#endgame-lounge
337195 messages Β· Page 468 of 338
I always feel toxic 

So should I just go off or.... I'm really confused
ask any questions you have 
if you wanna get better at the game
or just keep playing the way you've been playing (which is pretty bad but also doesn't matter significantly in the content you do)
guess i better stop shitposting here
ye start helping cause I have no idea how to tank properly at endgame
Well I want to actually improve and play the raids now considering the next one will be nier automata and I'm a huge fan of that
well
u said what needed to be said
nier automata is 24 man raid
its not gonna be remotely difficult
difficulty start from Extreme primals
and higher
Eden gonna be savage raid
I've mt on all the ex primals no one really told me anything π
That's including sb ex primals
they were baddies then
which is normal to see in EXs
in savage you have higher chance to meet ppl
who optimizes their play
to average level minimum
If I want to mt what class should I go for? π’
since i got a lvl70 how do i learn to another class/ job on same character?
?
- probably warrior
- though that can change in under 2 months
- if you don't care about optimizing your dps and improving you can mt on any tank (and be a pretty bad player)
- and the other tank will probably be happy about it cause he can focus on his own dps
Warrior for mt?
yes
that's the tank with highest aggro generation, which means you can easily get aggro, generate massive amounts and switch to dps stance
How does drk play in Savage and end game content?
FFXIV jobs are as balanced as they can get, despite some small differences
There is no jobs that you cannot play at end game
do i need accept quest if i want to level up another class/job since I only have one 70?
what quest
Just go to the blue quest for so you want to be a for the second or third job
this has nothing to do with endgame, please ask in #questions-and-help @maiden ermine
all questions here are about endgame raiding and optimizations
along with endgame crafting and gathering
I feel like if i of tank I'm more on the lines of dps so going warrior would be a better fit for me? π
I'm much more comfortable mting
that can change in 52 days
every tank should focus on dps, doesn't matter if you're main or offtank
warrior usually does higher dps even if it's mt i thiiink
but in high end content there's gonna be tank swaps every couple minutes to better utilize both tanks' cooldowns
so the term main tank doesn't really mean much
except for "currently tanking tank", which changes often
war just build fast and high starter aggro
after aggro is established
it doesnt matter who is mting
I haven't seen a tank swap in ages
I do
But I'm just like.. So mate do you want to mt or should I
Usually they don't startπ
there's tank swaps in like every ultimate, tank busters apply a debuff that make the next auto lethal to the tank who took the TB
every extreme*
I tend to use shrink and provoke to swap is that what you mean by swapping?
Royal Authority = dps
Rage of Halone = aggro
Does that guide keep updating each time there's a major patch?
yes, all faq guides are kept up to date
plus there's been like no changes to pld since 4.0 release
If adjustments are made to a job in that patch, yes
Well... Holy Spirit got balanced nerfed hard
Yeah
jobs change, guides get updated, pld doesn't change, the guide is updated anyways if the authors decide there's anything worth adding
only change pld got as noticable
Iirc, SMN rotation in early SB has you do Ruin 3 until you are almost dry

exactly
Amusingly I actually disagree with it slightly
I feel like it comes down to different definitions tho
Thinking about it it definitely is different definitions
I'm just reading and taking this to consideration cause I really want to play better π
Yeah
But in that paragraph, main tank refers a tank that always tanks the boss
And off tank a tank that never tanks the boss
Unless required
Oh
Never mind
I just can't read
Please ignore me
Lmao
just know it only applies in 8man content cause optimizing 24mans is large meme
How do i play 24 man than?
tank the boss, if someone else is tanking boss then respect it and tank your adds
you win
well in 24 man
u can play like you do in 8 man
except
assume you arent mting this
tho idk anyone on their right mind
go tank 24 man
given long que
Why do people say main and of tank when the paragraph says to just ignore that.
old habits die hard
the paragraph says delete the thought of always main tank and off tank
and yeah, its not saying to get rid of the idea completely
just don't focus on there always being a main tank and an off tank
like warr isn't always the main tank, pld isn't always the off tank. since there are fights that require swapping and things like that
Do people still do savage or is that old stuff now? Considering we are only 2 months from ShadowBringers?
PF is kinda empty but there's still some casual groups progging stuff and practice/kill PFs pop up from time to time
can always make your own
But will I be too late to join?
not really? I mean tier is long over and there's echo and a lot of people already killed and farmed as much as they wanted to, but there's still practice parties like I said
same as ex trials, there's still practice/kill parties for Shinryu after like 2 years
Good cause I want to farm for that glam
better start learning then cause more and more people are unsubbing till 5.0 and o12s is two fights, with final having some of the most convoluted mechanics in the game
no
maybe sometime in late shadowbringers in like i600 gear
Let see... Some of HW EX still cannot be carried
but hello world would still be very lethal
Cuz your mistake will wipe the team
Unless it happens early and people don't rez you
I've done all of HW EX playing the way I play /:
I'll change now that I looked through the guide and hopefully be the one carrying xD I doubt it but hey I'm willing to try given the new found info
How hard is it to farm for this full?
Depends on your luck
That's the Alphascape set
Can't tell whether it's Omicron or Omega
Yes
So no need for savages. Nice I love that gear π
Not sure if this is the right place but is it true that we are getting a ng+?
yes
I don't need to dye. The black tanking glamour is beautiful
cool
The limitations of getting one is lifted right?
correct, there's no weekly lockout
Can i ask how people usually do it without getting burnt out?
Don't do it all at once
Have people help? What if I'm not in a fc or know anyone in ffxiv π
so join one and make friends 
But people are unsubbing
what does that have to do with anything
Not many fc are recruiting are they π
People are unsubbing?
Also there always are FCs that recruit, and moreso when there's an expansion out
plenty of people take a break between now and expansion launch
Yeah but "people are unsubbing" makes it sound like it's an abnormality
People are unsubbing and subbing all the time
it is an abnormality compared to the other 95% of the expansion life cycle
Is Eureka a desolate wasteland now?
No. Plently of people.
Eureka probably has more people doing it than anything else atm lol
Is there still a weeky lockout on alphascape crystalloids?
Nope, can freely farm them
Indeed, nothing is on weekly lockout anymore except Cracked Clusters for Ivalice Raid.
and 900 genesis cap
I'm betting E1-E12 will be the go too
No idea Calc
Sigh just trying to be better in the game but when I logged in today. People were asking me to main tank when there was a warrior whom had better gear than me. Warriors generate more aggro so I was like you go and I'll dps π honestly really just don't understand people at all.
If there's a WAR I'll yield MT responsibility immediately
I thought war is always mt?
Was the Warrior new?
Could be they didn't know the fight
In which case they will often defer responsibility
I would say go into a duty without stance
see if the other tank takes the mantle
if within 10 seconds they don't, just stance yourself and pull.
if its a WAR
if its not a WAR, just make a decision
DRKS are in this weird place where some will auto stance and some will refuse
In End game raiding though WAR should know they are supposed to pull
in any other situation just have to go with the flow
and never assume
it's a good thing that giant aoes appear in the order the fans dropped
I mean I honestly don't know I was still learning to play Alphascape v4 (I suck so bad there) go into duty without stance π never thought of it like that.
I explicitly just waited over a minute wondering if he/she was there only to get wipe and than being told I should tank and I'm like.... Urm you can generate more aggro than me (playing as pld with sword oath)
cant*
its not like u cant do it
just might lose broil if u identify it later rather than sooner
and i love my broils
I know I can tank it but usually I saw warriors are supposed to pull first no?
I really don't know how or what to do π
It doesnβt matter on casual content
Anyone who willing to tank is fine
V4 has 2 bosses, and each tank have to take one anyway
I can get up to v4 split but than I just suck and have no idea how to play it
You are correct, WAR should Pull, but that honestly only matters a lot for end game raiding
anything that isn't savage, ultimate or extreme just bite the bullet and MT it
if they don't do it in 10 seconds
the run will get cleared and everyone moves on
if someone doesn't volunteer to main tank safe to assume they don't want to.
or don't feel comfortable with the responsibility.
@clever sphinx
swiftcast broil lol
nothing wrong wtiht he swiftcast broil
pro strats
Slidecast broil then XD
don't doxx me please
oof, did a few more wipes to final omega
the last one before disband was the most frustrating since it was directly my fault for not pointing the camera in the right direction (so by running back I ran west not south on hw2)
tanking in alliance roulette is a gem
Other tanks have they enmity generation skill up so I drop mine but somehow some other dps have aggro
Do I trust them or no
no
I just wish if tanks were gonna pull crap off the MT they'd have the decency not to cleave everyone else by standing behind the boss before they pull aggro
happens constantly in Alliance raids
But that takes the fun out of alliance raids
ikr
i just like seeing someone pull early when i do a countdown and i just stand there and let them tank it
On the other hand
i mean i just assume someone is gonna try to get me killed
If youβre not pulling within 20 seconds
which is why i play tank
Not because of people trying to explain mechanics
Youβd know I pull
and they pull at 8s
Thereβs groups where despite everyone being here nobody pulls
you queued as a tank go do your job
always kills me on the inside seeing dps do less dmg than me on tank
Running WoD the other day and saw adds Iβve never seen
imagine ppl being so slow on cerberus that he dmg stacked to the point that he one shotted me
and then proceeded to kill the entire alliance
Its basically an enrage timer disguised as a buff.
I'll π explain π£ it π π to you π once π― more β so that π you π₯ understand π§ π€ i don't π give π a π© shit π what π€· other tanks π« π do π i don't β care π€ what they π― do π I'M π― THE π€ WARRIOR β I know π§ my class π i will π₯ see π what i can πͺ and what π€ i cannot π do π i don't give π a fuck π π¦ what other π₯ tanks π‘ do π
are you okay bud
Oh, my static member had linked that clip in our discord server yesterday morning haha
Basically some guy raging about being asked to go defiance for adds phase in ucob
defiance is so good
oh i wanna see this clip
amazing
yeah plus u have unchained or w/e
and they get to smack their dick on IR decimate after plummet/claw
They also needed to tell him that dps past a certain point on Baha doesn't matter
then you only go tank stance when there's a thermo triple quote and you're holding twin and to IB the double tank busters
Since he didn't know that Golden spawns with 100%
if its Baha then 
if he wants a good parse then just assassinate the caster/ranged
He generally didn't do research on the fight
in golden*
people doing research 
actually why the fuck wouldn't he go defiance
im assuming they recently got to adds
so why wouldn't he perma tank stance for a few pulls
cause DPS is more important than prog
oh no my prog parse
gotta make sure you get max deeps while dying to Ifrit for the eightieth time
not really comparable but ok
hol' up
why would shadowfang be more valuable during trick than armor crush
wait
!action shadow fang
yes
Of course
it's why bard uses Iron Jaws twice a litany/chain strat window
one at the beginning so you can start the proc machine, and one at the end so you get another ~30 seconds of proc heaven
of course there's some wonky situations in fights with heavy downtime where you're gonna have to trick, and have to refresh huton
FUCK
Well at least you know now haha
i'm so mad at myself right now smh
but for the opener you still put shadow fang outside of trick
yes
i am done 
Someone has no life
@lusty turret what's your favorite one though
Nice!
weapon
ucob brd
Just a quick question what are Alphascape Crystalloid used for?
I have 3 of them /:
the genesis weapon
genesis weapons?
you exchange 4 for a military-grade(?) tomestone in rhalgr's
then you also exchange 1000 tomestones of genesis for 10 tokens
Is there a point of rolling for them?
you don't roll for the crystalloid
You automatically get it whenever you complete o12
Should you go for the military grade one or not?
yes
depends on what you've got/class
Genesis weapons need 10 Genesis tokens worth 100 each (7 tokens if you're a paladin) and a Military-Grade Tomestone
I'm using for my pld
I got 19 days and barely touched Ereuka. Is it even doable? Got 3 of the crstyaloid and 200 Genisis
probably be quicker to get the genesis weapon then, tbh
You can get 900 Genesis per week, so you can get it this week if you farm genesis
I'm just farming Alphascape just to get the full set
Well, that will get you 380 gear so thats good, but for Genesis you'll want to farm level 70 dungeons
and the 70 roulettes
or do Eureka
or Hunt train
those are fastest genesis options
I prefer Eureka and Hunt Train myself
but Daily Expert Roulette and latest lvl 70 dungeon spam are fine
I'm mainly just doing it on the sides since I really like that glam to use.
I'm doing roulette for my Drk leveling that up to max.
Well level 70 roulettes don't give levels, just tomes.
so you can just do the level 70 dungeons ones for tomes
and use the rest for leveling
I've not ran the level 70 or 60 dungeons yet says I need to unlock it by completing the dungeon first
Is ilevel 379 all right for those dungeons?
I'm about to cap out on Mendacity is there anything I should buy with it or just keep it cap?
you can buy crafting materials to sell for gil.
Check the prices of these on the marketboard and see what sells the best and fastest. I recommend getting the NQ versions since they sell more often than the HQ versions generally.
You can also use it for Doman Reiyakyu to upgrade Rakshasa gear from i380 to i390 if you have any of that.
I got my shield blade and head gear
Is it better to get the Genisis weapon or to upgrade my Rakshasa blade?
genesis weapon
Genesis because it can be upgraded to i400
using 1 of each coin from the 3 rabanastre raids
to buy upgrade item for it
So run the 24 man raid and do omega alpha 4 and roulette to get the ilevel 400 weapon.
Run each 24 man once for coins, do alpha 4 4 times and get 1000 genesis for blade and shield
then grab upgrade item for weapon, trade weapon and item for i400 version
To get the upgrade item for both shield and sword I would need to do twice for each 24 man no?
The item should upgrade both if I'm not mistaken
I'll double check though
Confirmed The Augmented Scaevan Magitek Katzbalger and Augmented Scaevan Magitek Shield are traded as a SET
so get both, and one Scaevan Ester and you'll be fine.
Hardest part is getting the 1000 :(
Well, if you run Expert Roulette thats 90 right there
you'll get about 100 from your Alpha and ivalice runs
altogether
the rest you can get from spamming the latest 70 dungeons for 50 per run
or you can do hunt trains
or you can do Eureka
Wondrous tails also occasionally gives 300 as a one line reward
Stormblood A Rank Hunt Trains and Eureka are both super fast for capping Genesis
and the methods I most recommend
Since a full SB A rank train will net you 120 genesis
and takes about 30 minutes to do usually
and Eureka gives between 6 and 40 Genesis per NM
so a couple hours there could net you a few hundred Genesis as well
I've barely even touched Ereuka so that's a no go for me
Are you on Aether Dominic?
I'm on chaos
Ah ok, if you were on Aether I was gonna link you to our hunt discord, not sure if Chaos has one
I get pings whenever a server has an A rank train ready to go
often can do 3 or 4 back to back
I think hunt trains are not a thing in EU. They drop in for the one A/S rank and then disperse.
Maybe its the time of day.
NGL but I'll just kill any ARR A ranks I see without calling them out.
When EU is asleep, hunta rarely occur but EU primwtime you have to r3act within 1-2 minutes or you miss it.
Thats a shame, its a fun community activity and a great way to get resources for end game
3000 isnt great
Ikr. I really miss coeurl's hunt train
500 seals every noon amd evening like clockwork
rather run the 24 mans
With Cross World getting 3000 is easy
than hit or miss hunt
I like the hunts because they are very social.
I've gotten 4000 from doing 9 trains split in two parts of the same day
24mans always feels like a chore where everybody just wants it to be over with.
Upgraded 2 accesories
and managed to cap genesis for the week too
Once you cap genesis I agree 24 mans make more sense
Cross world made hunts VERY effiicient in Aether though
Yea its alot easier to get the coins for upgrading.
Well oiled machine on most servers now.
Im jelly
eureka been a new good way to cap weekly tomes
I agree, but if you want upgrades too its a good way to do both, especially for folks who don't have Eureka mastered yet.
I miss aether so much but my server got quarrantined to cryatal.
When EU is aslwep, i do the bunnies in pyros
I can also get tons of mendacity and poetics for other things.
in hunt train
as I'm gearing up my alts with Yama gear
Well yeah, if you can do savage everything I'm saying is a moot point.
or o11s
When i resubbed, i only had diamond gear so i didnt savage. I thought i needed better gear.
I gear people for savage, I don't really care to run it XDXD
If you had full Diamond set you were golden
but having higher ilvls would of helped
Now im almost augmented scaeven but still alittle uneasy
ppl were clearing o9s and o10s on i370
Well Savage has echo now, so if you had the skill to get diamond I'm sure you will do fine.
Oh true. 15% right?
yes
Hmm, after i finish BA, ill go savage again.
Practice party healers are too busy DPSing instead of cleansing rock debuff off themselves or the tanks
I probably wouldn't still be subbed if I wasn't a raider.
same
For me I don't find any value in raiding unless a raid gear piece fits into a glam, so far nothing has compelled me enough to reach for it with any intensity, since literally every other activity can be done without raid gear. If they tied story to raiding like they did Coils I would do it, but I'm glad that they don't force that anymore, because I'd probably get burnt out due to lack of skill.
Or at the very least lack of a skilled commited group
it's more about the challenge for me, all normal/ex difficulty fights have like zero mechanics so doing something that requires some thinking is definitely more fun
i got bored of savage after the 8 months its been out so i only log in for ultimate reclears if i get into any 
I've usually never been the sort of gamer that plays the highest difficulty options unless the reward entices me or seems reachable.
I tend to not really push my limits unless I have a lot of support or a drive to do it
which is less and less the case as my free time becomes higher value due to lower supply.
For me Savage and Ultimate are far out of my reach mainly because a talented team is also out of my reach without putting in a lot of work I don't want to do XD
the ultima weapons look damn nice i have to agree though
and yes i like to play games on hard difficulties
to make it fun experience
otherwise i would sleep if its easy
the problem is
when hardest difficulty is still easy
like tales of berseria
Normal and above normal are usually the difficulty curves I run at and they are challenging enough for me, I could put in the time to master them enough to push the higher difficulty, but its rare I ever have that much motivation, once I've absorbed the story and all the places I can go to the fullest I tend to be done with any game.
If there is story gated behind high difficulty like in Valkyrie profile thats when you will get me into hard mode.
valkyrie profile was gated behind difficulty?
You had to do all the hardest dungeons to get the best ending
and you had to play on the higher difficulty setting to do that
i only played VC2
which needs beating game 50 times
to get hardest difficulty
and no ty
not doing that
yeah if it was that ardous I'd just look up a youtube vid LOL
seraphic gate was fun
But like Coils, if I was playing actively when it was relevant, I would of done them.
fucken dirna
because of Story gating
Yeah, Seraphic Gate is Tri-Aces Middle Finger in all their games LOL
True True
I got six of those alpha crystaloids yet barely even getting anything to get the full set for Omicron gear. Is there really no easier way to get the gear I really want.
What is the gear you really want?
can always do savage instead
But going into Savage is hell compare to just farming o8 to o12
harder but more consistent, easier but RNG. have to choose
Sadly its all about winning those rolls
Unless you can get a pre-form that wants to let you win rolls out of the kindness of their heart you are going to have a tough time.
How hard is Savage vs the normal raid?
Just saw Savage actually gives you the gear instead of rolling π
Its night and day
and the gear technically looks different so its not the exact same set.
it's the same but is dyeable
sometimes there's slight embellishments but generally looks the same
Oh is it? thats different
In HW they were totally different
and previous SB tiers
fair enough, I guess I'm misremembering the way the sets looked or the dye made a huge difference
I have 0 confident in doing Savage runs π
anywho, returning to the previous question. The first two floors in a savage tier are like, around ex primal difficulty
especially with echo, the difficulty has dropped further. Still not just straight up easy regardless of whatever like normal mode version of raids are but
they're pretty reasonable even if you're newer
Should i jump into ex primals before I even tackle Savage than? I've done some just not all of the primals on ex difficulty
personal preferences
How do i even know if I'm ready to take on the Savage raids than :(
EX raids are the best practice for savage imo
I know the normal raids pretty easily now
or at least getting a feel for your job at that scale of difficulty
Is it better to role need or greed? I keep rolling need but is greed better
So everyone that are in o12 with me will always roll need?
yes
Yep
Yep
Everyone wants to gear up their alt classes
and since they can need, they will
some are farming glams
some just turn the stuff in for seals or desynth
nobody is going to say no to loot they earned unless its worthless
or they have no inventory space
Well I've been rolling it wrong than :(
Yep, if need is available always do Need.
no reason not to.
Only time you have to worry about loot courtesy is things like Treasure Maps of Farm partys that have an established rule.
*or farm partys
otherwise everyone needs if they can.
I know there are party finders in the game but if I was to set a omega alpha Savage practice would people join? I'm thinking of jumping into Sigmascape first but will that be far too difficult.
If you specifically say Fresh Practice in PF for Alpha people will join.
People are more likely to join an alphascape savage party than they are a sigmascape one, by the by
But I just never done sigma. Will I be all right?
They all have the same type of challenge, just different gear levels.
Sigma experience won't really help you in alpha as each fight is its own dance
It will help in understanding speed and pacing, but so would EX
is there a list of priority in terms of dragoon tether for general groups?
is it bard/mch for openers?
i have seen people ask for sigma savage on PF, people will do it if thats your concern.
There's honestly not much reason to start in sigmascape anyway
@kindred fable Opener I give it to MCH or BRD then during the rest of the fight I give it to the other melee
I mainly just want to get alpha but I was wondering if i go though sigma first it will help me understand. But if I can do a fresh party on alpha Savage than I wouldn't mind knowing fully well that I'm on a fresh start and the challenge is still relevant to a new raider
o9s and o10s start out easy enough with o11 and 12 ramping up
If there is no other melee or the other melee is terrible then adjust, give to tank or nearest range
if they will stay close
I've done some primals as I said before on ex but that was years ago
i often get tether as SCH because i stand in melee range for miasma 2
@lunar pollen awesome thanks!!
i was always confused at first when the other dps was ranged
its totally fine. Alpha now is eaier because of echo
Obviously if there is not MCH or BRD give to highest DPS potential caster such as SMN or BLM
in opener
What's echo?
Echo is a buff that gives your party 15% dmg, max hp and incoming healing
if you wipe
you must fight for at least 7 or 8 minutes i think?
they add it to fights when they become old to make it easier for people afraid to try it.
for sigmascape its 20%, alphascape is 15%
the correct target for tether will depend on which tether it is and what the job has up
I really just don't want people in the chat just screaming at me saying I don't know stuff when i am clearly just learning. Been through that a few times when I was doing o12 and a few dungeon viab party finder
BRD is actually generally the best by far to give in opener
unless they have real bad RNG, but you don't really count on that
Whether you do sigmascape or not
isn't going to change people being dicks like that
then usually you continue with giving them every 2nd tether, generally swapping between them and a melee
bad people happens sometime, if you put practice in the PF, it would alleviate some
Because you're not learning how to do alphascape by doing sigma
i see i see. alternating tethers is something i havent considered. thanks
You need to go into alphascape savage to learn alphascape's dance
o9s is intended to be an easy starting point for savage
whether you have previous exp or not
I was mainly using sigmascape cause is an earlier raid so thought it would be easier. I'll just do practice o9 than when I feel I'm ready for o10 to o12 eventually.
Plus loot still drop from them rightπ€
yes
Well all the more reason to do practice and than hopefully with the next expansion I'll be confident enough to do the next set of raids
the only thing sigmascape is really going to offer is a general feel for savage
may as well jump into o9s because it'll do the same thing
while giving ilvl 400 gear
^
Youβre gonna have a hard time finding sigma delta parties
Plus since most people outgear them now, they donβt give too good of a feeling for savage
Is there a 12s guide that has pug strats in it?
Pug Unreal is basically this except flipped 180 and tanks go to A for the last set of defamations https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1d6pbEYqVx2jclVyvll8-CEMLozcYtk-mm_KyBSNf158/edit
Ref: https://youtu.be/d9msqyVnTng You should do this for both HW1 and HW2, there just won't be any towers or rot the first time (It gives you good practice for the movement). A B C D 1 2 Arena
That's for way later into the fight, but that looks like the unreal I see in party finder all the time
I need something for the whole fight
ive been enjoying ninja but the more I play it in the 50-60 range, the more I see its getting kinda stale, do skills like ninki/tenchijin make it dynamic enough to be engaging
im mostly just mindlessly spamming 124>123>123, repeat with 125 thrown in when I need huton refreshed, and getting in raitons or suitons every 20 seconds
It's just a buster and patch before that
That slideshow has HTTH patch which is what pugs generally do
And the other mechanics are literally just follow someone who know where they're going
Except Index which is just stretch your tether and wing it on the spread if you don't have one
@kind schooner when you get tcj youβre either gonna love it or hate it
Ninki is braindead without tcj
without tcj, its just bhavachakra > hellfrog
Aight. And how are sams in the meta, like if they filled the same role as they do now moving into shadowbringers
I havent looked at sam since 4.3 back when the hot take was that groups excluded* them in parties because party buffs > selfish dps
still pretty much the same in that aspect.
Ah. They still do high enough dps to warrant that role though? Or are they not close to smn/blm in dmg over utility aspect
I at least have a static now so if I break into raiding with sam I dont need to worry about people stressing over logs
I think they're 2nd place with BLM at 1st.
no ninja is bottom dps monk is 2nd best melee dps but SAM no utility
SAM/BLM are "selfish" DPS, they are viable but they make your group sad
Healers adjust for BLM
I want to main SAM
but will never get into raid lol
I really dont want to play DRG or NIN lol
and for tanks im good with Paly hate warrior DRK is cool but none take them either lol
if DRG requiored then NINJA should be too
But it's not
Drg is only required for piercing
If you have a war then the slashing from nin isn't required
they give SATA
Sata
etc other utility for raid
What's sata
sneak attack trick attack and all that stuff
Sneak attack was removed from the game in 4.0
trick attack isn't necessary
its question you have it boosts all dps
or not have it and get a SAM or something
what will net you highest dps overall for raid?
what I see if WAR(mt) PLD(ot) then SCH and WHM or AST and Summoner with DRG BRD and NIN
Triple ranged is also a valid comp
Brd mch caster
brd/mch/caster
/p like RDM BRD SMN?
Yeah
That's an okay comp
It's definitely not as common
But it's fine
Very solid prog comp
having trick and shadewalker makes your group happy
also looking cool is important
so ninja out of question
leaves SAM DRK or PLD or DRG
whats it for healers and tanks
this makes it pretty clear what the preferred classes are in endgame
ultima tanks
ultima healers https://www.fflogs.com/zone/statistics/23#class=Healers
ucob tanks
Ultimate is a very specific set of requirements
guess warrior MT otherwise everything else seems interchangeable
oh DRK i guess gets the shaft lol
I wouldn't use ultimate comp to describe what best overall at endgame
ultimate also requires a fair bit different from savage
if a class it's better in ultimate, it's also better in other content
No haha
what does savage have that make a class better than in ultimate?
I can't think of even 1 example
Tough prog is a focus in ultimate, while Savage you see a lot more optimization and SR
the same classes are optimal though
people only do speedruns with SAM/BLM if they want to meme
BLM is actually considered meta in a good comp
not if they're being serious

But good Lord it's so good in ultimate
Yeah it's kinda ridiculous
Two targets that live for an extended period of time, with multidot and cleave
I can see why firewall is a thing 
I'm pretty sure SAM is only used in LB cheese runs, only 5 of the top 40 speed kills on M/F are with a SAM
and LB cheese is far more niche than ultimate
and you can smash ruin 2 as you do mechanics for minimal loss
I don't think this even qualifies as a meta
Because it's just straight up better than nin in mf
if only 5 out of 100s of groups used it
It brings more rdps since only 4 people can take advantage of trick in the latter half
Yeah but there's a thing called
Theory
Turns out player skill is more important than what jobs you bring in
Who knew
but it's a fair enough point that there's 1 niche where SAM is better than NIN
so I'll give you that
also the whole point of meta is getting the most dmg out of a possible team comp
so SAM IS meta for o12s
I wouldn't call a 0.00001% niche a meta
It is meta for that fight
for o12s...it is
Its meta for mf
Like BLM is elsewhere
is it really the meta if you have to do things like LB cheese for it to be better?
and normal groups don't do that kind of thing?
Even if people don't run it as much doesn't make it not better
Lb cheese is speedrunning
Idk why youre relating lb cheese to sam
Since they have no relation p much
well, sure, if you want to do that kind of thing you're right
People lb cheese every fight.
but it's not very relevant to most people
It's the same answer whether you lb cheese or not
Yeah but there's a speedrun meta
It has nothing to do with SAM being meta for M/F
99% of the people who do savage aren't gonna speedrun, so SAM sin't gonna be better for their group
When people talk about meta
Actually, for worse groups, SAM will be better than other options
Because they get worse at making good use of raid buffs
And an optimization meta
And most of the people who savage don't know how to make use of raid buffs
so the point is moot then
You still have to do final omega after m/f
But the optimization meta is exactly the same as speed just you take drk over pld
which is the more important part
yeah you're right
for the 0.0000001% who do speedrun, sam is meta for that fight
but that doesn't appy to the other 99% of endgameplayers
where SAM isn't meta
yes and for the 99% who don't it doesn't really matter
it sounds to me like you're just trying to come up with excuses to play a less-optimal class
^
if you honestly are trying to say that SAM is some speedrun nonsesne
and what if i am
trying to come up with excuses to play a less optimal class
so what
true, I only have 100s on a couple of fights, not all of them, sorry
because meta and speedrunning tbh kind of go hand in hand
Regardless though, most players don't make good use of comp synergy to begin with
legend
I mean, I agree with you that SAM can be meta on an extremly tiny niche
not sure why that isn't enough
but if you're not in that niche, I'd say bringing a sam is going to make your group perform worse
It's a curve
Because people can't take advantage of trick attack as well
that's true
Therefore the rdps that nin brings would be below the pdps advantage than sam has
Therefore Sam would be better for the group
If you have a player who plays better on SAM than they do NIN, its better for them to play SAM
well, sure
So to answer your question
"why would someone wanna play a less optimal class"
Because they find it more fun
I don't think you need to optimize much for trick rdps to be better than sam personal dps
I mean
line it up with litany and battle voice
You'd be surprised
tell people to save pots for it
If you have the warrior literally unga his combo
and you're probably ahead of SAM already
And heavy swing 4x during trick
Lot more groups than you'd think fall beneath that line
Yeah people suck at this game dude
Where utility actually is more useful than pdps
don't need to tell me that, I've had O12S PFs where the NIN had less than 1 trick every 2 minutes
but I don't think that's the norm
maybe if you're a 90%+ player and you step into a PF where most people are 10-40%, you're giving the group more DPS by playing SAM than you would by playing NIN
but if you're looking for a static you should be looking for one where people are near your skill level
Tbh
Idk why this conversation is happening
Since all theorycrafting goes out the window when you start taking people's skill level into account
@kind schooner was asking if it was better for him to play NIN or SAM
play what ya want, nerd
^ sticky this!
my initial response was
by viable I meant pretty much equally viable
but I'm hinting that NIN makes people happier
and I prefer to make my group happy
especially redesign / changes coming soon
i mean except blm actually is meta in double caster but im not repeating the conversation
BLM is very powerful but needs a good BLM player to make it worthwhile (or a slightly more mediocre group, for that matter) <3
if my group would be mad at me playing sam or blm that means its time for me to find a group of people that are a bit more
mature
my group wouldn't be mad at all for me playing SAM, I played a lot of SAM
they are just happier when I play NIN or DRG
so that makes me happier
I hope they do something about that in shadowbringers tho
same with WHM
well, things are already far better than they were in late HW with regards to balance
so hopefully they continue in that vein and make it even better in ShB without homogenizing jobs too much
personally i quite like the range between raid buff jobs and selfish dps jobs
yeah, the balance in the game is pretty good right now
the only reason people in ur static were happier is bc their parse is higher π€·
but I would prefer it if jobs like WHM/SAM/BLM got some kind of utility like cards, chain strategem, trick attack
I'd prefer not every job has utility, it's kinda nice that it's not all about that for everyone
granted, f4 is now 301p
the balance itself is pretty good nowadays between it, I guess really by now it's mostly on the community perception of still wanting to stick to certain comps
301?
it's base 300 potency, then eno and AF3
well if I'm tanking I really love to have shadewalker too, makes my job easier by a lot

its always hey if you could play ninja or dragoon that would be cool but if you play samurai you will literally lose custody of your kids and your dog will be kidnapped
the only difference is makes is let you swap a daps to a dase as drk
threat resets π‘
just aggro combo lol

i fucking hate that about tanks tbh
like sure yeah its ur job to pump out dps as well
but like 40 potency isnt gonna do shit
oops now you've done it you've opened the floodgates
I just enjoy it more when I don't have to worry about it
expect a couple dozen angry letters from blue parsing tanks soon
like the 3rd buster on twintania on ucob when shirk sin't back up yet
having a shadewalker there just makes it comfier

its fuckin twintania
ur gonna be doing it a bazillion times
you're gonna stop thinking about it anyway
you underestimate the value of comfiness
every time I pug that fight on NIN
the tank is so happy when I give them shade
on that tank swap
it makes them feel loved
they are probably fine with doing an aggro combo, but getting some love sometimes is nice
ye, eventually you can do twintania and nael half asleep
it doesn't make you exhausting
and ucob has long downtime
I guess we can all be happy about one thing
we're not playing WoW where you need no less than 7 warlocks for the last boss of the tier
in a 20 man raid
wat
I'm exaggerating, some groups took shamans or shadow priests
but the balance in that game is really bad right now
every group that cleared the new raid only brought 1-3 melee
and you barely see any DPS outside of warlocks, shamans, shadow priest
you can just kill the other tank and still get aggro for the 3rd Death Sentence
If I'm starting with the intent of wanting to raid (wow refugee) is there a job that I can focus on that's in demand? I'm happy to fill any role/function
If you want to go with what's currently trending, BRD, NIN, SCH, AST, DRG, SMN, WAR, PLD.
This might change with 5.0 however, which is in a few months
Got it - any suggestions out of those for a noob to learn?
that's up for debate and people are free to correct me on this, but WAR is both easy to learn and always in need as it is a tank role, which is played the least generally speaking.
π
honestly just kinda go with any job that sounds interesting to you haha
^ also that
don't really feel confined to try any sort of job
any and all jobs are plenty viable and wanted, and we're past the point where meta is actually all that relevant anyways
and there's likely to be changes to the meta with the expansion anyways, and they like to keep all jobs plenty fine so
really just find a job that interests you and you feel like getting good with
and you'll be plenty fine raiding
Ok - I'll just continue plowing through the MSQ then... Sounds like that should be my priority before the new expansion drops
absolutely
absolutely. And you can always pick up a second job, or all of them, if you want and leveling alts is tons faster
can't do new stuff if you're not caught up~










