balmy ore
I'm trying to add custom discs to my game, but after following all the steps, Minecraft returns ```txt
Malformed 'minecraft:jukebox_playable' component: 'Failed to parse either. First: Not a string; Second: Not a string'
..._playable={song:"nophunintended:lovely"}]<--[HERE]
hardy sequoiaBOT
I'm trying to add custom disc*s* to my game, but after following all the steps, ...
balmy ore
quasi hamlet
the problem is exactly what the output log already tells you
put playable="nophunintended:lovely"
quasi hamlet
yes
balmy ore
😭
quasi hamlet
well, the Minecraft wiki has the correct information
quasi hamlet
well, the most reliable source on that would be the game files themselves, which are mirrored here:
https://github.com/misode/mcmeta/blob/summary/item_components/data.json#L15987
balmy ore
put `playable="nophunintended:lovely"`
er?
/give @s minecraft:stick[minecraft:jukebox_playable="nophunintended:lovely"]
whole command
quasi hamlet
so it says that the jukebox song doesn't exist
abstract mauve
do you have logs enabled
abstract mauve
do the json file names need to be the same?
elaborate?
balmy ore
yes (im using prism)
balmy ore
elaborate?
i did this for organisation
abstract mauve
is there anything showing up in your logs regarding your track
balmy ore
is there anything showing up in your logs regarding your track
uhhhh
balmy ore
they do need to be the same
i see
i was unsure about doing this
guess i was right
ghashgdsh what
balmy ore
they do need to be the same
fixed that, now what 
I will uhh
just push my changes
and leave it in https://github.com/blryface/top-discs
it probably helps you all too, right?
if ya'll find the problem, pls ping 🙏
for now i'll work on making a bus skin for beam ng 😭
abstract mauve
fixed that, now what <:ohno:1346256213360246844>
i. hm. what versiom are you on??
balmy ore
i. hm. what versiom are you on??
1.21.10
abstract mauve
Weird.. sorry idk how to help
balmy ore
😭
dusk patio
and leave it in https://github.com/blryface/top-discs
@covert path hey look what this guy is making
dusk patio
ghashgdsh what
this is actually pretty confusing
is your resource pack set up correctly?
covert path
<@880000911848636468> hey look what this guy is making
already talked about it in #💬┃general :3
balmy ore
is your resource pack set up correctly?
I think so?
it's all on the repo!
inb4 it's a misspelling 😭
plucky sky
I think your datapack is skipping your sounds.json altogether with inline sound_events that should probably include the subfolder jukebox_song (as that is where the sound files are located)
Or you should reference the sound events from your sounds.json directly. Which would be something like:
{
"comparator_output": 0,
"description": {
"text": "Tyler Joseph - Always [No Phun Intended]"
},
"length_in_seconds": 219.0,
"sound_event": "nophunintended:music_disc.always"
}
I think you can pick either, please correct me if I am wrong guys.
I was wrong, after reading this on the wiki:
sound_event: One sound event (an [String] ID, or a new [NBT Compound / JSON Object] sound event definition) — The sound event to play when the item is inserted in a jukebox. **Note that only vanilla Minecraft sound events can be referenced directly by [String] ID; custom sound events must be specified in [NBT Compound / JSON Object] object form. **
I would however say that you don't need sounds.json for the jukebox_playable component
balmy ore
interesting
balmy ore
I'll try and see if that works when I have the time, thanks for everyone helping me