#subtlety

1 messages · Page 31 of 1

vale pine
#

haha

near rivet
#

dem stacks

hazy breach
#

If it works sure

hard ember
#

wait is actually working lke that

#

LMFAO

#

that sounds like it's not going to continue to work like that if it does

haughty mural
clever delta
#

coioked spec

vestal escarp
#

Now we only need to get access to roll the bones...

latent tundra
#

anyone got working weakauras for missing poisons?

fleet maple
#

The pinned message says playing sub over sin for the same reasons. What are the reasons to play sub over sin?

wraith sphinx
#

reset cometh

vestal escarp
#

We dont lose vanish.....

near rivet
wraith sphinx
pliant topaz
vestal escarp
#

The bug is live for symbolic victory tho

pliant topaz
#

What exactly is the bug?

near rivet
#

spec DS, take symbolic victory

#

use shiv as as sub on training dummy

vestal escarp
#

Sub shiv is proccing sin shiv talents

#

Like symbolic victory and supercharger

uneven scarab
pliant topaz
#

Oh I see, it’ll be fixed probably

near rivet
#

symbolic victory is confirmed live, supercharger is speculation

pliant topaz
#

Good catch though

near rivet
vestal escarp
#

It will

pliant topaz
vestal escarp
#

It will get attention and be hotfixed

#

Symbolic hasnt so far cause no one is using it

near rivet
#

that you get the buff by pressing shiv when you spec it

vestal escarp
#

Despite having more bugs on it

near rivet
vestal escarp
#

So the question arises naturally

#

Has shadowed finishers been tested with supercharger?

pliant topaz
#

Doesn’t work

vestal escarp
#

Given.

pliant topaz
#

Shadowed finishers I mean

vestal escarp
#

Since either symbolic doesnt

haughty mural
#

Shadowed finisher is a good design Surebud

vestal escarp
#

If only it worked

haughty mural
#

works so well

vestal escarp
haughty mural
#

never krangled

#

good thing to have

vale pine
#

!up

mental herald
#

Hey, I'm currently playing Assassination, but considering switching to Subtlety, which weapon types can I roll need on? I have daggers atm, but going into the raid idk if I should stay assassination or go Sub

pliant topaz
#

Sub also uses double daggers.

#

U can technically loot non dagger offhand, but it’s a large dps loss to have non dagger offhand

rocky wolf
#

isnt a white dagger better than like mythic sword

woeful egret
#

I thought you used sword in OH for better non-lethal poison procs?

woeful egret
#

There is actually a truth to that unless they changed it. In PVP at least, using a slow OH was better for applying crippling

tranquil egret
#

is there a reson ppl play sub on queen and silken over assa is it the dmg profile ?

woeful egret
#

the dynamics of playing sub on that fight will change tomorrow if I'm not mistaken

lilac stag
pliant topaz
pliant topaz
woeful egret
#

That was back before shadow technique and all that, I guess I'm a boomer wow player lol

young path
#

Are you guaranteed shadowcraft procs / combo pt refunds every time your off hand strikes?

covert anchor
hazy breach
wind canopy
covert anchor
#

Also pin doesn’t say sub over sin tho

pliant topaz
covert anchor
#

Or am I blind

hazy breach
#

Yep

pliant topaz
#

Bug

hazy breach
#

I got griefed though

pliant topaz
#

Let’s go!!!

hazy breach
#

2 orbs turned out to be 4 💀

covert anchor
#

Is that for silken?

pliant topaz
#

Time to kill bug queen

covert anchor
#

Oh

#

Yep

#

Gz bud

pliant topaz
covert anchor
#

Dude the orbs sometimes you are not gonna pick up and swerve around it and you still pick it up

#

Actually happened so many times

wind canopy
#

Is this the sub version of scanaw ?

hazy breach
#

Well ye i saw they were 2 orbs stacked

#

Turned out to be 4

wind canopy
pliant topaz
wind canopy
#

@pseudo hollow Can we make this scanasub

craggy quest
shut sonnet
#

I am ready

pliant topaz
#

@hazy breach queen sub angle now

pliant topaz
#

He anticipated

#

The day would come

covert anchor
#

Team team was goated wdym

hazy breach
covert anchor
#

Also fuck red team

#

Most cringe as melee

#

You lose a whole ass dmg amp

hazy breach
#

Yes

#

It stinks

craggy quest
#

Our red team mega griefs sometimes

#

I walked into an orb and legit got a 4 stack

#

?????

young path
pliant topaz
#

50% chance on 3rd auto, 100% on 4th. Shadowcraft makes these 2nd and third auto

pseudo hollow
wind canopy
young path
pliant topaz
#

No, because shadowcraft makes this 2/3 instead of 3/4

#

U can just sim the difference

#

During sod that is

fair stump
#

The pin says "The reasons to play subtlety stay the same as before the patch! ", what were those reasons?

pliant topaz
#

And then there’s wind fury

fair stump
#

I played sub because I found it fun, we had specific reasons?

pliant topaz
#

If u enjoy sub a lot

fair stump
#

Aside from court

vale pine
#

betraying us like this

open vortex
#

red group

shut sonnet
hazy breach
#

I literally did

vale pine
#

i missunderstood

wind canopy
vale pine
#

red = red name = sin

wind canopy
#

ily

vale pine
#

instead of red group

fair stump
#

so what were the reasons, aside from enjoying it?

vale pine
hazy breach
#

Because its good

#

On court

fair stump
#

yeah, aside from court

wind canopy
#

ily scana, not fuu, screw that fuu guy

#

jk, love you too

pliant topaz
#

I see how it is… okay…

wind canopy
wind canopy
vale pine
fair stump
#

oh really?

#

I'll start getting some logs on queen then, to get a feel

vale pine
#

i didn't say absolute best

fair stump
#

Do we still play trickster on queen?

vale pine
#

because i can't judge that

#

11.0.5 looks like a trickster angle everywhere

#

or you mean today?

fair stump
#

yeah. 11.0.5

vale pine
#

basically

fair stump
#

Is DS getting irrelevant again? Damn

vale pine
#

deathstalker only rly wins by a tiny margin

#

in single target

#

the sim slightly overvalues

fair stump
#

Does that mean BP is no longer going to be used?

vale pine
#

you rarely use it

#

on trickster

#

on deathstalker, a lot

fair stump
#

Well, I like that angle

vale pine
#

its like this

#

Deathstalker can shine in long sustained aoe

#

Trickster is good in single target and cleave

#

(deathstalker is good in st too)

fair stump
#

We would still play trickster on m+ as well in that case, wouldn't we?

vale pine
#

gameplay wise trickster feels better

#

whats best is hard to say, both have trade offs

fair stump
#

I see

vale pine
#

if you have a lot of long living targets and big pulls

#

deathstalker might be better

#

but gameplay wise, it feels worse

fair stump
#

Yeah, I feel bad playing combo into BP specially

#

Is flurry back to 50% on 11.0.5?

#

Or we'll be able to find that out tomorrow?

vale pine
#

it was never lower

fair stump
#

I thought there was a bug

#

And that it was hitting for 40%

wind canopy
#

I mean, we'll find out tomorrow if they actually fixed anything Smile

keen dome
#

Big hope. 🙏

solar charm
#

!fuu

wicked joltBOT
lucid trail
#

am i right in thinking that trickster loses some burst on reset

#

with the loss of dust

hazy breach
#

No, dust isnt really a burst talent

#

It makes us do our burst more often

pliant topaz
#

the new sims show trickster burst being at 4.2-4.3M when live is at 3.8-3.9M

#

so prob not

lucid trail
#

ait ait

#

tyty!

vale pine
#

so tis whatever

lucid trail
#

so u think that sub still gonna be the play on silken

#

trying both atm

vale pine
#

i can't say

lucid trail
#

understandable, fuck it time will tel

barren plume
#

They fixed nothing, and sub still feels bad. No gains, defensive loss with dust gone. Blizz just fucked sub and rogues in general I don’t think any spec benefits from the change the way other entire classes and specs got treatment

lilac stag
#

Assa got lovely changes.

#

It’s also pretty complete going into the patch

#

so it’s not fuck rogues

barren plume
#

Sin is still the same supercharger. Isn’t that big a change for them

jaunty heath
#

Sub is not real

#

It’s a myth at this point

uneven scarab
#

enigma for real

lilac stag
#

TTK and dashing is a bigger change.

#

Shouldn’t be shocked at this point on one of the least played classes that one of the two dagger specs isn’t getting attention.

#

welcome to sub rogue

bronze turret
#

Pls

hard ember
bronze turret
#

Sub rogue has been eating good since early sl

lilac stag
#

design wise no

jaunty heath
#

Numbers wise maybe

lilac stag
#

Tuning sure

bronze turret
#

Sub rogue is still the play on mythic ansurek

uneven scarab
#

Bc of numbers yeah

jaunty heath
#

Does it mean it’s well designed?

hard ember
young path
hard ember
bronze turret
hard ember
#

yeh

#

he was here too!

lilac stag
#

I just accept that design wise we ain’t getting shit.

bronze turret
#

The gameplay has been good in episodes, i didnt hate any iteration

lilac stag
#

If it’s tuned it’s tuned.

hard ember
#

tbh i still miss shuriken combo, and the interesting design space of literally not having aoe really

bronze turret
#

I am a sub enjoyer

#

Most versions are fun

lilac stag
#

Raid dmg overall tuning is within 4-5%

#

M+ just is pure misery.

tepid trellis
#

miserable

#

experience

hard ember
#

i think sub might play better in m+ as trickster after the update tbh

bronze turret
#

Assa doesnt feel well suited for the fight cus of cds

hard ember
#

cuz many symbols means you have energy to do stuff

tepid trellis
#

Assa is fine for p1-p3

#

just not p2

#

it does nothing at all during that

bronze turret
#

Ye but does fuck all between

young path
bronze turret
#

Which is the problem

hard ember
#

right now you feel kind of dry and bored alot, or maybe i'm bad

#

and whenever i have to go like do something crazy like cast cheap shot

#

etc

#

i feel like my life is over

tepid trellis
#

back to playing sub tmrw tho

bronze turret
#

The lows must be low for the highs to be high

next valley
#

Does anyone play with the Harvester's Edict trinket from ara kara, if so does it feel alright?

uneven scarab
#

others have higher highs without being as low as we are though joe_shrug

hard ember
#

i think the spec could potentially be really interesting if shiv actually just triggers supercharger and they leave that in

bronze turret
#

The spec isnt meant to enjoy backstab moments, the cds should make up for backstabs

lilac stag
#

The cdr makes me cry

vale pine
#

!design

wicked joltBOT
#

Subtlety is designed to be a spec with highs and lows. During your cooldowns you do immense burst and have plenty of buttons to spam but conversely outside of symbols and dance you do not do any damage whatsoever. This means that having some periods of "afk" downtime where you do not press a button because you're out of energy is the intended way the spec plays. As long as its not happening inside your cooldowns (flag/blades/dance/symbols) its not a problem at all, and especially nothing that having more haste would "fix".

bronze turret
hard ember
#

i kind of miss the one-dance early dflight sub

hard ember
#

where you like just popped out with sectec

#

and did a gorillion

young path
lilac stag
#

The eye rolls at single dance at first was fun

bronze turret
#

I wonder if outlaw isnt shit on it

hard ember
#

i actually thought i would hate single dance

#

but after playing it just a little i was very pleased

young path
#

Getting invites to 12s is impossible though 😒

bronze turret
#

Technically you should be able to cancel the drag with the outlaw mobility thingie

lilac stag
#

I legit don’t understand wanting to push keys this tier.

tepid trellis
#

cancel drags with step

#

we dont need no hooks

lilac stag
#

Let me just fill my vault and GTFO

bronze turret
#

On a dk?

#

Or how

#

Dh?

tepid trellis
#

well you can step the boss in p1

hard ember
#

shadowstep

bronze turret
#

Ye well

hard ember
tepid trellis
#

and you have mobs in p2

bronze turret
#

If you step into shit later on

#

Prob not ideal

tepid trellis
#

and in p3 you step a mage to ignore the portal mech

weary kite
#

If you want to do aoe in deathstalker in raid. Do you change the talent tree at all or just leave it in ST and cast bp and shit?

bronze turret
#

Painsmith all over again

jaunty heath
#

I wish someone would step me fr

bronze turret
#

Free ride

tepid trellis
#

so you cant really get around it

bronze turret
#

I see

tepid trellis
#

you spawn webs where you get yoinked from

#

so you walk into shit to place it

bronze turret
#

Boss is dead next sunday, calling it

pliant topaz
# young path (The un-simmable factor)

your math is missing so many variations. 2/3 doesnt mean two thirds... it means instead of 50% on 3rd auto and 100% on foruth auto, during sod it become 50% on 2nd auto 100% on third. also why are u just assuming 50% the whoele time? it resets once proc has come through. and u cant factor in the amount of sht lost to wm procs etc. its much much bnetter to sim. the sim actually accounts for all of that but a super simplistic math model doesnt

bronze turret
young path
#

Hence why I’m asking

pliant topaz
#

run a sim with slow offhand, and non slow offhand. then press the html report button. look at how many sht procs u got in each set

#

thats the median of the number of procs u get

#

then u can compare easy

hard ember
#

it's honestly a rather straightforward sim question, where this is one of those cases where you'd expect it to be very accurate

young path
#

Thanks!

hard ember
#

the things that you can't really sim are things like needing to do utility casts, or the like

#

something like sht procs which you can track with the naked eye (well not anymore with shadowcraft tbh, not easily)

#

that's the sort of thing where it's like

#

a sim will be modelled incredibly accurately

lilac stag
#

anyone want to guess what time N.A. beta testing of 11.0.5 starts tomorrow? Normal maintenance they’re up by 10 AM

hard ember
#

i think 3 hours

pliant topaz
#

they announced

#

until 3pm pdt

hard ember
#

oh

#

longer, then

#

wait actually is that longer

lilac stag
#

Announced and guess not the same. Haha

#

I’m thinking 5 pdt

hard ember
#

i was guessing 3 hours overtime

uneven scarab
#

6pm sounds accurate

lilac stag
#

I’m kinda expecting raid to get canceled.

hard ember
#

"surprise we didn't realize we buffed fdk so much despite everyone being confused about us buffing fdk!"

#

"also we finally figured out how to make 2nd boss mists miserable again, so the balls are actually no longer killing the clones, it works as intended now"

lilac stag
#

I’d like the ptr to come back to try shiv

hard ember
#

dude shiv looks so fun to figure out

#

like i really wonder, shiv before it all starts to build stacks, shiv possibly in a gap during your blades? shiv with premed - but before symbols possibly? etc

#

lowkey i've replaced my snd bind with shiv

#

hoping to manifest it

#

into actually staying that way

lilac stag
#

would be something different

pliant topaz
hard ember
#

a kind of amp cd taht contributes to the window, that requires a global yeah

hard ember
#

i kind of wish finality was tuned a bit higher so tehre could be variations of 1/2/3 symbols

#

cuz i think that could have been interesting

pliant topaz
hard ember
#

but probably would have ended up like ds vs es, where like one was clearly better

#

dependin on the patch

#

or situation

lilac stag
#

Watch assa get a 2% nerf and the floodgates open up to its dead how is sub

uneven scarab
hard ember
#

a 2% nerf after a 6% buff Deadge

hexed bluff
#

Assa gonna be just fine this whole tier

lilac stag
#

pmuch

hard ember
#

they really buffed enhance, fdk and assa

hexed bluff
#

Us sub lovers have been getting the shaft

hard ember
#

it's crazy work

pliant topaz
#

there are much better solutions

hard ember
#

Yeah I see what you mean

lilac stag
#

please delete sechtech pets, make it an evis amp with aoe splash and a stupid purple visual.

bronze turret
pliant topaz
#

thats true, and theres things to be genuinly mad about, but that doesnt really help us at the end of the day

#

it just craetes a sad depressing enviornment here

hard ember
#

I guess I would like to see a world where you could get to a numerical similarity with like variations of 1 or 2 dances paired with 1-3 symbols etc

bronze turret
pliant topaz
#

exactly

#

those guys are mad about good changes too

#

we dont wanna go there

vale pine
#

we found some rly nice apl changes

#

so ye

#

it does not play like shit

#

sub does what sub does best

lilac stag
vale pine
#

find a way to make things work

lilac stag
#

people love their purple ninja rp

vale pine
#

we just play trickster everywhere

#

and be happy

keen dome
#

Being able to glow purple is good and cool

pliant topaz
#

i dont think this .5 patch was meant to have class changes

lilac stag
vale pine
lilac stag
vale pine
#

no trickster on assassiantion

pliant topaz
#

we'll see in 11.1

keen dome
#

Stepping stone changes that are part of some bigger revamp

lilac stag
#

I mean. 35 BP…

keen dome
#

Absolutely, firmly agreed that these were meant to be the 11.0 changes.

lilac stag
#

keys are clearly not a focus

pliant topaz
#

its just the tuning they always do

#

somethingds really bad compared to alternatives -> they buff it

#

somethings not played at all -> they buff it

#

nothing special about that tuning

lilac stag
#

BP +4000% after zero DS sub rogues in play

hard ember
#

wish we could have idk like

#

spent tdn on bp and reapplyed with ss

#

or osmething

#

it's so awkward

#

doing that evis

uneven scarab
#

Should work with secret

hard ember
#

that would be really cool

uneven scarab
#

Works in st and aoe Shruge

formal helm
alpine wraith
#

time to give us the shadowstrike on finishers again

#

so we can always proc it with coup

#

ez

#

that tier would have been so good if the blades didnt also proc from it

pliant topaz
#

wtf is even happening there lmfa

signal smelt
#

old tier that had a chance to shadowstrike 5 targets after u used a finisher, he ended up getting like 7 procs

#

so just spamming evis for free

#

was fun asf to play w

wind canopy
#

Ahh yeah, that tier set

alpine wraith
#

basically better ace

#

if more than 2 targets

alpine wraith
#

i farmed it so many times to try and get the rings

#

with socket

jaunty heath
#

Top despairge

#

Fun on some specs not so fun on others

#

Cool dungeon tho

#

Theme and shit was on point

uneven scarab
#

I just loved the boss fight designs in there

#

i played law at the time i think

jaunty heath
#

Besides pvp boss

#

I agree

signal smelt
#

ToP on a weekly w friends was unmmatched vibes

uneven scarab
#

Nah pvp boss was bis

#

Always cc’ing my friends

#

ya LMAO

jaunty heath
#

Pvp part was cool but

signal smelt
#

getting put in the rage cage w ur mage and making him sit a full blind into sap

jaunty heath
#

Killing add in time is never fun in higher keys

uneven scarab
#

Dude i used to do exactly that to my surv hunter friend lmao

uneven scarab
#

i can agree with that

signal smelt
#

pvp boss on actual push keys was obnoxious fs tho

#

fun as hell otherwise

jaunty heath
#

I miss when weekly keys were just fun activities and an actual breeze

#

While I see the problems with that

#

But man

uneven scarab
#

yeah same

jaunty heath
#

My weekly freeholds where the best part of the week

uneven scarab
#

Its too much effort these days for like

#

Not really much reward

signal smelt
#

squish made blasting through a bunch of free max vault keys kinda obnoxious

jaunty heath
#

Pugging 10s is just really not fun idk, with a group it’s okayish but even then I’d have more fun blasting weekly keys any other season

uneven scarab
#

Ive had a bad taste for keys since my 73 runs of doti for nicholas of time

jaunty heath
#

That one was easy to drop took me 3 tries

#

On my rogue alt

uneven scarab
#

I got nothing until my last two runs

#

I got two back to back

jaunty heath
#

Altho idk why that dungeon liked me but

uneven scarab
#

You shouldve see the amount of those leech legs i had in my bags

jaunty heath
#

I got all timestrike weapons on all specs I played

#

Pretty fun

clever delta
#

you saying playing trisckter everywhere but pinned sims are ds

lilac stag
clever delta
#

i missed the second sim

#

my sub gear is kinda shit now, sub would actually need to pull ahead for me to play it again

#

its not even better on court now

steel horizon
#

Dungeon slice winner: trickster

fleet maple
#

!fuu

wicked joltBOT
glacial tundra
#

are we ready to #bringbackDFA? @vale pine

vale pine
#

na, secret is fine

vale lagoon
#

i think we were in the 1.5 mils for overalls

#

for dslice

vale pine
#

4% buff

#

~

vale lagoon
#

im so confused

vale pine
#

you mean for dungeon slice

#

oh

#

thats because

vale lagoon
#

i think i've heard the idea that dslice isn't the exactly damage we're supposed to do

vale pine
#

nimble flurry was fixed in simc to work correctly

vale pine
#

its a mixed fight style

vale lagoon
#

but previously the 1.5 mil for sub felt pretty accurate

#

and the 1.9-ish for sin felt accurate too

#

maybe even a bit low

vale lagoon
#

how was it not working b4 lol

#

but regardless, we're just

#

not saved in any way

#

rip

sweet summit
#

we WILL be saved brother

#

not in .5

#

but it will happen

vale lagoon
#

to keep myself from pressing BtE on myself

#

irl

sweet summit
#

u have to come out of stealth

#

and it wont work

#

lol

#

maintain a constant state of just unstealthing and u cant bte urself

vale lagoon
#

KEKW

#

outlaw bugs too

#

love t

#

truly one of the small indie company moments of all time

sweet summit
#

so fucking fire isnt it

vale lagoon
#

that this motley crew is running the most successful franchise of all time lol

sweet summit
#

its pretty funny

#

might have to get into ff14

#

thats pretty much the only mmo i hear ppl praise rn

vale lagoon
#

ff14 races are SO lame tho

#

like wow doesn't have the asian MMO sliders but like

#

ur choices are so awesome

sweet summit
#

im gonna be so real why the fuck does wow races have limits on what classthey can be

vale lagoon
#

but like what other game has dragons who's racial is FLYING

#

and literal zombies

sweet summit
#

i think the races r cool in wow

#

idk much about ff14

vale lagoon
#

usually it's just color swapped supermodel elves

#

yeah wow is such a good game

#

these ppl just put so little effort into QC

alpine wraith
#

can ptr PLEASE GO UP

#

i need to test shit mang

sly shore
#

wait

#

we just completely drop snd tracking from auras wednesday lmao

alpine wraith
#

yes

#

this row will lose its inhabitants

#

thanos snapped

#

3 for 1

hoary sun
#

Can thanos snap some damage back into the spec perhaps?

alpine wraith
#

just crit more

#

ez

#

crit the 6 strikes of your 15 cp coup every time

#

why 6?

#

because fuck you

vestal escarp
#

reaper of kyveza is so cool

#

ong

steel horizon
#

New flag icon is so flaccid

graceful crown
#

crazy 4 % damage buff coming

steel horizon
#

That blood dripping or w.e the hell it is is way better

graceful crown
fair stump
alpine wraith
#

there are some fringe cases

sweet summit
alpine wraith
#

looks like shite

sweet summit
#

yikes

#

ngl blizzard kinda lacks in icon art

#

some go hard dont get me wrong

#

but the amount of reused icons between class / specs is weird

cerulean beacon
sweet summit
#

i will macro the old icon over it

delicate ridge
#

Look I dont hate it its just that it is sort of worse so its a bit of a ? change

#

make it more purple or somethin

hazy breach
#

Theyre redoing all covennant abilities icons to be less "covenanty" and fit more with the class themselves

#

They had another one for sepsis too, but obv no more of that

clever delta
#

new flag is fine with me

ebon tiger
#

I'm all for some SL erasure

hazy breach
#

I agree with the old flag being cooler, but i see why theyre doing it

delicate ridge
#

Nah like I get it but realistically flag is not even covenanty its just a blade drenched in blood

#

the og ability was a red poison iirc which I assume is where the icon came from

#

but obv flag aint that today

#

and you could just colorshift echoing reprimand without changing the blade to look less sharp and making it wider

halcyon ridge
#

!fuu[

#

!fuu

wicked joltBOT
fallow nimbus
#

Slaughter poison

brazen steppe
#

!fuu

wicked joltBOT
sour tulip
#

Heyya 🙂 What are the reasons to play sub over assa mentioned in the pinned post?

vale lagoon
#

bcuz otherwise ur just fking inting

slow ruin
sour tulip
#

Ah I see…

vale lagoon
#

it's not more shameful than being a sub onetrick lul

slow ruin
proper fulcrum
#

Thats insane lmao

#

Raid team is cooked

vale lagoon
#

always some teammates out there who makes our spec look non-garbage

slow ruin
#

preach

vale lagoon
#

man im so sad tho

#

i rly dont wanna go play OL

#

and fuck sin in the ear

#

but like

#

i can't fking get over this shitty run

#

i literally watched that ret go from less dmg than me in overalls, to the same dmg, to crushing me

#

in the span of 2 weeks

#

im don't think i was playing anything particularly wrong in NW

proper fulcrum
#

Ret is cracked

vale lagoon
#

and yet they're only like b tier

#

sin and frost still above them

proper fulcrum
#

One of the best in keys

vale lagoon
#

SIN > ret

proper fulcrum
#

I'd say Ret is definitely A tier in keys if not S

vale lagoon
#

ret's strong

#

but not the most broken one

proper fulcrum
#

FDK

next valley
vale lagoon
#

and ret's already crushing us like ants

proper fulcrum
#

Sin definitely really good too

next valley
#

and just ranked up the dmg from trash

vale lagoon
#

i was like 40% more dmg than him on stitchflesh

vagrant fulcrum
vale lagoon
vagrant fulcrum
#

I do agree the spec isn't as useful as sin for other reasons but if all we're talking about is overall at the end of a key ret can win

vagrant fulcrum
vale lagoon
#

bcuz sin deals the same dmg as me just by garroting and rupturing from stealth

#

as when i fucking send flag + shblades + 2 dance

vale lagoon
#

like every pack they're spiking to like 3 million dps

vagrant fulcrum
#

I suspect the floor for ret is higher but the ceiling is clearly lower

vale lagoon
#

meanwhile im 1 million dps if i only have dance + symbols

#

legit below tanks

vagrant fulcrum
vale lagoon
#

HAHAHHAHAHA

#

im going to hurt myself physically

proper fulcrum
#

Sin gaming

vagrant fulcrum
#

issue with this list is it measures top x number of keys from a spec

#

problem for sub is it's probably not ran by serious players

vale lagoon
#

WE DO THE SAME DMG AS AUG

vagrant fulcrum
#

59 runs of 8+

#

is probably in 8-9-10s by casuals

proper fulcrum
#

True of what you say Mo for sure

vagrant fulcrum
#

while sin is compiled from 12s and above

#

sample size of sub is far too low

vale lagoon
#

lul

proper fulcrum
#

Not many people playing sub period, but especiallly in the higher keys

vagrant fulcrum
proper fulcrum
#

If you are good at sub and have good gear though you can do more than 1.1m for sure, even in your SS bug you had like 1.6

vale lagoon
#

in personal experience tho, sub REALLY doesn't go much higher than 1.5~1.6 million

proper fulcrum
#

how geared are you

vale lagoon
#

sin's like 2 million

#

625 ilvl

vagrant fulcrum
#

I suspect sub can pop off but you'd need the stars to align

vale lagoon
#

nah

vagrant fulcrum
#

black powder pumps since the buffs

vale lagoon
#

not really

proper fulcrum
#

Can pop off but yea still gonna be below Sin sadly

hazy breach
#

Sub is definitely better than those charts suggest

vale lagoon
#

it barely feels stronger than trickster

hazy breach
#

But its not better than sin

proper fulcrum
#

Sin definitely the better choice in keys but fuck it

#

We ball

vale lagoon
#

i feel like sub is a whole 25% behind sin

#

idk

vagrant fulcrum
#

core problem is blades isn't that big in aoe

#

while the extra bp dmg is nice it's not enough

vale lagoon
#

core problem is fucking flag being so powerful

#

so our base dance is now just worthless garbage

proper fulcrum
#

Core problem is Sub isnt sexy enough

#

Give us the sexy buffs

#

Let us slam

vale lagoon
#

like DANCE is our identity

#

not some frozen leftover from the single worst expac of all time

#

why the fuck is it even tuned like this man

vagrant fulcrum
#

you probably liked pre-rework sub

#

v good overall, frequent strong dances

vale lagoon
#

WoD sub was cool, DFA Legion sub is awesome, DF S1 Sub is the goat

vagrant fulcrum
#

2min dmg was fake

vale lagoon
#

idk man

vagrant fulcrum
#

i'll say this, I think that list really under-represents arcane

vale lagoon
#

just so sad to see dance play second fiddle to so many things

vagrant fulcrum
#

nothing functions without dance atm

#

it's a pre-requisite to doing anything pretty much

vale lagoon
#

it should be the ONLY thing that matters

vagrant fulcrum
#

dance and symbols stopped feeling like cds

#

and started feeling like requirements to do dps

vale lagoon
#

this shit about symbols

#

is so ass too

#

dont even get me started

vagrant fulcrum
#

is there any reason they don't just bake symbols into dance?

vale lagoon
#

like why is dance waiting for something else lmao

vagrant fulcrum
#

who enjoys having naked symbols

vale lagoon
#

exactly

vagrant fulcrum
#

dust is going away

vale lagoon
#

to be replaced by just more symbol stacks

#

great

#

now i can sit in "sYmBolS oF DeAtH" more

vagrant fulcrum
#

it would be cool if they could make blades proc something like a sectec cd reset

vale lagoon
#

while my dance still does nothing

vagrant fulcrum
#

to make up for dust

vale lagoon
#

nah

#

the idea of multiple back to back sectechs is just stupid

#

imo

#

more power to those who can pull off the resets reliably ofc

vagrant fulcrum
#

it's the strongest thing we have really

vale lagoon
#

but like, one big sectech is way better than 3 small ones no

vagrant fulcrum
#

pumping BP or evisc both come with problems

#

bp does little prio / pad spell

vale lagoon
#

was saying this yesterday, but like, i want sectech to be a thing where if i press it with the right setup, i literally SEE the trash's hp go down from like 100% to 60%

#

even in like a 12 or above

vagrant fulcrum
#

evisc doesn't aoe / nimble flurry bugged + bp buff made bp a lot better in actual aoe

vagrant fulcrum
#

as far as individual globals go it's quite powerful

#

maybe not enh level

#

but not super far off

vale lagoon
topaz raptor
#

those numbers are logs counting out of combat time right

sly cove
#

@vale pine nice writeup on the wowhead review mate. Out here fighting the good fight 💪

tribal blade
#

i love the fact that arcane mage in keys doesn't do the best aoe but BLASTS st

#

and they're getting a 12% st buff

vale lagoon
#

i love the fact that i pay $15 a month to not even have a shot at being competitive because I'm drawn to a certain spec's fantasy

jaunty umbra
#

then cancel your sub. if you wanna be competitive you play a competitive spec

vale lagoon
#

2 options right

#

kek

hazy breach
#

Or you could calm down Surebud

vale lagoon
#

meanwhile fuu has to end everything he publishes with "but it's a good patch overall"

#

kinda obnoxious at this point

pliant topaz
#

okay but its not that deep. sometimes spec good sometimes spec bad

#

you can do what I do, play sub in raid and sin in keys

#

or you can do what stealthi does, play another game until they fix it

vale lagoon
#

and this too

#

like it's completely fine to have a patch where some specs are super behind

#

but like, buffing the strongest specs and not helping the weak specs by the next patch

#

that's where it gets sus

#

pls tell me im not crazy for thinking that?

pliant topaz
#

theyre not buffing anything though. theyre making the changes and the buffs are a side product, not the goal

#

theyll probably hotfix it later

weary saffron
#

yeah these arent really "tuning" notes for rogue or most specs

vale lagoon
#

and maybe buy the 12 month sub lmao

strange chasm
vale lagoon
#

HAHAHAHAHAHA this is golden tho

strange chasm
#

Raid logging this early into an expac is great game design

vale lagoon
#

seems like they have the same problems as us huh

#

the “50% tooltip 40% in game" thing, altho i know that one is just a dummy bug for us

jolly hare
#

why play sub over sin in mythic raid? im kinda newb but if they are similar whats the bif between on demand amp dmg for m court?

pliant topaz
#

sub has better burst, its also a 1.5 min spec and dances are more frequent than kb windows

wispy bolt
#

!bugs

wicked joltBOT
barren plume
#

Oof I must be bad I parse way better in sin than I do in sub

vale lagoon
#

ur like

#

actually just parsing against fuu and armin lmao

barren plume
#

Lol

vale lagoon
#

legit them and no one else

#

no pisslow new players to pad with

barren plume
#

I’ll get there

vale lagoon
#

lol im just waiting for the hotfixes that armin "promised" me

#

surely they finally aura buff us and make us not piss!

barren plume
#

Lol you silly bitch thinking like that will get you nothing but disappointment

steel horizon
#

on wclogs, is there a way to change this so i can only see the last 2 weeks instead of top 100 all time

#

i wanna see if more people are playing ds on mythic brood since the bp buff

vagrant fulcrum
#

it just happened as a consequence of the talent changes

#

lowkey idk if blizzard even knows the impact of talent changes on damage

vale lagoon
vagrant fulcrum
#

issue is what if something is a nerf unless players change how they play

#

are you supposed to anticipate the change in apl for sims?

vale lagoon
#

well it's a good thing we have people like fuu literally losing their hair to update APLs

#

almost like he should be getting $$$ and official recognition for his efforts

vagrant fulcrum
#

thing is sim and apls are changed AFTER blizz post patch notes

vale lagoon
vagrant fulcrum
#

idk if blizzard have an internal tool like simc

vagrant fulcrum
#

so how is blizzard supposed to know

vale lagoon
#

literally all blizz needs to do is to actually lock in the changes and clear about it

vagrant fulcrum
#

can we trust the buff %s?

vale lagoon
#

as opposed to doing literal last minute changes just so they can be lazy and not held accountable

dark oak
#

!up

vagrant fulcrum
#

if your answer is yes

#

look at outlaw's sims

#

do those reflect reality?

#

!fuu

wicked joltBOT
vale lagoon
#

and dslice still shows what's a buff and what's a nerf

vagrant fulcrum
#

look at dslice

#

outlaw isn't even close to sin in dungeons

#

there's a lot of problems

vale lagoon
#

that's the nature of dslice lol, the actual numbers isn't what we're looking at

vagrant fulcrum
#

we have to be real

#

it's difficult

vale lagoon
#

it's just the general of numbers going up or going down after a change

vagrant fulcrum
#

for blizzard to forsee the impact of changes that are mechanical in nature

#

and not just x number goes up

vale lagoon
#

and for a spec that's already at the bottom of all tier lists, their new sims shouldn't have them going down

#

or even going up by very small margins

vagrant fulcrum
#

things like twist the knife for example

short radish
#

you cant compare dslice numbers between different specs

#

but yeah sub is still kinda poop

vale lagoon
#

again, just see if the dslice number is going up in general

vagrant fulcrum
#

sure, but it proves my point that sim numbers aren't really trustworthy

short radish
#

well they are

vale lagoon
#

and whether it's going up a lot or a little

short radish
#

you just gotta read it in the right context

azure mauve
vagrant fulcrum
#

perhaps for comparing an item

vagrant fulcrum
#

him losing to the tank xd

#

you can't tell me it's not an OL issue

short radish
#

if you are reading dslice sim and thinking "i should do this exact damage in dungeons" then you are reading it wrong

vagrant fulcrum
#

im saying the sim assumes unrealistic things

#

the execution carried out by the sim is NOT really replicable by humans consistently

short radish
#

it is on single target patchwerk

vagrant fulcrum
#

why isn't OL topping kyveza?

#

spec sims a ton higher than other rogue specs

short radish
#

because its not single target patchwerk

azure mauve
#

sure doesnt seem like hes getting bodied

vale lagoon
#

and im saying i doubt there are times when the sims fucking show you a spec going down, but you end up going up in actual gameplay

vagrant fulcrum
#

alright, st patchwerk doesn't exist ingame atm then

azure mauve
#

i mean only one dungeon but ive watched his stream plenty of times

#

hes keeping up

vagrant fulcrum
#

either way back to the original point

#

it's tricky for the devs to know ahead of time

#

easier for them to hotfix nerf / buff things

#

after the mechanical changes have gone through and players have optimised gameplay around the design changes

vale lagoon
#

it's tricky for devs to know ahead of time because most of them are dogshit at playing their own game lol, imma go out on a limb and say not all devs are like that realz individual

#

and that's why these ppl need to intereact more with theorycrafters

short radish
vagrant fulcrum
short radish
#

and all of since beta ended

vale lagoon
#

so they can serve the necessary changes days in advance, instead of weeks late

short radish
#

it's a resourcing issue

vagrant fulcrum
# short radish they had all of beta

we, as a community are dogshit beta testers, we only play w/e build does best numbers, we dont test all the talents etc until the broken thing is nerfed / fixed

#

look at mages on beta

#

litterally didn't see a non fire mage for weeks

#

then it got butchered and they all went to arcane for ages

#

when that was broken

vale lagoon
short radish
#

also i only really speak in context from rogue

vagrant fulcrum
short radish
#

but i wouldnt call our rogue TC's dogshit beta testers

vagrant fulcrum
#

no, they're not

#

but to produce usable data there needs to be a decent sample sizew

vale lagoon
vagrant fulcrum
#

also I suspect blizz don't dedicate that much time to balance

leaden prairie
#

or well im better

#

lets say

vagrant fulcrum
#

^

#

like watching zac global to global

#

ain'tnoway he doesn't deserve more dps

#

he's hella clean

azure mauve
leaden prairie
#

none

#

it doesnt sim better in m+

vagrant fulcrum
#

compared to a similar skilled player on sin the overall wouldn't be as closee as sims would suggest sin and OL are. basing balance decisions from blizz's side on sims alone is risky business

leaden prairie
#

sin players are delusional

#

if i do a nw against casual addict

#

he can do up to 40% more damage than me

vagrant fulcrum
#

yeah

leaden prairie
#

sin players will say outlaw is fine

vagrant fulcrum
#

XD

#

one day they will remove the cap

#

live for that day

azure mauve
#

sure

#

one day...

vale lagoon
#

they're ultimately still trying to sell their game to dogs who think AoTC/KSM are milestones

#

and ig it works for them financially

pliant topaz
tribal blade
#

i'm very happy i chose to move off sub to push

pliant topaz
#

NW 13 for me was 2.4M overall

tribal blade
#

because based on this tuning blizz is doing

#

can't rely on good tuning to catch up with a worse spec

leaden prairie
short radish
#

yeah, im gonna try out sub a bit still for last 2

#

but ive basically just respecced for sin now

#

with gear and stats

leaden prairie
short radish
#

see how the new patch feels

#

probably ass

leaden prairie
#

i have seen casual do 2.65 in mist

#

my top is 2.1

short radish
#

i didnt win mythic transmitter roll as well

#

so i still have a normie one

#

reeeeee

leaden prairie
#

and its mist, there isnt even any uncapped packs really

vale lagoon
#

yay fun

pliant topaz
#

sin cannot be beaten overall

pliant topaz
tribal blade
#

you have to have serious willpower to keep at it

leaden prairie
pliant topaz
#

oh yea

#

pack lives im vibing

leaden prairie
#

13 is still kinda low for sin to tryully shine imo

pliant topaz
#

it iss

#

gatekeeper died before kb

leaden prairie
#

ye

#

14 is prolly fine

#

15 you get full potential

vale lagoon
#

just like it isn't impossble to recover from cancer

#

but i still dont want any sort of cancer

tribal blade
#

the longer this goes on the less and less they're able to nerf stuff

#

because once the season becomes established

pliant topaz
#

not really

#

so like, they did say this to be honest

#

they said that they dont want to nerf the "meta"

tribal blade
#

mmmm

pliant topaz
#

because this is an mmo, people make their characters and its not a good idea to break that

#

but they said theyre open to buffing things

tribal blade
#

it's a fair point by them

vale lagoon
tribal blade
#

but yeah they should mega buff stuff that's underperforming

vale lagoon
#

like

leaden prairie
#

dk getting buffed next week

vale lagoon
#

nothing about the meta is surprising rn no?

leaden prairie
#

is so funny

tribal blade
#

dks actually getting a big buff is just wild

vale lagoon
#

we all knew this was how shit would shape up

short radish
#

!specs

#

!spec

wicked joltBOT
#

All Specs are good and have niches and strengths that they play to. All three specs are looking viable with Assassination/Subtlety being preferred in raids. Mythic+ meta has not solidified yet but Assassination looked promising during beta.

Be aware that Simulations are a tool to be used to compare things like talents/gear/rotations, they are not the definite answer to what is meta or not meta. While outlaw is ahead in sims right now, especially dungeonslice, you have to take a step back and realize these are synthetic/generic situations that we use as a baseline. Dungeonslice has always been a great showing for outlaw simply due to the fight style matching well with the spec. This is not unusual or unheard of.

You can view logs of the raid when it comes out Here, or view the mythic+ run leaderboard Here.

short radish
#

damn

#

ass looking promising in beta

vale lagoon
#

HAHAHAHAHA it's literally just fuu trying his best to not shit on the devs

#

must be tiring to still act so nice in the face of incompetence

short radish
#

!dot5

wicked joltBOT
#

The power level of the spec stays about the same but the changes are generally a downgrade.
Things that get worse in the patch:

  • Talent diversity
  • Defensives
  • Gameplay
    This does not meant he patch is bad, just that it isn't a great update to Subtlety.
short radish
#

i mean

#

we're getting a 5% dps inc

#

so we take that i guess

vale lagoon
# pliant topaz calm down.

i'm not gonna talking about the devs directly man, absolutely good there, im just saying it seems like fuu is also trying to be indirect

vagrant fulcrum
#

it's a game at the end of the day, people like sub if it does good dps or not and will play it regardless

short radish
#

nah

#

even when sub does good dps

#

ppl still dont play it

#

or ppl are mad they have to play it

#

source: amidrissal

vagrant fulcrum
#

you seem to be talking to people who don't like the spec

short radish
#

its just the general vibes

vagrant fulcrum
#

of my co-rogues 2 of them really love sub

#

and gravitate to it whenever given the choice

tribal blade
#

nah he's right, that's actually what happened with sub during amirdrassil

short radish
#

echo or liquid was like "hey can we get more playing sub for smold it's fuckign bonkers"

#

"lol nah too fucking hard"

tribal blade
#

the amount of sin rogues who were furious they had to go sub on smoldy onward

vale lagoon
#

even in df s1 i saw fellow rogues complaining about sub being at all viable

short radish
#

yeah it's acutally the opposite with ppl in sub. the ppl here that play sub really fucking love it

#

there are dozens of us or something

short radish
#

but like fuck its sohard to justify playing sometimes

vale lagoon
#

yeah at this point i just hope blizz can slap a bandaid aura buff onto us, make us at least better than half the specs in keys and worse than the other half

#

and i'll never yap again

tribal blade
short radish
#

yeah i am one of them 😦

tribal blade
#

because there's no way to justify using sub in high level content

#

i'm one of the die hard sub rogue players

#

and i'm now sin

#

it feels dirty, but had to be done

vale lagoon
#

i remember the screenshot of 3.7k io lmao

#

this man fking pumps

tribal blade
#

dude i literally swapped sin and gained ~70 points of IO in 3 hours of keying

short radish
#

sin is so chill as well

vale lagoon
short radish
tribal blade
#

i had a hard time getting used to the aoe rotation, it has a lot of moving parts

vale lagoon
#

everything else was on +11, that one was on +6

tribal blade
#

but once you get the hang of it, it's fine

vale lagoon
#

yeah honestly i wouldn't accuse current sin of being too ez

tribal blade
#

in ST it is for sure pretty easy

#

in aoe less so easy, but not the worst

vale lagoon
#

oh god ST

#

such a 2010 idea

short radish
#

honestly i hate sin in ST

#

it feels so clunky

tribal blade
#

haha sin in ST is kinda funny

vale lagoon
#

they keys are where it's at maaaan

tribal blade
#

whenever i swap back to sub now the ST rotation is so much sweatier than sin

vale lagoon
#

i fking swear m+ is so awesome, u use so many weird shit from ur kits

tribal blade
#

much more GOGOGO

short radish
#

yeah but sub ramps up and down

vale lagoon
#

my flag macro is literally called "GOGOGO button"

short radish
#

feels like a steady pace

#

youre under control

wispy bolt
#

a big problem is no one knows anything about subtlety other than subtlety players. usually people know a decent bit about every spec at high levels but for subtelty is just "yeah idk what youre talking about but can you play assa"

tribal blade
#

the thing is even with sub's downtime it's kind of sweaty in a sense because you're trying to maintain as much uptime as possible

short radish
#

sin has moving parts of maintaining envenon/garrote/rupture

#

not complicated

#

but still a pain

#

how is sub feeling for last 2 bosses with the changes btw?

tribal blade
short radish
#

does 1:30 still line up

tribal blade
#

except "why are you pressing black powder"

short radish
#

or is it all ass now

tribal blade
#

"why aren't you funneling"

short radish