#jojolion

47 messages · Page 487 of 1

lofty quail
#

I think it has some interesting shit in it, but I believe it's bogged down by just meh writing overall

sick beacon
#

just doesn’t measure up

rocky charm
#

It's still good now

viscid pike
#

Part 2 is a fun time but if it ended there and there was no part 3 I would throw that shit to the bottom of my list

sick beacon
#

thats why i give it like a B or C tier

wicked wind
sick beacon
#

good god no

lofty quail
#

yeah it's not an F

viscid pike
#

I don't like how everyone sucks except Joseph.

sick beacon
#

i didnt care for jojo part 1 but i liked it a lot more than other anime

ruby river
#

technically, jjba as a whole could end after part 3

#

think of it

lofty quail
#

yeah

sick beacon
#

like black bullet or dxd no

ruby river
#

the main conflict is over

#

and the end

#

its so climactic

lofty quail
#

You could see the other parts after part 3 as side pieces if you really wanted to

ruby river
#

like the "ties with dio are over"

rocky charm
viscid pike
#

Logging off for a bit guys

sick beacon
#

the rest of the series is just exposition

lofty quail
#

aight

#

cya dude

sick beacon
#

see ya nyves

ruby river
sick beacon
#

mmm

#

kinda

lofty quail
#

correct

ruby river
rocky charm
#

Oh, well sure.

ruby river
#

the ending feels goddamn climactic

sick beacon
#

but its still kinda like exposition

wicked wind
#

Guys got a question

#

Fr

lofty quail
#

shoot for it

wicked wind
#

Best op?

rocky charm
#

If I pretend that Parts after Part 1 don't exist, then the Part 1 ending feels like it could end a series

wicked wind
#

Which one

sick beacon
#

great days

lofty quail
#

bloody stream

#

or great days

wicked wind
#

I like traitors requiem

ember light
#

He wasnt just a "standard person" lol he had his life ruined constantly by dio and his one escape from that, erina, got messed up by dio too. He also sometimes had trouble keeping up the gentlemanly expectation from his dad when he was young. The pain from then shaped him into who he is later. He was really really depressed at times but still his feelings for dio are something more nuanced than just hatred. If I can defend one thing about part 1 itll be that Jonathan is more than just a standard protagonist. also yeah like you said the ending wasnt standard either, in fact it not being an expected ending resulted in an incredibly well done death and one of the best endings in the series

rocky charm
ruby river
#

part 1 ends with a cliffhanger

#

part 2 hints to part 3

wicked wind
#

Damn

rocky charm
ruby river
#

we cant

rocky charm
#

Obviously if we're treating it as a series end we wouldn't include the cliffhanger lol

ruby river
#

that doesnt count

wicked wind
ruby river
#

plus erina survives with a decendant

lofty quail
#

he was a standard person, got involved in a conflict, had to change because of dio, got trained by a mentor, and so on and so on

#

that is what is referred to as an "inciting incident"

rocky charm
#

"Someone survives" doesn't mean the series can't end there

lofty quail
#

dio comes into his life and changes him

rocky charm
#

Jotaro survives the end of Part 3, so I guess that can't be the ending

ember light
#

yeah idk what you mean by "standard person" or how any of this is bland anyway

ruby river
#

but the fact that she remains in a coffin in the middle of the ocean

uneven tendon
#

That was a joke, though I am more than interested to see how everything seemingly goes back to normal

lofty quail
#

how isn't he bland in your opinion?

rocky charm
#

There's such a thing as an "open ending"

wicked wind
#

Well part 3 couldve been an actual ending to jojo

ruby river
#

and also the fact that part 1 is incredibly short and feels rushed

lofty quail
#

not saying you should only hold my belief or anything

#

just curious, what do you find so unique about jonathan

sick beacon
#

compared to any other series its pretty bland yeah

ruby river
#

^^^ i dont know what are you trying to prove here caroni

sick beacon
#

jonathan is just a base for the rest of the joestars

ruby river
#

cause part 1 definetly doesnt feels like the end

sick beacon
#

thats not unique at all

rocky charm
#

I'm saying that just about any ending can be said to "feel like an ending"

ruby river
#

even without the hint on part 2

minor ore
#

I love araki

#

Araki never forgets

#

NEVER

ruby river
#

yeah it doesnt

wicked wind
rocky charm
#

If NO parts were made after Phantom Blood and it were just a short, 44 chapter manga, then no one would be saying "Ah man this doesn't feel like an ending"

sick beacon
#

physically maybe

#

i guess

hard meteor
#

Arakis so based

sick beacon
#

but how does that reflect on him as a character

uneven tendon
ruby river
rocky charm
wicked wind
#

Dam

minor ore
#

JOSHUA

rocky charm
#

There are PLENTY of series' where the villain gets beaten, maybe the hero dies, and then it just ends

uneven tendon
#

Joshua? More like: inferior Joshu

ruby river
sick beacon
#

just just replace all characters with joshu and be on our way

true ore
#

!w plant

mental ridgeBOT
minor ore
rocky charm
#

Radiant Historia is a perfect example of leaving an ending open but still having it feel like an ending.

sick beacon
wicked wind
#

I liek how every chat has people except part 1 chat

sick beacon
#

or the giver

ruby river
#

alternate timeline: jjba ends at part 1 and araki abandons the project

wicked wind
sick beacon
#

my favorite jojo is johnny

wicked wind
#

Damn

true ore
#

I like kirafumi

sick beacon
#

why do you ask

ruby river
#

imagine how much popularity would the manga have, few japanese fourms from 2005-2006sh?

wicked wind
minor ore
wicked wind
#

Johnny is cool

sick beacon
#

well i mean you can

#

just wont be satisfying

#

usually

ember light
# lofty quail how isn't he bland in your opinion?

I explained it mostly here "He wasnt just a "standard person" lol he had his life ruined constantly by dio and his one escape from that, erina, got messed up by dio too. He also sometimes had trouble keeping up the gentlemanly expectation from his dad when he was young. The pain from then shaped him into who he is later. He was really really depressed at times but still his feelings for dio are something more nuanced than just hatred." His duality with dio is well done and I love how dio rejected his humanity and makes others lose their humanity while the power that Jonathan uses is literally pushing life energy into others. I love how dio stated himself that without Jonathan, he might not have been able to get to the point that got to, while at the same time Jonathan is the reason dio stopped progressing. They both are the starts and ends of each other and I love it so much. In most aspects of his character theres something more than just generic gentleman which is what I see him called so much. Not saying hes best protagonist ever, but yeah hes good for the reasons I stated

true ore
minor ore
ruby river
#

the ending is too "open" tbh

#

so much so that it still feels like a cliffhanger

sick beacon
rocky charm
#

Play Radiant Historia

ruby river
#

i wont

true ore
rocky charm
#

I'm disguising this as part of the argument but everyone should play Radiant Historia

ruby river
rocky charm
#

Ah, yes

ruby river
#

jorge????????

sick beacon
#

i have it but ive never played it

kind owlBOT
#

@ruby river, Your Hamon Rank is now level 5 !

rocky charm
#

The most important character in Phantom Blood

#

Erina.

true ore
#

imo

ruby river
#

thats just being ignorant at this point

rocky charm
#

She............... got molested by Dio........ grabbed a kid........ and that's basically it.

true ore
#

yes

rocky charm
#

Erina is important for being Jonathan's wife

true ore
#

but jonathan died

#

so

rocky charm
#

You can end a story with someone saving someone and then disappearing forever

sick beacon
#

not really man

ruby river
#

^^^

rocky charm
#

Having someone survive is NOT clues for a sequel

sick beacon
#

it could have ended there

#

easily

#

who cares? fill it in. that’s how a lot of endings are

rocky charm
#

Jotaro survived Part 3 and so did Anne, whom he saved, therefore Part 3 could never be the ending.

#

OPTIMISM

#

Pushing a message that even if you can't save everyone, save who you can

true ore
#

Anne is the part 9 protag

sick beacon
#

like the same thing happened in part 4 with shizuka and that never went anywhere

rocky charm
#

^

ruby river
#

fair enough with shizuka, though anne is a really bad example

true ore
#

shizuka is in like 3 chapters

#

and i mean appearances

#

not plot wise

sick beacon
#

open-ended endings happen all the time, regardless of whether or not you think they’re good

ember light
# sick beacon yeah i mean as a foil he’s fine but as a character in and of himself he’s just n...

Eh alone I still like him and I dont see why we should judge him by himself either. Humanity is one of major themes so I dont see why we shouldnt take into account how the relationships humans make with each other change them. His Dio relationship just makes him so much better. plus there are other series that have characters that get incredibly highly praised and a lot of the good in them comes from their relationships with each other. Example: guts, griffith, casca

sick beacon
#

it definitely COULD have happened

true ore
#

I dont anyone realizes

#

that jojo has an open ending

#

that we dont

#

even think about

sick beacon
#

part 6 has a VERY open ending

true ore
#

thank you

rocky charm
#

And?

true ore
#

We dont know what happened to emporio

rocky charm
#

Actually thank you Gold

true ore
#

he had been in stone ocean for since like the tenth chapter at least

rocky charm
#

Emporio is a random kid Irene picks up at the end of SO and that's never brought up again

true ore
#

he's in a different universe

sick beacon
ruby river
#

part 6s ending is different in context of 5 OTHER PARTS CMON

#

its actually obvious it was going to be a final one

true ore
#

he is stuck with the people he was once friends with, and is both happy and sad that they died and are alive at the same time

sick beacon
#

the gentle giant sort of character has been done time and time again

#

and i think you’re just sort of contriving meaning that isn’t even that present

rocky charm
ruby river
#

also isnt emporio a reaccuring character who is a part of the main cast

rocky charm
#

Yeah that point was a joke

true ore
#

Still emporio is a main character

#

he killed pucci

sick beacon
#

im just saying he’s uninteresting to me

rocky charm
#

OK, fine

#

I can call every character in Jojo boring because I'm able to describe them in a few words and refuse to look for meaning

sick beacon
#

because his character AND his circumstances are both utterly boring to me because its stuff ive seen time and time again

true ore
#

he is uninteresting araki didnt come out of the womb ready to tell the story of jonathan

junior coral
#

fooey

#

😠

true ore
sick beacon
#

i see the meaning i just dont care for it

true ore
#

He is in a different universe

sick beacon
#

im not just deciphering every line while im watching jojo anyways

lofty quail
sick beacon
#

telling me that my opinion on a character isn’t valid because i don’t think about it the same way you do is silly

ruby river
#

lets be honest johnathan isnt exactly..... a "cool" character with a certain bright personality trait

true ore
#

we were talking about endings that seem like theres more

ruby river
#

maybe thats the reason of the lack of his appeal

sick beacon
#

to me at least

true ore
#

its because hes perfect

#

no one finds a perfect character

#

interesting

sick beacon
#

its because hes literally a textbook shonen protagonist

lofty quail
sick beacon
#

which for the time was fine

lofty quail
#

oh no def

sick beacon
#

but now its like

#

wow another one

lofty quail
#

in 1986 it was very different

sick beacon
#

and i dont get why people are so defensive about it either

viscid pike
#

Hahaha what did I come back to??

true ore
#

not much

sick beacon
#

just because i dont like him as a character doesnt mean im going to invade your mind and rip out all of your love for jonathan

rocky charm
lofty quail
#

just discussing stuff and things

true ore
#

Jonathan isnt bad

lofty quail
#

He isn't bad

true ore
#

hes just no fun to read about

#

not bad

lofty quail
#

def

runic adder
#

Lmao gotta love we are discussing the very first jojo character on the same day the latest chapter came out

viscid pike
junior coral
#

Jonathan is cool but he is very static

true ore
#

he said that he wouldve gave him for flaws

junior coral
#

Has almost no development

rocky charm
#

Definitely the place to discuss Phantom Blood

runic adder
true ore
#

Its not like his hamon changes or anything

#

like joseph

#

he is the same the whole time

rocky charm
#

Jonathan gets the power-up when Zeppeli dies

sick beacon
#

nothing about him changes after the first episode or two

late lagoon
#

Joshu almost did something this chapter, it was insane

sick beacon
#

oh well yeah i suppose he kinda does

ruby river
#

literally the most heavy content filled chapter just came out
"lets discuss part 1 in #jojolion!"

viscid pike
#

I get it. Phantom Blood didnt age well. It's still a great part, still a great JoJo but in the context of the series as a whole he's not that interesting

sick beacon
#

but even that feels stilited

sick beacon
true ore
#

yep same here

viscid pike
#

But in 1986, he was revolutionary as a shonen protagonist

sick beacon
#

was great for the time im sure

viscid pike
#

Ya gotta take the good with the bad

lofty quail
#

I really really enjoy how jonathan got killed off. It took HUGE balls for araki to do that.

kind owlBOT
#

@lofty quail, Your Hamon Rank is now level 4 !

viscid pike
#

It's like watching the original Star Wars. That aged poorly. It's still fine but if that released today people would shit all over it

lofty quail
#

I agree

viscid pike
#

Star Wars episode 7

#

Err

#

No I mean 4

sick beacon
#

imagine if guardians of the galaxy game out in 1969

kind owlBOT
#

@sick beacon, Your Hamon Rank is now level 7 !

true ore
#

but yeah we shouldnt care so much about this

kind owlBOT
#

@wicked wind, Your Hamon Rank is now level 3 !

true ore
#

part one is okay

#

not in comparison to parts 7 and 8 in my opion

#

but its a legacy

sick beacon
#

and just okay

#

definitely not the worst thing ive watched or read

#

black bullet was awful no

ruby river
#

part 3-part 5 part of timeline is pretty cool

viscid pike
#

He sets the stage for the rest of the JoJo's and that means a lot to me personally because I love the series so much

true ore
#

Dio was honestly what made part one good

#

a bad person

runic adder
#

Dio carried the part hard

true ore
#

and a good person

sick beacon
#

yeah he did a good job of being a basis for the rest

true ore
#

it was balanced

sick beacon
#

ill cede that

true ore
#

correctly

ruby river
#

seriously we get it, part 1 didnt age well

true ore
#

it's that it didnt age well

sick beacon
#

damn

true ore
#

it follows a formula that is just not very good

viscid pike
#

Now, let's talk about part 6 haters and how small brain they are

true ore
#

yes

sick beacon
#

i used to hate part 6

true ore
#

dont

viscid pike
#

Because Jolyne is the best JoJo I will fight anyone

ruby river
#

how do you hate part 6

sick beacon
#

read it again and i like it more

true ore
#

the ending is genius

opaque quest
#

Joseph is my personal favorite

true ore
#

I like hat josuke

sick beacon
#

johnny’s my favorite

ruby river
#

literally good setting, cool characters, somewhat quircky villian with deep motivation

sick beacon
#

i didn’t like it because it seemed confusing or arbitrary. the ending actually made me like it more on first read

ruby river
#

also stupid good main cast

#

it has everything

sick beacon
#

yeah really good main cast

rocky charm
#

People rewatch Part 3, reread Part 7, and then tell us that Part 6 has bad pacing.

sick beacon
#

part 6 definitely had good pacing but i just felt like it was all kind of arbitrary

viscid pike
#

I didn't like part 6 the first time because of Anasui but I grew to like them a little more

#

Still, I think he drags part 6 down

opaque quest
#

Anasui is one of my favorite parts of Stone Ocean

true ore
#

I really like jotaro

ruby river
#

my only problem was how easy the part just throws away the prison setting

true ore
#

he was the best part 6 character

ruby river
#

like sure there is qutie a build up

true ore
#

i have tiny brain opinions

ruby river
#

but still

sick beacon
#

i think that a lot of the problems i have with part 6 will be alleviated by david productions

#

when the anime comes out

true ore
#

i guess

ruby river
#

and late part 6 just feels

#

wierd?

true ore
#

maybe anasui will have a definite gender

viscid pike
#

Jailhouse Lock arc was great

rocky charm
#

LAte Part 6 is weird as hell

opaque quest
#

indeed

rocky charm
#

I love it

sick beacon
#

i dont like the setting at all but i personally just hate florida so

true ore
#

or maybe there will be an explained gender change

elfin tangle
#

Anasui's amazing

ruby river
#

like in a good way, but i cant really find a certain way to describe it as a whole

#

like there is no setting

lofty quail
#

I did not enjoy the prison setting personally

ruby river
#

its just chasing pucci

junior coral
elfin tangle
#

A really funny character that would shine more in the anime as there'll be no more shit translation and his shining scenes will be a lot more clear

rocky charm
junior coral
#

no need for an explanation if the gender change is omitted

#

nope

true ore
sick beacon
#

i cant wait for the explained weight change from early funny valentine to late funny valentine

rocky charm
#

Parts 1, 2, 3, 5, and 7 also have the characters moving around and thus having no fixed setting

junior coral
#

The only given reason is that Araki wanted to draw an androgynous character

viscid pike
#

Keep Anasui gender ambiguous

junior coral
#

anything about editors or transgender/gay/whatever is a fan theory

ruby river
#

just florida

true ore
#

part 6 wasnt doing good with 12 year olds so the editors didnt want to ruin sales more by having a lesbian in a story that targeted 12 year old heterosexual boys

ruby river
#

THOUGH NGL

sick beacon
#

uh no it was because the writers didnt want a gay relationship in 2001

true ore
#

U sure

junior coral
#

nope

#

lol

rocky charm
#

That is a made-up lie that people spread as fact

junior coral
#

that is just not true

true ore
#

oh so what was it

rocky charm
#

If you can find ONE source you can keep saying it

sick beacon
#

“nope lol youre wrong”

junior coral
#

The only reason that has ever been given is that Araki wanted to draw an androgynous character

rocky charm
#

But without sources, it is the only thing we have a source for: Araki wanted to draw Annasui androgynous

junior coral
#

There is no such quote of Araki saying anything about the editors or changing it

#

Because looking like a woman isn't androgynous

lofty quail
#

nooooooo

#

they deleted it 😦

true ore
#

K

viscid pike
#

Part 6 wasn't doing well as a shonen so they flipped the gender

true ore
#

nah

junior coral
#

no!

ruby river
#

KENNEDY SPACE CENTER IS A REALLY COOL FINAL BATTLE LOCATION

junior coral
#

that is not it!

sick beacon
#

mmm wiki says otherwise

junior coral
#

I legit explained it twice just now

viscid pike
#

Right???

ruby river
#

like i love it

sick beacon
#

i dont see anywhere saying what you do

viscid pike
#

!w Stone Ocean

mental ridgeBOT
#
JoJo's Bizarre Encyclopedia - JoJo Wiki

Stone Ocean (ストーンオーシャン, Sutōn Ōshan) is the sixth part of JoJo's Bizarre Adventure, serialized in Weekly Shonen Jump from January 2000 to April 2003. Originally titled JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Part 6 Jolyne Cujoh: Stone Ocean (ジョジョの奇妙な冒険 第6部 空条徐倫 ―『石作りの海(ストーンオーシャン)』, JoJo no Kimyō na Bōken Dai Roku Bu Kūjō Jorīn -"Sutōn Ōshan"-), the arc spans 158 chapters and is preceded by Vento Aureo.

junior coral
#

Who cares

cunning vapor
#

Anasui is boy

junior coral
#

that is the only reason Araki gave

rocky charm
#

We literally just said that there is no source on that, it's a bullshit fan theory, and Araki said otherwise

ruby river
#

in general all final parts nail the climaxes

junior coral
#

Nothing about the editors is ever said

#

that is a rumor

#

made up by the fandom

cunning vapor
#

Anasui is boy bruh no more

true ore
#

So can someone explain what happened in full

#

i just want to know

#

without interuptions

rocky charm
#

Like "DIO was supposed to have all of the Stands", or "Josuke was gonna go back in time and save himself"

junior coral
#

"At Lucca Comics and Games 2019, Araki revealed that the reason behind Anasui's sex seemingly changing after his first appearance was that he wanted to portray a character with an androgynous image that went beyond the standard definition of genders."

This content comes from JoJo's Bizarre Encyclopedia (https://jojowiki.com), and must be attributed to its authors, as specified in the license.
JoJo's Bizarre Wiki (the FANDOM wiki) is prohibited from using it, for repeatedly copying without giving attribution.

#

That's it

junior coral
#

that is literally it

rocky charm
true ore
#

i dont think it was always the plan

rocky charm
#

Araki himself said the person was unimportant

true ore
#

and it was maybe dropped

#

yeah

viscid pike
#

I have no sources I lied my b

true ore
#

i just think it existed at one point

sick beacon
#

this is a dumb argument

junior coral
#

it's not an argument lol

elfin tangle
#

Can't wait for Anasui to be fully male so people can shut the fuck up about it already.

junior coral
#

yep lmfao

viscid pike
#

Nooooooo

junior coral
#

people will still say they changed it though

#

"they"

viscid pike
#

Gender doesn't matter anyway

junior coral
#

Big Shuiesha changing genders and such

#

No

proven eagle
#

can someone link chapter

sick beacon
#

yeah hold on

true ore
lofty quail
#

why does it matter

proven eagle
#

Thank uuu

junior coral
#

It matters because people keep spreading misinformation

#

Just correcting them

sick beacon
#

yeah but who cares either way it makes literally zero difference

junior coral
#

It makes a difference that people are spreading misinformation

#

I'm just correcting you

#

because I can

sick beacon
#

if it actually mattered

junior coral
#

Don't believe araki then

#

what the fuck do you want from me

lofty quail
#

nah just about issue regarding anasui's gender

sick beacon
#

no i believe you i just dont care

lofty quail
#

it doesn't really matter if it's a he or a she

junior coral
#

So then what is the point of saying that

viscid pike
#

Give Anasui both the femme and masc look and have a trans identifying person be their VA

lofty quail
#

In my opinion

ruby river
#

which is also dumb and unninteresting at this point

sick beacon
#

whats the point in going around correcting everyone you deranged redditor

viscid pike
#

Make everyone happy and mad at the same time

junior coral
#

If I went around saying that the moon is made of cheese you'd be like, no it isn't

#

Same dish

lofty quail
#

the moon IS made out of cheese

sick beacon
#

moon denier

junior coral
#

bad example I knew that

lofty quail
#

why do you think it's yellow sometimes you silly face

junior coral
#

true!

viscid pike
#

It's Schrödinger's moon

#

It's cheese or moon rock depending on when it's observed okay

junior coral
#

anyway here's this

#

just in case some of you didn't believe me lmfao

viscid pike
#

I like the comment right below it

sick beacon
#

oh okay i just realized why people are so crazy about this

viscid pike
#

A male character that doesn't fit the masculine sterotyoes

sick beacon
#

cause trans rights and all that

junior coral
#

??

#

watch the interview D

#

I gave a twitter link

rocky charm
# sick beacon if it actually mattered

If someone says that the editors got mad at Araki for adding another woman to the plot and made him change it to a man, then people are going to be upset at the others.
Innocent people are getting slandered because of a fan theory

#

If you "can't see the harm in that", then I don't know what to tell you

viscid pike
junior coral
#

But he isn't

ruby river
#

why does it matter

junior coral
#

lol

#

he isn't trans though

ruby river
#

he just changed his mind

#

thats it

#

moving on

rocky charm
#

The interview was 2019, SO was a while back

junior coral
#

exactly

junior coral
sick beacon
junior coral
#

He isn't transgender

sick beacon
#

no i know he isnt

#

but it could be mistaken for that

junior coral
#

He said he wanted to write an androgynous character, therefore redrew him that way

sick beacon
#

with the androgynous character thing

junior coral
#

the one he redrew

#

the one that's not clearly a woman

rocky charm
#

The one with his tiddies out

junior coral
#

lol

#

don't ask us why

#

he said it

#

lol

rocky charm
#

Araki wrote and drew every character in Part 5 and then said "hm what would happen if I made an androgynous character"

viscid pike
#

Abbachio was pretty dang androgynous

kind owlBOT
#

@viscid pike, Your Hamon Rank is now level 7 !

viscid pike
#

Lmao

junior coral
#

okay

#

I'm just telling you what Araki said

#

i don't know his reasoning behind how he drew it

#

No Andy

uneven tendon
junior coral
#

All I'm saying is whatever the reason, it has nothing to do with the editors or Diver Down, or him being trans

#

as far as we know

#

Lots of people like to say "oh he just used Diver Down to get into the women's prison"

#

like, no

#

??

lofty quail
#

I love that

viscid pike
#

My headcanon is Anasui met Jolyne presenting female and used diver down to change their appearance to be more masculine to try to get with her

rocky charm
#

He

#

did

#

not

junior coral
#

Andy you're late to the party

viscid pike
#

It's not true

#

It's not official canon

junior coral
viscid pike
#

I like to think that lol

junior coral
#

this is the only reason why

#

alright

uneven tendon
#

Green Giorno, you do realize that saying Anasui being a female isn't a retcon, right?

junior coral
#

hm?

uneven tendon
junior coral
#

FF didn't meat Anasui before that scene

sick beacon
#

i think it’s silly to care so much whether someone thinks if his gender was changed or not

junior coral
#

Listen Illious

#

Idk if you know me

#

But I correct people about everything

uneven tendon
#

Araki just wanted to have a character who looked like both genders, it wasn't a retcon if he always planned it that way

summer nova
#

araki was just doing a little trolling

junior coral
#

It matters to me when people perpetuate weird headcanons and try to convince others "this is what araki said!!!"

#

Andy dude

#

we not talking about pronouns

uneven tendon
#

I don't think stuff like ''Anasui used Diver Down'' should be disregarded as dumb theories

junior coral
#

He has boobs, then he doesn't

uneven tendon
#

Because part of it's powers is restructuring

junior coral
#

it's a dumb theory because it is not true

#

I gave a link to the reason araki gave

uneven tendon
#

I know that reason

junior coral
#

So you don't believe araki now? You're saying he had an ulterior motive?

#

he lied in the interview?

#

what?

uneven tendon
#

But it's still not a dumb theory like you like to say it is when it's the closest thing to an in universe explanation

#

I do believe him though

junior coral
#

lol

uneven tendon
#

I just point out that it wasn't a retcon

sick beacon
#

araki is lying to sell more manga 😈

uneven tendon
junior coral
#

So she didn't see him when he "was a woman"

summer nova
#

who are anasui and ff

#

im only reading jojolion

sick beacon
#

nobody’s ever thought of that before no

sick beacon
#

why?

viscid pike
#

It wasn't concrete though. He just said at the time he wanted to create an androgynous character and thougbt it'd be alright in a manga aimed at boys

rocky charm
#

He's joking

viscid pike
#

Thats it

sick beacon
#

oh

lofty quail
#

oh you are just joking

sick beacon
#

my bad

summer nova
viscid pike
#

FF is plankton

lofty quail
#

I was so confused at first

sick beacon
#

truuue

junior coral
summer nova
#

no

#

well

#

they do

#

but sexless

#

i think

viscid pike
#

FF self-identified as a she

rocky charm
summer nova
#

FF is sentient so she can identify as female

viscid pike
#

That's all that really matters

sick beacon
#

they are hermaphrodites if im not mistaken

rocky charm
#

Alternatively, sentient plankton has trouble telling gender

viscid pike
#

That's sex not gender

sick beacon
#

lets not get political

junior coral
#

FF has a gooch because she's in Atroe's body, but being a plankton, she technically is sexless

summer nova
#

so funny

junior coral
#

we're not gonna get into that

rocky charm
#

That could just be force of habit (or maybe the translation. idk I haven't seen the Japanese). Lots of people are more comfortable saying "he" or "she" instead of "they". So even if FF was knowledgeable to understand the concept of identifying as "they" and then chose to identify as "they", Jolyne "You throw like a queer" Cujoh would probably still call FF "she"

lofty quail
#

I wonder what that video is

junior coral
#

All you need to know is that she is made out of plankton

viscid pike
#

We can take that convo elsewhere if you're interested

junior coral
#

plankton don't have private parts

#

Discussion of past parts are allowed here

#

If you want to steer the convo to jojolion do it

#

Yeah

#

lol

#

The rules are that future parts can't be discussed

sick beacon
#

we talked about part 1 for like 45 minutes up there

junior coral
#

pretty sure it doesn't say anything about past parts

sick beacon
#

before that we talked about JJL 106

runic adder
sick beacon
#

retcon means to change retroactively

runic adder
#

Something that contradicts an element of the story previously by changing it

sick beacon
#

in a work of fiction

junior coral
#

Basically to rewrite past events.

burnt quiver
#

where will we find 106 now that mangadex is deceased

rocky charm
#

A retcon is when an author retroactively removes or changes something from prior canon

sick beacon
junior coral
#

revise (an aspect of a fictional work) retrospectively, typically by introducing a piece of new information that imposes a different interpretation on previously described events.

runic adder
#

So for example rais backstory was retconned, his backstory changes in chapter 99/100 iirc

burnt quiver
#

eng TL i mean

rocky charm
#

That's not what retroactively means. Unless someone travelled back in time to fuck up your marriage.

sick beacon
#

i win

runic adder
rocky charm
junior coral
#

what was his backstory before chapter 99

runic adder
#

Could have sworn he said his orchard burned done originally

junior coral
#

if any

#

don't think so

runic adder
#

In his first arc he talks about his past

sick beacon
#

mmm no it was a storm wasnt it?

#

or something?

rocky charm
#

The same thing that happens to everyone else

runic adder
sick beacon
#

is that what happened?

#

i speedread through that portion truth be told

runic adder
sick beacon
#

well if i talk about jojo anymore im going to lose my mind

#

have fun guys

lofty quail
#

cya NERD

#

:)

sick beacon
viscid pike
#

Buh bye

summer nova
#

fellas, past parts are allowed but this is still a jojolion discussion channel

junior coral
summer nova
#

coolcool

viscid pike
#

BOY HE THICCCC

summer nova
#

truee

runic adder
burnt quiver
#

huh

#

neat chapter

viscid pike
#

DAMN THATS A THICC ASZSZ BOI

#

THICC boy ded yall

rocky charm
#

Rai is too thicc to die

burnt quiver
#

i guess

runic adder
#

And the reason the orchard failed was cuz the secrets of the cultivation were leaked

runic adder
#

So yea, unless there’s some weird stuff going on it’s a retcon

runic adder
burnt quiver
#

what was retconned

rocky charm
#

Wonder of Retcon

viscid pike
#

What about that baby

runic adder
burnt quiver
#

also is this chapter good or not can someone tell me because i cant form my own opinion

junior coral
#

It’s good

viscid pike
rocky charm
#

GUys

#

What i

burnt quiver
#

is joshu dead

rocky charm
#

if joshiu ided

#

deid

#

died

lofty quail
#

thank god

runic adder
#

Joshu is probably not dead given the flashforward

#

But then again..flashforward

#

Is kinda wack

proven eagle
#

So is there a release for ch 107?

#

date

rocky charm
runic adder
#

But the flashforward had joshu using his stand, so it makes sense he WOULDNT be an illusion

rocky charm
viscid pike
#

If Joshu's the new Emporio, I stg

rocky charm
#

That's how monthly manga works

viscid pike
#

It's a monthly release

runic adder
#

The only consistency in the flashforward is that norisuke was attacked

#

Read chapter 83

#

It’s a way to bait the readers

rocky charm
#

The scene where it said "13 minutes to the Harvest" and we saw the Higashikatas goofing around and Joshu molested his sister and Norisuke was in a body bag

runic adder
#

I gotta say, if Araki doesn’t retcon the flashforward, it might be some of the best trolling of readers I’ve ever seen

runic adder
#

Well, if it showed exactly what was happening at that new moon yea

rocky charm
rugged pilot
#

C moon type beat

kind owlBOT
#

@rugged pilot, Your Hamon Rank is now level 3 !

rocky charm
#

Still molestation

viscid pike
#

I don't

rugged pilot
#

Flash forward then?

lofty quail
#

The jojolion channel is the most chaotic channel in the server

rugged pilot
#

Flash forward happens a lot in heist movies where they talk about the plan as it happens

rocky charm
viscid pike
lofty quail
#

Looked through everything

#

lmao yeah

rugged pilot
#

Oof spoilers

#

I’m at the chairlift chapter

runic adder
#

Chairlift>transmission tower

hard meteor
rugged pilot
#

Lmao mans has a treadmill with the most motivation. If u stop you fall off

hard meteor
#

tfw trolling with an ear lick makes you a molester smh

viscid pike
#

Rei pushing Yasuho off the chairlift pissed me tf off

rugged pilot
#

Bruno molested giorno then

woeful sluice
#

talk about new chapter here?

viscid pike
finite wadi
#

bro

#

in order to understand jojolion you have to be high

#

istg

hard meteor
rocky charm
woeful sluice
#

YASUHO LIVES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

rocky charm
#

There's only room for one thicc ass in Josuke's life

finite wadi
#

true

#

he no match for tw tho

rocky charm
#

Honestly you gotta respect him taking the incentive

viscid pike
#

That's why they call his stand Doggystyle 😏

finite wadi
#

I was just about to say that

finite wadi
#

"stand names reflect on the users or the ability"

#

wait

#

IS TAHT DOGGY STYLE HIDDEN ABILITY

#

TO

#

##############

viscid pike
#

I think I know where you're going with this

runic adder
viscid pike
finite wadi
#

:)

runic adder
#

And that Kira is a queen?

finite wadi
#

yes

#

but also the lyrics

runic adder
#

Yea ik what you mean

finite wadi
#

the stand name and the lyrics

runic adder
#

Yea

finite wadi
#

we just do a little trollin

rocky charm
viscid pike
#

Explain Joshu's Nut King Call

finite wadi
viscid pike
#

IN APPROPRIATE

rocky charm
finite wadi
#

he tried to do his mom

rocky charm
#

He even has nuts on his undies

viscid pike
#

No

finite wadi
#

mhm

#

one is dead

#

how they fight

#

but

#

ig wou

#

wou is a stand you dont fight

hard meteor
#

Deadman Kira

finite wadi
#

its a stand you run the fuck away from

hard meteor
#

Can’t kill ghosts nyohoho

finite wadi
#

ghost cant kill you

#

they go like professor quirell

viscid pike
#

Why did Tooru/Head Doctor/WoU even go after Rai anyway?

finite wadi
#

when harry touched him

finite wadi
viscid pike
#

What was the motive?

#

Oh sorry I meant in the past

finite wadi
#

oh

#

looking into the higashikata family

#

maybe even

#

j o b i n

#

wink wink

rocky charm
#

I think Rai's father just happened to "pursue" the Head Doctor and ended up sying

winter spade
#

It was part of the flow ultimately bringing the rokakaka towards Tooru

#

Rai even acknowledges that the calamity works longer term to help Tooru succeed

finite wadi
#

I think theres some connection with jobin and tooru

#

jobin was "dead" before he even got there

#

(not confirmed)

#

I dont wanna say anything and then be totally wrong yn

#

hmm

#

but if kira touches tooru

#

he crumbles

#

yeah but

#

how he gonna fight

#

ghost gun

#

ig

#

tooru would probably catch on that he's avoiding touching him and then pursue him

#

he big grain

minor solstice
#

did new chapter drop

#

chapter 106?

#

epic

copper jay
#

since mangadex is down, what are some other good places to read the new chapter

elfin rivet
#

can we talk about anytime the fanbase talks about a character being missing something bad happens lol

viral plume
#

Quick thing to say about the recent chapter: I think its really fucking bad that ||Gappy's injuries magically dissapear when he gets Obli off of him. He is seen to be so insanely injured that he is bleeding to a disgusting degree, obli itself causes blood and its spread throughout his entire body and as soon as he gets in the water, obli just goes off? and the injuries are nowhere. Really fucking bad imo||

rocky charm
#

Y'know, Karera's been missing for a while

elfin rivet
#

karera gonna get bodied if she comes bavk lol

viral plume
#

I miss karera

ruby river
#

good ol early jjl

sudden nymph
lofty quail
#

this is where the addiction to the joshu torture porn starting taking effect

primal lintel
sudden nymph
primal lintel
#

Oh aight

rocky charm
#

Rai and Josuke both got hit by several Calamities

sudden nymph
ruby river
#

also this means that there are no new rokas left right

sudden nymph
#

Yeah I think

rocky charm
ruby river
#

less likely

sudden nymph
#

Unless there is that they are all gone

ruby river
#

plus the higashikata garden was on fire

#

doubt the tree survived

sudden nymph
#

Maybe there are more than two on the branch

#

It just hasn’t even started growing yet

ruby river
#

maybe

#

though without the mcguffin of the part

winter spade
#

At the very least the cactus grafted rokakaka branch is out of usable fruits now

ruby river
#

the conflict dies

runic adder
sudden nymph
#

I wish Araki gave nut king call and paisley park a barrage sound for when they did there barrage

ruby river
#

im pretty sure that exchanging with someone to heal WAS a smart move, but not with yasuho

hard meteor
#

Well there is another way to heal the curse away

runic adder
#

Don’t mention rais curse line

viral plume
runic adder
#

Don’t you dare mention it

runic adder
ruby river
#

cause if tooru ran away then he would just be hit with the bubble

sudden nymph
viral plume
#

But only two have fruit is the thing

winter spade
runic adder
viral plume
runic adder
#

The theory is that josefumi grafted two branches, and this can be visible seen during the vitamin c arc

viral plume
#

But they mentioned tooru...

winter spade
#

Josefumi only removed 2 branches when he pulled off the branch heist on aisho

runic adder
#

So because rai never actually saw the second branch, someone else stole it

#

Before it got burned

winter spade
#

Entirely possible

runic adder
#

It is possible

upper knoll
ruby river
#

maybe

winter spade
#

Kaato perhaps?

sudden nymph
#

Let that happen

runic adder
#

I think it kind of undermines the entire hunt for the locacaca?

ruby river
#

its highlikely kaato

winter spade
#

Well it depends how it’s handled

ruby river
#

shes already around during the branch arc

sudden nymph
#

I’m pretty sure it’s Caato not Kaato but it doesn’t matter

runic adder
runic adder
upper knoll
#

Unless...?

ruby river
#

im comfortable with kaato

runic adder
#

Yea doesn’t entirely matter, it’s just one letter

hard meteor
#

Yeah but I prefer Kaato more

runic adder
#

And it’s pronounced the exact same

ebon rampart
#

I will kick that cringe ass nae nae baby

runic adder
#

Don’t you dare

#

Tsurugi doesn’t deserve that

ruby river
#

i wish toorus death was slightly more climactic

winter spade
#

Tsurugi is precious

winter spade
runic adder
viral plume
ruby river
#

rn Rai's death is the most impactful one

sudden nymph
#

I’m gonna send this based picture again

runic adder
ruby river
winter spade
#

Well it was just spreading off of the blood josuke already had on him?

runic adder
ruby river
#

well thats good

runic adder
#

Until he turns to rock he’s not dead

winter spade
#

And the blood from his attempts to get it off himself

ruby river
#

oh yeah

runic adder
winter spade
#

Idk how water removed Obladi so easily but it’s a bug so

runic adder
#

Obladi was still eating his flesh tho

viral plume
#

Fucking...what

runic adder
#

Like the wounds would still be there

ruby river
#

hot spring maybe?

winter spade
runic adder
#

The blood could be dissipated from the water, but the wounds are there still

viral plume
#

He should be bleeding out

ruby river
#

he could simply drown it at this point

runic adder
#

And did obladi just...eat the rock eye off?

#

Lol

viral plume
#

Dont tell me it diiiiiiiiiiiiiid

winter spade
#

It’s not like it was carving through his hand, it just latched onto the skin on his hand

ruby river
#

lol what

runic adder
sudden nymph
hard meteor
#

Meh never really cared about the rock eye

#

He looks better without it

viral plume
runic adder
#

As a retcon it’s not a huge deal

sudden nymph
viral plume
#

Like, fucking what? Thats it? Hes not gonna bleed to death?

ruby river
#

IT FUCKING DID

viral plume
#

JOJO HAS ESTABLISHED THAT PEOPLE CAN BLEED TO DEATH! TWICE!!!

#

No, THRICE!!!

true ore
#

abbachio

#

kakyoin

#

who else

winter spade
#

Also wait why does Obladi go “gah” when it’s drowned lol

viral plume
#

Kakyoin and abba were because their internal organs were gone

winter spade
#

Is the bug itself making that noise?

hard meteor
#

Yes it makes sounds

ruby river
#

bro obli literally ate rock eye

sudden nymph
runic adder
#

Josuke didn’t die to bleeding, jobin alive confirmed Smugechi

viral plume
#
  • bloodloss
viral plume
#

Thats a based take, ya know

runic adder
#

Jobins leg is still fucked up tho

true ore
runic adder
#

Ofc I don’t think he will die but he’s still incredibly injured

sick gate
sudden nymph
runic adder
viral plume
true ore
#

damn

ruby river
#

btw is the next chapter coming in may

viral plume
#

And Abba was around the chest area

true ore
#

welp i thought jojo sense would kick in

ruby river
#

or we have another hiatus

hard meteor
#

Yes

sudden nymph
hard meteor
#

It comes in may

runic adder
#

No hiatus I think

viral plume
#

||OBLI WAS ON HIS FUCKING FACE!!! WHY ARE THERE NO INJURIES!!!!||

#

AAAAAAAAAAAAAA

ruby river
#

well, we'll find out if kaato is a villan or not

runic adder
viral plume
hard meteor
#

Damage isn’t consistent in jojo

#

This is not new

viral plume
#

I HATE THAT THIS IS ONE OF THE WORST CASES!!!

winter spade
#

Yeah I also think the blood was simply signifying where Obladi was spreading to

viral plume
#

THIS IS IN THE SAME CHAPTER!!!!

sudden nymph
sick gate
#

why would Kaato attack Josuke or Yasuho now though

winter spade
#

Not that the bug itself was causing much damage

runic adder
#

I believe both will come back

sudden nymph
winter spade
#

Since we even see that the ones on his chin aren’t digging into his skin

viral plume
runic adder
#

Im a certified jojolion hopium inhaler

ruby river
#

isnt yasuho at her most vaurnable

#

and with tooru almost down

bitter tundra
#

Just read chapter 106 and I just wanna say

#

Tooru get BTFO LOL

winter spade
ruby river
#

she probably wants to heal tsurugi

#

ooooooooor

true ore
ruby river
#

she could be with rock humans

upper knoll
#

what

winter spade
#

Also I didn’t even notice but Kaato has her card deck on her hip

viral plume
#

The floor was drenched in blood, obli was causing a fuckton of damage to Josuk8

ruby river
#

btw which song refference is "go beyond"

kind owlBOT
#

@ruby river, Your Hamon Rank is now level 6 !

viral plume
#

||And we straight up see here that parts of his face are bleeding allot||

sick gate
#

probably a lyric or something else

hard meteor
ruby river
#

are you sure its that

hard meteor
#

It’s the closest we could find

ruby river
#

sub ability

#

its normal now

sick gate
#

could be

viral plume
#

This is Soft & Wet.

ruby river
#

way better than evolution

viral plume
#

And this, is to go even further beyond...

upper knoll
#

Oh I didnt even think it could a song reference

ruby river
#

uh, thats obvious though?

upper knoll
#

seems not

winter spade
#

It’s always a song reference

sick gate
#

Love train’s lyrics are tied into it’s ability to an extent

ruby river
#

i mean, "to go beyond" is our only bet rn

sick gate
#

I don’t know that To Go Beyond song so idk if that holds true

ruby river
#

its written by enya

upper knoll
#

Well it's an Enya song so its plausible

ruby river
#

soooooo

#

yeah

viral plume
#

Sorry for harping on this so much, but it was on his fucking throat dude NotLikeThis

winter spade
#

Idk

viral plume
#

God, this annoys me when I see it

winter spade
#

At this point I think araki just wanted to incapacitate josuke without prolonging a fight with Obladi Obladi

crystal ginkgo
winter spade
#

Since it would be boring af and draw attention away from the fight with WoU

ruby river
#

another prince refference would give me an orgasm

viral plume
#

I guess

crystal ginkgo
#

when the alien crawled inside ryan reynolds through his mouth and ate his insides

#

that was terrifying

viral plume
#

I understand the intent, but by god could he have made the structure of it all better

winter spade
#

Probably

crystal ginkgo
#

i was thinking araki could do something similar

#

in terms of body horror

viral plume
#

Also, we gonna talk about ||how Mitsuba and the group got fucking blasted by the door||

winter spade
#

||She uses Tsurugi as a shield lol||

hard meteor
#

That was the impact from the house

winter spade
#

^