#assassination

1 messages · Page 3833 of 1

prisma monolithBOT
pliant apex
#

is there a classic wa i can get for assa, like that shows rupture , garrote cd and all?

#

i had it and then with pre patch it wouldnt work

#

and luxithos' wa dont have those

royal lantern
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
royal lantern
#

afenars works great

pliant apex
#

omg why do they have icons when not in combat

#

like the wa is always on my screen

#

my older one used to only display once in combat

dry atlas
#

you can change that yourself

pliant apex
#

how ? please tell

#

can i do it to afenars ?

dry atlas
#

change the conditions

royal lantern
#

/wa->click on it->load->set too in combat

#

@pliant apex

pliant apex
#

ok hold on let me try please

dry atlas
pliant apex
#

ty for being so helpful

wary ice
#

have yall still been running 3x eb in keys? i cant figure out if i like it or not. i feel like the list of dungeons its less good othan stats in has increased - tanks are pulling much smaller lately in pugs in my experience

balmy condor
#

Yep

#

3ss 3eb

civic hatch
#

@civic hatch make sure you report it has to be a bug because its only the combo of EP and Subterfuge that breaks it. You can use any other combo and it doesn't break stealth. Hopefully if more people report it it'll be fixed.
@marble ruin Ye thanks for the reminder, reported it now

balmy condor
#

Ye it’s been a bug on beta for like a month now too

#

they’ll fix it at some point

pliant apex
#

what chnages rotation wise with slice and dice, mut , rupture if 4, mut, garrote and then slice and dice?

#

?

balmy condor
#

Slice, rupture, envenom

#

In terms of finishers

pliant apex
#

ahh slice takes precedence over rupture now?

balmy condor
#

Yes

pliant apex
#

but the opener with 4 mut will still be rupture?

#

or s and d?

balmy condor
#

The opener with 4 mut?

#

The opener changes based on subt/ma and azerite traits

pliant apex
#

i mean ma

balmy condor
#

Ma no SS is mut slice Mut

pliant apex
#

ohhh

#

and then garrote and rupture?

balmy condor
#

Yeah

#

Garrote rupture vendetta vanish mut env mut env

#

Etc etc

pliant apex
#

dam slice changes everything eh

balmy condor
#

Does it?

#

You just cast it at the start, and everything else is the same that it’s been forever

pliant apex
#

but i keep casting it whenever its about to go

#

over rupture

#

thatll take some getting used to

balmy condor
#

Yeah, the pandemic time is like 10 seconds

#

So it’s mega easy

#

Should be enough time to cast whatever you want in any order

#

Just get yourself a weakaura that tracks it all

#

Ez pz chillington

pliant apex
#

thanks really helpful whisp

#

i copied all of what you said

#

youre so right, once opener is done with cd's , it dont matter what order you refresh in , as long as you do eh

#

just gota keep looking at wa

balmy condor
pliant apex
#

oh thats your own wa?

balmy condor
#

Yup

#

Got pandemics on everything

#

If it’s green, you’re good to go, if garrote’s orange, it’s empowered, don’t touch it

pliant apex
#

wow getting it now bud

#

thanks so much

balmy condor
#

Np, it’s not everyone’s cup of tea, but if it works for me, might work for someone else right :)

#

I think there’s a glow effect on snd though, that shouldn’t be there, might have to update

pliant apex
#

you must be like a top player, orange parses and stuff eh?

balmy condor
#

Nah

#

I’m just a nerd

#

There’s plenty of rogues in here that wipe the floor with me, nairda and hemo and ryler and rae, mata, stunkei, tyra

#

Countless great rogues, I ain’t one of those xD

pliant apex
#

but you must have prange.purple parses ?

#

im sure

paper hatch
#

@balmy condor I was referring to the 60 energy you gain over 3 seconds from using vendetta, and if I used Vendetta after having slice and dice up I would utilize the entire Vendetta Window efficiently

#

from my message yesterday

balmy condor
#

I don’t remember the full context I’m sorry

#

But the 60 energy would be there regardless of when you cast stuff

#

Casting vendetta after having everything up is just more damage in an increased damage window

#

@pliant apex I’m a purple boy yeah xD maybe the odd orange sometimes. I raid pretty casually honestly. I have a guild where I made my best friends and I would rather play with them than be a top 100 raider

#

I still do mythic, I’m just not big

gentle locust
#

if you could ask for one buff for assassination, what would that be ?

rough agate
#

A insta kill button

nimble tartan
#

kingsbane back

main warren
#

increase mutilates damage by a factor of 10 and remove it from gcd

fleet whale
#

to buff ST: add this interaction for both mut and ambush

#

when you use mutilate/ambush while envenom buff is up, you deal additional damage as poison damage

#

buff envenom slightly

#

This will act both as a buff for assassin

#

while also being a little more rewarding for better envenom pooling

verbal knot
#

Hey guys,does anyone know if the assasination rogue hidden artifact appereance is still obtainable?

drifting cloud
#

it is

balmy condor
#

all the hidden ones are still obtainable

#

mage tower isn't

verbal knot
#

Thanks,does the artifact weapon still need to be rank 4 on artifact power in order to get it?

balmy condor
drifting cloud
#

it was artifact research, those things arent in the game anymore 😛

#

so you can get it as soon as you have the artifact

verbal knot
#

Oh alright then

#

Thanks a lot!

fleet whale
#

yeah, for the assassin one you just need to farm rares in the dalaran underbelly (Legion) and it will drop

#

sub is the Throne of Thunder trove scenario thing

#

and outlaw is combining two low drop rate items from Nelth's lair and vault of the wardens

grizzled jay
#

or 2nd and 3rd clears if you're me

verbal knot
#

Thanks for the helpful info,appreciate it.

fleet whale
#

for the trove scenario, it's been awhile but i think there is a perk in the rogue order hall tree

#

that makes Marin Noggenflogger, the goblin, give you something daily, and one of the things you can get are keys

inland lintel
#

Any mythic raiders here who main rogue

balmy condor
#

none whatsoever

inland lintel
#

I've seen your name before

balmy condor
#

Blush at least take me out to dinner first, I'm very shy

vital haven
#

ill take you out to dinner

balmy condor
#

nairda bb you don't need to take me out to dinner to get some ;)

vital haven
#

❤️

fleet whale
#

so i just traveled time

#

as soon as my clock hit 2 AM... it back to 1 AM!

#

(Yes i know it's daylights savings)

low girder
#

i wasn't watching and wasn't sure if things had flipped back or not yet

#

lol

earnest nimbus
#

Anyone know the deadly poison ***debuff ***spell id offhand? Trying to add it to nameplate aura tracking and no luck so far

balmy condor
#

2823

#

and if that doesn't work

#

uhhhh

#

2818?

earnest nimbus
#

Seems to be the spell id of the buff itself

#

okay awesome I'll try that one as well 🙂

#

Yep, 2818 is the one. Thanks Whispyr! 🙂

balmy condor
#

no problemo

earnest nimbus
#

tangential deadly poison question, actually. Tooltip says 12 second duration. Debuff on target is showing as 15 seconds when applied.

Scanning talents I can't find anything that augments that. Guessing its just a tooltip error?

balmy condor
#

12 second with a pandemic of 3.6 seconds is 15

earnest nimbus
#

AH! its being double applied so quickly when I initially attack the target. Got it. Thanks!

balmy condor
#

yup

#

np

earnest nimbus
#

was trying to sort pandemic timers at 15 sec rather than 12. Cheers!

balmy condor
#

also worth noting mutilate can apply twice

#

since its both hands

proper basin
#

Is sharpened blades still a thing?

#

im getting this buff everytime I autoattack

#

Is this a known bug or something?

royal lantern
#

allright,i never seen THAT lmao

#

must be a bug

dark crag
#

Reequip your azerites maybe you have a bugged piece

snow forge
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
pliant apex
#

rotation wise, will the covenant ability simply fit neatly at the same spot as current button for neck does?

#

and in the same rotation priority? or not going to be this straight forward/

grizzled jay
#

I am putting it on the same button, yes. And Covenant ability will pretty much always have highest prio when it is up (with some exceptions).

royal lantern
#

f1 essence/covenant ability gang o/

grizzled jay
#

I use C

#

For Azerite EssenCe and Covenant Ability

nimble tartan
#

i use 7 🙂

real bay
#

gigahands

grave monolith
#

!guide

prisma monolithBOT
fleet whale
#

i know this sounds noobish but i've actually never used WA's before. Which WA has SND in it? I've tried Miz's but it doesn't track snd

balmy condor
#

dunno

#

I think afenar updated his

#

I know mine does

#

miz isn't updating his wa's till sl

grizzled jay
#

my personal one tracks SnD

#

ive been lazy about making better WAs

#

i need to update my RtB one

hearty basin
grizzled jay
#

i have a scuffed setup where i write a suite independently for each spec lol

hearty basin
#

but why?^^

grizzled jay
#

cause

bright path
#

Luxthos’ wa are the best and more polished

peak jungle
#

I've seen countless videos on outlaw and sub rogues and how they feel in the beta, but I've seen far and few for assassination. Are we still looking a bit weaker out of the three in terms of raw numbers?

balmy condor
#

yes

#

~10%

#

also sin didn't have any legendaries doubling their dps in beta like sub, so not hype

#

and didn't receive anything really new

#

so not hype

#

and not hype = no videos

fathom swift
#

It also feels a lot slower to play cause no haste at start of expac and slice n dice isnt that fun to use for assa

balmy condor
#

yeh

#

its back to boring residentsleeper sin

peak jungle
#

I'm really hoping that we get the old ability we had in.. MoP? WoD? Where envenom refreshes SnD. Having to juggle like 6 different up times is not fun

balmy condor
#

and no one gives a rats ass(assination) about that

#

snd doesn't really change things that much, at least imo

#

people keep doom and glooming how shit snd is for sin and how it feels bad and its so much juggling and oh my god the uptimes

#

but like

#

its got such a long duration

#

I personally don't see it as a problem tbh

peak jungle
#

I see not SnD as the issue, rather being energy starved due to early in expansion with so many things to juggle

fathom swift
#

The thing i dont like about it is having to spend most of your finishers on maintenance buffs/debuffs

fleet whale
#

blindside helps a bit with apm

#

but it should be baseline imo

fathom swift
#

Its not like awful tho its just like slightly worse than before imo

balmy condor
#

you cast snd like 8 times in a 5 minute fight

fleet whale
#

the only issue i have with snd is the opener

#

other than that i don't mind it that much

balmy condor
#

if those 8 casts are what you hate

#

then so be it

fleet whale
#

there are also the awkward moments

balmy condor
#

but to me

fleet whale
#

where you need to refresh both snd and rupture in a shiv window

balmy condor
#

that's fucking silly

fathom swift
#

Yeah i didnt like playing inq on ret for the same reason

balmy condor
#

snd pandemic is longer than a shiv window

peak jungle
#

My last question - are you guys planning to stick it out as assassin and hope that it just 'gets better' or are you planning to respec?

balmy condor
#

unless it stays this bad, I'm playing sin

#

its numerically behind, but aside from that, its the same good ol sin that it has been for like 4 expansions

fathom swift
#

Personally no ill play whatever spec is best for the boss

strange python
#

I find sin hard to enjoy at the start of xpacs because of how slowly it plays. Later on though it always becomes a super fun spec for me as it speeds up.

shadow tulip
#

That's fair

fleet whale
#

it's either frost DK or rogue for me in SL

balmy condor
#

yeh, everyone has their own likes and dislikes

fleet whale
#

probably will level both

balmy condor
#

sin rogue is one of those niches

#

completely understandable that 40apm is too slow for people

peak jungle
#

Boomer spec

fleet whale
#

people always say that

shadow tulip
fleet whale
#

yet i've seen too many bad sin rogues to count

strange python
#

^

balmy condor
#

there's bad players in every spec

strange python
#

lol funniest shit ever when someone complains about it being so slow and still screw it up

balmy condor
#

that's not really a sin only thing

strange python
#

like druids that need to stand in one spot to heal

fleet whale
#

I find BM hard to screw up tbh

shadow tulip
#

I could screw it up

#

Coz' I just hate it

#

I don't like hunters

dry atlas
#

even MM is hard to screw up as

fleet whale
#

MM is broken right now

dry atlas
#

mm should always be better than bm as its more demanding even if just a little bit

#

theres too much damage in pets

shadow tulip
#

SHOULD

fleet whale
#

i mean if you're talking pvp at this moment

#

MM is just rapid fire and aimed shot, lol

ionic quartz
#

Honestly ill probs play sin and sub, between the two im sure it'll cover or be performant for most fights. I don't mind outlaw but something about it feels off in my hands. Always end up firing extra abilities when spamming keys if I pivot for a proc...not sure if its ability queuing or the animations or what.

strange python
#

!guide

prisma monolithBOT
strange python
#

I'll probably never let go of all the rogue specs until they let me mog a single 2 handed katana and fedora onto sub rogue, at which point I'll become a sub rogue loyalist

grizzled jay
#

isn't that Assassination Blade

#

oh nvm that's a sword

strange python
#

if they let us make the offhand "invisible" then for sure

#

but even "invisible" would have you punch randomly which looks dumb

#

then I just need to work out how to /say "nothing personnel kid" in the other factions language

delicate dagger
#

Is Kyrian still the move?

balmy condor
#

yes

inland lintel
#

Hello friends

#

How are all of you doing tonight

balmy condor
#

Fine, and you?

strange lichen
#

is there a reason why you would have your higher item level dagger in your OH? just seeing if i'm missing something lol

royal lantern
#

uhm

#

higher ilvl in OH is probably the worst thing you could do

dry atlas
#

no cause oh does less damage

strange lichen
#

this dude in my guild is running and i'm like wtf lol, just picked up

royal lantern
#

you always want the ilvl in your mainhand

#

cus of how skill dmg is calcualted

#

offhand is more or less a statstick

balmy condor
#

^

royal lantern
#

like

#

i could eq a random questing green dagger in my OH

#

and dps would not really go down by much

balmy condor
#

I think mythic cara to mythic wrath daggers main hand are about 1-1.3% difference

#

in offhand its like 0.5%

strange python
#

So basic gist, always put the higher ilvl in your mainhand and tell your guildy that they nub

balmy condor
#

yes

tropic ocean
#

So basic gist, always put the higher ilvl in your mainhand and tell your guildy that they nub
@strange python tell your guildies they are nub regardless 😁

shadow tulip
#

Any re-evaluation of covenants after the change?

vestal wren
#

pins should be up to date

shadow tulip
#

So Kyrian is still the way to go?

#

Didn't check how much they changed it

vestal wren
#

kyrian is the go to on 30+ reown (so on beta)

shadow tulip
#

Guess there will be an update before launch for that then?

vestal wren
#

i update the pins regularly

#

the aim of sl information is mainly to help you test things on beta, so there is no reason to talk about things that are relevant past release with this many changes every week

distant cypress
#

how much i would fuck up if i would go and pick up nightfae as sin rogue ?

strange lichen
#

!guides

prisma monolithBOT
vestal wren
#

how much i would fuck up if i would go and pick up nightfae as sin rogue ?
probably not a much early

distant cypress
#

so im looking at small loss early expansion wise and huge loss later on if nothing changes in covenant balance

#

god damn it

vestal wren
#

you can switch at any time

#

you are not hard locked to your covenant

distant cypress
#

thats true, its just i really dont like kyrian, like ugh

#

its like forcing horde player to be human

vestal wren
#

kyrian is probably not best before 30+ reown

#

so don't worry you might play bone spike early

distant cypress
#

thanks

fleet whale
#

also note that certain covenants give you certain perks depending on the dungeon

vestal wren
#

utility traits might matter

#

and ofc the non damage covenant ability

odd flax
#

compendium trinket BiS for m+?

shadow tulip
#

Scribe trinkets bis for many LUL

#

Int trinkets on rogues, warriors and hunters

#

And BTW, Nihal, I know you don't like Kyrian, but I personally prefer the feature some give instead of a few raw numbers

#

The potion will be handy to dispell in the raid

#

Just like that's the reason I played dward (dark iron ATM) for M+. Easy budget cloak was good

vestal wren
#

trinkets on beta are wild

pure spire
#

Hey guys, does Sepsis covenant ability work with assassinations mastery? New to rogue and trying to figure out which spec to play.

vestal wren
#

no

fleet whale
#

it doesn't work with assassin's mastery. However, shiv does buff up the dot

#

except for the final tick for some reason

vestal wren
#

thats a bug

fleet whale
#

that shiv is working with sepsis, or the final tick not working

honest rain
#

0 means random in the pins?

#

for talents

fleet whale
#

0 more or less means your choice in terms of talents on that row

#

they are utility rows

#

they don't influence dps

#

with that said, highly recommend Cheat Death when raiding/doing M+ if you are new to rogue

#

and leeching poison for WQs

balmy condor
#

the final tick not working is a bug

vestal wren
#

0 is for rows that have no dps talents

balmy condor
#

^

#

0 = pick your preference

#

or niche for utility

real inlet
#

is there anytime i'd rather use mutilate over ambush when ambush is available? if not i can make a macro and put them on the same button?

balmy condor
#

not right now

#

unless you're using blindside obviously

#

in shadowlands you would ambush in opener sometimes, and blindside is competitive

#

so you could macro them onto the same button

#

probably wouldn't be too big of a loss in the opener, even if it ends up being worse

real inlet
#

and when blindside procs it would just go back to ambush

balmy condor
#

yup

real inlet
#

i imagine it's the same for SS and ambush in outlaw?

balmy condor
#

probably

real inlet
#

sweet, ty

real inlet
#

well they way i thought i was going to make this macro work doesn't work. anyone know how to do that? cast ambush when stealthed OR have blindside buff, then cast mutilate any other time

balmy condor
#

you need gnome sequencer

opaque grotto
#

Macros don’t work with conditions like that

balmy condor
#

yup

opaque grotto
#

You can’t make it cast and ability if you have X buff

balmy condor
#

base game doesn't allow that

opaque grotto
#

An*

real inlet
#

i see, i have one in sub that goes from shadowstrike back to backstab when i shadow dance, but that works because it changes the bar right?

balmy condor
#

yes, that's a stance change

real inlet
#

gotcha

vague vapor
#

!guide

prisma monolithBOT
unborn root
#

There's no way to macro ambush and mut onto the same button for blindside procs, huh?

balmy condor
#

gnome sequencer allows it

#

but nothing in the base game, yes

slim briar
#

Anyone still playing elaborate planning?

low girder
#

you play EP in prepatch, so yes

fleet whale
#

can you use legion gems with BFA gear? I might get a saber's eye of agi

balmy condor
#

should be able to, yes

#

but I don't know if its worth it

fleet whale
#

tbh i just want to get it

#

cause im at 999 agi atm

#

just want to get to over 1000 lol

#

yeah not really worth the 4k gold since saber's eyes are expensive for some reason

#

would legit be like a 1.5 dps increase over a crit gem lol

marble magnet
#

Aside from Legion, Shaw using Garrote confirms him as a Sin rogue right?

fallow otter
#

When you talk about lore you might aswell be speaking mandarin

balmy condor
#

Shaw lore isn’t really spec discussion

fossil slate
#

I've not really been scrubbed up on rogue going into SL so apologies for the lazy question but am I right in thinking Sub is fairly ahead of Sin going into SL as it currently stands?

balmy condor
#

~10%

vestal wren
#

sub is 10-15% ahead of sin with current tuning

fossil slate
#

Fairs what's causing that with sin? Is it just mostly down to tuning at present then?

balmy condor
#

bad numbers ye

fossil slate
#

And thanks for always being there for answers fuu and whispyr 🥳

regal cloud
balmy condor
#

:) I mostly just regurgitate fuu's answers

vestal wren
#

assassination still beats sub in cleave even with the low tuning

fossil slate
#

I've spent like all beta learning Shadow priest then have moved back to rogue last minute so trying to brush up haha

#

assassination still beats sub in cleave even with the low tuning
@vestal wren
Oh that's interesting! Good to see

balmy condor
#

sub has awful cleave

#

its just rupture

#

and an aoe finisher

#

well

warm drift
#

dimishing stats are live on pre patch right? if yes when does crit dimish

balmy condor
#

"awful"

vestal wren
#

sub cleave is:

  • spreading fw on multiple targets
  • spreading rupture on multiple targets
  • higher cp gain
  • vault on 3+
balmy condor
#
warm drift
#

cool thank you 🙂

balmy condor
#

np

warm drift
#

would u ignore that for m+ and go full crit ? with 3 eb?

balmy condor
#

yeh pretty much

warm drift
#

my sims confusing me

#

okay

balmy condor
#

still crit/vers

vestal wren
#

sin is atm ~5-15% stronger on 2 and 3 target cleave

#

but outlaw beats both sin/sub usually

#

outlaw is ~10% ahead of sin on 2 and 3 targets

worn pebble
#

Is it correct to look at is as of right now, oulaw is best tuned for m+ but for raids it depends on the fight with outlaw/sin being better on cleaves and sub best on ST?

balmy condor
#

correct

worn pebble
#

Thanks 🙂

inland lintel
#

Is it worth it to learn sin for SO

#

SL

balmy condor
#

depends entirely on what's worth to you

inland lintel
#

My goal right now is to guarantee I earn a raid spot. So I need to perform really well that first week of castle nathria

balmy condor
#

all 3 rogue specs will do that just fine

#

sin, with current tuning, probably less so for single target

#

but as per the discussion above, its still strong on cleave

inland lintel
#

I'm guessing you can play all 3b pretty well

balmy condor
#

I refuse to play outlaw

#

but I can play sub and sin, yes

inland lintel
#

I've been playing subtlety and it seems pretty straightforward.

balmy condor
#

sin and outlaw are more straightforward than sub for most people

inland lintel
#

Maintain SnD & rupture. Then spam shadowstrike and eviscerate, right?

strange python
#

yea

#

its very easy

balmy condor
#

pretty much

#

lining up cooldowns, pooling into shd windows

#

but that's the gist

inland lintel
#

And you're saying assassination is easier than that?

balmy condor
#

yes

#

its slower, and as long as you maintain gar rup and snd

#

you're basically there

#

less short cds as well

#

less punishing to mistakes

inland lintel
#

Niiiiice

#

Outlaw seems chill too, I've been playing it

#

I just don't understand how it does damage.

vestal wren
#

assassination is a questionable pick with current tuning

balmy condor
#

faceroll harder

#

if outlaw doesn't do damage, you just gotta smash your keyboard till the keycaps fall off

inland lintel
#

I just don't see where it would even come from

#

I use Sinister and pistol shot procs as my builders

balmy condor
#

melee, mastery, sinister strike atm

inland lintel
#

Then I spam between the eyes on cooldown otherwise I use dispatch.

balmy condor
#

yuh

#

that's 90% of your damage righ there

dry atlas
#

Blade flurry bro

inland lintel
#

Blade flurry seems like dogshit compared to shuriken storm

balmy condor
#

^ only with traits though

#

blade flurry is crazy tbh

#

just as a concept

dry atlas
#

They're completely different

inland lintel
#

Maybe I don't understand how the skill works but it seems really weak.

balmy condor
#

a % of your damage is just cleaved to everything around you

native lynx
#

it hits on melee mh+oh strikes, as well as abilities

warm drift
#

u need uptime for the cd reduce so u can have high uptime on bf

#

if that makes sense:D

inland lintel
#

BF?

native lynx
#

what

inland lintel
#

Oh

balmy condor
#

bf is blade flurry

warm drift
#

blade flurry

balmy condor
#

we're kinda straying into #outlaw land tho

inland lintel
#

How much of the damage comes from getting lucky on roll the bones.

native lynx
#

@warm drift "u need uptime for the cd reduce" what is this

inland lintel
#

Yeah I guess so

dry atlas
#

Outlaw is crazy as a concept in general compared to sin

warm drift
#

@native lynx if u dont have high uptime on ur finishers u loose uptime on bf

dry atlas
#

"you need uptime so you can have uptime " Pepega

balmy condor
#

stop fighting

warm drift
#

sry

#

i dont fight. i just cant explain well ^^

native lynx
#

Ok, i thought you meant you need the cdr buff from rtb, which is not true, but yes youre absolutely right gotta get those finishers in so that bf comes off cd during its uptime window

inland lintel
#

Assassination seems like the most monotonous spec of the three.

balmy condor
#

it is

inland lintel
#

Feels like feral druid Jr.

#

Outlaw kind of feels like enhancement shaman instead of stormstrike procs you get pistol shot.

dry atlas
#

Feral is way more complex than sin lol

inland lintel
#

Yeah but sin is way better.

dry atlas
#

Well yeah

#

Lower risk higher reward

inland lintel
#

@vestal wren who are some of your favorite rogue content creators on YouTube?

balmy condor
#

I would be surprised if he recommended anything on youtube

#

tbh

vestal wren
#

i don't watch a lot of youtube

#

maybe red rogue?

#

he seems like a nice guy

balmy condor
#

can confirm

#

is a nice guy

#

also would be my choice if I had to pick someone

#

doesn't clickbait, accurate, just generally a good time

inland lintel
#

Okay, I'm going to check it out right now. Thank you!

visual dragon
#

Infexious is good

balmy condor
#

that's quite an opinion

#

but I guess everyone has their own tastes

#

crim's pretty good too, I like him

#

crim's pretty good too, I like him

#

forgot about him

regal cloud
#

Hey sorry it's more an general question so mby not the most accurate channel but can someone answer me about soulbinds?

#

Like if I choose necro as sub, if I switch for OL for whatever reason, the soulbind way still the same or can I switch it?

balmy condor
#

Still the same

#

It’s character specific, not spec specific

fathom swift
#

you can change soulbinds or soulbind paths however you want, just not the actual conduits you slot in

#

those take the points to replace

strange python
#

i believe the paths change depending on spec but the conduits stay in

balmy condor
#

Yeah

#

The conduits need points

regal cloud
#

OK so it's a bit flexible

#

Atleast

fathom swift
#

yeah you can set it up to have a soulbind for each spec or something if you want

regal cloud
#

Would like to be a bit less dogshit on aoe encounter

jaunty arrow
#

How looks assa now on beta? Its worth to play it?

balmy condor
#

Behind sub and outlaw

#

Numerically at least

jaunty arrow
#

So nothing superior

strange python
#

But I heard that's typical for assa before huge gear upgrades. Don't quote me tho

balmy condor
#

Kind of a bait argument

#

Performance is most often dependent on the borrowed power

dry atlas
#

other specs will also get the same huge gear upgrades

balmy condor
#

Exsang was nuts at the start of legion

#

Ss was nuts in uldir

#

Sin is slower at the start of an expac apm wise

#

But dps wise there’s no statement to be made about any spec being inherently bad at the start of an expac

strange python
#

Gotcha :)

minor thicket
#

I’m surprised why isn’t Necrolord the best covenant

#

Kyrian for all? That’s wild

dusky walrus
#

Pelagos for all

plain thistle
#

well, they nerfed necro pretty hard

#

not surprised

minor thicket
#

Is pelagos part of Kyrian?

vestal wren
#

palegos is overtuned, its not about any other soulbind being bad

wicked drift
placid cobalt
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
echo gust
#

so whats the new covenant sims now?

subtle drift
#

Pinned

fleet whale
#

so i did it

#

i have 34% crit now

royal lantern
#

congratz.now you can do dmg

maiden wolf
#

!stats

prisma monolithBOT
#

Pre patch: Versatility > Critical Strike > Mastery > Haste
**Shadowlands: ** Haste > Versatility => Critical Strike => Mastery

unreal fern
#

How is sin rogue gameplay state atm? Is it ok or some problems?

crimson palm
#

Dead

vivid summit
#

I feel like I saw people say CT was worth singletarget when prepatch came out. Was I stoned or is that the case?

vestal wren
#

assassination is atm undertuned

fleet whale
#

CT is not worth it anymore in ST

unreal fern
#

@vestal wren im more interested in rotation st/aoe if there are any design problems or it feels okayish, not numbers :)

vestal wren
#

assassination in 98% unchanged

#

if you don't think there was a design problem in bfa or legion, it will have no issue in sl

past haven
#

@vestal wren Is Assa undertuned in terms of talents or conduit/soulbind?

vestal wren
#

it is undertuned in terms of baseline tuning

#

all borrowed power systems (with the exception of celerity that will see tuning sooner or later) are about as good/bad on all 3 specs

#

assassination just isn't compatitive without a slight buff

#

i can see that this is a conflict for a lot of people given assassination was now the best rogue spec to play for 2 xpacs straight in raiding

#

but i think we will see tuning changes sooner or later

fair rain
#

Fuu POGGERS

vestal wren
#

hey tumna

#

*tuna

past haven
#

Sin is my favourite spec since forever, so i'll probably stick with that only hoping for some good changes

broken moss
#

Sin Raid Outlaw M+ Sub PvP is the normal world

#

Hopefully changes go that way

vestal wren
#

is the normal world
not at the moment ^^

#

sin was even in pvp the better/more pupular pick in bfa iirc

balmy condor
#

Correct

vestal wren
#

sub is in a well balanced enviroment slightly ahead of sin (not significantly like now) because sin is better to deal with raid mechanics and more forgiving what makes it even then the stronger progress spec

royal lantern
#

eh like

#

you can probably just play sin fine for raiding

#

people make a bigger deal out of that stuff then it really is tbh

covert patrol
#

!stats

prisma monolithBOT
#

Pre patch: Versatility > Critical Strike > Mastery > Haste
**Shadowlands: ** Haste > Versatility => Critical Strike => Mastery

vestal wren
#

pre patch has no new content, so it does not matter

#

you can play the worse spec in the game and its fine

strange python
#

That makes sense

inland lintel
#

hey guys im bouta try assassination for the first time, wish me lucK!

#

any tips?

balmy condor
#

maintain everything

inland lintel
#

@balmy condor Thank you!

#

!guide

low girder
#

that's interesting

#

!guide

prisma monolithBOT
low girder
#

ah there we go

inland lintel
#

ty

#

Do we know what race is gonna be best for SL?

#

for rogue

#

for minmaxing dps

balmy condor
#

doesn't matter

inland lintel
#

realy?!?!

balmy condor
#

racials are minimal

#

if you really REALLY care

#

you can do that

#

and get your

#

0.7% dps

#

maybe

inland lintel
#

nice

#

i wont change then

upper wasp
#

Hi guys! Have any of you tried to do freehold by yourself? Before pre-patch i could, but now mobs bishotting me XD
Any suggestion?

low girder
#

wait til SL

#

we lost a lot of relative power when corruption was deactivated

upper wasp
#

oh ok! ty! 😄

peak jungle
#

Any word on potential buffs to assassin? spent the day trying sub and I hate it, lol

balmy condor
#

No word

#

But it’ll come probably

fallow otter
#

Hi guys! Have any of you tried to do freehold by yourself? Before pre-patch i could, but now mobs bishotting me XD
Any suggestion?
@upper wasp if it's for speed leveling they nerfed it i thought

strange python
#

For progress and multitarget assa will be in the same Spot and also if ur not a wf Raider, play what u want

mossy crown
#

!guides

prisma monolithBOT
bronze kelp
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
worn pebble
#

!stats

prisma monolithBOT
#

Pre patch: Versatility > Critical Strike > Mastery > Haste
**Shadowlands: ** Haste > Versatility => Critical Strike => Mastery

tropic ocean
#

For progress and multitarget assa will be in the same Spot and also if ur not a wf Raider, play what u want
@strange python imagine actually playing and having fun 😁 sometimes when reading disc I feel like everyone is a full time esports player 😋

strange python
#

iam doing less 5 dps...benched...but the shadow died on the pull, but he is top dps...i hate the game is so numberfocused

viral aurora
#

If you get benched, its most likely a combination of things, that is of you arent like 20% beneath the second worst dps. Then you dunno wtf you are doing most likely.

strange python
#

U wont get benched cuz of ur spec its pretty much that u dont know how to play the spec
except if u are a wf raider but then again udnt be asking this if u were

sterile jackal
#

Will we get some new patch notes for SL today?

balmy condor
#

It’s possible

shrewd night
#

Likely not today, but tomorrow

#

afaik wednesday is more about prepatch

balmy condor
#

Wednesdays are beta usually

tropic ocean
#

U wont get benched cuz of ur spec its pretty much that u dont know how to play the spec
except if u are a wf raider but then again udnt be asking this if u were
@strange python on lower Rankings wr 200 or lower, its more nepotism than actual performance

#

😋

strange python
#

Just hope assassa can be a little competetive in lower raiding come SL cause I'm rly enjoying the spec :).

royal lantern
#

there is a reasonable chance that sin could be the go-too progression spec simply because of how it works

frail jungle
#

Assassination is generally a safe spec for progression, yes.

vestal wren
#

likely, but tuning is currently not in fav. of it

fleet whale
#

People always bring up assassin being best for progression, but more often than not, most players choose the best performing spec for progression

#

unless if the gap is really close

vestal wren
#

assassination was the best performing one for 2 xpacs now

#

there is a certain perception build with that

#

but even ignoring that, if both sub/assassination are tuned about equal there is no reason to look at subtlety if there is not a specific fight that lined up a lot better with its cooldowns.
Assassination is less punishing, usually more consistent and does not suffer from downtimes as much.

lean marten
#

PES2_Boxerv PES_Boxer = assa v sub

past haven
#

I would like to use Assa in M+ without having to feel like a piano player while trying doin some decent AoE

neat topaz
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
kind vault
#

Should I be opening with Ambush or Garrote? I’m so used to going with the talent that gives me extra time to use stealth abilities+garrote dmg and then garrot’ing multiple enemies

#

But it feels like when I use ambush there’s not enough time to fit in an extra stealth attack like there is for garrote

balmy condor
#

If you’re using subt you’re gonna use a garrote, and 3x gar from aor

#

Aoe

spring sparrow
#

Having trouble figuring out this rotation. So I've been playing outlaw exclusively. I'm used to SS to build points and then a finisher. What's my spammable on this build?

drifting cloud
#

mutilate

spring sparrow
#

ty

prime pine
#

!guides

prisma monolithBOT
prime pine
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
hollow hawk
#

What does "until cancelled" mean for shiv

rough agate
#

Maybe til dead or you apply it on a different target 😮

karmic cedar
#

that has to be a datamining error...

balmy condor
#

Most likely error

karmic cedar
#

ooh, Rushed Setup buff

#

20% energy reduction on Sap/Cheap/Kidney at rank 1 now

surreal torrent
#

Shiv seems to be a wowhead datamining error. Ignore that line.

#

Still 9s

grizzled jay
#

Shiv toggle like Breath Pog

glad spruce
#

Assassination getting buffs lolfunnyfrogfacex3

last root
#

@grizzled jay what does it spend? energy per second or?

#

ah datamining error

#

nvm

grizzled jay
#

Runic Power

last root
#

jaja

random comet
#

What does "until cancelled" mean for shiv
@hollow hawk I saw that and thought it'd be a toggle dot like ashvane coral?

#

that'd be at least interesting

balmy condor
#

It’s just a datamined error

#

It’s just like toxic blade now

#

9 seconds

obsidian mountain
#

a nerf to Pelagos' Soulbind trait Let Go of the Past. peepochrist

balmy condor
#

Deserved

fleet whale
#

you could argue that the nerf wasn't enough

grizzled jay
#

If it's like a half percent DPS loss, that puts Venthyr + Nadjia within 3.5%

#

and def puts Emeni + SBS over it in AoE

fleet whale
#

If you're talking ST, then Night fae should be within the same area

#

i mean Venth was literally just one dps higher lol

urban marsh
#

Any idea what do they mean by "Until cancelled" on Shiv?

#

Is it a Toggle now?

low girder
#

bad datamine

#

it's still 9s

urban marsh
#

Oh ok

balmy condor
#

Should have moroes post that once an hour :P

low girder
#

lol

strange python
#

what does this even mean

dense cedar
#

I believe that is a datamining error

drifting cloud
#

go read literally 4 posts up

sick scarab
#

so guys any news ? i was oflline for some days

low girder
#

This happens literally constantly with the "until cancelled" stuff. Idk why people fall for it.

grizzled ruin
#

so is the 1% on pelagos enough to dethrone him ?

fair rain
#

It makes it closer

drifting cloud
#

the 4s is way bigger change

#

shits on uptime

sterile jackal
#

sin has enough skills to smoothly maintain full buff. 4s is long enough for us.

mint kindle
#

!guide

prisma monolithBOT
vestal wren
vestal wren
delicate bone
#

still tuned under outlaw for ST? kind of crazy

dry atlas
vestal wren
fair rain
#

Fuu you the best don't let anyone tell you different POG @vestal wren

balmy condor
#

@delicate bone all the tuning happening so far has been generalized, we haven’t gotten sin-only tuning

#

So it’s gonna be behind until then

delicate bone
#

yea but still, leggo tuning is essentially spec specific

#

but i see where youre coming from

#

hopefully with not buffing legos for sin, they have plans for the spec tuning itsels

#

itself

somber bison
#

Yeah bench plans

vestal wren
#

i don't expect big changes to legendary items

#

they could nerf celerity a bit more, but not rly seeing a outstanding good/bad one else

#

shadowdust is still not good

somber bison
#

I assume emi is Emeni ?

vestal wren
#

yes

jaunty arrow
#

@wild kettle stupid question for m+ is best conduit on kyrian kleia or pelagos for all (raid atd.)

balmy condor
#

Wrong ping

fair rain
balmy condor
#

But Pelagos still the strongest

#

That’s why the soulbind chart has Pelagos as the overall best

jaunty arrow
#

I get it but u cant use one for all, so thats why ask coz necro have for m+ shown

balmy condor
#

Why can’t you

#

Just switch out a conduit

jaunty arrow
#

But u cant switch that every day or?

balmy condor
#

It’s an energy system

#

You’ll be able to switch in and out of your raid set as long as it’s not all the time

#

Won’t be able to change per boss for example

jaunty arrow
#

Ok, ty

quaint sequoia
#

The change to shiv is a buff to sin right?

plain thistle
#

no, still 9s

#

just a datamining error

quaint sequoia
#

Damn, so no buff to sin this build either then 🙃

plain thistle
#

hopefully they will do a aura buff before launch, but right now it seems they are focusing on balancing convenant-conduits choice

#

like they did to legendaries a few weeks ago, to bring every legendary to 5% or less dps increase

vestal wren
#

its likely that blizz buffs/nerfs classes sooner or later

past haven
#

Echoing Reprimand will charge a random combo point or is based at which u have at the moment u do the spell?

shadow tulip
#

Random

#

2-3-4

fleet whale
#

so how about sub rogue being about 600 dps in front of sin...

strange python
#

what about it?

vestal wren
#

specs are not tuned yet

#

blizz did tune legendary items and other systems

rough agate
#

Think they'll ever make venom rush viable or would they need to remove alacrity

vestal wren
#

they just need to buff VR a bit more

fleet whale
#

so it looks like they finally fixed the improved poisons perk

#

just attacked about 10 mobs one by one from stealth

#

and both poisons were applied immediately

vestal wren
#

we saw a lot of bugfixes

pliant apex
#

if first mut from opener, doesnt crit, im supposed to re cast till 4-5 points, then slice and dice, and then do i mut again now or garrote-mut till 4 and rupture

#

this in case opener mut doesnt crit

#

i know rotation if it crits on opener

#

basically asking opener for non crit mut

balmy condor
#

Same thing

#

You would cast the slice if it doesn’t crit

pliant apex
#

so i would cast slice WITHOUT 4-5 points?

#

on opener? if mut dont crit?

balmy condor
#

Yes

#

You would cast at whatever cp you end up at

pliant apex
#

ahh ic

#

casting an extra mul will be dps loss?

#

im guessing i cast garrote if second mut doesnt crit either?

balmy condor
#

pretty negligible overall

pliant apex
#

hmm

#

so basically mut slice mut, garrote, rupture, irrespective of crits .. long story short?

balmy condor
#

yes

pliant apex
#

ty, youre really helpful

balmy condor
#

if you run subterfuge, you would obviously open with the garrote first into a slice

pliant apex
#

ma will be good enough im sure for purple logs in aotc guilds right

#

not chasing CE or orange parses

balmy condor
#

ye

wild kettle
#

@jaunty arrow I assume that wasn't for me kekw

prime pine
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
prime pine
#

!stats

prisma monolithBOT
#

Pre patch: Versatility > Critical Strike > Mastery > Haste
**Shadowlands: ** Haste > Versatility => Critical Strike => Mastery

prime pine
#

!guide

prisma monolithBOT
unkempt spade
#

hello best covenant for asa rogue?

fleet whale
#

right now kyrian but all 4 are really close in ST

nimble garnet
#

hey guys, hows assa looking atm? pve/pvp wise thanks!

balmy condor
#

Worse than sub

strange python
#

But we don't know how it will look once stuff starts rolling sadly. Blizz is the company of surprises :)

nimble garnet
#

in paper tho, the 4 bleeds plus doomblade lego and +envenom dmg sounds pretty good, is it just a numbers thing then that puts assa behind?

balmy condor
#

Yes

strange python
#

I never got the hate for SnD. I feel like it has good synergy with the spec :)

balmy condor
#

it just doesn't change the feel or the gameplay

#

but I personally like it too

grizzled jay
#

people randomly started hating maintenance buffs

balmy condor
#

wouldn't call it random

#

maintenance has always been not the most favorited thing

#

adding it to sin just adds another one

#

and people especially don't like that

frail birch
#

Idk I like slapping that snd right at the perfect moment before it ends

#

Same with pandemic timer on bleeds

grizzled jay
#

i think it's just for Legion/BfA we had Spec > Class and a lot of current players started in Legion so are used to that philosophy. Not many WoW players are used to Class > Spec, where your spec adds on to base abilities.

balmy condor
#

snd pandemic is so long

#

so I don't really care too much

#

and I definitely don't think its that XD

#

but we all have our own opinions

low girder
#

i actually hate it way more for outlaw personally but

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

topaz talon
#

still cant get used to SnD being on sub and sin

fallow otter
#

And outlaw

#

It's a maintenance buff imo

topaz talon
#

i feel like it makes more sense with outlaw, just not the other two

#

i dunno though

fallow otter
#

Im not a fan but it's a rogue way of life now

#

Feels best on sub imo

#

But in all fairness I haven't even bothered with pre patch sin

#

Cbf

topaz talon
#

like i am by no means an expert on how rogues work, i jsut stab things and smile, but it feels like with sin it makes sense due to poisons being applied faster, and outlaw with weapons being slow, but doesnt sub white hit like a child?

balmy condor
#

sub and sin white hits are equal

#

because they're both daggers

#

sub gets energy and cp from autos as well

topaz talon
#

yeah but sin has the added bonus of poisons actually being applied faster and more effectively though right?

balmy condor
#

which kinda makes up for it

topaz talon
#

ok that last part makes more sense then

balmy condor
#

I mean its strong for both

#

idk who exactly its stronger for

#

I think that's splitting hairs

#

but sub adds something gameplay

#

and sin doesn't

#

and that's the main complaint

#

because people want something new from sin

#

and snd isn't it

topaz talon
#

oh im not complaining, i mean sins rotation was pretty boring, at least SnD makes it alittle more interesting

balmy condor
#

yeah I think most people would tell you that another maint buff isn't more interesting

#

but I like it so idk

topaz talon
#

to each their own

#

i was mainly just looking for clarification as to why youd even bother with it on sub, which i think i got my answer to

#

guess i couldve just asked that in that channel though

balmy condor
#

the melee damage is huge

#

the cp/energy is the cream on top

#

snd is the sole reason why you see melee damage topping every damage chart

loud brook
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
strange python
#

Most of them are outdated

loud brook
#

yeah I know, I just need something since my ssd decided to seppuku

#

and I didn't save my weakauras on my backup

bright path
#

@loud brook just go to wago.io and download luxthos wa.

loud brook
#

alright

gentle locust
#

mmo champion Spell Changes shows they removed nature damage buff from shiv, is this just a typo?

jaunty arrow
#

U dont like 0% for 0?

gentle locust
#

they may as well make shiv a pvp talent

#

and give me some other button

jaunty arrow
#

Dont think so

gentle locust
#

exsanguinate baseline on all targets, rather than just one target 😄

jaunty arrow
#

I want see some sinergi with snd, like envenom crit give u 3s snd or smth like this

gentle locust
#

well, then you would just use those CP to overlap another envenom

#

at least now we can still have our brains engaged 😄

jaunty arrow
#

I dont mind use snd but for me feels like forced comback child u dont like

gentle locust
#

it gives me Cataclysm vibes, but without stacking Deadly Poison

jaunty arrow
#

For exampl yes

#

Smth like that

#

Also rework talents, HB is just w/e atc

#

If they switch hb to eb trait, that will be good

vestal wren
jaunty arrow
#

@vestal wren ty fuu

vestal wren
#

Grove Invigoration was not updated in the sim yesterday. Night fae looks very appealing now for sin/outlaw

jaunty arrow
#

Yep looks good

vague rock
#

how would you make venom rush a good talent, and improve that row in general?

#

it's not very competitive is it

vestal wren
#

buff it

vague rock
#

so if it refunded more energy, it would actually be used

vestal wren
#

8 -> 10 energy

vague rock
#

wondering if that energy you get back ever beats alacrity

jaunty arrow
#

Nope

vague rock
#

like even if you buffed the energy

jaunty arrow
#

Maybe but its hard to say

vague rock
#

i'm interested in how much energy it would have to give back to be even or better than alacrity. Is it 10 @vestal wren ?

vestal wren
#

10 makes is compatitive

#

but idk if you would pick it given vr alacrity does not lose value if you get more targets

vague rock
#

true

#

so it's a talent that really just needs a rework

vestal wren
#

idk

#

i don't think its bad

#

unlike exsang

jaunty arrow
#

Exs is kinda rip i guess

vestal wren
#

it does look quite bad rn

#

don't think we will see a return any time soon

jaunty arrow
#

Still if exs should by playable i will need 3 hand

strange python
#

Venomous Wounds is a passive rogue ability learned at level 46 for those with the Assassination specialization. Working in conjunction with [Rupture], it has a high chance to deal additional nature damage and restore a significant amount of energy.

#

This is all i want

vestal wren
#

i don't think that we see ability reworks

#

shaowlands is to close now

jaunty arrow
#

Maybe after frst raid

vestal wren
#

all specs have some minor things that could change, but tbh so has every spec in the game

#

assassination would like to see changes in vr and exsang
outlaw probably would like changes in roll the bones buffs
subtlety would like to see a change in shadow blades and a buff to dark

crimson palm
#

exsang's fine tho

vestal wren
#

and this is ignoring minor things like normalizing procs

#

is it?

crimson palm
#

hb/vr/alac need a complete overhaul

#

like hidden blades is still a talent kekw

vestal wren
#

hb might be decent with PK

crimson palm
#

is there any other talent in the game

#

that forces u not to press a button

#

i legit wonder

vestal wren
#

i mean

#

that was the complain we had about the legendary too

#

but i agree, having to decide between 2 inefficient choices does not feel great

#

a easy fix is to just make it a cooldown

#

that gives you "max stacks"

crimson palm
#

its a last row talent

#

it needs to be gameplay defining

#

like sin is probably the only spec in the game that has bullshit last row

vestal wren
#

idk about a "must"

#

last row of sin i as exciting as it is for subtlety

crimson palm
#

sub does change gameplay

vestal wren
#

mos is passive like pb
ct is similar to secret
tornado is niche, like hb

crimson palm
#

ye but mos grants u energy and u dont have to pool before windows

#

so in a way it does change the way u play

#

pb is just passive proc that doesnt do shit

vestal wren
#

they both work out similar

#

so idk

ruby idol
#

anyone noted if Sepsis scales with Mastery this build?

frigid kestrel
#

I love this list of emotions I have to go through.
Practice Nerco, no more necro
Practice Venthyr, no more Venthyr
Practice Kyrian, no more Kyrian

#

And now, Night Fae

#

YAY, I’m officially ready for anything.

rich yew
#

@frigid kestrel yay!

#

Better be prepared right?

prisma yoke
#

just wait until the Jailer pocket dimension becomes a covenant and you have a new ultimate :D

echo gust
#

NF is the only way

spice marsh
#

I’m hoping the dps difference is to far apart. I like necro armour and weapon mog

echo gust
#

well they nerf kyrian

#

and NF got utility

frigid sleet
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
lost niche
#

what would be the opener for assa with the singletarget build ? (Master assassin)

quaint sequoia
#

Do you think sin will get a buff before release? or do I have to go sub 😦

delicate bone
#

id still be cautiously hopeful for some tuning to help sin out.. but its looking a little rough

royal lantern
#

eh, its possible, but at the same time sin could go into the corner sub was during bfa

#

aka: 2 specs work, we ignore the 3rd

zinc frigate
#

Question:
I am new with rogue was reading through the guide and it seems that Vendetta and Vanish are mostly used together except in the opener.
So my question is should I make macro for them since they are both off GCD and use them separately only in the opener and is it good if I do it that way?

balmy condor
#

You use them separately in m+ and pvp a lot of the time

#

And there’s also some cheese with raid mechanics sometimes where you can vanish a couple things

#

I wouldn’t macro it

zinc frigate
#

Ahhhh okay thank you for the info makes sense

grim jay
#

@balmy condor are you currently raiding in retail?

#

in any shape or form

balmy condor
#

Ye

grim jay
#

how high are your sims and do you have any difficulties meeting them?

balmy condor
#

Where are we going with this

royal lantern
#

its close too impossible too get your sim dps in reality lol

#

when do people finally understand that

grim jay
#

@royal lantern nice that you answered something with a sarcastic answer thats 100% unnecessary and stupid, ty

royal lantern
#

its not sarcastic

grim jay
#

@balmy condor I had some people simming for lower than they actually deal damage

royal lantern
#

its how it is

balmy condor
#

Well

#

are they simming accurate lengths

#

And accurate fight types

royal lantern
#

a sim is 5min no movment no mechanics with a good amount of crits/procs

#

and you play 100%perfect

grim jay
#

they simmed for same duration with a ST fight

#

so they should sim higher

royal lantern
#

reality can have you be really lucky with crits during cd windows, and now your dps is simply higher cus of that

obtuse anvil
#

what's the variance

grim jay
#

than what they actually did

balmy condor
#

Okay

royal lantern
#

or you play perfect, and get 0 procs/crits and your dps is lower

#

thats how reality works

balmy condor
#

So if they simmed for single target

obtuse anvil
#

you're talking about a statistical model

balmy condor
#

and the fight was the same length

obtuse anvil
#

not the word of god

balmy condor
#

Then how much higher are they

#

Are we talking like 20dps? Or 200

grim jay
#

like 200-250-ish dps

balmy condor
#

That is pretty weird then

#

What fight?

obtuse anvil
#

are all the options in the sim matching the log? buffs and consumables?

#

lust getting popped asap etc

#

and what fight is it

balmy condor
#

Yeah

royal lantern
#

reality can have you be really lucky with crits during cd windows, and now your dps is simply higher cus of that
thas 1 of the big things too peeposhrug

balmy condor
#

200-250 isn’t lucky crits

royal lantern
#

for 1 fight? it sure can be

balmy condor
#

Unless you’re shooting like 20% higher

royal lantern
#

always? then maybe the sims are wrong

#

dunno how optimized the sims for other classes are

#

we have fuu

balmy condor
#

Yeah I mean there can be GIGA rng

#

But I find it doubtful

grim jay
#

I think it was shad'har

#

hc tho

balmy condor
#

Ye shouldn’t matter

#

Shad is single target no adds

royal lantern
#

what classes?

jaunty arrow
#

Welp u can be super unlucky but

balmy condor
#

So if it’s 200 higher, somethings wrong between the sim and the fight

#

Or it’s one in a million rng

#

Or it’s a class that has some missing implementation

royal lantern
#

eeehhhhh

#

like

#

its enough for fights like shad

#

when you get a OP proc+high crit count during your cd windows allready too get a bigger impact

#

cus the fight is over so fast

balmy condor
#

Well yeah but I’m assuming ~5 min

#

Cause I wasn’t told otherwise

grim jay
#

was a shortly above 3 min kill on a twinkraid

royal lantern
#

timer it is

balmy condor
#

3 min can swing a little harder

#

So not unheard of, yeah

royal lantern
#

if it is a class with a 3min cd

#

and they used a cd the 2nd time during the last 5-10seconds

#

ofc the dps will go up by quite a bit again

jaunty arrow
#

Also bl can do smth i guess if u have or not have cds

grim jay
#

ye thinking about it it might just be the extra cd you maybe get in in the 20-ish seconds between sim and actual fightlength

royal lantern
#

like i said

#

always remember that a sim is 5min patchwork

#

but reality tends too be different

grim jay
#

you can sim on 3 min tho

#

which they said they did

royal lantern
#

fight lenght alone has a big impact of the dmg a class can do

balmy condor
#

Sims run with 20% fight length variance, so there’s already that happening

#

But obviously if it’s longer

#

You’ll end on the higher side of that variance

royal lantern
#

+it deepens on how good the sims are handled during prepatch

#

its possible that they are somewhat funky for some classes/specs rn

grim mason
#

in M+ w/ no EB do i still run Blood,