#✨|sdxl
1 messages · Page 93 of 1
And not a workstation GPU
Those don't need high end workstations.
Simulating relies more on a CPU, than a GPU.
Im not intending to build one for those
Since im gaming as well
A gaming computer should cost max $3.5k usd.
You don't need a 4090 for gaming...
1.800/3.000 just with a GPU alone
But kinda "need" it if i want to play 4K with raytracing at most extreme level possible
at 1440p, my 4080 could do a little better at rdr2
And still have over 100 fps
i dip to about 50 when that wide open world is maxed up
One day you will realize you will start a family and want to retire, but you're free to be a consumer.
weird flex
Granpa why are you living with us
Because I wanted those dank fps on Max settings.
Others spend that money on other stuff
Cigarettes, alcohol, etc.
Young men have this idea that because others do it I should too.
You
re free to do what you want though.
I didnt need to spend thousands on my art workflow and workspace, but i did because i wanted it
Its about what you want
Expectations
Maybe 4090 will drop in price next year
There's going to be a market crash, but you could keep warm with your new computer possibly 😄
0_0
I own a company and make quite a bit a year, if I can give you any advice, don't buy useless things you don't need. Unless it can give you a return. Invest in your skills and other sectors to grow wealth.
I have 2 4090's and they make me money, but other than generating for AI I wouldn't purchase the cards. But you're free to do what you want.
@slender coral respectable. And you are actually right. Better dont find out that im still a beginner in art and co. and still spent all the money from the beginning
Hardware and software
Actually my idea is essentially to earn secondary income besides of my current full time job that i might eventually replace if i get good enough with programing and jump to the IT sector.
Best decision you can take, I'm a Software engineer.
Spend that money on school.
What do i want with that secondary income? I want to invest in even more stuff related to secondary income and art like buying a good 3D printer at some point and make a "business" out of it by making and selling 3d figures as well. Also i want to educate myself
Pay courses
Some of which are expensive af
Let alone online degrees
The only thing I've used my 3D printer was for printing parts and upgrades for the 3D printer. Having tools and toys doesn't make money. Knowing people does, that's how you get contracts and projects.
Yes. Networking and building necessary skills
Having a product wont make me money automatically
Dont get me wrong, im not interested in this area just because i want money
My interest and fascination for those are on the first place, money earning with those is just a ideal case but not a necessity
Money gives freedom, but i look for other factors as well
Free time, atmosphere in the company and the team are important for me as well
Does anyone know if LYCORIS works with ComfyUI
iA3 does not, nor DyLoRA.
Sure. But those factors change. The whole idea of company culture in tech is bullshit HR talk to keep you not asking for raises.
I've worked on nfts the last few years, I hate nfts but it allows me to support my own projects and buying 2 4090s.
But yes, go to school, it will be the best investment you can do.
Learning programming online I wouldn't recommend. It takes about 2 years of acedemics to actually learn and understand it. Anyone trying to sell you a bootcamp or online cert is just scamming people.
Valid, and yes when I do my own changes I have a custom .py file (SolesbeesSaloon) I make all my additions or changes to.
I made that mistake once 😅
I'm going on the hunt for things that I can add to my workflow, Can you give me a list of all the things that DO currently work in ComfyUI with SDXL models? Please and Thank you...
I can't because I don't use it now since it refuses to work with the lora types I train, and use.
NFTs? Damn i dislike those lol.
For the education, i definitelly want to do something but going to those in real life has a high price tag and not only financially. For studying i dont even need to talk the route for now at least.
Some of my friends got into the industry without a formal education, they were at some online courses but more importantly...built a portfolio while attending those and after as well
anybody happen to know how to stop python from forcing your GPU to boost clock when at idle?
cause its using a lot of power, and making a lot of heat
I cant figure out how to stop it from sucking power when paused/idle
use .Sleep not a pause
My bad, I'm not running my own code
I have this problem when automatic, comfy UI, and oobabooga are idle
The reason it's expensive is the same reason why you make 100k+ a year.
Take out a student loan, it will be the best investment for you.
Unless there's some running threads (and I don't think there are) I don't see idle being an issue, the reserved memory should be released. GPU is different.
Check your cpu / gpu at idle and see your percentages.
They're both below 2%, that's not the issue I'm having
The issue was that Python.exe is forcing my GPU to stay at boost clocks, even when it is idle
Pyhton doesn't do that, it's whatever process you have running.
Check your PID processes and see what's consuming the most.
So then it's command line?
ps -ef | grep python
With Pixai
This is probably the best Stable Diffusion provider with anime style
afterburner could probably create a python specific profile for it. maybe even geforce experience
It is like he's cheating for sure
wait afterburner doesn't have per app settings. mb
Hold on let me try again
pytorch is doing it likely, since it has the cuda library talking to the drivers. but windows sees that as python.exe
It's a FUCKING green
green is not a creative color
Now this IS BLUE
Python just runs Python there's no processes it runs. So Python is all you see.
If you want to see what's running you have to list the Python modules.
I'm using the comfy node that gives you a feed of images at the bottom—is there a way to load one of those images into the workflow?
drag the image from your output folder into comfyui
Yeah I just do like 50 gens at a time and it's just a touch of a hassle to find the right when when I have this gorgeous feed right there
or go to history (theres a little button) and load
Yeah there's just no clean mapping between that feed. Its not a huge deal would just be a nice lil QOL thing
@indigo carbon finally figured out what screwed up my speeds a while back, i nuked my CUDNN drivers somehow and that was the culprit
back to higher it/s on your workflow
what was the change in speed?
8s difference in generation on Tdg workflow
using default workflow, it was down from 10s for 1024 (vanilla) to 7.99s (AIT+CUDNN)
20% change ish
wait shit
thats what i mean. that's why they see python.exe using the gpu, because as far as the kernel is concerned, it is
thats without AIT
lol
with AIT it went down to 5.79s on default workflow 1024x1024
that sounds a lot better
it took FOREVER to figure out
which version did you install?
yep thats good
even tried to compile ait for 3090 but im stuck on compiling
aitemplate module is giving me issues in python
have ot rebuild the whl
Huh, did you actually manage to set up the compilation script? I tried for AGES to do that to have my own modules, never worked
nope, im stuck at compile.py
tells me aitemplate isnt a module
and then i do a pip ls, and its sitting right there
🤷♂️
Did you manage to run the build script? That's what I'm always stuck on
hahahha, that damn script is stupid on windows cause you dont have write permissions on the folder without a bunch of jumping through hops
so i just renamed the folders in setup.py
Hi, for some reason Searge's workflow inpainting don't work for me (img2img works). Inpainting just delivers the drawing of the girl (img2img delivers results)
i got the whl to build but there is some incompatibility with one fo the dependancies
Is it the kernals? That's what I get when python setup.py bdist_wheel
this is what i changed, "aitemplate2"
ah shit your error must be different, i was getting write errors because the file existed
Man, idk how the fuck Hlky does this shit
is low learning rate (0.0001) and high epoch count what trains the model towards detail? or are there other parameters too?
DUDE, i feel like i know the guy, been reading so many of his threads
hes BUSY
What is your denoise value set to
@strong field mind taking this to DM? I am also always trying to compile myself
lets go
0.74, but it doesn't seem to matter (and I think I tried some other number) as it never produce any result, just paste the drawing of the girl
can you send me a screenshot
https://www.reddit.com/user/hlky 👀 hope not this guy
i got curious cause y'all were excited bout hlky threads
sure, here
I messed up the heigh and width but it show it doesn't take the image
Dont think it knows Linus's face
oh I figured it out, I need to put the image both in the source image and in the inpainting mask 😒
@indigo carbon do you know if there was anything new with AIT for Lora and VAE decode?
This image was created with base SDXL + refiner.
That's really kool Patt
my new routine at the gym
"I have no eyes but I must see"
dont need no eyes when u look this beautiful
@visual glade sorry to bother you over this again, but I have talked to some other friends/colleagues, and they are also having this abnormally high idle VRAM draw from comfy, and other AI programs.
I am not sure why, as the GPU's are set to idle state, but they max out their clocks and just sit there doing nothing
Would be curious to see the results of people in this server in terms of idle GPU power consumption and clock speeds when not generating in comfy
I have it in RVC, auto, comfy, ooba, kohya, and Derrian
I am assuming its just some underlying issue with python that causes the GPU to be clocked up for no reason wasting power
all I know is I really wish it wouldn't, cause its running up my cooling, and thus my electric bill, while already using unnecessary power
mine clocks down, but I dont have gpu-only. Maybe that is the cause?
I have this issue in all AI suites, and it's been on all of my GPU's as well
When you just have comfy open and not generating, how much power does your GPU use?
it could be nonsense. but I read today that 720 hours of a 4090 running hard will cost about 32 dollars on average in the US
something along those lines
Oh ok. I havent seen that before also with A1111. When not generating in A111 or comfy open its like 40W
it doesn't happen here
I'm not sure why it works for you then...
For me, my GPU permanently stays clocked at boost clocks and just sits with 0% utilization while sucking down 140 Watts to do nothing
And I have talked to others with the same issue
33W / 450W | 8617MiB / 24576MiB
do you have hardware accel gpu scheduling turned on in Win?
No, it's off
COmfy, 24 idle, ~135 generating
I always make sure that's off
hmmm Im not sure why
Same here
Like I said, does it with oobabooga, auto, comfy, kohya, Derrian, and RVC
Just cranks up the clocks for no reason while doing literally nothing
I know, but nearly 5x normal idle is definitely not off by just a little guess haha
are the temps fine?
And my GPU runs much hotter roo
*too
The temps are 14C higher
When idling with comfy open
32C normal idle vs 46c idle in comfy
I keep my pc running 24/7, work on it all day, so generally have something batched more or less, or working on something for it.
For 1 month use I'm at 141 kWh, costing me about 14 bucks.
Normal idle is only a few 100 mhz, but "idle" in comfy is 1800mhz core and 9501 mhz VRAM
God, what I wouldn't give for such cheap power lmao
valid, it's cheap here
It's fucking expensive here
And I also live in an extremely hot area, so hours of dumping 110 watts of unnecessary heat into a room also hurts my electric even more on cooling
I work in my basement, so I enjoy the extra heat, especially with my pc at my feet 😆
yeah me too. but then i turn the AC on and worry about power usage
My mom and I were just hit by a fucking absurd power bill. And now I'm worrying about every little power draw
| 0% 37C P8 25W / 450W | 8608MiB / 24576MiB
and now the fans stopped with comfyui still open
so it must be an issue with your driver maybe?
my gpu isn't idling high
Maybe, but it's happened across 3 GPUs on 2 completely different PC's for over half a year now
could it something related with remote PC access?
I don't access my PC remotely
werent you generating from your phone for a while?
It's python.exe forcing my PC into boost even while reporting it at idle, it only happens when python.exe is open
Yeah, but I haven't in well over a month
even if you're just running the python terminal?
That I haven't tested
nothing special set in nvidia control panel 3D settings?
I'll have to test tomorrow, I am off my PC now
Nope, checked power profiles and preferred performance
First is optimized, and second is normal power scheduling
out of ideas, sorry. Hope you can find the problem as I dont think thats normal for idle
No worries, and no, it's definitely not. My GPU normally idles at 30 watts
I suppose I can switch my GPU to stock VBIOS and see if that helps, but I happened on my 3080 and 3060ti too
only last thing would be to do another DDU wipe of drivers
did a quick test
wattage doesnt seem to be elevated when idle
im still currently at 22/24gb for vram though but that might be an AIT node thing
mine clocks right down
ya nope nvm thats not an ait node thing, im assuming comfy just keeps the model cached in vram (super high usage with sdxl) but that might be by design or with --gpu-only
on the bright side, clocks goes right back down as expected
this is pure python script of kohya with canny edge detection and lite controlnet generation,not novalAI
are you sure its not something else taking advantage of the fact that python is idle to use your GPU as I don't see that behaviour here.
anybody fancy of a precious stone?
how are you monitoring your watts?
with programs like gpu-z or hwinfo on windows for example
How reliable is afterburner in watts measuring?
@high skiff
To the LHS of the green tick is no Python running at all
Green Tick I started ComfyUI
Next Spike is when I ran an Image Generation
@visual glade I am running with smart-memory disabled (orange tick) however the VRAM is no longer releasing at the end of the Image Generation as it used to do in earlier builds (although Noted sperately if I start a new generation you will see it briefly try to clear)
you can also open a command prompt on windows (should work on linux too) and use the Nvidia SMI tool to monitor your GPU. It's part of the driver
nvidia-smi.exe -q -d utilization -l
And that's why I included a readme file 😉
it reads the sensors from the gpu - so it should be accurate
@upbeat summit thank you!!!
you're welcome. compare it with gpu-z or the nvidia smi tool if you are unsure. but they should be the same
i used that command for gb checks but didnt realize that it was also giving info no watts nice
you can monitor it in real time using these parameters: nvidia-smi -q -d power -l
but only on supported GPUs
or just use HWINFO (free edition) and get little graphs 🙂
i got report i am exceeding 119 power percent. 🙂
Im guessing you have set the Power limit in After Burner to 120% then
is it Lovecraft, or rather Giger?
@soft zealot no, 100% and 83C
I think it is power of gpu+cpu probably?
depends where the warning came from,
no warnings, just reading max values
from?
From Afterburner
GPU power only
i will post so you can check. But yes seems gpu only
no need too,
weird it has limit to 100% probably so short, i noticed it is at start of generating, some shock to system 🙂
some cards spike , is it the 4080 or 4090 especially ?? Cant rememeber
i have only 3070
or maybe it was the 30 series
oh I'm reading right now, couldn't get to that part
youu would likely get more attention paid to it if you called it a "dontreadme" file or "ignoreme" ;o)
Anyone have an SDXL installation tutorial for beginners who have only used Easy Diffusion UI? I'm sure it's been asked many times. I'm looking through YouTube right now.
but I think for inpainting for fixing details I'll use old Automatic, as it takes a lot to generated and results are I would say evasive and it is kind of exhausting to set it all. For great changes sort of img2img yes def.
@upbeat elbow i would go with default workflow in ComfUI. It is easy to install and SDXL perform well. What is your GPU btw?
Also don't know how to prompt for inpainting, I guess it is more like a general img2img, or just the part you want to change?
Gtx 2060, and thank you
not sure how well it will works, but for sure better than A1111
Anyway if anybody knows a good workflow for upscalling in SD XL, I apreciatted. I mean I tried some but gave me out of VRAM
How long would you all say you've been working with AI image generators anyway?
not sure, suggesting resolution 1024x768 or other way round. For sure it takes more than previous models.
is this pure Giger?
Trying to combine him with Lovecraft therefore asking 🙂
Anyone had issues with running Base SDXL 1.0 with https://huggingface.co/diffusers/controlnet-depth-sdxl-1.0 in webui?
Seems like results are not taking controlnet into the account
Not sure I need to update something 
you can run controlnet thr diffusers python code
btw the current canny edge detection model can't generate proper images with complicated contour
Okey code it is, thanks
new virtual environment, everyone. very cool
like this
looks a bit disheveled in there
yes 😄
this is the original image, i just detected the canny edge,it looks like have to adjust and modify with params
experiment failed with diffusers canny
lol. nice. I get those wrong so often. from that canny image it looked like some sort of abandoned room that is being overtaken by vegetation. at least that's what my mind saw
it run well on this tornado on grass contour,it's strange maybe prompt should be more task-specific
hey guys, I'm using auto1111 - and i have a veryyyy (at least very annoying) big problem. I have a RTX 3070 (non lhr) and when I try to generate images it takes about 11 seconds for the generation, and additional ~30 seconds just for the VAE decode / idk what else it's doing (I'm dumb).
anyways, anyone knows what could be the reason for this? it wasn't like this until a few days ago and I really can't think of anything I could have done to make it this slow.
-- already tried updating drivers
-- already tried removing and re-enabling xformers
what model? SDXL?
dreamshaper xl
does the vram max out?
oh, it is based on sdxl supposing and performance of A1111 and sdxl models is realy bad
I mean even if it is, it wasn't that slow a few days ago - was like a few seconds at max
also just tried using a different SDXL model and same thing...
i have as well 3070 just supposing LHR and it is pain, so more ppl leaning on A1111 therefore switched to different UI until this is solved.
but it does seem to be a problem with sdxl - when I'm trying a 1.5 based model it's super fast
you experiencing same shit as well?
yes it is problem of A1111 and SDXL
but I could swear it wasn't like that a few days ago
yes, i am now using comfyUI therefore
btw - set COMMANDLINE_ARGS=--no-half-vae --medvram --xformers --api
could the medvram affect the vae decoding time?
:(
not sure but for SDXL it is somehow Must
what if you try lowvram
damnnn I'm not complaining about slow speeds ever again
lemme play with it a bit
yeah spend 25 minutes just to have the vae not work
bc my 16gb vram maxed out (on 1.5)
@uncut fiber you using medvram or lowvram?
lowvram i think will not help you as it is another performance hit.
medvram
But not now, in ComfUI
I am doing almost full HD images super quickly.
didn't they say there's a special UI developed by the SD team?
is the vram even getting used? that's pretty nutty
@patent badger there is feature, making generating even faster for 3xxx and 4xxx
yeah I used comfy for a while but A1111 is just so much better experience for me
They did Stableswarm-UI i believe is it
anyone used / using it?
k I'll test it out now
front end is similar to a1111. not as many extensions. but also not as many headaches. and you can switch tabs to go full noodle with comfy if you ever get the urge
lmao
Just what you will choose. In ComfUI, i can create 1920x1024 in 25secs. Time matter.
If you want a proper UI, use auto111. if you want a fast software with many flexibility, use ComfyUI
for SwarmUI I would wait a few months until it is usable
rowlocks
a1111 was all good until it crapped out.
SwarmUI?
SwarmUI is prinmarily a front end to control multiple instance of A1111 of ComyUI from one pleace.
It's a UI to other UIs nt a magic bullet ;o)
true enough
I just think it's a good thing for some people as it gives them the node option without requiring them
yeah, sure, but the UI is horrible
I recommended a friend SwarmUI when he asked me which would be a user friendly SD UI
not sure why some people are so intimidated by them. but I also understand the casual users that don't want to bother with it
If you 're new and simply want to be able to generate images locally without paying fro an Online service then consider Foocus
https://github.com/lllyasviel/Fooocus
If you want to tiunker, stay away from it
how do I let multiple UIs like auto111, comfy, use the same folders for all the models I have downloaded?
even I'm annoyed that I reinvent all my workflows all the time. There is not even a simple drowndown list for predefined workflows X_x
I use Symlinks
yeah
Foocus is really basic
I sometimes forget how deep I've gone into this stuff. and most of you guys know a lot more than me, lol
I have used it for SDXL
I knock my down like sandcastles all the time
you save your workflows with a disntinct name in a folder called Workflows and open from there, not rocket sceince
but I have the feeling loading an old workflow via drag&drop and modify it is also not efficient
on the one hand I'd agree, but I've also learned a lot of new things using the nodes. I learned quite a bit with a1111. but didn't go nearly as deep
all in all productivity is definitely higher with a1111
I used diffusers for that xD
a lot of the stuff I was doing I understood only so far as how it impacted the images
Hi guys, hope this is the correct channel for this question..
I've downloaded SDXL 1.0 but it won't generate when I try, could it be my GPU is too old/weak? (RTX 2080)
no i think no. What UI? @north sluice
Using Automate1111
it has A1111 issues with SDXL
however, one thing I like on ComfyUI: In diffusers I so often had memory leaks, cause its a hell to do proper memory management in a jupyter notebook environment. In ComyUI it works really well how only models are loaded I currently need and how everything is cleaned up in memory
Aha !
well im using an even older 1080ti without any issues
Glad to hear, what UI you guys using ?
I like how quickly it loads. well how quickly it will load when I finish reinstalling the virtual environment
comfyui , SDXL1 support in A1111 is still I believe hit 'n'miss.
ComfyUI is a steeper learning curve but glad I switched
Hmm I'll look into it, thanks !
Photoshop, no joke
lots of people trying it out
but as I only posted a few minutes ago
I have the photoshop plugin or whatever, never actually used it though
There are several of those
@north sluice Just try stay with default UI for some time, there are more complicated and bit harder to understand them.
default Comfy you mean ?
Alkaid.art/ImageCreator, Alpaca (is new), Gyre AI which i heard about from a user days ago and then there is Firefly, generative fill which is basically based on FF and DALL E plugin etc
how is fooocus? in terms of results
it does the work for you
not bad results as I understand it
but also not as much control
@north sluice default comfyUI workflow
Thanks will keep in mind
maybe start with that, but one thing I've learned is everyone has their own version of the truth when it comes to comfy setups
one thing most people would agree on is don't start installing all the node packs all at once. look them over, decide what interests you, install as necessary. but don't install a whole stack of them all at once unless you're feeling very ambitious
True
I installed someone elses workflow before deinstalling this and it was too much lol
This should be happy picture.....
I'm weird so I actually liked noodling right off the bat
but I guess that's not the case for a lot of people
People dont have the same workflows and one should end up having one based on his needs
Not what others have
yes. it's fine to emulate and use what other people do. I don't think there's a right or wrong way. but I'd suggest learning how the stuff works on your own as well. so many people asking for workflows, lol
I like to make really impractical things just to see what happens and then abandon them to do something else equally impractical
but that's just me
and then theres me, I leave my workflow in my images but if you do decide to blow your mind make sure you have full read and inwardlydigested this message from the sponsors before asking any bloody questions!!!
Pretty similar to art workflows
With all the softwares
I always leave my workflow in images. but I'm fairly certain people look at them and move on, lol
Is there way to update nodes? If some new version i mean, by manager?
i got portable only version
thisd all makes sense to me lol
pretty sure that wouldn't change the git pull. but do what works for you
going to try it
I only use it as a last resort option though. sometimes for whatever reason the manager goofs and doesn't install something quite right
Generating the femcel ( thought is is not SDXL )
I think i gonna try SDXL again and see if it will still continue my 30 minutes bicycle ride
you guy can't put SD1.5 LORA to SDXL right?
cats version 🙂
well you can. but you probably shouldn't
figured out a weird approach with the canny 1.5 model and sdxl
used it to make weird noise nonsense with an xl model. then used that to render on
prompt:a woman, close up, detailed, beautiful, street photography, photorealistic, detailed, Kodak ektar 100, natural, candid shot.the diffusers/controlnet-canny-sdxl-1.0-small runs faster than the previous unet full attension fine-tuning model
is there a on/off switch node for comfy?
comfyroll custom nodes has logic switch nodes
you can right click and deactivate
but yeah, also on/off nodes that take boolean input. and then you can customize nodes with on off switches if you feel ambitious.
or bypass them ctrl+b i think
nope can't do
@uncut fiber do you have the refiner extension on auto1111 by any chance?
i have but not activated.
it's weird, when messing with it a bit I cut my VAE decoding time by like 60%
actually nvm I'm stupid
many of workflow creators claims they next version will be without it.
Yes it is 5GB model is another 6GB it is large
you have 3070? then in Comfy, there is big boost thing, making it working even faster.
I can send you it in image, just using very basic layout. @patent badger
well it beats up what you're doing, and no one really knows how it works, lol
ask someone how to set up the refiner prompt
literally no answer out there
you can only set number of steps in A1111 UI for refiner extension. Not any special prompt. Just 10 steps default.
ahhh, a1111
you would usually use same prompt as for base model
refiner is basically an image2image step
did anyone try different prompt for refiner?
supposing it is that language model and supported is refiner, isnt it that way?
I just found the sd ultinate upscaler node has an interesting 'dirty' effect when used with a value of 1 upscaling (so not upscaling at all) don't know if it is a bug or a feature
the refiner is only using CLIP-G and not CLIP-L. So its text encoding input is slightly different than for base
don't know what you mean
i will make screenshot. It is in Sytan 1st workflow
that's what I've been doing. but then what about loras and other things. it's just ambiguous to me. I play around with it and make educated guesses
ah, in Sytans workflow there are different prompts for CLIP-L and CLIP-G
you can mess around a lot in SD, trying many different things, using different prompts, different models, switching models or prompts during generation and all that stuff
I thought refiner didn't even use 2 clip models
yes, refiner is using only clip-g
just got into SDXL today...Loving how far you can push the resoluion.
which is called "linguistic prompt" in Sytans workflow
I've just been doing things like separating L and G for base, then combining them for refiner
the thing is: the "correct" way of using it is using ONE prompt for clip-l and clip-g and the same for refiner
well sometimes just 2 positives, but send the same negative to all 3
where "correct" means the way SDXL was trained and developed.
yes. "correct" way is using the same text in "linguistic" as in "supporting"
but as said, you can mess around in SD and do things differently. Just play around with it if you want
also, I think a lot of people are looking for the magic formula when there really isn't one necessarily
some things obviously work out better under normal circumstances
I think it is reason why workflow creators claimed next time without it 🙂
and you drop refiner?
the refiner is always just optional
Sytan and another one i know but dont know name
it is not necessarily improving your image
I don't think there's a united team of workflow creators all with the same mindset
and dropping it makes things easier for sure (in particular if you use different checkpoint models or loras)
i mean workflows creators, like many individuals, not as groups
I need to work on getting images to come together completely without it
the only reason I'm using auto1111 is the easier img2img and inpainting UI - it's my main usage anyways, so there is a huge benefit by using auto1111, anyways, I downloaded this "tiled vae" extension, and the vae decoding is basically immediately now. like 0-2 seconds at max, with almost identical results (not better not worse, just a tiny tiny bit different)
I would just always create two images: base and refined, and then decide for the better one
I save way too many steps of my workflow
@uncut fiber one of them is without the tiled vae, one of them is with it. guess which one is which😂
This is how my Prompt Createion gets split out and wrapped insid e Styles and wheat evenetually ends up where
currently trying to figure out these stupid custom nodes and broke something, lol
get a little something wrong with the node mapping and you won't have a fun time
i hardly spot difference, not sure which is which honestly
tired of nodes I want not existing so gotta make my own
and spend five hours making what it'd take some people in here 15 minutes to do
also tried zooming in and try to see if there is any difference in quality, tbh after testing like 3 different prompts, there is literally 0 difference
without using the VAE tile
with the VAE tile
what is your card? 2080 or 3070. I forgot.
hmmmm
DIdn't you switch the screenshots ?
Event TiledVAE is saying that there is no point tiling with the size you're asking for
lol
3070
tbh I tried testing some different sizes in it just auto-disabled so I counted it as turned off
I can try again with the option turned off😂 one sec
@slim wren first generation without the extension, second one with it
~14s for latent for both (rtx 3070)
+~25 seconds for vae
+~2 seconds for vae with tiling
Is it possible to run SDXL locally on AMD 6600XT (8GB)?
yes, but it still be extremely slow, like 20 minutes per gen
because amd needs 2x vram compared to nvidia so you need 16gb
from sdxl release: Linux users are also able to use a compatible AMD card with 16GB VRAM.
damn, part of me was hoping that the latest iterations will be also aiming to reduce the system requirments and optimizing for larger variety of consumer tech. What do you suggest as best alternative of usage away from my own PC, but still safe in terms of privacy?
guyssss I need sdxl controlnet tilessss. images are just so low quality (when using subject loras) and I can't keep upscaling them in sd1.5
I would try it regardless and see the speeds, I am using runpod right now but its kind of expensive
gpu market right now is gonna get even worse as AI demand increases
and the average consumer wont be able to upgrade for a few years
I put $25 on runpod and I get get like 54 hours with a 3090
yeaah, that is bit too much for me, I am currently using Mage Free account that uses Web GUI and runs SDXL, but was hoping my specs are enough for having under one minute creations on latest SDXL or free cloud option with some anonymity enabled.
I run a 1080Ti that cost me <£200 a few months ago (with fitted waterblock plus the OEM cooler) and that can generate standard sized 1024 x 1024 images using SDXL models in Comfyui workflows in 50-60 seconds.
yeah, that's the Nvidia bias 🙂
ah you're an AMD person . My acommiserations ;o)
haha, yeah poor AMD again, constantly beaten in the game 🙂
how many steps for 60 seconds?
keep the AMD for gaming and buy a 1080Ti for platyng with Stable Diffusion. Sure its not the latest gen but it meets your <60s image generation criteria and theyre relatively inexpensive on the pre loved market
I srick at 25 steps for everything by default
20/25 steps does for 30 seconds in amd last year gpu
was doing 25/30 at 36s or something
well thats nice isnt it
yea it's cool
it cost more cuz it was the whole covid thing at the time but they're cheap now
anyone know if easy diffusion supports controlnet?
wonders which of us is being the most sarcastic ;o)
wym
sigh Never mind, moving on out ;o)
Trying to reinstall a1111 and keep getting this error:
ERROR: Could not find a version that satisfies the requirement tb-nightly (from gfpgan) (from versions: none)
ERROR: No matching distribution found for tb-nightly
anyone have any idea?
How you reinstall? Clean install?
hands is hard
oh I have no compalinst about the hands, they look to have the right number of fingers erc.
They just dont appear to match the rest of the body lol
Mickey mouse gloves 😄
how long does it take you to generate that image tho
deosnt he only have 3 fingers?
12 years
upscaled to that size? around 120-130 seconds
Less time than it takes to make a cup of coffee or take a dump ;o)
cool
for future people coming across this problem.
this is how to solve it:
Focus on the error "No matching distribution found for tb-nightly". This error means that there is no corresponding "tb-nightly" dependency package in our pip source.
View the configuration of pip: pip config list, see the configuration as follows:
global.index-url='https://pypi.tuna.tsinghua.edu.cn/simple'
This shows that the tb-nightly package is missing from the pip source of Tsinghua University. Then let's change the source of Ali and use the following command:
pip config set global.index-url https://mirrors.aliyun.com/pypi/simple
Check it out again: pip config list, the configuration has become Ali's address:
global.index-url='https://mirrors.aliyun.com/pypi/simple'。
Re-execute the installation: ./webui.sh
It is pretty fantastic... AI art has come a long way in the last year for sure.
why the fascination over how long it takes?
Speed isnt everything.
A Mini will get you from A to B as well as a Ferrari .
and yes I am fully cogniscent of the fact I'm not running the worlds fastest GPU . So what ?
Tortoise & Hare 🙂
(apologiers the whole speed is good is a bugbear of mine lol)
longer it takes one appreciates it more
That's actually pretty awesome considering the tech you are using. That just proves this process is improving a lot.
sorry mate
rest of the system is built around 5600X and 64Gb RAM.
I've never been a gamer per se. Originally I was running an old 980Ti in here , the 1080ti was an upgarde to get 5Gb more VRAM
Mine all take between 60 and 90 seconds upscaled to roughly 4k ballpark depending an chosen resolution... I prefer a greater level of control over speed and I know you do to Mr. Woof... great workflow
oh and with the water coolong GPU temps never go above 38c when generating inages lol
I literally see this in every thread. People obsessed with it/s
I would love it/s lol
Meanwhile back in the real world is s/it ;o)
whats a good upscaler?
Haha
wow Mine usually get upto around 65c when generating.... But hey cooling an i9 and a 4090 isn't easy and there is no AC down here... Its an oven... Especially with my wife's pc with similar specs and my dual xeon server running 24/7
dont think anyone is obsessed i was just asking if it was normal cuz someone said amd doesnt work
Im not using AMD either lol
amd CPU should be fine... Its AMD GPUs that seem to be an issue
if you aren't using CPU to generate that is
yea im running amd gpu
there's the rub
I'm using AMD
can you train on it?
Yup
it was failing on me with kohya train_network
I would rather poke my own eyes out with hot needles than run on CPU only lol
Lora, haven't tried dreambooth full model
I've been getting pretty good results with my setup and workflow.... check this out
Which might need more VRAM
how do you do that?
ya the only way I could see that working is well never.... unless nvidia starts making their own consumer CPUs and get rid of the need for GPUs... that would be great
wonder how a ThreadRipper would do ?
lots of practice
that might do alright but still slow compared to GPU... structure isn't made for it.
Which card do you have, and what was the error... Might just need some different settings
6800, was giving size mismatch after loading the model and saying Missing key(s) in state_dict: "down_blocks.0.attentions.0.norm.weight",
@spring fulcrum dio you klike my idle temps 🙂
That is awesome... My idle temps are sitting right at 44c right now.... when absolutely idle they are about 33c
I have the 6800xt.... You should be able to get it working. I used train_unet_only flag in extra options, disable xformers, enable the other memory one, I think flash memory attention or something, I don't have it open ATM. Use adafactor optimizer, with constant learning, and LR of 2
adafactor is better on VRAM
thanks
I did bf16 mixed precision, but fp16 should also work
I may not have the fastest GPU in the world but it may possibly be the least stressed GPU in the worl lol
This si about about 5 or 6 minutes into a batch run (whilst foing other stuff such as "work" lol
I wish I could keep my card that cool it is really way too hot in this room for high temps to be coming from my setup
And if you're training sdxl, you'll want the res at 1024x1024, default is 512
sdxl seems almost perfect for watch dial Roman or Classical numbers.
@fair stag somebody yesterday posted resolution on which it was trained. Not just and only 1024x1024
Perfect eyes on the close up image.... Great hands on the zoomed out image
I haven't played around with other res, but I think training at 512 wouldn't be good
Simply because the base model isn't good at producing it
That might be a good thing to try, if 1024x1024 gives oom
also helps my ambients arent too high at aroun 22c
my ambient temp is about 30c
apple-punk, i like that anthene 🙂
Do I need to duplicate my SD checkpoints from auto1111 folders to comfyUI folders?
cant comfyUI just take the models from the auto1111 checkpoint folder
i think it is not NEEDED :), and it is described on github comfUI page
nope way to warm for me lol
crazyy good, is there anywhere i can learn to make images as good as yours?
If you use comfyui you can just drag and drop the image right into your browser and it should load up the exact workflow
What node/node pack can scale by height? It has one for width, just not height. As i'm trying to regenerate it, but wider
Take a look at this from Deerfu
weill upsacale or downscale to the lntghth given based on an input images longest side
I am certain
'nuff said
GPU z, hardware info 64, and afterburner. I am able to see the power draw from all three of my AX pin connectors, as well as my PCIe Lane
I have tested it extensively by killing every process on my computer, and the only point in which my GPU clocks down to base idle clocks is once I close out of command line as a whole
As I've said, it's been a problem for about half a year now
Or at least, I've known of it for about a half a year
most ofdd, has anyone else said theyre seeing thesame pattern of behaviour?
I talked to a few other people who said that they were having this behavior in my research group, but it seems to be a minuscular amount of people
Figures, it only happens to the person who lives in a region that is extremely hot and has exceptionally high electricity rates lol
do you have anything like nvidia instant replay or whatever its called running?
fortunatelky I dont live in a hot part of the world (as you may have seen my Ambient & GPU temps are quite cool lol #✨|sdxl message)
Electric is expensive everywhere.
For reference Im paying
Standard unit rate 7.513 p per kWh (approx 0.101USD /kWh)
Standing charge 29.106p per day (approx 0.369 USD /Day)
I also think it probably costs more to keep my 300l (80 US Gallon) aquarium at a constant 26.5c/79.7f in ambents of 18-22c /65-72f than it costs to run my GPU although maybe I should actually calculate that one day and scare myself lol
I live in the senoran desert. My GPU is a little heater. And as for the comments on resolution earlier, you can adjust from 1024x1024 if you maintain specific aspect a ratio such as 1152x896.
Exact pixel count is pretty important I’ve seen.
Aye. But i don't want it's side, i want it to scale based on height to retain height, but "outpaint it" to be wider by regenerating the entire image since we don't have controlnet outpaint for SDXL yet.
Use the Gimp and reimport
or use this which I believe is core COmfyUI
Unfortunately, our electric prices are considerably higher than that 
really ?? And yet I've seen seevral NA Youtubers commenting on that in their opionion prices over this side of the puddle were higher
Our current plan is a 24-hour fixed rate, and it is $0.43/kwh
Or, we could switch over to a day night cycle plan, where our night will be $0.26, an hour day will be $0.68
@high skiff whats the current status of your refund?
I escalated it to a supervisor, called her out on her bullshit, proved her wrong through her own company's emails, and forced her to comply because somebody above her told me improper information in my favor. I have a scheduled call with her later today to handle a PayPal personal payout rather than an actual refund
theres an interesting tangential thought given not all US customary Units are Identical to UK Imperial measurements (eg a US Gallon is smaller than a UK Gallon) . areis a us kW/h the same as a UK kW/h
Hmmm
we got 2 tier charging here. 10c /kwh for the basic usage, than anything over the threshold is 15c/kwh. all my appliances eat the basic rate so i count gpu at 15c
It's a kilowatt, it's 1,000 w
I guess this lies then
https://www.energysage.com/local-data/electricity-cost/
Electricity prices vary greatly across different states in the US. Read our article to find out how much people in your state are paying on average.
the US uses metric in some cases, just like the UK uses imperial in some cases. a metric gallon is more of a french gallon aint it?
what would imperial version of kwh be
theyre also both called gallons but yours is only 3.78 litres whereas ours oare 4.54 lites (meaning our pints are bigger as well lol)
this is our rate if we switched to hourly, its actually higher than I remember
true
oof
thats so much
yeah, my mom and I are getting taken for all we have
ever thought about solar? with those prices it would pay off in a few years
we aren't even living comfortable, and our electric bill is almost $500 in a decently small house
yes, but thats somebody my mom can't afford at the moment, so I will be looking into a custom reclaimed solar array when I get a job
wait, a gallon is different across countries?
isnt a unit meant to be constant?
it breaks the fundamental of calling it a unit
no, they are different units with the same name, its hard to explain
I think ton and tonne are different as well IIRC
500?
thats too costly if considered in my country, like really costly.
idk abt the electricity bills in the us
Im a knob, those figures were my Gas Rates not my Electric rates!!!
so that equivalent to appros US$0.37 per kWH with a approx US$0.66 standing charge per day
ok, so not too far off from us
Our flat rate through the whole day is $0.42, or we can do the 28/65
ones a US gallon, the others a UK gallon / Both are defined against the litre
dude, even $0.37/hr is too costly for electricity, isnt it $0.07/kwh if you choose to pay for consumption?
no lmao
well I didnt know that
--
Way back - at the time we all lived together - we had used the Queen Anne's gallon of 3.785l to measure wine. We also had different volumes and names to measure both beer and grain. When we realised that this was silly, in 1824, the UK chose a single imperial term and lumped together all three measurements, picking a roughly-average volume and calling it a gallon. American colonists, though, stuck to tradition and kept just the Queen Anne's volume for their own gallon definition.
https://www.thecalculatorsite.com/articles/units/us-gallons-imperial-gallons.php
Find out the reasons why the US gallon is 20% smaller than its imperial cousin
I wish we were still in 1990 with rates like $0.07kw/h
instead, my mom and I are being shook down like nerds by a school bully for lunch money
Mind you wehn comparing cost of living its not as straightforward as compationg costs directly.
Average Wages etc also need to be taken into account.
Strictly speaking for a true comparison it should be the cost of an item as a percentage of avearge wage (or some such metric)
yeah
average wages being accounted for i think drives costs up. its what i am seeing here in vancouver region. minimum wage goes up and increases the average wage. landlords and realtors all account for that and drive the cost up calculated from what they think a full time worker would make
thats exactly how economics works
raising the minimum wage never helps, just closes the middle class gap to the poverty floor
I liked Vancouver when I vistied there back in 85
are the sdxl CN models officially released by SAI
its a pretty obvious theory. BC has the highest minimum wage in the continent and the highest rent prices. https://twitter.com/j_mcelroy/status/1691663491135099095
travvelled across the contry bu train to Toronto stopping off en route.
Local breweries were on strike so could only drink imported beers and whilst I was in Toronto Air India Flight 182 got blown up mid atlantic
our minimum wage here is basically $16.50
oh damn, CA way back in 85, what was the population like?
lol to prevent scraping i guess twitter has disabled video embeds now. content delivery is getting so shitty
Twitter is dying anyways
sont you men "X" ;o)
I hate to say it, but threads is gonna take over, one they fix a couple issues and default to dark mode
vancouver was huge in 85. i think 86 is when the world's EXPO was there
literally the world's fair
Elon is too much of a fucking joke for me to call his little shit baby site by its code name lmao
yes that was 86, they were building stuff ready for it when I was there
notice even he cant get x.com lol
yeah
hhe's got it. it redirects to twitter
I think people forget that Elon has never been smart, he has done like nothing
bugger
i think they're using the old domain mainly for legacy support
i dont think so, as the controversy kings wouldnt move there instantly and even famous celebs posting on X wouldn't change
landing rockets is huge but that wasn't him. engineering teams under his employement
well yeah, X will stay around for the radical biggots until they all die off and X fizzles out in a $50B whimper
They can't even manage to do that consistently for like more than 3 times in a row lol
their newest test lasted for what, 1 minute in air?
Japanese is the second largest active group on X,lol..
what do you mean? they've been landing rockets for years
and also caused like $75M damages to their take off site, while also damaging infrastructure for miles
the last hover test was for starship booster iirc. that thing is bigger than any first stage thats ever been built
lol yeah that was epic
yeah, and it was broken on launch
they made a big booster using a bunch of impromperly made small boosters
Some analog photography images made with Aether Real - a SDXL model by @icy brook
global market and supply chain,don't forget manufactory asks for more parts
where is Aether real out?
oh, never knew that
Neat! So it will regenerate OG, but add more to left and right? As currently now, the wider just squishes top and bottom by the looks of it
you have to ask joachim about that
do you know style?
no that's not how the engineering on this beast works. it uses all new types of engines
hate elon sure, but spacex is awesome and doing it
random aside:
I rmeber as a 5 year old child being allowed to stay up late at my grandparents and watch the Eagle land on the moon
SpaceX is nearly as big of a loss of cash flow as X, and has just as fake and misleading promises as Tesla
no idea, not used it. just found it
elon's an idiot and you can be assured that he's just doing busy work over there, if anything
spacex is designed to be a cash eater. the investors there want elysium
I am not even talking about Elon, SpaceX is also another failing company
i dont see spacex failing. literally going to the moon
their strategy is outside of profits. it's a big big deal
they lose like $6B a year, and have made nearly no successful trips other than putting some satelites in the atmosphere (and sometimes still exploding), in like 2 decades
some sattelites? It is almost ring
also, their numbers they stated for the projected growth are impossible, which is interesting
$6b a year is a drop in the bucket compared to the profits heavy lift systems will bring them
thats all speculation
wait 6b like 9 or 12 zeroes 😄
these are the voyages of the starship spacex
You are huffing too much of their promises without looking at the numbers lol
Nice, thanks:P It did something, but not outpaint sadly
i wouldn't consider $6B loss a big loss considering its valuation
OpenOutpaint?
Elon is the same guy that said we would already have a colony of humans on mars by today on multiple occasions lol
Yet they can't even get a rocket out of low orbit
pennies for them really
where do you think they are getting money?
european billions are 1000 x more
I will try it 
yeah exactly, the new age startups lose billions, this isnt very big for spacex
the falcon can insert into high orbit. maybe you're huffing to much anti elon sauce
where do you think the ISS is stationed?
oooo, high earth orbit, that is practically on the surface of mars a year ago when Elon musk predicted
India on rise
wait,
@polar epoch i tried it only with A1111
Or not. As comfy is way way lighter on vram than automatic's, and openoutpaint is an extension of automatic, i can't use it as i plan to make it 1080p/1440p ultrawide.
lets hope their lander touches down softer this time
I remember that lmao
How are the CHinese & Indians doing these days anyways?
I am just wondering how long it will take for Elon musk to go away for life for the sheer dozens of times he has lied to investors and consumers
Only thing I can think of that hes made properly is Tesla's, and even that is debatable
everyone wonders what Musk is up too but there are otheres.............
yeah, there are smart people
that started by converting a Lotus lol
then there is Elon lol
exactly
chinese are getting a space station up there bigger than the iss
by a CEO before Elon
the govt is shit, they are pro-religious political party
thye've got a massive heavy lift campaign going on and are launching huge modules
and he bought in to it rather than createdit
I think people forget that Elon got rich off of being fired from PayPal
paypal bought x.com so they had no competition. they named elon a co-founder. hardly "fired"
tax payers lol..
that's a huge win
thats not what i would be concerned about, if they get their hands on GPUs, then i am worried
you think they aren't producing models? they are
and the tax is also is too high
they are, but i am talking about semiconductors
China had hard time cracking semiconductors
it's more like geopolitical
wonder how effificent a GPU running in a vacuum at sub zero temps is??
you need to be precise, so i can answer
wait, are you talking abt superconductors
@polar epoch yes i forgot i am in SDXL. But for A1111 it is miracle. You can outpaint in it very large image, not limited by sizes even it is A1111 1.5 or similar models
i often wonder about supercondictive transistors. isn't resistence required to prevent the current from passing throuhg the circuit?
all bits are 1 with no resistence right?
i dont know
That's why i use stable diffusion infinity. Largest canvas i made there was 5000x5000 something, and it barely touches my ram and video memory :P
I look forward to BYD coming over to America more and pushes Tesla out of the US market
does BYD have auto-driving?
not that I know of, and neither does Tesla-
Tesla atleast has some kinda auto-driving
but thats not the main thing, but Tesla is very hyped
it has an "auto" pilot of which has caused several crashes
They are far behind their competitors by a lot in self driving, its kinda sad
so i dont think its gonna fall down anytime soom
Teslas FSD is a joke, and a sham
i think it's ready and good to go. just a bunch of red tape in the way
Tesla is only at Level 2 Autonomy
safer than any human on the road imo
bruh
seirous. people suck at driving. fucking maniacs out there
oh my god, the amount of huffing in here is insane
i dont care if its tesla self driving, apple, toyota, whoevers self driving. human drivers are just dumb
lets get them off the roads
congestion? it's all because of dumbass drivers. roads can support all the traffic we throw at them until the human element is in play
rich ppl usually do not be a driver,it's a very complicated situation of electric car development and the gasoline car
fair enough, but Tesla is nowhere near good enough to do that while they are still causing car accidents that are avoidable by humans with basic perception skills
red tape is the only thing preventing deployement of these systems really
Thats funny, cause Waymo is already at Level 4 autonomy and they need 0 human monitoring for their steering wheel and have been running for years 😅
no I was just thinking out loud
it's a niche market,food, close,resident,the last is automobile,climate change is another big issue
granted, Waymo is still far off from what we need, but they are leagues past Tesla FSD
only in what? 3 or 4 major cities? red tape
does google sell waymos to everyoen?
The problem with waymo is in order to be way better than tesla, which they are, they need a lot more data than tesla
but I mean, teslas are still getting into car accidents when being summoned, and slamming on breaks for no reason in FSD mode, which has caused several accidents
i remember when waymo first hit the scene and i said to myself "that design won't last long"
one of those "wtf where they thinking" moments
their new model is the "Waymo one!" trying to pretend that thing didn't happen
The golden melon graces us with its presence.
have u ever heard of Faraday Future
yeah i think thye're ugoh too
bit of a joke imo
their marketing hype. it's an all ability car with hyper+
all-hyper hyper+ systems
they're going to make people take electric cars less serious. it's like if homer simpson made a car
Self driving without human intervention is still very much an unsolved problem. It might be barely capable of some highways or in highly documented urban areas, but no one has been able to demonstrate a system that is effective given arbitrary roads. Especially poorly maintained roads which are unfortunately way too common.
The whole thing with SD suddenly adding extra legs or fingers? Self driving cars have their own version of that problem, except they see false road signs or miss signs that are actually there.
It is getting better, but the technology isn't there yet. At best, we might soon get cars that let a driver take a nap while on roads that the car is capable of like well maintained highways, then wake the driver up when entering secondary roads.
Which would frankly revolutionize things like long-haul trucking, but is a long way from the hype 7-8 years ago that human controlled cars would be gone in the next five years.
just an engineering problem really
hello! i'm getting an error from my own trained sdxl model, can anyone help out here?
Hey mass is that aether real model public yet? Looks amazing!
bad idea to use ai for things that allow zero mistakes. much better to use it for things that allow 10% error rate as long as ai saves 15% time.
Thank you! Glad you like the images. I'm currently working on and testing @icy brook's model. It's not publicly available yet.
Nice, I’m looking forward to playin with it
is there a node to allow you using local LLMs to generate prompts in ComyUI?
At this point in time is it reliant on a high positive and negative to get a good output in regards to texture?
Am i missing something? Wanna make a portrait image of a bunny holding a cheese, but the geneation makes a annoyingly tiny one instead, Using a 1080x1920 white image as the img to img
Didn’t see it in scrollback… did you get an answer to this?
@polar epoch 1080 is bad idea. not divideable by 16, try 1088 or 1024
Why would you use llm in comfyui? You could just use it seperate
anyone have a decent easy to adjust Comfy workflow? There really are very few that get traction on civtai
ping?
oh, no
its not out
Bummer, thanks!
What do you mean easy to adjust? Like just a simple workflow with some knobs and a output?
Like something where I can just easily click to change models or use/dont use refiner/upscaler/img2img
but I'd take anything people like to test out really
I mean there’s plenty of workflows that do that on civit. Sarge, sdxl ultimate to name a couple
Searge doesnt even have a knob to disable refiner and multiple other things
and I oom hard with it
The magic for me was learning that ctrl-b bypasses nodes
tho currently instead I get a way more bizare vram oom with sarge
Requested : 3.75 MiB
Device limit : 23.99 GiB
Free (according to CUDA): 14.62 GiB```
So on those big complex ones you can just ctrl-b on the retailers and upscalers etc and then just drag out a single preview from the base or base+refiner
And it makes them a little easier to work with because you’re not trying to understand a giant 50 node workflow
getting pretty disappointed that stability decided that comfy is the future and that that it'll get enough momentum because of it to become the standard
I don’t think that’s true?
nothing is mandatory, and it running on background, SwarmUI will be official front end
Stability said nothing of the sort
comfy should be the standard, node based is absolutely based
how is it not true? Didn't the guy behind Comfy had access early while automatic didn't which made them ahead + is hired and chosen by stability thus actually gets funds to work on it
I am honestly not sold nodes as the best workflow
while automatic didn't
did you read this from the reddit thread
this is how fast misinformation is spread lmfao
and people are already using Comfy because it's ahead due to stability picking it even when they dislike the workflow which means things will get built on top of it because it's head
Well it’s also the most flexible, so it kinda is what you’d want to build on top of
no from here mostly but I am asking is it not true?
SAI have said that they worked with the big bois from the very start with sdxl: comfy, a1, kohya
is the Comfy guy not hired by Stability and paid to work on Comfy?
a1 didnt care to make an updated workflow as much as comfy did
should I add more LoRAs? make it a 5 stack or a 10 stack?
the stability team definitely pushed Comfy a lot in the launches and said that's what they prefer to use and fund
yea is there something wrong with that lol
Is comfy funded by SAI? I was actually looking for a tip jar cause I’d love to kick in for all the work
I think they're allowed to have preferences
Well, when you have a preferred workflow, and one platform supports that, and another platform won't update to allow that....what would you do?
not wrong, but as I said I'm disappointed we are going to get stuck with it because of it since it's way less pleasant to work with
That's a developers problem, not a stability problem
i dont see how a1 is affected by comfy getting more popular
Get mad at A1111
they can obviously make decisions by their preferences, but I can be personally less pleased for myself when they meet my needs way worse
when I first downloaded a1111 I pretty much assumed that it was the official UI for stable diffusion
so they had the ball in hand
I mean isn't a111 doing it for free basically why Comfy is getting funded by stability?
if that's not true then sure it's just worse vs better development
I hope he is getting funded
people that make useful things that are used by a bunch of people should get compensated
I won't make any official statements as I don't know, but I highly doubt the A1111 dev is doing all that work for free
The lead developer of Comfy was hired to Stability
https://github.com/Stability-AI/StableSwarmUI/blob/master/docs/Motivations.md
My first UI was InvokeAI. I then moved to Auto1111. I now use Comfy and Fooocus UI.
I still think that Invoke has the most user friendly UI yet.
everyone in the scene has always been doing it for free, thats kinda what foss is
just because someone gets hired on doesnt mean quality loses or something
I think that a1111 just got bogged down by two many people or something
Stable Swarm is not Comfy. It uses Comfy
yes.. how does that change the quoted statement?
tenoke, what's your issue?
Rather than them reaching out (I believe since it is opensource) they are just using it.
again it's not an issue. Just personally I don't enjoy Comfy and personally it is worse for me that it is on its way to becoming the standard because stability chose it
since snese? which should I use there?
if they pick one UI, and that UI is head then others work on top of them and make extensions/tooling for them before anything else
thats the thing, its fine to have preferences for one or the other but how does comfy getting more popular hurt you or a1
Just using it?
They literally got comfydev on the payroll
making extensions and implementing code for a1111 is no different now than it was before
A ton of extensions were only for a111 before since it was the most popular. Now they are going to be on Comfy and not a111 or something else I actually like working with
Yeah that's the entire underlying issue.
A1111 doesn't want to change to support, or at least they haven't, to fully support the workflow of SDXL.
That's entirely an A1111 issue, and zero to do with Stability
Then I'm wrong and should've had better wording.
Open source code is easy to port usually
ya its all open source so anyone is free to create new extensions
in theory sure. In practice were all extensions ported for the 3rd most popular UI before? not really
Again, developer problems
unfortunately the world does not cater to any of us
Anyone can port an extension.
This has only been around for barely a year. Confirmation bias is a bitch
like is there even stuff like deforum or roop on Comfy now for example?
yes
Hi, has anyone here finetuned the SDXL model with Kohya_ss gui?
Does it run well?
DUCK Howard?
anyway, rather than be upset with comfy or with stability, maybe focus your frustration on the a1111 developers for dropping the ball
because they had the lead by a huge margin
and goofed
as of 3 days ago the issue on their repo says no way to install deforum and no repo shows up https://github.com/comfyanonymous/ComfyUI/issues/1134
Not deforum but tools like deforum yes. Roop yes
A1111 could've switched to better architecture long ago but voldy argued and knew better
No one stopping anyone from using automatic. Judging from what's on civit, it's what most use still.
Not a lot of comfy meta data on civit
again, cutting edge stuff mostly get done for the most popular one and there's momentum where the next person builds on top of it. Yeh you can use a less popular UI but the less popular it is the less support it will have for newer stuff
yes and lot of users went comfy just temporary until SDXL will work with A1111
Comfy is cutting edge and wasn't popular at first
SDXL doesn’t work with A1111? What? That’s what I started with like 2 weeks ago
it's cutting edge and ahead in part because that's the one stability is paying to be developed full time
Was there a regression?
a1111 requires more vram than comfy to run it
A ton of the bleeding cutting edge stuff comes out for a scripted interface most of the time
comfy is lean which helps when using big xl models
This is like, how software eng works? The closer you are to “the metal” the faster you can release
Then it gets ported by users of different projects
it kind of works with a111 but there's even more memory leaks, problems with stuff like refiner or more complex workflows for now
There is no regression, A1111 does not allow for splitting of clip, as is a large underlying thing behind SDXL
you're so far off base, lol
That's an A1111 issue, not an sdxl issue
in what way?
yes, and most of the nodes are made by people for literally no money, or maybe a nominal amount
same for workflows
people getting some donations from people that appreciate them
A1111 has to gut his entire pipeline to introduce multiple clip support I think. Why it's taking him so long
but beyond that not like they're on payroll