quasi viper
I'm just testing out immich now hoping I can make it work for my use case.
For right now I'm just trying to get some info on how the videos are handled. What is purpose of the encoded_videos folder? Is that like a temp folder where videos go before they are transcoded?
Is there anyway to keep an original version of the video in the app as well as a transcoded version for viewing?
midnight bobcat
Hi! The encoded_videos folder is where transcoded videos are stored. Transcodes are used for viewing on web and mobile, but we always keep the originals untouched.
You can also customize the policy for which videos get transcoded in the admin settings. If a video isn’t transcoded, the original is shown for viewing.
quasi viper
Hi! The encoded_videos folder is where transcoded videos are stored. Transcodes ...
so in the main images folder, that's where the original files are stored?
midnight bobcat
yep, we store original photos and videos in the library folder
and then upload is where uploaded files are temporarily stored until they're migrated to the right folder.
thumbs stores generated images (small thumbnails, medium-size preview images and thumbhashes that are shown as placeholders until a thumbnail loads).
quasi viper
yep, we store original photos and videos in the library folder
Ok, so when you access the file via the web browser you'll see the "encoded_video", but when you click download, you'll get the full quality video?
astral mason
Yup. You also might get the original in the web browser depending on what codec the video is using and what settings you have set regarding transcode options.
quasi viper
ok cool. That makes sense. So I can change my transcode version back to something reasonable lol
I have it set to original, but that's not necessary as originals are maintained
do the transocode settings apply to live photos as well?
quasi viper
and those are stored right alongside the original file, i.e. IMG_01010.JPG/HEIC & IMG_01010.mov
astral mason
So we are talking about originals vs generated content.
Originals include both parts of live photos, which are named like this, yes:
quasi viper
originals
astral mason
IMG_01010.mov is an "original" and will have an associated file in encoded_video/id.mov if it needs to be transcoded based on the settings, etc.
All originals are in library/. And all of those originals will have two thumbnails in thumbs/. And some of the originals (that are videos) will have an encoded video in encoded_videos/.
quasi viper
gotcha, just making sure I understand things properly for testing this external folders PR, as I plan to use an app called photosync to get my files off my phone and into the "external" folder. It does the same thing with live photos
it stores them alongside photos with the exact same name
astral mason
Naming them like that isn't actually how we detect they are live photos though. That is a separate process.
quasi viper
hmm gotcha, I'll have to see how it reacts to my current setup
working on getting that pr build installed now
astral mason
Once they are in the external folder are you going to get them into immich using the library PR?
quasi viper
Yep, I'm going to see how that works yeah
I haven't setup the docker container with that version yet though
astral mason
Got it.
quasi viper
I was using martabel's CA docker image, and am now switching to a docker compose build
astral mason
For that, the files should be scanned/read, and it should still generate the same generated content (thumbs, encoded videos, etc.), which will always end up in their respective folders.
In both situations originals are kept and generated content is added (especially regarding transcoded videos).
quasi viper
alrighty. I'll let someone know how it goes 😄
astral mason
You can let etnoy know in here: https://discord.com/channels/979116623879368755/1140279982875230248
quasi viper
Hey @astral mason since I've got your ear, you had mentioned the PR tag, would that go into the env file on docker compose?
astral mason
Ultimately you need the image to use the target tag