#ask-for-help-here
1 messages · Page 190 of 1
Also for port defense and border defense is this template fine ? I can’t afford support equipment to my main attack divisions
remove support artillery
if u can afford it keep the engineers but you dont need them either
It means your divisions can't beat them on the offense. What was your division again?
but i literally have one of the strongest tank divs u can make in singleplayer
.
Why remove the arty ?
It isn't
makes it more expensive
They should be spgs and 36 width
i dont wanna make spg's tho
the machine building plant gives really good production stuff for medium tanks
The buffs apply to spgs too
I have no problem with arty production just support equipment or am I putting too few on it ? Should I put a lot of mills normlay on Support equipment so my attack divisions can afford it ?
For port garrison you only have to put them on ports, and you just need them to hold the line for a bit so that you can get your better divisions over to clean them up
Okay then
Like you're on the right track but SPGs are better and you should ignore 1940 chassis and use 1938 chassis
Also what are your doctrines?
question..?
Like you have gbp but I can't see the others
You get air and land xp, you help them by sending volunteers
guys i restarted on a new run and finally capped it
Also there's general grinding to get op generals
grand battleplan defensive postures field engineering
and ill get streamlined deployement
Yeah those subdoctrines kind of suck
i can get a total of 60% planning bonus with my tank general
Do you have railway guns then?
wdym
no
grand battleplan is the best doctrine for tanks
bcs of the planning bonus
The best ones are individual excellence/self propelled support/streamline/grand assault if you're doing spgs
im so sorry to bother but in the tech support page i have a mjor issue that i have been trying to solve for like a few years now and i just have no clue man
Ofc with tank divs you can ignore self propelled support
idk i have alot of infantry too so the more entrenchement and less supply use just seemed pretty good
They're not needed
And individual excellence is an infantry tree
It gives you infantry buffs
You might want to just wait a while and let Germans attack you
So they lose equipment and you gain XP and mastery
One way to get a lot of early mastery is to get a lot of one inf divs with light tank recon and support art and then train them
just chill behind the river?
So 36 withd?
Is this way too few on support equipment should I have a lot more ?
See if you can hold the frontlines
Do you need them? Are you at a deficit?
1 on AA😭
how do i make the navy reach here
set their main naval base there
I don’t know haha that’s the issue I don’t know if I’m supposed to produce more aren’t most of my divisions that I use for offense to have enginerr?
am spain brother
iirc
1st: how tf am I supposed to know based on your screenshot and 2nd: if you can't go there, don't go there
easy
nah dw its fine
issue is
how the hell do i end the war
theres usually clues
he just has to set it to vladivostok port
control right click
nvm thanks
Also I can’t use support company engineer on 24 of my divisions because then I get minus on a 400 or something only on my defense template or same template copy just for defense I can have enough of
But I don’t know if I’m supposed to this or if it’s ineffective
@glacial steeple youre a saviour thanks
what did i do
just saved my ass from struggling with japan for the next 20000 hours
well then you'll need to ask yourself if you can build more mils to get more support equipment or need to move around mils to do that
Guys, what tanks are the best against online players? medium or heavy?
I am so good at it but I need some notes and tips how to make good divs and how to build them faster
heavy tank destroyers
The guys I play with use a lot of artillery and artillery doctrines. What should I do for this in attack? I use companies that gives me attack bonus on forts and rivers also flame tanks for higher soft attack
medium flame tanks, medium spgs and support artillery is good
ok brother ty
I will try the tank destroyers and spgs for first time
I hope the spgs are better than tanks in attack
spgs are good against infantry but not tanks
Does anyone know of any videos that can help me learn how to play?
yes because we put guns that use HE (soft attack) but in tanks we need to use hard attack
How long does a puppet need to sit at max autonomy to get free? Its at least 1 year at max. still nothing... someone know whats going on ?
It depends on
Yeah I know that it’s more about is it a waste or not for engineer support company since I’m still learning I don’t know if that’s something most do having more mills on support equipment to run that on their main divs
There are so many videos but you got to learn by nations
start with Germany
on what?
Also a different question when I’m about to caputale a country if I encircle a big group of the country divisions do I get their equipment once they caputale and man power or not ?
If you import from your puppet, this will give it points to free itself from you. Also, when you build inside his country this will make you get more and much points to annex them.
You can import from your puppet 80 steel with 1 civil factory but you will lose points to annex
As far as I remember, less than if they were not encircled but still some
Exactly
Fastest way to expand with Italy prior to WW2 kicking off?
You're importing from your puppet and importing from puppet is more like them helping you because you take so much resources with 1 factory. Also, you lead them into a war and they fight.
So what’s the best way to get enemy equipment? Just destroy them in the field ?
You make them lose 1000.04 but they gain around 3K
Ive done everything. Its years since the bar is full
Also i don’t understand fully how i get the engiener trait on my generals should i just stand on river or how it works fully ?
If the bar is full you will need 300 political power to annex
well annex him would be the opposite ha.
You want to free your puppet or annex him?
free him
unless you have massive capture ratio (ie: commie china), no
pretty sure there was an option to free him, let me remember
Should be from occupation territory tho
I will check now for you
I had a puppet that freed him self so its possible.
puppets are not under the occupation option
I would annex him If I could but if I want that I need to stop importing materials from him and I need that stuff
There is no easy way to free puppets
at least don't build in his land
building in his land make it much harder for your puppet to free himself
I only build the infrastructure up because I wanted more resources 😛
real
is it normal for the italian AI to take THIS long to take ethiopia 😭
so i have never gone this far in a game, and I cant defeat the other countries armies easily. they always can resist and walking into a tile takes long too. what should I do?
Itlian war never ends
This area is totally dead out of supplies
should I build like supply hubs or smth?
also my divisions are so slow
what could I do to speed them up
You should take some troops back from the front line becuase you have huge number of troops and you don't have supplies for all of them. Build supply hub nearby them and build railway level 5. Press on the FieldMarshall face, you will find a button
click on this horse twice if you have enough cars to supply your divisions
This is normal. Your divisions are slow because there are supply, no railway and fighting on big mountains
Also, weather has much effect to attrition
Do I get more equipment if I leave enemy divisions alive on field ?
man I wish you could like white peace with others
my allies went and declared war on britain
while fighting the whole china and japan
you can add mods for this but I don't know what it is
should I try to go around the mountains or get mountaneers then?
im kinda new to the game
like 80 hours in
Of course, the mountaineers are so much better
we all are new 😭
Can you take me a photo of the whole area?
?
Infantry equipment = guns
im not at war with the british (my allies keep telling me JOIN THE WAR)
ah what is this
Build railway from nearest capital to your troops and and build new supply hub
yeah ethiopia goes into exile
Fighting in Asia is hell
ohhhhhh that explains it
guns, ammo, outfits, helmets
depends
hi casey
it depends on if you have an inf/mountaineer/air build in the first place
you should specialize and focus on something specific or you will have many things that are all bad
until they save up 300pp
the vanilla ai never does this so
and you usually shouldnt either tbf
so I am blocked because I really need the resources from him. I can not annex him if I keep importing
wdym
autonomy system goes 2 ways
Well I saw Denmark do it. 2 years ago he did free him self
Hey do I get more of country equipment if I leave the divisions alive on the battlefield ?
yes iirc
My equipment ratio is 0 so how can I capture more is there other mechanics?
They don’t get destroyed?
well If I import resources my puppet get more autonomy or do I read this whole graph wrong?
they do
also just usually never puppet
unless you are idk saudi arabia and cant afford manpower for garrisons
if your issue are garrison losses theres a small variety of ways to fix that
I still barely can afford garrisons. France did free himself, same with spain. but they are different because I got them because of the war and not with the focus tree.
well youre just mishandling it lol
probably on mil governor with like your inf template or something
na, I have a full template with the crap tank and MP
yea they only get the crap tanks
like 5-10 factories on it at least from like idk 1937 if youre ger
yeah but do you have enough
if youre in a deficit youll need to go up a lot in production
I would say yes because the 21 is it
man, I just watched a guide on how to play autria, and germany has like 5x more divs and is super agressive ...
cool
Hey @glacial steeple was your reply to this. ?
im pretty sure you do but idk
No worries
is there a way to automatically assign the troops you get? I want my marines and infantry to be in different armies but doing it manually is tedious
@glacial steeple Can you help me a bit with my austrian campaign ? I get obliterated by the germans as soon as the attack (after refuseing to give them sudetenland)
ive played austria maybe twice after the dlc idk
have you tried winning
not holding frontline
making more guns
making AA
using the terrain
communist path militia spam idk
whole fron has forts, army will be reay in a short amount of time, holding the frontline isn4t really possible against germany rn and I have AA in every state at the border
because equipment isnt a problem rn
well no it is
you can always make tanks or air
how am I supposed to contest that ?
Man its lost
forts are actually countered by air
100% lost
theyre likely not producing all that many planes
already deleted that save
thats cuz that only works vs strat bombing and logi strike
you need divisional aa or fighters
or tanks to push probably since germany is a lot of forests and plains
Try change your plan
how can i get the papal state
they give state debuffs to your enemy
support aa or an aa bataillion ? idk what the difference is in terms of effectiveness
both do the same thing just with different amounts of attack
what is more optimal ?
Medium canon or medium howticher on tank ?
Medium canon gives 60 piecing
cuz support slots valuable
it does do that
i usually want to damage my enemy so if they have low hardness id go howitzer with the artillery role
My mod I made is kinda broken
are we playing the same austria ? I don't have any support company except aa, arty, engineer and recon (by the time the war starts)
as austria maybe you want the support slot idk
you can def get like
It’s vs AI
I don’t have flame tank yet
their units are soft
So just howticher?
probably
Im trying to do the achievement where I invade britain as fascist france and I just cant get the naval supremacy to naval invade. My para troopers also keep dying everytime i try a mission
what is the best motorized division template for single player?
I can refit later maybe ?
It still early
Waiting to unlock flame tank
Anyone know a good way to do this>
is it possible to stop the mission a spy is doing?
when you do super heavy howitzer do you have to go for the super heavy howitzer doctrine or is fire concentration fine
yes
theres a button for it
best arty subdoctrine vs worst arty subdoctrine
as in fire concentration is the worst one
so the super heavy howitzer doctrine is meta atm
well IDK maybe theres another thats even more underwhelming
it gives 25% urban attack
as well as many other stats
does it give bonuses for line art
well I cant find that button
why do you want that
i enjoy them
its in the operations tab of the spy thing
and you click the mission
and theres a cancel mission button
i dont see that
is minelaying useful?
yeah, its ongoing. that was the initial question
At start of the war Italy wanted to say yes but now they don’t not sure how to get acesss need it to cap vichy france and if I get them to join they gonna ruin some stuff
I'm reading some tutorials and curious about one thing, why?
Delete all divs but 1 and train it.
army xp
not generally done anymore
at this point I would just expel the spy to hire a new one but its also not possible
but can't I keep all my divs and do training with 1 div?
no
it gives xp based on average div size
but it doesnt matter much now
you mostly need mastery now
yes
How do i hold speeches?
whats the best way to invade england as france?
If this is a mod, I’d try joining their discord and ask
probably decisions or just scripted
Thank god for the collapsing world dev team
can turkey even join the axis via this focus?
Why don’t I get planes when I beat vichy France ?
Is it because I let them puppet som me areas ?
When you say beat Vichy
As in you've done the peace thing with germany for vichy then declared on them?
I’m Iran so when vichy is created I declare war on them and beat them by calling in the axis because I need access to some of their land to attack in their African land but after peace deal I don’t have any planes that they have
And they definitely had planes?
If so It may be that the Axis capitulated them, the capitulation would've shared the equipment with whoever capped them
But don’t I get the most of it ?
From my understanding it would depend on warscore/cause of capitulation
If Germany or italy got a lot of occupation score for example, they may receive the equipment
As a minor nation, how many line holders vs like push units should I have realistically
4 good offensive units will bring you decently far
Okay, just wondering cause I feel like I get my lineholders then I forget about my good pushers
For general use, is 7 or 9 infantry better per division?
But I should be able to get planes no ?
A puppet I made got 300-500 bombers tho
New to HOI4 but played Stellaris/CK3, why is it saying I have no Close Air Support being produced when I'm building this plane with a small bomb bay?
Is there an easy way to tell what counts as CAS?
It's situational, as Vichy is an odd country in terms of existing and it''s annexation with potential script interactions with Germany its possible it saw it as a german case anton and annex it to germany
If that did happen the planes would've gone to germany
First air module dictates what the plane is
The light mg makes the plane a fighter, adding bomb locks to first slot will change it to a cas, or naval armaments will make it a naval bomber
It can still work as a CAS Fighter hybrid but it's actual class is determined by that first one
Easy fix, thanks!
i have a question about concentrated industry when i need to make later game tank chassis or later game guns do i make a new production line and keep the old going or just replace the old with new?? whats better
Why does it say 0???
But normally I do get the country planes right ?
Not always

Start the new line and gradually add more factories on it as production efficiency rises to the cap
Should see a bar fill up on the production line, it’ll be machine tools that influence that, where as the concentrated industry is base output
SPGs you’ll likely want to use the howitzer guns unlocked via artillery research, it’ll have a module that you can then make it an spg
As for the rest of the components it’s up to you tbh, make sure reliability is decent though, same for TDs except use High Velocity
then when it gets kinda close to old line i cant take the line off production?
The idea is to gradually move the production across to the new one
Whether that’s a couple of factories at once or 1 at a time
You can just move them all over, just having both running is useful especially when mid war and equipment stockpile is needing to be constantly replenished at the same rate
thanks man
Gradually moving across will ease any production shortages (I.e. dropping from 50 a day to 8 for example on guns)
thanks
No worries : )
please someone tell my why am i not gaining dominance?
need ships on patrol mission
naval support is useless
need to patrol for it
ohh hi vendrip
once your naval invasion starts you can switch to invasion support
hi casey
like irl?
like space ships
Stellaris
oh not really, i just spam strike craft
well not stellaris like space ship design
one of my friends is knowledgeable on it and i havent asked them but they havent been liking my design process coming to this creature
those are jet engines at the bottom rn btw so they wont work in space
last time i played that game i strapped like 50 solid fuel boosters to the capsule and let it go
@inland frost @glacial steeple @thin nebula Thanks that worked. I was following this video and i just couldnt select it to get green. Guess the video is outdated.
yea np
thats from the old system yes
Can someone tell me where i can find some unexplained focuses cuz i dont wanna save scum to figure it out
Which
id just use the console in a non iron man save
10 spg 8 truck/mech
If I was at my pc I would 
this
Add more delta V 😆
Easiest way imo is either looking at the wiki or making a save, starting console, the "fa" and just try out the focus. Afterwards reload the save.
whats this T_T
ive tried everything
i downloaded Visual C++ 2015
ive given permission to the game
what is this T_T
Is this first time launching?
its not that easy because the way im designing this thing is dumb
Lmao
prolly
Whats wrong with it
I'm just saying it bc of the memes 
How do I save this run??
what does it give when completed
i even unlocked it with console and i cant see a difference
just install C++ and .NET
i get that error still
Do u know if iron smooth or SOO optimization are compatible with achievements and badges?
no
it changes checksum
And there is any optimization mid compatible with it?
My game is unplayable from 1942 ahead
Each day gives a lag spike
U can quickly rebuild ships from decision tab iirc
there are these but they require different focuses
I cannot understand anything other than attack poland and defend from France been playing 4 hours as the German reich I wanna learn something and know what I’m doing
cant tell what youre doing wrong but germany is just really bad at showing you what youre doing wrong anyway TBH
help
Do you have any tips I could use like countries that could teach instead?
IDK i think finland is pretty decent because your main issues are like, stacking combat buffs, picking the right general and field marshal, your research is just guns and production, and you have a lot of OP buffs and advisors but you just need to like read
and its kind of the same for every nation in that sense
Ohhh I got it, I’ll try Finland out watch a couple tutorials also should I learn navy or is it too early
learn the basics first
play hungary to learn military inland and industry
Alr thanks
Alright I’ll try them out after this play through with Finland quickly
Thank you guys very helpful
Play china to learn combat
It is 1 dimensional warfare in japan china war
hello fellas
do we know if the soviet airforce bug is solved? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bCm-WS4zs8
I don't remember seeing anything in the patch notes and lately I've felt it harder to win the air war against the German AI despite using good templates o.O
The Soviet Airforce spirit is a lot of red debuffs but do they do anything, do they impact anything, should you even care? That's what this video will test.
Also tested out the air superiority guy.
Are you running fighters with 600 x 4 heavy mgs?
you're not supposed to do air as Soviets
its just so cooked
you get debuffs, no rubber, and no aluminum
you're better off using the production and focus time for other stuff
I believe night operations and bad weather are CAS modifiers
Or rather, might be
As far as I know none of the debuffs affect anything unless it has been patched
I see
Hey anyone know how the system with planes work when I beat an enemy?
Do I get planes ?
Because sometimes I do and sometimes not bit confused how it works
wdym by this?
you can get their planes when they capitulate
I’ve done multiple tries on Iraq for example and sometimes I got 200 planes other times 0 or 50 so I’m confused what decied how many planes I get ,
And with vicjy France I got none
Does buildings like civ factory and mil factory increase world tension?
No
whats a good mech template for UK
mix both without NSB, sp artillery with NSB
hiii
hello casey
If you exit the game on Ironman mode during a peace conference does it save the conference?
it'll restart the conference
if it doesn't, you can also copy the save file, change name, and paste it in the folder back then load it
that will go back a little in time usually
I’m at the start anyways, thanks
hru??
guys, what does improving relations do?
Does being in equio,ent deficit actually do anything? I can still spawn in new troops that finished training while being in like 5k equipment deficit
and for the anchluss, I need 50k infsntry equipment IN storage to get anchluss focus?
it increases relations with a country, meaning it can unlock some diplomatic actions and somewhat increase trade influence (allows you to buy more resources form them, very limited)
equipment is what gives you divisions stats. If you have old equipment, you won't have as much stats as shown in the designer, same if you're lacking equipment
for anchuluss, without GTR DLC, you need 50k guns deployed in the field. Meaning you must deploy divisions until 50k guns are in said divisions. You can see how many's fielded by opening the army screen (top right) then the equipment tab in the menu (top right of the UI that opens)
If my Naval Invasion doesnt land (goes from 70 to 60, 50 until the invasion breaks off) but i cant build more marines due to specialized unit cap, whats the next best unit to use? Or do stronger ships help? Im trying to land on Haiti or Domenican Republic so i cant really find a tale without enemy units
also does it help to paratroop onto the tile i try to land my naval invasion in to overwhelm the defense?
using CAS is better than this
except if you have the paratrooper doctrine that deletes half the enemy org
show the template, it's likely an issue there
sec gotta launch the game
you need to land with fat marines (fill with inf if not enough FS cap) and land around with regular inf to pin reinforcements or encircle if that's required
fill the combat width ofthe LZ then send the rest on the sides
force attack if you must but ONLY if you're about to win or have massive CAS on your head
So this is the base plan. Last 0 armies in the group are involved
whats the division template?
it looks like your trying to land on mountains
land on the ports
arent ports better protected and since im also landing with mountaneers i should have an adventage, no?
land with your marines in ports
otherwise you wont even have supply once youve landed
your just encircled then
so like this
your army is good
yes
do you have a navy to get dominance in 2 zones though
those are paratroopers
the marines are in guantanamo
first off, land on the port or don't land at all
you're lacking fs cap but you have paras, mountaineers and marines ???
also, what are the actual stats on your divs, not the designer stats
open the stats of a div in the field
looks good
yeah, that's good
I have like 80 of them opionon of me good and I have 10- of them, I can’t do shit bru
No demanding no actions
I’m playing on recruit mode btw
I’m Germany, how do I get rid of this war economy / mifo bills
the only exceptions being when you have focuses or decisions that require opinion
or to get the 20 opinion for an attaché
go down the prioritize economic growth path
I went 4 year plan sad,y
and I haven’t declared on Benelux or Poland. It’s 1937 December. I’m trying go very peaceful
I did anchluss and sudenlant
and allied with Hungary
and
if you went 4 year plan, first off, remember to read focuses before taking them ; then you need to do the achieve autarky focus and pillage gold from countries you capped until then
why did you go for the economy of conquest path then 😭
you wait
Because I declared on Denmark
I finsihed coal liqueur and I finished subsidize hosech
And estabalish reichwerks
do I finish until autarky?
I can research establish buna werke
Want to go historical and do lots of conquest ? 4 year plan and MEFO it is
Want to do anything else ? PEG it is
and most importantly, READ FOCUSES before you take them
I just look at the bonuses I get tbh
prioritize economic growth
I’m a very economical giy
I love focuses that give me contrustion speed or more resources
So what now, I’m doing firdt Vienna reward and I’m gonna brefriend Poland and subjugate Romania
damn
Also, I capped Denmark and did anchluss but I didn’t get seize gold
or you can say goddbye to your civs (you won't be able to build because 100% consumer goods)
it's a decision
anchuluss is automatic, it just reduces it automatically
Yeah ik, didn’t find it in decision
did you puppet denmark
you control the land, and got the economy of conquest (new name for MEFO once you enter a war)
My consumer goods factor at 40%
is the spirit called economy of conquest
yes
then decisions should be available
how do I remove it. Anyway to like wait it out or does it last oeemanlty?
Why are the mountanees go in first god damnit
Which decisions
provided you're at war and have capped a country
I’m not at war with anybody yet
higher breakthrough div go in first
the mountaineer being larger, they have more so they go first
just make them all 36w marines
why bother with mountaineers when landing :(
once you enter another war, you'll be able to
don't forget price control focus and decisions
I did all the price control I think
The butter something something one
and everything in the same section
oh, but I'(m guessing you did all focuses that give buffs you don't even use until 1939-40, did you ?
like refineries and oil
and foreign industries
uhh prolly
I don’t have foreign I think
Seize foreign?
haven’t reseafech3c
wair should I screen share
Is there something I can in settings on historical to make axis the more powerful that wins against Allie’s without player intervention just to make it a more enjoyable game as Allie’s
you can't just do focuses without reading them first bro 😭
these increase consumer goods too, only take them when you need them or can use their buff
buff axis nations in the game settings
so.. what do I do now..
you conquer stuff until you can achieve autarky
Annihilate the polish and French?
look at the resource you need and plan accordingly
I don’t need resources
I’m doing traces
I have 73 cigs
civs
47 mills
But I need the rest of the autarky things
then work towards it
Like bunra and seize
ok
guess I’m going to war
Im prolly gonna do Danzig or war
so I can
blots the French
just use a template with mixed mountaineers and marines
Uk isn’t gonan naval invade me right?
oooh they are
im still losing
broooo
that’s why I don’t wanna
What if I get 100% consumer factor, does it stay forever?
just put up a port garrison
At like all my ports?
if you want
invading the uk is the best choice thoo
idk how to
if you cant naval invade then paradrop
I don’t know how paradeopping works at all
you need paratroopers and transport planes at the airport
Is there a way to put spawn troop at like a certain city instead of areas
wdym
like when you select a location in recruit and deploy
it gives you areas
not cities
yk?
it gives you the tiles
not states
you can deploy in any state
that is owned by you
and connected to your capital
ok
@dusty sandal can I make the bills end without war, like make them reach 100% and they finish
Or do they last forever?
until you clear them with wars
if your a new player just go with the left eco path
I am
then go with prioritize economic growth
easier to manage as a new player
Can I make Soviet become facist and join axis ?
I’m gonna
micro in Spain some more, and wait until I finish Danzig or war and around the maginot
so uk is easy
shoukd I ally Italy??
yea i use them to distract the uk navy
I sent request, they rejected
how do I make them join
they will want to join in like 38/39
you also have a focus for that
That’s so Jewish
once they reach 100% you just get output debuffs instead of more consumer goods
they don't diappear
you can cancel them but then you're stuck at a permanent 40% CG factor
consumer goods
Oh
how do i form the nation of isroel?
HOLY ENCIRLMENT
Peace deal
You can puppet them
start as UK, release israel and tick "play as"
then spend hours of gameplay doing absolutely nothing because it's a shitter releasable not meant to be played
You could do that too
Why do I have DAY AND NIGHT CYCLES
I DIDNT HSVE THRM
HOW DO I DISBAKE THEM
SOMEONE HELP
Do you know if I can get Soviet to join axis as facist ?
or press N
Hello, does anyone have an exact number for how much reliability do recon light tanks need in order to move through mountains without taking losses ?
what's the command to activate resistance?
Holy if you guys ouod see the encirlment I just created
4 encircles, entire 80% of the spanish army and half of their land
from barcelona to Malaga
IVE MADE FACIST SPAIN WINNN
YAAAY
100% maybe
yeah, seems like it's linear, even at 98% there is still some losses, only after 100% they stop
Can anyone tell me how to use 100% of factoried in occupied countries,like Denmark and Iceland?
compliance ?
how much soft does super heavy howitzer deal
it’s time for me to go down the historical german path
what is the best motorised division template for single player
yea everything after 100% is useless
use tanks
cant you just check that
no
yes you can
either what the other guy said
or go to special projects
and check
random question, does anyone know what special projects have designers for them besides supersonic jet and mev?
ive seen before
some paratrooper hack where u can make the paratroopers the defenders upon paradrop
is that still possible
how to do it
usually people ask question while playing the game
@dusty sandal what else could i do if naval invasion fails? Should i just bomb them with CAS and Bombers for months and than naval invade? Or should i just nuke them? Or should i naval invade on several locations and not just 1?
¯_(ツ)_/¯
Or should i build amphibious tank divisions?
not needed in sp
marines are usually enough
just get cas
over it
CAS targetting the port or land units?
uhh both
wdym
its always gonna be over those
no i mean when you assign CAS you can select to attack the tank icon or the harbor icon
that would be port strike
so no
use ground attack
i had 100CAS assigned for that and it didnt help. So how many are needed usually?
1000 should be enough

were they trained and did you have superiority?
1000?
if i could afford tanks then i would use tank
oh
motorized is ass do special forces instead
cant atm cause that would overstep the special forces limit
few good units are better than a lot worse units
yeah but ill have to wait until more normal units are recruited before i can enlarge the existing special ones
whats your cas design?
i dont have dlc
i mean im mexico afterall
i cant just print stuff
you think this will do the trick?
probably
what's a good offensive infantry template rn for this meta, 18/0?
yea 36w inf bricks are the best for that
spgs
what if you have low mp
if your about to win you can force attack
you will take less casulties with big units
and for heavy mg or canons ? I just watched a bittersteel video where he says that canons are better, but most of the people I see use heavy mg
on planes?
yeah
this is the best fighter with the range mio, otherwise use the second one
Hey guys when I annex Vichy France I can’t get their equipment except guns ? It’s very confusing
Or planes
how do i complete the pacify ethiopia mission
like what do i actually do
i understand the goal
but how do i reach it
Why doesn't the oster conspiracy fire for me? I have been rejected both Memel and Sudetenland
Also what field marshal skilll is good to pick ? I’m playing Iran
not enough surrender progression ig
thorough planner all the way
You have gotterdamerung?
Can someone give me tips for the invasion of Poland?
logistics, offensive doctrine, charismatic, and sometimes the one that gives max planning buffs
Can i delete the civilian train from production?
just click on it and select armored
yeah and if you have so many trains in stockpile you don't need 6 mils on it
yep
Ok 👍
What are naval bomber Designs ? From land with large frames
how do i complete this decision?
I'm blocked here (ask if you need more screen shots). What should I do ? I've been able to repel any german attack, but I fear I am slowly losing to their air (they out-produce me)
small airframe = 1 engine. Period
you're wasting half the plane right now
didn't let me
your inf is too small for anything and cav recon doesn't do anything but cost a lot
no
what's making them shit rn is wasting half the cost
I know for the size, I've not been able to get a higher conscription law and more guns
less mils on support more on guns
so this ?
1 mil on arty is enough for the whole army
3 or 4 on aa
5 mils on support, one on trains, one or two on trucks, 1 arty (2 if you're in the red), 4 on aa (5 if you're in the red), rest on planes and 10 on guns
and this as for the infantry ? (haven't touched the size yet)
prepare offensive divisions too, stop using the crappy ones (remove their recon btw, it's costly for nothing)
you have no step back DLC ?
hoi4
:(
I'm sorry, I've not been able to get a better one ....
as long as I hold, I'm happy
why the engineer
125? ic
to be honest, there's forts everywhere
forts + hills make for quite the buff
its not half the unit worth of buffs
entrenchment ?
3
entrenchment is like a modifier in battle to your stats
and your units they have no stats
engis are like awesome for large divs
but like
it doesnt do a whole lot on 12w inf
ok, so I get rid of them ?
okok
how should I train units ? 24 at a time or a small amount set on infinite ?
you train for all that you need and then you don't need them anymore
although technically the best way is to train 1 unit infs + light tank recon + support art so you can train them until war begins to farm mastery
what exactly is this? I want to do the trotsky path
thats stalins paranoia if it gets over 80 the civil war will start early
just try to get it low
what can I do to keep the paranoia low?
purge the navy or do inspections
click the paranoia things like army inspections, falsify records, and if you want to, accept the events like the one you had, to reduce it even more
(army inspections etc ... in the event tab or idk how it's called)
no but youll need units behind it if you hold there
notice the italian border
also why units small?
as austria
your manpower is like really limited no
no
well, I used all my pp to get advisors to buff my army
I didn't change the conscription law
I got it by taking the Ministry of Italian Africa, Topple Amhara Rulers, and New Emperor of Ethiopia focuses. When the generals come forward, hire them to get bonuses in their regions. Put your garrisons on a garrison law that doesn't provide a compliance malus - you need suppression, but you need compliance before anything else. Invest in the Ministry of Italian Africa branch to get bonuses to the Colonial Police garrison law, then spend time and resources to develop the region.
you can also do it by making the puppet
Fair, but a lot of Italy's colonial focus options increase non-core manpower, and I think it's best to hold on to Ethiopia.
Im not entirely sure, but if youre gonna start the civil war soon then u can just let paranoia spiral
u only need it low if u need to stall to say do a few more focuses
should I be worried
To clarify, the Ministry of Italian Africa branch should have options you can take in the decisions tab that cost 25 PP and some civs to upgrade the outdated infrastructure in that area. Invest in those to boost compliance in the region - basically, you're heavily investing in Ethiopia to demonstrate that Italy can better manage it than their previous administration.
how do i make paratroopers the defenders on paradrop ive seen that before i think
and do the allies ever guarantee chinese warlord states
To the best of my knowledge, no, but they do generally form a faction with the Nationalist and Communist states against Japanese invasion.
If you're fighting one past a certain date, you should expect to be fighting them all, though you might be able to get Japanese support.
i have a very weird run in mind but cutting to the chase im doing the sino japanese alliance
but i wanna eat the chinese warlord and steal them from china
Are you playing Japan or China?
Japan, a taisho japan
is this only for ingame mechanics or aswell with truble shoting with the game?
I see, I see. I tried something similar a while back - there's generally some tensions with the warlord states anyway, and without the Japanese threat I don't know that they'll necessarily join forces with the big two factions. You might only be able to get one, though - when I tried it they still formed the front while I was busy.
H
When you are dropping
When you click the button and they launch and start fighting the enemy press H
what does h actually do lol
Idk I just know it makes them the defender
MUSSOLINI bro i swear this dude wont help
Well when im in sino japanese alliance i should be able to eat all of them as long as thhey dont get gauranteed
What do you want him to do 😭 😭 😭
China gets annex warlords VERY late in their focus tree, meaning they only have the ability to puppet
Which requires the warlords to be in same faction
And i will not let any in
If you go Facist you get the wargoals early
HE WONT EVEN PARTICIPATE I CALLED HIM5 TIMES
Italy ai only joins if you cap France I believe
i know this is hoi4 community, but authoritarianism is cringe
Lol
But free wargoals
Hey pls can someone help me
-
the medium plane I can’t see how much it’s bombing stats are not sure what to do
-
The basic heavey fighter is it the big frame or medium frame
-
I don’t have carriers and need to destroy ships should I build large or medium frame for naval bombs both for subs and battleships and cruisers in currently using some small frames until more is resseached
MUSSOLINI COUNT YOUR DAYS BRO
hi hazz
Hello
mediums can only be tactical bombers, which cant strat bomb for shit so dont worry about that
heavy fighter are mediums
build small frame ngl with torpedos
Honestly, I feel like the big benefit Italy gives in the war is mostly just opening up new fronts. British divisions that are tied up in Ethiopia and North Africa aren't British divisions backing a push across the Channel.
Of course, that's predicated on Italy actually joining the war. I don't know if you can salvage this, but probably best to push through the Benelux, keep a token garrison to tie up troops at the Maginot, and go historical capitulation of France.
For your naval bombers do a medium airframe add 1 light machine gun then after you can add double torpedos
If you have issues with subs build radar
💔
Incidentally, I'd like to ask for a bit of help about the historical AI. If Italy guarantees Austria and stops the Anschluss, am I correct in assuming that Germany won't push on to Czechoslovakia and Poland?
I DIDNT EVEN SEE FRANCE omg i do this EVERY time blast thru 4x speed and saw france when it reached berlin almost
What diff are u playin on
It depends if they do the focus then they can do Czechs and Poland but if they don’t then they can’t
the normal one
Yeah, I saw it as Allied Italy a couple times. The Maginot is a strong defensive fortification, but France can and does push outwards from it if left long enough. It's a solid fortification - you always have a fallback line.
I mean, let's be honest, Germany is essentially not pushing the Maginot, but they have to counter-fortify that border, because there tend to be a lot of troops there (it's their only major front line with the Axis because Italy hasn't joined).
i dont know , i put area defense on my coast AND france, and 1 second later bOOM
SIGH
i will NEVER play as reich again
only empire
Imperial Germany's a lot of fun, too, though.
I REALLY wanna finish this save but i cant
I'll sometimes just cede naval dominance to the English and join the Allies outright, start an Allied/Comintern war.
yes its so much cooler as a german empire, as reich i just die so quickly oh lord
and i started ww2. cuz of yugoslavia
i was so close to finishing but sadly i cant
On the ahist focus, I generally see Poland go communist and join the Soviets - it's still a lot of fun, it's just that it's mostly fun on the Eastern Front.
is byzantium formable ?
what do you think abt this save
HOLY ITS 1976
I feel you. I had a similar thing as Romania - conquered Europe, conquered Comintern, but kept getting stonewalled by the UK in Africa and at the Channel because I didn't understand supply or the navy.
yes that, AND the fact that when i press play i get 3 fps and cant move the map
Iron Storm moment.
Papal States?
wats that
Go non-aligned Italy, take Seek Papal Support, then finagle things to get His Holiness over 60% on the Balance of Power, and he'll overthrow the House of Savoy and get you a secret focus tree.
Very heavily tank-focused, gets war goals on most of Europe for being Protestant.
I always love it - it's my go-to "non-aligned world domination" strategy.
Habemus Papam, a run you cannot miss, or you'll go straight to hell!
An updated Roman Empire strategy, new templates, new focus and research priorities, and a lot more!
You can find all researches and focuses in the description!
You can find my most updated guides for Italy at this link: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLY4d0TUsYg8LMWGES...
Or you could try to conquer the world as a bear.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FBPdhlwqMwM
🇵🇱 Ready for the most legendary hidden path in Hearts of Iron 4? In this complete Secret Poland Guide, I show you exactly how to unlock Wojtek the Bear as your king and commander! We cover the hidden Focus Tree steps and the optimal setup to crush both the USSR and the Axis to get the secret Artillery Bear achievement! 🐻
📋 Research ...
oh pope
hm
What happens to those argentinian troops if i kick argentina out of the faction and immediatly declare war?
If memory serves, they get "exiled" - have to spend a while getting back to their home territory. You can probably invade then.
you need to get supplies
you're fighting with org capped at 15% and -80% breakthrough, -60% attack penalities
no wonder you're not pushing
Yeah, your soldiers are in critical condition.
Infrastructure in that area's never great, but you need to make sure you're investing as you go in your occupied territories.
Can’t I use large airframe ?
Also what should I do with these I can’t see how much bombing they have
its possible
There’s a nav design you can do with large I believe but I would recommend medium for navs as cheaper ic cost
Ah ok I unfortunately starred reaseaching large frame
You might have to check the design itself to see
I haven’t reaseached medium yet should I start doing it v its 1942 February
I can’t see since it’s foreign but i can use it to convert some no ?
You don’t need to have up to date mediums for your navs
I believe you can convert it as long as it’s the same module date type
You can also just use it for cas
its not actually tank focused
it just gives you bonuses for super heavy tank
which is bad
its funny how bad super heavy tank is compared to how good land cruiser is
when land cruiser is something that couldn't even work in reality
what are some chill achievements to do that are fun
great hunger ig
pretty easy
done
hmm
i need to play on that save to kill britain for palestine
will be ez
i just need to land
Damn truce ruins the plan 😄
Wth is going on here? Its always changing between way too much and not enough
new model ig?
i have that somethimes too
i think its need to be delivered to your units
one is on the field other is stockpiles afaik
just keep a certain amount on tho
If you look at your logi tab are you in a negative balance? Could be that you are producing less then you are losing, but you still have a massive stockpile
Incidentally, how do I use Land Cruiser? I've researched it, but I'm not sure how to best implement it - do you have a division template I should strive for?
good. hbu?
i never actually get to the part in the game where i use it, but it can have few uses
you can stack anti air on it to some silly levels
Patrick a new helper
Inf Brick port garrison :D They are best for defence, not really good offensively ironically.
It's more like a Bunker that can move but shouldn't
yess
what design would you typically use for that
congrats on reddening
Whatever gives you defence and soft attack. I think you can gain insane AA, but you probably don't need that. I don't know the modules by heart tho
ty
you can get like
500 aa
Also ofc you want to add armour to make the div unpierceable, but you probably don't need much for it
Congrats man
Does having a spy network in another country do something by itself?
You gain more intel and if you fight the enemy gets a Planning and Naval invasion defence debuff.
Ok thx
listening music
nice