#easter-eggs
1 messages · Page 119 of 1
I dont understand it, but im with you haha
Ok wait
the MIT scheme pattern is a match
Let me exaplin
b2,r,lsb,Yx .. text: ["U" repeated 16 times]
b2,r,msb,Yx .. text: ["U" repeated 12 times]
b2,rgb,lsb,Yx .. text: ["U" repeated 48 times]
b2,rgb,msb,Yx .. text: ["U" repeated 36 times]
b2,rgba,lsb,Yx .. text: ["W" repeated 8 times]
b2,abgr,msb,Yx .. text: ["W" repeated 8 times]
is it like there are 10 'W' in the image?
b2,r,lsb,Yx .. text: ["U" repeated 16 times] → 16 text layers ''U'' with that exact scale and size inside the image
b2,r,msb,Yx .. text: ["U" repeated 12 times] → 12 text layers ''U'' with that exact scale and size inside the image
b2,rgb,lsb,Yx .. text: ["U" repeated 48 times] → 48 text layers ''U'' with that exact scale and size inside the image
b2,rgb,msb,Yx .. text: ["U" repeated 36 times] → 36 text layers ''U'' with that exact scale and size inside the image
b2,rgba,lsb,Yx .. text: ["W" repeated 8 times] → 8 text layers ''W'' with that exact scale and size inside the image
b2,abgr,msb,Yx .. text: ["W" repeated 8 times]
and so on
ohh you got text layers?
damn
It's basically the history of the photoshop file
that's a lot of Us haha
b6,r,msb,xy,prime .. text: "uUUuUWUU" UwU 😆
I found that in the data online, didn't know how to interpret it.
Rob is a .. uhh...
Thanks for explaining that
RDI Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP) = https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acoustic_Doppler_current_profiler
so
What I say is
We extract the only text with only one letters
I was saying I tought it could be ''C-A-N Y-O-U R-E-A-C-H T-H-E F-I-N-A-L-S''
im already looking at the whole words we have
i think these are clues to the golden clues
b3p,abgr,lsb,xy .. file: MIT scheme (library?)
like this line points to MIT scheme
you have given us hope haha
Man im so happy lmao
good stuff @balmy fog how’d you pull the history of the file?!
Zsteg
you must've seen that and felt so relieved
You have no idea
when I saw UwU
I was like
oh Rob
I got you
thread might be good
How can this even be present in the file? I don't get it.
U+533 = Գ armenian capital letter gim
I'm looking at the description of it and it makes no sens to be included as a file to a png??
in this theres a line: b5p,abgr,msb,xy .. file: RDI Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP)
don't dig too deep for now
You can hide anything in a file
maybe the answer is actually easier than watching profiles
One of ADCP utilities: Modelling fish egg and larval fish dispersal in lakes and rivers where cooling-water intake entrainment is a risk
Maybe the golden egg is Caviar 😆
just to summarise before rabbit holeing, its used to measure water current velocites with doppler effect and sound waves
I used the Darker blend mode. Then moving the top layer around
What is happening
this
also
This is only Zsteg in black ?
imagedata .. file: VAX-order 68k Blit mpx/mux executable
b4,rgba,lsb,xy .. text: "fofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofo"
b4,abgr,msb,xy .. text: "ofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofof"
Could this be the history of how layers were moved around
It’s too much text
Also what image are you looking at? Ha
The white ?
Nah the symbols on the white ? were full of random texts
per example
b2,rgb,msb,xy,prime .. file: VISX image file
b2,abgr,msb,xy,prime.. text: ["W" repeated 10 times]
one layer of an image being added
W being repeated 10 times (with the same scale/size)
is there a way to remove these layers on the image?
ahhhh ok
rob probably did this
b2,abgr,msb,yx .. text: ["W" repeated 8 times] means W→is 8 times repeated with the same exact size/scale
why are there like 50+ layers then
and also what does the black image look like with this then
black image is this : #easter-eggs message
wdym
all the repeated layers means there must be like tens of them
probably more than 50
i was wrong in the letter choices but
this is 1/8th of the image
and look how many letters I could foresee behind the SCHEME patterns
"vvvvunvwumnmnnedd][[[b[[ZRZZRIQ@HGG???7?M=.>-=-%-$" is such a weird thing to name a layer
takes so long to do as well
he didn't name it that way
it names itself once you input the text in the image
haha well then what I mean is
crazy thing to name it
does it get named after the initial text?
yea
or the latest text you type in it
it changes whenever you change the text
I mean on the "History"
ahh k so the final version
yep
does it show folders too or nah?
nah I dont think so
b3,rgba,lsb,YX,prime.. text: "IrOIy'IrOm"
this one caught my attention
could you try saving this file and trying the method?
to see if all the layers get captured accurately?
yep
oo post results
actually no
can someone make a dumb photo on photoshop
and send me jph
jpg
cuz im not using photoshop
with random text
plz
Join the not-having-photoshop club!
I do have it but im at work lol
(temporary member)
Rob runesson
Robert Runesson 
To me this steps totally outside our own rules around where we search for answers. I don’t think we should be trying to solve it this way.
i think youve accidentally found files in the png we need to extract lol
Steganography is the practice of representing information within another message or physical object, in such a manner that the presence of the information is not evident to human inspection. In computing/electronic contexts, a computer file, message, image, or video is concealed within another file, message, image, or video.
100% agree. We are here to solve puzzles, not to find answers. Looking at things like this that spoil the puzzles are not part of what we do here 😅
I think it was accidental
I'm still not even sure what I'm looking at in those messages, seems like a bunch of pointless gibberish idk
yeah that’s where I’m at I’m not even sure it leads to anything
Also, for anyone not on photoshop, in https://discord.com/channels/1008696016318513243/1100745453206786078 it recommends a website (Stegonline). If you upload the tion.png to it, you can find the symbols easier there.
why would the tion file have a bunch of “clues” in that manner but not the ques file makes me think it could be what smashel said, gibberish?
I've found what we are looking at without photoshop now
edit: we need rob lol
I feel like Rob would've stripped this if he didn't want us to look at it? It's not hard to stip....
I think @proud minnow would be the one who needs to weigh in
Rob has mentioned before that no real clues would be hidden in metadata
Steg is hidden values in an image that you encode that way, a normal JPG cannot be Steg has there’s no value to be found since there’s nothing encoded
I personally think Rob wanted us to find the steg
I just made a dummy jpg image with bunch of words and then nothing showed up when I tried to Zsteg it
The only way you can find values in a Zsteg is if it’s encoded
As this says
Steg
i found this on ques.png
using stegonline
I agree that i think steg is the way, and its recommended
we've been looking at image metadata before, to be fair, and Rob's been hiding clues in that before
Zsteg is also a tool like Jsteg but it is used to detect LSB steganography only in the case of PNG and BMP images.
@balmy fog is right.
This is NOT extracting metadata from the image. Rob EXPORTED metadata (maybe), then HID the metadata in the image using LSB steganography
@pure loom
I've tried to decode an JPG image I did myself with bunch of text layers, then have it go thru the Zsteg and nothing came out, to find any text values it would have to be ENCODED in the matter of it
then decoded
detect stegano-hidden data in PNG & BMP
The compression in JPEGs will likely kill LSB steg
Oh my b
I dont know all the terms
but yeah, that's my 2 cents '' Rob EXPORTED metadata, then HID the metadata in the image using LSB steganography''
so
I might've been wrong
I think what we see is what Rob encoded in the image for us
it is not literal replications of the text layers

From what I read my understanding was that the photoshop history for the file was looked at, which made it possible to see an action Rob took making the file, is that not correct?
Wait, I'm confused... T3 images are JPEG?
Here's what I get when I try to run zsteg on them...
I wonder if they are highly compressed jpeg because they don't need to be high quality because there's nothing to find 
Zsteg is png and Jsteg is jpg I think @coarse dagger
If there's one thing I'm sure about, there is def clues in these images 😭
b5,r,msb,Xy .. text: "3F)e\pJ(" this one got my eye
Don't think Rob would ever release an image without anything hidden, especially a tier-ending image
i really think using stegonline and trying to extract files is the way forward
No that's my bad, poor description
we know the files are there now
I'm trying to replicate @balmy fog's results, but if he's correct in what he's doing and is using JSTEG to extract that output, then no.
Just wait for Rob to comment on that stuff honestly
cause either it's mastermind clue-hiding or an unintentional shortcut haha
Hmm
He has mentioned there are other “tools” to find hidden things
Yeah, this sounds like a grey area. I never look at any of the data parts when using Stegonline to avoid stepping outside our own “rules”
do you have that message
Again, if @balmy fog is correct the only way this could've gotten there is if Rob hid it
has rob specifically said what we cant do, or is it our own rules?
aside from the obvious brute forcing passwords, etc
no brute forcing, and a long running joke that rob wouldn’t hide clues in metadata after a funny incident early on, tho if people looked at the metadata in past clues they’d still find funny (note: not clues iirc) messages from rob every now and then
i think he knows someone will end up looking
yeah but it’d go against the status quo for him to hide something in metadata in the final tier
I can't seem to replicate these results with JSTEG
not that I even fully understand if what @balmy fog is metadata or not
tho if I remember correctly, steganography is not metadata, it’s things hidden in images
Exactly. I’d be surprised if he did that because he knows we’d need to break our own rules to solve it.
In which case we should be able to find them by image manipulation
well not exactly, steganogrpahy is more of a tech way of hiding things, not layers
i think steganography is the way, we just skipped some steps
Using the example JSTEG encoded image from the JSTEG documentation I can replicate their results:
https://wiki.bi0s.in/steganography/jsteg/
I cannot replicate your output @balmy fog .
Idk what utility you used, but I don't think the ouput it gave you is actually from JSTEG.
Again.........
If the results actually came from JSTEG this IS NOT looking at the image's metadata.
I currently suspect this output IS NOT from JSTEG.
we had metadata rules?
i was the one that made the tools list, and in fact, that infographic. those tools are not really brute force, and i only recommended them because of previous ARGs i participated/developed
usually when used, clues will appear rather easily — because they were meant to be found that way by the creator (same applies with metadata). if you can’t replicate something or it looks just too complex/random, chances are there’s nothing there — esp. if you can’t pinpoint the clues or connect them to existing ones
just wanted to comment that. anyway, carry on. glhf
cause Rob's been hiding stuff in metadata for a while anyways
with the "layer name" stuff we've been seeing already
I think it would be a problem if Rob asked us to not do certain things, otherwise I feel like he plans it
Trying to find mention of this, but Discord search is failing me....
In other news I wish I had seen this post earlier
Rob has mentioned before if we've been "overextending", a.k.a when we've been looking for clues when there wasn't
like here
Yeah, so the full story is: in the very first clue (the samurai “slash” image) the words “Devon crossing” were in the metadata which Duhmeister discovered because he didn’t know about not looking there. Rob didn’t realise they were in there and also probably didn’t think that most people in the hunt wouldn’t know rules like this, which stem from Battlefield EE days. After that the metadata became a joke place for Rob to essentially tease us about looking in there and we also established the rules - no brute-forcing passwords and no looking at file data that shows us anything that only Rob should know - photoshop file history would definitely fall into that, for instance. The metadata became kind of the boundary line (or the gap between what we can and can’t look at more accurately) because of Rob’s jokes etc in there.
that makes sense
I read Rob's initial messages a while ago, don't think I found that!
maybe it's actually a Rob react
There were a few DMs between us so those of us (me and Duh probably) aware of all this could suggest the rules.
Thanks for this! I think this should also really be in the egg-hunt-info
It is in my video 
Why you no watch 😭

haven't watched it since it came out 😭
do people usually rewatch vids like that 😭??
It’s not in cinemas anymore you’ll have to stream it 
I would've had to be in a low place to review the Beginners' guide again 
I watch it myself sometimes. #lowplacesarelikehome
@fallen jasper adding Metadata to the egg-hunt-info pile would be nice :)
wonder if Rob's just muted this chat so he can detox or something.. like he promised he would not help this tier..
I agree. With more victims people joining, the rules need to be very up front
better safe than sorry
but yeah Rockhound you can see why these (nearly) blank images lead us to look at the metadata or something else 😭
He’s probably busy to be fair
"Do not look at file data that shows us anything that only Rob should know - photoshop file history, etc." ?
is that you pointing out it's already there, or a draft of what to put in
Maybe add - if in doubt ask
haha
I wanna double check the EE related rules with the people actually doing anything with the EE hunt before I add things in 
Add: thou shalt wait until NamaTama images turn up before trying too hard 
Soooooooo
"It's agreed that metadata of the images do not contain intentional clues, and so shouldn't be accessed; photoshop file history, layer names, etc."
Do we look at it or no?
I extracted these infos from an image analyzer tool online
It's not a program I wrote lol
probably not 😭, but it's fine that you did. now we know there are CLUES in there 👀 ❤️
now we need to find them by actually analysing the image hahaha
Yeah, and I think add to that, if you’re unsure if you might be close to breaking the rules just ask
''Aperi'Solve is an online platform which performs layer analysis on image. The platform also uses zsteg, steghide, outguess, exiftool, binwalk, foremost and strings for deeper steganography analysis. The platform supports the following images format: .png, .jpg, .gif, .bmp, .jpeg, .jfif, .jpe, .tiff...''
Or work out if there’s an area we can look along these lines
- If you're unsure you might be close to breaking the rules, just ask!" put that a line break below
I don't think steganography is cheating tho....
I've watched that .txt file
Like I said
Yeah, so I think we need an explanation of it
I've taken a random .jpg I have made, with multiplate text layers and used it in aperi'solve
It gave me nothing
but
the jpg from rob
Hahaha
gives me something
why?
I don't think this is breaking the rules
I think this is intended
did you save it multiple times across multiple devices, and did you turn off file optimisation etc. ?
I did the exercise with multiple images
even #official-art images
and none of them were positive finds
all of them wrote this:
And was the Photoshop history not what was being revealed?
It's not a photoshop history
It's embedded message inside an image
go on
Ah ok. Gotcha
lol
And there’s no other way this could possibly be revealed?
Rockhound Steg messages are intentionally hidden ones
I dont think so
I tried to watch via the strings
and even extract them into different paths
but never came close too
plus
that or there to many people participating for him to look over hundreds of messages.
here's an other 2 cents
Did you get the ? images from a discord copy or the one hosted on Squarespace?
Yeah, I get that. I’m just trying to understand it fully 👍
squarespace
So
Right look at this
This was an A I decoded
I am 100% sure it's an A
But
in the Zsteg
https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/62d66fa29e72c560f8efc020/cac370a9-8940-4e3b-a230-2a0c1cd1c485/X.png?format=1500w See if this picks up anything on Zsteg
there's no mention of A text layers
I think you're just picking up data that got removed when you upload things to discord that aren't removed on squarespace images 
It gives me the regular string
Yeah, that’s where I thought overlapped images might complete the letters
Damn
Nah
There's hidden text that correlates some clues we've had
this per example: "?3?3?3?3?3?3?3?3"
and again
file: MIT scheme
gave us the actual symbols
Also
the evidence
The gold ? with black background if it was a PHOTOSHOP HISTORY, I shall have seen the importation of an image or an ? but it's only this:
imagedata .. file: VAX-order 68k Blit mpx/mux executable
b4,rgba,lsb,xy .. text: "fofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofo"
b4,abgr,msb,xy .. text: "ofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofofof"
No mentions at all of img or file nor ? text layer
I get way less output in this field, and the field being called ZSTEG (which doesn't work on JPEGs) makes me think aperisolve isn't accurately describing what that output is....
b5p,r,msb,XY .. text: "`goooooooo"
Andddd aperisolve doesn't seem to be working on a file I KNOW had data hidden with JSTEG:
It just "loads" forever:
And I've installed JSTEG on my machine and can extract the string from this image:
#easter-eggs message
But not from tfee_tion.jpeg
I don't
scan this
every time i look through this chat it feels like a bunch of hackers discussing their next move
if
we follow what we say
we would be supposed to see a bunch of text layers
LIKE PER EXAMPLE
b4,rgb,msb,xy .. text: ["A" repeated 24 times]
but we don't
To encode something in an image you have to manually do it
loaded up old images, these things are in all of them
then let's explain this
b3p,abgr,lsb,xy .. file: MIT scheme (library?)
how this
would lead straight to the patterns we have
on the actual image
Cool. What i'm saying is I don't think the output you're getting from aperisolve is actually hidden using JSTEG/ZSTEG
Oh that I don't know
But I know it has to be encoded some way
because you can't just open the .jpg in .txt format and see this
b5p,rgb,lsb,xy .. text: ["v" repeated 16 times]
Photoshop history would give us positions and actual movements
and clicks
don’t you normally need a key when it comes to steganography in order to access that stuff?
(that's T1A btw)
No password is also an option
ah ok gotcha
no pw is blank
look if this works on the older images and still turns up the exact same random text then I don't think it actually illicits anything intentional
In order to understand if it was intentionally hidden we have to understand where it came from.
b3p,abgr,lsb,xy .. file: MIT scheme (library?) either this is pure randomness
or it was hidden
Or it was metadata Rob never intended for us to see
It can't be metadata because you cannot metadata an image that isnt encoded!!!!!!!!!
That's what im saying
You'd have to encode something INTO an image already made
there’s a difference between metadata and an image/file/text hidden inside an image
steganography does not equal metadata
Agreed 100%
All you're doing is taking stuff, and hiding it within the bytes of the image. Doesn't change the image, but it does add some stuff to the background
I'm saying I can't verify the output that @balmy fog is getting is from steg
steganography also does not equal Things that we are supposed to find
yeah agreed @coarse dagger if we put past clues in there and get the same randomness my bet is that it’s not of value
b3p,abgr,lsb,xy .. file: MIT scheme (library?) then this is random and basically gave us what is the pattern we were looking at
all I know is that there are clues hidden in the actual image's pixels which we CAN find, and those WILL help
Has it been established that steg is not to be used? if it has then that’s my bad I am still pretty new to this ee community:) I’ve used it in past ee’s for other stuff
at the beginning we agreed not to look into the image's data
yeahhhh but the thing is there’s an argument to be made over what is data/metadata vs what isn’t
steg probably sits very comfortably right in both
OHEY! IT FINALLY LOADED!
Yeah this is definately not JSTEG/ZTEG.
Here's what was actually hidden using JSTEG:
Jsteg is used for JPEG steganaography.
and here's the output on aperisolve:
So yeah it's bullshit
language 😭
it's 100% data of an image in my eyes
@balmy fog it was a good place to run to but probably gibberish:/
fair:) I think next time we see Rob we should def ask for clarification on steganography
maybe he'll be silent until this whole tier is over..
He might be.. guess we’ll have to keep looking!!
MIT has a lot of open tech things which have been used https://www.gnu.org/software/mit-scheme/
especially in conjunction with photoshop and jpg/png files
these patterns
on that book
correlates to the patterns I watched for hours
I don't know why but they do
In our patterns you see a bunch of 25 facing each others like mirrored, you see the same on that book cover with R
all we know is that the image is divided into 8x8 pixel blocks
with blocks that repeat frequently
I think that version puts them in a very strange way
creates outlines that aren't there
wha?
like obviously this is not what it looks like in the actual image
there are hard outlines and brighter pixels
The lines are letters behind
bro 😭
the brighter pixels is on top with low opacity wich creates this
I'm saying it's not like that in the actual image
Yes?!?!
og image with totally nothing and image with curves and gamma adjutment
yeah there are loads of symbols like that
the only thing the filter does is outline everything he sees
yeah exactly
and you put the detail to extreme
but it doesn't create stuff
that is what I am saying
it simply changes the color of stuff
meaning it's easier to highlight patterns which aren't exactly there tho
can you let me know where that is in the image if at all possible?
just like zooming out and circling it or something
5 mixed with a 2
that is everywhere
on the image
is photoshop created too
or these binary too
or the same EXACT Y from you being seen lots of places
this tile
We've never worked with pure images like this
we've always had lots of treshold applied or some sort of changes
yep yep but the shapes of letters and symbols before did not need highlights, they simply came out. but Rob might be stepping up his game here.
obviously it's better for EVERYONE if you're right though. keep looking. but I will try and decipher the whole symbol alphabet in the meantime, even if that might be impossible hahaha
this was browse bitlanes on StegOnline
wich correllates 100%
to the one I have
altough mine is a tad more precise upper right
holy crap this is perfect
just went and tried a similar thing with the "superimposed" mode
this is a near-perfect grid
take this
and put it in front of mine
and lower the opacity
its the same thing
yeah I just needed something which showed the whole grid
without interference from the gradient nor the Qstn. mark
altough this is extrememly accurate with everything, even more accurate then what I had
k mine doesn't do that but cool either way
wym?
Mine is just black and white
No I know
I put my pattern behind
and then overlayed what you linked
ahhh
It fits perfectly
so both are good to use
but the black and white version is better for seeing the actual negative space
ie:
- we know that's an M so it can't be ''Can you reach the Finals'' so my theory with that is dead in the water
Seems like there was a big discussion about the meta data. But honestly just saying meta data might be to vague anyway. Technically the creation date for example is meta data. But there is no way we were not supposed to see it
also this is A in latin
I think we will need Rob to actually decide
First, was it accurate
secondly was it intended
thirdly can we use it
@proud minnow
Yeah of course. But I just think it might have to be a little more specific than just "meta data yes or no". Since the information in meta data can vary vastly
But yeah at the end of the day Rob just has to tell us if this was too much or not
much clearer to discern the "grid" now
and since this is all black and white pixels.. we can codeify it!
yo I actually see the grid now
you guys are this much just to go insane XD
Did you find out what kind of patterns these are supposed to be?
maybe the real pattern is the friends we made along the way (no)
looks like a big QR code for me XD
QR code
yep!!
depends, we're all hard-headed hunters, sometimes we hate eachothers, but sometimes we love each others
like 15 minutes ago I wanted to fight fish
now im glad he still me fwen
oh.. :s
just because I didn't see it don't mean I hate u or anything <3
I know
It's actually better that way cuz we both push each others to actually validate our findings
that's what fwen are for
let's solve this shit now im tired
Pretty sure there's a simpler way to select all the pixels instead of going one by one @sharp flame
how many pixelsxpixels is one square
8x8
it's pretty clear there's some sort of grid of symbols
That's gonna be a lot of pixels💀
send image I’ll try to see if I can separate it all into 8x8
nevermind bokb got it:)
png w transparent bg
Okay hear me out. What if instead of trying to find what the patterns mean, they are just supposed to represent a brightness values for a lower res image🤔
Like each 8x8 being one pixel
Because if you look at it from far away it does kinda look like there is something hidden in there
Shades of gray
I think
I think there has to be a way to use the 2 images at once
ques and tion
would make sense
maybe overlay them and said opacity at 50%
then do bit planes?
Tried that
The black images has nothing in background
So it’s just solid black
If we go into the meaning of gold you have to find it, I mean, gold doesn’t grow on trees so what I mean by that is searching for it
Maybe there’s a way to use the gold question mark on the planes
I'm gonna start writing a small program to try this out
tried to parse as many as I could before I got bored
it's definitely a symbol grid, and loads of the symbols are inverses or rotations of each other
Aren't some of these on the C64 keyboard cursor/painter thingy?
From a while back
I genuinely think the amount of unique symbols in there is <30
I just used a png image for the grid
was definitely something we were trying to look at earlier
I'm not good enough to code this but I know there are people here who are
so I need help
the one I posted you mean?
The grid is mine made with overlapping png images from google
which grid - mine or yours?
his
ok, well there is a grid there anyway
faintly visible in this one
plus the faint sloping lines like a forward slash
I definitely see it
Use the planes image tho
I think the forward slashes and the ? relate - a "shift" is required to go from a / to a ?
Need help - parsing the grid of symbols
oh right, I think I understand now
man the symbols seems like a gargantuan task without automation
but it's obviously solvable
I just hope we have someone with the skills™️ hahaha
since it's black and white it could be done by parsing the image into
strings of 64 1's and 0's, one for each pixel
That’ll take forever @sharp flame
code which goes through each 8x8 and notes down if its new, or counts it if it's not
Also has to flip it to make sure
And rotate
no need, worst case we'll have 8x the symbols we need
True
maybe the flip and rotate ones are different letters
I mean... yeah?
it's just 1 clue without any rabbitholing yet
maybe it gives us the psw, who knows 🤣
if we solve it in the next week it'll be the shortest recent tier
Is there a tool online for image similarities?
Okkkk
anyway in the meantime
let's start rabbit holing again
In arithmetic geometry, the Cox–Zucker machine is an algorithm created by David A. Cox and Steven Zucker. This algorithm determines whether a given set of sections provides a basis (up to torsion) for the Mordell–Weil group of an elliptic surface E → S, where S is isomorphic to the projective line.The algorithm was first published in the 1979 ar...
it is
Jésus
see? wikipedia can be fun too 😭
I will say though unironically the EE hunt is so vast now that this is a genuine connection
yeah so this was a dead end
that does look v. interesting though
I already observed some striking lines going diagonally
those White squares and Black squares have that large scale stripe formation
looks like a low-res image of Saturn's rings or something
I'm wondering if we can build a QR code out of the overlapped images? That would also link well with the / through the image
oh wait this is also the inverse. I should count the white pixels instead of the black ones
also very possibly
wouldn't fit with the 8x8 grid idea but would be it's own thing to look out for
I think @balmy fog tried the overlapping images thing but said it goes nowhere because ques image has nothing on it
since the 8x8 symbol grid is a different scale to QR
I mean using at least two layers of the "tion" image
This would be more accurate but still seems useless
maybe "ques" comes into part 2 of the solution
so looking for a part that can be converted into this for a start
we should also consider inverting them at the start
if the code outputs any type of square shape like that we should totally go for it
as Rob has hidden QRs before
also the "symbols" become way less recognizable and more granular the further down right we go into the image
am i the only one who can't find robs walk in the park message in the discord anymore?
search isnt showing it anymore
I couldn’t find it anymore a couple days ago
wonder if he deleted it because it was leading us the wrong way
well if its supposed the be a walk in the park isnt all of this a bit much work?
yes
but nobody else has any leads 😦
he did post one after the last tier was solved but yeah looks like he deleted it
because I remeber him saying it again
not really.. there aren't side paths or secondary clues..
in fact we only really have 1 clue on the grill at the moment
by walk in the park he means straightforward I think as well
#easter-eggs message this message by rob is edited btw
rob used "one" quite a bit last tier, not sure if that was supposed to get us to move to VI for 6, but if so wouldnt this password be roman numeral related again?
Just leaving the link to my python script here in case we need that in the future https://colab.research.google.com/drive/1F8Bb1QD-9HZ5aftkYV2DDhMw2WVoNoIk?usp=sharing
QR codes can have up to 177 by 177 pixels 
not as bad as our image.. 1149 pixels 😭
so much info to parse...
but @coarse dagger is on it. ❤️
a walk in a very large park
did we ever relate anything to rob liking the numbers 6000666?
1000111 is G in binary
ahh kk
obviously it's 6s instead of 1s, and so 6 instead of G
(and then vi, but we didn't have that brain capacity yet 😭)
🎵like a G6🎵
This is 6 layers overlapped using the "subtract" blend mode. There is a curious void, almost a circle shape on the left side which is completely empty of lit pixels compared to the other areas.
Also, having done this, I can see that it would be possible to actually form a star map with multiple layers on top of one another in exactly the right position.
hmmm... adding a 7th layer in really starts to form more voids, so maybe it's just where a lot of the darker areas are coinciding
Yeah I think you're just revealing the darker portions of the gradient
I feel like if the layer thing is the right path - we need some clue to tell us how many layers and their positions.
Having said that, it would be very easy for Rob to have used that technique to hide an image or words/numbers or a QR code in the image
You'd just draw what you wanted to be in there pixel by pixel over multiple layers - colour those pixels and then mess with each layer's pixels in whatever way you wanted (make the little patterns etc) being careful not to delete any of the coloured pixels, and then flatten the image
Ive been crossviewing the image and I feel like layers is the way to go (as a cross view is basically two layers). Hard to really study my way, though, as my eyes get tired and are by nature out of focus to view it this way.
I swear theres a schooner in there somewhere
what if the question marks are actually supposed to be inverted question marks?
I’m just curious if the answer is still GoldEgg related
whats the golden question? whether the chicken or the egg came first. Boom. Solved
I have tried turning them upside down and messing with them as layers, but didn't seem to gain anything that way
becuase in spanish they use 2, one upside down to start and another regular at the end
maybe the gold one contains clues to how we manipulate the layers in the white one
if it does, they are well hidden
yeah, the problem is the gold one doesn't have a grid like the white one - there's just no obvious clues in it
the dot on the gold one has some texture to it, but nothing workable
Maybe gold has half the answer and the white has the other. Put em together and you get ONE
Maybe over laying the white (egg) to the gold (yolk) and then do the image manipulation process and MAYBE we’ll get something 🤷🏻♂️
yeah, I tried this already, but because the gold one is basically featureless it doesn't produce anything
the upper part of the gold one has the same texture
tbh they all just look like jpg artifacts
the white one's grid patterns give us something to work with, which is great. But the gold one remains a mystery
weird page name when the URL was t1-f-1
not sure if this is anything, but almost looks like a word towards the bottom
this is on the black and gold one
S
Something
e
p
t
oh shit it does
I read beef, but I think that’s wrong 😂
hmmmm
Are you just hungry? 
bEEf
that was messing around with the select by color in gimp, you can selection certain spots and delete entire sections and stuff. kinda hard to explain
ill make a clip in a few
not sure how accurate using it can be
Did we ever mentionned those?
http://www.carlosbasanta.com/portfolio/the-man-who-stole-the-golden-egg/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vegreville_egg
Big eggs in parks 🤔
Essentially this is what im doing for those wondering.
maybe someone else will find this usefull
No and he also looks like a matchstick man kinda
I'm thinking, it could be a great idea to go back to the G doc, and try to find some new reachthefinals.com/......... links, with actors family name that seems like they meant something for the hunt.
You guys found a link with Burrow and with Galileo.
Last time you guys found a link, there was a picture with Namatama and saying Loading.
Oh burrow was Galileo?
And lately with got a Gif with loading written en nothing was hidden in it.
I bet while that gif was up there, it unlocked a new URL that we were then able to find, and until now no one found it.
They found a QR code with Galileo and a Diamond clue with Burrow if im not mistaken.
Egg is oval. Oval is an ellipse. The orbits of all eight planets (lots of planet and moon clues) in our solar system are elliptical, which means they are oval-shaped. The golden sun is in the center (first pic). It casts a shadow (shadow in second pic and not fully centered). Just things I’ve been trying to figure out if they point to something that connects them all now again.
I gotta dump all the words and phrases I tried once I can get access to that thread
Also Velga
Oh whoa me too
👍
Vega?
One rabbit hole I wanna figure out is if the shadow on the ? is casting to a particular date or time. Which maybe points to a particular person or event.
Something else to think about, usually when we solve a password the image we get is supposed to be for the next password. So was the abc pic "ques" supposed to help us get the next answer which gave us "tion"? and are we supposed to combine both photos for the final tier or is the final teir a summary of everything weve done?
sooo im really terrible at these, lol, but i hope i actually found something
Combine in some way. I agree. Just might not be the obvious ways we’ve been considering so far.
That one I idea I read earlier about using it as a magnfying glass gave me the thought about using it to cast a shadow with it as the sun on top of the ? Just need to try it when I get a chance
Im pretty sure it's artifacts
but you can try different %
I might be wrong
If we really go on that route, and the golden ? is casting a light ray on the white one.
Should we then look for a date as the password?
🜚 is the alchemical symbol for gold, looks like a comet (1064)
kinda looks like a telescope
🝁 is the alchemical symbol for quicklime (calcium oxide, maybe like cacoiii)
🝌 is the alchemical symbol for **calx **(Latin for limestone (cacoiii))
seems like there could be an alchemy connection throughout the tiers, especially because of the whole "creating gold" thing
and rob called the clues that lead to the final tier of level 2 "gold clues"
idk anymore. lol
Yeah I believe it was near end of T1C he said there were already 8 golden clues pointing directly to the final tier
Did we find and other answers using x = s or x = 5?
Which 8 might be a way to start looking and picking out ideas that connect as well.
we thought about this yesterday but the sheer scale of clues.. it would be incredibly hard to sort back through and determine what clues are pointing to the final tier
but not impossible
Team effort!
what if we each picked a tier?
we’d have to disqualify anything pointing directly to the tier answer I believe
We could and then I could as I have time go over others to see if anything was missed.
I was also thinking to tag each type of clue and see if there is a lot of something we haven’t used yet
Somethings like astrology were big early on pointing to answers, but then also had clues in later tiers which made no sense
honestly probably need to go back and look at https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1011929497139953744/1106236741037338634/IMG_CDIV.png?ex=6568a5bf&is=655630bf&hm=f51b985be441ed7755f8b6cd463e71ca1a06acf93c715526df4493c0087d2bbe&
and the periodic chart in the background
some things look they had edits on them
Small rabbit hole but I’ve been wondering if there’s a connection here
Arrows, squares, Xs,
This image has a Christmas card and wasn’t it posted around March/april?
And maybe what keys are missing / what keys he has his fingers on
And one last thing, the namatama on his shirt I’m not sure was looked at too much
DHL? are the keys I believe
Number 3 is missing too
Yeah missed that, good spot
What about the thing on the cup?
Maybe they’ve spotted these before, I can’t access the Padlet atm
I think the cup they said wasn’t part of the Easter egg
They have
It’s on one of the padlets
It’s on the wiki and Padlet but I don’t think all them have been fully solved or found all connections.
From memory I think they keys, namatama and Christmas card weren’t looked at in detail
The namatama looks so familiar
As in the one on the shirt
Yeah. The only thing was the compound mirrored on the wall mattered on this tier but the rest maybe seems for other stuff then.
Yeah I’m pretty sure it was
Snowflakes was a common clue that came up somewhere else
And rob mentioned Christmas a few times, so maybe referring to this picture
Did we find anything about the y=6 and x=5 on the top left?
Not anything conclusive.
I wonder if the periodic table is gonna be used as some sort of cypher key.
Lots of things underlined and crossed off
The PTE=CNS that we need to remember
We need to collectively look back if we start to lose hope with the ? Images
Or start a thread for it lol
The ? Images lead to more questions so far
First time I’ve seen clues so far with nothing obvious in them at all
Yeah and the issue is the non photoshop users can’t do anything now lol
So we’re just waiting
By the time I learn, it will probably be solved
yeah most of the clues here are unsolved, maybe some hints to a diamond clue tho
Yeah. Though that might be by good design to make us look back.
I think there’s another connection between some primary clues from different tiers that Rob referred to as golden clues.
there are definitely edits on it like hidden things.
im like 90% certain there is something written on both of their arms. and something above the coffee stain, possible arrow and some more stuff. but their are weird pixels all over.
its a chemical present in eggshells
should we start a golden clues hunt thread or nah
you guys ever use the x=s ?
or 5, not sure what it is.
I think its a 5, but no we never really solved that
i think it means 5 spots across, 6 spots down
which is the element Tantalum, possibly just a troll, like they're just "tantalizing" us
unless we have to convert roman numerals or something
what tier was this from again
golden clue hunt
yo @turbid tinsel
did anyone ever notice how edited this looks?
Can we make out the word that’s covered?
looks like a fancy signature of some kind
And also has anyone looked at the embark studios podcast Rob featured on?
I can’t find either to be a word though
It looks like a signature potentially
A signature is usually way messier
And not at the top of an award
This almost feels like it should be the name of the award itself
hm, I'll keep looking 🙂 it def looks edited onto it tho right?
it could just lead to that tiers clue but
speaking of which, which tier was this image from?
Cdiv 404. I think tier E
Aren't we supposed to look for 8 golden clues?
what about this? Fingers on
D
H
L
0 (maybe)
Missing keyboard inputs include
3
C
O
was this something you guys recall being in discussion?
sorry Ik I'm asking a lot of questions, just wondering what clues are/aren't looking into for golden clues
I believe it’s more that we know at end of tier C there had been 8 clues. More likely appear in DEF
there's definitely more than 8 based off wording, but as of 12/20/2022 there had been 8 released
So that narrows a search by a lot actually
And then the ones in DEF might become obvious
Wouldn't they relate to gold
Not necessarily
Uh oh. Quote from the podcast from rob “I need to spend some time in the incubator on this one cause I-I-I am cracking up”. Maybe a cacoiii hint
But there’s clues in the podcast
Omg I juts heard that too last night
we think it could either be gold related OR "golden" in the sense that it relates to the final clue
Egg incubator, cracking up and iii lol
we have no leads though
I’ll need to go back over it tomorrow properly
Look back at very recent Rob messages he throws in an extra i for no reason too
that's why we're looking back at the old tiers, Rob said the clues for the final tier are out there already, problem is what clues are for that tier and what clues are for the golden/final tier?
The iii I think is for cacoiii password
True true I kind of skipped to the end lol
How will we know if we find one
It’s late here so I’ll listen again tomorrow
we won't for now.. it may become obvious the more we find
It seems like each tier only uses one form of code.
There’s 8 golden clues between t1a and t1d, so we should all start together in the same place I think
But I can’t find t1a Padlet
hang on I can find it one sec
Correct. We might need a thread for unsolved puzzles? Even if we solve them to be yolk or something. At least it’s out of the way.
t1a is in the t1b pallet
Ahhh I see ty
Themes during T2ABC that don’t seem to be related to gold, egg or g6.
- Hours, days, months, any, ahead (time relations)
- One & i said often by Rob (could refer to 1 being i in next tier as each tier had its own leet used)
- Ticking repeated & laughed at gold clock. (more time relations)
- ETA Cassiopeiae (stars, time)
- Brilliant said often?
Wip but I’m working backward removing what was NOT related lol
Yeah start using the thread for this
I’ll leave that as a reminder but I’ll put other stuff there.
brilliant chess move
yep I caught this a while ago
this was never a clue, its a running joke because dusty accidentally sent typed that and sent it in this channel
noted 🙂
also the missing keys on the keyboard are 3 A C O, pointing to CaCO3 (the password)
perfect that can be eliminated then too
not sure if we ever figured out D H L though
Delivery?
Oh DHL is a delivery service lol
On that note. Is there a chance the solution from level 1 “geocache” might mean something overall to level 2 (3,4) solutions?
Gonna post this here. ? Clue maybe on this image that we wouldn’t have found without the new clues we’re given for this tier
At bottom of s pic
These possible TAM letters have probably been noted before, but maybe a possible path for them hasn't: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teen_Age_Message
The Teen Age Message (TAM) was a series of interstellar radio transmissions sent from the Yevpatoria Planetary Radar to six solar-type stars during August–September 2001. The structure of the TAM was suggested by Alexander Zaitsev, Chief Scientist at Russia's Institute of Radio-engineering and Electronics. The message's content and target stars ...
All "G" spectral types
and there are 6
Here we go again.
How's the hunting go lads
starting from the first tier lmao
what
G=6
Lmao
But don't worry, it's a walk in the park! We'll be through this park in no time.
Except it's getting dark, there's a ton of trees, and I'm suddenly in a forest with booby traps.
You forgot the distant growling noises
You heard those too? Thank Rob, I thought I was going crazy
@pure loom did you ever answer this? Sorry if you did and I overlooked
Thank Rob 😭
yeah, I did. It was blend mode
Which blend mode?
I tried various ones actually
Those lines seemed intriguing to me, do you know which one you used for that image?
I think I used "darker colour" for that one, but then that was using the old image, not the raw black and white ones from stegonline, so I'd probably ignore it
The lines on the left are a result of each layer being moved to the right
so only lines on the left would remain (mostly)
jsut a thought but... I'm noticing many different things that have to do with ressurection/respawning maybe?
an egg symbolizes fertility and birth/rebirth
jesus ressurection, rise from the ashes or "Oriri ex cinere" from dusty
i would not be surprised if the answer was a latin term
two words we combine
i do have the theory that in the last one we'll do something else new to change a certain letter into i
like E = iii
if anyones interested I think we've found a lot of potentially new things in #1176727687063154748
I'm gonna start a 1B soon
was this building ever identified
it could just be built like a cathedral for clue purposes
or it could be something else
I believe so. You can check the other padlets, but I'm pretttttttty sure it was one of the first few.
mmm I see that the pisa cathedral was named but that's it
it's not the pisa cathedral whatever it is
Saint Nicholas Cathedral
aha you're right
was that ever investigated?
The Cathedral of Our Lady of the Immaculate Conception (in French language: Cathédrale de Notre-Dame-Immaculée), but sometimes called Saint Nicholas Cathedral (the name of the old church which was demolished in 1874), or Monaco Cathedral (French: Cathédrale de Monaco), is the cathedral of the Archdiocese of Monaco in Monaco-Ville, Monaco, where ...
i think we investigated a little bit but nothing came from it as far as i know
seems like that could be important for the current tier? we'll have to keep that in mind
The present day Cathedral of Monaco symbolizes the rebirth of this small principality in the late 19th century, when Monaco turned into independent and very rich country. The old, medieval church was torn down and in its place was built new, magnificent cathedral.
rebirth... again
limestone used to build it
for everyone waking up in the am, please tear apart #1176727687063154748
bro???
it's there in real life Monaco 😭 we were all over that in t1A
wasn't too hard to find haha
dont act like everyones heard of the monaco cathedral lmao
i wasn’t here😭
when playing, i was calling it "castle" 
why do you think it's in the stage called monaco
I hadn't heard of it either lol, but like it's the main feature of the Monaco map haha
yeah its just not something you think about
We def searched it up
I’m a bozo
sorry
nah in all honesty I didn’t recall that maps name was monaco 🙂
Hahaha it's okay
All I was saying was we def covered it in T1A, not that I remember what we found
I didn’t see anything in the padlet unless I missed it
cause it wasn't exactly relevant iirc
It was there to point us towards Pisa Cathedral
It was related to T1A's Phoenix connection, but didn't really lead to clues
if you guys see anything interesting in #1176727687063154748 let me know or if you can add onto it
<@&1012034066876473384> homie posting this in a few diff channels now
This guy has a point, adding the words “最终决战” when looking in STEAM for the game (In mandarin) will make it very easy for mandarin speakera to find the game.
I don’t know if this is the right place to post it though.
感谢支持,我们中国人很喜欢这个游戏
Love you guys too! However it's the in server rules everyone uses the same language here, so please translate the messages next time!
What if @limber crest’s banner possibly has an Easter egg
Lmao it is not
😢
analyzing as you speak
The release of the sega saturn console was november 22nd…. Am I triping????
@jade citrus
yeah it looks like it
what about it

