#[Emilia] New Unit Megathread

1 messages · Page 4 of 1

proper plaza
ocean widget
#

SBS in the corner

proper plaza
#

Nah 50% is not enough

olive scarab
#

If we assume 20% charge speed as a more realistic / normal example

  • Burst takes 3.8 seconds
  • Normal takes 0.8 seconds
  • Could fire 4.75 NA in that time
  • Burst goes from 4.75x to 5.12x damage
proper plaza
#

Need to do 6 hits compared to burst duration

#

It is not that simple

olive scarab
proper plaza
#

Because attack has innate 0.2s delay

olive scarab
#

the innate delay?

dapper oar
#

theres an innate delay

#

on attack

olive scarab
#

so many innate delays in this game

dapper oar
#

.

proper plaza
#

More attack = more delay in total

olive scarab
#

I see, so with 20%

  • Burst takes 4 (3.8 +0.2) seconds
  • NA takes 1, occurs 4 times (0.8x4 + 0.2x4)

So it's 4x vs 5.12x

dapper oar
#

with 56% (maximum charge speed we can effectively get without full griefing) should be right around 5 shots if u let her just shoot

#

.44(1-.56)+.36666(innate) = .806

proper plaza
#

Need 6 to match

#

5 will still lose to burst

dapper oar
#

u can get faster if u manual

proper plaza
#

And 12 to be banned

dapper oar
#

manual still has some delay doesnt it? think

proper plaza
#

Yes

#

Let s call it 0.2s delay

#

Lowest bar

dapper oar
#

so if u manual u can get 6.25

#

and thats pretty stacked on CS

olive scarab
#

Stepping aside from the burst being an active demerit, let's take a hypothetical standard anti-water team of:

Liter/Blanc/Xmas Lud/Emilia/Noir

It's almost certain, that for any amount of charge speed, Noir burst will be better than Emilia

#

So you'd be better off swapping Emilia & Noir spots

dapper oar
#

with no charge speed we return to this

#

448.32% conversion + full burst bonus

#

noir is 351.64% conversion without fullburst bonus

#

+emilia can hit core/per part

proper plaza
#

Noir burst > Emilia

#

dafuq bruh

olive scarab
#

maybe that was a bit much

dapper oar
#

i dont think i would use emilia on no part boss so i expect 2-3x generally think

#

with 1 part+body or 2part+body

olive scarab
#

I'm considering her use for potentially pushing water stages

#

being our second decent water DPS

dapper oar
#

well it would still be per mob then but in campaign wave pushing theres also overflow u have to worry about

#

like i can sw burst a rapture and get tons of dmg but its not effective dmg

olive scarab
#

I won't lie I forget just how bad Noir's burst is lol

#

so used to burst 3 units have strong bursts that actually do stuff

dapper oar
#

but i think in campaign its also important to consider the burst explosion range increase

#

since campaign is usually more spreadout on mob layout

#

so u would likely be bursting anyways? think

olive scarab
#

her range probably isn't good enough tbh

#

campaign is too spread

dapper oar
#

shes same range is a2

#

a2 base and s1 is the same as her base and burst at the same levels

proper plaza
#

around 60% charge speed. With M-san help per hit

dapper oar
proper plaza
dapper oar
#

i have to change my rythem when burst happens

proper plaza
#

RL works as "bar" so there's checkpoint

#

41%
60%

#

anything inbetween falls to 41%

#

41% CS, which is 13.01% from S1

dapper oar
#

bar?

olive scarab
#

Oh wow, didn't know that

dapper oar
proper plaza
#

so 28% from CS

dapper oar
#

so ur telling me

#

cs works in breakpoints

#

y does it work in breakpoints

proper plaza
#

because 3.9/0.79 needs to be INT

#

what does 3.7 hit RL bring me?

#

3 hit

#

what does 3.99 hit RL bring me?

#

3 hit

dapper oar
#

r u trying to fit it in a certain ammount of time

proper plaza
#

yep

dapper oar
#

ah that makes more sense

proper plaza
#

burst charge vs hit normal instead

#

anyway, the lowest you can tolerate is 28%

#

which is 7% from each line

dapper oar
#

tbf 3.99 hit gives u 3 hits + 1 hit without full burst

#

i dont just lose .99 charge when it ends

proper plaza
#

there's still full burst

#

whatever we do, it's still 4s during fb

#

but it's out of boundary

dapper oar
#

ya but i mean if u get 3.99 shots during full burst

proper plaza
dapper oar
#

u get 3 shots in and 1 shot out

#

my .99 doesnt disapear unless timer ends

olive scarab
# proper plaza because 3.9/0.79 needs to be INT

I need to go sleep, but I think my conclusion is that her burst is slightly better than Noir, but in any 1/1/3 team Emilia is likely best placed in the fifth slot.

A Doro/Rem/B3/B3/Emilia team would lead to some hilarious post-match stats. Highest DPS could be anyone (well probably Doro)

dapper oar
#

gatrix

proper plaza
#

from Hermit

#

just stop bursting Emilia in PVP

dapper oar
#

do i 10/7/7 rem

proper plaza
#

no, you 10/4/4

dapper oar
#

but theres an ammo breakpoint at 7

olive scarab
#

10/4/10

dapper oar
#

no books

olive scarab
#

skill issue

dapper oar
#

i want to get my emilia higher skills

#

but i need to figure out my rem skills first

golden ridge
#

S1 can only compete with like 30+ max ammo.

dapper oar
#

rem

golden ridge
#

I did the maths.

#

Oh.

#

10/4/7

#

Or 10/4/10

#

Emilia is the one who doesnt need burst leveled unless its for Nihilister (in which case need 7)

#

But is it?

#

Does it have to be 7?

#

Where the fuck did @static maple get 7 from

dapper oar
#

i havent tested explosion range in pve

static maple
#

Wdym

dapper oar
#

7 is for pvp splash

golden ridge
#

Nihilister

dapper oar
#

iirc

static maple
golden ridge
#

See 6

#

Why need 7

#

Usseless

#

Dont burst with her in arena and save 7 days of grinding

static maple
#

Bich because
PvP needs 7

So I recommend upping it to 7 regardless

golden ridge
#

No I don't

#

Id leave it at 6

#

7/7/6 in particular

#

2B ate too much

#

If I hadnt invested in 2B

#

Last raid

#

I would have 10/10/7 her

proper plaza
#

where did it bring you?

static maple
#

Who are you talking wbout

golden ridge
static maple
#

You would upgrade Emilia skill 1?

golden ridge
#

Lmao

static maple
#

To 10?

proper plaza
golden ridge
#

Maybe or maybenot

#

But Rem is definitely 10/4/10

#

And thats no excuse

proper plaza
#

really

#

10/1/1

#

I call it

golden ridge
#

Wow

#

I bet Nihilist be like

dapper oar
#

im poor

static maple
#

Why do you want rem burst to 10

dapper oar
#

hand over ur books

golden ridge
#

Atk buff?

#

Its much better than Emilia

static maple
#

Man this is too expensive

#

No f2p can afford these chars

dapper oar
golden ridge
#

2B, Drake, and Guillo are in line for resets.

#

Already.

#

Half anniv, all back to 1 1 1.

dapper oar
#

i already reset 2b and never had drake humu

unborn surge
#

Guil for elysuon tower Copium

proper plaza
#

imagine 10/10/7 2B

#

bricked

golden ridge
#

@proper plaza ur damage chart

#

How many parts for Emilia

proper plaza
#

4

#

so much

#

should be 3 but well

#

4 phase 1 + 2 phase 2

#

3

golden ridge
#

Anyways

#

Doro Rem SAnis Privaty Biscuit

#

Biscuit no burst

#

Jk

proper plaza
golden ridge
#

Dont

proper plaza
#

yeah

#

don't

golden ridge
#

If Rem is to stay

#

Then Emilia is to stay as well

#

And next half Anniv is gonna be SG

#

@proper plaza was Tove after RH?

static maple
#

Yeah, right after

golden ridge
#

When was Leona and PrivM?

#

One after another?

#

RedHood SR
Tove AR
XLud MG, XMica SMG
SBS RL
Leona SG
PrivM SG
Moran AR
Elegg MG
D Killer Wife SR
Emilia RL
Rem MG
Ram SR

#

SG and AR are appearing soon.

#

SMG too.

dapper oar
#

surely itll be the b3 meta dps healer cdr pilgrim

golden ridge
#

No

#

It will be B3 DPS with stack refresh, healing, and full burst extension

worldly fulcrum
#

dropping 2 cdr almost back to back would be crazy

static maple
#

Also it's half anniv lol

#

Doro was a cdr

#

Right after sakura

limber gulch
#

Just curious, I skimmed through the prydwen review and I’m curious why Emilia is given SS for both story ratings and also SS for PvP considering it seems like her use in PvP is far above pve use. The article even says she is only a “solid situational unit to use for campaign”?

proper plaza
#

because she hits very hard on mob

#

harder than A2

#

and A2 is considered very great for clearing constantly

#

this was when A2 dealt double dmg on S2

#

Emilia is even better than this, so you tell me, is she great?

#

note that it was 37% deficit

#

which serves the condition of this tierlist (>30%)

limber gulch
#

Ok that makes sense. Didn’t realize that there was a hard criteria for the letter rankings regarding story. It just felt like the article itself was underselling her Pve performance and praising her PvP yet they both had the same letter rating.

oak marsh
proper plaza
#

how to get to boss

worldly fulcrum
oak marsh
surreal sorrel
#

Emilia is S tier and above? poggies

proper plaza
#

Mod burst to pass 14-12

#

I give you that

oak marsh
# proper plaza Mod burst to pass 14-12

前半をやり過ごせれば勝機あり

開幕ではアリスで雑魚をすぐに減らして被弾を減らしつつ、次の雑魚も適当に倒していきます。
2回目のバーストでは全員をハイドさせ、モダニアで雑魚を一掃すれば安全です(ここまでリトライ地獄でした)

最後は全力でボスを殴って終了。
モダニアの自己バフが5スタックで維持出来るようにダメージコントロール出来たら、もう少し早くボスを倒せたでしょうね。

▶ Play video
proper plaza
#

yeah have you seen A2 clear that stage

#

pretty much burst then auto lol

#

no mald, nothing

oak marsh
proper plaza
hidden fossil
surreal sorrel
#

Emilia is probably going to suck when it comes to beating up a typical wave boss

#

But often it isn’t the issue of killing that wave boss in a vacuum, it’s also a problem of getting there sufficiently intact… or clearing the enemies that escort it

#

Kind of like how Harran might be still viable for wave stages

#

But at least Emilia does much better against bosses that have parts you’re supposed to destroy, than Harran

proper plaza
#

most ver 1 Lord class bosses don't have parts

#

may be Laitance?

#

rebuilt version, well

static maple
#

She just stops one shotting

#

Completely

#

Harran when 35% deficit hits

proper plaza
#

I don't know if she's available even after 30%

#

but may be with Tyga helps

buoyant rivet
#

is she worth to get?

surreal sorrel
#

Depends on how many other great S tier or better you have

#

And your priorities

#

She’s good to get for PvP, Solo Raid, and even PvE. Check pins for more information

surreal sorrel
#

Emilia + A2!

wraith kraken
#

Emilia is taking some time to nuke mobs

#

The problem as always are skill books to do fast test ...

#

Another idea is to burst with A2 first and let her stay in mode B with Rem sustaining her, you can then forget her and burst with 2 other DPS like SBS, Emilia ... during the fight

#

Anyway it's needing test

acoustic timber
#

Im definitely pulling for rem, but is it worth it to still pull emilia if i already have sbs and laplace as my rl b3s

surreal sorrel
#

You can just multiply Emilia’s final damage by the number of expected parts for a close approximation

vapid tiger
#

how hard we skipping @static maple ? ScarletHeh

vapid tiger
#

Now I regret it

#

She stalks me

static maple
#

You don't PvP now? Momo left your PvP server iirc

vapid tiger
#

Yes

#

Pvp gone

static maple
#

Damn

vapid tiger
#

I am the evil one now

static maple
vapid tiger
#

Saving for rem

#

Best unit

static maple
vapid tiger
#

Overlord collab

#

Pls

static maple
icy zealot
#

no overlame collab. Konosuba > Tanya > ReZero Pt2 > Do 0 more collabs > Overlame

limber gulch
#

yeah overlame is truly lame

unborn surge
#

Boku no pico collab

vapid tiger
#

I need albedo the rest can go

ocean orbit
#

I keep seeing people keeping emilia's burst at lvl 4

#

is it that mediocre?

hidden fossil
#

Im expecting long term to have her 10 10 10

#

But no skill mats

#

We need perma full burst days

olive scarab
# ocean orbit I keep seeing people keeping emilia's burst at lvl 4

Her Burst adds very little to her overall damage. If we ignore the range buff it's basically a Noir tier burst (ok, slightly better than Noir but not by much)

Level 6 is enough for the range buff to enable hitting multiple parts with Nihilister.

Level 7 is enough to hit all 5 enemy. Nikke in PvP

These are both niche enough that many are keeping her at 4.

icy zealot
#

also most are saving to dump into Rems Burst which will have greater return

proper plaza
#

why are we still in Noir fiesta?

#

each diff of Emilia burst vs 3 hits RL is 3x times Noir burst

#

what the hell is this barely different

hidden fossil
#

Also u dont use noir burst for the dmg

#

U use for the hit rate in theory

mighty jewel
#

u use noir burst so mod doesn’t burst kekD

proper plaza
#

fact

#

I don't even remember Noir burst effect

#

it deals some forgetful dmg, meaningless hit rate

#

and not letting Mod burst

icy zealot
#

I've only used noir burst for mod. Only Minas uses it for dps

timid sonnet
#

how far is this true

hidden fossil
#

S as boss solo makes sense

#

everything else doesnt matter kekw

icy zealot
#

S2 really carries her in PVE

hidden fossil
#

tbh idk how most ppl push story but from what i see in really high hard mode levels

#

is just tia naga mod alice rh or tia liter naga mod rh

#

p much no one else other than ocassionally slotting some ele in

sour ingot
#

Can she instant kill elite rapture in hard stage to get SS tier PES_ThinkAboutIt

proper plaza
#

SS where

mighty jewel
sour ingot
#

Right, that tier list look like a bait for me wahahaha

proper plaza
sour ingot
#

Well my MW is shiet so have to use SW instead deadge

#

But look like Emilia can't be alternative ATM

mighty jewel
#

if there’s 20 mobs in the screen with the target and the 20 procs of s2 hit the target, maybe

#

but otherwise

rugged viper
#

I never understood why a lot of people hate prydwen

hidden fossil
#

Prydwen has improved

#

I take all credit

icy zealot
#

overall, its just opinions

#

but when it comes to tier list, visually, I think Prydwens is miles above the one NIKKE GG uses

#

as I think NIKKE GG's tier list is not visually organized well

olive scarab
#

Prydwen was the one which had separate tier lists for current bugged vs theoretical non bugged on game launch right?

#

I've always had a soft spot for them after that

hidden fossil
#

Nikke gg people are in my union and i still use prdywen wahahaha

proper plaza
#

Nikke gg review when

#

can't wait for them to berate Emilia

remote wind
golden ridge
#

Prydwen is the most valid one.

#

Nikke.gg has always given the same review as Prydwen.

#

Nikke.gg even said they copied Prydwen, and that's why their reviews are mostly late. I mean 1 person vs 3 people.

#

It's just Prydwen has many haters.

#

When everything is backed up by a lot of sources.

#

By many top rankers in SR and campaign tryhards.

proper plaza
#

nikke gg gives same review

#

Nikke gg is correct, prydwen bad

golden ridge
#

They have always had.

#

Look at SBS Story rating.

#

Literally the exact same fucking wording.

#

But they don't get backlashed.

#

People just listen to their desires and ego, my friend.

proper plaza
#

everytime people ask for SBS clearing, I show them 244F

icy zealot
golden ridge
#

Haters gonna hate.

proper plaza
#

most haven't reached that point

icy zealot
#

As for which one is accurate, I think they both are

proper plaza
golden ridge
#

Prydwen's becoming popular thanks to the controversy, however.

icy zealot
#

Criteria is similar enough with different takes

rugged viper
icy zealot
golden ridge
#

And so far, Prydwen is still leading versus Nikke.gg.

#

Based on web analytics.

#

It doesn't matter.

icy zealot
#

but i just learned a couple days ago pry has skill data now too

icy zealot
#

and, once again, the presentation for skill data on pry is better

golden ridge
#

Yeah thats thanks to Gatrix and Snake.

#

Im lazy af to make those

proper plaza
#

prydwen won't have skill per lv. Something I can guarantee

icy zealot
#

at the end of the day, use what you like.. I use both for different reasons

golden ridge
#

Prydwen just needs reconfirmation from Skyjlv, Timmaeus, and maybe Kira/Austin, or other creators.

icy zealot
#

Having multiple opinions on a "tier list" can be healthy. And tier lists dont really capture where the player is at anyways in the righ way

golden ridge
#

People listen to creators more.

icy zealot
#

i dont

#

Dont watch a single creator like them

golden ridge
#

Most.

icy zealot
#

didnt even know who sky was until a few days ago

#

I know tim cause he has a cool discord with cute stickers

golden ridge
#

Thats dumb wahahaha

remote wind
icy zealot
golden ridge
#

He felt offended

remote wind
icy zealot
#

regardless. I look forward to seeing how Nikke.gg rates emilia

#

and cant wait to see how rem truly interacts with her

golden ridge
icy zealot
#

who runs it

golden ridge
#

Snake's boyfriend

#

Valkin

icy zealot
#

sounds good

simple rock
# golden ridge People listen to creators more.

i usually avoids cc cuz above all most cc want the view/clicks so their review mostly on the opposite side of both ends (OP vs useless) cuz its more clickbaity than just "eh its okay"

i trust google spreadsheet created by discord theorycrafters more XD (though i think some cc also involved in this works)

proper plaza
#

don't trust me

icy zealot
#

which i wont accuse sky or tim doing because i dont know them

#

but at the end of the day, people DO like it because they like the "personality" and the entertainment, so they have value. At the end of the day, they make money on it, and some make a LOT. They have charisma, so they are pretty good.

obtuse prism
#

sky do extensive test, you can thrust him

golden ridge
#

Tim and SkyJlv are pretty neutral

#

Zxous is pretty biased

#

And likes following drama/trends

proper plaza
#

thrust sky

terse portal
#

To not trust you

golden ridge
#

On the other hand we have one more

icy zealot
#

I dont judge them as bad. I just dont care for it. They are successful in something I couldnt ever do. So they are better than me in that aspect. I can admit that

golden ridge
#

Sefhi

#

Which is interesting as hell

simple rock
#

i watch sky video once, jesus christ he indeed do the speeadsheet shenanigans which is good

but for tim personally i found him can be a bit clickbaity sometimes

golden ridge
#

So much randomness

icy zealot
#

the whole Emilia thing though

proper plaza
#

Sku has Altros to back him up, his review is definitely worth listening to

icy zealot
#

i see so many damn clickbait titles

golden ridge
#

Tim is a generic comtent creator

icy zealot
#

id rather just lurk here ask questions and harass @proper plaza until he tells me

golden ridge
#

And hes uh old?

proper plaza
#

but lastest Sky video was 5 days ago, so it could be outdated

golden ridge
#

No, as im

#

In

#

Its the content that most people his age make

simple rock
proper plaza
#

because the video was probably theorycrafting

#

not real testing

golden ridge
proper plaza
#

Emilia S2 is way better than we expected

#

like, way too strong

simple rock
#

fair enough

proper plaza
#

hit so many targets

simple rock
#

what i enjoy the most in the discord though, seeing real time shift from mocking a char kit pre release to praising it post release XD

#

and vice versa

golden ridge
#

Im never wrong

#

I didnt shittalk Emilia

#

I was the only one who said Emilia was broken

#

My review is never wrong

#

Valkin's probably not wrong but he takes 30 days

#

And Austin says every char is mid except Elegg and Moran

#

Which are kinda mid

proper plaza
#

add Rem

#

Remid

golden ridge
#
  • Never trust Austin.
#
  • Always trust me.
#
  • Never trust Snake.
#
  • Consider trusting Gatrix when he is arguing without his sheet as proof.
#
  • Trust Valkin 99% of the time.
simple rock
golden ridge
#

He gave an L advice once in maincord.

proper plaza
golden ridge
#

Like very L.

#

If that was Prydwen,

proper plaza
#

look at this baldsenix

golden ridge
#

Prydwen will get 90% dislikes.

proper plaza
golden ridge
#

What Valkin said was:

  • Mod doesn't need hitrate OL.
#

And everyone somehow agrees.

#
  • Forgets the fact that in Campaign, you are out of Burst half of the time.
proper plaza
#

that sounds like Austin

golden ridge
#

Austin wouldn't say that.

#

Unless he specifically mentions for bossing it's fine.

proper plaza
#

@hidden fossil confirm that Mod doesn't need hit rate

hidden fossil
golden ridge
#

For bossing no hitrate is ok.

#

You miss first 200 shots.

hidden fossil
#

idk how u guys play campaign lol

golden ridge
#

Thats what he said.

hidden fossil
#

u dont need hit rate evne for campaign

golden ridge
hidden fossil
#

at this point i just assume u guys r playing wrong

golden ridge
hidden fossil
#

@golden ridge wat do u think about

#

emilia into mother whale

#

should be busted right?

#

im on the campaign boss for mother whale in hard mode

#

maybe i wait till rem comes out and fight and record

#

liter rem a2 emilia noir?

#

wait

#

no noir

proper plaza
#

why are you so obsessed with Rem

hidden fossil
#

shes busted

#

idk why ur not obessed

proper plaza
#

busted your nuts

hidden fossil
#

oh doro rem a2 emilia privaty NoirStare

#

campaign mother whale parts are tanky it looks like

olive scarab
#

You'll know Nikke GG is stealing when it steals the typos too

#

Lowers her charge time considerably to increase charge damage for one shot.

If Nikke GG also accidentally says Emilia's burst lowers charge time, as opposed to lowering charge speed or increasing charge time, we know they're pure thieves without doubt

hidden fossil
#

@tribal grail better not catch u plagiarising

tribal grail
#

Time to plagiarize

#

Pretty sure Prydwen's web analytics counts for literally the whole domain

proper plaza
#

it is

#

baldsexnix

tribal grail
#

although i am surprised according to the web analytic that
around 44ish%? view nikke.gg and the rest for prydwen in the tier list

#

when my tier list is
visually extremely inferior

Not even my most viewed thing on nikke.gg either

mighty jewel
#

what is

#

i wonder if the advise cheatsheet table that I yoinked to a personal google sheet and have it in a pinned tab count as views

tribal grail
#

Welp, time to actually do work or something

tribal grail
tribal grail
#

AHHAHAHAHAHHA
that's great.

proper plaza
#

what the

#

dat advertising

tribal grail
#

Absolutely based ads

mighty jewel
#

i'm surprised they even do ads

surreal sorrel
#

Nikke.gg still has no tier for Emilia, Prydwen has S and SS tiers for Emilia

#

I have no idea what tier she is because of her niche as RL like A2, but would say whatever tier A2 was, it should be absolutely at least the same in PvE and better in PvP for Emilia

proper plaza
#

A2 before burst is pure dog shit

#

Not her appearance

#

She is pretty

ocean widget
#

Emilia for most people rn is probably mid cuz saving mats and gear exp for Rem kek

proper plaza
#

Remid

#

I call it first

#

Cant wait to see their shattered dreams

dapper oar
proper plaza
#

Re:mid

proper plaza
dapper oar
#

im still confused what u mean Kek

proper plaza
#

Just do it

ocean widget
#

Emilia's performing much better than I'd expected with low investment, so that's nice at least

ocean widget
dapper oar
#

surely they wont make that buff timeout

#

like dwife

surreal sorrel
#

Did anyone test if Emilia’s burst selfbuff is considered a debuff?

#

Does Ade backstab Emilia like she does A2?

ocean widget
#

For purposes of Ade and Cocoa?

#

Yes

surreal sorrel
#

Never trust a smiling maid

#

NEVER

ocean widget
#

Loses both the charge speed debuff AND charge damage buff

#

X Mica safe tho

surreal sorrel
#

I view that as a pure bug, ShiftUp needs to get up and reclassify this better

ocean widget
#

I mean, this has existed since Cocoa came out. thonk

#

And Privaty shows that it's not a bug, but simply how they decided to implement the skills coding-wise delugiggle

#

cuz unless I'm remembering wrong, Privaty's ATK buff remains even if the Max Ammo debuff is cleansed

surreal sorrel
#

I say it’s a bug, and the reason is most likely because they added on dispels later

#

In other words, dispel (or more aptly named “cleanse”) didn’t exist in the game at all

ocean widget
#

A2 was added after Cocoa

#

so if there's a bug, it's that Privaty's ATK buff remains kek

proper plaza
#

But same like guillo

#

Too hard to buff her

ocean widget
#

But considering she's primarily a healer that outdamages any other healer, doesn't that make her auto-meta?

dapper oar
#

shes a b2, she eats marciana's spot

#

surely

#

probably eats novel's spot too

oak marsh
#

BlancStare elegg?

ocean widget
#

Novel's been dead for a few raids now, no?

dapper oar
#

thats cuz our raids started to hurt

mighty jewel
#

novel is kinda dead because there's not enough cdr b1's

dapper oar
#

my highest atker is limping

mighty jewel
#

or any cdr b3

ocean widget
#

Also because Novel is garbage overall

mighty jewel
#

if there's a b3 cdr, pepper+novel can be a thing

ocean widget
#

Good burst (once she actually gets stacks), but completely useless as a Defender and deals no damage

mighty jewel
#

pepper heals and make novel stack up faster

ocean widget
#

She's literally just her burst

dapper oar
mighty jewel
#

but ofc that means you manual pepper

dapper oar
#

imagine rh/max/alice/sw without burst

#

🚮

ocean widget
mighty jewel
#

dolla as a b2 sniper cthulu_cry

ocean widget
#

If Dolla didn't have CDR, 🚮

surreal sorrel
#

I’ll just wait for Rem kit, it sounds good, detailed analysis can wait ‘til people find out whether the hype is real kekw

proper plaza
#

it's dead to me

#

SS Rem

dapper oar
#

wait ss is dead?

oak marsh
proper plaza
#

Noah right?

proper plaza
#

I use Noah

#

only nub run Nihi

ocean widget
#

Yeah, Dorothy + Noah + Mod burst = permanent burst chain sip

#

My shard is dead anyway, so towers are akkoShrug

mighty jewel
dapper oar
proper plaza
#

yep

dapper oar
#

rem prob the strongest SS in that list

proper plaza
#

I will suggest dropping all current SS to S

dapper oar
proper plaza
#

so Rem is the only SS in Solo Boss

#

which is very fair

dapper oar
#

3rd best dead to tswift

proper plaza
#

dead

#

trust

dapper oar
#

engraved on tomestone "not duo" - gatrix 2024

proper plaza
dapper oar
#

i think marciana having a spot there really shows u the state of b2 non duo

proper plaza
#

I actually want to make it like this

#

D and Doro feel like clown comparing to Liter and Tia

dapper oar
#

i think d is pretty good

#

due to current meta

#

surely she will get either rh alice or maxwell

#

right

proper plaza
#

which supports 2 units

dapper oar
#

or multiple of them

proper plaza
#

Maxwell is not... well

dapper oar
#

better than nothing

#

but surely she gets atleast 1 of those units right

ocean widget
#

D is good cuz pierce OP

#

and CDR OP

dapper oar
#

Only good cuz of our good snipers atm Doro

ocean widget
#

Wait for Crown pierce RL copium

proper plaza
#

good because of 2 units

#

SSS

dapper oar
#

How does pierce rl even mean

dapper oar
surreal sorrel
dapper oar
#

I think if/when rh and Alice aren't as

ocean widget
#

Dorothy being incompatible with ammo increases makes her automatically below Liter imo

dapper oar
#

High tier

#

She drops right beside them

proper plaza
#

people used to ride Doro because of her dmg

#

well back then top 1 DPS was Modernia

ocean widget
#

Liter can go into practically any team

dapper oar
proper plaza
#

now Modernia is the benchmark for being good

dapper oar
surreal sorrel
dapper oar
#

I think if our parts were like blacksmith

#

Where they exist the whole time

#

Doro is pretty good

surreal sorrel
#

Something I want to ask as well, do we downgrade other units if something comes out that powercreeps them?

dapper oar
#

They just kinda murdered all the parts HP since she came tho

surreal sorrel
#

Say something is released that does double everything Red Hood can do

worldly fulcrum
#

doro has the issue of basically no supporting capability

worldly fulcrum
#

privaty is basically the only buffer in final shot

dapper oar
#

It's better to knock down tiers than flood ur sss

#

To the point where it has no meaning

proper plaza
#

we demoted A2 because Emilia is just better A2

#

yep

#

that's why D and Doro

#

will be D

#

I mean SS

worldly fulcrum
#

doro should be SS

#

she only has one team

dapper oar
worldly fulcrum
#

liter and D can move between technically any team

surreal sorrel
#

Liter moves into S Anis team
S Anis shoots Liter, “get your filthy max ammo buff away from me!”

lyric herald
# worldly fulcrum she only has one team

doro doesnt just have one team shes just much better in that team so theres no reason to put her elsewhere especially since other teams can benefit from buffer supports

surreal sorrel
#

How much weaker does Dorothy get if she is in a max ammo squad? Like bunnies?

#

Let’s focus on the pure CDR part

lyric herald
#

ive used her with bunnies in campaign plenty, most of the time my cdr was just fine

surreal sorrel
#

So probably Dorothy is also “technically any team” fine too

dapper oar
#

it depends how much of a malder u are

#

my d at lvl 7 was not fine for me

#

i saw 1s cd

lyric herald
#

i gotta say tho i dont have my noir skill maxed that gives ammo so maybe there is some misplay if its a maxed skill, i think i have it on 6?

surreal sorrel
#

The lack of cover repair and instant gratification on burst is why she can’t handle Smol Liter

lyric herald
#

damn u really see cd with level 7? stare i didnt last union raid on the alice sbs team

ocean widget
#

Dorothy with bunnies (maxed Noir) with a high burst gen unit like Alice will see potentially up to 5s delay

#

if you're using a slow-gen comp like Modlet, then it doesn't cause much issue

#

I can't stand Dorothy with bunnies

worldly fulcrum
#

doro gets potentially cucked a lot yeah

lyric herald
#

if u play it well it really is not that bad

#

if u burst right when doro reloads u can get x2 cdr back to back

#

full burst i mean

#

like u start the burst and she goes on reload

#

then u full burst

#

and get another

dapper oar
#

if ur timing ur burst and delaying it ur inherently losing cdr

lyric herald
#

shes a 60 ammo unit its really not that hard to do

dapper oar
#

ya but if u delay ur full burst by 1-2s

#

u basically lost 1-2s of cdr

#

since ur next burst cycle is delayed 1-2s ect

lyric herald
#

im pretty sure u dont miss a full burst rotation overall but maybe im wrong i havent tested it properly shruge

dapper oar
#

depends on the stage usually

#

like some stages u just rh b1 twice and win uwucat

lyric herald
#

but either way i wouldnt really put her with bunnies in most cases anyway, as u say its better to just do red hood now

dapper oar
#

over 3 min boss fight i would expect some loss if u even delay 1s asuming ur team has the gen

proper plaza
#

it's so simple

#

Doro during fb = 1 ~ 2 proc S1 max

#

Doro during FB with priv = 3 ~ 4 proc S1, max

rugged viper
golden ridge
#

Rem is def SSS

proper plaza
#

over my dead body

golden ridge
#

U have no power

proper plaza
surreal sorrel
#

Rem is now SSS

rugged viper
#

Can Emilia with good overloads one shoot chatterbox or blacksmith in SI EX?

#

Chatty has 3 parts and blacky 2

worldly fulcrum
#

probably not

#

iirc only SW nuke can do that

#

and hers isn’t as good as maxwell’s right

rugged viper
#

I mean, I'll continue using Rh cuz she is auto free everything

#

But more options are always good

oak marsh
tribal grail
#

My rather unraised Emilia

Dealt 30m on BS

#

Surely
With
70% more ED and skill levels

rugged viper
#

Ok back to Rh auto

icy zealot
#

@static maple

#

put her above A2

slender oak
#

snake is gone for a while Sadge

sand cloak
#

You know what they should put in order from best to least for each tier in nikke gg

gloomy goblet
#

Rip a2

#

Refund when

solemn kelp
rugged viper
rugged viper
#

auto train

golden ridge
sacred citrus
humble bluff
#

damn prydwn said emelia better than A2, cap or nah

proper plaza
#

and with that, we are done with review

mighty jewel
#

check if it's written by chatgpt

proper plaza
#

he ran the math then said burst doesn't gain much dmg compared to just shoot

#

burst just deals double dmg compared to normal shooting and not much

#

I guess SS is mid, in the end

mighty jewel
#

ah yes the squarespace of Nikkeverse

tribal grail
tribal grail
#

that should've been done ages ago

tribal grail
#

yeah, not much

proper plaza
#

???

#

like noir?

#

I guess Sunburnt learnt that from you

tribal grail
#

Noir a stinky support

sand cloak
tribal grail
#

We need Sun nukes for DPS's

#

or you're not good, quite literally

sand cloak
#

So when is that gonna happen

#

Prydwen can never

tribal grail
#

I told the person that handles the tier list already

#

well make it exist rather

#

Also planning a char page reformat

#

but no idea when he'll get that done

#

i always have to poke him for stuff

#

dude just forgets

#

because he handles other websites

tribal grail
#

i can just chat gpt and call it a day

#

fuck

#

these reviews take me like a 2 hours to write

#

that's like
so long

surreal sorrel
olive scarab
#

Only Good Water Element AoE DPS as of now, which does add variety when tackling element based content, more specifically campaign

Vesti last seen lying dead in a ditch, rip

proper plaza
#

damn

#

the amount of empathy comments in Nikke.gg thread are so many

#

in a meantime

#

I don't even want to click the Prydwen thread in leddit

icy zealot
#

Team 4/5 is more in shambles for the less invested/F2P or newer players

#

so it isn't an inaccurate statement

olive scarab
tribal grail
#

Yes

#

I expect that much from a discord user

#

Mr sunburntvampire

olive scarab
tribal grail
#

We give each other the sucky suck

hidden fossil
#

i talk to snake and snake talks to sgay and sgay talk to me uwu

tribal grail
hidden fossil
#

tho sgay extra gay lately

icy zealot
#

Burst 1 commons include also SMary and pending the fight some use Sakura

tribal grail
#

Team 1-3

1b+ damage

Team 4-5

400M~

icy zealot
#

400m+ is not common in the regular playes

olive scarab
#

I think team 4/5 are partly in crisis because that's where you adjust based on boss

#

While teams 1-3 are strong regardless of element etc

hidden fossil
#

not sure if miranda is team 5 anymore

#

im prob resetting her next chance

icy zealot
#

These guides are great, but dont forget, most people that arent spending or are light spenders

Still struggle to get key units
Team Comps are often based on having some solid investment, not 1/1/1 or 4/4/4.
Lots of people still struggle to even get T9M equipment
The units that do well in there tend to require too much for them to be able to play, or are just flat out awkward to begin with

#

then, their team 4/5 dies within the first QTE because they cant survive past it or break the turret enough. Skill issue? I mean, if they are playing at a high high level, sure, but a lot of times its dozens of resets.

So, I think its a fair writing that team 4/5 is basically dead until we get ez units

olive scarab
#

Breaking turrets is giving me trauma from the damn orb boss which summons turrets everywhere.

As a phone players they spawn off screen so often, I don't see them until they've started firing badciv

#

On the flip side some definitely feel easier to aim on the smaller screen

#

Would be interesting to compare which bosses are easier on horizontal vs vertical mode

tribal grail
#

Because now

#

They have to pull rem and MAYBE emilia

#

On a surprise collab

#

And God knows how many people are yor up

#

I mean d: killer wife

deft herald
#

Ha, weakass Emilia and my team don't have Emilia or one-shot NIKKE type.
Top 10 pvp btw.

#

I fail to get Emilia...

icy zealot
#

to begin with

#

so they deserve to lose

#

and judging from the damage, probably didnt invest in her properly

proper plaza
#

that comp actually had idea

#

probably inspired by Keripo

#

the idea is: Emilia hits like isekai worker - a truck

#

so you just use Privaty to stall while Emilia shoots

golden ridge
icy zealot
deft herald
#

xD
Yeah, top 10 pvp in a nutshell

#

My comp have Modernia just raw shoot everyone

golden ridge
#

Emilia non burst is good

#

With sanis

#

Double pressure

olive scarab
#

Emilia not bursting is probably better in PvP unless you're explicitly trying to counter a Noah

#

Just use her for damage and burst gen

proper plaza
#

time to use chatgpt to translate prydwen review into japanese

tight terrace
#

i dont use reddit nikke lately

obtuse prism
#

Reddit is okay if you dont take it serious

#

just like any media platform basically

tight terrace
#

that

#

and

#

tier list always makes controversial shit

#

like 99% game i know

#

199%*

#

me checking the site

proper plaza
#

So true i kneel

#

Sss red hood pvp

rugged viper
#

Red hood is everywhere, powercreep when?

#

Imagine try +40% deficit in campaign without rh

icy zealot
#

and taking it out on the collab because their waifu didnt get in the collab

mighty jewel
#

yea man, my felix didn't get in the collab

tribal grail
#

My review:
Don't pull her

#

Comment: don't get tricked into pulling her

#

My tier list numbering admittedly is pretty flawed atm

#

Should find a way to fix that so it's a bit more
Clear

9 is simply too high to give a "good" nikke

#

Auster is such a fiend for making this system

icy zealot
#

My Review:

Pull if she cute

gloomy goblet
#

Yea man elsa and echina not in collab

#

Dogshit/10

tight terrace
#

she is anis tier

#

must pull

rugged viper
#

I want puck banner

golden ridge
#

I am planning to reformat Prydwen tier list to allow for 2 dimensional ratings, as an alternative option and a renewed design of tier list.

#

Since the current one is evaluated as strength + usability, it does not reflect the real world.

#

The redesign will separate strength & usability, allowing users to understand which units are universally good or have niche potential.

tight terrace
proper plaza
tight terrace
tight terrace
#

it doesn't matter if your judgement is the issue

golden ridge
fleet swan
#

hey how good is emilia for pvp?

slender oak
#

god

fleet swan
#

for pvp is 4/4/4 good enough? no OL

slender oak
slender oak
fleet swan
#

i see

#

i dunno if i can afford burst books though

#

4th best burst gen?

#

whos the other 3? jackal centi and noah?

slender oak
#

Anis = Jackal > Centi > Emilia

fleet swan
#

oh i forgot about anis

#

dont use her anyway

surreal sorrel
#

Somehow you’ve managed to confuse me 👀

#

When you talk about real world, seems like you’re saying you want to factor in whether the unit is realistically deployed as part of popular meta squads?

#

I think it’s probably excessive

#

Just rate by usability

#

Hence, the OP unit I mentioned, just give it F tier for all but Union Shooting Range

#

You’d have to do something like divide by role and grade there if you wanted to encapsulate all possible usability situations

#

Something like this. 👀
CDR | BUFFER | TANK | HEALER | DPS

#

Good luck 👀

ocean widget
#

What I think would be nice to see is a tier list that shows tier scaling of sort based on investment. A big issue with meta comps for majority of players, especially F2P, is resource availability

#

Like a Snow White or Alice with little skill investment is pretty much useless, while a Helm at 4/4/4 pretty much does her job

So system with essentially the "Skills 10" as the basic display with a secondary/tertiary "Skill 4" and "Skill 7" display on the individual page could be nice

wraith kraken
#

yes right, it's why my Alice is still 4/1/4 and ofc no OL gears so she is far to be SS tier on my side and not sure she will be one day at the rythm we are getting skills mats and with likely strong units coming

#

I understand the business purpose of their pack to sell skills but it's also to the detriment of the fun to build many teams and play/test what we want and not only Meta units

hidden fossil
#

Rem god

surreal sorrel
#

You can probably try something like a big portrait and 3 rows next to the portrait, for skills 4, 7, 10.

#

Ignore skill 1

#

But this won’t do justice to characters that like 10/4/4

#

Or ones that like 4/10/10