#sk-lore
1 messages · Page 292 of 1
I guess... i kinda noticed that widow looks so much like theese guys, forgot the hunters journal
no he does not he gives off conservative veteran vibes
Worse its soulslop AND voidslop
of course the correct solution would be to scrap silksong altogether and work on the mister mushroom game
There's an interpretation where Widow's the Weaver from the City of Steel, since that one was 'staked to service' and Widow had the world's worst acupuncture job done
He references tool so that tracks
when bell hermit started talking about how hornet grants herself so much power by deciding she can return bugs to their pain and suffering i thought they would actually make that a theme
We know the Snail Shamans kinda worship Void. Do you think they have roots tracing back to the Ancient Civilization?
Huh, are these spiders?
the stones in the abyss in both games have spirals on them, do you think there's some kind of connection
Hornet literally absorbed their ancestor that lived under the probably void worshiping temple so yes
I dont know, nothing looks like a proper spider in silksong
Those just look like ammonites not snails
Drape'mite' implies that they're mites, which are a different kind of arachnid
There's only two spiders in silksong, the Weaver related things and the things that used to be normal bugs they got turned into weavers
Mite name lost so much credibility cause like fourth of the enemies in game have that name
anyways i think it would be interesting if like they did the old hearts idea but with the bosses actually being real
guy who has never heard of divergent evolution
Crabs in the corner waiting for the turn in the spotlight
lore wise it makes sense though
I think it'd be interesting if old hearts had any relevance to the themes of Act 3 
pharloom is a land ruined by the weavers and GMS
and the areas
like coral gorge exists and khann is worried about whatever the fuck the citadel just did and you have to actually challenge him outside of a memory
blasted steps is really good and sands of karak is not i really wish they could have had both somehow
but we couldve had coral gorge
i like the platforming mechanic
this game does not need two sand areas
i know its not the most well liked but i thought it was pretty unique
The ever handy Starpengu cut of silksong's map:
I'll admit I didn't care much for Karak gameplay-wise. Blasted Steps is awesome tho
wrong reply whoops
the judges wouldve looked really goofy in coral gorge so blasted steps helps a little
Platforming in Coral was fun until I wanted to use a diagonal Pogo Crest on the boss
whoah i live there
i think i first tried raging conchfly lol
they're too familiar asethetically
which boss
Traffic cone v2
Ok diagonal pogo complaints make me feel like an actual platforming deity, I didn't have an issue using Architect's Crest getting back to Angy Drill
dont you have harpoon by then
haha no diagonal pogo for you !!1
cant you basically fly over the platforming sections anyway
say what you will about bilewater but visually it looks different enough from sinner's road
ok yeah karak could probably be like a wisp thicket type sub area to blasted steps
oh yeah its fine
purified ducts on the other hand 😄
the issue is ducts
a lot of these areas feel like subareas instead
ducts are terrible but bilewater has grown on me
I had harpoon but there's a lot of ceiling pillars in the way
i like the stilkin
Bilewater is peak. Sinner's Road is mid
im a god at diagonal pogo bc i play actually good games like celeste
Putrefied Ducts had more stonework, I guess?
it's crazy how this game has 4 green areas and the only good one gets locked off permanently from you if you defeat the area boss
(i hope everyone here realizes thats bait lol)
not saying celeste isnt good tho
you should play it
why is barnacle bay on the left
Verdania isn't good
So it can be below the other aquatic area
i disagree i like how they did verdania
i 100%ed celeste, probably why diagonal pogo is fine
it's visually my favorite in the whole game i like that green
Then yeah, they probably not related
Verdania is garbage it connects to no other areas and has nothing of interest
do you have 1k+ hours most of those being on mods
but hear me out why not just double the size of coral gorge
I kinda wish widow wasent a typical weaver but ascended drapmite, cause I wanna see other arachnids being ascended, like the skull spiders, or the bell spiders
Its good art-wise yes
it's crazy how this game has 4 green areas and none of them are good
moss grotto is good what
its crazy this game has 15 areas and none of them are good 💔
you're getting one weaver type and you're gonna like it 👹
The two areas would compliment eachother
also shellwood hate is crazy
Verdania had some of the best atmosphere in the game and I like the idea we're only seeing Green Prince's memory of something greater, but gameplay-wise it was kinda boring
Kinda, and I thought it was supposed to be green price kingdom, it looks pretty non kingdom to me
Verdania sucks, it's just black stone and collapsed garbage
Lost Verdania is gorgeous and has radicalised me against Nestle SA
name three things you like about it that is unrelated to it's art direction
I like the atmosphere yeah
true
its a cool starting area
lame
its the tutorial area what do you want from it
you can skip sister splinter
Well it'd be better if Pharloom was a lively kingdom with Verdania in the present day but whatever
hype moment aura
really realyl easily
do you want another kings pass ahh tutorial area
i hate the moss grotto green i'm sorry
moss grotto fucking clears kings pass so easy
nah you get act 3 and a worst coral area instead
I love the art and atmoshere of Shellwood a lot, and I found Sister Splinter decently fun for a beginner boss but she was very easy
ripping off ori in the soundtrack department and moss mother makes me moss puke
You get destroyed Bonebottom 🥹
also star why in your version do the saintly people passing through blasted steps also have to go through sinner's road
you don't get pharloom bay 😢
will of the wisps ripped off hollow knight so it's fair game
moss mother is so easy wtf
yeah exactly
isnt the point of sinner's road that the sinners can reach the citadel
Herrah would've been an amazing mother :(
Nah the pilgrimage goes through coral
Idk what Steps would be
did you want an impossible starting boss or some shit
no the road doesn't typically lead to citadel
hello Tammo
so are the judges just gone then
don't you?
maybe it could be like the citadel is carving up an area of it on their own and the karak are pissed about it
well i think it should so too bad
Grand Gate gets turned into a judge subarea trust
Team cherry in the process of deciding which area they wanna make explorable and which they wanna make a lousy coloseum of fools 2, the most popular trailer area vs moss grotto 2
what an amazing counterargument truly impressive I yield to your vastly superior intellect and rhetoric
the judges and the sandstorm are very cool together i cant really explain it
moss vessel 🤑
Wait wait put them in Barnacle Bay
verdania was pretty hyped up a lot of people wanted to see the clover area
What's going on?
silksong lore discussion
whinging
The winds effect the rains falling from the coral area above
verdania was like the 2nd most hyped area
It'd be auraful
i dont think this is necessary
sort of enforces the theme of the citadel destroying beautiful things of the past doesn't it? 
just have an area at the edge of coral gorge that looks like blasted steps and sands of karak and have the lore be that the ecosystem was destroyed in some past conflict
anyways yeah my version of silksong story would definitely have those areas still existing and old hearts youd actually have to challenge the bosses in real world instead of memories
It makes me violently angry whenever I see people oversimplify any green nature area as "Greenpath 2" or "Moss Grotto 2"
there is absolutely no point to pale stag, even in-universe it's merely a legend and hornet is fighting a figment of the green prince's imagination for no real reason, and it's attacks suck
and the citadel was built on top of the remains
I’ve realised that the Mist Wraiths look a lot like ||Phantom, who you find in the Exhaust Organ immediately afterwards||. Perhaps they’re ||lingering fragments of her desire to escape and rebuild herself with silk? Since they lunge at you and suck out your silk?||
grrr we're not here to argue that it doesn't fit the story we're here to say they should've come up with a better story to make cool areas RAGH. 🐺 🐺
unironically yeah kinda
That was not serious, I also love lost verdania, I just wish corral forest was done like lost verdania
they had a certain amount of bosses they needed to fit in and they had to come up with something so they didn't have to include sharpe
Sharpe and those enemies were an 800 Dollar Backer Donation, so they will come in uh.... something. at some point in the 21st century! 😂
anyways yeah back on my idea having it be like mortals are trying to mess with void would be an interesting spin compared to higher beings messing with void
i get why they did it i just think if you're gonna put style over substance in some places you should do it here too
Where does barnacle bay go then 💔
they could cut it from the game and nothing would be lost and now it's going to be a very long and gross speed bump in boss rush 4
you could maybe integrate automatons into that also
on the right where it belongs
your coral gorge is too small
DLC area that connects elsewhere, trust
it's how we get to city of steel for that dlc, trust
Once you go to #sk-lore you will never want to stop beating Barnacle Bay on the right truthers to death
fair. I was really looking forward to Coral Forest but I do like how they incorporated it into the worldbuilding. I like that being in the Citadel's shadow kinda chokes the life out of these other natural areas.
verdania lets you skip another of the old heart fights by ||using the green prince’s heart in place of it||, so it’s not completely useless
conductors messing with void would go so hard i kinda want to see it now
yeah I don't like the direction they went with things
I'd rather have a more alive and extensive act 2 then reducing things and trying to fit it in act 3
not to say that the art in the game isn't beautiful though like imagine having to be Ari and drawing all that
if you just watch the announcement trailer it's super obvious that pharloom bay was gonna be on the right not to mention the bilewater weavenest room and the pale lake
act 3 is stunning visually
i'm talking about pale stag
But its not as cool as my vision
and i would argue it has the best music and boss fights as well
man is using this fan image as his belief
nothing ever is
It was rather annoying to fight
love is being called intermission that's awesome
I could make a better silksong than team cherry
this goes hard
what is this 😭
hey we gotta get sharpe in here somehow
also 'man' c'mon fam it's next to my name
boat to steel city my beloved
speaking of Sharpe
😔
actually nah I already talked about this before I'm just gonna grab some of my messages
Imagine building Bonebottom up and it gets new establishments as time goes on
yeah thatd go hard
with what material
So with the new weapons of silskong, we kinda know most of the weapons in hollow knight world right?
Nail spear
Nail
Pin
Pin-nail
Needle
Husks/Horns (extracted from beasts and used like maces)
Hammers (like hegemol's)
Scissors (either connected or dual like dual swords.
Scythe claws
Claw boomerangs
Gun/shots/cannon basically fire weapons
Tacks
Rings
Balls
Bombs?
And that weird thing the father flame occultists use
This isn't Ori
I would want that as Act 4
That whould be very cool if they did this, pharloom bay is also an unused real area
You do quests (Actually fun quests not the ones we have now) to uplift the spirits and help the town
act 4 dlc where we help rebuild what's left after act 3 trust
ok so regarding backer stuff its either
TC is saving it for a dlc
TC reached an agreement to not add those contents with the backers and paid them back, possibly due to having to wait so long
we're missing a backer boss (sharpe)
we're missing two dungeons (the one in game being Khann's tower)
we're missing one village (antlion village)
and it fits with my idea of the conductors fucking shit up with void and you have to fortify towns in a struggle against the conductors
and then it still gets destroyed 
omg that is really cool. Basically would make it an entire spinoff game directly connected to Silksong's map
we probably don't know all the weapons in the world since different realms use different ones
Is Seth's shield still a coin or is it just a shield now?
chat is this accurate
It's a cymbal
flick the fixer every damn time
Yeah and its probably the first one
Zi foreshadows the steel assassins
hopefully dlc
there are like 4 people there
always bet on city of steel dlc
Seth if he got serious
Then make more people
im not saying it's good that they made it knockoff dirtmouth
You aren't thinking outside the box
What do you guys think of this skarr hierarchy I made?(also size comparison chart but I didn’t make that)
but they made it knockoff dirtmouth
if i was a backer being impatient with silksong would be kinda cringe tbh
I'm curious of what new "mini" weapons we will get.
What other small stuff we humans use that could be weapons?
songclave should be the one you build up
Yeah and that sucks
deep in enemy territory
like if im investing in a game i want them to take their time and not rush it
You should be building up all towns
The latter i have confirmed Is Unlikely But i can only share Evidence in DMS.
yep and god do I hope you're right that its DLC
Bonebottom is just the one I'm most attached to
is it because of the music
I already did with you nvm lol
yep
fortifying all the towns and uniting them in a struggle against conductors messing with void
i want it
I forgot how absolutely huge Old Karmelita is
Yes
fair
The second part of the Bonebottom theme feels hopeful and uplifting
Complete disconnect from the real Bonebottom
Meet potential town
The size different of red ants is crazy like
i will say definitely keep the skull tyrant jumpscare that shit is funny as fuck
I don't know it doesn't feel that uplifting
She's who you play the music for to get to the Karmelita fight
Act 3, the same zone the rest, you need silk soar
Yeah you can have a few hiccups and then the town bounces back stronger
but maybe have it be like bonebottom can be ready at different points for it
no so like maybe if you finished these specific quests bone bottom is ready and fights it off but if you dont its a hiccup
honestly the idea of it being built up would make it being completely destroyed in act 3 hit harder
Man listen to this part where the piano changes and the strings kick in and it feels like you can only go up from here https://youtu.be/e6b-lWhn8pg?t=102
This is a preview of the music for Hollow Knight: Silksong.
Featured Soloists:
Violin: Lachlan Bramble
Violin: Emma Perkins
Viola: Linda Garrett
Cello: Gemma Phillips
For more info check out www.hollowknightsilksong.com
Do you think dlc's will just work over the 3 acts we have by now or add a new act 4?
ok tbf they've been waiting like 10ish years ? just to not have it be in game yet
and we don't know their like monetary situation maybe they needed that money back desperately
idk what kickstarter's rules are though so take everything I say with like a handful of salt
The way I envision it the song starts with the depressing beginning, a short little harp(?) interlude of reflection, and then an uplifting ending
oh yeah that is true
Which one and what you mean with first try?
Difficult to say. but i would think Act 3+ for truly "new" stuff and not new mechanics.
I feel like that symbolizes the pilgrims in general, they have the false hope with the citadel pushing them through the horrible trials of their pilgrimage
i will say it feels like they forgot about bonebottom and they can do better with it
Probably both
but idk how exactly
and they paid like 800 bucks for it
that's a sizeable amount of money to care about
That’s the missing image bro
anyways in my alt silksong final boss could definitely be like lost lace and gms duo fight
that would be pretty cool
Well it would be satisfying if Sharpe became like a mian chracter kind of like LAce is
You forgot of far fields lava flood?
And no, I kinda took a lot of damage (I kinda would have died if not for lifeblood overdose)
in my alt silksong the final boss is flick the fixer
I think I might've taken damage but I finished the climb first try
I feel like it'd make more sense for the soundtrack to emphasize how the player/Hornet is feeling rather than the pilgrims
But also Hornet is supposed to restore hope to the pilgrims as well
in my alt silksong the final boss is gms but hard and involving some platforming
Take it up With Christopher larkin i guess lol
and you have to get the old hearts involved somehow to get the true ending
its in the that loop on the map in lower far fields to the left of the weavenest
SCREAM IF YOU hate CHRISTOPHER LARKIN
have it be you fight those bosses in the real world
again idk what kickstarters rules are
but would you tolerate potentally waiting 15 years for something like this
I don't know, bonebottom itself is the depressing start for a depressing pilgrimage, it'd make sense for the music to focus on the feeling with the pilgrims
can someone explain all we know about where shakra comes from?
What would be the implications of queen of silk ending? Did the kingdom fall due the silkfall? Will something happen to hornet?
Nah he did a wonderful job and its still a great track it just could've been better in the context of the game
it's also very old
Who would hate him he's done amazing work
You can’t actually just want radiance 2 like I get tc isn’t the most original in ss but cmon
it precedes the invention of act 3 abyss by like half a decade
congratulations you are a fish
What
me asf: 🤐
that was really clearly bait 😭
Not much.
a tribe of warriors that usually likes to wander and explore, so probably they work as wanderers, they have a curious use of weapons and (spells?) their weapons seem to be beads and rings.
Master Hu could be part of it
Its also the start of Hornet's journey

Who knows, Thats between them. But Team Cherry is known to Care enough about the backers to include them in the credits of both games and still Use thier Ideas even if thier plans change.
So i have faith idk
What I'm saying is it should accurately reflect both
I suppose
They should put the cut ending back in the game
i feel like team cherry probably gave the backer an update and their under an nda
or smth like that idk
if they really want there to be a higher being in the citadel and they want us to take it seriously they cant just brush it off early
that feels like the right thing to do in this situation
gms is narratively a joke anyways
Nah They had no idea. I have proof.
No,it's an even worse ending for pharloom
So legally Kickstarter doesn't have to chase people up about actually paying money, but the legal entities behind the kickstarters are liable to get sued depending on where they're stationed. KS can blacklist them, but otherwise it's more-or-less out of their hands. If you decide after the KS ends that you don't want a thing, then tough shit, you have to get a chargeback or take it up with the company
Okay to be honest a giant horde of ants mimicking the forms of different monsters or characters would actually be a baller idea for a boss in Hollow Knight!
No higher beings give us the Conductor big bads persecuting the poor little weavers like we DESERVED
radiance 2!
i want my void messing conductors
gms isn’t just a nothing burger because the fight is whatever she’s barely even an entity
(for the record the fight is also whatever)
ok tbh i like weavers not being good guys
Very bad first impression
im ok with not having gms be in the game at all but i think we kind of knew going in that the subject of pharloom's folly was probably going to be a higher being, and im operating based on that assumption
GMS is a pushover of a fight but that's fine imo
She has way fewer moves
She’s the Hollow Knight of Silksong
And not as much phase variety
I like gms somewhat because of the silk hearts
Its funny because, I feel like if gms and pale king met the world would kinda be in a great state
They would fuck
Join together and create sibling kingdoms, and defeat radiance or smth with silk
She's a fun fight its just bizarre how she's a blatant ripoff of a better one in HK
GMS is the hollow knight equivalent and they were also kinda a pushover
yeah ive been saying they should have made her important or quit while they were ahead
One of which is good but still way too easy to avoid
if you want to have her there you actually give her something to do in act 3
GMS isn't meant to be a radiance equivalent in difficulty nor story
what the fuck
Would be cool to have a rematch in which she’s even stronger and uses more complex silk skills.
she wakes up and starts wreaking havoc and that's the threat instead of just void
Also radiance is kinda weak most of the time is hard due to hollow knight dual fight
lost lace gms duo fight
GMS godhome version would be nice
Unlike THK there is no emotional depth to GMS being a weak loser baby
yes
you get healed at the start of radiance thk doesn't really add much
i feel like that is kinda split with lace 2 and gms
I mean I agree the act 3 we have is bleh and should’ve been something more cohesive
Silk primordial or smth
Actually there is, and it’s the fact all of her Weaver children willingly abandoned and imprisoned her lol
lace 2 is definitely meant to be more emotional at the end
Mostly fatigue if anything
on this topic
why did gms capture jornet
To eat her
To use her silk
IT DOES??? DAMN I WASTED SO MUCH SOUL HEALING EACH TIME
no that's hornet, he means jornet
Ah of course
And I'm supposed to care why...
😨 .... 😱 then control everything ??? then make a lace ?? (lace 2 ?)
Jornet’s my favorite Pablo character
honestly i kinda want to write out my full idea for a silksong in which act 3 happens with conductors fucking around with void
Can't wait for hollow knight:Pablo!
I mean, She was bassicaly exploited for her power and in turn she exploited The people later on. The story is less about Emotional stakes and more about How Pharloom is stuck in an exploitative cycle.
What was elder hu even doing in fungal wastes?
act 1 reach the citadel act 2 fight the conductors and then either flee or completely dethrone them, leading to act 3 gms is unleashed upon the kingdom causing widespread destruction coming from above and you have to figure out how to kill her with the help of possibly the old hearts
There kinda is? She just wake up from being sealed for thousand of years by the citadel and weavers
The game expecting you to randomly be very emotionally invested in lace is really funny though
That’s like the dumbest place to try and heal the infection
She would be basically in a similar state to hornet in the start of act 1
Because those exploitative cycles are oh so easy to break
That's why she's easy, of course
Yeah, which is why the true ending of Silksong is Hornet Breaking this cycle instead of replacing Grandmother Silk as Goddess Empress of Pharloom.
(Lace 2 is the best one)
Imagine a trio fight, lace, gms and phantom
Lace two killed me the most
I mean I felt bad for lace but it wasn't as gut wrenchingly cruel as what happened to the vessels
where is Lace 4 ?
Lace has no sauce
who does
Just wait it’ll probably be in the last content update or some shit
Her cutscene was cool
ass jim
oh yeah true
what if they had actually made her evil instead of just mommy issues
honestly the way this channel talks about silksong sometimes I feel like I gaslit myself into liking it 🥴
does Karmelita have sauce
Well, If you beat her without fucking thisngs up first, hornet just becomes apart of that cycle. Act 3 is bassicaly "you gotta fuck up the system irrepriably first before you fix it"
Ass Jim best boss in the game
itll be a postgame fight in act 4 when every dlc gets added
lace 2 is in my top 3 top 5 for the whole series maybe
Wdym look at her thighs
You must follow the opinion of the masses (vocal minority)
exactly, ppl took the phrase "temper your expectations" and just straight up tossed it in the trash
true...
I feel bad for Phantom, they were essentially yeeted by Grandmother Silk into Sinners Road to keep the Stillkin out with the Mist and slowly age away from their lack of silk.
I have not died to lace 1 at all, I took about an hour or so to beat Lost Lace, and Lace 2 was beating me up all evening even after I kept chugging flea brew
What are the lace 2 flowers even
everblooms !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
theyre just flowers
but it's like, I really do understand a lot of other people's problems with ss even if I myself was incredibly satisfied with what we got
meet potential woman
promises complex relationship with hornet, never gets touched on outside of two scenes
0 aura 0 replay value 7 times fought uhhhh
silk flowers trust
Oh yeah there’s nothing about that it went nowhere
That set piece looked way more important than it actually ended up being
Then again stilkin are jerks
Like bruh
lmao !
set dressing to look cool
my idea is act 1 is the same act 2 you ascend to fight the conductors and i think it would genuinely be interesting to have an actual bad ending where you fail to accomplish anything and get killed by conductors and then act 3 happens you challenge conductors and you resist them killing you but they spread the void or some shit and you have to unite the entire kingdom against them
If they were everblooms hornet would've just taken one of those instead of getting the hearts
They’re completely justified jerks
it amazes me how every fight ingame (even beastfly) has more aura than lace's fights
you will find very few online spaces more miserable than #sk-lore
The game's totally fine (dare I say good?), this is just the channel people go to to complain about it
fail to accomplish anything is crazy but im intrigued
yeah I hate Silksong.
Lace has one of the best boss themes tho
they're justified but oh my god they are so intense
Gang lace makes sense
nt as good as khann's
Because people totally can’t have criticisms of things they like
Silksong sucks we all hate it and we're gatekeeping all Silksong fans from tainting our glorious lore community
Initially she strikes Hornet out of the cage so silk doesn’t get a new plaything and toss her out
not as good as cogwork dancers !
She fights Hornet to kill her early on
Nuh uh
groal is actually one of my favorite characters in the series
not as good as strive!
God forbid people criticize games they love
if you really want to have an insane apocalyptic scenario at the end, using the higher being is the most straightforward way to do it imo
People are definitely in this channel because they hate the game and not to discuss the narrative and their opinions about it
like it would be interesting to have an ending that isnt like ambiguous if its good or bad like weaver queen or thk or sealed siblings but straight up terrible where like hornet gets killed or captured into whatever experiment the conductors are doing
we should all blindly like stuff this is true
yeah its not like everything about it is a shitshow
Popular & beloved things are often hated for the sake of complaining since our society encourages cynicism and wanting to tear things down for having flaws.
Ermmm...
is this dude plotting something
Lifeblood:
we ? have opinions ? crazy...
Then when she fights in the cradle she’s basically a cornered animal unleashing everything she has to stop Hornet from reaching mama silk
Doesn’t seem to be
I love silksong but I can admit it has some faults
Cursed Child
Speak for yourself
dare i say, lace is one of the best boss themes in the entire game, and i struggle to come up with any tracks better than it
Yes, he is like that fatty from fog canons, a thief
I for one hate this game
no I'm talking about the criticisms I see that I just go "yeah that's fair..." to a lot of the time
😱
just has an ant problem
ok cursed child is silly that doesnt really count lol
Hallownest clears the glorious land of gods vs the polluted slave land
Boss needolin dialouge is really cool
nyleth, khann, widow, strive, cogworks core
yeah its bad but its not like THE bad ending
lace is great but i dont think her theme beats those
I love this game... we should have more room in our heart to love.
Cant believe I didnt try using needolin a single time during a boss fight
yeahhhhh... lace is still better than these composition wise
hornet and gms die that seems pretty definitive
It just seems too risky lol
i don't know what world you live in, but in no way is cogwork core better than lace
IT is techincally THE WORST ending in the franchise lol
Hegemol snapping one in half over his knee:
the ever great 5 great knights of hallownest:
my fav song in ss is choral chambers cus im a normie
i think it wouldve been cool if lace was trying to dethrone the conductors and that put her into an alliance with hornet only for it to be revealed that she was in it to awaken gms
Cogwork core is the best song in the game
and you then have to murder lace in cold blood
Also there are only four choruses Hallownest has a bunch more big robots
khann and nyleth are both good tracks, but lace in it's orchestration edges it out
are we gonna have hallownest vs pharloom agenda posting now
but its not like a main bad ending as in what happens it feels like a kind of side secret ending
Pale Court Mystic Ze’mer would solo
how do you know there are only four
Kinda edgy man
powerscaling discussion 🤑
cogwork dancers is on par with trobbio, which is a layer below lace
last judge could smear dung defender
It seems like weavers are significantly more advanced than both
like imagine an ending where conductors actually kill you or capture you or some shit like that
I mean the named one is the fourth and we see three more seems like there are four
You're right, between the unique usage of silk in gameplay, fast paced acrobatic combat, thrilling and awesome bosses, creative and charming setting, and engaging quests, Monster Hunter Rise is surely the best game of the decade
Weird how the weavers in deepnest had none of their fancy technology
The power of yuri is quite the powerful one
I mean the weavers had teleportation tech they're VERY advanced
:catplush:
Once hornet’s actually managed to snare silk she rescues hornet so silk doesn’t take hornet to hell with her
So true
i can accept that
Maybe they’re Weaver Amish?
husk guard can no diff karmelita
oh god no bring back the complaints, push out the powerscaling
If silksong had gore magala it would be good
of the decade ? first hollow knight is right there bud.
nah bring in the powerscaling
The deepnest weavers were just the most stupid of their kin
HAHAHAHAHAHA
we ain't in the 2010s cuh 💔
widow and strive are similar levels of awesome, both are almost if not jsut as good as lace, but their complexity is just a bit of step below
radiance could clean out the entirety of pharloom without even blinking
They can’t even find a new site
Insane cope
Regardless on whether Pharloom or Hallownest is stronger, I think we can all agree that the Steel Masters are bum ass frauds
hungry knight.
I wish pale king had more combat feats, I want to put him against silk
anyways it would be interesting if like romino was a conductor who defected and tried to spin lace to oppose the other conductors or some shit
bro just typing shit
gms loses
Is GMS a demipale being
Nah the Pale Wyrm shows up, gets silk caught in his throat, coughs her up… leaves cuz he has spiderwebs in his throat
i am not cooking
fair, cogwork dancers is a REALLY good track in it's third phase, but as a COMPOSITION it isn't as coherent
We only know about the pale Kamehameha unfortunately
Yes
i think gms would lose to karmelita if she had the snail snare
buzzsaws cut silk so he wins
Pale King doesn’t need to be strong, he just needs to be a great leader (And godawful father)
pale king should've used the pale spirit bomb against radiance, why didn't he
I think karmelita is cool
She would
In Wyrm form PK absolutely beats silk
Does the pale king get a pale kamehema off or does silk speedblitz
GMS loses to everyone
gms would lose to nosk
gms loses to hornet and karmelita rivals her skill therefore gms loses to karmelita
gms is like weaker than unn 🥀
wasn't there dialogue saying karmelita was as strong as hornet or smth ?
failed at the first one but at least he succeeded with the second one
Steel Masters are frauds who’d get no-diffed by Zote
lets be real karmelita is way better than hornet shes just coping
Skynx is gathering enough silkeaters to consume GMS once and for all
nosk simply disguises itself as lace and the game is over
true...
we made a higher being that can be stalemated by nosk
Lace tries so hard to hype gms up and then she’s a fucking joke 
is there any karmelita haters out there I don't think a single one exists
Silk and the radiance are just really stupid
Nosk imitates lace, gets all the silk, the real lace is malnourished and dies, then Nosk snaps silk’s neck in her sleep
bardoon jumps once and pharloom crumbles into a bardillion pieces
Anyways powerscaling is stupid and food is smart okay bye
reddit because she parries every once in a while
All they had to do to win was move away from the thing trying to kill them and spam their range attacks
Those who claim themselves gods can rarely match the title, after all.
no way really
She who would snuff out hope of having fun with a single glance
Why did the radiance facetank the knight
theres people on r/silksong who hate first sinner
Five pebbles falls onto Hallownest, everyone dies except Menderbug
Guys, how mixed do you think deepnest weavers were? Or are they like, the same weavers that got there thousands of years ago?
its crazy
What made radiance think that a good idea
gms would lose to vespa
Stupids
thats what she gets for railing against nature
it's like a 60/40 split between people who like karmelita and people with wrong opinions
hes probably like 9000 years old he has a strong mind
no... no... this,,, CAN'T,,,,,, BE...
Karmelita is really fun but her spike attack is a bit on the annoying side unfortunately
🙏
can't believe people have opinions
Wait the team cherry hate sub must be popping off lmao brb I'm making a reddit account
TRUE
If you just keep mashing attack you can basically parry every hit of some multi hit attacks
AND THEIR OPINION IS WRONG RAGH
She couldve stayed as the sun and spammed her orbs
No posts for 2 years 💔
didn't even think of that oh my goodness
Even with hunters it works against the spinny boys in far fields
Post something
you can be the first in two years ❤️🩹
😭
What your PFP isn’t Gru?
damn rest in peace team cherry hate sub, you would have loved the simplified chinese silksong translation
I do wish first sinner had more to her but the fight itself is fun
0 upvotes 😔
fifty eight comments
How would it be
They are most likely the same. We know thanks to Widow that Weavers have extremely long lifespan.
they hated jesus because he spoke the truth
I will post a three part critique
ACT 1: GAMEPLAY
ACT 2: PROGRESSION
ACT 3: NARRATIVE
?av tammo
Joseph Anderson wakes up…
i see it
silksong sucks they should've put sans undertale in the game like with hollow knight
We need a pale king dlc with a 8 phase fight
awakening...? say that again?
Pale king goes ultra super wyrm mode in phase 6 and eats all of pharloom
wake up
?av andy070609
Why’d you leave the kids up on the table?
WHO ??
?av a_pogseal
ironically the greatest weakness of each act
this photo is goated
jk the gameplay in act 1 is pretty good
Fighting pk would just be him using infinite soul to create an infinitely large aoe attack dealing infinite damage
Phase 7 is dodging parts falling off the wyrm corpse and phase 8 is fighting a newly reborn pale king that is just a reskinned hollow knight
so insta kill
He really is a shagaru magala
infinite soul therefore he uses d dark for every attack
apparently the pink in the sky was caused by some sort of wildfire
who ?
The knight should just summon a void aura to consume the soul
its not real ???
Died of old age 2024 born 2025 welcome back Powdered
So yall ready for the black wyrm in ss
Anyway his charm produces infinite soul and his children are very proficient in soul usage
You know what could be cool? A spell crest that makes your spell take all of your silk but have triple damage.
But now you can only heal two masks/or heal like the knight from hollow knight (including ground only)
His palace also uses a bunch of soul tech
the seal is real i just havent seen it irl
Yeah all the gods have some sort of domain they control
Pale kings is presumably soul
Well control or have a very strong mastery over
this specific seal is from one of those videos that would randomly pop up in your recommended
powdered died ? :C
Well PK's main thing is uplifting the minds of bugs around him
At the ripe old age of 106 yes 😔
Pale king and White lady have Soul, but they use it different.
Pale king focuses in mind, transcend in intelligence.
White lady more into the "Life" part of soul, breeding and fertility
we gotta hold a funeral
So he does have soul affinity
he was so young, too 😔
yes it does
This makes me think all pale beings are soul related
And is the reason I feel like the radiance is not really pale
i don't think the radiance was ever said to be pale
yeah radiance isn't pale you just need to look at her compared to the actual pale beings
unless im missing something
Well soul might technically be related to dream essence
Well the fact that he and his wife made a wedding ring that produces infinite soul seems to suggest it is within their powerset
Who
pale beings aren't necessarily stronger than standard higher beings
She does use Pale Nails though.
Even if he didn't literally have infinite of the stuff he could probably take it from the air
Godseeker on her way to call some random feral beast “Gluttonous god of defecation” or smth:
Unn ain’t beating the Wyrm lol
okay but none of the pale beings are as strong as radiance
also nightmare king grimm, can't forget that guy
If Radiance was a pale being, Vespa's usage of "The Pale Beings" to refer to the Pale King and White Lady would be very strange wording
We get the Pale Nails silk skill from her severed arm
Visually it matches with First Sinner’s needles and Silk’s own needles
GMS is refferred to as the Pale Monarch, reffered to as Hornet's Pale Kin, and refferred to as a Being Pale.
oh
Oh I thought you were talking about silk
same lol

radiance uses the pale nails didn't you know
Yes but I have seen a lot of people saying she is.
But her light is always described more like "Warm" like the sun, and the sun isn't pale.
She just uses swords. Not nails, swords. Calling something a sword is something of an insult to things that wield nails.
I have pale nails too what does that make me
is shakra from pharloom?
no
dont think so
You got the right idea with the wrong example buddy
What kind of gods would pharloom bosses be?
just checked, shes from pharlooms edge according to her hunters journal entry
God of Pharmacy Overdose
For the lifeblood nameless boss
Warrior cartographer of a tribe from Pharloom's edge.
adjacent
I like how pale king is just paul atreides then both other pale beings are weird as shit in some way
yeah just found that in the text dump
The whole pale and higher being definition shit is just really odd, I do like the idea of pale beings just being higher beings with a focus of soul manipulation
Greater Conchflies: Encrusted Gods of Companionship.
Enraged Conchfly: Raging God of Grief.
I mean technically they are?
Groal the Great: “Vengeful god of filth”
it really just seems to be higher beings that desire dominion over bugs in some form
Which could fit the radiance as well if we do count dream essence as a byproduct of soul, given that damaging the radiance and dream bosses do give you soul
Most pale beings are either higher beings
Or have the potential to be.
The vessels and hornet for example
Not sure how sherma fits but we don't know what kind of power he has
Crust King Khan: Hardened God of Conquest
oh are we doing godhome titles
Omg crust king Khan gonna be so easy lol compared to Nyleth and Carmelita fights lmao
Phantom: Forgotten God of Silk
I do think both white lady and pale king would probably kick our asses if they ever fought
made of silk 
Nyleth, Goddess of Fertility
Trobbio: Eccentric God of the Arts
Tormented Trobbio: Mournful God of Nihilism
I don't know what else Phantom would be the God of, fucking God of Mist
TRUE
So are gret root and nyleth
🗣️ Mist God
Phantom, God of the Opera.
khann: god of potential
mayeb they'd use the term Forgotten God of Thread instead
potential man 💔
Frayed God of the Organ
God of the Discarded? Phantom is GMS's trash that takes out the citadel's trash
Shakra: Nomadic God of Loyalty
I love how unequal gms daughters are.
One is a main character that is literally the final boss
The other is a phantom of the opera reference
Lost Lace: Lost God of Void and Thread
Cogwork Dancers: Imitating Gods of Devotion
Green Princes: Divine Couple of Pride
Ah yes, Phantom. My favorite narrative afterthought.
probably except for the higher beings but yeah
Clover Dancers: Twin gods of vainglory
Godseekers and godtamer don't think the same
Sister Splinter: Fierce God of the Woods
khann: Bygone God of Crust
yes so she's God of Silk, what the fuck would Lace be the God of
no incest in my video game
song
Beastfly: Fools God of the Primitivism
God of silk and song 🗣️
Savage Beastfly: Despicable God of Rage
God of Fencing
Uhhh violence? That's pretty much all she does.
Lace: Holy God of the Fabrics
Probably be somwthing like god of insanity
Phantom would probably be god of the mist or the organ
Lace: Threadspun god of betrayal
Moss Mother: Protective God of Greenery
God of The Opera
Sherma: Pale God of Innocence
First Sinner: Punished God of Apostasy
God of the opera or forsaken god maybe?
oh shit that's fire, what would Lost Lace be then
are heresy and apostasy close enough or did i just say something stupid
What is the name of the threads that a piano has?
The phantom refight should be a prime version
apostasy is turning away from beliefs, heresy is making false claims of a belief
Widow: Malformed God of Control
Phantom: Forgotten God of the Wire.
widow: mutilated god of loyalty
Are phantom and lace siblings? They're both made of thread
like for example, apostasy is blasphemy against the holy spirit, while heresy is saying that joseph smith is a prophet of God
alright those are different enough that i think saying heresy there is probably inaccurate then imo
one of them calls the other sister in the exhaust organ needolin dialogue
Last Judge: Watchful God of Judgement
Widow: Staked god of restless service
I need to use my needolin more XD ty
Bell Eater: asshole god that makes me angry to fight
Hey Nightmare King Grim is God of Nightmares, Lost Kin is Lost God of the Abyss
(i dont like bell eater)
Lost Lace: God of motherfucker hold STILL that should've HIT YOU
Groal the Great: Enraged God of the Waste
Are phantom, Sister splitter, Last Judge and Fourth Chorus like, a quartet?
Bell Eater: Subterranean God of Gluttony
hey can you blame him, the fucking citadel ruined his home beyond repair
Broodmother: Alluring god of endless breeding
(yes were bringing back the flukemarm reference)
isn't that already flukemarm
flukemarm is alluring god of motherhood
i dont wanna go through this again
why didn't groal just enter the mist to kill phantom (the person responsible for bilewater), is he stupid?
We got theatre kid, the popular girl, DI-AH-RE-YA, and Rules of Nature
bro couldn't make it through the mist
Groal does seem like an absolute asshole
Hes like if khann was just an angry dickhead
At least Khann has a throne
Groal so useless that gms didn't came for him
hi chat whats the topic rn
groal was justified in his anger then decided to seize power and plan to commit genocide lmao
were coming up with names for possible godhome statues
(Memory Bosses)
First Sinner: Wrathful God of Truth.
Skarrsinger Karmelita: Warrior God of Song.
Nyleth: Lush God of Growth.
Crust King Khann: Tyranical God of Conquest.
Clover Dancers: Love-bound Gods of ||Incest|| Coordination.
groal kept dying to widow, so he couldn't unlock needolin to get through the mist
keep up
oh like before you unlock them?
First sinner is.. not exactly a memory… she’s weird
clover dancers description 
You don’t need the back-in-time song to fight her
But you don’t lose your stuff when you die
CLOVER DANCERS ARE NOT INCESTUOUS
there's like some weird alternate dimension shenanigins going on from what i've heard, it's strange
first sinner is long dead before you even find her
khann should be Bygone God of Crust
Yeah but hes not too angry
They’re just members of their species
the way i imagine the first sinner fight is that she won't let hornet simply take her ability, she wants hornet to prove that she deserves to learn her rune rage
He mostly just aurafarms
they were born on exact beat
Do you think first sinner kinda wanted to die?
no
first sinner: bound god of apostasy
Groal acting like getting vengeful spirit will allow him to beat the citadel
okay here's the first sinner explanation
i think that entire fight was first sinner testing us
Bitch silk is going to murder you and string your corpse up
Fucking trobbio would school him
I am of the belief that she is in fact a memory. Dying to her does not count as a real death, the enviroment of the cell changes when the fight starts and goes back to normal after it ends, and First Sinner's needolin dialogue works the same as it does for other memory bosses (the lines play automatically instead of the boss stopping to sing)
can't get ddark without getting vengeful spirit first, and ddark clears, so
trobbio: Vain god of spectacle
Second Sentinel: Gilded God of Devotion
the wiki basically says you basically fight her in a weaver memory
can i propose my own godhome names 
Groal the: Ungrateful Mod of Buck
eh, not many bosses perform for the sake of it so spectacle is accurate enough
tormented trobbio: forlorn god of lamentations
I meant guck
God of muck to mod of guck
He’s built like a discord mod
Question: is caseoh a mod on his discord server
Tormented trobbio: melancholic god of plight
Watcher at the Edge: Still God of a Forgotten Land
what would crawfather be
Craggler: Hanging God of lmao bro thinks he's on the team 😂
Crawfather:god of judgement
he's a judge but also the patriach of all craws
I feel like we could use 2 words to describe him
Pintress: Lonely God of Pin
elderly god of blank and blank or whatever
Judgemental God of The Jury
Father of the flame: construct god of obsession
Maybe lawful?
Scathing God of Justice
Lawful God of Craws would work
Crawfather: biased god of the court?
Oh you were talking of crow father? Why would he be a jury? I never did his mission
hes a judge
he slams his beak like a gavel and is the leader of the court of craws
Oh, so the courts are the judicial power of pharloom? That's interesting
his hunter's journal entry calls him the justice of pharloom's craws
Last Judge: Guardian God of the Gate
Maybe god of the trial
Grand Mother Silk: Holy God of Silk.
Kinda obvious ig
Pale god of silk can work too
does the crawfather die
Disgraced Chef Lugoli: Banished God of The Kitchen
I guess?
you never see him again so probably
Last judge: executioner god of the ascension?
i forgot what happens when you defeat him
garmond and zaza: gods of nobility
Maybe doorkeeper can be a title for her?
Forebrothers Signis & Gron: Dutiful Gods of The Docks
Stupid gods of spam 😾
I dont think we wil lget GodSeekers again
Im pretty sure hornet does just kill the crawfather
yeah I doubt they'd just repeat what they'd do in hollow knight exactly, we're gonna get boss rushes in a whole new way
last judge: righteous god of rapture
Well yeah, im saying the Boss refight Mechanic will Be tied to something diffrent
were gonna go into hornet's memories of fighting those bosses xd
it is fun to imagine what the silksong boss hall of gods would look like in terms of titles though
Deep memory is obviously what will probably be expanded upon
The reward for beating every boss all bindings hitless in in silksong will be a 2 second clip of the pale king talking to hornet
Calling her a broke bitch
Savage Beastfly: Enraged God of The Hunt
Savage Beastfly: fucking asshole
I do think a memory based dlc for hornet where you refight the bosses would be the best possible outcome
Team cherry can do a lot with that
Like have hornet face her regrets and demons that still plague her from hallownest
A theory on Pronouns in Silksong
Is it possible that the reason Pharloom characters constantly use plural pronouns to refer to themselves is because of the Haunting being a Blood curse.
Like originally it seemed like a strange quirk that some bugs are refer to themselves is plural “We” pronouns but then there was some other bugs who can’t tell, like there’s one bug who questions whether they call themselves “we”
I think the reason some bugs use plural and others don’t is because since the Sill curse is a blood curse that can pass from parent to child, and Silk has a kind of “essence” to it, it’s possible that ancestors literally pass their essences from Parent to child too.
The pattern I’ve noticed is that it’s mostly the skilled bugs who use “we” pronouns. Like the skills of their ancestors pass down across the generations to the point that the bug now considers itself a “we” simply because they can feel the “essence” of their ancestors as they perfect their skills
Also means we can get a vessel fight
I feel like this game just has too many bosses for a boss rush to be plausible
I need to see pale king godamn it team cherry
Probably the last pantheon would be a recompilation of the best bosses instead of the "All bosses" we had in pantheon of hallownest
I feel like it'd be more interesting, but also dear god pantheon of pharloom would be like a feature length film after dlc bosses
Have the pale king speak perfect english
Dont do the bug noises everyone else speaks, make him use english
Well yeah but WITH DLC? this game will have more
reminder that silksong's base game has more bosses than hollow knight with dlcs 😭
who would he be voiced by
this game is freaking massive, idk how
Yep.
Walken
YES, THANK YOU FOR NOT SAYING IT
It's not by much, but with dlc's a full pantheon is just too big
im gonna find you
christopher walken pale king hold up this is fire
he played the emperor in dune part 2 it could probably work
Shaman/beast/wanderer crest will peak in boss rushes
tbh pantheon five was already too big in the first game. I hope they do something slightly different with it.
beast runs out of steam by the end
idek wtf it means 😭 im just mad annoyed at ppl spamming it
it doesn't mean anything it's just a stupid meme people keep repeating
what the fuck? Where did you get that image from?
I'm being serious what the hell man
second sentinel pfp spotted
if you don't tell me where it's from, I'm just gonna assume you're an ai bro
not visual, but ethically and morally
No it’s directly stated that the curse is passed from parent to child. The Caretaker says it
I think there is a passive control that the silk curse causes. The Caretaker says that the “pull” of the citadel is because of the curse. Like the reason bugs inherently want to worship the Citadel is because their ancestors were already infected by the Silk curse and then passed it down onto them
So there is a passive Curse and then there is a direct curse when Silk directly just hijacks pilgrim bodies and controls them
I think a side effect of the passive curse is that it connects parents and children permanently in some like vague soul-bond way
We're certainly getting a vespa fight in the memory fights
I just realized that the bugs who got through the Blasted Steps and finally made their way to the citadel, would go to the only elevator, and the elevator only goes down to the underworks lmao, how did I not notice that on my first playthrough
yeah that's due to the silk being passed
absolutely 100% I would be vastly disappointed if they don't.
It's like the one thing I can think of that might be able to be better than your vessel
Then again they could probably think of something I could not possibly imagine
the silk is so ingrained in the bugs of pharloom that it can be passed down from parent to child
yeah
I feel like pantheon 5 kinda could have erased 10 bosses and keep as good
Trobbio: Thespian god of the theatre (I lie in wait on the stage)
First Sinner: Wrathful god of sin (I lay in chains within a prison)
Cogwork Dancers: Mechanical gods of dance (Together we wait within the city of song)
Grand Mother Silk: Pale god of threads (I lay asleep at the citadel's peak)
Seth: God guardian of the shrine (I stand guard at the edge of the citadel)
Crawfather: Honored god of the court (Summoned, I await you beneath the home of craws)
Lace 1: Pale god of the citadel (I wait within the maze of lava and iron)
Lace 2: Pale god of the citadel (I wait at the climb to the citadel's peak)
Lost Lace: Void-touched god of the citadel (I wait with my mother beneath the abyss)
Bell Eater: Enraged god of the hunt (I wait within the bellways)
Fourth Chorus: Slumbering god of machinery (I wait within the lava filled fields)
Last Judge: Mechanical god of judgement (I await at the top of the climb to the citadel)
Phantom: Mournful god of the mist (I wait within a maze of fog and ghosts)
Widow: Crazed god of silken thread (I haunt the town of bells)
Great Conchflies: Partnered gods of coral (We wait within the sand blasted wastes)
The Unravelled: Tormented god of husks (I wait in a pit within walls of white)
Pinstress: Skilled god of the pin (I wait at the frozen peak for your arrival)
ok bye chat [dies]
it takes like 40 minutes tbh I would've preferred if absolute radiance was just at the end of pantheon four and the enhanced versions of all the bosses were in the regular other pantheons
last judge isn't a robot
For examples, why do we fight Grimm and hornet just to fight Nkg and sentinel hornet after?
last judge should be the blazing god of judgement
Yeah and I think this is why some bugs use “we” pronouns. Some bugs have a stronger connection to their ancestors through the silk curse that connects all the generations and passes down.
And I think this is why Pharloom is so advanced. I think because bugs were infected and basically passed own their skills and learning through silk to their offspring. Bit by bit, generation after generation, the bugs became so smart that they created this huge steam punk kingdom.
doesnt last judge literally explode into flames?
aura farming
Yeah, they're incense burner explodes
not because she's a robot
i thought they just like. yk. self destruct as a last ditch effort
judges are purely biological
The fire thing they're holding does a big fire and the last judge gets fired
Yeah but It proved the Pale King to be a better leader by contrast so
I feel like the pantheon of Hallownest could have consist of: Every enhanced version of bosses.
Nkg
The four pantheon leaders
Absrad as final boss
ik the judges are! i thought the last judge was a construct
look at last judge, she's clearly an adult version of a squirrm
FULLY thought they were a construct
Why did you think they got winded after doing a big attack then?
pharloom so bad it got me making excuses for bug atreides
wear and tear, like the twelveth architect
Last judge kinda thicc
we're not even a couple months past release yet I don't think this is a fair thing to say haha
they've likely fought many a pilgrim and warrior trying to make their way to the citadel
i wouldn't be surprised if their gears were starting to wear out n stuff
We also have absolutely zero dlc give the game some time
problem with this comparison is imo those are the 2 best moments in their respective games
I honestly vastly prefer pharloom in terms of worldbuilding, and I loved hallownest a ton
even the cogwork dancers get "staggered" at some point (when theres only one of them left and they try to do the embrace attack)
what else
okay i love the abyss climb i wanna do it again SO BADLY
abyss climb feels uniquely awesome in hollow knight that's kinda why it's so good imo
same goes for red memory + last dive in silksong
i loved all of the "escape" sequences in silkson so much
The past of pharloom is much less the focus compared to the first game and hallownest,
and this makes sense when you consider the protagonist and their stories.
the knight IS deeply and directly related to the vessels and the past of the kingdom and the pale king and the infection that story is interlinked the past of the world is part of it a big section.
and the story that you play through is also deeply related to the past of the place and your character's backstory.
hornet in pharloom on the other hand is a different story, the only relation she has to the place is that it's her mother's homeland.
additionally it focusses much more on current active characters and their story arcs as opposed to what happened in the past, though that is still touched upon.
preferring one over the other is fair and well, but don't say that one is better than the other, especially since we've had almost a decade to understand, Hollow Knights story and not even a few months for silksongs
I don't really know what to say to that I was satisfied with silksong's story
okay question: other than the one mask shard escape sequence in far fields and the one when escaping the abyss, what other ones are there?
yeah
praying DLCs add more
I dissagree. its the same. Its just that With Pharloom its much more Obvious whats happening. The deep lore about the Weavers and the history of the Tribes is Just as Compelling.
I mean, the game about finally putting to rest a ruined kingdom has a more focus on the past, while the game set in a currently-active nation has more focus on how things currently are, that doesn't feel insane to me
also. can we have a quick discussion about the weavers and GMS?
it's hard to put into words why I like silksong's story, hell I can barely put into words why I like hollow knight's story lmao
How many masks did you have before act 3? Max was 9
these games mean a lot to me I can't even talk about them like a normal person
Exactly about what
that's fair enough.
I withhold judgement until the full story of this game is puzzled out though.
Or else let's imagine comparing this current state of things to hollow knight only when it had just released and how much people understood its story then.
see that's a good starting point but I always feel the need to keep going lol
so. was GMS evil during the time she made the weavers or was she just. doing higher being stuff and then the weavers were the assholes for putting her to sleep
i think i've put together most of the lore but some aspects are still blurry
she ascended the weavers from pharlids to sustain her light through song, she ascended weavers to enslave them
The second one.
we don't know of anything that she did besides somewhat probably conquering some places
well she wants loyal daughters
this "to preserve her light" motivation is pure speculation and should not be taken as any fact
Yep that, but I feel like the thing the weavers did of putting her to sleep thousand years may have been too much
Just putting that as a disclaimer before anyone gets tricked
"for her light eternal our song sustains" what does that mean then
whos a worse mother gms or white lady
i know that part but is it. morally bad to make something to work for you?
i mean. we make AI for that same purpose, are we assholes?
gms
Context
ai is not sentient (yet), she provided sentience then enslaved them
I mean, it's hard to say.
AI is not alive
slaves are
you get what i mean
that line is spoken by a specific person at a specific time in a specific context and even then you're making extra extrapolations that aren't confirmed
Well You still get Hallownest Lore in this game and We learn the Tragedy of The weavers like was implied in hollow knight.
This Game is More about Breaking a Cycle Rather than Euthinasia of a kingdoms ideals. i think its different and thats fine, Iwouldnt have wanted repeat hallownest again.
Like every part of lore in this game
making ai does make you an asshole, but for entirely different reasons
idk considering the memory showed a bunch of weavers playing their songs it didn't feel like that much of a stretch 🤷♂️
the entirety of hollow knight series is about breaking a cycle
for hk its the sealing of the radience
for ss its the sealing of GMS
what's the cycle in hallownest?
And also the legal implications of AI in Art and explicit content
Well,Its parallel. But This time Something can be Done Before the fact. Or at least on the Cusp of it. Thats The point of Silksong is that its Negative Polaroid Hollow Knight in every way really.
The argument about treating robots/constructs like people is something sci-fi's been doing since Metropolis. Fwiw it's probably not a good thing to create something that's sapient and then restrict its freedom, since you could (successfully IMO) argue that that's slavery, but that comes down to individual philosophies
how strong is nightmare heart
the hollow knight ending, where you take THK's place
i'm just put off by how it was framed as an unequivocal truth.
But ok let's examine things a bit more closely.
that line is said after the cut scenes were, they are playing their harps and then a light comes from the sky, going by this interpretation or any other interpretation, what does the light coming from the sky mean?
doesnt hornet literally say even though its baked into her blood shes like: i'm not gonna do that. im not like them
would it be above pv?
It kinda made me think of that radiance scene we get after beating pure vessel
she could deadass just. leave. after
white lady can defeat the shade lord i just cant prove it yet
it's because of the unconsensual scraping of text and artworks and the energy stuff and other stuff as well.
THe implication is that is no longer Hornet But something new and terrible
need to rewatch the widow cutscene but I'm pretty sure it plays a noise similar to gms + first sinner cutscene where it is definitely gms
Do you think we getting a Grimm/nightmare heart apparition in this game?
Something like a dlc were the stupid cult of father of flame brings nightmare heart intrrest
depends how you define power.
The nightmare heart certainly seems like it needs an avatar unlike some other gods.
and I think pure vessel could probably beat nightmare king grimm.
i'm not sure what power the heart has it on its own
pharloom isnt dead so probably not
grimm should get shot in the head by steel assassin sharpe in the city of steel dlc
world sense goes so much harder than farsight
I agree it's reminiscent of that heavily, but I just don't know what it means
Man wtf that hate came uta nowhere lol
took them a while to arrive to hallownest tho
Not necessarily reused.
As for example we got lifeblood and it was totally different in this game
it's more like something on the verge of death, any longer and it would've ended up like hallownest
call it theft or plagiarism or hell copyright infringement if you want.
The name for the act is less important than the act itself.
Possible That they are the smae mechanism since the weavers made all the runes in the Black Egg Temple
Sorry but this feels like that thing were people feel past stuff is better
What's the name of that thing?
nostalgia
it was able to turn grimm into nkg so its probably stronger
also I doubt they'd wanna follow up on the troupe and confirm which ending to that storyline is canon
It could try to control pure vessel, but that most likely would end with him getting sucked whole
tbh I don't think there's anything in silk song that pure vessel couldn't take care of.
New Threads for future content list:
LIfeblood
Greyroot
Everblooms
Steel Hearts
except for like... the void because they don't have any bullshit Weaver memory flower red memory spell stuff they can do
in my brain what happens is she absorb's GMS's power and thus becomes the "weaver queen", but shes still hornet, just, really powerful and "ascended" in a sense
cogwork dancers, they would make pure vessel cry and therefore it would understand that it is not pure
I mean we did? The only options we have in hollow knight is: Passing or Helping.
Run or Help
But not Fight
It might do the same for the dancers though
Well,The fact that shes going through a metamorphosis Makes me think her Personage is Changing
I feel like Everblooms don't have that much interest in their own.
But steelings and Greyroot are a must
hornet
idk a god's strength can be in many ways and combat is not necessarily chief among them
I was going to say silk but the pure vessel have a big control of its void
The Land Serene The White lady mentions in Hollow Knight is still of interest. Especially since she calls everblooms "The First Light" .Meaning they are EXTREMLY IMPORTANT in some kind of creation myth?
i do hope we see more lifeblood :))
wormways gets even more fucked up in dlc
tired: no grimm troupe dlc for silksong because we don't want reused content
wired: no grimm troupe dlc for silksong because it implies the knight went for carefree melody over nkg fight, and who would even do that
But it didn't really end the cycle didn't it? For what I got it just "Vanished from Hallownest" but it can still go for other kingdom to devour