#hoi4-general
1 messages · Page 189 of 1
Yeah but I hate playing the civil war. Also somehow I never won it. I know its a skill issue
way less civs than before
I only played Spain competitively so idk how hard vanilla civil war is
true
You need to add the AA armament first I think
Then switch
Put an AA gun on it
Add an anti air gun to it
You need an AA gun or autocannon i think as armament
Its interesting
anyone has singular SPAA divisions
Autocannon is an AA tech but cannot be used for SPAA
like i wanna go mass mob germany
Huge scam
but i dont wanna add spaa to my inf
I swore it used to be
Sounds useless
Besides it being yk the best cannon for lights
can i just make like 36 width spaa divs with motorized
You cant
You can try
idk i wanna see if it destroys the soviet air
i dont need them
knew it 💀
I usually have SPAA only in my tank divs
I believe AA only works while in combat btw
😭
No
uhhh
you have infinite manpower
It works in combat reserves too
so its fine
Well
maybe if i make normal infantry
Which is funny
like wait
Oh
Dang
What mod is that again
It adds silly
Theyre very cheap tanks
better division templates etc by idk who
but support aa alone doesnt have that much
Because theyre so cheap
like what if i make 20 of those
Well, you have a mod on
When do you get amphibious drive again
i know
Its like 2 ic ish right
5 ic
Loading into the game
Why would you use them for air attack?
You can use heavy SPAA for that
Gives you armor as well
what do u use spaa for then
Light SPAA uses 36 tanks per batallion instead of the usual 60 for lights
So they are actually the cheapest tank type you could make
I remember when TDs had half amount of tanks in them
Since they were designed to be small defensive battalions in nature or something like that
Ah Casey became a junior mod
Yeah
I havent been in here in like 4-5 months
who wants guns
:
Hmm, this doesn't seem fair
oh btw at this point i am producing destroyer 3s per production line every like 6 days
i am litterally shitting out destroyers at an extremly stupid rate-
imagine needing tanks

AH YES JUST WHAT I NEEDED, MORE F***ING BUFFS
I heave reached 1900 hours on hoi4
any tips on how to push trough?
If you want to see the worst HOI4ed Ive had... from a playthrough last year. Love the bugs in this game lol, may have been my biggest encirclement at that point ripped from me. Immediate rage quit
what map mods u using
alr ty
push through it works or build up supply
Pull tanks and troops out intil you dont have a supply issue. Make sure you have total air sup with a lot of cas. Bring tanks back in when u have air sup with cas
aight thanks
yessir, I hate the french death stack lol
gng i dont think 2.5m is enough for the stalin line i need more
imagine not having supply
rip
Take troops away
you have no supply
and get air superority if you don't already
how screwed is my map out of 10
triggered
2/10
This one destroyer wasnt messin around
THE GERMAN SCUM SHALL BE WIPED OFF EASTERN EUROPE
what mod
TNO requiem
ah
Gave me this offer sorta late
its so annoying when my troops get brain worms
communism does that? i didnt know
Looking for people to co op with against ai still learning the game
I think it may be time to play vanilla and get some achievements

Is this the highest KD ratio yall saw for Allies (the allies also done well) (this was a CAS fighters only build, with a mix of right opposition bloodless coup for a bit Of RP in there, I could have been stronger if I went Stalin, I had good 18th With, with support companies)
Mass mob right.
Wtf lol
British destoryers Just built different
hows this for a defensive line?
maginot no less lol
How does the navy work, im new to the game
you steal em from others
also nav bombers
Capitals (CAs, BBs, BCs) shoot big gun
Screens (CLs DDs) shield capitals, 4:1 minimum ratio for effective screening
Subs raid convoys
Carriers bring planes in to force multiply surface fleets
Most important ships are carriers for the planes, light cruisers (CLs) for the combat power/cost ratio and subs for torpedoes. Watch a couple of yt guides, Segl's is good
The speed of the fleet depends on the slowest ship
You don't want to have submarines and surface ships together
that too
3-4 screens per capital, 3-4 capital per carrier, 4-5 carriers per taskforce
and for submarines, usually in a wolfpack of 5-10 per task force or lower to maximize the amount of convoy interceptions
Gonna hold for sure!
how did u
germany exploited a gap in their line i think
it was them that broke the maginot somehow
i only encircled the rest
oh u arent the germans
what country u playin
rare german ai being successful
map mod?
TFR map
french france
and in a stroke of bitter satire
7.3
JOIN MP 2 FOR QUCIK VANILLA GAME
i think i figured out what i was doing wrong - i was using tank destroyers with motorised as an offensive unit 😭
90275755800135710
Build battleships
i have them
a lot
lets just say
i capitulated some countries
Well after 1941 subs become basically useless
too tired to
also
im going after britain
and then
i will be the owner of europe
and then i will go after the us and canada
i like my map cancerous
115 reserves
that's straight up false
subs are always useful and in SP they're so broken that cruiser or 1940 subs will sink AI surface fleets if not sent in shallow seas
don't go in shallow seas,
don't use 1936/early subs, they have too high visibility. Produce 1940/cruiser subs/1944 subs instead
don't go in areas where enemy has a lot of planes flying over you
what do i do with 723 divisions
use them
if they're not fully equipped, delete some if you don't need them
i just found out i got naval invaded
i can assure you thats the last thing to ever happen
using them as garrisons would be a good start then
i got a few guns
i think i have more victory points than all the countries in the world
combined
how does my bro have stalin as a field marshal
is that a path in the focus tree
i dont know either
I Hope darkest hour works now
bottom of the stalin focuses
he ain't good though
how dare you call the supreme leader of communism a bad field marshal
by the time you get him, he's washed
he also has -25% xp gain iirc
Is that the Swiss
i think that getting all their european territory and african colonies wasnt enough
alpine protectorate
So how do i make an revote in darkest hour?
Anyone down for mp?
why is the british east india company there??!?!
guys look its gandhi!!!!111!1!
bro germany is smoking me as im su
thought i could hold the frontline turns out i couldnt
stalin line is holding tho
just need time to get a functional air force and some good armour
how do u win the civil war as communist brazil?? i added all the civil war buffs and im still struggling
and also i have no mils so i run out of equipment quickly
cheese it
Why does my hoi4 launcher crash whenver I looka tmy mods
try asking in #tech-support . Maybe they know
how
get army experience, change all divisions to 1 infantry, then create template with 1 artillery, change everything to that after training a lot of small infantry, start civil war, change the shitty units you had to undersupplied normal infantry ones
or atleast thats how it works in every other civil war i played except spain
mkay
so like this
and when the civil war starts i change it back
yes
okay
back
Watch out for polish incompetence
Germany declares on them, and i think they instantly join your faction
And then die
great
it works for basicly every civil war btw, just not the spanish one
there were some real units but it was mostly the shitty artillery ones
and i just naval invaded vp's using shitty 1wt cavalry
yeah the AI creates them at the start
shockingly well
can anyone play a communist india for this game im playing
You're having issues with the civil war?
no im doing a nato vs warsaw alt history with some friends, and my india got grounded
Ah I see
What Trianon should have been🔥
are you able to help?
that's somehow worse than China annexing norway
This good?
You probably should have better guns
Also if this is multiplayer you should have 3 small cannon turrets + radio on the top row
also OKMO too
Problem... Running out of manpower, and Germany's too cowardly to start war with the Allies.
singleplayer
raise conscription
do the focus an entente of our own and invite more people
Done already
Hungary and Yugoslovakia refused.
did you start the war or did germany start it?
How would I have started it...?
easy maintenance?
and what should be the actual template
like 2 rows of heavys then 2 rows of motorized/mechanized?
Yeah 9 heavies 9 mechanized ideally
- assault engineers, flame tanks, field hospitals, ranger recon, and aa/logistics
alr and what about the flame tank design?
best flamethrower + radio + breakthrough modules (e.g. additional ammo, side skirts, autoloader, stabilizer)
okey thanks
Poland.
gosh damnit poland
@solemn onyx!
If I have higher attack than enemy has defense do i kill them?
Can’t wait to fight the allies as China :/
No you crit them
And that means?
I will first do an invasion of Philippines and Malaya. Followed by a push into India towards Iraq. Then I will just afk and port cheese them to death
4 * (attack - defense) + defense would be your damage
So every point of attack above defense counts 4 times
why does my game have this annoying black outline around text
when i enter the screenshot menu it dissapears
Thank you
but my game is stuck like that
windows shift s if you're on windows
Anyone here like eggs?
yes, that’s how i entered the screenshot menu 😭
how do i fix my game tho
Remembers me when one of my tanks got stuck in Krasnodar and I could not move it from there even tho it was my land and I was not even at war 🤣
I've gotten decent at saving Spain as a democratic minor
Diyarbakir also has the same issue if you enter with a tank you cant leave sometimes
It's a fun war though the Republicans make bad decisions
??
The republicans always have half their army go poof whenever I help them :/
Gets consumed by the cannibals ig
Lol?
I swear to God, the Allies will join in any war against me when I'm attacking some random minor nation, but won't join f***ing WW2 when this is occurring.
how do i turn austria into liechtenstein again
supply use....
org is a bit low and supply companies are off
I wonder how many times Hitler capped the allies in hoi that they won’t bother anymore with him
supply companies?
i just made this cuz i hotjoined an mp match as spain
Yeah assault engineers if possible
And flame tanks
and hospitals
And either light tank recon or ranger recon
and then logistics or aa
kill the germans 😡 😡 😡
I will!!!
MUEHEHEHE
i killed all British fleets around the UK. THe last of their navy is in the med
Nice
Maybe it's time for a sealion
But first take Malta
Yep. Troops are all ready to go
yeeaah I kinda left Africa
now do I join the Entente or the Reichspakt
Malta has 29 starving troops
It's free pickings
Alright sure.
i'll probably sealion 1st tho
Of course prepare your naval invasion of the UK first
Yep
Brazillians too in the med
I'll do a save right here and join the germans
maybe I'll come back and do Entente
but, givern that the entente is... 2 minor powers in europe
Hmm should I use regular hangar deck or PACKED hangar deck for my 1940 CV
what do you mean?
Design. I could have multiple "packed hangar decks" which have 30space for planes
It's probably the ice carrier
nah DLC
Can someone tell me if the Allies will eventually join somehow? Because Germany never invaded, and lost its wargoal on Poland... so...
Since they get 30-plane hangars that can support strategic bombers
Yeah it's better to stack as many planes as possible on your carriers tbh
more cost and operational flexibility
alright sure
Because you can only get so many air wings into battle
Btw its 1943 and I'm just now attempting a sealion(i started war in 1940 tbf)
FINALLY SOME ACTION
They... left
British bastards
You should really repair your battleships
and yet im capitulated l mfao as belgium
merry christmas
Yo does anyone wanna play HOI4 with me and two friends we lowk bored

good luck
Come on man hop on HOI4
What are you trying to do exactly?
Can't you just attack them directly from Albania?
avoid having to deal with the Greek troops bottling up in Thermopylae
Sometimes you do have to take Crete to capitulate Greece btw
Never happened to me
Did they fix the bug where you can make a collab government on a capitulated nation and release the controlled territory as a puppet?
why is this playing stfu I'm playing Germany lmao
Because you are about you get killed by giga chad Ike
More likely it is playing because of the in game date
That's how the speeches pack works
HUH
true, it is nice to hear them tbh
Expect 5 billion divisions to land in the Netherlands for you to encircle
It's like a more boring super event
I thought the trigger was like allied naval invasions
Idk what it is tbh
I know the chamberlain declaration of war is cause by Germany attacking Poland
The Stalin speech is caused whenever the Soviets are in a war with a major
The us war with Japan one happens whenever any country attacks the US
Doesn’t need to be the axis
With considerable delay usually
The one for the end of the war happens whenever the allies win a war
Ye
The speech irl happened around when Kiev was taken iirc
It gets annoying after the 5th mini war in 1947 when the speech starts again
where tf is their last fleet
Real
Hiding
Maybe it's losing a core state
If you open that tab it should highlight the sea zones their ships are in
If you have the intel
always hard to find em
wait which tab
i got 100% intel on their navy
Wait no it plays also in my soviet games and I never lose cores
Huh
Yep
didnt know u could see it
I bombed the allied fleet once with it
It’s hard to see
TURN OFF DAY AND NIGHT CYCLE YOU MONSTER
So darker color sea zones = more ships?
wait where is it
Idk. Just the highlighted areas have ships.
GUYS LOOK ITS GANDHI
Bottom right of screen
OMG OMG OMG OMG GANDHI
The sun and moon symbol
In the corner where all the other map settings are
OH
…
i never turned it off lmao
lol
LOOK ITS CHINESE GANDHFUERHITACOSPVNDGVRDKRNCT
ima assume the YELLOW piss zones = They have more task forces there?
This is ghandi
No that is yan xishan, learn to read
Do you have man the guns? Could be where you have the sea zone set to the cautious thing.
NO ITS GANDHI IM NOT BLIND
Yes
NUCLEAR GANDHI
No you're schizophrenic, it's different. It tends to develop after more than 900 hours in hoi4
Bro is schizomaxxing
max what?
oh i cans ee their exact missions
Fr
Do you have control of suez and Gibraltar?
found the Hood
bruh what am i doing
Not suez but gibraltar yes
Take suez
All divisions and ships will be stuck
Doomed
If you wanna pull a funny you can declare war on Turkey and steal all the chromium from the allies
yeah about that
south africa exists tbh
and cuba
Well most of it
Rip 🙏
Malta is looking very juicy
get balkanized nerd
YOINK
yeah ima sealion 1st probably
Shut
Nice
You are the person who helped me with making a motorized div last night. Ty
67 when?
stfu
Does the ai ever change what templates for divisions and ships it uses?
this dudes computer is full of videos
67676767
Or does it keep pumping out 1936 crap
Annoying is what
i havent clicked on anything youve sent
I can relate
PLEASE
It is moaning sfx
Naval bombers?
very little left
Make moar
k
MOAR
IM WORKING ON IT
oh wait
i got 8,4k fighters in storage
ill just switch that production
being a dumbass
alright ima invade malta
imagine a modern day hoi 4 mod whose premise is that yellowstone goes off and in the ensuing chaos the remaining existant U.S. states balkanizes and NATO is left without its superpower
what about a hoi4 mod where elon musk is therer
thats our timeline silly billy :3
jeez
project wingman be like
i remember yellowstone terrified me when i was young
but then again so did 2012
Offtopic but I’m taking a temporary break from hoi4
Playing some Rome II divide et impera mod
western roman empire or eastern roman empire guys
Eastern
But the mod doesn’t cover that era
It covers 278 bc - 30 ad I think
My special military operation in Chile isn't going so well. What do i do?
Escalate
yea
WHAT DO YOU MEAN
When the Rhine crossing of December 406 happened
the last time we tried to get united europe, it didnt go too well
I DON'T HAVE ANY GUNS TO ESCALATE.
Should i get a HOI4 cake for my birthday
It never really recovered from 406 and spiraled until it fell in 476
Lol their Manpower went up while the ships went down
Which nation are you
Does Infantry Expert affect Marshalls?
wb plunder of rome. what do you think of that
PERU BOLIVIA CONFEDERATION
Ah I see
Which one the 410 one or 455 one
You probably should build mountaineers
Vicking it rn
And if you're Peru generally attacking north is a better idea than attacking south
I NEED THIS
Since your navy is stronger than theirs and you can naval invade to victory
One by the Visigoths one by the vandals
usa PISS OFF
I AM AND MY NAVY GOT DESTORYED
Take some divs off
Hi chris
Against Colombia and Venezuela?
anyone know a good mod?
They alt tabbed and crashed
AGAINST CHILE
410
lol
I’m Rome 2ing it rn
Ah
also can THESE US SUBS STOP INTERCEPTING MY TROOPS
Yeah that's a problem
Not as bad as compared to 455
cross the rubocn
My special military operation in Kursk isn't going so well. What do i do?
🔥
I haven’t fought Carthage yet
Anyways then the only tip I can give is to get mountaineers and air
plz bro
aah goodluck
How much naval penalty do you have?
Its hard in the mod
idk
Like really hard
(a little is fine, it builds character commando)
Hover over the naval penalty symbol
You fight a 80 turn long death war over the western Mediterranean
wheres that
I love vic3 i love vic3 i love vic3 I LOVE VIC3 I LOVE VIC3
Btw can u check how much gdp the Russian ai has
Pls
I honestly prefer this over just steamrolling Carthage who is a pushover in vanilla
Your mairnes are performing a lot worse than they should
52.8
oh wait
Uk has 102
-18.10% naval penalty
Not even 52.8m 🥀
I have 2.7
Germany has 81.4
I never understood vic 3 tbh
and I lost
Italy has 64.2
Green number good
Strong
Like most paradox games
Oh yeah the germans have taken over my country
I’ve been trying to get into stellaris tbh
I’m replaying modded Rome 2 total war
Bro
18gb of mods to make it enjoyable and it crashes every two seconds
that's bad but not too bad, seems like your divisions are just not good
In a mod that makes Rome itself a decent challenge
why tf are my marines retreaeating into a surrounded tile
they should retreat to the nearest port
also how was sealion
Hows this for a marine template (i jjust made it 18w)
havent done it yet
OH SIHT
it auto triggeed
i aint ready
Really strange, that should not be having naval penalty
btw @sudden thistle
i have a lot of foreign money
i just made it 18w sadly. Before it was 16
65% bonus in naval invasions > 50% penalty, so there should be no naval penalty
Personally I'd add some support artillery and AA to that.
GO MY CHILDREN FLY LIKE THE WIND
3000 capacity air bases?
vanilla max is 2000 though
Patavium is mine
I wonder how much coverage the ones in the netherlands have
no idea
Definitely not enough
But the max is 2000?
Did you just land on Dover or did you land on the entirety of the southern coast
i tihnk i have a mod to increase building cap
okay cool then
You shouldn't just invade single tiles
yeah
Im gonna sink ENgland into the atlantic
Yay my last save was 5 months before this
I'm turning England into an underwater volcano
You could start building heavy cruisers for shore bombardment, super-heavy railway gun to neutralize the Dover fort, and other things
why can't i make any progress against france here? i have green airspace also
I think you can, you just need to reinforce meme them out of tiles
You clearly need to widen your frontline
Hopefully actually democratic
true
Oh yeah probably use those too
does anyone have the great war discord
idk
but i do have great war redux
FINALLY
how do i turn off autosave in ironman every 7 days??
@dusky burrow I did it :D
gonna blow up the Suez now
Nvm
british Scum have 18 divisions around it
GOTT IM HIMMEL
why the hell is it when i do my invasion that suddenly 12 enemies come outta nowhere
Is anyone in tno discord server
cuz sometimes enemies may be setting up their naval invasions from there
good for 38? ignore the supply use
yo what alternative history mod path should i play
lowk i wanna play with someone, im so bored and wanna do a game with someone
is there any mods like tno but are easier to run
Tno
6 7
uhh so is uk declaring war on Italy, germany, and soviets on historical normal
@gusty oracle can you help
sure
what are the best templates sir
can you send your current template
Im no expert but ill try to help
i uhm am not playing hoi4 but i played mp yesterday and made some trash divs
like 6 mehcanised and 1 artiller 2 anti tank and 1 anti air
I would do more mech and make the AA, artillery, and AT motorized versions
yeah i forgot to make trucks
btw im kinda stupid
you could say like
yeah always remember to make trucks
Alright whats in your opinion the best offensive infantry division design
i joined this server 2 years ago
and i didnt get an answear then
like 10 inf, 1 artillery, and good support companies
support artillery, support AA, recon, and flametanks if you can afford
heres the templates i use ik the mechanized one is bad also i couldnt get anti tank but i used it as a support company on the inf one and as both a support company and in the template
is that really the best
lets say im in 1944 what would be the best then
assuming i have all the equipment i need
ohhhh yeaaaah
yeah add more mech, motorize artillery and stuff, remove at least 1 artillery for the infantry
yeah pretty much
Anyone in Tno discord
If I go to war with the allies but call nobody in, will the allies still be able to trade with my faction members or not?
Yes
Fk
That is stupid
Do trade relations at least go down the drain to where they can only get some resources?
Anyone?
how do i fix my tank divisions losing alot of tanks on even good supply areas
I mean, if they arent at war, they can get as much as possible
reliability isnt even that bad
Im at war with Germany, they have Indonesia in their faction, but they didn't call them in
it shouldnt make me go on a 6K tank deficit
Im getting like 100 rubber from trade with Indonesia
That is actually annoying
Indonesia (axis member) is literally fuelling my airforce
Just cuz they didn't join the war
Especially since my first move will be to take Indonesia for the rubber. Hungary is also in Comintern with me so free aluminum
World map. I am China
Arrows are just my attak plans
they ban people from tfr server
Thats hella weird
why do i lose so much tanks in battle genuinely
Are you losing battles or getting encircled?
Bc that is the only thing I can think of.
winning battles LOL
Huh
they ban people from tfr cause they think the server has some weird idelogies ifykwim
yet im still losing a shit ton of tanks
I assume that the ai divisions are just good against tanks or smth
67777
Also your production is too low. Double it
how is it too low
i'm making 35 a day 😂
Try to get reliability at 80%
Also those tanks are slow af. Usually trying to get to 8-10km/ph is ideal.
Other than that idk
Average day of trashing the soviets
my path all the way from Nizhny Novgorod has come to this
Ok. Why in god’s name is being at war with a faction member not something that effects trade relations?
i will destroy the facists
Noice
The fascists cant even establish a frontline lmao
I port cheesed Japan into having 2 divisions left. They sent one of them to my port cheese. The ai is not smart lmao
Like ah yes send half to army to doom instead of keeping it on the home islands
Can somone

the Lair of evil is wide open, you can see victory ahead
Can u?
motorized artillery division
lmao
What about u?
No can do
Ok
The quirks of discord servers 
Im literally the USREA
The most wholesome path for russia
Dude Tno banned me from there discord because my tag was tfr
So Im pissed
And I need a unban appeal
FEllas
- Do I invade Egypt and blow up the Suez to trap the UK/American Fleets.
Or go for Sea LION
which do I do first
The situation in Africa atm
Your units are attritioning
I don't think you can sustain your presence on cyprus rn
Yeah its very ballsy. just a gamble
Capturing Cyprus itself wasn't a bad decision tbh
Yeah about that
trapping their fleets isn’t a horrible idea but they can repair it relatively quickly
what’s it look like in russia
idk i already killed everyone rn except soviets so idc
havent bothered with Russia yet.
Watching someone who knows nothing about history playing Hoi4 would be interesting.
again instantly dies
I think you should attack along more tiles
Orange France 🔥
Brits are always there and they isntantly die
me when 130 tanks a day
and dead agian
Yeah that will definitely hurt the enemy though
Ffs
You may be able to deny them supply
vic vic vic vic vic
time to load an older save once agian. This is so ass
There are some rumors that the folks in TNO don't like TFR
GDP GO UPUPUPUPUPUP
playing mobile warfare with speed buffs feels like playing on 4 speed when i play on
3
ig
This is what I'm trying. But then insatntly every single allied soldier with their fat mother teleports in to curbstomp me
you dont have supply
big red icon
I break through with the invaison but then it instantly dies
they are dying
Bro o need to know how to boost fps
You could probably go through their reddit page regarding that
already maxed motorized the naval base
do you like this map i made
Should I try blowing up the Suez 1st or just go ahead and sealion
its all ready to go
Italy you BASTARD of an ally
Caribbean really testing the power of friendship over here 🥀
Been messign aroudn with nukes for basically the first time, goodbye rhineland industry
ignore the date this has been an unserious secret project game
sea lion in 43,
Yes. I started the war in 1940, im doing a navy game
and it doesnt really matter what year unless its MP
Hehehehe
I've already killed many of their ships
British navy I've slaughtered it down to 59 ships. Last of it is in the med along with USA's navy.
If I blow up the suez i get em
if you play on 1 speed you can see the battle
Its satisfying when it hits
I CAPTURED PALESTINE
holy shit airfield with 1200storage for planes
and it fails agian...
every SINGLE TIME
navy is fun for the like 20 seconds that a battle goes on and you can see the enemy fleet die
or when you're killing a ton of convoys
that's about it
Why is this so impossible
Posted ts in off topic but had the show the peak here too 🥹
should i kill america before the soviets
plz
how did u lose africa
hiiii marcus hru
Idk
but im getting sick and tired of this anval invasion FAILING EVERY TIME
js sealion unless the americans are in
then shit out subs until their navies die
Ye, i just wnana kill the last of the navy first
also the muricans are already in
well better start shittin out sub 4s
prepare for d-day and make sure mussiolini doesnt do the italy thing
True i should do that
why dont the jews circumcise women
iwhat
because uh mods ban him
mods obliterate his ass
screm
So I was attacking the allies and all of my ~600 divisions decided to just vanish.
