#C.R.S. (Cannon Reputation System)

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

cloud sandal
#

currently all good suggestions that mightve been good immediately get trashed down by troll posts which are so bad and people in them chat because theyre so bad, and due to this many people get turned away or have keep bumping to not get drowned in the waters of old posts, to combat this i got an idea to have a reputation system, each role has a weight
(ranging from 0.75 to 15 weight is your top most role with weight) when you create a post you start with half of that weight as start, people can increase weight with /upvote and decrease with /downvoteand can be checked with/weight inside the targeted suggestion, weight can go to negatives but at negatives its only half of your role weight, zero for people with 1 vote strike
people can have diffrent opinions but if people are toxic or ask stuff that isnt balancing but just like trashes the suggestion they can be reported to suggestion mods and get a suggestion strike (i recommend having mods just for this)

Suggestion mod(s)

suggestion mods are mods that only have to review and moderate suggestions, they can only strike and mute, close suggestions, they need to call reinforcements if things are outta hand

Striking system

theres 3 types each fully disable the thing at second stage

  1. Suggestion creation at stage 1 nothing is applied to not limit creativity, at stage 2 however, you cant create suggestions at all
  2. Suggestion chatting at stage 1 you cant use images if you could before at stage 2 you dont get to chat, and react
  3. Suggestion voting at stage 1 you downvote the quarter of the weight at stage 2 you dont get to vote at all

what weight actually does

every week @regal pumice bot will post top 15 suggestions with most weight and a staff (preferably a suggestion mod) must review each to give 1 to 10 rating (also posts that have been posted cannot appear in weekly top 15s again)
⚠️(second is part below this)

8d317n.png
#

0: Rulebreaker (for people who seem to not read suggestion guidelines, must give strike along side)
1-3: Awful (either no skill or really unbalanced, can optionally give a suggestion creation strike at 1)
4-5 Ok (nothing to note or just very average or fine enough)
6-8 Awesome (for quality suggestions that actually have thought put in, minimum for a suggestion to be added)
review_perfect 9-10 Perfect (for suggestions that are so good they are getting added)
Role weight chart:
Member with a voting strike:0.25
member:1
Not every active and server booster:1.5
Badge roles (operator, ability warrior etc):3
chronically online:5
Any Staff:15

worldly lantern
#

I haven't even read it and I'll just say one thing: PEAK

#

I'm going to bump this up with my life

cloud sandal
#

nah no need tho

worldly lantern
cloud sandal
#

ok

#

like?

worldly lantern
cloud sandal
#

thx

worldly lantern
#

I just read it and it's the best suggestion; it might even revive the game

#

Don't vote for yourself, the devs don't like that

#

@wispy kiln

#

Here

wispy kiln
#

This is perfect, but there is just one problem: As you know suggestions are rarely reviewed nowadays, this is because moderators and testers have started to see it as a burden, so even then they still might not review many suggestions even if it is just a 1-10 rating

It's great but I just wish there was another way to get a 1-10 rating in reviewed suggestions, but that might be the only way

cloud sandal
#

thats why i put (recommend mods just for this)

#

so mods and suggestions mods do their own thing

worldly lantern
wispy kiln
#

How will they manage to seperate the suggestion mods and the regular mods' powers? Like being able to only mute and blacklist people from suggestions

#

I don't know if the owner would trust new moderators with as much power as that

cloud sandal
#

not much power

worldly lantern
cloud sandal
#

mute for neutralizing any drama
closing for preventing more people in drama
and strikes already mentioned

wispy kiln
#

Nice then

#

Hopefully more people see this later

cloud sandal
#

done, added: suggestion mods

#

also corrected a few typos

worldly lantern
#

I spread the word among all the good and forgotten suggestions; I don't think that's against the rules, right?

cloud sandal
#

yeah it isnt

candid grotto
#

make the rich richer and the poor poorer ahh

whole jay
#

What do you mean by "at negatives it's only half of your role weight"

marsh forge
chilly anchor
edgy spindle
#

this is so good?

cloud sandal
whole jay
cloud sandal
#

except the suggestion mods and the weight stuff

tough marten
whole jay
steep ridge
#

Me likey suggestion mods and the new review idea, but the weight thing feels very "rich get richer" (major yes on the mods thing tho cuz its gets rather awkward when sm1 is majorly disliked by your average aw suggestor and the only staff members that seem to care are critical strike and Jeb sheep)

steep ridge
worldly lantern
chilly anchor
#

it's always been allowed

cloud sandal
#

ok

cloud sandal
marsh forge
#

Hmm

#

Never read this

#

So this is like some improvements to suggestions?

cloud sandal
marsh forge
cloud sandal
#

.

pseudo hollow
#

i love this

north plume
pseudo hollow
#

i make so many mastery suggestions that i put quite a bit of effort into, only for like 3 pple to see em and like them and then i see the top suggestion is some dude getting clowned on for making a bad gp rework

north plume
marsh forge
#

Cuz i know that i said into a suggestipn of yours i will see and never saw

cloud sandal
#

bump

pseudo hollow
#

recently i made uhh blood god rework or mastery search it in the thingy if you want

cloud sandal
#

bump