#ask-for-help-here

1 messages · Page 55 of 1

edgy mesa
#

eh

#

can i make myself democratic?

#

or commu

#

so i dont get beaten

vital geode
#

That reminds me of a meme of a person saying why does everyone invade Russia like this (west to east), instead of this (south to north)?

edgy mesa
vital geode
edgy mesa
vital geode
edgy mesa
pliant condor
# edgy mesa

next time you play put more factory on guns, and if you don't have spy dlc, put whatever land you occupy under harsh quota and prioritize garrison manpower

edgy mesa
pliant condor
#

you want 2 collaboration goverment on basically any nation you would conquer

edgy mesa
tepid umbra
pliant condor
edgy mesa
vital geode
#

That is just handicapping yourself

#

You can toggle seeing AI units at the bottom right

edgy mesa
vital geode
#

You just have it turned off

#

And you cant see the enemy

#

You are fighting ghosts

edgy mesa
vital geode
#

Yes

edgy mesa
#

also how do i know if the dlcs are actually on

tepid umbra
vital geode
#

Home screen i think

#

Main menu

tepid umbra
#

that too

#

but iirc china map is changed

edgy mesa
vital geode
#

Launcher too I guess

tepid umbra
vital geode
edgy mesa
#

it says enabled

#

not enabled but

tepid umbra
#

make a new game

edgy mesa
tepid umbra
#

reload your game

edgy mesa
tepid umbra
edgy mesa
#

i quit and opened the game again

tepid umbra
#

try clicking the thing that says subscription is active?

edgy mesa
tepid umbra
edgy mesa
tepid umbra
edgy mesa
tepid umbra
#

what is poland united and ready

#

scroll up

edgy mesa
tepid umbra
#

huh

#

try asking in tech support

edgy mesa
#

aight

edgy mesa
edgy mesa
#

and another thing if i have the dlcs can i host a world and then my friend can join w/o any

tepid umbra
#

the host of the multiplayer game decides what dlcs are for the game

tepid umbra
#

btw the dlcs might be very overwhelming at first

#

there's a lot of new content

edgy mesa
#

and getting used to that

tepid umbra
#

sure ig

edgy mesa
tepid umbra
#

did you see the tech tree before man the guns got integrated into base game

#

it was so much simpler

#

instead of most of the navy techs there was like 6 ship types and that was it

glacial steeple
#

did they nerf it?

tepid umbra
glacial steeple
#

i believe people are on holiday rn

edgy mesa
tepid umbra
edgy mesa
glacial steeple
neat widget
#

I think there were other nerfs but I haven't tested it

#

the 15% hp might be a broken thing

neat widget
edgy mesa
#

what is a good starting division?

glacial steeple
neat widget
molten needle
#

should i use light spg or medium spg im poaying without any dlc

#

Playing*

#

anyone?

neat widget
#

light won't do too bad i imagine

molten needle
#

i want the most soft attack

#

to do quick encirclements and breakthroughs

neat widget
#

You'd get more from mediums

#

light spgs are just cheaper

trail reef
#

who the hell is this and how do i get her

vital geode
trail reef
vital geode
trail reef
#

how do you even do that?

vital geode
#

And I think another thing as well

vital geode
#

After the events fire

#

Or something like that

trail reef
#

my airwings does not gain experience no matter what

tepid umbra
trail reef
#

0

tepid umbra
#

huh

#

are they training

trail reef
#

nope at the lowest level

#

i try training and nothing happens

#

i try fighting nothing happens

tidal elk
#

Can someone help me I’m brand new

languid trout
coarse finch
languid trout
#

initiative does give faster planning but other than that its not that bad from my experience

coarse finch
#

@tidal elk these 2 videos specifically

iron pike
#

SOMEONE please, for the love of god can someone help me with soft attack and hard attack and breakthrough? like i know what they mean Im just confused on the numbers...... like wth does 100 soft attack mean or 5 soft attack, and how do i know if its effective against the enemy ?? all i know rn is red bubble = loose and green = win but i click the red or green button and dont know why im winning or loosing i just see a bunch of numbers...... please someone

sterile hearth
iron pike
coarse finch
sterile hearth
#

are you germany? @iron pike

iron pike
coarse finch
#

That explains how it actually works

neat widget
neat widget
#

And also hover over the little icons too

sterile hearth
#

ok so lets talk some basic stats. First hardness. A divisions hardness determines the ratios of soft to hard attack. a 0 hardness division will take 100% of an enemy divisions soft attack. 100% hardness means it will take 100% of the enemy divisions hard attack. mix the ratio. so if you division in the example had 50% hardness it would take 5-6 soft attack and 0-1 hard attack. Does that make sense so far? @iron pike

iron pike
sterile hearth
#

I will get to that in a minute. does the ratio make sense? 50% hardness means 50% soft attack 50% hard attack. 25 hardness = 75% soft attack 25% hard attack.

#

I am really neurodivergent so this is how I think and I have a hard time explaining it differently from the step by step way I think.

iron pike
neat widget
glacial steeple
#

10% hardness with no added hp

#

for like 2.5x the cost of cav

sterile hearth
#

you have it right. So once you figure out how many hard attack and soft attack you are going to get hit with, you then will add them up to a total number. so for the above ex

glacial steeple
#

but also soft attack % is decreased

#

like the factor of amount of soft attack that deals damage

#

if youre 10% hardness, 10% of the soft attacks do not do anything

sterile hearth
#

25% hardness = 0.25 hardness. 1-0.25=0.75 0.75=75% so 75% soft attack

#

@iron pike want to jump in helping lounge 1?

iron pike
#

wait let me get my mic

neat widget
# iron pike sorry what??

Basically if a division has 25% hardness, the amount of attack an enemy division inflicts on it is 25% of hard attack plus 75% of soft attack

coarse finch
#

Don't post modern politicians please

iron pike
iron pike
#

wait

#

let me change me input i cant hear u

#

actually ill just dm u

glacial steeple
coarse finch
# iron pike yes i understand this, if a unit defending is 10% hardness, the attacker will us...

Ok so basically copying from the wiki every hour a division is attacking it will take the soft attack and hard attack values based off the enemies hardness stat. And divide those by 10. Thats the amount of attacks something will have. Meanwhile the enemies defense is also divided by 10 get their defenses. So 100 attack is equal to 10 attacks. Now if for example you have something with 1000 attack and the enemy has 500 defense you'll have 50 attacks that are defended which have a 10% change of hitting. And 50 attacks that are undefended which have a 40% chance of hitting. And if an attack hits the enemy will take org and strength damage

coarse finch
glacial steeple
coarse finch
coarse finch
neat widget
#

Should I use jet engines or no

languid trout
#

hopefully they dont nerf it more

neat widget
#

i wonder though if irregular doctrine si better or not

languid trout
#

but militia gets more possible buffs

#

irregular only gets buffs from the guerilla war subdoc in operations

#

as far as i know

neat widget
#

irregular doctrine does buff militia so that's why I ask

#

with a good -0.4 combat width bonus

languid trout
#

that u get instantly when getting it

#

other than that i dont think irregulars get any more buffs than that

#

(besides focuses, especially afghanistan)

neat widget
#

Problem with Afghanistan irregulars is that you get like 24 x 9 battalion units

#

And it isn't that useful dropping it from 18 width to 14.4 width

quartz quiver
#

how to sealion

glacial steeple
plush mauve
#

the whisper command is STILL broken in multiplayer, why?

quick night
#

sp artillery is good in singleplayer right?

neat widget
#

yes

indigo sapphire
#

are ALL of the SPs good to use?

quick night
#

is this good?

quick night
neat widget
#

No

#

Those aren't useful

amber wren
#

is sheep's mod gone?

quick night
neat widget
#

if it is on schedule it will in about a week

indigo sapphire
quick night
quick night
neat widget
#

light, medium, and heavy spgs are pretty decent

#

heavy spgs are probably best if you're going late game

neat widget
#

actually mediums aren't that bad

indigo sapphire
neat widget
#

you don't need that much breakthrough in singlepolayer

quick night
#

im in 1945 i wanna know if ts is good

neat widget
#

this will boost your soft attack value

quick night
#

what should I replace it with?

#

the sloped armor or?

neat widget
#

If you want that much armor you can make a dedicated tank for that

narrow grail
#

These requirements mean that I should build 24 civs and 28 mils in 5 years or just have them? Currently I have 16 civs 14 mils

indigo sapphire
#

are ALL Special projects good to use and utilise?

quick night
neat widget
#

Turrets

#

Yes, I am telling you to make a multi-turreted tank

#

There should also be a small cannon turret, those are expensive but in MP worth it

quick night
indigo sapphire
neat widget
#

You should try all of them at least once I'd say

quick night
past mica
#

What should i do when my game crashes for no reason but only when i play as Spain ?

neat widget
quick night
#

cuz ts is a modern tank I wasnt able to find it for some reason

#

but when I built the medium tank I found it

neat widget
#

But the most useful ones in the early-mid game (so up to 1943 ish) are like

Land: flame tanks, military engineering vehicles, super-heavy railway gun, maybe super-heavy howitzer and its self-propelled counterpart, multi-charge cannon
Air: radar, helicopters, all of the jet techs, mothership aircraft, maybe flying bomb (and if you're late to the air game rocket engines mayyyyyy??? work)
Navy: super-heavy battleship, escort carriers, torpedo cruiser, cruiser submarine, fleet submarine

And the nuclear techs aren't bad either, I'd prefer commercial nuclear reactors to the fission bomb. All of these are roughly in the order of usefulness, except for the navy where they're roughly equivalent

neat widget
#

NO

#

🤦‍♂️

#

My fault, just click the top row

#

and then click secondary turrets

quick night
#

oh ok ty

echo night
#

Im pretty new to the game and the server and Im still trying to learn around hoi4. I had 1 save where I managed to get sealion off in... 1949 but I started a new save where I do it before 42 if possible any tips for sercuring naval dominace to kick it off

echo night
#

I have 0 dlc

#

IM BROKE

echo night
neat widget
echo night
#

oh thank god thx

neat widget
#

I was about to say you can replace the lmg turret with non-strategic materials usage

echo night
#

also quick question not so much help here but why when i build a sub fleet like geramny just as the fuher intended it is dogwater but the second I try building a big fleet with battleships and what not it shreds

placid cove
#

Hello, I remember seening somewhere there was a trick to change template and keep the experience of units. How do I do that? Like I want to make an infantry template, level it to level 3, and then swap it to tank but keep the level 3 experience

echo night
#

also does anyone know what the optimal combat width for marines are

split dirge
#

anything between that

echo night
#

alright

split dirge
#

go 16 width for spam invasions

stuck hinge
#

how do i unlock the bottom part?

twin fiber
#

what country has the most amount achievements i can do in a single run

split dirge
#

like gbp its inf

twin fiber
#

preferrably minor country

stuck hinge
languid trout
leaden cargo
#

is playing historical USSR just spamming mils day 1 and pumping out mediums with 9/0s

#

and then putting them on the Dnieper

dusty sandal
#

For reference, brk stat barely even changes between 1936 to 1943 from 2.5 to 3.5

charred needle
echo night
#

oh my days thank you so much bro

charred needle
dusty sandal
dusty sandal
lone sigil
#

i forgot

dusty sandal
#

Both, combat width is still the same since it's limited by terrain

glacial steeple
lone sigil
glacial steeple
#

only source of break

dusty sandal
fierce idol
#

no dlc, can someone explain air and naval stuff?

kind zephyr
#

what is a good destroyer and battleship template? I also need a good heavy mp advance figher also please.

sand hound
#

I have a big problem: HOI4 just stopped working on my microwave and i'm so sad now

#

any ideas how to repair it?

narrow grail
#

Does training time affect exercise?

quick forum
scenic nacelle
sand urchin
#

is this a good tank template for 1940 germany

ashen sigil
#

Is it possible for Republicians to win the Spanish Civil War with historical focus turned on + I am not even playing as Spain

kind tendon
#

I'm on Mac and have been having problems with troops, especially with aircraft (which, although handed missions do NOT intercept 🥀) and my troops are really slow (they supplied too idk) while the AI's are faster, even though they're not motorized

crystal fox
#

I lost to poland as germany, FOR THE SECOND TIME

#

maybe it was cuz of supply and no Air support cuz i forgot about it

#

but nah

#

Poland had hacks

shut edge
#

anyone have tips for Japan with the dlc?

#

Ive been trying different guides but then I always seem to get stuck after I take nanking, I dont know if its because im not going fast enough, a supply issue, or a simple skill issue but any tips and advice will help

peak elk
crystal fox
#

yeah

peak elk
#

That's okay

#

It means there is plenty for you to learn

#

Go watch bitt3rsteel

shut edge
peak elk
# shut edge Ive been trying different guides but then I always seem to get stuck after I tak...

I had 3 runs with new japan. This is what I recommend you to do.
-As soon as you start the game create a spy agency and start preparing collab governments when you have two but if you want you can wait till you get +1 spy from the focus. I do max collabs because I don't want to go to chongqing.
-Don't do the focus reinforce east hebei garrisons as it will trigger the war earlier. If you do want to go for it early on its your choice.
-I used 9 inf 2 arty with engineer, logistics and support arty as my main division. Built 2 armies of that.
-Take all of your puppet troops and use them as line holders. Put them to the border with the chinese warlords and use the main division to push into china.
-Switch to superior firepower. And get subdoctrines that boost soft attack.
-Only push into china. Encircle whenever you can, wherever you can.
-Don't bother naval invading if you aren't really stuck.
-Don't let them entrench, always have them on the go.
-Focus on supply hubs and railroads. Build and upgrade as you conquer.
-Your enemy has not much of an airforce so use it because cas is king.
-Make sure you have enough trucks and trains.
-I'm not sure if "Senbu" is good or not but I use it for occupation law.

#

If you do all that I think you capitulate china when you conquer all the lands that have proper railroads I'm not sure where exactly but half of china at least.

#

The part where supply isn't that bad

shut edge
# peak elk I had 3 runs with new japan. This is what I recommend you to do. -As soon as you...

so basically

Spy agency- collab governments as quickly as you can

Dont reinforce (Unless I want to go early war)

9inf 2arty eng logi support arty for my main offensive divs, use puppet troops as line holders for the mountains, use superior firepower and stack as much soft attack as I can

Push only into China, dont get bogged down and keep pushing them to make sure they dont entrench, encircle as much as you can and rush supply hubs and railways, and use your airforce

peak elk
peak elk
#

Hebei chahar->Shangdong->China

#

That's what you want

#

At the start rush to beijing and xian and then Qingdao

#

For supply

shut edge
#

alright

#

what about some of the early army stuff

#

like if they want 600k men

#

do I just focus entirely on mils

peak elk
#

Are you in the middle of a japan run? If yes then can you provide me a screenshot?

peak elk
shut edge
peak elk
#

Don't build tanks or anythşng just guns and artillery

#

And supp equipment

shut edge
#

I can pull up the run (im pretty sure I still have it)

peak elk
shut edge
#

if you want I can stream it, I think it should still be somewhat savable

peak elk
#

You got menjiang as a puppet right?

shut edge
#

yep

peak elk
shut edge
peak elk
# shut edge yep

Theres this option to get northern shanxi but I didn't really like it

shut edge
peak elk
#

So itll probably be very laggy

#

What I meant was that I'm not home with a good wifi connection

shut edge
#

ok, current status of my run

#

Im thinking I can regain control back where the cut my frontline inbetween shanxi

#

im SUPER close to their other capital

peak elk
#

Go for beijing

#

Regularly check the surrender progress of china

shut edge
#

the main issue is do I try to just rush for the cap points, or do I try to reconnect my lines

peak elk
#

Wait

#

Hebei chahar is your puppet??

#

How???

shut edge
#

Yeaaaah something weird happened

#

when the war started and I capped em it gave me a peace conference

#

I dont even know how

peak elk
#

Oh

#

Yeah normally when they cap china is supposed to annex them but its kinda buggy

#

So I gtg good luck with your game I hope my advice helps

shut edge
#

ye np

#

yeah no im restarting that shit

devout imp
#

is it worth it to just have my army, navy, and airforce train all the time before ww2? or would the civ cost for all the oil outway the xp gain?

lethal venture
#

could someone help me out on hoi4, i keep doing mp with my friends but i get battered everytime and i want to have a good fight instead of getting rolled

hollow linden
#

Of course if you need naval XP it's good

#

But not beyond that

#

Air is the most important thing to train. It's the difference between winning and losing

#

Having your army not green is also not bad but also not mandatory to have on lvl3

hollow linden
devout imp
crystal fox
hollow linden
#

So don't bother

lethal venture
# hollow linden What nations were you playing?

First time round Italy and it took me multiple years to take ethiopa and then my friend who was playing as britain just rolled through me in the war and then japan and I couldnt win against ai China.

hollow linden
#

And filling all your pp slots is also not the goal

#

You only have that much pp and xp

#

So you need to prioritise

devout imp
#

i see, so i just gotta cut my losses where i can. but im guessing i should at least get my division templates and unit designs ready for the war?

#

or at least get them finished within the first year of ww2

#

I know medium tanks aren't necessary per se, but they're cool to have. and i never have enough xp for ship and plane designs cause of the oil cost to train them

near citrus
#

how do i fix outdated production

devout imp
near citrus
#

if i dont have it researched, do i just ignore the problem until i research it

dapper pilot
#

Heya, i have two questions: Whats the best space marine template with all dlcs, and I cant counter the tanks a friend of mine just pumps out, they are crazily op. Whats the best way to counter them?

hollow linden
hollow linden
#

Just make special forces

devout imp
devout imp
hollow linden
#

You can at max do 2

#

And as Germany for example, army and airforce take priority

#

That's almost always the case

#

Navy takesa backseat

devout imp
#

yeah, im playing as Austria in kaiserreich and i also just ignore the navy. i train them till level 3 and then just have them guard the adriatic

hollow linden
#

But you can make a small navy with just 20 docks

hollow linden
devout imp
#

what about the oil cost to train units? im always completely empty when I train both navy and airforce at the same time (as Austria in KR), is it worth to spend the civs for more oil?

hollow linden
#

Like u don't need all your units at lvl3

#

Also trade for oil if necessary

#

Like running out of fuel is deadly

dapper pilot
hollow linden
devout imp
hollow linden
near citrus
#

how to get more political power?

devout imp
#

yeah im talking before the start of the war

hollow linden
devout imp
#

just to get more xp

hollow linden
near citrus
dapper pilot
hollow linden
hollow linden
#

Or exploit it

devout imp
near citrus
hollow linden
#

DW

#

I'm just surprised

#

Like if you're asking those kinds of questions, have you even opened the game?

dapper pilot
#

So just no line holder infantry, but purely special forces (+ my push units ofc)

hollow linden
#

Theres a tutorial for a reason

hollow linden
devout imp
#

aight

hollow linden
#

How are you going to have sf cap

#

Without normal inf

dapper pilot
#

Im asking what the best option for line holder divisions it, i thought it was space marines

#

And your telling me to do purely sf

hollow linden
#

With support AT

dapper pilot
#

I didnt, sorry. Thank you!

dapper pilot
analog maple
#

guys anyone know how do I rush fr*nce as Germany? i keep tryna attack lebanon after like 70 days but I can't get past Belgium. i managed to once and now i cant do it

hollow linden
#

With support AT

#

Maybe make some inf bricks with at too and go anti tank front line subdoctrine

hollow linden
#

Your enemy will probably have piercing

hollow linden
dapper pilot
#

DE hätte ich früher sehen können lol

hollow linden
hollow linden
rustic acorn
#

und uralt....

hollow linden
dapper pilot
hollow linden
#

Even AI gets piercing

#

I mean space marines have been shit for years now

#

People jusz propagate misinformation

#

Same with artillery especially now

#

It's shit idk why people don't get that

dapper pilot
#

Ok everyone knows line arty is dogshit 🙏

hollow linden
#

Not everyone

#

People are on reddit

#

And swear by 14/4

#

90% of the Player base is shit

#

That's why paradox won't improve the AI

jolly escarp
#

how do I beat japanese empire? they're such a pain

hollow linden
#

Because all the sp warriors will come crying that's its too hard

hollow linden
jolly escarp
hollow linden
jolly escarp
#

hoes is mad

hollow linden
#

It doesn't take 2000 hours to get good

jolly escarp
#

go learn grammar or something

hollow linden
#

Alr whatever

rustic acorn
hollow linden
#

What I can say is that at least the ck3 AI is somewhat competent

#

So they can make a good AI

#

They just won't in hoi4 for reasons stated above

rustic acorn
#

nope, CK3 AI is stupid as well

hollow linden
#

And as a player you're somewhat handicapped by negative events that it at least appears to be good

#

It's still dogshit because ck3 is easy as fk

rustic acorn
#

still I like it

hollow linden
#

But like if u play on hard and harder difficulties u just buff AI into being good

hollow linden
#

I myself have like 1.6k hours

#

That's only 1/5th of my hoi hours

rustic acorn
#

hehehe

signal island
#

Im interested in purchasing some dlcs or atleast one during this sale but im quite sure which ones

edgy mesa
#

what to do here? we keep loosing when attacking

gray veldt
#

Does anyone know why i didnt get the great hungry achivement?

hollow linden
gray veldt
hollow linden
#

Also pls for the love of God turn off nato symbols

#

Idk what your units are

lone sigil
#

also supply

stray trellis
#

Hello,
is there like a spreadsheet for army Templates and Tank designs (Light or Medium)
Right now i have Light tanks and they are so bad.. :c

hollow linden
silk parcel
# edgy mesa what to do here? we keep loosing when attacking

From a quick glance, looks like a few of your troops are suffering supply issues. Unless you've specifically built a small section of railway to connect up to the supply hub in Metz, that supply hub is disconnected. Doing so should fix your supply issues a little bit.

Beyond that, I would concentrate your air there. If you're attempting to reclaim the Maginot, strat bombing the forts/anti-air could be worthwhile to do, assuming you have Tacts or Strats to do so.

Dunno what to say regarding your divisions as I truthfully have no idea what the NATO symbols are.

hollow linden
#

I got this

#

Pins might be outdated since ncns

stray trellis
#

So we focus on SP artillery?

#

even with Light tanks?

hollow linden
#

Ever since doctrine rework normal tanks are redundant

stray trellis
#

kk

lone sigil
hollow linden
#

Spgs are so good now

silk parcel
#

Soft attack is incredibly powerful in SP. The AI doesn't really make good tank divisions - meaning you'll usually have enough piercing/hard attack as is.

hollow linden
#

Speeds kinda irrelevant

sleek remnant
stray trellis
#

Oh right. So a Doctrine meta is there too?

lone sigil
stray trellis
#

Cuz back when I played we had 20 CW with infantry and Artillery

#

and no tank designer

lone sigil
hollow linden
#

The inf doctrine can also be large unit tactics

#

Depends on your needs

hollow linden
stray trellis
#

i need to write that down

hollow linden
#

The reason you move faster than your enemy won't be your high base speed

#

It will 90% of cases be fuel or supply

#

Or the lack of it

lone sigil
hollow linden
#

On while we're on it, don't use artillery

#

It's ass

lone sigil
#

17 armor tick?

#

dawng

hollow linden
hollow linden
#

For the break.

lone sigil
hollow linden
#

That's what armor clicks do!

#

Reading is hard

stray trellis
#

For attack infantry and hold the line infantry

#

still CW16?

lone sigil
#

this gonna scrape you steel

hollow linden
#

I have spgs

hollow linden
#

Tanks aren't cheap

#

Atp you can just not use tanks at all and get the same result

#

Inf is insane as is

#

Tanks Are quite unnecessary

#

But if you were to do tanks, this is how

lone sigil
stray trellis
#

I mean If I play a nation who has a weak tanks

hollow linden
#

It is quite literally linear

stray trellis
#

or no industry for tanks

#

still the same doctrine or?

hollow linden
lone sigil
hollow linden
#

Make special forces

#

Better than tanks anyhow

hollow linden
#

Go back to 1st grade and learn spelling

#

Or the language idk

hollow linden
#

And large unit tactics

lone sigil
hollow linden
#

🤯

stray trellis
#

God thats a lot of stuff to learn

#

again

#

😢

lone sigil
#

hehe

hollow linden
glacial steeple
hollow linden
lone sigil
#

lol

glacial steeple
hollow linden
stray trellis
#

o bottle o water ?

#

@hollow linden Thanks for the infos

#

Gonna try that out in my new game (without getting crushed by AI)

edgy mesa
lone sigil
#

yea pushing with defaukt inf might not get you the best outcome

stray trellis
#

@hollow linden Uhm regarding Special Forces in infantry templates.
the special force cap still exists?

worn juniper
#

does anybody know why everytime my friend tries to join my mp game it says timed out?

worn juniper
#

yeah i did i got egoed

analog maple
#

guys if i get the fails to log map error does that mean that the mod dont work at all?

analog maple
elfin crystal
#

paratroopers or naval invade as germany?

#

uk

#

like

#

incading the uk

stray trellis
#

Ok and how is a legit infantry template?

#

16CW and stuff?

neat widget
#

What we're doing here is increasing the special forces cap so we can convert divisions later

craggy pumice
#

What are best uses for armored car in single player? Recon? Or strictly suppression

lean narwhal
#

Who is stronger, Pennywise or Freddy Krueger?

lone sigil
fossil walrus
#

Do i Annex or Subjugate China, it is 1938

lone sigil
#

there is a focus as italy : expand rome flight schools it sas it reducees the chance that somhone dies in an aircrafaft crash? wwho?

lone sigil
fossil walrus
lone sigil
fossil walrus
#

Do i just make it a puppet from the peace treaty?

lone sigil
#

annex it

#

you have the complaines thingi

#

right?

#

collab

fossil walrus
#

Nope

#

I went straight for changde with the starting army and some microing

lone sigil
#

bro

fossil walrus
#

?

lone sigil
#

uh idk you can just puppet and resoucrse right

#

and factorie steel

#

steal

fossil walrus
#

ooo alright

#

China got 11 factories left😭

lone sigil
#

huh

#

what about warlord?

fossil walrus
#

Uhh

#

I invaded before they formed the faction yk

lone sigil
#

alr you cooked

#

all you eco comes form china

#

have fun fighting us

fossil walrus
#

Thanks

#

My only goal is to nuke Usa

rain iris
#

Which subdoctrine is best for a small country? I am playing Mexico

carmine lichen
#

does japan still give you a white peace if you push them out of china? even if theyre not fascist

lone sigil
#

also they shouldnt attack if they not historical i think

tepid umbra
#

It's free manpower

carmine lichen
lone sigil
stray trellis
#

anything I should add for attack infantry? Ive got flame thrower tanks.

lone sigil
#

but this should work as line holder

#

do you have air?

stray trellis
#

nope

#

Air got destroyed

lone sigil
#

than add anti air

#

very importaint

quaint harbor
#

how do you fix supply fast?

lone sigil
vagrant glacier
#

can anyone help me explain the meta way to get doctrine xp now
when i play germany i use pure 18w inf with support engineer
but now the meta is spg with support arty doctrine

wintry matrix
vagrant glacier
#

do i have to start adding support arty to my inf to get the doctrine or wat

vagrant glacier
#

but i dont wanna produce artillery

lone sigil
#

its cheap

neat widget
#

But yes do add medium flamethrower tanks

#

then your fifth slot can be hospitals

#

do upgrade your engineers to assault engineers once you have the chance

stray trellis
#

noted

#

need to use infantry battalion cuz no indsutry for tanks right now

neat widget
#

Keep in mind you have 300+ tanks per tank division, but with flame tanks you only need 15 for the support company so they are relatively cheap

stray trellis
#

Producing a cheap tank divison right now for the beginning

glacial steeple
#

tanks are so silly

#

a 1 ic design difference is like a 400 difference in the div

neat widget
stray trellis
#

:omg

stray trellis
neat widget
#

Ah yeah

#

why are you on mobile warfare

stray trellis
#

im building tanks right now ._."

neat widget
#

It gives speed but not much else

stray trellis
#

Grand Battleplan?!

neat widget
#

you're better off sticking with grand battleplan

stray trellis
#

Like only 4 Light machine guns and go?

jagged hull
#

I need help can anyone please I'm trying to get my colonials for an achievement please

#

I'm on vc please help

vagrant glacier
#

so whats the best inf doctrine for germany

pastel tinsel
oak jasper
#

I'm looking to start cranking out 1939 destroyers ASAP. There'll be a 70-day window where the only thing missing is the torpedo launchers.

Is it a good idea to initially do the design without torpedo tubes, then alter the design the moment the advanced torpedo launchers finish?

pastel tinsel
neat widget
#

in either case you should max out HMGs not LMGs

#

LMGs and cannons may be for if you're doing air early

pastel tinsel
stray trellis
neat widget
#

heavy

#

i meant medium frame

#

you can't do heavy frame fighers rip

stray trellis
#

oh no

#

i saw this pic

#

and later switch to

carmine lichen
#

is there a way to stop british troops from coming? ive been destroying the indians but if these british troops come then im completely cooked

neat widget
neat widget
#

Yeah this does perform worse but well, going down two research branches is oof

dapper pilot
#

whats the next improvement to make and when? its currently 1936

carmine lichen
vital plinth
#

Can someone help me I’m new to game and I’m very frustrated because it’s hard to understand and very hard to get help on Reddit because a bot keeps removing post over some weird rule that I can’t seem to understand or fill probably and I’m at the edge of my anger 😪

I’m playing the tutorial, and tried to invade Ethiopia as Italy but my armies stopped around here and don’t move and then they also get a lot of red pins like attrition and low organization
I have no idea what’s wrong and I watched a video guy but either I am stupid because I can’t remember much of what’s mentioned too overwhelming for me, and I also don’t know what to do if I jsut playing the game so it’s back and forth loop

vital plinth
vital geode
jagged garden
vital geode
#

Shift right click to queue

lyric prawn
# vital plinth I know nothing bro some explanation please 😅

That is the guy that appears when you click the button left of your generals. You can shift and click on your generals and then press the field marshal to assign your generals to one. To simplify it, you can basically use him as an extra general that commands your assigned generals all at once.

leaden jay
#

is there a fix

vital geode
#

And change it

fading fern
leaden jay
vital plinth
vital plinth
tough stone
#

Any suggestions for a good nation in a first MP game, I have 500hrs just not sure about MP yet

lyric prawn
lyric prawn
stuck garnet
#

Low org causes slow movement

#

?

lyric prawn
#

I’ve not played for a long time I’m not sure at all but mby

vital plinth
lyric prawn
karmic terrace
#

How do I paratroop britain

vital plinth
lyric prawn
leaden jay
#

how do i fix this?

vital plinth
#

Can I max use 15 civilian factory to build 1 civilian facttory ?

oak jasper
light knoll
# karmic terrace How do I paratroop britain

you will either build an airforce or just wait for them to not have planes up, and paradrop on ideally like a port and the 2 tiles next to it, then you ship your army via the port

#

you can't really cap them immediately unfortunately like france

karmic terrace
karmic terrace
#

Niice this long ahh war is gonna end finally

grizzled surge
#

Can I naval invade from San Diego all the way to Tokyo?

oak jasper
#

So: if I understand correctly, Free Trade always reserves 80% of your strategic resources for export, even if you're not presently exporting? I just ran out of steel, and it looks to me like I either need to spend a few civs on import or change my trade law.

vagrant glacier
#

whats the meta naval bomber design

rustic acorn
#

you can go from Guam

pulsar beacon
#

what is the best inf/armor templates for 1941 soviets
also should i start mass producing army divisons in 1939-1940 so that i get minimum 200 divisions before invasion

dawn dove
#

how good is this template

rustic acorn
#

yo man, endtime tank... looks good

dawn dove
rustic acorn
dawn dove
#

ye i already took london

cold garnet
dawn dove
#

no

#

not yet

#

i add two more mech

#

for org

cold garnet
#

ok,

image hasn't loaded for me but it is prolly good enough

pliant condor
neat widget
#

Something's not adding up

#

also motorized recon and no flame tanks

deft onyx
rustic acorn
#

no, they are missing was meant

deft onyx
#

Yeah

#

I just realised

#

😭

rustic acorn
#

all fine

deft onyx
#

I was gonna say though

#

Flame tanks are peak

neat widget
#

They have motorized recon and no flame tanks

#

which is bad

deft onyx
#

Motor recon is mid in my opinion

rustic acorn
#

it´s what is missing to perfection

deft onyx
#

1k soft attack is needed trust

#

Totally not overkill

neat widget
deft onyx
neat widget
#

except if you go for assault infantry, in which case it gives less breakthrough than just using tank recon

#

and often less breakthrough than armored car recon

deft onyx
#

Its budget for assualt inf

deft onyx
neat widget
deft onyx
neat widget
# deft onyx

Ideally you'd use medium flame tanks but yeah fair

#

also probably replace one of your artilleries with something like hospitals, logistics, or armored signals

deft onyx
deft onyx
#

I just dug that up

dawn dove
#

hm

deft onyx
#

From september

dawn dove
#

i did miss the flame tanks

#

ill have to make those

neat widget
#

light flame tanks are useful for paratroopers or if you are like trying to buff a unit that is like 1000 ic total

deft onyx
#

I use mediums now

#

Because they are better

#

But i used light before because i liked to mass produce them

#

And slam them into infantry

neat widget
#

Light tank recon can be really cheap

#

cost should be 4.48 * 24 = 107.5 for the light tank recon

deft onyx
#

Yeah

#

Thoughts on this naval battle btw?

neat widget
deft onyx
#

Because of flame tanks

#

They are so peak

neat widget
#

Yeah

deft onyx
#

No flame tanks = not good tank template

nocturne cloak
#

Hey... @gentle crest It wasnt me...

#

Hey... @stoic charm It wasnt me...

lapis estuary
#

Yo, I was playing as Romania. My friend and I were fighting France when USSR js puppeted me out of nowhere, without a war or anything like that. Are there like scripted events for this or?

leaden jay
#

can my infantry convoys be sunk without the enemy having naval superiority?

tribal stratus
#

Sea lion not working bro, how do I get the British to stop defending south London?

wintry kernel
#

its my 4th time playing ethiopia i succesfully defended against the italians but iw was very late since the sultan declared independence and i could not reclaim my empire because they joined the allies i tried to attack it but i got destroyed by the allies i did a good defence tho untill i capitulated any tips?

#

im kinda new to the game too

tribal stratus
#

There’s literally nothing I can do

#

In the middle of the war with the Soviets too, it’s only August 1940 and I have Moscow but wtf do I do

#

Also straight out of man power

wintry kernel
# leaden jay nice

T h i hoped the axis do smth but what did i expected when i literally destroyed italy😭

tribal stratus
#

If anyone could help it would be appreciated

#

Because this might be my first 100% world run

tribal stratus
#

It’s not about that, I’m out of man power regardless.

vital geode
#

What are you consuming fuel on

tribal stratus
#

I have the necessary plans.

vital geode
tribal stratus
#

Nothing really, I guess I’m doing an infantry only build with planes and some motorized infantry

tribal stratus
vital geode
#

You are on limited?!

tribal stratus
#

I don’t have any resources anyway since my trade routes are fried

vital geode
#

Get to extensive conscription

tribal stratus
#

Don’t have the political power

#

I should have earlier, it was dumb.

vital geode
#

You only suffer penalties service by requirement and after

tribal stratus
#

That’s not my problem though, I can disband a few units if I have to

#

The issue is how do I get dominance over the Uk southern England?

#

I have probably 3,000 planes

vital geode
#

Use your air force when you have oil

#

3000 is nothing

tribal stratus
#

How would I get oil, as Germany with all my trade wiped out

vital geode
#

If Iran flipped, then you just trade with Romania

tribal stratus
#

I just traded with Iran, but there’s no way to get instant superiority or something

vital geode
#

Or you spam refineries

vital geode
#

There should be no issues

tribal stratus
#

I mean over London, I thought you could glitch it. To where if you held ur Air Force

#

You’d be able to

#

I guess that’s parhced

#

Parhced

#

Patched

vital geode
#

So no drop for you

#

Also paradrops on England always results in your paratroopers getting shredded

tribal stratus
#

I know. I landed a few

vital geode
#

What is the status of the Eastern Front?

tribal stratus
#

Going decent, Moscow taken.

vital geode
#

Finish the Soviets, then turn to the UK

tribal stratus
#

Only 55% capitulation though less probably

vital geode
#

Take the caucuses

#

Fall Blau

#

Case Blue

tribal stratus
#

will America automatically join in at 1941? Even if I’m not aligned with Japan?

vital geode
#

Get the oil

tribal stratus
#

when in 1941, it’s August 1940 currently

vital geode
#

Japan declares on the US and Allied colonies, bringing the US into the allies

#

What is the status of the kriegsmarine

tribal stratus
#

shit I’m bad with navy

#

Nothing

vital geode
#

You might have more luck with a naval invasion

#

Do you have a surface fleet

#

Or is it gone

tribal stratus
#

In the channel?

#

I have the base fleet I assume

vital geode
#

Okay, it can work

tribal stratus
#

I just assigned some admirals

vital geode
#

Dont use it now

tribal stratus
#

Hoped for the best

vital geode
#

Because you have no fuel

#

You are not going to cap the UK before the US joins

tribal stratus
#

I know.

vital geode
#

So just focus on the Soviets

tribal stratus
#

Alright then, thank you.

vital geode
#

And maybe get a small D-Day wall and garrison Italy

tribal stratus
#

I’ll push down south and try to capitulate fast

vital geode
#

Italy has a bad habit of dying

tribal stratus
#

yeah I know, they are always useless

#

sad

vital geode
#

Push from Moscow to Rostov by following the railroads

#

And encircle Ukraine

#

You can also go directly to Stalingrad

#

Your choice

tribal stratus
#

I’ll try that. Thank you.

vital geode
#

Also use field marshal frontlines

tribal stratus
#

I have Finland in my faction strangely enough

#

Really, why?

vital geode
#

Select the field marshal and hold left shift when you click

tribal stratus
#

Does it make any difference

#

I thought it made virtually no difference

vital geode
#

It will equally distribute all troops under 1 frontline

tribal stratus
#

Aha.

#

Alright

vital geode
#

Make sure you delete all frontlines before that

tribal stratus
#

Yeah I will thanks

celest quartz
#

Yo

#

I need guide lol just downloaded the game today

#

im kinda getting overwhelmed to how much sheesh there is on the game LMFAO

#

any advice on how I can learn faster

vital geode
celest quartz
vital geode
#

Yeah

#

It isnt great, but it is a start

#

If you have By Blood Alone, turn it off

#

Makes the tutorial not as painful

celest quartz
#

where do I find the tutorial cuz it kinda put me straight to a country HAHAHAHAH

vital geode
#

You play Italy for the tutorial

celest quartz
#

joke

#

HAHAHAHHA

vital geode
#

It gives you advice on what to do

celest quartz
vital geode
#

And how to do it

celest quartz
#

so thats the tutorial

#

i picked yugoslavia 😭

vital geode
#

Once you finish fighting Ethiopia, stop the tutorial and boot up a new Italy game that isnt the tutorial because the tutorial nerfs you

#

Wdym

#

There is literally a button called tutorial

#

How are you playing Yugoslavia

celest quartz
vital geode
#

Main menu

celest quartz
#

theres like

vital geode
#

Singleplayer

celest quartz
#

new game

#

so i picked new game

#

and

#

then I pick yugoslavia

#

bro the fact that theres soo man buttons make my head kinda hurt HAHAHAHAH

vital geode
#

Are you all the way in the main menu

#

Like the starting screen

celest quartz
#

I kinda restarted my laptop cuz it was lagging so I came back here to ask some advice hehe

#

but yeah lemme open it up real quick

vital geode
#

Oh no

#

What laptop do you have

#

Is it a good one or a mediocre one

celest quartz
celest quartz
#

it works on big games though like Suzerain and stuff

#

and yes your grace or bonefire

vital geode
#

Suzerain is not a big game

celest quartz
#

HAHAHAHAHAHA

vital geode
#

How well does it run Minecraft lol

celest quartz
vital geode
#

Because you are going to have a very long game if it struggles to run Minecraft

#

Bro

#

Minecraft is 27 USD, hoi4 with dlc is over 100

celest quartz
#

I only bought HOI4 cuz it had a discount and I couldn't miss the chance

vital geode
#

Nearing 200 probably

junior rivet
celest quartz
#

theres was a 70% discount bro, I couldn't let that pass

vital geode
#

Either case, game is going to run slow, but is playable

#

Basically watch the tutorial

#

Play the tutorial

celest quartz
#

like even if it doesn't run well, atleast if I get a new laptop I dont have to buy 2500 pesos for the game

celest quartz
vital geode
#

Watch the first one

#

@celest quartz

celest quartz
left glacier
#

🦒

tribal stratus
#

Thanks for the help

#

Very happy

#

Now the allies

rustic acorn
#

GZ 🙂

tribal stratus
#

Does it matter at all

#

That I forgot to annex

#

The Chinese pinsuela

#

Stalin is currently living there

#

By Alaska

rustic acorn
#

chinese peninsula in Alaska? must be alternative somewhat

tribal stratus
#

It’s not in Alaska