#♬ Miyolophone - Care for You (ft. Idrys) x Bruno Mars - Uptown Funk

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

junior stirrupBOT
shy flume
#

d dorian f major whatever the fuck

#

so is ts on key now or is it 5 sem

low cliff
shy flume
#

also yea the note that the bass returns to is D but the note that almost all the vocals are sung in is f so who care

#

its splitting hairs

steady jewel
#

sounds off to me

#

like that 0:18 section sounds fine

shy flume
#

wait woah hold on a minute

steady jewel
#

but 0-0:18

shy flume
#

i js assumed d dorian was the same thing

#

okay well lets figure ts out cuz

#

d dorian is the same notes as c maj

#

key chart says f maj

steady jewel
#

i think its a 5 semi

#

just by listening

#

cause that 0-18 section

#

very offkey

shy flume
#

alr so the only different between f maj and cmaj note wise is that

#

in fmaj the B becomes Bb

#

im playing out the melody of uptown funk rn

#

im not even sure if i remember them using either of those notes but

#

but ts song is so big there must be sheet music for it

steady jewel
#

there probably is

shy flume
steady jewel
#

wow

#

no way

#

we js sent the exact same link

shy flume
#

i mean heres the thing

#

it only actually uses Bb like once or twice in the song

#

so theres rly nothing stopping someone from representing ts song in D dorian

#

the base note is indeed D

steady jewel
#

so was i right

#

0-18 is offkey

shy flume
#

um i dont know

#

wym 0 to 18

low cliff
steady jewel
#

0:00-0:18

shy flume
#

is there

#

a key change?

#

what

steady jewel
#

it just sounds offkey to me

shy flume
#

ok i think ur actually right about it being d dorian sm124 lemme

#

record a little video

steady jewel
#

your investing alot of time into ts submission

#

just ask kacper the wizard

shy flume
#

its not even abt the submission anymore

#

its abt the key chart being wrong

steady jewel
#

oh

#

L keychart

shy flume
steady jewel
#

ok

#

so

shy flume
#

well the question is basically

#

d dorian or fmaj which sounds the most "uptown funk"y

steady jewel
#

ohhh

#

hollup ill tell you

shy flume
#

cuz like everywhere online wants to represent ts song as f major

#

which is fine

steady jewel
#

Fmaj

shy flume
#

i was just about to say that

#

i think the chords

steady jewel
#

it sound more like it

shy flume
#

the chords are definitely F actually

#

i forgot abt chords

#

i keep going back and forth on ts

steady jewel
#

ok so ive determined

#

Fmaj

#

is uptown funky

shy flume
#

ok lemme lay it out

#

The arguments for D dorian:

  • When putting this song in sheet music notation, D dorian requires less uses of flats, sharps, and neutrals
  • D is a note that the vocals and instruments return to frequently, and it is used to resolve a lot of the progression

Arguments for F major:

  • Almost everywhere else represents this song as F major
  • The chords fit better with F major than D dorian
  • It just intuitively "sounds" more like the scale for Uptown Funk
#

and also the other argument for major

#

is that dorian is like a "brighter" version of aeolian (which is what we usually just call "minor")

pyoign604ym31.webp
#

and the song definitely sounds closer to a major scale than a minor one

#

so yea im gonna settle on the conclusion that i think the key chart is right but

#

now after all that talk

#

i forgot what the issue w ts mashup even was 😭

#

frankly

steady jewel
#

0-18

#

offkey

shy flume
#

ok hol up tho

#

@low cliff whats the key of care for you again

low cliff
steady jewel
#

it sounds like a 5 semi dif to me

shy flume
#

ok rq cuz

steady jewel
#

cause just that part is off

shy flume
#

chordify and like an auto pitch detector got different results so

#

im gonna try and find the key of ts song

#

cuz it has a piano in it thats easy to follow

steady jewel
#

its like the last one left

low cliff
steady jewel
#

oh you arent

#

damn

#

so theres only like 1 active mashup staff

#

back to solo squads shlant

shy flume
#

well off the bat

#

im not sure about b minor

#

cuz ts song uses 3 notes not in that scale in the first few seconds

steady jewel
#

is that why it sounds off

shy flume
#

got i got it

#

im like so certain

#

its Bb major

steady jewel
#

the gd song?

shy flume
#

heres me playing a bit of the song

#

then playing the scale

#

and i mapped out the notes and they all fit within Bb major

steady jewel
#

hmm

#

send the same video but in Bm

shy flume
steady jewel
#

yeah its definetly Bbm

shy flume
#

@low cliff

#

we decided on Bb major

steady jewel
#

i mean Bb major whoopsies

low cliff
shy flume
#

like

#

im almost 100% certain

#

ok so that would mean with uptown funk

#

yea 5 sem diff

#

if u dont pitch the gd song

steady jewel
#

so i was right

#

bam

shy flume
#

wait

steady jewel
#

imma pro

shy flume
#

did you originally submit it unpitched

shy flume
low cliff
steady jewel
#

i didnt realize

shy flume
#

oh +2 is also 5 sem

#

ok so it was 5 sem before it js doesnt sound good

steady jewel
#

wait so im right again

shy flume
#

imo

shy flume
#

it was +2 previously and now its like -1 or -2 or smn

low cliff
shy flume
#

ok real quick

#

can u make a version with no pitch at all and js send it here

#

not submit js send it

low cliff
steady jewel
#

YES

shy flume
#

yea i still dont like how it sounds

#

oh

steady jewel
#

no that sounds good

shy flume
#

ok then how about

#

submit ts and

steady jewel
#

thats perfectly on

shy flume
#

i wont review it

#

ill leave it to sm1 else

#

jesus christ LOL

steady jewel
#

i can perfectly hear that thats on

shy flume
#

well at least we found the key for something

#

and proved chordify wrong

#

so it wasnt for nothing

steady jewel
#

yup

shy flume
#

id tell matthart but

#

ya know

steady jewel
#

me personally

#

im accepting ts

shy flume
#

u say like ur gonna get staff lol