#protection

1 messages · Page 1865 of 1

fringe mural
#

That'll be a new screenshot for prot hof

autumn roost
#

@lusty grotto

#

Crafting pants and got tier shoulders from vault

#

Should be 288 tonight when I pull lura

lusty grotto
#

good shit

autumn roost
#

Don't look at when I use ignore pain on lura

fringe mural
#

also nice title to fight her

autumn roost
#

Indeed

#

Actually I was having so much fun playing prot

#

This is already my highest io character

ocean valley
#

should i go druid or monk

#

what yall think

lusty grotto
#

go shaman

ocean valley
#

bear it is

fringe mural
#

I'm with nim, if you don't play warrior, play warrior support

#

go shaman

#

and help the brothers out with wf

ocean valley
#

man even with supp we be sucking

fringe mural
#

lol

autumn roost
#

When I tanked my pit, the healer said I was the "least spiky prot he's played with" - is prot warrior typically spiky in keys?

coarse bay
#

Bear’s current gameplay

#

Is something

ocean valley
#

gotta be relying on other classes just to hit the minimum 😭

coarse bay
ocean valley
#

if your health moves at all larias its spiky

lofty warren
#

Current bear domination

lusty grotto
#

lmao

ocean valley
#

on raider io i had to go all the way down to like #400 to find the first warrior when it came to top tanks...

lament osprey
#

Bad prot warriors like back shots

lusty grotto
#

bad prot warriors like to blame the class

#

and go into skyhold to "bait"

#

all while being dogshit

fringe mural
undone beacon
#

Big Pwarr guy

coarse bay
ocean valley
#

cant we just go back to when FBV was like 300%

autumn roost
#

Was hilarious

ocean valley
#

then we can survive like monks and guardians

fringe mural
#

if you know how to pull instances and have to play a 2 button spec of course you suddenly rock

autumn roost
#

I just macrod everything into shield slam

ocean valley
lament osprey
#

Low key throw axe OP

ocean valley
#

simply dodge the magic rotting dmg

autumn roost
#

I wonder if I could macro thunderclap into shield slam

#

Just casts whichever is up

lofty warren
#

Think the fact that moon bear has 3 buttons + it being the strongest is the most aggregrious

autumn roost
#

How are you still allowed in class discords

ocean valley
#

well that and it doesnt matter if youre hit in the back, or take magic dmg

#

you just heal it all up

lofty warren
plush tendon
#

its dodge

ocean valley
#

its chump change to em

fringe mural
#

it's not nearly as dangerous to them as it for us

#

What they lose is 20% dodge, what we lose is 40-80% dr when getting hit in the back

#

Or more even with parry considered

coarse bay
fringe mural
#

the difficulty comes in maintaining it while doing the other shit

#

imo

ocean valley
#

i honestly think if they just buffed FBV again and gave colossus more of ST dmg, we could actually feel a lil competitive against monks and bears. still not overcome them but at least not looked down like a pile of dogshit on the sidewalk

coarse bay
#

I dont think warriors are that behind anyways

#

Just nobody’s pushing it

fringe mural
#

of course nobody is when you can just roll through with a druid lol

ocean valley
#

nobodys pushing it because its defensives and dmg isnt nearly as good, how you gonna be shitter than both

fringe mural
#

but i will always play warrior as my main

crisp ocean
#

all tanks are buffed

#

VDH is rly fun

coarse bay
#

It’s probably 1-2 keys behind top keys, which isnt abnormal

fringe mural
#

i just love the class no matter if meta or not

ocean valley
#

like how you gonna make both aspects better on tanks than others

lofty warren
ocean valley
#

instead of one or hte other

crisp ocean
crisp ocean
fringe mural
#

I am not at a level where meta matters to me

crisp ocean
#

and teams want meta tanks

coarse bay
#

It isnt about getting invited

crisp ocean
coarse bay
#

It’s so easy to reroll and multiclass

crisp ocean
#

people rerolled to brew when it was #1 then to guardian

fringe mural
#

why wouldn't they play the meta if gearing is that easy

coarse bay
#

And not that many of the top tanks actually have a preference towards warrior, theyll only play it when meta

lofty warren
ocean valley
#

ya but the pain is rerolling where u gotta gear it out and grind a bunch again

#

and is it your playstyle? most people just like the class theyre playing just the balance is horrendous

crisp ocean
coarse bay
crisp ocean
#

solo

ocean valley
#

damn dude no job or family?

coarse bay
#

Idc what aggregate log stats you show, warrior is at most 1-2 key levels behind

ocean valley
#

eh warrior is like 2-3 keys behind

fringe mural
#

ah the good old no-lifer

harsh cypress
ocean valley
#

depending on dng

lusty grotto
#

did you come here so you would have emotional approval, @ocean valley?

#

here you go

ocean valley
#

nah just want to raise voices

lusty grotto
#

well thats too bad

ocean valley
#

idk why anyone is happy with the current state where a tank is better in both dmg and defense

lusty grotto
#

because the problem isnt the class

#

its the dungeon design

ocean valley
lusty grotto
#

🤷‍♂️

lofty warren
coarse bay
ocean valley
#

could always be bigger pulls cause theyr emore tanky pepega

coarse bay
#

You compare different key levels, comps, routes

#

It will be different

lofty warren
coarse bay
ocean valley
#

because we let blizz do whatever shitty idea they have

coarse bay
#

I am certain that if those top tanks wanted to push warrior, theyd make your statements look stupid

crisp ocean
#

every season they pick a tank who’s better than the other classes

ocean valley
#

swear to god a intern could balance better

lusty grotto
#

well if youre looking to make us close skyhold, that aint gonna happen you might have better luck on HoW though

#

good luck!

crisp ocean
coarse bay
coarse bay
#

It is literally just the fact that multiclassing and alts is easier than ever

lofty warren
coarse bay
#

And dps isnt everything

ocean valley
coarse bay
#

Pwar can most likely live the same key levels

#

Just need different routing

ocean valley
#

ya, its called smaller pulls so less dmg

coarse bay
#

No, its different routing

#

It isnt new that different tanks and comps need different routes

ocean valley
#

ah so warrior should be 0 key lvl difference

ocean valley
#

theyre just doing the right route cause theyre idiots

plush tendon
coarse bay
#

The current meta doesnt see much benefit in shout buff

lusty grotto
#

of all the things they could do he says FbV LMAO

#

at this point you gotta think blizzard "interns" do a better job at balancing

ocean valley
#

cause all id like to is a little more self sustain

coarse bay
#

Not all tanks need to self heal

ocean valley
#

so whats your fix for rot dmg?

#

or just general defense survival?

lusty grotto
#

are battleaxes rot damage?

#

yes or no question

ivory barn
#

Battle Axe require kite KEKW

ocean valley
#

or just cc, but thats not the point

lusty grotto
#

you didnt answer the question

ocean valley
#

you didnt answer mine

coarse bay
#

Are tanks dying to rot?

lusty grotto
#

you didnt have a question

#

oh nice edit

ocean valley
#

there, guess i had to grammar it for ya

#

didnt realize this was slow town

lofty warren
#

In skyreach bear only does 120k compared to pwar 100k (at 2 levels higher) which is a smaller gap than 40k in AA

lusty grotto
#

what rot damage are you dying to? the kind that can be outplayed?

ocean valley
#

i wonder if bear has to kite

plush tendon
coarse bay
#

Rot dmg isnt a problem for tanks usually

lusty grotto
#

can you give examples of this "rot damage"?

ocean valley
#

i like how youre going so in depth into this like you dont know what im talking about

lusty grotto
#

and can you answer my question: are battleaxes rot damage?

lofty warren
#

I woild say they are noy

#

But they do hurt

ocean valley
#

depends on what you classify as rot, any dot or bleed?

lusty grotto
#

i didnt ask you

#

its a yes or no question

#

are they or are they not

coarse bay
lusty grotto
#

are battleaxes rot damage

#

yes or no

ocean valley
#

if you have to kite you dont do as much dmg

ocean valley
#

im done talking to you nimchip, this conversation going nowhere since you dont seem to grasp the plot

lusty grotto
#

with the amount of dodging going on with this guy id say he def cannot play a prot warrior

ocean valley
#

i just dont care to argue with a dumbass

lusty grotto
#

stick to brew or bear

coarse bay
#

People are convinced that bear is 5x stronger than every other tank

lusty grotto
#

its a yes or no question darling, its pretty easy

ocean valley
#

no

lusty grotto
#

if you do not understand whats currently "wrong", we have no business with you

#

it aint "rot damage"

lofty warren
#

I wouldn't mind if blizz gave back spell block + buffed aoe stomp damage by 300% (for aoe threat issues just like bear)

ocean valley
#

then tell me whats wrong and how you would fix it

#

ill be waiting

lusty grotto
#

blizz fixes dungeon design

#

thats it

#

when have we EVER needed self sustain

ocean valley
#

are you srs

lusty grotto
#

did we need self sustain in BFA when we were meta for basically the entire expansion?

plush tendon
#

this convo aint going anywhere

lusty grotto
#

did we need self sustain TWW S4?

ocean valley
lusty grotto
#

"are you srs"

#

hey i gave you my answer

#

is it not dungeon design? list your points here

plush tendon
# ocean valley tell me about it

listen, if you want us to get riled up about current tank balance, it aint gonna happen. Personally, I think Prot War is in fine spot, but there are just better options for pushing M+

undone beacon
#

I want the opinion of the #1 parsing 230 pwarr in the world personally

ocean valley
#

i think theyre in a fine spot for raids

plush tendon
#

well see how things change over this expansion, but all things considered, Prot War is solid

undone beacon
#

That guy prob has an ideal take

lofty warren
coarse bay
#

No offense, but i dont think youre playing at the level where pwar falls behind bear. Neither do i

undone beacon
lament osprey
#

Idk usually just a healer dif in mythic plus for healing

ocean valley
undone beacon
#

wow this guy is awesome

coarse bay
plush tendon
#

also, blatant hostility in this channel is not appreciated; we are more zug zug here with happy vibes

lofty warren
plush tendon
lusty grotto
#

i could smell it a mile away

coarse bay
lament osprey
#

There are a lot of bad prot warriors for sure

ivory barn
plush tendon
#

if you want to improve as a Prot War this is the place, otherwise, general complaining about tank balance in high end M+ is just soooo boring of a convo

lusty grotto
#

0 good points, doesnt have a core definition of what hes crying about, immediately goes into ad-hominem attacks lmao

plush tendon
#

reddit is a better place for that

lament osprey
#

I got declined to a 19 AA

ocean valley
#

it aint even about high end keys, its about balancing in general. meta just refindes the rest of the game. even down to the low lvl shit. if yall really can look at a meta where one class does defense, dmg, utility, and mobility better than another and think thats ok

undone beacon
#

Dude feels the need to be an asshole about a joke he has no context for not even directed at him keks

#

This guy is a munch, fr

coarse bay
#

Then skill issue

plush tendon
#

Actually, low key meta is a good convo

#

I still think Prot Pal is S tier for weekly keys

lusty grotto
#

to reddit with you

plush tendon
lusty grotto
#

or the wow forums i guess

coarse bay
plush tendon
ocean valley
plush tendon
#

the buffs for sure help

ivory barn
lofty warren
#

I mean i dont necessarily disagree with kon that at least right now the tank balance feels like there are have an have nots with pwar being the have nots. Its not horrible but id say about 20%-40% worse that the "optimal tanks"

lusty grotto
lofty warren
#

Even ignoring all defensiveness and just look at damage

ivory barn
#

Nimchip helped me get a rank 4 parse, what are you complaining about

coarse bay
#

You and your damage deadge

#

Lets look at the dps balance then

plush tendon
#

no cap

ocean valley
coarse bay
#

There’s no blizz glaze

#

They suck

lusty grotto
#

the guy is agreeing with pepega of all people

vocal lintel
#

I think Blood DK is king of low keys, prot pala is close. No healer for tank needed ,ability to solo stuff down and grips for bdk vs buffs and party healing for pala.

undone beacon
#

Joins class discord
Whines incessantly
Gets mad when people dont suck him off for his opinions
???
Profit

ocean valley
#

then be more upset they let a class be better than you at everything

plush tendon
coarse bay
#

Balancing could be better, yes, but warrior isnt as bad as youre trying to make it sound

plush tendon
#

shield is sooo nice

coarse bay
#

I think you dont like warrior, maybe it isnt for you

ocean valley
#

i dont think its bad

undone beacon
#

Do you not have anything else to do with your day, go play another game if you're not happy with the state of it

ocean valley
#

im just stating AGAIN like the billionth time

#

it pales in comparsion to another tank

plush tendon
#

yea, we know

coarse bay
#

It doesnt pale in comparison

undone beacon
#

Okay? Go play that tank then. What is whining here doing about it

lofty warren
undone beacon
#

You think we don't know that there is a meta tank?

#

Are you that dumb?

jagged pier
#

if u care so much

#

play the other tank

undone beacon
#

We like pwarr so we play it, simple as

lusty grotto
#

its funny how whenever we're not meta its "we dont have utility! we dont have self sustain!", but then a meta season comes around and apparently those points are moot

ocean valley
#

a meta tank is only meant ot be the best tank, not best at everything. thats what you all fail to realize. and you sit here happy about it

undone beacon
#

Whining in discord doesnt do shit

ocean valley
#

bunch of trolls fr

lofty warren
#

Ohh yea im sure there's a bigger gap between unholy dk and whatever the worst dps is

undone beacon
lusty grotto
#

always

jagged pier
#

ppl said we had utility last time we were meta

#

we have more than last time

lusty grotto
#

"buff FbV" LMAOOOOOOOO i cant

jagged pier
#

and other tanks have the same

undone beacon
#

If we're not beating every other tank by a country mile we're fucking TRASH

#

But if we're meta, we're literally perfect

#

Simple as

jagged pier
lofty warren
#

Im dumb, what is fbv

jagged pier
#

it does

lusty grotto
#

fueled by violence pepega

jagged pier
#

so theres nothing to complain about

#

i dont have a problem getting into groups

ocean valley
#

i actually hate when were the best while other tanks suffer, cause again. it all leads back to a balancing issue

jagged pier
#

if u care so much about pushing find a group

ocean valley
#

20 yrs in now and we still have such dumb shit

vital stirrup
lofty warren
#

Why buff self healing rend thing

undone beacon
#

Its almost like an MMORPG with 13 classes and like 70 specs is going to be impossible to make perfectly evenly balanced and you should go back to minecraft or something

ocean valley
#

its rly no wonder the game industry is a pile of shit if this is the general consesus these days. happy with garbage

coarse bay
jagged pier
#

literally no tanks are suffering right now

lament osprey
#

Just skill issue now

coarse bay
#

Youre looking at the absolute top level of play to make your judgement

lament osprey
#

The 0.1% to be exact

jagged pier
#

look at all the paladins complaining that u cant play crit wings, yet yoda was playing crit wings in 20s

#

so is crit wings bad or ppl bad?

#

or is m+ about group play more than any class or talent setup

coarse bay
#

Yoda literally sold 21s on ppal, the carry doing 50k dps less than hopeful

wary gyro
#

theres always going to be a "best" of any role the only way for there not to be is for every spec to play exactly the same, most of the idea of the gap comes from community perception rather than what the spec is actually capable of

undone beacon
#

And the community we have is Kon keks

lofty warren
#

Would it be fair to say that yoda is a savante and sometimes savantes can get away with things that us mere mortals cant?

undone beacon
#

Instead of just playing they game they whine in discord and on forums

coarse bay
undone beacon
#

Or playing literally any other game

#

You dont have to support blizz and pay for a sub if you arent happy with it

jagged pier
#

☝️

lament osprey
#

Kiratank was doing 19s last month I think on prot warrior

#

Before buffs

#

And boosting ilvl

coarse bay
#

It’s simply that nobody’s playing it

jagged pier
#

sense 1 shot most of the keys on 20s before buffs

lofty warren
lament osprey
#

Hmmm, all evidence

plush tendon
#

ya know, with the ease of gearing, it prob contributes to the fact there is such a imbalance

#

its soo easy to have a 'raid toon; and a 'M+' toon

coarse bay
#

^

lament osprey
#

Man, the ability to hard swap to a toon is crazy now though

plush tendon
#

like, there is almost no reason to not swap

#

but, back when it was harder, youd didnt have that option

coarse bay
#

Exactly

plush tendon
#

could take weeks to get a new character up and running

lofty warren
#

I like how easy it is to swap

plush tendon
#

I do as well

coarse bay
ivory barn
#

You could get 11/14 mythic this week in loot on a character without trying

coarse bay
#

It’s good, yes, but expect extreme imbalances at the top end

lofty warren
plush tendon
lusty grotto
#

i mean larias

plush tendon
#

thats crazy

lusty grotto
#

got turbo geared on his prot war

#

he has posted it a few times

#

his prot warrior has more ilvl than my main

lament osprey
#

The numbers are you can only craft two items and mythic upgrade all

plush tendon
#

so for people who are very invested in pushing score, especially a role like tank where its kind of expected that you can play them all, there is really no reason to not have a bear or monk

dusky canopy
#

He did level 80 - 90 and also hit 287 ilvl in like 2 days lmao

lusty grotto
#

well to be fair, nimchipadin also got higher ilvl last week than my warrior

lament osprey
#

But now with crest cap gone. No need to worry

plush tendon
lament osprey
plush tendon
#

though thats mostly cause I had to get voidcore things last week

lament osprey
#

First world problems out here

lusty grotto
#

lol

lofty warren
#

Guess when bear got 300% buff to thrash so they could hold aoe threat better?

coarse bay
#

I stopped raiding when my mage was like 281, my pally passed it the same week. This was like a month ago or something

#

It’s the whole season

plush tendon
#

literally overnight

#

people were on bears

#

remember when Prot Pal had their big rework in DF? It took a couple of weeks for the meta to shift off Prot War to Prot Pal

#

This swap is instant

coarse bay
lusty grotto
#

yeah that basically happened

plush tendon
lusty grotto
#

rdruid into bear, brew into MW

plush tendon
#

but they decided to just gear new toons

coarse bay
#

Ya better long term

#

Still more power coming anyways

#

So the push isnt over

plush tendon
#

they were annoyed with the meta shift and complained that they had to swap

#

but, if gearing were harder, the swap would be much less attractive and I forsure think that less groups would have done it

coarse bay
#

It’s def odd that there was a shift this late into season but tbh it added a lot more comp variation

lofty warren
#

Blood moving by 3-5% each week

plush tendon
#

now its like 'bear buffed, everyone swap by EoD'

ivory barn
#

Tanks in guild were like "if they nerf me we stop raiding" lol

plush tendon
#

tbh, there was a little concern with bear when they nerfed their ST

coarse bay
#

I think bear was a little special due to it being used for raid and also having had potential early on. So i think a lot of people had them at least partially ready

plush tendon
#

since it was a 'cheat code' for Myth Belo pre nerf

plush tendon
lofty warren
#

Even before the tuning there were some bears doing 1 key below brew as dotc

plush tendon
#

like BDK damage is piss, but its prob the best tank on Lura prog

#

for most groups

#

or Prot War on Myth Paladins

coarse bay
#

Plus there’s no way anybody needs the damage from tanks at this point

plush tendon
#

naw, not for any of the fights

#

the only fights that needed the dam were pre nerf Belo and maybe RWF Lura

#

but liquid to make that work had to play OUT OF THEIR MIND in p1

#

like, the coordination for grouping that 3rd set of P1 adds with no bdk

#

insane work

coarse bay
#

Didnt someone mention max saying that they only did bear for leeway incase of a death?

#

Like they didnt actually need the dmg or something

plush tendon
#

idk, but I do know that damage checks on RWF was quite tight

coarse bay
#

The belo damage was crazy though

lusty grotto
#

well it was also because of the apex reset thing

plush tendon
#

oh 100%

lofty warren
#

Bear damage on egg was out doing other dps on egg i believe

plush tendon
#

it was legit nuts

#

but thats all bear brings to raid

#

and brew is actually kind of useless in Mythic Raid

#

not even all that tanky

#

Prot War is much tankier on raid bosses (unironically prob the tankiest)

coarse bay
#

But ya not intended

lofty warren
#

Bear bring buff, brez, tankiness, big damage. What else could you want tank to do? sadge

coarse bay
#

If rdruid was stronger than mw u wouldnt be seeing bears rn btw

plush tendon
#

How to pick a raid tank 101: Do you need grips? If yes, BDK is BiS. Do you need a raid buff? If yes, play the tank with raid buff

ivory barn
coarse bay
#

Mage at the bottom deadge

#

Dead class

plush tendon
#

a little sadge tbh

#

I think Frost is super cool

coarse bay
#

Overpruned mage

#

Yet didnt touch some tanky specs

plush tendon
#

someone has to do something about the evokers

#

literal getting carried to top IO

lofty warren
#

Paladin top but there's also a bigger pool of them

coarse bay
#

Funny how the took aug out back for a couple of seasons

plush tendon
#

Paladin is really good in this dungeon pool

#

for solving the problems presented

coarse bay
#

And theyre back to actually just being the best spec

coarse bay
plush tendon
#

its a S tier class for me for weekly keys

coarse bay
#

But the comp needed is a bit different

plush tendon
#

super easy, durable, can play at range, great util

#

not super CD relient/frequent access to damage

#

whats not to like?

coarse bay
#

The people that play ret

lofty warren
#

How is the current dungeon design bad for pwars now and tww s3 was good? Imo except for nexus dungeon design is much smaller than "pwar not do good damage"

ivory barn
#

Is there a cheat sheet on what dungeon to swap fttf for?

plush tendon
lofty warren
#

Use fttf on AA is the only one I know for sure

plush tendon
#

I just dont have enough experience doing high enough keys with this dungeon set

hazy crest
plush tendon
#

but I also dont think Prot War was that far ahead of the field in S3 of War Within

#

Prot Pal and Brew were for sure good in their own right

coarse bay
#

Ppal and brew were both competitive last season, warrior buff was good in the comp

#

Warrior damage plus buff brought a ton of dmg

jagged gust
#

Everything is good, some are gooder

#

4 legs good, 2 legs better

coarse bay
#

Tbh even bear was good last season

coarse bay
#

But things like the db debuff were very painful for them

#

Last season had very good tank tuning

tribal wharf
#

me in 2004/5 wow

#

except dwarf

lofty warren
#

Whats db debuf

plush tendon
#

Dawnbreaker debuff?

#

I assume after 1st boss

lofty warren
#

1st boss was nerfed bigly in s1 if I recall? That one dungeon with the priests for 2 seasons in a row was cruel and unusual punishment

coarse bay
#

The stacking debuff

#

From the trash

ivory barn
#

Wonder what S2 dungeon pool will be

plush tendon
#

since they could ursols to reset

coarse bay
#

Idk i heard db was a pain point for bear

#

My friends have a russian bear friend

undone beacon
#

The healing debuff stacked up super fast in DB and even once you got it down, it would stack up fast and ruin your day

#

Lot of magic damage too, which Ironfur didnt do much to help with

coarse bay
#

Ya i remember on my bear id look and be 99 stacks super quick deadge

#

But im a casual

undone beacon
#

Bear was giga for weekly keys last season

#

The damage was mid but it was so brain-off

#

Back in the Thorns of Iron days

ivory barn
undone beacon
#

Blizz music team boutta really pop off

undone beacon
#

Through some horrific pattern matching and word association I associate Johnny Cash with Aint no rest for the wicked by Cage the Elephant

#

Everytime I see his name I just hear the opening to that song

torn gulch
#

That video is an incredible representation of how ret players see themselves

#

Should be pinned on the ret paladin discord

opal lodge
#

yo if anyone can answer me this question would be great 🙂
haste 28% unbuffed(1100)
vers 5% unbuffed(282)

should i be using ver flask or haste ?

#

or that little vers doesnt matter

undone beacon
#

Haste

#

Just default to haste

opal lodge
#

easy

#

ty

ivory barn
#

When in doubt, haste it out KEKW

opal ledge
#

i was not expecting a haste helm in my vault...
this means i can go 1200 haste without the voidclaw gloves

#

how many ilvl a socket worth?

coarse bay
#

Its like 0.7% uppy for some dps specs but im sure it varies

#

Not worth ilvl though

#

Its a bonus, same with tert

robust moon
#

Question for you guys, I have both Heart of Ancient Hunger and Gaze of the Alnseer trinkets as 6/6 Hero. I will never Mythic raid because I just want to push high keys. Are those trinkets still BiS as Hero or are some Myth dungeon trinkets better?

lusty grotto
#

"bis" lists are always myth track

#

but they are not set in stone

#

they are just required for guides on websites such as icy veins (the one we support) or wowhead

#

you always want to sim

robust moon
#

Do I sim for damage since they are dps trinket?

lusty grotto
#

yes, like all tanks do

robust moon
#

Alright

lusty grotto
#

they are not strictly dps trinkets

#

heart has crit, gaze has strength

#

all of our secondaries and our primary stat have defensive value

#

the only way to get a sense of how much youre gaining is to sim

#

if you gain dps due to them, it means you gain defensiveness as well

robust moon
#

Thanks

ivory barn
#

Time to triple roll WRS and be sad

undone beacon
#

Yo what the flip IV had a big ol CSS overhaul

#

@ionic fern When did they do that

ivory barn
#

O.o thats a nice looking site

coarse bay
#

Did they make us S tier

lusty grotto
#

we're all S tier

#

in my heart

daring marlin
#

correct

lusty grotto
unkempt pebble
#

S tier Nim

cold pilot
#

If I have myth heart of ancient hunger and hero plume, do I need to worry about Gaze?

#

I'm simming now but I figured I'd ask 😄

ivory barn
#

fps? stonks.
looks? trash af

coarse bay
#

Assuming myth gaze

undone beacon
#

Wildin

#

I was gonna watch the new season but it seems the reviews place it as pretty middling

opal ledge
#

why i cant simulate the darkmoon trinkets

urban bane
undone beacon
unkempt pebble
#

I still use champion gaze

opal ledge
#

i'm with a single embleshiment equiped and it dont let me sim a single trinket

unkempt pebble
#

Sims better than most trinkets

opal ledge
#

i want get max ilvl possible, helps with invite, so i will craft one trinket to replace a hero heart of hunger, but can simulate which darkmoon is better

undone beacon
#

Hover over the little warning icon and see what it says

opal ledge
daring marlin
#

4 was the worst season

coarse bay
# opal ledge

Max out currencies at the top if u dont have enough

final jackal
#

do we open vault as prot or fury/arms?

lusty grotto
#

no reason to open as dps

#

you get all good trinkets as tank

#

if you have myth 1h and myth shield, you can opt to go dps to just remove those from the pool

ivory barn
#

guess its time to try a dungeon KEKW

opal ledge
tribal wharf
#

some day

ivory barn
#

10-15k increase.... all I fucking did was mentally be in the mob

#

12 Pit

lusty grotto
#

this is a retail channel

#

in case you mean wrath classic or something

modern patio
#

Oh yea sorry i just got into the server. Will delete and write it in general

lusty grotto
#

if you want

#

maybe they'll be able to help you out there

modern patio
#

Aight thanks

lusty grotto
#

i could but im a vanilla player so im not up to date on the classic version

#

stack armor pen i guess? 🙂

#

def capped for trial of the crusader or something?

#

is the unblockable set still a thing

modern patio
lusty grotto
#

its been a hot minute for me

modern patio
lusty grotto
#

i see

ivory barn
#

blizzard and the lovely random DCes

ivory barn
#

whats teh best 2 trinkets to Myth track in M+?

coarse bay
#

heart of wind and the solar whatever from skyreach? maybe?

#

probably sim it

#

idk heart and gaze are fairly puggable

ivory barn
#

gaze would be nice

proud marlin
#

Looking to dip into some mythic+ as prot, are there any essential add ons I should look at getting? Like is there an add on for good routes?

lusty grotto
#

if youre just starting, just use the guidance thing

#

MDT is the tool for routes, but youre gonna have to look for them, i recommend the raider.io weekly routes and keystone.guru

#

i wouldn't worry about routing early keys though, just press W and use soridormi's guidance

#

its more than enough

oak ivy
#

i got fed up with having a garbage ass fury parse on dragons, had to employ the mythical 4 tank strat

ocean heath
#

am I supposed to get scared when my HP is dropping and IP is instantly popped?

lusty grotto
#

do you have SB up?

ocean heath
#

yea

lusty grotto
#

IP instantly popping doesnt mean much

ocean heath
#

i feel naked without it lol

sleek forge
#

is 285 crafted shield with embellishment better than a 289 shield

lusty grotto
#

have you looked at my wall of text on how to use IP

#

cause you should feel naked (or bare ass if youre taking back hits) if SB is down only

#

IP being down is 🤷‍♂️

lusty grotto
#

but sims could have told you that

#

just recraft the embelishment on another piece

#

shield is always ilvl > all

#

you dont get block value anywhere else

ocean heath
#

how do you tell if you suck or if it's the dps or healer? sometimes it's like I'm fighting for my life on a relatively normal pull and then other times it's cake on big pulls with other groups

lusty grotto
#

logs

#

if youre inexperienced

#

otherwise its easy to tell for me

ocean heath
#

Like I use shield wall, but thats only 8 seconds x 2 on a pull that could last a minute+

lusty grotto
#

either way logs are good proof

#

cant really work on hypotheticals, we need logs

#

or with with, i should say

ocean heath
#

but you shouldnt need shield wall to survive throughout a whole pull right?

lusty grotto
#

it depends on a lot of variables

#

again, logs and we can tell you

#

and also there's 0 reason why you should hold a wall

#

considering AM

ocean heath
#

yea i use it as much as possible, but sometimes it seems like Im getting my ass beat when it falls off

lusty grotto
#

link a log

ocean heath
#

well i guess I gotta figure how to log lol

unkempt pebble
#

Check what really does damage in those pulls

lusty grotto
#

and see if there's a log associated with the leaderboard entry

unkempt pebble
#

Dont be afraid to use defensive stance

lusty grotto
#

wdym dont be afraid

oak ivy
#

bro

lusty grotto
#

he SHOULD be in defensive stance

#

the only reason you're not in defensive stance is for raid parsing when not actively tanking OR if youre doing baby/vault keys just for shits and iggles

#

this has been the case since TWW

#

theres 0 reason to be in battle stance otherwise

vale escarp
#

If I got myth Shild and Weapon it's fine opening vault as Arms to get some offspec weapon?

lusty grotto
#

sure

unkempt pebble
lusty grotto
#

but look up your character first, so we can go off of that

lusty grotto
#

its a very small optimization that just is not worth it

#

the recommendation should never be "you should not be afraid to use defensive stance"

#

battle stance is not our neutral stance

#

this aint DF

unkempt pebble
#

Yea, the reason i said dont be afraid is, its the defensive tool that most new tanks often overlook its defensive value

lusty grotto
#

what???

#

bro, you log in and you're basically in dstance

#

just dont say things like "Dont be afraid to use defensive stance"

#

thats it

unkempt pebble
#

Fair

#

My bad

lusty grotto
#

youre good

undone beacon
#

Be afraid to use defensive stance

#

Be very afraid

#

Everytime you turn it on it sends your data to Big Defensives

opal ledge
#

how hard it is chimerus mythic with pugs only?

undone beacon
#

It’s doable

#

Depends heavily on the group you get

opal ledge
#

i hate that raid trinkets are overtuned

ocean heath
#

hmm just realized now that piercing howl gives you speed boost

#

now do you hold SB charges while a boss is in a casting phase or still use it for more shield slam damage

lusty grotto
#

are you talking about raids?

ocean heath
#

dungeon

lusty grotto
#

are you playing into the fray?

#

take a look at the pins

#

you shouldn't be playing it if you dont have the required haste

#

and furthermore, the standard build in icyveins has Heavy Rep, not ITF

ivory barn
ocean heath
#

hmm ill have to look

lusty grotto
#

and make sure youre using the icy veins talents

glacial ridge
#

Ive been trying to get into a group, i know the fight, but I only tank on warrior so finding a spot has been hard (especially that I play in OCE so if it isnt OCE or LA, the lag is def noticeable)

undone beacon
tacit smelt
#

Can someone refresh my memory here regarding boss roll interact. If i get the myth item from vault is the item still going to be on the bonus roll loot table for the dungeon?

undone beacon
#

It is still on the table, yes

#

The only way to pull an item off the loot table is to roll it

wooden spruce
#

Made a similar rant on the ppally and dk discord but i also want your take here

seems i need to change or start ignoring my pushing team

they now want me to go bear, stop playing ppally anyomore because "noone is using them on MDI so they are crap spec" and not use pwarr/bdk after 15s because its also not used on MDI and only appeared on one key

and now they are straight up ignoring me for 15s/16s

i only wanna go up to 16s

undone beacon
#

Not to be an ass, but if you only want to go up to 16s it seems your goals are misaligned as is

#

Unless everyone else wants to stop at 16 too

#

If you want to play ppal and not swap for the comp, that’s totally fine. But they’re also not obligated to have you tank for them any more than you’re obligated to

wooden spruce
#

the goal was for everyone to do 16s and thats it but this season they became meta elitist

and this people are my friends irl

undone beacon
#

That shit happens, it sucks for sure

#

But if they’ve caught the M+ push bug and now want to go farther, then the goals are misaligned. Not saying that ppal cant go farther, especially in a dedicated group with comms

#

The “no one is using them in MDI so they are crap” line of rationale is very dumb tho

#

Like, very silly rationale. I’d be pissed about it too

#

At the end of the day they don’t pay your sub so they can’t tell you what to play. It sucks that they’re irl friends being dicks about a game, but at the end of the day it’s a game and I’d advise you to try and not let it ruin real friendships peepo

wooden spruce
#

im maining bdk, ppally i know is having issues but meh, they even ignored when they asked for dps, thats what pissed me off

one of them has done 18s and i've not asked him to joim because its what he wanna do

lofty glen
#

i have myth hands and hero head..... do i take the rare hands from seat?

#

hed has leech too

undone beacon
#

Technically seat gloves are farmable with rolls, and if I had to guess… myth helm will probably outsim on stat budget from hero to myth

#

But always worth a quick sin

undone beacon
sharp rover
wooden spruce
#

i think i'll take a break from tanking with them, and from doing higher keys after 12s, need a break

sharp rover
#

I can't even imagine IRL friends ignoring my messages like that. I'd have to ask if they're even really "friends"

wooden spruce
#

yeh, hey at least today i pass all my midterms haha

undone beacon
undone beacon
#

Don’t burn yourself out over group drama and the likes

#

Take the game at your pace. Pug through your 16s. Be a gamer regardless

wooden spruce
#

they wanted to sell carry, maybe they are pissed because i told them i dont wanna burn myself with that, already did it in the past and became a 2nd job that almost made me quit wow

round pendant
#

Your friends are cooked

#

Tank spec literally does not matter at that key level

jolly nimbus
#

ST Sims are telling me to gem off haste to Crit/mast with only 1036 haste am i being sim-baited here or is haste less value in raid?

vital vale
vale escarp
ionic fern
lone wren
#

to heal i onyl ahve ignore pain and victory thign no?

ionic fern
#

Leech,Ignore Pain,Impending Victory,Indom(if talented).

#

IP is also not a heal,just a absorb.

jagged pier
#

technically LS is a heal too

crisp ocean
#

did they change the ui of icy veins?

tacit smelt
#

yippee 3700

jagged pier
crisp ocean
jagged pier
#

thats subjective

crisp ocean
#

opinionated yes, but you cant please everyone

ionic fern
#

Looks better in my eyes.

dusty wedge
#

I agree, bit less 2000's vibes

round pendant
#

It's more intuitive I'd say

#

but icy veins hadn't changed in god knows how long

#

I liked it :(

vocal plaza
#

i have Myth track rings on the 2 rings from Seat (and + avoidance on one of the rings) and the Purloined Wedding RIng. Do i run the seat ring set or do i run the wedding ring + seat ring with haste/vers?

jagged pier
#

u dont run seat set its bad and pointless

vocal plaza
#

cheers

vital vale
#

if you dont step in bad you have 100% avoidance anyway

#

and unavoidable aoe damage isn't a threat to tanks anyway

broken marsh
#

Do flasks/buffs effect your breakpoiint?

broken marsh
jagged pier
#

no

next umbra
#

is it better to use myth crafted or myth weapon/shield for embelli?

jagged pier
#

myth wep and shield

#

and embleishment somewhere else

next umbra
#

what if im full myth tracked all slots

jagged pier
#

u still want emblieshments just nto on wep or shield

#

usually back and bracers

next umbra
#

aah

fringe mural
#

the weapon dps for your mainhand and the armor of your shield is too powerful to forfeit the extra ilvl for the weapon embellishment

#

in fury it's different, there the offhand dps is unimportant enough to keep the crafted oh

#

Primary and secondary stat difference of crafted vs 6/6 myth mainhand isn't really high
but it's the weapon dmg

#

the offhand weapon dps of the dw classes only scales half i think so embellish comes out ahead and they keep their crafted offhand

hardy snow
#

I like it, when I can just go to the vendor and buy as much myth crests as I need erga

stone tundra
#

my stupid ass did the upgrade thing before even tho i knew that moment would come

jagged pier
#

u never do that

stone tundra
#

i know

#

but i wanted upgrade fast

plush tendon
#

late to party, but if your 'push team' is doing 16s and thinks they need a bear or monk... they are actually cooked XD

#

also crazy comms to not play with the bois; thats 101 not homie behavior

#

and if they want you to play bear or monk (and you decide to give it a go)... they better fucking help you gear it

hardy snow
#

swap to bear, play bad so they regret forcing you to swap chatting

jagged pier
#

u cant play bear bad tho

hardy snow
#

unbind thrash clueless

jagged pier
#

swipe bis

plush tendon
#

to me, it just sounds like they feel hardstuck, looking for a scapegoat, and the first obvious choice is 'omg, its our tank!'

#

which is crazy coms

hardy snow
#

damn you Jakey, always one step ahead nodders

fringe mural
#

When i started levelling the bear, i bound swipe

#

Only to never use it again

#

sad spell is sad

#

Like ww on prot

#

so useless

#

i mean it is good for one thing though

#

doing old content

#

You just run and ww because ww has no cd and no rage cost

#

and any spell will kill stuff

ivory barn
#

Github being nuked wasn't on the bingo card

fringe mural
#

sry what?

ivory barn
#

Idk how to explain what happened but internal hack

jagged pier
#

it got breached

fringe mural
#

Oh no

#

Anyways

#

do you guys think mage will get a new spell in s2?

#

ring of fire?

#

badumm tiss

jagged pier
#

praying for shaman tank

fringe mural
#

because johnny cash returned to blizzard

glacial ridge
fringe mural
#

Today i transmuted adventure crests into mythic ones

#

81 to 1

#

like a true casual

plush tendon
#

the prune into Midnight hurt them quite a bit I feel like

#

though it could also just be a numbies thing

ivory barn
#

I played frostfire mage for a bit, kinda like it

plush tendon
#

Frost is really fun imo

#

though, it can get a bit stale

fringe mural
#

Spellslinger is pretty repetitive

#

idk about frostfire, i just know it's worse dps wise

plush tendon
#

havnt put too much time in my mage other then getting to 90 and some delves and what not

#

though, If I were to add new toons to play as a alt, it would be near the top... though I guess I should be gearing/leveling my brew and bear so I have all the tanks max leveled/geared

royal marten
#

Mage just needs some actual defensives back again mostly. Arcane needs to revert to TWW style too.

#

Mirror images no longer having DR blows, it was the only way to have a short term wall for rot damage.

coarse bay
#

I mean it wasnt a short term wall

royal marten
#

Short as in a lower cd wall

coarse bay
#

It had high uptime

#

I think the pruning would be ok if they gave it some passive to make up for it

royal marten
#

tbh just removing dr from greater invis would've been enough imo. No dual barrier/ice cold talent rither

#

Either*

coarse bay
#

Frost has had the extra defensives forever though

#

It’s just always tuned poorly

#

Mage is in a sad state

#

I think frost would be less stale with an actually impactful cd

crisp ocean
#

8 dungeons and no loot what the frick

royal marten
#

Have you tried getting lucky?

crisp ocean
#

I used 3 bonus rolls too

undone beacon
coarse bay
coarse bay
#

Looks like 2 slots perfect for crafting

royal marten
#

Or hell, just the random ass blues on the AH lmao

#

That's some strong commitment to the bit tho

crisp ocean
#

no I need upgrade from dungeon

crisp ocean
#

ig

undone beacon
#

133 ring is literally like last season keks

coarse bay
undone beacon
#

I mean crests are uncapped now

plush tendon
undone beacon
#

So if you're farming anyways, think of it like bad luck protection

plush tendon
#

3/10

crisp ocean
coarse bay
#

Yup

#

Keep playing

undone beacon
#

Very cool

#

Doesnt change my statement keks

coarse bay
#

Cant expect fully geared in 8 dungeons

crisp ocean
coarse bay
#

Ya

coarse bay
#

That is indeed not fully geared

undone beacon
plush tendon
#

I wonder if well see some patch notes for the .7

#

since they released the artwork

#

we usually get a rework or two around this time

undone beacon
#

Speaking of fully geared, once I have my crests for the week I'll be completely done gearing the priest until Sporefall

plush tendon
undone beacon
#

Full myth gang

crisp ocean
undone beacon
#

Thats not a patch note, thats a quest on the ptr

plush tendon
#

both still need 2 items to be full myth

undone beacon
#

Brutal

#

The last holdneck was my neck but i ended up taking Salhadaar neck from vault because shadow loves crit now

plush tendon
#

though its just rings on my war... hoping for good RNG in Nexus Point this week

#

I should have close to like a 66% chance of getting both this week

fringe mural
plush tendon
undone beacon
#

I got really lucky with my rolls in NPX, pulled one ring from the vault and the other from my first roll peepo

plush tendon
#

not even playstyle... I just think other tanks look cooler

crisp ocean
fringe mural
#

i really like the feel of prot pala

crisp ocean
#

thats it lol

plush tendon
#

heck, at least Bear is a Bear

#

and I love bears

crisp ocean
plush tendon
fringe mural
#

it's also squishy af

crisp ocean
#

bear is my least favorite

crisp ocean
plush tendon
#

Prot Pal is the S+ tier weekly key tank

#

and I stand by that

fringe mural
#

Hell i got two shot when running my first t11 delves to gear

undone beacon
#

Part of me wanted to play the crest optimization game and upgrade my warrs wrists to max to get discount on the priest but them i remembered its uncapped now keks

fringe mural
#

for whom the bell tolls

plush tendon
#

insane burst, amazing snap threat

fringe mural
#

dong

undone beacon
fringe mural
#

everything dies

undone beacon
plush tendon
#

VDH is fun; mine is pretty geared

#

but snap threat is just ugggg sometimes

fringe mural
#

also avenger's shield is such a satisfying spell to use

plush tendon
#

and with new util tools being added to other tanks, sigils feel kind of meh now

undone beacon
#

Unrelated, is there any use for hero crests aside from turning them into myth now?

fringe mural
#

for bonus rolls?

plush tendon
#

to save on Voidlight Mari/Gold when buying bonus rolls

torn gulch
#

i mean 5k is nothing

undone beacon
#

Why would i do that when i have 18 quadrillion marl keks

fringe mural
#

oh no 5k gold

plush tendon
#

i have like no mari

undone beacon
#

to be fair the 5k adds up across alts

ivory barn
#

I have used crests every week lol

fringe mural
#

yeah they do

#

but the alt also get multiple k

undone beacon
#

i use crests and then marl on alts with no crests

plush tendon
#

if you have the crests, I see no reason not to save the gold

fringe mural
#

From quests

undone beacon
#

rolling a new alt and dropping 25k on rerolls feels kinda stinky

ivory barn
#

Since my broke ass has 20k to my name

undone beacon
#

almost 65k marl

severe star
#

where do you all spend marl

undone beacon
#

after buying all the mounts from rep and the void assault mogs

severe star
#

ah

plush tendon
#

I need my guild to kill Lura

#

so we can start doing sales

fringe mural
undone beacon
#

You buy rep stuff with it. Each mount is like 8k marl

fringe mural
#

mounts, toys, pets and decor

undone beacon
#

Its also like 25k marl to get the purple T2 sets

fringe mural
#

i don't buy the ugly transmog though

plush tendon
undone beacon
#

And yeah if you fuck with housing then decor stuff is the marl sink

#

But to be fair i havent touched my house since the xpac launched

coarse bay
#

Marl has been draining through the bonus tokens on all alts for me

plush tendon
#

im still peeved my guild neighborhood is horde

#

instead of alliance

fringe mural
#

you struck me as someone who would tbh pash

coarse bay
#

Pash’s house is cool af

#

Even been murdered there

undone beacon
#

I still think housing is a great feature and during the downtime it was fantastic to kill time with but when more productive content came out it was hard to justify lol

plush tendon
#

My house resembles that of a young adult male

#

with limited income

#

so mattress on floor, a kettle in the corner, and a massive TV with surround sound and a lawn chair

undone beacon
#

My horde house is a mad goblin lab and my alliance house is a cozy conservatory peepo

undone beacon
#

To be fair i think if they add a save slot system ill go back and do a lot more with it

#

But i put so much time into what I have, i dont want to rip and replace a bunch of it for the new ideas

fringe mural
#

now that the guy who made pet battles and order halls returns

#

I wonder what comes next tbh

#

i'm a little afraid too

undone beacon
#

wdym order halls were like the best part of legion

fringe mural
#

i loved the artifact weapons too

#

it was something fresh

ivory barn
#

We need a new legendary KEKW

fringe mural
#

i want azurewrath

#

or eldruin

#

either is fine

ivory barn
#

D4 loot in wow monkahmm

severe star
#

its all 16s for 3.4k right?

coarse bay
#

Ya

ivory barn
#

I'ma start trying to get io prolly tonight/tomorrow

fringe mural
ivory barn
#

LMAO

#

No other tank at max prot war only LETSGOOO

fringe mural
#

give it a few days

#

when you come back here all beaten up

#

And declined

#

lol

coarse bay
#

Surely u cant get declined from your own key

ivory barn
#

^

fringe mural
#

well maybe he can

#

they join, they see him and leave

#

'Sry didn't see the class color'

coarse bay
#

I get dps complaining about lfg boss but not tanks

ivory barn
#

Cool, they didn't wish to play the game the fun way then

fringe mural
#

i'm just messing with you

#

you'll do fine

ivory barn
#

It's fun signing up to 2-3 groups tops, switching to dps it's a minimum of 10m before I say fuck it and make my own

fringe mural
#

play the supreme class

ivory barn
#

Meta chasing is for weekend players wanting a title KEKW

#

Must clap to victory

fringe mural
#

mountain thane ahooo

crisp ocean
#

+10s wtf is happening

#

Im getting like 20 applications in one second

ivory barn
#

Welcome to crests no longer capped

fringe mural
#

That's the alt army

#

who is geared now through uncapped hero crests

plush tendon
#

I get so overloaded when I post my key for some weekly 10s

#

I just look for whoever has the coolest name

fringe mural
#

like Hootini

plush tendon
#

insta invite

fringe mural
#

coolest owlkin ever

plush tendon
#

we had Bronnyjr last week

#

had to take him

#

or if I see a class that barely gets played

#

I take them

#

out of pure interest

fringe mural
#

yeah why not

#

Fire mage

#

lol

plush tendon
#

exactly

fringe mural
#

fire mage is visually great

#

also high apm class

#

So skillful too

undone beacon
#

i like people that put a fun note :3

fringe mural
#

or frost dk

plush tendon
#

fun notes are also extra points

#

Frost is actually really good

undone beacon
#

Sometimes I hit em with the "put me in coach im good for the money" when applying

ivory barn