Server kick mechanic

[north siren]

I'm going to school and I'll be without my phone all day, so leave your question and write below if I can tag you or not

[keen glen]

i was gonna dislike due to not liking votekicks, then i realised i've seen over 5 exploiters today, one with over 15k punches cause nobody ended up reporting it due to reporting being hard

[languid jay]

votekicking would be a good idea if you need like a 1+ year old account to do so

[north siren]

Vou adicionar isso

[north siren]

Thank you for approving the suggestion

[north siren]

I'll add this*

[north siren]

Since nobody likes to report, the best option would be to expel them, which would be faster and better

[north siren]

If you liked the idea (I'll be making more changes), could you please approve the suggestion?

Thanks

[trim vector]

I think this could be done but in a different way by applying a stricter anti cheat on them instead of kicking them, kind of like a "this person is suspicious", because otherwise ppl will just kick DoS and nuisance abilities' users while getting caught in the crossfire for just going with the crowd and voting yes in case they get applied the punishment

also forcing people to go to the discord breaks roblox tos

[north siren]

I'm going to change this so you change your opinion, but the message appears to everyone and the voting happens 5 minutes after someone uses the command

[trim vector]

yeah this is way too half baked

I'll make a spinoff suggestion on this later

[north siren]

The only way to report a player and have a ban lifted is through this channel, so I don't see much of a problem with people being "forced" to come here

[north siren]

Ok

[trim vector]

that's different

theyre not incentivizing going to the discord

you CAN go to the discord

but the perks are only found once youre here

by your system we'd be forcing people off platform

which is a direct break of roblox tos

[north siren]

I understand, is there any way for me to close the suggestion for a while to edit it and then open it again?

[trim vector]

I don't think so

[north siren]

I'll edit it then

[north siren]

Reduce the punishments so that it's not such a harsh and punitive system

And that wouldn't force people to go on Discord

Discord would only be an option if you want to guarantee a ban

[north siren]

I'll be back at 5 PM, but I'm in a different time zone

[sinful lance]

Roblox itself basically already breaks the tos

With the chat verification slop

[pulsar hare]

Reporting is easy.

Just takes time for staff to get to it

They are not robots

[keen glen]

it's hard cause i always have to upload the file as a yt video

makes it annoying

[pulsar hare]

Just clip as medal 30sec clip or smth then download the file and upload to yt takes 5 mins if you know what your doing

[keen glen]

medal?

[pulsar hare]

Or obs

[keen glen]

i dont have any of that

[pulsar hare]

What recording software do you use

[keen glen]

i just use roblox's in-built recorder

[pulsar hare]

😭 🙏

[keen glen]

i dont have the money for any of that stuff

[pulsar hare]

Ur on pc?

Or mobile?

[keen glen]

yeah

pc

[pulsar hare]

Good pc? What's the specs

[keen glen]

what's a spec?

[pulsar hare]

Cpu

Gpu

[keen glen]

idk bro

[pulsar hare]

The parts inside your computer

OK is it fast though?

[keen glen]

i never took a look inside after buying it

[pulsar hare]

Or good enough to play ability wars

[keen glen]

it's pretty bad in terms of fps

like 30 max

[pulsar hare]

Avg?

Damn

😭

[keen glen]

it can run decent games tho

like AW or SMB2

sometimes even SBSD

[pulsar hare]

They are both free

Obs is the streaming and recording software most youtubers use

[keen glen]

if they require steam to download then that's a no cause im permanently locked outta my account due to losing the password and email

[pulsar hare]

😭

[shy steeple]

So this is a vote kick? I would think shouldnt be added

Cuz people might abuse it with friends and could kick everyone they want

Also the server could not like a devourer at 180 souls and kick him

Which is kinda stupid

[wicked basin]

If a dos can't prove it then uh

gg

???

[trim vector]

so?

they can still ban us

[sinful lance]

both obs and medal are free...

[sinful lance]

Just saying

[north siren]

There's a warning and it takes 5 minutes. I'm thinking about the mechanics of the soul devourer regaining them when it manages to prove it

[north siren]

With some screenshots of the chat, you could prove otherwise

[north siren]

I created this because nobody likes to report things, and it's difficult to report through Xbox because my clip takes forever to load

[sinful lance]

I was stating that to Tomas but alright

makes sense too

[shy steeple]

Then people would not like the dos

[north siren]

I'll think of a mechanism to prevent that; I have two options. Which one do you prefer?

The first is that after a Dos is expelled from a server, when he joins another server he would regain his souls

The second is that if he proves otherwise, he would get his souls back

[north siren]

Nobody ever liked it

[shy steeple]

Idk

[north siren]

The first option would be somewhat unfair because it would disrupt the peace of a random server, so the second option is better

[shy steeple]

Yes

[north siren]

Have you done it yet?

[shy steeple]

Like send a message some what and could be accepted or not

[trim vector]

I gave up on the idea

[north siren]

[shy steeple]

I wanna rate

I am addicting to rating

[north siren]

I made some changes, would they change your vote?

[shy steeple]

I will see

[north siren]

If you have any tips or complaints, feel free to speak up

[north siren]

Sorry to call you again, but since the God Punch one-shots the Blood God inside the dimension, I thought of a suggestion to solve this. Could you take a look?

[proven grove]

This suggestion would probably be a DOS main's worst enemy.

[north siren]

I edited it to make it more user-friendly for them

[proven grove]

😶 will now be replaced with ✅.
Sayanora, exploiters!

[north siren]

Thanks

[idle sparrow]

Wat if someone can't use chat bc he no verify

e

[north siren]

I just remembered that, I'll add it to the requirements to appear in the vote

[idle sparrow]

O

[north siren]

If you don't have chat enabled, you can't vote and won't appear on the Voting

[north siren]

I've fixed that. Would you like to approve the suggestion now?

[idle sparrow]

Am don know

[north siren]

Let me know when you change your mind

[north siren]

Bump

[north siren]

Could I tag you in the new suggestion?

[wicked basin]

So what if it's a hacker, they see the warning, turn off hacks, and look like they're playing the game normally

[north siren]

The mechanics are designed to expel players; to guarantee a ban, the only option is Discord. However, if this happens, a player can post a clip on Discord to prove their point

[wicked basin]

So what if a person doesn't have discord

and gets false kicked

[north siren]

Which person? The one who was expelled or the one who did the expulsion?

[north siren]

I think I know a way to change that

[north siren]

After the vote, the person would only be expelled after 5 minutes And he would be given the option to prove otherwise on the game server

Sorry if there are any mistakes, my mother was robbed and I'm a bit tense because of it @wicked basin

So I'll be offline for a while, but I'll make the changes as quickly as possible

[timid pulsar]

If you kick the hacker they are just gonna go to a different server

Also could be problematic in servers with low players

[north siren]

Nobody likes to report it because everyone's too lazy; it's just a temporary measure

[timid pulsar]

Could kick who ever they dislike if you have a freind group

[north siren]

I'm lazy too :/

[north siren]

That's why the messages and temporary bans

The voting section warns that if they intentionally vote incorrectly, there will be consequences

[timid pulsar]

And how will they check if you vote incorrectly

And what’s the punishments

[north siren]

If the guy who was expelled proves otherwise

[timid pulsar]

Like how

[north siren]

If it's not showing up, I'll bring it to you

[timid pulsar]

This just makes it inconvenient for everyone

[north siren]

By the server

[timid pulsar]

Relies on perfect factors

Best solution to the hackers is a better anitchiest

[north siren]

I don't think they're going to add one

[timid pulsar]

They said they have too little time to work on it so they would if they could

Not worded like that but the idea is like that

[north siren]

It's a solution for those who don't report crimes, and it includes punishments for those who break the rules, as well as the option to prove their point

My translator is kind of bad. 😭 😭

I prefer not to use

[timid pulsar]

How do they prove they weren’t hacking, do they have to go to discord

[north siren]

Yes, this applies to both the person who reported and the person who was reported.

[timid pulsar]

Some people don’t have discord /cant get it

[north siren]

I put up certain warnings in case someone is unfairly expelled

[north siren]

I think I have another solution to this problem, just give me a break

[timid pulsar]

If the person who reports needs discord might as well report them through player reports

[north siren]

The problem is that nobody reports via Discord; it would only serve to prove the reason for the expulsion

I've seen scripts using railgun Power

[shy steeple]

If you wany

[wicked basin]

wth

dayum mb bro

ok but still tho a big problem about this system

is that people without discord cant do anything

[agile haven]

peakeap

ʞɐǝd

[north siren]

Perhaps the option of being on Discord to use it should work

[merry drum]

A votekick system would be extremely abusable

To the point where it's just not worth it

[frail iron]

This is sadly true :[

[north siren]

I think you're right, but I made that suggestion because nobody reports scripters

[merry drum]

I mean there's also these flaws

Even if you kick an exploiter, they'd just... terrorize a different server

All that does is add a highly abusable feature with little actual benefit

[north siren]

Yes, but it's a temporary solution. I think the real solution would be a stricter anti-cheat system that focuses on suspicious individuals

[merry drum]

A temporary solution that also comes with a major side effect

Of it being highly abusable

[north siren]

Perhaps someone should make a suggestion with the same idea, but instead of a server kick, it could be an anti-cheat system

[merry drum]

Verdict: /10

[north siren]

What does the star mean?

[merry drum]

Read what it says on the star

You tried

(And failed)

[north siren]

Thanks

[north siren]

😭

[merry drum]

Still better than that moron called ghaster

[north siren]

Is he the one who created the mastery of nuclear?

[merry drum]

And many other slop suggestions, yes

[frail iron]

Good job you failed 🎉 :D