#mop-discussion
1 messages · Page 7 of 1
@crystal robin thank you, I will look into it when I get home from work
@crystal robin thanks for sharing your logs - it's clear to me that I am doing something wrong haha. I feel as though I am confused on slam vs HS usage. Do you tend to use it only during procs and otherwise slam?
HS only used when you have ample rage for it to not impede your rotation (60+)
there are quite a few times I can recall getting incite buff, and not being able to use HS
and the buff going to waste
slam is used at any time when you cant MS, CS, OP
Got you. I might make a WA - I think I am constantly overcapping or over using rage.
Thank you so much, this has been helpful. Do you use any DPS cooldown macros?
you mean for like deadly calm/ reck/ bladestorm?
if so I only macro bladestorm to put me in zerker before spinning
Alright. Maybe I just need to get good. I've never understood when yo use inner rage outside of maybe when I get to 100 rage or something.
Anyway thanks again, heaps to think about 🙂
inner rage is
very very seldom
I bet if you go through
every single fight in my logs
you wont find 5 uses
Thank god
haha yeah you barely press that one
I think the only consistent time I think I cast it is
2nd boss in vortex pinnacle
I will warn u if u decide to ask questions in there
search in the search bar your question and variants of it before asking
Haha I won't ask, just look
they enjoy being prickly in there and fucking with ppl

lol ya its why I cant talk in there for more than small amounts at a time
Maybe I don't need to, when looking at their links for rotation it just goes to wowhead anyway, which is just sort of what our abilities do. Your logs are a bit more useful anyways 🤷♂️
nah
read the entire
info page
I say it like that so ppl read all the rules(important part at the bottom)

it tells u how to unlock the discussion channels
Yeah had that, cheers.
People that play Arms on Cata
do you have /use Berserker Stance under Execute, Mortal strike and shit
and /use Battle Stance for Overpower and Thunder Clap?
Just wondering
Yeah you only need to be in battle stance briefly for Rend OP and TC whilst the rest can remain in Berserker Stance given you so more DMG in Berserker with the 10% damage
abilites that require battle, macro battle into them. Everything else is zerker
and the macro is a little more than just an extra line of swapping to the stance, Ill post a couple that you can use as a template for your own macros
#showtooltip Mortal Strike
/startattack
/cast [nostance:3] Berserker Stance
/cast Mortal Strike
#showtooltip Overpower
/startattack
/cast [nostance:1] Battle Stance
/cast Overpower
@crystal robin
I have wondered what is the difference between this macro here and just typing '/cast berserker stance'?
I thought at first the macro I mentioned doesn't work but I tried it recently and it does cast the stance and also the attack at the same time.
its really just the start attack line
which just keeps your character attacking at all times
Ah that's fair! Thanks for the clarification
In hc raidng i need more then 26 expertise? Last time i got like 10 parry:/
26 you are 100% fine attacking from behind, no dodges or parries
perhaps you were in front of the boss at those 10 parries
how atak Magmaw begind? this impasible ;/
magmaw is a hard one for sure xD
I've been told if you hug the very far left or right of Magmaw then it'll class you as behind him. No idea id that's true tbh but I feel I get less parry's when I hug the walls
I’ve always approached this as “go to where the pets go”
Especially for someone like Magmaw where it’s ambiguous as to where actually it counts as behind behind him
whats up with the wowhead arms guide showing 3/3 Incite but in the written part it says use blood and thunder ?
its just lazily put together
the author also doesnt intend on much upkeep for it
id say play blood and thunder always, 3/3 incite compared to B&T on single target is only a couple hundred dps
but on aoe blood and thunder is a lot more
also I believe what you are mentioning says "in cleave fights"
Hello just joined this channel after spending a bit too long trying to figure out if whirlwind would be an useful addition to my bars or just bloat (as an arms warrior). Seems to be slight (minimal) dps increase on 5+ targets over cleave. What do you think? 🙂
tbh as arms just unbind it
its pretty dead ability
you could press it, and it may be a slight gain in aoe for padding overall damage in a dungeon or something
or do what I do, and just throw Thunder clap into my rotation in place of slam and do single target on the dangerous mob in the pack to murder it
Cool thanks for the quick reply 😄
Unless you PvP, you can definitely get away with playing as if battle stance was locked in. Heck, you can get away without stance dancing if you find it annoying. It won't be optimal but you're certainly not throwing by doing so
You just macro all of your abilities to swap your stance and don’t think about it
And it’s quite a significant damage loss to only sit in battle
dunno if someone replied, but for magmaw, tank is supposed to tank him in a corner, and everyone else stacks on the other corner, that way youre considered behind him and wont get parried
@restive gorge I got my 2nd 359 offhand, and played fury for the first time in raid.. I loved it!!! dont know when ill go back to arms but prolly not until heroic prog hahaha
Hey! got some questions Regarding CTC , im at 75% atm and im not sure how good that is
what acronym is ctc
oh its avoidance
uh you want 102.4% total
but thats legit all I know about tanks perhaps someone can help you in fight club
(check the pins for the invite)
alright
Hey guys, quick question maybe someone can help me. I just got the Fury of Angerforge trinket and now am asking myself if i have to delay my 2 min cds at the opener because i cant use fury of angerforge without 5 stacks.. so do i wait at the opener until i have 5 stacks and then press my 2 min cds all together or do i just use them unsynced on cd? maybe someone can help me. I used the tol barad exalted trinket until now didnt have that problems with that
I just send deadly calm then when I get 5 stacks I send reck
and after u just use everything on cd?
yeah but i mean do you wait on your second deadly calm for your angerforge cd or you just send it when its rdy?
Just use it with Deadly Calm or Reck, in your case in your second Deadly Calm should be good
In magmaw for example, if you Deadly Calm at the beginning. You have it for the first and third head
So you have trinket on first and thrid head as well
And the deadly calm + trinket sweeping strikes combo on the head, with an add besides it. Pumps
been looking through the chat and saw Ms - filler - filler - ms with cs>op>slam as prio which seems resonable but sometimes i have 1-1,5~ sec cd on mortal strike do i slam inbetween or wait out the cd? Feels like the slam + global delays ms too much.
ya just send slam
cool cool
just send everything on CD you really only need to be mindful for your HS usage
hi everyone , is there some 1 who can help tome ? i want to tank on cata i know as every patch prot warriors are on 3-4 rd place
so is it good idea to tanking on cata or not ?
Just play what you enjoy
If you want more information on prot warrior check the pins of this channel for the fight club discord
Hello is there anyway u can wall marco without the delay on the marco? that u epiud the weapon and shield to press wall two times is so annoying any ideas?
it seems like generally you need to better follow the priority of CS(no debuff) > MS > OP > SLAM
you cast a lot of slam
also on maloriak, dont press whirlwind its a dead button
just do ST with cleave in place of Heroic Strike, and pressing Tclap on CD to cleave
but for example on Omnotron defense, you dropped slaughter 3 times throughout the fight, on a fight with 0 forced downtime is a big loss
your opener on the same fight is also very cursed
if you want more/better help you can go to the discord in the pins and they can further help
I just kinda did a quick glossover
Need some help, I cant wrap my head around what im doing wrong exactly, i feel like i follow the rotation correctly but the other warrior is always outdpsing me by alot
anytime i check, he has like a shitton more dmg done with heroic strike and Im confused if im not casting it enough or maybe i need to cast it more often?
Which one are you? There’s 3 warriors on this log
oh yeah sorry
juggaboom
It looks like you are missing some casts of mortal strike, and you are also just missing globals
You might just be slightly slow which will add up
I’m on mobile so it’s kinda hard to tell rn
But like magmaw for example the other guy had +6 CPM more than you did
This includes OGCD stuff, but it doesn’t necessarily mean the 6cpm is made up of that, ya know?
But, for me since I have tier Mortal Strike is almost never below Overpower in terms of my damage breakdown
Barring parries or something stupid
for magmaw i jump on the head
he doesnt
so i think that affects some casts
what do you mean by globals
I think im missing mortal strike cuz when im focusing the big add, i have the blood and thunder talent
so im thunder clapping the add and magmaw to refresh rend instead of mortal striking
You know how when you press mortal strike or overpower you can’t press the other immediately? That’s the GCD or Global Cooldown
And if you are going up on magmaw your parse and damage is fucked anyways bc you likely stop slaughter
yeah so not being on mobile I can now get a good look at the timeline and see exactly what you are pressing
mortal strike needs to be every 3rd global, not every 4th
This is your atramedes kill: as you can see, you cast 3 things in between each MS twice in a row
@crystal robini see, i think i always cast slam then MS
and was thinking that im doing it on time
another mistake
when execute comes you just press execute and forego Mortal Striking at all
which you lose a TON of damage by dropping slaughter
oh i see
yteah thats definitely bad lol
after the first 14s of execute you are just straight up losing almost 30% damage
i think my biggest issue is trying to figure out when to use slam and heroic strike
and also when to use recklessness and deadly calm too
its pretty simple:
Heroic Strike any time above 75 rage OR when you are inside of deadly calm window
Slam is used when Mortal Strike, Colossus Smash, or Overpower are on cd/no Taste for Blood
DC for first use on pull to build rage/slaughter and then recklessness after it
assuming 2 uses
bump
yep 
pretty sure sending it with lust is also a fine thing to do, though im playing arms kinda casually in cata so min/maxers logs would be a better indicator
check ahlaundoh
ahlaundoh is like diehard parser no? i feel like he doesnt resemble a good fight chaos
He may play in a very well coordinated group, but his situational awareness is through the roof
the best use of cds will be shown in hisl ogs, whether or not he sends reck with lust specifically.
yeah just send in execute
No problem brotha! Best of luck to you!
https://classic.warcraftlogs.com/character/eu/golemagg/mazbannogh what actually makes my logs grey, means i do something fundamental really really wrong, what is it?
The number, and color of the parse represents your damage on that fight as a percentile compared to the rest of the arms warriors that have killed, logged, and posted their damage to warcraftlogs
If you get a grey you are most definitely doing something fundamentally wrong
Any tips on using Fury of Angerforge as Arms? It's listed as BiS, but since changing to it my parses have gotten much lower. I assume its a skill issue on my part.
Do you stance dance in cata or no?
You macro it into your abilities and don’t think about it
You pretty much just send ASAP, unless the fight timing dictates the build up of the trinket will cause you to lose a cast, then you switch off of it for impatience
do you macro inner rage and berserker rage into your abilities? or are there dmg windows you should use them in?
Good day fellas! Could anyone give feedback on this fight? It's a guildie and he feels he's playing it correctly but getting lower numbers than expected.
https://classic.warcraftlogs.com/reports/xn8QGdy2bLR6jMpV#fight=last&type=damage-done&source=1
any idea why runeforge lite is trying to reforge exp - spirit?
gotta use a preset, if not it will try to just cap 8% hit at any cost (even if it has to put useless stats)
he looks pretty good outside of execute, his looks like this:
should be more something like this:
you only need to weave in MS to refresh slaughter(very important), or OP if you have no rage to press anything else
His opener isn't great, he didn't charge in, he wasted a gcd inside deadly calm by using rend.
He should have lined up fury of angerforge with a colossus smash.
In my opinion execute phase needs to look like, Execute, Execute, colossus smash if available, mortal strike, over power, Execute, execute.
Weaving mortal strike buffs your execute damage by %10, weaving overpower gives a chance for you to gain some rage back instead of dumping execute constantly and being rage starved.
Lots of little weird things he does that aren't optimal but he's not doing bad by any means.
Yeah hes certainly a decent player. He just wants to be able to learn how to minmax it a little better so your input is very good!
Also note overpower needs to be weaved to maintain our set buff.
Happy to help if I can!
need some help on when to pop CD's. Do we pop deadly calm + recklessnesss on pull and then pop inner rage + berserker rage + fury trinket after?
@crystal robinbrotha do u have a WA for fury? or do u just have it on macro, i wanna track the stacks to know when i can use it
I use a weakaura
@crystal robinmind sharin g?
its from ahlaundoh who has people sub to gain access to his weakauras, and locked behind a cypher so youd have to go sub to get it
I prefer to play it yes
is the playstyle like retail fury or different?
its not as bad as people make it seem
different
rampage is a raid buff in cata, not a button to push
I’ve noticed on the logs I’ve seen that they are not using inner rage is there no benefit from this cool down? Not sure why it wouldn’t be used
You can use it when you have lots of rage incoming
Which is almost always never
Can’t really afford to suddenly rage starve if you’re a stance dancer
should you be using berserker rage off CD? sorry brand new to warrior
Unless there's an incoming fear or incapacitate that I can dispel with it, I use it whenever is up, when combined with the glyph it generates extra rage
Might not be the best usage, but it is what I do
I was honestly going to just macro it into my abilities lol not sure if that is best... how often in raid are you getting feared, sapped, etc.
@crystal robin yo i noticed from ahlundoh replays that him and the other warrior always run back and charge in, whats the tech behind that
im assuming its for rage? but I cant figure out when in the rotation do they do that
My guess is rage but without seeing it I don’t know for sure
And they’d do it when they have nothing to press and in between auto attacks
Charge weaving
I wanna say this was a thing until maybe Legion. Then later expansions you’re just swimming in so much rage that you really don’t have to do this anymore
yea, and when you go to do it make sure you dont delay your auto attack
got a question if anyone can help, our warrior always pulls threat over and over on cho'gall, this is the only boss it ever happens on, our tank never loses threat ANY other time and even tends to take threat from the other tanks just from doing damage so i have no idea what's going on, this happens EVERY time we do cho'gall
https://classic.warcraftlogs.com/reports/tm8PcRXBT3rkJ9v1#fight=66&type=threat&source=5
is cho'gall just bugged?????
warrior is not taunting or doing anything special, he just takes aggro somehow
I cant presume to know for certain, but the only "weird" thing I see i nthis log is your prot pala spamming the fuck out of taunt
he had to
the warrior kept taking threat
our paladin has no problems generating threat and the warrior somehow kept getting aggro on the boss
in fact the boss took a swing at our hpal for no fucking reason
chogall kinda does that on my raid too, I take some swings every now and then
we started thinking he attacks second threat or something, but the stupid boss was attacking our hpal after he killed the warrior
literally makes no sense
game is broken
yeah I dunno I dont think this has ever happened a single time to us
everyone who has looked at the logs has no idea wtf cho is doing lol
rightfully so
but he does this to us most weeks
Does the warrior player have threat plates or any indicator of threat? Might sound shitty but he may just have to stop attacking all together for a minute
Hello fellow warriors. Do you use a macro/addon to change impatience and angerforge?
Should u cast sweeping strike before bladestorming? Or does it not add to the dmg
You’re not meant to according to all of the guides I’ve seen, though I haven’t tested it myself
Cho is attacking the warrior at this point even though he has way lower threat and aggro. Blizzard confirmed it's a known bug with no known workaround. Guess we'll just wipe on hc prog anytime he feels like trolling us
it does add damage, but its not the best use of it. the only time its optimal to cast sweeping + bs is when you wont get a full use of sweep before/after the bladestorm
HEy i've been trying to figure out my Prot warrior. but i cant seem to find the right way to tweak it. using that Auto "avoidance warrior" on Transmog. but i ended up with like 78% avoidance, 32% Expertise and 1.8% hit.. i have full prot gear and i'm 349 ilvl -.-
As threat isn't a big deal in Cataclysm due to the 500% increase, any preset on any reforge addOn will completely ignore threat-generating stats such as hit, expertise or critical strike, and will focus on maximizing survival rate. If you want more of those stats you can have them but you will be losing some avoidance. Also remember that Taunt, Challenging Shout and Pummel can't miss in Cataclysm, so you don't need any stat for them
As long as you are pressing buttons and landing some hits you will be fine
Does anyone have a weak aura for Fury of Angerforge?
there is some essential macro for pve on arms ?
Make sure you have your stance dance macros, and also you can macro Rend/Overpower with charge, like this
Charge+Rend
#showtooltip [nocombat] charge;rend
/cast Battle Stance
/cast Charge
/cast Rend
This will get you in melee range if you are not, and if you are it will just use Rend instead of Charge (Change Rend for Overpower if you want to use it with Overpower, it works the same way)
im only getting a few hundred dps increase for ashkandi vs. another 272 weapon.. is that what ya'll getting as well? is it not a big dps increase for us?
A few hundred is quite a large leap assuming the same item level
1% extra damage just bc it’s ashkandi and not something else at the same ilvl is nuts
^ it is quite the upgrade really
since heroic strike resets seing timer, should i only be using it right after the swing hits?
sqing timer*
swing*
wait... i think my swing timer addon is bugged, looks like heroic is resetting the timer, but i still see white hits mid swing timer after hitting heroic strike
HS doesn’t reset swing timer
yea looks like im using a bad swing timer addon, any reccomendations?
You likely just need to have the weakaura or add on (i forget rn) that adds the correct timer to your swing
I can look for it rq and link
appreciate it!
Just have this and your swing timer should show properly
If not just try a different swing timer off of wago
thanks!
noticed that the top arms parse on wowlogs isnt using fury of angerforge, but heart of rage and impatience of youth, are those two BIS?
2nd best arms is using angerforge and heart of rage though
i spose its pretty close
It’s right dependent
Fight**
Mostly the length of the fight
The condition for change being: whether the build up time of anger forge will cause a loss in use
That translates to a fight length of about 2m-2m30s
And every subsequent 2 mins after
So not looking at the log, I’d guess there’s a high chance of the fight length being within the parameters I discussed above
I see, so for my group thats barely doing heroic raids angerforge is better, but if the boss fights only 2 minutes might as well grab the other trinket
Well this includes every subsequent 2 mins after 2 mins as well
So 2m-2m30s, 4m-4m30s, so on and so forth
But its most likely just better for you to use angerforge yeah
hi guys i need help with rotation/macros for waarrior in cata
my parse is bad haha
can someone give me a guide to follow or something cause my logs are grey i think im doing something werong, as mentioned in this thread earlier
check the pins for a discord link
that discord has more "ground level" information, for lack of a better term
Might want to link your logs when asking too btw, itll help those who have the time to help.
Mortal Strike on CD for Slaughter stack uptime (3 stacks) and only MS during execute phase to maintain the buff.
Overpower with Taste For Blood procs
Slam to fill
Heroic Strike when above 75 rage or inside Deadly Calm
Don't Bladestorm on ST
Macro /cast Berserker Stance into everything barring Overpower (MS, Slam, HS, Cleave, Colossus Smash).
Make sure you're uptime on the boss is as high as practicable.
Hit to 8% Expertise to 26 then Crit ->Mastery-->Haste
from a real quick glossover of your chimaeron kill. You consistently will press slam over ms just as it comes off of cooldown
the cadence ends up as something like MS -> x ->x -> MS
the x's anything else and what this means is MS should be every 3rd global
also the execute phase, you used exe as filler when it should be above everything aside from MS to maintain slaughter
I also dont really keep up with who provides what raid buff
but having all casters, and no melee buffs seems like it kinda fucks you up a bit too, though the rotational issues are worth more
I also dont see battle shout in your raid buffs?
@crystal robin yeah i might have been a little slow in the head during the raid fight, i've had a lot of issues with rage management earlier but now i've stopped using hs as frequently and it feels a lot betteer
i wil ltry conclave of wind hc today and see how my parse are
do you stop using overpower in execute phase?
@crystal robinhttps://classic.warcraftlogs.com/reports/L7YpVnW4ChKwvzTk#fight=last&type=damage-done
first time I actually survive a halfus fight lol
how the hell do you parse this awful fight
You ideally only want to pump Exe with MS thrown in to keep slaughter and enrage up.
You can OP if you're low on rage and in between white swings
do you guys have any tips for addons to use?
parse on al akir or halfus?
both boil down to how unethical are u and are u willing to smack the damage ampd boss> the adds u need to kill
🙂
Not much addons but weakauras if u need help with warrior
You can search for addons for everything you need, i took one addon and broke it down and only took what i wanted from it
Tracking rend and cs, tracking fury stacks, tmw is an addon i use to track cds
Hey cata warriors, is this our primary home for seeking out improvement or are there other Cata specific discords for us?
Check the pins
Not cata specific, but encapsulates all of classic
@crystal robin I appreciate the response, I found the pinned comment for the club. Thank you.
you will find useful information, tips and other stuff in both discords, keep an eye on both!
Halfus is awesome I can’t help myself but popping everything on pull while running blood and thunder and watch the dps meter go crazy. Even retaliation goes.
Hello everyone. Playing cata human Arms warrior. Does anyone know if the expertise gained from sword specialisation racial shows up when looking at character stats? If so is the Exp soft cap 23 or 26?
23% is fine, as long as you are using a Mace or a Sword, if you're using an Axe then you need 26%
Amazing thank you!
Hello guys can somone know maccro for arm cata as overpowered on berserk stance pleasze
I figured it'd be as simple as
/Cast Berserker Stance
/Cast Overpower
I've seen more complex versions but that one always worked for me just fine
@pallid crane i see thank
You can't be in Berserker Stance for Overpower
and @south basalt
To stance dance properly you need macros for most of your spell keybinds
/startattack
/cast [stance: 3] Battle Stance; Overpower```
Replace Overpower with anything else you need Battle Stance for
/startattack
/cast [stance: 1] Berserker Stance; Mortal Strike```
Replace Mortal Strike with anything you can buff your attacks with Berserker Stance
@primal cipher thank u , what's the difference between ur macro and the macro of azloo?
You cannot be in Berserker stance for Overpower
the game literally won't let you
but doing it this way lets you swap between Battle and Berserker
hence, "dance"
Say you were in Battle Stance and you hit Mortal Strike with this macro, you will swap into Berserker Stance before you do Mortal Strike. If you hit Overpower next, you will swap into Battle Stance before you do Overpower
etc. etc.
Yeah that was a mistake on my part. I meant battle stance but the macro still works for me regardless
Hey! How is slammin heroic strike into a mortal strike macro? Is that dumb or lazy? Or does it actually work? Saw it on YouTube the other day
Like baking heroic strike and MS together? That’s a terrible idea
And will result in a dps loss at some point in the fight
Unless you are only using it during deadly calm and have a separate version of both the buttons that aren’t together
Im new to warr, so trying to make it easier for myself. Idk if i should slam or HS, and if i should press MS and overpower on cd, or what is the prio system? Mind help me out a easy way?
Its so much and overwhelming
Mortal strike > OP > slam > HS in that priority
You only press slam if you have nothing else to press (includes CS)
You press ms every 3rd global MS-> x -> x -> MS
HS at above 75 rage or in deadly calm ONLY
In execute phase spam the fuck out of execute but press MS at least once every 14 seconds to maintain slaughter +rend
^
If any other questions I probably won’t be busy (at work) but my internet is very intermittent here so high chance I don’t see it right away
Thank you alot! That clears it up atleast! Just need to practice while leveling. Its so many buttons with cleave, whirlwind and thunder clap aswell into it.
You said slam if nothing else? Do you then mean if MS, OP and CS is on CD then?
In single target yeah
So in AoE just cleave instead of slam?
You can also just unbind whirlwind
That would be lovely ❤️
In aoe
Target the prior mob
And take single target rotation but you
Put Tc>MS
And replace HS with cleave
Dunno if you are playing blood and thunder a lot but
Be sure to apply rend first in ST always and AOE if playing B&T
Ait so cleave replaces Hs, But if i slam much more than HS, does that mean that HS is not much used outside deadly calm?
Use this weak aura: https://wago.io/Fxb1Ip6bK
Basically it tells you when you’re supposed to hit HS (when you’re at 70 ish rage), your HS keybind lights up
But you have to set it as to which keybind you have HS on or it won’t light up like it’s intended
Obviously you’re also spamming HS during deadly calm but using this weak aura maximizes your HS usage without rage starving yourself
Pretty sure it lights up when you have Battle Trance proc as well
HS/cleave is rage dependent, most of your prospective slam casts will be eaten by the constant use of TC
^^^
Oh thanks alot! ill use it for sure! Appriciate it! Just send me some other quality of life WA’s aswell if u know any
Yo Zaffe! is it possible to made an aura like this for Mortal strike aswell when its ready to be casted? that it glows?
^
Yeah no need a helper for that lol
The priority system for Arms is simple
Keep up C smash if available
Hit MS always, and that’s every 3rd global
Hit OP while MS is on CD, and if that’s not available, you Slam, until the next high priority button is available (could be OP, could be Slam again). Until you hit MS again
And make sure you Rend in the beginning. MS refreshes this for you (another reason why hitting this is important)
Never ever delay MS if it’s available
It does so many things. It’s one of your highest damage spells, it keeps up Lambs to the Slaughter debuff
Not even with Battle Trance? Because that's what I've been doing (using HS at 75+ rage, Deadly Calm AND Battle Trance) and my dps and parses are higher now
sure
if u dont press it then your rage will go to the point where u need to press hs anyways so
same result
Yeah I guess that makes sense
In execute phase I find myself missing CS procs because I waste my rage gain by pressing execute above 10 rage. Would an addon to track my melee swing timer help for this? So I know when I'm getting rage to stop pressing execute and be able to press CS
Bladestorm. I feel its an cringe button to press? Do we use it on singletarget? With our without reck? Where is it in our priorities. Should it allways be on CD? Or delay for something?
No not single target
ok so we dont press it on ST? not even with reck?
correct
join the discord in the pins
itll have a comprehensive list of the priority
in the pins of the cata-arms channel;
Tyty! I will for sure
That channel is a cesspool lol. You literally can just copy paste the links and screenshot the pins, then leave
90% of the populace is not helpful at all
Their sole purpose is to parrot “read sticky” and “sim it” or mock you for not knowing how to play
But if you bring something up that’s NOT clear at all (Execute phase rotation, as an example. There is a stickied rotation guide but it was recently just discovered that you DO do more damage just spamming execute if you are high in rage and not letting slaughter fall off)
You get zero to no response
Haven’t found a single person at least interested in engaging in healthy discussion even IF some of the knowledge has already been talked about or posted in pins
Especially if the “new” discussion has math and logs to back it up

Sure people can be dickheads in there, but just read the pins and leave
Or search your question, it’s very likely to have been answered
Agreed lol it's why I tend to check here more often than not. It's quieter but the people who respond here actually want to help without being arrogant douche bags
Anyone knows if spell reflect is useful in any fight?
it is for pvp fights
thanks
Is the a arms warrior guide for cata doc some where?
While leveling play whichever you find more interesting 🙂
Fury may have a slight edge over arms until you get victory rush (I don’t know what level you get that ability) but just choose what looks cooler
but its not my first time playing, i just wanna rush quick to max level tbh
i played the original cataclysm
Lower levels picks what you want arms will probably be slightly faster once you get into the talent points outside of arms tree
But really just play what you want still 
am i in the right place to discuss arms warrior questions? xD
sure but youll find much more interaction and resources in the discord in the pins
Hello, sorry if the question has already been asked, but why does no one use the rotation with double overpower?
Wait until the end of taste of blood > switch arm stance > overpower > overpower > then switch berserker stance ..
I can't find any information on the internet, but it seems more optimized to me to switch stances once to use two overpower attacks and maximize the time in berserker stance.
because double overpower inevitabely always causes a delay in either MS or CS which is bad
Hey! Could I post my logs here and get some help?
Also when reforging am I just supposed to focus on crit after hit and expertise cap?
Yes to your reforge question
One thing I saw right away is you refresh CS immediately on resets- you want to wait for the debuff to drop before pressing it again
Also you need to press MS on cd asap there are several times I identified in the first minute of this log where you didn’t and pressed OP or something
You also have random moments where you don’t press anything for a second or two
I’m on mobile rn so its hard to investigate further and give conclusive stuff but those I listed above are definitely some mistakes in your rotation
Also
During execute phase
Execute is priority not filler
You spam the shit out of execute and MS/CS to reapply slaughter + rend/CS respectively
Can also OP if you are a little low on rage
This might be pinned somewhere and Ill be a dofus for asking, but is there a weakaura for cata prot / arms pinned somewhere?
If it is it’s in the pinned discord
But you just want like an aura bar or like everything
I’m sure you can find what you are looking for on wago pretty easy if not pinned
which are the good servers for pvp on cata??
How can I use Heroic Leap correctly every time it's available during Colossus smash? I feel like every time I use it, it results in a DPS loss because I can't jump in place. I end up in front of the boss or off to the side, but out of attack range.
So I see all warriors bust on alakir
i got top dmg i get it but 30 parse... what am i doing wrong?
i also dont understand why exactly is alakir our favored fight lol, p2 were infront of him missing and dodging tornadoes, how are people cranking on him
P2 has a stacking damage amp
Hello everyone
does anyone know when to effectively use double overpower?
like should I only use it if the timing is right and CS and MS are on CD
Best just use it when there's nothing else to press or if you're low on rage. You're likely to miss out on a MS press if you save two OP
How can I use Heroic Leap correctly every time it's available during Colossus smash? I feel like every time I use it, it results in a DPS loss because I can't jump in place. I end up in front of the boss or off to the side, but out of attack range.
Be max melee range
so... ive got a question. i dont exactly know wtf im doing wrong here. but. Im a 359 worgen arms warrior. when im at the training dummy w/o buffs i do around 13k - 15k dps depending on crits etc. I feel like that is below average? ive watched multiple guides etc for a rotation but i still feel like i do somet wrong.
Is it due to using OP asap? Should one wait for it? I saw someone sayin to use it to gain rage more than dealing dmg?
As long as you're keeping MS on CD, using HS above 65 ish rage CS when you don't have the buff already active and using your OP proc before it resets or low on rage then you should be fine. Tbh I struggle figuring out if I should use slam more than HS or vise versa
Ive been told to use pummel when under 50 rage and Hs when over 50 rage.
you definitely dont press pummel for damage in st unless there something that actually needs to be interrupted
Slam over hs
I ment slam* damn.
can someone help explain the overpower window where you wait to use your taste of blood proc to a certain time and are able to cast overpower twice in a row?
For that you want to use overpower with 4-5 seconds left of taste of blood, since this can proc once every 5 seconds, it last for 10 seconds, and rend tics every 3 secs, so you will be proccing taste of blood every 6 seconds aprox.
anyway, doing this might not be the best thing to do, since it will at some point delay the usage of a MS or CS cd, and you don’t want that
^^^^^^
U do not want to do the double op thing
Just play priority in the order it comes
Double OP is something you ideally do not want to do but you do it in favor of losing an overpower/TFB proc
MS
CS(no debuff)
OP
Slam
HS at or above 70 rage
If CS resets while you have the debuff on the target hold it until it drops
You should very rarely find yourself in a situation where you can double OP and not clip MS or CS. Get a solid tfb tracker (i use fojji), and you'll be able to develop an eye for when it's appropriate.
does anyone have a screen shot of what reforge lite settings should be for arms warrior?
im not on rn, but theres a little drop down menu that should auto fill it near the top
let me log over ill take a SS
choose this
and itll auto fill
youll also likely want to change how fast it calculates
if you do it fast then press it a couple times
if you do it slow your wow will probably freeze for a quick moment before finishing
similar to when scanning the AH if you mess with AH addons
If that doesn’t works for you (I had some issues in the past) you can also use WoWSims to simulate your character, and there is an option to autofill your reforges. You can import that into the game. If you need help with this lmk
Is fury warrior a thing? Haha
Ive always thought it was CS first then Ms?! Please elaborate why. Since colossal boosts dmg?
short answer is thats how sims, and people who are much better than I am say
my guess is
ms cooldown is 2 globals so if you sit on ms you miss 1/2 of an ms
cs cd is a lot longer so the time youd be delaying your cs is less according to the cd if you get what im saying
So by doing cs THEN ms i loose potential dmg. Doing the opposite, ms then cs, increases dmg. Huh. The more you know.
well its more like if both are off cd which one is the lesser opportunity cost
any recommended WA that will show if you are hitting sweeping strikes on the additional add?
i have a cleave one.. but havent found a sweeping strikes one
You're going to get an MS in the CS window you delayed anyway. It's our hardest hitting ability, so I like to think about it this way: you do less dmg if you're missing an MS than if you're missing 2 seconds of a CS window.
You could probably create a duplicate of the cleave one and have it track SS instead. Not 100% sure on that though.
actually the cleave one only says how many targets i hit.. it doesnt indicate on the target nameplate if they are in cleave range.. which is what im looking for but with sweeping strikes 😦
Sweeping strikes hits closest to your hitbox
So if you stand inside the butt of the 2nd target you want to sweep onto it’ll hit it
how is war in cata
Is this channel all the resource we get for cata? I cant see any pins regarding firelands loot, valor prio etc for arms. Where do i find this?
when firelands launches the channel will be more active (probably).
When Cata launched this channel was super active and useful tbh
Anyway if you want some guides you could wait for the wowhead page to be updated
there is a pin for another discord with all of this
Why does no arms guide talent Blood & Thunder?
bc you are looking at pure st builds likely
just talent into it and drop the point in incite, the dps is hardly worth it
@uncut pasture
also do NOT trust the wowhead guides
those things are broken as fuck
Yeah but icyveigns is nothing better :/
Thanks for your reply
Do we stancedance again? Only use OP in Battelstance and the rest in Zerkerstance?
If you want to maximize your DPS then yeah stance dancing is still used as arms in cata.
Rend, OP and Thunderclap (to spread rend DMG in aoe) for Battle stance and then the rest can be used for Beserker stance.
However some people have said to not macro Heroic Strike to any stances as the main use for it is to stop you from rage capping so I'd use that in any stance as changing stances costs rage as it is
Go to fight club for the best resource
Yeah you macro every single ability to a stance except for HS
Is it just me or does Fight club have no discussion for cata warriors at all lol. They only have links to the wowhead guide.
gotta finish reading the info channel
gotta type something somewhere
I forget now
U right I’m dumb
New to Cata Classic, whats the best/fastest way to gear a fresh lvl 85 character?
Pve**
Do you ever get tired of telling people to read the info channel?
It's quite funny ngl 
It’s honestly quite insane how often I need to do it LOL
But I’d rather that then me go into FC and copy paste ALL of the resources
Well most of the people you tell to go there, don't show up, or lose at the Info Channel miniboss. But the ones who do make it, learn enough.
Which is funny.

You'd be surprised how many make it into the discord and then ask for answers which are clearly pinned. LMAO
Yeah
That’s why I was kinda cryptic saying
“Read the entire info channel” since it says read pins and search your q before asking
Bc if you do that you often get blasted which is kinda jarring
But also fair
Nah i see and and it is appreciated
I'm assuming most of the dents who actually come from other class discords know how to read resources. So they don't ask stupid questions often
It's the people first getting in or w/e who do.
I always assume not mostly because in here if someone asks a pinned question most of the time people will just answer and it’s nbd
Whole different ball game in fight club haha
Well, if it's clearly pinned or in the FAQ you know. You invite flame for not following basic Discord Etiquette imo.
Yeah I agree that’s why I say it’s jarring(to those who don’t know) but fair
Whats the best profession for Warrior in Cataclysm?
I could be wrong but the guides at one point said engi+tailoring until dragon soul then once dragon soul hits swap the tailoring to BS
personally I just went BS from the start bc I cba rerolling
Even then tailoring was minimal upgrade
does arms swap to t12 at 2 piece or 4?

Also came for this info here
If only there were a sim for classic arms
Yes
Your friend went to the Raid without you, and you can't find a group on your own?
Then the best choice is to book a spot in a Raid with the TOP Guilds! ✨
🔸 Get all the loot guaranteed from every Boss, unlimited Loot Traders
🔸 Fast Heroic or Mythic Raid run without wipes
🔸 Achievements, rewards and enjoyment of the game only for you
Buy World ...
Have no more friends anymore 😭
Guessing the above log review channel is for retail... anyone wanna help out the arms warrior in my guild with a log review? I'm RL and don't play warrior at all.
We would greatly appricate any help! I was mostly looking at our normal baelroc kill since its a target dummy:
he kinda seems to be missing some globals, also sometimes has an extra global where he presses Overpower above mortal strike priority
like for example at around 1m50s he randomly has some downtime, likely caused by something im unsure what as im not really playing cata rn
theres a possibility that is an outlier though.
but he seems to be doing for the most part pretty well
it seems like they waited 50s to use their trinket for some reason
were they asked to solo soak a crystal or somehting? he popped shield wall at some point. nm i see he taunted the boss, even worse
if that is the case then the overall dmg wont be good since you cant do that as arms w/o it severly affecting your dps
is this person usually a tank? is using the sinestra necklace with a stam+mastery gem
several swaps into defensive stance in a fight like shannox does not make a lot of sense. a lot of demo shout gcds
No, he doesnt tank. Not sure why he pops defensive stance. Maybe rage face was on him. The sinestra neck is actually decent for dps too, its not uncommon to use it, simply for ilevel and str. It was 2nd bis in t11
And yeah that taunt wasnt intentional thats not a reoccuring thing tho
why can't arms soak a crystal? Its in meele he shouldn't lose any uptime.
But yeah from looking at timeline I dont think hes lining up dps burst in CS windows so thats probs what I'm looking for
No offense but i dont think you understood what i meant
Its perfect to soak crystals
But you dont need a shield and shieldwall to do so unless you are soaking a lot of stacks and that will affect his performance. In any case, as i already mentioned, it was due to the accidental taunt
Second, the neck might be fine but the gem is extremely bad for dps, which was my point
Third, he is constantly using demo shout
Those are all fundamentals
that is not how cata CS works
you just follow a simple priority rotation and fill every gcd, as always. CS is not a big CD like on retail that you want to align with other CDs, you just attempt to keep the debuff up as much as you can/you are allowed by rng
there are no dps bursts in ST, and you should have a full CS window for your trinket/reck etc. in any case if you want to optimize that aspect tell him not to reck before rend, that is a lost gcd during reck and he is doing it constantly. rend > reck is better. in any case, as i said, he is underperforming due to more fundamental aspects
can anyone link me a good in-depth arms guide? other than wowhead/icyveins preferably like a google doc or something
There really isn't one. Your best bet is going to warcraft logs, going to top parses, and looking at the cast timeline
The differentiator seems to be good CS burst windows. Theres big dmg spikes correlated with deadly calm & getting a bunch of HS off in the window. The weaker logs don't sync this up as well. You can tell the gap in the dmg/casts from HS. & then consistently getting OP/MS in the CS window too.
Join the discord in the pins
Hey guys am I able to stance dance with slam? My macro doesnt swap to berseker stance when casting Slam, my macro is:
#showtooltip Slam
/startattack
/cast Berserker Stance
/cast Slam
You need to have that macro on your actionbar in both batle stance and in berserker stance (on the same keybind) or you need to have that macro on an actionbar that doesn't page e.g. actionbar 2,3,4,5
#showtooltip Slam
/startattack
/cast [nostance:3] Berserker Stance
/cast Slam
Ok thanks for the info, I’ll test it out tonight
That will work but isn't necessary since stances arent on GCD and if you're in berserker stance and cast berserker stance it will just auto skip over that line of the macro
If you need help making it work you can DM me
the point of it is so you dont need to swap stances manually, in cata you want to sit in zerker as often as possible
I just meant compared to my macro
Where you said [no stance:3] which will work but I don't think will fix his particular issue
this is a copy paste of a macro that has worked for me since the start of cata
I know, hence why I said they both will work
But he is still having an issue so adding that line of code won't do anything different than the macro he is already using. That's all I was saying
Thats not what I was having him do
I think his button layout is just such that when he hits his macro it's not casting slam, my suggestion is that that macro needs to be on the same bar location in battle and zerker if on action bar 1, or place the macro and keybind on a non paging action bar such as action bar 2
I see now
I assumed the problem was with the macro
since he wasnt swapping stances when pressing slam
Yea your macro is good to go too
I think it's having him swap stances but then I assume the slam isn't going off
Actually I just re read him, so it seems to just cast slam without using berserker stance. So I'm guessing maybe in battle stance you have your non macro slam and in zerker stance bar you have your macro, so the macro needs to be on your bar in both battle and berserker stance. Lmk if that fixes it italian
hey hopped on today and tried it out, and good catch, didnt have the macro on my action bar for when I switched to battlestance
great glad it helped
If you use ElvUI you can disable stance action bars and never have to worry about making sure stance action bars align.
Hey guys do you know any good guide for arms in cata? Im new to cata warrior so detailed guide will help a lot
check the discord in the pins, friend
@finite merlin if you want to DM me with questions Im happy to help you
Hi everyone ! Can anyone could help me to or give me some advice to improve my DPS please ?
I sim my character and try on dummy and i am on same dps range as the simulation but in raid, I can't parse purple/orange (I know the strat works but on bosses like Chambellan and Shannox, I can't do it).
https://fr.classic.warcraftlogs.com/reports/W9hHNpcMVtxkz6a7#type=damage-done&boss=-2&difficulty=0 (In this CHambella fight, i waste recklessness...)
thank's
Hi there, I was a little unsure what arms warrior opener is once you have T12 2-set and also the trinket: Apparatus of Khaz'goroth - Should we be trying to frontload all these buffs into recklessness opener or afterwards etc. Hope that makes sense to somebody 😅
for cata arms warrior, usually the filler must be Slam or Heroic Strike? is a bit weird compared to retail warrior xD
im reading the wow guides, wowhead seems to imply that Slam is better than Heroic Strike as a filler (when both Mortal Strike and Overpower is on cd), but icyveins seems to imply that Heroic Strike is better, according to the their priority rotation, hmm
If you have a free global always be using slam, heroic strike will always be in addition to global locking yourself with colossus smash, mortal strike, overpower, and slam. if you use heroic strike and you rage starve yourself so that you have a GCD go by where you can use an on-gcd ability its a dps loss. the exception is when you have an incite proc non battle trance heroic strike you can use in a colossus smash window along side mortal strike and an over power, and that incite proc is going to go unused otherwise (i.e. the buff is about to fall off), then you can use it instead of slam. However this is a super niche situation, so if you simply use heroic strike exclusively in moments of excess rage, for battle trance procs, and during deadly calm window spamming it, you will be fine
With t12 2 set and apparatus the opener is Prepot -> Battle shout+Berserker Rage+Inner Rage+Synapse Springs+Charge -> Rend+Heroic Strike -> Colossus Smash+Deadly Calm -> Mortal Strike+Heroic Strike -> Overpower+Heroic Leap -> Overpower+Heroic Strike, and then continue with your normal rotation using Apparatus as soon as Synapse Springs falls off and you have 5 stacks. On Ragnaros, you will wait 50 seconds and then on your second Battle Shout+Synapse Springs->Colossus Smash you will recklessness/heroic leap and continue with normal rotation. Other fights will demand specific recklessness usage, but in general, if you can only get one recklessness usage you will save it for execute phase. This is also when you would use your 2nd golemblood potion. If it lines up you should also have a battle shout synapse springs and heart of rage proc for that recklessness also unless your heart of rage wont be up for long enough in execute phase
in retail Cata amrs was a think only in DS due to gurthalak. Isint the classic tiers scaling the same way like they were suposed to?
Arms*
Do you have specific questions related to the boss and your rotation or im not sure what your question is. On staghelm due to the mechanics your parse will almost entirely depend on taking damage as infrequently as possible and maximizing your uptime on the boss since he is leaping away a decent amount. On shannox it will basically depend on your uptime on the boss as doing things like running rageface through traps or dodging stuff or being kited away by your tank will reduce your uptime and your dps. otherwise shannox is pretty much a tank and spank so im not sure what you want to know
Thats awesome help thanks so much!
Actually you should use CS before Rend, it makes it hit harder
Everything else seems fine to me
Are there any log reviews for cata?
Ive been helping a couple people with that if you want to dm me, but it would also help if you have specific questions to go along with it
Looking at logs of top DPS warriors I dont see this to be prevalent at all and just from a commense sense perspective doing this would mean one of your abilities (MS or one of your overpowers) would not benefit from CS debuff so this doesnt seem to make a lot of sense. Also based on my understanding of snap shotting and how dots are refreshed the next MS you do outside of CS would overwrite the stats of that rend so that it didnt benefit from the debuff anymore. Don't think this is right but if you have some logs or analysis to prove this id be interested to give it a look
Sweet! Ill DM you tomorrow! Thanks
damn I guess you're right
Hi Warriors, i wanna change the sound of charge with leatrix but i cant find the ability in the addon. Can someone help me please?
This is correct, only thing I would change above is taking out inner rage in the opener. Can't use it with Deadly Calm, best to use after DC or during hero/lust.
Rend scales with weapon damage, CS decreases enemy armor. The two are not the same thing.
Sorry I should have specified in that post. You do indeed need to include inner rage, because if you do so, you can 1 extra heroic strike usage in your opener. When you colossus smash+deadly calm after your rend+heroic stike global, your deadly calm will include a /cancelaura Inner Rage macro that you will spam. This will allow the next heroic strike going into colossus smash (paired with mortal strike) to retain the lowered cooldown but you also have the deadly calm buff. Of course, if there was an extremely fight dependent mechanic that required a genuine inner rage usage sometime in the first 30 seconds then you wouldnt want to use it, but I don't think there ever is a fight like this.
Is 4 set t12 decent? I do like the 10% DMG increase of the 2 set but the 4 set seems a bit odd. Logs seem to suggest it doesn't do much dmg
Ah, makes sense
From my very basic testing the 4 set bonus at my gear level is around a 700 dps increase. Just based off comparing the two, this number could be lower in fights with less than ideal uptime compared to the 2 set bonus, and the 4 set also scales heavily off weapon damage, so with a 391 weapon the bonus is probably slightly more valuable compared to having a 378 weapon of similar overall ilvl. But 700 dps increase is about half the DPS increase as going from zoids normal mode to the greataxe heroic was for me at my gear level, so i'd say it seems pretty good. Not sure about that number compared to the value of the t11 2 set and 4 set
Thanks for the info! I do have 4 set but I really need the shoulders as the helm feels really nasty to use given it's haste compared to the lovely alysrazors helm
1-2% dps inc
Shush
is it not?
Nah that traccks.
It's not a huge increase but you just really want the stats more than anything else. I was just shit talking.
Gotcha
Good know I'll just stick with chest legs and gloves for now then and worry about 4 set once I have the shoulders
Hey everyone! I’m trying to do better with my parses. I’m reviewing Warcraft logs of top ranked warriors. I wanted to know if anyone knows if there’s any VODs available of a top warrior with with tips, tricks, and audio explanation involved? Thanks
hi i know this is older, but can you explain to me please how the heroic leap works into this? Is it macro'd with the overpower so that you don't have to click the screen to jump?
Look up shoopp cata heroic world first
Hi, so I use a different keybind no macron combining it, however I use the macro /cast [@cursor] heroic leap so that as soon as I push my keybind down heroic leap goes off to where my mouse is aiming, I don't need to click the mouse button
I also use a weakaura that is anchored to my mouse cursor that doesn't disappear when I hold right click to turn camera, and if you use the heroic leap macro it will jump to where that weakaura and thus your mouse cursor are locked at, without you needing release right click to aim heroic leap
aah ok that makes sense. i'm use to healing so this is all new to me lol
one more thing while i got you, i have all my stances macro'd to my moves but it looks like from your opener you have multiple moves macro'd together..the only one i have right now is charge > rend so apparently i'm missing out. Do you have any must have macros that you recommend?
I wouldn't macro any moves together. Including chsrge and rend. Any time I wrote ability1 + ability2 that simply means abilities used in the same global cool down. For abilities on the gcd in sequence, that's when I used arrows like ability3 -> ability4
I do however macro engi gloves into battle shout, and apparatus into deadly calm, although I have a separate keybind for apparatus as well
It's not required but macroing inner rage into charge is also fine although it's good for that to also have it's own bind
On heroic Shannon's it's also useful to have a mouse over charge macro to charge weave the dogs if they come close to shannox so you don't have to Un target shannox
oooh ok! thank you so much!
Hey I really appreciate this advice man! sat down and watched the run a few times over. thanks again 🙂
np, i found it really helpful myself along with analyzing logs of warrs like him. also his music is really good 😄
this is my rotation
alright i need a arms expert
im about to giveup on my lvl 85
what is your question lol
Anyone a protection warrior expert? Switching from arms to protection for my alt raid. Need some help with stats and etc.
theres some prot discussion above I specifically remember people talking about stats
it was awhile ago but its in here somewhere
Hey Guys, Hit Level 85 a Few days ago, can u recommend which weapon should i be aiming for? 359 ashkandi for the Stone fissur currency? 365 Blacksmith weapon ist way too expensiv and stats are Not the best. I Take any advice 🙂 Ty in advance
I imagine the ashkandi sword would be better. Whilst it's a lower ilevel it has far better stats than the BS sword as haste is a dead stat to arms
Why imagine when you can sim it
arms warrior simulations for World of Warcraft® Cataclysm Classic.
Idk if I should post it here or in the review logs channel as most of the things besides this channel is for retail but can I get anyone to help me work out what I’m doing wrong or if it’s just a gear issue? (Guessing it’s not)
I’m Varrokk in the log https://classic.warcraftlogs.com/reports/WBzPHC27AYdFvNtZ?fight=36&type=damage-done
Mind you this is my 4th alt and just picked it up 2 weeks ago but would like to know what to work on
Easiest thing to do, compare your casts per minute to someone who is better with similar kill times, and see what you're lacking.
Also wtf is your casts on some of these fights 
Bro 15 CPM on slam?
You CPM is all funky. You need to understand the priority because with all these slam casts 100% you're delaying MS and that is very bad.
Okay thank you
Again idk what I’m doin im just hitting what I know from retail, guides on this class are very meh and not in depth at all
People stopped making warrior guides yeah
If you want to actually read shit, the pinned discord will have all the information you want.
Hunter and rogue are super intricate and done well warriors are “Hit buttons kill things”
As long as your skin is thick enough to take some constructive criticism that's bordering on flame.
Yeah I just got this discord I was in the classic warrior one and it was sooooo bad
Yeah, I’ll check out the one here, I’m good with constructive criticism. I enjoy performing not being average
If you join Fight Club remember to read pins/faqs etc for shit. Thick skin is a must and you should really read the info channel to understand how to see channels
Search bar too
So from what I’m getting prio is
Cs>mortal>OP>?
Yeah
I guess that’s where I kinda get messy is that
The cata arms channel has a few pinned messages you should read
Beyond that it's like, reviewing the sims posted and seeing what the sim does
Checking the priority list etx
Okay fair enough thanks man
You can post your logs in the arms channel and if people want they'll look over them and you'll get feedback
That’s a scary thought lmfao maybe after I read up and do what I can lol.
Quick question cause all I see is links to the same wowhead guides I’ve been looking at. Do I go for expertise cap? Been just using the reforgelite template for arms and it’s got me only getting to like 6.5-6.75% expertise. Is that right or should I be going for cap?
Reforgelite is good
Okay thanks
I wasn't sure where to put this exactly but I'm annoyed and wanted to gripe. I apparently pulled aggro on Shannox and got grieved pretty heavily about it, how unloading on the boss on pull is wasting everyone's time. Reviewing logs, I didn't charge until 4 seconds after pull, giving tank time to get in position, and didn't go up in the chart til a solid 7 seconds in, simply doing my normal rotation. The tank pulled with Faerie Fire and only auto attacked, saving his mangle til 8 seconds in when the entire raid was already attacking the boss. Another warrior was even on the meter, which I marked as "Not me", til I started attacking lol. Now I'm having to wait a solid 10 or 15 seconds so I don't "unload and grief everyone". I guess this is just part of being a warrior? Video to show me charging in from the right.
Have you tried calling the people in raid some really rude names and seeing how they take it?
No, I generally try to be nice lol
That’s a tank issue
As a RL if I reviewed that and seen the tank doing MINIMAL damage in everyone’s opener I would let them have it for griefing the dps cd’s/prepot
That's what I was thinking, what is even be the point of me prepotting if I can't even do my opener 15 seconds into the pull? And I can't help my mortal strike and heroic strike both crit. If he had called for a misdirect wouldn't it have been irrelevant?
The RL is the tank. It's honestly been really hard to find a competent raid on the server I'm on.
Reminds me of my favorite video to exist
Tank might be giving Rikus a run for their money.
Wait Hunter isn’t MD off pull??? As a Hunter main that’s a gg
I md every pull and have a blood dk tank so I don’t really need to. But with any other tank I burst 50-60k if they aren’t hitting hard and I don’t md im having to feign or it’s coming after me. Bad hunter and bad tank
I'm assuming the hunter didn't because neither were on the meter, but I would have thought if they had I wouldn't have been able to pull aggro. The group had 2 hunters and a rogue :\ The mages, warlock and other warrior were on the meter before I had even charged. I'm just being grumpy about it lol
Don’t blame you. Plus dogshit hunter 😂😂 I’m topping meters at very least until combust goes off and even then I’m combating my staffed fire mages
This was our bale kill , that with both of us subbing into crystal rotation due to order getting messed up multiple times
https://classic.warcraftlogs.com/reports/m1TDaVWnx6hQvHwR?fight=41&type=damage-done&source=35
Trying to figure out why I am bad at arms for our heroic rag prog.
I am just not sure what I am doing wrong.
I havent played cata since like halfway thru p1 so myt advice might not be 100% correct
Also, this was just a quick look as im not 100% sure how things changed with firelands in cata but
looks like you are missing TFB overpower casts
also I dunno the rag fight but casting bladestorm on st is a no go
I also think you are just missing some globals or not casting something directly on the GCD which could be a consequence of using slam> op
Also seems as if you missed a CS or two which could be due to the fight or some other factors
for reference im comparing casts of a chimaeron fight in my logs thats about 40s shorter than your fight
those are some preliminary ideas to consider, but like I said I havent played cata in forever so sorry I cant be of more help haha
Whats the timer for a boss spawn reset? (When you FD Pull a boss for example)
Usually 30s right?
Is there a working WA for apparatus? couldnt find any
I charged at Rhyolith's left leg and it shot me off the side of the volcano 🥴
💀
Yeah that's happened to me a few times. I've never been flung THAT far though lol
Did you manage to find a WA for this?
Also as DS PTR is now in play has anyone discovered and cool tips and tricks? Only tips I have come across so far is switching to def stance on every stomp on morchok if your soaking stomps is helpful as it’s physical damage. Also how OP warriors are on yorsahj against the slimes with our movement.
Is single minded fury the way to play until you get basically BiS two handers?
also shouldnt draenei be good race choice for the hit chance?
worgen is bis race as of current for damage
and the SMF vs TG thing is always gonnabe a sim question, theyre kinda close so u can realistically play whichever u prefer
in reality its going to come down to smth like the ilvls of your respective 1hs vs 2hs with each talent set
Question…as a person who never played cata back then…as a fury warrior is it better to have one handed duel wields? Or just one two handed weapon? I’m a lvl 20
might as well have 2 1h's until around 40 when u can get TG, or just keep using 1h with smf
Leveling a worgen fury warrior I’ll find out soon enough if it’s good or not. Either way I still love it. Fury till the day I die 🤘
(Don't play fury unless your guild doesn't mind you griefing)
pretty sure I was there when that copy pasta became a thing 
fury owns akshually
🤓 👆
also no I will not provide more contexyt
🫃
@grand viper sry for ping but got a question, does apparatus of khaz'goroth hav some stupid bullshit like fury of angerforge where I need to wait a million years for the stacks
or is it quick/virtually no ICD on stacks when I crit
It prob has an ICD?
hm ok if its some weirdo shit like angerforge does unless it drops in raid im just not gonna use it
fuck angerforge
It's better than angerforge iirc

ok someone just bought it for me guess im using it

is it worth rending 2 or 3 targets if they live long enough
just run 2/2 blood & thunder 
have the theorycrafter ppl began working on mop shit yet? I am tryna find resources im preparation for it but its impossible to find anything like what race is bis for fury
ik either orc or troll for horde surely
Probably? I couldn't really tell you tbh
frick
the only resource I could find was a cringe preach video that was just wrong

I don't keep tabs on Cata much anymore
I'm sure people are, but tbh there is content out there once you get into MoP era that is relatively like competent
yeah it is just hard to find good resources backed up with anything other than "just trust me bro"
theres also a big chance im just an idiot and dunno exactly where to look
I doubt fart club keeps supporting warr going into MoP
There might be a small group, but who knows

I cant blame them that shit must suck ngl
also update on my trinket u may find funny:
I raided with this guild who gifted me the trinket - they gave me crystallized firecore to upgrade it to 391
I xfer off to horde last night 
not full context but I like looking myself look like max dickhead
Eh, if you already planned to oh well
Golgachad ❤️
Anyone doing the PTR? Twilight dungeons incredible fun with the haste buff, especially as a fury!
Been gaming them all night now my fingers are exhausted kek!
I’m new here, the guides I find online seem out dated for prebis, is there a list somewhere for arms?
What guide are you looking at? The babyhoof wowhead guide is pretty good in terms of prebis. considering DS is not out yet
If you want more information- join the discord in the pins.
Be sure when you join to read the welcome channel fully this will save you a ton of trouble after joining
Maybe just my lack of knowledge, I was expecting different trinkets I think.
there are slightly better trinkets, sure but idk if you read teh s1 wowhead guides but they were uhhh not great
and much worse
which trinket is best can always be answered by a sim as well
True. I guess I was most surprised by the cheap dark moon card being useful.
I’ll check the new discord. I appreciate the insight
Apparently OH gurthalak proccs alot more than expected
Thats nice :>
4 tentacles on single target not unusual! TG is back
Anyone here able to help me with my arms rotation? I'm missing some slam damage and trying to find the areas to add it to. also for ideal colossus smash
Post a log homie
Generally MS>CS>OP>SLAM outside of execute
Inside of it MS(If slaughter will drop)>CS>EXE in execute
I am new to WoW and wondering where I should go as a lvl 26 dwarf?
Hillsbrad foothills my friend ❤️💪
I appreciate that thank you !!!!
If you post a log of a boss kill we can go into it and deep dive the mistakes you make
Does fury overtake arms if we get 2 Gurthalaks
sims will answer that for ya mate
Yes
But its mostly coming down to your play style pref this tier. You will do most dps with the specc you enjoy playing! Technically they are really close now with fury a littlebit ahead if 2x hc gurths. Before then arms a littlebit of edge compared to fury, but it all comes down to your pref play style. Both is massive pumper specs this patch
Thanks legend
anyone got some experience with this pre pull action stuff going on?
from sims i only can tell the mastery trinket gets activated 20s pre pull and cds used 0.2s befor
but no matter what it changes nothing on the sim.
Also it got a lot of item switch stuff in there which i assume its for T12 shout bonus? dont get it for the mastery trinket tho
You're asking in the wrong discord
Go to the pinned one, they care far more about your fury dream.
I dont think the sim takes mastery snapshotting into consideration afaik. But its still crucial way to play to maximize the fury fun for a great opener!
Any question regarding the sim you should ask in https://discord.gg/jDHuVQwn in the cata-warrior channel! They are pretty awesome 🙂
which trinket is that
what about 2 gurths from the lfr vendor? Are they preferable to a standard 391 2h for arms?
Is this really the case? The BIS simcraft profile from when DS was current had the axe as an off hand due to Gurthalak proccing less in the OH?
Did they program it differently this time around / hindsight?
1s wrong link
Go check, they are very good at detailing their changes/updates to the sim. You can check their cata channels
There is a lot of testing involved too
I am already there but I’m not paying attention to convos 24/7
I am just responding to what someone said here
It's not even a convo what?
You literally look at the Cata Sim update channel and just read those messages for changes made? 
Unironically the most recent post gives insight.
Or you can simply, ask in there.
Do we wanna swap out HC set with new LFR/Norm set?
Sim it
K. Yeah. Read what I said again. I responded to what someone said HERE. The simcraft profile from a decade ago originally didn’t proc tentacles as often in OH as in MH. So I was just wondering what changed. I did see the update channel but it doesn’t say WHY. So no, my dude, I didn’t pay attention to the discussion to how they GOT to that updated profile. And sure, I can ask over there, but I was responding to someone HERE.
I can easily just religiously follow sims now as I have in the past and you wouldn’t get any pushback from me.
I mean, they're gonna test stuff.
But idk, go off king.
If you don't wanna ask and wanna just have a conversation that goes nowhere because you don't ask the right people in the right setting, GGs
Literally you go into the Cata channel and go "Hey guys, you tested proc chances on Gurth, what does it show for the OH" and like, you'll get your answer most likely and now you know.
I asked them (the two devs who do the warrior shit the most) in Fight Club and i got an answer pretty quickly with Logs to showcase the Proc Chance as well as like a graph.
Also, you don't need to pay attention
You can use the search bar, it's a relatively new part of Discord but i'm sure you can figure it out.
Full bis it is. And any fight with cleave arms>
Whats the best site for talents/build etc
Welcome!
Two very good websites are:
Wowhead Classic
Cata Sims
-Not sure if I'm allowed to put links here sorry!
https://www.wowhead.com/cata/guide/classes/warrior/arms/dps-talent-builds-glyphs-pve
I would change 3/3 incite in the prot tree to 1/3 incite and 2/2 Blood and thunder
very large aoe gain for a very minimal single target loss
or conversely a very large aoe loss, for a very minimal single target gain
https://wowsims.github.io/cata/
For the sims, youll want to download an addon called "WoWsims exporter" get in game type /wse and then import it into the import and addon section of the sim for whatever class/spec u are on
Simulations for World of Warcraft® Cataclysm Classic.
u can use this to compare gear, talents, gems, enchants, etc
I see a heap of high parse logs still using "Apparatus of Khaz'goroth" in DS can anyone confirm if this trinket is meant to be BIS still?
In which stance i use heroic Strike and cleave as am arms warrior ? Im now new at warri and found some stance Dance macros but There no Markos for This 2 Spells
In whichever stance you are currently in. The point of the raw use of HS is to not overcap rage, and stance dancing costs rage by itself
If you dont have both Bone-Link fetish and Creche, and neither Eye of Unmaking, the next best trinket is probably Heroic Apparatus
Maybe up there with the VP trinket but if you already have Heroic apparatus you can run it
This is a sim it question.
Take gear, put into sim.
Okay thx
Guide on wowhead dont even mention Bracers of destructive str instead of ex (Matredor). Arent they alot better? +200 ish
I wouldnt recommend using the wowhead guide for gearing choices, I would use the sim website I linked
but yes theyre better
does arms keep using overpower during execute window?
Nope
Hi everyone! Which of these NPCs has the longest respawn time in Kalimdor? 🙃
https://youtube.com/shorts/drs6O5UKQf0?si=WvlEm3c7mC63-nOu
Rare NPCs of Kalimdor! 🌍💎 Have you encountered them all? 😱
NPC List:
Arcanus, Bloodroar the Stalker, Brother Ravenoak, Carnivous the Breaker, CIDA, Diamond Head, Doomsayer Wiserunne, Dustflight the Cowardly, Fidonis, Gezan, Gibblesnik, Harb Foulmountain, Harbinger Aph'lass, Heronis, Lady Moongazer, Licillin, Norissis, Scorchscale Drake, Silithi...
A lot of guides say prot warriors don't need to worry about hit/expertise, but without it, the other tank pulls aggro easily from me constantly missing. Any advice here? What's the sweet spot with hit/expertise?
You don't need Hit/Expertise
You hold threat from DPS that's what matters, if another tank rips, oh well.
Survivability matters
Beanna knows what they're talking about. If you care to hear more (they will tell you the same thing most likely with a few better explanation) join the discord pinned and ask in the tank channel.
Sorry I know this is for cata but i want to prepare mats etc for mop. For a min/maxer where is there any information on professions for prot warriors in mop?
whats the general rotation with the new 4 set gear?
it doesnt change
ms>cs>op>slam
in execute u spam execute aside from applying cs and refreshing slaughter
thank you brother!!!!!!
with the new 2 set heroic strike cost reduction, are we factoring that into anything or is it just useless?
If you expect times of high rage due to damage taken yes
I end up just pressing it right before I normally would press it to prevent wasting rage
then I will use a rage generator in place of where slam would normally be to keep spamming it
almost certainly a misplay but
I do ok enough
So are we MS>CS because of our 4 set having the chance to proc CS and lambs to slaughter
Do you use Single-Minded Fury until you get bis 2H or second bis or do you go for Titans Grip as soon as you can?
(Leveling atm)
can someone explain to me what the execute phase rotation is like cus its not very well explained in the icy veins guide i feel like
what am i pressing and in what priority
this is arms btw
Execute execute MS on CD to keep slaughter up and fish for enrage procs and CS when it's not already on the target
thanks for that!
hey guys anyone know where I can get the swap 2 set fl pre pull macro from?
I do it with itemrack, you can bind your gear set
hello guys, is there another dc for classic/cata stuff? or do i find infos here as well? looking for the generel stuff like rotation/macros etc. (arms) 🙂 i checked the pins but didnt see anything bseides a tbc discord
its called fight club
np have fun
Is the only pre pull tech for arms T12 shoot buff ?
T2 2p as well 
Is there any good quest mod that shows on minimap/map or perhaps even an arrow or where to go?
I downloaded kaliels quest tracker and really liked the look of it but didnt really show where to go 🤔
Any help/tips is much appreciated
Hello there !
I would like to know if someone can check these log on ultraxion to see if there are any points for improvement/optimization. There are over 10k DPS difference with the first ones.
https://classic.warcraftlogs.com/reports/4DWRqgtGXd61pH9Y?fight=10&type=damage-done&source=12 (i'm Zäi)
Is this an appropriate channel to ask for cata log reviews? I joined "Fight Club" but I only have access to a bunch of channels and no text channels I can type in
read the entire rules page
In fight club?
yes
also u can post logs here, but I cant guarantee there will be as much or as good feedback
I am not going to super deep dive, but the only thing I really see could be improvements is 2 things that stuck out:
- sometimes u drop the cadence of Mortal strike - x - x - Mortal Strike, youll add in an extra OP or CS in the couple of examples from this kill
- sometimes u randomly OP in execute, you shouldnt ever really come across this unless you press MS and then dont have enough for execute, which youll have zerker rage for ideally
I didnt look @ all at your cs uptime or anything to see if there were overlaps
Ok thank's, so really spam MS even if OP proc is going to fade ?
I like use CS before MS but if i understand well, we really need to not delay MS
Yes for OP in execute, i know it but i'm still did it
Yeah there shoudlnt be a rotational reason to delay MS, outside of Execute it should always be MS - x - x - MS
Can you charge ultraxion in ds and not fall down?
You can Yeah but as Golganarr said, it's absurdly huge. You need to be where thr aspects and thrall are. Then after a charge you'll probably want to heroic leap as you'll still be too far from the boss after charging lol
zugzug
Im looking forward to play fury warrior in MoP, it looks interesting!
hello! new warrior here. Currently leveling as prot (84 atm) and i think i will stick to prot. What valor pieces should i get from my alts (bracers/boots), the dps ones or the prot ones? Generally asking, i will be most likely soloing some stuff and doing 5mans (Mop waiting room)
You probably want classic discord https://discord.com/invite/RbCZJtw
Im on the MoP Beta atm testing fury! Very refreshing and promising!
Havin super fun already cant wait to explore it more tomorrow ❤️
fun in grim batol ^^ https://streamable.com/og58jm
They gonna nerf this 100% but nice way to get to 90 fast on the beta 😛
Hey everyone. I'm in a unique scenario with my current raidgroup, all through progression I was parsing very high and my dps was great, however we run a super cracked demo lock, fire mage, ele shammy, and sub rogue that all have prepull sets. With the 20% nerf (soon to be 25%), our killtimes are so low that I've made my way from the top of the back to the bottom. I'm almost thinking that on fights void of cleave / aoe that fury might actually outpreform arms on some fights (particularly Ultraxion) Where i'm getting drastically outshined by comps that are taking advantage of mastery / prepull sets and mechanics. I'd try the cata server but the only thing under they fury thread is, "Dont play fury." I'm an oldschool 8/8H Player, and bored trying to theory craft to make it through the next few weeks before mop hits.
I believe fury can also benefit from a mastery prepull set amongst other things and if anyone has tried this i'd love to chat
Yep mastery snapshotting deathwish is super fun! Ive done it alot and i highly recommend it if you are not into arms! Curently my mastery snapshot gear gives me 65% damage on deathwish for the first 30 seconds! Gapping the opener 🙂
I love arms, I just get lower and lower every week we get more geared and the bosses get less health
i can only get 6-9 executes off in a pull now with how front heavy our comp's damage is
I’m on the fence about pvp trinket prepull as arms. Im not confident that the bonus str for hopefully 10-12 seconds if they perfectly on pull timer, is worth losing bone link / crèche ICD. My damage is pretty much the same whether I use prepull trinkets or by standard trinkets
hello what's better for fury i have nhc gurthalak and the two-handed axe on hc should i put gurthalak on the mainhand or offhand?
Gurth maintains mainland slot for proc rate from my understanding
https://wowsims.github.io/cata/warrior/fury/ is ur best friend
fury warrior simulations for World of Warcraft® Cataclysm Classic.
I use that religiously I am told that it doesn’t properly compute offhand gurth damage though
Is single minded fury viable in cata and mop ?
For casual player like me. Random dungeons, hc dungeons and lfr raid for mop.
sure, you can play however you like
numerically TG is better until mop starts then I THINK smf pulls ahead but dont quote me im not 100% sure
but since u are doing stuff that the optimization wont necessarily matter, then just play whatever looks coolest or you think is fun and just have a good time
Perfect thanks !
if you are interested in whats numerically better going into mop, I suggest you join the discord in the pins, theyll have way more information regarding this coming soon
I think guides are being written right now
SMF does pull ahead in mop and sits right there with TG until you get very specific itemization from what I remember when it was live.
Fury isn’t bad in dungeons and stuff right now. Bronze buff in twilights with titans grip is very high dps
i dont see any mop info on warrior in there do you? I have been looking for mop warrior discord
They’re currently writing it.
^
Is there a discord around mop warrior discussion? Similar to thr mage discord for mop?
It’s pinned
hey guys! for pvp, what is the usual priority sequence when purchasing honor gear?
probably highest stat budget downwards
something like wep > trinket > head/chest/leg > shoulder/gloves/boots > cloak/wrist/ring
but Im not a pvp guy so good chance thats wrong
is there any pre pull shenanagins arms warrior can do?
Every class can prepull currently. You just dont benefit from any mastery / snapshotting like the really broken classes do.
circle of flame and 2 pvp trinkets (one 390 one 403 because the proc ID's are different). Start the pull with +2700 strength before pre pot making that 3900 after. Keep in mind your trinkets will be on ICD when you switch back to your normal set though
I run Eye of Unmaking and Bone link which dont have an ICD Like Creche if I decide to do anything prepull
Rag trinket is giga ass but also has no ICD and ive seen it used at very high levels of play because of that
Fury is better for fights without cleave or aoe phases in my group, but we have DS on farm and we have bosses dying insanely fast. I have a mastery set of junk gear to get my mastery to 4300, circle of flame to proc pvp trinkets giving me 2700 str on pull, pop deathwish to snapshot that mastery, prepot and equip my normal gear. Brings my deathwish up to a 50% damage increase (from 30% in my normal gear). However after your first deathwish all you can do is pray for mega gurth procs because you turn into a wet sock really fast
yea im doing the strength pre pull stuff just wasnt sure if there was anything else
if you do that on a fight that doesnt end fast all you do is mess up your icd on creche which is your bis trinket so
but i run creche so i get around that but just doing one trinket instead
just keep that in mind
yeah
so you only really benefit from one trinket
which isnt bad
you can try firelands 2set too
still a free 1400 strength XD
10% dmg increase on battle shout but only 10 seconds
wire the firelands 2 set for 10% physical
still 2-3 abilities
macros baby
if your group is cracked and you hate being left in the dust i hate to say it but try fury
in july it will be the best spec with prepatch again anyways
then once mop hits it will be below arms (which will be meh) until ToT
oh firelands 2set is only 6 seconds, itll be your first global maybe two if you hit it perfect
best case scenario like your first CS MS
Which channel is it pinned in cannot seem to find it
In this one lol
for those who pvp in cata still, what is the main way people try to find 3s/2s team since they broke/removed? the xrealm LFG custom tab?
tab is still there, just not xrealm anymore for some reason, but that's what we were all using before
In MOP when do warriors switch from Arms to Fury
I am following the priority list from WoWhead but I don't feel like I do enough dmg, compared to other people with the same avg ilvl
SoO
if you post a log maybe I can help? idk im not great at cata myself
For some fights in tot when your gear is good
@crystal robinbro can i get a TLDR on how retail mop is do u know
can u like swap specs normally
I think you can still swap freely between your two specs however to change talents you need the inscription mat that gives you a buff for 60s
Give me like 30
