#assassination

1 messages · Page 4235 of 1

limber lion
#

I had to hold my damage for 20+ seconds completely in p1

cold spoke
#

same Sadge

nimble tartan
#

are you 2-1-1 or 2-2

limber lion
#

and I still did 7.5k in overall

#

You just need to learn to maximize your output in p2

pale fossil
#

Oh my good god

limber lion
#

Be it keeping dots up on everything

fluid eagle
#

Yeah I know, that's why i said its not an excuse

#

2-2

pale fossil
#

I just did a Sludge pull and had NO soulbinds activated

limber lion
#

Having higher up time

#

Or whatnot

nimble tartan
#

oh 2-2 should be good to go for parsing

limber lion
#

How much dps are you doing in p2 and p3?

gusty mirage
pale fossil
#

I clicked the Sanctum Report to confirm that I had Niya up and there was nothing below the Renown bar hahahahaha

limber lion
#

Around 6k is fine for p3

cold spoke
#

who needs soulbinds

limber lion
#

P2 should be around 8k+

#

Feel free to link the log, I can take a peak.

fluid eagle
limber lion
#

was that you held your Vendetta after the overlap

#

That's actually kinda bad because you use lust after second blood price (which is the norm for melee)

#

But by you holding Vendetta, you don't get the last 20s of lust

#

inside of your Vendetta window.,

fluid eagle
#

what do you mean by after the overlap?

#

do you mean i heald my 3rd vendetta for P3 rather than using in p2

limber lion
#

After the last massacre+ravage+shattering pain overlap

#

You held your very, very last Vendetta

fluid eagle
#

gotcha let me look

limber lion
#

for like 16s

fluid eagle
#

yeah i did... hmm ~17 secpmds

#

seconds*

limber lion
#

So you didn't get much value out of the lust

#

Blue is lust
Red is vendetta

#

By using the Vendetta on cooldown, you would have gotten the full value out of it during the lust.

#

Would highly recommend that

fluid eagle
#

Yeah I didn't have it all during lust i dont know why i dindt cast it for 18 seconds...

#

that is pretty dumb

limber lion
#

There should be some downtime before the overlap as well.

#

You also, for whatever reason, use Mutilate at max-1

#

a lot

#

and garrote at max combo points

#

Don't do that

#

You always use a finisher at max combo points or max-1

#

And since you're playing with Vigor, that means at 4-5 CP

#

There is no need to build to 5 CP every time.

#

You shouldn't waste combo points with garrote either

#

It's a generator, use it when you're missing combo points, not when you're maxed out

pale fossil
#

If you mess up are you're at max CP, but garrote will expire before the GCD after your finisher, you go ahead and garrote, right?

#

It's just that you messed up by being in that situation in the first place.

limber lion
#

Pandemic exists for a reason

#

It's 5.4s or something for Garrote

#

That's a lot of room to do stuff

#

To finish, to build

#

etc.

#

That's a very basic thing though, you NEVER EVER press Mutilate when you're at max-1 or max combo points.

#

Energy waste and combo point wastes are one of the major things to keep track of, alongside high bleed uptime.

#

In p2, you don't want this to happen

fluid eagle
#

All of that makes a ton of sense, and definitely things i need to improve. Would you suggest I don't run EP vigor or is that fine. It looks like hte next week I did the vendetta correctly and used it at beginning of lust full duration

limber lion
#

Always make sure to keep SnD up with Envenoms

#

Never let it drop so you have to cast it again

fluid eagle
#

yeah its awful that i cast that during vendetta; should never cast it besides at beginning of fight

limber lion
#

Even if it means not refreshing a rupture early

#

Yeh

#

You just maintain it with Envenoms

scenic meteor
#

what are the exact pandemic times ?

garotte : 5.4?

limber lion
#

But yeah, there's quite a few minor things you can improve on

scenic meteor
#

what about rupture and CT?

limber lion
#

It's different for each combo point

#

Because the more combo points you use, the longer the applied duration

scenic meteor
#

ah okay

#

i was assuming 5 cp

limber lion
#

But for 5CP rupture it's 7.2s I think

scenic meteor
#

but then you have DS

limber lion
#

CT is 4.something

#

It's safe to just use a weak aura that tracks pandemic

#

And just reapply when they start to glow or whatever.

#

You don't have to remember the exact numbers yourself.

#

!pd

prisma monolithBOT
#

Pandemic takes up to 30% of the duration of a applied dot/buff and adds it to your new applied one. The duration depends on the new instance.
Example: Garrote (18 sec) can be extended by up to 5.4 seconds from an existing instance.
Note: Pandemic applies to most but not all debuffs/buffs

scenic meteor
#

cheers

fluid eagle
#

Oh a question for how to play CT properly in ST, is it actually worth pressing? my average cast of CT in P3 did 5.3k and the average envenom did 7.2

limber lion
#

@fluid eagle Are you looking to get a better parse or what's the plan?

limber lion
#

Let's compare your p2 and my p2 damage breakdowns, shall we?

fluid eagle
#

great

#

I appreciate you doing this btw

limber lion
#

You did 7060 dps, I did 9094 dps.

limber lion
#

Here's your breakdown

#

Here's mine

#

What do you notice immediately?

fluid eagle
#

I definitely do want to get a better parse but its less about the parse and more about improving. I played Outlaw the majority of hte tier and know i will have to play Assass in SoD.

#

my CT damage sucks

#

yours is great

limber lion
#

Is there something that pops out right away?

#

Yes pretty much

#

You should be utilizing CT way more

#

I pretty much cast CT 3 times every time you cast it once.

#

CT is our biggest finisher in AoE

#

You should have ruptures and garrotes on both Sire/Remornia at all times, right

fluid eagle
#

I try to yeah

limber lion
#

So when the cabalists spawn, you should prioritize using CT right away

fluid eagle
#

gotcha

limber lion
#

And only after that start applying more ruptures

#

Making sure to always keep SnD/CT up

steep kelp
#

Hold on a second... I'm new here. CT is best talent for ST?......

limber lion
#

CT is nutty in 2 targets, let alone 4.

steep kelp
#

Ok thank you. I was starting to get dizzy

limber lion
#

We're talking about Sire Denathrius, where we commonly use CT.

maiden plaza
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
steep kelp
#

I think I understand. For the melee adds and Remornia. Sorry for butting in

limber lion
#

No worries

fluid eagle
#

So I did notice that about my CT usage and then tried to use CT more but I dont know why it feels so awkward to me

balmy condor
#

You still cast it in single target

#

Is the thing

#

It’s just not better than pb

limber lion
#

Whenever there are 2+ targets, you need to prioritize CT a bit higher.

#

But that's not the only problem

fluid eagle
#

okay, doesnt surprise me

limber lion
#

Look at the amount of casts as well.

#

I pretty much cast everything more

void pecan
#

Sudden fractures the go to potency? or should I just sim between them to find out

balmy condor
limber lion
#

That's probably because I made sure to always keep bleeds up on both Remornia and Sire, which in turn gives me more energy to do things.

#

Let's see how our energy gain compares

#

Do note also

void pecan
fluid eagle
#

1300 less

#

and i wasted 500 more

limber lion
#

that our P2 is the exact same length

fluid eagle
#

so i gained 1700 less than you

limber lion
#

I got over a thousand more energy than you

#

during p2

fluid eagle
#

oh im looking at a different one of your logs

#

where you had even more than that from me

#

1700 more

limber lion
#

Yeah no, this is my private log

fluid eagle
#

gotcha

limber lion
#

That's the only public log I have

#

That's a really bad one, don't look at it.

#

Anyways

balmy condor
limber lion
#

I had over a thousand energy in p2 compared to you

#

And that's only because I made sure to always keep bleeds up on multiple targets

#

AS WELL as keeping poisons up

#

That's a really important thing to remember

#

If you slap a 32s rupture on Remornia, you will have to slap her a few times during it

scenic meteor
#

is there a video of your kill ceverion?

limber lion
#

because your poison will run out

limber lion
#

You need to make sure to track both bleeds and poisons very actively

fluid eagle
#

So yeah I see that i only had 71 % uptime for deadly poison and 59% uptime for garrote on remornia. and only 75% for rupture

limber lion
#

The second your poison drops, you lose all the potential energy from the bleeds.

lone moth
#

whats fastest way to gain renow. just changed to necro

limber lion
fluid eagle
#

they all dropped off at the same time pretty much

#

and for al ong time

#

23 seconds strraight

limber lion
#

Yeah, here's your deadly poison uptime on Sire specifically

#

Here's mine

fluid eagle
#

oof yeah i had a 32gap there too

limber lion
#

All the other bleeds have lower uptimes as well, so you really need to pay more attention to it.

#

This is an outlier though:

fluid eagle
#

so that was the first time i had ever used CT in my life

limber lion
#

That's fair enough.

fluid eagle
#

still should be better

#

but that is the case

deft obsidian
#

Cev in p2 are you priortising dotting cabalists after sire/remornia or just CT and maintaining focus on the other two?

limber lion
#

But yeah, that's quite a few things already that we're gone through.

fluid eagle
#

Best way to practice for these type of things? should I just run heroic sire a bunch or just do M+ as Assass?

limber lion
#

Just:

  1. Make sure to keep poisons up on your bled targets at all times
  2. Make sure to keep bleeds up on your main targets (Sire and Remornia) at all times
  3. Use CT more actively
limber lion
#

Heroic raids are a good practice spot for sure.

fluid eagle
#

So I have a heroic sale on sunday, should I just use CT for every boss just so I use it more?

limber lion
#

So when the cabalists spawn, I can instantly CT and change to rupturing them

limber lion
limber lion
#

But you can definitely just rock it from start to finish

#

And get some single target practice in as well.

#

(Useful for p3)

fluid eagle
#

k I think i'll do that because I have a feeling this talent wont be going away in 9.1 and will have use on bosses. and if I run CT do I always run EP/Vigor?

balmy condor
#

I have a feeling this talent wont be going away in 9.1

god I hate that you're right

limber lion
#

Make CT baseline prayge

deft obsidian
balmy condor
#

100% true

#

should be baseline

fluid eagle
#

Same, but it is what it is. I appreciate you taking time to walk through that with me, I did see a lot of those issues but I didn't realize how glaring some of those were.

balmy condor
#

but also god damnit why are we casting it in single target

#

fuck that

granite fjord
#

For current content is Doomblade best in slot on shoulders or hands?

balmy condor
#

hands, but will be cloak in like 2 weeks

#

10 days?

granite fjord
#

Got it. Thanks @balmy condor 🙂

balmy condor
#

my pleasure

limber lion
#

If anything comes up, feel free to dm me

#

I'm an EU frog though, so if I'm sleeping, I'm sure our lovely @balmy condor would love to help out in my stead. whispyrheart

south oak
#

Is it bad to go venthyr when doing a little bit of m+ pushing on the side of raids?

limber lion
#

If you're not pushing for world ranks for mega high keys, you'll be fine.

thorny pond
#

CT baseline then what goes in that slot for talents?

balmy condor
thorny pond
#

Exsang that is good?

south oak
#

Fleshcraft seems alot more useful than door of shadows though monkaHMM

limber lion
scenic meteor
#

/wa

#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
limber lion
#

Good night lovelies. whispyrheart

hollow river
thorny pond
#

Give us that old guaranteed crit on next ability use

#

The talent before seal fate

shut garnet
#

a new exciting talent

#

someone say venom rush?

thorny pond
#

Get out

shut garnet
hollow river
#

something to make FoK crit like SS would be nice

balmy condor
#

2 changes I giga want to see:
Ct baseline
Fok 2cp baseline

thorny pond
#

Shrouded suffocation—-

#

Or Echoing

shut garnet
#

expedient baseline Smilers

torn atlas
balmy condor
#

Turn hidden blades into echoing, turn ct into shrouded, and idk, turn pb into “shiv makes your next envenom deal 1000% damage” or some shit

soft shale
#

pb can be kingsbane

balmy condor
#

Sure

thorny pond
#

Just make PB legion version

soft shale
#

noonono

balmy condor
#

No

shut garnet
#

assarogue would be so cocained out

#

if those changes went thru

balmy condor
#

Definitely not that

dawn ivy
#

Pb legion was fun only because it was addictive to get massive bombs

#

but it wasnt GOOD gameplay

thorny pond
#

Yea

#

Let me get giga tilted still

shut garnet
#

poison bomb is actually a meme talent Sadge

soft shale
#

every day ct ST comes closer

#

and a day passes in africa

balmy condor
#

Poison bomb debuffs the enemy, increasing poison damage for 15 seconds

#

You still get the giga rng of lining up with shiv

#

Everyone wins

shut garnet
#

ngl is there any spec that actually has 0 rng

#

attached to its performance

soft shale
#

rogue the spec where aoe/cleave talents are only 3% worse than the st ones

thorny pond
#

There needs to be some drawback

dawn ivy
#

there are some specs that arent RNG dependant

dry void
#

its kinda funny how bad exsanguinate is since the nighthold relic nerf

shut garnet
#

exang was nutty in 8.3

scenic meteor
#

so do i need to craft doomblade again? out of the glove spot

brazen rampart
#

Did they buff sylv dagger in today's build? I remember the pin yesterday saying it was garbo but now it says it's very good

shut garnet
#

they buffed it by like 500% or something ridiculous

#

i think?

brazen rampart
#

Sick, can't wait to not get a single one for months KEKW

dry void
#

thank god we have that sick raid utility so we can trade with fellow rogues in the raid

brazen rampart
#

Shroud on pull is bis utility

dry void
#

u know whats the best

#

distracting the boss during shroud to cause your raidmembers a heartattack 👍

brazen rampart
#

Distract the boss to look behind so it can't parry anyone's first hit on pull

eager river
#

distracting shriekwing is bis

#

she just flies the entire fight

hollow river
#

wut

steep kelp
#

Since we're on the subject of the dagger, will it drop on all difficulties?

dawn ivy
#

yeah

severe sparrow
#

sooo there's not a huge reason to go grind for assa gear atm, eh? im geared dumb cuz i just swapped from outlaw, but dogekek general consensus to save the face slamming, right?

plain thistle
#

assa gear? just use your outlaw gear for now, equip 2 daggers of course

severe sparrow
#

like, not VERS 2 DA MAX

strange python
#

Secondary stat optimisation across the board isn't THAT big of a deal.

#

It won't make or break you at least

severe sparrow
#

well my trinkets are garbage but i guess those arent spec specific

#

point is, there's no point in going hunting for shit rn

#

right?

strange python
#

Trinkets aren't really spec tuned for us

plain thistle
#

your outlaw gear is probably fine

strange python
#

Good ol trinks are just good rogue trinks

severe sparrow
#

yes i worded that dumb cuz im drunk

gusty mirage
#

I played a buncha vers when I first switched

#

and did fine

plain thistle
#

dont worry too much about secondary

shy dust
strange python
#

Yeah I still popped an 80 something rank on sploogefist with vers gears and a 220 offhand

#

You're fine

severe sparrow
#

yeah but if we were not right before a patch id attempt to give a small fuck about secondaries

hollow river
#

how much easier do mythic raids get later in xpac? jw

gusty mirage
#

they usually get tuned down so it becomes more accessible

#

and strats get fine tuned

hollow river
#

during the same xpan?

gusty mirage
#

oh I'm dumb I read that as same tier

hollow river
#

(:

strange python
#

Do you mean if you go backwards?

hollow river
#

yeah

strange python
#

It depends on the power creep

hollow river
#

i couldn't get the whole CN xmog mythic ):

strange python
#

Like bfa starting raids were a fucking joke by 8.3

#

Coz the power creep was completely insane

gusty mirage
#

yeah corruption took the creep and multiplied it by like 1000 too

hollow river
#

i'm wearing like half mythic half heroic/m+gear

#

lol

strange python
#

But it's not a thing you do anymore

#

Lfr gear in 9.1 is nearly on par with mythic gear

#

You leave old raids completely behind

gusty mirage
#

afaik the EP trinkets were still incredibly insane

#

which is why at the beginning of 8.3 people were still farming them

strange python
#

Super big outlier though

gusty mirage
#

yea

strange python
#

Thats mega rare these days

#

Nearly reminded me of dst from tbc

hollow river
#

i know that

#

i want the rest of the mythic set anyway x.x

strange python
#

Oh icic

gusty mirage
#

if you wanna farm mog, people will do mog runs and it'll get easier as ilvl gets higher

hollow river
#

i need the glowy glowy

strange python
#

Well all I'll say about that is it will be a hell of a while before slg and sire are rollovers unless your guild already rolls them

hollow river
#

rofl

#

5/10 atm

strange python
#

And your headpiece is locked to sire

#

Lol

hollow river
#

trying to find a better home

loud silo
misty edge
#

The rumors are true the dagger was buffed! 🤗

bleak sky
#

well shit
sbs feels preeeeeeetty good

hollow river
#

yup

shadow wedge
#

Hello boys, doomblade legendary will be viable in 9.1?

thorny pond
#

Just changing slots

shadow wedge
thorny pond
#

Currently best slot to craft on is hands but due to new socket system we will be crafting on cape

#

Barring any last minute changes

hollow river
#

so SBS crit was already added

#

and i'm seeing 2 ticks of bleed every tick

#

idr if that's how it was already or not

loud silo
thorny pond
#

Domination sockets

loud silo
#

oooooh

#

oh wow those are pretty cool ngl

#

is there a limit to how many you can have or does it work like a regular socket

balmy condor
hollow river
balmy condor
#

Or 5 slots

#

I guess there’s 2 pieces for some slots

hollow river
balmy condor
#

2 ticks for every tick?

#

What’s that mean

hollow river
#

Two instances of damage

#

On 1 tick

balmy condor
hollow river
#

Swear

balmy condor
#

That’s not how that works

#

Are you using sudden fractures?

hollow river
#

Yes

#

Is that why

balmy condor
#

Yeah

hollow river
#

I’m dumb

#

Big dumb sorry

#

But man that damage tho

#

My SBS used to do like 183

soft shale
#

let me tell you it can also crit now

#

stonks

hollow river
#

Now it’s doing like 330 and 260 added on most ticks and critting for 520+260

#

I know I didn’t know that was already implemented

#

Thought it was a 9.1 thing

balmy condor
#

No worries

#

I thought you meant the crit was showing as a second tick

#

And I was like

hollow river
#

Lol

edgy cosmos
#

anyone willing look over some of my mythic pulls for the very small things i can improve on LF absolute OCD master

humble ginkgo
#

do I run sudden fractures right

soft shale
#

yes

humble ginkgo
#

ok

soft shale
#

only boss you dont is sludge

#

that one wps is better

humble ginkgo
#

wps?

soft shale
#

well placed steel

humble ginkgo
#

what do you do on lets say huntsman while trying to keep up 2t dots and the dog runs away and ur dots fall off on the dog

#

I heard theres a lkot of 2t bosses

#

and 2t assa wins compared to outlaw

#

Just feels like pointless

soft shale
#

if tanks play well dots dont fall off

humble ginkgo
#

hm okay

#

do you run single target talents in 2-3T fights?

gloomy knoll
#

you can run subterfuge as well (i belive for full 2-3 target cleave and not just partial it is better) me personally i like MA

humble ginkgo
#

I like MA

gloomy knoll
#

but that's only because the two target cleaves we have now are kind of

humble ginkgo
#

2-3 target you go crimson?

gloomy knoll
#

meh or not full 2t cleaves

#

yea crimson any time there's more than 1 target

#

basically

#

or when boss has super high movement like denny so poison bomb loses value

humble ginkgo
#

wtf

gloomy knoll
#

?

humble ginkgo
#

I mean it says ex 5 man instances

#

thats why im suprised

#

so 2t bosses I go crimson tempest

#

like huntsman

gloomy knoll
#

multi target is anything over 1

humble ginkgo
#

ok

gloomy knoll
#

technically but yea

#

huntsman you'd go ct

humble ginkgo
#

what is CT

#

oh

#

crimson tempesst

#

ok

#

when do you even use that finisher?

soft shale
#

keep it up outside shiv windows

humble ginkgo
#

oh its another bleed

#

shit ok

cobalt pelican
#

big reading power

humble ginkgo
#

on huntsman do I want to do normal opener and apply both bleeds on huntsman then do them on the dog?

soft shale
#

it is a but diff but i dont remember

#

i mean if youre necro you sbs snd sbs

#

or wait maybe 1 garrote so it does not have cd

humble ginkgo
#

oh I see that

#

he Sbs slice and sbs the dog im guessing

#

he starts on margore

sonic schooner
#

u want to keep all bleeds up, CT aswell

#

i usually go sbs sbs snd on the opener cause i dont enevenom early enough to keep the buff rolling

#

dont know if it s the best but that s what i founnd for myself

safe barn
humble ginkgo
#

u got this

#

xqcl

drifting cloud
#

why is your vendetta running there monakS

safe barn
#

idk dude

#

i was in "fuck this" mode

severe sparrow
#

what plates are those?

#

or like uh

#

is it plater? fuck sorry words are hard KEK

humble ginkgo
#

plater

#

atrocityUI

gloomy knoll
#

@balmy condor for that keep ct up except during shiv windows rule at what density would you just keep ct up regardless

#

denny p1 for example

#

say shiv window is when ads spawn

#

i'm 100% cting

#

regardless

#

and quite often during raid encounters aoe is in a limited window where ads come in etc

#

so that rule never really made sense to me

muted adder
#

is it worth it to craft legendaries now or wait until 9.1?

#

heard we might have to recraft

gloomy knoll
#

we can't craft them now

#

the option isn't available

loud trench
#

Roast me for not knowing 2/1/1 well enough but also, my ph1 damage, i feel like i have a CT falling off during transitions or right before adds spawn so im just sending another CT and then FOK FOK/CT and then funneling back into the boss but they always seem to happen during shiv windows too

gloomy knoll
#

sometimes ct falls off right before or a couple seconds before ad spawns

#

i generally just hold it for those couple seconds

#

since i know i'm going to be casting it when ads spawn anyways

#

but yea shiv lines up with the ad spawns as well

#

but the density is so high there

#

it's def worth to CT

#

even if in a shiv window imo

loud trench
#

yea I have no idea if im just blowing my windows or what but i feel like im doing it "right" but im leaving ph1 at like 6k on a somewhat decent pull w/doomblade and i feel like that is far far too low

gloomy knoll
#

i mean your damage in p1 is entirely dependant on your raid

#

not super important

loud trench
#

also my ph2 damage, granted I have never really seen the fight as melee nor 2/1/1 but I feel like im hardly casting envenoms with the amount of time i am trying to send off and refresh bleeds on sire and remoria and a calbst or two

gloomy knoll
#

you envenom a lot less in cleave build yea

#

but you still do it

#

once bleeds are gucci

#

and during shivs

loud trench
#

ok ty

muted adder
#

is it better to refresh rupture a couple secs before it expires or just right at the last second

vernal tapir
#

Switching over to sin in time for the new patch. Is venth bis here?

gloomy knoll
#

you want to rupture in pandemic

#

which is 30% of the casts length i believe

#

a general rule is ~7 seconds or less left on rupture though

gloomy knoll
#

sin / sub = venth

#

sin / outlaw = necro

vernal tapir
#

It seems like I have a decision to make..

#

I'll want to keep sub for pvp but Outlaw for M+

#

fuk

gloomy knoll
#

sin pvp will be better than sub next tier

#

or at least it's lookin that way

vernal tapir
#

sweet

#

Reckon hold off on crafting Doomblade lego until 9.1 patch?

thorny pond
#

Probably

gloomy knoll
#

yea we'll more than likely be making it on cape

#

once 9.1 drops

#

to allow for dom gem

limpid plinth
#

But we can farm soul ash indefinetly in 9.1 so does not really matter

thorny pond
#

Just one more thing we would have to do in 9.1

balmy condor
hollow river
#

is 5 bleeds "saturated"?

balmy condor
#

kinda

hollow river
#

is there any DR or stop on energy regen with VW?

balmy condor
#

for all realistic purposes, 5 bleeds is saturated

hollow river
#

or will you just be giga "over saturated" at a certain point

#

right

balmy condor
#

we don't "stop", but we do change the time to death because of it

#

so if you're saturated, you wouldn't rupture with like 5 seconds left

hollow river
#

right

balmy condor
#

but on something like sire

#

where you aren't

#

you would hit the add with a rupture

hollow river
#

hmm

#

was playing around with 4 targets

#

keeping all bleeds up

balmy condor
#

mhm

hollow river
#

and i could actually utilize every GCD

#

felt nice

#

think we will be able to run EP deeper in m+?

#

possibly

#

9.1 ofc

balmy condor
#

you already kinda can

#

it's very close

hollow river
#

really

#

my only worry would be ST

balmy condor
#

well the worry should be the lack of energy to work with

#

cleave/aoe openers are really awkward and sketch

hollow river
#

i need to mess with more out of the box thinking sims tinfoil_pepe

#

yeah true

sand sigil
#

jw, but on st i keep hearing ppl telling me vigor + EP is strictly better if u know how to "pool properly", even tho ds/bs clearly sims better by a notable amt... do the ppl telling me this just not have good enough gear so their ep + vigor just happens to sim higher for them? like every time i run deeper + blindside ppl always ask why and i'm like well it's a clear dps increase so why wouldn't i?

hollow river
#

the ramp up would be even slower

#

well yeah everyone sims different

balmy condor
#

so there's that

hollow river
#

for a lot of people BS DS is only like 20dps gain

balmy condor
#

yeah it's quite close

fleet anchor
#

jw, but on st i keep hearing ppl telling me vigor + EP is strictly better if u know how to "pool properly"
I don't really see how it's anything other than a numbers game. Vigor + EP vs. Deeper + Blindside is a pure numbers game

#

And it's very close

hollow river
#

and it highly depends on how well you play with either

sand sigil
#

idk mine simmed 0.6% more. but ppl saying there's some 'pooling magic' to outplay the 0.6% lol

balmy condor
#

there is not

sand sigil
#

like u telling me if i pool energy all the sudden ep + vigor just catches up 0.6%? idk i don't think so so i just have played ds/bs

balmy condor
#

sims naturally pool

sand sigil
#

ok ok

balmy condor
#

so it's already accounted for

sand sigil
#

yeah idk everyone always says play vigor and it just clearly sims worse if u have bis gear so idk was confusing for me for a while

#

just gotta make sure i get all the bases covered going into 9.1 lol

#

it's sin tier baby

hollow river
#

9.1 may change things

sand sigil
#

yeah for sure

hollow river
#

but for the beginning i think we go with what we know now

#

until at least after heroic week i would assume

balmy condor
#

but you're probably staying necro for m+

hollow river
balmy condor
#

so that's kinda doomed

hollow river
#

and cleave fights

sand sigil
#

well if venth sub was like notably better on the last bosses or something i wouldn't mind

balmy condor
#

yeh

dawn ivy
#

is sub REALLY a potential though pepechortle

balmy condor
#

sub venth is like 100 ahead in single target, and also wins against sin/law on 5+ target I think

sand sigil
#

but like idk the only true st fights are tarragrue and guardians

balmy condor
#

maybe 6 target

hollow river
#

against law?

balmy condor
#

but the cleave on sub

sand sigil
#

all the rest like 2/3t cleave or st + adds for like 10-20% of the fight

hollow river
#

oh shit

balmy condor
#

just blows

#

so hard

hollow river
#

yep

#

won't be required for raiding

#

i mean

balmy condor
#

sure it will

#

it's competitive

hollow river
#

won't be necessary

balmy condor
#

it just probably won't be the best option

hollow river
#

yeh

#

i misworded there

cobalt pelican
#

would see good play if you didn't need to commit in advance to play it smile

sand sigil
#

i mean if it's better execute than sin then u could definitely make an argument for it on the phylactery team on kt and sylvanas p3 but

#

idk i haven't heard anything abt sub being better st than sin execute

balmy condor
#

sin execute is stonks

#

not happening

soft shale
#

yea zold is really strong and also works with sbs

hollow river
#

whispyr

#

sub>outlaw aoe?

#

o.o

balmy condor
#

on higher target counts yeah

#

easily

soft shale
#

only on 6+ targets yea

hollow river
#

fuck yeah

balmy condor
#

is it 6?

#

even on 5?

soft shale
#

idk about 5

hollow river
#

it looked potential on 5

soft shale
#

seems dicey

hollow river
#

what does law do on 5?

soft shale
#

although with new dagger who knows

#

sub goes do 16% more dmg on its procs

hollow river
#

ryfie was doing 20k on 5

sand sigil
#

does sub 8 beat sin 8?

balmy condor
#

not even a competition

hollow river
#

sub has no ramp up

fleet anchor
#

I think the only fight people regularly use EP+Vigor on right now is Sludgefist

sand sigil
#

i think sub would be sick in halls then

#

all the rest of the dungeons ud wanna outlaw probably

soft shale
#

yea well lets just say on tornado pulls you do around 40k dps

fleet anchor
#

And even then I'm not totally convinced that's not just kinda placebo lol

soft shale
#

for around like 10 secs

hollow river
#

halls..mists...DoS...

sand sigil
#

not mists

cobalt pelican
#

i use it on a lot but i won't argue it's for any reason other my ui half breaking when i play ds atm hehe

soft shale
#

the trick is just to keep track of fws and just move a lot

sand sigil
#

mists outlaw would destroy sub

balmy condor
soft shale
#

like a crazy chickeen

sand sigil
#

dos only an argument if hakkar is so easy it doesn't matter

soft shale
#

mists i would pick sub just because of first boss

sand sigil
#

and u skip all of mechagon ofc

soft shale
#

but if that is not important nono

#

maybe on tyr weeks but even then

sand sigil
#

sin and sub gain additional value over outlaw w seasonal affix tho

hollow river
#

yeah i mean it might not be super viable is +22s and such

sand sigil
#

16% crit goes a long way on sub and sin

hollow river
#

outlaw uses crit too doesn't it

soft shale
#

who knows right now but it seems cool all specs have their dungeon more or less

hollow river
#

yup

sand sigil
#

i mean like disproportionate gains

soft shale
#

right now i only see sub 100% on hoa

sand sigil
#

outlaw just gains bte dam which doesn't even flurry properly

hollow river
#

gonna be nice being able to fiddle with sub without getting ejected from the +14

fleet anchor
soft shale
#

but with 9.1 sin and sub are stonking

#

sadly im not into assa that much to know where it would pop off

sand sigil
#

honestly just halls or dos imo

hollow river
#

ToP and SoA for sure

soft shale
#

sub on DoS makes sense

sand sigil
#

soa has an argument if u have bad routing i guess

#

and go left

hollow river
#

i mean for sin

sand sigil
#

for sin yeah

hollow river
#

ye

sand sigil
#

but no top

#

that's outlaw bread and butter

hollow river
#

wut?

sand sigil
#

every pull like 4 targets

#

maybe sin on tyrannical top

balmy condor
sand sigil
#

also top is so annoying w no gouge

hollow river
#

idk what each spec is pulling in each dungeon atm so

soft shale
#

depends if bear tank continues being immortal

#

many dungeons are gonna get big as f pulls

#

but then you also will have cuck weeks for doing dungeons in general

sand sigil
#

yeah we only playing rogue in maybe 3 or 4 dungeons next patch

soft shale
#

rogue seems fine on HoA mists and what else

sand sigil
#

i mean

#

fine for a 26 sure

#

not fine for a 28

soft shale
#

you mean surv or dam

sand sigil
#

mostly dam

#

frost fire ele going to pump way more than any rogue spec

soft shale
#

that is sad then because sp and mage are only getting stronger

#

yea forgot ele too

hollow river
#

ranged meta

soft shale
#

well sub is also kind of not target capped but even then

#

earthquake is just so good apart from damage

#

and they also heal etc

#

rogue has blind and gouge if outlaw

#

and thats it

gloomy knoll
#

@sand sigil doesn't plume proc disproportionately on classes that do less dam than those that do to somewhat ease out the damage disparity between specs

#

from my testing it seemed like it procced 24/7 365 for outlaw and almost not at all for the fire mages

#

same with venth paladins for instance they got almost nothing from it

hollow river
#

i don't see them tuning each anima power proportionate to each spec

gloomy knoll
#

i remember reading somewhere that, that was one of the points of plume

#

to help with the damage disparities

hollow river
#

hmm

gloomy knoll
#

testing seems to back this up as well but i haven't done it extensively

#

only like 3-4 keys

cobalt pelican
#

sounds very made up

gloomy knoll
#

i would hope not

#

that'd be a pog change

#

make more specs viable

#

end hpal domination

cobalt pelican
#

an affix that deals flat% dmg propping up your spec is barely 1 toenail above doing nothing

hollow river
#

rofl

gloomy knoll
#

i mean if you can't clear above a certain key lvl with say

#

rdruid for instance

hollow river
#

why wouldn't they just do more lazy aura buffs? lul

gloomy knoll
#

because you just lose 4k dps in the key

#

this would remediate that problem without the need for major balance changes

#

i hope i wasn't misled and this is actually a thing

fleet anchor
#

I thought plume was just straight RPPM?

gloomy knoll
#

it could be i might just be wrong

fleet anchor
#

When I last looked at the spell data it appeared to be

#

Like straight non-hasted vanilla RPPM

cobalt pelican
#

ya, just 4

fleet anchor
#

So shouldn't really matter what the spec is at all, other than odd generic multipliers like Celerity

#

or Guile Charm

gloomy knoll
#

huh

#

might've just been confirmation bias from people i knows testing then

#

sadge

winged basin
#

you think it would be worth to run double on use? I have a 226 Shadowgrasp and a 220 dreadfire, but I have been using Hateful chain 213 and shadowgrasp

#

feel like its gonna feel really rough lmfao

soft shale
#

if its sims more its k

winged basin
#

true simself

sand sigil
#

nobody takes plume

dawn ivy
#

all my homies hate plume

winged basin
#

thank the lord, sims said I get to keep using chain shadowgrasp

#

no double on use

gloomy knoll
balmy condor
#

yeah

#

it's giga nerfed

#

ryfie was complaining about it too

hollow river
#

oh you didn't know that

#

it went from like 15-20% of your dps to like 2-3%

gloomy knoll
#

sadge

#

plume was fun

#

why blizzard always gotta ruin fun

#

necrotic revert plume nerfed deathspike gutted

sand sigil
#

ya now u just pick the 8% stat stick

gloomy knoll
#

all my homes for next season deterred just as soon as they arrived besad

#

*hopes

hollow river
#

:/

balmy condor
#

it's prideful but you get to choose stats instead of just getting them

gloomy knoll
balmy condor
#

the kind of iteration we like to see

hollow river
#

echoing bring back the real mvp spell

gloomy knoll
#

at least sub aoe got buffed

#

i'd rather die than play kyrian

#

miss me with tht shit

hollow river
#

pvp sub rogues going back kyrian

gloomy knoll
#

good thing i don't care

hollow river
gloomy knoll
#

kyrian could be bis for every rogue spec not touching that shit covenant with a 10 foot pole lol

balmy condor
gloomy knoll
#

i'll reroll another class before i play kyrian

hollow river
balmy condor
#

are they actually

#

going kyrian

hollow river
#

yes

#

some are

balmy condor
#

that sounds not great

hollow river
#

for the leggo

balmy condor
#

what

hollow river
#

jep

balmy condor
#

the lego seems so bad in pvp tho

hollow river
#

well

#

since they got nerfed so hard in pvp

#

they think the easier special CP hit

#

with evis

dawn ivy
#

wouldnt venthyr/obedience be nuts burst for pvp

hollow river
#

will be better

gloomy knoll
#

imagine nerfing a bad spec kekw

balmy condor
#

that's so fried

#

honestly

hollow river
#

jep

gloomy knoll
#

meanwhile dk got so many buffs i'm never stepping in another arena again

hollow river
#

well necro and venth for sub are kinda crap so is NF

#

its all crap tbh

gloomy knoll
#

venth is burst

balmy condor
#

fried pvp brains feelycrafting their way into kyrian jank

#

venth is great

#

what

#

venth damage is huge

hollow river
#

for pvp

gloomy knoll
#

obedience also gives hella vers

#

which is pog in pvp

hollow river
#

meh

balmy condor
#

venth will do more damage in pvp

#

than kyrian

#

and it's also burst

#

and easier to use

drifting cloud
#

I like turtles

balmy condor
#

and gives stats

#

like I can understand if they were like "oh but the kyrian pot"

#

sure

#

whatever

#

but for damage reasons?

#

lmao

#

no

gloomy knoll
hollow river
#

🤷‍♂️

gloomy knoll
#

just like lying in a ditch on some island kek

#

*giant tortoise

modern heart
#

my spiritanimal

urban grail
#

if using CT this week, where do you put it in the opener using subterfuge/elaborate?

balmy condor
#

after shiv

urban grail
#

then go into mutilate/ envenoms

#

?

balmy condor
#

you would do like gar (snd if you have to), mut rup vend shiv mut+env spam, then CT after

mortal pike
#

How we feeling about assa bois?

vestal wren
#

good

drifting cloud
#

about the same as last week

fallen arch
#

Fucking great

pallid hollow
#

Venthyr still looking to be BiS for raids in 9.1? Currently trying to decide between rogue and monk for raiding. Really don’t want to play DK but if I don’t make a choice that’s what guilds going to ask me to do D:

balmy condor
#

If you’re gonna play sub venth is good

#

If you’re gonna play sin/outlaw, probably should go necro

pallid hollow
#

Yeah sin for raid outlaw for m+ is what I was feeling.

balmy condor
#

Necro for sure

pallid hollow
#

Played paladin this tier and while fun the numbers just aren’t there basically

#

Can get the same numbers from classes 15 ilv lower

drifting cloud
#

uhm

#

what

brazen rampart
pallid hollow
#

At 210 on my DK, ele sham and hunter I can get the same numbers or near enough as I get at 220/225 as paladin outside of last 3. Not tried other classes in raid that much but looking to swap as we already have 3 paladin mains (daft I know).

drifting cloud
#

I mean sure nothing wrong with rerolling but ret really isnt that bad

#

its still better than like half the melee specs

pallid hollow
#

Yeah just cba with the situation I had half of this tier with messing with conduits every other day and being able to only do m+ as prot on certain days as you ran out of conduit energy.

sharp echo
#

Would it be safe to start farming necro renown as of now?

dawn ivy
#

yes

balmy condor
#

Yep

vestal wren
#

having necro/venthyr on max renown is a good preperation

torpid sparrow
#

so i just noticed with the new socket i got doomhand on gloves and zoldyck on boots, i m fucked and got to recraft both? xD

hollow escarp
#

we still have some time to see if they change or adapt anything

#

and you will probably want a rank 5 legendary or even 6 in a few weeks after patch so they might implement something about it

#

if not, worst case scenario is that there is still time to farm soul ash to recraft everything

forest delta
#

maybe they give the option to account bound trade soul ash from other characters

pallid hollow
#

Literally in 9.1 in the same way you got packages of war resources in bfa

mortal pike
#

Are there any updated numbers from more recent 😮 ?

balmy condor
dawn ivy
#

isnt there a list of all the sim updates?

balmy condor
#

There’s a document

#

But it’s not really updated that often

final sky
#

is it worth getting my lego now? (zoldyck) or wait until 9.1

north basin
#

how long would it take for 9/9 campaign completion for necro if i rerrol ?

final sky
#

i did it in 2 days as an ilvl 170

pallid hollow
#

3/4 hours

#

But depends on renown drops too

north basin
#

fine. so right now 90% of raid orientated players going or already necro?

balmy condor
#

Pretty much

pallid hollow
#

Campaign is 3/4 hours.

Spam heroics to 20 renown apparently then go campaign

north basin
#

ok so i will too, if its mistake at least everyone failed xD

pallid hollow
#

BiS for outlaw m+ and then decent for raid too as sin so can’t see the downside!

north basin
#

ye i just remember faye --> venthyr hype back then. but it didnt last long

pallid hollow
#

Flagellation just feels bad to@press

#

Same as sepsis

north basin
#

agree

#

hope blizz wont switch tides after first heroic week and give some enormous buff to some other cov,

cobalt hemlock
#

!guide

tame cypress
#

SbS works with Assa Passives ? like mastery and VW

quasi grotto
#

So is necro the go to now for 9.1?

#

Is there any sims available yet

#

I normally play sub for m+ perhaps it's time I practice sin in m+

teal bloom
#

Mastery affects sbs but venomous wounds only works with garrote and rupture (and kidney shot if you are using internal bleeding)

#

Necro looks great but sims for covenants aren't ready yet as far as I know

rustic thunder
#

lmao the 235 legendary leggins go for 150k on my realm wtf tinfoil_pepe

rustic thunder
north basin
#

u just do content. lfr raids m+ etc. and u will gain it fast. thats all

timid grotto
#

is there any point staying venthyr for 9.1?

strange python
#

if u play sub

timid grotto
#

damn, is there any point on upgrading zoldyck to 235 with the new deathspike lego?

lean coral
#

what slot do you have it on

timid grotto
#

legs

#

only on 190 tho

lean coral
#

ash is easier to get alot of next patch

#

so you can make it if you want

#

most people are remaking their doomblades first afaik

#

and you dont get the deathspike leggo right away so you have time to get ash for when you do get it

vocal karma
#

Is it yet known when and how we are getting the deathspike leggo?

lean coral
#

renown reward

timid grotto
#

yeah im still waiting to get my stone legion shoulders before i remake doomblade

lean coral
#

i mean dont bother remaking till 9.1

#

gotta toss it on a cloak

timid grotto
#

you can craft it on cloak tho

lean coral
#

not till 9.1

timid grotto
#

oh they are adding slots or making it so u can craft any lego on any piece?

lean coral
#

its only craftable on gloves shoulders rn

#

cloak is being added as an option in 9.1

timid grotto
#

ok cool thx man

ornate raptor
#

Could venthyr be viable for sin in 9.1? Or is it so far necro all the way? I mean things could still change right?

final sky
#

should I get my Lego now or wait until 9.1

tulip nacelle
#

depends on what lego

#

doomblade will go on cloak when 9.1 comes for example

final sky
#

zoldyck

tulip nacelle
#

zoldyck should be fine on pants

final sky
#

but I don't even have a Lego rn and I'm doing around 3.6-4k average dps

umbral rapids
#

@balmy condor was it venthyr in 9.0.5 or are you guys already necro ? PepeSus

vestal wren
#

venthyr was hyped at the start of 9.0.5

umbral rapids
#

yeah i didn't really stay up to date on sin stuff since then

vestal wren
#

but people got convinced that necro is better because its not significant behind on st while offering strong cleave/multi target

#

so now people assume that necro is the best choice

umbral rapids
#

you say "assume" because it's the wrong choice according to you or ?

#

or just "it depends"

vestal wren
#

i say assume because it highly depends on what content you do

umbral rapids
#

yeah thought so

vestal wren
#

and if you want to play multiple specs

#

i can go a bit more in detail, if you want

umbral rapids
#

ye i'm down i'm interested

#

i main outlaw i'm already necro, i was somewhat surprised to see that sin was necro as well

#

since sbs counts as a bleed i assume doomblade still does good stuff on it, along with mastery, energy regen etc

indigo mulch
#

It does not count towards energy regen.

umbral rapids
#

oh it doesn't ?

indigo mulch
#

Only rupture and garrote does that.

umbral rapids
#

oh ok

ornate raptor
#

I will see what i will do. Right now i am happy in venthyr still

vestal wren
#

venthyr is in pure single target the highest output for all 3 specs.

Subtlety benefits the most from it because it can get full efficiency from Flag and the new covenant legendary will give it another damage push. Outlaw and assassination both already have very strong legendary items and can't utilize flag to the same extend this means they mainly gain a slight boost from the covenant conduit.

Outlaw and Assassination can get a big damage boost in multi target and aoe due to how sbs works with BF/mastery and how well the additional cp gain synergizes with the spec.
Given that the potency conduit is the main power diffrence both of them are not significantly behind in pure single target (only ~100-200 dps) but gain more in cleave/aoe.
Subtlety on the other hand does not benefit a lot from the additional cp income from necrolord and necrolord
isn't giving significant uplifts in aoe outside of sustained cleave besides losing the damage gain from the legendary and conduit (~4-5% dps).

Kyrian could end up as a very strong pvp choice, and isn't terrible in raid but probably won't be played outside of pvp (and also only in pvp if it becomes meta)

indigo mulch
# vestal wren but people got convinced that necro is better because its not significant behind...

I mean, when you say that its just slightly behind in ST but overtakes in multi target scenarios. Dosent that mean based on how CN currently looks like that it would be better? Correct me if i'm wrong though. Overall necrolords just looks better than what venthyr does. Not to mention if your focus is raiding your most likley doing m+ aswell to gear even if your not pushing high keys.

Yes, you can do keys as any covenant, but if you want best of both worlds necro is the way to go, specially if you run outlaw as offspec in m+.
Personally i don't bother going outlaw for m+ anymore. I only do between 15 and 20 keys never anything higher. Venthyr is fine in those keys aswell. Necro does a bit more damage but you can still run venthyr without any issues as assassination in m+.

Or is that just community perception playing tricks on my eyes?

vestal wren
#

we talk about 9.1

#

so its not related to cn

indigo mulch
#

I mean there are way more multi targets fights than there are pure sustained single target.

warm parcel
#

Question is how much do you value damage to nonbosses

vestal wren
#

it depends

warm parcel
#

If the value is 0, any gain necro gets is also 0

vestal wren
#

having adds on a fight does not mean you want to do damage to them

umbral rapids
#

Thanks mate that makes sense

indigo mulch
#

No, thats true but you can "kinda" funnel a target as assassination.

warm parcel
#

you can do that regardless of your covenant, but yes

vestal wren
#

it comes down to where your raid team needs the damage, necrolord is the convenient pick because its "always good"
if its the best pick rly depends on the fight design

warm parcel
#

Necro absolutely is more flexible and nice to play

#

But ven still offers something different

vestal wren
#

^ this

umbral rapids
#

Itns potentially free cp for your prio target with sbs ?

vestal wren
#

the flexibility of necro is why everyone plays it

indigo mulch
#

Agreed.

vestal wren
#

it feels better to have options for other parts than feeling restricted by your choice

umbral rapids
#

Makes sense

warm parcel
#

Theres no extra cp to be had when sludge crashes into a pillar

#

Nor is there extra funnel to be had when you go down KT phyl

umbral rapids
#

I meant on non boss enemies

warm parcel
#

Youre just there with your spike vs flag

indigo mulch
#

Dosent that make it overall the best then? Or i'm i out swimming in the theorysea?

umbral rapids
warm parcel
#

again we go back

#

what do you value

#

do you want overall

vestal wren
#

also necrolod is gameplay wise very good, it boosts your action economy and somewhat makes the spec feel less "slow"

warm parcel
#

or are you there for your job

umbral rapids
#

Ok I just had no idea what sin played :p

indigo mulch
#

I mean everyone has a job in mythic.

umbral rapids
#

Thanks @vestal wren that was very nicely explained :) makes a lot of sense

indigo mulch
#

Fuu is bae.

umbral rapids
#

Fax

#

Don’t tell whispyr i said that

indigo mulch
#

He will never know.

warm parcel
#

everyone does have their job in M

indigo mulch
#

kekw

umbral rapids
#

:p

warm parcel
#

and if I were looking for a comp for KT I wouldnt want a necro rogue

#

Id much rather take ven for phyl

dusk basalt
#

doomblade, what stats do we craft? haste/crit

warm parcel
#

Cause it has flag necro doesnt

vestal wren
#

i mean if we strictly speak of funnel, subtlety esp. with tornado is probably hard to beat

warm parcel
#

if I want the adds to be killed upstairs, Ill just take a boomy and few destro locks

#

its their job, not the rogues

indigo mulch
#

How much ahead is venthyr on ST compared to Necro bois though?

vestal wren
#

i think its vital to have differences on opinions there

#

every raid team differs and you need to decide yourself what your raid team needs

warm parcel
#

it doesnt even have to be ahead

#

it offers a different profile

indigo mulch
#

True.

vestal wren
#

or you can discuss it with your officers and make them part of the process

warm parcel
#

you have 40 seconds to kill the shade

#

flag makes you pump

#

you get to dish out the needed burst when you want to

modern heart
#

monkaHmm well I am a big pumper monkaHmm

vestal wren
#

the burst potential of flag is def. higher

#

but its possible that kyrian beats it

#

thats why kyrian could be relevant in pvp

dusk basalt
#

do i craft doomblades on gloves with crit/haste?

indigo mulch
#

But if you want burst single target you don't really bring rogues do you?

subtle kiln
warm parcel
#

Have you been in the phylactory on KT encounter

#

It very much suits rogue

dusk basalt
#

okay so i should just hold off till then?

subtle kiln
#

can you craft it on cloak now?

#

no

#

so hold off

north basin
#

just swapped to necro 10 mins ago, well on dummy it feels much better. u have this additional /once per 30 sec/ button which smooths out whole assa rotation u just press it and it gives cp, nice nice

indigo mulch
#

Its actually once per min. 😮

#

If you have gem.

vestal wren
#

oh yes, something worth mentioning is that we probably want to re-craft legendary items in 9.1 due to slots

indigo mulch
#

Cloakbois

#

I wish we could have gotten doom on ring though.

#

Its hard finding good rings 😢

dusk basalt
#

how about zoldycks for M+? is new slot best?

indigo mulch
#

still pants.