#assassination

1 messages Ā· Page 911 of 1

oak tangle
#

like inside dm kb?

#

i can see that argument

royal lantern
#

??? no, just Overall lol

oak tangle
#

how does that work

royal lantern
#

did you play the spec inside a raid

midnight mist
#

ye thats why I stopped playing sin

oak tangle
#

i did

midnight mist
#

way too fast for me

royal lantern
#

the amount of time you actually run low on energy and cant do anything is low

oak tangle
#

i haven't played it when fights have been sub 2 mins though

#

still had to pool when i raided

royal lantern
# midnight mist way too fast for me

outlaw brains when a class that is balanced around a 1sec hard gcd and as a result hardcaps at around 50-mid 60apm (depeending on the amount of off gcd abilitys avaible) has 2specs around 50-mid 60 apm:

oak tangle
#

it's a effect of short fights and tea use right? what you mean? so it's not really sustainable on long stuff

#

or am i completely off mark

royal lantern
#

you just generate a shitton of energy Overall

#

combined with the absurd high stats we have rn, WFT, 2free tea charges, blindside etc....

oak tangle
#

oh yeah early patch execute was gcd

#

i remember that

#

most of my kills are between 3-4 mins

#

and those were reclears, so more like 5 mins when progging (Heroic)

balmy condor
#

yeah assa is

#

"slower"

#

but it's not really all that slow

subtle tundra
#

the trick is to realise i wont parse well regardless so i just watch something on my 2nd monitor disregarding performance

#

šŸ™

balmy condor
#

on fyrakk I'm still easily 50-52 apm

#

with a bit of downtime for rends and him jumping away

midnight mist
#

pressing health pots to pad apm

balmy condor
#

fresh technology

midnight mist
#

wtf, insane apm god gamer

balmy condor
#

but yeh idk

#

assa could be a couple apm slower tbh

subtle tundra
#

yes!

royal lantern
#

spamming detection for apm

royal lantern
#

or in case of bfa

#

spamming detection for corruption procs

subtle tundra
balmy condor
#

even after rework and sanguine eating energy and envenom duration reduced and blindside nerfed, envenom is still like 75% uptime

#

idk what the goal is for that number

subtle tundra
#

fyrakk prog was a LOT of meowing

balmy condor
#

but things like twist the knife existing in a design space where envenom is 75% uptime without much effort

gaunt moat
#

okay i take that back

balmy condor
#

seems really weird to me

royal lantern
#

man, i really dread the day poopyblades is played around

#

such a horrible desinged talent

balmy condor
#

Better than exsang kek

#

And tbh might be a vicious venom angle if I’m being honest

royal lantern
#

its just

#

"do passive more dmg for not doing anything lol" is so horrible

#

i rather have shit like the current 4ser where its atleast SOMEWHAT involved

#

yes, ik that the current 4set is not really big aswell cus envenom uptime is so high, but it still beats "do nothing and do passive more dmg lol", cant tell me anyone actually would enjoy playing around that talent

gaunt moat
lean aurora
#

looking into the future to s4, how do we scale with a higher statpool compared to outlaw/sub?

balmy condor
#

Sanguine might need to SCALE

royal lantern
balmy condor
#

Only matters in a vacuum with 0 tuning

#

Is season 4 going to have 0 tuning?

royal lantern
#

like the "you do more mut dmg against a target with garrote"

why is that a thing lol, put some deffensive thing there

#

the entire tree having 1 utility talent and 0 deffensive ones is just kinda weird

gaunt moat
#

Probably not gonna happen
But we'll see what we're getting with the hero talents

royal lantern
ripe carbon
#

what dps should i be doing at full 476 single target? i sim at 180k but im like 40-50k under that

balmy condor
#

Only reasonable thing would be looking at logs

#

And seeing if you’re fucking up rotationally

clever sapphire
ripe carbon
#

well like im doing lfr to get my sims

#

i mean get my runs

oak tangle
#

and are you getting priest simped

ripe carbon
#

no, and i dunno about the sim.. ill have to check

balmy condor
#

I haven’t done LFR in maybe 7 years

ripe carbon
#

i am fucking up my rotation tho

balmy condor
#

How long are those fights

ripe carbon
#

but i was more wondering am i doing horrible

royal lantern
#

thats like, 12k dps alone

oak tangle
#

your best bet, is to do a dummy parse no buffs, and do a sim with no buffs

midnight mist
ripe carbon
#

ok ill try that...
and i dunno how long fights are

balmy condor
ripe carbon
#

they feel about the same as when i pugged normals. i havent done much raiding/single target stuff yet mostly just mythic+

#

can i vanish in dummy runs? or will it cancel

pseudo hamlet
#

We are getting new hero talents today! What are your prediction guys? What do you hope for?

clever sapphire
#

im hoping to get another off gcd cooldown with a 1:15 timer that snapshots onto kingsbane

royal lantern
#

that fatebound gets a different name

clever sapphire
royal lantern
#

i can respect hater Energy

#

but thats too far

clever sapphire
#

i am the hate

#

do we know any specific time when the talents gonna be revealed btw?

pseudo hamlet
#

Nah, just day

balmy condor
#

might not even be rogue

royal lantern
#

i doubt that tbh

clever sapphire
#

imagine another priest one

#

cause they fecked up the last so hard

royal lantern
#

like, why say "8classes" and NOT show some for the remaining ones that didnt had one at all yet

#

inc: i hate myself for typing that in 12hours

royal lantern
# clever sapphire cause they fecked up the last so hard

it was just a miracle

when its so fucking bad that everything is just bad

the idea? bad

the gameplay it would promote? LMAO

the rng? bruh

the balance bettwen specs? it favors disc 20x over holy (but thats just blizzard disc vs holy balancing overall tbh)

#

not a single redemable thing OMEGAKEKW

clever sapphire
#

wdym, it sounded really fun to have your pi be a rotating ability that you have to press twice in the correct second

royal lantern
#

every 50seconds

clever sapphire
#

not like you would ever have buffed someone besides a mage with the wording that was there

royal lantern
#

while movment+mechanics are happening

clever sapphire
#

nvm warri too

royal lantern
#

and you are supposed to heal at tze same time

#

šŸ™‚

clever sapphire
#

git gud

#

and then the dps gonna blame you for giving him the wrong buff or 5 seconds too late cause you missed the buff

royal lantern
#

that 2/9LFR guy that never did a heroic dungeon knows the facts mate

clever sapphire
#

well maybe he is the target audience, how could you know you top 1% hardcore player (this a joke in case someone feels offended)

#

you shouldnt make decisions for the casual 2/9LFR players

#

(nvm the fact that that guy would probably forget to press pi twice and press it again 50 sec later)

bronze pike
#

I have a late night hero talent cook for y’all

#

Steroids: the rogue infuses the friendly target with a special poison, increasing their mastery by 25% for 12 seconds

#

Double dose: the rogue gets the benefits of steroids if casted on a friendly target

#

That’s your beginning hero talent and your capstone

#

Enjoy

clever sapphire
#

can we make it a 4 different stat thing that rotates every second?

#

and i have to press it twice

bronze pike
#

That sounds op so we gotta balance it

clever sapphire
#

it becomes a random proc on who else it goes on besides you

bronze pike
#

Make it grant 50% of the stat to the rogue instead of 100%

clever sapphire
#

can it stack?

#

what if another rogue gives it to me

bronze pike
#

No

#

It cancels out due to some weird wotlk era bug with stealth bar switches

#

Don’t ask how, speggty coding

clever sapphire
#

my biggest fear is that bonespike will forever be a useless talent

#

i cant see how they would make bonespike playable with hero talent trees

#

seeing as only assa has it

bronze pike
#

Ez, the hero talents turns bone spike to something else for sin

pseudo hamlet
#

Maybe they'll add Shadowlands perks for those talents

balmy condor
#

that's cooked

tepid hornet
#

weapon poisons are total 7 including talented ones?

balmy condor
#

yeah

#

4 lethal 3 non lethal

tepid hornet
#

instant
wound
crippling
deadly
amplifying
numbing
atrophic

#

missed something?

pseudo hamlet
#

...or Torghast powers! Like explosive inflamation or something! Sepsis spreading to 3 other targets and doing AoE at the end. šŸ˜„

tepid hornet
#

now i need to blacklist duplicated from garrote rupture and lethals during deathmark, someone has their ids?

clever sapphire
pseudo hamlet
#

Prepare for big Envenoms then kekdog

royal lantern
tepid hornet
#

the tier 4pc, procs when u envenom with the lil buff u get after envenom up?

#

that says increased poison aplication chance?

slate crown
#

Yes.

tepid hornet
#

everytime i cast envenom with this up, 4pc is proccing?

#

ok

tepid hornet
#

im gonna always keep shiv for kingbane windows?

#

i dont press shiv outside of it?

clever sapphire
#

yap

#

you want 2 shivs for kb

rotund oak
#

and a tea dont forget the tea

#

for some xtra sauce

gusty mirage
royal lantern
#

thats not depression

#

thats cooking

shy pecan
#

SnD forever

rotund oak
ember mural
#

Real

vestal wren
#

snd should be passive on all 3 specs

#

it hasn't rly proven to be a interessting key press

dark token
#

Same thing goes for poisons on outlaw/sub

vestal wren
#

and all 3 now have passive options to either not cast it or cast it less frequently

dark token
#

Both were added in BFA because hurddurrr people miss classic it was peak wow omg let's add these useless spells to get back to rogue identity

vestal wren
#

i think poisons should be

#

once per login

#

so you keep the nostalgia/engagement

dark token
#

Every time you change spec is annoying

#

As someone who multispec

#

Only sin should have poisons

#

Outlaw/sub don't really care and don't have gameplay interactions with em

vestal wren
#

thats what they did in legion and changd back later

dark token
#

Ye ik I'm saying the bfa thing was a mistake

vestal wren
#

it was SL

#

not bfa

dark token
#

Was it BFA that added snd back

#

Or was both in SL

#

Anyway

#

Even if they keep them

vestal wren
#

they did for SL, because of nostalgia

dark token
#

Ain't no one nostalgic for snd

#

Or applying instant poison on sub

vestal wren
#

the success of classic was basically the kickstart of the idea to bring classic mechanics to modern wow

dark token
#

Ye that was a mistake

#

Keep classic classic

grizzled jay
#

Adding CttC back was the bigger mistake

dark token
#

Modern wow has improved from it

vestal wren
#

it was an interessting cycle

#

bfa trid to slim down specs to the core and remove redundancy

dark token
#

No one wants old clunky RPG mechanics in my modern PvE instanced combat hacknslash

grizzled jay
#

Current Sin plays a lot similar to Cata Sin, kinda funny.

vestal wren
#

DF did the complete opposite and tried to add a lot of complexity for the sake of it

grizzled jay
#

Just with Deathmark, SD, and KB

vestal wren
#

i think too much damage on sin is in cooldowns

grizzled jay
#

Cause Cata is the expansion where Sin presses Backstab in Execute. Gets removed in MoP then DF adds it back (kinda).

vestal wren
#

KB does a shitton of damage, and while its nice to have this burst

#

it also relies on critical strikes now to be "nice"

grizzled jay
#

So the feel of Cata and DF Sin is pretty close.

vestal wren
#

having more damage in bleeds would feel more in line to

#

... well how assassiantion worked for years ...

grizzled jay
#

I loved it tho

vestal wren
#

people hated 8.3 sin

#

not becaue of bleeds but because of corruption

#

corruption powers did lead to a energy overflow

#

basically, what happened was you could just delete your energy bar

#

because it was always full

#

and a lot of people loved it

#

because it removed any thinking about ressource management

#

and made you never wait to use a spell

#

to be exact, a lot of long term players did not like it, so it was mixed feedback

woeful meteor
#

can still loot in Raid but at least this is a real trinket now HappyCat

royal lantern
#

like srsly

storm belfry
#

both my druids looted that today

royal lantern
#

every 2nd sentence that comes from you is some "league of legends ranked only" bullshit

dark token
#

Wat

#

That sentence translates to "keep classic to classic, retail is better and should be it's own unique thing, we can go pay classic if we want that"

vestal wren
#

if you want to appreciate random m+ keys, you can play a game of ranked soloq in league

dark token
#

Which I don't think is a bad take?

woeful meteor
# storm belfry lmao based

this took more tries than branch on my rogue also fort bolstering needs to be removed shit is so cringe

royal lantern
#

was adding back SnD a mistake? yes

#

is poisons comming back good? yes

#

1 hour duration on them? bad again cus its pointless

vestal wren
#

i think its just a consequence of design

#

not every decision will be a W

#

there are always some L's

royal lantern
#

ye

#

but RPG mechanics are important

#

its a frking mmorpg

vestal wren
#

yes, but everyone defines rpg mechanics diffrent

royal lantern
#

might aswell go full ff14 otherwhise, where every class is just a re-skin of eachother

#

almost 0 balance problems, cus they all do excatly the same and abilitys are litearlly just re-skins, but hey its better balance for a "hack and slash PvE game"

#

(gameplay is the worst part about ff14 cus of it btw)

normal mist
past forum
#

It’s simple, make every single spec fun and engaging with just enough complexity but no bloating and also make them 100% balanced in all content. Just do that and game’s saved

normal mist
#

Also ff14 is an rpg first and an MMO later, what they lack in gameplay (in terms of fighting) they have extra in the fight designs in my opinion

#

(talking about raids, trials, etc)

royal lantern
past forum
#

And also have build diversity but also make every build good in everything

normal mist
#

That's such a weird take

#

Did you read what you wrote before sending?

#

Stupid example : why would a ST build, designed to do the most ST DMG possible, shine in an AoE scenario?

clever sapphire
#

im pretty sure he was being sarcastic

normal mist
#

I saw no sarcastic emotes, fuck me

#

This is why emotes exist šŸ’€

#

I'll crawl back to another channel and die from shame for a bit

agile geode
#

Sin rogue design rn is on his perfect form imho

pseudo hamlet
#

Nah, too much focused on Kingsbane and the AoE sucks. Everything need to live for like 10 minutes to actually unleash full potential of the spec

agile geode
#

outlaw is cool but i a bit awkward, sub too is good, only the vanish mechanics is shit

spice spire
#

But it’s definitely in a better form than it has been in recent memory for all content. Revolving around kb kinda sux tho

#

Hoping dungeon pools next season allow for build diversity

quiet oar
#

Gottem

spice spire
#

Ty king

tepid hornet
#

its kinda satisfying to dot things in open world and u can just go and they drop in 2 sec

arctic socket
royal lantern
#

i mean, did you do it?

arctic socket
#

I traded a guildie 50gold for some consumables

royal lantern
#

and now the full truth

proven jasper
arctic socket
#

Well it could be me buying the mount off of someone for 500g

spice spire
#

Seems like a classic Andy issue tbh

royal lantern
#

its just

everytime somebody comes and says "i got banned for no reason", there actually IS a reason

spice spire
#

I’ve seen people banned for no reason

#

It definitely does happen

royal lantern
#

new trees out

#

its sub/outlaw

#

lmao im happy we dont have to deal with that BS

#

DEFFENSIVE SKILLS AS OFFENSIVE ABILITYS

subtle tundra
#

surely we say some bad stuff and they dont actually do this

limber lion
#

always feint before pressing kb

royal lantern
limber lion
#

jk we still get parried

royal lantern
#

not assa

limber lion
#

I know

royal lantern
#

we are spared

subtle tundra
#

feint last 5 seconds

#

of kb

#

POG!

royal lantern
#

distract as offensive cd

#

holy shit poor subs

#

first they have to play the garbage spec that is sub and then THAT

woeful meteor
#

and it's a ks tree for law xdd

tepid hornet
#

assass feels so chill after playing outlaw for a while xD

#

its smooth too

proven jasper
tepid hornet
#

one is slow smooth other fast smooth

#

i like the assass pace

proven jasper
#

Trickster is not it yall LMAO

#

jeez

#

I cant wait to killing spree!!

tepid hornet
#

are there stat breakpoint for assass? like i need a minimum of something?

royal lantern
#

no breakpoints

tepid hornet
#

or just priority and sim

royal lantern
#

that stuff doesnt exist in modern wow

#

you sim gear

#

stat breakpoints only really existed cus people didnt sim back in the days

#

or like, it was not wide spread

bright turret
#

Wonder what you gotta smok to think "ah yes lets make rogue's defensive a core part of damage rotation"

proven jasper
#

You put on whatever gear gives you bigger number

tepid hornet
#

i know, but still some specs like want a minimum amount of haste at least or something along these lines dont they?

proven jasper
#

I think

bright turret
#

I think they were trying to be clever since sometimes you press feint a lot

royal lantern
bright turret
#

but i don't think people want another button as part of their damage rotation

tepid hornet
#

assass doin well in m+?

proven jasper
#

Its okay

royal lantern
proven jasper
#

other two rogue specs better

royal lantern
#

you wont struggle in your normal keys cus you play assa

#

just can feel kinda bad in low keys cus stuff dies fast

#

and your aoe dmg is slow and needs some buildup

tepid hornet
#

i barely know what im doin and i see the dps and it was looking much higher than i thought

#

so im thinking what if i knew

green juniper
#

bois I dont have a shammy discord and you guys are the smartest ones for some reason.. is ench shaman wort it to level is it fun ?

tepid hornet
#

i have some trouble with garrote on multiple targets that live long enough to need refreshes, if you dont have vanish to reapply garrotes quick, how do u do it?

#

do u reapply early to have cd up?

#

if i apply lets say on opener, if i wait pandemic to reapply garrotes, i cant without it dropping on some targets?

royal lantern
#

its a fast spec that is heavy proc based

#

if thats your style, sure

green juniper
royal lantern
#

its overall gameplay is more like outlaw

#

fast button mashing, reacting to things happening

green juniper
royal lantern
#

if that helps you

green juniper
#

yeah thanks

royal lantern
#

its more "clearer" and obvious then outlaw tbh

#

like, outlaw has some weird things in its kit and is overall a spec that crutches on weird interactions

#

ench shaman is just "you use many abilitys, your procs hit HARD"

tepid hornet
#

on multiple targets that live more than garrote duration, and you dont have vanish, how do u reapply garrotes? u dont wait pandemic?

#

bcos the cd makes it hard i think

royal lantern
#

you spread your bleeds in aoe once wide

#

after that its mostly just "keep them running on important targets"

tepid hornet
#

does rupture also have some kind of empowerment like garrote does after stealth?

#

it doesnt right?

marble hemlock
#

through Nightstalker, but nearly as potent

misty holly
#

Did they really just make feint a dps move for outlaw/sub? Those poor rogues lol.

vestal wren
proven jasper
#

Oh please no

royal lantern
proven jasper
#

dont do that to me

vestal wren
#

yes

royal lantern
#

we need to dig deeper

#

into bad mechanics

proven jasper
#

NO DEFENSIVE BUTTONS AS OFFENSIVE

vestal wren
#

cloak of shadows is also a brilliant idea

#

but i rly like the sprint idea

proven jasper
#

Yeah cloak gives +15% magic damage

#

Great idea

vestal wren
#

because you need to actively need to run through your targets

proven jasper
#

Makes sure to cloak last 6 seconds of your kb

misty holly
#

cloak reflecting magic damage would be kinda cool. But come on dont turn defensives into rotation abilities

proven jasper
#

If it reflected it, itd just be spell reflect for warriors

loud light
vestal wren
#

could be a talent node

#

we already have almost half of the tree done

#

nice

weary stump
#

Clearly what they need to do is give us a pocket sand ability in outlaw assassination

proven jasper
#

i just hope deathstalker gives us some real cool stuff

#

Im very hopeful

#

Even after seeing the trickster tree

subtle tundra
#

i have 0 expectations

#

i'd rather them not do hero talents lol

#

and just expand the normal tree

proven jasper
#

Shit id be happy if they gave us even one of the defensive talents sub/law have

#

not fair they get them all

weary stump
#

Give us the ability to sap people in combat

vestal wren
#

deathstalker is the one i look for the most tbh

proven jasper
#

Same

#

to me it seems like the one that can be fucked up the least

#

but idk

grizzled jay
#

Oh shit we have talents

proven jasper
#

Yeah sub/law tree is out

misty holly
#

thing is, if feint still worked like it did in 2004 where it was just threat reduction then okay cool. This tree would be fine with that version of feint. But we already got the bonus effects to feint when they made it reduce aoe damage - now that is the primary function of the ability. Even being called "feint" today is like a legcy thing that isn't indicitive of what the skill does anymore.

vestal wren
#

trickster, at least from the name seemed like one of the coolest themes

#

you could do all kind of trickery/illusion stuff

proven jasper
#

i expected it to be a pvp tree kinda but

vestal wren
#

missed oppotunity

proven jasper
#

Yeah

#

Bigtime

vestal wren
#

now its

#

"haha, i used a defensive BUT ACTUALLY i used a offensive"

proven jasper
#

Not even a hidden opportunity just a missed one OMEGAKEKW

vestal wren
#

🤯

proven jasper
#

yeah i dont like that

#

ngl i already dont even like pressing feint

grizzled jay
#

That talent tree seems really bad for Outlaw!

#

Why we pushing Outlaw towards Mastery lol

proven jasper
#

Yeah like

#

Atleast it seems USABLE for sub?

vestal wren
#

its interessting

proven jasper
#

Atleast a little bit

vestal wren
#

well keep in mind

#

its the first iteration

grizzled jay
proven jasper
#

but like it straight up forces outlaw into ks which is dog

vestal wren
#

so it shows the direction they want to go in tww

proven jasper
#

ks is just a terrible ability rn

#

yeah it does

vestal wren
#

but isn't a complete thing

grizzled jay
#

This would be like if they attached the same idea to Exsang for Sin

vestal wren
#

tww is still quite a bit away and its likly that we see changes

proven jasper
#

just feels like they picked the least used abilities

#

and tried to make them do something

uneven bronze
#

when they see how unhappy people are they probably will make changes no?

vestal wren
#

i do like the distract idea

grizzled jay
#

They will

#

They changed Oracle already

proven jasper
#

The distract idea actually got my attention a little too

#

Also like

#

Ive been wanting smoke bomb as a pve ability

#

For a min

#

Could easily do something with smoke bomb

vestal wren
#

it might be just flavor, its unclear if its a smoke bomb effect

#

could be just fancy visuals

proven jasper
#

yeah probably knowing blizz

spice surge
misty holly
#

Bringing smoke bomb back as a pve ability would be ideal.

spice surge
#

Like for example when people heard the "meme dragonflying boss" was gonna be the penultimate boss everybody said it was doomed

proven jasper
#

i mean im pretty sure the feint thing actually is going to be real strong

#

it just sounds like ass

spice surge
#

Turns out its among the best bosses they've ever made

proven jasper
#

Agreed actually tindral is a dope boss

misty holly
spice surge
#

But ye having 30%+ uptime on a 50% aoe reduction is gonna be insanely strong

proven jasper
#

Yeah man

spice surge
#

We're already immortal anyway

proven jasper
#

outlaw is only getting tankier

#

Real cool

#

meanwhile still not even 1 defensive talent in ass tree dogeing

vestal wren
misty holly
uneven bronze
vestal wren
#

i agree that its unclear how the changes play out, it seems less prblematic overall

#

the tree is fine, but it only has small parts that seem exciting

proven jasper
spice surge
#

It does damage and gives combo points

#

Does pressing shiv feel terrible as assa?

proven jasper
#

Yeah i mean theyre basically making it part of the rotation

#

Just give outlaw cannonball barrage at this point also

tepid hornet
#

at how many targets u use fan instead of mutilate?

proven jasper
grizzled jay
#

What's Unseen Blade

vestal wren
marble hemlock
# spice surge Worth keeping in mind a lot of the times people have no idea what they'd actuall...

I'm gonna shit on your parade and say that having even more utility tied to DPS to the point where the utility has to fall to the way side if you want to do maximum DPS; which is what the game will be tuned around, will essentially once again lock us into a situation where we have to forcibly choose between doing less DPS or not having the same utility.

I think after all those years of complaining about tricks being a DPS Increase that eventually got removed, and all the years of complaining about vanish being a DPS CD for us, but not the other specs, they are going more and more in the wrong direction with this.

Vanish is now a big DPS CD for all specs, probably more so for Outlaw/Sub than us at this point, and this feint/distract stuff just exacerbates the issue.

vestal wren
#

initial point in the hero talent tree

tepid hornet
#

pog

#

thats sick

grizzled jay
#

Hmm

#

Feint being permanently added to rotation is weird

marble hemlock
#

I don't see why this stuff has to be tied to utility skills, instead of introducing either new skills that do the exact same (smoke bomb instead of distract, revealing strike instead of this feint stuff), or at least tie it to actual dps skills.

spice surge
tepid hornet
#

dont think that means we will use feint every 5 sec thats a bit weird no?

spice surge
#

But like, does pressing shiv as assa feel horrible?

marble hemlock
#

Warriors had the same shit with ignore pain giving a dmg buff and they hated it too. I honestly' dont know anybody who actually likes it.

tepid hornet
#

feint on cd xD

marble hemlock
#

Outside of raging, ofc not, because it just does that one thing, which is DPS: It doesn't have any other value, because lets face it, the 70% crippling slow from shiv has no use in pve.

vestal wren
#

smoke bomb distract seems fine

#

it just adds a trade off

royal lantern
grizzled jay
#

The 1hr Tricks is really cool!

royal lantern
#

tindral is not really liked eleem

marble hemlock
#

"we need you to distract a pack in a minute" "sorry that means ill do 10% less dps this pull" "just get a warrior, at least he buffs battleshout"

spice surge
royal lantern
#

i wish

proven jasper
#

Yes

royal lantern
#

not legal

#

and im poor

grizzled jay
vestal wren
marble hemlock
#

for 5 sec, vs distracts 10

misty holly
#

Lets play a game of guess which underused skill will become part of our rotation with the other paths.
Death Stalker: Shadowstep scares your target and your next ambush or backstab deals an additional 500% damage. - Detect Traps also detects the weakness in your opponents armor all damage increased by 10% for 6 seconds.

Fatebound: When safefall triggers the fates are on your side, all abilities have cooldown reduced by 15 seconds. Kick: when a spell is kicked the opponent curses your name, but the gods are on your side and instead they are cursed and take extra damage for 6 seconds.

marble hemlock
#

so you can choose to only have 33% of the fazed uptime you could have, or 100%. that seems like a really bad decision to be forced into for utility vs dps

grizzled jay
vestal wren
#

*both is 5 secs

proven jasper
#

I can totally see the shadowstep one too

vestal wren
#

feint is 5 secs too

proven jasper
#

oh boy

vestal wren
#

so its not as dire

marble hemlock
normal mist
#

Me reading the Trickster stuff: "yadayadayada Fazed yadayadayada Fazed"

marble hemlock
vestal wren
#

ye, so ideally you can get 15 secs of fazed from it

marble hemlock
#

distract is gonna be a 90sec dps cd on 2 specs that can reduce CD

misty holly
marble hemlock
#

and its gonna be aoe fazed

grizzled jay
vestal wren
#

it allows some optimization around dps for sure

marble hemlock
#

like, rotationally speaking, i think this trickster tree is really fucking good. i just dont understand why it has to be tied to:

  1. a utility cd
  2. a defensive cd
  3. an outlaw capstone talent
  4. forces sub into playing dust
proven jasper
#

if theres no seal fate talent synergy ill be real surprised

vestal wren
#

you probably want to use secret and feint thi

#

because both proc

#

so you want the mastery for your aoe

spice surge
vestal wren
#

means smoke bomb is just in terms of optimization lower in priority

#

still not a fan of feint as offensive cd

marble hemlock
#

coup de grace is interesting design, although i think it misses the mark because while youll want to get the damage amp on your big hits, youre not gonna hold your sectec or ks just because youre already at 2 unseen dagger stacks. sure, you could feint twice to get the amp but now youve just spent 2 GCDs just to get to 4 instead of sending everything on CD like always

youll also get the mastery bump after using your big hit, which is weird.

vestal wren
#

i assume the mastery is after the initial secret hit

#

what could make it perfectly fine

marble hemlock
#

it doesnt proc on sectec

#

it procs on evis/bp

vestal wren
#

flawless form says "secret technique"

marble hemlock
#

im talking about coup de grace

#

which gives 5 stacks of flawless form

vestal wren
#

oh yes sry missed that

marble hemlock
#

so youll get 15% mastery after using evis/bp/ks with 4 unseen blade stacks. so do you hold sectec if youre at 3 stacks already? do you use feint, potentially overcap cp? it just screams "shtech 2.0" to me

#

but i think it could lead to interesting reactive gameplay

#

just... why feint kekdog

spice surge
#

Why would you hold

#

Its not capped

marble hemlock
#

because youd wanna use the sectec after you get the 5 stack mastery buff, not before

normal mist
#

Won't it be a problem if those specs turn into a feint spam and they wont have it for actually defensive stuff or it will be up so often that it wont matter?

marble hemlock
#

and still have 1 feint charge left for defense

spice surge
minor gate
#

Giving mastery to outlaw as well doesn’t seem that good

marble hemlock
#

they can just change what stat it gives, its the idea thats important

#

cause that is likely going to stay

vestal wren
#

auto attacks triggering unseen blades is def. an interessting decision

marble hemlock
#

just sounds like shtech to me

#

idk

vestal wren
#

well it plays into coup

#

because it does remove control

marble hemlock
#

instead of auto attacks giving energy/cp, you get a stack of unseen blade which will give you fazed and stack up towards the coup the grace proc

pseudo hamlet
#

what the fuck are these hero talents omegalul hahahaha

marble hemlock
#

i legit think if you replace "feint" with "new skill#1" and "distract" with "new skill#2" this tree would be banger

minor gate
#

Making tricks an hour is wild though

vestal wren
#

idk, i don't think its a banger

normal mist
#

dungeon wise its cool

#

since there's only 1 tank really

marble hemlock
#

theres enough in it that it might favor certain talents, and if you dont like those talents, youll just play the other hero tree. and its impactful and rotationally impactful enough, that it might change the way you play or create reactive gameplay. i think thats great.

proven jasper
#

The only banger talent in there is the hour long tricks tbr

vestal wren
#

the smoke bomb talent could be nice or dissapointing

normal mist
#

BACK IN MY DAYS IT USED TO BE A DEFENSIVE! (feel old yet?)

marble hemlock
#

its weird that theyre giving 10% crit to finishers vs fazed, and 25% cdam to builders kekdog

pseudo hamlet
#

Fatebound hero talent idea: Whenever you lock pick your haste is increased by 5% for 10 seconds.

minor gate
marble hemlock
#

"Pickpocket now grants you 1% Haste for 1 hr, stacking up to 20 times"

#

Go pickpocket some trash before raid

lean aurora
normal mist
bright turret
#

Already have enough buttons as it is, don't really need new skills just so a hero tree is less garbage

marble hemlock
#

at least this means

#

rogue will be perma pick in MDI again because itll pull 15 different packs for the tank while theyre scratching their balls

#

think theyll have to limit the range of tricks to like 40y or 50y instead of 100, cause otherwise this might lead to... things.

grizzled jay
#

Make it 1000

marble hemlock
#

especially because its only the activation thats limited to 100y, once its triggered and you have the 6sec buff, you can pull whatever you want with it

grizzled jay
#

Let us snapshot minibosses to the tank

grizzled jay
#

Have Rogue go pull the dino miniboss on to Rezan 😌

marble hemlock
#

then have it randomly reset because your tank got hit by storming

#

oh wait thats already happening now

agile geode
#

They see rogue tank on SoD and they tought "why not even on retail?"starege

arctic socket
#

Rogue in sod is in a bad spot

sharp viper
#

just read the new talent tree

arctic socket
#

Rogue be getting shitted on in retail

#

Everywhere

arctic socket
forest nacelle
#

or are you talking about pug life?

marble hemlock
#

sub is doing very well

#

outlaw has an unusable damage profile

#

assa is just the little brother that wasnt planned but your parents got too drunk on eggnog after christmas

forest nacelle
#

i tried playing sub in an 18 for giggles, how do ppl play it....

marble hemlock
forest nacelle
#

you know what i mean.....

marble hemlock
marble hemlock
#

but ye idk

#

shadowdust isnt fun to play, imo

#

its awkward

raven egret
#

I mean, sub doing good but I feel Shadowdust created a rift between people who played it - it's taken the spec over and thats not fun. Thankfully they do dmg so, yay...

marble hemlock
#

but you get used to it

#

i think if sub did bad damage

#

there would be a lot more criticism about it

forest nacelle
#

i can't do AoE with sub. i guess my brain is just DoT oriented.

bright turret
#

it's easy to like it when it makes sub the best raid spec in the game

raven egret
#

Sin is taken over by KB but at least I like that ability.

tepid hornet
#

the only thing kinda feel off on assass is ur sprint is literally 1 min

marble hemlock
#

but it has crazy good damage patterns so its very strong on basically every important fight this tier

tepid hornet
#

u cant reduce it can u?>

raven egret
marble hemlock
tepid hornet
#

well its still good

marble hemlock
#

between having high base ms, sprint and 2 steps, i dont think ive ever run into mobility issues

tepid hornet
#

not sayinnn

forest nacelle
#

but i got 12% leech šŸ˜„

#

instead of 6%

tepid hornet
#

and also

#

u basically cant go without thistle tea? its significant dmg from any other talent for that point?

#

my stats are not good but when i sim without thistle tea it was 8% dmg loss

#

dunno if its correct

#

thats pretty big

proven jasper
#

tea is big for us

#

Mastery buff = huge, plus the energy considering we are the most energy starved rogue spec

marble hemlock
#

having more energy is just very nice

proven jasper
#

Yes

forest nacelle
#

its the mastery for KB which was important

proven jasper
#

yeah i mean currently all roads lead to kb

forest nacelle
#

yea

tepid hornet
#

is there builds that dont use shiv rotationally?

#

or thats big dmg too?

spice spire
#

No

#

Buffs nature damage. And we do a lot of nature damage

marble hemlock
#

hope yall ready for dmg amp after shadowstep to snapshot your dots.

#

for the sub+assa tree

vestal wren
#

sub + outlaw -> feint is a dps cooldown
sin + outlaw -> sprint is a dops cooldown
sub + sin -> shadowstep is a damage cooldown

grizzled jay
sharp viper
#

wdym? there's gonna be a rune to run around like in the legion world quests, once you do that for 2-3 laps you get a damage amplification after you shadow step to a friendly target afterwards to an enemy target (damage increased by more rounds)

spice spire
#

Real

proven jasper
marble hemlock
#

ye, outlaw+sub gonna get "if youve run a full circle around the enemy target while sprint is active, your next finisher after your next 2 builders will have a 17% chance to proc a thing that lets your next vanish apply a buff to your next finisher"

proven jasper
#

If we have to be marathon men to do damage im going back to everquest

void mesa
proven jasper
#

Yes

void mesa
#

I kinda hope we dont get more "utility becomes dmg", I think the feint thing is "okay" but no more

spice spire
#

Also good job not being the first slow mode of spoiler season homies

#

I’m proud of u all

marble hemlock
#

i mean

sharp viper
marble hemlock
#

thats cause it doesnt affect us nearly as much

#

you think if this wouldve been a sub+assa tree, we wouldnt have gone slowmode already?

arctic socket
#

Ret paladin has a cool looking tree

#

Rogues tree is wierd

#

I don’t like jt

void mesa
spice spire
#

I’d be yelling at dumbasses

marble hemlock
#

exactly

gusty mirage
#

popping in to say nerf dust

spice spire
gusty mirage
#

feint as a dps cooldown is cringe

spice spire
#

Amen brethren

shy pecan
gusty mirage
#

and get me out of here

marble hemlock
#

i ate a bag of chips while trying to have a conversation about it in outlaw but was kinda impossible

spice spire
proven jasper
#

Yeah it was ww3 in there for a min

arctic socket
#

@spice spire can you give me a tree review?

gusty mirage
#

quake out here proud of the 3.5 people still playing assassination

#

times are tough

proven jasper
#

Who is the .5

sharp viper
void mesa
#

oh god what is happening in outlaw

gusty mirage
#

that's not hyperbole btw

arctic socket
spice spire
gusty mirage
#

feint + distract make you pew pew

spice spire
#

See the logic just not a fan

spice spire
#

I’m just around

gusty mirage
#

y'all hype for the 5% damage buff for shadowstepping the target?

arctic socket
#

So my defensive button is now

#

A damage thing

gusty mirage
#

if I'm right, I'm uninstalling wow

arctic socket
sharp viper
#

I wouldn't mind distract and pick pocket to be given an use mid combat

spice spire
#

About to shadowstep to u oxi

#

5% mental dam

bright turret
#

CoS becoming a DPS CD will be a banger obv

gusty mirage
bright turret
#

time to cull the weak

arctic socket
proven jasper
#

Pog

gusty mirage
#

any day now

#

SURELY

sharp viper
proven jasper
#

Omg recup BUFF MAYBE?

gusty mirage
void mesa
#

What if reapplying poisons is gonna give us a shorter dmg buff and we have to reapply the same poison we already have?

proven jasper
#

yes

#

LMAO

sharp viper
arctic socket
#

Bring back poison charges at this point

proven jasper
#

Honestly make poison last 10 mins only

spice spire
sharp viper
#

did you say vanishing powder?

proven jasper
#

I wanna have to keep reapplying

spice spire
gusty mirage
arctic socket
#

Only able to be applied in stealth

gusty mirage
#

door of shadows goated, venthyr since day 1 don't @ me

spice spire
#

Amen

#

I left for my love

arctic socket
#

Kyrian ability was goat

spice spire
sharp viper
#

ER was great fun*

proven jasper
#

Flag + kb combo surely balanced just give it to us

spice spire
#

Sbs literally goat ability

#

Fleshcraft double goat

arctic socket
#

Naw

spice spire
#

Ye

arctic socket
#

Kyrian ability hit different

#

Even if the tmog was shit

proven jasper
#

nah cant defend u on that one nephew

spice spire
#

That’s my bit wtf

proven jasper
#

LMAO

#

i aint hears someone call anyone nephew in years

arctic socket
#

Been out uncled

#

Damn

spice spire
oak sky
sharp viper
proven jasper
spice spire
sharp viper
#

congratulations, grab a marriage certificate and a pitchfork on your way out

arctic socket
#

Aunt kastle, will you give me a log review?

spice spire
arctic socket
#

Take your meds old man @spice spire

spice spire
#

Got no meds. Just some migraine medication for u fucks sometimes SoCute

proven jasper
arctic socket
arctic socket
#

Sec

spice spire
arctic socket
spice spire
#

Proud of u for that one dog

arctic socket
#

Updogg

spice spire
#

Man it feels like wrongdog in here

proven jasper
#

I calls it like i sees it

#

Whats wrongdog

spice spire
#

God I miss her

proven jasper
#

u can tell me

#

me too

spice spire
#

Amen big dog

#

@ember mural it’s a joke

#

Smdh

ember mural
#

I will not suck anything ty

spice spire
#

??????

proven jasper
#

LMAO

shy pecan
proven jasper
#

HUH

ember mural
#

Idk suck my dick hater popped into my head

spice spire
#

Unironically the second person that’s said that to me

ember mural
spice spire
ember mural
#

I'm unhinged

spice spire
#

Brother

#

I been holding it in

#

It’s about to get wicked

proven jasper
spice spire
ember mural
spice spire
gusty mirage
#

im too busy eating to actively judge you but know I'm judgng you

spice spire
proven jasper
#

I read that as edating

spice spire
proven jasper
#

ur so right

#

Ive been infected

spice spire
#

Unluigi

grizzled jay
proven jasper
sharp viper
grizzled jay
#

quake knows I'm right

proven jasper
#

I know you could be right and thats what scares me

royal lantern
#

its a good day to be awake

#

cus i saw that we didnt get that pile of shit tree

proven jasper
#

i can only imagine this channel if any of our trees are that cursed

royal lantern
#

i mean, i can understand them rn

#

cus man, its Bad bad

#

with a capital B

gusty mirage
proven jasper
#

i dont even like pressing it as a defensive

gaunt moat
#

wth, they released hero talents for everything but assassination šŸ‘ŗ

royal lantern
royal lantern
#

monk says whats up

proven jasper
#

Lock too

#

The lock ones kinda goated

royal lantern
#

lock got one

#

and its good

#

like, really good

proven jasper
#

Yeah that one sounds suck

gaunt moat
#

We don't to whataboutism here

#

i only complain about rogue

royal lantern
#

what the trees are supoosed to be, your overall gameplay gets improved

#

and not this shity "we make a minigame on top of your gameplay xd"

proven jasper
#

Id say they actively made the gameplay for both trickster specs WAY WORSE lmao

proven jasper
#

Like tf is sub gonna do

royal lantern
#

that tree has legit 0 salvagable stuff

except the meme 1hour tricks OMEGAKEKW

proven jasper
#

Seriously

gaunt moat
#

I'm just reading it now
using utilities for DPS omega cringe

proven jasper
#

Sub rogues gonna be quadruple feinting in openers OMEGAKEKW

royal lantern
#

like, i get the base idea

"use your deffensive abilitys and get rewarded for it"

#

just

#

thats NOT HOW IT WORKS BLIZZARD

#

its the opposite, you gonna use feint on cd for dmg, and not for deffensive value OMEGAKEKW

vestal wren
#

i like defensives/utility and offensive strictly seperated

gaunt moat
#

It's bad enough we use vanish for DPS
why do they have to triple down on bad ideas?

vestal wren
#

hot take, i think vanish is fine

marble hemlock
vestal wren
#

because vanish is more niche

proven jasper
#

I think vanish ended up being fine the way its used also

marble hemlock
#

vanish is fine for us now, but its not fine for outlaw/sub anymore. and in SL/BFA, vanish was too big of a dps increase for us to not use it just for utility

vestal wren
#

its just like shiv for assassiantion

gusty mirage
#

you only say its fine now because you were stockholmed into thinking its fine now

marble hemlock
#

if the dps gain is small, its barely acceptable imo

#

but overall i think

vestal wren
#

it can be annoying if you could utialize it better

gusty mirage
#

vanish is the same as it was in BFA

marble hemlock
#

utility being dps is fucking awful, or mobility for that matter. momentum for DH is fucking trash, dont @ me

gaunt moat
# vestal wren hot take, i think vanish is fine

It's not fine when you need to use it in dungeons for some mechanics, but you also need it for DPS
hecc, even in raids sometimes you need vanish (ex: roots on tindral. but yes, we have alternative in the form of cloak for that)

spice spire
#

Shiv vanish and feint as dps

marble hemlock
#

ye but bfa had SS and 75% subterfuge, so not using it on cd for dps was pretty noticeable, whereas now its "just" an MA buff and one NS snapshot

spice spire
marble hemlock
#

not being able to vanish the fixate from rezan for example

#

is just ass

royal lantern
#

realz, if you read us, please for the love of god, bring it back too the drawing board, its really not a good idea

and thats not the ussual "tryan is bitching all the time" cus i wont even play sub/outlaw anyway, but man just the idea reads so bad, i feel bad for the outlaw/sub players

marble hemlock
#

especially when other specs can use theirs freely

#

dont see hunters or mages getting dps increases from their combat-dropping abilities that can be used to avoid certain mechanics

vestal wren
#

i think mage had some similar issues

royal lantern
marble hemlock
#

imagine if blink gave a dmg amp

royal lantern
#

rn

marble hemlock
#

instead of being used for repositioning

royal lantern
#

where frost shield gives dmg

#

(its bad)

vestal wren
#

i remember mages complain about it

gaunt moat
grizzled jay
#

Outlaw channel seems to like the tree lol

gaunt moat
#

That should tell you everything

royal lantern
proven jasper
#

Zac was calling it pure garbage an hour ago what happened

spice spire
#

Afaik neither like it

grizzled jay
past forum
#

i was hoping they'd hate it so i could go in and say "what are y'all complaining about? it's amazing for pvp"

royal lantern
#

what do i hate about assa

#

lol

spice spire
spice spire
royal lantern
#

its not even a issue for assa

spice spire
#

Amen

royal lantern
#

its pointless, but not big for the spec

grizzled jay
spice spire
#

Gabagool

proven jasper
#

Sin rn i feel is the best its been in a long min

#

its not perfect or anything

grizzled jay
past forum
#

holy smokes, pick pocket range increased??? sorry boys, rerolling to outlaw

proven jasper
#

Fuck exsang

grizzled jay
proven jasper
#

Exsang was ASS

shy heron
#

All my homies hate exsang

royal lantern
spice spire
#

Don’t listen to me tho, I’m literally an idiot

proven jasper
#

You’re completely right though

#

Its great rn

grizzled jay
proven jasper
#

Parsing is BS though

gaunt moat
spice spire
gaunt moat
#

no you don't

proven jasper
#

he definitely doesnt

grizzled jay
gilded oasis
#

I care, getting close to mobs is spooky

past forum
#

increased sap range is gonna change the game for wpvp

spice spire
#

You ever ran the SD gauntlet and some idiot pulled one of the guards before hand

#

Increased range

#

Would have fucked with the lights on

balmy condor
#

the node is for the blind/shroud cooldown, the rest is just flavor

gilded oasis
balmy condor
#

thing that confuses me is why feint and distract are dps cooldowns

#

that's cooked

gilded oasis
#

burnt*

proven jasper
#

One good talent in that tree

#

is depressing

spice spire
past forum
#

the flavor is me bein rich cause i pick pocket every bitch in the city

spice spire
#

Soon cloak and evasion will also be Dam abilities

balmy condor
#

like the tree is great, except for the feint/distract stuff being attached to damage

#

cause like

#

fuck that

spice spire
#

Based

gaunt moat
#

How come kick doesn't do DPS though starege

spice spire
past forum
#

every rogue ability in the spellbook will now be worth dps and become part of the rotation

gilded oasis
spice spire
#

Choose between step and kick for dps

proven jasper
balmy condor
#

the whole fazed thing is fine, flawless form is good, nimble flurry and coup de grace, all fine

#

whole thing is good

#

but then they just hamfisted feint and distract into it

#

for fun

gilded oasis
#

"sorry guys can't kick I used it for combo points and damage amp"

spice spire
#

Utility/defensive abilities being tied to damage sucks

#

Even beyond rogue. Hated the IP arms meta

proven jasper
#

I think hed block me

past forum
#

pretty new to rogue, has vanish always been this important for dps? and will it likely stay this way?

gilded oasis
#

at least all my missed kicks would be worth something right?

marble hemlock
proven jasper
#

hahaha

spice spire
spice spire
marble hemlock
spice spire
#

Babe?

#

@ both

gilded oasis
#

Judge?

spice spire
#

Sup dog

gilded oasis
#

Kitten would like more snack but I said she had enough for the morning, how do you rule?

spice spire
#

Please feel free to appeal to the next level court

gilded oasis
#

fk ok

#

back to dooming

gaunt moat
#

Which other buttons do we have as rogue that they can make us use in other trees

gilded oasis
#

Detect

gaunt moat
#

Cloak of shadows is DPS?

proven jasper
#

detect traps

#

cant wait for that one

gilded oasis
#

yeah you detect more weakness and get a 3% dps boost

proven jasper
#

shit goes so hard

gilded oasis
#

pick lock?

proven jasper
#

yeah we had a little idea for that one

gilded oasis
#

pick the enemie's belt buckle and his pants fall down, increasing damage he takes by 4% for 5 seconds

proven jasper
#

Not sure im a big fan though LMAO

gaunt moat
#

oh no, i just realized what they're gonna do

gaunt moat
#

They're gonna make using SnD while SnD is active do more damage, so it'll be part of your rotation

proven jasper
proven jasper
#

oh god no

gilded oasis
#

bringing up SND just made my cat almost puke on my head

#

she hates SND

gaunt moat
#

good cat

balmy condor
#

you sure it's a cat and not a bunny?

gilded oasis
#

hmmm 82% sure its a cat

balmy condor
#

I'll take those odds

gaunt moat
gilded oasis
gaunt moat
#

wait, it's the otherway around

gilded oasis
#

I hope they buff poisoned knife

balmy condor
#

I don't want to find a keybind for poisoned knife

gilded oasis
#

wym its shift 2