#subtlety
1 messages · Page 227 of 1
One of these things is not like the others
This also highly depends when your guild pushes
if it pushes close to 2min your screwed
Look at 18 mate. That’s nothing to do with pushing.
he is australian
its reversed down there
what can you do
send the dingos after em
The difference between R1 and 18 is the 2min
yes you are. You will say later during full farm you need mostly 90-100 sec push to do good dam
its w/e its first boss doesnt matter
What if you turn it upside down?
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
Is there a fix for tricks bug?
How do I tell the apl to start rupturing X seconds before flagellation comes back up?
Could swear I saw someone posting it here
Cast tricks and hit something in the first 30 seconds.
guys can i trust the raiderbots dslice sim if it tells me to use old 2p + new2p?
instead of old 4p
at high enough ilvls it will be
for the coldblood on second sectech do we just not send it outside of cooldowns? it feels like it doesn't line up with any shadowdance
You just use with flag
so we could lose like 2-3 uses in a 4.30 fight?
feels like if need to have 2 shadow back to back during flag+shadwoblade, i need to hold a shadowdance leading up to the CD back on?
correct, but you can fuck up way more by not using it right on cd. Just not worth it.
i just havent quite worked out when to start holding it. anyone has done the maths?
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
stealthi - can you please help me? is there a maths somewhere when i can start holding shadowdance to be able to have 2 dance back to back for flag + shadowblade?
anyone know how and when to bait amplifiers on mythic rik? we got double amps a lot
Right from the method guide
cool. another question is, are we actually doing not using winning streak (by not doing any evis / bp) until CD are back thing in key?
45 seconds of no evis/bp feels sad if CD back but no big mobs really to be pumped then lol
raccoon has sepsis in guide still.
Ignore tier
What is this blue icon?
A relic of a bygone era
You use it for Flag?
(I don't like boring grey flag icon)
ok so ignore the pinged messaged
What pinged message
Didn't fuu make a recolor of the recolor that looks way better
Got my 4 piece and I regret making WA for tracking it
lol, i swear i didnt make up, but that pinged message from elieen about holding 45 seconds only doing rupture is gone from pinged

it was changed 2 weeks before tier launch
i was about to find that pinged message, and i was able to read it even yesterday, but i can see now it's removed from ping
Like not even 10 seconds before burst window?
guess to not confuse people
i mean i would not use finishers that could reset it but over 100000 sims in average it wont reset enough to be important
on avg it wont matter
is sub better than assasination is better for m+?
Play what you like
Do not compare ret to assa
Ret is pad damage
why is ret pad dmg
nah sub rogue wont top anything apart from burst maybe
Because no prio
sub if can do similar dmg to sin overall, i'd rather play sub, cuz it has more ST in m+ build
i feel like the dps from sub is underwhelming
sub is fine
I'm having a blast while blasting
people don't want to hear this but that's really how it should be in a balanced game. doing all your damage in a tiny burst window is an advantage of its own, you shouldn't also have a top-tier throughput if you have a top-tier burst.
had a lil baby 18mil cinderbrew first pull
ideal tier is everything but gloves yes
cool cool
do you delay cds on hc rik or just start doing that on mythic?
You mean for adds?
Ye
I saw Stealhi and Zac slightly delaying second set of cds
yea on M you begin cds at like 14 secs
Idk im not really a fan of it
on hc idk if you mind that much
havent gotten to the boss
so cant say on hc i just send it
Like the second SecTec was for adds spawn
Maybe I misunderstood
yeh delay em
is house of cards 658 better than 639 transmitter?
its barely better than a 626
depending on your stats it might be neutral or a slight loss
god i didnt get the heroic one and i just wanna get rid of transmitter :c
for me HoC was 0.4% better so I'd imagine its a loss
I don't have transmitter so I use pvp trinket
I got myth signet, do I just hold it for 1m every time?
Yes, i would probably suggest trying to get the pvp trinket (or house of cards/transmitter ofc)
Is there any world where one would refresh rupture outside of Pandemic window before sending Flag window
As 2 minutes is kinda oof
if rupture wont last the entire burst
Perfect ty
There are a lot of Times where rupture has like 12 sec left when 2nd flag comes off cd
And i already am holding coup
I have a mythic transmitter and still opted to use a pvp trink instead
Was like 1% loss but I feel like my openers are much more consistent and I'm not wanting to scream
hahaha fair point yeah, for me right now is 0.6% loss, i might take it and get rid of transmitter
https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/nKRBdkcRCPsBZxG1cQRjAM
might be hard to tell but if i only use coldblood on second sechtech throughout a whole dungeon would that be better than just macroing it?
yes - one of the benefits of a separate CB/SecTec keybind is that it means we always use it during major CDs
which means a guaranteed crit on SecTec when you have another metric shitton of mastery
just full sending with a CB/Sectec macro every time means you'll guarantee a crit on a "normal" sectec (i.e. a sectec you cast between major CDs), which is a DPS loss as CB won't always be back up for shadowblades / etc.
oh wait
yes it would be better
sorry I answered the opposite of your question, have edited above
so only sending in flag/blades would be a dps increase over a whole dungeon aswell, seems crazy but will keep at it
yes
your major CDs account for a LOT of your damage
just try and get the tank to pull big when they're up 
and i guess as you get more comfortable you can try and squeeze a few extra CBs in outside of cds when you will have extended downtime
!sod
Macro to prevent accidental uses of extra charges: #showtooltip Symbols of Death /castsequence reset=2 Symbols of Death,null /cqs
you'd be holding CDs for min 30 secs
if you wanted to align with the CB cooldowns of 1min
which is a bad idea
When to use shuriken or backstab/shadowstrike on aoe?
cd is 45 seconds, so you should get 2 every flag no?
1 during and 1 inbetween potentially
wait am i stupid, i've been working on the assumption it was 1min
Yes but you need to use it literally on cooldown
Otherwise you end up needing to delay flag
Which is not good
correct
fine to risk it, probably ok to risk in dungeons that have a little bit of downtime between packs
but know the trade off is potentially delaying way higher damage
What's the thoughts on Eye of Kezan post nerf? still worth it as a second trinket?
!macro
Subtlety Macros:
It is not recommended to macro most cooldowns, including Cold Blood+Secret Techniques and Dance+Symbols.
The following macros are an exception:
/cast Shadow Dance
/cast Thistle Tea```
```yaml
/cast Shadow Blades
/cast Blood Fury
/cast Ancestral Call
/use House of Cards```
When using diffrent macros, make sure to keep the cooldowns on a seperate key.
Why in the example from my quick sim is it using signet after flag ends
Its doing it at 22s into the pull which is weird. Its not correct I think
how do you guys play during the downtime after your major cds end? and do you use black powder in big pulls?
pulls with more than 8 targets u can use bp
during shadow dance i only use shadowstrike to build, no matter the pull size right? and outside of sd can i use shuriken stom to build or is backstab with nimble flurry better for dmg?
should I backstab after secret tech if i have premed up?
@tepid trellis
my man geared to the teeth
In shadowdance you use shadowstrike. If there are 8+ targets in range, you can cast shuriken storm once for the Danse macarbe stack, but then you go back to shadowstrike.
Outside of shadowdance, you use backstab on ST and shuriken storm on 2+ targets
only loot i got was the junk maestro trinket
think im in unless we change something from last week
wouldnt mind beeing benched
dogshit loot on the boss anyways
Styx is the worst designed boss of the tier
Is there a reason why I cannot socket a red gem on my algari competitors leather goggles
it is not a gem socket
yo btw does 4 piece change any rotation at all in the slightest be it in raid patchwork or m+ between packs
haha
Ok, so what's the name of it and the best of it for pvp?
I am in on Stix 
Hey guys, New at rogue / sub rogue, im curious when you guys use Shiv?
Oh. Well that makes it simpler
How can they bench the goat
I'm sending a strongly worded letter to <colour>
not the worst in the world
there are no rogue loots there + melee sucks + getting ball during cds is a thing + stealthi is ungeared + can chill on bench tbh it looks like a frustrating boss to progress 
i said during the rwf prog on this, idk how lower guilds will do this boss without the bench 
yea afaik
When to use shuriken or backstab/shadowstrike on aoe? trickester
this is just stupid at this point
and then u have one armed, which is just cheeses by having 3 affli

I guess that's what happens when you are giga good at one thing
apparently blizzard closed mugzee a bit
they must have fixed some stuff cuz they were cheesing this boss again x)
last time i checked they played only one side, cheesing the other side and cheesing the soaks idk how
so i need backstab on bars with stealth?
omfg
!bs
Backstab/Shadow Dance Macro:#Showtooltip Shadow Dance /cast [bonusbar:1] Backstab; Shadow DanceThis will cast Shadow Dance on first key press and Backstab on second key press.
use that
I can replace shadowdance hotkey woth that?
yea so, u still need to have bs on your non stealth bar, and u can have another bind with this macro, in both stance
which, as said, make u dance when you re not stealth / dance, and bs when you re in one of them
and is there a macro or something so the camera wont spin when using shadowstep?
i dont this there is a thig for that
u can maybe find a force camera stuff in wagoio or idk
but that s not something i m aware of. I know we have a weakaura on that purpose for killingspree, so that s possible but that s not a thing i ever heard being requested
big d energy

love to see that knowledge shared
not as good as him tho unlucko
did your guild let u solo them or they still bangabang barrels ?
i hate mythic sometimes
u assume there were strats being done besides kill stuff
now show boss dmg
does anyone have a link to the loot table for delves
either i'm an idiot or can't find anything
comparing to others im doing all the mechanics
how could u do everything on vexxie
when u cant soak everytime
and cant throw bikes everytime


im also probably bad
yee
my raid team assigned people to do bikes
and i wasn't one of them
as it should be
is sub good in pvp rn?
any tips on Cd usage on AOE'
how much of a damage increase is it to use backstab as first builder in SD?
wait share with the class
" /cast Shadow Blades
/use Prized Gladiator's Badge of Ferocity "
would be how I do the macro yes?
when heading into a big pull saying for example 10-12 mobs in m+ ,are u spreading rupture on them before using your major cds?
below 7 evis , 7+ pouder

he posted it publicly above
Imagine if they didnt nerf our tier set on the ptr, our bonks wouldve been huge
yea that was sad we werent even that good on overall dps
Aside of Damage , does rapture gives us something?
this is not wod or mop
Nop
Huh the guy is far ahead
Surely that one secret tech won’t bring me up there
You press that button

Top of the meters
biggest bonk was tomb of sargaras DfA
I can’t watch rwf currently as I’m on the go, is exile playing sub or sin for mugzee?
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
It seems like a really good sin fight to me
Trying both, currently on sub
sectec is DFA if it wasn't the worst spell ever made
fair
He was saying in chat you kinda need to play sub since assa can't easily swap to the gaol eles
Gameplay right now is kinda peak ngl
even if execute is sin
Having to blow all three symbols on trash pulls in m+ then hitting like a wet noodle feels absolutely awful
you put ignite on both then go outside and use the phoenix thingies to refresh it
Yeah don't do that
Sometimes you compete with tank for damage
And that's okay
Sometmes you oneshot a pack, sometimes you do healer damage
Thats just the way it goes
Yep probably not intended but it works
@white briar tried in our raid today, obv heroic but I don’t see a reason why that would change
Boss is big so hitbox big

Man watching Firedup play mage is honestly such a treat
I don’t even like playing mage but every time I see him play I feel like playing mage (gladly I know that feeling is wrong and I don’t
)
Subtlety Macros:
It is not recommended to macro most cooldowns, including Cold Blood+Secret Techniques and Dance+Symbols.
The following macros are an exception:
/cast Shadow Dance
/cast Thistle Tea```
```yaml
/cast Shadow Blades
/cast Blood Fury
/cast Ancestral Call
/use House of Cards```
When using diffrent macros, make sure to keep the cooldowns on a seperate key.
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
!sod
Macro to prevent accidental uses of extra charges: #showtooltip Symbols of Death /castsequence reset=2 Symbols of Death,null /cqs
Im struggling to get that last shadowstrike in my dance windows on opener, am i reading the guides wrong?
You should be getting 8 spells casted during your shadow dance always
Otherwise you are not pressing the buttons enough
Yeah im doing 7, cant ever get 8 the gcd seems like its so much more delayed nowadays
I get that it's part of the way sub works but man it just doesn't feel good.
Idk i think its good
Or well, i think the payoff of being able to do a lot during your burst is worth not doing a whole lot outside of it
Turning off all addons did the trick. now to cleanse.
Trying to time a key and sitting there under the tank during trash feels like I'm not contributing lol
So would you say only use one symbols per trash pack? I'm having trouble knowing when to sit on them and when to blow them
between tfd and chaining 8 stacks of tier set entire dungeon sub feels pretty good in keys
You should always be able to symbols, sectech and dance twice during every flag+blades
So save symbols for flag cooldown?
Absolutely obliterating bosses feels good too
Yesnt.
You want to use as many as possible inbetween, but still make sure you can use two during blades+flag
first boss motherlode/floodgate go hard
Ye those especially but even just standard bosses too
And that's where I have issues. Guess I'll keep practicing i guess
Going into a boss with 8 stacks of tier, 4 coups stacks, pot ready, flag+blades ready and close to 2 dance stacks 
You know that boss is getting sent to the shadowrealm
is it worth going elusive on mugzee
Agreed, when I have everything up sub feels amazing lol
yes
elusive?
I have yet to swap out of cheat in raid yet
was that a yes to my question
havent really felt like i need the dr from elusive
The only sad thing about sub burst is when you have literally everything up and the tank decided to pull like a baby
Yesssss
Thanks for this, for the 8th spell info, really made a big diff once i knew it was some addon that was messing up my latency
Good stuff
If you’re pushing 12 keys should you go with vers flask instead of alchemical chaos?
guys is sub good in pvp ? if so what situations does it excel in compared to the other specs?
this is a sub specific question
so?
How does Sub's boss damge sit compared to Sin in the typical M+ build ? (comparing standard M+ sin vs M+ sub)
OH wow, wait are you saying Sub's m+ build is almost twice as good at bosses than Sin's ?
Or which direction was your comment
Ohhh gotcha, thats cool
(theres practically no aoe talents to even choose)
Actually I did realize when I was just taking a look at the wowhead builds it was very very similar to the raid st build.
Sorry I'm just touring here from Assassination. I want to try Sub!
Thanks for the info Eleem
Twice is a bit of an overstatement for sure, but def like 50% more
More if the fight is like 2 min like they often are right now
no first dance keys
First dance pretty close even on ST 
But ye thats the "pretty much" part and not the literal exact same 
tell them to take the thing that blocks annoyances off
Riktus Reverberation has been slain
Now i get a day off or maybe 2
As i am off of stix
I would run with this weakaura to apply your tricks with
net a 95 on our first Rik kill with the holding tech, heck yeah
I was holding but my guild actually started annihilating barrels after 12 or so pulls
the what?
when exactly are you holding
dn
you hold cd's until 14ish secs
ah ok for adds to spawn
yessir
cool cool
whats the difference in damage betwen 2 tier v 3 tier whetstone?
working at all for anyone? I'm not getting any buff from it now, feels like it broke more
Is there a bug with Coup? Some pulls it's not being consumed and not building stacks
!logreview
can you cloak ice spike on mugzee?
uneq and eq it again might solve this unless its a new bug
no
is there a target counter weak aura?
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
alt-f4 to fix that
i just did an 11 priory with the tank single pulling the whole dungeon after 1st boss
holy shit
yeah sub tanks in damage when the tank is not pulling well
new bug it seems
@tepid trellis so you are using flag/SB at 0:14 1:50 3:55 and 5:23 am i reading that right?
then just dancing between then
reading this hurts my head cuz i dont think of timers this way lmaoo
Yeah that’s what it means
i have dance up with sectech for quite some time during these downtimes how long is it worth to sit on?
As long as ur not overcapping charges it’s fine
I moved the 355 blades slightly earlier to like 342 which let me get another dance sectec off on the add set at like 410 since we wiped to it
But that could’ve been a mistake
kk were pulling it so ill keep these notes up and try to watch
!wa
Bottom one
any hot tips to do "some" damage in between cds during keys?
spreading ruptures is usually decent
and after do you shuriken storm -) evis? or shuriken blackpowder
do you just always hold cb for the 2nd sectech in the burst window?
yer
well u can use it on CD afterwards just to get an extra use but yeah
In cds its better to CB 2nd sectec
Grats
had to pay 100k for it
worth it
was stuck with this heroic transmitter, not even the 636one
stix sucks fuck that boss
we use Backstab once every time we Dance right?
!wa
yes during premed
it is wierd that the method guide doesnt include using it
but the wowhead guide does
anyone else use Afenar weak aura pack? i've been using it forever so idk if its still good but it hasen't been showing me when I have supercharged combo points
when can you get the key deplete protection
If ur talking about afenarsa modified, I dont track it cuz U dont need to
I try to only track stuff that does anything
also the rank 1 world parse on gallywix does not use backstab inside shadow dance at all
and what about it
rolled 100 on eye of kezan but why couldn't it have been house of cards
not the modified, just the standard pack Afenar | Rogue | TWW weakaura
I'd personally suggest mine over his fwiw
I use his as a framework but make it more useful to ppl playing rogue
ill check it out 🙂
its relatively new info that its worth doing again, and its a minor optimization even then
so yeah sometimes you'll see that
just like how some high logs are still sending cb on first sectec
how many sockets did you get for your pvp neck

!UP
Gotta grind like 50k honor for 2 sockets.. hahaha
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
ya it's 10k
kinda rough ngl
cant u just buy em
you need the pvp socket item
which is 5k honor per
!cds
Cooldown Use:
Every 90 seconds you want to cast Flagellation and subsequently Shadow Blades. When these two are up you always want cast 2 Symbols of Death, 2 Shadow Dances and 2 Secret Techniques.
To ensure you have enough cooldown reduction on your Shadow Dance to attain that you need atleast 1 charge and roughly 40 seconds left on your second charge before casting Flagellation.
Yeah Ik can't u buy those off the ah?
you can buy the other item you need
but you gotta farm out the 5k honor per socket
it's like some blood crystal + 5k honor
I swear u could also buy them on ah
if you can that'd be based
i wasn't aware
In DF we could use normal sockets
Now u need PvP ones
How we feeling about crafts next week?
I'm definitely thinking I'm gonna rip my second 675
I'm on team neck
I'm currently on team boots but only because my boots are turboshit
They're simming pretty similar
Guess I wait for vault tho
ya I finally got the pvp neck, so I think boots, bracers, or gloves are the move for me
boots, bracers or neck prob
i'm leaning team boot, even though my bracers are the weakest slot. 🤞 bracers from raid
Neck maybe one day get lucky and get BOE boots
in s1 u could buy bloodstones from AH
im not 100% sure if u can buy the entire socket though
im farming honor on my mage so i dont bother looking,its rly easy
yeah I think you can still buy the bloodstones
it was a nice way of making gold early as a pvper,10k gold per bloodstone
but gotta farm the honor it looks like
yup most likely
!log
Could you buy the thing on AH?
in heavy aoe fights 7++ targets. shadow dance is running. should i shadowstrike while dance is running or should i shuriken storm to generate combopoints ? right now i shadowstriked during dance and shuriken storm afterwards ?
Hey guys does anyone have a list of spells in m+ that I should use feint on? Right now I'm using it whenever I see incoming damage but I was told that I should only aim to use it for unavoidable damage
You can get the s2 dungeon weakaura pack, calls out aoe dmg etc etc
!prekey
!oh
Shadow Techniques is not normalized and this makes a slow weapon (axe/sword/mace/fist) in offhand significantly weaker and almost never worth equiping.
Here’s your answer, in short - no, 2 Daggers
how random is cyrce's circlet?
also asking this because signet is still bugged in sims (iirc), it doesnt matter if i change my highest stat to vers from mastery right bc they are somewhate equal?
whats the command for the dance bs macro?
Backstab/Shadow Dance Macro:#Showtooltip Shadow Dance /cast [bonusbar:1] Backstab; Shadow DanceThis will cast Shadow Dance on first key press and Backstab on second key press.
Got it
ty
Is this necessary if you can simply do
/SD
/backstab
?
!macro
Subtlety Macros:
It is not recommended to macro most cooldowns, including Cold Blood+Secret Techniques and Dance+Symbols.
The following macros are an exception:
/cast Shadow Dance
/cast Thistle Tea```
```yaml
/cast Shadow Blades
/cast Blood Fury
/cast Ancestral Call
/use House of Cards```
When using diffrent macros, make sure to keep the cooldowns on a seperate key.
on 7+ targets, do i use shuriken storm during dance ?
always SS in dance
sorry 
AOE opener = ST opener?
Very similar
similae but not the same
You use shuriken storm at fisrt global after shadow dance iirc
but you can think of it like "you play single target during cooldowns up to like ~7 targets
Do you know the changes i should do? I've been doing the ST opener/cooldown rotation on 6 or less targets and feel like my damage is kind of low during burst windows. Need to optimize more
Yhea, should i shuriken storm 1st global during dance with the rotten to apply find weakness?
Yea
idk if its worth it since sec tech aoe damage is shadow damage and that already ignores armor
the main diffrences are here
idk
you will adjust in your aoe opener to the situation
is the group gathered, you might send cooldowns asap
is it not gathered, you might want to spend a few ruptures
simialrely you might want to send cold blood on your first secret
if the group dies fast, like in a lower level key
yhea, i've started to adapt to that if damage is strong in group
subtlety has the benefit of having so much damage in cooldowns
so you can adjust to your group, to pulls
also the backstab in dance, especially on 7+ targets, you can skip
it becomes fairly damage neutral, but it is in the apl as well as the guide
for consistency
Ah ok
Do you bind backstab with dance?
I was still backstabbing 1st global
(apl mostly because the condition is simpler, and simpler is usually better)
Backstab/Shadow Dance Macro:#Showtooltip Shadow Dance /cast [bonusbar:1] Backstab; Shadow DanceThis will cast Shadow Dance on first key press and Backstab on second key press.
yhea i adopted it because im just done with having too much buttons
^ the macro does keep my button count the same
and i can just press dance a 2nd time
and poof backstab
This is only while Shadow Blades are up?
Or also without
I had to spare a button for the CB + Sec tech macro
always

i did simulations on all combinations
and with the highest gear
it is not diffrence
but someone in this chat did try out the same chanegs with lower gear levels
I feel like I miss a global if I don’t bind backstab with dance
and he had backstab always as the slightly better option
you can skip it too
its 0.3% dps without tier set
you shouldnt since dance is off global
and gets to ~0.5% with the new 4 set
I’m not fast enough to press dance,symbol, and backstab at the same time haha
fuu, when im sending a "naked" symbols + dance combo in a pack, should i stack danse macabre? like we did in DF
example= dance, symbols, backstab, evisc, shadowstrike, sec tech?
i dont get why i would want to do that, besides to get sec tech cdr rolling
but if i dance with 10s remaining on sec tech i feel like im good
!wa
or maybe delaying the symbols so backstab doesnt consume a rotten stack
dude my fingers are gone after a couple hours of M+
Sir
But it’s weird that I can outlaw
oh i havent touched it
OL is a different beast
im waiting for them to bring back combat rogue 
@cloud rover 
My brain melts when doing sub rotations, it’s about practice ig

Hell yeah 40% melee attack dmg

@vale pine sorry for pinging you i couldnt hold myself back
Bring back long arms
like what is this
you never send naked symbols + dance
what
secret cdr is higher than dance cdr
oh yhea thats what i meant
basically dance cdr's at half the pace of dance
sec tech + symbols + dance
so you will always have secret up for dance
w/o flag, trinket or blades
means there is no "naked" symbols/dance without secret
my bad on wording lol
oh shit, that scared me coz I didn't know what was being referred to as "naked symbols / dance"
for danse macabre
it actually does not matter much
you can absolutely do
symbols-dance-evis-backstab-secret (for example if you are on high cp)
and the sim will do that often too
but the sim would also symbols and dance already before secret comes off cd
so the first finisher would cdr secret enough to use secret 2nd
yhea, so that evis brings sec tech back
the treshold to do so is roughly 10 secounds of remaining cooldown
sometimes i get a CDR of 12s
thats exactly what im doing, with around 10s remaining on sec tech
idk why im doing bad damage, i need to find where my CD windows fit best i guess
the exact amount would be:
2 sec (from gcd's)
- 6-7 sec cdr from the finisher
- 3 sec from supercharger
i dont understand the part with backstab. why would i backstab instead of shadowstrike while dance is running ? i think im missing some information 😅
because of strike gcd?
yhea
it is fairly simple
premeditation makes your next combo point builder generate full combo points
backstab is a combo point builder, and you want to send it early in dance because of how bad its damage is
the generated danse stack is worth the trade off
oh shit. i totally missed that part. so after dance i should do a backstab to get combo points from premeditation, after that i shadowstrike?
no, after that you secret technique
the main point is for stacking more danse macabre so your attacks during dance deal more damage
premeditation makes it possible to send backstab because it will give you 7cp anyways, so its the only moment during dance that you can sustainably send it
otherwise if you backstab w/o premeditation, you will recieve little combo points and probably will have to shadowstrike after to build more cp, and that makes backstab not worth it during dance
(i fucking think)
oh damn. so backstab is another 6% because it's a different attack used, afterwards i shadowstrike, so another 6% = max dmg . right ?
exactly
wow.. thats min maxing 😅 and the dmg gain is only around 0.5% overall ? on bigpulls it cant be that low right ?
thank you guys for explaining. ill macro dance+backstab right when im at home
backstab (with premeditation gives max combo points) > secret technique > shadowstrike > eviscerate > > >
Would it be benefitial at all to send symbols after dance + backstab before first sectec?
it's not gonna be a huge min max because strike does way more damage than backstab
would probably be more optimal, but it's not a huge deal
Im looking for small deals
idk im attached to stacking danse macabre from DF
yes, but as mentioned above the backstab optimization is very minor so feel free to skip it initially and start doing so once you get more familiar
so ill keep my backstabs inside my dances
agreed, its insanely min/maxy and you should nail down more important stuff before worrying about 0.5% dps gain
oh what the fucky @vale pine
really that minor ? i feel like on big big pulls in m+ those 6% more dmg during dance can make a big difference in burst ? no ?
we dont run legendary??
It got nerfed
nope
yhea, no more sea mother or something like that
but damn, i wasnt aware we stopped wearing it for that
huh?
sorry, that was my reaction to realizing that we dont run legendary citrine anymore
i got startled
ahh
you trade off a global of doing a inefficient builder
danse macabre is a bit of a tricky spell because you usually forget about trade offs
many people especially new to subtlety try to be very creative to get it up to as many stacks as possible
Guys, share your keybindings pls. Trying to figure out layout on sub after assa.
because thats intuitively what you would asusme does the most damage
but in practice, we have so many inefficient spells and secondary dependencies
that going for "bro 7 stacks secret goess brr" is not a very smart move
makes sense. you guys are good in explaining stuff 
thats a thousand percent me
during DF
i was doing atrocities to get an extra stack
How u Guys sim for m+ ?
5 tar 5 min patch?
thanks, i do theorycrafting for quite a while now, so i hope i am not too bad at it ^^
dungeon slice is good for now
fuu is good, im just trying to replicate what he says
dungeon slice, and if you want to optimize for more specific parts of the key the specific thing
e.g. if you want to optimize for aoe, do a aoe sim
Ty
if you do so, keep in mind:
- You won't have all raid buffs ---> so tick off the raid buffs you don't have
- You probably want to sim for more than 40 sec
Jop
^ 2nd point is important, you migth want to sim for 2 minutes at least to remove impact of bloodlust and the initial burst
a lot of people loved to do 20 or 40 sec simulations with all raid buffs in the past
and to quickly highlight why this is bad
a sim has a 20% lengh variance
so a 40 sec sim is 32 sec - 48 secs
if you have bloodlust
it last as long as the sim
or lets say a on use trinket
it lasts 15 secounds
you have 1/3 of the sim that
short fight lenghs just have too high impact from things which would averge out better on longer figths, and as such are mostly missleading
thanks for the clarifications fuu
Is anyone aware if they have patched the free 658 ring upgrade yet?
The trick with siren isle ring
how much of a nerf did the circlet get? it still sims higher than using my 658 rings for me still
the have not
its still good up to like mythic
Fuu btw, I swear we ran thunderlords crackling gem for a while no?
Did they nerf it?
Or I guess with more stats shit like that died
the old gem setup should be somewhere in the tc channel, the new one i had pinned but i removed the balance pins recently
there is a text file in #tc-research too you can copy/paste for the ring to sim all combinations
they nerfed some of the best gems
some specs/classes just swap gems
for us its enough to make the ring slightly worse in general
lucky subtlety
fuu, how does flask of alchemical chaos interact with tempered potion? I've seen some people saying it makes the potion stronger
or i might just have misinterpreted the fuck out of some statement
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
you can sim the combination and see if there is a impact on output in the combination, but i would say there isn't
also you can just use vers flasks instead for more consistency
versatility flask for ST and mastery for dungeons?
i cant open raidbots again im going insane
haha both should be fine
think top players typically use mastery because of better aoe
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
Tempered potion gives you stats for the thing you aren’t flasked for. So if you have mastery flask, potion gives haste & vers & crit, but not mastery
Alchemical chaos is not a tempered flask so you get all 4 stats from the potion
That’s why it “makes the potion stronger”
oh wow, that was unexpected
not worth it for sub because if you get the haste buff with alchemical chaos in cds it's very sad
Morning all, did someone ping me then delete it?
I have a message notification but no message 
have you simmed it prophet?
honestly no, but i prefer running either vers or mast flask
for less rng with damage
@tribal blade I've got a quick M+ question for you. Detection mobs and distract. I was told by a tank last night that if we used Distract on the big horseman (I.e., the detection mob) at the start of ToP, it would 'turn it off' and we could shroud past him and into boss without him. Is.. that a thing? Would distact actually do something? 'Cos it didn't work for me, haha
detection?!?
yes it does work for a little bit
Huh, damn
what
Well, I've gotta practice it then.
oh you mean true sight mobs?
if you shroud then distract the mob away from everyone you can get past, but it'll only work if people are far away enough
it's very finnicky
Yeah, I can imagine. I assume it operates on typical stealth detection where they have less sight 'behind'?
so if you mean the rager after the 1st pull, i don't think it'll work with that mob
because that mob is so close to everyone when you're shrouding
Yeah, precisely that guy.
This even work for delves, you can distract, into shadowstep into sap the elites that have true sight
He was adamant we could, and I'm curious if it's possible.
it might work yeah
does this mean for me my BIS trinket from dungeons is the mechanocore? https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/sGVrdy432ZqfELXVrQ73KT
like if you didn't have someone who could open the shortcut in mists at the start you could do that
I know back in DF, in the megadungeon, you could do it to the drake that flew in after the second boss. But you had to time it just as it landed.
you would go right, shroud everyone and distract the tree
Makes sense
and everyone could walk past and not aggro it
but that tree is a lot further away than the rager
Yeah. The gap is tiny.
I'll go practice it solo and see if I can do it properly 'cos it seems like a neat tech
and yeah i think it's a small window of time for everyone to walk past
so the timing has to be precise
Ye. Probably not going to happen in most pugs.
but also there's no need to do that, the optimal routing is you pull that rager into 1st boss 😉
and blow it up on 1st boss
I think i've seen some video where monk ring of peace the horse guy away and with distract/priest one they can go in with shroud, maybe i'm wrong and it triggers combat
i don't think you can ring that mob
Agreed. But, the tank was adamant and I'd rather make sure than just believe I'm right haha
it does definitely work for sure
(in general)
Rules to know!
never tried it on that mob though
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/3nxZkdzTfJCMmq4j?fight=27&type=damage-done gus why is my akaaris soul again not in my dmg?
We used to skip it in SL and then fight it at the end while waiting on mordretha rp. So you can definitely get by(or could then). But I wouldn’t trust a pug to do it.
That's cool to know. So i guess you all pack up on the rogue on the left, they shroud, then distract the mob to look away and book it?
Just checked, you are right is the pull before. Misinformation avoided
Saw someone say it has to do with the person logging being too far away. So if the logger is on Dino when you’re on gorilla.
that would make sense
usually pretty big elite mobs like that are un-ringable 😉
i didn't know for sure but i had a hunch that was the case
If in doubt: convince a monk.
You can just try it on SL version, no need to go for m+ one
oh also that mob requires a soothe, so if it was cc-able it wouldn't be a scary mob at all
Yeah. That's where I'm gonna go practice today. Just hop into it on normal
overal which is better subt or Assa ?>
They're both great!
!warn @young mural filter evasion
sprry
Purple in sub 
subtlety is purple, so checks out
fuu why are you not purple
guys isnt the pvp trinket just as good as the hero transmitter?
I am growing a bit frustrated with my gameplay as sub seeming to fall off a cliff ever since I read more guides and gotten 4set so I've got some questions of any can provide some answers.
- Should I play around new set in any way or just treat it as passive?
- Should I backstab at the start of every dance window?
- Should I ever send sectec without dance and symbols up? My CDs sometimes come to a point where I can symbols and sectec but dance has 25-30sec left on cd. Do you save or send symbols+sectec in that regard.
- Is my dance not having 2 charges in a cd window me missplaying my CDs (the 2 uses 2 uses 1 use rotation) or does it just line up like that at some point?
I seem to be playing it all wrong after reading more on it. For instance I sim at almost 2mil ST, my DPS mug HC was barely over 1.6mil and in general I can't seem to log higher than in the 80s
guys
I like how people who struggle with fundamentals get advice about small optimizations
i see blades comes before 1st sec tech.
a lot of logs have blades right after sec tech, is that an error on the players or am i reading the guide sequence wrong?
- doesnt matter
- doesnt matter
- you can, if that won't ruin the blades/flag window
- 1 dance and 40sec left for second charge is enough for blades/flag window
i explain it in the "optimization" section, but it does not matter if you use blades before or after secret as long as the cast is before the first clone hit which is exactly one second after the cast.
nice, thanks fuu
1 no, its passive.
2 yes u can, it s mostly important during cds but since u ll get the habit do it every dance if You meet the conditions
3 if u cant send another dance sod before CD, it can be optimal to send à dry sectech as long as its ready for your next CD set
4 You should always have 2 sod 2 dance,in your CD. So yea u overusing it in between probably
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
Hi, what do you mean with point 3? how can blades/flag window be ruined?
every window needs 2 symbols
oh!
Does a day go by where there’s no purple tagging David? 
don't think thats a positive
I can just share my blocked users from the channel. They seem to keep needing special attention from the purples. 
Thanks a lot man. So I'm playing mostly correctly it's just not overusing CDs. I tend to send every time sectec is up unless 20-25sec before flag+sb
Guess I have to get used to the 2-2-1 rhythm for CDs how it's listed in eleems guide
2 1 1 2 1 1 2 1 1
Is kinda the flow
That s in st
In aoe u get more CP so more cdr so can squeeze some more dances
So 2 uses of dance+sod+sectec in CDs and only 1 in between all the time?
Not familiar
Get on the website and sélect à boss without bizarre mecanics like cauldron
U ll get to see CD usage maybe that Will help
Yeh I'm guessing my in my opinion shitty DMG compared to my SIM also might have something to do with how mugzee HC is designed and me trying to play ethically with the soaks and such
Gotta do what u gotta do and adapt
why are people using backstab on the first shadowdance in cds but not the second one where the coldblood sectech is?
Danes macabre stack
Oh that I don't know. From what I gathered you should do it in every but it's small optimization
I try to backstab after every dance
Unless I'm at Max CP already
Thanks for all the answers btw. Just gotta improve my cd usage and reacting more to shadow technique procs as I sometimes strike with full CP coz too much spamming
if i find myself in a situation where i have to kidney first 2 spenders after popping cds, does kidney eat a charge of supercharger?
probably not recommended but i've put kidney and cheap on the same keybind on stealth bars for that
it does not consume it, just tested
Can someone teach me how to setup tts notes for cds?
i just write with marker on my monitor
when i dont have marker i just make a method raid tools note
we can quickly discuss it
install method raid tools. open it with /mrt and on top right you got Note.
you write one and then you can move it on screen
if the cooldown magaement is not obviouse
i am not a big fan of a set order but lets discuss
basically, you use 2 symbols every 90 secounds, so you have 2 symbols of death casts set in your 90 sec interval
@vale pine
symbols of death has a cooldown of 25 sec, so you generate at least 3 charges of symbols of death
I mean a note like healers have that plays the game for them. Like you get a tts "blades in 5"
3 charges would be 2 during big cooldowns and 1 in between
25 sec cooldown on symbols means 3 charges are 75 sec of 90
this means you generate additional 15 sec of cdr every 90 sec
the reason people state 2-1-1-2-1-0 is this
over 2 "cycles"
you generate 30 sec of additional cdr
Yes
ah ok. i dont use those so they must be weakauras with sound queues, maybe someone has them
with 25 sec cooldown on symbols, means 5 extra sec of symbols
so technically, if the fight goes on very long
Nowadays its not as big but back in dust days they were huge
you might get to 2-1-1-2-1-1 very late in the fight
tho most fights end before that
when you use the "in between" symbols is also not that fixed
as long as you are not overcapping on symbols, you have a certain amount of dynamic
given that we align symbols with other cooldowns
you also see how aoe does not change the above noticable
just makes it easier to get dance to every symbols use
They use MRT plus a WeakAura. https://wago.io/n7l5uN3YM
Kaze's MRT/ERT Timers Notifications V3 #### !! Compatible with Viserio's he
But how do you write the note for this wa to work?
check wago
hover over the name and click the file icon
Then put your character name in
you can then edit it as you please
and use that formatting
Is this based around having 2 or 3 charges of symbols? If the "rotation" is 2-1-1 why does eleems guide say 2 in CDs 2 in between 2 in CDs 1 in between so 2-2-2-1 now?
do you guys thinkg Vexie is bad for sub because most groups will just delay for 2m timing
no
I'm sry if I'm dense and misreading your explanation too
With 3 charges of sod I never really find myself without a stack of sod, more so without a 2nd dance if I overuse it
think thats a missunderstanding on yoru site
its 2 symbols during cooldowns
then 1 or 2 between
2 should happen every 2nd cycle
so you start out with
symbols-symbols(during flag/blades) and symbols 2x before the next flag/blades
after that the next cycle has
What do you thinkg about first dance vs weaponmaster, it feels like in most of the dungeons I dont benefit that much form first dance, and also tank chain pulling is kinda meh for it too
symbols-symbols(during flag/blades) and only 1x in between
because you don't have enough cdr on symbols for another one
and after that you essentially have enough to return to the first one
Oh yeah that is how I understood it maybe it's just my failure to put that into coherent words that makes it weird. But basically that is how we should generally aim to use our CDs yea?
it's not really a huge deal because sub has more damage in cds than other specs
even 2 min specs
So now I have some avenues to improve my play in cd usage less spamming and proc wasting and then finally getting rid of the CB+sectec macro
i should probably do a fancy picture to explain it, cooldown management seems like a thing people struggle with
I think it would help, yeah
Granted this is the 2nd week I play sub in ever but yeah. I think cd management is the thing I struggle with the most. And cold blood without a macro
At least when it comes to stuff unique to sub. Can definitely be a spammy baboon when it comes to any spec though 











