sk-discussion

[heavy minnow]

Nahh reaper is the only defensive type crest

[fathom rapids]

With the already crazy bind passive, what ya think they should buff

[native canyon]

SUCH A GOOD EFFECT

[rich herald]

reaper bind is the weakest of them all

[fathom rapids]

Game changing fr

[heavy minnow]

Ah yes the reaper crest is based of grim, for sur- oh my god you're right

[dawn needle]

Crust King Khann really becomes a pushover once you're used to his moveset

[native canyon]

reaper bind would be incredibly goated if it gave a speed buff like beast

[pure pine]

Consindering most bosses is so damn aggressive, i think i agree (?)

[native canyon]

imagine reaper nuke build but reaper bind has a speed buff that'd just be better witch arguably

[glacial rivet]

I'd much rather have the +50% needle damage from the Flintslate, much more consistent.

[low pond]

maybe I should do an area gauntlet

[hybrid root]

Reaper Bind should add needle damage

[rancid stag]

sk gets so boring lategame bc you've killed most bosses and basically just doing only quests

[rich herald]

reaper crest is named reaper because greymoor was a farming town…

[heavy minnow]

Reaper buff should be 2% speed buff for every silk particle you get during the burst

[rich herald]

True…

[glacial rivet]

That, and the idea of smiting your opponents with a flaming weapon is just plain awesome.

[rich herald]

tbh it should just add the extra silk it generates after binding to your total automatically

[earnest drift]

I wish pollip pouch and flintslate didn’t have anti synergy

[rich herald]

and remove a red tool slot for an extra silk skill slot

[verbal trench]

maybe just make each hit spawn more orbs than it does right now, i think how it is right now is fine but giving it a buff would give a bit more incentive to use it

[native canyon]

anyways I tire so good night chat good night oomf @rich herald and look at this

[earnest drift]

because a flaming poison blade is fucking sick

[heavy minnow]

But the sprint attack is grim's and the normal attack is nkg's fireball attack

[sharp slate]

I could see that

[earnest drift]

eepy

[rich herald]

I wish pollip pouch would DIE

[light swan]

:( witch always gets left behind

[hybrid root]

SoS will give us the Alchemist’s Crest which has lifeblood mask and tank shenanigans just so Reaper has no niche after the early game

[earnest drift]

but it’s so cool and purple weapons

[rich herald]

goodnight shades i love these 2 characters that are merely acquaintances

[low pond]

which is better, Coral Tower or The Mist

1️⃣ for Coral Tower
2️⃣ for mist

[earnest drift]

also did anyone notice that generally the better a red tool is, the worse it synergises with pollip pouch

[sharp slate]

time to do my pantheon run of the day yolo

[pure pine]

Should i honestly try upgrading Hunter Crest and get used to its pogo

[sharp slate]

cogflies are horrible noted (joking)

[heavy minnow]

At least the tower looks cool

[orchid locust]

it’s a 0.2 percent increase which is pretty close to 0.25 which is a quarter and a quarter is almost as big as a half cent which is 0.5 and 0.5 is half of 1 which in probability is your whole range so it’s 50%

so in conclusion dice boosts wanderer crit chance by 50%

[verbal trench]

i like reaper but the passive ability of the bind isn't really enough to make me want to use it over something like hunter

[earnest drift]

cogflies don’t synergise that well with pollip pouch, only if you have one out at a time

[verbal trench]

but if the ability is either given a buff where more orbs spawn or the time is extended i think more people would like it

[heavy minnow]

Is fully upgraded hunter a good crest?

[hybrid root]

The passive is more to mitigate Reaper’s downsides than actually making it strong on its own

[earnest drift]

it’s the best

[coarse leaf]

fuck yea it is

[sharp slate]

yep, high damage if you dont get hit

tbh you are probably still getting hit though

[hybrid root]

All crests are good so yeah absolutely

[light swan]

it’s the strongest

[pure pine]

Godhome players dream ngl

[low pond]

which is better Mount Fay or Cogwork Core

1️⃣ for Mount Fay
2️⃣ for Cogwork Core

[heavy minnow]

I cant use architect nor shaman

[coarse leaf]

trust illusion on that, he made those witch quick kill gifs

[sharp slate]

maybe, i have been liking wanderers more for godhome so far, more consistancy (i defintely think hunter, wanderer, beast are godhome crests imo)

[heavy minnow]

Mount fay is so peak but cogwork got that epic music

[light swan]

trust me on what

[glacial rivet]

Yep, sadly, fire and poison don't really mix well.

[unkempt prairie]

Is this silkposting? Cuz they don't have silkpost tag on it

[coarse leaf]

statement of hunter is best

[hybrid root]

Both are amazing crests

[glacial rivet]

But fire and electricity mix wonderfully.

[fathom rapids]

No shit

[earnest drift]

but the purple flintslate looks so cool

[earnest drift]

what is this

[sharp slate]

hunter is the best if you are just comparing raw dps numbers which i still think is a useless metric

[low pond]

it’s a tie so vote now or forever hold your peace and let the wheel decide

[sharp slate]

watch me smack grand reeds is such a bad metric for judging crests imo

[verbal trench]

cogwork core music was so damn good i had to stand there for a few minutes when i first heard it to just absorb it

[glacial rivet]

Flintslate + Volt Filament, Flintslate for buffing melee, Volt Filament for buffing Silk Skills like Cross Stitch and Pale Nails.

[coarse leaf]

no it's genuinely a very strong buff

[pure pine]

Beast is good for godhome, except for like, the PoP ahh pogo

[light swan]

aint no one talking about using grand reed to judge rn

[heavy minnow]

I mean nobody is gonna complain if i say reaper is the worst if you want to go fast

[sharp slate]

its a strongh buff, if you can hold it consistently, thats the problem (im assuming for most players even highly skilled ones they cant)

[coarse leaf]

well, I can

[light swan]

i personally think hunter is just the strongest flat out when player correctly

[heavy minnow]

What about witch + druid eye

[vivid belfry]

recovering from damage (that is to say, not dying) necessitates landing a bunch of hits without taking damage yourself

[sharp slate]

im curious how much up time is needed to be better than wanderers for the buff

[light swan]

because it were talking about player error included then every crest sucks

[light swan]

what’s the point of this

[glacial rivet]

Reaper is less speed and more methodical; analyze the opponent's attack pattern, dodge, and counterattack, rather than attack blindly, it rewards defensive combat.

[ruby dune]

Yes its Silkposting

[low pond]

Which is better the slab or the underworks

1️⃣ for slab
2️⃣ for underworks

[rich herald]

unrelated but is your username an umineko/higurashi reference

[heavy minnow]

Exept wanderer because you can litterally push skarr lady and kill her asap

[ruby dune]

Slab

[sharp slate]

fair, but you can heal alot in this game as well, 9 hits doesnt bring you to full damage boost from hunters right? 9 hits heal 9 hits heal not getting full damage

[light swan]

so does witch i love wirch

[vivid belfry]

yes I just played Umineko like last month

[rich herald]

based i love umineko

[vivid belfry]

I don't think it brings you to full but the second threshold is a smaller damage boost than the first one anyway

[fluid arch]

any idea how to hit this lever from this side?

[rancid stag]

anyone that plays don't starve together i wanna hear y'alls opinions

what's the best duo oat that can be made

[vivid belfry]

I skipped Higurashi but I'm playing it now

[heavy minnow]

Its for people that like to heal or use silk abilities

Like me

[pure pine]

What the.

[rich herald]

I have a better question

[coarse leaf]

great slash prolly gets it?

[light swan]

what if i just removed healing from the game

[vivid belfry]

ehhhh the slow attack speed gets in the way of silk generation

[pure pine]

Wormwood and Woodie (/j)

[heavy minnow]

Shaman crest?

[light swan]

that would make people actually play well rather than just healing every time they get hit

[sharp slate]

yea fair, i would be intrested to see the calcs on uptime needed to compare to others crests damage, i might do that in the future just for fun tbh

[light swan]

can still heal

[dawn needle]

Khann has perished.

[heavy minnow]

Wait what how

[light swan]

press the heal button

[heavy minnow]

Im stupid bro i was mixing hollow knight's keybinds

[low pond]

which is better the Marrow or Shellwood

1️⃣ for marrow
2️⃣ for shellwood

[light swan]

what 😭

[ruby dune]

https://tenor.com/view/address-me-gif-3314967408153193330

[light swan]

first off how second off what does that even change

[glacial rivet]

I, too, like using Silk skills, but I think the Shaman Crest's 3 silk slots is excessive. The Queen Crest modded Crest is ideal, I feel. 1 Red slot, 1 yellow slot, 3 blue slots, 2 silk slots. You have everything you need.

[rich herald]

do you not use your hk keybinds largely for silksong too

[young saffron]

Shell woods way better wtf, the marrow does not have enough meat to it

[light swan]

cant you still heal by pressing heal in hk

[young saffron]

Not saying it's a bad area but compared to shell wood

[ruby dune]

Dont take that out of context

[heavy minnow]

Like the button to heal and use spells is the same in hk

So i thought using the heal would do a silk ability instead of heal cuz it replaces red tools
Its like 4 am im not clean

[young saffron]

[fluid arch]

tried that. i cant think of any other way to hit the switch

[rich herald]

both the marrow and shellwood are quite boring

[pure pine]

Those tree looking mf don't look like meat

But the environment look good ngl

[white sequoia]

Think about it

[coarse leaf]

self react spotted

[heavy minnow]

I have seen them in the same room

[light swan]

all act 1 areas are low-key boring except for greymoor shellwood and blasted steps personally

[rocky lotus]

i hate pavo now

[young saffron]

Act 3 slop

[light swan]

i can’t fucking type

[heavy minnow]

Abyss was peak wtf

[low pond]

Which is better Sands of Karak or Hunter’s March

1️⃣ for SOK
2️⃣ for HM

[light swan]

i messed up replacing 3 with 1 four times

[rich herald]

i thought pavo was cool until i realized he is basically a landlord

[fluid arch]

uh i dont have a hitbox anymore

[young saffron]

My "hot" take is that act 3 was kinda buns

[white sequoia]

Think of their attitude in act 2 compared to act 3

[light swan]

i somehow typed a fucking basketball and autocorrect stopped me from typing one like twice

[pure pine]

I ain't gonna step on fire ant bro

[dapper sail]

How do i learn the lore

[pure pine]

Def 1

[pure pine]

#sk-lore

[heavy minnow]

Yeah but lore is cool

[pure pine]

Or uh, the tablet in the game

[glacial rivet]

I like Pavo, a bit sensitive and overly emotional, but he means well enough, and, he gives Hornet a HOUSE.

[low pond]

WHAT THE HECK I DIDNT EXPECT SOK TO GET A SINGLE VOTE?!

[light swan]

my hot take is that act 3 was fun

[young saffron]

WYM, hunters match and deep docks was very nice

[rich herald]

Early early game hunters march though… 🤑

[pure pine]

We ain't stepping on fire ant bro

[light swan]

i think they’re boring

[rancid stag]

as a don't starve together player yes i main webber

[light swan]

hunters march was more interesting but in retrospect they’re still boring

[heavy minnow]

"Half the game sucks"

[plucky stag]

this has to be a silkpost because otherwise i'd have seen more people talking about this date

[young saffron]

Severe lack of a green path + queen garden equivalent in silksong

[pure pine]

You control spidey boy main??

[dawn needle]

I now have one heart to get

[light swan]

lower deepdocks should’ve been act three exclusive

[rich herald]

you mean to tell me you dont love fighting the big ass skarrguard without any items…

[rancid stag]

yeah

[light swan]

no just cuz areas are boring doenst mean half the game sucks

[heavy minnow]

Moss grotto? Shellwood? Verdania?

[dawn needle]

Skarr Singer Karmelita

[light swan]

oh it was super fun and so was everything after the area itself was just boring tho

[fervent viper]

all act 1 areas lowk boring except mosshome, bone marrow, deep docks, hunters march, far fields, greymoor, blasted steps and shellwood

[heavy minnow]

Fun boss

[young saffron]

Moss groto is too small, shell wood is not green path, verdanaia yeah ig verdanaia can pass

[rich herald]

incredibly weird how it just is not

[low pond]

Which is better, the highest of the highs or the lowest of the lows

1️⃣ for Abyss
2️⃣ for Cradle

[rich herald]

fair

[heavy minnow]

Memorium is kind of like queen's garden too

[light swan]

i never once thought to myself “damn this is a cool area” until greymoor

[rich herald]

I like itemless hunters march even though its kinda nothing at all besides the enemies and that one gauntlet

[glacial rivet]

A house that can be upgraded with a sauna. Hornet deserves to kick back and relax every so often, given the crap she has to deal with in the completely insane land of Pharloom.

[young saffron]

When you play silksong after coming from HK the enemies in hunters match are great to see

Super cool encounters

But that's just my opinion :(

[misty storm]

I just beat father of the flame it was not fun

[rich herald]

but then shakra shows up and ruins the fun 💔

[light swan]

oh skarr stalkers are my favorite enemies in the entire game by far

[low pond]

tie game

[heavy minnow]

The marrow was so cool like wdym you dont like fire and lava?

[young vortex]

when does normal garmond stop being fightable
the wiki says it's when you get the threefold melody but i swear i remember hearing that it's when you get two thirds of the threefold melody

[light swan]

the area itself was still kind of boring

[rich herald]

deep docks:

[arctic epoch]

me to but it was sands of karak

[light swan]

nothing made it interesting jts just bones and lava

[stable mica]

u can fght garmond???

[heavy minnow]

No thats bad but since deep nest ive ptsd of the word deep

[young vortex]

yes

[misty storm]

Should I use the lantern tool for the high halls gauntlet I’ve heard so much about

[young saffron]

Praying the dlc is like elden rings dlc 😔😔

[light swan]

there’s no cool backdrops or interesting concepts or even unique colors until greymoor

[ruby dune]

Yes go to whispering vaults

[rich herald]

deep docks is the better fire area
the marrow is just bone bottom and deep docks had a baby and it created a very boring and uninteresting area

[light swan]

good looking but not unique and interesting

[young saffron]

In your opinion, rank the 3 acts

[heavy minnow]

Mosshome?

[light swan]

very fun but still boring

[stable mica]

use cog work wheel is good for the clappers

[misty storm]

Alright

[light swan]

still believe the same thing

[rich herald]

Mosshome is also boring af

[stable mica]

if u want go with tacks

[rich herald]

i honestly liked the mist

[light swan]

2 1 3 best to worst act 3 loses purely content wise

[young saffron]

I think for me I'm just a sucker for chill environments and calm ost, I found each area to be very immersive

[misty storm]

I might use ascendants grip with the lantern for infinite damage but I’m not sure

[clear delta]

I loved deep docks and far fields tbh

[rich herald]

the mist probably in my top 3 act 1 areas

[heavy minnow]

Im not a silksong glazer at all but gotta say the game is very diverse and very entertaining to see and play

[low pond]

Which is better, Bone Bottom or Songclave

1️⃣ for BB
2️⃣ for SC

[clear delta]

Ik most of the early game areas feature lava but they feel sufficiently different

[light swan]

yea same

[rocky jolt]

bone bottom is kinda ahh

[pure pine]

Did you donate tho

[sharp slate]

1 hit to phantom so far i hate myself lol, 😭

[arctic epoch]

just sad that they rushed Act 3

[young saffron]

How does one access the mist in act 1? Do you not need double jump?

Or do you skip using a pogo off a crow

[light swan]

why would you need double jump or skips

[rich herald]

sinners road entrance

[ruby dune]

Cant believe ts is not popular in HK youtube

[vivid belfry]

I think Jubilana is an asshole in a more interesting way than Flick so I pick songclave

[rancid stag]

tbh i don't know why i play a lot of wes now

[rocky jolt]

i kinda wish songclave got attacked by a beastfly

[heavy minnow]

Yeah you got a forge, a volcano, some kind of volcanic outskirts

[young saffron]

I thought the jump is too far to reach with a sprint jump

[clear delta]

Songclave gets attacked by the Supreme Reed if you kill too many grand reeds for damage testing

[rocky jolt]

who x reacted

[light swan]

what jump are you talking about

[rich herald]

it isnt

[rancid stag]

silkshot made in mt fay is the best one right?

[ruby dune]

Is ts true

[rich herald]

you just need to break a wall

[clear delta]

Yeah

[low pond]

which is better, Choral Chambers or Bilewa- ok do I really need to do this one

1️⃣ for CC
2️⃣ for BW

[young saffron]

The one from half way home to reach sinners road

[ruby dune]

Bilewater is the best

[pure pine]

Me and someone else before me

[heavy minnow]

Dont even put the :2:

[arctic epoch]

CHORAL CHAMBERS GET SLAMMED BOY

[low pond]

6-7

[young saffron]

Bile water is legit a good area lol

[clear delta]

I like both but I have to give it to CC

[sleek cypress]

6 7 😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹

[rancid stag]

i think both tbh

[rich herald]

this is accessible in act 1 without skips yes

[heavy minnow]

Something something silkpost

[pure pine]

GET OUT

[worldly lake]

hi

[stable mica]

Groal is ez, its hard cuz the run back is shit

[light swan]

bilewater is unironically my favorite area in the game and definitely my best experience in the game so far

[low pond]

No shot Bilewater stands a chance no way

[young saffron]

Damn I'm just stupid then

[light swan]

still don’t know any jump at all

[heavy minnow]

Shoot this man

[worldly lake]

something something pure instinct

[sleek cypress]

1 is the best one

[ruby dune]

I like Bilewater to

[light swan]

shooting me for a fucking opinion okay

like my bad for enjoying the game

[arctic epoch]

One moment it's a genuine fun conversation

The next it's filled with oversatured number brainrot that doesn't even mean anything funny...

[young saffron]

Bile water ost is top tier

[heavy minnow]

Shoot him too

[ruby dune]

No

[light swan]

bilewater has the best song in the game

[heavy minnow]

I will shoot anyone that even enjoy bilewater

[rich herald]

the only lame part about bilewater is stilkin jumpscares but otherwise its genuinely peak and overhated as fuck

[stable mica]

prob to make the area not entirely bad

[light swan]

what if i shoot you first

[low pond]

bilewater wins

[clear delta]

Bilewater was lowkirkenuinely fun to explore

[young saffron]

TRUE

[heavy minnow]

garama

[light swan]

stilkin which only spawn in 4 rooms btw

[worldly lake]

i've barely been to bilewater so i can't judge

[ruby dune]

The only annoying part was Stilkins but then again you can counter rhem with Pogos

[pure pine]

Send a firing squad after this guy (/j)

[clear delta]

Yeah didn't really like the stilkins whole mechanic

[stable mica]

muck maggots r annoying + benchs r rare

[young vortex]

bilewater actually is peak but its problem is that it's way too good at what it does and what it does is being intentionally awful

[clear delta]

But it's very unique

[rich herald]

how to avoid muckmaggots: Dont fall in

[ruby dune]

Grr you will watch this (/j)

[arctic epoch]

Bilewater is genuinely peak fiction

it's so peak there is a stockholm syndrome slander

[light swan]

muck maggots make the game more tense and interesting to navigate through

[heavy minnow]

Ahah so fun xd 20 explosive enemies and 20 explosive pogo + 20 hidden enemies + you just lost all your silk to water

[sharp slate]

4 most annoying rooms in the game i

i still love bilewater though

[ruby dune]

The Hive had One Bench back in HK

Soul Sanctum had fucking 0

[low pond]

Which is better Blasted Steps or Sinner’s Road

1️⃣ for BS
2️⃣ for SR

[light swan]

if you don’t want to you can just not interact with them because there are silkfarms everywhere cuz tc is good as designing areas

[rich herald]

explosive enemies which you can easily get out of range for

[light swan]

lack of benches is not a bad thing

[rancid stag]

honestly webber is only good solo unless you know how to actually build a base for webber and another character

[ruby dune]

Sinners road is insanely overhated

[light swan]

ain’t no way youre complaining about the explosive enemies

[heavy minnow]

Not when there are 20 of them

[rich herald]

upper bilewater has some insanely fun platforming

[clear delta]

Most easiest thing to dodge in the entire game

[worldly lake]

sinner's road is not that bad

[rich herald]

this just does not happen

[light swan]

bilewater has some of the best rooms in the game with the bloatroaches

[rancid stag]

and

[heavy minnow]

You like path of pain dont you

[rich herald]

it is not that crazy

[velvet verge]

bilewater is top 5 areas for me but I totally understand why people dislike it

[rancid stag]

i do

[sharp slate]

tbh my only problem with bilewater is the bullshit hidden bench

[rich herald]

yeah because. its fun

[low pond]

y’all are forgetting about the muckroaches

[heavy minnow]

Youre a vessel not meant to feel

[rancid stag]

[sharp slate]

yes lets hide a bench where someone has to willing jump into maggots for

[heavy minnow]

So you like pain

[rancid stag]

well i like Path of pain

[low pond]

ok then sinners road wins

[rich herald]

yes!

[arctic epoch]

Path of Pain is fun actually, y'all Path of Pain hater is too spoiled by TC to know what an intentionally frustrating platformer challenge is

[atomic crow]

am the only one that actually found that by my self

[clear delta]

Clawline + double jump

[rich herald]

white palace is my favorite area in hk

so yes i love me some platforming

[clear delta]

Very valid tbh

[sharp slate]

i meant to find it

[heavy minnow]

At least pop is fair and square
Bilewater is catch these hands or ill take your wallet

[rancid stag]

i love it for the platforming

[velvet verge]

the feeling of stumbling onto sinner's road, the mist and bilewater pretty much simultaneously is just unbeatable to me

[light swan]

nothings obviously perfect but bilewater was still my top 1 silksong experiences

nothing can change that

[worldly lake]

honestly there are only a few muckroaches that are actually a problem

[arctic epoch]

Bilewater is fair

it respects you once you learn the area

[heavy minnow]

Yeah valid

[low pond]

Whiteward vs Putrified Ducts

1️⃣ is for WW
2️⃣ is for PD

[heavy minnow]

I will never forgive them for the bench that bring you back to 3 floors down

[velvet verge]

putrified ducts has FLEATOPIA!!!!

[atomic crow]

god who actually likes ducts

[light swan]

bilewater makes sure youre good it doenst hold your hand

and jt doenst encourage you into a passive playstyle at all due to traps and muckmwggots and the enemy design

it’s aftually so good

[rancid stag]

people like ducts? (apart from topia ofc)

[arctic epoch]

imagine getting clipped farm

[dawn needle]

I tried earlier
Got turned into an example of what trypophobic people are scared of

[light swan]

horrible run back

[heavy minnow]

Either mental or physical trauma

[orchid dome]

[rich herald]

ducts has fleatopia while whiteward adds some of the coolest lore and atmosphere to the game

[velvet verge]

but like
fleatopia

[ruby dune]

I like Ducts

[rancid stag]

it also has a silk heart

[low pond]

whiteward lowkey too small

[dawn needle]

(Trypophobia is the fear of lots of small holes)

[heavy minnow]

There is no holes tho?

[arctic epoch]

i like Ducts because i think the primal aspid reference is funny

[ruby dune]

Because i find Barnaks fun

Because i am a Half Life fan ngl

[dawn needle]

Im basically saying I got turned into swiss cheese

[heavy minnow]

Oh lol

[clear delta]

I think whiteward is fine as it is but yeah would benefit from being bigger

[rich herald]

ductsuckers are so cute

[low pond]

Deepnest is one of the biggest areas while whiteward is teeny tiny and only spawn a single dregged enemy outside of bosses or gauntlets

[clear delta]

The area that really should've been bigger is high halls wtf were they doing

[worldly lake]

whiteward is lowkey just my favoite area

[dawn needle]

Shredded swiss cheese

[arctic epoch]

Any areas from Silksong would benefit from becoming bigger, but TC rushed the game

[light swan]

ducts is like bilewater but you take away all the good parts

barbed bracelet but there’s no damage boost

shaman crest but spells don’t exist

[night ruin]

Six more years

[light swan]

i agree silksong is too small for me

[rich herald]

raaaaughhh :)

[heavy minnow]

16 more years

[heavy minnow]

KILL THIS THING

[light swan]

only 3 areas truly captured my sense of exploration

[ruby dune]

Rip off Moss Charger

[clear delta]

Ducts has 3 extremely annoying enemies working together constantly

[velvet verge]

i NEED my dlc

[rich herald]

noooo theyre so cute

theyre just so beady eyed

[dawn needle]

The only redeeming quality those guys have is that they have floof

[low pond]

which memory is better

1️⃣ for RM
2️⃣ for LV

[heavy minnow]

Too many tentacles

[dawn needle]

how do I access those

[heavy minnow]

I didnt go to any xd

[rancid stag]

2 really good areas

[low pond]

just tap them

[atomic crow]

the tongue guys always make you get hit by the others

[ruby dune]

Ask #sk-help

[rich herald]

easily red memory it was the first time in silksong i genuinely cried

[heavy minnow]

It wouldve been so funny if you died there

[worldly lake]

i am at neither

[arctic epoch]

We could have had a city of steel reference
We could have seen Coral Gorge in its prime
We could have fought Prime Karmelita
We could have had Pharloom Bay
We could have had another ending
We could have had actual solid lore with no retcon
We could have had peak fiction

But TC needed to pump out a game every 7 years

[ruby dune]

Seeing the Stag Station sign and Wijgsmould was such peak

[dawn needle]

I think I accidentally closed without saving after killing Khann
uh
woops

[rich herald]

Gore of my comfort character…

[light swan]

if ducts was bigger and had a bit more crafted counter play i’d like it so much

[velvet verge]

||red memory is required for progression in act 3, lost verdania involves a "side quest" with the green prince in act 3||

[earnest drift]

we did fight prime karmelita

[night ruin]

Those bastards..

[clear delta]

"We could have had Pharloom Bay" just wait a few months bro 😭

[earnest drift]

i feel like people who keep demanding “prime” versions of bosses don’t really pay attention

[rancid stag]

june 3rd for sure

[arctic epoch]

WE COULD HAVE HAD PHARLOOM BAY 4 MONTHS AGO

[heavy minnow]

Silksong fans watching in horror as pharloom's bay become their new nightmare

[rich herald]

b-b-but muh godhome dlc!!11!1!1!!!1!1

[lofty shell]

the only prime version of boss i want is phantom

[light swan]

i really love the bluer colors the architecture of the ducts and bridges and pillars and outside of the aspids i love the enemy design

[earnest drift]

what retcons, the only thing that got changed was herrah being a weaver

[night ruin]

Red Memory is such a great look into our protagonist

[arctic epoch]

i demand Prime Karmelita, simply because she's way too easy

[clear delta]

This is why Khann needs a direct buff to his normal fight

[rich herald]

where is phantom lost kin fight

[ruby dune]

The only prime boss i want is groal

[earnest drift]

TRUTH NUKE

[velvet verge]

dlc 2 is most probably gonna be steel stuff

[night ruin]

Red memory also has such fantastic writing behind it

[ruby dune]

And i want a Savage Beastfly in there prime

[clear delta]

What if dlc 2 has a smaller scale

[low pond]

There is an odd number of areas so vote one of these 3 W areas to move on

1️⃣ for WV
2️⃣ for WT
🧌 for WW

[velvet verge]

I'd like prime chorus

[rich herald]

I want a harder fourth chorus but i doubt thatd show up

[arctic epoch]

i watched a retcon list video from mossbag but i'm just adding seasonings for the drama effect

[rocky lotus]

in dlc 2 we will get the craw king with 9 mandatory gauntlets before him

[atomic crow]

these are all pretty mid areas

[clear delta]

Love vaults

[earnest drift]

guys why don’t we fight prime lost lace smh team cherry is lazy

[heavy minnow]

Fourth chorus? Imagine fighting the 3 firsts at the same time

[light swan]

ngl i feel like so much of silksong would’ve had so much more appeal to be if it was just bigger

[velvet verge]

you get my vision

[ruby dune]

Ngl i like wisp thicket cause i like cults in games

But Whispering Vaults ost SLAPS

[rich herald]

whispering vaults probably the most boring area in the citadel

[heavy minnow]

But music

[clear delta]

High halls and grand gate

[rich herald]

nah

[ruby dune]

https://tenor.com/view/judge-sentencing-meme-bilewater-silksong-gif-6507327091380503587

[velvet verge]

whispering vaults would be the most boring area if not for TROBBIOOOOOOOOOOO

[atomic crow]

grand gate

[light swan]

too small

[rocky lotus]

i like whispering vaults

[young saffron]

Testing

[earnest drift]

HIGH HALLS IS BEAUTIFUL

[young saffron]

I think people feel this way mainly because hollow knight had godhome so in comparison it looks smaller than hk

[night ruin]

Block puzzle W

[heavy minnow]

Theyd be happy and thats the worst part

[rich herald]

high halls gauntlet and second sentinel fight
grand gate is fair though

[rancid stag]

i only like wisp thicket bc lantern (yes i use it for damage during bosses screaming)

[earnest drift]

if I was lace I would’ve spent all my time in high halls and killing pilgrims only in there

[rich herald]

yippee

[clear delta]

LIKE FOUR MAIN ROOMS AND A GAUNTLET AT THE END (It's cool though) AND IT BARELY LOOKS DIFFERENT FROM CHORAL CHAMBERS

[low pond]

Bellhart vs High Halls

1️⃣ for BH
2️⃣ for HH

[worldly lake]

TROBBIO !!!!!!!!!!!

[light swan]

i also wish the dinners road to bilewater connection was more hidden

and the vaults to bilewater connection more apparent / official entrance rather than secret

[ruby dune]

And you will watch this in Bilewater

[earnest drift]

THE FUCKING MUSIC AND ENEMY VOICE ACTING

[rich herald]

I will close my eyes

[clear delta]

High halls is genuinely potential area

[young saffron]

High halls is buns

[ruby dune]

No you cant if you close your eyes your executed

[clear delta]

THERES 2 NEW ENEMIES IUTSIDE OF RHE GAUNTLET

[earnest drift]

I’m dying because of the high balls slander

[rich herald]

But being executed spares me from having to watch that anyways so either option saves me

[heavy minnow]

High balls

[clear delta]

I know it won't happen but I genuinely would like a high halls expansion

[night ruin]

Peak platforming vs peak boss thats a toughie

[light swan]

hh was cool and fun but too small

[worldly lake]

https://tenor.com/view/silksong-widow-hornet-bonk-arito-gif-13643966964603239778

[clear delta]

Yeah genuinely needed more rooms

[trail holly]

uh you mean high halls?

[mystic knoll]

nah mount fay is the most boring honestly it's a poor mans path of pain

[low pond]

Deep Docks vs Greymoor

1️⃣ for DD
2️⃣ for GM

[clear delta]

Another flaw to me is that yes it has differences from choral chambers but they could've been more noticeable
Most of it is the same as the memorium anywaysss

[rough quiver]

Is there a way to translate the mottled skarr's dialogue?

[ruby dune]

Deep docks cause Ballow Exists

I love Ballow

[clear delta]

Quite close imo

[arctic epoch]

Act 1 Mount Fay:

[rich herald]

mount fay is not apart of the citadel
also get that slander out of here twin its PEAK

[night ruin]

Deep docks clears

[lofty shell]

ngl
forebrothers is the most underrated boss in silksong

[heavy minnow]

Greymoor was kinda disappointing
Like its cool but not as cool as i thought

[atomic crow]

‘citadel’

[rancid stag]

i need godhome dlc soon

[young vortex]

i like how he still says this if you do not take a single hit

[night ruin]

This guy gets it

[ruby dune]

https://tenor.com/view/juan-air-balloon-gif-22978602

[velvet verge]

greymoor is peak atmosphere

[mystic knoll]

mb mb i only ever got to it in the citadel

[arctic epoch]

-# peak atmosphere goes to Bilewater

[rich herald]

mount fay platforming is good stuff

[night ruin]

Love

[earnest drift]

worst area is Putrified ducts

[finite swift]

thank you, transsexual tapeworm

[lofty shell]

so basically
grimm troupe was a halloween DLC
we are not getting a christmas DLC anytime soon
my theory is that
we would get an easter DLC next after sea of sorrows

[atomic crow]

yes

[heavy minnow]

Worst area is pharloom

[velvet verge]

b-b-but... fleatopia!!!!!

[earnest drift]

worst area is city of tears

[rich herald]

Wormways worse imo

[rancid stag]

yeah hallownest lowk better

[night ruin]

Youre welcome absolute apostasy

[ruby dune]

Find the Moss Mother Eggs

[clear delta]

Objective worst area is grand gate

[trail holly]

are they putting resurrection of pablo aka hollow knight jesus in it or something

[heavy minnow]

Vine boom

[atomic crow]

or non act 3 wormways

[finite swift]

the WORSE objective is "Collect 10 ___"

[low pond]

Final round of round 1

Far Fields vs Moss Grotto

1️⃣ for FF
2️⃣ for MG

[trail holly]

i had high expectations for it honestly

[mystic knoll]

i like the little creatures that come out of the floor i think they are cute

[night ruin]

I guess the question is if we should be reviewing our understanding of what makes an area, furthermore a good one.

[heavy minnow]

Hallownest had free healthcare
Pharloom have catch these pilgrims needles

[velvet verge]

who ate the pixels

[heavy minnow]

Mb

[earnest drift]

what free healthcare

[mystic knoll]

hallownest had a freddie kruger moth

[clear delta]

If it shows up on the zoomed in map as a distinct area then it's an area

[atomic crow]

area is anything place you enter and like big text pops out imo

[rich herald]

bone bottom village or dirtmouth

[rancid stag]

sea of sorrows might be in easter

[night ruin]

?

[heavy minnow]

Free benches and no traps

[velvet verge]

there are at least 3 different objective definitions of "area" that I have seen being used

[atomic crow]

big text

[earnest drift]

I don’t think everyone gets healed just by sitting down

[night ruin]

Just goes to show we arent a monolith i suppose

[worldly lake]

mount fay isn't boring that's for sure

[mystic knoll]

what is the worst area including both hallownest and pharloom

[low pond]

Ok round one is finished here are the results

[heavy minnow]

Well everyone is kinda dead so that makes me the everyone

[clear delta]

Like the map which shows area room layouts

[rich herald]

royal waterways in hallownest wormways in pharloom

[worldly lake]

however it did also make me feel very bad feelings

[light swan]

why is wormways bad

[finite swift]

Hallownest when Pharloom lobotoimizes and forces their people to endless labour

[earnest drift]

worst to traverse, Putrified ducts
worst as in lame, Royal waterways

[light swan]

i thought waterways was cool

[clear delta]

Royal waterways is lame????

[mystic knoll]

worst as in lame

[light swan]

love the concept love the exploration

[atomic crow]

waterways is disgusting

[heavy minnow]

Waterways is just gross

[mystic knoll]

between both games which is the worst

[earnest drift]

ok then uh
idk fog canyon?

[clear delta]

Grand gate

[atomic crow]

waterways

[trail holly]

pharloom is detroit in like 1900s

[light swan]

fog canyon looks amazing so definirely not

[night ruin]

I suppose i shouldve thrown in the word "effectively" in there to avoid confusion

[atomic crow]

i hate waterways

[atomic crow]

WHATS WRONG WITH FOG CANYON

[heavy minnow]

Fog is peak and small outside of moromon

[finite swift]

Atleast Waterways have a disginuished water system compared to the Citadel

[mystic knoll]

personally i hate deepnest

[clear delta]

Fog canyon is really cool and unique even if it's dmall

[finite swift]

fuck ass nuclear bomb jelly fish

Monomon please why did you create nuclear bombs

[atomic crow]

just don’t hit them???

[clear delta]

Deepnest has too many cool enemies and critters

[velvet verge]

I love the lifeblood stuff but I'd say wormways is the worst area

[mystic knoll]

the cool critters are little bastards who take 2 hp

[heavy minnow]

Are you fr

[trail holly]

grand gate and white palace

[atomic crow]

my least favourite thing abt deepnest is the floor randomly breaking

[mystic knoll]

white palace is fun wdym??

[light swan]

theres only 2 areas throughout both games that have areas with contrasting hues
coral tower and fog canyon
so fog canyon gets my respect

[clear delta]

It may be annoying to traverse but like I genuinely love the enemy diversity in deepnest

[velvet verge]

grand gate would be worst but seth and nyleth are technically there depending on your definition

[finite swift]

Team Cherry please give us healthy yaoi please

[heavy minnow]

Deepnest and bile

[rich herald]

deepnest is great because nosk is there and nosk is a peak character

[low pond]

Coral Tower vs Cogwork Core

1️⃣ for CT
2️⃣ for CC

[trail holly]

i hate it

[clear delta]

They are there on the map yeah

[atomic crow]

i like both these areas 😭

[finite swift]

COGWORK CORE IS THE GOAT

[rich herald]

white palace is goated as fuck

[night ruin]

This is basically asking if you value combat or platforming

[atomic crow]

coral tower is so fun

[light swan]

so is core

[finite swift]

Its a ass area after you complete everything, including path of pain

[heavy minnow]

Core got peak music and peak gameplay

[clear delta]

Love both
Combat Vs platforming ig, core feels more like an area area so it gets my vote

[mystic knoll]

respectfully you can have your own opinion but yours is wrong in every sense fo the word

[trail holly]

i was expecting progression when i spent 3 days on white palace

[light swan]

coral tower was incredible for the first 10 seconds the rest it was still awesome but not enough to be better than core

[night ruin]

https://tenor.com/view/hollow-knight-silksong-silksong-this-post-was-fact-checked-this-post-was-fact-checked-by-real-citadel-patriots-silksong-grand-mother-silk-gif-15533073062746572687

[atomic crow]

no bcs theres only combat in one and both in the other

[velvet verge]

tower got peak visuals and peak gameplay

[low pond]

Slab vs SOK

1️⃣ for Slab
2️⃣ for SOK

[heavy minnow]

Did you get all the lore tablets and hidden areas

[night ruin]

Read that out loud three times in the mirror

[clear delta]

What's your favourite and least favourite CITADEL area

[trail holly]

#sk-discussion message

[rich herald]

not really, i do both repeatedly for fun even though ive done practically everything there is to do in a save file

[trail holly]

im crying why is nobody voting slab

[light swan]

favorite choral chambers least favorite memorium (not cuz its bad, everything else just better imo)

[rich herald]

also doing white palace without monarch wings is fun as hell

[ruby dune]

Choral Chambers is the best

Grand Gate is ass

[trail holly]

i'll try it later

[clear delta]

I loved memorium tbh

[heavy minnow]

Ok i was sure you were crazy but not that crazy

[light swan]

i dont like counting grand gate it just ruins discussions cuz its not actually an area

[velvet verge]

I love slab but the competition is steep

[night ruin]

Id like to vote Slab but im mad at tc for making the breakout sequence skippable

[mystic knoll]

quick question. How many times did you die to last judge

[velvet verge]

sands of karak is my personal favourite area

[light swan]

its awesome i just liked everything else more lol

[light swan]

valid

[clear delta]

Could've had more unique enemies though

[finite swift]

Last Judge was a goated boss

[ruby dune]

3-4

[trail holly]

isnt grand gate just like ONE room? i only hate it because of the fucking bells

i loved last judge sm

[heavy minnow]

Queen's garden but cool aka mini pharloom

[clear delta]

But crustcrags and mossgrubs and memoriae are good enough ig

[night ruin]

Infamous if nothing else

[light swan]

grand gate is like 3 rooms maybe 5

[mystic knoll]

hm so you really just hate it thought you just were salty you kept losing to last judge

[low pond]

Shellwood vs Cradle

1️⃣ for SW
2️⃣ for TC

[velvet verge]

depends on if you consider seth and nyleth part of it
because they technically are according to the minimap

[clear delta]

The Memoria should have showed up around memorium instead of barely being there

[light swan]

god i love cradle this is so sad

[rich herald]

what can i say its quite fun

[earnest drift]

cradle cos lace is there

[atomic crow]

cradle is just 2 bosses

[night ruin]

See what i mean like lol

[mystic knoll]

shellwood has my favorite boss

[ruby dune]

I just hate Grand Gate because its boring and you only visit it once or twice

[clear delta]

Team Cherry

[finite swift]

The cradle is both cool... But shellwood is bigger

[mystic knoll]

sister splinter

[trail holly]

still like 5 rooms max

[velvet verge]

also the one room with the balance puzzle is peak

[heavy minnow]

Cradle music and lore and bosses are peak

[ruby dune]

I mean i define Blasted Steps flea as Blasted Steps

[clear delta]

Cradle has insane atmosphere but shellwood is def more fleshed out

[mystic knoll]

i cant beat lace because i have a skill issue so i have a grudge against the cradle

[worldly lake]

sans of karak

[heavy minnow]

Also cradle have the path of inconvience

[night ruin]

Does the number of rooms play a factor? What if the area is intentionally small

[trail holly]

💔

[rich herald]

beast pogo surface platforming 🤤

[heavy minnow]

Bellhart is like 2 rooms and its peak

[low pond]

Songclave vs Bilewater

1️⃣ for SC
2️⃣ for BW

[ruby dune]

Damn

[trail holly]

wait for an interview lmao

[low pond]

bro.

[ruby dune]

Damn is😂😭

[trail holly]

LMAO 5 VOTES INSTANTLY

[heavy minnow]

ARE WE FOR REAL

[night ruin]

Wait r u sure? What do you define as a room

[rich herald]

bilewater mogs songclave

[finite swift]

Songclaves side view is cool. But Bilewater is better

[velvet verge]

nah
widow and the city are great, but the tunnels...

[heavy minnow]

THE RAGE BAIT IS TOO MUCH

[trail holly]

BILEWATER HOW DO I ASCENDDDD

[velvet verge]

songclave is barely an area

[light swan]

youre ragebaiting yourself rn

[mystic knoll]

bilewater can suck my left toe that freaking magot curse eating my silk is so annoying

[night ruin]

One has amazing writing and the other has muckmaggots

[heavy minnow]

1: bellhart
2: bellveins

[night ruin]

I mean i guess

[velvet verge]

on the area - subarea spectrum, songclave is lower than fleatopia

[mystic knoll]

the worst area in silksong is the mist

[heavy minnow]

Valid

[rich herald]

false

[atomic crow]

theres 2 bell veins so 3 rooms

[rich herald]

the mist is awesome sauce

[light swan]

if i had a coin eveyr time theres an endgame area called the cradle which has one boss from the beginning of the game and one new engame boss and is an area housing a "god", has an amazing ost but leaves exploration to be desired, and is also kinda blue, id have 2

just putting that out there

[heavy minnow]

There is also widow arena and hornet house so thats like 5

[low pond]

Sinner’s Road vs Whiteward

1️⃣ for SR
2️⃣ for WW

[atomic crow]

true

[gloomy hill]

What’s the other game? Xenoblade?

[heavy minnow]

Im sinning it so hard

[mystic knoll]

i didnt know how to get out of it was there some like needolin lore that told me to needolin near the butterflies?

[light swan]

sinners road was the thing where the more i played it the more i like it
opposite for whiteward'

[night ruin]

Whiteward lets you interact with sherma at his absolute best in terms of writing so i give it my vote

[low pond]

Also there’s an odd number of areas again so I’m bringing back Choral Chambers since it was robbed

[light swan]

afterimage

[finite swift]

White ward has amazing detail honestly

[gloomy hill]

[worldly lake]

songclave because it has sherma
-# in all seriousness this is literally coughing baby vs hydrogen bomb

[rich herald]

yea you play your needolin and follow the silk flies which leads you to the exhaust organ

[night ruin]

What makes one the coughing baby

[mystic knoll]

ik i alr beat phantom

[light swan]

oh yea both cradles have a very big geometric shape that the world somewhat revolves around!

[velvet verge]

coughing pilgrim VS. muck bomb

[mystic knoll]

which i hate because fighting hornet's duplicate with a hornet moveset sucks

[light swan]

if witch crest and bilewater didnt exist, afterimage would be my 2nd favorite game over silksong

[heavy minnow]

One sucks to have by your side and the other kills you

[rich herald]

phantom fight is peak cinema what the helly…

[low pond]

Lost Verdania vs Whispering Vaults

1️⃣ for LV
2️⃣ for WV

[night ruin]

Phantom is such a great boss

[clear delta]

What's the other cradle

[light swan]

both areas are too small but i think verdania looks cooler and has a better ost

[night ruin]

Lore lore lore lore

[trail holly]

VAULTS HOW DO I ASCENDDDD

[finite swift]

LOST VERDANIA WINS THE VOTE

[light swan]

the cradle from afterimage

[atomic crow]

lost verdania would be better if clover dancers wasn’t so ass

[night ruin]

Whispering vaults have lore

[ruby dune]

This whispering vaults disrespect shall not be tolerated

[heavy minnow]

Gorb

[finite swift]

Verdania is better because it has a unlimited supply of yaoi

[worldly lake]

it's 1 room and not a particularly interesting one (except for my goat sherma)

[mystic knoll]

i never went to verdania

[night ruin]

Oh fuck when you put it that way

[velvet verge]

clover dancers should have a third phase

[night ruin]

Does it need a lot of rooms?

[toxic holly]

Chat I just beat Cogwork dancers
EMOTIONAL TRAUMA

[atomic crow]

it was so ez and so boring

[weary hatch]

Clover dancers should have a reboot where its a good boss

[young vortex]

about to do high halls gauntlet in steel soul

[worldly lake]

again it's not a particular ly interesting room

[night ruin]

Also with all the dialogue you can enact in songclave what does it need to be more interesting

[mystic knoll]

emotional trauma for what? they prolly the 2nd easiest boss in the citadel

[atomic crow]

do u have help

[night ruin]

I thought the idea was that it is a haven

[toxic holly]

Phase 3 and 4

[velvet verge]

clover dancers IS a good boss honestly
but since we fought it expecting a better version of cogwork dancers, everyone went out disappointed

[rancid stag]

nice i just bought the snowfallen webber pack and got the carol emote
yes i'm playing don't starve together

[bronze spruce]

Its almost like its a bile, haven..

[mystic knoll]

i beat them 2nd try so idk how you had trouble with that

[worldly lake]

in terms of that then yes it does an excellent job conveying that

[trail holly]

@low pond WHERE IS THE NEXT VOTEE

[rancid flare]

https://tenor.com/view/marvel-fan4stic-fantastic-four-the-thing-say-that-again-gif-9345984830195785978

[weary hatch]

Yeah so the clankers clear 💯

[tiny pelican]

im so lost after act 3 started, what should i start with bruh i defeated bell eater now idk what else to do😭

[low pond]

Bellhart vs Greymoor

1️⃣ for BH
2️⃣ for GM

[toxic holly]

The emotional damage was the issue

[worldly lake]

but bilewater has like so much more to its name

[weary hatch]

Read ur objectives

[night ruin]

Saving bellhart is a highlight of act 1 for me

[low pond]

ok come on guys it’s greymoor

[worldly lake]

songclave is not beating bilewater

[atomic crow]

i don’t think u know what he’s talking abt

[heavy minnow]

Greymoor's rain is bilewater fyi

[light swan]

wait theres NO WAY BELLHART OVER GREYMOOR

[trail holly]

the most underwhelming area honestly

[velvet verge]

not everyone has the same skill level

[light swan]

WTFFFFFFFFFFFF

[atomic crow]

HOW IS BELLHART BETTER

[low pond]

ITS NOT THE SEA OF SORROW?!

[night ruin]

Bilewater has... well, bilewater. Songclave has sherma character development.

[weary hatch]

Greymoor is such a snoozefest sorry

[toxic holly]

Tf is happening

[light swan]

greymoor was actually so fun

[trail holly]

10:6 ratio is insane

[heavy minnow]

No its piss from the citadel

[plucky stag]

bellhart specifically is why i want to see an act 4; to see it devastated in act 3 is just sad emotionally

[atomic crow]

WHY IS BELLHART WINNING

[night ruin]

Bellhart has the widow where greymoor has the moorwing. The vote is clear

[light swan]

i explored it 3 different times and all 3 times were amazing

[mystic knoll]

greymoor was fun bro wdym?

[light swan]

it actually fullfilled my desire of exploration

[night ruin]

Also towns are cute

[finite swift]

GREYMOOR IS SO COOL WHAT DO YOU MEAN

[gloomy hill]

It’s cog dancers, if you got past Last Judge or Phantom shit should be atleast way easier than those two

[toxic holly]

Emotional damage

[clear delta]

Greymoor has so much shit going for it

[night ruin]

Bellhart has better upgrades too

[weary hatch]

Bellhart sweep

[low pond]

Far Fields vs Choral Chambers

Yall Bilewater stans eliminated it too soon so it’s back

1️⃣ for FF
2️⃣ for CC

[toxic holly]

https://tenor.com/view/hollow-silksong-cogwork-cogworks-cogwork-dancers-gif-762033653749454765

[mystic knoll]

the entire point of GREYmoor is to be "boring and dull" but it still has so much life

[light swan]

bellhart geniunely wtf

[finite swift]

BELLHART IS SUCH A SMALL AREA JRASJGDSGDJGDSHAG

[earnest drift]

I hate bonebottom

[light swan]

is that actually what its meant to be

[covert bloom]

this is so funny and dissapointing at the same time

[weary hatch]

And its awewsome

[mystic knoll]

i mean

[plucky stag]

i was so scared it was about to go beserk that i didn't pay attention to the screen there

[clear delta]

Ok fireb0rn

[toxic holly]

This was the issue with Cogwork dancers

[trail holly]

ditto

[night ruin]

This is a tough one for me there is so much you can do in cc

[earnest drift]

I hate fireb0rn too

[mystic knoll]

The name and atmosphere and enemies all speak for themselves

[misty storm]

I just beat the high halls gauntlet by using wispfire lantern and ascendants grip to cheese the clapper guys

[heavy minnow]

That doesnt make it good

[weary hatch]

😭

[night ruin]

But far fields has one of the best visuals ive ever seen

[toxic holly]

I was expecting an obobble

[light swan]

i genuienly cannot believe greymoor lost

[toxic holly]

Nope the opposite happened

[gloomy hill]

The only time I have actually been shocked or sad at a character’s death is Ghost of Tsushima

[light swan]

only act 3 act 1 lowkey boring but i said tha talready

[mystic knoll]

you can have your opinions but i stand with greymoor

[night ruin]

Bellhart has widow and better upgrades

[trail holly]

copium

[clear delta]

I tried watching his stream vods and they were kinda snoozefests so yeah me too maybe.

[young vortex]

from garmond

[night ruin]

Cap

[heavy minnow]

I like it but it couldve been so much better

[atomic crow]

ok

[young vortex]

and i did it! no loading required

[low pond]

Round 2 results

[weary hatch]

Guys hes just washed its ok

[light swan]

widow cannot carry an entire area, especially when we're ranking AREAS
upgrades does not changei f an area is more fun or not

[earnest drift]

who would win bretta vs the knight

[clear delta]

Is this even a question

[gloomy hill]

Greymoor is peak, Bellhart is ok

[plucky stag]

games do that so you don't have to restart the whole game to get 100%

[heavy minnow]

Lifeblood

[clear delta]

Actually bretta wins due to NPC plot armor

[tiny pelican]

i lowkey didnt notice that😭
Thank youu

[earnest drift]

no

[atomic crow]

i bet bilewater or bellhart wins

[light swan]

was it really more fun exploring and platforming through bellhart and its enemies compared to greymoor

[night ruin]

Widow surely can carry an entire area, not that she is or needs to. Why the hecky would you ever consider an area sans enemies in the first place? That just sounds stupid

[rancid stag]

knight if zote's alive and even dead

[trail holly]

tiso

[earnest drift]

I hate zote and pilby and pablo

[gloomy hill]

I love that we have more than 1 area with a grey/black colour scheme and a really nice boss

[covert bloom]

ik but the fact she thought she was stuck

[velvet verge]

how did mount fay lose in round one?? who was it against

[low pond]

Cogwork Core vs SOK

1️⃣ for CC
2️⃣ for SOK

[lofty shell]

greymoor needed more bosses

[light swan]

what does sans mean here

[low pond]

cogwork core

[gloomy hill]

People just be hating on Moorwing 🥀

[trail holly]

i had to react early sorry

[earnest drift]

if Pablo died there are approximately -0.5 people who would miss him with a margin of error of 0.5

[light swan]

like we arent rating the bosses in areas we're rating the areas themselves

[night ruin]

Also why wouldnt we consider upgrades in an area??????? So many exclusions...

[velvet verge]

makes sense

[atomic crow]

sorry karak 😔

[weary hatch]

Not even a question

[gloomy hill]

dlc surely

[low pond]

you good you’re really fast thank you for participating

[heavy minnow]

I swear if bilewater win the poll

[light swan]

they dont impact how fun the area is

[weary hatch]

I love u cofwork core

[median ivy]

should i play blasphemous

[night ruin]

Cogwork core has my favorite npc as well as my favorite platforming challenge

[clear delta]

It has 3!

[trail holly]

is that a compliment🥹

[clear delta]

And a new one unlocks in each act!!

[night ruin]

You shouldnt say that objectively

[low pond]

yah

[lofty shell]

moorwing is one
name the other two

[trail holly]

11:0 SWEEP IS INSANE

[weary hatch]

This is the fastest poll voter I know

[misty storm]

I got all of the melodies now

[light swan]

yea this entire conversation is subjective anyway

[velvet verge]

crawfather

[gloomy hill]

Cogwork core cause I hate sands of Karak cause it took away coral gorge

[clear delta]

Shakra and crawfather

[plucky stag]

I know, and to be fair she had good reason to believe that; many retro games (like smw and sm64) and even some modern games (like undertale pacifist route) just hang at the end screen and all you can do at that point is reset

[light swan]

i also think threadstorm and reaper crest are so much more interesting gameplaywise than 4 needle upgrades and needolin

[night ruin]

True it is literally a popularity vote.

[gloomy hill]

Shakra isn’t a real boss

[toxic holly]

Chat please tell me why I had to do the Cogwork dancers like that

[atomic crow]

i think everyone’s clicking the wrong button

[low pond]

Honestly this is a cool matchup since these are foils of each other

Shellwood vs Bilewater

1️⃣ for SW
2️⃣ for BW

[trail holly]

Silksong area popularity vote

[weary hatch]

Wdym shes in the game

[lofty shell]

crawfather is good i guess
shakra sucks

[clear delta]

Felt enough like one

[light swan]

BILEWATER!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[gloomy hill]

They deserved it

[trail holly]

BILEWATER MY GOATTT

[heavy minnow]

Didnt shellwood lose

[clear delta]

Bilewater is gonna win

[velvet verge]

I love bilewater but it can't win

[toxic holly]

I had to receive emotional damage for Cogwork core fuck it

[clear delta]

Bilewater will sweep

[finite swift]

waWAWAWA

[toxic holly]

NO NUH UH

[light swan]

10-2 !!!!!!!!!!! i love bilewater

[clear delta]

Bilewater or choral chambers maybe

[weary hatch]

Keep convincing urself

[gloomy hill]

Yes they did

[night ruin]

Im actually gonna go bilewater on this one. It does what shellwood is trying to do but in a more interesting way for me. Plus bilewater has better bosses

[toxic holly]

How so

[light swan]

bilewater is so good

[trail holly]

remove one vote because of obvious reasons

[fluid osprey]

HAHAHA I FINALLY BEAT THE CRAW LAKE GAUNTLET

[light swan]

9-1

[weary hatch]

Bilewater bad cuz I dont wanna fucking be there

[heavy minnow]

Thats fake

[trail holly]

yeah

[gloomy hill]

For being a mid boss

[night ruin]

Valid af but once you get the hang of it its really no biggie

[velvet verge]

final round will be either bellhart vs bilewater or bellhart vs sands of karak

[toxic holly]

Best boss in the damn game you can’t tell me otherwise

[heavy minnow]

Cradle would never lose to evil greenpath

[lofty shell]

best boss is first sinner or lost lace

[night ruin]

We need a losers bracket

[gloomy hill]

how did you get access to the next to next Ultrakill update wtf, do you live in the future???

[worldly lake]

shellwood

[weary hatch]

I hate Surviving His gauntlet

[light swan]

i was here at the beginning and i shall proclaim the end

[atomic crow]

buddy they barely make top 10

[gloomy hill]

You mean like top 10 worst bosses yes

[trail holly]

im on 8-4 bud (IS THAT OUT ALREADY??)

[weary hatch]

Chill on my clanker baes

[low pond]

Sinner’s Road vs Lost Verdania

I really don’t wanna do the 1️⃣ and 2️⃣ explanation every time, left is always 1️⃣ right is always 2️⃣

[toxic holly]

Phase 4 is the only thing wrong with them

[light swan]

lowkey sinners was funner

[trail holly]

oopsie

[light swan]

but verdania looks cooler idk

[night ruin]

Goated pro choice npcs sinners road clears

[light swan]

id say i like verdania more

[atomic crow]

u can stop going on abt it now

[gloomy hill]

No it got delayed to 2026, they made an announcement abt it, it was supposed to be this month

[toxic holly]

Ok I’ll chill

[night ruin]

Holy freudian slip

[heavy minnow]

Reminder that sinner had the dogs and the guys that threw spikes

[trail holly]

hakitaaaaaaaaaaaa

[weary hatch]

mfw cogwork dancers is my 4th fav boss

[plucky stag]

hope you can defeat Bowser at the end

[light swan]

which are goated

[night ruin]

I do love cogwork dancers

[rancid flare]

Could you send the link to this tier list?

[night ruin]

Theyre not by any means difficult but the loooooore

[trail holly]

bowser is in fact an ultrakill boss

[light swan]

chalamet skip!

[heavy minnow]

Loud incorrect buzzer

[toxic holly]

See someone who agrees

[low pond]

Final round of round 3:

BELLHART VS CHORAL CHAMBERS

[atomic crow]

bro can’t stand bell beast

[light swan]

chalamet... CHALAMETTTT

[velvet verge]

tf did fourth chorus and nyleth do to you

[weary hatch]

U wouldnt undertsand....

[worldly lake]

what did bel beast do 😭

[lofty shell]

put tormented trobbio higher

[plucky stag]

was referencing the 8-4 more than the ultrakill part

[earnest drift]

Shakra

[atomic crow]

I SWEAR IF BELLHART WINS

[night ruin]

Basically towns vs exploration. I vote towns

[trail holly]

i know

[night ruin]

Customizable bedroom wins

[light swan]

yea FUCK bellhart

[heavy minnow]

So we are just gonna ignore how cool widow and saving lost bellhart was?

[graceful oyster]

Verdania is a recollection of a boring story with 2 lame bosses (one of which, Clover Dancers, is straight up just a disappointing version of a great boss) where the main theme is just GREEN (VERDANia? Really?).

Sinner's Road has like a bajillion cool environmental storytelling elements and has a lot of really cool design features and also Ass Jim which is a solid boss. Among other good things

[plucky stag]

choral chambers's track just made me pause in awe the first time I got there

[trail holly]

bellhart in the face of choral chambers is an obvious choice

[night ruin]

Not meeee

[light swan]

so we just gonna ignore how awesome choral chambers was

[heavy minnow]

Yes

[grizzled birch]

Pov if hornet had the tools she has now back in hollownest

Hornet with the rosary America fighting the knight -

[plucky stag]

good list

[light swan]

average bilewater hater
hates fun areas

[gloomy hill]

Knight still wins

[trail holly]

hornet with the nuke build

[night ruin]

Bellhart vs choral chambers is tough cause both areas have drastically different intentions for the player

[low pond]

Here are the results of round 3. There are 3 matchups left until the winner of the area bracket fight is revealed!

[heavy minnow]

Average anyradiance completionist
Love pain and suffering

[plucky stag]

the fact that rosaries are this game's money makes the america joke even more prescient

[weary hatch]

Be really miserable to fight

[trail holly]

LETS FUCKING GO SON

[light swan]

i bet you dont like conflict in stories

[night ruin]

Can we get a losers bracket

[rancid flare]

Does anyone have a good skong boss tier list

[atomic crow]

so u would rather sit in a town then play the game and explore

[heavy minnow]

People only like conflicts because its bad

[graceful oyster]

Yes, here, enjoy

[low pond]

ok yeah pick 2 losers to rejoin or smth

[trail holly]

MOUNT FAY

[low pond]

While that’s happening…

[atomic crow]

fore brother in s

[night ruin]

Any area with 3 or more losses

[heavy minnow]

Id rather fight a boss and save something than get a random song to kill mommy silk

[rancid flare]

I meant a link… lmao

[weary hatch]

https://tiermaker.com/create/bosses-hk-silksong-16741430-2

[gloomy hill]

I think they wanna make a tier list

[lofty shell]

didn't cogwork core lose?

[graceful oyster]

I don't care any excuse to post my opinions

[night ruin]

CC absolutely dumps on bilewater

[low pond]

nope

[rancid flare]

https://tenor.com/view/peter-griffin-family-guy-perhaps-maybe-gif-16249623

[trail holly]

cmon guys vote bw...

[light swan]

PLEASE BILEWATER I NEED THIS

[heavy minnow]

Popularity poll if yall missed it

[atomic crow]

bellhart has literally one boss and some shops

[night ruin]

It is a town yes

[weary hatch]

And awesome fricken ost that I adore

[heavy minnow]

Fight me

[trail holly]

67

[finite swift]

67777

[light swan]

only way this is close is if you guys are comparing osts but BILEWATER SO MUCH BETTER

END IT END IT

[heavy minnow]

MAKE CC WIN PLS

[trail holly]

bilewater is so much better than cc im crying

[graceful oyster]

Cogwork Core is really lame as a region, it's so small

[finite swift]

COGWORK CORE IS THE GOAT

[light swan]

6 9 YEAA

[night ruin]

Cogwork also has better upgrades than bilewater

[atomic crow]

yes and choral chambers has better ost and actual exploration

[trail holly]

well folks 2:3

[rancid flare]

This list is buns but I’ll take it