#Research Dungeon

1 messages · Page 6 of 1

half grove
#

so scarlet burst doesn't get boosted by Full burst, Range, Weakspot
( once you press the burst. it basically snapshots all the buffs )

#

yeah i did

#

the non-buffed area is what i calc and tested

sweet ocean
#

like, can legit knock her off a tier

half grove
#

i'm not sure if others work the same

wintry ravine
#

hmm I feel like you are over complicating your math

half grove
sweet ocean
#

we did work earlier and lap's burst is affected by full burst bonus

wintry ravine
#

try without all the other characters

#

just use scarlet and 2 R's with no buffs

half grove
#

yeah i did that test

#

the none buffed

#

one

wintry ravine
#

I did I quick test earlier and seemed like her burst was effected by burst 1.5x to me, guess I could test again

#

oh god

half grove
#

lemme send a clip

#

this is what i did

#

and from my calcs, range full burst and weakspot don't count

wintry ravine
#

I'm gonna test without attacking with her and no buffs at all, simplifies it all

half grove
#

oh yeah if you crit, just add crit modifier to it

sweet ocean
#

damn, so like
if instant-cast b3s aren't affected by FBB

#

that's gonna break the current meta a bit

half grove
#

i feel like i remember checking on harran and she also doesn't get FB bonus, weakspot and range as well on Burst

#

i was doing calc on the pierce

#

and also the Charge bug

sweet ocean
#

I'm pretty sure only a few people know about instant-cast b3s not being affected by FBB atm

half grove
#

well i know it doesn't get affected by some unit

atomic gyro
#

Would that affect the other bursts too? Like Burst I and Burst IIs not being applied their respective buffs?

sweet ocean
#

another batch of findings to the note deadge

half grove
#

that needs to be tested

atomic gyro
#

So internal logic would be Burst Logic -> Buff

#

Instead of Buff -> Burst Logic

half grove
#

iirc once you press the burst, it basically snapshots the buffs, is what i coming up rn

wintry ravine
#

huh you are correct, her burst doesn't get the 1.5x burst time bonus

half grove
#

hmm, then again it might only be a scarlet thing, so prolly need to test on other units as well

wintry ravine
#

my test btw

#

12893 atk * 5.3071 = 68424

68424 x 1.5

expected
102636

half grove
#

yeah only crit modifier gets added

wintry ravine
#

yup

#

that is pretty big honestly

sweet ocean
#

gigantic

half grove
#

basically also proves that burst skills can also snapshot?

sweet ocean
#

this flies over casual's head but it's about the biggest discovery since the game's release imo

willow pecan
#

It's totally over my head rn

#

you're basically saying we can yulha buff scarlet/laplace burst for 90% more damage?

wintry ravine
#

laplace stocks rising KEKL

half grove
#

not for laplace

#

i think

#

laplace is based on duration

willow pecan
#

Interesting

half grove
#

actually no. i did test it before

#

when i was doing pre-analysis

willow pecan
#

gonna wait for the geniuses here to make a TLDR/PSA so I can benefit praydoge

sweet ocean
#

@willow pecando you know about full burst's damage bonus?

wintry ravine
half grove
#

CB_facepalm it is based on duration of buffs

willow pecan
#

I think I get the concept

willow pecan
#

just not the implications

#

yes to @sweet ocean and @wintry ravine but thank you still.

sweet ocean
#

This affects Harran and Scarlet@willow pecan since their bursts are both instant

half grove
#

then there is also this one as well

willow pecan
#

non-instant burst = privaty/yulha?

#

since it takes time for the missiles to drop

wintry ravine
#

yeah privaty should gain the 1.5x as it's damage over time I think

half grove
#

Risk sharing is Dolla's S2 where you get atk buff

willow pecan
#

hard to know how to use this information tbh

wintry ravine
#

would have to test but the visuals and how it feels to me suggest it is damamge over time

sweet ocean
#

I actually don't think so, will need to test priv. Luckily she's free

willow pecan
#

privaty burst is still <<<<<<<<< scarlet burst damage atm

#

so IF she is benefiting from 50% and still inferior to scarlet

#

well, that's fucking sad

wintry ravine
#

as when bursts start leveling privaty will gain a lot

willow pecan
#

in practice I can see her fail to oneshot things my friends' scarlets are having no issue overkilling

trail falcon
#

privaty sends two barrages on burst right ?

willow pecan
#

oh, yeah. burst fix might come in play too

#

3 barrages I think

sweet ocean
#

the bulk of priv's damage isn't in her burst lmao
it's in her s2. And that is affected by FBB, core hit and crit

willow pecan
#

all I'm saying is that even with this discovery factored in, current live testing says scarlet/harran >>>> all

#

which is why I'm curious about why this is such a big deal, application wise

half grove
wintry ravine
#

scaling on bursts will change alot and tbh I already believe live laplace is better than scarlet KEKL

willow pecan
#

in her niches, maybe

#

scaling on burst is maybe the only thing that can change things around, given this information

wintry ravine
#

she doesn't really have niches, that's much overblown

#

she does good aoe and good single target

sweet ocean
#

the only weak thing is that she doesn't have an instant screenwipe imo

half grove
#

SuzunaWut i feel like i'm getting scammed

#

Dolla's S2 is apparently Going in FB mode

#

this one

#

welp

#

we got another translation error

#

again

willow pecan
#

activation delay maybe?

half grove
#

its full burst

wintry ravine
#

what diff does it matter when dolla skills activates

half grove
#

not burst skill

willow pecan
#

as in they parse burst 3 > full burst before activating that skill

half grove
#

the diff is well, you get atk boost before burst 3

willow pecan
#

maybe they can't parallel parse both 🤣

half grove
#

but instead you get atk boost after burst 3

wintry ravine
#

oh I see so scarlet doesn't get dolla boost

half grove
#

which makes you not getting atk buff, crit buffs ( in later burst cycles )

#

yeah

wintry ravine
half grove
#

translation error

#

it isn't burst skill

#

but full burst

wintry ravine
#

laplace stocks rising

#

wait what about liter buff?

half grove
#

liter works fine

wintry ravine
#

hmm weird

half grove
#

again, also this same video

sweet ocean
#

We are already doing so much work and the general research area isn't even public yet wahahaha

half grove
#

its after scarlet deals dmg then Dolla S2 proc'd

sweet ocean
#

I knew inviting you here was the right choice

half grove
#

yuisweat i'm busy tho

wintry ravine
#

I guess dolla skill is linked to full burst and full burst doesn't start until you do the 3rd burst, makes sense tbh

half grove
#

like i have different theory crafting session to attend in different gacha

wintry ravine
#

liters skill 1 buffs liekly work the same way

#

only her burst will work for scarlet

sweet ocean
#

So another one to the board
Instant-cast bursts aren't affected by FBB or "Cast when entering Full Burst" buffs.

molten robin
#

during all that laplace testing, was it tested if the true damage scales down with power penalty?

#

I saw the conclusion that FB bonus affects it, so the % math aligns

sweet ocean
wintry ravine
sweet ocean
#

oh fuck sorry lmao

molten robin
wintry ravine
#

it was tested though actually

#

and it follows my logic

sweet ocean
molten robin
#

maybe I missed that, it was 500+ messages I skimmed

molten robin
#

allen tested the non-true damage there

sweet ocean
#

@molten robin from Rayel

Conclusion :
Power Level Penalty applies to stats, and not final damage calculation. But yes, it is apparent that it affects the damage output, regardless of the damage being classified as "True Damage".

molten robin
#

since he forgot he had to stack the buff

wintry ravine
#

allen did a test while being underpowered and I did some math just after let me find it...

half grove
#

Cp penalty i think is at the end of the modifiers tho i am not 100% certain

#

worryHmm or maybe i'm tripping

wintry ravine
wintry ravine
#

but her burst will still perform well when under powered if the damage formula is atk - def (idk if it is)

molten robin
#

it is

#

def subtracts from atk in the formula

half grove
#

yeah it is

wintry ravine
#

her burst suffers a bit less than others then

half grove
#

i use that formula for my calcs

molten robin
#

so laplace very good against high defense

wintry ravine
#

yes

#

though I don't think we have enemy stats 😛

molten robin
#

which works against attack reduction since you're making your attack:defense ratio worse, yea

half grove
wintry ravine
#

by tests earlier suggest it doesn't have def value

#

laplace true damage matched the core damage / 2

molten robin
#

True danage ignores defense lol

wintry ravine
#

myabe I am getting mixed up it's been a long day, there was a point when I thought the union had 100 def

molten robin
#

Can't test enemy defense if you're ignoring it

wintry ravine
#

yes but laplace damage displays two instances

#

one regular and one true

molten robin
#

Yea

trail falcon
#

do you guys level your nikkes evenly because I've had sources that recommend leveling your main dps 20 levels higher would be better allocation of resources

wintry ravine
#

evenly is better

sweet ocean
#

@trail falconwhat are your sources?

wintry ravine
#

I guess actually resource cost doesn't go up until over 20 levels

trail falcon
#

the TW whale recommends leveling your main dps 20 levels higher and there are some other whales that recommend it as well

wintry ravine
#

hmm yeah might make sense

molten robin
#

I think specifically they suggest going to the next core dust breakpoint

atomic gyro
#

That only works if you have max lb SSRs no?

wintry ravine
#

yeah it only makes sense if resource cost isn't increased

molten robin
#

Because the dust breakpoints give more power per battle data than normal

trail falcon
#

yea it only works if you have limit broken SSRs

atomic gyro
#

Full whale tactic only, else we're reliant on synchro

molten robin
#

Well not quite, you only need one limit broken to do this

#

You don't need 5

half grove
#

do you guys have burst 1 laplace multipliers?

sweet ocean
#

@half grove 8.58/7.03 iirc

half grove
#

ok thanks

whole fox
#

I would Sadge

half grove
#

bruh

#

don't tell me her burst doesn't get range mod

whole fox
#

But hey at least it got u guys testing right? 😄

half grove
#

don't do this

#

ffs time to make another whole file on specific ranges with laplace

atomic gyro
#

NyX, get into the factory and start working

#

Need more sets of eyes on it

wintry ravine
sweet ocean
#

so the guy who did https://rentry.org/nikg_tryhard came up with another chart

half grove
#

oh yeah

sweet ocean
#

He's planning to add damage improving abilities too next revision.

half grove
#

i thought her burst is a MG kek

whole fox
pearl parcel
#

that guys is insane

atomic gyro
#

time to touch some research floors

whole fox
#

I did

atomic gyro
whole fox
#

I started the does laplace true damage ignore stat pen

wintry ravine
sweet ocean
#

According to this guy, Eunhwa has the best DPS in B2 if discounting damage improving skills

half grove
#

yeah, makes sense for RL

sweet ocean
#

Interesting

wintry ravine
#

I'll note that all this testing just confirms what I already knew, Laplace is SS tier 😎

atomic gyro
#

Laplace has been out DPSing my Alice, Drake, and Rupee ever since I switched teeth

whole fox
#

well i would just say i would take repsonsiblity of that

#

but hey at least it did also get more other results too right

wintry ravine
#

yeah we discovered a lot of interesting stuff

vapid geode
#

both in the img and the link

whole fox
#

dont just slam me hey maybe thats something worth looking but it didnt work but the result did give something

wintry ravine
#

xD

sweet ocean
#

I almost want to invite him to this place, but folks over there do not want anything to do with Discord.

#

Eh he's doing fine by himself anyway

atomic gyro
#

Maybe invite him after we publicize our research dungeon center

whole fox
atomic gyro
#

just invite, we won't force

#

but once he gets here we should roll in the red carpet and lock the doors teeth

whole fox
#

well he will be at the other research duneon Factory

half grove
#

ok yeah. its confirmed ( double checking to be sure )
Laplace's True dmg is actually True dmg, also gets affected by Full burst ( can't get Crit Mod nor has a Weakspot Mod )

sweet ocean
#

It can't crit ?

#

It can core hit at least?

half grove
#

yeah

whole fox
#

i belive it can hit core

half grove
#

True dmg can't crit

#

also doesn't get weakspot mod

#

but the 8.58% can get the Weakspot + Crit + Full burst

whole fox
#

hey at least my topic from "does true damage ignore stat pen" slowly trinkle into another topic like "Can Laplace crit with burst?"

#

dats a W

half grove
#

well as we all know, true dmg can't get away from the mighty cp penalty

whole fox
#

yea since it's tested we can say it does get affected by stat pen

half grove
#

as expected

sweet ocean
#

So
Laplace's burst's first part can benefit from Core Hit + Crit + Full Burst.
True dmg part can't crit or Core Hit, but benefits from Full Burst.

#

that correct?

#

Right, another one to the board.

wintry ravine
#

hmm actually

#

I think we did see some variation in the true damage numbers didn't we

#

like some being higher

#

I think KEKL

#

It's been a long day

half grove
#

from the testing i did, i don't see any variation of numbers

whole fox
#

take a rest dont hurt or break your back over a stupid random theory/comment like me thinking hey lets give this theory a shot

half grove
#

unless you buffed laplace's attack

wintry ravine
half grove
#

true dmg does get crit

wintry ravine
#

see the 1759's

unborn glacier
wintry ravine
#

did we ever figure out those 1759's @unborn glacier

unborn glacier
#

and yes that screenshot seems to indicate true damage can possibly crit

half grove
#

yeah it can crit

unborn glacier
wintry ravine
half grove
unborn glacier
#

im not surprised it can crit

wintry ravine
#

hm I guess it could have went either way

unborn glacier
#

but then, no one said it couldnt.. unless someone did

half grove
wintry ravine
#

laplace ult with some good crit buffers is gonna be nutso KEKL

whole fox
#

let not point fingers over a comment arite

wintry ravine
#

when they fix crit

unborn glacier
#

when they fix burst skills

#

the damage will go multi nutso

wintry ravine
#

I guess in fairness liter burst already very good for laplace

unborn glacier
#

just verifying something

wintry ravine
#

if they release a good crit buffer in burst 2 spot it would be good

unborn glacier
#

are attack buff additive or multiplicative to each other?

wintry ravine
#

additive surely

unborn glacier
#

you know the devs have poor reputation with math sometimes

wintry ravine
#

_>

sweet ocean
#

might be additive from the same unit but multi from others
need testings either way

unborn glacier
#

its not too hard to test, but im tired and its 1:30 am here

whole fox
#

you can always do it tommrow

#

always i need to continute on visual effects node editing so remeber to log dem in #1046549179918458890 arite II_thumb_pepe

whole fox
#

then i need to learn how to port Houdini effects to unreal or Unity

unborn glacier
#

fire, nice

whole fox
#

im still learning the grips of visual effectstoo

#

cuz if i cant a grip of this then im gonna struggle hard in houdini

unborn glacier
whole fox
#

work related

#

cuz im studying a vfx for film and games

#

cuz my lecturer who is teaching us in visual effects r aprt of the team who did most of the visual effects of marvel like avengers and siderman and dr strange stuff and the latest avatar stuff too

molten robin
#

I just realized this, but the power penalty must not be reducing base attack

#

It can only be reduce attack after defense is subtracted, or is a modifier

#

Otherwise different people with different setups would be seeing a different % reduction from the power penalty, because defense would have an increasing impact the lower your attack is

pearl parcel
#

I will probably move research-factory later to a new made category

#

actually lemme do that rn...

molten robin
#

To take a step back though and not rush to a conclusion too hastily, have we actually compared the power penalty reduction among varying attack levels, or was it just one person primarily responsible for testing/compiling the data?

#

I'd assume that test has been done by various people.and the results all match, but I haven't checked that

pearl parcel
#

I hope you guys can see the channel and new category

#

maid for you rank now create additional channels for the new category btw

whole fox
#

Ah yes Prayge

molten robin
#

@still drift I assume would be the most familiar with how power penalty was tested

pearl parcel
atomic gyro
#

wait since when

#

Then why can't I make this shit kekwwa

pearl parcel
#

Try now

atomic gyro
#

Same error

#

Time to make me purple teeth

pearl parcel
atomic gyro
#

Nice

#

It works

#

Now to remember to lock it to maid only writes when we go public

pearl parcel
#

it's like that

#

it's private

atomic gyro
#

Yeah I saw when syncing the permissions to the category

still drift
molten robin
#

@unborn glacier maybe you can share insight into this then: we have the %modifiers for cp from rayel, but has it been established whether the final observed damage reduction varies by target or person to person?

atomic gyro
#

I'm going to be cleaning up and going over one more time and closing all the issues for prep before the publicity

sweet ocean
#

kek might want to take this joke tag off to make room for one more

atomic gyro
#

It'll stay there unless there's a need for more tags teeth

#

(It will go after we set it to public)

pearl parcel
atomic gyro
#

Oh shit

pearl parcel
#

I am everywhere my friend

#

you can't escape me

atomic gyro
#

sorry alex

pearl parcel
#

I am in your walls rn

atomic gyro
#

i did you wrong

#

I fixed it for you

pearl parcel
#

I will look into the ticket bot when I have time

sweet ocean
#

My only concern is we can't have 2 pins up at the same time
So we can't have the current megathread for new units up with the how-to thread

atomic gyro
#

I will edit the pinned message whenever a new unit come sout

#

and then pin the new thread accordingly

pearl parcel
#

Probably that pepehmmm

atomic gyro
#

I guess

sweet ocean
#

gravy, then that's taken care of

atomic gyro
#

Considering the pinned post and the guideline are basically duplicates anyway

#

Just done for visibility's sake

pearl parcel
#

Yeah cuz people don't read rules anyway

#

even if they be would be sticked right in front of their face

atomic gyro
#

Since I have both guideline and pinned thread, I will indiscriminately ban people from the research lab teeth

pearl parcel
#

or you can leave the guildelines only

#

and do that thing with announcing new units idk

atomic gyro
#

I believe it shows when you make the thread

#

Can you check Alex?

#

Try making a new thread

pearl parcel
#

but sucks f-ing Discord made only a book up there

atomic gyro
#

See if the guideline shows up

pearl parcel
#

only the book

#

idk wtf they did

atomic gyro
#

As in, type something in then press create

#

it'll expand

pearl parcel
#

it used to show in the right side when the forum feature launched

#

aaa you mean this

atomic gyro
#

OH IT SHOWS UP FOR YOU?

#

It doesn't for me, so I wasn't sure

#

Since I wrote up the guidelines

#

So do we want to take down the guideline thread in favour for new unit thread?

sweet ocean
#

Yes, when the next unit launches
Perfect time to go public

atomic gyro
#

we go public in two weeks? TOMstare

tall fern
#

new character already announced TOMstare ?

sweet ocean
#

Anyway, the only thing left is to finalize the templates imo

atomic gyro
#

ye, so we don't really have to wait that long

#

I can take down the thread guideline and create a new unit thread

#

@pearl parcel do we want a special role for those who contributed research for the good of Ass ?

sweet ocean
#

I vote for.

#

We need to know who's the big dick big brein around 'ere

pearl parcel
atomic gyro
#

Also, if nobody's stopping me, I'm going to remove the pinned guidelines and rely entirely on the discord guideline to pin the new unit megathread capiche?

pearl parcel
#

next Nikke arrives

#

Also mark this with an *

#

and bold it

atomic gyro
sweet ocean
#

Oh

#

We're still missing a general chat area for researchers

atomic gyro
sweet ocean
pearl parcel
atomic gyro
#

already done

pearl parcel
#

you guys have access to edit the category

atomic gyro
pearl parcel
#

how much you want

sweet ocean
#

because I'm not the shotcaller here wahahaha

atomic gyro
#

why does it not let me sync permissions to category KekWait

#

bubba

#

we're all equal here

atomic gyro
#

nice

pearl parcel
#

try that

#

if not

#

you need to use Italic on every single raw above and just bold to that phrase after

atomic gyro
#

oh fuck

#

wtf * ** turns it into a bullet point?

unborn glacier
pearl parcel
atomic gyro
#

yeah

#

gimme a sec

sweet ocean
#

I'm in favor of keeping the Megathread minimal in casual discussion and focused on findings only, to make things easier to sort out later

#

like what I suggested

atomic gyro
#

Ah mb

#

Will change it

#

Now just gotta wait for the template

#

Gonna go fix that weird bold italics thing now

#

Fuck yeah

#

Markup is dumb

sweet ocean
#

Maybe we should have a picture of the nikke's kit instead of linking to Prydwen. It's more "accurate"
Just a suggestion

#

They do post this kinda thing every time before a new unit's released aye?

atomic gyro
#

Yes

#

Gimme that img

#

yoink

#

Fuck can you not add the image back in?

#

There we go

copper nexus
#

PEEK hello friends

tall fern
copper nexus
#

Not sure if you guys have seen it but I have a bug list that might be helpful to keep track of fixed, and non fixed/confirmed bugs

sweet ocean
#

invited him in

tall fern
atomic gyro
sweet ocean
#

Drop the payload m8

pearl parcel
#

It's seems we have another fellow researcher PrettySmile

copper nexus
#

I keep it updated

atomic gyro
copper nexus
#

I can be the bug catcher guy KEK

atomic gyro
#

Now I can just point people to the damned pins again

tall fern
#

oh wait you're the dude who made the speadsheet tierlist Pog ?

copper nexus
#

Yes I am

tall fern
sweet ocean
#

oh my fucking god
score

copper nexus
#

Trying to move from spreadsheet to nikke.gg now because sheets is struggling with the traffic

sweet ocean
#

give this guy and chills Maid for You imo

copper nexus
#

What is that lol

sweet ocean
#

ze big brein role

whole fox
#

Thats the researcher role

atomic gyro
#

OH FUCK

#

I HAVE THE POWER

#

TO MAKE YOU A MAID

copper nexus
#

I'm a maid?

atomic gyro
#

A DRAGON MAID

whole fox
#

Welcome

copper nexus
#

Lmao

#

Thank you

sweet ocean
atomic gyro
#

ofc

sweet ocean
atomic gyro
#

what if

#

i made a maid only break room

copper nexus
#

Very cool stuff you guys have here

sweet ocean
#

they actually have those in the places that I got my inspirations from

atomic gyro
#

wait

#

@pearl parcel why does image prisoners have access to view the research dep?

atomic gyro
#

wat

pearl parcel
atomic gyro
#

interesting

#

do we have to coordinate with you

pearl parcel
atomic gyro
#

to go public

#

or do i have the power

pearl parcel
#

Yes

atomic gyro
#

to have the research department

pearl parcel
#

without me you won't go public

atomic gyro
#

randomly flash people

sweet ocean
#

ok AFTER the templates are finalized I have another proposal

#

A read-me channel to teach people wtf the section is actually about

#

kinda like this

#

rules can be pasted there

copper nexus
#

Is this gonna be the keqingmains of nikke lol

sweet ocean
#

and what the roles actually represent

#

and what the channels are about

sweet ocean
#

anyway what I posted was just an example, we don't need to go balls-to-the-walls like these guys did

tall fern
#

ngl i think alex and the gang have given up on that idea or have just not had that idea cross their mind because

#

uhhh

#

the average nikke chatter aint too bright

pearl parcel
#

that problem is that some people are not into this

tall fern
#

and that

pearl parcel
#

like explaining every channel

#

ofc as long as you guys do the text before

copper nexus
#

Yeah better to keep things short and simple for smol brains

pearl parcel
whole fox
copper nexus
#

Btw should I add an invite link to this discord to my communities list?

sweet ocean
#

well, we can always need more people

pearl parcel
copper nexus
#

what invite link should I use

sweet ocean
copper nexus
#

yeah different links have different limits

#

some expire after time or too many uses

#

how’s this KEK

atomic gyro
pearl parcel
#

Good PrettySmile

molten robin
pearl parcel
#

anyway going to sleep bb guys

#

take care

copper nexus
#

goodnight

molten robin
#

if instead we observe no variance, we know it is acting on attack AFTER defense is subtracted

atomic gyro
#

wait

#

Alex

#

why are you sleeping so late

#

isn't it like, almost morning there

pearl parcel
plush gazelle
#

alex

#

who is this

#

is it really sugar?

atomic gyro
#

it's kubaba

plush gazelle
#

idk

atomic gyro
#

dc kubaba

unborn glacier
pearl parcel
#

I think it's from Destiny Child

plush gazelle
#

my friend has been staying up to watch football

#

until like 5am our time

atomic gyro
#

Because ass

unborn glacier
copper nexus
#

didn’t realize this was a horny chat

atomic gyro
molten robin
unborn glacier
molten robin
#

lol

#

it's mostly important for laplace, since if cp reduces base attack, ignoring defense is better than if it reduces post-defense

#

she would get better the higher your cp is

#

as opposed to post-defense reduction where it will always have the same % effect

#

it shouldnt be too hard to test, you just need to choose a big target in a lost sector floor and try to have two players with the same combat power

#

and the same unit but with different attack stat

copper nexus
#

wouldn’t it be easier to test same attack stat with different cp

#

it only takes 1 person/account that way

molten robin
#

or rather the same person can test it, and change their unit's attack while keeping cp the same via adjusting gear on others

copper nexus
#

Btw don't mean to change the topic but is anyone still working on burst bar generation?

molten robin
#

technically you dont even need to change variables

#

if you do a single test and your observation is different from rayel's table, that alone would do it I'd think

sweet ocean
copper nexus
#

Per character

sweet ocean
#
#

same guy made this

#

and no he isn't in this server DoggoSmile

copper nexus
#

I did some scuffed testing with someone from maincord before and it seemed pilgrims have different burst gen rates which kinda make sense

#

Our working theory was that burst gen is dependant on reload type

#

Not damage

still drift
#

@copper nexus Night mode for Nikke.gg when PES2_PepeGaBlind

sweet ocean
copper nexus
#

Yeah

copper nexus
#

Then the guy up and left the server LOL

#

Dude disappeared on me rip

whole fox
still drift
#

joypalm Use an extension, google sheets in charge

whole fox
#

im always blinded by your exel everytime update the campaign missions

copper nexus
#

I wanted to check reload time vs burst gen for other weapon types as well though

whole fox
#

yea chapter 4 hard is updated

#

100k power recommened at chapter 4 hard

sweet ocean
#

do we even have alternate reload styles for other weps
aside from sg/rl

copper nexus
#

No alternate styles

#

But there are different reload times

whole fox
#

i think in terms of reload animation

#

crow has a unique 1

#

where she just throw her gun away

copper nexus
#

Not sure about animations

#

My theory is that base reload time effects burst gen

unborn glacier
#

@molten robin got busy with work

#

let me do my test now

#

while

#

this means stats are reduced upon entering the stage

#

and not reduced upon damage impact/damage formula

atomic gyro
#

Shouldn't the second one have a larger amount of health? 🤔

unborn glacier
#

wait lol

#

i cant edit and post image, but here is the correct one

molten robin
#

aka base attack is reduced

#

is that a safe assumption though?

unborn glacier
molten robin
#

I'm not sure it is

unborn glacier
molten robin
#

well yea, but I'm not sure it has to be implemented on base attack

unborn glacier
#

your assuming(logic) the penalty is damage penalty (where doing the attack reduction seperately,might make sense)

#

and not stat penalty

molten robin
#

so some takeaways: 1. attack buffing is stronger the higher your penalty is, one of the reasons we see scarlet pushing so well deep into penalty
2. you can't say a 25% penalty means a 25% damage reduction, they aren't directly correlated
3. laplace gets betters the higher your penalty relative to non-true damage dealers, as shredding defense is more impactful the lower your attack:defense ratio

#

does that all seem reasonable?

unborn glacier
#
  1. though correct, im not sure how its different from the current belief that attack is more valuable in the damage formula as it is XD

  2. yes, they arent cause its a 25% stat penalty.. people just got used to calling it damage penalty (me included) until i saw rayel's file

  3. correct, for true damage component, which theoretically account for 25-40ish%(guestimate) of her damage output in a battle..

#

the larger chunk of her damage though still, behaves like normal nikke's

molten robin
#

right

molten robin
#

I've never seen anyone discuss the ramifications of attack:defense ratio on just how good attack buffs are

#

it is still true without cp ofc, but it's much more pronounced under cp

unborn glacier
molten robin
#

as cp is worsening the attack:defense ratio

unborn glacier
#

@molten robin by ay chance have you tested/check if attack buffs are additive or multiplicative already?

#

to each other

molten robin
#

no, but that's a simple test

unborn glacier
molten robin
#

yea

#

do we KNOW shooting range defense is 100, or is that just speculated?

sweet ocean
#

That can be tested easily too I think. Just need a Def debuffer

unborn glacier
half grove
#

well for my calcs in shooting range 100 defence on enemy seems very true because i'm getting my numbers right most of the time

vocal vale
#

guys
more bug/ fucked up mechanics
Gravedigger missiles damage
80lv 143949,120lv 148023,124lvl 137410

vocal vale
#

so someone used Noah to test up damage received during GD I-S missiles damage

unborn glacier
#

the level is noahs?

#

i-s, stands for.. interception?

sweet ocean
#

interception S

vocal vale
#

yes

molten robin
#

@unborn glacier definitely additive

sweet ocean
#

additive with the same source or with all sources?

molten robin
#

I can't quite match my observed damage via the damage formula, but it's only 70 off so could be rounding, or defense isn't exactly 100

molten robin
#

2 diff characters

sweet ocean
#

👌

molten robin
#

used liter + rupee

#

and generic burst 3 with no buffs

unborn glacier
molten robin
#

rupee has stacking selfbuff, all allies on burst, and liter full burst

#

instead of 70 off, I'd be many hundreds off

#

if it was multi

unborn glacier
# vocal vale yes

not sure, whats special if its noahs level? she will get more def she levels right? so take less damage?
or this is data so we can refer to how def works? 🙂

wintry ravine
#

yo guys, I/m just awake but I had an epiphany about laplace burst.. we've been thinking about it entirely wrong lol

vocal vale
unborn glacier
vocal vale
#

people are hinting of fluctuating difficulty

molten robin
#

seems likely

whole fox
molten robin
#

it would be trivial to scale the boss a bit based on average nikke level

whole fox
#

some reason today grave digger seems easier

vocal vale
unborn glacier
sweet ocean
#

@molten robinthat aligns with a test that I remember a week or so ago
someone in maincord did some quick tests and Helm was giving more team dps than Maxwell
Helm has the only multiplicative atk% buff in the game

molten robin
unborn glacier
#

@whole fox maybe interception is also affected by a hidden recommended power rating ?

whole fox
#

i mean yea? but still it feel weird cuz usually i would miss 1 set of circles but idk why seems like im abit to hit all of the circles this time

unborn glacier
#

i noticed my girls tanking a bit better than usual lately

whole fox
#

maybe its just luck?

#

im not sure

unborn glacier
#

when i only raised them by 1 level

whole fox
#

however there is 1 thing is constant doe
U can only miss 1 full set of circles

U cannot miss more than 1 if not u will die without healers

wintry ravine
#

our line of thinking has been "oh it has true damage, it's good vs high armor targets!"

this is not true.

It's only been given true damage for 2 reasons,

  1. to avoid double dipping vs def so it's not underpowered

  2. It actually does damage over 94ish instances. The regular damage portion will suffer massively vs high armor targets. The burst was given a true damage component to ensure it doesn't do lik zero damage vs high armor targets. The true damage is like a lowest possible damage safety net.

The only times when the true damage would end up making her do more damage than is in super niche examples where the devs code an enemy with like 1million def instead of 100% immune for some odd reason. At least her burst would still damage through that but you'dlikely not want to burst then anyways.

unborn glacier
vocal vale
#

is this not the place for tldr

molten robin
#

but it DOES perform better vs higher armor targets (or when your attack is lowered)

whole fox
#

even im at 120 or even 150 im still only able to soak 1 boss attack

unborn glacier
molten robin
#

relative to not having true damage, obviously

unborn glacier
#

at 120 im done to like 2% hp

#

now at 130
my remaining hp is like 50 with cover gone

molten robin
#

I understand what you're trying to say, which is that higher defense still reduces the bulk of her damage

unborn glacier
#

( i always hide behind cover when boss attacks)

molten robin
#

but that's more true for characters without true damage components

whole fox
#

yea i always hide behind cover too

#

but i miss 1 set in Wave 2 and 1 set in wave 3 and im ded

molten robin
#

or without self-stacking attack buffs

unborn glacier
wintry ravine
#

all other burst are single high instances

#

they will add true damage for every machine gun like burst

#

they will have to

molten robin
#

the % modifier from your weapon doesnt care about defense

#

you're misreading the damage equation

sweet ocean
molten robin
#

the defense is subtracted from base attack + attack multipliers, and the weapon modifier is applied AFTER defense is subtracted

#

that means weapons with higher rates of fire and lower weapon mods dont suffer more vs high defense targets than the reverse

wintry ravine
#

🤔

molten robin
#

let me make an example

sweet ocean
#

interesting, I thought it would be the reverse

molten robin
#

say we have 1k attack and 500 defense, with a weapon that does 10% damage with 10 shots per second, and a weapon that does 50% for 2 shots per second:we have a 500 final attack 1k - 500, so we'll then take 500 * 0.1 * 10 = 500,
and 500 * 0.5 * 2 = 500

#

that's the impact of the weapon mod being after defense, and not before

#

as you can see it's after the parenthetical statement

wintry ravine
#

that seems so weird to me

molten robin
#

if the weapon mod were instead being applied before defense, as if it were a part of the attack power buff sum variable, we'd have:
1k * 0.1 -500 * 10 = -4k damage

molten robin
half grove
molten robin
#

most games handle defense as a % modifier, so being subtracted instead leads to interesting consequences

molten robin
wintry ravine
#

working out the final damage of the weapon and then subtracting def before considering the weapon mod is like.... super odd no? Do many games do this?

half grove
#

finished the calcs

molten robin
#

that's very unusual

wintry ravine
#

it's like it ignores the actual instances though

half grove
#

^

#

yeah

wintry ravine
#

the method of damage delivery is basically window dressing

#

unless I'm still missing something

molten robin
#

wdym?

wintry ravine
#

well it doesn't matter if you do 10 instances of 100 or two instances of 500 vs a 500 defence target, the total attack (1000) is tallied up and put vs the 500 def for the calculation

molten robin
#

there's differences in raw dps, range values, ability to clear smaller targets or charge up before a prio target, etc

#

there's many differences, just how they interact with defense isnt one of those differences

#

I mean it's normal for defense to not matter for high vs low attack speed

#

defense is normally a % modifier that affects both equally in most games

wintry ravine
#

there is no diff in raw dps between 10x100 and 2x500 if they both interact with def the same

molten robin
#

they just replicated that here without a % def modifier with how they arranged the formula

molten robin
wintry ravine
#

in every game I've played where def acts as a flat reduction as opposed to a % reduction it usually cucks small instances, they way they've set it up is really weird imo

sweet ocean
#

If this is intentional then that's one of the smart things they did

molten robin
#

WoW is a classic example of where defense is a % modifier, and doesnt care about the speed or magnitude of inputs

wintry ravine
#

yeah most games nowadays use % and it's fine

molten robin
#

you state yourself why that system is bad lol

wintry ravine
#

not when you are talking about flat reduction. That would be expected when it comes to flat reduction. I agree its the problem with a flat reduction model, that's why most games use % now. But their solution...

molten robin
#

their solution seems...perfectly reasonable?!

#

idk I must be missing something lol

wintry ravine
#

nah I wouldn't agree

molten robin
#

the only weird thing in this convo is why you seem like you WANT faster weapons to be cucked lol

wintry ravine
#

I will need to think on it more but it just makes firerate basically a for show element

#

it doesn't make any mathmatical diff

unborn glacier
sweet ocean
#

that's perfectly fine imo

unborn glacier
#

@molten robin mind helping me test another topic?

molten robin
#

hit me

unborn glacier
#

damage overflow

#

kill a mob using smg or AR

#

check data result (the damage report)

#

then kill same weak mob with full charge sniper or RL

molten robin
#

I dont think I have a shielder

unborn glacier
#

check damage result

molten robin
#

oh you mean overkill

#

not shield overflow

unborn glacier
#

my theory is the game damage report is RAW

#

meaning damage overflow is counted

wintry ravine
#

It's not hard to not cuck faster fire rate weapons in a more regular flat def damage formula, you just give them special mods like penetration or don't thus giving you options. Putting your solution directly in the damage formula limits what can be done going forward

unborn glacier
#

impact is smg/AR/MG will damage will look weaker cause they generate less damage overflow

unborn glacier
molten robin
#

oh yea that's super trivial to test

#

brb

unborn glacier
#

thanks

wintry ravine
#

ugh yeah that damage formula leaves a bad taste in my mouth lol

half grove
#

its a bad formula fr

unborn glacier
#

math is math

unborn glacier
#

someone said he needed 9+m damage to clear a stage

#

but i only did that same stage with 6m damage done

molten robin
wintry ravine
#

wait a min.. how can that damage formula even consider multiple instances before they hit

molten robin
#

confirmed @unborn glacier

#

first fight lost sector 1, same mob killed both times

unborn glacier
#

ohh then yeah

#

confirmed

molten robin
#

the mob died in both screenshots yes

#

it was a 5k power fight lol

wintry ravine
#

are all machine guns hit scan?

molten robin
#

that's why I said it was trivial to test

#

lost sector op

unborn glacier
#

so using damage result to say hey look my x damage is doing much better.. isnt 100% accurate.

molten robin
#

right

#

I have a question myself

#

two actually

unborn glacier
#

so applying to the other topic

wintry ravine
#

so the screen wipe bursts are inflating scarlets numbers then

unborn glacier
#

faster fire weapons/low damage per bullet have more "efficient" use of their damage

molten robin
#
  1. dealing damage to a boss part deals damage to the boss itself I assume?
  2. more important, when a boss part is destroyed, who gets credited with the damage the boss takes?
sweet ocean
#

another one to the board

molten robin
#

if we look at interception, someone must get the credit since the boss has a set hp

unborn glacier
molten robin
#

my point I'm leading up to being that laplace damage numbers are overinflated on boss part fights

#

she's taking up a larger % of boss part last hits than normal

sweet ocean
#

I'm adding completed researches to my trusty notepads so I can ping peeps wahahaha

unborn glacier
#

can test by not last hitting the part

molten robin
#

not only because she's hitting all boss parts every shot, hence just being more likely to land a last hit, but her focused damage + high rate of fire during burst mans she's super likely to also score the last hits during it

half grove
#

so the dmg shown isn't accurate because of overflow dmg you deal when you kill HmmmmNoted

wintry ravine
#

if she is doing 90% of the damage she will be allocated the damage 90% of the time

#

the other 10% the other person will score the last hit by chance

#

so it's a fair system

molten robin
#

I'm not sure I quite agree with that analysis

#

in principle you'd be right

wintry ravine
#

you just need to average it out with many runs

unborn glacier
molten robin
#

but I think the way she is played, and being a high-radius RL user, means she's going to score more last hits than the % damage she's dealing

wintry ravine
#

you could say the nature of burst means it's more likely to score a last hit too, I think your logic sounds good but isn't accurate

#

if scarlet hit her burst anywhere near the say 20% mark it will score the kill even if it does 2% damage

unborn glacier
sweet ocean
wintry ravine
#

also laplace shots outside her burst actually have a low firerate

#

so are unlikely to pick up last hits

molten robin
#

well I definitely disagree there

wintry ravine
#

idk I think in an actual match there are too many variables to make any statement on it

molten robin
#

faster hits should only be marginally more likely to last hit when factoring overkill damage

#

but the RL is never gonna miss

#

esp on say chatterbox, other units will be missing a lot when he jumps back

#

but it could also be said that controlling a unit inflates your damage on boss part-bosses to begin with

#

you're far more likely to score the last hit yourself than other units

wintry ravine
#

hmm oh I know

#

if you wanted more accurate data just don't test vs bosses

molten robin
#

idk how ai targeting works but they definitely arent shooting boss parts all the time lol

wintry ravine
#

the boss missions will be a bit misleading unless you have a large sample size and even then due to burst timings etc they may always be misleading

#

so probably boss battles are simply not a great metric for comparison

unborn glacier
molten robin
#

I mean they MUST be a metric for comparison

#

being good against bosses is a worthy niche for a character

unborn glacier
#

i lost track of what the main point of current topic is

wintry ravine
molten robin
#

I was just pointing out I thought laplace numbers on bosses, like the 33m on chatterbox, are inflated

unborn glacier
#

or we disagreeing how it can be tested?

wintry ravine
#

yeah but the problem goes beyond laplace, whatever you main dps is will have inflated damage

unborn glacier
#

but the theory sounds correct?

sweet ocean
#

we just need to confirm that the nikke that does the last hit gets the part break damage contributed to her

wintry ravine
#

basically main dps damage is inflated on boss stages

unborn glacier
#

fixing my question:
the theory everyone agrees, but proving it will be hard?

molten robin
#

I agree it basically boils down to, controlling a character on a boss fight biases the damage more than normal

#

I think is the takeaway

wintry ravine
#

proving the theory shouldn't be too hard tbh

trail falcon
#

hitting the missile projectiles from chatterbox contributes to your dps right

molten robin
#

if in that screenshot of 33m laplace vs 11m scarlet on interception, if he controlled laplace all the way, scarlet likely wasnt hitting boss parts the whole fight

unborn glacier
molten robin
unborn glacier
#

should "minimize" it

molten robin
#

people were surprised at the damage liter was dealing when she was actually hitting boss parts and not being played by shit ai

molten robin
#

those screenshots of liter topping dps, they prob destroyed more parts

wintry ravine
#

I would just avoid boss fights when doing baseline damage comparisons tbh

unborn glacier
trail falcon
#

Certain weapon types like sniper rifle struggles to hit the projectiles from chatter box, whereas weapon types like RL, shotgun excel at clearing those. That inflates the dps a lot.

unborn glacier
#

if you testing how good a nikke is vs a boss, then it relevant

#

if your just testing numbers, then its another test enviroment

molten robin
#

that's why I said boss damage must be a metric

#

it's just important to keep in mind the biasing effect

wintry ravine
#

yeah but then you are testing who is good vs the boss not a dps test at all

unborn glacier
molten robin
#

or even rng, if you have a fight where laplace destroyed all boss parts, her damage will look insane

wintry ravine
#

not really semantics, it's testing entirely different things

unborn glacier
#

there is
DPS test
then there is
DPS on Bosses
DPS on mobs
DPS on Elites

etc

trail falcon
#

you mean to say that the unit that takes the last hit on body parts takes the 7-health bar worth of dmg or whatever it is ?

wintry ravine
#

if you have a solid baseline dps test you can extrapolate their damage on bosses with knowledge of the boss

trail falcon
#

or do you mean that it takes the overkill damage

molten robin
#

unverified, afaik

unborn glacier
wintry ravine
#

but if the boss parts theory is true the data you get in boss fights is going to be very inaccurate.. I just don't see value of collecting data there. It's pretty easy to just boot up a scarlet and boot up a laplace and see who performs better if that's what you wanted to do

molten robin
#

I think the real moral here is screenshots of damage done is a poor metric

unborn glacier
#

i think we all agree it inaccurate then 🙂

molten robin
#

my only point was boss damage is even more inaccurate than normal lol

unborn glacier
#

how to test it better, lets worry about it when we actually want to test something for actual conclusion

wintry ravine
still drift
#

Due to some top players getting exceptionally close to Lv200 Character Synchro; I have updated my sheet with the respective values to Level 400.

#

And yes, 10k core dust per level past lv200

#

Cores have a purpose past 181.

molten robin
#

10k per level? jesus

unborn glacier
wintry ravine
#

whalebait is their purpose trolldespair

still drift
#

Actually maybe I should just hide Lv300+ for now

#

Its kinda long road there

unborn glacier
molten robin
#

that means core dust is the main wall after 200, right?

#

surely 10k dust takes longer to get than 21m battle data

unborn glacier
sweet ocean
#

that's what they want you to think
all 3 resources are walls

still drift
#

My only purpose is to add Data and visualizers to them, deep analysis and calculators I leave to others.

molten robin
#

ah though at 252 battle data and credits double while dust remains the same

still drift
#

Unhid the rows so you can check 300+

sweet ocean
#

2nd part only works when you use her burst, but it's a little delayed

half grove
#

i've also talked with aus before about it

#

prolly S2 has delay

#

if i just auto burst, my scar can't keep getting the dolla S2 atk buff

wintry ravine
#

a method to test the boss parts theory.. basically enter any battle with a boss part that damages the boss health (like chatterbox). Use a burst 3 nikke with a single target burst. Have the burst 1 and 2 nikkes be something which won't interfere like healer / tank. Manual control the burst 3 nikke from match start and do 0 damage (hold their reticule somewhere low offscreen). Only activate the burst when your burst 3 nikke will kill one of the parts, target it an kill the part; pause and note damage.

sweet ocean
#

sounds like a job for a snow white enjoyer

wintry ravine
#

she'd work well since she is easy to target with her burst

#

you could do it with like guillotine if you could target the ult well enough

#

even if you fire a few rounds her dps is low with machine gun won't throw off the test

#

I would do it but I cannot be bothered KEKL I just woke up and have a hair cut appointment coming up KEKL

vocal vale
#

bugs that causes u to lose potential gems
dispatch range is 2*- 6*
but 1star mission can come out

vocal vale
#

correct

whole fox
unborn glacier
#

FYI
thanks to @solid relic , burst bar build up now has noah!

#

conclusion: her charge speed is above average for rocket launcher

#

doing 35 - 45 seconds, which is roughly half-ish the speed of anis/centi, which is still sorta fast

#

as most nikke charge at 45 - 60 seconds

solid relic
#

Not sure if this qualifies as a bug but the "Reinforce a Nikke's Core +X for the first time" mission is better worded as something like "Reinforce any Nikke's Core X amount of times" since it's cumulative across all Nikke. ie: I completed the +4 mission even though I only have Liter +1, Drake +1, and Sugar +2 .

meager elbow
#

Can anyone test if Full Burst has damage multiplier?

plush gazelle
#

it does

#

x1.5 iirc

willow pecan
#

50% yea

meager elbow
#

ok, then that effect on Laplas true damage?

plush gazelle
#

yes

#

it does

#

we spent a lot of time yesterday figuring that out

meager elbow
#

but not core hit?..hmm

plush gazelle
#

nope

#

because the damage is calculated before

#

but core hit is calculated “on hit”

#

laser probably doesn’t take into account crit hits either

#

in other words….. it’s not as powerful as we would want it to be

#

think her damage overall still pretty solid against bosses tho

unborn glacier
#

minor correction

#

the laser can crit

plush gazelle
#

can it? i did not see that

unborn glacier
#

but the laser cant core hit

unborn glacier
sweet ocean
#

I think I saved it somewhere

#

Laplace's burst's first part can benefit from Core Hit + Crit + Full Burst.
True DMG part can't Core Hit, but can crit and benefits from Full Burst.
True DMG part is actually true DMG.

plush gazelle
#

aahhhhhh

unborn glacier
#

but some did an ss showing it can happen

plush gazelle
#

let me try using crit rate meme team

#

i see if it happens

meager elbow
#

her normal attack alone is already powercrept vesti

plush gazelle
#

vesti was garbage alr

#

not really power creep kekw

sweet ocean
#

vesti literally needs like a buff refresher to function

meager elbow
#

their attack and multiplier on normal is almost the same

sweet ocean
#

aka only pepper atm deadge

plush gazelle
#

i think i see it

#

she does from 1195 -> 16 sth

#

used volume to buff

unborn glacier
#

yep

sweet ocean
#

coincidentally volume's buff is also 5s

unborn glacier
meager elbow
sweet ocean
#

they do, true damage's based on total atk

meager elbow
#

thanks

rare shell
#

does anyone want to help with the Team Building document?

rare shell
#

updated the document with explaining BiS per roles

still drift
#

MiharaScream Im growing balder by the day looking at how these devs round their numbers.
Seriously getting out of hand how they handle it.
Never a damn lick of consistency

sweet ocean
#

@rare shellfor a first draft that looks decently comprehensible for someone experienced

still drift
#

Like what kind of rounding system is :
If there are decimals, just simply move them to the "Mid Range"

sweet ocean
#

I feel like people are really forgoing healers for more damage in the B1 slot

#

Prob because they don't use or don't have Pepper, she's really highly rated in CN/JP

still drift
#

If you're healing while pushing powerlevels, you're seriously risking a TIME OUT.

sweet ocean
#

meh you do 0 dps if you die anyway deadge