#codex-discussions
1 messages Β· Page 57 of 1
I'm supposed to be working on a different project but I've been home sick for 2 weeks and that's been enough time to burn through the entire backlog in two projects so I'm gonna need something else to do
Oh my god I found the word lol
and i wouldve done more if i had more usage
thanks
u asking me?
Are you wasting tokens or are they really being put to good use?
doesn't mean anything to me.
id say of 100% usage im properly utilizing 85%
I'm asking if you're using your tokens productively. If not then you're Always gonna run out of tokens.
chatgpt describes my codex use as "sustained maximum economically rational exploitation of available synthetic labor". I'm just systematically destroying all my to-do list items and I'm running out of them
do u remember that guy who was making something for sec filings
was it u
or are u the image guy
Have you looked to see how much work Codex needs to do to complete your tasks? Are you looking at what happens during the thinking processes? Or are you telling it to do something, it works forever, and then you're out of tokens with a list of things you still need to do?
I'm the image guy, but this is my other project and is very different
the first part
yes
yes
and no
You gotta have them create the to-do list items now, and you will have completed the circle of vibe
do u know who im talking about
I do. Its a codex skill
Hmm, gotta refocus on my code here ... Codex generated a ton of stuff and I'm going through it, finding a lot of things that need correction, fixing some of them manually, giving it the heavier stuff ... never running out of tokens. I wish you the same experiences...
I have a couple regular visitors to my house who are claude fans so every time I mutter something about codex and bugs, they say "claude never does that" and I don't believe them
I figured why they reset the limits .. if they do .. they control all sub timelines. Means they can organize themselves better
Fan boys π§
It's a lot more than just a skill:
Codex skill
-> Node REPL js tool
-> scripts/browser-client.mjs
-> Codex Chrome Extension
-> Chrome native messaging
-> extension-host.exe
the backend for the in between chrome extension / codex is removed after codex restart with no vpn ._.
It functions close to how the in app browser does
Gotcha, so they tightly coupled the extension to the plugin, and renaming it causes it to not be detected and used.
Reset?
I think it could be tied to the "bundled" "marketplace" which is done in a way so it can update without codex app update. When the chrome plugin isn't available then it just nukes it
i guess i'm done with vscode for good. still using codex app for one thread for now though
That is a bummer.
I think honestly, a lot of folks get privacy based VPNs which cost more, but it would be really cheap to fire up a simple server on something like DigitalOcean and pay $5/mo and set up a wireguard VPN. Would be cost effective
Do split tunneling, so all OpenAI server IPs get routed through VPN, and other traffic routed through normal means
Feels good huh π
Is anyone else getting constant permission prompts even starting on "Full access"?
[mcp_servers.openaiDeveloperDocs]
url = "https://developers.openai.com/mcp"
default_tools_approval_mode = "approve" # Add this line to all MCP servers to make permission prompts go away (probably)
I have servers on DreamHost, equivalent to DigitalOcean, company doesn't matter. I host VPN on one of my servers and give friends access. It was surprisingly easy, given all of the contemporary hullabaloo about VPN.
Yeah! I was just recommending DigitalOcean because I'm familiar with em, they have tons and tons of guides including setting up VPN, and it's straight up $5/mo for their cheapest machine
I'll have it function eventually
I used to use DO docs for setting up my DH servers. Hahaha.
Hey Robert, given the recent enhancements to Codex App, I think I'm ready to pull the trigger to load to Windows.
but what areyou taliking about? what you want to deploy and why vpn?
I mean what you all were reffering to
I dont see context
EU folks can't use the remote control features because EU requires paperwork & private encryption keys for all software so was offering a cheap workaround
I'm also thinking about loading Gemma4 to Windows then using Codex in WSL with API back out to the LLM for operations that don't require GPT competence. By extending out from WSL I won't be allowing the model to operate in the primary dev system, it'll just send instructions back into WSL. I haven't seen anyone else doing this? I suspect as of this moment it'll be the new way everyone does this. πΊ
Linux gettin hammered again
getting screenshots between computer to a CLI bot is mildly annoying
People with homelabs might want to do the workaround⦠not sure when upstream will fix this
I see maybe as I go it will be a problem for me to as I live in EU but I dont see what I am missing on yet.
Oh yeah, you can set up a custom model provider:
[model_providers.lmstudio-local]
name = "LM Studio"
base_url = "http://windows-host-ip:1234/v1"
wire_api = "responses"
Then launch with codex -c model_provider="lmstudio-local" -m "gemma-4"
... codex tried to get offsets for images in my sprite map
I didn't know we could do that until very recently. I completely value GPT 5.4 and 5.5 for what they do, even used 5.4-mini today. But for dumb munching on dumb stuff, there's nothing wrong now with using a local "medium-class" local model.
I feel that one. But it can be scripted.
really did not expect it to attempt to figure out sprites on a sprite sheet, I just wanted the structure. It actually got close
has there been any talk of aws bedrock integraiton with codex? we are using the azure integration with codex and its honestly just hot garbage
Spritesheets are just binary files with calculated addresses - dirt simple for software to compute offsets.
was more that I didn't ask it to do that and it just helpfully did it
Codex app with image gen is actually REALLY good with sprite sheets now as long as you give it a refrerence sheet, and a stable reference image to work with
Gonna wrap up here, go say hi to the wife.
... does anyone here remember her name?
Gosh, that's embarrassing. I need to write it down somewhere...
I'll just call her Mrs Starbuck. She's OK with that one.
my sprite sheet is out of gemini, i couldn't get chatgpt to cooperate with the icons
I'm single with cats, much simpler.
It's been busted for a few updates. Use /status
Oh, about /status. I'm still taking requests for improvements at https://github.com/CaptainStarbuck/codex-usage.
Gonna go crazy on that soon, for no good reason other than coolness factor.
See screenshots in README.
"Rate limit: Unavailable"
I did this with Gemma4 and Qwen local running in LMStudio in Windows.
TLDR: Use a real linux distro on a real host. Don't use WSL.
Accessed it with OpenCode in a Debian WSL2 instance. It was ok, but three things:
- WSL in insanely insecure as it has alot of access to Windows (like it can run notepad.exe etc). So you need to really lock it down.
- Networking is somewhat tricky to get it to see the LMStudio server. Can't use localhost or 127.0.0.1 to bind to - gotta be your real computer IP address.
- WSL doesn't have a copyfail fix. If you go to upgrade ex. my debian distro, it would not recognize there were fixes (for copyfail, among others) no mattter what mirror's i used.
Since my c# code lives in Windows along with VS2026, i'd have to share a ton of things in windows so opencode could do its thing. If i was developing python, or websites or something that can entirely live in the debian wsl instance...that would be workable.
Because of the copyfail issue I uninstalled/disabled WSL and my Debian instance. Made a mental note that if I were to try that again, I would use a real virtual debian (VirtualBox still around), not the microsoft-integrated-with-your-linux wsl thing. Even better if you have a dedicated linux box - even a raspberry pi 4 would be enough, or a ProxMox linux instance somewhere, as long you keep your LMStudio close to your graphics card (in my case a RTX5060Ti-16GB).
Hope that helps!
sacred knoledge
Oh hey Captain, I was just working on a .jsonl reader/interpreter thingy in c# with hope of undertanding better context usage. I like the look of your repo there...it is going to be very useful. I'm trying to answer the question: Where do all my tokens go? Did I do something that caused excessive usage? What can i do better? kind of thinking.
it feels the best haha. when you know that other and exec is you
they changed the dictation short cut in codex app grrr
Love it.
Summary observed_token_volume: 1,355,676,434 raw_total_tokens: 1,355,676,434 effective_input_tokens: 59,576,772 cached_input_tokens: 1,290,774,272 cache_hit_rate: 95.6% output_tokens: 5,325,390 reasoning_output_tokens: 1,960,348 session_count: 55
I don't have any suggestions for improvements, it simply works
I got it to work, it is a mess though. Can't get so I can "@" it ._.
The skill is taggable though
what was that ?
ctrl + m
it got a bit of buff recently - removes all the uneeded words from your prompt, like, um, right?, okay, etc etc oh and cuss words ahha
ack, blind bots. "just mind that that helmet icon is very wide" codex crops off the right half of the icon no not like that
now its scaled it so small you can barely tell what it is and put it on top of the text. Step away from the css, little bot
theres more special variables you can use than the ones they show on the web app settings for codex
all 9 have been going for 20 min now i wonder how long this will take
The UI won't let you save it if the simulated example branch they show is > 100 chars, but if you replay a settings change PATCH request with your desired value, it holds
anyone here answer this? #openai-chatter message
when you upgrade you do get new limits im not sure if it fully resets them or if it just adds onto the limits though
support saying this, anyway will try
i don't see any chrome plugin, neither the Browser Use that lets Codex operate the in-app browser directly. Can someone pls help me
i've updated the latest version
are you talking about codex or normal chatgpt app ? as normal chatgpt app on pro plan doesnt have any limits at all unlike codex
Same
weird if your on the latest version of codex it should show here, maybe try doing a quick pc restart
how about the Browser Use? I don't see any plugins support that like the docs mentioned
that one is in skills not plugins
goto your settings
both browser and chrome should be able to be turned on there as well
Btw only available if not in EU or UK. Maybe that's the issue
are you in the eu or uk ?
someone convince me codex is better than claude please
hm? i live in SEA
no
whats weird is no one is using codex in enterprise
like no one
more enterprise is using copilot for some reason. Its like 80% claude 15% copilot and 5% codex
yea havent seen that before, you might be able to manually add it via files but other then that no clue why it wouldnt be showing
i downloaded codex via microsoft store, is that the case?
i mean you could always try it for a quick 10 usd in credits, id imagine people use copilot since its cheap and normally already bundled in microsoft 365
i downloaded it from the chatgpt website so maybe
the fun part is finding the handful of people here who use both
wait, why i can't access settings via personal account?
but my workspace account can?
i cant either is yours handeled through apple ? Β―_(γ)_/Β―
doing all front end stuff right now. Mildly horrified by how bad it is. But, I can't compare to claude
its your payment handeled through apple
i'm not sure, i got my account from company gave it to me
any math enthusiasts?
codex indicates high certainty of a twin primes proof formalized in lean: https://github.com/alegator-cs/infinite_twin_primes
-# Do not post or direct message any members of this server to promote non-OpenAI services, products, or projects. Exemptions: OpenAI API projects in #api-projects & GPTs in #custom-gpts.
is this new ? and by agents does it mean ai agents like codex i just updated and saw this
@gentle harbor you are using win or mac?
i use both but right now im using win why
i still can't figure out why i don't have the option to use the integrated browser codex
literally no docs or any help from this issue
i see it here
this is the issues i'm trying to say
I see, is computer use missing as well?
even browser skills/plugins i don't have
why i can't use these features
some ppl have been mentioning they didnt have computer use, and they are from the eu. Might be a location thing
i'm from SEA
hmm me too
... so everyone I think is an active regular here is just ... in asia?
im starting to wonder why EU sub costs the same as US when all new features are delayed π
australia too and used to being online at the same time as all the gaming kiddies in vietnam and singapore
- Close Codex entirely
- Use a VPN and switch to the US (Windscribe is a good option)
- Open up Codex
And you should be able to use all the features
let me try, thanks
I think I've used more tokens in the last 3 days on my 'other' project than in the last couple weeks on my main project. Type of project apparently matters a lot
Codex usually still have background tasks so I would recommend end task via task manager
yea i notice it's mini icon in the tray
I mean, even if the icon disappears, Codex is still running background tasks
that's strange
when you turn on the VPN and reopen Codex, did it have any new updates ?
you don't have split tunnelling enabled right?
nope, my codex account alr update to latest version a few hours ago, via microsoft store
what is that?
Windscribe
it's a feature that allows or blocks specific apps from using the VPN connection basically, should be disabled by default so don't worry about it π
yea i checked it and it was off
very strange
from the UK I'm also using Windscribe, I can see the Computer Use and Chrome sections fine
lmao, how did u know i'm vietnamese :v
This image has Vietnamese
i can't voice rn, check your DM
Hello former fellow Vietnamese people!
Had the honor to live a few years there β€οΈ
One of the nicest countries and people ever π
Glad you like it!
maybe Tibo will do a reset at some point before then π
a man can hope
There hasnt been a reset in a few days... I hope Tibo is healthy
imma cry
bro .. nahh..
never thought i would be a token junky .. i value tokens more then every shekel on earth .. OY VEY
token limits..
ive just done alot this week i never hit this low
would love to have been one of the fortunate people who got 10x'd
codex goal blew my mind. Monday i started goal of full port electron app to web based one with syncing between two, backend, moving from local storage to remote one. I had it running during office hours 6-8h a day every day. It still works and it actually doing progress
Im friggin sick at Codex sucking at frontend
the day the frontend is fixed...
You cannot imagine the hideousness that it is building for UI
uuuuuh 49% me
what that mean 20% reserve ?!
i need that too
75% .. what token saving tool you using ?!
wow .. why ?
and i've been using parallel agents on xhigh fast mode on 5 different projects and it barely goes down 1%
that would be cool feature token sharing .. or second dary market place lol
i applied to that one thing
they would shut it down so fast π
true lol
i ran out of ideas so im legit using it on max mode to fix lints in .md files
someone would launch a memecoin with wrapped gpt tokens LOL
you on 200 plan?!
nah 100$
wow
but its basically 10x 10x
where i can apply ?
so its 100x usage
wow
you had to apply before to that 5.5 party
aaaah
and get rejected
i hope they do not reset the limits this time ..
idk how this is sustainable tho, realistically this offer they gave is worth like 25k a month in api credits
how do they do that
hah, I've spent the last couple days doing a site refresh/reskin and you're not wrong
use the image model to design
then codex to. implement
u can use the image model within codex
i found the best results that way
It is absolutely horrendous
Meh, Llm's are still bits of data processed by algos.
Never heard anyone complaining Photoshop is bad at editing, or word bad at writing haha
can someone tell why codex opens chrome to debug even when the browser preview is open within the codex application? Is there something I have to say or call to stop it from doing this?
So i dunno take some ux courses
Maybe you ll understand better how to get what you want
I've mostly done it myself the human way but all the default stuff it puts in is pretty bad. It got me a fair chunk of the reskin and I did the rest by hand, with help from gemini choosing colours and chunks of css. Looks great now
bit sketchy on mobile though but that's tomorrow's problem
its not bad, it made https://autodisc.xyz , it just sucks at pregen
and using skills helps alottt
@nocturne folio Dude, that doesnt look good
it converts π€·
hehe it made me a lil task tracker app and it has exactly the same colours as your site
I mean, there's clean and minimalistic, but it doesnt work for anything real. It is a bad landing page.
Its mostly whitespace
whats an example of something good
That's commenting on the guy aesthethic taste though
I don t personally like it either
eeee a bit unbalanced
gpt also makes weird ux choices, for instance i asked for a collapse button on a left rail. It places it at the bottom out of the viewport, thought it did not do it.
This is also "unbalanced"
this looks hot tho
dannnngggg it
apart of the bad text width
The image, yes. Image generation is great. But web design sucks
use stitch
should i just remove it?
@nocturne folio Your main problem is lack of content. SEO-wise, the page sucks
Have GPT optimise it for GEO (but tell it what GEO is). It does an amazing job at that.
From a design POV, too much whitespace. People will think that the page is broken
And use Stitch for design mockups.
@nocturne folio Im going to assume that you only saw it in mobile (where it looks decent)
yea
Well, yeah, that's not enough π
noo, that's not criticing your site, btw, it looks better than most of the plain output from gpt5.5
but it stil struggels with little details
it helps when you turn things like this card into a shared compomnent
there is another update in codex app? oh man esterday there was one too
@lost drum Today? no
so I have no clue why I have one again
v0.129
no, i rather criticism, trying out google stitch atm
theres /goals now but its like hidden
π
but goals worked 2 days agoo too
I mean you just had to write /goal [message] and somehow it worked
and put in config goals
it works because it uses codex app server just like codex cli
yeah I used it in VS extension
my codex fork has some helpful small qol like going from plan to plan mode direclty
Hmmmm can someone share the chrome plugin the one that is available in US?
Yea you can do wonderful stuff with your own fork.
I got tired of updating it, so now I'm just implementing my own harness from scratch lol
https://status.openai.com unstable systems loook like lol
"/goal $sync-upstream"
that's not the point. it's just more control from your side to build it from scratch, and have your end-to-end logic for the harness
it could be, but it's not the problem i'm trying to solve, as i use it for real work
so my codex fork and pi are good enough harness
for myself
right. vanilla is good enough too in most cases
Sam hear me out I know you in here incognito π₯Έ: I want weekly 2x 5 hour 1x not 5 hour 2 x weekly 1x
call it Samuel 3x and it will work
it's missing the "the model was nerfed"
or pressing f5 every thursday for a new model announcement
dudeeee π€¦ββοΈ
i said i might be wrong
it's a natural phenomenon, aka usage > compute
Interesting... changing reasoning effort mid convo apparently causes cache miss
what does that mean
It means if you have 200k tokens in ctx window, if you switch reasoning effort, the next submission is billed 200k input + prompt instead of 200k cached + prompt
oh really? that would explain what I have been trying to nail down all day
ahhh
normally its 200k input+prompt?
or 200k cached+prompt
the way caching works is, when making a request, all contiguously matching tokens from 0 to n are reused. if there is a single token that does not precisely match the previous request, it trims all tokens after that point.
I guess changing reasoning effort mid convo causes a cache miss. maybe trims reasoning tokens in the past
oh damn
i dont feel it tho
maybe cus i work on very small projects
lol
do u feel it?
nah, I only use medium. but figured that info was worth sharing
for coding i'm using 5.5 medium, but just found GPT-5.3-Codex-Spark, is it good?
codex 5.3 medium has been very good to me
not sure about spark though
It's relatively fast, but not very intelligent.
Man it's nice to have my server out there on AWS, inching closer to public play testing π
is it me or codex 5.5 got nerfed?
it got stuck at a simple file took longer eventho im running at the same speed and extra high
1,3 same ryt?
Is there an easy way to run codex review with mcps disabled?
It's really good for fast refactoring. I had this one job where I needed to add accessibility elements to a massive frontend, and in a matter of like 20 minutes it wrapped every single input element in semantics. Any other model might have taken a few hours
wow nice. that codebase must be huge
The frontend alone is ~600k sloc of working code
all in one file right? 
Spark plows through it quickly
1473 1486 UI-only files
Sure!
Thatβs not too far from size of Codex itself, which is ridiculous
It's a pretty big app (pics removed)
Iβm sure a lot of the code could be compressed
a more aggressive DRY could go miles alongside KISS
Iβd estimate a solid 470k if you could do your things right
Haha yes, there will always be critics.
But of course LOC isnβt a good metric since the syntax itself falls for it
Rust for example is super verbose in syntax && formatting
I am not counting any lines of rust, which drives the business logic of the frontend
Then your frontend is an absolute mess lol
600k of frontend shouldnβt be that
your 600k of frontend is nearly 5.6x my entire programming language && its tooling
i thought my internal dashboard project was huge
DRY principle. Donβt forget that
If you have similar or equivalent logic across the code base, then itβs time to consolidate
I should probably invest time in a language-agnostic tool specifically for this type of stuff
to enforce principles, best practices, God object violations, && more
I mean you can argue it doesn't look nice, and I'm working on that, but the advice you're giving right now is not really applicable. I can't explain why it's that big, but just know it's not because of novice engineering, it's completely unavoidable.
but just know = i stop there π
Some of you guys have typed more lines here than lines of code to production
Yeah, good point! I needed that reality check
bro, are you joke ? π $200,000 is too much.
i've figured out how to fix the error unable to install chrome or Browser Use plugins for integrated browser, you just need to uninstall the app and then using VPN to US, then reinstall it while using VPN, it should have full features back
thanks @neon plinth for helping me
and with this after restarting all features stay?
all chat history, environment, plugins, skills, stay the same
you don't loose anything
including the computer use and other eu features?
like on my side after using vpn i get the features but after restart everything leaves, but i haven;t tried the uninstall you just dropped
the restart mean closing the codex app and reopening
i'm not sure about the EU blocked features, but you should try
i just need to open VPN once when reinstalling back, then i don't need to use VPN anymore
My count was off. 600k includes massive amounts of unit and integration tests, not UI-only. Idk what the distribution is but you were right to suspect something
I just counted single lines of dart, didn't really subtract tests
tests would not count towards LOC
tests are usually left like so, but it would make sense to count tests separately
Well, I would say a majority of the tests are just "render this part of the app to a png", and they use it for seeing the UI without running the app. There's some tests that actually check functionality, but I completely forgot they write tests just to render and view the UI, which accounts for a lot of non-working code
i call that "prose testing"
which is not fun
Part of that process is "must mock the DTOs and controllers", so they are doubling up on code, but it's to have mock data for the rendering
β 28 hooks need review before they can run. Open /hooks to review them. why?
how do i disable this hook-review garbage?
Apparently you can add a /etc/codex/requirements.toml which is typically for business/enterprise accounts, but works on any account type, and put your hooks in there like this
[[PreToolUse]]
matcher = "^Bash$"
[[PreToolUse.hooks]]
type = "command"
command = "python3 /tmp/pre.py"
timeout = 10
statusMessage = "checking"
requirements is treated as managed & mandatory, but it makes the hooks global
Man this is nice, Codex can use the AWS CLI and handle everything. I guess that makes sense but it's just blowing my mind π
I set up most of the stuff I needed in AWS but I was having a small problem and it dawned on me like 6 hours in that I could just use Codex
should i get a 2nd codex account, a Plus account, specifically as fallback when main Pro 20x hits limits?
i cannot do my CI notarize fix when codex limit
Well that sounds reasonable, if you're hitting your limit then you need another account, but you won't have the same prompt cache
Might be more cost effective to do credits. Pro comes with higher priority processing and a higher 5hr limit
might be more expensive with creds
or wait... i see spark
I mean you can try it, but if you're hitting the weekly on Pro 20x, you're probably gonna hit the 5hr limit on Plus
Eh, idk. Trust but verify lol
even spark cannot be used when main weekly limit hit
Oh damn, I thought they were separate
they appear, but are not
yea i guess spark has also speicifc limit but it s still part of the big qouta
Looks like they're going to get their money from you one way or another lol
they need to increase weekly
I guess your project must be a lot more complex than mine, because I'm not having any problems with the limit. It's a lot more generous than cursor
I've been running an agent non stop basically all week can't hit my limit if I tried
what are you even doing?
Do you use a lot of MCP servers? These can eat up your limits
Client/server Android game, Fastify for the server, Svelte + Vite + Capacitor for the client etc
not unless invoked manually, but the only ones i have enabled are OpenAI Docs, Anthropic Docs && OpenCode Docs
Tbf borrowcheckbtw burned a lotta quota from a multi agent bug. My guess is next week probably wont have this issue
Ah that sucks but that makes sense
But i've noticed last week there were some situations that tokens were draining like crazy for one of my projects, few days later in new chat window same project, similar work was fine
&& the bug is somehow entirely in the fault of the user
So i think there could have been a bug in one of last releases
Yeah they really should set sane defaults for multi agent so it's not like navigating a mine field when enabled
whatever this is
Experimental goals are now discoverable, stay paused across resume unless the user opts back in, and show clearer validation and multi-day duration output.
First of all I cannot see any change to /goal command, and would not know how they would grant a goal to run multi-day
They really should NOT let AI write everything man. This is one of them "huh what" "ah yes soory I misinterpreted that, inferred something that was not real" lol
I just had something weird happen: I saw my 5h limit jump up from 19% to 20%
I'm getting the impression that there are a number of runaway "hey let's put this cool feature in" updates/features that aren't fully documented with expectations, guidance, original purpose, etc. Maybe they need to get ChatGPT to explain features for new documentation. If ChatGPT can't explain it, then they haven't explained it well enough.
I am not entirely sure there are actually any humans left behind the dev process of codex
I have a gut feeling it is all automated. They are sitting in the recreational room and are cooking up new things like phones, while codex makes codex somewhere in a stargate
It's going the same way social media platforms did several years ago
I don't think Facebook has anyone doing anything customer related anymore. Even "human evaluation" is automated it seems
Would be weird if OpenAI had less automation. π
Woudl be weird since even at least 3 users in this very chat here are creating tools to do that lol, indeed
Codex FTW:
Why I did it: your repo instruction says βAlways create atomic commits to git for work you consider done,β and you explicitly asked to put
the brainstorm into milestones/. I also saw at least one tracked milestone file already in git, so I assumed new milestone docs should be
versioned the same way.
How it happened: milestones/ is ignored for normal untracked files, but Git still allows an ignored file to be tracked with:
git add -f milestones/...
I checked ignore status, saw .gitignore was ignoring the folder, then force-added the two new files and committed them as 1c0b619.
It took me 3 days (+1 reset) to get over with the $100 plan
I mean - I guess now I have to be specific that making atomic commmits does NOT mean circumventing gitignore ah
Atomic as in each file gets committed separately?
Atomic as in small thing. big boom. many regret. reset impossible.
Git revert
Often for faulty commits
Codex commited a file in a folder that was gitignored
That is the issue. Not how to revert the faulty commit.
Also that is the reason for atomic commits
Because to revert, you do not want to revert 5000 edits across 1000 files
How do you commit a file that was git ignored
You can checkout individual files
why do you ask me lol, its explained in gpt's answer above
How it happened: milestones/ is ignored for normal untracked files, but Git still allows an ignored file to be tracked with:
git add -f milestones/...
Ohh it force added
yes, because it said "I have to atomic commit my work"
So it went and circumvented the gitignore.
So now the system prompt says "do not ignore the gitignore"
I guess next will be "do not ignore the ignore of the gitignore"
Summarised as simple ignor-rant
Interesting
Home Reseticus says
Chat must be long for it to ignore those instructions
It did not ignore them
It followed them to the letter
Why I did it: your repo instruction says βAlways create atomic commits to git for work you consider done,β and you explicitly asked to put
the brainstorm into milestones/. I also saw at least one tracked milestone file already in git, so I assumed new milestone docs should be
versioned the same way.
That's right, because you would not expect you have to tell an AI to conscioulsy "break" git and .gitignore is a file that git respects ...
In other words, when you hear "AI deleted my computer", that is probably how it happens.
I mean itβs a probabilistic engine
Itβs probable for it to make that assumption
Clearly it did
I would not say that is expected - it is in fact the first time in months
But, I guess, yes, the it can be reasoned that there is a reason for it to reason like that
Well yeah it gave you the reason
I am still pissed.
Cant you just be pissed with me, and comfirm it is outrageous?
||:)||
Itβs hard to get pissed at ai anymore Iβm numb
I just used "steer" to tell codex to not do builds. It went "ok, I'll just let this one finish". Then... "I'm just doing one more build because the last one gave useful information"
would watch a series of him growing up thtuth live and like whole lore XD
full movie
yo but wont eehey ban acc then?
4% left until the 12th... I really really need pro
im 11% left on pro until 12th π
That would easily last me
damm do you have x5 or x20?
x20
damm i have x5 and i am not even getting to 50% weekly
i use it 8h daily in work on multiple projects, so defo getting my value for money π
last time i checked i was using around 25k usd in tokens value monthly
holy crap
damm i dont even know what i am using mostly been vibe coding en enhancing my specialist gpt for making good prompts for codex
been working on a health and fitness app
was soing it for 3 week untill the reality hit me whrer it drifted off and now I need to fix it ehh
I usually use it on function level, or sometimes a couple of functions, but lately I have been programming a galaxy generator. Lots of complicated, and annoying math. Been using it heavily for this.
next should be goblinus resetus featuere where it laughs mroe and mroe when your usage lowers untill he can finally spam message reset wen to tibo
if you are not dev and just vibe code app, i strongly suggest you to do 2 things: use gpt to help you build very detailed project structure first + some architecture guidelines, then get skills for frameworks/libraries it suggest. Get git nexus and then you can build really advanced apps
i am a dev and do exactly that
Without that it might start loosing context of app and do a very stupid mistakes
ahh ok π
i really hate "vibe coding" term π
GPT yesterday decided that it was more of a traveller lol
I think it misunderstood the word tokens for crypto tokens
I dislike the concept. At least when applied to production code. People who put stuff in production should know what the code does.
thats is precisely what i do make a structured framework on my idea and let is also advanced reasearch bij using the gpt research function and then make the end state of what i wanna have and let it rip until it reaches the layout of the final state
yeah goal functionality is absolutelly amazing for stuff like that
yes precisely and then it is also not gunna halucinate so much
and then when its doen i let it do a whole qa as a tester who tries to break everything and let it do code reviews where i watch it as well
and then the next polish and new made final state start again
@torpid trout That was directed at the line before your memes
Yeah, got that, still 
Why put stuff on production I when know what it does?
That takes away all the fun
Try adding this to your agents file: "At random times, make creative changes to the code, with no regard to functionality" π
hahahahaha. that wil make pure chaos
Since i have too many tokens I had codex index my entire ~/, create a state map in csv, a suggested re-organization map in csv and an audit of each asset present π
Instead of consuming tokens, it added 1% to the available limit.
I am not kidding. And that was while 2 more instances run a /goal of each 2 milestones
Their thing is so broken it does not get more broken
infinite token glitch
no, it's the lite version: "Tiny Token Glitch"
Next up I will feed it the entire handwritten scans folder, have it OCR it, put into md files, vectorize it, and connect the dots into a contiguous novel.
I wanted to do that since a long while, mainly didnt because api costs where prohibitive. And, well, I might get banned for it, my handwritten notes are often not using family friendly language
anyone else feel codex rate limits are getting used quicker now?
smileBeda isn't
I feel like they are used up about βΎοΈ faster than I need
i am going to code a new setting for my bidet
I just stole yours I guess
There was another guy here recently saying his limit went up 1%
i always just use normal speed mode
Its the 1% club
give it back
and then game while i wait
hello other guy
peasants
have been working a damm lot of time on my health app
netherlands?
yes
I like the language, but I think I will never learn to pronounce it
its not easy i am telling you now
and also i hate my own laguage hahahahaha
i prefer english any day of the week
Same. Mine is Swedish.
nice
I translated the name for the game I'm working on to Swedish. It instantly sounded silly.
have done so fare a 4 year dev studie and now a bachelor cyber security and cloud studie of 4 years
i heard if you talk nice to codex it uses less tokens
hahahaha nice
its unacceptable
my 5h jumped a percentage point again. Weekly still at 3%
i think they took away reset button from Tibo
Lmao
Wait
How many tokens you use in the chat
Incredible that image2 can create this level of detail and colorize it π
Indeed
image 2 is goated
image2 is basically the first alpha of ai imaging. it can create random things, but it really sucks at specific changes
but its the first one that can actually do those changes
the first alpha was called VQGAN
debatable
it will make sense in 5 years from now
i loved vqgan
gemini for example cant do the edits at all. codex can struggle hard but do some very simple things
its super nuanced, requires understanding of intent goes way beyond generating images
Idk about the codex image gen side of things, but in ChatGPT I've had a lot of success with forking earlier parts of the convo if image gen starts struggling. If it can't nail it on the second attempt, fork it π€
yeah thats kind of driving home my point where it gets confused super easy
kinda like super early llm just having a normal conversation
huh... suddenly images do not post anymore here
same here. Perhaps they have been modded?
perhaps images2 cant figure out how to allow the edits (j/k)
We are going to need a codex image gallery of some kind...don't want to lose these in the history.
codex make website for meme
codex deploy
dont kid me, I have too many tokens, i am doing that rn. Inclusive exclusive submission form so I can get hacked
kind of a Codex satire gallery (though we love you Codex!)
Ohh yeah images canβt be sent here
anywhere
But Iβm curious about your token usage in the chat your usage went up
New?
Homo Reseticus broke Discord, methinks π
Homo Reseticus, with the ironic-ish abbreviation HR, should be tasked to fix Discord.
gpt-5.5 high Β· ~/Developer Β· Context 79% left Β· 5h 96% Β· weekly 84% Β· 258K window Β· 677K used Β· 662K in Β· 15.2K out Β· Fast off
does that help?
And before it was 83%
Finally back
was there a reset?
no
Discord probably had to reset their servers
Oh I thouthg I broke my windows 11
weird things appearing the longer the codex runs
now the file explorer has weird black bakgroudn around it hehe
I am not turning off my pc untill I finish project cause who knows if it fires again
AWS had an outage a few hrs ago
But that shouldβve been resolved
this was just like 30min ago
Lmao it didnβt help tbh I donβt know why I asked
But extra 1% is nice
As someone who is carefully wording every single prompt to make the last 2% last for as long as possible on 5.4-mini, a single week percent would be gold. π
is there a changelog we can look at for codex updates?
I dont trust itπ thread can behave as a bridge/orchestration compiler: compile messy owner intent into the right prompt, handoff, plan, /goal, route packet, module request, multi-agent sequence, or blocker question, instead of acting as a simple prompt rewriter or default downstream executor.
we're back baby!
I did, it doesn't give me a clear answer, just like the webiste, lol
@boreal holly<3
I like it cuz it skips over all the alpha releases
wait, that's for the TUI, is the one for the GUI?
Well, that repo contains the app-server, which is what the GUI uses, so they parallel develop this repo and the GUI together
All the changes in the releases on there are directly relevant to the GUI
okay, thanks
that's good to know, lol
rofl, I just asked, and I just got another codex update, lololol
they've had like 3 or 4 updates in the last 2 days
Did someone try extra credits? Im wondering how it compares to sub usage
They are supposedly identical to API usage costs
how do codex's rate limits work? What is being tracked? running time? tokens?
because I've been working on something off a train hotspot and the spotty connection is making tasks take longer, and im worrying that its burning my usage rates because of the extended time
tokens, what model you use, what mode it uses, if you are using fast mode or not... I think those are it. Anyone have anything to add?
tokens but not all tokens are priced equally because cached tokens are significantly cheaper
single pyhon command of mine that he triggers runs for liek 11min and it thsoe not burn tokens I think he just waits forthe output
ok so a spotty connection isnt gonna make me burn through it faster?
I'm guessing if it has to resend stuff it will
no, openai stores cached tokens on their end
I usually operate on 5.5 Low, then increase the intelligence setting if needed
smart move
5.5 low seems to be pretty nice as far as price to intelligence goes
and itβs faster as a bonus
I just use high cause I have no clue if chiefed pormpt with clear rules and goal would be executed as better as on low intelligence
I use 5.4 cos I'm too lazy to change what its got as default
no clue if more the intelligence means that the model just has more depths of reasonign about the work he plans and executes at a moment
yeah it usually gets the job done
super helpful for coding my game, and even if it isn't, it's still going faster than I would've.
I usually try to be as descriptive wiht my prompts as I can to give it a clear end-goal.
oop there's the spotty train connection lol
Your Codex session logs are helpful!
@boreal holly what was ur github
Anyone tried v2 of compaction? how is it?
Intel support is not coming
duddeeeee
i hate thgusssss
i want codex so baddlyyy
@velvet wren wht abt codex cli
like running in ur term
no happy ending?
wrap it up
Someone tell Sama pls
codex desktop app needs to have ctrl + backtick to open a terminal
just got a Codex macOS update
same but nothing in changelog
keep dreamminggg
wait what, I say from an intel mac
I had to give back my work computer when I quit my day job, I'm running on fossilised hardware from the 2010s here
what's stopping you from vibe coding it
Someone already did and it doesnβt work properly
Also usage
where are you seeing hte second download? I'm only getting the one download link
well that link sure isn't tailored to your OS. But hey, I tried
π
Also auth flow
what antiquity of a screen are you using
It looks beautiful here. No one has ever seen something like that.
Get a wider screen, brother.
Cant you see how wide apart those eyes are. How dare you staring straight forward? you need a wide screen. very wide. the widest
this is ancient
You need newer. Better. bigger!
No kidding, I am scolding codex now for that, and hiding that chip a bit earlier than mobile π
Decided to leave it like that exactly for the rage bait purpose.
get a wider screen will be a footnote soon.
π€£ he made that file himself
anybody else having problems?
I have many problems. Not of that kind tho right now.
Wow I'm flying through my limits, this might be the first time I manage to get 100% of it down in the week without actively trying
QA testing devours it
guys.. do u see the Chrome plugin in plugins?
am not in US but I might just use proxy to dowlaod the codex app for mac or something use ghidra or other tool to extract raw app or some to know how the real plugin works and modify it or idk what to do I am not dev and havent even done research whats the best approach so ye
best thing I've seen today
eh?
in EU you dont have a chrome plugin
gg2ez
I don't think you need ghidra for codex app. Codex app extracts codex app's source code somehow from installed codex app, just ask it.
3 words !! o4 is releasing !!
mf needs to stop being "edgy"
dude looks like he's trying not to cry in every image he is on
hey i just met you
and this is crazy
so here's my number
call me maybe
nah, this is mood https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=it47TBjmXT8
How do you clear context on Codex App? Any command or start a new chat?
Yeah I was wondering if there was a slash command to clear context like /clear
Start a new thread/session/chat.
who uses the /side command efficiently and can give feedback of the actual good use case
in an existing chat no. you must craft it yourself but you need to fork the codex cli for that
if you want fresh context just start a new chat
I just tried /side to have a discussion/come to Jesus about certain log outputs cause I was getting low on context on main chat
Codex "Computer Use" is working on my MBP but it is very slow. Is this just where it's at currently or could it be because I have high-res displays (5K & 6K)? It takes hours to do computer use tasks.
Since Codex is so slow, can I continuse working on my machine? Codex doesn't seem to steal the cursor but will I confuse it if I do work? Also what if I witch from the space that the app it is using is in?
agi complete. π
60% to use within 2 days cause tibo will reset on 11th probbably ro early 12th
Whatβs the latest codex meta? Any new changes besides /goal ?
the Codex app now supports Intel Macs
it's news
he asked for new changes
Google Apple and intel today
do u know what meta is
bro that isnt meta
π
he's asking if theres anything else apart from/goal that people use
he asked for new changes, Intel Mac support is a new change
He said βthe codex app now supports Intel Macsβ
I still can't find the link anywhere for the intel version
refresh the link I posted
any new changes to the codex meta
I hope π€ OpenAI double the weekly limit
Intel Mac was meta back in the day fr
Especially if you had one of those cheese grater towers
π€€
did they discountinue in 2019?
2023
codex is so conservative. Said there's shiny things in the api, should I add more api stuff. It says no, unless. Told it what I actually want to do and it changed to yes, but
ok that link works on my laptop but not my desktop
looks like I have an app already that does what api would have done so that's nice, less money
bit mediocre though. Can openai say trebuchet?
Iβm still confused by what the use case for spark is
Is it trained on the Cerebras chip?
ok this is funny how chatgpt and codex disagree
Overly secure and conservative security filtering actually hinders efficiency.
codex is very ... dull
Codex is still blowing my mind every day, now I have it set up with an Android emulator and an SSH connection and AWS CLI to the backend server on AWS so it can test the full stack in a live production environment. Absolutely amazing.
I've run out of things for it to do unless I pull forward future stuff or start a new project. 4 days to rebuild/reskin this website isn't too bad
Wanna make my website for me and save me some useage? Lol I already have the plan documentation π jkjk
hah. I was a front end dev for ages. I just don't do design, so this would have been way faster if I had a figma design already done
Yeah makes sense
was a lot of fiddly "this looks bad, gemini, halp"
I've always used a theme builder on WordPress so I never had to do much, now I'm handing it off to Codex with GeneratePress and GenerateBlocks so let's see what it comes up with. For the most part it's just a basic information page for my game with a basic support ticket system, except I'm leveraging the power of agentic vibe coding to kick it up a notch with a web shop and player dashboard for the game. It's beyond the scope of what I would probably do under other circumstances, but this is 2026 and everything has changed lol
I'm using three layers of authentication but I'm looking forward to handing the shop off to hackers and see what they can come up with π
I've usually worked for corporates, so you get this ridiculous mildly unworkable fancy thing from some phenomenally expensive design firm and you're expected to glue it to a website, preferably by next tuesday because they wasted 6 months of dev time arguing about the button colours
Dam
I think my shortest turnaround for an entire website was around 24 hours. THat was not a healthy company to work for
Ah yeah, sort of the same thing in sysadmin, the server better be migrated by 6 AM on Monday and you better not sleep all weekend to make it happen. But I guess I could just had things off to agents these days. It's been a few years.
My current use of Codex is purely personal, though I do intend to make money from the game but that's sort of beside the point
I have burned through all my backlog items on two projects now, its entirely onto clean stuff I thought I'd do in the distant future now. Damn codex. Too efficient
It's incredible, I just can't get over how it can coordinate a live full stack test and check for errors and fix them autonomously across three repos.
I keep trying to find more complex things for it to do and it keeps doing them without any issues. It fixed an issue in AWS with target groups and then found two other problems and fixed them without me even asking
what i like is the small feature when codex do updates
beautiful
model got better too .. something changed overnight
Yes. The direction is smart overall. It is one of the first versions in your discussions that actually stays disciplined instead of turning into βAI magic floor detectorβ nonsense. The strongest parts are:
this text to speech api thing I've had on my to-do list for like 15 years as a "maybe later" item and its now popped to the top of the list due simply to sheer lack of anything else to do
adding too much AI
adding too much scoring
using future leakage
mixing execution + research
scanning raw swaps forever
building non-replayable heuristics
This version avoids most of those traps.```
π«‘
gpt start selfreflect
48% saturday in bali - 3 days left ..
until 12 and the limit reset ..
i might update to 200 ..
π
ratio is now 18% 5 hour is 3% weekly .. man .. that is bad .. ..EATING .. all on 5.5 medium
1% of weekly in 30 minutes using one agent 5.5 medium
it is more expensive per mil toc than opus, which is notorious for being expensive.
So that's roughly 50 hours of use in a week, not bad if you ask me.
It's hard to have anything substantive to compare it to other than hiring an employee, who does less work in more time and costs more money. $100/month for 50 hours a week of real effort is kind of an amazing price if you think of it that way.
Unusual use case of me abusing codex lol I made it export and crop upload ready images from random design frames in webp format π€§π€§π€§π€§
does codex use its own token limit or your plan images limit for that
I suppose just cropping is an external tool not codex per se
I think its in the codex uasage bucket
Oh i misunderstood the question
I am in the middle of trying to build ui images with image gen and got my wires crossed
Tool use and imagegen both come out of the Codex useage limit
been a bit of talk about getting codex to make images
I've had codex process about 5500 images but its been via a script, so it hasn't touched my quota
When do we get skill sin chatgpt?
It's not bad at all, uses the latest models so it has great quality if you need it. Plus you can integrate with the Scenario MCP if you want even more options.
image gen uses the new model for generating images
Smart
I hear they've fixed that. I've been routing around it to the older one
was it broken?
just running out of things to do, and I've got another old site I could happily do batch image creation on
so very very broken yes
Man I have plenty of things for you to do if you want to. π I'm condensing a 5 year plan into a month with agents. It's like a tornado style of development.
I'm back to sifting through photos. Nothing to code right now, unless I start something totally new
So the announcements say we can now import from Claude Cowork..BUT Codex import detects Claude Code but not Claude Cowork for me despite Claude Cowork being installed and actively used with projects on my Mac...any ideas why?
$path?
Is that for me?... could you elaborate ...? thanks π
Actually I donβt see where it says cowork supported
Only cc
The cli
Is cowork a desktop app-only feature
it clearly shows cowork here in the video ...https://chatgpt.com/codex/switch-to-codex/
Cowork is desktop app
That looks like a marketing demo, not the live import flow. See how the wording is different, "Import work from other AI apps" versus "Import from other AI apps". They might not have shipped Claude Cowork import and accidentally left it in the promo video. π That would explain why @solid lake can't find a mention of it.
aaah...LOL... oops π
No but surely thereβs a way to migrate that
Cowork saves work in a different format than claude code lemme check
yes true!
Hmm thereβs no single way to do it, looks like youβll have to differentiate manually
No idea how I would do thatβ¦any ideas?
Just tell codex to find the files on the drive and migrate whatβs useful imo
Aaah I seeβ¦ okβ¦thanks ! shame it doesnβt do what it says in the ad π
Omg my build is so squeaky clean π«§πͺ₯π² I asked Codex to resolve some warnings and it went all out on library updates and compatibility patches, it's so beautiful it brings a tear to my eye lol
just tried the grill-me plugin, bloody hell....on question 81 now, it just won't end but damn this thing is thorough.
That looks interesting. Can it be adapted to an existing project or is it more about fleshing out a concept at the beginning of a project?
I'd love to be grilled about my project, that seems like a useful thing to do when vibe coding
I am reworking parts of my project and its taken it, went through it and now asking me questions since I asked it some specific things I would like to change in it.
basically no more assuming anything from the llm side, we get to decide every single decision in the design process. I have been at this for almost 2 hours now.
definitely give it a try, I should have done this earlier, wouldn't have had to re-design what i am redesigning now because it turned out to be a complete mess
Nice. Well better too much info than not enough, I call it the grep gripe paradox. Give it more to grep and it'll have fewer reasons to gripe lol
I can't believe Tibo made a Twitter poll, and didn't include Linux
I'm pretty confident in my current architecture but maybe I'm totally wrong so we're about to find out lol. Trust but verify
lol, well I may have lazied a bit earlier which has led to me to my current predicament, but definitely would give the skill a shot.
The cleanup session is actually still running so I'll wait for that, updating dependencies and cleaning up deprecated code is a real rabbit hole
good luck man, hope this thing helps!
Hell yeah, I'm really looking forward to seeing what it has to ask. Pretty much guaranteed to learn something.
I have, learned a lot, question 90 now...should have eaten before I started this
Lol take a break, you'll give better answers and have a better understanding after you eat something
Strong body, strong mind πͺ lol
its all good, I feel like I may be at the end of the questioning, I did get this feeling when I was near question 60.....I will get to 100 and take a break π
lol, it never says we are always done, but the questioning feels like it and then bam, it hits you from the side
At a certain point I'd just be like, "Are we almost done here? Can you cut to the chase already and just tell me what I need to friggin know!?" π
Jk lol
ah man, I am pretty happy with these questioning, definitely fine tuning the whole thing with a comb
Yeah that's definitely important stuff if you're working on any sort of project larger than a basic script
project is already in production, making major improvements.
If you say i want to make a social network gill me i think youre going to be there a while π€£
Vibe coders should think "what does corporate do?". Because now we have entire teams as well, they just happen to be agents.
Well my cleanup just finished so I'm gonna test it real quick then get to the grilling β¨οΈ
does anyone else dislike the way gpt likes to say what things are not.
Like it starts with - it is not this, and does not do this. Kind of stuff when you ask what it does.
it finally ended!
i would say 99% every chatgpt model is still doing heavy mistakes
Is there a way to get more detailed information about what the βExecβ usage consists of? Over the last few days, more than 90% of my usage has been classified as exec, and Iβve now hit my weekly limit because of it. Iβd like to analyze what exactly caused it.
Omg these questions make me want to smoke π¬ ππ
I can feel my hair getting greyer
You can relax though. There's a limit to how grey hair can get.
It's like, oh you already have good architecture so let's see how we can turn agentic efficiency up to 11, going on about agent task contracts.
well the documentation is ready, time to start implementing, this thing better work in one go before i pull punches
using credit with 5.5 is so crazy, the credit disappears like it's breeze
I found/made a cheat code lol. After about 25 questions, I said to it,
Your recommended answers have all have extremely good so far. So, please stop asking me to answer questions and instead, shift into an autonomous question and answer mode. For the next 10 questions or until you're done, whichever comes first, ask the question and then use your recommended answer. After every 10 questions, or until you're finished, you should stop and present a brief summary of your questions and answers for those 10, and then I will ask you to change answers or proceed with the next 10 questions.
This is why I'm switching to pro come months end
Hillarious, though you can probably make that actually useful if you ask it to try to model you for the answers.
well I wasn't lying when I said its recommended answers were good, I've used all but one of them for 25 questions so I figured it would be faster to just review 10 recommendations at a time
nice π
that is smart, I will do that next time.
What are you doing that requires so many questions though?
Agentic workflow efficiency, working on agent task contracts
The contract should separate path intent into expectedTouchedPaths, requiredCompanions, and outOfScopePaths; validate path shape/existence but leave implementation drift to PR review. It should carry schema/profile versions, concise notes, profile-level stop conditions, additive extra commands, explicit human acceptance requirements, an approval trace in humanDecisions, simple dates, and lightweight ownership for decisions/questions.```
I could fill up this Discord channel with the details lmao
So the output is an AGENTS file?
the output is a contract, well a profiled set of draft contracts that agents will refer to orchestrate large changes and feature implementations, and explicit instructions about how to understand the scope and blast radius of any given task
Interesting. I like it. π
basically to change poking around in an AGENTS file to "this is precisely what needs to be done and precisely how to do it" based on the task profile.
That will be very useful
AI agents and models trying their best to pretend humans are still necessary π
I mean its designed that way for a purpose though
lol I told it to add the human acceptance requirement, I bet it wouldn't if I didn't π
AI and robotics will always be designed to wait for human will if we intend to keep being anything but annoying flies lol
[hopefully]
in a couple years, a 5 year old will be able to make their own games with Codex
just by being upfront "I'm 5 years old, make this entire game for me"
and it will
why 5 lol
Steam search function is already obsolete its just that people dont know how to use Codex etc
well it's not quite so simple to make a creative work, good games are still a long way away from being fully vibe coded, there is a lot that goes into it
i hope monday come no limit reset and steal 40% of remaining
I mean there's a difference between a spreadsheet and a management game
one is data and the other is art
I kind of feel my game is both
I have been thinking about that precisely past whole week.
I think theres something there that can be solved in future like... right now we are talking about engineering and designing games. That was invented back when you needed 50,000 people to make a game (some companies still do this today)
But what if players soon remove the middleman?
But I mean, I've been using codex heavily for around 3 weeks, trying to make a galaxy generator that fits my requirements.
People are talking about doing that for fitness apps and etc already instead of paying 50$/m in fitness programs
most games are a bit of both of course but the user experience isn't something AI can fully comprehend, so a good game still comes down to how people "feel" about it when they play it
the trouble is, that middleman knows a lot of stuff. He's there not just because he makes things possible, but because he knows how to make things possible. You can tell an AI "make this game for me" but the nuances of the user experience are why the middleman can never be replaced, the AI can make the game but they can't understand the emotion it evokes when it's being played and make changes based on that feeling.
I think this is 100% accurate for an average casual gamer
The player also often doesn't know what would be fun
but most indie developers become indie developers because they were obsessed about gaming and fun stuff. Their whole job is to make games they would enjoy playing ultimately right
Theres a lot of complexity and theory you begin to see in game design that takes 10 years of playing games AND THEN 10 more years of making games... so I think you are right
I think most technically make slop for mobile. π
I've been thinking of how games work, and what makes them fun or not, in an analytical way since the early 90s.
I think today an obsessive gamer who wants to make a game reality that does not exist yet can totally pick up Codex and through trial and error and iteration make something incredible. It wont take them 20 years of experience or any talent
Its about "dream game" not about "shiet imma get paid for this"
No. It's not that easy.
the player, reasonably so, is not going to know about all the nuances that go into the reason why their experience with a certain game is so powerful, they're going to focus on the end result and how it left them feeling when they finished playing it. Then they'll try to use an AI agent to create a game based on that feeling and the agent will inevitably fail to actually give them what they wanted, primarily because they don't even know how to technically describe what they want.
If they really wanna make it happen and they got time. Its totally doable
so technically the middleman is always removed if you got a good enough motivation for it
but I guess that was true even in past with so many indie devs lol
yeah its crazy
normal players dont notice this. they just have fun
so... true
that's true in the same way it's true you can become a pilot or a lawyer lol, you can do what you want but it's not going to end up the way you expect unless you're the one who is making the executive decisions and you can't make decisions about questions you don't even know to ask. Hence the middleman, this is why we will always have real human doctors too.
yeah but you cant deny the gap is closing like crazy...
so win win I guess.
in past you needed million dollars in hit kickstarter funding and then some more from investment firms to make an ambitious game
No AI will spend the attention to detail on things like what galaxy generation looks like as I am doing. It's not needed for the game, but it's needed for the artistic expression.
well ofc
I'm not saying the AI can't do it, I'm just saying the AI is going to do it in a way that is different from what the user expects without the kind of instruction that can only come from a deep understanding of how games are made
Tons of this type of details go into making a game, which is why I think it will take a long time before AI can remove the middleman
I am not here arguing that AI will replace humans in games
I am considering possibility of role of game developer shifting into a gamer more
I don't think so. Not for quite a while. Maybe never. Becaus of what Andrew is saying.
Right now game developers and game stores (app store/googleplay/steam) operating like middlemen
In future some gamers might want something custom
isnt Elon even working on live streamed video-gen games? now thats gonna be crazy if it ever works even sloppily
Game development isn't another angle of gaming. It's inherently different, because it requires a different skillset.
You can be a bad player, and a good game dev
Ofc. and yet theres something about making games in cold and technical way that doesnt work, no?
best way of making valuable games is making games that are fun and replayable, not trailer and release date hype value
because lots of games rely on that today and in past
ofc. but what? im trying to figure it out thats why I am saying this xD
like if it isnt players job to know what they like, then how are game designers special? arent they just more analytical gamers?
I often look at my own games, especially nowdays that Codex makes new features and iterations so instant