enfusion_workshop

[hard mountain]

thanks, i'll have a look for it,

[warped oasis]

Hi, I managed to create a chest with custom functions. I'd like to add this item to the game master's catalog so I can spawn it whenever I want during the game.

I'm having a hard time; I've tried consulting both the Bohemia and chatGPT documentation, but I can't seem to figure it out.
I tried creating (following the guides) a scr_editableentitycomponent by inserting the item's data, I created a custom catalog to insert the item and have it loaded from game mode, and finally I added the catalog I created with the item to the game mode's entity catalog, but despite all this, I can't seem to get it to appear in the game master's list.

Can anyone help me?

[dark crow]

Did you add it to placeable entities?

Check the faction creation tutoral in the wiki it explains pretty well how the placeable prefabs work

[red moat]

Classy, my mods just randomly deleted themselves.

lul just wish it'd be easier to find files that deleted themselves as dependencies with unpublised mods 😭

[raven sequoia]

Workshop is down? Can't update my mods

DEFAULT   (E): Uploading failed! Reason: ""```

[flat pelican]

Yeah, having the same issue.

[raven sequoia]

I restarted the app and solved

[flat pelican]

I tried, the error was there. I’ll try again now.

[dark crow]

Got past that issue by using a VPN

[flat pelican]

It loads all my mods except the map. It refuses to publish the map with this error. I’ve already tried everything

[glad oxide]

Any chance we could get collections on the workshop? Would be nice for both modders and people who play with mods to get some way to organize their mods.

[rocky bobcat]

close reforger workshop, try again, if that doesn't work check in files the addons files and see if there's a blank requirement

[nocturne temple]

Anyone having problems with adding contributors when publishing mods? No one I am adding as contributors is getting an invite. I've reached out to other people and they are having the same problem.

[dim harbor]

Anyone know how to contact MrPotter from the Workshop I’m trying to figure out this mod

https://reforger.armaplatform.com/workshop/644F551B3512AE7F-RaidableObjects

[kind cloud]

All of my characters for my custom faction end up looking the same even though I have visual identity stuff set up, any input?

[rocky bobcat]

#enfusion_configuration

[kind cloud]

didnt see this earlier thank you

[magic star]

What would cause my vehicles not to drive.. they turn on.. wheels move.. but they dont?

[rocky bobcat]

#enfusion_terrain

[soft lichen]

Believe it or not, I was told that #enfusion_configuration has nothing to do with config files and is actually for configuring settings/stats for almost everything. I believe #enfusion_scenario might be the proper config channel.

[rocky bobcat]

Wtf?

That doesn't make any sense

I think you're very wrong if you scroll through that chat

Scenarios is like missions setup

[soft lichen]

Yeah missions and factions

[dawn echo]

ok so i made a car .ent but dont know how to publish it, what should i do 🧍

im confused

wanna be able to access it in heavy vehicle spawner and stuff but dont know how to set that up

i know how to publish but like no one would be able to spawn it in in game

[solid dagger]

Is workshop dead rn?

[minor pine]

I am working on a map and was wondering if there is a way to increase the view distance from the base? Everything I have researched has come up with nothing.

[cloud kernel]

I'm adding a colleague's email to the "contributor" section of a mod, then publishing. But afterwards, if I open the publish menu again, there' email isn't there and they aren't recieving an invite.

Is this feature bugged currently?

[magic star]

i some how lost GM ability in my game and not sure what i did... vaugue .. but any where to look ?

[quaint solar]

anyone know if someones made a nice FN FAl Mod here been looking for one that isnt huge and looks good

[cloud kernel]

Have you tried this one? https://reforger.armaplatform.com/workshop/651D71B6C09E3A84-ArmaConflictFAL

[quaint solar]

Yeah i did lil to big for what im looking for currently checking out https://reforger.armaplatform.com/workshop/623E0EA4ED5F44D5-FAL

[vernal bay]

enable your dependencies

[vernal bay]

duplicate the prefabs to your world file and place them via world editor GM, set up dynamic loot spawns and make a raid timer for them to spawn the dynamic loot at certain times

[dim harbor]

It’s says GM placeable, nothing about having to use world editor

[vernal bay]

yeah so are you using the GM gamemode and do you have the required dependencies loaded
ACE Tactical Ladder Dev
ACE Core Dev

[dim harbor]

Yes

Can not find them anywhere in the GM menu

[vernal bay]

also if you want to learn how other modders set up there mods you can always load there test worlds, check components and set ups to duplicate to your world

[vernal bay]

you will need to duplicate the prefabs

got to workbench, find mod, prefabs, .... item you want, duplicate to your world

[dim harbor]

This isn’t the ship asset mod, the description clearly says GM placeable props, I should be able to load it to my server go to the GM menu and place them

[vernal bay]

yeah so in editor there will be a props folder under the mod required with the assets you need to add them to your world files and add them in world editor, if you do them in GM on the server the scenario wont save or be permanent, you will have to set it up everytime you load the server, you need to prefab them in the editor, place them, save and upload new mod version

[dim harbor]

So this is workbench side, not server side?

[vernal bay]

one sec ill add it and show you

[dim harbor]

Thank you

[vernal bay]

have you added the mod and deps to your world? and do you know how

[dim harbor]

To my server is all I done

[vernal bay]

messaged you instead of spamming here dude

[willow iris]

i cant add one specific contributer the email looks like '[e-mail]' i could add him to previous project but not this one, help ?

[elfin vector]

It has been like that since Thursday.

Can't upload anything and multiple people are having the same issue.

[willow iris]

Well let's hope its linked

[elfin vector]

Most people are getting error code 524

I see you getting 404 which means something is not found.

Go check in-game workshop.

No one has updated any mods for a while, so I do think it is linked to this issue not your mod.

[ruby sphinx]

How do you identify what could be causing a fragment in a mod download?

[quasi sable]

anyone still having upload issues? my mod keeps failing

[quartz vault]

?

[quasi sable]

it wont compile to the workshop, blank code with an unemployed 5xxx message like its been doing for the past month. but today its really bad

[mellow creek]

I'm not having issues, but a few others have been posting about it the last few days.

I'm guessing only a select few are having issues

[obtuse tiger]

Same issue

[twilit dove]

How do you add contributors to your mod?
i keep following the bohemia way but its not working

[stuck remnant]

Hello everyone! Please tell me, is it necessary to register all files and folders in the mod? Is it required for all files and folders of the project? I am interested because I improve and correct files in the folder, and then copy them from there to the project folder and then compile the mod ready for publication. I do not know the exact answer. Perhaps all files and folders are registered automatically upon publication and there is no point in manually registering +100500 files and folders? And hence another question. Is it possible and if so, how to register several files or a folder with files at once? @sacred heart

[fleet sedge]

Maybe some one have contact of this guy?

[rocky bobcat]

he left the community

[fleet sedge]

Ooh, so sad, his 5-flor civilian building its great, but destroying from 1-2 tank shoots, wanting to ask about up "armor", but.....

[rocky bobcat]

you can make a dependency of the mod, that creates overrides of the building where you can increase the building health, you just need a PC steam copy AR to get access to the workbench.

[fleet sedge]

I cant

[rocky bobcat]

oh

might ask the people making the map you're working on if they can modify the health of it

or make a custom scenario of that map, created a override of the building there

[fleet sedge]

You misunderstood me a little, the thing is that his mod is under APL-ND, this category prohibits any modifications except for using "out of the box". In fact, I can technically do anything with his houses even without having the source code, but - this will violate the agreement and I will get hit on the head)

[crimson sequoia]

this category prohibits any modifications except for using "out of the box"
This is not true. You can modify it as long as your mod package does not contain any copyrighted elements from the original. Prefab override does not contain portions of the original unless in some specific edge cases.
https://reforger.armaplatform.com/news/workshop-licenses-and-ip-faq

In particular:

The modding of config formatted text files (for example .conf, .et, or .ct, .ent) is similar to scripts. Because of how "overrides" and "inheritance" work for mods, such files must not contain the full original to reference or change its data. For example, the config below tweaks a small setting inside a very large config. The only reference to some copyrighted material is the original path of the file and some of the structure of it. "MyMod" must again not contain the copyrighted material to be compatible with it - and again, the dependency mod it references is theoretically interchangeable. Permission may not usually be strictly required to make small changes like this, but we recommend evaluating each issue on a case-by-case basis.
However the last sentence is important. It's best to open your override as a text file and compare with the original prefab text content to actually verify if nothing that could be copyrighted got copied.
In doubt, best to reach the original author.
This is not a legal advice.

[dense scaffold]

There is disagreement on what constitutes a derivative around here so until someone shows up with some actual legal advice we don't really know

[fleet sedge]

I agree about the position with legal cases, in general I work in a field closely related to jurisprudence, from my experience and vision the situation is such that, for example, even an APL mod for equipment, in which there is an open from the rank of sergeant, and I change its opening to corporal in my scenario - in fact, it is already a change. Yes, not affecting, for example, key parameters, but nevertheless - the class that determines the level of access is a class that is part of the prefab, on the other hand - if the class is vanilla, and not custom - then the SAS prefab belongs to the author, but the class is the property of Bohemia. So now think about what to do))))

[elfin vector]

Is there any news or information on the failing to upload to workshop situation?

[mellow creek]

I don't think as many people as you think are having problems uploading, you seem to be part of a minority having this problem.

[elfin vector]

I'm going to try a VPN tonight, hopefully it works

[eternal geyser]

Quite a few people had trouble updating larger mods a couple of weeks ago. VPN seems to the best workaround in that case.

[mellow creek]

Someone's also made an official ticket for this issue here: https://feedback.bistudio.com/T194844

[elfin vector]

Do you think there will be throttling or limitations in the future ?

I was thinking about how much data BI will need in order to keep the Reforger & A3 mods available, surely the amount of mods are over a Petabyte by now

[ivory fjord]

Takes me two or three attempts to push an update

[mellow creek]

A3 mods are on steam, not the bohemia workshop like reforger mods

[elfin vector]

Ah yes, that is true.

[silver bison]

If you want to know, there are already 3 TB of data related to uploaded mods on stable.

[young coral]

I'm sure a lot of that is obsolete versions?

[elfin vector]

That is crazy !

@young coral I somewhat some agree on that, many mods are also just "Test" and never get removed.

[fleet sedge]

Guys, please tell me a mod (if one exists) so that in the conflict scenario, teams cannot leave the main base until a certain timer, and those who try die or run into an invisible wall (something like the planning stage in Squad)

[elfin vector]

I wanted to share this information if you having issues uploading to Workshop.

I used a VPN connected to the Nederlands and it worked.

Hope this helps if you having an issue.

[plush otter]

Workshop uploads still borked today, bouncing between "bad gateway", "524" and "payload too large" errors (mods smaller than 1gb)

[woven island]

Any solutions on mods not updating on workshop or is it a Bohemia thing that’s getting sorted?

[gilded root]

If it gets stuck or failed, close your tools for a minute, go back to publish it again but you need to go up one numeral in the version or it'll get caught in a failed loop.

so if it fails on 1.0.12, you need to close out and publish again on 1.0.13

[candid basalt]

https://discord.gg/UxVGY6dcSC
in my server you can Make friends, Chat with others, Play games together, Promote Servers, Rate people’s edits, Post your scenepacks in the “🎥Scenepacks🎥”Forum Post your videos in the 🎥YouTube” channel in the server you can ask the people in the server for any editing help in the “👌help editing” channel Feel free to join today!

[quasi sable]

this timeout issue has made it so i cant publish anything

[mellow creek]

Extreme cringe alert! This is not a channel for advertising... 🤦‍♂️

[earnest quail]

So im rigging a weapon, and then the armature keeps coming up at the top. Is there a way to fix this?

[earnest vapor]

Grass is green type of comment

[coarse lichen]

My guy, there's a probability one of your objects doesn't have weights and / or vertex groups assigned to it

Btw

should look something like this

and all of your bones should be parented to the w_root bone, be careful with the empty objects being parented too.
You can try moving the Armature bone around to see what object or vertex is missing a group / weight

[earnest quail]

thank you

is there a certain reason it is reading my muzzle as a bone?

[coarse lichen]

yes, maybe accidentally made it into one, you should move that one around too just to see

what i recommend you doing is taking your muzzle onto another blender instance and export your weapon system without it

then you can make the attachment duplicating an existing prefab

just double-check you don't have anything that can be linked to that specific object via weights

Usually that happens whenever theres vertex without weight, as i said just move it around inside tools to see what is moving whenever you move that empty object which is being detected as a bone

[earnest quail]

alright im pretty certain i got it

i just cleared the vertices and rerigged it

thank you

do i parent it to the root by making the armature or is there a process i have to follow?

so in the above picture, the w root moves all of the bones, but then the bones themselves move the correct way

[coarse lichen]

Here goes bud

The thing is

your main frame on the firearm should have been weighted to the root lol
However, if the firearm is functioning correctly DO NOT MOVE IT.

Double-check inside the game if your character moves correctly

if not, adjust the w_root bone and weight your frame to it (only the frame, not the moving parts)

[earnest quail]

lol

gosh its always something so simple

tyvm i got it

[coarse lichen]

Yeah that happened to me a lot of times lol

[coarse lichen]

No worries, let me know if anything else pops out

[earnest quail]

i really appreciate the help!

[coarse lichen]

You got it

[crude star]

This worked for me but I had to go from 1.0.09 to 1.1.0 for it to work. Does it matter? Who knows? Could it have just been lucky timing? possibly

[fleet sedge]

Guys, please tell me, if a mod developer uses a script or part of a script's code within their mod that destroys a working mod without the author's permission (in the form of a piece of code that needs to be added to the script for normal operation) - isn't this considered a violation of the same EULA?

[obtuse tiger]

Any word on the WS issue? Iv tried doing the VPN thing and also the other tips but nothing will upload, gets stuck at 99% still then fails with no reason given " "

[real fiber]

Yeah I’ve been trying to upload yesterday and today and it has not been working. Same error

[twin thicket]

Somehow it worked after several attempts from multiple regions via my VPN

I opened the WS tools while I was in CA, then disconnected (back to SE) and uploaded, it somehow worked

but I think it's more of a stroke of luck that anything

[real fiber]

I tried like 10 times in a row😭 why won’t it work

[quasi sable]

do we have any word on when this stuff is gonna be fixed? Like do they even know its broken at this point?

[open pewter]

hey yall. working on getting my own server running. i keep running into this error when trying to publish my mod

BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[490] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_CreateAssetUpload] Error Code:400 - Bad Request, apiCode="ValidationError", uid="1758434594550-791488", message="Referenced dependency doesn't exist or isn't accessible"
DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: "Referenced dependency doesn't exist or isn't accessible"
BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[491] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_CancelAssetUpload] Error Code:400 - Bad Request, apiCode="ResourceNotFoundError", uid="1758434599700-988443", message="assetVersionUpload 6626410936B0A1B0 1.0.0 not found"

[lost kestrel]

I've also been trying to upload for a few days, like you guys failing with error " "

Its odd, can only update about half my mods.

Guess it is region based, VPN to paris and worked first shot, tried 20+ times without a vpn all failed.

[quasi sable]

france is indeed working

[obtuse tiger]

Nope its not. 🙈

BI workshop is still fubar. I wish we could get an official update as to why.

[rocky bobcat]

it has alot of reworks needed, I'm glad this is the test game, instead of Arma 4

If A4 has all these issues with workshop near constantly it's going to be even more annoying

[obtuse tiger]

This time abouts last year it was also fubar and there was a giant DDOS thing I dunno

Who knows maybe the same

[rocky bobcat]

that was Febuary March this year

[obtuse tiger]

Ai well is what it is

Hope its sorted soon , this sucks

[mellow creek]

The official word will be here: https://feedback.bistudio.com/T194844

[rocky bobcat]

this is showing up on an old project of mine I'm trying to open, anyone have any advice?

[near dune]

Can someone help me understand why or how this mod works. I have it in the server but can't find the property https://reforger.armaplatform.com/workshop/61E2DD518BEEB7B5

Maybe @katatafish could help me thank u

[dark pulsar]

Animals category but no animal support. Teases.

Non humanoid skeleton support when?

[twin flower]

Might be a unused/forgotten tag, it was already there in august 2022 (wayback machine)

[dark pulsar]

What about these?

I know they are for birds and such, but seems like a waste to not have other skeleton support.

[lost geode]

Uhh, any skeleton of any kind in supported by the engine...

[dark pulsar]

For animation?

[lost geode]

Yes

[dark pulsar]

Why no animals then

[lost geode]

Ask the devs

[dark pulsar]

Cool i'll have to give it a shot one of these days.

[lost geode]

The one animal we got just flies away and doesn't actually roam or anything

[dark pulsar]

Yeah I can do the behavior

[lost geode]

The animations aren't the issue.

It's, what components and settings do we need to have an actual animal

I've only been able to get things to work as a scr_chimeracharacter

Using the character ai stuff

[dark pulsar]

Ok. I will prob try with ChimeraCharacter because my game mode avoiding SCR stuff whenever possible

[lost geode]

Thats dumb

[dark pulsar]

It's a life mod framework

[lost geode]

And?

[dark pulsar]

I dont need a bunch of crap that is tied into SCR

[lost geode]

The scripted versions of things have more functionality

[dark pulsar]

I dont use factions. Repalced with jobs system. Stuff like that

100% custom spawning chain

[lost geode]

That's still irrelevant

[dark pulsar]

It makes me have to add components that I dont need. But idk

[lost geode]

No it doesn't lol

[dark pulsar]

faction system, laodout manager, scr_respawn all that stuff throws errors when it's tied in

[lost geode]

SCR prefix literally just means it resides script side.

[dark pulsar]

with my experience, but im not doubting you.

Yeah im not avoiding SCR completely, just a lot of vanilla systems

[lost geode]

Well duh

I think you're somehow confused as to what the "scr crap" is lol

Some functionality doesn't even work correctly without the scripted versions of classes.

[dark pulsar]

Yeah i phrased that wrong.

But I thought that scr_character class would make me need faction manager.

Will be a good while before i even look into the animal thing

[pseudo robin]

Anybody else having this issue? >>>> BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[10] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Error Code:524 - Unimplemented 5xx, apiCode="", uid="", message=""
DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: ""

I got it go past that error but comes with this popup error with this "Addon processing on Workshop side failed!
Error: Request failed
Error UID: 1758556537681-866908"

[indigo mesa]

Hey guys, working on my first mod (clothing) and after importing my texture NMO map and moving to upload/publish the mod I keep getting a error with Reason””

Any idea how to fix that issue?

[pseudo robin]

Did you put some tags in? Thats how I got around mine I left mine blank when I tried to upload it and it would give me that error to. Until I put in some tags and it went away.

[indigo mesa]

interesting ill try that

[indigo mesa]

what do i put for tags? could you provide examples

[pseudo robin]

For mine I put Offroad since I was uploading some offroad vehicles. I think you can put TAG then space TAG and etc

I hope it helps or fixes your issue 🙂

[indigo mesa]

THE GOAT, THANK YOU

[pseudo robin]

It fixed the issue for you?

[indigo mesa]

yeah weirdly enough

or not...

nvm were gucci

preciate the help

[pseudo robin]

Np 🙂

[untold topaz]

I cant upload either

[pseudo robin]

Damn, yeah I got past that error but it wont let me upload either it gives me a pop up error whenever I do try to upload it. Before it would get stuck at like 96% and then throw off that backend error. Next thing I tried is making sure everything was filled in even the tags and the addon type. Idk you could try doing that maybe?

[open pewter]

BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[533] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_CreateAssetUpload] Error Code:400 - Bad Request, apiCode="ValidationError", uid="1758591702281-133405", message="Referenced dependency doesn't exist or isn't accessible"
DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: "Referenced dependency doesn't exist or isn't accessible"
BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[534] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_CancelAssetUpload] Error Code:400 - Bad Request, apiCode="ResourceNotFoundError", uid="1758591704826-975731", message="assetVersionUpload 6626410936B0A1B0 1.0.0 not found"

is this just a BI problem?

[golden ether]

have the same error so i guess so

[rocky bobcat]

anyone know where I can post a question about making a custom seat position for someone to sit that can alter the way someone sits. example, somone tries to sit in the seat, but the seat turns them into a tpose on a position on the vehicle hood?

[lost geode]

That's a weird way to want to position someone lol. Regardless thats all related to the animation.

[fathom jacinth]

Anyone been able to get around this error when trying to upload to the workshop?
BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[78] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKBENCH_GetAsset] Error Code:400 - Bad Request, apiCode="workshopApi.assetNotPublished", uid="1758671767252-209281", message="Asset 666F71648B1FC436 is not published"

[fathom jacinth]

DEFAULT (E): Addon processing on Workshop side failed! Error UID: "" Error Message : "Unknown Error"

[deft token]

Still getting error 524 also

[real fiber]

Try using a VPN and connecting to a different country. Worked for a bunch of us. I did mine through Netherlands and other did through France

[fathom jacinth]

I tried both Netherlands and France and still didn't work. Received the same Error.

[fathom jacinth]

Is there any Admins that can give us a reason for the Backend errors we are experiencing when attempting to upload our mods? I haven't seen any technical statements on X or Discord that acknowledge an issue. Just a few people posting here that are experiencing difficulty publishing. I'm hoping that BI/Arma is about to rollout with 1.5 this week and that's the reason why there's a issue, because of an infrastructure update.

[open pewter]

for real, i finally got my map done after 5 attempts and cant publish it

tried with a vpn and still didnt work

[sacred heart]

Someone change the hamster... He died again.

Yea I am getting a mix of errors of d/l'ing. Some do some don't.

[elfin vector]

It has been like this for 3 weeks, you guys are kinda late to the party 🥳 🎉 😅

[sacred heart]

Yea my head is buried in v1.5. First time I've used v1.4 in a little bit.

[elfin vector]

Yeah, been missing you on the Scenario Section 😕

🍻

[golden ether]

is the backend fixed or nah?

[rocky bobcat]

I can't even update mods ithe workshop half the time without it fail 2-3 times, per mod updated

[plush otter]

its completely borked the past 48hrs or so, 2 days ago it worked for one update

[fathom jacinth]

I don't know why we can't get anyone from BI or Arma team to respond acknowledging an issue with uploading and let us know they are working on it...

[rocky bobcat]

We could at a dev, but I don't know any usernames

[humble current]

They do know there are issues. I believe a BI peep mentioned it above

#enfusion_workshop message

[brave egret]

I’m currently working on AI Chopper Pilots working.

I can place ai members in the pilot seat but when I order them to get in they just get in the usual seat.

Is the prefab getin or get in nearest?

[hard dawn]

whats the max gb size of mod that i can upload to workshop (i know that the limit was increased)

[dense scaffold]

7 gigs or something, someone will fix me if I'm wrong

[hybrid fossil]

If you mean vanilla they will never get into the pilot seat because they can't fly.

[grand rain]

Anyone know how to make a flashlight from scratch in the workbench? I have the flashlight and the light entity, but I cant figure out how to make the light entity emit light or how to enable the flashlight

[brave egret]

I know that. That’s why I am making a mod to get them to do that. I used the compartment configurations to allow the pilot seat and they will be placed in them now (in GM mode) but when I tell them to get in they won’t.

I can create behavior trees to get them to learn how to fly helicopters but and exchange move, get in, and get out orders to handle well with choppers but it’s the getting them to just go in the damned seat in game.

[quasi sable]

anyone know why an asset i made would be causing a group=1, reason=9 mass dc?

[graceful dew]

Is the workshop backend down? We're getting JIP replication errors

Replication error 8 (JIP)

[ocean tinsel]

JIP error not from backend, it's something in engine/scripts/mods

[graceful dew]

Ty. We got it fixed. The scenario conf was borked

[open pewter]

useless error codes

DEFAULT : Validating bundle successful
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 5%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 10%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 15%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 20%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 25%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 30%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 35%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 40%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 45%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 50%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 55%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 60%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 65%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 70%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 75%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 80%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 85%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 90%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 95%
BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[16] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Error Code:524 - Unimplemented 5xx, apiCode="", uid="", message=""
DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: ""

[real fiber]

Try uploading using a vpn connected to a different country

[warm canyon]

I also encountered this problem.

[spring osprey]

This worked for me in case anyone having the same problem, download proton vpn for free and just get any region beside US

[loud flicker]

For me, restarting the computer lets me upload.

[quasi sable]

im using a vpn and this is happening, how fix?

[silent token]

lucky you. I've been trying all day yesterday and today and nothing

[silent token]

will try

[plush otter]

Can confirm that using free option from protonVPN yielded a slow but successful upload when ported through Netherlands

for anyone still facing 524 error code

[fading shore]

12h later

[cedar wigeon]

has workshop been absolutely fucked for uploads today for anyone else? all of my files are failing at like 20%, regardless if i'm using a VPN or not

ive tried 10+ times in multiple different countries

and usually only get the error 524 after reaching 100%, this is consistently failing below 25%

[cedar wigeon]

this is genuinely so frustrating lol

[dawn lotus]

steam in admin mode, vpn to prague, still no upload

y u do dis BI

[dawn lotus]

https://tenor.com/view/throwing-papers-at-desk-frustrated-gif-12652969

[fleet sedge]

Please tell me a mod, I saw it but I don't know the name - so that when a character falls wounded, he remains in the same position and does not roll over onto his back

[versed crag]

wish i could

update my mods

but i guess thats too wishful a thought

https://tenor.com/view/stitch-frustration-史迪奇-gif-4802586

[vital mist]

So the workshop is down, it isnt just a me thing?

[cedar wigeon]

havent been able to upload all day

[barren dagger]

Been this way for 7 days

BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[15] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Error Code:524 - Unimplemented 5xx, apiCode="", uid="", message=""
DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: ""

Fixxxxx this!!!!!

[cedar wigeon]

it would honestly be nice if there'd be some type of official acknowledgement of the issue

there is a feedback post that has been responded to that confirms it's a BI/Cloudflare issue and not a user issue, but that was opened weeks ago with no real update on the situation other than 'This is something we are aware can occur and we are working on solution for the future.'

this has to be a priority to them, right...?

[barren dagger]

Idk it’s driven me nuts

[fading shore]

I know how 7 days it does me my I managed to publish my pus at all 0 for 2 days now

[candid ice]

Few months ago we couldn’t publish for about 45 days straight

[cedar wigeon]

no wonder so many developers tend to leave reforger lol thats honestly mind boggling

you'd think that'd be one of their top priorities seeing as this franchise is so succesful due to modding

[leaden zodiac]

cant publish rn as well

[barren dagger]

https://tenor.com/view/panda-angry-bad-keyboard-smash-gif-12744796

[leaden zodiac]

me when i try publish for the 5th time knowing its not gonna work but want to try

[barren dagger]

Actually it’ll tell you as soon as you hit publish to workshop befor it lets you type in descriptions so you don’t have to waste your time the error will populate

[leaden zodiac]

i keep getting after my publish gets to 10%

BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[25] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Error Code:524 - Unimplemented 5xx, apiCode="", uid="", message=""

[barren dagger]

Yea

Don’t even gotta try it’ll just populate the error code

When it try’s and connect to their servers

[cedar wigeon]

the last big mod (100mb+) they had uploaded to workshop was the 30th lol hopefully they're at least aware that the issue has seemingly gotten worse

ive been having to use a VPN for weeks to upload, but today its failing no matter what i try

its also showing behavior i havent seen before. typically the upload would go to 100% and then fail, pretty much every time.

today it's been failing at random percentages, as well as just outright getting stuck and not failing whatsoever

[dawn lotus]

so can we get a word on this workshop bs so hundreds of people dont waste their time trying to upload? @greennames

[cedar wigeon]

i wouldn't hold ur breath lmao

[barren dagger]

Had to download a vpn and try from across the pond befor it worked

[cedar wigeon]

I tried literally every Central European country available through a VPN and failed over 50 times yesterday lmao - here’s to hoping the Bohemia gods bless me when I get off work

[barren dagger]

I got through in the Netherlands

Posted 2 1g plus mods

[boreal pulsar]

Same, the VPN trick was working for me for a while and now it’s not at all. I was using UK, Singapore wasn’t working. I did try Netherlands today as well and no luck. 😑 so guess these updates will wait until Arma fixes these issues

[barren dagger]

Netherlands worked for me a hour ago

[boreal pulsar]

I’ll give it a shot tonight, I have two maps that need updates 😩

[cedar wigeon]

Was that this morning/today? I tried Netherlands like 3 times yesterday. Spain/Netherlands are usually my bread and butter, but yesterday nothing would work.

[barren dagger]

Hour ago

[cedar wigeon]

That makes me hopeful for when I get off work lol, thanks brother

[mellow creek]

Only change I've noticed is that uploads are much much slower now (on experimental)

[cedar wigeon]

tried spain and netherlands 3 times each once i got home, still nothing but failures 😭

[boreal pulsar]

Same, im just trying them all at this point XD

[versed crag]

I was able to upload my smaller mod on Netherlands but my bigger one couldn't make the cut.

Seems like I'm not able to maintain a connection long enough to complete the upload.

[silver bison]

Have you tried in the last few hours?

[true hedge]

No luck at all this morning too

[river sorrel]

I did new mod its like legit 50mb and it get the same error!!

Is the workshop down? what is going on guys

[silver bison]

But a meant few hours back when i replied

[true hedge]

Sorry, I had been trying for since an hour or so before you commented.

[silver bison]

Ok thanks

Just keeping track

[true hedge]

No problem

[cerulean stone]

Yeah, something is broken
DEFAULT : Validating bundle successful
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 5%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 10%
BACKEND (E): Curl error=Timeout was reached
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 0%
BACKEND (E): Http Error (TIMEOUT)
BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[12] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Timeout
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 5%
DEFAULT : Uploading status: 10%
BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[13] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Error Code:524 - Unimplemented 5xx, apiCode="", uid="", message=""
DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: ""

[leaden zodiac]

Its to with cloudflare and not BI from what I understand

Nothing on our end

[whole stirrup]

Guys I uploaded one of my scenarions on workshop but when it is loaded on server it is not starting (it is giving errors). Yesterday everything was fine. Is there any problem with workshop that can cause this ?

[leaden zodiac]

Workshop is having issues rn due to cloudflare. Could be the reason behind it that or check ur server logs and try and see if its something else

[whole stirrup]

Will do 🫡 thank you

[flat pelican]

I’m really sorry, but can someone please tell me when this problem will finally be fixed?? I haven’t been able to upload a 700 MB map for two days now! Before, using a VPN helped, but now I’ve tried everything and nothing works. This is already unbearable!

[leaden zodiac]

apparantly its nothing to do with BI and is to do with Cloudflare.

[dense scaffold]

Yes, but actually no

[candid ice]

Can’t even upload 150mb without failing

12mb works

[hybrid fossil]

split your mod into 12

[candid ice]

Whatever compression magic bi uses its def like pushing it to the limit

30gb mod packs into 2.3gb

[flat pelican]

Maybe someone can help — is there any solution to this problem? I’ve already tried everything, but I can’t upload my 700 MB map. The server is running. I’ve tried every possible and impossible option, but it absolutely refuses to upload. I’d be very grateful for any information.

[silver kayak]

so if the server is running then turn the server off and then DL the map

[flat pelican]

No, I meant that I can’t start the server because the map isn’t there. I can’t upload it to the workshop. It’s been 4 days and absolutely nothing is working.

[leaden zodiac]

I assume its the same issue as last time. I am too having the same issue and I assume most people are too.

[coral lynx]

Heey heey, I try to update my mod, sadly I get the next error code and I dont know if the fault is on my end?
Error Code:524

[versed trail]

some people had luck uploading with a VPN outside the US(Netherlands), some not.

[coral lynx]

I live in the Netherlands and I cannot upload :C

[versed trail]

i never had any luck with Netherlands

[boreal pulsar]

I tried all countries last night. Turned off the VPN and it got to 35% and just sat there for 20mins and I aborted cause I have to leave for work.

[versed crag]

this is ridiculous

[grizzled sorrel]

Does anyone know of an existing mod that is just stationary undriveable vehicles to use as props? Trying to add a bunch of vehicles to my map but its causing too much lag.

[versed crag]

Just successfully published through the Netherlands

[coral lynx]

What magic did you do sir?

My mod is 400 mb, I heard mods below 12mb have no issues.

[versed crag]

No idea it just worked 😭

[coral lynx]

I am going to try again, see if it works. 😮

Nope didnt work :C

[dusty ore]

BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[28] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Error Code:524 - Unimplemented 5xx, apiCode="", uid="", message=""
DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: ""

[dusty ore]

BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[96] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Error Code:524 - Unimplemented 5xx, apiCode="", uid="", message=""
DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: ""

[brave egret]

Have a question how do I get a prefab vehicle to spawn already running or in engine on state?

[calm lintel]

i have a problem i did take wcs everon and wcs core to make a new map i copied the wcs world to my new mod to put the hq in the south more to the water so i can build an take off for planes. problem is it always shows me can not load mission header and showing unable to initialize game idk what to do i set everything up i think. idk whats wrong ive benn trying since 13 hours now i poublished the mod new 15 times and still not work the jason is showen valid 2025-10-05 20:56:55: RESOURCES : GetResourceObject @"{3AF24D4E81E4C4D6}Missions/Invictus_Barranka.conf"
2025-10-05 20:56:55: RESOURCES (E): Failed to open
2025-10-05 20:56:55: RESOURCES (E): MissionHeader::ReadMissionHeader cannot load the resource 'Missions/Invictus_Barranka.conf'!
2025-10-05 20:56:57: PROFILING : Initializing scripts took: 11.774300 ms

[versed crag]

Anyone having luck today? Still trying to upload. No luck.

[brave egret]

I have uploaded 7 updates to 3 separate mods.

[versed crag]

just got through

right after posting that message

thank the lord

[boreal pulsar]

Its working again!?

[versed crag]

yep

actually for me its reversed

with a vpn i cant get through

but in canada/us? works fine

but it seems to still be time dependant rather than size

if you have a fast upload speed you can get through but you might struggle at slower rates or higher uploads

[boreal pulsar]

I pretty good internet, butttt im still gonna kick the kids off everything 🤣

[versed crag]

leave it to bi to have us moving like we got dial up

[grim crater]

Looked and had some hope, no dice.

[oblique pollen]

its been 6 days, 12 hours, and 42 minutes since I was last able to upload. Ive begun hallucinating the reforger red X wherever I look

https://tenor.com/view/peter-griffin-peter-griffin-family-guy-psych-ward-gif-26893232

[deft token]

Same

[leaden zodiac]

Got nord VPN in attempt to update mod...still failed.

https://tenor.com/view/balthazar-crazy-family-guy-fou-gif-11775947423386520412

[dusty ore]

BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[25] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Error Code:524 - Unimplemented 5xx, apiCode="", uid="", message=""
DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: ""
This is my newly created MOD, 800mb in size. Why did the upload fail?

[dense scaffold]

MANW is over so no need for new mods sorry guys

[real glen]

Just started making a terrain in enfusion, want to publish it to workshop and keep getting error at about 75% complete...DEFAULT : Uploading status: 75%
BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[10] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Error Code:524 - Unimplemented 5xx, apiCode="", uid="", message=""
DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: "" its about 270mb and has gamesmaster subscene, can play it fine in the enfusion engine

[halcyon frost]

try vpn or just try on next day its by many problem

cant also even upload 150mb

i have no idea if i can make parts of navmesh its about 3gb and on upload 800mb ...

[oblique pollen]

How the hell can they have such a critical issue like this and not even make a public announcement about it? They post shit about an arma 3 livestream, but dont even mention that the house is on fire?

Like...hello bohemia? You realize most of your player base plays modded content right? If we stop making mods and your players lack new content. that's probably a net negative for everyone. This has been an issue for A MONTH NOW

[boreal pulsar]

Thats what Im saying to, like two or three until they can gather and get to the root and then update us. We are on a week with being left on read XD

[oblique pollen]

exactly. Im starting to get genuinely pissed off. Its not that fucking hard to communicate with your community. Give me something to pass on to my community members to explain why the fuck I havent dished out new content in weeks.

[halcyon frost]

I couldn’t find any information on how to fix this or anyone who knows how to solve it.
All I found in the group is advice to try using a VPN with different countries or just wait.
I can upload smaller files (up to 100 MB) without any issues, but when it’s between 100 MB and 1 GB,
I get the same error as you.

[oblique pollen]

I had no luck with the VPN thing tbh. I was able to get a 300MB update out by spam attempting for about 6 hours. But my main map is 1.3GB

lmfao

seems highly time based.

[halcyon frost]

I can’t even start the server — I don’t have the navmesh, and to download it I need an 800 MB file.
No matter what I try, nothing works, and now the server has been down for a whole week. 😅

[oblique pollen]

https://feedback.bistudio.com/T194844

If your having the same issue report it here guys, this seems to be the only place we have a chance of getting their attention

[subtle dust]

Anyone have a good banking system ?

[violet berry]

@oblique pollen

[lavish chasm]

[halcyon frost]

who is Louie?

[lavish chasm]

https://reforger.armaplatform.com/workshop/664E0A097C173E83-Outlasted

[silver bison]

Downstream restrictions of this mod seems to contradict APL-ND @ebon river

[ebon river]

I'll check it out,.

[hybrid fossil]

The irony as he seems to be using nearly every existing mod from the workshop in his own 😅

[ebon river]

[prisma fox]

Anyone know how to edit a vehicles actual armor?

[halcyon frost]

yes in vehicle prefab

there is damage component

with hizones

[prisma fox]

Can you show me?

Are there separate CE and KE values?

Or do those have to be made

[halcyon frost]

there is many configs to edit its not so easy...
write in search damage and find DAMAGE component - by vehicle prefab UAZ.et

[prisma fox]

Is the armor shown in MM?

Or like a component

[halcyon frost]

every car has .et file u have it?

like ur character

wait a moment i upload now when its done i make a screenshot

[halcyon frost]

there is no armor there is damage maanger

and its very hard to edit it

beacuse there is many damag configs like collasion/kinetic/fire exploision and more

[prisma fox]

What does it look like?

May I see what the main frame of the Uaz looks like for example with that?

[halcyon frost]

its from arma reforger vanille car u can open like me by duplicate and looking by component what there inside better use GPTchat its says correctly what to do

u losing here many time just write on google gpt chat it says in 10 seconds all what u have to do step to step

and also how to config ur damage component

[prisma fox]

And if it’s a modded Vic?

[halcyon frost]

u can also find an damage manager but modded is more diffuclt to edit because some dont have hitzones u have to look into it and config with gpt chat

[halcyon frost]

Error Try the suggestions in this Community Tip to help you fix Error 524: A timeout occurred. Background Error 524 error indicates that Cloudflare made a successful TCP connection to the origin web server, but the origin did not reply with an HTTP response before the connection timed out. Typically, Cloudflare waits 100 seconds for an HTTP response. If the origin doesn’t respond in that time, Cloudflare closes the connection and you’ll see “Error 524: A timeout occurred”. [PRO UP SELL] Qui…

[hybrid fossil]

the damage component is what I told you about earlier..

lol

[halcyon frost]

Bohemia write me answer per email lol
i should use mobile internet wtf 😄 i have only mobile internet...

maybe someone will help this info

"Life's hard enough, and now I'm supposed to act like an FBI agent and fetch files from the Pentagon just to install Workshop mods."

this comments in forum xD

pls write who tested to use mobile internet if it help u to fix the problem

can we break the 100seconds line?

[halcyon frost]

if someone can upload pls conatact me i have about 800mb mod can u publish it for me

[clear willow]

There’s a large amount of people who can’t upload, myself included whether it is 4mb or 1000,

Shit has been broken for nearly a month for me.

If you haven’t already add to the list here.

https://feedback.bistudio.com/T194844

[dense scaffold]

Does this happen in exp workshop as well?

[clear willow]

Not sure, haven’t tried there.

[silk stream]

Hey all, having a big problem trying to open up Reforger tools on my desktop.
Seen a ticket open for a while: https://feedback.bistudio.com/T192593

The logs in this ticket are pretty much the same as mine but the project doesn't live on One Drive.

Anyone know any tricks to get it working again?
I've reinstalled the tools, created a project with just Reforger but have not gotten any luck just yet.

Experimental works like a charm

[lavish gyro]

https://community.bistudio.com/wiki/Arma_Reforger:Startup_Parameters#clearSettings
try this

-clearSettings add it to your startup paramters for the workbench on steam

[silk stream]

ahhh brilliant! Worked like a charm. Thanks a million 😁

[nova whale]

Please Help. Got this error. Uploaded my project many times... but this time i got this.

[nova whale]

Ah Sorry. I got it. Dont use a leading Zero. i did 0.5.01 this is wrong with 0.5.11 its working

[nova whale]

LOL i have a 4050mb Mod and cant upload. using VPN sometimes gave better results but now its always break at 8-12%

[clear willow]

Join the ticket is all I can say at this point, there’s a long list of people on it already at this point and I don’t know how else it’ll get through to them.

It’s almost a month now I’ve had this issue.

[boreal pulsar]

Who else comes here once or twice a day to see if the issue is fixed

[cedar wigeon]

i just wanna upload 😭

[warm belfry]

so if its not working how am i getting mod updates every day still

[hybrid fossil]

Doesn't seem to be a global problem. I haven't had any issues

[nova whale]

A few days ago i uploaded a update for my mod at first try without problems...now with a few fixes and stuff i got this error for 2 days now. I have bad luck because i can run the upload beside work in blender and spam the upload button again and again for my 4gb mod

[cedar wigeon]

are ur mods small? i only have issues w my larger ones

some days you'll have short spans where you are able to upload, but majority of the day its endless error 524s for anything over 100mb

[dawn lotus]

anything over 80mb for me will fail upload.

and 90% of my mods are over 80mb.......... =[

[mystic sparrow]

ouf. Hey Gator, you able to hit me up about using one of your vics as a dependency? I have a cool one cooking but I need to swap the base vic and saw your Gatoma

[dawn lotus]

are you talking about mesh swapping something onto my gatoma?

[mystic sparrow]

so texture swap and throwing the auto cannon and eventually auto sam onto the back

[fathom jacinth]

What causes rifles to only be held by one hand and not raise to the eye when ADS?

[dawn lotus]

bad anim setup #enfusion_animation

[dawn lotus]

https://tenor.com/view/i'll-allow-it-gif-17514413855288578269

[mystic sparrow]

I'd fucking kiss you but I'm not Reptophile

[low drift]

I uploaded 400mb today. But my 2gb main gear mod Ive been trying over a week and still nothing.

[oblique pollen]

I think it has to do with upload speeds.

If you can upload before cloudflare times out your connection (like 100 seconds) your golden.

[nocturne oracle]

Ah, looks like I'm not the only one getting the timeout error

212mb upload error 524. It's a good time

[wooden quartz]

Good evening, I have a question: I want to make the boats from the RHIB mod appear, but they only spawn on land . I can’t make them appear directly in the water. Do you have a solution to make them spawn directly in the water

[rare otter]

Any terrain editers here? looking for someone to work with on making a Everon X Arland X Kolguyev map, with possible help creating a scenario with it

[boreal pulsar]

I was able to get to 91% on 900mb and then timed out 😑 lol

[nocturne oracle]

Yeah the workshop is not having a good day today

[oblique pollen]

so close XD

I usually get like 20 percent of the way... I have slow upload speeds and the map is 1.2GB

[mystic sparrow]

https://reforger.armaplatform.com/workshop/667B178339E77ACE-PhaToma4x4

[elfin vector]

You being sarcastic right ?

This has been going on since early September....

[dark pulsar]

Monetization of selling skins / clothing etc.. I'm assuming has to be custom models, like not models from a clothing mod on the workshop yes?

[spark plume]

I can't attach silencers to some weapons. Why is that? I'm using the Bacon mod as a silencer.

[cold grail]

not for everyone so some people arent even aware

like personally I have had no issues uploading (from East Coast NA)

[elfin vector]

I have given up...

It has been a month and can't upload 😭.

[cold grail]

maybe try using a vpn in east coast NA?

[elfin vector]

I have tried all over the world !!!!!

Nothing works...

Netherlands worked a few times for me and now it doesn't...

[lavish chasm]

you, sir, should offer VDI so ppl can upload their projects through a Virtual Desktop at your crib. Because apparently your able to deliver something VPN's (Proton and NordVPN all locations, Azure virtual desktop Ireland, Contabo Virtual Desktop Germany) cant deliver: a working upload to workshop.

Have you tested with projects of 1GB or more?

[river rapids]

how big was your upload?

[nocturne oracle]

Never had an issue up until yesterday. Interesting.

[leaden zodiac]

Its got that bad that I now get "cloudflare" adds on youtube because of this problem.... they are watching me

[elfin vector]

Sorry to hear that.

Hope you manage to come right.

I'm just waiting for a fix so I can upload, my mod is just getting bigger at this point since iv been working on it this month and haven't play tested at all.

[leaden zodiac]

im scared that ima be able to upload updates on my mod and stuff breaks to then not be able to upload fixes

[elfin vector]

You concern is real.

This is my concern aswell.

That is why Iv been going through every little thing to make sure the mod is without major issues.

[nova whale]

Did Bohemia said anything about this topic these days?

Not realy make sense but maybe is has something to do with Make Arma Not War?

[cold grail]

couple hundred MB

i dont remember exactly it was one of the WCS mods

[cold grail]

couldnt i just give my email so you could add me as contributor and then upload?

oh wait that would require an update i think

i dont see why a VPN wouldn’t work, as long as the vpn connection holds

[final talon]

The connection doesn’t hold. That’s the issue. It times out. I don’t know the technical details but that seems to be why larger mods have more trouble than smaller ones. Smaller ones get through before timing out

[vast vale]

any solution for this? trying to add this helis on server but cant place it on helipads.

[oblique pollen]

I would guess its an issue with the model itself? like they had it negative on the axis so it clips into the ground

if anyone is like me periodically checking to see if enfusion uploady worky.

Still no dice.

[halcyon frost]

Been trying all day, still no luck....

[nocturne oracle]

VPN to the Netherlands worked for me. I'm East Coast USA

That's been after 30-40 tries

[halcyon frost]

Im in Norway, tried since last friday

[quasi sable]

anyone trying to upload a mod only to have it stop and stick at a random percentage?

[halcyon frost]

Had that happen as well, but the last few days the upload fails at 20 or 21%

[quasi sable]

https://tenor.com/view/sad-pepe-cry-tears-frog-gif-17646741

[nocturne oracle]

That is the current conversation good buddy

[oblique pollen]

literally going to pack up my entire PC and drive to some families house with gigabit speeds just to publish this map update in a few days XD

muh player base craves content

[halcyon frost]

Hopefully it helps!

[halcyon frost]

At this point it kind of feels pointless to mod on Arma Reforger, i had an update ready for 9 days now and because bi cant get their shit together the update and mod is useless, Just sitting on the workbench gathering dust, a few more days and im just going to delete all my mod files and permanently remove Reforger from my steam games and just forget about the whole Arma series.

[silver kayak]

id be careful saying that kinda suff if i was you

[halcyon frost]

Why? Am i going to get banned like anyone else who got anything critical to say? 😅

[silver kayak]

its just not good to say bad stuff you know that

[halcyon frost]

Last time there was a problem with uploading Reforger mods it only lasted for 2 days, but 9 days and still no solution, doesn't make me more hopefull for Arma's future.

[oblique pollen]

It does suck yea. But Im happy to cut my teeth in reforger tools developing my skills to hopefully take somewhere else.

It'l come back, take a hiatus or just stack up a mega update!

They are working on it, arma has a vested interested in letting Modder's mod. If the mods stop flowing popularity for their game will slump over time.

[halcyon frost]

Yeah that's true, Just worried that there will be another 9 days where we cant update og upload our mods, but have given me time to polish up the look of my mod. https://youtu.be/0d3dYz05JAA?si=YEmXFnm13pSatSrp

[dawn lotus]

gl

we have 2gbit and cant get past 60% on a 2.3gb mod

wish we could sign up for like priority uploads, ill give bohemia my identity\location\guid\mod names if that were a thing

like if someone has 500+ consecutive uploads and mods they need to update\support, that should be a thing.

[oblique pollen]

😭

[elfin vector]

I did this !

Got to work early and setup my PC, the boss looked at me like WTF...

[oblique pollen]

😂 helll yea.

did it work?

[elfin vector]

Bro 9 days .... ???

This issue has been going on for 40 days for me.

[oblique pollen]

yea its been an issue for a month

but it was intermittant before

now its constant.

[elfin vector]

No.... 😭

But try anyway anything is possible

[oblique pollen]

riiip

[elfin vector]

I had a few people say there is no issue or only a few people are having this issue but everyday I see more and more people coming here and saying the exact same thing about 524 error.

[sacred quarry]

Bohemia most likely has a long term contract with Cloudfare and can’t switch to another more reliable CDN to resolve the issue

[nova whale]

But Cloudflare has to ensure that the service is working fine. For Sure the Contract isnt that people cant upload stuff

[sacred quarry]

It’s probably cost prohibitive for them to break contract due to service unfulfillment. They probably have a good service rate that they want to keep and hope the Cloudfare gets their stuff fixed.

[nova whale]

Did Bohemia said anything about this?

[sacred quarry]

They said the issue is with Cloudfare and it’s not something that their team can address

[nova whale]

Okay. But its very unlikely that a big company dont get thinks like that fixed after so much time

[sacred quarry]

You would think, but I don’t know. Have you been reading the news around Cloudfare recently? Not looking to good.

[sacred quarry]

Bohemia might have no other choice soon to drop Cloudfare, but that being said, there was a DDOS attack for two months earlier this year that took workshop down and they just waited it out until it stopped.

[hybrid fossil]

They waited it out? surely they did something about it?

[sacred quarry]

Sadly not.

[nova whale]

Why someone attacks modding platforms. for what reason.

[sacred quarry]

There’s a lot of losers out there

[hybrid fossil]

it was someone from Russia attacking the game just because it was fun to him

[nova whale]

But it would nice if bohemia made a official statement with some infos what we can expect.

i mean Reforger lives for its mods

[sacred quarry]

Yeah, we all wish that Bohemia was more transparent about their service functions. The best we can do is hope that the admin on the Feedback page for Bohemia refers your report to the team and enough people do that so the team cannot ignore them anymore.

[sacred quarry]

We need very accurate reporting with a lot of data. Otherwise it’s just noise to their team.

[nova whale]

Yes thats right. How can we do this? is there already a report site or something?

[sacred quarry]

https://feedback.bistudio.com/T194844

[mellow creek]

They did indeed do something about it, they got cloudfare!

[sacred quarry]

Lol

[mellow creek]

That's what stopped the ddos stuff iirc

[sacred quarry]

Bohemia be like “oppsy”

[mellow creek]

Hey I mean it stopped it successfully! Wasnt until only about a month ago people started having upload problems with the current issue.

[sacred quarry]

It’s a little disconcerting that’s all I’ll say. What are year for a modding competition when their services are off-line for half the year

[mellow creek]

It hasn't been half a year, you're exaggerating

[sacred quarry]

Your right, only for 4 months

[mellow creek]

LOL still exaggerating

[dawn lotus]

but yet they keep using cloudflare and nobody can upload anything over 50mb

ive noticed that if something doesnt effect the dev team directly they dont give a single fuck about it

[dawn lotus]

yes

[halcyon frost]

Damn.....We'll see how long it takes before people can upload their mods again.

[oblique pollen]

Yea I just moved my PC to a place with much faster upload and Im still unable to publish. Seems upload activity goes in very rapid spurts. almost like its doing one file, pausingg, then another file.

Im confident that if it were to upload continuously Id be able to upload within the roughly 100 second cloudflare timeout window.

I was getting much farther in the upload though. around 60% instead of my usual 20%

VPN usage reduced average percentage.

[halcyon frost]

Guess we just have to wait and see... How long it will take i do not dare to predict.

[dark pulsar]

Dev has verified on here they are working on it several times but it's not an easy fix.

On my 4th try uploading one this morning

[empty flicker]

Experimental... tryed 5 times.

[versed trail]

7% was the furthest i got this morning before it stalls out(no VPN). Now it wont even go past 1%...Last week I used VPN Netherlands and got to 80% then failed. Netherlands is crap now too.

[dawn lotus]

since we cant upload any significant asset mods (this is mainly what is being effected as small mods are able to publish >30-50mb)

give us the full persistence system in experimental so in the mean time everyone that uses EPF\EDF can migrate their systems while you guys (bohemia) fix whats wrong with the workshop.

thank god you guys moved away from steam workshop right? 😄

so far the only caveat to not using steam is so consoles can download mods....

[halcyon frost]

Have anyone tried to publish larger mods on the experimental workbench?

[oblique pollen]

yes read above a bit.

has the same issue

[halcyon frost]

Really sad that the pc users have our experience ruined because of the console bots....

[oblique pollen]

console wouldnt be so bad if xbox didnt have their shitty series S

[dawn lotus]

consoles cant contribute to modding arma.

[halcyon frost]

Too bad, would publish my mod on there if it would work, but at least i'll get time to figure out how to play custom music tracks in my missions

[dawn lotus]

a certain credit is due to pc users for making all the mods that console users play with.

give us a break BI, we get it you want console sales, but at what cost?

[oblique pollen]

lmao my biggest issue is that PC modders (the only modders) dont actually optimize their mods

[dawn lotus]

games from 12 years ago perform better in some areas than this 'modern' engine

[oblique pollen]

if I see one more mod with 0 LODS and more verts than a helicopter for a shirt ima lose my mind XD

[dawn lotus]

we could all just make a arma pc modders union and make our mods so that no console can run them

[oblique pollen]

nooo

console is not the problem here

[dawn lotus]

since consoles cant contribute to modding why are we optimizing for them?

[oblique pollen]

people dont lmao

I do because I have community members who enjoy playing in my server who come from all platforms

[dawn lotus]

i do too, half my population is console players

[oblique pollen]

most people do not give a damn to optimize their mods. its actually insnae. PC just brute forces through it

[dawn lotus]

but if this is going to be a pattern into the future - every time a major update is on the way the workshop takes a dive.... whats the point?

[oblique pollen]

the point is to gain experience and get what you can get. if its not enough then nobody is holding anyone hostage in the modding community. were very fortunate to have powerful tools like we have

most games dont release the resources they used to MAKE the game

[dawn lotus]

not to mention new consoles will be coming out in the next 2 years, and they will have to rebuild everything for the new systems

[oblique pollen]

Maybe

[dawn lotus]

nvidia just joined with intel.

[oblique pollen]

hopefully the new ones mesh in pretty well. at least performance will be better once they are linked in

[dawn lotus]

computing in general is about to have a major shift, possibly with windows being able to run on ARM chips

which will make current pc's and consoles obsolete

[dawn lotus]

i get that and i halfway agree, but we're in a time in the world where technology is moving so fast, that relying on old methods is just going to hold everyone back

just so what, publishers can make more $?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7NF3CdXkm68

wonder how long it will take for engines to adopt this tech amongst 100s of other optimizations coming our way hardware and software-wise

[lethal night]

years if ever.

[oblique pollen]

ultimately its gonna come down to people choosing to spend money on consoles, or PC's. If the general population decides consoles are a waste of money (and they are, if your tech savy imo) then naturally commercial enterprises would move away from limiting themselves to console hardware

[dawn lotus]

we may have a few years where console hardware is more powerful than any pc, with what nvidia and intel are working on

[oblique pollen]

I doubt console hardware will ever be more powerful than PC. Consoles are just closed system PC's

unless theres something im missin

[dawn lotus]

nvidia\intel are working on system-on-chip architecture for consumer electronics, i.e. consoles, handhelds, and phones

gpu-cpu-ram all on a single chip

[dark pulsar]

Yeah everything will be actual pcs soon

Consoles will be apps on them

Or just their own brand of them but open architecture. Like a gaming box or something.Entertainment box

[dawn lotus]

there will be no more upgrading single peices of hardware, every few years you will have to buy a SOC device to stay current

[dark pulsar]

It'll be subscription based prob so you never own anything.You just lease it and get free replacements upgrsdes repairs or whatever

[dawn lotus]

i really hope developers are keeping an eye on this stuff and preparing for it, otherwise we will just be in the same boat we are now: software is 2-6 years behind hardware

[oblique pollen]

that sounds terrible XD

Not trying to naysay, the tech sounds great

but fuck man. the subscription model is really the enshittification of everything

[dark pulsar]

They already have tvs and stuff like that

But yeah not saying I love it

[dawn lotus]

if people keep buying it, they will keep making it.

[dark pulsar]

They will own your hard drive.

[dawn lotus]

https://youtube.com/shorts/SOq5ha0hLAE?si=PkdcZi-Wnq1YaKqe

expect that for early-mid 2026

[hard dawn]

Half of the mods at the workshop are not optimized in any way.

[rotund bane]

Is it correct to assume that mods uploaded through Experimental Workbench don't show up on the external Workshop.

[dawn lotus]

what external workshop?

[rotund bane]

Browser version.
https://reforger.armaplatform.com/workshop

[dense scaffold]

My banana peel mine has no LODs

Thankfully pixel size scale makes it disappear pretty quick

[dark pulsar]

No, you have to make a second bohemia account on the experimental server

[rotund bane]

What I mean is mods uploaded through experimental are only visible through in-game experimental workshop but don't show up via an external browser search?

[nova whale]

Thats crazy bro. Making Lods was the next thing i learned after the first stuff. Last month i downgraded a lot of my textures because i was feeling bad using 2k materials for some stuff

[dark pulsar]

Correct

They are completely different databases

[nova whale]

I wonder how long bohemia will stay silent...maybe some people will wonder if there is no RHS, WCS or one of the great Community Arma Drivers receiving updates anymore. I love reforger and the Enfusion is an amazing engine...but thats makes it hurt much more.

[empty flicker]

We need to try Exp. 1.6 Updates on our dedicated.... but can't upload

[nova whale]

Are the guys with the ARMA after the name devs?

[hybrid fossil]

Don't be so hard on console players and consoles being part of the game in general. I am a console player AND a modder and I assure you I wouldn't even be playing the game if it hadn't arrived on xbox. I'm sure this is the case for many people too.

I don't think console is the issue anyway. Many games are on console and PC and do well. It's the job of the devs to maintain and keep all versions of the game running as good as possible.

[candid ice]

It’s more of a time and energy thing than discrimination against console players

Optimize for 3 platforms and their unique hardware or optimize for one, which one takes longer and more effort

[hybrid fossil]

If other companies can do it surely BI can? We need to stop treating BI like some indie developer they surely have the money and the means to do a better job

[candid ice]

Innovations for pc platform hardware and software come out every day, but since this game is made for consoles as well, it’s unlikely we will ever see those kinds of optimizations

[lavish gyro]

plus the requirements to have a game on xbox or playstation are FAR stricter (at least 5x as strict as Steam imo)

bohemia need to be very careful about everything they do because of big corpo

plus there arent many alternatives to this sort of thing, like what, youve got squad? and mods for that are pc only...

[hybrid fossil]

You mean alternatives to Arma on console? SQUAD is not on console.

Hell let loose is probably the closest thing

And there are no mods at least on console

[lavish gyro]

so none really then

imagine if VBS4 was open to the public

[dawn lotus]

one of the downsides of using a proprietary engine is teaching new staff how to use the engine before they can actually get any work done. where as engines like unreal, you just hire someone who knows unreal engine.

from what ive heard yeah they are not an indie studio but they are also not a large group.

[dense scaffold]

"Cant upload mods to workshop"
"It's because consoles"
Some folks are just obsessed

[humble current]

I heard consoles are the cause of most world problems to be fair Bacon.

Remember how we lost the last harvest of corn?

[dense scaffold]

I blame consoles every time I get shot in reforger

[nova whale]

RoN also get bader after Console Release... But to be fair its not sooo bad like many people say.

[dire copper]

I thought hackers or something caused the workshop issue

[nova whale]

I dont know. i cant find any official info about that

[dire copper]

Me either just saw some suggestions of someone saying it’s happened before for the reason

[halcyon frost]

You're the one suddenly babbling about your console lol also your mods aren't all that good either.

[dense scaffold]

https://tenor.com/view/boom-cat-cat-boom-boom-cat-funny-funny-cat-boom-cat-explode-gif-9960205079262219110

[halcyon frost]

It's happening cause the devs are a bunch of lazy drug addicts and a bunch of women have been added to the dev team, so that wont make things much better either.

[dire copper]

I understand women might be on average worse developers than men but we can’t say it’s a women’s fault also the dev team has so much there doing other than workshop issues that happened randomly
.

And yes I know what if a women messed it up but what if a man did.

[true hedge]

It's 2025 not 1925. Get with the times. Neanderthals are alive and well it seems.

[hybrid fossil]

I think he was banned already 🙏

[true hedge]

Good

[nova whale]

Cant say that women's are more worse artists then man. saw a lot of crazy good stuff from Last of Us made by woman's.

[oblique pollen]

Fuck this guy lmfao

[silver kayak]

yeah he has a big mouth

[dire copper]

I was trying to be considerate of his claim and why people have doubts on women talent idc if there good there good bro

[elfin vector]

Damn...

Keep it chilled

It is a videogame no need to blow a gasket and start calling the Dev's drug addicts and bashing on women dev's.

https://tenor.com/view/sitting-here-like-tired-sleepy-blinking-blink-gif-12067726

[dire copper]

The guy that said ts got banned

[versed trail]

i want my MTV

[dawn lotus]

well i mean... if we had steam workshop.......

whats easier to attack, a single workshop from BI or all of steam?

[dire copper]

Yes but people like console gamers which not just console sales encourages community activity and keeps games alive and allows people on ps xbox and pc to enjoy arma a game around mods personally people are reasonably mad abt having to do console things but it’s helping the community also in pretty sure you don’t have to make console key binds or anything

[sacred quarry]

Additional console player base is a net good. More players = more fun.

[leaden zodiac]

Cant even download bloody minecraft resource packs cus of bloody cloudflare

[dire copper]

I just like the idea of a unified game not fighting for mods on Xbox or ps and being able to play with pc playing with mods

[versed trail]

https://www.securityweek.com/record-breaking-ddos-attack-peaks-at-22-tbps-and-10-bpps/#:~:text=The attack was aimed at,known and zero-day vulnerabilities.

[versed trail]

success, just uploaded VPN Netherlands. give it a shot peeps.

[boreal pulsar]

How many mb?

[versed trail]

2065 MB i think is what it said

[boreal pulsar]

https://tenor.com/view/tears-of-joy-tears-happiness-kevin-hart-crying-gif-18835009

[boreal pulsar]

Now I gotta 10 more hours of work to see if it’ll work for me 🤣

[versed trail]

bummer

you seem sick

should go home

[boreal pulsar]

🤧

[versed trail]

ugh. one of my lakes dissappeared. now i have to update it or leave it. I was hoping never to get back in to workbench ever again....

fingers crossed i can upload again

[true hedge]

not working for me still. gets to 65% then fails.

[empty flicker]

15%... 😄

[simple ferry]

18%...

[empty flicker]

Default 120 sec cloudflare timeout

[true hedge]

fernz took our bandwidth guys, wheres my pitchfork lol

[empty flicker]

im in germany, we never have bandwidth 😄

[true hedge]

Im in rural Wales, our bandwidth is made from wool off the sheep

[nova whale]

😃😃😃 Fühl Ich. Nutze den Gigacube hier auf dem Land 🤣

[nocturne oracle]

Denmark and Netherlands worked for me.

[sacred quarry]

120 sec cloudflare timeout on 820mb upload from Netherlands. Still broken.

[sacred quarry]

Upload successful, 820MB from East Coast USA/Canada. no VPN

[dawn lotus]

tried uploading 2.3gb from east coast USA no luck.

[leaden zodiac]

Any news?

Any like trails of just progress being made to fix this?

[empty flicker]

Also today, no luck... NL - DK - PO - CZ - DE always 120 sec timeout

[dire copper]

Project mythic was able to update the mod today

It was a decent size to

[plush otter]

I was able to update twice today without vpn, 1gb each. Yesterday was only able to update mods under 500mb. Not sure if lucky or situation is improving

[dawn lotus]

moving into week 5 of not being able to update my mods -.-

[oblique pollen]

yea I got all excited cus it sounds like some people are having success but Its still not workin for me

[outer tartan]

mod size 500mb

[oblique pollen]

whats your upload speed? Cus I moved to a spot with better wifi and I realised that im actually bottlenecked by bohemias upload speed. at a certain point I was getting diminishing returns because it doesnt upload everything all at once. It was like it started and stopped a hole bunch.

Im curious if the timeout was still there and bohemia was just accepting faster uploads

[plush otter]

at least a gig up/download speed, on ethernet connection not wifi

[humble current]

I know we've had issues updating British Forces, but all the sub 100mb ARMA-RY mods I think have mostly been able to upload, bar some occasional failures.

It is frustrating.

[boreal pulsar]

Anything over 800 is the limit for me

[whole harbor]

I try every day to have a luck to update my mod (2Go)

[true hedge]

I'm unable to do my map at 700mb

[cerulean stone]

Same here, 1.3gb map always stops at 11%.

[low drift]

I was able to upload 1.2gb yesterday

[lethal night]

It depends on how busy our backend is, if it does not repond fast enough it will fail. Until we have fixed the issue you can realistically just stop trying

[empty flicker]

So, its need to response in the 120 Sec ? Because it always failed after exactly 120 sec.

[lethal night]

Yes

[oblique pollen]

I know this probably wont get a response but. Any word from the guys that are working on the fix as far as timeframe/difficulty of fix? Obviously nobody can pin an exact time but, is this something that's expected to be an issue for months, or a weeks?

[lethal night]

I do not know, and I believe we do not promise any timeframe on this until we could confirm our idea for fixing it actually works.

[dense scaffold]

Cloudflare enterprise plan too pricey for this project?

Could work around the issue by just having a cluster of reverse proxies that are not cloudflared, 20 minutes of work and people can upload beyond 2 minutes (until a solution is created)

Ie. even a bunch of unmetered hetzner servers

[barren palm]

I'm just glad its not only me.

[oblique pollen]

Appreciate the reply. I'll pass this along to my team.

[empty flicker]

But if this is the case, the backend is always maxed out. Because you can't even upload at 03:00 CET where the most Europeans are on sleep.

[low drift]

Woah woah woah pal. Let’s not muddy the conversation with your… logic.

[real glen]

anybody want to upload my mod for me?? lol been trying for about 2 weeks, its 275mb the closest ive got is 80 odd percentage, its a good map mod come on take it workshop. dont give me your errors, just let me share 100 hours of painting textures lol

[blazing rivet]

Anybody know any good tutorials? I made arma 3 mods and want to make a patch for a mod for reforger, but the workbench is uh, pretty different than A3 tools lol

[dire copper]

the bohemia wiki takes awhle but its the best so far

[blazing rivet]

Awesome, thank you!

[elfin vector]

There is a lot of tutorials and information out there just have to search what you want to do, a good start will be YouTube and this Discord.

Using the search function in the Discord can help alot, just have to scan through the comments/messages until you find the answer.

[blazing rivet]

Thank you!

[fervent summit]

https://tenor.com/view/waiting-loading-fail-throw-rage-gif-7225569

[elfin vector]

If you have questions send them through.

The Enfusion workbench is way more powerful than A3 stuff, there is just a rather big learning curve, in my opinion make a test project and just start messing/playing around this way you will learn the interface of the workbench whilst not messing up any inportant work done.

https://youtu.be/Fgl_mAHReP4?si=BDf0jj2sH6c7lMGN

[silver bison]

It's not only the timeout. There is also an issue that our uploads get flagged and blocked.
The issue is more complicated than that and hence why we do not provide ETA. @oblique pollen

Also we can not just change how it uploads to any other service or setup as we do not do regular file uploads. It's more complicated than that.

[oblique pollen]

👌 I appreciate the information!

[silver bison]

If it was an easy fix, as bacon implied. It would have been solved quickly.

Unfortunately it is not.

[empty flicker]

But why we did not had such issue 2 - 3 weeks ago? Any changes made?

[silver bison]

The issues have been there for months

Also, the more you try. The worse it gets for you.

So give it some time, then try later

[empty flicker]

Not notice, but thanks for the update Mario

[oblique pollen]

I understand. Yea I know we have been a bit rowdy lately about the whole situation. obviously everyone has a lot invested with everything. (you guys working on the issue, and us as modders)

I do appreciate the update and hope that you guys keep us posted. Ik theres nothing we can do about it on our side, but open communication about everything smooths everything out a lot. Even if it feels like a waste of time.

[blazing rivet]

Thank you, because im just trying to make a patch for a mod ( its license is APL ) and im just trying to figure out where to make, binarize, and upload the thing 😅

[silver bison]

Just for reference as well, it is only actually 524 Cloudflare error if the error message mentions the timeout specifically unlike in this picture.

The ones like the one I mentioned here, are other Cloudflare issues.

That is why on some it says specifically what happened, and in others it does not and says Unimplemented 5xx

[silver bison]

If it does show like in here, with the explanation "Timeout occurred", then it is in fact 524 Cloudflare error. Anything else are other things.

[empty flicker]

Its always 524 after 120 sec and 15% - Also the upload time does not care

[silver bison]

Unimplemented 5xx show 524 yeah

but they are not 524 as in the actual error that happened

only the one that says timeout is the true 524

Unfortunate as it misleads people into thinking the issue is just timeouts

[outer tartan]

what could be the cause of my error?

[empty flicker]

Ok, no its always the timeout. Yesterday i talked to Niles, would be could to Release 1.6 after this issue is fixed

[silver bison]

All the other 5xx errors

The logging for them is unimplemented so who knows what happened there

[outer tartan]

is it something related to me or it's only a problem of the BI backend?

[silver bison]

Niles does not know about this

All he gets is people complaining about 524

[outer tartan]

I can upload mods of smaller size

up to 200mb, after that I get 524

[silver bison]

and everyone says 524 because unimplemented 5xx always shows that

[silver bison]

Can't tell because you got 5xx unimplemented

Could be us, could be you, could be your data got blocked and flagged, could be cloudflare

[empty flicker]

i think you guys know what you do. Only hope we can upload again before 1.6 coming out. Otherwise we have no time to test updates on Exp and dedicated

[outer tartan]

uh? data blocked and flagged?

it's my custom made assets pack for my map fishers island

[silver bison]

If cloudflare recognizes your uploads as suspicious and similar to an attack, it can block you.

[outer tartan]

oohh you mean packages not actual mod data

[silver bison]

If it shows unimplemented 5xx. It shows when the return code was higher than 530, which can be any of these as well https://developers.cloudflare.com/support/troubleshooting/http-status-codes/cloudflare-1xxx-errors/
and
https://developers.cloudflare.com/support/troubleshooting/http-status-codes/cloudflare-10xxx-errors/

[dense scaffold]

Who would flag uploads made through reverse proxies that aren't behind cloudflare?

[candid ice]

My team hasn’t been able to upload anything over 800mb on a 300mbit upload speed connection

We were able to upload everything under 800mb

The 2 minute window is what it’s looking like

[silver bison]

It is set to 600 secs iirc.

But if you get the error

pls post the whole error and specific time and timezone

that way we can track

[silver bison]

Just posting this, does not help us track specifically what happened in X case

[empty flicker]

So, we should no longer post errors? We do not get more feedback from workbench and we already talked about the timeout 2 hours ago?

[versed trail]

RESOURCES (E): Failed to load metafile of image: UI/Textures/MissionThumbnails/Default.edds
BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[18] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Error Code:524 - Unimplemented 5xx, apiCode="", uid="", message=""
DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: "" just now. 5:11 US EST got to 14% and failed. VPN Netherlands. (initially i thought VPN was off)

[stable rune]

BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[107] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKBENCH_GetAsset] Error Code:400 - Bad Request, apiCode="workshopApi.assetNotPublished", uid="1760733989381-698393", message="Asset 6544A9B43E0BCA61 is not published"
BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[108] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_CancelAssetUpload] Error Code:404 - Not Found, apiCode="NotFound", uid="1760733989583-547210", message="Not Found"
BACKEND (E): Curl error=Timeout was reached PDT Time

[silver bison]

Just send them to me, and @cloud glacier.

We will aggregate them 🙂

[obtuse tiger]

2 months now. 😔

(Didnt bother to scroll up but did now) Hope its fixed eventually. 🤞🏻

[grizzled sorrel]

FYI, the 400 and 404 errors only started for me after adding a contributor email address to my project. I can remove the contributors and it uploads fine! @silver bison thoughts?

[grizzled sorrel]

do you have contributors listed by chance in your project?

[versed trail]

SUCCESS

[pine sluice]

Jealous

[obtuse tiger]

negative

[silver bison]

Has the contributor uploaded anything in workshop before?

[grizzled sorrel]

No, that was it. He went to an invite in his email but it said it was invalid. but it worked the next time i tried anyway.

[hasty tundra]

DEFAULT (E): Addon processing on Workshop side failed! Error UID: "" Error Message : "Unknown Error" i keep getting this error? what am i doing wrong? Lmfao. someone please help

[hasty tundra]

https://tenor.com/view/why-persian-room-cat-guardian-but-why-trendizisst-anyaboz-gif-2156104475561014590

[oblique pollen]

just read up a bit man

been an issue for a month now

[spice citrus]

Why am I getting 'Can't initialize engine' when I try to use the reforger tools for the first time?

This is what's on my screen

[quasi sable]

how

[gilded root]

This is getting ridiculous

[quasi sable]

its fully blocking progress until the timeout after 120 secs. been doing it for a week now, when the timer hits 2 min my upload stalls and holds for 2 min then 524.

[stable rune]

@quasi sable youre not the only one Im having the same issue I cant even update my map and its been over 2 months but all we can do is be patient wait until they can fix the problem

[old yoke]

Oh my god, please add a web page where the author can interact with their published projects, add and remove contributors without having to publish an addon just to change the list of contributors.

[versed trail]

No VPN. First shot. 2067 MB. Lucky.

[lunar cove]

Hey everyone, I want to publish a new version of my mod.
But I've got this error? How can I fix that?
The actual version is 0.0.49 and I wanted to publish the v 0.0.50

DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: "Remote request failed"
BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[76] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_CancelAssetUpload] Error Code:400 - Bad Request, apiCode="ResourceNotFoundError", uid="1760873841963-383545", message="assetVersionUpload 65FEA44AE0EAFC4F 0.0.50 not found"

[lunar cove]

I have a feeling that this problem has been there for a while?

[dark pulsar]

Scroll up

known issue for awhile

[meager dust]

07:05:44.280 BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[104] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Error Code:524 - Unimplemented 5xx, apiCode="", uid="", message=""
07:05:44.280 DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: ""
12:08 UTC

So nobody can upload larger mods anymore from what I'm seeing?

[true hedge]

Nope

[lunar cove]

Personally, I don't see the solution to the problem. What's more, even after deleting the mod from the workshop to try to publish it cleanly, it still doesn't work.

@silver bison Can you do anything about this?

[dark pulsar]

There isnt a solution its been asked a million times and you arent going to get anywhere tagging the devs. They are working on it. All there is to it.

[lunar cove]

That's pretty cool.

[quasi sable]

https://tenor.com/view/toby-cry-phone-spider-man-cry-phone-spider-man-phone-toby-phone-gif-12875606672124040541

[versed trail]

make sure the weather is clear skies. Moon is in the waning phase. Scratch your head in a circle and scratch your belly while clicking your heels.

[quasi sable]

https://tenor.com/view/spongebob-worship-worshipping-now-bowing-gif-12297363

i can do that

[elfin vector]

Out of interest what region of the world did you upload from ?

[versed trail]

US East Coast

first try today worked for me. No VPN. Hope it starts working for you guys.

[empty flicker]

did you upload in less then 120 sec?

[elfin vector]

This is the second time I've heard of East Coast working without VPN and with a mod bigger than 500Mb.

[versed trail]

yeah it was pretty quick. 2067 mb again.

[candid ice]

Not working for me with 2.3gb >.<

[meager dust]

I'm paywalled by upload speed

[nova whale]

Thats so sad. For me not able to test things life slowly get sucked into other games with my buddy. Thats a thing i was always feared of...to loose the interest in reforger mapping. Hopefully it comes back.

[brave egret]

Has anyone had issues with mods uploading without tagging dependencies?

[tame kelp]

Hey y’all, could we get some help? Trying to do a WW2 server and keep getting this error:

scripts/Game/BP/Components/Gadgets/SCR_ConsumableItemComponent.c(23): Overriding function 'RpcDo_BP_SetHealedGroupBroadcast'
but not marked as 'override'

Any help would be greatly appreciated. It’s really frustrating lol. I’m attaching the mod list

[tame kelp]

Fixed this issue. It was missing a mod that’s hard to find in the workshop. Now having an issue with some items not showing up. Not sure if it’s a load order issue or what (using GTX for server).

[magic cliff]

Just out of curiosity for those of you who have had luck with uploading in the last 72 hours: are any of you using a VPN? I know it’s working for people without one, but sadly Canada still doesn’t work so I need to use it to stand a chance at uploading. I’ve heard Singapore and Netherlands works but unfortunately those haven’t been successful for me yet. Kind of curious if there’s a different country that’s showing successful results 🙂

[sleek maple]

Can anyone tell me why I can’t get my admin stuff to work even after putting server admin tool still WON’T let me login in

[warm belfry]

Is your host side config setup

[versed trail]

no vpn

[dense scaffold]

Server Admin Tools has nothing to do with being able to login as admin. It may add some more features but your admin functionality needs to work on the server beforehand.

[dark pulsar]

It ain't working for anybody unless you have a blazing fast connection as far as I know or get lucky.

[eternal geyser]

Or you have small mods

[dark pulsar]

I'm not on vpn and I can't get a big one uploaded for weeks now along with many others. It is being worked on allegedly, is all we know.

Yeah gameplay one is fine but not the assets ones that are bigger.

Trying a 1.7gb one over and over rn for awhile.

[dreamy glen]

im making a huey thats overpowered do i make it in the world editor?

[low drift]

I was able to upload my 1.2gb mod the other day. NA West Coast no vpn

[dense scaffold]

Thats what she said

[rocky bobcat]

This is insane, can we get a fix for the love of God

[clever gale]

can someone help me im locked out of my own mod

[elfin vector]

Make sure you are using the workbench mod not the workshop version.

For example if you added your uploaded mod through "autoscan for mods" and if you select that mod it will be locked.

[clever gale]

@elfin vector ya I know what you mean but the editable version isn't there anymore. I manually deleted my mods because Reforger was being stupid and wouldn't download my mod in-game but now I'm locked out of it

[fervent kettle]

if you don't have the original source files then unfortunately I think you're shit outta luck

[clever gale]

@fervent kettle bohemia interactive really failed to make this tool user friendly then

How do I get it removed from the workshop then?

[fervent kettle]

I think you should be able to create a dummy mod, paste your mod GUID over the generated one in the addon.gproj file then if you restart workbench you should be able to unpublish it (assuming you still have access to workshop account)

[rose moat]

Same bro

Always erroring on 86%

[fervent kettle]

can you guys stop trying to upload your mods so their servers can finish uploading mine thx 😄

[rose moat]

lol

[gilded root]

I’ve been getting around it by maxing out my upload speed to 690mbs but that’s been it

Mods over 1.5gbs is like a crap shoot rn

[cerulean stone]

My up is 10mb/s, 1gb mod takes like 15min to upload or more. VPN just slow it more and dont help at all.

[dusty ore]

How can I solve this problem? When I upload, I get the following error: BACKEND (E): [RestApi] ID:[13] TYPE:[EBREQ_WORKSHOP_UploadAssetFile] Error Code:403 - Forbidden, apiCode="", uid="", message=""
DEFAULT (E): Uploading failed! Reason: ""

[mellow creek]

Y'all should split your mods up rhs style if you're still having problems uploading. Just make em smaller so you can complete an upload!

[candid ice]

Works for about everything except maps 🙁

[rocky bobcat]

what about map asset packs? Literally anything over 500mb struggles

[nova whale]

Got also 10% today with my 4gb... Nothing changed since weeks. And Bohemia is still silent...

Saying split the mod makes me tired...heared this so often. It worked before and i hope it will work some day again...i realy dont want to mess up my map because the upload is broken.

We should think about to make T-Shirts with this Error.

[whole harbor]

Answer by BI there -> https://feedback.bistudio.com/T194844

[mellow creek]

They're not silent, they've responded to this issue multiple times. Just gotta scroll up and read stuff. Tldr: they're working on it.

[mellow creek]

My issue is not uploading mods, but that it takes me like 5 minutes for me to get on the feedback tracker website. I keep having to refresh cuz it thinks I'm not human.

So I usually just give up on reporting issues

[dawn lotus]

it makes sense that people with fast connections get kicked off the upload - to cloudflare it can look like an attack, like BI has stated.

but what doesnt make sense is when im trying to upload with a slow connection and i still get booted off, and by slow connection i mean ~2mbit

i used to be able to upload my map (2.3gb) from my connection, it took about 80 minutes. and i could actually upload fine, sometimes it would fail.
now with my connection i cant even upload a 80mb mod without getting dc'ed by cloudflare

other members of my team can upload my mods for me successfully with fiber-grade connections. having success with pretty much everything under 7-800mb.

but theres no way to split my map up into less than 800mb peices so ive been shit out of luck for the past 2 months.

if they made some kind of account system thats built into the tools that is something like a portal for uploading mods, keeping version history, upload dates etc, and giving us a dedicated connection to the workshop would work wonders.
for protection against attacks, they could make it so only people with a history of mod uploads and mods they maintain, get priority connection without the use of cloudflare.
if its an account that has no mods and tries to attack through the portal, it could have the cloudflare protection and boot them off the upload like its doing to EVERYONE right now.

pretty much right now anyone with a large mod or slow connection is getting punished because of a few bad eggs.

[dark pulsar]

Really hope they are working on something for arma 4 at least workshop workbench integration

[rocky bobcat]

that's over 2 years away, they need to fix it within the next month or so or the modding community is going to slowly die off

[warm belfry]

@dense scaffold which version of your loadout mod was the one where you could load your ranked loadouts ie sergeant etc even at private mate

[dense scaffold]

No idea

[dark pulsar]

Yeah definitely. I was more referring to the workshop itself being in the workbench not on the crappy website, or at least a new spiffy website for it with a lot more features like filter by publisher and other things.

[boreal pulsar]

Is the highlighted for everyone trying to publish? I scroll the update that’s coming out.

[whole harbor]

We hope it's that xD

[lethal night]

No this is unrelated to publishing, the issue persists

[dark pulsar]

Damn. Ty for answer though.

[rocky bobcat]

So will the workshop ever be fixed? Because if people can't upload maps that's going to be an issue

[dark pulsar]

Yeah been trying to upload our mod so we can start internal testing and it's holding us back.

Also trying to add names to the publishing on the map so devs can use the lock terrain tile feature

[meager dust]

Im sure they're working on it as they've stated. Mod creators net BI a handsome financial return.

[boreal pulsar]

https://tenor.com/view/yoda-star-wars-gif-10940865116650073754

[magic cliff]

I sure love posting mod teasers and then receiving dozens of messages over the course of the following month asking when I'll get around to adding them to my server 😭

[dark pulsar]

You are just flaky haha

[rocky bobcat]

I feel your pain

[hard dawn]

dedicated server tool exist

[dense scaffold]

Is there something holding y'all back from deploying a bunch of hetzner servers to use as reverse proxies to workshop backend without cloudflare? It would hide your backend address and bypass cloudflare related upload issues temporarily until a real solution is implemented. I can also help test this idea if you'd like using my own infrastructure.

[dark pulsar]

Yeah thanks, but I don't want to set up all the launch parameters and crap for the clients and other devs.

Already doing twenty things at a time and have five hundred things to do

[outer tartan]

is there a way to make the server load a local addon?

I have my own created addons but even using -addonsDir parameter I cannot launch the server

[dense scaffold]

There is a no backend guide pinned in the servers channel

[outer tartan]

do you know if there's a way to bypass the workbench on looking for the graphics adapter? I wanted to try to use my server internet bandwidth to upload the mod to the workshop and bypass the 120 secs timeout by having more than 1gpbs upload speed

[dense scaffold]

There was some way but I forgot

[undone cradle]

Bacon, when can I become Turkey bacon?

[outer tartan]

nice, everyone with workshop issues is fckd now

i don't think it's possible to run the workbench in server enviroment

[empty flicker]

You can just use commandline -> https://community.bistudio.com/wiki/Arma_Reforger:Startup_Parameters (check publish commands)

[lethal night]

-enableWARP

[barren palm]

I realised that I wasn't using any AI in my MP scenario and therefore didn't need a navmesh. This got me down from 800+meg to 11-ish. Now I can update just fine. Probably not useful to everyone but if you're having issues uploading a pure MP mod it might be worth trying.

[empty flicker]

Then you did something wrong. Navmesh is only required by the world, not scenario. And you also do not need to add it, just rebuild it on the fly.

[barren palm]

@empty flicker My scenario is based on game master mode. When I tried to upload the first time it wouldn't work and gave me errors about the navmesh, so I added one and the errors went away. I never thought about it again until the size of the mod became an issue. Whatever caused the problem must have changed because I deleted the navmesh and it still works. All I did was respond to errors.

[oblique pollen]

you can upload the navmesh in any mod, as long as you tell your manager that handles the navmesh to call on the right location.

In theory if your having problems updating your map, you could offload the data to a smaller mod (like your mission file (scenario) to reduce the max upload size)

[nova whale]

Can we briefly summarize again why the servers are not functioning properly? In other words, why we have been unable to upload practically anything for many weeks? For a better understanding...

[lavish gyro]

should probably pin the answer to that question too at this point

[dark pulsar]

Something with cloudflare thinking it's an attack or something.When the connection times out.

[elfin vector]

Hey Reaper

Could you elaborate on this please for me.

Iv got a PVE scenario and heavily modified world of Everon.

If I don't have a navmesh the AI get stuck all the time. How do I rebuild on the fly

Or am I misunderstanding what is being said ?

[empty flicker]

You can use two methods on "SCR_AIWorld" -> RequestNavmeshRebuildAreas (for bigger areas) or simple -> RequestNavmeshRebuildEntity (for one entity)

[elfin vector]

I need to research this more and implement it !

Thanks for the information 👍

[outer tartan]

using a vps server connection I happened to publish 1gb of assets

[rocky bobcat]

I have over 4gb of stuff to unpload

And I know someone with atleast 10gb of stuff.

[river sorrel]

Hi guys, is there any mod that enhances the game master, for example creat a move point, or distroy task or hunt task , or just place a timer in player screens like countdown timer for the mission

[rocky bobcat]

CRX

[river sorrel]

not for the Ai

[grim crater]

You can make simple objectives' using the vanilla GM function like this. Faction>custom objective>(context menu)edit properties.

[hybrid fossil]

If you didn't have a navmesh the AI wouldn't move at all.

[rocky bobcat]

They can still move, but they don't react or see any terrain whether and obstacle or terrain cliff or MTN.

[empty flicker]

All default BIS Worlds have a navmesh... you only need to generate a new one, if you building your own terrain. If you just mod the original, you do not need to build any Navmesh and you also do not need to pack into your scenario... See also ScenarioFramework from Yethe. If you spawn an entity, the Navmesh will be rebuild on the fly. And this method can also be used.

[orchid sleet]

https://reforger.armaplatform.com/workshop/62021EB6163A2698

Does anyone know of this author having a Discord server so that they can be contacted? I'm trying to contact MrPotter about some mod concerns, but I am unable to reach them.

[elfin vector]

Even if I add a whole new town and villages with a ton of clutter and wrecks all over the world ?

Is there a setting in AIworld that allows navmesh regen ?

My AI are still geting stuck at the first modded obstacle when using the default navmesh for Everon

[oblique pollen]

in the world editor, there is a button that looks like a cursor or arrow. click it, generate a new soldiers, low res, and BTRlike

then

you need to save those somewhere

have your AIworld call on the new files you generated

whenever you change something, or add new things, you will need to regenerate those meshes.

[elfin vector]

Yeah I have created a navmesh for my scenario and I do update every time I change something in the world.

But according to Reaper this doesn't need to be done and we can use the default navmesh which will update itself and therefore we dont need one.

[elfin vector]

Read up you will see the conversation.

[oblique pollen]

Sooo its basically both streaming the navmesh and loading the original? I guess that makes sense.

I always just rebuild mine to save performance

but if it works it works

[empty flicker]

Just setup the default Navmesh in the AiWorld, then create a placeholder prefab with the dimensions you need to rebuild. Use the bounds of this placeholder to call SCR_AIWorld" -> RequestNavmeshRebuildAreas. So Server will rebuild this areas on Init

[solar cargo]

The only solution is to create a small support mod containing the changes you make. Obviously, it must be a dependency on the main mod.

[oak thorn]

1 Best mod for weapons attachments including aks and ar15 platforms

2 Best mod for us and ru uniforms,vest etc

No rhs please i want small simple mods if is possible

[oblique pollen]

How long has it been since we could upload? 😂

[hard dawn]

just upload in 120sec

[oblique pollen]

Easy when you make small mods lmfao. I can’t upload my maps fast enough. Even when I have the upload speed I’m limited by how fast Bohemia can receive

Plus it’s not just the timeout issue. There’s multiple things not working in the upload process

[fathom crescent]

Any advice on making custom cadre shirts?

[hard dawn]

pay2upload

network speed issue

[oblique pollen]

no, its literally not a network speed issue lmfao

if I have gigabit up, my 1.2 gig mod should be uploading.

[fathom crescent]

Anyone here know how to get shirt texture to actually sit properly?

Concept vs outcome

[hard dawn]

make good uv

[dense scaffold]

One nitpick here: The speed at which you upload data to a remote server is as much dependent on your upload speed as it is on the download and upload speed of every system (let's say hop in a traceroute) along the way to your destination. Bohemia's servers might be 500 Gbps but a random node on the way being saturated means you upload at 10 Mbps.

This isn't the cause of the upload issues though.

[oblique pollen]

Makes sense, thanks for the info 🫡

[rocky bobcat]

HOpefully when the update comes out it fixes the workshop, with our luck everyone will be updating their mods and crash the workshop

[river sorrel]

Make it .BCR

Name.BCR.png

Any one know a mod that make a sandstorm weather?

[dawn lotus]

UV's are shifted on that

[boreal pulsar]

Praying for it 🙏