnt an excuse to not use a basic and balancing mechanich
it really depends on the server tbh, still if it was enforced i wouldn't mind
I wouldnt really care of It being enforced if no alt turn players didnt act like the game was supposed to be that way, and if they didnt made balance suggestions around no alt turn
oh yeah definetly
Im fine just simply ignoring theyr servers
overall if animations are added it would something interesting to look at, as 2 legged dinosaurs would require to take a couple of steps to completely turn around
Idk if you played jwe but they have pretty good animations for everything turning around
@barren zephyr Aquatics are already planned, there's been tons of streams showing work on Deinosuchus recently.
Pretty sure there's also gotta be more substance than "add x"
Actually saying add x isnt a suggestions is a demand
@lilac swallow yeah the JWE ones are a good example
i don't wanna see my dinosaurs turn to ballerinas when they've gotta turn around cause someone bit me on the ass
but, yknow. i think it'd be pretty cool
I used to enjoy using alt turn but then I started playing without it and honestly I prefer it without. I shouldn’t have to worry about getting behind a rex and then it just turning on it’s tip toes to bite me lmao
You are the type of player that many here hate then
Imagine dying to a 2 hour utah as a 6 hour rex.
Yeah so balanced
Alt turn needs proper animations and proper turn speeds it's a joke atm
you probably shouldnt proceed to sit behind the rex tbf
Would you eat if It hadnt animation?
I would
Im not fucking diying to a lack of animation
the animation tends to make it look more unrealistic/out of place/unreasonable than it is, so ehh
The animations and the speed do
and i think people are just not used to seeing large animals turn in place, so they think it just doesnt happen
3 dinos has a overtuned alt turn thats all only these 3
It should happen but not as fast and not like a ballerina
the ballerina aspect is just the lack of animations
Yeah I've stated 3 times animations and speed need fixed
The others arent fast
Rex is even to fast imo giga is just ridiculous.
Rex fast?
Yeah it alt turns to fast mixes with broken hit boxes makes the game way less fun
Dont tell me you are one of these that think this game is a fighting game
if youre a smart low or mid tier, you can absolutely get on a rex's ass even with alt turn
the broken hitboxes are getting fixed any way
If you are smart you simply dont fight the rex
yeah that too
Im not leging a Rex kill me
It's a survival horror game. Should be one even if your a rex. It's also a pvp game as stated by the devs so ya I expect balance
I just run away
and lot of luck tbh
Balance is the speed a grow
Also a rex can eat you with it's ass due to bad hitboxes just. It is not fun
Rex is slower has less stam and grow slower why the hell should It fear a fucking utah
like i said, hitboxes are getting fixed
Speed of grow can't be your only balance that's asinine
And yeah Broken hitboxes doesnt matter as they are being fixed
it takes six hours to grow a rex but like 2 to grow a utah. the rex should very much have a huge advantage in that fight
It's a problem now and isn't fixed so yes it does matter
I never said it shouldn't have an advantage y'all can't read I. Afraid
yeah i was gonna pull that up
Im
And a rex shouldnt die to some assriding utah
I never said Utah once lol
Is a example
So the servers where that does happen, those are perfectly balanced?
And part of surviving is running
Y'all can't even read bo point in speaking with you good day tho
kay hon have a good day
dont be condescending considering you cant seem to read
You dont get our point too
youve been putting words in their mouth the whole time though
what points are you making if you wont even acknowledge what theyre saying
Exactly
My point has been made already just takes a simple read over my comments
I didnt understood your point and rereading wont help, pls tell me your point
basically they were saying rex's alt turn is a bit fast, giga's is ridiculous, and things should have some kind of chance to kill other things, however miniscule, as it's a survival horror game and there isnt a lot of horror to playing a rex other than starving to death
and somehow you all picked up that they want no alt turn at all
My point is alt turn is in a ridiculous state it's to fast and has no animations. A proper animation alone would slow it down most likely to a ok state
Slate said it better then I do lol
And me showing that dondi image doesnt invalidate the "should stand a chance"?
and after you posted that image, nines still saw fit to put words in proxys mouth
A pack of them should have a viable chance yes
I dont think animations would slow it. I understand your point about fast alt turns, especially with giga, but that's something that could easily be fixed if you suggested giga's alt turn get slowed down. Giga's a bit fucked anyway right now
considering proxy never said alt turn should be removed
As i said earlier, this as a survival game consist of surviving
It should be a survival game to rexes to
And killing rexes is not how you survive It as an utah
Horror survival
to be fair the horror aspect is more for humans
Horror id for humans and maybe juvies
I dunno when I'm a single rex and I see a pack of dilos I should be afraid
A Rex having horror of something tat isnt a hyper doesnt make sense
Dilos can indeed kill rexes on alt turn
Never said they could not in perfect scenarios. All a alt turn rex needs to do now is sit against a rock or water and it's very safe
I'm scared of dilos as anything but a giga
[faint maia laughter]
well yeah that too but i dont play maia much
I wanna see a hypo Maia lol
its just actually sonic
Lol
Hypoc carno?
While this topic is here, i think we should also bring up the negative effects the current alt turn has on mid tier battles. Balancing is a fickle beast, and right now you have some mid tiers that are balanced around their agility, or lack thereof the current animation less and speedy alt turns destroys this balance amongst mid tiers
I believe they'll be implementing an animation for alt turn sometime in the future so it may not be an immediate or fast turn like it is now, but only time will tell what they have planned for it
@cloud cosmos got any reason for those dinosaurs to be in the game? what would be their unique gameplay aspects and niches? youve gotta elaborate further than a massive list of a bunch of random dinosaurs you want in the game just for the sake of being there
Brachiosaurus is already planned as AI, tarbosaurus is never coming to the isle and neither is carcharodontosaurus since the first is a reskin of t rex and the second was actually just used for a giga model at one point
to add all of those they'd have to spend at least $217,000
Troodon has a venomous bite they could use that
Why did you have to make that so hard to read.
lmao
isnt dilo meant to have venom lol
dilo wasn't actually venomous
Dilo is meant to have an anti coagulant type venom that causes mass bleed
dilo is going to have venom eventually
(1) Troodon technically isn't a thing, it's...I can't be bothered to type the name.
(2) Troodon didn't have a venomous bite in real life, so it'd have to be fantasized like Dilo.
Pectinodon iirc
so other than troodon what would the others even possibly bring to the table
Let's go down the list, shall we?
Stygimoloch, it's literally just a smaller Pachycephalosaurus.
Cant be bothered it hurts my head just reading the first sentence It really needs some spaces in there haha
Iguanodon: This one actually interests me, I have some ideas about that one but I'm keeping it to myself for now.
iguanodon would be neat, i agree
Isnt an iguanodon just a smaller maia?
Not quite.
Anyway, Kentro does have some potential, but I personally can't see it being anything else other than a weaker Stego with passive damage via the spikes.
Kentro has a model doesn't it?
that's an iguanodon
incredibly so
Alright, what else.
Aptato/Diplo/Brachi
We're supposed to be getting Bronto at somepoint, We have Cama and Brachi is on the way so, pointless.
Penta: Triceratops, next.
Sauropelta: Basically just Kentro with less spikes and more Anky armor.
thumb
Wasn't it Apato we're getting not Bronto because I remember seeing a model with the neck spikes
we dont really need another sauropod
Styraco: Honestly not sure about this one, as much as it would probably suit being a Diablo skin, it'd need a different bitbox due to the horns.
Pretty much only 1 dino from that entire list is interesting
I'm going down the entire list
is it worth it
microraptor would be kinda cool
microraptor 🤪
Sino: Damn, a Pachyrhino reskin
the rest are clones, clones and more clones. With the odd few that might be able to cut it only if a really good mechanic can be proposed
Years ago micro was brought up and I think they said it was too small
too small, has been suggested a lot.
Microraptor is genuinely useless, please stop asking for it.
I'unno, general size. The small horn could be swapped out for the...whatever Pachyrhino has.
theyre trying to stick to things that are at least as tall as a human, i believe, a la utah and austro
Pachyrhino breaks bone, sino is basically styraco but close to trike size
Sino is larger than Pachyrhino
Eucephalo: It's just Anky.
Ourano: I'm keeping that one to myself
Nodosaurus: Sauropelta again.
Amarg: No.
still, as much as I like Sino, still a clone
Irritator is literally just Baryonyx
Slightly smaller but still basically the exact same animal
DESTROY.
Honestly, I legit can't see a single Carnivore that wouldn't just be a reskin.
Much as I'd like Concavenator, it'd just be a smaller Allo / skinnier Cerato
What would it have though?
Diabloceratops --> Triceratops
Maiasaura --> Parasaurolophus
Dryosaurus --> Gallimimus
Euoplocephalus --> Ankylosaurus 
Euoplo confirmed viable to be candidate
Heresy
Ceolo actually pains me
because I had an idea for it, only to realise said idea was awful
what was the idea lol
Qianzhou and Alioramus are literally the same thing. I don't think the guy actually read what he's typing in.
Horde mechanic. Player Ceolo's could summon weaker AI
AI would run the risk of turning on you if they aren't fed.
And smaller tyrannosaurid niche is already taken by Alberto. A shame. Long snout rex would be more interesting
Rugops has more of a chance since he already has calls and a model
Yeah, as AI
Oh boy
I love playing as weaker Carno
I'm just going to give the egg stealing mechanic I thought up for him to Herrera.
It'd help to explain what each animal could bring to the game mechanic wise instead of "Add it because it looks cool"
playing as weaker clone versions of dinosaurs is p cool and totally worth adding, according to survival mode
i mean if it did an unlocking system where playing the weaker version unlocked the better versionnn...
@torn thistle Can we please get a rules channel for suggestions or something.
@brittle bough NO. NOT PROGRESSION.
not like that lol
Cease
i mean, say, present all of the weaker options to start with
e.g. diablo, maia, and dryo
through playing them you can unlock their respective 'better' forms (trike, para, galli)
what about plateosaurus
model looked cool
and also you lost everything after death
I was considering doing a Suggestion doc for Plateo, but I literally just scrapped it a few hours ago.
why
Honestly, while I think it was perfectly playable, and pretty interesting in it's own right.
ya'll need to stop hating on the god which was prog
There are other creatures that can do it better.
guess ive just been dismissed, peace out ig
@cloud cosmos Dondi already mocked Tarbosaurus
Its kinda an iguanodon since it does have spikes on its fingers
and feasibly could run on 2 legs maybe?

Basically it was going to be something like Maia/Para, although able to defend itself from the front with the claws and stun attackers from behind with a tail swipe/slap.
But I feel like I need to tone down on the amount of playables I keep pushing for, so I put some on the cutting room floor.
this could be ai
protoceratops
Yeah, that'd be fine AI.
Small, but could potentially murder Juvie raptors and whatnot.
would give more food than velo, oro and taco but less than ava
perfect sub adult food?
sub adult food

It'd be Psittaco but more bitey
and rammy, prickly
taco quill shoot when
Giga clone: Mapu, Carchar, Tyrannotitan
Allo clone: Metri, Concav, Yuty, Torvo, Megalo, Eocarchar, Sinotyrannus
Alberto (sub rex) clone: Alio, Qianzhou, Daspleto, Gorgo, Appalachio, Alectro, drypto
Rex clone: Zhucheng, Tarbo
Carno clone: Majung, Skorpio, Raja, Kryptops, Rugops
Dilo clone: Cryo
Utah (small carni) clone: Troodon, Coelo, Dromaeo, Achillo
@cloud cosmos

would be nice if we had 1 of each dino from a different clade in survival like one ankylosaur, one sauropod, etc
im alright with 3 of a kind personally (3 ceratops/diablo-trike-ava, etc.)
Pachy clone: Stygi
Stego clone: Kentro
Anky clone: Edmontonia, Sauropelta, Euoplo, Nodo
Trike clone: Penta, Sino,
Diablo clone: Styraco
Maia clone: Ourano
Sauropods that serve no purpose whatsoever: Apato, Diplo, Amarga
@cloud cosmos
so yeah, only Iguanodon is left. We could use more large iguanodonts. Ourano would be cool as well, though the community generally wants the more iconic Iguanodon more
How does Apato serve no porpuse
How does Diplo serve no porpuse
Explain me properly.
Still want pachyrhino to come..
There was that Apato model sitting in the backburner but
big sauropods tend to play the same to my experience in games that have multiples of them
they also tend to be either boring or op based on those same experiences lol
Brachio @barren zephyr . There's ur explanation.
no large sauropod is gonna be playable, Brachi being the only large sauropod ai is good enough
@brittle bough "op" is subjective
its op for obvious reasons
and they should be op
backburner model basically equals not gonna be touched until after 1.0
it would be the players fault for taking on them
more referring to the sauropods who decide to be rude and trample over players/chase them down/whatnot
sauropods in the game i played were fairly fast compared to what you would expect, combined with reasonable trample damage it wasnt a great time
"chase them down"
CHASE THEM DOWN?
"trample over players"
but its the players fault
not the sauropod's
its the players fault for being too fucking close
explain to me how more sauropods would benefit the game greatly as of now
and how is a sauropod gonna chase something die
"sauropods in the game i played were fairly fast compared to what you would expect"
they would: Bring an extreme risk, extreme reward gameplay
Vulnerable younger stages
SO brachio
theyre either too fast, or so slow that whoever is playing them is bored to shit.
explain how Apato, Diplo would serve any purpose
a camara is never going to catch up to a theropod
Slate.
Its your fault for letting it do so
its stronger than you
its tougher than you
im talking about other herbis
Reminder that no large sauropod is gonna be playable
you are much faster than it
they were kfsing.
even a trike's sprint is faster than camara's sprint
you seem to keep missing the part where i said they were too fast, to make them not boring as piss to play. and you keep ignoring flaffy.
what can Apato and Diplo bring to the table that Brachio doesn't
easier food than a brachi
Not a good reason to spend 7000$ on 2 dinos that's just gonna be weaker brachios
Want easier food? hunt weaker AI or other players
@cloud cosmos not easy at all
@barren zephyr Cama has a possibility of getting implemented into survival. Isn't that already enough considering how many times the devs said they aren't going to add them as playables yet are attempting to now
A single neck slam could cripple an apex
so youre saying that they would be the same as brachi then lol
since ur anal about science and stuff, I assume you know that brontosmash is still highly speculative
Ask Rizky that
Ask Randomdinos that
There is evidence of supportive reinforcements on apatosaurus's neck fossils
Oi.
If your way to justify something is saying Ask this person you should probably form your own opinion 😄
and dont come with the "you started it"
if i started it
then i can end it
Now peace out
never even responded to me lul, but ight sure

lmaooo how on EARTH does someone get themselves killed by a cama
the only possible excuse would be if you were trying to hunt it or something
or if you were like a slow hatchling maybe
What would be The Isle's version of Scruff McGruff?
Do you really think that #general-feedback-discussion is the best place to ask this?
Considering I saw both suggestions & discussions in this chat title, I figured you guys would have the badges to handle this pokemon
Just go to #401470471750811669
@worthy tusk Probably would be best to be asked in #401470471750811669, this channel is more for discussion of suggestions made in the #general-feedback
@barren zephyr Please do not write troll suggestions with only two words and input meaningful suggestions as trolls can get you kicked from the discord, galli already has a jump, thank you.
"troll"
i dont post troll suggestions.
its more of me complaining about the game, not troll.
but understood, i guess
When you post "galli jump", that's not a suggestion for anything and doesn't provide any context 👍
yep, i understand that.
the part that i didnt understand was how you called it a troll suggestion, thats all
a troll suggestion is a meaningless/useless suggestion, or one done as a joke
a la saying "buff rex"
?
.. just suggesting "galli jump" is like saying "buff rex", it has no substance nor context and is hard to take seriously, thus called a troll suggestion. :v
i didnt type it as a joke tho
Slate stop feeding the troll 😉
Let's move on from this discussion. If you need more clarity about what I meant, please feel free to PM me
nah im done with this discussion
Didn't Rex have a septic bite, too?
huh?
Actually
Rex certainly doesnt need it in isle
The proposal of T-Rex having a septic bite came from the old theory that Komodo Dragons had a septic bite from bacteria in their mouths, which scientists have proven false, as they discovered Komodo dragons have venom sacs in their jaws which ooze venom when they bite down on prey.
So maybe, Rex didn't have a septic bite after all. However, I do, mechanically, think the septic bite fits Cerato for being the 'vulture' of the Dinosaur world. A gross animal (vultures piss on their legs to cool them down and kill bacteria) who consistently scavenges rotting flesh.
What's this in reference to?
Your Cerato having a septic bite
Honestly, though, I think a lot of dinosaurs should drool at some point
Oh, wow. Wasn't aware people were still reading it.
Honestly, this conversation reminds me of that one vine]
'Oh my god, is that a mini dinosaur?'
'No, you dumb bitch, that's a kramoda dragon.'
"ah, true!'
Komodos functionally do have a septic bite, in a really roundabout way. Their venom makes wounds bleed a lot and stay open, and most large mammals they live with when they get bitten go run off and hide in mud wallows which are like 75% water buffalo shit and get really horrible infections from it. So like it ends up basically working as a septic bite haha
oh its a meme.
@paper crag @bright elm you should be discussing suggestions here, not on the suggestions channel
Regardless the mix packing is not a realistic rule, and the trikes cant mix pack is included look at dino digs they are all mixed
Trikes cant mixpack because of herbivore death squads and players did this to themselves. The server rules do not aim to be realistic.
Like Nines mentioned, the #general-feedback page isn't the place to discuss your opinions. If you would like, you can post in the #401481402782056460 to give constructive feedback and how you would balance between the rules if you'd like
There's to many forum pages you have 3 pages to do the same thing
The official servers do not have realism rules, if you don't agree with it, there's plenty of other private realism servers that would pander more closely to how these dinos would have reacted and lived
So what's the real reason behind the rules?
Is it server load problems? Where packs cant be big with over 100 players?
To keep order in the servers and not have everything gone to hell
Herbivore death squads with trikes were overly aggressive. I dont like that they cant mixpack, but herbivores were actively hunting down carnivores
And its not alright
It's to keep balance and try to keep the population overall happy. If you would like to discuss the rules, feel free to join the #401464048610312195 or you can PM Punchpacket if you would like more clarity on the reasons for the rules set in place.
This section is to discuss suggestions put forth by other players, thank you!
That's how it started I put it in the suggestion page and reasoning behind it
What did you even want anyway, didn't see it
Told that's not the place for that and it was here now I'm told to change again
Mixpacking
I believe with rex and utah and then utah and trike
I couldnt understand it horribly well
you were told to move because you and someone else were posting stuff other than suggestions in the suggestions channel
just go to servers that allow that then lol
That was just an example, Alex to none apex
i.e. discussing the suggestion
then just now you asked about a rule, which isnt related to discussing a suggestion
then those end up being scouts which can get pretty awful pretty quick
Carnivores should never be able to mix pack. Herbivores should and I feel honestly bad for trike players but it happened and now we have to wait
You were told to come here if you were discussing a suggestion, not a server rule. If you want to discuss rules, you can visit the #401464048610312195. If you have an issue or would like a further explanation for the rules, feel free to PM Punchpacket
The suggestion was an idea to balance with my thought and I was told to come here
Then I asked if anyone knew the reason since I was already talking about a suggestion
The suggestions tab is to input a suggestion, you were submitting a suggestion and talking about trikes mixpacking. Go to the appropriate tab #401464048610312195 to discuss the rules.
Carnivores should only be allowed to mixpack if you're ERPing
Erping?
Erotic role playing

Hows that have anything to do with mixpacking
It was a joke
yo people when u make a suggestion bare in mind theres a difference between "realism for the sake of fun." and "realism for the sake of realism". realism for the sake of realism, generally is cool and fun for like 5minutes then its boring and or just annoying. try not to add suggestions that are literally just "well THESE animals do it like THIS" , or "well actually i think you'll find they were more like this". its a game. it needs to be fun and engaging.
animals shit so there should be a shitting mechanic because realism 
@brittle bough i like your thinking
I actually really want a shitting mechanic for ptera
trying to poop on apexs would be the most fun thing in the entire damn game
unless they add like dino's shit being food for another dino.. or some sort of valuable resource for the humans. i dont see it being added. 
@blazing charm I honestly like the septic bite idea for Cetatosaurus, I was thinking of something like that as well
at this point aren't all "DoT" effects just essentially bleed knock offs.
need something more unique.
I personally think, giving it a stacking slow from minor to major, depending on the amount of bites could be also considered as an option
It would mimic paralyzing, since septic bacteria often do that
high bleed and bone break are the same thing its crazy
i like the affinity lowering
i still like my cerato musk suggestion where if it sprays you you light up on everyones smell for a good while
bam no one wants to deal with it
yeah i like the idea of a dino that excels at tracking
works in the rain, boom unique dino
lol
And it would emphasize into Cetatosaurus' good turning radius, if you can grab hold on someone with your septic slowing, you can juke them fantastically with the run turn and maim them
giga doesnt need any more tricks.
give giga a jump

proportionally the size of utahs
lmao
i still say the best way to fix apex populations is to make them all feathered
watch the population cut in half instantly
inflate gigas dewlap to fly
give giga feathers but they look like wrinkles like the old dryo
It's like Stego with feathers
i do like the idea of a poison dinosaur tho.. not one that can inflict poison directly but IS poisonous if eaten/bitten, to deter bigger dino's from hunting it unless EXTREMELY necessary
make giga cockatiel colored/patterned and rex could be a lovebird
like poison spines.
make every apex skin bright pink
be so fun "go ahead giga.. bite me.. make my day"
but whatever the devs do, please dont put white as the body4 skin
devs PLS
@grave karma rex , anjanath from MHW skin when
Yes, crocodiles can eat food in water. They can't eat underwater though, or at least not without swallowing a shitload of water.
I thiiink the plan is for bodies to float?
Thank you
The water in this game is transparent. It's really bad.
They will increase it. It won't be like that in the future
nice
To my knowledge, Acro has been vanquished into the shadow realm it will be AI only
Along with Baryonyx and Shant
no way...
A shame because i allways like bary more than sucho
Acro has been a favorite of mine since i was a kid, sucks it wont be playable in the future
I mean, Baryonyx has no reason to be in the game when Spino and Austro is finished, Shant neither because of Camara and Parasaurolophus... And Acrocanthosaurus, as much as I like it, is just a fat Allo with Rex ambush, as well as Giganotosaurus being a thing
But I agree, it sucks 😞
At least for Acrocanthosaurus
What i meant with bary is that it could have been a better mid sized aquatic than sucho as sucho is pretty big
Shant can rot in hell
Shant is just a hadrosaur skin for a sauropod
I thought Acro could be a good equalizer to the Spinos as its land based
Thing is, Sucho is better because Deinosuchus and Spinosaurus will be a thing and Baryonyx would be bullied to high heavens. As well as, with a semi-aquatic, you either has to be Austro level of fast to evade predators or beefy enough to hold territory
Sucho is better suited for the latter, to secure ponds and rivers and being able to at least repell Allos in the future when it will be more defense oriented
And it's fast enough to run from things bigger than it
Baryonyx imo would be constantly bullied by Allo, Cerato
So I kinda agree with Sucho being the Dev choice. Even though I like Bary more as well
You made me understand the sucho choice
ill like Sucho when its Juvie can run faster than a human lol
only thing you can catch is a Taco
I will like the game in general when juvies arent better at afking rather than actually playing
I think we should move to #401464048610312195
True
yea
lets nerf acros damage and health but also make it even bigger
turn the glass cannon into a Balloon? Sure!
Acro is oversized and needs to be made smaller, so i agree with making the model smaller to make it fit the weight it should be.
@rough acorn I kinda like acro being this big
for a weird reason
its like being this big fits its role of being
a pseudo-apex
looks huge and intimidating
but is nothing but a mid tier killer
Its way too oversized
The Camera angle is broken too
Unless its irl the same size as rex and giga, make it smaller
and it weighs 4.7 tons in game but more massive than a Spino
irl acro is way smaller
Yeah so make it closer to its real life size estimates
Yes
@rough acorn Acro needs alot more than just a size adjustment. If you're wanting it to be playable that is.
@blazing charm Ok, what would you say it needs in simple terms
Well, it needs some kind of unique mechanic, something to help differ it from other playables.
I had an idea myself for one, but I'm honestly unsure if it'd still work.
You don't have to make a document like I did, I just did it because it's a nice way to convey a large amount of information without clogging up the Suggestions channel.
Jeez, looking back on this. Gonna have to redo the entire thing once the code rework is out.
Wow, this is really well thought out. I really appreciate your hard work making this. When you ever update it please let me know or DM me I would love to check it out. your Ideas are spot on!
@blazing charm
@barren zephyr lets not bring back the black+green neon dino skins please.
Its not just disgusting to see
but also decreases chances to survive
in survival
Why dont let people freedom, i want blacks to parts of my dinos
I want some damn greens for camoflauge
I'm sick of catshit colors
I want actual green
@lilac swallow freedom =/= immersion/horror/realism
How the fuck is it horror to see a green neon pink allo running around
i'm sorry boohoo youre gonna see some neon colors but oh well. some people want legit camoflauge
They only asked for the brighter greens available for dilos to be available to other dinosaurs
nothing in the entire game is horror
no one said jack shit about neon pink so i dont know where you got that
A fucking dryo doesnt give horror
the only spooky thing at all would be that tisso giga with humans at night
The game is supposed to be horror focused.
well its not
@lilac swallow Herbis are fine.
literally nothing is scary at all on any level
Im tired of having the fucking same skin on all my dinos
Okay and part of horror is hiding yourself, is it not? I cant do that with only greys and blacks and browns. because there's more than that in the landscape. There are brighter greens in the map
super mario 64 is a genuinely scarier game
Neon Greens and Reds are not gonna help you.
. . . The scary part is night, and you can't see color at night with the current nv system so why not allow some brighter colors? Especially for males.
And btw wit our current colors people still do shit skins, they wont do worse ones with more colors
regardless of horror, colors that are useful for camoflauge, like some of what dilophosaurus has, would be perfectly fine for other carnivores. Dilos are not neon green. Youre overexaggerating
Hurr durr muh edgy green neon + black gigosurssuzzz im so collzz
No one's asking for that get off your fuckin high horse or whatever youre on
You talking like im some kind of edgy
nno
I still completely genuinely want a muted purple body color for rex
No
we're asking for some better fuckin colors than catshit, grey and brown
I mean the players that want non colors.
well that wasnt the point of the suggestion
It's almost like some animals have bright colors
the point was asking for colors like what dilo has to be made available for other dinosaurs
We have fucking banana color they cant make worse skins with neon green
so maybe read next time
You can easily make a good green skin look natural, rightfully camouflaged while looking nice at the same time. Triceratops is a big example, people go all black because it lacks good patterns, but if you explore it more you can always make a good skin that looks nice, not everything gotta look bright and all pastel colored just because "muh cool"
There's nothing wrong with having more options though, is there?
no
Just add different patterns.
But muh inmersion
The store page refers this game as Realistic, Gritty and "world designed to kill you"
Your pastel colored shit doesnt work here
we should have free reign of colors basically, maybe minus weird shit like neon radioactive pink or whatever
i dont see why youre so against this. no one asked for bright neon green, no one asked for purple or pink. we asked for some lighter greens to blend in with the landscape
Do you think neón green is worse
lmao sorry not everyone wants an edgeasaurus
Well why not more colors found in birds?
not every dinosaur needs to look like shadow the hedgehog
Okay, then dont complain when some predator saw you from miles due to your glowing radiation levels of red and black
I wont
It will be your fault
Not asking for everyone to be a "edgeasaurus" but some people like variety.
i would love some variety
I like variety
Their "variety" is edgy neon greens and reds.
I wont be a fucking glowing stick
instead of people crying about how all we do is make edgey dinosaurs
Our variety is fucking banana
I already love my trike skin, its subdued colors that blend in well with the landscape.
It's called being smart when making a fucking skin. It's very simple, but that doesnt seem to be sticking in your head
its not smart to request colors that are too bright
If we can have banana skins we can have almost everything
People already do Black and Neon Green on their Dinos still. I just want to have some old colors returned like they used to have. If I want to be an Oreo rex, then Ima be one. Black makes for some pretty killer camo too.
i want everything to have a shitload of color options. Who cares if someone tries to be a neon orange rex and get eaten
Wolf girl definitely cant survive properly
I want options maybe dont use them but i want options
Some people don't want the same skins/colors and I respect that.
we're not asking for this
my goto giga skin is bright orange with blue highlights lmao
Im fucking tired of being puke green+brown
we're asking for simple greens that can help with camo
I don't seem to take the game as seriously as you do. I am fine if I get eaten or I don't blend in, that's fine with me either way.
At the very least all dinosaurs should have access to all the colors in game imo
You bought the wrong game if iyou bought it expecting to be all charmy and unstoppable. its meant to be a hardcore game.
something like this would not be "Uh muh edgey green dino"
For fucks sake we actually can go fucking banana
seriously, chill the fuck out when people want normal ass camoflauge colors
When you buy the Isle, your signing up to be eaten. You die. It's an unforgiving game. That's a given.
how is someone saying this when their icon is a sparky bright gold dragon lol
Then why does it pain for you to have higher chances of survival
The difference is some people want a couple more pattern options and a few other colors.
I would just enjoy having access to the Dilo colors for the Dilo and allowing some of them for other Dinos too, the blacks and greens do work pretty well together.
You see what I mean
I really want pattern options too
If we can have fucking banana rexes running around and they dont break your inmersion let people more colors
why is it so bad to camoflauge yourself to try and survive better?
then ASK FOR FUCKIN PATTERN VARIATIONS
but radiation-edgy skins kill the immersion of a gritty, realistic, hardcore game.
Hear me for once
Fuckin scroll up and look at the colors
We have fucking bananas
Tentacle, sure the current state might not be
No one asked for bright ass neon green. We asked for some normal not catpuke
but its fated to be like that
There is no more disgusting that this yet we have it
shaved raptors literally erotic roleplaying on top of crates sure is gritty content
I mean... You desire a realistic game yet we can have a banana looking Dino, you ask for more patterns which would be cool but what type? Like go in depth a bit of what you would want.
Thats their players fault.
not the dinosaurs and the game.
There are yellow variations. Why can't have a subdued Jade green color?
no one even uses yellow beyond making cool or stupid skins
spinos that are psychic and eyeless and also control the weather sure are realistic
Patterns that could camouflage better while looking nice
Or you get nested in with the weirdest colors ever. Lol! XD
So the Greens, Browns and Blacks with a pattern would look great.
so we can have nasty ass bright yellows but not normal greens found in nature?
What about some cassowary blue for crest colors?
Yet you bash me and say I cannot survive well enough because I ask for more colors?
No nines It seems we cant
tentacle you are killing what the game store's page offers
no one's looking like my bearded dragon in this game
Youre getting off topic. Respond to the actual conversation instead of arguing about some dumb shit
Stop ignoring the yellow argument
the game itself kills what the store page offers
Depends what Kind of Yellow you want. Like... Bright yellows or dark yellows?
because it is in a super early state and its not the games fault
but the players.
@night mountain if youre gonna continue an argument not about the suggestion, can y'all just take it elsewhere? we're trying to have an on topic conversation
May as well get rid of every color and just be all brown
To be fair, if you are a full adult rex I doubt whatever color you are is going to help that much with camo just from your sheer size.
youd be surprised what good camo can do in the right areas
Putting this here
Haha, all brown huh? Atleast we can blend in with the dirt and logs.
And not to mention colors and patterns on animals in nature have a lot more purpose than just camouflage.
Why are you tagging me in it im nit the one who keeps bringing up the games store page and whatever lol
Then you are doing good
you are surviving
you brang up the game not trying to be realistic
but the developer and the game store really mentions it
@barren zephyr can you also not continue your dumbass argument here
so i brang it too
If youre gonna talk in here, talk about the suggestions and the arguments we are making for it instead of acting like literal children
All I'm trying to do is to refuse neon or bright edgy dinosaurs running around because thats not what the game intends the horror + grit to be like. I'll never accept bright reds, greens,blues on predators or maybe herbivores for all of that.
although I DO want more variety by suggesting different skin pattenrs
patterns
Guys
so then we can get rid of yellows then? why can we have banana yellow but not natural greens
I dont like the bright yellows either, i suggest toning them down just aswell
You can literally have a power rangers pack of carnos, thats gritty realism to you? lol
Colors and patterns on animals in nature have a lot more purpose than just camouflage.
should i bring up examples of green animals that use that shit for camo?
do i really need to do that?
lol
I just dont want bright skins to kill the game's mood, immersion and horror.
Hi how to get terezino?
Not a survival dinosaur
wrong channel
@finite viper no proper chat to ask read the rules
Ok
Okay? The game still implies a HORROR survival game
We do have great access to alot of different browns and have some greens but adding back/in the Dilos Greens and thr Giga 5 black for the Body 1/2 slots.
If someone desires to have an almost Neon Green/Yellow Dino then that's okay. It's what some folks like, could even present as a challenge to survive.
If you don't like it, then that's cool but no need to bash some folk if they desire to be funky looking creatures.
Thats not what gritty+horror brings
what does that have to do with color options that allow for better camoflauge in the environment?
sure real life animals can be bright
but this is a(once again) gritty and a horror survival game.
do you know what those animals use that green for
blending in with the leaves, grass and other green shit in their environment
"The game still implies a HORROR survival game" Well its not, and likely never will be.
"this is a horror game so you cant blend in" is the dumbest fucking argument every
FUCKING TAKE YOUR SHIT ARGUMENT ELSEWHERE I SWEAR TO FUCK
Get the fuck out if youre gonna keep bringing up the damn store page
Stop arguing "gritty and horror", that has little to do with colors. If I'm a juvie trike and I get attacked by a bright green and pink dilophosaur, you can bet I'm still as scared as if it were jet black and brown.
"gritty and horror" does not mean "shit browns and grey"
A yellow Rex and a camoed one scares me the same
we can be bright white currently, wtf are yall on about with "but green is bad because camo" lmfao
@barren zephyr And thank you for acknowledging my previous statement.
Do you still feel the same immersion by being attacked by a pastel colored radioactive dinosaur than something that can easily stalk you and ambush you a t any time.
Oi
it means trying to survive in your environment to the best of your abilities and that sometimes means using greens
oh wow, what a crazy idea, normal colors animals use
No problem, I agree with you but my response is getting somewhat pushed down by all the chatter.
sorry
Y’all calm down or I’ll remove you from the conversation altogether.
The current color system is the true scary aspect of the game, he's technically right lol
tell them to stop bringing up something not at all related to the discussion please
cause i'm getting damn sick of it
what are you guys even talking about?
Yes'sir. Anyway, if anyone has any comment actually related to color schemes, I'll be watching the chat. 😃
Okay then, go have your dreamy bright ass skinny colorations. but please do not complain or get salty when your hiding does not work because your color choices does not fit the envinronment. That is why you make skins supposed to blend in with certain foliage, if you people are just making cool bright skins just to look flashy then it will be your problem and you'll still be killing the future horror of this game
@lament thorn Colors for dinosaurs.
Well i know that but whats got everyone so shook
Who?
And i'm gonna be honest, i dont care what people do with their dinosaurs. it's not their job to act how you want them to. If they want softer and greener greens, then let them instead of acting like an ass when someone makes a suggestion
No problem, Gar.
Also Purple, why do I feel like I know you from somewhere. I think I have seen you before within a server..
I never ever implied that i want everything to be dark grey and green/brown
then why are you throwing a fit
because all youre doing is whining instead of offering any sort of criticism
if you have a discussion about the suggestion, please lets hear it
I think it might be best for y’all to just move on 
@barren zephyr I do believe we may have herded together as Triceratops on a server before. ☺
We just had a 20 minute discussion about a dinosaur coloration suggestion. you had it and i bought my points, but its not worth it anymore since everyone here wanna be pastel colored
Yeah, I was nested in I think. My colors looked like a dulled down Volcano and it was awesome!
I wont care anymore about that too
and i brang a reason why i dont want them
Yep! I think it was me that nested you. I still use the same skin even now. 😃
There’s already edgy shit and people will always try to make it.
^^^
Exactly gar
Now that’s enough, unless y’all can keep it civil.
Yeah sorry
Okay
I want a muted purple for rex
monster you do know that adding a bright green wont delete all the other options right? its like saying that since we have bright white currently, everyone will ignore camouflage to be bright white. 's a bit silly, is all
And no one is forcing you to use these skins neither
aye, like lizard/anole greens
You are gonna be sealing your fate by not being able to properly hide. for now i'll no longer care about that
Yeh not a fan of that
i brought up several examples of animals that use greens
..we already can with white though, is the thing
most modern lizards are rather bright but thats because their environment is
If i seal my fate isnt your matter
by all means, i can just be solid white and say fuck it to camo if i want to. thats.. my choice for my gameplay, it doesnt really affect you
exactly
