#ask-for-help-here

1 messages · Page 190 of 1

vital plinth
#

It’s January 1941

hexed verge
#

i can

#

i should win this battle, why do i keep deorging and losing?

vital plinth
#

Also for port defense and border defense is this template fine ? I can’t afford support equipment to my main attack divisions

hexed verge
#

if u can afford it keep the engineers but you dont need them either

austere roost
hexed verge
#

.

vital plinth
austere roost
#

It isn't

hexed verge
austere roost
#

They should be spgs and 36 width

hexed verge
#

i dont wanna make spg's tho

austere roost
#

And replace motor recon with light tank recon

#

Why don't you

#

For rp reasons?

hexed verge
#

the machine building plant gives really good production stuff for medium tanks

austere roost
#

Also 1940 chassis sucks

#

Mystichy?

hexed verge
#

yeah

#

the mio

austere roost
#

The buffs apply to spgs too

vital plinth
# hexed verge makes it more expensive

I have no problem with arty production just support equipment or am I putting too few on it ? Should I put a lot of mills normlay on Support equipment so my attack divisions can afford it ?

hexed verge
hexed verge
austere roost
#

Like you're on the right track but SPGs are better and you should ignore 1940 chassis and use 1938 chassis

#

Also what are your doctrines?

lusty basin
#

question..?

austere roost
#

Like you have gbp but I can't see the others

#

You get air and land xp, you help them by sending volunteers

humble flare
#

guys i restarted on a new run and finally capped it

austere roost
#

Also there's general grinding to get op generals

humble flare
hexed verge
#

and ill get streamlined deployement

austere roost
#

Yeah those subdoctrines kind of suck

hexed verge
#

i can get a total of 60% planning bonus with my tank general

austere roost
#

Do you have railway guns then?

hexed verge
hexed verge
#

grand battleplan is the best doctrine for tanks

#

bcs of the planning bonus

austere roost
#

The best ones are individual excellence/self propelled support/streamline/grand assault if you're doing spgs

vestal adder
#

im so sorry to bother but in the tech support page i have a mjor issue that i have been trying to solve for like a few years now and i just have no clue man

austere roost
#

Ofc with tank divs you can ignore self propelled support

hexed verge
#

idk i have alot of infantry too so the more entrenchement and less supply use just seemed pretty good

austere roost
#

They're not needed

#

And individual excellence is an infantry tree

#

It gives you infantry buffs

#

You might want to just wait a while and let Germans attack you

#

So they lose equipment and you gain XP and mastery

#

One way to get a lot of early mastery is to get a lot of one inf divs with light tank recon and support art and then train them

hexed verge
#

just chill behind the river?

vital plinth
#

Is this way too few on support equipment should I have a lot more ?

austere roost
austere roost
sacred patrol
#

how do i make the navy reach here

twin kayak
vital plinth
twin kayak
#

or lobger range ships

#

control right click the port

sacred patrol
twin kayak
#

iirc

twin kayak
#

easy

sacred patrol
#

issue is

#

how the hell do i end the war

glacial steeple
#

he just has to set it to vladivostok port

#

control right click

sacred patrol
#

nvm thanks

vital plinth
#

But I don’t know if I’m supposed to this or if it’s ineffective

sacred patrol
#

@glacial steeple youre a saviour thanks

glacial steeple
sacred patrol
austere roost
buoyant cargo
#

Guys, what tanks are the best against online players? medium or heavy?

#

I am so good at it but I need some notes and tips how to make good divs and how to build them faster

errant chasm
#

heavy tank destroyers

buoyant cargo
# errant chasm heavy tank destroyers

The guys I play with use a lot of artillery and artillery doctrines. What should I do for this in attack? I use companies that gives me attack bonus on forts and rivers also flame tanks for higher soft attack

errant chasm
buoyant cargo
#

ok brother ty

#

I will try the tank destroyers and spgs for first time

#

I hope the spgs are better than tanks in attack

errant chasm
#

spgs are good against infantry but not tanks

winter vapor
#

Does anyone know of any videos that can help me learn how to play?

buoyant cargo
tall zodiac
#

How long does a puppet need to sit at max autonomy to get free? Its at least 1 year at max. still nothing... someone know whats going on ?

vital plinth
buoyant cargo
#

start with Germany

tall zodiac
vital plinth
#

Also a different question when I’m about to caputale a country if I encircle a big group of the country divisions do I get their equipment once they caputale and man power or not ?

buoyant cargo
# tall zodiac on what?

If you import from your puppet, this will give it points to free itself from you. Also, when you build inside his country this will make you get more and much points to annex them.

#

You can import from your puppet 80 steel with 1 civil factory but you will lose points to annex

primal silo
buoyant cargo
charred fable
#

Fastest way to expand with Italy prior to WW2 kicking off?

buoyant cargo
#

You're importing from your puppet and importing from puppet is more like them helping you because you take so much resources with 1 factory. Also, you lead them into a war and they fight.

vital plinth
buoyant cargo
tall zodiac
vital plinth
#

Also i don’t understand fully how i get the engiener trait on my generals should i just stand on river or how it works fully ?

buoyant cargo
tall zodiac
#

well annex him would be the opposite ha.

buoyant cargo
tall zodiac
#

free him

primal silo
buoyant cargo
#

pretty sure there was an option to free him, let me remember

buoyant cargo
#

I will check now for you

tall zodiac
#

I had a puppet that freed him self so its possible.

#

puppets are not under the occupation option

#

I would annex him If I could but if I want that I need to stop importing materials from him and I need that stuff

buoyant cargo
#

There is no easy way to free puppets

#

at least don't build in his land

#

building in his land make it much harder for your puppet to free himself

tall zodiac
#

I only build the infrastructure up because I wanted more resources 😛

brazen panther
#

is it normal for the italian AI to take THIS long to take ethiopia 😭

tired moon
#

so i have never gone this far in a game, and I cant defeat the other countries armies easily. they always can resist and walking into a tile takes long too. what should I do?

buoyant cargo
tired moon
#

also my divisions are so slow

#

what could I do to speed them up

buoyant cargo
#

click on this horse twice if you have enough cars to supply your divisions

buoyant cargo
buoyant cargo
vital plinth
#

Do I get more equipment if I leave enemy divisions alive on field ?

buoyant cargo
#

@tired moon

tired moon
#

man I wish you could like white peace with others

#

my allies went and declared war on britain

#

while fighting the whole china and japan

buoyant cargo
tired moon
# buoyant cargo

should I try to go around the mountains or get mountaneers then?

#

im kinda new to the game

#

like 80 hours in

buoyant cargo
buoyant cargo
tired moon
#

so get mountaineers

#

also what exactly is "infantry equipment"

buoyant cargo
tired moon
buoyant cargo
tired moon
#

im not at war with the british (my allies keep telling me JOIN THE WAR)

buoyant cargo
#

ah what is this

buoyant cargo
glacial steeple
buoyant cargo
#

Fighting in Asia is hell

brazen panther
glacial steeple
errant chasm
#

hi casey

glacial steeple
#

it depends on if you have an inf/mountaineer/air build in the first place

#

you should specialize and focus on something specific or you will have many things that are all bad

glacial steeple
#

the vanilla ai never does this so

#

and you usually shouldnt either tbf

tall zodiac
glacial steeple
#

autonomy system goes 2 ways

tall zodiac
#

Well I saw Denmark do it. 2 years ago he did free him self

glacial steeple
#

you can annex a puppet

#

denmark does it through focus tree, its different

vital plinth
#

Hey do I get more of country equipment if I leave the divisions alive on the battlefield ?

glacial steeple
#

yes iirc

vital plinth
#

My equipment ratio is 0 so how can I capture more is there other mechanics?

vital plinth
tall zodiac
#

well If I import resources my puppet get more autonomy or do I read this whole graph wrong?

glacial steeple
#

also just usually never puppet

#

unless you are idk saudi arabia and cant afford manpower for garrisons

#

if your issue are garrison losses theres a small variety of ways to fix that

tall zodiac
glacial steeple
#

probably on mil governor with like your inf template or something

tall zodiac
#

na, I have a full template with the crap tank and MP

glacial steeple
#

awesome

#

are you making the tanks

#

you have to equip them

tall zodiac
#

yea they only get the crap tanks

glacial steeple
#

like 5-10 factories on it at least from like idk 1937 if youre ger

#

yeah but do you have enough

#

if youre in a deficit youll need to go up a lot in production

tall zodiac
#

I would say yes because the 21 is it

twin kayak
#

man, I just watched a guide on how to play autria, and germany has like 5x more divs and is super agressive ...

glacial steeple
vital plinth
glacial steeple
vital plinth
tired moon
#

is there a way to automatically assign the troops you get? I want my marines and infantry to be in different armies but doing it manually is tedious

twin kayak
#

@glacial steeple Can you help me a bit with my austrian campaign ? I get obliterated by the germans as soon as the attack (after refuseing to give them sudetenland)

glacial steeple
#

have you tried winning

#

not holding frontline

#

making more guns

#

making AA

#

using the terrain

#

communist path militia spam idk

twin kayak
#

whole fron has forts, army will be reay in a short amount of time, holding the frontline isn4t really possible against germany rn and I have AA in every state at the border

glacial steeple
#

forts 🥀

#

why not mils

twin kayak
#

because equipment isnt a problem rn

keen hemlock
#

well

#

you want mils before it becomes a problem

twin kayak
#

the problem is this

#

I just can't hold

glacial steeple
#

you can always make tanks or air

twin kayak
#

they had 1400 cas and idk how many fighters

#

gonna be difficult

glacial steeple
#

ok?

#

you get rid of them by shooting them down

#

forts dont do that

twin kayak
#

how am I supposed to contest that ?

little cloak
glacial steeple
#

forts are actually countered by air

twin kayak
#

I had max aa in every state

#

didn't do much tho

little cloak
#

100% lost

glacial steeple
twin kayak
glacial steeple
#

you need divisional aa or fighters

#

or tanks to push probably since germany is a lot of forests and plains

little cloak
#

Try change your plan

glacial steeple
#

like IDK forts arent useful

#

stronghold networks arent as bad

pine smelt
#

how can i get the papal state

glacial steeple
#

they give state debuffs to your enemy

twin kayak
glacial steeple
twin kayak
#

what is more optimal ?

vital plinth
#

Medium canon or medium howticher on tank ?

glacial steeple
#

idk probably lin

#

line

vital plinth
#

Medium canon gives 60 piecing

glacial steeple
#

cuz support slots valuable

glacial steeple
#

i usually want to damage my enemy so if they have low hardness id go howitzer with the artillery role

terse notch
#

My mod I made is kinda broken

twin kayak
glacial steeple
#

you can def get like

glacial steeple
#

ranger recon

#

flame tank

#

logi

#

arty AA

vital plinth
#

I don’t have flame tank yet

glacial steeple
vital plinth
#

So just howticher?

glacial steeple
#

probably

glad sphinx
#

Im trying to do the achievement where I invade britain as fascist france and I just cant get the naval supremacy to naval invade. My para troopers also keep dying everytime i try a mission

half lake
#

what is the best motorized division template for single player?

vital plinth
#

It still early

#

Waiting to unlock flame tank

glad sphinx
tall zodiac
#

is it possible to stop the mission a spy is doing?

rain hawk
#

when you do super heavy howitzer do you have to go for the super heavy howitzer doctrine or is fire concentration fine

glacial steeple
#

theres a button for it

glacial steeple
#

as in fire concentration is the worst one

rain hawk
#

so the super heavy howitzer doctrine is meta atm

glacial steeple
#

well IDK maybe theres another thats even more underwhelming

glacial steeple
#

as well as many other stats

rain hawk
#

does it give bonuses for line art

tall zodiac
glacial steeple
rain hawk
#

i enjoy them

glacial steeple
#

and you click the mission

#

and theres a cancel mission button

tall zodiac
#

i dont see that

glad sphinx
#

is minelaying useful?

glacial steeple
#

youve already paid for it tho

tall zodiac
#

yeah, its ongoing. that was the initial question

glacial steeple
#

well you can refund it in the first stage

#

not the second

vital plinth
#

At start of the war Italy wanted to say yes but now they don’t not sure how to get acesss need it to cap vichy france and if I get them to join they gonna ruin some stuff

jovial wigeon
#

I'm reading some tutorials and curious about one thing, why?
Delete all divs but 1 and train it.

glacial steeple
#

not generally done anymore

tall zodiac
#

at this point I would just expel the spy to hire a new one but its also not possible

jovial wigeon
glacial steeple
#

it gives xp based on average div size

#

but it doesnt matter much now

#

you mostly need mastery now

jovial wigeon
#

can I train it before war?

#

the mastery(?)

glacial steeple
#

yes

keen hemlock
#

Atachee

#

Gives some too

lone isle
#

How do i hold speeches?

glad sphinx
#

whats the best way to invade england as france?

keen hemlock
uncut narwhal
lone isle
vapid gate
#

can turkey even join the axis via this focus?

vital plinth
#

Why don’t I get planes when I beat vichy France ?

#

Is it because I let them puppet som me areas ?

visual zodiac
#

When you say beat Vichy

#

As in you've done the peace thing with germany for vichy then declared on them?

vital plinth
visual zodiac
#

And they definitely had planes?

#

If so It may be that the Axis capitulated them, the capitulation would've shared the equipment with whoever capped them

vital plinth
visual zodiac
#

From my understanding it would depend on warscore/cause of capitulation

#

If Germany or italy got a lot of occupation score for example, they may receive the equipment

somber spear
#

As a minor nation, how many line holders vs like push units should I have realistically

uncut narwhal
somber spear
#

Okay, just wondering cause I feel like I get my lineholders then I forget about my good pushers

dense stone
#

For general use, is 7 or 9 infantry better per division?

vital plinth
#

A puppet I made got 300-500 bombers tho

primal igloo
#

New to HOI4 but played Stellaris/CK3, why is it saying I have no Close Air Support being produced when I'm building this plane with a small bomb bay?

#

Is there an easy way to tell what counts as CAS?

visual zodiac
#

If that did happen the planes would've gone to germany

visual zodiac
visual zodiac
#

It can still work as a CAS Fighter hybrid but it's actual class is determined by that first one

tropic wolf
#

i have a question about concentrated industry when i need to make later game tank chassis or later game guns do i make a new production line and keep the old going or just replace the old with new?? whats better

gleaming grove
#

Why does it say 0???

vital plinth
buoyant cargo
#

How to design the best SPG?

#

And tank destroyer?

visual zodiac
gilded plover
visual zodiac
#

Should see a bar fill up on the production line, it’ll be machine tools that influence that, where as the concentrated industry is base output

visual zodiac
#

As for the rest of the components it’s up to you tbh, make sure reliability is decent though, same for TDs except use High Velocity

tropic wolf
visual zodiac
#

The idea is to gradually move the production across to the new one

#

Whether that’s a couple of factories at once or 1 at a time

#

You can just move them all over, just having both running is useful especially when mid war and equipment stockpile is needing to be constantly replenished at the same rate

visual zodiac
#

Gradually moving across will ease any production shortages (I.e. dropping from 50 a day to 8 for example on guns)

tropic wolf
#

thanks

visual zodiac
#

No worries : )

gleaming grove
#

please someone tell my why am i not gaining dominance?

inland frost
glacial steeple
thin nebula
glacial steeple
#

ohh hi vendrip

thin nebula
#

once your naval invasion starts you can switch to invasion support

thin nebula
glacial steeple
#

are you knowledgeable about space ships

#

theyre like ships but in space

thin nebula
#

like irl?

glacial steeple
#

like space ships

visual zodiac
thin nebula
#

oh not really, i just spam strike craft

glacial steeple
#

one of my friends is knowledgeable on it and i havent asked them but they havent been liking my design process coming to this creature

#

those are jet engines at the bottom rn btw so they wont work in space

thin nebula
#

last time i played that game i strapped like 50 solid fuel boosters to the capsule and let it go

gleaming grove
#

@inland frost @glacial steeple @thin nebula Thanks that worked. I was following this video and i just couldnt select it to get green. Guess the video is outdated.

inland frost
#

yea np

vapid gate
#

Can someone tell me where i can find some unexplained focuses cuz i dont wanna save scum to figure it out

keen hemlock
buoyant cargo
#

I wanna spg div design asap

#

please

serene karma
visual zodiac
#

If I was at my pc I would KEKW

vapid gate
hoary glen
# vapid gate this

Easiest way imo is either looking at the wiki or making a save, starting console, the "fa" and just try out the focus. Afterwards reload the save.

keen beacon
#

whats this T_T

#

ive tried everything

#

i downloaded Visual C++ 2015

#

ive given permission to the game

#

what is this T_T

visual zodiac
#

Is this first time launching?

glacial steeple
hoary glen
#

Lmao

keen hemlock
#

prolly

serene karma
hoary glen
vale cypress
#

How do I save this run??

vapid gate
#

i even unlocked it with console and i cant see a difference

vale cypress
keen beacon
#

i get that error still

vale cypress
#

uhm

#

reinstall the game?

keen beacon
#

im trying that rn

#

🥺

fringe hill
#

Do u know if iron smooth or SOO optimization are compatible with achievements and badges?

fringe hill
#

And there is any optimization mid compatible with it?

#

My game is unplayable from 1942 ahead

#

Each day gives a lag spike

serene karma
vapid gate
rare spoke
#

I cannot understand anything other than attack poland and defend from France been playing 4 hours as the German reich I wanna learn something and know what I’m doing

glacial steeple
vale cypress
rare spoke
glacial steeple
#

and its kind of the same for every nation in that sense

rare spoke
keen hemlock
#

learn the basics first

vale cypress
rare spoke
rare spoke
#

Thank you guys very helpful

blissful nova
#

It is 1 dimensional warfare in japan china war

vagrant cosmos
#

hello fellas

#

do we know if the soviet airforce bug is solved? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bCm-WS4zs8

I don't remember seeing anything in the patch notes and lately I've felt it harder to win the air war against the German AI despite using good templates o.O

The Soviet Airforce spirit is a lot of red debuffs but do they do anything, do they impact anything, should you even care? That's what this video will test.
Also tested out the air superiority guy.

Twitch.tv/71Cloak

▶ Play video
fickle moon
light knoll
#

its just so cooked

#

you get debuffs, no rubber, and no aluminum

#

you're better off using the production and focus time for other stuff

neat widget
#

Or rather, might be

vagrant cosmos
vital plinth
#

Hey anyone know how the system with planes work when I beat an enemy?

#

Do I get planes ?

#

Because sometimes I do and sometimes not bit confused how it works

obsidian cedar
#

you can get their planes when they capitulate

vital plinth
icy jolt
#

Does buildings like civ factory and mil factory increase world tension?

echo night
#

whats a good mech template for UK

twin kayak
#

tanks or sp artillery ?

#

what is the best

versed rose
#

mix both without NSB, sp artillery with NSB

glacial steeple
versed rose
#

hello casey

final tartan
#

If you exit the game on Ironman mode during a peace conference does it save the conference?

light knoll
#

if it doesn't, you can also copy the save file, change name, and paste it in the folder back then load it
that will go back a little in time usually

final tartan
#

I’m at the start anyways, thanks

glacial steeple
dawn epoch
#

guys, what does improving relations do?

Does being in equio,ent deficit actually do anything? I can still spawn in new troops that finished training while being in like 5k equipment deficit

#

and for the anchluss, I need 50k infsntry equipment IN storage to get anchluss focus?

dusty sandal
# dawn epoch guys, what does improving relations do? Does being in equio,ent deficit actual...

it increases relations with a country, meaning it can unlock some diplomatic actions and somewhat increase trade influence (allows you to buy more resources form them, very limited)

equipment is what gives you divisions stats. If you have old equipment, you won't have as much stats as shown in the designer, same if you're lacking equipment

for anchuluss, without GTR DLC, you need 50k guns deployed in the field. Meaning you must deploy divisions until 50k guns are in said divisions. You can see how many's fielded by opening the army screen (top right) then the equipment tab in the menu (top right of the UI that opens)

gleaming grove
#

If my Naval Invasion doesnt land (goes from 70 to 60, 50 until the invasion breaks off) but i cant build more marines due to specialized unit cap, whats the next best unit to use? Or do stronger ships help? Im trying to land on Haiti or Domenican Republic so i cant really find a tale without enemy units

#

also does it help to paratroop onto the tile i try to land my naval invasion in to overwhelm the defense?

dusty sandal
dusty sandal
gleaming grove
#

sec gotta launch the game

dusty sandal
#

you need to land with fat marines (fill with inf if not enough FS cap) and land around with regular inf to pin reinforcements or encircle if that's required
fill the combat width ofthe LZ then send the rest on the sides
force attack if you must but ONLY if you're about to win or have massive CAS on your head

gleaming grove
#

So this is the base plan. Last 0 armies in the group are involved

uncut narwhal
gleaming grove
uncut narwhal
#

land on the ports

gleaming grove
#

arent ports better protected and since im also landing with mountaneers i should have an adventage, no?

uncut narwhal
#

otherwise you wont even have supply once youve landed

#

your just encircled then

gleaming grove
#

so like this

glacial steeple
#

your army is good

uncut narwhal
glacial steeple
#

do you have a navy to get dominance in 2 zones though

glacial steeple
#

since the port is north

uncut narwhal
#

the marines are in guantanamo

glacial steeple
#

im dumb

dusty sandal
#

you're lacking fs cap but you have paras, mountaineers and marines ???

#

also, what are the actual stats on your divs, not the designer stats

#

open the stats of a div in the field

gleaming grove
glacial steeple
#

looks good

dusty sandal
#

yeah, that's good

dawn epoch
#

No demanding no actions

#

I’m playing on recruit mode btw

dusty sandal
#

I didn't say it was efficient

#

it's basically useless for 95% of the game

dawn epoch
#

I’m Germany, how do I get rid of this war economy / mifo bills

dusty sandal
#

the only exceptions being when you have focuses or decisions that require opinion

#

or to get the 20 opinion for an attaché

dusty sandal
dawn epoch
#

and I haven’t declared on Benelux or Poland. It’s 1937 December. I’m trying go very peaceful

#

I did anchluss and sudenlant

#

and allied with Hungary

#

and

dusty sandal
#

if you went 4 year plan, first off, remember to read focuses before taking them ; then you need to do the achieve autarky focus and pillage gold from countries you capped until then

dawn epoch
#

How do I lower weld tension?

#

I got autuarky

dusty sandal
dusty sandal
dawn epoch
#

I finsihed coal liqueur and I finished subsidize hosech

#

And estabalish reichwerks

#

do I finish until autarky?

#

I can research establish buna werke

dusty sandal
#

Want to go historical and do lots of conquest ? 4 year plan and MEFO it is
Want to do anything else ? PEG it is

dawn epoch
#

I have 6 volunteers in Spain rn, I want republic to capitulate

#

uh what’s peg

dusty sandal
#

and most importantly, READ FOCUSES before you take them

dawn epoch
#

I just look at the bonuses I get tbh

dusty sandal
dawn epoch
#

I’m a very economical giy

#

I love focuses that give me contrustion speed or more resources

#

So what now, I’m doing firdt Vienna reward and I’m gonna brefriend Poland and subjugate Romania

dusty sandal
#

you're not gonna befriend anyone

#

you're gonna conquer stuff

dawn epoch
#

damn

dusty sandal
#

until you can do the achieve autarky focus

#

until then it's war, war and more war

dawn epoch
#

Also, I capped Denmark and did anchluss but I didn’t get seize gold

dusty sandal
#

or you can say goddbye to your civs (you won't be able to build because 100% consumer goods)

dusty sandal
#

anchuluss is automatic, it just reduces it automatically

dawn epoch
#

Yeah ik, didn’t find it in decision

dusty sandal
#

did you puppet denmark

dawn epoch
#

nope..

#

annex all

#

I’m a noon

dusty sandal
#

you control the land, and got the economy of conquest (new name for MEFO once you enter a war)

dawn epoch
#

My consumer goods factor at 40%

dusty sandal
dawn epoch
dusty sandal
#

then decisions should be available

dawn epoch
#

how do I remove it. Anyway to like wait it out or does it last oeemanlty?

gleaming grove
#

Why are the mountanees go in first god damnit

dawn epoch
#

Which decisions

dusty sandal
#

provided you're at war and have capped a country

dawn epoch
#

I’m not at war with anybody yet

dusty sandal
#

just make them all 36w marines

#

why bother with mountaineers when landing :(

dusty sandal
#

don't forget price control focus and decisions

dawn epoch
#

I did all the price control I think

#

The butter something something one

#

and everything in the same section

dusty sandal
#

oh, but I'(m guessing you did all focuses that give buffs you don't even use until 1939-40, did you ?

#

like refineries and oil

#

and foreign industries

dawn epoch
#

uhh prolly

#

I don’t have foreign I think

#

Seize foreign?

#

haven’t reseafech3c

#

wair should I screen share

vital plinth
#

Is there something I can in settings on historical to make axis the more powerful that wins against Allie’s without player intervention just to make it a more enjoyable game as Allie’s

dusty sandal
dusty sandal
dawn epoch
#

so.. what do I do now..

dusty sandal
#

you conquer stuff until you can achieve autarky

dawn epoch
#

Annihilate the polish and French?

dusty sandal
#

look at the resource you need and plan accordingly

dawn epoch
#

I’m doing traces

#

I have 73 cigs

#

civs

#

47 mills

dusty sandal
#

autarky requires resources

dawn epoch
#

ok

#

ohhh

#

THISE

#

THOSE

keen hemlock
#

Ye

#

I know you need like Casablanca

dawn epoch
#

But I need the rest of the autarky things

dusty sandal
dawn epoch
#

Like bunra and seize

#

ok

#

guess I’m going to war

#

Im prolly gonna do Danzig or war

#

so I can

#

blots the French

uncut narwhal
dawn epoch
dusty sandal
#

oooh they are

gleaming grove
#

im still losing

dawn epoch
#

broooo

#

that’s why I don’t wanna

#

What if I get 100% consumer factor, does it stay forever?

uncut narwhal
dawn epoch
#

At like all my ports?

uncut narwhal
#

invading the uk is the best choice thoo

dawn epoch
#

idk how to

uncut narwhal
#

if you cant naval invade then paradrop

dawn epoch
#

I don’t know how paradeopping works at all

uncut narwhal
dawn epoch
#

Is there a way to put spawn troop at like a certain city instead of areas

dawn epoch
#

like when you select a location in recruit and deploy

#

it gives you areas

#

not cities

#

yk?

uncut narwhal
#

it gives you the tiles

#

not states

#

you can deploy in any state

#

that is owned by you

#

and connected to your capital

dawn epoch
#

ok

#

@dusty sandal can I make the bills end without war, like make them reach 100% and they finish

#

Or do they last forever?

#

until you clear them with wars

uncut narwhal
uncut narwhal
#

easier to manage as a new player

vital plinth
dawn epoch
#

I’m gonna

#

micro in Spain some more, and wait until I finish Danzig or war and around the maginot

#

so uk is easy

#

shoukd I ally Italy??

uncut narwhal
dawn epoch
#

how do I make them join

keen hemlock
#

Or they should

uncut narwhal
#

you also have a focus for that

dawn epoch
#

That’s so Jewish

dusty sandal
#

they don't diappear

#

you can cancel them but then you're stuck at a permanent 40% CG factor

dawn epoch
#

FAAAAAHHHH

#

what’s cg.

uncut narwhal
dawn epoch
#

Oh

clear zenith
#

how do i form the nation of isroel?

dawn epoch
#

HOLY ENCIRLMENT

keen hemlock
dawn epoch
#

I’m gonan do an insane encirlment

#

in Spain

#

30 tiles

keen hemlock
#

You can puppet them

dusty sandal
keen hemlock
#

You could do that too

dawn epoch
#

Why do I have DAY AND NIGHT CYCLES

#

I DIDNT HSVE THRM

#

HOW DO I DISBAKE THEM

#

SOMEONE HELP

vital plinth
keen hemlock
#

Upper middle iirc

dusty sandal
#

or press N

dawn epoch
#

Oh n

#

Thank you

#

N

white sequoia
#

Hello, does anyone have an exact number for how much reliability do recon light tanks need in order to move through mountains without taking losses ?

floral shale
#

what's the command to activate resistance?

dawn epoch
#

Holy if you guys ouod see the encirlment I just created

#

4 encircles, entire 80% of the spanish army and half of their land

#

from barcelona to Malaga

#

IVE MADE FACIST SPAIN WINNN

#

YAAAY

white sequoia
#

yeah, seems like it's linear, even at 98% there is still some losses, only after 100% they stop

dawn epoch
#

Can anyone tell me how to use 100% of factoried in occupied countries,like Denmark and Iceland?

white sequoia
#

compliance ?

rain hawk
#

how much soft does super heavy howitzer deal

dawn epoch
#

it’s time for me to go down the historical german path

half lake
#

what is the best motorised division template for single player

uncut narwhal
uncut narwhal
rain hawk
#

no

keen hemlock
#

you can

#

in production and when you edit your division

uncut narwhal
#

either what the other guy said

#

or go to special projects

#

and check

keen hemlock
#

random question, does anyone know what special projects have designers for them besides supersonic jet and mev?

obsidian badger
#

ive seen before

#

some paratrooper hack where u can make the paratroopers the defenders upon paradrop

#

is that still possible

#

how to do it

rain hawk
#

that's why i asked

uncut narwhal
gleaming grove
# gleaming grove im still losing

@dusty sandal what else could i do if naval invasion fails? Should i just bomb them with CAS and Bombers for months and than naval invade? Or should i just nuke them? Or should i naval invade on several locations and not just 1?

rain hawk
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

gleaming grove
#

Or should i build amphibious tank divisions?

uncut narwhal
#

marines are usually enough

#

just get cas

#

over it

gleaming grove
#

CAS targetting the port or land units?

uncut narwhal
#

wdym

#

its always gonna be over those

gleaming grove
#

no i mean when you assign CAS you can select to attack the tank icon or the harbor icon

uncut narwhal
#

so no

#

use ground attack

gleaming grove
#

i had 100CAS assigned for that and it didnt help. So how many are needed usually?

gleaming grove
uncut narwhal
#

were they trained and did you have superiority?

gleaming grove
#

1000?

uncut narwhal
#

yea

#

and whats your marine div?

gleaming grove
half lake
uncut narwhal
#

oh

gleaming grove
#

change them all to marines now

#

its 8 full exp marine units

uncut narwhal
uncut narwhal
#

add pioneers

gleaming grove
#

cant atm cause that would overstep the special forces limit

uncut narwhal
#

few good units are better than a lot worse units

gleaming grove
#

yeah but ill have to wait until more normal units are recruited before i can enlarge the existing special ones

gleaming grove
#

i dont have dlc

uncut narwhal
#

ohhh

#

get more planes then

#

non dlc plane arent that great

gleaming grove
#

i mean im mexico afterall KEKW i cant just print stuff

gleaming grove
uncut narwhal
gleaming grove
#

Still losing...

#

ah nvm now its moving in my favor slowly

twin kayak
#

heavy mg or canons ?

#

medium tanks or spg ?

rain hawk
#

what's a good offensive infantry template rn for this meta, 18/0?

uncut narwhal
uncut narwhal
rain hawk
#

what if you have low mp

uncut narwhal
uncut narwhal
twin kayak
# uncut narwhal spgs

and for heavy mg or canons ? I just watched a bittersteel video where he says that canons are better, but most of the people I see use heavy mg

twin kayak
#

yeah

uncut narwhal
vital plinth
#

Hey guys when I annex Vichy France I can’t get their equipment except guns ? It’s very confusing

#

Or planes

half glade
#

how do i complete the pacify ethiopia mission

#

like what do i actually do

#

i understand the goal

#

but how do i reach it

red grove
#

Why doesn't the oster conspiracy fire for me? I have been rejected both Memel and Sudetenland

vital plinth
#

Also what field marshal skilll is good to pick ? I’m playing Iran

fathom thistle
fathom thistle
ashen sigil
#

Can someone give me tips for the invasion of Poland?

austere roost
gleaming grove
#

Can i delete the civilian train from production?

fathom thistle
austere roost
#

yeah and if you have so many trains in stockpile you don't need 6 mils on it

red grove
vital plinth
#

What are naval bomber Designs ? From land with large frames

vapid gate
#

how do i complete this decision?

twin kayak
#

I'm blocked here (ask if you need more screen shots). What should I do ? I've been able to repel any german attack, but I fear I am slowly losing to their air (they out-produce me)

dusty sandal
#

you're wasting half the plane right now

twin kayak
dusty sandal
#

single engine 2, no armor plates

twin kayak
#

you sure ?

#

will it not make them shit ?

dusty sandal
#

your inf is too small for anything and cav recon doesn't do anything but cost a lot

dusty sandal
#

what's making them shit rn is wasting half the cost

twin kayak
dusty sandal
twin kayak
#

so this ?

dusty sandal
#

1 mil on arty is enough for the whole army

#

3 or 4 on aa

#

5 mils on support, one on trains, one or two on trucks, 1 arty (2 if you're in the red), 4 on aa (5 if you're in the red), rest on planes and 10 on guns

twin kayak
#

and this as for the infantry ? (haven't touched the size yet)

dusty sandal
#

prepare offensive divisions too, stop using the crappy ones (remove their recon btw, it's costly for nothing)

#

you have no step back DLC ?

glacial steeple
#

hoi4

twin kayak
#

as long as I hold, I'm happy

glacial steeple
#

125? ic

dusty sandal
glacial steeple
#

thats like

#

thats like half your unit cost

dusty sandal
#

forts + hills make for quite the buff

glacial steeple
#

its not half the unit worth of buffs

twin kayak
glacial steeple
#

entrenchment is like a modifier in battle to your stats

#

and your units they have no stats

#

engis are like awesome for large divs

#

but like

#

it doesnt do a whole lot on 12w inf

twin kayak
#

ok, so I get rid of them ?

#

okok

#

how should I train units ? 24 at a time or a small amount set on infinite ?

austere roost
#

you train for all that you need and then you don't need them anymore

#

although technically the best way is to train 1 unit infs + light tank recon + support art so you can train them until war begins to farm mastery

gleaming grove
#

how can i select what the missile attacks?

#

nvm

tired moon
#

what exactly is this? I want to do the trotsky path

manic depot
#

thats stalins paranoia if it gets over 80 the civil war will start early

#

just try to get it low

tired moon
#

okay

#

what should I do for this

twin kayak
#

do I need 4divs for this tile ?

tired moon
manic depot
#

purge the navy or do inspections

twin kayak
#

(army inspections etc ... in the event tab or idk how it's called)

glacial steeple
#

notice the italian border

#

also why units small?

#

as austria

#

your manpower is like really limited no

twin kayak
#

well, I used all my pp to get advisors to buff my army

#

I didn't change the conscription law

crisp ledge
# half glade how do i complete the pacify ethiopia mission

I got it by taking the Ministry of Italian Africa, Topple Amhara Rulers, and New Emperor of Ethiopia focuses. When the generals come forward, hire them to get bonuses in their regions. Put your garrisons on a garrison law that doesn't provide a compliance malus - you need suppression, but you need compliance before anything else. Invest in the Ministry of Italian Africa branch to get bonuses to the Colonial Police garrison law, then spend time and resources to develop the region.

glacial steeple
crisp ledge
#

Fair, but a lot of Italy's colonial focus options increase non-core manpower, and I think it's best to hold on to Ethiopia.

obsidian badger
#

u only need it low if u need to stall to say do a few more focuses

tired moon
#

should I be worried

obsidian badger
#

ive never seen that

#

lol

#

i have two questions

crisp ledge
obsidian badger
#

how do i make paratroopers the defenders on paradrop ive seen that before i think

#

and do the allies ever guarantee chinese warlord states

crisp ledge
#

If you're fighting one past a certain date, you should expect to be fighting them all, though you might be able to get Japanese support.

obsidian badger
#

but i wanna eat the chinese warlord and steal them from china

obsidian badger
ocean birch
#

is this only for ingame mechanics or aswell with truble shoting with the game?

crisp ledge
# obsidian badger Japan, a taisho japan

I see, I see. I tried something similar a while back - there's generally some tensions with the warlord states anyway, and without the Japanese threat I don't know that they'll necessarily join forces with the big two factions. You might only be able to get one, though - when I tried it they still formed the front while I was busy.

obsidian badger
#

At

lyric geyser
#

When you are dropping

#

When you click the button and they launch and start fighting the enemy press H

obsidian badger
#

what does h actually do lol

lyric geyser
#

Idk I just know it makes them the defender

misty wagon
#

MUSSOLINI bro i swear this dude wont help

obsidian badger
lyric geyser
obsidian badger
#

China gets annex warlords VERY late in their focus tree, meaning they only have the ability to puppet

#

Which requires the warlords to be in same faction

#

And i will not let any in

lyric geyser
misty wagon
lyric geyser
obsidian badger
lyric geyser
#

But free wargoals

vital plinth
#

Hey pls can someone help me

  1. the medium plane I can’t see how much it’s bombing stats are not sure what to do

  2. The basic heavey fighter is it the big frame or medium frame

  3. I don’t have carriers and need to destroy ships should I build large or medium frame for naval bombs both for subs and battleships and cruisers in currently using some small frames until more is resseached

misty wagon
#

MUSSOLINI COUNT YOUR DAYS BRO

glacial steeple
lyric geyser
obsidian badger
crisp ledge
# misty wagon MUSSOLINI bro i swear this dude wont help

Honestly, I feel like the big benefit Italy gives in the war is mostly just opening up new fronts. British divisions that are tied up in Ethiopia and North Africa aren't British divisions backing a push across the Channel.
Of course, that's predicated on Italy actually joining the war. I don't know if you can salvage this, but probably best to push through the Benelux, keep a token garrison to tie up troops at the Maginot, and go historical capitulation of France.

lyric geyser
#

If you have issues with subs build radar

misty wagon
crisp ledge
#

Incidentally, I'd like to ask for a bit of help about the historical AI. If Italy guarantees Austria and stops the Anschluss, am I correct in assuming that Germany won't push on to Czechoslovakia and Poland?

misty wagon
#

I DIDNT EVEN SEE FRANCE omg i do this EVERY time blast thru 4x speed and saw france when it reached berlin almost

vapid gate
lyric geyser
misty wagon
crisp ledge
#

I mean, let's be honest, Germany is essentially not pushing the Maginot, but they have to counter-fortify that border, because there tend to be a lot of troops there (it's their only major front line with the Axis because Italy hasn't joined).

misty wagon
#

i dont know , i put area defense on my coast AND france, and 1 second later bOOM

#

SIGH

#

i will NEVER play as reich again

#

only empire

crisp ledge
#

Imperial Germany's a lot of fun, too, though.

misty wagon
#

I REALLY wanna finish this save but i cant

crisp ledge
#

I'll sometimes just cede naval dominance to the English and join the Allies outright, start an Allied/Comintern war.

misty wagon
#

and i started ww2. cuz of yugoslavia

misty wagon
crisp ledge
#

On the ahist focus, I generally see Poland go communist and join the Soviets - it's still a lot of fun, it's just that it's mostly fun on the Eastern Front.

misty wagon
#

is byzantium formable ?

misty wagon
#

HOLY ITS 1976

crisp ledge
misty wagon
crisp ledge
misty wagon
#

what are some other fun playthru i should try

#

i did HRE

#

and thats abt it

crisp ledge
misty wagon
#

wats that

crisp ledge
#

Go non-aligned Italy, take Seek Papal Support, then finagle things to get His Holiness over 60% on the Balance of Power, and he'll overthrow the House of Savoy and get you a secret focus tree.

#

Very heavily tank-focused, gets war goals on most of Europe for being Protestant.

#

I always love it - it's my go-to "non-aligned world domination" strategy.

crisp ledge
# misty wagon wats that

Habemus Papam, a run you cannot miss, or you'll go straight to hell!
An updated Roman Empire strategy, new templates, new focus and research priorities, and a lot more!

You can find all researches and focuses in the description!

You can find my most updated guides for Italy at this link: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLY4d0TUsYg8LMWGES...

▶ Play video
#

Or you could try to conquer the world as a bear.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FBPdhlwqMwM

🇵🇱 Ready for the most legendary hidden path in Hearts of Iron 4? In this complete Secret Poland Guide, I show you exactly how to unlock Wojtek the Bear as your king and commander! We cover the hidden Focus Tree steps and the optimal setup to crush both the USSR and the Axis to get the secret Artillery Bear achievement! 🐻

📋 Research ...

▶ Play video
misty wagon
gleaming grove
#

What happens to those argentinian troops if i kick argentina out of the faction and immediatly declare war?

tired moon
#

Do I need to get mountaineers for this shit

#

What even is this

crisp ledge
dusty sandal
#

you're fighting with org capped at 15% and -80% breakthrough, -60% attack penalities

#

no wonder you're not pushing

crisp ledge
#

Yeah, your soldiers are in critical condition.

#

Infrastructure in that area's never great, but you need to make sure you're investing as you go in your occupied territories.

vital plinth
#

Also what should I do with these I can’t see how much bombing they have

glacial steeple
lyric geyser
vital plinth
lyric geyser
vital plinth
#

I haven’t reaseached medium yet should I start doing it v its 1942 February

vital plinth
lyric geyser
#

You don’t need to have up to date mediums for your navs

lyric geyser
#

You can also just use it for cas

light knoll
#

it just gives you bonuses for super heavy tank

#

which is bad

#

its funny how bad super heavy tank is compared to how good land cruiser is

#

when land cruiser is something that couldn't even work in reality

rain hawk
#

what are some chill achievements to do that are fun

fathom thistle
#

pretty easy

rain hawk
#

done

fathom thistle
#

hmm

rain hawk
#

i need to play on that save to kill britain for palestine

#

will be ez

#

i just need to land

fathom thistle
#

pretty easy

rain hawk
#

you're right

#

i need to do that

gleaming grove
gleaming grove
#

Wth is going on here? Its always changing between way too much and not enough

keen hemlock
#

i think its need to be delivered to your units

glacial steeple
#

just keep a certain amount on tho

hoary glen
glacial steeple
#

efficiency matters

#

hii patrick hru

crisp ledge
hoary glen
light knoll
#

you can stack anti air on it to some silly levels

errant chasm
hoary glen
#

It's more like a Bunker that can move but shouldn't

hoary glen
light knoll
light knoll
hoary glen
hoary glen
hoary glen
#

Also ofc you want to add armour to make the div unpierceable, but you probably don't need much for it

errant chasm
tight mesa
#

Does having a spy network in another country do something by itself?

hoary glen
tight mesa
#

Ok thx

glacial steeple
hoary glen
#

nice