#hoi4-general
1 messages · Page 615 of 1
I mean you could do that as the Soviets too
Do you happen to be an expert on tank design and templates?
I can never make my tanks work.
Just take Poland from the Germans before they take it and ruin them
Just stack armor, Youll be fine
These DLCs made the game way too complicated for my low level of intellect and 300 hours played
my server has two dudes that know all the templates
What time frame roughly should you take Poland?
im SO BORED
Invite me to ts gang
Probably game start I guess if you really wanted to, that or turkey
Also. Is there, in single player, any use to building large numbers of 10 width garrison units?
You get free Romania because of that
honestly depends
Or should you invest in proper infantry units to do the job?
Not really
That’s kinda op
i personally dont use them
Dont garrison anything, just have a few tanks in reserve
So what should port garrisons look like?
well idk
I do not use tanks in most cases
How much 36w infantry should one produce to gank people? I’m talking 4 sets of artillery at the front
I use infantry to push
depends on country
as italy
dont use tanks
but as france
Then just have an army of infantry with CAS And Youll be fine in SP
use heavy tanks
Just produce a small amount of tanks and push on plains biomes
I want to use tanks.
The Ai doesn’t know how to do invasions
But I always fail at making good templates
Like I mean literally anyone can land an invasion, but keeping it going it the difficult part which the Ai struggles with
A lot of people spawn way too many tanks that aren’t needed. An equal amount of infantry divisions to your opponent + 1 heavy tank should be able to push most
Im telling you, just stack armor for the designs and soft attack and make a 36w tank template that has 200hp
You don’t have an ss of the template do you?
No, dont do that. It takes up your width
Let me see
Those are heavy tanks
yes
500 soft attack 🤤
i love heavy tanks
No medium or light tanks?
I been playing the game wrong for ages 😭
as france heavy tanks are the way
as germany honestly idk
medium
As most countries they’re the way ibr
Yeah I think so
Do flame tanks
And ig light tank recon aint bad
go forth my legions, take back what's ours
Is it better to learn France or soviets first?
It’s a very old picture but the template should look like this
Thanks appreciate jt
Basically this template but replaced with mech marines and heavy mech tanks
with mechanized instead of motorized
why put your battalions like this 😭
When you get mech obviously
I put my battalions in all crooked forms, what’s it to you.
Hoi4 police, hello??
Is it scummy to take Poland turkey romania in like the first 2 years of the game and just gank Germany?
Or well is it worth it
1937
Does that affect anything?
No it doesn’t
Ahh I always wondered
you just violated article 43 of the hearts of iron criminal law
It’s your game bro, if someone tells you not to do something but you want to do it dont listen to them
Waste of tech slots
can and bul can do it
In mp ig, not so in sp if you’re playing neither
How much speed?
10.4km
Weak
ik
licensed mech is quite powerful, your military factories are more efficient producing mech than infantry equipment (since that comes later)
what is the map mod 🙂
millennium dawn
cooked
TNO
yeah that's funny
counter offensive 🙂
worst part is the encirclements are marsh tiles so its hard
Definitely Zhukov as a field Marshall
gulp
historical asf
germany after winning the courland pocket
Wahahaha
Why I feel like the more deeper I getting into German territory the harder I can attack or capture
you're probably losing planning bonus, and yeah the terrain gets worse the further east you go
dark days for the allies
the one time the axis doesnt get curb stomped in 42
this is a 1/100 game
ehh id say that this is savable for them
they are slowly getting pushed out of italy 
ur luxembourg
you kind of cant do shit
maybe turn on the allies grab some land
then pray u get some of the benelux
im already at war with them
and formed the benelux, just got pushed out because the soviets fell and didnt get to hold on the industry enough to make sufficient equipment for divisions
but now im holding
ok then u can get an armor meme tank and push them out of benelux easilly
not how it works but okay
space marines work good for luxembourg up until like 42-43 where even though they cant pierce you cant replace them enough from losses
same for spgs
kind of hard to keep up with losses when you can only produce 1 tank every 3 days
my question is
how did you even get to this point
wdym
what year is it
well can you join the allies?
oh with both oops
hitler actually made guns this time so his troops dont starve at barb
hmm
maybe if you overran divs?
of allies
after they cap ger
not sure if u have the manpower for that
like with spgs
yes u wont be able to replace the spgs quickly
but you can get a lot of casualties in and maybe even some of ur cores
yes lemme switch my entire industry of 11 mils to that rq
and somehow magically outrun divisions so that i overrun them without getting pinned by 200k troops
my worst save i have gotten myself into was as spain vs the entire world being with allies
"Sir they are right outside Berlin"
"Who are"
"The Danes sir"
why is russia and poland in berlin
alone against the world
oh its allies
damn hows ur pc not cooked
9700X (cpu)
mine gets cooked at 1944 against bc china n jap have 4k total units
its 1948 😭
i get 1 frame per sometimes
ah
Isnt that just the autosave though
no
the game gets incredibly laggy lategame if ur pc aint god itself
I know but still, literal 1 FPS usually only happens during autosave
its a bit exagerated
My PC is pretty solid, 1 hour to 1948 if I don't pause or slow down
i keep getting reinforce memed out of every single tile
heuh
what.
uhm
how do you obtain such power
yeah thats the issue
maybe get some charismatic traits
on ur divs
not divs
gens
and my manpower is running so low
i did
yeah fall back
and signal company to everything
you cant push them
my navy is literally carrying
25% shore bombardment bonus
lowk good kdr 💀
i might honestly have to give myself cores on some german territories or my run is cooked
its not cooked
my manpower issue is solved by getting one core state
i dont see a single tank
should i replace the mech with more special forces or
pick your doctrines bro
you have 500 xp everywhere but doctrines to pick
its just special forces stuff
radio out there serving no purpose 😭
i need the reinforce rate my man
add medium flame tank instead
you mean the insane doctrine buffs ?
pick them
i alr maxed my marine ones?
max mountaneers aswell
it doesnt rlly help (according to my experience not the spreadsheets)
each doctrine gives 10% sf attack when you complete the last branch
or whatever else
should i replace the mech with rangers or keep it
its a lot of attack-
and special forces capability
definetly replace
mbe not rangers
tho
I'm sure you don't
AI doesn't have nearly enough stats to punch you out quick enough
your divs are also too bg, that's a 40width div I'm looking at, which is the reason you might have reinforcing issues
bring it down to 36width, do your radio techs (electronics) and watch your issue disapear
mech are useless in a div that has a unit that isnt faster than 4
that's simply not true
36
hm
mech has high HP, high defence and hardness
isnt that optimal
oh yeah, I can't count apparently
ok but it also brings some debuffs in terrain
its fine
doesn't matter much, the debuffs are like 5% more in forests than marines
and there's the elephant in the room in the form of heavy SPG
so i get rangers...?
get medium flame tank, replace the radio with it and it'll be better
can you rush supersonic jet as the us
if you have full ranger doctrine it's good
do i replace all mech with it or what idk
do you have mountaineers with doctrine as well ?
uhh
just yes or no
then do something like this with your SPGs that replace either some marines or rangers
if your sf cap allows it though
and don't forget AA because this is a green air template
this?
they are, but mountaineers paired with rangers is currently the best SF template you can get
il replace the radio when i finish researching
you might not need this many marines. Reduce their numbers (replace by rangers) until landing penality is down to +50%, if it's already lower then you can leave them
although I don't see why you need marines in a land warfare scenario
I'd replace everything but the SPG with rangers tbf, and then pioneers with engineers (as it only buffs landing and marines)
i used marines cause i needed to add more combat with with naval invasions cause pushing out of denmark into germany was impossible with only 2 tiles
i thought that would help
feels the aura
thy'"re preparing a naval invasion
you should encircle them
il try
like just naval invade the next two tiles, then pin that stack while you encircle it
what
idk why but the ai isnt putting ships out anymore
and its not like they dont have any left
Am i become better?
Are you french?
yes
hi is there any good Germany tutorials
bittersteel made one a month or 2 ago
uhm
so the pinning was a bit too strong
and they gave up
idk about you but i cant follow his
idk i might just be shit at the game but i cant understand anything from it
do you have any dlcs?
yes
bruh
i got all of them
well my bad :/
lol
I recommend Italy
Very easy and makes you learn all aspects of the game
I highly doubt the very easy part
Or Romania, you have a focus that can change sides if you lose
USA, sov, can, hungary and germany are the best new player picks
i got like 400 hours but i only played finland and just learned something idk
of course, always on historical
rip encirclement
😭
kingdom of denmark
are u from denmark by any chance
thats fine just battleplan
ok
denmark is in asia?
if you can somehow reinforce meme 80 divs i think you can just roll them over
yeah but my equipment...
denmark is in asia
🤡
river crossing btw
wtf
- fort
idk alot abt this game but is that 2.8k Soft attack
wdym
will this work tho
try it
wtf is going on
realistic game btw
alone against the world
i dont think i have enough divs to hold this position tho
yeah i do not have enough divisions
2 divs per tile ;-;
should i do this or fall back even more
????
million dollar game company btw
apparently convots can walk on land now
How many mods you have installed? Because I never seen this happen on my end
you can save up divs on your garrisons
garrison ports first, if you aren't filling the combat width on the port tile, there's absolutely no reason to hold the flanks
place 2 36w pure inf with support arty, aa, engi on each port and you'll be fine. Everything else can be ditched
i dont rlly wana go through the pain of cleaning up invasions every other day
il try
if they try to land, you just put those two divs in a new army and keep using last stand until you get reinforcements and kill the divs on the flank
free casuality farming
fps map, alone against the world, building slots expansion
and i think a few more misc mods
does the empty port trick still work
or did the ai get smarter
still works
kinda cheesey tho
but you have an active frontline so it won't work as well
and should i fall back from sweden
why
hold the supply hubs and you'll be fine
its eating up a ton of garrison manpwer and divisions
make the enemy attrition
aight
this looks like it's easy to hold
denmark OP
Is this guy playing ragnarok denmark
Give me a good country that has range focused mio
chile
im not touching chile
chile
you get one of those
One of those what
you get a navy yes
i mean naval mios
does chile get naval mios
Alright guys so uhh
the soviets have launched an offensive, I have killed over 1M men in encirclements
itably 🤡
"rookie numbers"
denmark 🤡
trust
nah
they did operation bagratian
benelux
feels the aura
yes
I had the stalin line secured
ok i might try chile
I got pushed, they did the courland pocket on me but I reclaimed it
Is chile a good country to play?
child
child is meta in america bro
AMARICA
i played america 10 times
"amarica"
ask me anythingrica
slovakia
play indipendent state of croatia by releasing as italy and retaining core states and form austria hungary
sheep?
oh hell no
feels the aura x2
wtf
mods this guys showing swastika
I remember it going up to 300+ millions as I pushed into china
indeed, forgor
i didnt even know japan had 18 million men
have to do operation save italy tho
c*mmunist fr*ance
they aint
there, better now
china major???
2018 hoi is so cursed
old UI hits hard too
im gonna deploy more dday wall troops
THEN WHY ARE THEY THE LEADERS OF THE ALLIES
is promoting to field marshall worth the stats
WHY DIDNT IT SURRENDER
????
idk vro
WHAT THE HELL IS HAPPENING INTHERE
wait what
MY EYES HURTS WHAT IS THIS MAP
well, yeah it 1950 in a game version where china annexed all warlords in early 1937 for free from the united front event
btw I got auturkey achieved 💀
before waking the tiger DLC
they aren't can u stop larping
how do you even kill that many men bro
260 million
and you havent even pushed that far into ussr
there was endless waves of enemies
I remember pocketting about 300-500 divs in norway
so generals what do I do about operation bagratian
BagratiOn 🙂
minsk pocket
noo they ran
successful
civs not building 💔
time to reclaim the stalin line
guys eastory got terminated?
i think it was in france
why hard attack
hi, i returned to this game after 5-6 years and i dont understand anything, help pls xd
i lost my 2 runs with sovielts and germany
sheeps
right
cmon stalin line
then you need to max out armor for breakthrough and use radio
d day wall looking fire
Nobody does
yeah radios i know but yeahh
its usually my MP build for france sorry
damn marsh
booom
This should be tito's portrait in hoi4
Assalamu alaykum
PLEASE research bro
afk for 2 weeks then check back
so moscow or stalingrad
moskow
both at the same time
what kind of question is that
I can only do one operation at a time
Why is he enjoying a succulent bar of chocolate
you aren't filling the combat width on ports, then why hold the empty coastline ?
bro doesnt have any heavy tanks
Why not he looks so serious in the hoi4 portrait
Because
they stopped the attack dw
my tanks were in paris
i swear i almost destroyed my computer whn trying to manage the navi, its terrible i dont understand shit
i had another 48 divs in training, they're deployed now anyway
also its winter in the east im kinda stuck
Let the man enjoy some chocolate😭
ffs italy
unemployment final boss flexing hoi4 naval battles
denmark on top
Navy is useless if youre a minor
i was germany xd
Its only useful for naval invasions
||me not playing denmark||
spam light attack cruisers
top row 2 light battery+2secondary battery
put lv2 armor
so ai small ships cant pierce you
Historically accurate
its so fun
idk depends
its easier if you play japan
idk ive seen people having to capture every single chinese vp to win but idk how that happened
never seen it
i just do 2 collabs then roll them over
doesnt even need to release reorganised china
technically you can just do 1 collab then use senbu/east asian prosperity garrison order
infantry only goes hard
took 20k more casualties for this
Special forces are basically tanks
vanilla navy is just spam one design and hope the rng doesnt fyou up
light cruiser carrier bb spam goes hard
yeah
ive just done three uk playthroughs
i didnt need to construct a single new ship
it was stupid
the british starting navy is enough for wc
well when your fighting the bs of a navy called "all country navy smashed into one deathstack" you do
more than enough
play vanilla navy rework bro
i looked away from my air stuff for a year or so
peak low cortisol gameplay
being reinforced
encircled one hunded and fifty soviet divisions in one encirclement
this is beautiful
yeah every icon in this game has a tooltip
they deathstacked all their inf divs in belarus and got smashed
do i stack breakthrough on flame tanks or what
my highest casualties in a single encirclement is 2.76m
yes
kk
this one got me like 1.5mil
pretty nice
theres literally nothing left on their frontline to encircle bruh this is the last one im doing
the state of the soviet frontline
is this ok (idk how to make flame tanks)
divs?? what are those
thats not even set to a flame tank and it doesnt have a flamethrower
push up armor ticks it gives free break
the soviets had 13 thousand planes at the start of the war
this is 2 months in
i LOVE special forces
you annihilated the soviet air force
and their army
should i add mech to my defensive inf (i have a shit ton of excess mech and tiny manpower) or make tanks for space marines
how bad
for armor meme
the kdr is a bit skewed
beautiful
when did you start the war?
no just make tank divs
2 months ago
actually 3 now
started marcfh its june
damnnn what year?
?
i actually like the UK tbh
its boring
you train up 3 armies of 18w divs
throw them into france
germany never makes it past belgium
win the war
done
exactly, i also think poland is fun
put your entire fleet in the pacfiic so japan cant invade a single island when they declare
so the pacific war for uk is also super boring
tbh i sometimes forget my navy
is logistic strike worth the ic
not against the ai
they cant handle their logistics anyway

they deathstack 30 divs on a tile and logistic strike themselves
Yugo was my puppet. They then, somehow, instantly became independent and joined a faction with Bulgaria after which they immediately were turned into a puppet by austria.
lol very awesome of yugo
Austrian POLAND??
yeah its cooked
bro what is Austria doing??
in my current game france turned communist and joined the allies
Do you realise how cooked I am now?
then democratic france started a civil war while we were fighting the soviets so democratic france is in comintern and communist france is in nato
99% of my playthroughs half the world goes communist
rip
on non historical yeah but im playing historical
I like non historical, brings more fun to the game
I guess my best choice is to retreat towards Genova and Bologna....
Set up a line there
i play it sometimes but i prefer historical
what the actual hell
playing as japan whats the right time to challenge the USA
how does this have 1k soft
welcome Ducko and Cynicalyz
thats some crazy stats for a 24w div with shit support companies for offense lol
theyr meant for defense
thanks
meta slaves 🗣️ 🚿
I dont even follow meta for divs, try not to at least lol
i honestly dont understand the dmg calculation for vanilla now
how does one get 1.1k soft...?
but.. my ten thousand soft attack spg divs..
what.
your WHAT
its not hard its just weird that those templates have it
yeah
how
spgs!!
HOW
yeah fair SPG moment
spgs
the most i got was 4k
spgs make the game boring anyway thats why i use inf only
they just roll through ai divs like they dont exist
I like to ignore air instead but follow template meta
tbh this div also works like a tank div except it can fight in jungles mountains across rivers and in areas with shit supply
very nice
under red air too
but i dont usually have red air unless if i just ignore the air force
Who needs fighters when you have CAS
They killed Vittorio Emanuele....

Starting king of-
Heresy, Italy is quite fun
if i wanted to play italy i would just play the uk
Very much untrue
its the same thing but you do more stuff
Not when my puppets are being stolen by Austria for no bloody reason
beautiful
I like rushing Rome
austria cant be that hard to kill
or making a mega faction in the Balkans
It is not just Austria though...
Italy can have like all the Balkans in a faction by 1938
i havent tried forming rome in a very long time
yeah
💀
less
Being overrun tends to do that
cooked
I lost several unites retreating to my current positions
Yugo was my puppet.
retrain
I have yet to process what happened
HOW
abandon zadar
How did they puppet Yugo
This is some bullshit...
"bro i dont even invest that much into navy"
yk how yugo is stacking a ton of divs at zadar
u have to abandon zadar for a bit
Its not looking too hot for the soviets
so they stop stacking
isnt commonwealth of nations just democratic imperial federation
This game is already messed up
Not worth continuing
play on the beta
is there a way to get more manpower from occupied territories
bro austria and the others cant be that hard to kill
just raise ur conscription
unless if you mean puppets
fuuuuuuuuuuu
"what if Hitler heeded Grand Admiral Thrawn's advice?"
where do i push now
Meh
I have been getting unlucky all day
and should i release germany as puppet
play denmark
some juicy encirclements
to save on manpower
First my luck ended here.
where
that was the game I had yesterday
abandon territory if u cant even hold it
keep north africa and the levant though
Just great
everywhere hey have like 300 divs in that screenshot
In truth. It is worthless advice
js release as puppet
i need defensible terrain
do i swing to rotterdam or
arent you on the offense?
No.
well yes but my manpower
fair
what is it and what conscription law
And you... are not making it any better
400k service by req
dude show me ur map then
ur current map
what country is this
denmark.
I deleted my units
400k is bad thats more than enough to go on the offense
if you have the right div templates
isnt
I am honestly a bit sick of this game now.
u did that deliberately
Yes
30 of these
(will switch radio out for flame tanks soon)
thats prolly good enough
just encircle
if you pull back to defend youll just lose the mp war
This... is not even worth trying anymore
bro its service by req alr ;-;
thats not bad
my industry
aas is not ideal but itll work in a pinch
abandon piedmont
since u cant even hold the alps
so i dont think youll be able to hold piedmont either
Yugo was my puppet. I was building factories in their territory to annex them. Suddenly they just become independent for no bloody reason and join a faction and a few days after that they became a puppet of Austria
With such RNG... how can this game be fun
still not bad just cap them you're italy
oh yeah they can do that
they didnt update yugo
That is bullshit
It is absolute trash
oh wait
what templates r u using
hes allied with the soviets
why did you ragequit this brother 😭
italy and the soviets against poland and the balkans
you roll them bruh
Ok. So. Austria declared the war against me. So I pushed into Tirol and took some territory there before they could put more units in. Then... they, without warning, ANNEX SWITZERLAND and outflank my lines
probably the most winnable disaster save ive seen yet 
its not even a disaster save
its just a regular game
A soviet union that is in a civil war and losing?
he ragequit bc he couldnt save it so technically it counts as
And does not even have a border with poland?
they are still a distraction
yes mate
youre italy bruh this should be a cakewalk even solo
I ragequit because the game has been throwing these kind of situations in my face all day. You get tired when RNG is constantly against you.
multiple spears is certainly a choice
invade frankfurt and the rhineland
but dude this is quite winnable
u r literally italy
i assume u have good templates
hopefully
soviets started with an estimated 450-650 divs ive destroyed like 300 soviet divs
its hilarious
I use relatively standard 7, 2s.
I would love to use tanks.... but nobody has good templates for me.
line artillery??
#ask-for-help-here literally has templates pinned
if you asked anyone in here theyd tell you that
🥀
use improved howitzer
as the turret
I am not talking about the tank design.
they have div templates too
mountaineers + tanks
12 mountaineer bats and 6 tank bats
btw go for the one mountaineer doctrine that lowers combat width
You wanted the 1944 italy game?
ur italian industry cant be that bad
u should have enough mils to efficiently mass produce tanks by 1940
theres no way u dont
What do you want to see.
u tried italy twice?
happiest italy player
3 times actually. 2nd time Ethiopia refused to surrender so I restarted the game.
your mp is gone
MP?
manpower
Ah
ur screwed on that one
in what mod is austria and switzerland a threat
increase conscription law for manpower
or is this multiplayer
im terrified of the crack eight austrian inf/militia divs
abandon anatolia
its vanilla mate
abandon iberia
what nation u playing
im joking
italy?
but keep gibraltar and the tiles around it
its not my game
I am not abandoning all of my recent gains
keep north africa
u cant hold it
u could keep iberia
but i dont think u can hold anatolia
They should not even have been able to push me out of Romania
what are these numbers
infantry only btw
With supplies
not a single tank in my battlelines
how'
u should have tanks by now def
also consolidate ur divisions
consolidate ur divisions
and delete some of ur divisions
abandon anatolia and iberia
u genuinely cannot hold those
These guys are tanks that can go on any terrain
I am not.
I had some light tank divisions that I parked on the frontline while trying to mop up an encirclement
More for decoration that fighting
Since all of my other divisions were understrength
then delete them they give you mp back
??
focus on north africa, italy, and greece
The manpower you would get from those 3 divisions is not worth deleting them
keep greece, it has some resources
theyre useless might as well delete it
they sit there soaking up supply and doing nothing
Supply means nothing anymore anyways.
???
Since even with supply my units were, somehow, unable to hold a river.
ur saying u would rather have decorative divisions that do nothing than give supplies and equipment to ur divs that are actually doing stuff

that means your units are understrength / not enough equipment or had a shit template
an 18w inf div will hold like a brick wall across a river
can i please have the save download
Where do I get that one from

search up how to access ur hoi4 saves
Why do you even want it
i wanna see what i can do with it
ill play it tmr
This is what I had before the war in spain
its in documents
the units on the borders were at full strength