#ask-for-help-here

1 messages · Page 217 of 1

gusty hinge
#

no need to build navy

#

or take the navys of people

neat widget
#

guys, this guy is serious. your naval dominance is determined in part by how much manpower are on your ships

#

this is why battleships get better dominance per ic than destroyers

olive sierra
#

i’d genuinley turn the game off than research naval bombers

#

ruins the fun in navy too 😞

neat widget
olive sierra
neat widget
#

ah i see

olive sierra
#

does bba add more navy stuff?

neat widget
#

good set of dlcs

#

no bba adds air stuff

olive sierra
#

ohhh

fathom thistle
gusty hinge
fathom thistle
#

they made it free

#

kind off

neat widget
#

it's really the last of the major game-changing dlcs after the ones you have

olive sierra
#

Best investment

neat widget
#

gotterdammerung and no compromise no surrender don't add as many game mechanics

vital plinth
#

Is Germany battleships old chassis is that why I can’t put better guns etc ?

#

And not the basic heavry ship or early heavry ship chassis

olive sierra
gusty hinge
#

sorry for earlier

errant chasm
errant chasm
#

The only dlcs we got for free were together for victory, death or dishonor, waking the tiger, and man the guns.

keen hemlock
#
  • the poland one too
obtuse anchor
#

SOME german götterdammerung focuses were added to vanila as to replace the old outdated tree

#

Ncns barely adds anything, just makes the navy a bit harder to understand

slate nimbus
#

as if it wasnt already a bit of a headache to make work

obtuse anchor
#

And graveyard of empires only adds focuses which nobody asked for

#

Before 2022, dlcs used to be made with actual good ideas, actual gameplay changes

#

Not whatever this filler shit is

slate nimbus
#

if they just adding focus trees atp just download em from the workshop

scenic nacelle
#

actually everything germany related except alt hist tree

vital plinth
#

Im fighting Italy as France don’t have much mountainairs yet but I can’t push them at the border of France Italy what should I do ?

obtuse anchor
neat widget
#

and perhaps more cas

glass panther
#

No through testing, no balancing, creating random minor metas

slate nimbus
#

i wonder how the QA testing for this games done

glass panther
#

IMHO, China, Finland, India are amongst the worst.

#

Communist China have way too much positive modifiers on militia. India have a huge amount of ahistorical cores, and Finland having wayyyy too muchhhh positive modifiers

opaque zealot
#

GOOD TANK DIVISIONS??

glass panther
opaque zealot
#

ALRIGHT SO TAKE 2 ARTILLERY OFF??

glass panther
opaque zealot
#

i cant gng

glass panther
#

And you don’t need that signal company, nor most of that support company

opaque zealot
#

i cant keep sacrificing artillery

glass panther
#

Keep it below 36 unless you intend to use it on certain terrain.

opaque zealot
#

can i keep it like this??

keen hemlock
#

get assualt engineers

glass panther
# opaque zealot

I’d say add one more mechanized infantry, replace signal company with engineer company and logistic company

#

You don’t need that helicopter stuff

keen hemlock
#

^

glass panther
#

Throw another support artillery in there and you should be fine

#

Also why full on self propelled artilleries

opaque zealot
#

like this??

opaque zealot
#

i think it wont be better

#

with something else

glass panther
# opaque zealot

Replace the helicopter companies on the bottom with support artillery and logistic company

glass panther
opaque zealot
#

the transport helicopter

#

is better than the

#

normal logistic company

fathom thistle
#

but keep org around 30

neat widget
opaque zealot
#

so good

glass panther
#

Take a screenshot then.

opaque zealot
glass panther
opaque zealot
#

nah no need

#

70% is good

glass panther
#

You don’t need that much speed, your regiment can’t go that fast

neat widget
opaque zealot
#

single player

#

but cc told me to get tank destroyers

#

idk why

#

do i get them or no??

neat widget
#

tank destroyers are a multiplayer thing typically

opaque zealot
#

alright

glass panther
#

Afaik AIs now puts a lot more mechanized and armored into their template

#

As part of the update I believe

opaque zealot
#

do i stay with this now??

glass panther
neat widget
#

missing assault engineers for one

loud matrix
#

based latvia player

eternal grove
#

Hello guys

neat widget
#

@thin girder what dlcs do you have btw

#

and why are you producing so much artillery

tight coral
#

does anyone know how to win against sheeps mod in the benelux

neat widget
tight coral
sand ember
#

Unless they changed it so all join the war at once

#

I haven’t played it in a while idk

thin girder
#

why?

neat widget
#

dlcs influence division design

#

in any case try to eventually get to like 21/0 for your infantry

tight coral
#

it was a mp campaign btw

neat widget
#

was your opponent france?

tight coral
neat widget
#

also divisional template?

tight coral
neat widget
#

what dlcs do you have btw

neat widget
tight coral
#

romania germany italy japan hungary

neat widget
# tight coral romania germany italy japan hungary

I think have Italy focus on air, you as Germany focus on tanks, and romania and hungary focus on infantry (probably 9 mech 10 tank with medium flame tank, assault engineers, logistics, light tank recon, and hospitals)

odd canopy
#

What is the PNM? I don't have it.

keen hemlock
#

non alligned party

thin girder
neat widget
#

mechs are in base game

#

but say, recon rangers aren't

#

and units like logistics companies and special forces get buffs in dlcs

autumn steppe
#

hey guys, Ive played many games and honestly think Im doing good with Germany, but everytime I get stuck at naval invading UK. does any of you have a tech ?

neat widget
#

what dlcs do you have

autumn steppe
#

um battle for the bosporus, la resistance death or dishonor together for victory and waking the tiger

fleet rivet
#

Literally the most important dlcs

#

By Blood Alone, Man the Guns, and No Step Back

red mesa
neat widget
#

yeah

keen hemlock
#

When should I use pioneers over base engineers

lunar notch
#

they already show their bonuses on specific terrain types

fleet rivet
keen hemlock
fleet rivet
#

That doesn't have naval designer in it

keen hemlock
#

yeah but mtg has been base game

#

since ncns released

#

iidc

slate nimbus
#

yeah MtG is now base game, i know cus i didnt buy any but it says i have it

gloomy vector
#

anyone know the kr meta?

neat widget
neat widget
glacial steeple
errant chasm
#

hello liv, hello casey

#

anyone know why a few states aren't getting 100 percent compliance i annexed the warlords first then China?

errant chasm
# glacial steeple skip turn

still ends up the same i did skip, annex warlords + mengkuko + communist china then skip then annex china. But the states i shown are still not 100 percent compliance. At this point I think i will just give it up and call it a bug.

glacial steeple
#

all states

#

in a turn

#

i forgot tho and am not playing hoi for a bit

#

cute vid up above tho

neat widget
#

were these the provinces you were occupying before hebei-chahar and shandong surrendered?

errant chasm
#

This was a previous practice game I had it was a southern state that didn't get compliance

#

strangely in this practice session Sinkiang never joined the Chinese United Front so I had to declare war on them manually before I capped china. Also Mengjiang delayed joining too until later so I just mircoed them to cap them so they didn't breach the Mengjiang-Manchurian border during my practice games.

fleet rivet
gusty loom
#

Can anyone help me out, I always feel like I'm out of materials or losing all of my battles.

gusty loom
lunar notch
#

for example, lets say you have 20 steel and produce 100 tanks in a month

#

if you have less than 20 steel, this will reduce how many tanks you produce in a month

#

for example, 18 steel means 90 tanks, 15 means 60 tanks etc.

#

these are not real numbers, i made them up

gusty loom
lunar notch
#

you can use trade tab to import resources from other nations

#

but be careful, you CANNOT trade with nations you are at war

#

nations might embargo you to prevent you from trading

#

nations might attack your trade convoys to prevent you from receiving traded resources

gusty loom
lunar notch
#

you take your factory back if you cancel the trade

#

basically you trade a factory for 8 resources

gusty loom
#

do I get the factory back or is it gone forever and I have to build another one to replace it

lunar notch
#

its only gone as long as you keep trading

#

its still there but not usable

gusty loom
#

so it will just keep auto trading as long as I dont cancel it?

lunar notch
#

if you see a resource in yellow numbers, this means you have enough of it and you can stop trading

#

if you see it in red numbers, this means you dont have enough and you must trade

#

if you see it in green, everything is fine

gusty loom
#

Okay I think I understand it now thank you for the help

blissful depot
#

is this a good unit for 1939?

sand ember
#

and you should really use all your support company slots

keen hemlock
#

more soft attack

crimson heron
#

I just had a couple questions. I’m new so please don’t get mad if my questions are stupid.

  1. How do I manage my resources? It says I have deficiencies but I have no idea how to fix them so I usually just leave them alone even though the big red button is on the top of my screen.
  2. How do I build the best template? Or what is the current meta that I should use?
  3. How in the hell does the navy work and how do I keep supply of oil and energy high?
  4. What are the best nations in the game to learn to play the game with, I have primarily played minors because I don’t want to get steamrolled by Poland as Germany.
sand ember
# crimson heron I just had a couple questions. I’m new so please don’t get mad if my questions a...
  1. You use the trade screen to buy more resources. One civilian factory for 8 of that resource is the usually rate. Check your production tab, missing resources gives you a debuff to whatever production uses those resources and doesn’t have them
  2. The pins in this channel have some general template advice
  3. Too complicated to answer in a single message but generally just keep all your ships in one big deathstack (no submarines cause they slow it down) and use it to beat the ai fleets since they divide theirs. You shouldn’t be patrolling with like 100 ships for a long period of time because it destroys your fuel.
  4. I’d recommend Germany and France until you get good at both
crimson heron
sand ember
crimson heron
unreal abyss
crimson heron
#

Yeah man this game is very confusing. Watching videos doesn’t even really help, I’ve just decided that making a ton of infantry and trying to gain air superiority is the best strat cause it helps frontline pushing.

unreal abyss
#

the only person ik thats good at the game everytime they try to coach me they yell at me cos i dont know how to do certain stuff and ask for help

crimson heron
#

That sucks. This game truly is one of those games where you are going to fail a ton before you succeed.

#

You have to accept getting stomped in a couple campaigns before you actually grasp the mechanics of the game.

unreal abyss
#

yeah

#

i just triad checoslovakia and got bodied by germany and italy

lunar notch
#

experience is the best teacher

unreal abyss
lunar notch
#

aight

unreal abyss
#

haoi4 has zero tutorials i have 130 hrs and i only learned u could but these in ur divs a few days ago because the game doesnt teach u anything and if i didnt have a freind to tell me this existed i prolly wouldnt have realised

lunar notch
#

well tutorial is indeed weak

#

but it would be practically impossible to teach everything in a tutorial

#

because they are endless

#

and thats why hoi4 tutorials on yt are over a hour

proud parcel
#

how do i make it so my army doesnt get mogged by france

lunar notch
#

area has a lot of mountains so panzers and irregular infantry will have a hard time

#

train some mountaineers and reinforce them with special forces doctrine

proud parcel
#

oh i see, i’ve never made anything other than normal troops. i’ll try that

#

how do i add more special forces cap, wont let me train them

vital geode
proud parcel
#

this is my troops rn

lunar notch
#

a little too large

vital geode
#

Should be good enough

#

I do suggest getting support AA

#

That will do wonders

proud parcel
#

i’ll try to get that asap, i’m out of military points

keen hemlock
#

Never heard military points

proud parcel
#

army experience

#

idk the correct terms

lunar notch
#

green stars

last arch
#

all of those tiny units that have like 4 battalions in them are worthless and should just be used to port garisson

#

a simple army of 24 18w's will hold against france, if you want to push you'll want mountaineers and/or air + better infantry

last arch
keen hemlock
proud parcel
#

alright this is the squad now

#

we are at war!

native gorge
proud parcel
#

i lost all 60 submarines in like 1 month of the war, but france surrender so

#

good job germany

sand ember
#

It’s a shallow sea

#

You shouldn’t put them there cause they get found really easily

#

Instead split them into smaller groups and send them into the deep ocean

proud parcel
#

i just put everything in the mediterranean

#

didn’t know the shallowness was a thing

sand ember
#

Oh are you Italy

proud parcel
#

yeah

sand ember
#

Yeah look at the bottom left

#

When you select an ocean tile

#

It tells you the depth

#

Try not to go into shallow areas with submarines cause they get a debuff

proud parcel
#

oh crazy

#

nah it’s all ocean around me tho luckily

wheat moss
#

Even tho i have 800 hours in HoI4, i suck ass at it. Is it just me, like am i just bad?

I know how to play, like i know the basics, but i suck at making divisions. Can anyone help me with divisions and shi?

proud parcel
#

yo holy dopamine rush

wheat moss
vital geode
devout quartz
#

I feel like this probably gets said here all the time but I wanna try playing multiplayer but I'm also like big noob, I understand basic mechanics and stuff but I can tell I'm not rlly good at prioritizing the right things, I just don't wanna be throwing ppls games

#

any knowers on how not be a generational thrower?

wicked oasis
#

Hey what's up. Guys what best ways for Poland with all dlc ?

austere roost
devout quartz
#

i had a friend tell me ussr was rlly hard in mp if you don't have co-op is that real?

#

i also don't know what spg is (I have like 200 hours)

austere roost
#

Self propelled guns

#

I mean ussr is just trying to hold the river line

#

And investing everything in your TDs

devout quartz
#

that makes sense, I also feel ike I'm gonna get overwhelmed if I can't pause frequently like I do when I play singleplayer

austere roost
#

Well that's just part of mp

devout quartz
#

true and real

#

will come with time methinks

austere roost
#

Also just practice your strat in sp

#

So you don't make mistakes

devout quartz
#

Like having a specific build before I go into the game that makes sense

austere roost
#

Like if you play ussr you need to know when you can declare war, when to research 1938 med + 1939 anti tank + 1939 maintenance and such

devout quartz
#

So you don't think starting on a minor so I have less game impact is better?

austere roost
#

There are newbie friendly MP rooms

#

But like you should at least be able to beat allies + ussr as Germany or take out Germany no sweat as USSR

magic finch
#

im saw this video
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R_dXGnCGHFs&t=255s
why ppl say this templates dont work?

⚔️ The 2026 META is officially here! This is the DEFINITIVE Guide to the Best Division Templates and Designs in Hearts of Iron 4 in 2026! OP Special Forces, Large Width Infantry, Unstoppable Tanks, and Space Marine builds that will dominate the game in any scenario! Whether you are a beginner or a pro, this is ALL you need to WIN every war!
...

▶ Play video
devout quartz
magic finch
#

idk why

devout quartz
#

ok uno mass question do i need all the dlcs?

ashen marten
#

Is the Race for Germany achievment bugged? i was able to conquer germany after france fell and i made sure the allies never took a core but the achievment didnt fire for some reason

wheat moss
devout quartz
#

no matter how much i play i am still ass

wheat moss
devout quartz
#

fr fr

red dragon
#

how do I get better at this game

#

i lost to the polish peasant union

cold garnet
#

Anything related to meta is controversial anyway

#

Theres like one trillion things that can work

dusty sandal
dusty sandal
devout quartz
#

question chat, does modifying planes with like different guns and stuff come with a dlc?

#

I just possess the base game

dusty sandal
#

It's by blood alone dlc feature

devout quartz
#

understoodable

dusty sandal
#

Without it you can just stay up to date on your models and you'll be fine

BBA makes the game much easier since AI doesn't know how to design planes

devout quartz
#

damn

#

i wanna get the dlcs but there is so many I don't even know what I should be buying and what I shouldn't

#

plus they are not the cheapest

dusty sandal
#

Arms against tyranny and No step back are best

Then it comes to personal preferences

devout quartz
#

yes sir 🫡

dusty sandal
#

I'd say la resistance, gottamerung and trial of allegiance are fine

By Blood alone and No compromise are very much underwhelming

Graveyard and Battle for bosphorus are mediocre at best

devout quartz
#

if i play mp is it expected I have em all or?

sick ginkgo
#

i tried submarines with naval bombers and still couldnt do sea lion

#

should i build destroyers instead?

echo void
#

I easily take over all the allies with germany but I fail everytime with the UK can someone help me ?

inner sparrow
devout quartz
#

oh does it apply to everyone in the game?

sick ginkgo
#

how a good battleship design looks like?

jagged cargo
#

or airdroping

#

literally, just attack and seize the ports then kill them

red mesa
sick ginkgo
#

oh

#

what about destroyers?

sick ginkgo
#

What’s a cost of the light cruiser?

#

Idk but they cost 5-6k for me

red mesa
#

I normally just add slight upgrades to the Leipzig class and spam that. You need the screening to allow your air and capitals to work, need the AA to counter the carriers, and light attack to chew through their screens so the torpedoes can hit the capitals

left mica
#

hoi4 navy is so washed

uncut narwhal
left mica
#

yeah that too

indigo sapphire
#

should i produce between 78 to 87 ships or more?

#

or just keep building em infinitetly?

uncut narwhal
indigo sapphire
#

alr

#

as germany i build ALL Ships

uncut narwhal
indigo sapphire
#

alr

#

i do like the panzer ship and pre dreadnought

uncut narwhal
indigo sapphire
#

IF im desperate

sick ginkgo
#

i should produce both?

#

what about capital ships?

uncut narwhal
#

rather steal them

sick ginkgo
#

germany doesnt have any wars with majors if you go historical before britain

#

so

uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
#

dont you?

uncut narwhal
#

spam

#

light cruisers and dds

#

with torpedos

sick ginkgo
#

do i need capital ships to invade uk?

uncut narwhal
#

germany has enough

#

get cas

sick ginkgo
uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
#

i have one for light cruisers

uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
#

wait what ship (hull yk) i need for torpedo dds?

uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
#

i play hoi4 on Russian so i dont know

sick ginkgo
#

well i had an issue

#

lemme send it rq

#

i cant put torpedo in that one slot

#

is it fine?

#

this is what i run as torpedo dds

uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
#

battery

#

anti air

uncut narwhal
#

or add a light battery

left mica
uncut narwhal
#

not sure whats best

left mica
#

why are you even leaving it empty

sick ginkgo
#

oh wait i can put anti submarine stuff

left mica
#

its only like

#

200ic

#

yeah that works too ig

sick ginkgo
#

the deep water bombs (iim trying my best to translate)

left mica
#

depth charges

sick ginkgo
#

should i use light batter or depth charges?

left mica
#

hum

#

depth charges

#

try to get better light hulls and weapons

sick ginkgo
#

okay, thanks

left mica
#

and fire control

sick ginkgo
#

also around what amount of dockyards i lowk need

left mica
#

50+

uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
left mica
#

and 1944

#

no need to rush ahead of time though

#

1940 is more than enough

uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
#

if i build 30 dockyards as germany, do i need naval bombers?

uncut narwhal
#

just use cas

#

on naval strike

#

like 2k

sick ginkgo
#

oh okay

uncut narwhal
#

more cas is always better

sick ginkgo
#

uhh i think i can get 2k cas only if i include the 1936 tech cas

uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
#

do i even build civs actually

uncut narwhal
#

not as germany

uncut narwhal
#

you can put more mils on it

#

like 30 at least

sick ginkgo
#

i have 25 usually

uncut narwhal
#

and start producing

#

in like late 38

#

your good with like 30

#

to get a good amount

sick ginkgo
#

bro playing as germany seems like ignoring the production researches ignoring civs and just focusing on army

uncut narwhal
#

wdym ignore???

left mica
#

who cares about production cap

#

its a trash tech

sly charm
#

hi guys do you know a mod or a setting for make my game run better for optimize pls

sick ginkgo
#

I think I can’t get all the navy air and tank techs alongside the production

sly charm
left mica
#

yeah just ignore production techs

left mica
#

im saying that for a reason

#

iykyk

uncut narwhal
sly charm
left mica
#

um

#

try BM optimisation

sly charm
sick ginkgo
left mica
#

better mechanics

uncut narwhal
left mica
#

and SOO optimisation

#

let me ask amine

uncut narwhal
sly charm
left mica
#

mod

sick ginkgo
#

sounds wild but im gonna try

uncut narwhal
sly charm
uncut narwhal
#

and your fine

sick ginkgo
sly charm
#

can i play online with it or i need to disable it

uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
#

and i always wondered

uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
#

i saw britain does kind of deathstacks in 1938 already

sick ginkgo
uncut narwhal
#

which you dont want

sick ginkgo
#

id rather get the 10% reliability thing than soft attack

uncut narwhal
#

to

#

with tanks

uncut narwhal
#

just dont attrition

#

and fight in bad supply in general

#

just bad

sly charm
sick ginkgo
sly charm
#

can someone give me their exemple of template im so bad making it

static turret
#

template of what tank?

left mica
sly charm
uncut narwhal
left mica
#

same speed and max armour tick

#

assuming you alr have basic hull available

sly charm
left mica
#

otherwise yeah just use iw

sly charm
#

and for kill tank

#

?

uncut narwhal
sly charm
#

tds ? im so bad english speaker bro sorry

uncut narwhal
sly charm
#

yes i want make a lot of damage for win please

sick ginkgo
dusty sandal
#

tank destroyers are a tank variant (designation in the tank designer)

left mica
#

tank destroyers destroy tanks

dusty sandal
#

this is a regular tank

sick ginkgo
#

we are talking about sp

dusty sandal
#

this is a Tank Destroyer (TD)

sly charm
#

je étudie le francais @dusty sandal

dusty sandal
left mica
#

french people as masters at gatekeeping their language, or so i was told

sly charm
dusty sandal
sick ginkgo
#

should i do focus on the prussian legacy or new tank doctrine for germany?

uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
#

русский тоже не прост

sick ginkgo
dusty sandal
sick ginkgo
#

mostly infranty

uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
#

tanks

left mica
#

which is kinda unfortunate

dusty sandal
uncut narwhal
#

get some nice buffs ig

sick ginkgo
#

uh 4 year plan or the other thing?

sly charm
sick ginkgo
sly charm
#

there is more bonus

dusty sandal
# left mica interesting

if you want a viable comparison, think of english in Ireland
go 50km west and you may not get the same way of talking than where you were
although in Ireland it is way more extreme, in france it's basically a North-South and East-West divide (with "normal" french in the middle along Paris, the Loire valley and the Seine)

sly charm
left mica
#

@uncut narwhal bm optimisation still works

dusty sandal
left mica
left mica
#

central vietnamese is unintelligible to the rest of the country

uncut narwhal
dusty sandal
left mica
#

hum try that again then

dusty sandal
#

(you will be weaker at the start and middle of the war but you'll pick up some real momentum by mid 1941)

sick ginkgo
#

oh okay

#

i dont like 4 year plan bc i always had no civs left at the end of the war

indigo sapphire
#

how many ships should i build as Germany

inner sparrow
#

if not and if done right peg is more ic output at barb

indigo sapphire
dusty sandal
#

you don't even need to kill the sov either if you invade romania

inner sparrow
#

yeah ofc but thats in theory ahist

dusty sandal
indigo sapphire
inner sparrow
#

4yp is just better in sp bc u can do what u want

dusty sandal
inner sparrow
#

truke

indigo sapphire
#

i do always produce Ships infinetly

light knoll
#

having allies is griefing in sp anyways tho

#

you get so much more value from invading hun rom and italy than them as allies

sick ginkgo
#

how do i assign naval missions?

inner sparrow
#

ofc

#

anything controlled by ai is useless

sick ginkgo
#

ive built a few light cruisers and torpedo dds

thin axle
#

has anyone got the Battle Royale achivement? I think its bugged or something ive done it like 3 times now and its still not popped

sick ginkgo
#

hey

#

my whole fleet is usually on repair

#

but i dont want my ships drowned

#

what can i do? (i have them all in 1 task force, 65 ships, some are light cruisers and some are torpedo dds

sick ginkgo
#

yay

#

i did sealion

#

ehm

echo void
#

can anyone send me a strong air force build to destroy the uk ?

sick ginkgo
#

why oman became a major

echo night
#

I know this isnt meta or practical at all but if I made a plane that has both fighter and naval bomber capabilities for fun, how would it behave in a naval battle? Would it only do fighter stuff or use the torps it has

echo night
#

If you turn on minors again and its still there good luck mate

sick ginkgo
#

ggs

#

war screen doesnt open

echo void
#

can anyone send me a strong air force build to destroy the uk ?

sick ginkgo
#

i have one more question

#

if there are no majors and yet allience does not capitulate

#

what am i doing wrong

spring shore
#

is it even possible to build a navy to rival the UK as germany?

echo night
sick ginkgo
#

uhh

spring shore
echo night
#

Just try saving close game

#

Reopen and then see if it works

sick ginkgo
#

i tried it alr

echo night
#

Wait send your war screen

sick ginkgo
#

some nations randomly capitulate

#

thats all from allies who are left

echo night
#

Toggle minors

sick ginkgo
#

if i capture them they capitulate one by one

echo night
#

What in the world

sick ginkgo
#

i dont want to go into india man

echo night
#

I have no clue man

#

Im sorry

sick ginkgo
#

no problem

#

its just a game glitch

#

wait

#

i wanna try 1 thing

#

if a major joins the faction and capitulates

#

would the other stuff capitulate or will it stay bugged

echo night
#

One you could TRY is to go to france open click any southern province, open octtania and then it takes you to diplo screen. From there you can click the majors button to see if someone in the faction is actually a major

subtle socket
#

it happens bc of 2 bugs actually

#

sometimes when u declare on a major the button to auto call everyone in or vice versa doesnt happen so only certain countries join that war and thw capping that major caps only the countries that joined the 2 war

sick ginkgo
#

none are

#

gonna get sweden who is a major into war

#

uh

#

australia became a major

#

wait what

#

in war screen australia is a major

#

in diplomacy it isnt

#

it stopped being a major

#

when i reopened

#

seems cursed

hollow jewel
#

yo

#

whats the current navy meta rn for MP

frank grotto
#

Hi is there a mod to prevent 80% of the countries from joining into 1 faction
All of them join the allies in late game

frank grotto
hollow jewel
#

disable factions

#

or play as one of the allies instead

frank grotto
hollow jewel
#

be one of them

#

be usa

frank grotto
hollow jewel
frank grotto
sick ginkgo
#

So

frank grotto
sick ginkgo
#

as i understand

sick ginkgo
#

combination of torpedo dds with cls is the best, right?

hollow jewel
#

whats the current navy meta rn for MP

frank grotto
#

I still need to search for a solution

scenic nacelle
hollow jewel
scenic nacelle
#

Make sure to do the torpedo primacy doctrine for screens

hollow jewel
scenic nacelle
#

That could work too

#

Not many people talk about navy so who knows

hollow jewel
#

or smaller task forces

scenic nacelle
#

But torpedo destroyers do work quite well in sp

scenic nacelle
#

It wouldn’t hurt

#

But getting stuck in the med or smth would suck

hollow jewel
#

i will figure it out

frank grotto
#

I think i found it called factions distance limiter

inner sparrow
inner sparrow
#

it also depends on what country u play

hollow jewel
#

will that work for byzantium?

inner sparrow
#

not really unless youre gonna focus heavily in building docs

#

only real countries that can make navy in mp are the ones that start with high doc count or a big one

#

or have focuses that give u a lot for navy ic

sick ginkgo
fathom thistle
twin kayak
#

how does this work as norway :

#

how do I get that support

fathom thistle
twin kayak
#

nothing for now

#

nvm

#

it just needed a day to update

#

my bad

fathom thistle
#

alg

sick ginkgo
fathom thistle
#

dd's and cl's are both schreening ships

sick ginkgo
#

you can deathstack them

fathom thistle
#

making both of them is not efficient

sick ginkgo
#

i tested 1 of my runs

#

i had 50 dds and 10 cls

#

when combined, they won the sealion

#

when only 50 dds, they lost

fathom thistle
#

more efficiently you could use those cl dockyards to build capital ships

sick ginkgo
#

3 battleships aint doing anything

#

also starter capital ships are enough

fathom thistle
#

not battleships

sick ginkgo
#

i can try build dds with capital ships

sick ginkgo
#

can you send a design?

#

ill try it out to see myself

fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

all dlcs without chezchoslovakia one

#

peace for our time i think

#

im gonna play as soviet union if it doesnt affect much

fathom thistle
# sick ginkgo then

refit the old capital ships with better design, then either you can just stick to buidling dd's or build carriers + heavy cruisers to schreen it. But dd's are sufficient enough

#

why heavy cruisers? cheaper than battleships to schreen carriers

sick ginkgo
#

i dont have any carriers

fathom thistle
#

like I said you can just refit old capitals and spam torpedo dd's

sick ginkgo
#

is this a fine torpedo dd

fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

i couldnt put it into the top left slot

#

it just doesnt let me

fathom thistle
#

idk if you need engine 3 really

indigo sapphire
#

what types of ships should i build/produce?

fathom thistle
#

try bottom one at least

fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

top left choices

indigo sapphire
sick ginkgo
fathom thistle
fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

50 torpedo dds no capital ships nothing else lost the same battle that 10 cls without anything else won

fathom thistle
indigo sapphire
#

how many Torpedo dds should build produce

fathom thistle
#

not soft I mean light

#

xD

sick ginkgo
#

in both cases all ships were 1 task force

fathom thistle
# sick ginkgo

it works yeah, with dd's you want to have some kind of capital ship for sure, cl's have armor so their survibality is better

sick ginkgo
#

in my run i combined dds with cls

#

bc i have no capital ship design nor understanding

#

i have understanding of screening ships and submarines

fathom thistle
#

later on getting dual purpose batteries which can do both

indigo sapphire
fathom thistle
indigo sapphire
#

alr

sick ginkgo
#

which ones i need for capital ships

fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

ehh that makes me like capital ships even less

#

like i wanna build them as soon as possible

#

and yet their tech is gone through cls

#

and if i wanna refit ones built with heavy batteries its gonna be the cost of 1 cl

#

just refitting

fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

do i get battleship or battle cruiser armor

indigo sapphire
#

how good are panzer ships and Pre dreadnoughts?

sick ginkgo
#

uhhh i dont like 11k ic

#

2 cls

#

10 torpedo dds

indigo sapphire
sick ginkgo
iron shale
#

why am I not getting any naval dominance when my ship are on strike force

sick ginkgo
#

wait

#

do i need heavy ships to build capital ships?

fathom thistle
indigo sapphire
#

alr

sick ginkgo
#

as i said i have 0 understanding of capital ships

fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

are capital ships built on heavy ship hull?

fathom thistle
#

Cl's and dd's are scrheening

uncut narwhal
sick ginkgo
iron shale
#

ty

fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

im trying to first make a design

fathom thistle
#

For what now?

sick ginkgo
#

to try to play with capital ships with dds

sick ginkgo
fathom thistle
#

Again like I said top row 50/50 on batteries and AA. Bottom row just the standard thing you use

sick ginkgo
#

like total noob

fathom thistle
#

Putting heavy batteries on cruiser hull will make it heavy cruiser

sick ginkgo
#

and what armor? battleship or battle cruiser

#

ohh heavy cruisers

#

mb misunderstood

fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

this should be it right?

#

replaced all light batteries with heavy batteries

fathom thistle
#

Looks good

#

Don't forget mio

thin axle
#

light attack is better than heavy

sick ginkgo
#

mio?

fathom thistle
#

Not schreening

thin axle
#

you dont need capitals

fathom thistle
thin axle
#

just go 100% LC Ha isnt needed

sick ginkgo
fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
thin axle
#

capitals are fine if you wanna larp but they are mostly a waste of ic

fathom thistle
#

Maxing out production output on mio is great

fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

i just cant use 10 dockyards but i think its fine

fathom thistle
#

That thing is mio

sick ginkgo
#

oh that thing

thin axle
#

slower to make and slower in combat, CL is meta

sick ginkgo
#

i just couldnt translate it bc ik it on my native language but not english

stone summit
sick ginkgo
fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

i spammed cls with dds

fathom thistle
#

Ic cost wise

twin kayak
#

should I give up ? germany will probably take out the soviets, the allies are stupid and I'm in a "weak" nation

thin axle
#

i love navy i even make SHB's capitals are for larping i love it

gloomy vector
sick ginkgo
#

uh im gonna try as soviet union as someone whos day 1 into good navy

gloomy vector
sick ginkgo
#

in past i spammed submarines and they failed

sick ginkgo
fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

the top one right

stone summit
fathom thistle
gloomy vector
#

What about torp techs

#

And doctrine

sick ginkgo
sick ginkgo
fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

about air

#

i just use cas

fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

someone here told me to use just cas

gloomy vector
fathom thistle
#

CAS is great but for naval bombing it's not the best

gloomy vector
#

Or just first tech

sick ginkgo
#

naval bombers better but i dont think i can produce fighters cas spgs and naval bombers at the same time

#

so i gave up on naval bombers

uncut narwhal
#

but navs arent needed

#

cas is enough

fathom thistle
#

They are pretty cheap too

sick ginkgo
#

how much naval bombers i usually need against allies?

fathom thistle
#

I don't have the exact number. They are not a necessity but having like 2-3 mils on them wouldn't hurt either

sick ginkgo
#

oh

#

just 2-3?

#

i thought 15 at least

fathom thistle
sick ginkgo
#

oh okay

#

gonna try as soviet union

indigo sapphire
#

how many capital and screen ships should i build produce

sick ginkgo
#

do i need the survivability techs?

indigo sapphire
vital geode
#

Carriers also need another capital to protect them along with the 3 screens

indigo sapphire
#

alr

lyric agate
#

can someone help me become confederate US

fathom thistle
indigo sapphire
#

alr

jade tulip
#

so Im currently stuck on this position, I cannot attack hungary in any way, do I just wait for their supply to run out or something?

left mica
#

how do you fail to push them

#

just battle plan a bit more since they have no gun stockpiles

#

they'll eventually break

#

put up some cas as well

uncut narwhal
#

you can prolly get budapest

#

then you win

sick ginkgo
#

but why universal battery feels worse than heavy battery

fathom thistle
#

It is but it also acts as AA so that's why you would use it

sick ginkgo
#

they are light weapons

#

would researching better heavy batteries make it much worse ?

subtle thorn
#

what div template should i be focusing on as ethiopa anarchist african union

drowsy holly
#

<@&916727971820240976> hello, im new to hoi4

how do i know how many boats and airplanes to make, and which ones?

#

also like how much infantry vs tank i should make and whate template

stone summit
#

Boats for the most part are a very optional aspect of the game

tired moon
#

what should I do with the navy right now?

#

like group them all in one port or smth ?

stone summit
#

I personally do a surface fleet and a submarine fleet

#

As my default at least

#

Just merge them all together and give them an exercise order go now since you’re not at war

tired moon
#

it says i have fuel

#

and also out of fuel?

#

can someone explain

stone summit
#

It’s just a warning that you’re effectively out

#

If you were to start using a lot like at war

#

You only have like a month’s worth just based on your max daily consumption

uncut narwhal
stone summit
#

Like on your units? Maybe?

uncut narwhal
drowsy holly
stone summit
#

“Need” is a strong word

#

As the UK in particular you have the most powerful navy, and you don’t need to build much of anything else. What you start with is plenty

drowsy holly
drowsy holly
stone summit
drowsy holly
drowsy holly
stone summit
#

Good luck building a navy that can compete with the UK as Sweden, especially as a beginner

#

But then again the naval ai is just trash half the time

drowsy holly
#

so like i need to solve that

dusty sandal
tired moon
#

i know it is

dusty sandal
#

it's absed on your reserves if you were to use everything at once, it's basically useless

fathom thistle
stone summit
#

Naval invasions are a little different, if you build submarines you can counter them pretty easily

#

Just by sending their armies to the bottom of the ocean before they reach shore

tired moon
#

I cant wait to inevitable be forced to fight the allies and then try invading britain for 5 years straight and then give up

unique tundra
#

Hey, I cannot make custom plane designs in tfr pls help

obsidian sundial
#

is nazi germany new player friendly?

spring shore
obsidian sundial
#

anchluss?

spring shore
#

mostly army templates

obsidian sundial
drowsy holly
#

can anyone give me some good inf & tank division templates for the different eras

bronze flume
#

If i do offer vassalization as qing china do I have to annex the puppets I get via autonomy or are there decisions

keen hemlock
#

if you are able to take all the other nordic navies that would be a good starting point

keen hemlock
#

because the nordics dont have alot

drowsy holly
keen hemlock
# drowsy holly how do u do that

copy the biggest non special forces/ armor template they have, spam recruit it untill italy runs out of manpower, then annex them and delete all the divs

keen hemlock
#

as for offensive, you want to aim for 36 width

#

prolly use rangers/mountianeers as sweeden

#

and for armoured divs use 10 spgs/ 8 mech

keen hemlock
#

although it really depends on the play thru and what your goal is

tired moon
#

why am i not getting fuel :((

#

i have many synthetic refineriex

keen hemlock
#

you are gaining like 1.9k while you are using 3.2k

tired moon
#

i have no time

keen hemlock
#

And pray

proud parcel
#

so do oceans not pop up as green/red depending on control you have anymore? planes still do it, even tho it looks like that changed a bit too

drowsy holly
#

why is naval invasion greyed out

uncut narwhal
proud parcel
iron shale
#

why cant I put my ships in these regions even tho I am in a faction with germany

uncut narwhal
gusty hinge
#

with gibraltar

iron shale
gusty hinge
#

you should also naval invade them

lofty tusk
#

How many divisions is enough to naval invade UK?

gusty hinge
olive tapir
#

I’m playing as the Soviets just capitulated France how do I get uk I can’t naval invade they’re navy will destroy mine and don’t have that big of an airforce because no rubber do I use pataratroopers in this situation?

spring shore
#

how many mils should i put on fighters to win the battle of britain (germany btw, if it wasnt obvious lol)

sage orchid
#

i still dont know how to naval invade can somebody help

austere roost
austere roost
#

Idk

#

That depends on your industry

uncut narwhal
austere roost
#

Are you trading well? Only you can tell

spring shore
uncut narwhal
#

air designer

austere roost
#

Plane designer dlc

uncut narwhal
#

dlc

spring shore
#

im justt stacking light mgs, best engine and fuel tanks

austere roost
#

Are you following the pin design?

uncut narwhal
#

important to have focke wulf upgraded

#

to get the range from it

spring shore
uncut narwhal
spring shore
sacred patrol
#

anyone can give me a cheap good cruises model?

obsidian badger
errant chasm
sacred patrol
obsidian badger
#

Good cruisers are like dual purpose guns + deprh charges

errant chasm
sacred patrol
obsidian badger
#

meh

#

i would use armor 1 and slap more guns

#

or an aa

agile rivet
#

how did they get sudetland