#feedback (to be like you)

17 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

fathom furnace
#

Your anger like an everlasting flame
Quick to rise and hard to tame
A chokehold under your forever demise
Simplistic manipulation in disguise

Your harsh words causing suffocation
My lasting sadness your exasperation
I really wonder if you knew
How much I wished to be like you

But I don't want to cause others pain
Don't want to be known by your name
I hope you know I'll never be like you
My growing despise pushing us askew

I wish sometimes you could see
Just how much you're really hurting me
I hate how much I seek your approval
And I hate how your disappointment causes reproval

I feel so worthless under your stare
So damn ruthless like you couldn't care
Sometimes I hoped you really knew
Just how much I wished to be like you

swift shuttle
#

I like it a lot, and it doesn't necessarily need changing, but here are my personal thoughts: (have a wall of text lol)

It seems in the first two lines that you're using iambs, which has a nice flow to it, but you lose that later on. I'm generally very strict about rhythm which isn't required of course but I think it's nice to have a clear rhythmic goal. The problem for me in this case is that you seem to want to use iambs but you don't stick to them, leaving you in a sort of limbo.

A specific example:
I'm not a big fan of the rhythm of the "how much I wanted to be like you" lines, although in sentiment I like them a lot. You might consider, "how much I wished to be like you" instead, since it gives it a more longing and bitter tone (imo) to fit better with the piece as a whole and the "wished" is one strong syllable instead of the strong-weak of the "wanted" which throws me off balance.

To be clear, there's no reason that you shouldn't use something other than plain iambs or just abandon rhythm altogether in general, but giving us some rhythm and pattern and then taking it away makes me, at least, feel a little uncomfortable.

I didn't notice the count of the syllables getting in the way of anything, btw, and, of course, if what you're going for is a sort of stressed/uncomfortable tone, using a slightly erratic rhythm might not hurt at all.

Although the general meaning is always clear, and the specific meaning usually clear, there are some lines that just don't mean anything to me. Obviously, that could just be a fault in my understanding, and another person might find them easy to understand.

a. A chokehold under your forever demise.
I get all the rest in this stanza without difficulty, but this line I have no idea. It has the sound of potentially having been chosen simply because it rhymes.

b. My growing despise pushing us askew
Somehow this one doesn't seem right to me, although I think I see what you're getting at. (continued)

#

(continued) actually with a little more thought this one fits just fine. I like how it has an edge of bitter defiance to it.

c. And I hate how your disappointment causes reproval
I don't understand in whom it causes reproval... it just doesn't make much sense to me.

#

Finally, just one last thing:

"so damn ruthless like you couldn't care"
it took me a while to understand where this fit grammatically in the context of the stanza but I feel like just by adding "you're" you could dispel all confusion about this line without disrupting the rhythm. Otherwise, it reads that the narrator feels ruthless, which doesn't make sense.

#

remember that these are all really nit-picky things. I would have trouble finding general complaints about this. It's got a nice tone and meaning

#

Hope this is helpful!

fathom furnace
#

It is actually a lot. So with the ruthless, the person is ruthless, like they don't care about me

#

Reproval, it causes him to doubt me, my work and how much he loves me

#

Chokehold under his demise, because I'm never good enough. He constantly wants perfection, and it's like a chokehold, can't breathe and constricting

fathom furnace
swift shuttle
#

mad or rude is definitely not the vibe I'm getting. A little bitter, but I think that contributes to the sadness you're aiming for. Sadness is such an umbrella emotion, and in this case, I think bitterness is a specific tone under that umbrella

swift shuttle
#

not just the tense, but the feelings

#

I wouldn't change that though, it's perfect

fathom furnace
#

Well I wrote it right after something happened that inspired it.

#

Like an hour later

swift shuttle
#

that's very clear, it has the feeling of a fresh wound