#general-2
1 messages · Page 391 of 1
Warum so ernst man
Welches?
Mannheim? Oder Bodensee?
Ähm , Mannheim
Ist ca 40 Minuten von mir entfernt
Ah okay und wo wohnst du ?
Heilbronn & Ludwigsburg
when Wirtschaft means both economy and inn/pub
@hot cloak weswegen fragst du?
Irgendjemand wach?
Nein
Also
Ich werde dort Sprache studieren
Für ein paar Monaten
Und ich will gern mehr Informationen darüber wissen
Das ist warum ich hab' dich gefragt
Das ist echt toll
Dats gut.
Ich hope zu komplett lernen Deutsch soon.
Was willst du studieren?
Deutsch studieren für ein paar Monaten
Das dauert viel Zeit Leute
Und dann ich muss mich an eine Universität melden
Ok fine
Also
Ich möchte Psychologie studieren
Hat jemand eine Idee darüber m
Ja. Ich lernen dies für mein Sophomore year.
@plucky marsh ijew here
Eine gute Wahl ich habe nicht mehr darüber Information
@plucky marsh @vagrant cobalt @tawdry loom
Ah okay genau
was ?
Aber viel Glück
Vielen Dank
aber ich möchte sprechen
Ah okay
Wie alt bist du?
20
Halo
Halo
Hallo.
Ich bin bssisa
Wilkommen.
Ahah @plucky marsh
hghhhhh
Kannst du bitte erklären was bedeutet bsissa
Bssisa
Auf jeden Fall weißt du nicht
Wir essen es gern in ramadan
Ramadan
hahhahahhahaha
Halo
absolut
Ich will dass alle meine valise mit bsisa wird
aber bissa ist mehr gesunder
Healthy
Bier ist auch gut
nur mit glas
Es ist so rzina in der bauch
Nein ich bin dagegen
Warum reden wir um bier
ja
Hast du beer einprobiert
Du bist immer dagegen , aslek mou3aredh
ich möchte eun bier jetzt
Was
@potent steppe rede mit uns
Du hast bier anprobieren
Nö
ja
Warum
Ein langweilen topic ja ?
Anprobieren = Kleidung testen
Aaa
Tragen ?
Testen
weil ich sehr traurig bin
Like if they fit or Look good
Danke !
In klasse benutzen wir immer anprobieren mit welchem objekt
Aaaah , traurig ?
Mit alle 😂
Trake7 fi arno ye whayda
Das lehrer sagt nicht darüber
deutsch bitte
Imma Screenshot that besh ytardek
Darum trinkt er Bier
Bier ist faaselnd
bier mit bsissa ist wünderbar
Ich genieße mein essen nur mit einem Glas bier
Gute Nacht
Huhn?
jani nome hhhhh
Auf Wiedersehen alle.
auf wiedersehen!
Wann kann ich sprache im Mikrofon gut Deutsch? Nach b1?
Entschuldigung, Ich spreche schlecht Deutch. Ich bin Anfänger :(
ich denke nach b2
Guten Nacht, alle.
Guten Tag mein Deutsch ist nich gute
Hallöchen
Guten morgen
guten morgen ;-;
Ich weiß nicht ob ich Guten Morgen oder Guten Nacht jetzt muss sagen...
Vier Uhr Freunde, wo sind Sie? 
es ist zwei heir 
Hallo
Hallo!
Halo! wie gehts es dir ?
Mmm das ist nicht gut
change ur pfp pls
Merhaba. Nasılsınız? @sage kayak
Immer noch falscher Channel
@unkempt wyvern Ich hab mich nur gefragt, weil wenn du die im Lateinischen verstehst, verstehst du die dann deswegen auch im Deutschen?
Inzwischen ja
Sieht also aus wie Genitiv 
Aber vielleicht erkennst du nur nicht ob eine Präposition einen Fall oder den anderen verlangt o.Ä.
Also, Deutsch verstanden hab ich natürlich schon vorher, aber durch Latein verstehe ich inzwischen auch, was Fälle sind und wozu sie da sind
Aber es ist nicht einfach Genitiv, sondern ein anderer Fall?
Oki o:
Und eigentlich nicht wichtig
Wie gesagt, das mache ich im Deutschen halt intuitiv 😄
Hmm~
Glaub, Latein fand ich auch hilfreich, um doe Grammatik von Deutsch 'mehr zu verstehen'
Also auf die nicht so intuitive Weise
Ja, genau
In einem Bild erklärt, warum Fälle nicht zu ignorieren sind
Jede zusätzliche Sprache hilft da irgendwie
Wobei es bei Japanisch irgendwie schwierig ist, Gemeinsamkeiten zu finden
Kann leider keine anderen Sprachen :(
Ich hatte zwar 3 Jahre Spanisch in der Schule, aber hab da gefühlt nichts gelernt
Ja, schon
Zu viele... 👀
Welche würdest du am ehesten einfach jetzt können wollen? ~
Oder sind das auch zu viele?
Gute Frage
Italienisch, weil ich ziemlich viel italienische Familie habe, aber das früher niemand mit mir gesprochen hat
So wie alle meine Fragen~
Falls du vor hast nach Amerika zu kommen sprechen ganz viele hier auch Spanisch, also, auf Mexikaner bezogen @unkempt wyvern
Chads lernen Schwedisch
~~Du denkst also, ich könnte Spanisch? ~~
Ich denke du könntest von denen zumindest was lernen 
Glaub Latein sollte sehr hilfreich sein bei den Sprachen :3
denke auch
Los, Emilia, lerne sie~
Schule ist nicht immer das Effektivste
Gibt auch da Sprachlernserver~
Aber aber aber Zeiiiit...
Eigentlich nie
Eines Tages wirst du sie haben
Aber nicht jetzt 😦
Und eines anderen Tages wirst du dankbar sein, dir die letzten Monate / Jahre täglich die 10 - 20min genommen zu haben~
Das kann nat. sein 
Ok, du hast recht
Thehe
Stimmt
Immer
Frag Carrots
(Carrots, sag ja oder werde gebannt)

Hehe
But it's spoken in the vatikan 
Ich hab ein Meme für alles
Außer er spricht seine eigenen Gedanken aus
rennt weinend aus dem Raum
😏
Bulli, was lernst du so für Sprachen?
Ihr wisst dass es teilweise stimmt 😾
Japanisch
und ich will unbedingt mal Finnisch lernen
Aber Japanisch reicht erstmal~
schon 
Finnisch find ich auch total interessant
Jahaha
Vittu
Ja
Japanisch wirkt auch cool, aber da weiß ich nicht wirklich, wie es, äh, funktioniert
Ja indeed
anders~
so wie das Finnische geht da viel über Suffixe
und die werden einfach angehängt und ändern nichts am Stamm
Aber für 'Fälle' bzw. so was ähnliches gibts Partikel, also extra 'Grammatikwörter'
So, jetzt weißt du alles
Cool, danke 😄
Kein Ding 
Hallo alle
guten tag👌
Hallo was macht ihr gerade so ?
Ich sitze in einer Klasse
dein mutter ah ah ah ah
entschuldige mir
ist ok
@buoyant kestrel why do you say that
for me it wasn't hard to do that
maybe i can give you advice
Germans swap to English if they hear you struggle at all
Even though their English often sucks too
Xd
not all of them
i mean ive had that experience before but it's really not every single one of them
you have to be clear about your intentions
It's a very large percentage of them, enough so that it's become a stereotype
tell them, pls dont switch to english
Idk all my friends in Germany saying that
I mean if you are at C1 or so, you will find yourself talking naturally to them
But when you are still learning, good luck trying to sustain a conversation with a native
that's the impression they gave me at least
when i was an exchange student this happened to me but my friend said for him it was only because since he came to america to live with me first, it felt strange to suddenly talk to me in german
but
there were some others that did it to me
one year later i did a study abroad though
my german was better then
and it actually pretty much never happened during that
but still, sometimes it happened just because a german wanted to practice english or whatever
some of them even seemed like they were trying to show off to me
i completely understand your struggle @buoyant kestrel
you have to find someone who will actually listen to your request
that being "pls do not switch to english, unless i switch to it, or if i ask you to"
if they don't want to do that, find someone else
Germans in general think English is wayyy easier than German imo and they overestimate their English ability while underestimating your German ability
But obviously not all of them
Yeah they are always more keen on improving their English
reset their "default mindset"
i have plenty of friends i talk to in German without them switching, and yes, maybe it's easier for me, but i had to get here somehow, and that was by talking to them when i was worse at it
i did find germans who would just talk to me in german
despite my struggling or mistakes
some of them are more flattered than others that you are even trying to learn it
those ones will tend to be more helpful
but some are more self-centered, and only want to speak english and never german with you
Okay what?
@olive sentinel well, @buoyant kestrel was saying whenever he tries to speak German with Germans, they all just automatically switch to English
so I am trying to give advice
Tell them you wanna improve your german?
(Obviously don't do that if pure communication matters more than learning the language in that moment)
i told them they should just tell them their true intentions
like they should tell them, they don't want them to randomly start speaking English in the middle of the convo
not that "you can't practice english with me", but just, while i am trying to speak german, could you please also keep speaking it
that sort of thing
if you don't tell them then they are more likely to do it
baby car is running crazily into a lake
Deutscher: "Hey! Hold the car!!"
Oblix: "Err.. Entschuldigung, ich möchte mein Deutsch verbessern, würden Sie so lieb und nett sein, das noch einmal zu wiederholen, aber dieses Mal, bitte, auf deine Sprache, die ich mich seit einer gewissen Zeit so leidenschaftlich die Mühe gebe, um besser und natürlicher zu... (...)"
DUDE!!!
I would talk about my situation, i took a German crush course but have completly no idea about to find a real man to talk with me in German. Then I fell into self-doubt for a really long time cuz i think i've learned a lot about German but I could't understand what peoples talking about
This feeling sucks:(
The real man part makes me confused too
They're not a native English speaker probably just unfortunate coincidence double mistake
Don't sound native at least
You must truly like German men, hm?

When a typo fucks up your whole message
Lol @half lynx
*crash
*real person
Unless you meant what you typed.
hallo
Hallo, wie geht’s?
Hallo, ich bin gut, danke. Ich habe nur heute die grosse Discord-Servers entdeckt, darum bin ich ein bisschen ueberrascht.
: (
same story bro
nope. I tried my best to make the sentence. Had no practice for a half a year or so
damn half a year? this going to be my first time lol
good for you to join here then : D
B) appreciate it
Mein kopf explodierte von deinen super perfekten satz
: DDD
Danke sehr!
Haha same
Ich muss wie B1 sprehen, jedoch fuehle ich wie A2 oder schlechter
I didn’t know danke sehr was a phrase until now 
Ich mag diese Gruppe
!
First sentence in German. Congrats!
Ich bin nicht sicher auch
But now you know when using “I” you conjugate the verb “magen” which means like to “Ich mag”
Nein, danke sehr ist richtig aber Ich benutze “Vielen Dank ” weil Ich dass gehört hatte
Na ja, ich habe "vielen dank" komplett vergessen.
Wow, the server has meme-cat as a sticker. I already love it
Ich hatte „satz“ vergessen lol
Ultimate battle
How do you overcome a level, where you already know a bit of language, but still require dictionary at hand to somehow express yourselves and understand others?
I don’t really use a dictionary, but I usually google translate a phrase if I don’t understand it and pick it apart into simpler pieces to digest the content individually
I do that to understand what others are saying, and I think it kind of works for me
But if I wanted to create my own sentences I’d learn some grammar and experiment with building sentences
i dont really understand whats going on
i dont even know how im gonna start the lessons lol
don't do that. use Deepl.com if you're going to use a translator
duden is a great online dictionary
with examples, declension, conjugation etc etc
I also use wordrefrence.com, but I’ll try that website out
I’d recommend you start with introducing yourself and present tense grammar, Lucci
Well, you could find different ways to introduce yourself, such as “Ich bin _”, “Mein name ist _, “Hallo, Ich bin”
Forgot about that one
ich is only capitalized if at the beginning of a sentence
Wait, it‘s not oops
whats that
it directly translates to 'i am called kevin'
Ich bin Kevin
it's just another way german says my name is kevin
Wie heißt du is a common way to ask what's your name
literally 'how are you called'
how i do the b between i and t
Or „Was ist dein name?“, but I think that‘s less common
I just use the german keyboard
that is an eszett. it makes an s sound like in snake
if you don't have a german keyboard, you have to use the number pad and press alt+0223
or copy paste
dein Name
i'm dumb but capitalize
big important
woooooo
Yeah, I‘m always lazy with capitalizing my nouns it‘s a bad habit
ß
noice
k pro
You can just write a "ss" in place of "ß" for now. Writing it as a capital B, on the other hand, is very much not advised.
I was going to suggest it, but it kind of looks weird using the double ss
so
It does the job, though.
where do i start lol
That’s fair
faq nico
FAQ not found. I found the following similar entry: nicos.
ive been here for the last 10m
Nicos Weg is a free online program aimed at helping people learn German. It includes video, audio, text, grammar explanations, notes, vocabulary, and exercises. It also includes very useful cultural and bureaucratic information, such as how to open a bank account, while teaching you the relevant grammar and vocabulary.
It’s fairly popular and well-recommended, but keep in mind that you can’t learn a language with only one resource, even if it’s a good one!
You can find the courses here: https://learngerman.dw.com/en/overview/
You can also see various other courses for learners by dw.com here: https://www.dw.com/en/learn-german/s-2469/
Wie ist dein Name? I dont think its formed with was
Apparently you’re right, my bad
I’ve been using it wrong all my life 
Das ist sehr gut 🤣
привет немцы
Haaa?
I think we were taught it as "was ist dein Name" in class lmao
lol it could be said that way, my teacher was always like nonononon its wie
I think I use both :FeelsBadMan:
both works :3
just say: "Darf ich um Ihren/deinen Namen bitten?"
"Würden Sie mir Ihren Namen verraten 😉 "
hi
hallo
hi
Hi
Hey
@somber forge @urban wolf
Heeey @hot cloak~
The topic you brought up is not very liked here :blobupsidedownr:
You can also find it in #rules.
Also the bot muted you, since it's very popular with trolls~
Jetzt bin ich neugierig darauf, was sie gesagt hat 👁️
I'm curious what the topic was now TBH 
Das ärgert mich 😠
Willkommen!
Tja~p
Ohne jetzt unhöflich sein zu wollen, glaub ich, dass dir schon oft genug gesagt wurde, dass du da nicht ao neugierig sein sollst 
Aber ihr könnt in DMs fragen
Also mich
Das Übliche halt. Siehe Regel 2
Willst du dass ich sag dass nocheinmal 😂 ?
Gut
Diggi, 'hab nur gesagt, dass ich neugierig drauf bin
Macht Sinn
Wie geht es Ihnen?
ihr könnt's mir sagen, bis ihr blau im Gesicht anlauft
Gut, dir? :3
Wie meinst du das?
Das erinnert mich daran dass ich mir ein G&T holen sollte
Was ist ein G&T?
Gin and Tonic
Bis du umfällst und dir dein Gesicht grün und blau schlägst
Mir geht's auch gut 🙂
Das freut mich c:
Umfällt 
Ich werd immer was dazu sagen, wenn ich wissen will, wie gelöschte Kommentare lauten
Die werden dir halt nie im Chat beantwortet, weil wir ja eigentlich dafür zuständig sind, die so schnell wie möglich zu entfernen
Der Hochstapler sieht alles
I don't get on discord to actually talk much, but i finally invested in a German tutor and did my first 1 on 1 lesson the other day. This has been something I've been anxious to start (tutoring) but my learning was getting to a point in which I couldn't learn/understand much further with self research.
Proud of myself 😅
Where are you from?
Schweden
Ok
Mir geht es auch gut, Danke!
hey
amazing!
Hallo !!
Hallo, wie bist du?
Mir es gut, und du?
Ich bin ein bischenn schlecht weil ich viele Hasaufgaben habe
Ahh hausaufgabe ;-;
@sharp lantern @sage kayak @lavish saddle @arctic atlas @opal sequoia
someone attempted a funny
ping spamming mods upon joining? no but yes
not forbidden but people like this usually turn out to be trolls
guten abend zusammen
Abend guten
Imagine pinging all the mods but @sudden panther You're not acknowledged by the troll 
Imagine thinking there are only 6 mods. 😔
Wait, I forgot about aden
but he's almost never online anymore :/
And I still can't come to terms with him being a mod now 😔
Ja. They just went for people who were online at the time, and I was being productive™️ so I had Discord closed for most of the day.
Damn
Actually aden is just fake offline most of the time, so even when he's there you can't see him in the list. 


That's Aldi
I highly doubt it 

av 630758737702944798
Or is it a secret?
Pretty similar I'd say
arrem seit wann bist du ein zug
arrem fährt richtung baden
No it actually is aldi. But she only agreed to let us add it under the condition that we don't modify it in any way so we can't have the
version of
. 
Wait really? @sharp lantern I thought you had another hair color
I think this is a joke

Oh :/ Why 

She's not a natural blonde, yes.
the hoi person is not me
I can't trust Arrem 
This is aldi 2 years ago
Never trust a person with a red name 
but tbh, that's on me 
yeah
I'm an idiot, but he did tell me that
is 0x1 and I believe that to be true
See I hate how you keep doing this because of course everyone's gonna believe you. It's unfair as shit. 
but that could also be absoluter Blödsinn


Red. Wherever the road tracks take me.
Wait till you hear about
Well now I have my doubts

to space
Die U1?
is that actually arrem?
Why do I even ask... nvm
Of course it is
i actually am but a really extremely dark blonde 
We've talked about it, no you're not.
dark blonde = brown
nah, brown is different afaik
let aldi hope
There isn't even a hint of blonde in there. 😌
Oh my God. Honestly whatever, think whatever you like. 
I will 
its me
what is you?
mit Dunkelmodus kann ich das nicht sehen
Ich auch nicht lol
gefährliche unsichtbare Spinne
hier sind die spinnen aber seeehr sichtbar
aufgrund ihrer Größe und ihres haarigen Aussehen

Australia is just one giant spider
mist wer hat dir das denn verraten, das soll geheim bleiben
Bulli der Wicht 
verbrenn ihn auf dem Scheiterhaufen
Australier auf dem Weg zur Schule
allerdings
zum glück muss ich das nicht mehr tun, heutzutage begebe ich mich auf dem Weg zur Uni
was insgesamt nur 2 Schritte beinhaltet, da Uni immer noch Online ist 

du machst dich über mein Elend lustig
er meint das nicht so
ich meins auch nicht so, ich mache nur ein bissl spaß
Lüge
Meine ich schon so. Mir bereitet es viel Spaß, wenn andere leiden 
Din mamma
Böswewicht
(Böse)Wicht
oops, danks dir Primax
Danks dir
oh ne ich würde mich so umnennen aber mir gefällt bluwus cluwus zu sehr


was bedeutet Cluwus?
Clues
Ach so, Grüwüs Hinweise
does anyone have a book or app you would recommend to learn german
This badboy right here
Ooh thanks
You're welcome!
ist diese Buch hilfreich?
I go to General 2!
Y'know
I cant stress enough how perfect and delicious pretzels are
A gift from the heavens
That is all
hallo
Hey
wie gehts
Mir geht's gut, und dir?
gut, auch
Nice
Ich lerne Deutsch, und ich komme auf der (forgot gender, I should know it by now) Vereinigtes Königreich
kuhl
aus dem Vereinigten Königreich
Bist du lernst Deutsch auch, oder?
Danke!
Aah okay
Drei Jahre, aber wirklich angefangen habe ich diesen Sommer
hey
hey
woher kommt ihr
Albanien
oh ok
Ich habe deutsche gelernt for 3Jahre aber mit Französischer stüdent und das ist nicht ein sehr gut Level
Sie Leben in Deutschland ?
nein
ich lebe in polen
und sory fur meine grammatik aber ich lerne. Mein level ist nicht sehr gut
Ich hoffe hier zu lernen
mir auch !
; )
Wie alt bist du ?
Ach so jung
Ich bin 14 Jahre alt und 15 inn March
omg jünger
Wie alt bist du ?
warum? 64?😂
22 
also das ist gut ! du bist nicht sehr alt !
oh nice
aus den USA! Du?
Polen
Ich fühle mich manchmal wie das

😂
was macht ihr?
ich mein Hasaufgaben gemacht
jaaa ich musst auch
meine deustche hausaufgaben, das ist sehr schwierig !😭
oh
wir werden das sehen !😅
😆
If your credit card number was the amount of money youd have how rich would you be
good one 
2320819954661312
Süß
📮 find the amogus Charakter
What a smart and yet insanely stupid question
If the three numbers in the back of you ur credit card were the amount of days you have left how many days would you have left
lmao
Hallo İch bin Hikmet .ich bin 23 und wohne in der Türkei. İch bin neu hier.
wenn sie lust sprechen haben ,bin ich immer hier
Wie gehts
Gut?
Ss
ßuß
Hat jemand gute deutsche Songempfehlungen? (Entschuldigung mein Deutsch)
um ungefaehr 10.000 aber hier ist ein Lied
Tschick hier streamen: https://verifiziert.lnk.to/tschick
https://www.instagram.com/verifiziert/
Beat: Florida Juicy
https://www.instagram.com/florida_juicy/
Engineer: food for thought
https://www.instagram.com/foodforthoughtmusic/
Mix & Master: Niklas Neumann
https://www.instagram.com/nklsnmn/
Video by Catism
https://www.instagram.com/cat...
Danke!
Ich mag Annenmaykantereit. Hier ist ein Lied von ihnen; https://youtu.be/nSaZMAFEW2U
Provided to YouTube by Universal Music Group
Ozean · AnnenMayKantereit
Ozean
℗ A Vertigo Berlin recording; ℗ 2019 Christopher Annen, Henning May, Severin Kantereit GbR, under exclusive license to Universal Music GmbH
Released on: 2019-09-20
Producer, Studio Personnel, Mixer: Markus Ganter
Studio Personnel, Mastering Engineer: Zino Mikore...
Danke
Welche Genres hörst du denn am liebsten?
If you are an A level Latin speaker and see this leave a
emoji, if you are a B level Latin speaker and see this leave a
Emoji. if you are a C level Latin speaker leave a
Emoji. Just Curious
(from @hot plover)
pinging @unkempt wyvern and @haughty sparrow again btw im so sorry lol
Thanks
libenter id feci
In Deutschland leben Menschen aus über 190 Ländern. Jeder vierte Einwohner Deutschlands hat Migrationhintergrund. Deutschland ist damit auch ein Land, in dem unterschiedliche Religion Sprachen und Kulturen aufeinandertreffen.
Was bedeutet genau damit hier?
hello guy I'm new to this server and I'm really looking to learn German so where and how do i start learning German because i don't know anything about the german language
Damit ist so that right? But it doesn't fit the context. I also dont under the point of auch here
">faq beginner" in #botchannel
Damit bedeutet auch 'thereby', also in dieser Satz: 'Germany is thereby also a country in which...'
Ach so, und was ist mit auch? Sie haben nicht von einem anderen land bevor gesagt. Also dann warum auch mit Deutschland
Warte, ich habe gerade merken, dass ich in General gepostet habe, stattdessen Questions
Es ist okay
Die Sätze versuchen zu sagen, dass Menschen aus viele Ländern kommen, und deshalb viele Kulturen, Sprachen und Religionen mitkommen
Also Deutschland ist gut für Auswanderen, und damit auch für unterschiedliche Kulturen usw
Aha, verstehe!
so uh
wasn't the holy roman empire a thing spanning over like
germany + a little to the south?
Yes
it was never really rome but they called it that because the romans had weirdly fragile egos
Long after the western Roman empire fell
And a thing that most people fail to mention is that the Byzantines were not the Byzantines when the Byzantines existed
If that makes sense
If you walked up and asked them, they were Romans
most of europe didn't know they were chilling there
they only decided to call them the byzantines because
at least from what I know
they were like:
"let's have a renaissance! we're gonna go back to the roots of the great rome!"
"what do you mean there are still actively alive romans?"
"you know what? no, they're not romans, call them something else"
north italy is one of the richest regions in whole europe / the world
rich in what
rich in rich
pasta
€€€
yea
idk Charlemagne was cool and all but the holy Roman empire was very disconnected from the actual roman empire
the reason italy AS A WHOLE doesn't have a much higher GDP is because of the poor south
yea well sure it has nothing to do with rome, just as little as byzantium 😄
they just claimed the name + other stuff
Saying Byzantium has nothing to do with rome is like saying California has nothing to do with the USA
The empire fell for external reasons, the Byzantine empire was wholly roman the entire time and stayed in power in the region for over a thousand years
Rome the city lost power after Constantine
i feel we're talking about different things here
you are talking about "who's more roman"
I have learned an important lesson
I am talking about who is roman point blank period
Never bring up that godforsaken word that I brought up
i am talking about "who saw themself as the roman successor"
There's no point to that because even America sees itself as the successor
well if you are saying: "who is roman", then you are wrong, i mean ... they were not roman, but kept the roman traditions etc.
people who're living for 500 years in america and keep their german heritage alive are still not german
they are just not
What makes them not roman? Ethnicity? Then absolutely neither were the holy Roman empire
technically lines get blurred all the time
i'm not claiming the HRA was roman, all i'm saying is that they claimed to be the sucessor
so if you're looking at it on a tiny time scale they might have totally been romans at some point
haha well yea if you keep that as a standard, no one and everyone is a successor 😄
Maybe it's a difference in language but your first msg was 'we were rome' not 'we called ourself Rome' so perhaps that's the issue here
yet, it was tradition for the HRA emperor to be crowned by the pope, and only then could he become the "true" emperor
(which created a myrriad of problems on it's own)
Thats an understatement
yea idk if it's a language barrier, but when i'm saying "we were rome" then it's just that what i'm saying
the people back then
saw themselves as the natural successor to the roman empire
they were rome
they were just as much rome as they were created by god and would go to hell if they did something wrong
this is not a matter of perspetive of legal thoughts
they knew that it was like that
this was common knowledge just like nowadays nobody would argue about that we need oxygen to breath
again, they didn't chose the name roman empire, this was intentional
There is definitely a language barrier here (your English is fantastic but just this understanding of the word). Using this verb in this way can be dangerous bc then you can say things like '___ bad person was right (because he thought he was right)'
the term "holy roman empire of german nation" was added hundreds of years later
until then it was the Sacrum Romanum Imperium
you mean indirekte Rede?
Yeah like er sei
yea, but i do not mean "sei" haha 😄 i mean: "die Menschen waren"
Anyway that's probably wrong but point being English doesn't have that so you have to kinda specify
They weren't though
as in, the indentified as
They just thought they were
but not as in, thought themselves to be something, like we'd define "identity" nowadays, they just were, without doubt or question
I can think that I'm an eagle, historians in the future wouldn't say 'he was an eagle' but rather 'he thought he was an eagle'
it's a little hard to wrap your head around this stuff, honestly.
Fully believe it, whatever
well yes ofc
but you have to view these topics from the perspective of the people back then
else you'll judge them by modern standards
burning women because you thought they were witches seems absurd by modern standards
Okay view it from my perspective of completely existing in my life believing I'm an eagle
This is not a matter of perspective
but if you view it from their perspective: badly educated, couldn't read, believed what they were told, no contact to the outside etc ...
Them fully existing in their minds as Romans still required 'they thought they were' because it's identifiably false information 1300 years in the future
well yes it is a matter of perspective, this is what it is about
no, honestly, i've studied history and my professors would wholeheartly disagree with you on that one. Yes, by modern and academic/scientific standards you're absolutely right, BUT that way to even look at stuff just did not exist back then
there was no doubt that, say, god existed
there was noone who did not know he exists
that way of thinking just didn't exist
So speaking of the napoleonic empire, do you also say they were romans?
Or at least napoleon himself
He 100% believed he was a Roman
Descended from Charlemagne himself
so, using the same thought process - the holy roman nation was created and continued as it was seen that the world would end / the last judgement would come upon mankind when the 4th kingdom, which was the roman one, would end
when god exists and the end times are not upon them, then you have to be roman because, well, otherwise the world would end, pretty easy 😄
The Roman empire 'ended' (since Byzantium is apparently non existent) 300 years before Cjarlemagne even existed
well is that a matter of personal/individual heritage?
No for either group
cause my mother also says she has italian/roman genes in her blood (and so, in turn, i'd have too)
which is kinda cute and also ridiculous because basically every single living european will have to some degree italian, german, english, french, spanish, polish and russian ancestors
The Roman empire at its highest, 350 years before its fall, and 700 years before the holy Roman empire, never even remotely reached mesrly half of the holy empire
well yes but not to the people back then, it literally COULD NOT have ended
why? because armageddon had not come yet
you're viewing all of that from a modern, logical standpoint
you've to put yourself in their shoes, at least as far as you can
just because it doesn't make sense logically viewed
No I am viewing it from a barbarian trying his damndest to defend his home from the disgusting Romans standpoint
doesn't mean it wasn't what was true for themselves
People were united under Charlemagne and the pope not the name rome
go back 100 years and you'll read tons of arcticles about how black people are less intelligent
those people back then, you can call them racists, but in reality they saw themselves as scientists and worked like scientists
Yeah and with your language and logic you would say 'Black people were less intelligent'
go back 200 years and people believed you could cure someone by bloodletting
no, that is not what i'm saying, quite the opposite
And no, the abundance of abolitionists and anti racists prove that the people knew what they were doing
or well, i haven't said anything about that matter
People believed it so you should say they were
People believed they were roman evidently so they were
People still believe that in some parts of the world 😦
what i'm saying is that people back then firmly believed this, it was their reality, a unquestioned reality
What I'm saying is your language choice is poor
Not your native language so it's not a big deal but 
idk, maybe it is
but what i'm trying to tell you is
again, i've studied this, bachelor only but whatever, still spend quite a time with wrapping my head around just what you are trying so hard to fend off right now
that you have to put yourself in their shoes
this is not making it morally correct
or your point of view wrong
this is not a right/wrong or even a moral decision
it's a matter of view of the world and what you hold to be unquestionable true
I'm just gonna end here because you're being very circular
👋
a truth so deep and unquestioned that nobody, NOBODY is questioning it 😄
hi
Hallo
I try my best to be relevant but I guess not all stars are meant to be the brightest
Among us
Hi guys
Hallo
@wise gyro i think your example is too complex, maybe something like sich beeilen might be more clear
Or sich interessieren
Something simple
Lassen is a bit of a tricky verb when learning german
well i'm not going after the verbs but the concept of reflexiveness
doesn't really matter which verb i chose for that does it?
Using simple vocab and grammar makes it easier to understand
Like sich X lassen is a kind of passive replacement, which makes it a little more confusing than it needs to be
Most beginners know sich setzen and sich interessieren so its a good place to start
idk, i don't think i understand where you're going at 😄
to know the verb is literally not important to understand that concept
i could make up a verb and the concept would work the same
what was the argument about?
this is a english chanel right?
Or german :)
I'm only just starting to get the hang of it 
purpose #general-2
This channel is intended as a less strict version of #german-only. In other words, you may speak English here, but you are encouraged to speak in German, and only use English when you, for example, need to explain grammar concepts
This channel can also be used if #general is getting too busy and you want to continue a conversation with someone here.
I don't see why that should be the case.
Maybe it also depends a bit on what you mean by that.
To really be able to call someone a friend takes quite a long time and it is a question of whether you want to invest it, assuming that the other person might not stay in Germany permanently.
But there is no reason why you should not find people with whom you get along well and also do things together.
I am normaly a cold bastard myself. I am living in Egypt which is a hyper socialising country. People here make friends out of chitchats in markets malls or any place, here you literally can make a friend from randomly bumping to someone in a street.
But I ended up with 1 or 2 friend lol
Averages person here makes like 50 friends. The definitions are different I guess. What Germany calls a friend is a best friend not just a friend. In Egypt a friend is just someone to hang out with.
I remember a fellow student at university who was also from Egypt. She was surprised that no one at the bus said hello to her, which would be perfectly normal in Egypt, and also found everyone very reserved.
We don't say hello in a bus ourselves. But we do like smalltalk alot. I guess that's what would annoy Egyptians the most. The no smalltalk rule. Or the fact that you can be familiar to a german but he would pass you the other day without any greetings. We would interpret that as rude lol
Personally I don't like having best friends at all. Just familiar friends that one can hang out with from time to time.
I can understand that. It probably just has its advantages and disadvantages. On the other hand, you have a real friend here for a lifetime and you can really rely on each other. There is not much guessing.
Seems like Germans are quite opposite they would only want best friends lol
Making a best friend is so damn hard tho. I suspect many people would just end up blatantly lonely.
We have another expression for people we know casually but don't quite consider friends. Bekannte.
To be honest, this is really a big problem.
Yeah it's impractical to say the least lol
Also to what extent a best friend is a best friend because people tend to change over life.
And what one was relating to in the past won't be the same ever again. I suspect out of loneliness you would be obliged to stay with a kindergarten friend forever or sth
Many still have their best friends from childhood, maybe 2-3 people, and only get to know a few people later in life that they would call that.
Yes it's the only logical outcome lol
Hm, that's really difficult, you're right. However, the value of friendship is so highly valued that people are relatively tolerant of each other's lifestyles.
What I would like to investigate tho is what would happen when said best friend's personality changes over time and you no more relate to him
Or is the german society structured to have as little value changes as possible
You always have the events and experiences that have connected you, which then in the end weigh more heavily than different views on certain things.
So you would just neglect any balue changes and suck it up lol
I think that you can definitely achieve making casual friends in Germany (and almost all countries). It helps to put yourself in situations that help make it more likely.
Like for example, if your city has some meet-ups for language exchange, or some other similar types of events.
I find myself befriending people based on my current circumstances.
For example, I'm at an age where many of my friends are changing a lot and starting families of their own and then have other interests. That is completely normal. But we still all make an effort not to lose sight of each other and keep in touch.
A lot of people on this server also made friends with other people on the server who live in a close area to them. Of course I should add to that: always be careful about meeting random people from online.
Many expats experience otherwise though. From what I have heard/read.
I don't see why that would be the case.
Yeah I assume late 20s early 30s lol
Like there may be some small cultural barriers like you described, but overall, Germany is not some totally strange and different culture or anything. They're normal and friendly people who enjoy getting to know others, just like most places.
When I was a student, we regularly went out and partied with our foreign students, which was quite fun to be honest.
And you can also meet many people who are also not born in Germany, who can be great friends.
Yeah expats befriending each other is easier for sure.
Well I am thinking seriously about moving to Germany. I would do fine being an introvert it's my fiancee I think would get mostly affected.
If you're someone who is comfortable speaking to new people then I think you will be fine. I think only really shy or introverted people could struggle, but that's also true for most places.
But like I said, it's important to find situations that encourage meeting people.
Always thought it starnge how westerners who move abroad are expats while everyone else is an immigrant.

I'll be honest with you, people won't always be as open and warm-hearted with each other as you might be used to but that doesn't mean you shouldn't have the chance to meet really nice people who are valuable to you. What is true, of course, is that age also plays a certain role. With increasing age, people become more and more reserved.
Besides, it is a bitter truth that there is racial prejudice aswell...
To a certain extent, you have to be able to deal with it and remember that not everyone is like that, so you don't become unhappy.
Yeah I guess the most affected peeps would be mid Easterns
is this directed at me?
To any foreigner I guess
but we're all foreigners to each other here : D
Not directly, it was more a continuation of my previous remarks.
It's all about the cultural values of the host country I guess..
oh okay. : )


emoji, if you are a B level Latin speaker and see this leave a
Emoji. if you are a C level Latin speaker leave a
Emoji. Just Curious