#assassination

1 messages · Page 307 of 1

drifting cloud
#

yes

sinful latch
#

Ty

green apex
#

Does Deathmark make Slicing Malestrom from the Whetstone double tap?

spice spire
#

No

green apex
#

Weird. Feels like it's doing more damage as Assassination but I think I may just be going crazy.

balmy condor
#

Trinkets inherently don’t interact with any spec mechanics

limber lion
#

okay finally got 424 dagger and the stupid eranog ring. hold on to your parses boys.

balmy condor
#

EXCEPT GS AND BTE BEFORE THE OUTLAWS CLOWN ON ME FOR LIKE THE FIFTH TIME I KNOW YES

limber lion
green apex
#

That's why I asked NGL. Fury warrior in my guild asked me how my Whetstone was slapping so hard and my response was "im sub it does more dmg with find weakness" then I realized I was a posion fella

#

and I was like uhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

#

no idea

limber lion
#

whetstone slapping hard

twin iron
#

did you tell him to git gud?

limber lion
#

I'm confused

#

oh the trinket

#

lmao

#

bye

gaunt moat
#

Me everytime i'm looking at other rogues logs

static glacier
#

you don't get windfury

#

wth

gaunt moat
limber lion
#

windfury is like 20k extra raid dps

#

basically a mandatory raid buff

gaunt moat
#

no WW either

spice spire
limber lion
#

ww?

spice spire
#

Monk

royal lantern
#

i mean, dont need a ww when you have a monk tank

spice spire
#

Debuff

royal lantern
limber lion
#

doesn't need to be windwalker

#

can be mw or bm

spice spire
#

I assume is what he meant in general

#

Is just no monk

gaunt moat
#

ah, no, actually i wasn't aware brewmaster also applies the debuff

empty tangle
#

What proffesion should i get for assasination rogue?

gaunt moat
#

there are no "spec-specific" professions.
you can buy anything through AH or work orders, and it would probably be cheaper than leveling a profession.

That being said - alchemy is usually pretty safe choice, since it allows for phials to last longer than 30 minutes, thus saving a lot of money.

prisma monolithBOT
frozen iris
#

!whispyr

empty tangle
#

Thank you. Probably i go with these.

stiff vale
#

Imo only go engi if you're planning to craft stuff from previous xpac, or if you have a lot of gold. It's just a complete money sink right now, and honestly a lot of the things engis make kind of suck right now. Brez bracers have been clutch for me many times tho I guess (when it doesn't fail)

#

I've had it fail a few times, but it's never been drastic with the talents you mentioned. I'll just press it again after I'm out of whatever CC it puts me into lol

royal lantern
#

ye, they made the rez more reliable for engineers

#

at the start the engi rez was 200%troll

#

had like 25% sucess chances with all stuff maxed out lmao

sacred gate
static glacier
#

you should sbs before cds, your rupture isn't max pandemic'd before exsang

#

you forgot to tea while on 3 charges with dm / shiv in cds

spice spire
#

You’re missing a lot of the basic things

#

I’d recommend looking at WoW analyzer (can’t believe I’m actually able to say this, ty @main vessel ) to fix a lot of your errors

#

And then after that we can look at some more in depth things to fix 🙂

sacred gate
#

Great thank you

limber lion
#

monkaS opener

#

take damage = press all defensives at once

thorn fjord
#

atleast they didnt exsang their dm

#

mfw you find out their boon button has evasion feint and cloak all macro'd together

sacred gate
#

Alright don't take the piss lol

spice spire
#

But yeah. Foundation is a bit shaky but there. Analyzer will help the super basic kinks. Then we work on opener etc

royal lantern
#

nobody is taking a piss, dont worry

limpid ermine
#

Make sure you use vanish in your rotation as well 🫡

sacred gate
#

Thx looking at Analyzer now, starting to make sense

runic hinge
nocturne current
#

I had to run away here from off topic.

thorn fjord
#

Yo hyper

#

Add me to that blizzard disc

#

Lol

nocturne current
#

Oh it's the second one on the search list but since it's not verified I doubt it's legit from Blizzard tho sadly.

thorn fjord
#

Ahh

thorn fjord
#

@gusty mirage laying down the law like a proper lawman

main vessel
#

I haven’t worked on it in a bit, but I’m planning to get back to it soon

#

Maybe sub/outlaw if I have the time for it and a honey do list of things

thorn fjord
#

Sub is actually super easy to play

novel arrow
#

Hey my friend just got back to the game. Is the Catalyst locked at 1 per week? Or can he get all 4 uses today?

main vessel
#

Whispyr told me there was less of a need for it for sub

novel arrow
#

He got 1. But he doesn't know how to get the other ones

limber lion
#

I just went from very mediocre gear to really good gear in one raid lol

#

eranog ring and 2 424 daggers

nocturne current
thorn fjord
#

I bet your “mediocre” gear was still based

limber lion
#

that took a while

thorn fjord
#

But that is huge

limber lion
#

pants

#

missing a bunch

spice spire
thorn fjord
#

What’s your IL now?

limber lion
#

418, boots are 408 so tanking it a bit

nocturne current
#

please be 420..

#

Damn, it's only 1 above me lul

thorn fjord
#

No more sparks? Why not just craft boots

#

I’m 417 also

#

If you craft boots you’ll for sure the higher IL boots right after

#

On account of how the universe works

limber lion
#

I probs have a spark left in me

#

I've been warming up the bench for good over a month

#

haven't really been playing the game at all

nocturne current
#

Craf that shit yo.

limber lion
#

killing rasz for the first time today lol

brazen zodiac
#

lol

thorn fjord
#

You’ll get your pants today then

limber lion
#

Surely Prayge

nocturne current
#

All I need is the damn daggers to complete the transmog set.

#

It looks like I'm wearing Gucci, but then I drive a Honda Minivan.

thorn fjord
#

Aint nothing wrong with that

#

All i really NEED is eggnog ring at this point

#

Really dont even give a shit.. sitting at 4 keys done for the week and i aint doing anymore

nocturne current
#

I literally had same dilema

limber lion
#

glad boys are done with prog and I'm allowed to join reclears now

brazen zodiac
#

any alts u game on?

limber lion
#

nah I've been super busy irl

toxic burrow
#

Playing my butt off 95% of the time with my guild during raids. Doing solid DPS and mechanics perfectly.

The 5%? Wow, I really spaced out while listening to my RL and... Oh. Forgot my food buff, my phial expired, whiffed my rotation. (And of course we kill the boss when this happens.)

spice spire
#

Happens to the best of us

frigid pilot
#

is there a bis list that doesnt feature rng 421 vault bullshit?

limber lion
#

No because then it wouldn't be bis

#

and bis lists are dumb

frigid pilot
#

i alrdy ran droptimizers across m+15s raid etc. but as stat scaling changes with secondaries etc. kinda hard to have an accurate picture of what to chasedown besides giga rng shit

royal lantern
#

thats the point

#

bis doesnt exist anymore cus of that

#

espacily because secondarys most of the time are not even a really gigantic difference

#

your "BiS" is: get the best trinkets of the patch, and the high ilvl stuff from the last 2 raid bosses

#

and then highest ilvl on all other slots, preferably with stats that are somewhat better then the other stats for you

limber lion
#

What he said

#

There's no breakpoints which would skyrocket one item from 150 dps to 1k dps. If an item is like 200 dps for you now, it'll be around 200 dps for you regardless of what gear upgrades you might get for other slots before it.

snow zenith
brazen zodiac
#

siege has a pretty high chance to drop a spark i tell you haha

thorn fjord
#

fake news

#

been wanting to craft an OL MH and not a single spark has dropped for me since the last guaranteed one 😦

brazen zodiac
#

have you done the siege every hour?

#

ive gotten a spark on 3 different characters now :o

thorn fjord
#

LOL

#

Guess i should try

brazen zodiac
#

now wait before yo ulaugh

#

u can afk it!

#

what i did for cope was complete all WQs then just spam siege/kill biscus on the hour mark and its worked so hehe

#

idk if u actually have to complete all wqs i think u spamming the siege just counts as u doing all kinds of content so

thorn fjord
#

Sounds like id actually have to kind of play the game though

brazen zodiac
#

yeah

wet iron
#

hey, not really sure where to ask this, but around the 395 ilvl mark - with 4set bonus what kinda of aoe would one expect from assassin. i'm just using the 5 target dummies in valdrakken. the difference with my s.priest is vast. like 106k vs 190k - does that sound right ?

balmy condor
#

Seems realistic

#

You could always sim 5 target dummies

#

And then see if you can hit that number

#

Or at least get close

wet iron
#

so is assa much weaker then aoe wise? (sorry i dont know much about rogues)

#

vs the other specs

balmy condor
#

Than spriest? Yeah

#

Assassination does single target and single target

wet iron
#

and vs other rogue specs

balmy condor
#

For aoe it’s usually sub > outlaw > Assassination

royal lantern
#

assa is mid at best

#

soooooooooooooooooooooooo.............

wet iron
#

lol ye spriest is broken

#

how is sub at single target? is it much worse than assa - talking m+ mostly

balmy condor
#

Not really

wet iron
#

ah ok cool, thanks for that

#

helps to just have a better rough understanding

molten galleon
#

WE are progressing Senarth, and we are still missing some DMG in last Phase. Is there any good way to take 3th point of Zold? 🙂

grim tangle
#

just do more damage earlier in the fight you'll need less damage in the last phase

subtle tundra
keen spruce
#

Zoldyks gains more value when there is an execute phase that is either disproportionaley long or has some specific damage check/requirement during that execute. Sennarth can be burned down during the entire fight to shorten the execute so losing overall dps for more execute damage doesn't make sense

echo heath
#

Make IC work with deathmark and let sin be broken for a while

ebon notch
#

@keen spruce were you the one talking about blessing of autumn not doing anything?

ebon notch
#

it does work

#

we just tested it

keen spruce
#

someone else had brought it up but all of my testing showed that nothing was affected

ebon notch
#

reduced the cd of deathmark

#

@limber lion use smart words

limber lion
#

So the timers in WoW are dynamic as are most of weak auras because they are directly pulled from the game.

#

What you can do is set up a real timer and then press the ability

keen spruce
#

I was just lookin at the cooldown on my action bars

#

unless the display there is also wrong

limber lion
#

There is no display

#

It just goes down faster

keen spruce
#

can you elaborate

limber lion
#

You just set up a timer, press the ability during autumn then look at the remaining duration of the ability after autumn ends

#

Let's say you press Deathmark then get Autumn

#

After 30s of Autumn, your Deathmark will have charged 15s faster

#

meaning that the cooldown is 1minute 45s instead of 2 minutes

keen spruce
#

hmm

limber lion
#

It's not something that the game shows you with fancy texts or effects

keen spruce
#

but theres no visual indicator that would suggest it

limber lion
#

And it appears to go down just as slowly as it would normally because it's quite minimal

keen spruce
#

i mean like the cooldown text on your action bars

limber lion
#

Yeah

#

It just ticks down faster

keen spruce
#

it just counts faster

#

ah

limber lion
#

It doesn't go from 120s to 95s

#

because it's not an instant effect

#

Autumn is a 30s buff

keen spruce
#

Paladin discord thinks that it is supposed to affect all abilities

limber lion
#

And during that buff cooldowns recharge 30% faster

#

It does

keen spruce
#

i guess it would be even harder to see on shorter CDs

limber lion
#

Yep

keen spruce
#

cuz the difference is so minimal

#

hmm well good to know

#

not like we're getting it cast on us anyways, but at least it's not broken

limber lion
#

Yeah it works on every ability that has a cooldown

#

even stuff like shroud

keen spruce
#

yeah when i was testing i ripped everything that had a number with a mix of before it was cast/during it's cast. I expected to see a CD number adjusted by X amount instantly when cast during autumn.

frigid pilot
#

howcome i see people with super zoomed cam, i have cam maxed and even tried maxcam addon

#

not working

hollow river
frigid pilot
#

ye its at 2.6

hollow river
#

i thought that was the max

#

only addons i know of that have that function are leatrixplus and dynamicCam i think

thorn fjord
#

They fixed that a while back

#

You were able to push it back at the start of DF with a console command

#

Fuckers fixed it

vale shore
#

does anyone else's stealth and vanish buttons grey out when in certain areas such as Imbu in Azure Span?

hollow river
#

i know i used leatrix for all of SL for the extra cam zoom

storm forum
#

is a normal eranog ring worth over 415?

thorn fjord
#

@storm forum not for me

#

But I have brood heroic ring and 415 cos ring

#

Should try simming

storm forum
#

i guess i should just run the droptimizer

thorn fjord
#

Yeah that’s quick

storm forum
#

i was wondering before i got try to PUG normal

#

<.5% increase probably not worth the stam loss

thorn fjord
#

Eh if it’s an increase might as well pug jt… first boss shouldn’t be too much of a headache

amber briar
#

General question 35 crit 11 haste 37 mastery 9 vers seem off ? I’m 383 ^

mystic garden
#

anyone else running into energy problems

#

should i be pooling energy instead of using every GCD the second i have it

#

i feel like im doing something wrong

drifting cloud
#

pooling correctly is less than 1% overall dps gain

#

if anything you will lose more dmg trying to do it

mystic garden
#

joy

drifting cloud
#

but yes theres definetly times where you can just not do anything for 3-4 globals

#

but dont try to overthink it

mystic garden
#

fun

#

ok so im not crazy about that

#

ty

vale shore
#

take a breath, sip some thistle tea and get back in there!

vale shore
thorn fjord
#

No stealth zones

vale shore
#

sips thistle tea SPITS WHAT!?

tiny finch
#

what is the pandemic window for rupture again?

#

i know garrot is 6 sec

drifting cloud
#

!pandemic

prisma monolithBOT
#

Pandemic takes up to 30% of the duration of a applied dot/buff and adds it to your new applied one. The duration depends on the new instance.
Example: Garrote (18 sec) can be extended by up to 5.4 seconds from an existing instance.
Note: Pandemic applies to most but not all debuffs/buffs

tiny finch
#

ty!

#

do we need a weak aura to optmize pandemic tho?

#

im so rusty lmao

vale shore
#

I usually do it in the last quarter of the dot, just going off the icon

#

unless its an empowered garrote from stealth, then I hit it on the opener after lighting up slice n dice

tiny finch
#

i generally use 6 sec to reaply garrote

#

and 8 sec for rupture, but im just following the old glowy weak aura that i had

thorn fjord
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
tiny finch
#

oh great idea will steal from theirs

floral stone
#

trying to learn assass and just dbl checking since it doesnt directly state it in the faq, you dont save deathmark for exsanguinate windows on ST right, just only when they naturally overlap

lucid mirage
#

You only save death mark to pair with vanish for empowered garrote

#

but they should always come up together

floral stone
#

ok thats what i figured was just doubing checking, ty

keen spruce
#

you can hold exang for deathmark tho

static glacier
#

you can "hold" dm for exsang if the fight wouldn't allow for an extra dm

#

aswell

severe sparrow
#

ive been struggling with dmg compared to ilvl across all specs and i finally did the math and looked at other rogues, and compared to the other sin rogue in my raid i have 1k less agi and im not sure how

#

by gear, i have 26 more, and we use the same consumables

drifting cloud
#

unless theyre hacking their number is probably just with battle shout or whatever

#

and yours isnt

#

and maybe some other buffs

#

who knows when the log snapshots those stats

gusty mirage
#

no it's an issue with crafted gear

#

sometimes it pulls from wowhead's database

#

at like an obscenely high ilvl

drifting cloud
#

ah ok because im looking and I have 7.8k agi unbuffed ingame at 419ilvl

gusty mirage
#

ye

#

sometimes it pulls the dagger

#

at like

#

450 ilvl

#

for whatever fucking reason

severe sparrow
#

ohhh yup that's it

#

he's actuall 7452

#

he still hits like 2k harder than me on everything

gusty mirage
#

side by side, your average hits are actually more than his

#

the only thing he beats you on is garrote

severe sparrow
#

i also realized ive been forgetting to use my pots tonight

gusty mirage
#

ye that'll also do it

severe sparrow
tiny finch
#

thats so offensive lynari

severe sparrow
#

sorry cecil youre my favorite co-ass blushcatto

tiny finch
#

CO ASS

#

im reporting

severe sparrow
#

butt buddies

tiny finch
thorny pond
#

@spice spire

#

congrats!

spice spire
thorny pond
#

you did it?

spice spire
#

No

#

@oak sky just calls me a wife guy because I’m a major simp for my fiancée

#

Just a joke kekdog

grim tangle
#

gratz

thorny pond
#

ah

spice spire
#

Any askers?

oak sky
#

no

spice spire
#

Go back to ot papi

#

You’ve earned it

oak sky
#

dont have to tell me twice

echo heath
#

why cant my guild just live on spider boss

#

😢

#

bunch of greedy fucks

idle coyote
#

@balmy condor checking in on you after icey veins put us as the worst Mythic dps spec

#

Literally unplayable

odd dew
balmy condor
#

Tier list where?

#

By what content creator?

bronze pike
#

what but what about alll those aoe talents they made to improve sins aoe :)

idle coyote
balmy condor
#

No offense to @marble hemlock’s employer

#

But like

#

Icyveins Warcraftlogs reviews

#

Is uh

#

Not hitting that wide of an audience

idle coyote
#

Idk how to hide a message on cell phone so it’s not taking up everyone’s screen

balmy condor
#

Wake me up when the wowhead post comes out

#

People will read that

#

And shit post

balmy condor
#

You gotta put the link in the middle of them

idle coyote
balmy condor
#

My bad

#

I’ll write up a section on how to ignore Warcraftlogs charts

idle coyote
#

Ty I’m literally the last ranked dps I can’t play the game

balmy condor
#

Real

odd dew
# idle coyote That would be insane

Would it? I feel like I can keepup with other classes/specs when ID is available but do fuck all if we pull a pack and its not up.
Would making it a passive but capping your Rupture/Garrote to 8 targets not make us just consistant with pulls?

idle coyote
balmy condor
#

What’s ID

#

I didnt read

odd dew
#

IC sorry

balmy condor
#

Oh

#

IC being a passive would be stupid busted op yeah

#

At least for like 5-8 target

#

The capping thing is an interesting concept

#

Problem with that though is it would hurt our aoe a ton

#

Like academy would be unplayable

idle coyote
#

You don’t play sin for optimal aoe

balmy condor
#

Yeah but that’s what he’s trying to fix is it not

odd dew
#

Why would capping rupture/garrote to 8 targets make academy unplayable?
I feel you wouldnt be applying it anything more than that really with how IC is atm anyway.

And sure Sin isnt meant to be an AoE spec but we fall far behind other specs in AoE to just barely get infront for ST

idle coyote
#

Balance though

balmy condor
#

Yeah that’s fine

#

I thought you meant all bleeds

#

And capping ct to 8 would be killer

odd dew
#

Nah I just mean, IC is just a passive now but it caps at 8 so you cant just spam your bleeds and cheese big pulls

balmy condor
#

Sure

#

I mean it’s kinda already like that cause you have it every pull

#

There’s like a bit of downtime in the end of a pull

#

But yeah that’s definitely one way to buff it

odd dew
#

Some pulls feel awkward though, especially if you pull another pack halfway through one pull

balmy condor
#

Yeah but if you’re chain pulling you don’t really need to setup

#

You already have the energy

#

So you’re good to go

#

like it's a buff, of course

#

but if you're just gonna make it passive

#

then yeh

idle coyote
#

If it’s a high key I just go subt so I can turn off brain

balmy condor
#

the real benefit would be like 2-4 or 5 target

#

cause that's the part where IC kinda sucks

idle coyote
#

But tyran I’m mode popeye biscuit

balmy condor
#

it would make our cleave kinda ridiculous I would think

odd dew
#

Yeah small packs suck to deal with. I

balmy condor
#

but the aoe is mostly the same

odd dew
#

Yeah just a thought I had that might make us a bit more consistant throughout the dungeons

balmy condor
#

here's an idea for sin aoe right

idle coyote
#

The coolest thing would be if they removed puzzle box

balmy condor
#

CT explodes poisons on targets it hits

odd dew
#

oof sounds fun, like drops poison bombs?

odd dew
idle coyote
balmy condor
#

I was thinking more like you CT -> it takes like half the duration and it pops for aoe

#

would have to be like reduced or whatever

idle coyote
#

Wouldn’t that also be insane

balmy condor
#

yeah but there's a fuck ton of numbers you can tune on it

odd dew
balmy condor
#

could bring it in line eventually

#

like you can target cap that, make it deal reduced damage, lower the damage itself, lower the aoe

idle coyote
balmy condor
#

you could even like ICD it

#

so mobs can't get hit by more than 2 ticks of it

#

or whatever

#

plenty of ways to make it work

idle coyote
#

Lower IC cooldown

balmy condor
#

would be thematic and scale into aoe, which is kinda the real issue

#

like sin is good at 1-2, decent at 6-8ish, and kinda rubbish everywhere else

idle coyote
#

It pwns up let fly mythic+

balmy condor
#

AP could be the fix for anything less than 8, had they just decided to do any tuning

#

idk

#

there's still very core foundational problems with sin aoe

#

cause it's a spec that hasn't changed since cata

#

and CT is problematic, the gameplay loop just is janky lowkey

#

so really the solution should be a full rework of anything cleave/aoe

#

but that's a lot of work

#

so they could just duct-tape it like usual

#

and add some shit in

#

like the poison pops (it's just echoing blades don't tell anyone)

#

or some other thing

idle coyote
#

Kingsbane

balmy condor
#

kingsbane now applies to all targets in range

#

there

#

sin fixed

slow marsh
#

Broken

balmy condor
#

think about the aoe dance synergy though

#

see

#

not broken now

#

you just synergize the really op talent with the really shit talent

#

and they balance out

slow marsh
#

I mean you do big damn for 12 seconds or whatever every minute

#

But no shrouded suff

balmy condor
#

like seal fate being 18% in dslice

#

im actually a little confused why they don't let scent of blood go crazy

slow marsh
#

They really fuckd kb by putting it on DTB

balmy condor
#

like sin has issues ramping with more targets

#

just buff scent

#

idk

slow marsh
#

You would think

balmy condor
#

add garrote to scent, remove cap

#

sin aoe fixed

slow marsh
#

It also would give some measure of 'skill expression '

balmy condor
#

it really wouldn't

#

scent is just a passive IC buff

slow marsh
#

It wouldn't but you could tell the denters who ask for it that it is

#

I started a feral druid today and already at level 11 its bleeds are way more satisfying than the 2 we have

idle coyote
#

Furry

dreamy gull
#

Idk why it's so much fun to play bleed specs

jade abyss
#

You enjoy to see things dying slowly

gaunt moat
#

It's kinda satisfying to keep things up

snow zenith
#

hello can you explaing me why my casts of envenom has less average dmg?

balmy condor
#

less mastery, less agility, lower ilvl mainhand dagger, no puzzle box

#

also looks like you missed an ER cast, so you're probably casting with less average cp

#

you also missed a shiv cast, so that doesn't help either

#

you also cast less tea than him, had lower sophic devo uptime on that pull, lower lariat uptime, had less elaborate planning uptime

#

hope that helps @snow zenith

spice spire
#

Insert ibai meme

snow zenith
#

Thank you very much

gaunt moat
#

2nd week in a row of bottom overall DPS.
The buffs are DEFINTELY coming copium

balmy condor
#

top 3 in boss damage

#

unlucky

#

no buffs

gaunt moat
#

Explain BM
Checkmate atheists

balmy condor
#

bm now equal to rogue

#

buffs worked

gaunt moat
#

That's a very loose meaning of equal

balmy condor
#

yep

#

balanced

#

looks good to me

little light
#

its ok cause outlaw is lower

#

🙂

gaunt moat
#

Just WATCH them buff outlaw only.

little light
#

could happen

#

blizz balance = wildcard!

gaunt moat
#

Dartboart balancing

static glacier
green juniper
#

What u guys think

balmy condor
#

not really much to think about is there

#

their data says sin rogue does lower keys than sub and outlaw

#

seems reasonable to me, considering its the worst of the 3 specs in m+

#

worse spec does lower keys, lower keys means lower ranking

#

pretty straight forward stuff, dunno

subtle tundra
#

that list is not a how good the spec is list

balmy condor
#

yeh

#

I mean list just compares levels of keys done

subtle tundra
#

data interpretation is wild

balmy condor
#

sin doesn't do as high keys as sub/outlaw

static glacier
balmy condor
#

it's the worst of the 3

subtle tundra
#

so yea its bad data

gaunt moat
#

We can do 20s and people think we're subs when they invite
So we're all good kekw

brazen zodiac
#

do what i do when they ask why im sin

#

ask them why they arent unholy dk or BM or hunter or

static glacier
#

I mean the logs are public for these affixes

#

and just don't show up

gaunt moat
#

wtf does x with line over it mean

royal lantern
brazen zodiac
#

time to make a lightforged dk

royal lantern
#

they overbuffed frost dk by so much, people are just AGAIN to slow to catch on

static glacier
#

I play with a one trick frost dk and the 2nd dk played a lot of frost earlier into the expac, spec didn't seem bad

#

main issue is that breath isn't rewarding since they can keep it up permanently, just punishing if you get a mechanic or fuck up - shit design by blizz imo.

grim jay
static glacier
#

but im saying how they were before the buff

#

and why the class was seen as underpowered

vestal wren
grim jay
#

Breath is a shitty ability anyways, thats why I'm happy for every fdk that you will most likely play oblit everywhere in 10.0.7 if it goes like this

#

Oblit is badly designed aswell bcs your second ressource is basically useless, might aswell only have runes

#

But its way better than breath

royal lantern
#

figures why smoothbrains want that gameplay then dracthyr_kek

grim jay
nocturne current
#

But that, given the fact it's also mediocre in ST show how much love Blizzard has for assassination (again).

#

I was excited before the expansion until they started throwing all random nerfs and abilities.

brazen zodiac
#

just wait till our 5%

#

📈

#

🚀

gaunt moat
#

Anyday now copium

nocturne current
#

Never, because that would break PVP.

grim jay
#

Its still one of the better performing ST specs, so whatever. But some nerfs def werent needed

gaunt moat
#

Maybe after they nerf sin 3 more times in pvp

brazen zodiac
#

idk i was watching the arena stuff sin looks cool in pvp 👍

static glacier
#

if the repeat buffs to other specs didn't happen the sin nerf was justified

#

as it stands now they court revert the nerf and we's till be behind arms uh and bm

royal lantern
#

like, tuning abilitys up and down every patch in minigame mode only

#

oh w8, that happens every single patch

nocturne current
#

What specific PVP changes lol

#

Nerfing an item

#

Half the time they have no fucking clue what to do with PVP, they design for PVE and let PVP be what it is, then if it messes with PVP they just nerf PVE

#

Its been like this since the game beta

#

80% of the kit you use is the same from PVE, even the rotation's the same

#

None of the PVP specific talents have an impact that they just touch the PVP specific talents, they barely even touched then. They're so afraid of tuning PVP they rather nerf the set by a whole 50% than touch any core ability

#

Only reason why you don't use Sepsis as of now, it's just because the damage was so broken and unhealable already in PVP that if they made it viable in PVE it would break PVP

#

Unless they did a whole special passive for PVP only for it

balmy condor
#

you.... you do realize they do pvp only tuning right

#

they can tune them separately

verbal mantle
kind talon
royal lantern
#

litearlly the last balance change for assa was a PvP only change

kind talon
#

poor frost :(

royal lantern
#

lol

nocturne current
#

Yeah a lazy change, because they're so afraid of touching anywhere else but borrowed power.

#

Because anything they touch it would make it out scale and them having to re-calculate the abilities sclaing in pvp & pve all over again if they touch any ability.

#

Tune Bone Spike and now you have to dedicate man hours to recalculate all the scaling for pvp and pve separately.

verbal mantle
#

you should apply for a game designer job

#

definitely your stuff

nocturne current
#

Isn't design issue, it's them not wanting to invest more man hours for a larger balancing team

royal lantern
#

i mean, game balance is a really hard thing

#

like, REALLY hard

nocturne current
#

I don't blame the team because I'm sure they do the best they can with the limited time they have for it. Hence why you see these lazy 5% buffs and nerfs instead of going to fine tuning.

royal lantern
#

what else are they supposed to do instead of nerfing or buffing a talent or ability

balmy condor
royal lantern
#

"oh, its problematic, just delete and make something new xd" all the time?

nocturne current
tiny finch
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
nocturne current
#

Hunters cry for survivability and they give it a 5% buff you know why?

#

Because if you give hunter proper survivability now you have a potential broken PVP spec.

#

It's been this dilema since day 1

#

So now you have a spec that continues making no sense but deals 5% more damage, they have no burst, no proper cleave, no surviv, but hey you do 5% more damage.. anyways

normal mist
#

But hunters arent bad in arenas tho

#

All 3 specs are doing fine

nocturne current
#

Yeah but that's what I'm saying, how do you balance now PVE without having to do tons of man hours not to screw PVP or do tons of ability separation

subtle tundra
#

What the fuck is a pvp

nocturne current
#

Like BM's a joke without the bow, touch anything in PVE to fix it and PVP blows, like give it a whole defensive passive for PVE and now its suddenly PVP meta.

#

Unless you do PVE only ability which Cring

#

They could tune it so it wouldn't be reliable on the bow to be competitive.. But then they have to do all sorts of adjustments to PVP and I guess that takes a ton of man hours they dont have I guess, idk how they run the team budget

#

Anyway, this is assa channel, I should keep this to some other channel

teal iris
#

rank 1 afflock is only 2.9k wtf

royal lantern
#

why play a spec that has more effort for LESS payoff

empty tangle
#

Wha poison you guys use in dungeon, raid, and pvp?

balmy condor
#

read faqs

teal iris
#

2900 is like giga low

slow marsh
#

Sin always talking about balance

subtle tundra
#

Yea ofc when we are always overshadowed in m+

slow marsh
#

True

#

Not saying it's bad

#

Just dude said this is assassination channel they should keep balance talk to another channel

subtle tundra
#

This is assa. Also known as off topic 2

royal lantern
tribal mauve
#

!neck

prisma monolithBOT
eternal quail
#

so whats up with top logs not using exsang at all?

odd heath
balmy condor
shrewd night
#

inb4 Heroic

balmy condor
#

I have no clue what you’re referring to

odd heath
#

Only council isn't using exsanguinate

#

Others all using exsang lol

balmy condor
#

For pretty much every boss

#

Maybe he’s talking about mythic+ or something idk

#

Guess we’ll have to wait and see

balmy condor
#

That is one log that doesn’t use exsang, yes

#

What’s the question exactly?

odd heath
#

Funny that the 3 logs above this one use exsang

#

But were skipped due to idk?

#

Lol

slow marsh
#

Prolly cuz it supports them not wanting to play exsang so they cherry picked it

eternal quail
#

i want to play it, its bugging my deathmark atm however

shrewd night
spice spire
#

How

shrewd night
#

Are you pressing exsang after deathmark?

eternal quail
#

of course not

shrewd night
#

Then how does it bug

balmy condor
eternal quail
#

its not doubling the dmg

balmy condor
#

It’s not supposed to

#

Exsang cuts the duration in half and doubles the tick rate

#

They tick twice as fast

#

Same damage

quasi pine
#

Yeah It's just a 80% up in the tickrate, but still /2 the time left on your dots right?

balmy condor
#

Nah it’s 80% and whatever 80%

quasi pine
#

Oohh ok thought it was still/2

balmy condor
#

The damage the dots do stays completely equal

#

It’s the time that changes

#

The dot simply compresses

eternal quail
#

I understand how it works, let me link some other logs, sec

balmy condor
quasi pine
#

Maybe cause It's supposed to "double the dmg" in that time window

balmy condor
#

I mean he understands how it works

#

So idk

#

I haven’t heard of this bug

#

But I also have no clue what he’s talking about

#

Please sir a crumb of context

eternal quail
#

ignoring everything besides deathmark dmg here

slow marsh
balmy condor
#

Well when you exsang->deathmark, it duplicates the sped up bleed, so you get more duplicated ticks inside of Deathmark, which is more ticks total

eternal quail
#

thats what I do every time

balmy condor
#

Okay

#

So what’s the bug

shrewd night
balmy condor
#

I can’t keep asking what the bug is over and over man

#

I mean I can

quasi pine
#

cast of exang

#

and dps of garrot

#

i think it's working?

balmy condor
#

The interaction works fine

#

I Just still have no idea what this bug is

#

Cause it’s impossible to get a straight answer

eternal quail
#

why is blakadders deathmark 1.29m, where aprroo is 2.33m

quasi pine
eternal quail
#

aprroo is 2.33m without exsang, blakadders is 1.29m with exsang

spice spire
#

What

eternal quail
#

both only 2 casts, just comparing the deathmark dmg here

quasi pine
#

wait garrote + ex it's like 10s max no? before garrote runs out?

balmy condor
quasi pine
#

and idk but garrot at 3s of fight and then ex and no garrot refresh till 23s seems weird

brazen zodiac
quasi pine
#

maybe ran out before the deathmark

spice spire
#

Blakadder is also 5 ilvl less and doesn’t have PI

balmy condor
spice spire
#

Among a million other reasons

balmy condor
#

Like

#

Idk man

quasi pine
#

there is a tons of reasons why

#

it's not a bug

balmy condor
#

You linked a garbage log that doesn’t pad deathmark damage

#

And a decent log that does

#

It’s not surprising that the Deathmark is gonna crank if the guy is trying to crank it

eternal quail
#

so aprroo finds over a mill damage from just deathmark, without exsang, by lining up puzlebox, tea and PI?

brazen zodiac
#

sounds about right

odd heath
#

4k mastery from puzzlebox + % from tea and haste % from PI. Yeah

quasi pine
#

yup It looks like it

balmy condor
#

20% haste, almost 40% mastery

#

Makes sense to me

shrewd night
#

I mean, sounds alot more plausible than saying its a bug without being able to answer straight what the bug is.

eternal quail
#

i never said anything about a bug!

shrewd night
#

"Its bugging out my deathmark"

eternal quail
#

nope lol

#

🙂

spare bobcat
#

wut

brazen zodiac
#

it was lightiegirl

balmy condor
brazen zodiac
odd heath
#

🤡

balmy condor
#

Is this an elaborate troll or something

brazen zodiac
balmy condor
#

What the fuck is happening

brazen zodiac
#

its an alternate reality whisp

balmy condor
#

Is there a hidden camera

#

I’m getting pranked right

odd heath
#

His dog typed, he didn't know

brazen zodiac
#

turn around

royal lantern
#

worst timeline

spice spire
#

He’s an ilady

brazen zodiac
#

when i first turned into whisp stream i really was surprised to see that he wasnt some depressed egirl

#

and just a rogue gamer with green hair and racoon eyes

royal lantern
balmy condor
#

Killer combo

brazen zodiac
#

have you tried dyeing your hair again

#

usually that eases the voices for a few weeks

#

i just did mine red 👍

spare bobcat
#

Brain: You're tired. You:Take a Nap. Brain: Absolutely not.

balmy condor
#

It’s 7am

#

You think I sleep today?

spare bobcat
#

It's tuesday and you're a wow nerd. You may sleep during server reboot

balmy condor
#

I went to bed at 8am yesterday, and woke up at noon

#

And now it’s 7am

gentle gyro
#

ok, i take a few weeks break to play classic, i return and...kingsbane unplayable?

balmy condor
#

And I can’t sleep

gentle gyro
#

omegaSadge

brazen zodiac
brazen zodiac
#

COME ON

#

too soon

gentle gyro
#

classic is cool, but sin rogue is literally 2 buttons and my guild is incapable of clearing ulduar hardmodes

ebon notch
gentle gyro
#

so retail it is

spare bobcat
#

At first they came for my exsanguinate. I said nothing(jk) because I didn't like exsanguinate. Then they came for my KB. I said nothing because I don't like button bloat anyway. Perhaps soon we'll just be an AA class as god intended

gentle gyro
balmy condor
#

100% envenom uptime god bless

brazen zodiac
balmy condor
spare bobcat
gentle gyro
brazen zodiac
#

haha

#

what r the odds i can find a new guild on mally

gentle gyro
#

when i say mut mut env I mean that literally.

spice spire
#

wtf

spare bobcat
#

Love WOTLK Classic Ass rotation

ebon notch
brazen zodiac
#

do you?

spice spire
#

Because you were copying me smoge

#

He did at that time

brazen zodiac
#

actually better question did he sound like him or was he saying stuff that joe rogan would say 🤔

ebon notch
#

:thinkspin

#

wtf

#

where is thinkspin

#

NO

brazen zodiac
#

pepelove gone too i think :C

spice spire
#

Get woke buddy

spare bobcat
#

You're finished

shrewd night
autumn frost
#

how accurate are the weekly dps rankings for voti... I was looking it says we're number 25 in overall damage

#

also says we're 4th for boss damage

balmy condor
#

Correct

autumn frost
#

pain

balmy condor
#

On both of those

autumn frost
#

I was hoping my eyes were tricking me

balmy condor
#

Assassination add damage doesn’t exist

#

No platforms on dathea, no adds on diurna, intermissions are trash on raz, we don’t cleave very well on spider and kurog, we’re one of the worst on council

#

Is what it is

#

We do damage to 1 target and only 1 target

autumn frost
#

Do you think if they gave us baseline crimson, that would help?

balmy condor
#

You mean would getting an aoe talent, help our aoe?

oblique jackal
#

Yes 100%

balmy condor
#

Idk seems like pretty reasonable logic to me

autumn frost
#

i meant more like would it be enough

oblique jackal
#

Whispyr.. did Realz say anything about the useless shiv talent that they gave us

balmy condor
#

Oh, no lmao

oblique jackal
#

RIP

#

A useless capstone talent

ebon notch
#

im waiting for the overbuff

#

double target count

echo heath
#

Sin rework when?

ebon notch
#

double its damage

#

wreak havoc

balmy condor
#

We take all the aoe we can on council and we’re one of the worst specs on it

#

Can’t be salvaged

#

Need to rework cleave and aoe from the ground up

oblique jackal
#

I feel like they over nerfed us before raid

balmy condor
#

CT carnage and scent of blood just aren’t working

ebon notch
#

were there other suggestions from beta that you think would be a better replacement?

balmy condor
#

I don’t remember

#

But like

#

Replace flying daggers with poisoned knives or something

#

Would instantly help

ebon notch
#

as in swap them or

balmy condor
#

Buff scent so it’s not just a carnage buff

ebon notch
#

i dont remember what poisoned knives is

balmy condor
#

Legion artifact trait that made fok do a portion of poison damage on targets as additional damage

#

Basically echoing blades without the degenerate shit that echoing blades had

#

Flying daggers is just such a joke talent

#

The poisoned knives on the tree we have now is kinda mid as fuck too

#

Could buff it

#

Could make fok 2cp baseline

#

Could buff scent

#

Could rework exsang into something that helps on all target counts

#

Could make venomous wounds do damage again

#

Could do many many things

ebon notch
#

im assuming its a 10.1 thing

#

with a sub rework for the nightstalker changes

#

but who knows

steel ridge
#

We havent heard anything about rogue for quite a while

burnt star
#

Also remember the animarche cp reduction

ebon notch
#

i mean we couldnt rly anticipate the reworks and buffs/nerfs other specs got

#

that resulted in us being put behind

#

we're kinda using the gift of hindsight

burnt star
#

Fine. But maybe its time to adjust now

steel ridge
#

Sin went from #1 to last

ebon notch
#

we were still very strong after the nerfs in comparison to others

steel ridge
ebon notch
#

sin is still a very good raid spec

#

its just not the best

burnt star
#

Its just last in this aoe favored raid

#

Wich is... padd city

steel ridge
ebon notch
#

yes but you're looking at a ST specialist in the context of aoe

#

sure this raid has multiple aoe favoured scenarios

#

but assa is performing well at what it specialises in

#

which is pure boss damage

#

if you have a problem with the flexibility of the spec then thats fine

steel ridge
#

ST specialist getting absolutely gapped by bm hunters

ebon notch
#

assa rogue absolutely gapping 90% of other specs in single target

#

beaten by 2 outliers and close to 2 others

#

the amount of doomers in this channel is so annoying honestly

#

it makes it sound like the spec is unplayable

steel ridge
#

i am not a doomer

burnt star
#

Need to remember that dk/bm are also getting pi'ed

ebon notch
#

yeah

#

unholy dk without PI is kinda meh

#

its basically the venth boomie or demo lock of this tier

burnt star
#

Pi gives us like 6k

ebon notch
#

gives them over 10k

burnt star
#

No i mean

#

Add that to the metric

#

Wr wouldnt be that far behind

#

Seeing how close we are

ebon notch
#

true but that is not a good lens to view logs through

#

you cannot just mentally add dps to things that arent there

#

cause that isnt the real world

steel ridge
#

I haven’t gotten PI since week1 besad

burnt star
#

I mean it is.. u need to consider external buff on singular class. Blizz is clearly not designing their balance around that

ebon notch
#

i only get pi cause it lines up with spriest PI

steel ridge
#

Now substract windfury

#

Assa without wf is just not good

strange python
steel ridge
#

its just ok

ebon notch
#

not even 1%?

#

are you sure about that

strange python
#

Did you just look up stats by all bosses by boss damage?

ebon notch
#

filtering for 95th percentile also

strange python
#

Because you know why that's incredibly misleading right?

#

Specs that CAN pick up multi target will, and will reduce their boss damage. You need to look at ST damage in a ST context.

steel ridge
#

Boss dmg is scuffed, many specs are assigned to adds on diurna

strange python
#

^

#

Or multiple plats on dathea, or primarily spec to kill adds on kurog, etc. It's not that their boss damage is worse, it's a choice.

#

You have to look at terros to judge ST capability

#

Most of those other specs could do Sin ST if they wanted, but they're choosing cleave

steel ridge
#

assa being anything else than #1 in pure ST is just horrible

strange python
#

I mean BM is also pure dogshit at AoE

#

Sins not the only st niche spec

#

But it's definitely not as far ahead on st as it should be

burnt star
ebon notch
#

true, in this tier with the very few ST encounters its representation will not be amazing

burnt star
#

This is 95th percentile on terros

strange python
#

I feel like you just didn't read a word I said

burnt star
#

See how its really not "that" goood

ebon notch
#

but there have been misrepresentations over assa's viability in the raid this tier

ebon notch
#

i read and understood it

#

it just meant i needed to change how i presented my point on viability in this tier

strange python
#

Sin being 5k behind BM on terros means the spec is desperately undertuned.

burnt star
#

The point was assa wasnt even 1% ahead of other

ebon notch
#

BM is also certainly overtuned

burnt star
#

Terros log shows exacly.that

ebon notch
#

like

#

they just got a 5% buff

strange python
#

And being barely ahead of frost dk and outlaw and fury

ebon notch
#

they were strong before the buff

molten galleon
#

hate it that outlaw is even viable in ST \o/

strange python
#

I think "sin wasn't overnerfed and doesn't need buffs" is a hard stance to take when a spec with a pure-ST niche is competing with cleave specs for ST damage

steel ridge
strange python
#

But casuals whined about rogue so we got fucked and now it's sub until next tier and hopefully we don't get reactionary balance according to community bitching

ebon notch
#

i just said that when they were originally nerfed at the beginning of the tier the landscape for specs was very different

#

the arms warrior changes for example were huge to their overall performance in the raid

molten galleon
#

@steel ridge I dont mind, I just think that the specc identity is something real different, its about heavy Cleave dmg but still good in ST dunno that just does not fit

#

and hating outlaw anyway lol

strange python
#

I mean. Nerfing the spec that only does ST based on heroic logs, knowing mythic has more adds, and before tier sets came in, was always incredibly scuffed

steel ridge
molten galleon
#

I want the KB Build to be stronger than DTB, so much more fun to play and more Skill expression.

#

@steel ridge huh, not saying Outlaw is bad, I just heavly dislike it lol :

steel ridge
snow meteor
#

Hi all, I heard this is the best place to go for Rogue business but first I would like to say Happy Valentines Day. In honor of this day and to be part of the gang (https://www.google.com/search?rlz=1C1CHBF_enUS1034US1034&tbm=vid&sxsrf=AJOqlzUBIq-toa1Svjnm0bt6A-A-126dSw:1676386881749&q=the+little+rascals+valentine&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjQwN7ko5X9AhWwkGoFHb90DXEQ8ccDegQIFxAH&biw=2048&bih=1011&dpr=1.88#fpstate=ive&vld=cid:49c86d8e,vid:m5-oZFXSKIs) I would like to start and ask my very first question... What are the ideal talents/glyphs config for a new/low geared Assassination Rogue going into Ulduar?

steel ridge
molten galleon
#

@steel ridge I played it a ton in SL and Start of DF aswell, just highliy dislike the randomness and type of play, just feels 0 like rogue. Used to love Combat back in the days. Also the Pirat/Outlaw theme disgusts 😄

limber lion
#

randomness?

steel ridge
#

Subjective randomness

molten galleon
#

where is it subjective ?

steel ridge
#

its the least random it has been in a while

dreamy gull
#

wtf i dont remember finding this dagger

molten galleon
#

Doesnt Change that is Random 😄

gusty mirage
dreamy gull
#

oh

#

i was raiding while super fucked up last night

#

so maybe thats wh

#

y

gusty mirage
#

or assassination?

dreamy gull
#

yahtzee ninja

gusty mirage
#

because every spec in the game has quite a bit of variance

#

and outlaw isn't any larger of a variance than the other specs

dawn kelp
#

B2B guzzlers in vault starege

gusty mirage
frigid pilot
steel ridge
dreamy gull
#

maybe

dawn kelp
steel ridge
#

Hey hey leave some good loot for me you feckers

dreamy gull
steel ridge
dreamy gull
#

its better than trying to find a mythic game ngl

frigid pilot
#

bold move linking an lfr vault

dreamy gull
#

honestly i have 0 friends so its not my fault i dont have any better rewards

deft vault
#

You can pug heroic and normal

steel ridge
#

Make friends

#

join a guild

#

Look for people with a common goal

dreamy gull
#

is normal harder than lfr

#

or the same

steel ridge
#

Lfr is harder than normal with people that are not apes

dreamy gull
#

ok but i barely have a pulse im not contributing to the raid regardless

frigid pilot
#

still using 415 offhand

#

my trinket luck has been nuts though

#

got offered puzzle and whetstone in vault b4

steel ridge
#

Lfr raszageth is peak progression raiding

#

If you can suffer through that, you are already a curve-able player

dreamy gull
#

i havent done the diurna raszageth raid yet

steel ridge
#

oh boi

#

what are you even doing here then? Stop wasting your time in this god forsaken place and play the game

#

shitposting in class discords is not playing the game Comfy

unreal bear
#

heroic raz is legitimately easier than lfr raz

steel ridge
#

Leave that to the apes (like me)

dreamy gull
#

i looked up 1 video about how to fight raz

#

forgot everything about it

#

tiem to queue

steel ridge
#

Thats the way

frigid pilot
#

BabyRage when your guild hasnt killed diurna yet

dreamy gull
#

i mean dont most boss fights come down to not standing in the swirly parts of the floor

#

wonder if i can solo this

#

maybe ill try and vanish if things go south

#

update

steel ridge
odd heath
dreamy gull
#

im rly happy with this

#

considering i felt hardstuck at 343 a couple weeks ago

limber lion
#

yeah take your time, enjoy the game

willow tendon
#

So this is more of a sim question but I figured I could ask here anyway, since valor is unlocked and every item I have I can technically farm enough for it to be at a higher ilvl, is there a way to while simming top gear make every item the same ilvl to find the best combination of items?

limber lion
#

But if you already have all the items and you want to compare the items that you own only, then you just press the + sign next to the item and choose the ilvl you want. By pressing the + and choosing 415, another item that's 415 appears.

willow tendon
#

Ohh okok thanks!

spice spire
slow marsh
#

Meanwhile I'm reeeeeeing that I'm only 399