#plugins-and-tools

1 messages · Page 11 of 1

hard jay
#

Update Windows.

nimble grove
#

srt not support

#

?

hard jay
#

Windows 7 is not supported by OBS.

#

The whole program.

nimble grove
#

can it be from him

#

I will test on another windows 10 pc

#

@hard jay

hard jay
surreal stump
#

Is there a way I can program my scenes so that if a channel point scene is redeemed, it can return back to the previous window without having to program every single one? For example: If I'm playing a PC game (Gameplay Screen), can a viewer redeem Silly Dancing Scene with channel points, and then automatically switch back to Gameplay Screen (Or Just Chatting, Drawing, and any other misc. scenes) when the 20-second video clip is over?

#

I basically want a catch-all type of setup so that no matter what scene I'm on, once the Dance-off is completed, I can go back to whatever that previous scene was

harsh topaz
#

no way for adv-ss to know what channel point redemption you've gotten

#

at least not directly

#

maybe a combination of streamer.bot & adv-ss

spiral ruin
errant geode
#

with adv-ss, is there a way to make the scene delay transitioning to the next one for 0.5 seconds?

#

I'm trying to make it so when i switch from one scene to another, an element on the previous scene fades out, and then the scene transitions

harsh topaz
#

I don't think so, if there is it might be very hacky.

Adv ss detects things happening every X Ms. So you'd already have triggered the scene switch.

And I'm not sure if there's a way to store what scene you were trying to go to, to go to it later.

#

Depending on your transition (?) if its custom you stinger you could add 1 sec of nothing to the stinger, and have adv ss detect the transition happening and do what you want before any actual visuals appear on screen.

errant geode
#

hmmm
i think i have a workaround idea

harsh topaz
#

There might (again, big might and hacky) be the possibility of something nutty like
Macro 1:
"If transition from X to Y
Go to X"
Macro 2:
"If transition from Y to X & in the last 2 seconds transition from X to Y do this:"
Wait 3 seconds
Transition to Y

#

But I've never dabbled in such shenanigans.

oblique yewBOT
#
ℹ️ Info
  • macOS 12.5 (OK)
  • No Output Session
Hardware Check

Apple M1 Pro 8 Core 3200 MHz - OK! / Apple Apple M1 Pro (not in benchmark DB)

errant geode
#

^ ignore that, i had a problem but i fixed it

unreal lintel
#

Hello and a good day. i search for a TTS Multichat as an alternativ for SheepChat- Any suggestions?

regal breach
#

instead of trying to hack into the transition

royal gale
#

i fhink this is the right channel for it, im looking for obs labels like latest sub, latest follower lastest ect ect but how do i install that tho?

fossil wyvern
royal gale
#

so then it do be this? bcs it takes like 5 min to download i whas like is this what i need KEKW

fossil wyvern
#

that can do it, but you don't need a whole separate app

royal gale
#

do u by anychance maybee have a link? bcs i get easely confused when it comes to downloading stuff and computer stuff D:

royal gale
#

:o

#

oo

#

fhank u

royal gale
fossil wyvern
royal gale
fossil wyvern
#

no, you can test it out by emulating an alert

royal gale
#

what is emulating?

#

wait ill look it up

fossil wyvern
royal gale
#

oow

#

gotcha fhank u, lemme try

#

aaa its such a labels, sadge, i whas looking for a permanent one like this one

fossil wyvern
royal gale
#

hmmm then i might looked over it

fossil wyvern
royal gale
#

ow ow the + i whas looking on the site, oke gotcha fhank u again <3

signal crystal
#

Hi. When i start the recording while playing, it's getting lag of games. When I stop the record of OBS and then close it. The games is playing smooth. thanks

calm shell
#

Hello ! I hope you guys are alright ! I have an issue, the streamlabs URL for the chat box seems like to working at 50%. Sometimes it shows the messages, sometimes it doesn't... I don't get it, I have to refresh often... This is happening since I updated OBS. Can you help me please ?

fossil wyvern
fossil wyvern
#

then it's a problem of streamlabs, not OBS

calm shell
#

Oh my bad then

#

Thank you

umbral lake
#

salve a tutti avrei bisogno di una mano.. come posso vedere su obs chi mi sta seguendo in live su twitch? grazie

oblique yewBOT
# umbral lake salve a tutti avrei bisogno di una mano.. come posso vedere su obs chi mi sta se...

Welcome to the official OBS Community Discord server! Unfortunately, our support volunteers can only provide support in English. Most of our support documents and guides are also only in English. If you feel comfortable using a service like Google Translate, feel free to use that to send messages to us. We'll do our best to understand your intent, and we'll try to help you as much as we can. google_translate Translate

umbral lake
#

hi everyone I need a hand .. how can I see on obs who is following me live on twitch? thank you

umbral lake
#

I apologize probably I expressed myself badly or the translator translated badly .. I set the alerts .. I would just like to see who is watching me on the twitch channel shows it to me on obs I did not understand how to do it

fossil wyvern
umbral lake
#

practically the symbol of the little men?
the strange thing is that they are always the same and remain there even when I conclude a live .. is it normal that this is the case?

gilded folio
#

!plugins

oblique yewBOT
untold jay
#

@mortal harbor does it have to be the same text file, though? you can set up multiple instances of counters and display all of them in separate sources

quiet bramble
#

If you make note of the names of those "viewers", you can go in the same game category you streamed in, look at channels of similar viewer count to you, and open up one channel at a time, wait for it to load, look at their viewer list, take a screenshot, close the channel, open the next channel and do the same. Then look at how many of the names of the people in your own viewerlist are not only in other streams, but are in 10/20/50/100 streams simultaneously. They are not real human viewers but are bots that just join channels to gather data such as follower count, viewer count, possibly record the discussions in chat, and gather other statistics either for driving some public statistical website like Twitchtracker or Commanderroot etc., or for some unknown reasons.

#

Twitch is infested with hundreds of bots that just join channels and never say anything, just sucking up data for whatever purposes.

#

They are generally connecting only to chat however through IRC rather than on the web page as a normal viewer, so there is no web session associated. Twitch does not count these bots as viewers on someone's channel, so this is why you might see 30 names in the viewer list in chat, but only have a viewer count of 10-15 or so. The rest are bots.

mossy lintel
autumn pond
#

You want snaz

quiet bramble
mossy lintel
quiet bramble
#

The problem with that, is that banning an account on Twitch does not remove the user from chat. They can still come to the stream, can still watch etc. or gather data. So the bot isn't a real viewer anyway and is just there to monitor the channel which it can continue to do even when it is banned. So basically banning bots is completely ineffective.

#

All it does is prevent them from speaking in chat, but most of these bots explicitly do not ever speak in chat to begin with, they're just data harvesters that work still even when they're banned.

#

If a bot is a spambot, then banning them will prevent them from spamming, but not from joining chat.

#

Since it is ineffective, IMHO it is not worth banniing them as it doesn't accomplish anything, but it does risk possible false positives of banning legit viewers.

#

It would however be nice if there were a way to actually ban accounts completely from accessing a channel altogether including chat. I imagine Twitch doesn't want to do that because just taking away a viewer's ability to chat effectively bans them but they can still watch ads and make Twitch money. 😛 If they were a real viewer actually watching of course.

mossy lintel
#

Banning is exactly what it is. After banning them they are removed from chat list. And are not able to join again. It's basic IRC stuff.

untold jay
#

you don't need an account at all to view chat, so that doesn't matter either way

#

if you needed an account to view chat, that'd be a different issue, though then i suspect data harvesters would start mass-making accounts, good luck banning them all

quiet bramble
#

Banning on Twitch is equivalent to "quiet" mode on IRC effectively.

fossil wyvern
#

it does stop them from viewing chat tho

mossy lintel
#

⬆️ This

quiet bramble
#

If it does that now, it is a newer behaviour as it wasn't always like that.

mossy lintel
#

Couple of years

fossil wyvern
#

possibly, I've only been on twitch for a few years

quiet bramble
#

I've been on Twitch since 2017 and we used to ban people in chat but there was no way to remove them from actually being there. It was a common complaint to Twitch.

errant geode
#

if i want an advanced-ss macro to open a webpage, what action should i select?

fossil wyvern
#

what exactly do you mean by "open a webpage"

errant geode
#

like it opens a link

#

to the internet

#

not on my stream, just on my computer

#

not entirely sure if that's possible

fossil wyvern
#

I was about to say no, but as it happens, you actually can, use the "Run" action

errant geode
#

oh nice, thanks!

quiet bramble
#

Yeah, I think in general whether someone is asking if Advanced Scene Switcher can do something or not, or asking if well... well, if anything at all is possible ... just saying "yes" is a good bet for Advanced Scene Switcher 🙂

#

"can it ..." Yes. Yes it can.

#

😛

fossil wyvern
#

adv-ss official moto "well I thought it couldn't but I checked and it actually can"

#

actually just realised, the fact it can run any shell script means that the answer to "can I automatically delete the mkv file after it auto-remuxed to mp4" is "with adv-ss, yeah"

#

jesus fuck adv-ss can run any arbitrary script

#

at which point does it become skynet

quiet bramble
fossil wyvern
#

fair

quiet bramble
#

Advanced Scene Switcher is going to get so advanced that it ends up not only having it's own plugins, but its plugins themselves have their own plugins too.

fossil wyvern
#

lmao

quiet bramble
#

What'd be funny is if the Advanced Scene Switcher plugin plugins had their own fully fledged plugin manager with auto-updates etc. before OBS did. LOL

oblique gate
quiet bramble
wispy urchin
#

Soooo I'm new and need help 🤣

autumn lynx
#

does anyone know how to do virtual camera filter on obs 28 with droidcam plugin or something similar because the app i want to use the virtual camera with does not work with obs 28 virtual camera but works with obs 27 virtual camera

glacial pollen
#

Hey, I need help with the Source Record plugin

#

When I have 1 Source Record plugin for my Camera and 1 other for Gameplay the recording is just so laggy

#

any fix to that?

oblique yewBOT
glacial pollen
#

I tried that already

spiral ruin
glacial pollen
#

Yes

spiral ruin
#

Can you link it again? I'm scrolling back and not finding one right away.

glacial pollen
oblique yewBOT
# glacial pollen Here: https://obsproject.com/logs/izE4EzF3Vsftljbt

Log contains debug or verbose error messages (browser/ftl/directshow/etc), for a filtered version click here

🛑 Critical
  • MP4/MOV Recording
  • 79.7% CPU Encoder Overload
⚠️ Warning
  • Integrated GPU
  • 7.1% Rendering Lag
ℹ️ Info
  • Windows 10 21H2 (OK)
Hardware Check

Intel Core i5-8250U @ 1.60GHz - Possible bottleneck / Intel UHD Graphics 620 - Possible bottleneck

spiral ruin
#

Yeah... You'll have trouble doing 2 or more encoding sessions with that hardware.

glacial pollen
#

Yea

#

I'm just trying to do my Camera and Gameplay

#

Is there anyway to fix that?

spiral ruin
#

You need a better system. Something with a discrete GPU. Laptops that old aren't designed for the performance you need for one encoding session for recording, let alone 2 or more like you want to do.

glacial pollen
#

Okay thanks

old bay
#

Is there a new version of OBS virtual camera that is compatible with version 28.0.3?

old bay
#

hm

#

weird

#

it looks weird

mortal harbor
#

what specific features from the plugin did you need?

old bay
#

well uh

#

i dont want it looking like this

mortal harbor
#

and that's using the built in virtual camera, not the plugin?

old bay
#

mhm

mortal harbor
#

screenshot your virtual camera settings and your main OBS window.

old bay
#

I honestly have no clue whats going on with the camera

mortal harbor
#

the OBS preview window doesn't look that way?

old bay
#

Nope

#

Looks completely fine on the window

#

But the output into discord or anything else is

#

that

#

thing

mortal harbor
#

change your output resolution in settings>video to 1920x1080

old bay
#

It worked

#

Thank you lmao

willow jacinth
#

how can it be that under tools - elgato stream deck is displayed, although I have reinstalled obs?

bright sapphire
willow jacinth
#

if i do that then i have two entries

bright sapphire
#

@willow jacinth - need to remove the old plugin

willow jacinth
#

and how?

bright sapphire
#

Go to your plugin folder and delete the old one from there

willow jacinth
#

I have reinstalled obs, there can be no plugins at all

mortal harbor
#

reinstalling OBS doesn't matter, the stream deck plugin doesn't load from the OBS plugins folder.

willow jacinth
mortal harbor
#

yeah that screenshot doesn't change what i said.

willow jacinth
#

do you mean the folder under %appdata%

mortal harbor
#

i'm trying to remember where it loads from. maybe c:\program files\elgato\something

#

C:\ProgramData\obs-studio\plugins\StreamDeckPlugin here maybe

bright sapphire
#

It's also under Programs and Features in Control Panel

#

Best to always run OBS on C: drive / your main drive / partition

willow jacinth
#

@mortal harbor Thank you! But why does he install something on C: when I told him to install everything on F:? very confusing

mortal harbor
#

ask elgato, i'm not sure.

willow jacinth
#

especially since the ProgramData folder is also invisible

mortal harbor
#

OBS plays no part in the elgato plugin install process, it just loads it like any other plugin.

willow jacinth
#

what is obs-studio-hook? can i delete this?`😅

mortal harbor
#

i'm not sure why you'd think to randomly delete hidden folders.

willow jacinth
#

sry but I'm trying to delete everything from obs right now, reinstall this so hopefully it won't crash anymore

mortal harbor
#

oh

#

what do you mean when you say it crashes?

willow jacinth
#

obs-websocket settings under tools, is this also a plugin or does it belong to obs by default?

mortal harbor
#

it is built into OBS.

willow jacinth
#

when i close a game, then obs freezes

#

I have already been told that it does not seem to be due to obs, but to my system.

#

i'm looking for the cause right now and think if i reinstall obs it might help

mortal harbor
#

the last log you posted shows a few third party plugins which usually end up being the cause for this sort of thing.

#
01:10:23.994:     StreamFX.dll
01:10:23.994:     transition-table.dll
01:10:23.994:     StreamDeckPlugin.dll
01:10:23.994:     spectralizer.dll
01:10:23.995:     move-transition.dll```
willow jacinth
#

that's what i think too and that's why i want to get rid of all these plugins, which isn't that easy at all

#

my biggest mistake was probably not installing obs in C:.

#

How do I see if all plugins have been removed now?

oblique yewBOT
signal crystal
#

When I turn on the game capture in the source, it cannot appear of games in the screen of game capture. can you tell me how to fix it?

oblique yewBOT
oblique yewBOT
simple birch
#

hi

#

how to start obs

oblique yewBOT
wise palm
regal breach
glossy hatch
#

Hi
I am using StreamFX for show and hide transition and for some reasons in the beginning and at the end of the video It shifts to the side and then back when hiding it
The position of the source is not changed, when this "twitch" happening
And this bug appears when you applying transition shaders

vale vine
#

But it should be fixed in the next update or 2 of obs

regal breach
vale vine
#

👍

regal breach
#

is the workaround to turn off anti aliasing or something?

vale vine
#

Yep

regal breach
#

oh ok

#

@signal crystal

north arch
#

I am having an issue trying to get a chatbot to show up on my channel. i can pull it up to my stream but not to size i tried messing with prop;erties to size it to fit and it just wont work.

fossil wyvern
north arch
#

I am using stream elements as my bot but am trying to use the chatbox from stream labs because that is where i get my overlays. for some reason it just doesnt fit right. it only covers a 1/4 of it... i tried messing with the coding on it and it just never worked out

fossil wyvern
north arch
fossil wyvern
north arch
#

it wont let me size it right and the chat drops way down below the frame.

vale vine
#

I'd first crop the bounds close to the edge of that border. And then stretch it.

#

!crop

oblique yewBOT
#

To crop sources in OBS Studio, first reset the source to its default size by clicking on it and pressing ctrl+r. Then hold the alt key and drag the red box around the source you wish to crop. The sides will turn green to indicate they are cropped. Note that the preview must be unlocked in order to do this.

vale vine
#

To stretch after cropping, hold shift key while adjusting edges

#

Actually

#

Don't do that. Didn't realize the border part was also part of the browser source

#

You cant size properly inside of the streamlabs editor at all?

north arch
#

negative

vale vine
#

That seems dumb LULWW

#

I personally haven't touched SL stuff in a while.

north arch
#

right??? i dont care about the border at all... is there any other way to use it?

vale vine
#

If you dont want the border, why not just grab a transparent chat from another service that will let you adjust the size how ya want?

#

I've found stream elements editor to be fairly straightforward

north arch
#

any suggestions??? i havent found any videos from there they all lead straight to labs

vale vine
#

Stream elements. Then go to the overlays editor. Add in chat. Position/size as needed, drop url into obs as browser source

north arch
#

stream elements was great only thing was that it kept squishing all my lettering together but i figure out a way to get rid of my overlays and everything and started fresh with it and it looks freaking amazing!!!

vale vine
#

NICE JOB!

solar tiger
#

Good evening I have a question is it possible to add a dock on obs without internet link for example a window of a software that I use on computer ?

vagrant minnow
#

If it's already it's own window, why not just use the window?

solar tiger
#

it is to have it on obs to avoid going to the window

#

??

vagrant minnow
#

Then don't use display capture.

solar tiger
#

I do not understand what the screenshot comes in the subject

#

??

vagrant minnow
solar tiger
#

merci beaucoup

south vigil
#

does anyone know if OBS NDI has been updated to 4.9.2 for mac os on M1 proc

solar tiger
#

Thanks a lot

low island
#

Looking for sound filters that improve feel of the room

#

Do you know of any?

regal breach
vague shale
#

I am using OBS Studio 27.2.4 with Streamelements. I have tried downloading plugins like Tuna, but they are not showing in Tools. Is there a prereq file or something simple I am overlooking? I installed them in the 64 bit plugin folder.

mortal harbor
#

pretty much all current plugin releases are only compatible with v28 and above

vague shale
#

@mortal harbor I had tried v28, same issue. Also it took my smooth running Hunt Showdown stream made it choppy as all get out. Cannot figure out how to get it back to being smooth other than reverting version.

oblique yewBOT
# vague shale <@456226577798135808> I had tried v28, same issue. Also it took my smooth runnin...

A clean log file is required to help fix your issue. To make a clean log file, please follow these steps:

  1. Restart OBS
  2. Start your stream/recording for at least 30 seconds (or however long it takes for the issue to happen). Make sure you replicate any issues as best you can, which means having any games/apps open and captured, etc.
  3. Stop your stream/recording.
  4. Select Help > Log Files > Upload Current Log File. Copy the URL and paste it here.
plain geyser
# mortal harbor pretty much all current plugin releases are only compatible with v28 and above

Thanks for this small but crucial piece of information.

I've had issues with installing plugins the last few weeks and couldn't figure out why.

As a developer I thought that if backwards compatibility was broken it should say so, but on the plugins I've downloaded it doesn't.

But downloading the version before adding support to OBS 28 made the plugins work 🙂

So again, thank you so much 🙂

solar dust
#

The backward compatibility was broken only for plugins relying on the Qt5 framework.

#

So the plugin you had a issue with didn't have this breakage.

twin basalt
clever plaza
#

Anyone have what feels like a " Leak Issue " when you have Source Record Installled? ( Latest versions of Source Record and OBS )

winged canopy
civic pawn
#

When you realize you can't use OBS 28+ at all because it doesn't have NDI support 💔

vapid charm
#

Officially it doesn't

#

Unofficially it does.

civic pawn
#

Oh...really? How so?

vapid charm
#

While the official people are working on an update there's this "alpha".

#

Emphasis on alpha.

civic pawn
#

Sweet. And do BOTH PC's need to have that version or can I leave one on pre-obs 28 and use the official version there?

vapid charm
#

I'd say no unfortunately

#

So either update both or stay on 27.

civic pawn
#

Fair. I have updated my laptop to 28 and got the noti that NDI was out of date. Hadn't done my PC yet.

#

Overall, I'm assuming OBS 28 is worth an update to?

mortal harbor
#

i would say it's always smart to be on the most recent version. it's the only one we offer support for.

oblique yewBOT
#

Self-advertisement or advertisement for others is not allowed on this server unless it's directly relevant to a discussion or question. Please read the rules in the #rules channel.

clever plaza
mortal harbor
#

it's a nitro feature and may still be rolling out.

clever plaza
#

Anyone else having basically a " Leak " of some sort with " Source Record " ? ( OBS FPS Goes very low/laggy )

clever plaza
wet moth
#

Another thing, do you solve doubts about LioranBoard 2 here?

high fern
#

anyone have a fix for OBS or Streamlabs Virtual Cameras not showing up in Discord?

#

The only solution i've found is:

#
sudo codesign --remove-signature /Applications/Discord.app/Contents/Frameworks/Discord\ Helper\ \(GPU\).app /Applications/Discord.app/Contents/Frameworks/Discord\ Helper\ \(Plugin\).app /Applications/Discord.app/Contents/Frameworks/Discord\ Helper\ \(Renderer\).app /Applications/Discord.app/Contents/Frameworks/Discord\ Helper.app
#

which causes the app to no longer be able to open at all 😂

reef heron
#

I just recently switched over to OBS from SLOBS, what r some essential plugins? I’m new to streaming

mortal harbor
oblique yewBOT
quiet bramble
#

Some of the more popular and useful plugins include StreamFX, OBS Shaderfilter, all of Exeldro's 10,000 plugins, Advanced Scene Switcher to name a few, but there are a lot more that are potentially useful. Just make sure that the plugin explicitly says that it is compatible with whatever version of OBS you are using first before trying it (or they wont work).

patent birch
#

for example i got my nintendo switch and got my laptop and i would need to get up to the TV and switch it to different settings each time.

#

going back and forth from smashladder to my Ultimate.

rapid pulsar
#

using the nvidia audio noise removal for my mic sounds good but has an obvious delay, any way to fix this?

#

and I'm using the plugin IN obs28 not using nvidia broadcast as my mic source

untold jay
#

@rapid pulsaredit > advanced audio properties, change sync offset

rapid pulsar
#

hm doesn't seem to make a difference

untold jay
#

@rapid pulsaryou won't hear it yourself, but streams and recordings will be affected

rapid pulsar
#

how to test how much offset to use then? recording?

untold jay
#

ya, make a few test recordings to dial in the correct offset value

rapid pulsar
#

seems to be pretty unstable too, making my obs crash a few times

#

ok offset helped ty ❤️

untold jay
#

uh, no, sync offset has always been stable, but if you're having such issues, we can try to troubleshoot that too

rapid pulsar
#

oh nah I mean the nvidia noise removal seems unstable

mortal harbor
#

!log @rapid pulsar

oblique yewBOT
#

@rapid pulsar

A current log file is required to help fix your issue. Please post a link to your current log file.

  • In OBS select Help > Log Files > Upload Current Log File.
  • Click Copy URL and then paste the link here.
rapid pulsar
#

doesn't say anything in the log unfortunately I checked but maybe it's because I was turning it off/on/off/on a lot and overloaded it

mortal harbor
#

the log was for me to check, not you 🙂

oblique yewBOT
mortal harbor
#

try adding your mic with nothing else but an nvidia filter. i see a lot of VSTs in the log.

rapid pulsar
#

I just used RNNoise and messed with my eq and it's fine, thanks though

mortal harbor
#

!log

oblique yewBOT
#

A current log file is required to help fix your issue. Please post a link to your current log file.

  • In OBS select Help > Log Files > Upload Current Log File.
  • Click Copy URL and then paste the link here.
little sandal
#

Quick question regarding Advanced Scene Switcher... can you nest macro conditions, like if A and (B or C) => action or would it be better to split it up into two macros if A and B => action / if A and C => action?

regal breach
#

so you could make that B or C and A to execute the or first

#

you could also group conditions by having a separate macro with only the conditions you want to group, then in the other macro, you add a macro condition that says If conditions of Macro B are true

#

so it would be "A and macro B is true"

little sandal
#

Okay, thank you.

dark hornet
#

ey i have a mini issue with win-capture-audio, and it is that it gets the volume a bit low

#

top one is the general capture output audio that comes with obs

#

the bottom one is the plugin win-capture-audio

regal breach
# dark hornet

that's because on some devices, the speakers are actually boosted

#

like +10dB can be added, or some audio drivers enhance the audio

#

and what obs captures as desktop audio is already modified by the drivers/OS (which one modifies it, i'm not really sure)

dark hornet
#

so

#

to fix this

#

what can i do

regal breach
#

well, what are you looking to do? increase the audio of the win-capture-audio?

dark hornet
#

i was testing things

#

and with the speakers

#

i get a normal audio in the win-capture-audio

regal breach
#

so what do you want?

dark hornet
#

thats with speakers

#

same levels

#

with my headsets

#

it gets low

#

but only in the win-acpture-audiop

regal breach
#

so you want the win-capture-audio to be louder? YES or NO?

dark hornet
dark hornet
#

if i increase the db

#

ill get static

regal breach
#

that's not how it works

regal breach
# dark hornet

you can see "Music" here has lower volume so you would either increase the volume of Music, or lower the volume of the Desktop Audio

#

it's one or the other

#

and no you won't get audio clipping

dark hornet
#

hm

#

ill do that but still not a good fix i think

#

i still dont know why with the desktop audio it works normal but with headsets the plugin lower it down

regal breach
#

right click sound icon in the Windows taskbar, then click Sounds

#

go to the Playback tab, select your speakers, then click properties

#

in Enhancements tab tick "Disable all sound effects"

wet moth
#

Hi guys, anyone who can help me with Lionarboard2 (SAMMI)? I have it all set up but when I open SAMMI and OBS, SAMMI automatically closes me OBS to reconnect because it "loses connection". Does anyone know what I can do?

dark hornet
regal breach
dark hornet
#

it does not have enhancements

regal breach
#

screenshot yours

dark hornet
regal breach
#

translate those tabs for me please

dark hornet
#

general

#

levels

#

advanced options

#

special sound

#

but i have all disable

regal breach
#

show levels and special sounds

dark hornet
#

levels is at 40

#

but cause i have it like that

#

to not explode my ears

#

if i rise it to 100 it does not change in obs

#

its just the headsets lvls

#

and special sound is deactivated as i said

#

ive tried everything to fix i this

#

nothing works

#

ill get the +13db in filters and happy with that

#

not a fix but

tardy warren
#

Are there any obs plugins for adding screen overlays during LIVE streaming.
If not is there any one who is ready to build. DM me for mor e details

undone hemlock
#

i installed audio monitor 0.8.1 plugin for my obs studio 27.2.4 but the plugin is not showing up when i click on filters. Any solutions? #plugins-and-tools

regal breach
undone hemlock
gaunt zealot
runic sail
#

Anyone have experience with Soundtrack by twitch? The audio doesnt go through the audio bar it generates, and after I uninstalled and tried reinstalling the pluggin, it doesnt work at all anymore.

quiet bramble
# undone hemlock where can i get a plugin for 27.2.4 (sorry for the crosspost)

It can be a little tricky, but most plugins as they are updated over time, only maintain compatibility with the current version of OBS, which means those of us who stay on older versions for whatever reasons need to carefully check the version of the plugin and its compatibility information to make sure it is compatible with the version of OBS we're using, and then never update it to something newer, as plugin devs almost never provide their plugins for older versions of OBS as it is too much effort and too confusing for people to figure out which thing they need to download. You can usually look at the github repository of a given plugin and go through all of the older releases, reading the documentation of each one for indication of what version of OBS it is compatible with.

#

What I do here, is have OBS downloads folder, and then OBS-plugins-<version> folders where I download plugins compatible with that version of OBS so if I need to reinstall or set up a new portable install, I don't have to re-research what version of which plugins to use in that version of OBS.

#

The downside of using an older OBS release in this manner is that we miss out on new features and bugfixes of the updated plugins, but c'est la vie as they say. 🙂

untold jay
#

@quiet bramble but you also miss out on the newly added bugs, too, so there's that

quiet bramble
#

yup

#

New bugs and new "features". 😉

#

I'd love to stay on the most recent version of OBS at all times TBH, but so much is changing over time that it is a bit harder and harder to keep up with it all when you have a complex setup.

#

The smart thing to do in that case for me at least is to adopt "if it ain't broke, don't fix it".

untold jay
#

i usually only update when i know it's stable and all the major issues have been ironed out, and the lack of stable streamfx is certainly a major issue for me

quiet bramble
#

So I still use 2.6.11 for my most complex stuff that I have setup, 2.7.4 for a much simpler streaming setup, and soon 2.8.0 or 2.8.1 for experimental streaming also.

untold jay
#

apparently Xaymar can't quite figure out what's up with the currently bundled ffmpeg build, but these issues don't reproduce with a newer ffmpeg build, so maybe obs-studio will need another ffmpeg update? but that also means obs-ffmpeg-afilter will break again

quiet bramble
#

Yeah, having a reliable StreamFX is absolutely critical for me, so any OBS release that requires a new StreamFX and some other plugins to which they do not have the same level of stability/features/compatibility I can't adopt.

#

It's comparable in a sense to why the OBS developers took so long to update to Qt6 or newer CEF. The newer libraries had issues that they couldn't deal with for a long time so they pushed it off until the future.

#

Eventually they were able to integrate the new deps and resolve longstanding issues that prevented them from being able to update.

untold jay
#

did you mean qt6?

quiet bramble
#

oops, yeah QT6

#

Also in my case, if need be, I can use the latest OBS to stream to a given platform, but use an older release to composite, and pass video between the two with Spout et al.

#

I'm all about having my cake and eating it by the fistful at the same time. 🙂

#

I've tested that out, compositing on 26.1.1 and streaming to YT with 27.2.4.

gaunt zealot
runic sail
#

I get that. Thats why Im trying to use soundtrack that twitch specifically made. So I uninstalled the pluggin, and it is still broken. It was fine a few days ago.

glad oak
#

Hey, i've been trying to redownload my old obs setup that was using the obs 2.7 release and i'm having some trouble installing some plugins, specifically move transition and transition table. Did something happen and transition plugins don't work anymore or might i be forgetting to install something?

vapid charm
#

Assuming you meant 27 are you using the correct version for it?

mortal harbor
glad oak
#

yeah, but i tried updating to v28 and some of the plugins just did not work or weren't updated yet so i prefer to keep streaming on 27 until everything is fine.

And i am using the correct version of those plugins, always checking the minimum version of obs they work one and it seems fine. I might just download an older version of the plugins and see if they work and the "minimum" is wrong.

mortal harbor
#

what plugins specifically do you use that don't work on v28? it's been out for quite a bit at this point so everything is working apart from some edge cases.

glad oak
#

for example, when i downloaded streamFX on v28 it didn't have the 3d transform filter anymore, and i couldn't understand why it was happening

#

i'll backup everything and try the update again

mortal harbor
#

yeah weird, working fine on my end.

#

the streamFX install notes do say that you need to totally uninstall your current version of streamFX before installing the compatible alpha for v28.

#

!plugins there's a full compatibility list here

oblique yewBOT
glad oak
#

oh wow

#

it worked now, at least streamfx did

#

let's try the transition one

#

while i'm doing that, is there a way to change the visual of obs to the old one?

#

Yeah, everything is working now, seems like i'm just a stubborn baby

vapid charm
#

Assuming you mean theme go to settings and change the them option to dark.

glad oak
#

nice, thanks

vapid charm
#

While I'm thinking of it: is there any way to manage which output device renders the audio for VLC source? I'm wanting to manage it via my GoXLR and I just need to be able to get it set to a specific routing where I can split the volume separately for myself and viewers.

untold jay
#

@vapid charm if you dont' mind running obs-ndi and 2 copies of obs-studio, you can use that + audio monitoring

quiet bramble
vapid charm
#

Oooh. That is exactly what I want.

undone hemlock
wary belfry
#

does anybody know what OBS-camera is and why its messing up my other programs that need the camera? it's not virtual camera because i already ininstalled that

mortal harbor
vale vine
#

But it shouldn't stop what I'm assuming is a built in laptop camera from working.

#

Regardless of virtual cam plug in or built in variant.

mortal harbor
#

agreed but they wanted to remove it regardless so i figured i'd point that out. they have stated they ran the uninstaller already so i'm not sure what else would need to be done as i'm not really familiar with the plugin.

wary belfry
#

virtual camera was the first thing i uninstalled

#

OBS was the second

#

this is still there

#

preventing me from taking a job interview

#

i have no built in camera

vale vine
#

It's not preventing anything. Having any of the virtual cams doesn't block built in cam from working

wary belfry
#

except that for whatever reason chrome defaults to OBS-camera and wont allow me to change it on the site

vale vine
#

Does the built in camera show up in windows devoce manger?

wary belfry
#

i dont have a built in camera

#

i have an external camera

vale vine
#

Does it show up in device manager

wary belfry
#

no

vale vine
#

Then how is that an obs issue?

wary belfry
#

look at the screenshot

vale vine
#

Sounds like a hardware issue to me

wary belfry
#

the device i need is right there

#

but theres something obs related thats being defaulted to

mortal harbor
wary belfry
#

i tried 7 browsers and finally got it working in firefox

#

sorry if i was coarse

mortal harbor
#

so you don't want to remove OBS-camera?

wary belfry
#

if you know how, it will be helpful

mortal harbor
#

see my previous comment

wary belfry
#

done

mortal harbor
#

paste regsvr32 /u "C:\Program Files\obs-studio\bin\32bit\obs-virtualsource.dll" and press enter

#

this may not work i'm following very old instructions.

pale grove
#

hello
please help me
I just uninstalled and reinstalled OBS because I have the problem that my obs freeze every stream several times
now I have the problem that I can separate my audio tracks, but can no longer add an audio track for obs itself, which means you don't hear any alerts in the stream

anyone can help out ?

oblique yewBOT
wary belfry
#

i think because i already nuked everything out of that folder it cant find the DLL

#

thanks anyway

delicate rock
#

someone know a audio plugin to make my microphone audio glitch? just for fun

small epoch
#

I am getting a black screen using the OBS background removal plugin I have been all over trying to fix this and can't find a solution. Please help me

#

When I move the threshold all it does is eventually bring me back with all of my background. I am going nuts

oblique yewBOT
# small epoch

A current log file is required to help fix your issue. Please post a link to your current log file.

  • In OBS select Help > Log Files > Upload Current Log File.
  • Click Copy URL and then paste the link here.
small epoch
oblique yewBOT
# small epoch https://obsproject.com/logs/zWkKtUs3YAvlrCTN

Log contains debug or verbose error messages (browser/ftl/directshow/etc), for a filtered version click here

🛑 Critical
  • Outdated Plugins (1)
⚠️ Warning
  • Browser Not Accelerated
ℹ️ Info
  • Windows 11 22H2 (OK)
  • Not Admin
  • No Output Session
Hardware Check

Intel Core i7-9700K @ 3.60GHz - OK! / GeForce RTX 2080 SUPER - OK!

small epoch
#

I don't know what that means I update when it tells me to

mortal harbor
small epoch
#

I tried that isn't working either @mortal harbor

#

it says no updates are avaliable

mortal harbor
#

it's a black screen as well?

small epoch
#

yes

mortal harbor
#

send a screenshot with the filter turned off so i can see what the camera feed looks like.

small epoch
#

one sec

mortal harbor
#

sorry if you're shy 😄 need to see it as i had similar results under certain circumstances.

small epoch
#

yea I am trying to move stuff around stand by

mortal harbor
#

i'm really not certain, hmmm.

#

have you tested the NVIDIA Broadcast application before?

small epoch
#

no

mortal harbor
#

i'm interested to see if it works in there if you don't mind testing.

hard jay
#

The log seems to indicate that none of the broadcast effects are installed, or are partially installed.

#

[NVIDIA RTX VIDEO FX]: enabled, redistributable found it finds the redist, but all the filters are showing: Unable to get model filename modnet_simple.onnx from plugin.

#

indicating some kind of install issue, running the broadcast application to test if it works there might trigger an update/download of the missing components

small epoch
#

how do i fix that? when I go to update it says there are no updates available

mortal harbor
#

ah, i only saw 12:29:34.169: [NVIDIA RTX VIDEO FX]: enabled, redistributable found

#

!nvafx running this installer again should fix it up for you.

oblique yewBOT
#

The redistributables required for the NVIDIA Noise and Background Removal filters can be found here: https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/geforce/broadcasting/broadcast-sdk/resources/

Once both are installed,

The NVIDIA Noise Removal option will appear as part of the "Noise Suppression" filter, alongside RNNoise and Speex.
The NVIDIA Background Removal option will appear as its own filter under "Effect Filters."

small epoch
#

So are you saying I need to update the background removal plugin? Because I did that already. I'm sorry I don't know what this is saying to do

hard jay
#

Not the plugin, the nvidia software itself.

mortal harbor
#

i'm saying to click the link above, scroll down, and press the "download" button in the video effects section for your 20 series card.

#

or just click that and run it once it downloads.

small epoch
#

nvidia broadcast is doing the same thing

#

OMG I got it to work in NVIDIA

#

is there still a way to trouble shoot OBS? Which is better Nvidia or OBS?

hard jay
#

If it's working in broadcast, close broadcast, restart OBS, and see if it's working there now.

small epoch
#

It doesn't look like I can record in broadcast? Am I missing something

#

ok one sec

#

In OBS it goes back to the black screen again

hard jay
#

broadcast is basically a "passthrough"

#

can you grab a new log?

small epoch
#

yep one sec

oblique yewBOT
# small epoch https://obsproject.com/logs/1sY_wRqx7LgT3Ias

Log contains debug or verbose error messages (browser/ftl/directshow/etc), for a filtered version click here

🛑 Critical
  • Outdated Plugins (1)
⚠️ Warning
  • Browser Not Accelerated
ℹ️ Info
  • Windows 11 22H2 (OK)
  • Not Admin
  • No Output Session
Hardware Check

Intel Core i7-9700K @ 3.60GHz - OK! / GeForce RTX 2080 SUPER - OK!

hard jay
#

Hm. Same thing.

#

You do have a broken install of StreamFX though and that plugin is notorious for messing with nvidia SDK stuff.

small epoch
#

Ok so how do I remove it

#

I am not using it right now

hard jay
#

there should be an uninstaller in programs and features like a normal application, I believe.

small epoch
#

one sec

hard jay
#

I don't know exactly though, I don't use the plugin myself because it causes issues for me.

small epoch
#

I just don't know enough about this stuff so I am trying to remove it

#

Holy Shit!!! i got it to work in OBS

#

so I was logged into stream elements so I logged out, and then I changed my filter from background removal to NVIDIA background removal

#

That wasn't working before so it had to be what I changed in NVIDIA broad cast that made it finally work!!!!!

#

Now I have to figure out how to put something behind me but I will google and youtube that unless someone can tell me how real quick

hard jay
#

depends on what you want behind you

small epoch
#

at this point anythjing!

hard jay
#

if it's just an image, just add an image source, size it to the same size as the camera source, and make sure the camera is above the image in the source list.

#

the source list is the layers, so sources at the top of the list show on top of others, but the background removal will add the transparency, so you can see the image behind it.

small epoch
#

so if I just right clicked on image and hit transform/fit to screen as I did on the video that is what you are meaning when you say the same size as camera source rigth?

hard jay
#

yup yup that should work

small epoch
#

Ok thank you to you and Yolo for all your help. I have been working on this issues for months with so much aggravation!!

stoic oxide
#

anyone know a plugin that logs u out of the streaming service u use once u turn off computer? or is there an actual setting to do that

quiet bramble
#

If you turn off the computer that is streaming, there will be no data going to the streaming service and it will timeout the connection and the live broadcast will automatically go down.

stoic oxide
#

i no that but like once i close computer it logs me out of twitch for example, disconnects my account from obs until i log in after restart

wise palm
#

Probly not the right place for this Report, but with Win Audio Capture - The Capture All button, if used while Streaming, crashes OBS rather hard. Seems to work fine if checked when not Live

hard jay
#

Pretty sure that's a known issue if you're talking about the plugin version, you can check their github though.

mellow lynx
#

Do we have any move transition gurus here?

quiet bramble
#

There might be someone present who is able to help figure out how to do something with move-transition, but whom does not self-identify as being a "guru" with it. You might be better off mentioning what problem you are wanting to solve etc. as someone might be more likely to respond, than to think of themselves as a guru.

broken lagoon
#

Hi, Dont know if this is the correct thread, but since I updated to the last OBS-version I cant find, or update NDI source. So when someone calls from skype i cant "get" that picture in to the screen for a video. I only get the sound. Someone who can help me?

analog ruin
#

there isnt official support for the usual NDI plugin on the latest version. There are some other 3rd party (4th party?) that has made a compatible version, and there is also an early build of the updated NDI (5 instead of 4), but im not sure I would recommend doing either if NDI is crucial for production. If it is, it might be better to wait a while longer on OBS 27 @broken lagoon

#

if you'd like to try one of those other builds, I can point you in the right direction

broken lagoon
#

Thanks alot @analog ruin for your answer. But is there any other way or system to use, that is better? I mean alot of people are using OBS and Skype to both record sound and live video? 🙂

analog ruin
#

the skype ndi integration is really cool, and I dont think there is anythign quite like it 😅 If that is a crucial part of production, I'd still say its best to wait a bit more (on 27)

broken lagoon
#

Ok=) Yeah its crucial, since the ones who listen, only can hear my guest and not see them=)

analog ruin
#

then I'd say the best option is to downgrade and stay on the latest OBS 27 until the new NDI release comes along. I've been testing it, and its been great, but its not supported yet, missing some features etc. Not ETA on release tho

broken lagoon
#

Before I had NDI as a source, and now its gone - thats why it doesnt work. Ok, maybe I have to go back, as you say, to the old version.. Strange that a new version doesnt support NDI as a source.

obsidian agate
broken lagoon
analog ruin
#

its a bit unfortunate, but they are working on it 🙂

broken lagoon
#

Thanks alot for your time and answers @analog ruin Atleast I can stop trying to make it work, haha!

civic crescent
#

Hello I am getting those very strange crashes recently
I think it is linked to Source Record, since my OBS crashes after I turn off the record of a source that was on for a few hours

I stream with CPU, record with GPU, source record is also done with GPU
The GPU is not maxed
CPU average between 80/90%

The crashes happen midstream

Log before first crash : https://obsproject.com/logs/bGYaC4og9Y6N-wtQ
Second crash : https://obsproject.com/logs/mCiaV5YGVfHJXBGn
Crash after having ended stream and closed OBS : https://obsproject.com/logs/ngiPFwJ55YgPvssz

Crash logs :
First : https://pastebin.com/VKCduSDm
Second : https://pastebin.com/VKCduSDm

oblique yewBOT
frozen grail
#

since NDI is currently shabusted with v28 but I like other v28 features - can anyone recommend an NDI alternative that works? Low latency isn't urgent as I just use it to feed cats treats as a channel point reward and for small little RL break things

obsidian agate
frozen grail
#

the camera is either my android phoen or this old iphone 6 I have

#

I am not going to lug a laptop around to blast a scene over lol

obsidian agate
#

Teleport is not an option then.

frozen grail
#

yeah decent suggestion for a lot of folks using NDI between two PCs

#

not applicable for my workflow though

spiral ruin
#

I use Droidcam and VDO.ninja for my re-purposed phones-now-webcams.

frozen grail
#

I'll have to check those out

#

I looked at droidcam before NDI, I hate IOS, but something wasn't great about it compared to NDI

#

but anything is better than nothing 🙂

crystal echo
#

Hello! i need help, maybe someone here can help. ive been trying set up streamloots for my stream, but it dont work. I have installed obs27.2.4 from a video i watched, ive looked up videos and troubleshooting guides and tried everything i could think of but it still dont work, not sure what im doing wrong or missing. Although i did learn a lot along the way in the last 3 days

vivid sapphire
crystal echo
#

i did follow this guide, but im still at a standoff, i feel that im missing something somwhere

#

the alerts are not comming through nor the overlays

vale vine
#

worked here.

#

sure you copied the correct url when making the browser source?

frozen grail
#

that's even easier 🙂

vapid charm
#

@crystal echo While official support is off for the weekend being M-F you can always ask someone in their server for help. Invite code is 54Uvqs7hP7

agile mountain
#

Hello Boys! If someone knows this please help. I would love to setup ways to have obs react to ingame content. Imagine Im low on health i have red camera, or if Im healing my camera turns something else.

If something like this is possible I would improve my stream in several ways. Does anyone know a way to search for this?

I know theres a streamer outthere that does this on fortnite. (I dont play fortnite)

How can i search for this? I googled but cant find so i ask for help here and on the forums

analog ruin
#
  1. The game supports game states that you can get at. This is unlikely, as i think it's limited to a few source games.
  2. Write a detection that is aimed at some UI element, like health bar. This will be very difficult. Pixel detection probably
vale vine
#

There's another that did it with minecraft. Relied on game api

#

EposVox had an interview with the MC one

analog ruin
#

There is 👀 or were they somehow watching a memory adress :0

vale vine
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

#

Been a while since I watched

autumn pond
obsidian agate
#

Yes. Scrolling down to the previous version, v1.1.0, shows that it has been updated to be compatible with v28 of OBS

autumn pond
obsidian agate
#

Dunno, i dont use either

civic belfry
#

Hello! I am wondering if any mac users have been able to get streamdeck to work with OBS? the plugin version is 5.3.2.27 but the streamdeck software is now 5.3.3 so they won't connect!

#

when I uninstall and reinstall it still puts the old plugin version in the obs folder for whatever reason

oblique yewBOT
civic belfry
#

Fair enough!

mortal harbor
#

Hello, does anyone know of some stream chat overlays for when Im streaming I can see the chat on my screen whilst playing the game so that I dont have to buy another monitor that will be used just for that?

uncut isle
mortal harbor
#

Yeah I was thinking of doing that

#

Probably will

#

Someone did give me something maybe a month ago or something

uncut isle
#

Another solution you could try is see-through windows.

mortal harbor
#

What is that?

uncut isle
#

It's a program that can make any window(you can choose which ones) into a semi-transparent window.
It also has an option to make the windows click-through so that you don't click on them whilst playing a game.

mortal harbor
#

Okay

uncut isle
#

And if you're capturing an application instead of your entire screen, then the viewers won't even have to see it, and can enjoy the gameplay without being interrupted by you looking at the chat.

mortal harbor
#

Hmmm

#

This obs stuff is confusing

#

Ive used it before and had no problems

#

Would you mind if we do like a vc or something so I can share my screen and if you can help me that would be great

uncut isle
#

I would if I were allowed to be on my stuff past nine pm, but I've only got one minute left.
Maybe send me a message(DM) and we can do it tomorrow.

mortal harbor
#

Oh alr cool

#

Ill try to do it tomorrow

wise palm
red light
#

I can't install stream FX, could you help me? 😦

vapid charm
#

2 things

#

Are you sure you're using tthe correct version for your OBS version?

#

Actually just 1.

modest mango
#

hello guys. I want to try and build/upgrade (if will be possible) the old obs-virtualcam for obs v28+
however... i can't figure out how to configure DepsPath (path): FFmpeg folder in OBS dependencies package

i tried set DepsPath="D:/OBS/obs-virtualcam/obs-build-dependencies/windows-deps-2022-08-02-x64" and other variants, but it was not successful

can anyone help me figure this out?

oblique yewBOT
#

Welcome to the official OBS Community Discord server! Unfortunately, our support volunteers can only provide support in English. Most of our support documents and guides are also only in English. If you feel comfortable using a service like Google Translate, feel free to use that to send messages to us. We'll do our best to understand your intent, and we'll try to help you as much as we can. google_translate Translate

agile spade
spiral ruin
lucid galleon
#

hello someone could help me, I want to put music in my obs, the problem is that the new plug which is in beta version to capture windows. Spotify is not recognizing me and what selection the pug in captured the name of the application and creates the channel for me but the audio does not come out through the bar created.

agile spade
spiral ruin
agile spade
#

hmm yes i see

willow jacinth
#

Hi I wanted to ask if there is a plugin that can play videos in a playlist?

agile spade
wise palm
# agile spade does anyone know what the difference is between these two tools for multi platfo...

I've used Restream before, it used to be sweet til they gimped the service to an insulting & laughable degree.
The difference is Restream let's you stream to 2 platforms at once for free (Used to be like 8), and you only process/encode/upload ONE Stream.
Something like Multiple RTMP Plugin let's you do a different resolution, bitrate, ect & push a 2nd Stream to another platform (Not sure how many, but I know it's more than 3)
If you have the upload speed for it, and the processing power to pull it off, I reccomend Multiple RTMP Plugin.
Using Multiple RTMP Plugin you can push a beautiful 1440p Stream to YouTube, a nice 720p Stream to Twitch, and other services, each with their own settings & quality rates.
If you don't mind paying, and only have so much upload speed - Restream is your friend, if you felt so inclined, use Restream in conjunction with other similar services to maximize your reach/minimize processing power required, if you use the Custom RTMP option you can link multiple services such as Restream together (LIVEPUSH is another decent one)
I hope you learned something 😄

agile spade
#

ye already decided to go with the plugin to check it out

wise palm
tiny burrow
#

can someone help us with obs ndi plugin , the new verion of obs

crystal mesa
#

so i have a generic question it is sort of related to OBS but also streamlabs... so i am just looking for a way to have asthetically pleasing looking graphics on my stream showing my last three follows. currently i am using one and it works fine but it's kind of ugly. is it possible to get nice looking free ones or are all the good ones pay only? ty

spiral ruin
crystal mesa
# spiral ruin Finding something you like or consider "nice-looking" may mean searching through...

right ok.. thanks a lot for your answer. so i am looking through the streamlabs website. there are some good free ones. do you know if to use any of the good looking free ones i am obligated to download streamlabs desktop? and if i do, can i still use OBS or are they going to try to make me use their service instead of OBS? i really don't want to use another service, i really like OBS it has always worked great for me

#

right now i just use the streamlabs dashboard in my browser and it works fine, no need to download anything

spiral ruin
crystal mesa
#

but like i said, the event list is kind of not really nice and the chat is kind of blurry and weird looking

crystal mesa
#

thanks a lot it's appreciated

spiral ruin
vestal gust
#

Hello, I don't know if this is the right channel to ask this question:
Is there a way to select certain sources in the VOD and not others?

For example: I have a streaming show, I want to show my alerts notifications source live, but not on the VOD. Thanks.

gaunt zealot
gaunt zealot
oblique yewBOT
#

If you need help or have questions about OBS, check out our #support-portal first!

vestal gust
vestal gust
gaunt zealot
#

All you need to do is enable the second audio track in OBS while Twitch is your configured streaming service, then map your audio sources to those tracks.

#

Just keep in mind that VODs won't save you from DMCA strikes

quiet bramble
# agile spade does multi streaming cost more resources? https://obsproject.com/forum/resources...

Yep, if you are streaming from your computer to multiple remote platforms at the same time you will have an outbound connection to each platform requiring the full bitrate you're using. So if you are streaming with 6Mbps for example, and you want to stream to 4 platforms, you will need 6Mbps * 4 = 24Mbps upload bandwidth for the stream. Also, since you should never generally stream more than half of your upload bandwidth because other programs use some of it also, and the Internet is "up to" rather than "guaranteed", you would need to have a reliable 50Mbps upload to do this.

#

Another way to think of it is take your ISP advertised "up to" upload speed, divide it by 2 to get the effective max upload speed, then divide that by the number of streaming services to get the effective max speed per service. Of course you also have to honour any individual streaming service's max ingest speed too.

#

That ballparks what you can do at least.

vestal gust
quiet bramble
#

A lot of people do not have high bandwidth upload speed to deal with that, so they use a service like restream.

gaunt zealot
tiny burrow
#

Please someone help me with websocket for OBS new version

spiral ruin
#

What help do you need with the websocket?

forest arrow
#

hi ,i want to know how to change a URL window transparency automatically 。

quiet bramble
#

If you're meaning in a Browser Source loaded webpage, you'd have to modify the CSS for it in the OBS properties dialog, or alternatively modify the web page's CSS directly. Might be more of a question for #stream-setup perhaps.

sudden zodiac
#

can someone help me install move transition plugin? does not work for me

#

no tutorials online

quiet bramble
#

You just have to run the EXE file and choose the correct path to your OBS installation, after confirming that the version of move-transition (or any plugin for that matter) is compatible with the version of OBS you are running, usually listed in the system requirements for the plugin or the OBS Version requirement.

sudden zodiac
quiet bramble
#

Help is provided right here in text chat on this server where everyone can see it and potentially weigh in, and where the moderators can moderate.

quiet hazel
sudden zodiac
#

okay 👍 i show you what ive done in screenshots

#

i also installed the visual c++ thing and still not working

oblique yewBOT
sudden zodiac
#

log file?

#

how do i do this

oblique yewBOT
sudden zodiac
#

i fixed all issues

#

still not working

#

😢

quiet bramble
#

You're using an outdated version of OBS, and the move-transition plugin you are trying to use is made for OBS 28.0. You either need to upgrade OBS to version 28 (which may break your setup as all plugins need to be updated and may not have updated versions available), or you need to downgrade move-transition to a version that is made to work with OBS 27.0. Unfortunately the "OBS Version" mentioned on the move-transition plugin pages is inaccurate (it says 25.0+ on it for example and the current plugin is built for OBS 28).

sudden zodiac
#

i just did this

#

i updated

#

wait im confused, it says version 27.0.0 on my obs but i just updated to latest version

quiet bramble
#

@weak escarp Might need to update the "Minimum OBS version required" for move-transition on the wiki, if I'm assuming correctly that it will only work with version 28

#

You might have multiple versions of OBS installed simultaneously and the icon you're using to start OBS is starting an older version rather than the one you installed.

sudden zodiac
#

let me check

quiet bramble
#

You can look at the shortcut properties to see the details of what binary executable is being started and where it is located.

sudden zodiac
#

im using 64 bit right now

#

so i have 64 bit downloaded but also 32 bit

my 64 bit is on version 27.0.0
my 32 bit is on 27.2.4

#

neither are on 28

#

how do i update to 28

quiet bramble
#

Having multiple versions of OBS installed at the same time can confuse the plugin installers to install them in the wrong place if you just accept the default directory. You need to make sure the directory it is installing the plugin to is the correct OBS installation you plan to use it with.

sudden zodiac
#

it does not give me an option where to install it

#

can i just uninstall 32 bit version? i dont know how to do this though

quiet bramble
#

In Windows Settings -> Apps, you can uninstall any programs/plugins which were installed via using a proper EXE/MSI file installer package. Any plugins installed manually by dropping the files out of a zip file into the OBS installation can not be uninstalled and have to be removed manually by knowing which files were put where, and deleting them individually.

sudden zodiac
#

it only show one obs

#

but when i search here it shows 2

quiet bramble
#

Right now it is best to use 64bit OBS 27.2.4 if you use various plugins, unless you can confirm each plugin is compatible with OBS 28, in which case OBS 28 might work out. There are a number of plugins not yet updated to work with OBS 28 however, such as NDI, StreamFX and others.

sudden zodiac
#

how do i update my obs 64 bit?

quiet bramble
#

Downloading the installer for OBS and running it like a new install.

sudden zodiac
#

doing this now

#

will it break / overwrite anything?

quiet bramble
#

that's possible

#

Your scene collections and configuration profiles should be fine, but the program operation and working of things may or may not work depending on your setup.

#

As I mentioned above, a lot of plugins broke and require the developers to update them for OBS 28, and not all of them have done so yet, so if you rely on any plugins or other apps that haven't been updated you could have problems.

#

People with very simple setups and no plugins are probably ok, but people who use plugins are best to avoid updating to new OBS releases until its been out for a while and they can confirm every plugin is updated and works with the new version.

sudden zodiac
#

wow i love the look of 28.0.3

#

im only using this one plugin

#

i dont use any other

#

it works!!! aha yesss!!

#

thanks so much for being patient with me

#

very much appreciated

quiet bramble
#

Another more advanced option mainly for advanced users and developers, is installing OBS in portable mode, where you can install multiple versions of OBS at the same time and each of them has their own configuration independent of each other. Allows for testing out new versions without breaking an existing setup, but it is more advanced to set it up.

#

Ah, nice!

#

Hopefully in the future OBS will get the long desired built in plugin manager that could in theory take care of all of this complexity. 😛

sudden zodiac
#

yes this would be amazing

quiet bramble
#

Maybe someone will surprise us in OBS 29.0 or 30.0 et al. 😛 Fingers crossed.

fossil wyvern
sudden zodiac
#

im trying to haev 2 videos run simultaneously but for some reason one appears to be faster than the other. they are both the same video except the bottom one has an open mouth and one is behind the other, i have it set up that when i talk, the top one goes invisible and the bottom one is shows but theya re always not in line, along with that, how do i get them to play at the same time at the push of a button?

fossil wyvern
sudden zodiac
#

i have them paused right now as they align on the first frame

sudden zodiac
#

i would like to have a hotkey to start them at the same time but the hotkeys tab does not offer this

fossil wyvern
sudden zodiac
#

no

fossil wyvern
#

check it and try again

sudden zodiac
#

okay

#

appears to work for now, will leave it for a min and see if they go off sync

fossil wyvern
#

normally it shouldn't drift

sudden zodiac
#

i think they start off sync

#

theyre sort of like 1 frame off sync

fossil wyvern
#

even when you have that setting checked?

sudden zodiac
#

yes

fossil wyvern
sudden zodiac
#

okay i will do via drive

#

yes they become more off sync the further i leave it

#

as if one is slowed down slightly

fossil wyvern
#

ouki, send the files so I can see if I can replicate

sudden zodiac
#

will do

#

uplaoding to drive rn

fossil wyvern
#

👍

sudden zodiac
#

okay whenever i talk into mic, the top layer goes invisible as expected but the video also pauses...

#

this explains the offset

#

it pauses for short time

fossil wyvern
#

oh you have smth that pauses the video when you talk?

sudden zodiac
#

nope

fossil wyvern
#

wait, this is for pngtubing?

sudden zodiac
#

making for someone else but im guessing so

fossil wyvern
#

what do you use to have one video hide when talking?

fossil wyvern
# sudden zodiac move transitions plugin

ok, so, I understand what the problem is now :

  • you need to check "restart when source become active" for both sources to start at the exact same time (when you transition to the scene) otherwise there is no guarantee that they'll start at the same time
  • when you speak, it hides then unhides one of them but since it has "restart when become active", when it unhides, it restarts that source, hence desyncing them
    I have a workaround, gimme 5 to test whether it works and to type it up
sudden zodiac
#

thanks

fossil wyvern
# sudden zodiac thanks

ouki, so I have two solutions for you both of which involve the advanced-scene-switcher plugin :

1 :

  • keep your show-hide setup as it is right now,
  • uncheck "restart when active" in the source properties
  • and instead use adv-ss, to sync the videos each time you enter the scene.

2 :

  • keep "restart when active" to sync the sources when entering scene
  • instead of show/hiding the top video when talking, change the order of the sources in the scene list, so the one you want is visible but both are still active and still running so keep synced (that can be done with adv-ss, maybe move-transition can too, idk, I never really used that plugin extensively.
fossil wyvern
# sudden zodiac thanks

!sceneswitcher here's the adv-ss plugin I'm talking of, tell me which solution you want to try and I'll show you how to set it up

oblique yewBOT
sudden zodiac
#

does scene switcher have transitions for switching layers? like fades etc?

fossil wyvern
sudden zodiac
#

yes

fossil wyvern
#

not easily, since it isn't an actual transition it's probably not easy to put a "transition" effect on it and trigger it. It's likely doable but might need some figuring out

#

I get solution 1 is the preferable one then?

sudden zodiac
#

yes, likely

fossil wyvern
#

👍

#

ouki, install adv-ss, I'll show you how to set it up to sync the videos

sudden zodiac
#

however i dont think solution 1 will work because whenever i talk the video pauses for some reason, does adv-ss sync the videos only at the start or anywehre through?

fossil wyvern
quiet bramble
fossil wyvern
fossil wyvern
sudden zodiac
#

also whenever the videos restart they always have a black frame at the end, not present with the original video files

fossil wyvern
# sudden zodiac yes

are you absolutely 100% sure it actually pauses and not restart from its beginning once you stopped talking?

sudden zodiac
#

can we vc so i can show you? maybe i am wrong

fossil wyvern
quiet bramble
fossil wyvern
quiet bramble
sudden zodiac
fossil wyvern
quiet bramble
#

OBS and its plugins are too much of a moving target to upgrade every single release and then deal with broken plugins, etc. I have something that works and keep using it and it keeps working.

fossil wyvern
fossil wyvern
quiet bramble
#

Different changes that have happened in OBS have caused stuff I've built over time to not work properly, so I'll keep using OBS 26.1.1 until the stuff either works in a newer release (ie: bugs get fixed), or I have to migrate my code to work with a new release for other cases.

#

Doing this for 300 shaders and various other stuff every 6 months isn't fun.

fossil wyvern
#

oh yeah lmao understandable

#

forgot you were the shader guy

quiet bramble
#

I mostly use 26 for local recording or for streaming over Discord.

#

I use 27.2.4 for streaming to YouTube with a fairly barebones setup just screensharing without fancy stuff

#

I got some of my stuff working with 27 in the past, but now 28 changed everything

#

So I haven't been working on code for a while as I've been doing other hobbies mostly, and having my brain sucked out through a straw with video games LOL

fossil wyvern
#

@sudden zodiac I'm sorry, I'll have to be going, we can take it up again later

quiet bramble
#

The sRGB changes and some of the alpha blending isn't working on things in newer releases. I haven't had time to figure out whether some/all of it is just things I have to adapt my code/math to, or bugs in OBS that need addressing. There are some open bug reports from others claiming alpha blending is broken but I haven't looked into it myself and don't know what the official word is. So right now it's just "this used to work and now it looks different and not right, why?"

quiet bramble
#

"Lets spend 3 weeks figuring it all out and fixing it" isn't high priority 🙂

#

My hope is that as new releases come out, any bugs there are get magically fixed by the time I am coding again, I test things and they either just work, or I can quickly figure out what I need to do to make my existing code work as expected again.

#

And if I need to use 27 or newer for some reason such as Twitch API update etc. I can pipe the output of 26.x through Spout to the newer release and have my cake and eat it too. Bungie cords and duct tape FTW.

#

😛

#

At the same time, I am eager to poke around with 28 portable when I'm back into it. 😛

#

28.1 will likely be out by then

#

Hoping to convert some of my stuff to proper native plugins sometime too for a current release.

tired crown
#

Hi All, Im looking for filter/effect that puts glasses on like ThugLife anyone knows?

west summit
#

What was Plugging's name to only capture selected App's sound

oblique yewBOT
west summit
#

Its still in beta?

#

Damn

fossil wyvern
vestal gust
#

Hi, for any reason Recording Source plugin is not working in my OBS 27. I installed last version and the 0.27 but both dont work. Any help?

oblique yewBOT
vestal gust
oblique yewBOT
regal breach
#

and all releases of it have "beta" in their tags

fossil wyvern
#

oh mb

west summit
fossil wyvern
fossil wyvern
vestal gust
fossil wyvern
vestal gust
fossil wyvern
fossil wyvern
# vestal gust

can you right click the shortcut you use to launch obs, click on properties and send a screenshot of the window that appears?

west summit
fossil wyvern
fossil wyvern
oblique yewBOT
# west summit thiz?

To capture only audio from specific programs:

Windows

  • add an Application Audio Capture (BETA) source and select the program to capture
  • alternatively, you can also use the win-capture-audio plugin on Windows 10 2004 and later

macOS

  • macOS 13 (Ventura): add a macOS Screen Capture source, use Window or Application, and select the app to capture
  • for previous versions of macOS, follow the macOS Desktop Audio Capture Guide
fossil wyvern
#

there

#

blue text = link

mossy lintel
#

@vestal gust @fossil wyvern but log says C:\Program Files\obs-studio\bin\64bit\obs64.exe. People should pay more attention where they install their things 😛

fossil wyvern
fossil wyvern
mental hamlet
#

question im using the "freeze frame" plug in and sometimes when i jump between scenes without a camera to a camera scene it activates. and i have it set to not activate till the filter is visable

oblique yewBOT
regal breach
mortal harbor
#

how do you delete plugins?

oblique yewBOT
spiral ruin
#

Doesn't Blade offer support for their app? I don't think there is much that we can do for support, as Blade is not affiliated with OBS Project, and it's an independent mobile app, not a plugin which runs in OBS.

#

I believe there is, but I don't use it personally. I use Touch Portal.

#

Define "easier"? 😉
Touch Portal is for way more than just OBS, streaming and recording. In that way, it may not be "easier" if all you need it for is external control of OBS instead of using keybinds or mousing to second display or tabbing out of game to another window on a single display. There's a free version you can test drive, and it works with OBS 28.

#

Yes, and even though I'm on the Touch Portal support staff, I won't disrespect this server by filling this server with off-topic support. There are connection guides on the Touch Portal FAQs site, and you can get support from the TP Discord.

#

Like I said, it does way more than just OBS, so it may not be easier than using the OBS remote app (if it's still maintained)

#

I don't know. Google is your friend there. There are lots of OBS remote apps, just need to find the one that's maintained and works with OBS 28. I can't recommend something I don't know anything about.

#

Droidcam is for using a phone's camera as a webcam.

#

I don't know. I googled OBS remote apps and got lots of different things. Oddly, none of them were Blade even though I checked out the github site for it.

oblique yewBOT
#

If you'd like to control OBS Studio remotely, you have a few options.

To control from the web on any device (including phones and computers), use OBS Tablet Remote (requires obs-websocket).

If you'd prefer a mobile app that works like the Elgato Streamdeck, you can try Touch Portal, UP Deck, or Deckboard.

spiral ruin
#

Thanks, Bot Angel

lament leaf
#

Interesting 😮

#

Are you on v28?

#

Last update on that was 2020, although since it is just a remote to OBS, I don't know if the plugin would need a compatibility update.

I will keep looking.

#

At least, I am assuming it would still utilize a plugin lol.

#

<--- only has Tuna installed

#

Oh ok, looks like all you need is Websocket, which is built into v28, so you should be good. 🙂

fossil wyvern
#

if it uses websockets and hasn't been updated since 2020 it actually probs need the 4.9-compat websockets, not the v28 builtin that's 5.0

lament leaf
fossil wyvern
#

you're on OBS 28, right?

visual lantern
#

Is there a plugin to denoise my video

quiet bramble
snow grove
#

How do i get rounded corners for the webcamera?

vale vine
#

Usually using an image mask

#

"Image mask obs" should result in some helpful videos from a Google search

topaz crypt
#

Is it possible to stream and record to disk with overlays only enabled for the stream but removed for recording to disk?

vale vine
#

with source record plugin, sure

topaz crypt
#

ok, bummer, i was never able to get that to work without horrible latency issues

glossy oriole
oblique yewBOT
oblique yewBOT
fossil wyvern
#

you're not installing the right version

glossy oriole
# fossil wyvern you're not installing the right version

I installed the very latest version, yet it still isn't working. The site says it's updated for 28. I even went in and manually removed the old version and then installed the new version, rebooted the computer, never installed when the program was open, etc. Even when I removed the old version manually and before I installed the new version (so technically there should be NO version of it on OBS) I still get this:

fossil wyvern
glossy oriole
fossil wyvern
glossy oriole
fossil wyvern
glossy oriole
fossil wyvern
#

Yes is not a path

#

well, not a valid windows one

glossy oriole
#

Sorry my old eyes saw "that's" and not "what's" lol. In looking I think I found the problem. I had an older version installed on the C: drive so I removed that. I believe that's what my task bar OBS icon was pointing to. Gonn try a few things and see if they work. If not I'll be back here. Thanks for the help. I hope I didn't waste too much of your time.

fossil wyvern
#

np

wintry barn
oblique yewBOT
wintry barn
#

done the installer and still the same when live

#

just lagging everywhere

fossil wyvern
#

why in this channel?

wintry barn
fossil wyvern
torpid bay
#

Hi, I'm curious is there is a tool that I could make a text source be the sum of other text sources? For example tallying a score of a game by Round, Say player A scored 5 points in Round 1, 6 in Round 2, and 2 in Round 3, how can I have it automatically summed up in a Final Score source? Thanks

fossil wyvern
torpid bay
#

Thanks

oblique yewBOT
#
🛑 Critical
  • Outdated Plugins (2)
  • Hardware-accelerated GPU Scheduler
⚠️ Warning
  • Windows 10 Version Unknown
  • Wrong YUV Color Range
ℹ️ Info
  • Not Admin
  • No Output Session
Hardware Check

Intel Core i7-10700K @ 3.80GHz - OK! / GeForce RTX 3060 Ti - OK!

ruby jasper
#

I got a question about dynamic delay, anyone use it and could help?

#

As far as I know, dynamic delay has to be activated via hotkey. Is there a way to activate it automatically?
How I use it is I have it permanently on slow-mo, and enable/disable the filter itself, since my program which controls it can't use hotkeys

weak escarp
undone vessel
#

Source record keeps crashing my OBS, any ideas? Source dock also not working for latest OBS even after updating plugin

quiet bramble
#

Source Record is an experimental plugin with instabilities currently. There's not much that can be done about that AFAIK.

ruby jasper
silent cedar
#

see how to fix this

#

it is not showing another pc name how to fix

regal breach
worn oracle
#

can anyone help me with audio ?

spiral ruin
mortal harbor
#

Does Source Record use all audio sources/tracks active in that specific scene or does it use the ones set for recording only?

tribal dirge
#

Hey has anyone ever used filters or vst plug ins for live streaming drums?

mortal harbor
tribal dirge
#

Can you put a triggered or effect sound say from steven slate onto obs and get a good sound. They are acoustic mic'd drums

mortal harbor
#

Can you explain what Steven slate is?

#

Guessing it’s some sort of drum/DAW software based on the context.

wise palm
# tribal dirge Can you put a triggered or effect sound say from steven slate onto obs and get a...

Perhaps post images of your setup, maybe someone might need a bit more context as to what you're trying to do. The only person I know of that Streams live Drums is 66Samus, his setup isn't the most advanced, but it does get the job done & his sound is pretty good, maybe send him a superchat if you can't find answers here on Discord?
(Or that 1 Gentlemen with the 50 gazillion Cameras that Streams Drums, though I don't know his username, might check Nutty's channel, I think the video title is something like "The craziest Twitch channel I ever seen" or something like that)

mortal harbor
#

I don’t know that pictures would really help here. I’m fairly confident I can help and have already responded to them so no reason to send them somewhere else.

tribal crystal
#

Is there a way to add a automatic counter, for example for deaths, wins? (not manually changing text everytime)

mortal harbor
tribal crystal
#

I want to add +1 when I type command in chat maybe?

vapid charm
#

That'd be one way

mortal harbor
#

Well that sounds manual

#

I'm using FireBot, a command and a text file that gets updated (+1) via the command

vapid charm
#

There's no real way to do it automatically without the assistance of another "entity".

fossil wyvern
quiet bramble
gentle granite
#

What is the start sync check box used in rtmp?

#

Also, how do I setup it up so that Youtube specifc menus show when I use RTMP?

gaunt zealot
#

Selecting Youtube as your streaming service under Settings -> Streaming, logging into Youtube, then saying OK should enable any Youtube-specific stuff in OBS

gentle granite
#

I figured it out. I was using multi-RTMP so the easy way to do things was not an option.

#

Reminder to make a bug report on the RTMP module. Question.Delete is not a valid question.

wise elk
#

Anyone know the last version of obs-studio that works with the ndi plugin?

lament leaf
wise elk
#

thanks

native crescent
gentle granite
#

It says encoding error

small creek
#

rtmp://lhr08.contribute.live-video.net/app/your-stream-id-here

gentle granite
#

Doesn't the key go on the key line?

small creek
#

oh for multi rtmp plugin ? possibly yes, apologies

gentle granite
#

notice.getencoder

feral carbon
#

not sure if this is the right place for this but can you apply luts to a certain part of your web like the lower 50% for example???

quiet bramble
#

You can but you'd have to composite it from multiple copies. You can crop the first one to the top half, and the second one to the bottom half. Apply the LUT to only the bottom one.

#

For duplication you can use nested scenes, or you can use StreamFX source mirror if you're using OBS 27.2.4

feral carbon
#

im sorry

#

I have no idea what you mean

gentle granite
#

Do you know how to enter a Twitch stream into the field?

#

I tried different formats for stream servers like

tyo03.contribute.live-video.net
tyo03.contribute.live-video.net/app
rtmp://tyo03.contribute.live-video.net
rtmp://tyo03.contribute.live-video.net

All the previous ones with /key on it

I even tried with key slot empty.

#

How are twitch keys and servers supposed to be entered into the addon?

#

Isn't only Partner tied?

native crescent
gentle granite
#

English

#

I am using the flatpak version

native crescent
gentle granite
#

Oh, so I have to activate OBS's stream before this will activate?

untold jay
#

could it be that the translation file is missing or outdated?

native crescent
#

Yes if your output item's configuration is "Get encoder from OBS"

gentle granite
#

@native crescent That worked. I just noticed there is no stop streaming button if I start it that way

#

Changing configuration seemed to have stopped the stream.

brisk summit
#

Hey y’all I’m needing some help

#

When ever I try to open Obs it keeps doing this

regal breach
gentle granite
#

@native crescent Nevermind, I didn't see the stop button because the stream crashed already.

#

Everything seems stable now. I think my computer was just overheating because I didn't have my laptop on a block of ice.

#

@native crescent ありがとうござます

#

ごんばてくださいね

native crescent
gentle granite
#

Laptop was overheating

velvet forge
#

Can obs run chrome extensions?

mortal harbor
velvet forge
#

Dang

#

Lol

#

Different language I guess

dark sapphire
#

well, yeah, OBS isn't Chrome

#

iPhone can't run Android apps either

hollow mulch
#

Hi all, is there a way to do Object Tracking live in OBS? I found a few plugins that do Face Tracking through StreamFX (f.e. https://youtu.be/i1SeCHmkRKM) but I'm looking to track the print-head of my 3D printer. Which isn't a face (unfortunately)

Anyone who can help? (please ping me if you reply 🧡 )

#

P.s. I'm okay with sticking markers on my print-head if necessary

valid matrix
#

Upgraded to v28. Updated plugins. Downgraded due to v28 crashing constantly. TUNA now doesn't show up in the Tools menu anymore? Any idea from anyone what I'm meant to be deleting/installing for it to show up again?